SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  13
Sydney M. vanderWal Comprehensive Review May 20, 2011
Taking digital classroom photographs and displaying these photographs of student exploring scientific discoveries is what I do…. But I am not sure if it makes a difference in their cognitive growth.
What I have learned…. 	My Leadership Style     Metacognition    Brain Research and Brain Structures		 	Learning Theories my Favorites are:  		John Dewey, Lev Vygotsky, 		Lave & Wegner 	Science Educational Needs    Science Notebook    	Draw a Scientist Research Applications    Declarative Memory
What I have learned …    Research Methodologies    Visual Literacy     Science Literacy    Organizational Change    Children’s Thinking    Statistics    Mixed Methods    How to Write    This list could go on and on….
Three Research Projects The foundation to where I am as a researcher. Quantitative: Independent Study Qualitative: Phenomenology Mixed Methods: Group Project
Independent Study   Science Literacy Through Declarative Memory One treatment with four levels: science notebooks, digital pictures, science notebooks and pictures, and a control were used to stimulate declarative memory on an post-test 12 weeks after the pre-test was given. Results : No significance, F(3,74) = 2.56, p=.061, partial eta2= .094. Further investigation: Significance was determined within sections of the test.
Qualitative Research Interviews and  Memory Recall with Digital Classroom Photographs One-to-one interviews were administered. Students were asked a specific question, allowed to answer and then shown a digital classroom (personal) photograph and were asked the same question again. Three themes were discovered: digital captures enforce language comprehension,  digital captures stimulate informative thought allowing existing knowledge to be retrievable at a greater depth,  digital captures illustrate what it means to do science transferring personal ownership qualities.
Mixed-Methods ResearchGroup Project The purpose of this mixed-methods dissertation proposal is to refine a nested, fully mixed, sequential, equal status, explanatory mixed-methods research study using digital classroom photographs as the focal point.
Mixed-Methods ResearchGroup Project     Three identical review tests were given to 5th grade students; however, content areas within the test offered different memory priming: classroom digital photographs, generic photographs, and no photographs. Research Questions: 1. 	How does visual priming, with photos of past, personal science experiences, affect students’ recall during science tests as compared to performance on tests without pictures or tests with conceptually related but unfamiliar scenes? 2. 	Does science test performance in 5th graders improve when test items are accompanied by photographs of scenes from those students’ classrooms or from generic classroom scenes? 3. If the photos affect test performance, then how do students use the photos?
Mixed Method ResearchGroup Project Findings      No significant difference was found between scores on test items with classroom photographs, generic photographs, and items without photographs.        However, qualitatively we found that for some students the pictures, both classroom and generic, did seem to positively impact test performance.  These students were overwhelmingly English language learners and disproportionately female.  We found that these students used the pictures in different ways to help them with test responses. A deeper understanding of the characteristics of effective pictures is warranted.  
Proposal: Mixed-Method Research Study  Fourth grade science students will be digitally photographed  during science exploration. These photographs will be applied to half of the unit post-test. Tests will be identical except for digital photographs. Small focus groups, one-to-one interviews and science notebook entries will also be used to help explain the impact of digital photographs. Here a more personal approach (photographs of the student in question) will be used to prime memory recall qualities.
Mixed-Methods Research QuestionProposal  Overarching: How can the themes that emerge from qualitative interviewing data and possible science notebook reflections over digital classroom photographs be used to provide a deeper understanding to the possible impact digital classroom photographs have on declarative memory test scores?  Quantitative: Do digital classroom photographs have an impact on declarative memory recall science assessment scores?    Qualitative: What aspects of small group discussions, one-on-one interviews, and journal entries contribute to explaining the impact of digital classroom photographs?
Conclusion     I am ready! My passion has always been digital classroom photographs and declarative memory recall. But this time I will have learned from my previous research mistakes, and I will be doing research outside my own classroom.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Second Presentation
Second PresentationSecond Presentation
Second Presentationlynn3940
 
1400 lap kichan_videotriggers_1
1400 lap kichan_videotriggers_11400 lap kichan_videotriggers_1
1400 lap kichan_videotriggers_1Tian Stella
 
Second Presentation
Second PresentationSecond Presentation
Second Presentationlynn3940
 
