SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  7
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Rescuing Airlines from the Trap of Cost World
                 Tracking and Demystifying Inefficiencies within Airline Industry

First Draft
Needs Editing

With this article we start tracking Airline Industry, with a special emphasis on Business
Model Innovation and Operation Excellence.

Key words: Indian Aviation Industry, Airlines, India, Air India, Jet Airways, Kingfisher
Airlines, Spice Jet, Indigo, C. K. Prahlad, Bottom of the Pyramid, BOP, Ramadorai,
Mohandas Pai, TCS Story, Economic Times, Business Model, Business Model
Innovation, Operations, Alfred Angula, Tata Steel, Airline Industry, Managing Aricrafts,
Operating Airline Business, Gartner, Hype Cycle, Easy jet, Ryan air, South West Airlines


________________________________________________________________________

7th Nov 2011

“Airlines in India are in turmoil”, this has been now the headlines for over a couple of
years now.
The argument goes like this:
<start> Indian aviation market is one of world’s most expensive one, due to high levies
on fuel, (appx 24%) and airport charges, (while the base oil price itself has surged 40%
during past year), adverse impact of depreciating Rupees (more than 10% this year, while
more than 1/3rd of operating cost is dollar dependent). Further, the Indian sky has opened
wider, leading to cutthroat competition. And finally, the threat of another slowdown is
looming large. And ……. To come out of this situation, Indian aviation industry believes
that it now needs huge FDI. <end>

Given this situation, airlines are cutting cost by, timely payments to Oil companies ( 10-
15% discount), efficient flying (saving 2%, taxing with one engine, flying short route
flights at low altitudes, better cleaning to reduce friction etc.) and re-negotiating Food
contracts(saving 0.5%).

The industry as a whole feels that, it can not do much about fuel price, depreciating
rupees, artificial low ticket prices. They know that they can bring the cost in other areas.
And so, they are squeezing every penny, laying-off staff, outsource internal work and
adopting automation.

After using all the tricks in the book to cut the cost, it is now waiting for Policy clearance
on foreign investment. Wrong prescription for a classical management problem.

Yes, this is a pretty classical state of industry description.
                                                                                               1
Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.
Consider this, India is one of the fastest growing aviation market (growing at 20% YOY).
And look at Rahul’s blog (http://www.review-airlines.blogspot.com/) , on Indian aviation
industry, to know how poorly Indian aviation industry is being managed… Kingfisher
hasn’t seen black since 2005. Market leader Jet Airways hasn’t sniffed profits since 2007-
08.

The less said about AirIndia, the better it is. Mohandas Pai’s lamentation in the Economic
Times (today) on the state of affairs at the national carrier is not without reason.

But despite all odds Spicejet and Indigo have shown quick turnaround and healthy
prospects.

The question is, why big airlines are going burst despite significant growth in the
passengers. Their finger pointing on external issues does not seem justified, and least to
one who has spent time in ‘Operations.’

Lets see more things:
Gartner brings out yearly status (or maturity) of different technologies, called hype cycle,
that help technology creating and adopting organizations to build strategies on when they
want to enter the market. Some of the organizations (read start-ups), play early in the
hype cycle, where they build on the initial market euphoria and high valuation, with an
intention to quit when the hype peaks. These hypes are created by media, subject matter
experts, entrepreneurs, investors and consumers by outlandish projection of benefits of
each technology, as the all time best opportunities. And as we know not several of these
early stage companies last longer, despite which a large number of entrepreneurs are able
to cash out rich.

Characteristics in Service sectors in any growing economy, like India, follows a similar
pattern. Whether it is telecom, retail, power, renewables, infrastructure or for that matter
aviation industry. Not for nothing, the sustained high single digit growth of India, led to
setting high expectations and sequential projections, that led to high aspirations of
entrepreneurs and businesses (also government). Organizations, therefore, took long
range shots, but committed and elevated their capacities too early, in the hope that the
growth will be unidirectional. Every airline tried to book and hoard as many aeroplanes
as possible (even created artificial production constraints for aeroplane suppliers), they
recruited and created bench for as many pilots as possible and over built ground and
office resources as much as possible. While they were doing this, they built their books
fatter and claimed higher valuation. They amassed massive debts and operating cost,
much before the demand actually took place. And since the market does not remain as
you think initially, organizations were locked in the debt trap of their investments. As
troubles kicked in, they further lost focus of good business, as their attention was
diverted towards protecting and justifying investment than on increasing revenues.

The way they built their organization was on building infrastructure and capacity, too
early. They followed the philosophy of ‘more from more’, which is a trading mentality
                                                                                               2
Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.
(and of speculation). Managers after managers brought in new capacity enhancement
plans, new routes, new buying agreements, expensive media expenses, hiring of costly
pilots, all went year after year. The top management got their bonuses and hefty hikes;
and airlines started protecting their investment while the productivity continued to
plummet. And, they waited till the slowdown and global phenomenon to strike, to find a
guinea pig. And now they say that there is a policy constraint.
Thus a majority of these players was to cash on the early hype and build valuation, (and
possibly, exit before the hype peaked). But it did not happen so. Actually, it happens
rarely so.

You can bet that there is no single individual in Airlines Industry, who ever thought that
Fuel prices would not rise the way they did last year, dollar would not fluctuate the way it
has, competition would not kick start the price war, India is not price sensitive etc. Every
body knew it, but were blinded by their forecast and the way people act in a growth
economy. Which means that these risks were considered in the strategic plan itself. So
why are they crying foul, now. Of course, now there is a big deal of when an airline
opens up a new growth story.

The real growth of an organization as we know is, increase in revenue productivity. Thus,
Organizations went all wrong. They never considered productivity as a parameter,
whether productivity of money or people.

Having built the fat, now they cut the fat. In a rush they signed all sorts of contracts and
now they are spending enormous attention of management on re-negotiation, even on
supplies that could be less than 0.1% of their cost. And people who cut the fat or cost
fastest, get the reward and career growth.

The fundamentals remain the same. A business has to sustain and flourish on its own. Its
business model must be innovatively built and operated excellently. Every organization,
need to have a decisive edge for the space it wants to operate. If there are n number of
companies, then there has to be n different business models and n differentiators. No two
companies can be operate the same way in same space for long time. Today, you have
more than two companies with identical business model.

There is no bigger necessary condition for businesses than to increase their revenues, and
these revenues must increase faster than the increase in cost, while other things remain
the same. Plenty of examples are available in airlines and other industries about the
native innovations in business model. Indian airline industry so far rode on the growth
curve of general economic buoyancy, can not do justice to its aspirations if it does not
innovate itself. As of now we do not see any major innovation, than just replication of
Easy jet, Ryan air and South West airlines business model.

