SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  34
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
3 legal mechanisms
for sharing data
  {   The limits of using the law to ensure proper credit



                        Sarah Hinchliff Pearson
                        Senior Counsel, Creative Commons
                        August 22, 2011
attribution ≠
credit ≠ citation
1.licenses
2.contracts
3.waivers
licenses & contracts
           require
         { attribution
waivers
       do not
     { require
       attribution
1. licenses
licenses ≠ contracts
license

right
©
© = automatic
© ≠ fact
©=?
EU
     Sui generis
     database
     rights
=©
©=?
attribution stacking
attribution ≠ norms
2. contracts
3 Legal Mechanisms for Sharing Data
contract

 right
attribution ≠ norms
contract < license
contract > license
3 Legal Mechanisms for Sharing Data
3.waivers
3 Legal Mechanisms for Sharing Data
waivers ≠ control
waiver ≠ ?
law ≠ perfect
1.   ©=?
     2.   attribution ≠ norms




licenses
1.   attribution ≠ norms
    2.   obligations > rights




contracts
1.   waiver ≠ control




waivers
law ≠ perfect
Sarah Hinchliff Pearson, August 22, 2011
    slide show licensed under the
    CC BY international 3.0 license

Contenu connexe

Plus de Sarah Hinchliff Pearson

Presentation on springing licenses at CC Global Summit 2017
Presentation on springing licenses at CC Global Summit 2017Presentation on springing licenses at CC Global Summit 2017
Presentation on springing licenses at CC Global Summit 2017Sarah Hinchliff Pearson
 
What is Wrong with Copyright Law and How CC Can Help
What is Wrong with Copyright Law and How CC Can HelpWhat is Wrong with Copyright Law and How CC Can Help
What is Wrong with Copyright Law and How CC Can HelpSarah Hinchliff Pearson
 
Interoperability between CC licenses & ODC-BY and the UK Open Govt License
Interoperability between CC licenses & ODC-BY and the UK Open Govt LicenseInteroperability between CC licenses & ODC-BY and the UK Open Govt License
Interoperability between CC licenses & ODC-BY and the UK Open Govt LicenseSarah Hinchliff Pearson
 

Plus de Sarah Hinchliff Pearson (7)

Presentation on springing licenses at CC Global Summit 2017
Presentation on springing licenses at CC Global Summit 2017Presentation on springing licenses at CC Global Summit 2017
Presentation on springing licenses at CC Global Summit 2017
 
Creative Commons 101
Creative Commons 101Creative Commons 101
Creative Commons 101
 
Legal considerations for platforms
Legal considerations for platformsLegal considerations for platforms
Legal considerations for platforms
 
Why We Share
Why We ShareWhy We Share
Why We Share
 
What is Wrong with Copyright Law and How CC Can Help
What is Wrong with Copyright Law and How CC Can HelpWhat is Wrong with Copyright Law and How CC Can Help
What is Wrong with Copyright Law and How CC Can Help
 
3 Legal Mechanisms for Sharing Data
3 Legal Mechanisms for Sharing Data 3 Legal Mechanisms for Sharing Data
3 Legal Mechanisms for Sharing Data
 
Interoperability between CC licenses & ODC-BY and the UK Open Govt License
Interoperability between CC licenses & ODC-BY and the UK Open Govt LicenseInteroperability between CC licenses & ODC-BY and the UK Open Govt License
Interoperability between CC licenses & ODC-BY and the UK Open Govt License
 

Dernier

Outage Analysis: March 5th/6th 2024 Meta, Comcast, and LinkedIn
Outage Analysis: March 5th/6th 2024 Meta, Comcast, and LinkedInOutage Analysis: March 5th/6th 2024 Meta, Comcast, and LinkedIn
Outage Analysis: March 5th/6th 2024 Meta, Comcast, and LinkedInThousandEyes
 
Oracle Database 23c Security New Features.pptx
Oracle Database 23c Security New Features.pptxOracle Database 23c Security New Features.pptx
Oracle Database 23c Security New Features.pptxSatishbabu Gunukula
 
Technical SEO for Improved Accessibility WTS FEST
Technical SEO for Improved Accessibility  WTS FESTTechnical SEO for Improved Accessibility  WTS FEST
Technical SEO for Improved Accessibility WTS FESTBillieHyde
 