Formative assessment and increased student involvement increases grades in Bi...
Formative assessment and increased student involvement increases grades in Bi...Formative assessment and increased student involvement increases grades in Bi...
Formative assessment and increased student involvement increases grades in Bi...zoogran
 
Literature table june 26
Literature table june 26Literature table june 26
Literature table june 26lsnourse
 
Oral defense presentation_Ennis Brinson
Oral defense presentation_Ennis BrinsonOral defense presentation_Ennis Brinson
Oral defense presentation_Ennis BrinsonEnnis Brinson
 
Querol, Rosales, & Soldner_FINAL
Querol, Rosales, & Soldner_FINALQuerol, Rosales, & Soldner_FINAL
Querol, Rosales, & Soldner_FINALBeatriz Querol
 
Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...
Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...
Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...Matthew Prost
 
Caryn Long - Research Proposal
Caryn Long - Research ProposalCaryn Long - Research Proposal
Caryn Long - Research Proposalnasateach
 
Experimental Research
Experimental ResearchExperimental Research
Experimental Researchhelen0906
 
Experimental Research
Experimental ResearchExperimental Research
Experimental Researchgaoy0906
 
Dissertation defense ppt
Dissertation defense ppt Dissertation defense ppt
Dissertation defense ppt Dr. James Lake
 
Observation without Active Participation is an Effective Method of Learning
Observation without Active Participation is an Effective Method of LearningObservation without Active Participation is an Effective Method of Learning
Observation without Active Participation is an Effective Method of LearningNicholas Kman, MD, FACEP
 
Museums & the Mind I, ASTC 2008
Museums & the Mind I, ASTC 2008Museums & the Mind I, ASTC 2008
Museums & the Mind I, ASTC 2008Jayatri Das
 
Correlation Research
Correlation ResearchCorrelation Research
Correlation Researchdejlight
 
Known knowns & unknown unknowns
Known knowns & unknown unknownsKnown knowns & unknown unknowns
Known knowns & unknown unknownsRoxanne Russell
 
Mobile, Instant, and Electronic Feedback to Increase Participation and Learni...
Mobile, Instant, and Electronic Feedback to Increase Participation and Learni...Mobile, Instant, and Electronic Feedback to Increase Participation and Learni...
Mobile, Instant, and Electronic Feedback to Increase Participation and Learni...Spencer Jardine
 
Correlation Research
Correlation ResearchCorrelation Research
Correlation Researchdejlight
 

Tendances (20)

Second Presentation
Second PresentationSecond Presentation
Second Presentation
 
IRA poster presentation
IRA poster presentationIRA poster presentation
IRA poster presentation
 
1400 lap kichan_videotriggers_1
1400 lap kichan_videotriggers_11400 lap kichan_videotriggers_1
1400 lap kichan_videotriggers_1
 
Second Presentation
Second PresentationSecond Presentation
Second Presentation
 
Formative assessment and increased student involvement increases grades in Bi...
Formative assessment and increased student involvement increases grades in Bi...Formative assessment and increased student involvement increases grades in Bi...
Formative assessment and increased student involvement increases grades in Bi...
 
Literature table june 26
Literature table june 26Literature table june 26
Literature table june 26
 
Oral defense presentation_Ennis Brinson
Oral defense presentation_Ennis BrinsonOral defense presentation_Ennis Brinson
Oral defense presentation_Ennis Brinson
 
Querol, Rosales, & Soldner_FINAL
Querol, Rosales, & Soldner_FINALQuerol, Rosales, & Soldner_FINAL
Querol, Rosales, & Soldner_FINAL
 
Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...
Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...
Research PresentatioThe Effects of Student Assessment Choices on 11th Grade E...
 
Chapter 3
Chapter 3Chapter 3
Chapter 3
 
Caryn Long - Research Proposal
Caryn Long - Research ProposalCaryn Long - Research Proposal
Caryn Long - Research Proposal
 
Experimental Research
Experimental ResearchExperimental Research
Experimental Research
 
Experimental Research
Experimental ResearchExperimental Research
Experimental Research
 
Dissertation defense ppt
Dissertation defense ppt Dissertation defense ppt
Dissertation defense ppt
 
Observation without Active Participation is an Effective Method of Learning
Observation without Active Participation is an Effective Method of LearningObservation without Active Participation is an Effective Method of Learning
Observation without Active Participation is an Effective Method of Learning
 