Since changes will happen externally as well internally, with notice or without notice,
things have to change by design, quickly within the organizations to make it nimble
enough to deal with change. Of course, the ability to respond faster to change is dictated
                                                                                               3
Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.
by how flexible and responsive is your ‘operations’. Cost cutting will make one only
slim; but approaches of lean, six sigma and execution excellence could create long term
competitive edge and hedge against changes in market place and prove viability of airline
business.

Why do I say that airlines in India are merely copy pasting external model; because they
lack the behaviour and heart while implementing those models. Take for example, you
would see that in the name of low fare, the airline staff is almost as fickle (sometime
rude) as it can be, without realising that it is still a part of hospitality sector. Often, they
treat low fare or no frill passenger worse than your city bus conductor and driver do.
They are yet to understand, what it means to offer desirable service at low cost. Even for
the bottom of the pyramid, C K Prahlad warned that it is never low cost but lower cost at
the same quality. It is true sometime that you can migrate bus and train passenger to take
flights, but if you do not give the right experience, you would lose your business not too
late. The fact remains that not only low fair airlines have misread the template of their
business models but full service ones that run low frills and full service, you see the
difference in attitude and quality of service. Every body knows that sheer focus on cost is
only going to break the service quality.

Just look at, how well have airlines segmented their customers, not just by their paying
capacity but by intrinsic need of passengers. Luxury clients definitely want to have their
exclusivity, and therefore, mixing both class of passenger takes away the value an airline
provides for luxury loving clients. The erstwhile full service airlines are trying to make a
‘difficult’ balance between the cosy comforts of full service model and low frill model.
But the mistake they are making is often an ugly compromise for both the model. As we
know, a compromise is not a sustainable solution, for it places your staff as well as the
passengers into great conflicts on regular basis. What is needed is separation of the two
model with a win for both class of clients, since the airlines are not yet matured to find
synergy between the two types of operations.

What spice jet and indigo have done is precisely being focused on a particular segment of
clients and allow themselves to grow naturally. They are trying to promise what they can
deliver, and not more. So passengers have the right expectations. They are creating a
difference on the level of satisfaction based on their promise, that is only increasing with
time with their competitors. Now as they move ahead, they are going to create loyal
clients who got used to their commitment. And it is just the time that they are going to
add other benefits to their clients. Contrary to the general operation philosophy of huge
economy of scale is not a necessarily a key reason condition for their early stage superior
performance, they have modeled their business and executed the model in such a focused
way that they are able to create a unique experience to passengers with just enough scale.
And as it is, the market is big enough not just for existing airlines, but for a few more.
Big boys, Jet, KF and Air India, all thought that by having best of both world, they would
derive huge scale of operations, and ran after market share; but they failed royally in
trying to grab market share and made ugly compromises. This has nothing to say that
bigboys’ business is not profitable, it only means that they have got their model mixed up
                                                                                               4
Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.
and wrong, with what ever objective they built it, it is not built to transform with the
changes in airline as well as external industry. Also the lessons they need to learn is that
when the opportunity is aplenty, instead of committing to fulfil all needs of the market, it
is important to fulfil at least one significant need of the clients like no other player can
and would, and thereby create a differentiator. Today, low cost airlines have created at
least one such significant need of the clients by an order of margin compared to full
service players.

Now as airline industry looks forward, the investment policy for investment of foreign
airlines would come in when it would come in, but that should not be the reason for the
existing airlines to improve their business model. By waiting for the policy to come and
then act, will be too late. Nothing prevents them from getting operationally prepared,
when the policy comes and have a head start. As of now, not many are really thinking
about the head start, they are looking at a valuation game a la telecom, power and
infrastructure sector.

The release of TCS Story and beyond by its CEO, Ramadorai, is timely in this respect,
and airline industry as a whole has a lot to learn from it. It tells why not to blame external
parameters that could be as strong as license restrictions or policy inadequacy. TCS is a
story of dreaming to fulfil a necessity to bring India on global road map, about entering
intellectual business, and making is happen, irrespective of odds. It just happened that
after a decade of its entry , opportunities followed a plenty. You would also understand
from the book, why TCS is a class apart and why TATA is a brand that it is, because its
business is not born to exploit an opportunity, but fulfil a need, meet a necessity and
solve a problem. TCS has its own business model and its own DNA.

Let’s see how things unfold, even when more passengers are taking flights. It will be
worth watching how organizations battle it out, and if they make business model
innovation and operation excellence, central to their business. The least they should
blame is unfair low pricing by competitors or policy bottlenecks for investment. The guy
who created disruption in pricing, has already encashed his investment and in any
industry, there can not be too many Captain Gopinath; it is time to operate the system
more efficiently and effectively, that is where the buck lies. There is no other way, “Take
it or leave it”, as my friend Alfred Angula, the mass leader from Namibia says.
There are a plenty of ways to improve operations of airlines. But do you have pearl of
ideas that seamlessly weave into a business model that can make a successful and unique
airline business. And most importantly, it should not only be built to perform profitably
today, it must also sustain its superlative performance in future as well.

If you look at the performance of Spicejet during the past two years (this year Q1 was a
blip), you would get some idea, but I am still not convinced about the future as they ‘buy’
more aircrafts and a large number of aircraft will cause them to get into higher
maintenance cost as well as downtime (read B, C and D checks.) and if they are aware of
innovating their model. Their last years annual report says that their performance was
mainly due to high load factor. And you can very easily understand that load factor is
                                                                                               5
Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.
nothing but the utilization, which is a prime operational metric. Spicejet is what it is
today, primarily because of operational excellence and the way they opened up their
business model ‘one step at a time’. For them cost reduction is not the driver, rather cost
effectiveness is inbuilt in the design itself (a la TataSteel). So they do not take knee jerk
reaction to worsening situations around.

There are three layers the way you drive your revenues ( and Spicejet is not too far in
working on them). First Flight Plan- the sector-wise distribution of flights, which comes
in the domain of flight planning. Second- Aircraft availability, which is how fast aircraft
is turned around in B, C and D check (as of now, because of leased airlines, Spicejet is
not facing the burden of D-check on its availability), this is in the domain of operation
engineering and maintenance department (MRO). Third –Utilization, which is the load
factor, i.e. revenue per available seat kilometre. It is not just these 3 parameters that
Spicejet has excelled and is ahead of others, the important point is that, Spicejet did not
blindly copy paste any body’s business model. Rather it leveraged advantages of their
being new organization and avoided all the disadvantages of the incumbents, which is an
inherent characteristics of a successful Startup company. They are just 6 yrs old, and still
seem to have the agility in their business model to meet external challenge.

