SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  2
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Bio 103 - Introduction to Biology
                                    Chapter 12: DNA Technology
                                      Extracting DNA from White Onions

Background: DNA is present in the cells of all living organisms. This procedure is designed to extract DNA
from onion in sufficient quantity to be seen and spooled. It is based on the use of household equipment and
supplies.

Materials:
   1. two 4-cup measuring cups (1000 ml) with ml markings if possible
   2. one 1-cup measuring cup (250 ml) with ml markings if possible
   3. measuring spoons
   4. knife for cutting onion
   5. large spoon
   6. thermometer that will measure 60o C (140o F), such as a candy thermometer
   7. strainer or funnel that will fit in a 4-cup measuring cup
   8. #6 coffee filter or cheese cloth
   9. hot tap water bath (60o C)(a 3-quart saucepan works well to hold the water)
   10. ice water bath (a large mixing bowl works well)
   11. distilled water
   12. clear shampoo, such as Suave Daily Clarifying Shampoo
   13. medium sized onion
   14. table salt, either iodized or non-iodized
   15. 1 test tube, preferably with a cap, to contain the onion solution. (A narrow glass container or clear bud
       vase can substitute for the test tube.)
   16. pasteur pipettes or medicine droppers
   17. 95% ethanol (grain alcohol)

Objectives:
   •   to extract DNA from white onions
   •   to view “real” DNA

Procedure:
1.. Set up hot water bath at 55-60o C and an ice water bath.

2. For the onion, make a solution consisting of one tablespoon (10 ml) of liquid dishwashing detergent or
shampoo and one level 1/4 teaspoon (1.5 g) of table salt. Put in a 1-cup measuring cup (250 ml beaker). Add
distilled water to make a final volume of 100 m (10 tablespoons)l. Dissolve the salt by stirring slowly to avoid
foaming.

3. Coarsely chop one large onion with a knife and put the pieces into a 4-cup measuring cup (1000 ml).

4. Cover the onion with the 100 ml of solution from step 2. The detergent dissolves the fatty molecules that hold
the cell membranes together, which releases the DNA into the solution. The detergent, combined with the heat
treatment used in step 5, causes lipids (fatty molecules) and proteins to precipitate out of the solution, leaving the
DNA. The sal enables the DNA strands to come together.
            t

5. Put the measuring cup in a hot water bath at 55-60o C for 10-12 minutes. During this time, press the chopped
onion mixture against the side of the measuring cup with the back of the spoon. Do not keep the mixture in
the hot water bath for more than 15 minutes because the DNA will begin to break down.

6. Cool the mixture in an ice water bath for 5 minutes. During this time, press the chopped onion mixture
against the side of the measuring cup with the back of the spoon.

7. Filter the mixture through a #6 coffee filter placed in a strainer over a 4-cup measuring cup. When pouring
the mixture into the strainer, avoid letting foam get into the measuring cup. It can take more than an hour to
recover most of the liquid. The filtering can be done in a refrigerator overnight. When the solution is removed
from the refrigerator, it should be gently mixed before the test tube is filled.

                                                             1
                                              success = preparation + execution
8. Dispense the onion solution into the test tube. The test tube should contain about 1 teaspoon of solution or
be about 1/3 full, whichever is less.

9. Add cold alcohol to the test tube to create an alcohol layer on top of about 1 cm. For best results, the
alcohol should be as cold as possible.

      The alcohol can be added to the solution in at least three ways.
            (a) Fill a pasteur pipette with alcohol, put it to bottom of the test tube, and release the alcohol.
            (b) Put about 1 cm of alcohol into the bottom of a test tube and add the onion solution.
            (c) Slowly pour the alcohol down the inside of the test tube with a pasteur pipette or medicine
            dropper.

DNA is not soluble in alcohol. When alcohol is added to the mixture, the components of the mixture, except for DNA,
stay in solution while the DNA precipitates out into the alcohol layer.

10. Let the solution sit for 2 to 3 minutes without disturbing it. It is important not to shake the test tube.
You can watch the white DNA precipitate out into the alcohol layer. When good results are obtained, there will
be enough DNA to spool on to a glass rod, a pasteur pipette that has been heated at the tip to form a hook, or
similar device. DNA has the appearance of white mucus.