Museums & the Mind I, ASTC 2008
Museums & the Mind I, ASTC 2008Museums & the Mind I, ASTC 2008
Museums & the Mind I, ASTC 2008
 
Correlation Research
Correlation ResearchCorrelation Research
Correlation Research
 
Known knowns & unknown unknowns
Known knowns & unknown unknownsKnown knowns & unknown unknowns
Known knowns & unknown unknowns
 
Mobile, Instant, and Electronic Feedback to Increase Participation and Learni...
Mobile, Instant, and Electronic Feedback to Increase Participation and Learni...Mobile, Instant, and Electronic Feedback to Increase Participation and Learni...
Mobile, Instant, and Electronic Feedback to Increase Participation and Learni...
 
Correlation Research
Correlation ResearchCorrelation Research
Correlation Research
 

En vedette

TBY Magazine Article 9 6_05
TBY Magazine Article 9 6_05TBY Magazine Article 9 6_05
TBY Magazine Article 9 6_05Denis Rigdon
 
Faith based team mentoring training cd
Faith based team mentoring training cdFaith based team mentoring training cd
Faith based team mentoring training cdDenis Rigdon
 
Presentation to the Community on CBE Progress - August 2010
Presentation to the Community on CBE Progress - August 2010Presentation to the Community on CBE Progress - August 2010
Presentation to the Community on CBE Progress - August 2010yscommunityresources
 
Yellow Springs Business Retention and Expansion Study Presentation
Yellow Springs Business Retention and Expansion Study PresentationYellow Springs Business Retention and Expansion Study Presentation
Yellow Springs Business Retention and Expansion Study Presentationyscommunityresources
 

En vedette (8)

TBY Magazine Article 9 6_05
TBY Magazine Article 9 6_05TBY Magazine Article 9 6_05
TBY Magazine Article 9 6_05
 
We can do better strategic plan
We can do better strategic planWe can do better strategic plan
We can do better strategic plan
 
Lg oep
Lg oepLg oep
Lg oep
 
Concept 08 07
Concept 08 07Concept 08 07
Concept 08 07
 
Faith based team mentoring training cd
Faith based team mentoring training cdFaith based team mentoring training cd
Faith based team mentoring training cd
 
Presentation to the Community on CBE Progress - August 2010
Presentation to the Community on CBE Progress - August 2010Presentation to the Community on CBE Progress - August 2010
Presentation to the Community on CBE Progress - August 2010
 
Yellow Springs Business Retention and Expansion Study Presentation
Yellow Springs Business Retention and Expansion Study PresentationYellow Springs Business Retention and Expansion Study Presentation
Yellow Springs Business Retention and Expansion Study Presentation
 
Presentation to Council on CBE
Presentation to Council on CBEPresentation to Council on CBE
Presentation to Council on CBE
 

Similaire à Comprehensive review ph d

Question 1 By definition, mixed-methods research designsin.docx
Question 1 By definition, mixed-methods research designsin.docxQuestion 1 By definition, mixed-methods research designsin.docx
Question 1 By definition, mixed-methods research designsin.docxmakdul
 
Bornali poster final
Bornali poster finalBornali poster final
Bornali poster finalBornali Kundu
 
Online Video-making Tasks to Motivate Autonomy
Online Video-making Tasks to Motivate AutonomyOnline Video-making Tasks to Motivate Autonomy
Online Video-making Tasks to Motivate AutonomyJorge Zea
 
Micropolitical Behavior of Second Graders: A qualitative study of student Res...
Micropolitical Behavior of Second Graders: A qualitative study of student Res...Micropolitical Behavior of Second Graders: A qualitative study of student Res...
Micropolitical Behavior of Second Graders: A qualitative study of student Res...Jack Frost
 
Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"
Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"
Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"CITE
 
‘‘The Impact Of Intrinsic Motivations On Students Performance At Primary Lev...
‘‘The Impact Of Intrinsic  Motivations On Students Performance At Primary Lev...‘‘The Impact Of Intrinsic  Motivations On Students Performance At Primary Lev...
‘‘The Impact Of Intrinsic Motivations On Students Performance At Primary Lev...Pakistan
 
Chapter 3 homework
Chapter 3 homeworkChapter 3 homework
Chapter 3 homeworkKellyh84
 
Method inquiry proposal
Method inquiry proposalMethod inquiry proposal
Method inquiry proposalAisyah_41
 