Key Trends Shaping the Future of Infrastructure.pdf
Key Trends Shaping the Future of Infrastructure.pdfKey Trends Shaping the Future of Infrastructure.pdf
Key Trends Shaping the Future of Infrastructure.pdfCheryl Hung
 
My key hands-on projects in Quantum, and QAI
My key hands-on projects in Quantum, and QAIMy key hands-on projects in Quantum, and QAI
My key hands-on projects in Quantum, and QAIVijayananda Mohire
 
From the origin to the future of Open Source model and business
From the origin to the future of  Open Source model and businessFrom the origin to the future of  Open Source model and business
From the origin to the future of Open Source model and businessFrancesco Corti
 
The Zero-ETL Approach: Enhancing Data Agility and Insight
The Zero-ETL Approach: Enhancing Data Agility and InsightThe Zero-ETL Approach: Enhancing Data Agility and Insight
The Zero-ETL Approach: Enhancing Data Agility and InsightSafe Software
 
Explore the UiPath Community and ways you can benefit on your journey to auto...
Explore the UiPath Community and ways you can benefit on your journey to auto...Explore the UiPath Community and ways you can benefit on your journey to auto...
Explore the UiPath Community and ways you can benefit on your journey to auto...DianaGray10
 
Webinar: The Art of Prioritizing Your Product Roadmap by AWS Sr PM - Tech
Webinar: The Art of Prioritizing Your Product Roadmap by AWS Sr PM - TechWebinar: The Art of Prioritizing Your Product Roadmap by AWS Sr PM - Tech
Webinar: The Art of Prioritizing Your Product Roadmap by AWS Sr PM - TechProduct School
 
Q4 2023 Quarterly Investor Presentation - FINAL - v1.pdf
Q4 2023 Quarterly Investor Presentation - FINAL - v1.pdfQ4 2023 Quarterly Investor Presentation - FINAL - v1.pdf
Q4 2023 Quarterly Investor Presentation - FINAL - v1.pdfTejal81
 
GraphSummit Copenhagen 2024 - Neo4j Vision and Roadmap.pptx
GraphSummit Copenhagen 2024 - Neo4j Vision and Roadmap.pptxGraphSummit Copenhagen 2024 - Neo4j Vision and Roadmap.pptx
GraphSummit Copenhagen 2024 - Neo4j Vision and Roadmap.pptxNeo4j
 
2024.03.12 Cost drivers of cultivated meat production.pdf
2024.03.12 Cost drivers of cultivated meat production.pdf2024.03.12 Cost drivers of cultivated meat production.pdf
2024.03.12 Cost drivers of cultivated meat production.pdfThe Good Food Institute
 
Top 10 Squarespace Development Companies
Top 10 Squarespace Development CompaniesTop 10 Squarespace Development Companies
Top 10 Squarespace Development CompaniesTopCSSGallery
 
EMEA What is ThousandEyes? Webinar
EMEA What is ThousandEyes? WebinarEMEA What is ThousandEyes? Webinar
EMEA What is ThousandEyes? WebinarThousandEyes
 
Trailblazer Community - Flows Workshop (Session 2)
Trailblazer Community - Flows Workshop (Session 2)Trailblazer Community - Flows Workshop (Session 2)
Trailblazer Community - Flows Workshop (Session 2)Muhammad Tiham Siddiqui
 
Patch notes explaining DISARM Version 1.4 update
Patch notes explaining DISARM Version 1.4 updatePatch notes explaining DISARM Version 1.4 update
Patch notes explaining DISARM Version 1.4 updateadam112203
 
Stobox 4: Revolutionizing Investment in Real-World Assets Through Tokenization
Stobox 4: Revolutionizing Investment in Real-World Assets Through TokenizationStobox 4: Revolutionizing Investment in Real-World Assets Through Tokenization
Stobox 4: Revolutionizing Investment in Real-World Assets Through TokenizationStobox
 
Design and Modeling for MySQL SCALE 21X Pasadena, CA Mar 2024
Design and Modeling for MySQL SCALE 21X Pasadena, CA Mar 2024Design and Modeling for MySQL SCALE 21X Pasadena, CA Mar 2024
Design and Modeling for MySQL SCALE 21X Pasadena, CA Mar 2024Alkin Tezuysal
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 2
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 2UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 2
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 2DianaGray10
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop Series - Day 3
UiPath Studio Web workshop Series - Day 3UiPath Studio Web workshop Series - Day 3
UiPath Studio Web workshop Series - Day 3DianaGray10
 