Analysis:

1. This is a complicated lab. Please describe your trials and tribulations as you experienced them while doing the
lab.


2. Did the DNA appear/look like you thought it would?



3. Would you expect similar results if you substituted liver for the white onion? Why or why not?




                                                            2
                                             success = preparation + execution

Contenu connexe

Tendances

karyotyping Practical Procedure
karyotyping Practical Procedurekaryotyping Practical Procedure
karyotyping Practical ProcedureAsmaraAslam1
 
Trichrome stain procedures
Trichrome stain proceduresTrichrome stain procedures
Trichrome stain proceduresashraf Rajasab
 
Western blot complete protocol
Western blot complete protocolWestern blot complete protocol
Western blot complete protocolSalman Ul Islam
 
Filter Extraction of Heavy Metal & Benzo Pyrene
Filter Extraction of Heavy Metal & Benzo PyreneFilter Extraction of Heavy Metal & Benzo Pyrene
Filter Extraction of Heavy Metal & Benzo PyreneECRD IN
 
Gzb course presentation
Gzb course presentationGzb course presentation
Gzb course presentationECRD2015
 
Preparation of reagents for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIK
Preparation of reagents  for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIKPreparation of reagents  for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIK
Preparation of reagents for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIKImran Nur Manik
 
Dr.Lavanya.S.A - Analytical parameters of kshara kalpana
Dr.Lavanya.S.A -  Analytical parameters of kshara kalpanaDr.Lavanya.S.A -  Analytical parameters of kshara kalpana
Dr.Lavanya.S.A - Analytical parameters of kshara kalpanaDr.Lavanya .S.A
 
Presentation
PresentationPresentation
Presentationjomovie
 
Genomic Dna Isolation From Blood, Bacteria and Plasmid DNA Isolation
Genomic Dna Isolation From Blood, Bacteria and Plasmid DNA IsolationGenomic Dna Isolation From Blood, Bacteria and Plasmid DNA Isolation
Genomic Dna Isolation From Blood, Bacteria and Plasmid DNA IsolationAnkita Gurao
 
Preparation of reagents for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIK
Preparation of reagents  for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIKPreparation of reagents  for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIK
Preparation of reagents for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIKImran Nur Manik
 
DNA extraction method for Plant sample
DNA extraction method for Plant sampleDNA extraction method for Plant sample
DNA extraction method for Plant sampleAhmed Madni
 
DNA EXTRACTION BY SHAISTA AND KANWAL STUDENTS OF MICROBIOLOGY QUAID E AZAM UN...
DNA EXTRACTION BY SHAISTA AND KANWAL STUDENTS OF MICROBIOLOGY QUAID E AZAM UN...DNA EXTRACTION BY SHAISTA AND KANWAL STUDENTS OF MICROBIOLOGY QUAID E AZAM UN...
DNA EXTRACTION BY SHAISTA AND KANWAL STUDENTS OF MICROBIOLOGY QUAID E AZAM UN...shaistakhalid
 
Secondary elements estimation of soil
Secondary elements estimation of soilSecondary elements estimation of soil
Secondary elements estimation of soilAyush Choudhary
 
B. Pharm. (Honours) Part-III Practical, Analytical Pharmacy,MANIK
B. Pharm. (Honours) Part-III Practical, Analytical Pharmacy,MANIKB. Pharm. (Honours) Part-III Practical, Analytical Pharmacy,MANIK
B. Pharm. (Honours) Part-III Practical, Analytical Pharmacy,MANIKImran Nur Manik
 
Lab1 spectrophotometry
Lab1 spectrophotometryLab1 spectrophotometry
Lab1 spectrophotometryCody Taylor
 

Tendances (18)

karyotyping Practical Procedure
karyotyping Practical Procedurekaryotyping Practical Procedure
karyotyping Practical Procedure
 
Trichrome stain procedures
Trichrome stain proceduresTrichrome stain procedures
Trichrome stain procedures
 
Western blot complete protocol
Western blot complete protocolWestern blot complete protocol
Western blot complete protocol
 
Filter Extraction of Heavy Metal & Benzo Pyrene
Filter Extraction of Heavy Metal & Benzo PyreneFilter Extraction of Heavy Metal & Benzo Pyrene
Filter Extraction of Heavy Metal & Benzo Pyrene
 