The fundamental that organizations somehow miss is that investment in business is done
to create value and generate revenue. Without creating enough value with the already
invested money, trying to seek more investment is not the way to meet the demand. Look
at the operational parameters of full service airlines and look at their operating
parameters, they actually have not done justice to their investment. So their call for more
investment does not hold water. Keep it simple, organizations are not able to operate as
promised. They must first operate the existing business more effectively and efficiently,
before they ask for more money and changes in policies. And Rahul is pretty much right in
complaining on behalf of stakeholders, for the enormous loss these organizations have
caused.

So do you see any good movement in the thinking process of other airlines. Let me know
if you got any idea, on how Indian airliners need to move ahead. Or wait for a complete
business model, when it comes out here.




Clet:32-11




                                                                                                6
Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.
___________________________________________________________________
CVMark handholds business leaders in creating organizations that are built to transform.

For developing, innovating and executing your business model, call Tel: +91 94480 70081 or Email details to : lolla@cvmark.com .
CVMark Consulting, #2304, Nandi Park, Gottegere, Bannergatta Road, Bangalore 560083, INDIA Web: http://www.cvmark.com




                                                                                                                                   7
Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

A Case Study on Maruti Suzuki
A Case Study on Maruti SuzukiA Case Study on Maruti Suzuki
A Case Study on Maruti SuzukiQazi Faheem
 
Maruti Udyog Limited
Maruti Udyog LimitedMaruti Udyog Limited
Maruti Udyog LimitedAijaz Aryan
 
Strategic Analysis of TATA Motors with emphasison JLR acquisition
Strategic Analysis of TATA Motors with emphasison JLR acquisitionStrategic Analysis of TATA Motors with emphasison JLR acquisition
Strategic Analysis of TATA Motors with emphasison JLR acquisitionSIBASIS MOHAPATRA
 
Foreign direct investment by Rakesh Dawani
Foreign direct investment by Rakesh DawaniForeign direct investment by Rakesh Dawani
Foreign direct investment by Rakesh DawaniRakesh Dawani
 
Workshop 2: Tipping Point Analysis Preview ("From the Fund Management Jungle:...
Workshop 2: Tipping Point Analysis Preview ("From the Fund Management Jungle:...Workshop 2: Tipping Point Analysis Preview ("From the Fund Management Jungle:...
Workshop 2: Tipping Point Analysis Preview ("From the Fund Management Jungle:...Koon Boon KEE
 
Swot analysis of tata motors
Swot analysis of tata motorsSwot analysis of tata motors
Swot analysis of tata motorshiteshkrohra
 
Swot analysis of tatamotors
Swot analysis of tatamotors Swot analysis of tatamotors
Swot analysis of tatamotors hiteshkrohra
 
Porter's five forces and value chain model AirAsia
Porter's five forces and value chain model AirAsiaPorter's five forces and value chain model AirAsia
Porter's five forces and value chain model AirAsiamariammana
 
Swot analysis report_on_tata motors
Swot analysis report_on_tata motorsSwot analysis report_on_tata motors
Swot analysis report_on_tata motorsYuvraj Shah
 
Order processing,company profile,about company,vision & mission, executive su...
Order processing,company profile,about company,vision & mission, executive su...Order processing,company profile,about company,vision & mission, executive su...
Order processing,company profile,about company,vision & mission, executive su...Ajeenkya D Y Patil
 
Hr policy in maruthi
Hr policy in maruthi Hr policy in maruthi
Hr policy in maruthi Babasab Patil
 
Ola, Meru Seeks Govt. Intervention to Fight MNCs
Ola, Meru Seeks Govt. Intervention to Fight MNCsOla, Meru Seeks Govt. Intervention to Fight MNCs
Ola, Meru Seeks Govt. Intervention to Fight MNCsAshish Jhalani
 
Developing People Managers at Interglobe Enterprises ( Indigo)
Developing People Managers at Interglobe Enterprises ( Indigo)Developing People Managers at Interglobe Enterprises ( Indigo)
Developing People Managers at Interglobe Enterprises ( Indigo)Best Workplaces Conference
 
Maruti suzuki STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
Maruti suzuki STRATEGIC MANAGEMENTMaruti suzuki STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
Maruti suzuki STRATEGIC MANAGEMENTsanjay p
 

Tendances (18)

A Case Study on Maruti Suzuki
A Case Study on Maruti SuzukiA Case Study on Maruti Suzuki
A Case Study on Maruti Suzuki
 
Maruti Udyog Limited
Maruti Udyog LimitedMaruti Udyog Limited
Maruti Udyog Limited
 
Strategic Analysis of TATA Motors with emphasison JLR acquisition
Strategic Analysis of TATA Motors with emphasison JLR acquisitionStrategic Analysis of TATA Motors with emphasison JLR acquisition
Strategic Analysis of TATA Motors with emphasison JLR acquisition
 
Foreign direct investment by Rakesh Dawani
Foreign direct investment by Rakesh DawaniForeign direct investment by Rakesh Dawani
Foreign direct investment by Rakesh Dawani
 
Tata motors Financial Analysis
Tata motors Financial AnalysisTata motors Financial Analysis
Tata motors Financial Analysis
 
Workshop 2: Tipping Point Analysis Preview ("From the Fund Management Jungle:...
Workshop 2: Tipping Point Analysis Preview ("From the Fund Management Jungle:...Workshop 2: Tipping Point Analysis Preview ("From the Fund Management Jungle:...
Workshop 2: Tipping Point Analysis Preview ("From the Fund Management Jungle:...
 
Swot analysis of tata motors
Swot analysis of tata motorsSwot analysis of tata motors
Swot analysis of tata motors
 
Swot analysis of tatamotors
Swot analysis of tatamotors Swot analysis of tatamotors
Swot analysis of tatamotors
 
Porter's five forces and value chain model AirAsia
Porter's five forces and value chain model AirAsiaPorter's five forces and value chain model AirAsia
Porter's five forces and value chain model AirAsia
 
Swot analysis report_on_tata motors
Swot analysis report_on_tata motorsSwot analysis report_on_tata motors
Swot analysis report_on_tata motors
 
Scote projt bunty
Scote projt buntyScote projt bunty
Scote projt bunty
 
Order processing,company profile,about company,vision & mission, executive su...
Order processing,company profile,about company,vision & mission, executive su...Order processing,company profile,about company,vision & mission, executive su...
Order processing,company profile,about company,vision & mission, executive su...
 