Dernier (20)

Outage Analysis: March 5th/6th 2024 Meta, Comcast, and LinkedIn
Outage Analysis: March 5th/6th 2024 Meta, Comcast, and LinkedInOutage Analysis: March 5th/6th 2024 Meta, Comcast, and LinkedIn
Outage Analysis: March 5th/6th 2024 Meta, Comcast, and LinkedIn
 
Oracle Database 23c Security New Features.pptx
Oracle Database 23c Security New Features.pptxOracle Database 23c Security New Features.pptx
Oracle Database 23c Security New Features.pptx
 
Technical SEO for Improved Accessibility WTS FEST
Technical SEO for Improved Accessibility  WTS FESTTechnical SEO for Improved Accessibility  WTS FEST
Technical SEO for Improved Accessibility WTS FEST
 
Key Trends Shaping the Future of Infrastructure.pdf
Key Trends Shaping the Future of Infrastructure.pdfKey Trends Shaping the Future of Infrastructure.pdf
Key Trends Shaping the Future of Infrastructure.pdf
 
My key hands-on projects in Quantum, and QAI
My key hands-on projects in Quantum, and QAIMy key hands-on projects in Quantum, and QAI
My key hands-on projects in Quantum, and QAI
 
From the origin to the future of Open Source model and business
From the origin to the future of  Open Source model and businessFrom the origin to the future of  Open Source model and business
From the origin to the future of Open Source model and business
 
The Zero-ETL Approach: Enhancing Data Agility and Insight
The Zero-ETL Approach: Enhancing Data Agility and InsightThe Zero-ETL Approach: Enhancing Data Agility and Insight
The Zero-ETL Approach: Enhancing Data Agility and Insight
 
Explore the UiPath Community and ways you can benefit on your journey to auto...
Explore the UiPath Community and ways you can benefit on your journey to auto...Explore the UiPath Community and ways you can benefit on your journey to auto...
Explore the UiPath Community and ways you can benefit on your journey to auto...
 
Webinar: The Art of Prioritizing Your Product Roadmap by AWS Sr PM - Tech
Webinar: The Art of Prioritizing Your Product Roadmap by AWS Sr PM - TechWebinar: The Art of Prioritizing Your Product Roadmap by AWS Sr PM - Tech
Webinar: The Art of Prioritizing Your Product Roadmap by AWS Sr PM - Tech
 
Q4 2023 Quarterly Investor Presentation - FINAL - v1.pdf
Q4 2023 Quarterly Investor Presentation - FINAL - v1.pdfQ4 2023 Quarterly Investor Presentation - FINAL - v1.pdf
Q4 2023 Quarterly Investor Presentation - FINAL - v1.pdf
 
GraphSummit Copenhagen 2024 - Neo4j Vision and Roadmap.pptx
GraphSummit Copenhagen 2024 - Neo4j Vision and Roadmap.pptxGraphSummit Copenhagen 2024 - Neo4j Vision and Roadmap.pptx
GraphSummit Copenhagen 2024 - Neo4j Vision and Roadmap.pptx
 
2024.03.12 Cost drivers of cultivated meat production.pdf
2024.03.12 Cost drivers of cultivated meat production.pdf2024.03.12 Cost drivers of cultivated meat production.pdf
2024.03.12 Cost drivers of cultivated meat production.pdf
 
Top 10 Squarespace Development Companies
Top 10 Squarespace Development CompaniesTop 10 Squarespace Development Companies
Top 10 Squarespace Development Companies
 
EMEA What is ThousandEyes? Webinar
EMEA What is ThousandEyes? WebinarEMEA What is ThousandEyes? Webinar
EMEA What is ThousandEyes? Webinar
 
Trailblazer Community - Flows Workshop (Session 2)
Trailblazer Community - Flows Workshop (Session 2)Trailblazer Community - Flows Workshop (Session 2)
Trailblazer Community - Flows Workshop (Session 2)
 
Patch notes explaining DISARM Version 1.4 update
Patch notes explaining DISARM Version 1.4 updatePatch notes explaining DISARM Version 1.4 update
Patch notes explaining DISARM Version 1.4 update
 
Stobox 4: Revolutionizing Investment in Real-World Assets Through Tokenization
Stobox 4: Revolutionizing Investment in Real-World Assets Through TokenizationStobox 4: Revolutionizing Investment in Real-World Assets Through Tokenization
Stobox 4: Revolutionizing Investment in Real-World Assets Through Tokenization
 