2014 ku village presentation pbl ct for participants
2014 ku village presentation   pbl ct for participants2014 ku village presentation   pbl ct for participants
2014 ku village presentation pbl ct for participantsJuleeSPoolePHD
 
ENGAGE MOOC problem solving
ENGAGE MOOC problem solving  ENGAGE MOOC problem solving
ENGAGE MOOC problem solving Alexandra Okada
 
MSUD UG Rsrch Day Apr 2016 - Rsch prnstn UPDATED 4-21-16 v4
MSUD UG Rsrch Day Apr 2016 - Rsch prnstn UPDATED 4-21-16 v4MSUD UG Rsrch Day Apr 2016 - Rsch prnstn UPDATED 4-21-16 v4
MSUD UG Rsrch Day Apr 2016 - Rsch prnstn UPDATED 4-21-16 v4Johnny Sandoval
 
Module 4 application action research
Module 4 application  action researchModule 4 application  action research
Module 4 application action researchLaura Smith
 
Higher order thinking skills question in teaching
Higher order thinking skills question in teachingHigher order thinking skills question in teaching
Higher order thinking skills question in teachingaugust delos santos
 
Brianjdixon Dissertation Defense
Brianjdixon Dissertation DefenseBrianjdixon Dissertation Defense
Brianjdixon Dissertation DefenseBrian Dixon
 

Similaire à Comprehensive review ph d (20)

Cal Research
Cal ResearchCal Research
Cal Research
 
Student Engagement
Student EngagementStudent Engagement
Student Engagement
 
Question 1 By definition, mixed-methods research designsin.docx
Question 1 By definition, mixed-methods research designsin.docxQuestion 1 By definition, mixed-methods research designsin.docx
Question 1 By definition, mixed-methods research designsin.docx
 
Bornali poster final
Bornali poster finalBornali poster final
Bornali poster final
 
Online Video-making Tasks to Motivate Autonomy
Online Video-making Tasks to Motivate AutonomyOnline Video-making Tasks to Motivate Autonomy
Online Video-making Tasks to Motivate Autonomy
 
Jurnal p pt
Jurnal p ptJurnal p pt
Jurnal p pt
 
Micropolitical Behavior of Second Graders: A qualitative study of student Res...
Micropolitical Behavior of Second Graders: A qualitative study of student Res...Micropolitical Behavior of Second Graders: A qualitative study of student Res...
Micropolitical Behavior of Second Graders: A qualitative study of student Res...
 
Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"
Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"
Gobert, Dede, Martin, Rose "Panel: Learning Analytics and Learning Sciences"
 
Making Connections
Making ConnectionsMaking Connections
Making Connections
 
‘‘The Impact Of Intrinsic Motivations On Students Performance At Primary Lev...
‘‘The Impact Of Intrinsic  Motivations On Students Performance At Primary Lev...‘‘The Impact Of Intrinsic  Motivations On Students Performance At Primary Lev...
‘‘The Impact Of Intrinsic Motivations On Students Performance At Primary Lev...
 
Irb jefferson hartman
Irb jefferson hartmanIrb jefferson hartman
Irb jefferson hartman
 
“Discovery with Models”
“Discovery with Models”“Discovery with Models”
“Discovery with Models”
 
Chapter 3 homework
Chapter 3 homeworkChapter 3 homework
Chapter 3 homework
 
Method inquiry proposal
Method inquiry proposalMethod inquiry proposal
Method inquiry proposal
 
2014 ku village presentation pbl ct for participants
2014 ku village presentation   pbl ct for participants2014 ku village presentation   pbl ct for participants
2014 ku village presentation pbl ct for participants
 
ENGAGE MOOC problem solving
ENGAGE MOOC problem solving  ENGAGE MOOC problem solving
ENGAGE MOOC problem solving
 
MSUD UG Rsrch Day Apr 2016 - Rsch prnstn UPDATED 4-21-16 v4
MSUD UG Rsrch Day Apr 2016 - Rsch prnstn UPDATED 4-21-16 v4MSUD UG Rsrch Day Apr 2016 - Rsch prnstn UPDATED 4-21-16 v4
MSUD UG Rsrch Day Apr 2016 - Rsch prnstn UPDATED 4-21-16 v4
 