Hr policy in maruthi
Hr policy in maruthi Hr policy in maruthi
Hr policy in maruthi
 
Ola, Meru Seeks Govt. Intervention to Fight MNCs
Ola, Meru Seeks Govt. Intervention to Fight MNCsOla, Meru Seeks Govt. Intervention to Fight MNCs
Ola, Meru Seeks Govt. Intervention to Fight MNCs
 
Tata motors
Tata motorsTata motors
Tata motors
 
Developing People Managers at Interglobe Enterprises ( Indigo)
Developing People Managers at Interglobe Enterprises ( Indigo)Developing People Managers at Interglobe Enterprises ( Indigo)
Developing People Managers at Interglobe Enterprises ( Indigo)
 
Maruti suzuki STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
Maruti suzuki STRATEGIC MANAGEMENTMaruti suzuki STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
Maruti suzuki STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
 
Maruti
MarutiMaruti
Maruti
 

Similaire à Rescuing airlines from the trap of cost world

The Southwest Airlines
The Southwest AirlinesThe Southwest Airlines
The Southwest AirlinesKimberly Jones
 
The Profitability Of The Airline Industry
The Profitability Of The Airline IndustryThe Profitability Of The Airline Industry
The Profitability Of The Airline IndustryMonica Turner
 
Case Study Of United Airlines And Continental Airlines
Case Study Of United Airlines And Continental AirlinesCase Study Of United Airlines And Continental Airlines
Case Study Of United Airlines And Continental AirlinesJessica Tanner
 
External Environment Factors Affecting The British Airways...
External Environment Factors Affecting The British Airways...External Environment Factors Affecting The British Airways...
External Environment Factors Affecting The British Airways...Yolanda Jenkins
 
The Most Memorable College Admissions Essays Reddit Has Ever Seen Will
The Most Memorable College Admissions Essays Reddit Has Ever Seen WillThe Most Memorable College Admissions Essays Reddit Has Ever Seen Will
The Most Memorable College Admissions Essays Reddit Has Ever Seen WillDawn Rodriguez
 
Airasia Swot Analysis
Airasia Swot AnalysisAirasia Swot Analysis
Airasia Swot AnalysisTina Jordan
 
Hawaiian Airlines Mission Vision And Values Essay
Hawaiian Airlines Mission Vision And Values EssayHawaiian Airlines Mission Vision And Values Essay
Hawaiian Airlines Mission Vision And Values EssayJamie Miller
 
The Philosophy Of Passive Management
The Philosophy Of Passive ManagementThe Philosophy Of Passive Management
The Philosophy Of Passive ManagementMichelle Madero
 
Financial Issues Faced By Delta Airlines
Financial Issues Faced By Delta AirlinesFinancial Issues Faced By Delta Airlines
Financial Issues Faced By Delta AirlinesJessica Briggs
 
Allen Aircraft Radio Corp Executive Summary
Allen Aircraft Radio Corp Executive SummaryAllen Aircraft Radio Corp Executive Summary
Allen Aircraft Radio Corp Executive SummaryChristina Valadez
 
Lufthansa Case Study Essay
Lufthansa Case Study EssayLufthansa Case Study Essay
Lufthansa Case Study EssayJuanita Conklin
 
Essay On Proj 595 Project Part 1
Essay On Proj 595 Project Part 1Essay On Proj 595 Project Part 1
Essay On Proj 595 Project Part 1Christy Davis
 
Airline Business Environment In Asia
Airline Business Environment In AsiaAirline Business Environment In Asia
Airline Business Environment In AsiaSusan Migliaccio
 
Virgin Atlantic Strategy
Virgin Atlantic StrategyVirgin Atlantic Strategy
Virgin Atlantic StrategyAlicia Johnson
 
Strategic Management Assignment
Strategic Management AssignmentStrategic Management Assignment
Strategic Management AssignmentKimberly Yang
 

Similaire à Rescuing airlines from the trap of cost world (20)

The Southwest Airlines
The Southwest AirlinesThe Southwest Airlines
The Southwest Airlines
 
The Profitability Of The Airline Industry
The Profitability Of The Airline IndustryThe Profitability Of The Airline Industry
The Profitability Of The Airline Industry
 
Case Study Of United Airlines And Continental Airlines
Case Study Of United Airlines And Continental AirlinesCase Study Of United Airlines And Continental Airlines
Case Study Of United Airlines And Continental Airlines
 
External Environment Factors Affecting The British Airways...
External Environment Factors Affecting The British Airways...External Environment Factors Affecting The British Airways...
External Environment Factors Affecting The British Airways...
 
The Most Memorable College Admissions Essays Reddit Has Ever Seen Will
The Most Memorable College Admissions Essays Reddit Has Ever Seen WillThe Most Memorable College Admissions Essays Reddit Has Ever Seen Will
The Most Memorable College Admissions Essays Reddit Has Ever Seen Will
 
Airline Industry
Airline IndustryAirline Industry
Airline Industry
 
Airasia Swot Analysis
Airasia Swot AnalysisAirasia Swot Analysis
Airasia Swot Analysis
 
Hawaiian Airlines Mission Vision And Values Essay
Hawaiian Airlines Mission Vision And Values EssayHawaiian Airlines Mission Vision And Values Essay
Hawaiian Airlines Mission Vision And Values Essay
 
The Philosophy Of Passive Management
The Philosophy Of Passive ManagementThe Philosophy Of Passive Management
The Philosophy Of Passive Management
 
Financial Issues Faced By Delta Airlines
Financial Issues Faced By Delta AirlinesFinancial Issues Faced By Delta Airlines
Financial Issues Faced By Delta Airlines
 
Allen Aircraft Radio Corp Executive Summary
Allen Aircraft Radio Corp Executive SummaryAllen Aircraft Radio Corp Executive Summary
Allen Aircraft Radio Corp Executive Summary
 
Lufthansa Case Study Essay
Lufthansa Case Study EssayLufthansa Case Study Essay
Lufthansa Case Study Essay
 
Comair
ComairComair
Comair
 
Essay On Proj 595 Project Part 1
Essay On Proj 595 Project Part 1Essay On Proj 595 Project Part 1
Essay On Proj 595 Project Part 1
 
Airline Business Environment In Asia
Airline Business Environment In AsiaAirline Business Environment In Asia
Airline Business Environment In Asia
 
Southwest Swot Analysis
Southwest Swot AnalysisSouthwest Swot Analysis
Southwest Swot Analysis
 
The Sky’S The Limit
The Sky’S The LimitThe Sky’S The Limit
The Sky’S The Limit
 
Virgin Atlantic Strategy
Virgin Atlantic StrategyVirgin Atlantic Strategy
Virgin Atlantic Strategy
 
