More Related Content
Similar to EHR Qualities Semantic Interoperability Privacy - Gerard Freriks
Similar to EHR Qualities Semantic Interoperability Privacy - Gerard Freriks (13)
More from Wydział ds. eZdrowia, Departament Polityki Zdrowotnej, Urząd Marszałkowski w Łodzi
More from Wydział ds. eZdrowia, Departament Polityki Zdrowotnej, Urząd Marszałkowski w Łodzi (20)
EHR Qualities Semantic Interoperability Privacy - Gerard Freriks
- 1. EHR-Qᵀᴺ Polska 2012
EHR Qualities
Semantic Interoperability
Privacy
(Lodz, 29 November 2012)
Gerard Freriks
Gerard Freriks. ERS B.V. © ERS 2012
- 2. "It's the economy, stupid"
• Slight variation of the phrase "The economy, stupid"
which James Carville had coined
as a campaign strategist of Bill Clinton's successful 1992 presidential
campaign
against sitting president George H. W. Bush.
• Carville's original phrase was meant for
the internal audience of Clinton's campaign workers
as one of the three messages to focus on,
the other two messages being:
• "Change vs. more of the same"
and
• "Don't forget health care"
2
© ERS 2012
- 4. MIE2012-Village of the Future
• Point on the horizon
–All must communicate
–Now and in the future
–How? It is the semantics stupid!
Blue Line
4
© ERS 2012
- 5. Topics
- What is the EHR?
- Semantic Interoperability
the Semantic Interoperability Stack
- Data and Information: Interoperability
Privacy
- Standards for Semantic Interoperability
- International Developments
- National/regional Governance
Quality Assurance
- Conclusions
© ERS 2012
- 7. I- Bakery
Kitchen
Instructions Ingredients Moulds Oven Pastry
machines
7
© ERS B.V.
- 8. I- Bakery
Kitchen
Instructions Ingredients Moulds Oven Pastry
machines
Rules Information Presentation Software Hardware EHR
8
© ERS B.V.
- 9. I- Bakery
Kitchen
Instructions Ingredients Moulds Oven Pastry
machines
Rules Information Presentation Software Hardware EHR
9
© ERS B.V.
- 10. Instruction Ingredients Moulds Kitchen tools Oven Pastry
Rules Information Presentation Software Hardware EHR
10
© ERS 2012
- 13. EHR and Privacy
ACL
Trust
ACL
Flexibility
It is the Semantics stupid!
ACL
Patient Mandate
ACL ACL ACL
Author and
Patient
controlled
13
© ERS 2012
- 14. Health Information Security
450.000 records not secured
Names, Date of Birth, addresses, telephone
numbers, Patient ID, Governmental ID
14
© ERS B.V.
- 15. Health Information Security
What is needed:
–Deploy top to bottom in each organisation
– ISO 27799:2008 Health informatics
Information security management in health using ISO/IEC 27002
–Treat health software and the development of it
as a medical device
–Deploy 13606 EHR Communication 15
© ERS B.V.
- 16. Health Information Security
CEN/ISO 13606 EHR Communication
–No patient identifiable data in the Record
–Each data object carries the Patient Mandate
(who has access to what kind of data)
16
© ERS B.V.
- 17. 13606-4 Patient Mandate
CEN/ISO 13606-4 TS: Security
–is a profile of the
• ISO 22600
• Privilege Management and Access Control
17
© ERS B.V.
