This document discusses legal issues related to corrections and the death penalty. It covers topics like constitutional principles, prisoners' rights, statutes, case law, regulations, access to courts, and key Supreme Court decisions. Prisoners' rights issues are examined under the 1st, 4th, 8th, and 14th Amendments. Grievance procedures, ombudsmen, mediation, and legal assistance for inmates are also addressed.
3. Constitutions
Basic principles
Procedural safeguards
Institutions of government
▪ Legislature, judiciary, executive
Powers of government
Rights of individuals
Bill of Rights
4. Restrictions on the Rights of Prisoners
Maintenance of institutional order
Maintenance of institutional security
Rehabilitation of inmates
5. Statutes
Laws passed by the legislatures
Federal and state
More specific than constitutions
6. Case Law
Court decisions
Precedent
Regulations
Rules made by federal, state, and local
administrative agencies
7. The End of the Hands-off Policy
Cooper v. Pate (1964)
Habeas corpus
Anti-Terrorism Act
Prisoner Litigation Reform Act
8. Access to the Courts
Jailhouse lawyers
Law libraries
The Prisoners’ Rights Movement
NAACP’s legal defense and education fund
American Civil Liberties Union
9. The First Amendment
Least restrictive method
Compelling state interest
Clear and present danger
Rational basis test
▪ Rational connection
▪ Alternative means
▪ Minimal impact
▪ No less-restrictive alternative
10. The First Amendment
Speech
▪ Censorship of mail only allowed in cases of
compelling government interest in maintaining
security
Religion
▪ Black Muslims
▪ Native Americans
▪ Orthodox Jews
11. The Fourth Amendment
Selected Interpretations of the Fourth Amendment as
Applied to Prisoners
12. The Eighth Amendment
Tests to determine constitutionality
▪ whether the punishment shocks the general
conscience of a civilized society
▪ whether the punishment is unnecessarily cruel, and
▪ whether the punishment goes beyond legitimate
penal aims
Totality of conditions
Extreme conditions
13. The Fourteenth Amendment
Due process in prison discipline
▪ Solitary confinement
▪ Good-time credit
Equal protection
▪ Racial discrimination
▪ Female offenders
14. A Change in Judicial Direction
Less supportive of prisoners rights over the
last 30 years
Deliberate-indifference
16. Inmate-Grievance Procedures
Most correctional systems use a three-step
inmate-grievance process
▪ Receipt of complaint
▪ Investigation of complaint
▪ Decision
Some grievances easier to resolve than others
17. The Ombudsman
Investigates complaints and recommends action
Mediation
Voluntary process
Intervention by a neutral third party
Legal Assistance
“jailhouse” lawyers
Law school clinics
18. Key U.S. Supreme Court Decisions
Furman v. Georgia (1972)
Gregg v. Georgia (1976)
Atkins v. Virginia (2002)
Ring v. Arizona (2002)
Roper v. Simmons (2005)