Creative accounting
Creative accountingCreative accounting
Creative accounting
 
Strategic Management Assignment
Strategic Management AssignmentStrategic Management Assignment
Strategic Management Assignment
 

Plus de Shridhar Lolla

What's Inside the Growth Curve?
What's Inside the Growth Curve?What's Inside the Growth Curve?
What's Inside the Growth Curve?Shridhar Lolla
 
Ambiguity.Dilemma.Conflicts - The powerful force blocking growth of the orga...
Ambiguity.Dilemma.Conflicts  - The powerful force blocking growth of the orga...Ambiguity.Dilemma.Conflicts  - The powerful force blocking growth of the orga...
Ambiguity.Dilemma.Conflicts - The powerful force blocking growth of the orga...Shridhar Lolla
 
How is Your QC Boosting Business Results?
How is Your QC Boosting Business Results?How is Your QC Boosting Business Results?
How is Your QC Boosting Business Results?Shridhar Lolla
 
Innovating Business Model of System Integrators- In Motion Weighing
Innovating Business Model of System Integrators- In Motion Weighing Innovating Business Model of System Integrators- In Motion Weighing
Innovating Business Model of System Integrators- In Motion Weighing Shridhar Lolla
 
Manufacturing Managers, are you ready to be the CEO!
Manufacturing Managers, are you ready to be the CEO!Manufacturing Managers, are you ready to be the CEO!
Manufacturing Managers, are you ready to be the CEO!Shridhar Lolla
 
Manufacturing News 2014 Feb
Manufacturing News 2014 FebManufacturing News 2014 Feb
Manufacturing News 2014 FebShridhar Lolla
 
The temptation of integrating a new opportunity
The temptation of integrating a new opportunityThe temptation of integrating a new opportunity
The temptation of integrating a new opportunityShridhar Lolla
 
Capacity Hunt Program - generic version
Capacity Hunt Program  -  generic versionCapacity Hunt Program  -  generic version
Capacity Hunt Program - generic versionShridhar Lolla
 
Formulation and api plants join to deliver benefits of capacity hunt program
Formulation and api plants join to deliver benefits of capacity hunt programFormulation and api plants join to deliver benefits of capacity hunt program
Formulation and api plants join to deliver benefits of capacity hunt programShridhar Lolla
 
Capacity hunt program reveals huge hidden capacity
Capacity hunt program reveals huge hidden capacityCapacity hunt program reveals huge hidden capacity
Capacity hunt program reveals huge hidden capacityShridhar Lolla
 
Take the Capacity Hunt Challenge
Take the Capacity Hunt ChallengeTake the Capacity Hunt Challenge
Take the Capacity Hunt ChallengeShridhar Lolla
 
1 day workshop managing service organizations - the toc way
1 day workshop   managing service organizations - the toc way1 day workshop   managing service organizations - the toc way
1 day workshop managing service organizations - the toc wayShridhar Lolla
 
1 day workshop managing operations - the toc way
1 day workshop   managing operations - the toc way1 day workshop   managing operations - the toc way
1 day workshop managing operations - the toc wayShridhar Lolla
 
1 day workshop managing manufacturing organizations - the toc way
1 day workshop   managing manufacturing organizations - the toc way1 day workshop   managing manufacturing organizations - the toc way
1 day workshop managing manufacturing organizations - the toc wayShridhar Lolla
 
Building design capability
Building design capabilityBuilding design capability
Building design capabilityShridhar Lolla
 
Operation management summary of presentation
Operation management summary of presentationOperation management summary of presentation
Operation management summary of presentationShridhar Lolla
 
Toc for smart production- excerpts of invited lecture delivered at the colloq...
Toc for smart production- excerpts of invited lecture delivered at the colloq...Toc for smart production- excerpts of invited lecture delivered at the colloq...
Toc for smart production- excerpts of invited lecture delivered at the colloq...Shridhar Lolla
 

Plus de Shridhar Lolla (20)

What's Inside the Growth Curve?
What's Inside the Growth Curve?What's Inside the Growth Curve?
What's Inside the Growth Curve?
 
Ambiguity.Dilemma.Conflicts - The powerful force blocking growth of the orga...
Ambiguity.Dilemma.Conflicts  - The powerful force blocking growth of the orga...Ambiguity.Dilemma.Conflicts  - The powerful force blocking growth of the orga...
Ambiguity.Dilemma.Conflicts - The powerful force blocking growth of the orga...
 
How is Your QC Boosting Business Results?
How is Your QC Boosting Business Results?How is Your QC Boosting Business Results?
How is Your QC Boosting Business Results?
 
Innovating Business Model of System Integrators- In Motion Weighing
Innovating Business Model of System Integrators- In Motion Weighing Innovating Business Model of System Integrators- In Motion Weighing
Innovating Business Model of System Integrators- In Motion Weighing
 
Manufacturing Managers, are you ready to be the CEO!
Manufacturing Managers, are you ready to be the CEO!Manufacturing Managers, are you ready to be the CEO!
Manufacturing Managers, are you ready to be the CEO!
 
Manufacturing News 2014 Feb
Manufacturing News 2014 FebManufacturing News 2014 Feb
Manufacturing News 2014 Feb
 
The temptation of integrating a new opportunity
The temptation of integrating a new opportunityThe temptation of integrating a new opportunity
The temptation of integrating a new opportunity
 
Capacity Hunt Program - generic version
Capacity Hunt Program  -  generic versionCapacity Hunt Program  -  generic version
Capacity Hunt Program - generic version
 
Capacity Hunt Program
Capacity Hunt ProgramCapacity Hunt Program
Capacity Hunt Program
 
Formulation and api plants join to deliver benefits of capacity hunt program
Formulation and api plants join to deliver benefits of capacity hunt programFormulation and api plants join to deliver benefits of capacity hunt program
Formulation and api plants join to deliver benefits of capacity hunt program
 
What is operations
What is operationsWhat is operations
What is operations
 
Capacity hunt program reveals huge hidden capacity
Capacity hunt program reveals huge hidden capacityCapacity hunt program reveals huge hidden capacity
Capacity hunt program reveals huge hidden capacity
 
Take the Capacity Hunt Challenge
Take the Capacity Hunt ChallengeTake the Capacity Hunt Challenge
Take the Capacity Hunt Challenge
 
How did it start
How did it startHow did it start
How did it start
 
1 day workshop managing service organizations - the toc way
1 day workshop   managing service organizations - the toc way1 day workshop   managing service organizations - the toc way
1 day workshop managing service organizations - the toc way
 
1 day workshop managing operations - the toc way
1 day workshop   managing operations - the toc way1 day workshop   managing operations - the toc way
1 day workshop managing operations - the toc way
 
1 day workshop managing manufacturing organizations - the toc way
1 day workshop   managing manufacturing organizations - the toc way1 day workshop   managing manufacturing organizations - the toc way
1 day workshop managing manufacturing organizations - the toc way
 
Building design capability
Building design capabilityBuilding design capability
Building design capability
 
Operation management summary of presentation
Operation management summary of presentationOperation management summary of presentation
Operation management summary of presentation
 
Toc for smart production- excerpts of invited lecture delivered at the colloq...
Toc for smart production- excerpts of invited lecture delivered at the colloq...Toc for smart production- excerpts of invited lecture delivered at the colloq...
Toc for smart production- excerpts of invited lecture delivered at the colloq...
 