Gzb course presentation
Gzb course presentationGzb course presentation
Gzb course presentation
 
Preparation of reagents for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIK
Preparation of reagents  for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIKPreparation of reagents  for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIK
Preparation of reagents for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIK
 
Dr.Lavanya.S.A - Analytical parameters of kshara kalpana
Dr.Lavanya.S.A -  Analytical parameters of kshara kalpanaDr.Lavanya.S.A -  Analytical parameters of kshara kalpana
Dr.Lavanya.S.A - Analytical parameters of kshara kalpana
 
Presentation
PresentationPresentation
Presentation
 
Genomic Dna Isolation From Blood, Bacteria and Plasmid DNA Isolation
Genomic Dna Isolation From Blood, Bacteria and Plasmid DNA IsolationGenomic Dna Isolation From Blood, Bacteria and Plasmid DNA Isolation
Genomic Dna Isolation From Blood, Bacteria and Plasmid DNA Isolation
 
Analysis of pollutants
Analysis of pollutantsAnalysis of pollutants
Analysis of pollutants
 
Phage
PhagePhage
Phage
 
Preparation of reagents for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIK
Preparation of reagents  for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIKPreparation of reagents  for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIK
Preparation of reagents for Qualitative analysis of salts MANIK
 
DNA extraction method for Plant sample
DNA extraction method for Plant sampleDNA extraction method for Plant sample
DNA extraction method for Plant sample
 
DNA EXTRACTION BY SHAISTA AND KANWAL STUDENTS OF MICROBIOLOGY QUAID E AZAM UN...
DNA EXTRACTION BY SHAISTA AND KANWAL STUDENTS OF MICROBIOLOGY QUAID E AZAM UN...DNA EXTRACTION BY SHAISTA AND KANWAL STUDENTS OF MICROBIOLOGY QUAID E AZAM UN...
DNA EXTRACTION BY SHAISTA AND KANWAL STUDENTS OF MICROBIOLOGY QUAID E AZAM UN...
 
Secondary elements estimation of soil
Secondary elements estimation of soilSecondary elements estimation of soil
Secondary elements estimation of soil
 
B. Pharm. (Honours) Part-III Practical, Analytical Pharmacy,MANIK
B. Pharm. (Honours) Part-III Practical, Analytical Pharmacy,MANIKB. Pharm. (Honours) Part-III Practical, Analytical Pharmacy,MANIK
B. Pharm. (Honours) Part-III Practical, Analytical Pharmacy,MANIK
 
Caffiene
CaffieneCaffiene
Caffiene
 
Lab1 spectrophotometry
Lab1 spectrophotometryLab1 spectrophotometry
Lab1 spectrophotometry
 

Similaire à C12 Dna Extraction

Chemistry experiments for kids at home
Chemistry experiments for kids at homeChemistry experiments for kids at home
Chemistry experiments for kids at homeBÜCHI Labortechnik AG
 
Chemistry experiments for kids at home
Chemistry experiments for kids at homeChemistry experiments for kids at home
Chemistry experiments for kids at homeBÜCHI Labortechnik AG
 
2 Dna Extraction Lab
2  Dna Extraction Lab2  Dna Extraction Lab
2 Dna Extraction LabBob Smullen
 
Dna Extraction From Wheat Germ
Dna Extraction From Wheat GermDna Extraction From Wheat Germ
Dna Extraction From Wheat GermTeriT
 
Extraction of DNA from human cheek cells
Extraction of DNA from human cheek cellsExtraction of DNA from human cheek cells
Extraction of DNA from human cheek cellsErin Mucci
 
DNA Extraction Lab
DNA Extraction LabDNA Extraction Lab
DNA Extraction Labjfg082
 
Food and health
Food and healthFood and health
Food and healthnaykulap
 
DNA Extration Methods
DNA Extration Methods DNA Extration Methods
DNA Extration Methods RammeharSingh4
 
Abda30bf 44b5-469c-9e7a-823267dcc812 - 3
Abda30bf 44b5-469c-9e7a-823267dcc812 - 3Abda30bf 44b5-469c-9e7a-823267dcc812 - 3
Abda30bf 44b5-469c-9e7a-823267dcc812 - 3JuanPortilla9
 