- 24. Semantic
Interoperability
Stack
Common
Trusted
Facilities
Semantic Interoperability
© ERS 2012
- 25. Semantic
Interoperability
Stack HL7
EHR
v3, CDA
Extract
RIM
Common
Facilities
Documentation Documentation
Archiving Archiving
Semantic Interoperability
25
© ERS 2012
- 26. Semantic
Interoperability
Stack
Semantic Interoperability Levels
Semantic Stack
26
© ERS 2012
- 27. Semantic
Interoperability
Stack
Semantic Interoperability Levels
FP7-SemanticHealth Project
27
© ERS 2012
- 28. Standards
Enterprise CEN/tc251
System of Concepts for EHR-systems
viewpoint
Continuity of Care
using
Information HL7
CEN/tc251
viewpoint EN13606 EHRcom
Information Bus All viewpoints
Computation programmed in
viewpoint CEN/tc251 Health one system or
Health Information Services
Architecture message
Engineering
viewpoint
Technical
viewpoint
© ERS 2012
- 29. Standards
Message based Archetype based
EHR-systems EHR-systems
Production of
1-3 years Minutes
message
IHE process 1-2 years nil
Programming 1-2 years nil
Roll Out 1 year nil
Total YEARS MINUTES
© ERS 2012
- 30. CEN/ISO13606
Standard
Reference Model
Archetype Object Model
Term List
Patient Mandate
EHR-extract exchange
© ERS 2012
- 31. CEN/ISO13606
Standard Coding systems
Archetypes
Templates
Rules
Patient mandates
EN13606-2 Tools
Software
EN13606-1 Tools
Services
© ERS 2012
- 33. Semantic
Interoperability Stack
Model for Knowledge Encyclopedia
SNOMED
WHO
Loinc Model of Meaning Dictionary
SIAMS Models of General Use Generic Phrases
CEN/ISO 13606-3 Models of Specific Use Specific Phrases
CEN/ISO 13606-2
CEN/ISO 13606-1 Models of Archiving ‘Syntax’
Models of Storage Database Schema
33
© ERS 2012
- 34. International
Developments
- Renewal CEN/ISO 13606
- Integration of 13606 with:
- System of Concepts for Continuity of Care (ContSys CEN/ISO 13940)
- Health Information Services Architecture (HISA CEN/ISO 12967)
- Harmonisation with HL7 CDA
- FP7 SemanticHealthNet
(make 13606, CDA, coding systems and ontologies work together)
http://www.eurorec.org/RD/SemanticHealthNet.cfm
- Clinical Information Modeling Initiative
http://informatics.mayo.edu/CIMI/index.php/Main_Page
- New FP7 2013 call:
- epSOS EU-USA, Semantic Interoperability EU-USA, ...
© ERS 2012
- 39. (Inter-)National Governance
INFOstructure
Direction
Healthcare
Patients
Stanardisation organisations
Ontology / Coding systems
Clinical Information Models
Providers
(Inter-) National Project
Government
Local Communities
Insurers
Re-Users of data
IT- Vendors
Quality Assurance
© ERS 2012
- 40. (Inter-)National Governance
Direction
(Inter-) National Project
Healthcare
Clinical Information
Patients
Ontology / Coding
Providers
Stanardisation
organisations
Government
systems
Insurers
Local Communities
Models
Re-Users of data
IT- Vendors
Quality Assurance
• Essential elements
–All actors co-operating in their natural role
–Direction based on expertise, knowledge and authority. Not too much money.
–One standing (virtual) organisation)
–With ongoing secured funding. The INFOstructure is not a one time project.
© ERS 2012
- 41. (Inter-)National Governance
Direction
(Inter-) National Project
Healthcare
Clinical Information
Patients
Ontology / Coding
Providers
Stanardisation
organisations
Government
systems
Insurers Local Communities
Models
Re-Users of data
IT- Vendors
Quality Assurance
INFOSTRUCTURE
–Production, Maintenance, Publication of all semantic interoperability artefacts is very
resource intensive (money and expertise)
–Even big countries can not create a full Semantic Stack on their own
–European countries (and more) had better co-operate and provide jointly the
resources needed
© ERS 2012
- 42. (Inter-)National Governance
Direction
(Inter-) National Project
Healthcare
Clinical Information
Patients
Ontology / Coding
Providers
Stanardisation
organisations
Government
systems
Insurers Local Communities
Models
Re-Users of data
IT- Vendors
Quality Assurance
INFOSTRUCTURE
Ongoing projects
–SemanticHealthNet (SHN)
–Clinical Information Modeling Initiative (CIMI)
–...
© ERS 2012
- 43. (Inter-)National Governance
Direction
(Inter-) National Project
Healthcare
Clinical Information
Patients
Ontology / Coding
Providers
Stanardisation
organisations
Government
systems
Insurers Local Communities
Models
Re-Users of data
IT- Vendors
Quality Assurance
© ERS 2012
- 44. Conclusions
1. No semantic interoperability without the
Semantic Stack
2. Base standards, Coding systems and
Ontologies constitute the Semantic Stack
3. Using Base Standards
profiles/archetypes/templates
define the clinical statements
4. The Patient Mandate is an integral part
of Interoperability
© ERS 2012