Dernier

Michael Vidyakin: Introduction to PMO (UA)
Michael Vidyakin: Introduction to PMO (UA)Michael Vidyakin: Introduction to PMO (UA)
Michael Vidyakin: Introduction to PMO (UA)Lviv Startup Club
 
Lecture_6.pptx English speaking easyb to
Lecture_6.pptx English speaking easyb toLecture_6.pptx English speaking easyb to
Lecture_6.pptx English speaking easyb toumarfarooquejamali32
 
NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023
NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023
NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023Steve Rader
 
TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...
TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...
TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...TalentView
 
PDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdf
PDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdfPDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdf
PDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdfHajeJanKamps
 
Project Brief & Information Architecture Report
Project Brief & Information Architecture ReportProject Brief & Information Architecture Report
Project Brief & Information Architecture Reportamberjiles31
 
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access
 
BCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John Meulemans
BCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John MeulemansBCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John Meulemans
BCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John MeulemansBBPMedia1
 
Anyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agency
Anyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agencyAnyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agency
Anyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agencyHanna Klim
 
Developing Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, Ours
Developing Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, OursDeveloping Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, Ours
Developing Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, OursKaiNexus
 
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptxHELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptxHelene Heckrotte
 
Talent Management research intelligence_13 paradigm shifts_20 March 2024.pdf
Talent Management research intelligence_13 paradigm shifts_20 March 2024.pdfTalent Management research intelligence_13 paradigm shifts_20 March 2024.pdf
Talent Management research intelligence_13 paradigm shifts_20 March 2024.pdfCharles Cotter, PhD
 
7movierulz.uk
7movierulz.uk7movierulz.uk
7movierulz.ukaroemirsr
 
Building Your Personal Brand on LinkedIn - Expert Planet- 2024
 Building Your Personal Brand on LinkedIn - Expert Planet-  2024 Building Your Personal Brand on LinkedIn - Expert Planet-  2024
Building Your Personal Brand on LinkedIn - Expert Planet- 2024Stephan Koning
 
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdfChicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdfSourav Sikder
 
The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003
The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003
The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003believeminhh
 
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking ApplicationsUpgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking ApplicationsIntellect Design Arena Ltd
 
MoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor Presentation
MoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor PresentationMoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor Presentation
MoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor Presentationbaron83
 
A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.
A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.
A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.mcshagufta46
 

Dernier (20)

Michael Vidyakin: Introduction to PMO (UA)
Michael Vidyakin: Introduction to PMO (UA)Michael Vidyakin: Introduction to PMO (UA)
Michael Vidyakin: Introduction to PMO (UA)
 
Lecture_6.pptx English speaking easyb to
Lecture_6.pptx English speaking easyb toLecture_6.pptx English speaking easyb to
Lecture_6.pptx English speaking easyb to
 
NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023
NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023
NASA CoCEI Scaling Strategy - November 2023
 
TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...
TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...
TalentView Webinar: Empowering the Modern Workforce_ Redefininig Success from...
 
Investment Opportunity for Thailand's Automotive & EV Industries
Investment Opportunity for Thailand's Automotive & EV IndustriesInvestment Opportunity for Thailand's Automotive & EV Industries
Investment Opportunity for Thailand's Automotive & EV Industries
 
PDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdf
PDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdfPDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdf
PDT 88 - 4 million seed - Seed - Protecto.pdf
 
Project Brief & Information Architecture Report
Project Brief & Information Architecture ReportProject Brief & Information Architecture Report
Project Brief & Information Architecture Report
 
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
Borderless Access - Global B2B Panel book-unlock 2024
 
BCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John Meulemans
BCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John MeulemansBCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John Meulemans
BCE24 | Virtual Brand Ambassadors: Making Brands Personal - John Meulemans
 
Anyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agency
Anyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agencyAnyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agency
Anyhr.io | Presentation HR&Recruiting agency
 
Developing Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, Ours
Developing Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, OursDeveloping Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, Ours
Developing Coaching Skills: Mine, Yours, Ours
 
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptxHELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
HELENE HECKROTTE'S PROFESSIONAL PORTFOLIO.pptx
 
Talent Management research intelligence_13 paradigm shifts_20 March 2024.pdf
Talent Management research intelligence_13 paradigm shifts_20 March 2024.pdfTalent Management research intelligence_13 paradigm shifts_20 March 2024.pdf
Talent Management research intelligence_13 paradigm shifts_20 March 2024.pdf
 
7movierulz.uk
7movierulz.uk7movierulz.uk
7movierulz.uk
 
Building Your Personal Brand on LinkedIn - Expert Planet- 2024
 Building Your Personal Brand on LinkedIn - Expert Planet-  2024 Building Your Personal Brand on LinkedIn - Expert Planet-  2024
Building Your Personal Brand on LinkedIn - Expert Planet- 2024
 
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdfChicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer.pdf
 
The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003
The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003
The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_MARCH 25, 2024_EN_Vol. 003
 
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking ApplicationsUpgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
Upgrade Your Banking Experience with Advanced Core Banking Applications
 
MoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor Presentation
MoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor PresentationMoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor Presentation
MoneyBridge Pitch Deck - Investor Presentation
 
A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.
A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.
A flour, rice and Suji company in Jhang.
 