Design and Modeling for MySQL SCALE 21X Pasadena, CA Mar 2024
Design and Modeling for MySQL SCALE 21X Pasadena, CA Mar 2024Design and Modeling for MySQL SCALE 21X Pasadena, CA Mar 2024
Design and Modeling for MySQL SCALE 21X Pasadena, CA Mar 2024
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 2
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 2UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 2
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 2
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop Series - Day 3
UiPath Studio Web workshop Series - Day 3UiPath Studio Web workshop Series - Day 3
UiPath Studio Web workshop Series - Day 3
 

3 Legal Mechanisms for Sharing Data

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. Sharing data = easy. But lose control, including credit. Obvious if no license, contract or waiver. But true even if any one of those legal mechanisms is used.
  2. Define terms. Attribution = legally-imposed, remedy is lawsuit. Credit = what we want. Citation = rooted in norms of scholarly communication, purpose to support with evidence, but now proxy for credit. Important starting point.Attribution ≠ expectations for credit or citation standards. When remedy is lawsuit, recognize incongruity.
  3. Turn to the law. 3 main legal mechanisms. When data shared, possibility it won’t be properly cited.
  4. Licenses and contracts impose attribution
  5. Waivers do not. Consequences to each and will address each
  6. Licenses – grant permission under conditions like BY
  7. Sound like contracts
  8. Built on underlying exclusive right. To understand scope of license, must understand right. Typically © or SGDR
  9. © - bundle of rights
  10. Automatic when fixed
  11. Limited in scope and duration. Most important limit is © does not extend facts. No one can © fact, but can © collection of factsScientific data not subject © But collection of data could be
  12. Line is murky, varies by countryEven where subject to ©, it only extends to original aspects and never facts. General rule = can extract facts from © database without infringing
  13. Not in EU. They have SGDR. License can be © or SGDR, or both
  14. Example = CCIF applied to database, license applies to data and databases, all to extent ©. Use of data that implicates © triggers attribution.Use of data that does not implicate © - e.g. if in public domain, does not trigger attribution.
  15. Difficult to decipher © in scientific data and databases, hard to know when license applies. Creates risks.Risk that data provider be misledRisk that data user will under or over comply
  16. Impose burdensome reqts – data from many sources, attribution stacking
  17. Attribution reqts = inflexible. Absurd situations, must cite 1000 diff providers in 1000 ways. Could do all this and still not satisfy norms or expectations
  18. Variety of names
  19. Does not require underlying right, requires formalities, offer/acceptance, click thru, terms of use. Terms often require attribution.
  20. Downsides = confusing obligations, no standardization, each user agreement has diff reqtsPeople may avoid data source b/c can’t understand the terms
  21. Only binds parties, unlike licenses. Contracts more limited than licenses in that respect.If someone obtains licensed data and shares it, someone who obtains data from second user still bound by license. If data had been shared by contract alone, person who obtained data from second user would not be bound by contract terms b/c not party.In this respect, contracts more limited than licenses.
  22. Broader reach than licenses. Not tied to right, can take away rights of public.
  23. Example = Govt of Canada terms, violation if hurt rep of govt, was removed quicklyTroublesome. Esp when rarely read or negotiated.
  24. Waiver. Can take many forms, but places in pd.
  25. Not enforceable in all places. CCZero – 3 levels, waiver, fall-back license, non-assertion pledge.
  26. Means no control. Can’t require attribution.But think back to probs with licenses and contracts. (attrib stacking, inappropriate obligations imposed on given community)Avoided when waiver used and relies on norms
  27. Waiver provides legal certainty. No need to decipher © protection or sift through confusing legalese. If silent, people have to guess and may avoid b/c of risk of liability.
  28. Summarize, each approach has consequences.
  29. Licenses – (1) legal uncertainty about scope, (2) reqts that can be inconsistent with norms
  30. Contracts – (1) burdensome reqts as each institution creates its own terms, (2) exceed scope of rights with reqts that take away rights of users.
  31. Waivers – avoid problems. But lose control.
  32. Each approach requires loss of control. No mechanism that imposes legally-binding obligations in way that perfectly maps to citation norms or academic expectations. By trying to use law, we risk unnecessary transaction costs on data sharing and pushing potential users away from our data.
  33. Choosing right approach requires understanding consequences. Today’s conversations good start.