Strawberry dna extractionlab.docx
Strawberry dna extractionlab.docxStrawberry dna extractionlab.docx
Strawberry dna extractionlab.docxsxl070
 
Carla - afternoon tea
Carla  -  afternoon teaCarla  -  afternoon tea
Carla - afternoon teaMargaRenedo
 
Homemade Natural Personal Care Products - A Guide for Making your own Body Ca...
Homemade Natural Personal Care Products - A Guide for Making your own Body Ca...Homemade Natural Personal Care Products - A Guide for Making your own Body Ca...
Homemade Natural Personal Care Products - A Guide for Making your own Body Ca...v2zq
 
10 Best Tips to Help You Avoid the Coronavirus and Flu While In Quarantine
10 Best Tips to Help You Avoid the Coronavirus and Flu While In Quarantine10 Best Tips to Help You Avoid the Coronavirus and Flu While In Quarantine
10 Best Tips to Help You Avoid the Coronavirus and Flu While In QuarantineTerryClark17
 
Instant Pot Recipes Free Cookbook eBook
Instant Pot Recipes Free Cookbook eBookInstant Pot Recipes Free Cookbook eBook
Instant Pot Recipes Free Cookbook eBookDavid Murphy
 
Hasta la cocina inglés..., 1º eso a elisa palacios moreta
Hasta la cocina inglés..., 1º eso a elisa palacios moretaHasta la cocina inglés..., 1º eso a elisa palacios moreta
Hasta la cocina inglés..., 1º eso a elisa palacios moretaMargaRenedo
 

Similaire à C12 Dna Extraction (20)

Chemistry experiments for kids at home
Chemistry experiments for kids at homeChemistry experiments for kids at home
Chemistry experiments for kids at home
 
Chemistry experiments for kids at home
Chemistry experiments for kids at homeChemistry experiments for kids at home
Chemistry experiments for kids at home
 
2 Dna Extraction Lab
2  Dna Extraction Lab2  Dna Extraction Lab
2 Dna Extraction Lab
 
Dna Extraction From Wheat Germ
Dna Extraction From Wheat GermDna Extraction From Wheat Germ
Dna Extraction From Wheat Germ
 
Dna from a banana lab report
Dna from a banana lab report Dna from a banana lab report
Dna from a banana lab report
 
Dna from a banana lab report
Dna from a banana lab report Dna from a banana lab report
Dna from a banana lab report
 
Extraction of DNA from human cheek cells
Extraction of DNA from human cheek cellsExtraction of DNA from human cheek cells
Extraction of DNA from human cheek cells
 
DNA Extraction Lab
DNA Extraction LabDNA Extraction Lab
DNA Extraction Lab
 
Food and health
Food and healthFood and health
Food and health
 
DNA Extration Methods
DNA Extration Methods DNA Extration Methods
DNA Extration Methods
 
Abda30bf 44b5-469c-9e7a-823267dcc812 - 3
Abda30bf 44b5-469c-9e7a-823267dcc812 - 3Abda30bf 44b5-469c-9e7a-823267dcc812 - 3
Abda30bf 44b5-469c-9e7a-823267dcc812 - 3
 
Strawberry dna extractionlab.docx
Strawberry dna extractionlab.docxStrawberry dna extractionlab.docx
Strawberry dna extractionlab.docx
 
Carla - afternoon tea
Carla  -  afternoon teaCarla  -  afternoon tea
Carla - afternoon tea
 
Isolation of genomic DNA from Bacterial cell.pptx
Isolation of genomic     DNA from Bacterial cell.pptxIsolation of genomic     DNA from Bacterial cell.pptx
Isolation of genomic DNA from Bacterial cell.pptx
 
Homemade Natural Personal Care Products - A Guide for Making your own Body Ca...
Homemade Natural Personal Care Products - A Guide for Making your own Body Ca...Homemade Natural Personal Care Products - A Guide for Making your own Body Ca...
Homemade Natural Personal Care Products - A Guide for Making your own Body Ca...
 