Rescuing airlines from the trap of cost world

  • 1. Rescuing Airlines from the Trap of Cost World Tracking and Demystifying Inefficiencies within Airline Industry First Draft Needs Editing With this article we start tracking Airline Industry, with a special emphasis on Business Model Innovation and Operation Excellence. Key words: Indian Aviation Industry, Airlines, India, Air India, Jet Airways, Kingfisher Airlines, Spice Jet, Indigo, C. K. Prahlad, Bottom of the Pyramid, BOP, Ramadorai, Mohandas Pai, TCS Story, Economic Times, Business Model, Business Model Innovation, Operations, Alfred Angula, Tata Steel, Airline Industry, Managing Aricrafts, Operating Airline Business, Gartner, Hype Cycle, Easy jet, Ryan air, South West Airlines ________________________________________________________________________ 7th Nov 2011 “Airlines in India are in turmoil”, this has been now the headlines for over a couple of years now. The argument goes like this: <start> Indian aviation market is one of world’s most expensive one, due to high levies on fuel, (appx 24%) and airport charges, (while the base oil price itself has surged 40% during past year), adverse impact of depreciating Rupees (more than 10% this year, while more than 1/3rd of operating cost is dollar dependent). Further, the Indian sky has opened wider, leading to cutthroat competition. And finally, the threat of another slowdown is looming large. And ……. To come out of this situation, Indian aviation industry believes that it now needs huge FDI. <end> Given this situation, airlines are cutting cost by, timely payments to Oil companies ( 10- 15% discount), efficient flying (saving 2%, taxing with one engine, flying short route flights at low altitudes, better cleaning to reduce friction etc.) and re-negotiating Food contracts(saving 0.5%). The industry as a whole feels that, it can not do much about fuel price, depreciating rupees, artificial low ticket prices. They know that they can bring the cost in other areas. And so, they are squeezing every penny, laying-off staff, outsource internal work and adopting automation. After using all the tricks in the book to cut the cost, it is now waiting for Policy clearance on foreign investment. Wrong prescription for a classical management problem. Yes, this is a pretty classical state of industry description. 1 Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.
  • 2. Consider this, India is one of the fastest growing aviation market (growing at 20% YOY). And look at Rahul’s blog (http://www.review-airlines.blogspot.com/) , on Indian aviation industry, to know how poorly Indian aviation industry is being managed… Kingfisher hasn’t seen black since 2005. Market leader Jet Airways hasn’t sniffed profits since 2007- 08. The less said about AirIndia, the better it is. Mohandas Pai’s lamentation in the Economic Times (today) on the state of affairs at the national carrier is not without reason. But despite all odds Spicejet and Indigo have shown quick turnaround and healthy prospects. The question is, why big airlines are going burst despite significant growth in the passengers. Their finger pointing on external issues does not seem justified, and least to one who has spent time in ‘Operations.’ Lets see more things: Gartner brings out yearly status (or maturity) of different technologies, called hype cycle, that help technology creating and adopting organizations to build strategies on when they want to enter the market. Some of the organizations (read start-ups), play early in the hype cycle, where they build on the initial market euphoria and high valuation, with an intention to quit when the hype peaks. These hypes are created by media, subject matter experts, entrepreneurs, investors and consumers by outlandish projection of benefits of each technology, as the all time best opportunities. And as we know not several of these early stage companies last longer, despite which a large number of entrepreneurs are able to cash out rich. Characteristics in Service sectors in any growing economy, like India, follows a similar pattern. Whether it is telecom, retail, power, renewables, infrastructure or for that matter aviation industry. Not for nothing, the sustained high single digit growth of India, led to setting high expectations and sequential projections, that led to high aspirations of entrepreneurs and businesses (also government). Organizations, therefore, took long range shots, but committed and elevated their capacities too early, in the hope that the growth will be unidirectional. Every airline tried to book and hoard as many aeroplanes as possible (even created artificial production constraints for aeroplane suppliers), they recruited and created bench for as many pilots as possible and over built ground and office resources as much as possible. While they were doing this, they built their books fatter and claimed higher valuation. They amassed massive debts and operating cost, much before the demand actually took place. And since the market does not remain as you think initially, organizations were locked in the debt trap of their investments. As troubles kicked in, they further lost focus of good business, as their attention was diverted towards protecting and justifying investment than on increasing revenues. The way they built their organization was on building infrastructure and capacity, too early. They followed the philosophy of ‘more from more’, which is a trading mentality 2 Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.
  • 3. (and of speculation). Managers after managers brought in new capacity enhancement plans, new routes, new buying agreements, expensive media expenses, hiring of costly pilots, all went year after year. The top management got their bonuses and hefty hikes; and airlines started protecting their investment while the productivity continued to plummet. And, they waited till the slowdown and global phenomenon to strike, to find a guinea pig. And now they say that there is a policy constraint. Thus a majority of these players was to cash on the early hype and build valuation, (and possibly, exit before the hype peaked). But it did not happen so. Actually, it happens rarely so. You can bet that there is no single individual in Airlines Industry, who ever thought that Fuel prices would not rise the way they did last year, dollar would not fluctuate the way it has, competition would not kick start the price war, India is not price sensitive etc. Every body knew it, but were blinded by their forecast and the way people act in a growth economy. Which means that these risks were considered in the strategic plan itself. So why are they crying foul, now. Of course, now there is a big deal of when an airline opens up a new growth story. The real growth of an organization as we know is, increase in revenue productivity. Thus, Organizations went all wrong. They never considered productivity as a parameter, whether productivity of money or people. Having built the fat, now they cut the fat. In a rush they signed all sorts of contracts and now they are spending enormous attention of management on re-negotiation, even on supplies that could be less than 0.1% of their cost. And people who cut the fat or cost fastest, get the reward and career growth. The fundamentals remain the same. A business has to sustain and flourish on its own. Its business model must be innovatively built and operated excellently. Every organization, need to have a decisive edge for the space it wants to operate. If there are n number of companies, then there has to be n different business models and n differentiators. No two companies can be operate the same way in same space for long time. Today, you have more than two companies with identical business model. There is no bigger necessary condition for businesses than to increase their revenues, and these revenues must increase faster than the increase in cost, while other things remain the same. Plenty of examples are available in airlines and other industries about the native innovations in business model. Indian airline industry so far rode on the growth curve of general economic buoyancy, can not do justice to its aspirations if it does not innovate itself. As of now we do not see any major innovation, than just replication of Easy jet, Ryan air and South West airlines business model. Since changes will happen externally as well internally, with notice or without notice, things have to change by design, quickly within the organizations to make it nimble enough to deal with change. Of course, the ability to respond faster to change is dictated 3 Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.