Module 4 application action research
Module 4 application  action researchModule 4 application  action research
Module 4 application action research
 
Higher order thinking skills question in teaching
Higher order thinking skills question in teachingHigher order thinking skills question in teaching
Higher order thinking skills question in teaching
 
Brianjdixon Dissertation Defense
Brianjdixon Dissertation DefenseBrianjdixon Dissertation Defense
Brianjdixon Dissertation Defense
 

Comprehensive review ph d

  • 1. Sydney M. vanderWal Comprehensive Review May 20, 2011
  • 2. Taking digital classroom photographs and displaying these photographs of student exploring scientific discoveries is what I do…. But I am not sure if it makes a difference in their cognitive growth.
  • 3. What I have learned…. My Leadership Style Metacognition Brain Research and Brain Structures Learning Theories my Favorites are: John Dewey, Lev Vygotsky, Lave & Wegner Science Educational Needs Science Notebook Draw a Scientist Research Applications Declarative Memory
  • 4. What I have learned … Research Methodologies Visual Literacy Science Literacy Organizational Change Children’s Thinking Statistics Mixed Methods How to Write This list could go on and on….
  • 5. Three Research Projects The foundation to where I am as a researcher. Quantitative: Independent Study Qualitative: Phenomenology Mixed Methods: Group Project
  • 6. Independent Study Science Literacy Through Declarative Memory One treatment with four levels: science notebooks, digital pictures, science notebooks and pictures, and a control were used to stimulate declarative memory on an post-test 12 weeks after the pre-test was given. Results : No significance, F(3,74) = 2.56, p=.061, partial eta2= .094. Further investigation: Significance was determined within sections of the test.
  • 7. Qualitative Research Interviews and Memory Recall with Digital Classroom Photographs One-to-one interviews were administered. Students were asked a specific question, allowed to answer and then shown a digital classroom (personal) photograph and were asked the same question again. Three themes were discovered: digital captures enforce language comprehension, digital captures stimulate informative thought allowing existing knowledge to be retrievable at a greater depth, digital captures illustrate what it means to do science transferring personal ownership qualities.
  • 8. Mixed-Methods ResearchGroup Project The purpose of this mixed-methods dissertation proposal is to refine a nested, fully mixed, sequential, equal status, explanatory mixed-methods research study using digital classroom photographs as the focal point.
  • 9. Mixed-Methods ResearchGroup Project Three identical review tests were given to 5th grade students; however, content areas within the test offered different memory priming: classroom digital photographs, generic photographs, and no photographs. Research Questions: 1. How does visual priming, with photos of past, personal science experiences, affect students’ recall during science tests as compared to performance on tests without pictures or tests with conceptually related but unfamiliar scenes? 2. Does science test performance in 5th graders improve when test items are accompanied by photographs of scenes from those students’ classrooms or from generic classroom scenes? 3. If the photos affect test performance, then how do students use the photos?
  • 10. Mixed Method ResearchGroup Project Findings No significant difference was found between scores on test items with classroom photographs, generic photographs, and items without photographs.   However, qualitatively we found that for some students the pictures, both classroom and generic, did seem to positively impact test performance.  These students were overwhelmingly English language learners and disproportionately female.  We found that these students used the pictures in different ways to help them with test responses. A deeper understanding of the characteristics of effective pictures is warranted.  
  • 11. Proposal: Mixed-Method Research Study Fourth grade science students will be digitally photographed during science exploration. These photographs will be applied to half of the unit post-test. Tests will be identical except for digital photographs. Small focus groups, one-to-one interviews and science notebook entries will also be used to help explain the impact of digital photographs. Here a more personal approach (photographs of the student in question) will be used to prime memory recall qualities.
  • 12. Mixed-Methods Research QuestionProposal Overarching: How can the themes that emerge from qualitative interviewing data and possible science notebook reflections over digital classroom photographs be used to provide a deeper understanding to the possible impact digital classroom photographs have on declarative memory test scores? Quantitative: Do digital classroom photographs have an impact on declarative memory recall science assessment scores? Qualitative: What aspects of small group discussions, one-on-one interviews, and journal entries contribute to explaining the impact of digital classroom photographs?
  • 13. Conclusion I am ready! My passion has always been digital classroom photographs and declarative memory recall. But this time I will have learned from my previous research mistakes, and I will be doing research outside my own classroom.