10 Best Tips to Help You Avoid the Coronavirus and Flu While In Quarantine
10 Best Tips to Help You Avoid the Coronavirus and Flu While In Quarantine10 Best Tips to Help You Avoid the Coronavirus and Flu While In Quarantine
10 Best Tips to Help You Avoid the Coronavirus and Flu While In Quarantine
 
Instant Pot Recipes Free Cookbook eBook
Instant Pot Recipes Free Cookbook eBookInstant Pot Recipes Free Cookbook eBook
Instant Pot Recipes Free Cookbook eBook
 
Writing a report
Writing a reportWriting a report
Writing a report
 
Tomato sauce
Tomato sauceTomato sauce
Tomato sauce
 
Hasta la cocina inglés..., 1º eso a elisa palacios moreta
Hasta la cocina inglés..., 1º eso a elisa palacios moretaHasta la cocina inglés..., 1º eso a elisa palacios moreta
Hasta la cocina inglés..., 1º eso a elisa palacios moreta
 

Plus de swalden01

Personal Space
Personal SpacePersonal Space
Personal Spaceswalden01
 
Metriccnvsn2
Metriccnvsn2Metriccnvsn2
Metriccnvsn2swalden01
 
Lab Report Form
Lab Report FormLab Report Form
Lab Report Formswalden01
 
C18 Mark Recapture
C18 Mark RecaptureC18 Mark Recapture
C18 Mark Recaptureswalden01
 
C13 Peppered Moth
C13 Peppered MothC13 Peppered Moth
C13 Peppered Mothswalden01
 
C09 Pedigrees
C09 PedigreesC09 Pedigrees
C09 Pedigreesswalden01
 
C08 Mitosis[1]
C08 Mitosis[1]C08 Mitosis[1]
C08 Mitosis[1]swalden01
 
C07 Chromatography[1]
C07 Chromatography[1]C07 Chromatography[1]
C07 Chromatography[1]swalden01
 
C07 Chromatography
C07 ChromatographyC07 Chromatography
C07 Chromatographyswalden01
 
C06 Food Energy
C06 Food EnergyC06 Food Energy
C06 Food Energyswalden01
 
C05 Demonstrating Diffusion
C05 Demonstrating DiffusionC05 Demonstrating Diffusion
C05 Demonstrating Diffusionswalden01
 
C04 Cell Surface Area
C04 Cell Surface AreaC04 Cell Surface Area
C04 Cell Surface Areaswalden01
 
Plant Phylogeny Lab
Plant Phylogeny LabPlant Phylogeny Lab
Plant Phylogeny Labswalden01
 

Plus de swalden01 (16)

Personal Space
Personal SpacePersonal Space
Personal Space
 
Metriccnvsn2
Metriccnvsn2Metriccnvsn2
Metriccnvsn2
 
Lab Report Form
Lab Report FormLab Report Form
Lab Report Form
 
C18 Mark Recapture
C18 Mark RecaptureC18 Mark Recapture
C18 Mark Recapture
 
C13 Peppered Moth
C13 Peppered MothC13 Peppered Moth
C13 Peppered Moth
 
C09 Pedigrees
C09 PedigreesC09 Pedigrees
C09 Pedigrees
 
C08 Mitosis[1]
C08 Mitosis[1]C08 Mitosis[1]
C08 Mitosis[1]
 
C07 Chromatography[1]
C07 Chromatography[1]C07 Chromatography[1]
C07 Chromatography[1]
 
C07 Chromatography
C07 ChromatographyC07 Chromatography
C07 Chromatography
 
C06 Food Energy
C06 Food EnergyC06 Food Energy
C06 Food Energy
 
C05 Demonstrating Diffusion
C05 Demonstrating DiffusionC05 Demonstrating Diffusion
C05 Demonstrating Diffusion
 
C04 Cell Surface Area
C04 Cell Surface AreaC04 Cell Surface Area
C04 Cell Surface Area
 