  • 4. by how flexible and responsive is your ‘operations’. Cost cutting will make one only slim; but approaches of lean, six sigma and execution excellence could create long term competitive edge and hedge against changes in market place and prove viability of airline business. Why do I say that airlines in India are merely copy pasting external model; because they lack the behaviour and heart while implementing those models. Take for example, you would see that in the name of low fare, the airline staff is almost as fickle (sometime rude) as it can be, without realising that it is still a part of hospitality sector. Often, they treat low fare or no frill passenger worse than your city bus conductor and driver do. They are yet to understand, what it means to offer desirable service at low cost. Even for the bottom of the pyramid, C K Prahlad warned that it is never low cost but lower cost at the same quality. It is true sometime that you can migrate bus and train passenger to take flights, but if you do not give the right experience, you would lose your business not too late. The fact remains that not only low fair airlines have misread the template of their business models but full service ones that run low frills and full service, you see the difference in attitude and quality of service. Every body knows that sheer focus on cost is only going to break the service quality. Just look at, how well have airlines segmented their customers, not just by their paying capacity but by intrinsic need of passengers. Luxury clients definitely want to have their exclusivity, and therefore, mixing both class of passenger takes away the value an airline provides for luxury loving clients. The erstwhile full service airlines are trying to make a ‘difficult’ balance between the cosy comforts of full service model and low frill model. But the mistake they are making is often an ugly compromise for both the model. As we know, a compromise is not a sustainable solution, for it places your staff as well as the passengers into great conflicts on regular basis. What is needed is separation of the two model with a win for both class of clients, since the airlines are not yet matured to find synergy between the two types of operations. What spice jet and indigo have done is precisely being focused on a particular segment of clients and allow themselves to grow naturally. They are trying to promise what they can deliver, and not more. So passengers have the right expectations. They are creating a difference on the level of satisfaction based on their promise, that is only increasing with time with their competitors. Now as they move ahead, they are going to create loyal clients who got used to their commitment. And it is just the time that they are going to add other benefits to their clients. Contrary to the general operation philosophy of huge economy of scale is not a necessarily a key reason condition for their early stage superior performance, they have modeled their business and executed the model in such a focused way that they are able to create a unique experience to passengers with just enough scale. And as it is, the market is big enough not just for existing airlines, but for a few more. Big boys, Jet, KF and Air India, all thought that by having best of both world, they would derive huge scale of operations, and ran after market share; but they failed royally in trying to grab market share and made ugly compromises. This has nothing to say that bigboys’ business is not profitable, it only means that they have got their model mixed up 4 Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.
  • 5. and wrong, with what ever objective they built it, it is not built to transform with the changes in airline as well as external industry. Also the lessons they need to learn is that when the opportunity is aplenty, instead of committing to fulfil all needs of the market, it is important to fulfil at least one significant need of the clients like no other player can and would, and thereby create a differentiator. Today, low cost airlines have created at least one such significant need of the clients by an order of margin compared to full service players. Now as airline industry looks forward, the investment policy for investment of foreign airlines would come in when it would come in, but that should not be the reason for the existing airlines to improve their business model. By waiting for the policy to come and then act, will be too late. Nothing prevents them from getting operationally prepared, when the policy comes and have a head start. As of now, not many are really thinking about the head start, they are looking at a valuation game a la telecom, power and infrastructure sector. The release of TCS Story and beyond by its CEO, Ramadorai, is timely in this respect, and airline industry as a whole has a lot to learn from it. It tells why not to blame external parameters that could be as strong as license restrictions or policy inadequacy. TCS is a story of dreaming to fulfil a necessity to bring India on global road map, about entering intellectual business, and making is happen, irrespective of odds. It just happened that after a decade of its entry , opportunities followed a plenty. You would also understand from the book, why TCS is a class apart and why TATA is a brand that it is, because its business is not born to exploit an opportunity, but fulfil a need, meet a necessity and solve a problem. TCS has its own business model and its own DNA. Let’s see how things unfold, even when more passengers are taking flights. It will be worth watching how organizations battle it out, and if they make business model innovation and operation excellence, central to their business. The least they should blame is unfair low pricing by competitors or policy bottlenecks for investment. The guy who created disruption in pricing, has already encashed his investment and in any industry, there can not be too many Captain Gopinath; it is time to operate the system more efficiently and effectively, that is where the buck lies. There is no other way, “Take it or leave it”, as my friend Alfred Angula, the mass leader from Namibia says. There are a plenty of ways to improve operations of airlines. But do you have pearl of ideas that seamlessly weave into a business model that can make a successful and unique airline business. And most importantly, it should not only be built to perform profitably today, it must also sustain its superlative performance in future as well. If you look at the performance of Spicejet during the past two years (this year Q1 was a blip), you would get some idea, but I am still not convinced about the future as they ‘buy’ more aircrafts and a large number of aircraft will cause them to get into higher maintenance cost as well as downtime (read B, C and D checks.) and if they are aware of innovating their model. Their last years annual report says that their performance was mainly due to high load factor. And you can very easily understand that load factor is 5 Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.
  • 6. nothing but the utilization, which is a prime operational metric. Spicejet is what it is today, primarily because of operational excellence and the way they opened up their business model ‘one step at a time’. For them cost reduction is not the driver, rather cost effectiveness is inbuilt in the design itself (a la TataSteel). So they do not take knee jerk reaction to worsening situations around. There are three layers the way you drive your revenues ( and Spicejet is not too far in working on them). First Flight Plan- the sector-wise distribution of flights, which comes in the domain of flight planning. Second- Aircraft availability, which is how fast aircraft is turned around in B, C and D check (as of now, because of leased airlines, Spicejet is not facing the burden of D-check on its availability), this is in the domain of operation engineering and maintenance department (MRO). Third –Utilization, which is the load factor, i.e. revenue per available seat kilometre. It is not just these 3 parameters that Spicejet has excelled and is ahead of others, the important point is that, Spicejet did not blindly copy paste any body’s business model. Rather it leveraged advantages of their being new organization and avoided all the disadvantages of the incumbents, which is an inherent characteristics of a successful Startup company. They are just 6 yrs old, and still seem to have the agility in their business model to meet external challenge. The fundamental that organizations somehow miss is that investment in business is done to create value and generate revenue. Without creating enough value with the already invested money, trying to seek more investment is not the way to meet the demand. Look at the operational parameters of full service airlines and look at their operating parameters, they actually have not done justice to their investment. So their call for more investment does not hold water. Keep it simple, organizations are not able to operate as promised. They must first operate the existing business more effectively and efficiently, before they ask for more money and changes in policies. And Rahul is pretty much right in complaining on behalf of stakeholders, for the enormous loss these organizations have caused. So do you see any good movement in the thinking process of other airlines. Let me know if you got any idea, on how Indian airliners need to move ahead. Or wait for a complete business model, when it comes out here. Clet:32-11 6 Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.
  • 7. ___________________________________________________________________ CVMark handholds business leaders in creating organizations that are built to transform. For developing, innovating and executing your business model, call Tel: +91 94480 70081 or Email details to : lolla@cvmark.com . CVMark Consulting, #2304, Nandi Park, Gottegere, Bannergatta Road, Bangalore 560083, INDIA Web: http://www.cvmark.com 7 Copyrights ©2011, CVMark Consulting, All rights reserved.