C02 P H
C02 P HC02 P H
C02 P H
 
Plant Phylogeny Lab
Plant Phylogeny LabPlant Phylogeny Lab
Plant Phylogeny Lab
 
Bio 127
Bio 127Bio 127
Bio 127
 
Thankyou
ThankyouThankyou
Thankyou
 

C12 Dna Extraction

  • 1. Bio 103 - Introduction to Biology Chapter 12: DNA Technology Extracting DNA from White Onions Background: DNA is present in the cells of all living organisms. This procedure is designed to extract DNA from onion in sufficient quantity to be seen and spooled. It is based on the use of household equipment and supplies. Materials: 1. two 4-cup measuring cups (1000 ml) with ml markings if possible 2. one 1-cup measuring cup (250 ml) with ml markings if possible 3. measuring spoons 4. knife for cutting onion 5. large spoon 6. thermometer that will measure 60o C (140o F), such as a candy thermometer 7. strainer or funnel that will fit in a 4-cup measuring cup 8. #6 coffee filter or cheese cloth 9. hot tap water bath (60o C)(a 3-quart saucepan works well to hold the water) 10. ice water bath (a large mixing bowl works well) 11. distilled water 12. clear shampoo, such as Suave Daily Clarifying Shampoo 13. medium sized onion 14. table salt, either iodized or non-iodized 15. 1 test tube, preferably with a cap, to contain the onion solution. (A narrow glass container or clear bud vase can substitute for the test tube.) 16. pasteur pipettes or medicine droppers 17. 95% ethanol (grain alcohol) Objectives: • to extract DNA from white onions • to view “real” DNA Procedure: 1.. Set up hot water bath at 55-60o C and an ice water bath. 2. For the onion, make a solution consisting of one tablespoon (10 ml) of liquid dishwashing detergent or shampoo and one level 1/4 teaspoon (1.5 g) of table salt. Put in a 1-cup measuring cup (250 ml beaker). Add distilled water to make a final volume of 100 m (10 tablespoons)l. Dissolve the salt by stirring slowly to avoid foaming. 3. Coarsely chop one large onion with a knife and put the pieces into a 4-cup measuring cup (1000 ml). 4. Cover the onion with the 100 ml of solution from step 2. The detergent dissolves the fatty molecules that hold the cell membranes together, which releases the DNA into the solution. The detergent, combined with the heat treatment used in step 5, causes lipids (fatty molecules) and proteins to precipitate out of the solution, leaving the DNA. The sal enables the DNA strands to come together. t 5. Put the measuring cup in a hot water bath at 55-60o C for 10-12 minutes. During this time, press the chopped onion mixture against the side of the measuring cup with the back of the spoon. Do not keep the mixture in the hot water bath for more than 15 minutes because the DNA will begin to break down. 6. Cool the mixture in an ice water bath for 5 minutes. During this time, press the chopped onion mixture against the side of the measuring cup with the back of the spoon. 7. Filter the mixture through a #6 coffee filter placed in a strainer over a 4-cup measuring cup. When pouring the mixture into the strainer, avoid letting foam get into the measuring cup. It can take more than an hour to recover most of the liquid. The filtering can be done in a refrigerator overnight. When the solution is removed from the refrigerator, it should be gently mixed before the test tube is filled. 1 success = preparation + execution
  • 2. 8. Dispense the onion solution into the test tube. The test tube should contain about 1 teaspoon of solution or be about 1/3 full, whichever is less. 9. Add cold alcohol to the test tube to create an alcohol layer on top of about 1 cm. For best results, the alcohol should be as cold as possible. The alcohol can be added to the solution in at least three ways. (a) Fill a pasteur pipette with alcohol, put it to bottom of the test tube, and release the alcohol. (b) Put about 1 cm of alcohol into the bottom of a test tube and add the onion solution. (c) Slowly pour the alcohol down the inside of the test tube with a pasteur pipette or medicine dropper. DNA is not soluble in alcohol. When alcohol is added to the mixture, the components of the mixture, except for DNA, stay in solution while the DNA precipitates out into the alcohol layer. 10. Let the solution sit for 2 to 3 minutes without disturbing it. It is important not to shake the test tube. You can watch the white DNA precipitate out into the alcohol layer. When good results are obtained, there will be enough DNA to spool on to a glass rod, a pasteur pipette that has been heated at the tip to form a hook, or similar device. DNA has the appearance of white mucus. Analysis: 1. This is a complicated lab. Please describe your trials and tribulations as you experienced them while doing the lab. 2. Did the DNA appear/look like you thought it would? 3. Would you expect similar results if you substituted liver for the white onion? Why or why not? 2 success = preparation + execution