SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  40
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
University of Sydney
           COCO-CHAI-LATTE Joint Seminar



    Orchestrating collaborative
technology-enhanced ecosystems:
How to support teachers with conceptual and
            technological tools
             Prof. Yannis Dimitriadis
           GSIC/EMIC research group
             University of Valladolid
                  May 30, 2012
     Based on work by L.P. Prieto – S. Villagrá
TEL/CSCL ecosystem




                     2
Outline
s   The two hats of this seminar
s   Hat 1: Conceptual tools
     s A framework on orchestration
     s Multi-level patterns as mediating tools
s   Hat 2: Technological tools for
     s Learning design
     s Flexible deployment




                                                 3
The two hats of this seminar
s   Personal
     s Engineering background + Interest in education
s   Audience (and associated drinks …)
     s CHAI-LATTE and CoCo
s   TEL research
     s sound pedagogy + efficient engineering
s   Quest for sustainable innovation
     s good research for understanding, abstraction and
       evidence
     s effective support to actors – teachers, learners or
       even service and technology providers            4
The two hats of GSIC/EMIC
 s   “Dark and bright side” in a group since 1994




 s   Focus on CSCL: complex and innovative
 s   Support real-world actors and own action-research
 s   Inquiry cycle (design-enactment-evaluation) for
      s teaching/learning and technological support
                                                    5
Hat 1: Conceptual tools

s   Analyze and understand the field of orchestration in
    complex TEL ecosystems
     s The “5+3 aspects” framework for orchestration


s   Collect and use knowledge in terms of good
    practices during the CSCL cycle
     s Multi-level patterns




                                                       6
Orchestration: Moving target
s   Increasing presence in literature, but what is it
    about? Is there a new focus?




s   Efforts to define the field/concept/metaphor:
     s Stellar NoE deliverable, CSCL 2011 and ICLS
       2012 workshops, collective paper
     s New proposal for “5+3” orchestration framework
       and validation through expert panel          7
Focus of orchestration on …
s   Acknowledge complex ecosystems for innovative
    TEL/CSCL environments
s   Support teachers as orchestrators (and think of how
    to minimize-distribute the orchestration load on
    teachers, learners and systems)
s   Build on pragmatism and minimalism as keys for
    sustainability
s   Explicit emphasis on how to flexibly manage
    (learning time) enactment
s   Design for adequate orchestrating and orchestrable
    technologies (and conceptual tools)
                                                     8
The “5+3” framework
A diagramatic view




http://prezi.com/aa2vighak7hh/orchestration-in-tel-cscl-as-easy-as-53/
                                                                     9
The “5+3” framework
A process view




                      10
Evaluating the framework
The setup
s   Research questions on
     s Completeness of common understanding
     s Usefulness for researchers
s   Two panels (March – May 2012)
     s Pilot phase: 22 Spanish researchers of low-
       medium expertise (2.58) and more technological
       profile (16T-7E-1M)
     s International panel: 24 researchers of medium-
       high expertise (4,46), high research experience
       in TEL (15,8 years), more balanced profile
       (6T-11E-7M)
                                                    11
Completeness of framework
s   Quantitative and qualitative data
s   Non-normative and inclusive
s   Need to clarify role of actors, technology, theory
s   More than 4,5 (Lickert scale of 1-6) for all items
s   Logical: 4,78 –Comprehensive: 4,52 –Relevant: 5,13




                                                    12
Usefulness of framework
s   To be referenced in papers, checklist and didactic
    tool for young researchers
s   But need for normative advice and real-world
    examples
s   Will be used in future (4.43)




s   Provided new insights (4.17)

                                                         13
Multi-level patterns
s   But the “5+3” Orchestration framework is a
    conceptual tool mainly for researchers
s   Tools (conceptual or technological) for orchestration
    should also support “teachers”
     s Exploiting articulated (design) knowledge
s   (Pedagogical) patterns as mediating tools regarding
    various orchestration aspects
     s Design and Management of learning flow,
       Assessment, Adaptation …
s   Related fields of
     s Learning Design, Educational Modeling, Scripting
                                                       14
Collaborative Learning Flow
and assessment patterns
s   Learning Flow



s   Assessment




                              15
Aligning both sets of patterns




                                 16
Usefulness of patterns
s   Are these patterns useful for practitioners?
     s Evidence for learning flow patterns for OER
       repurposing to collaborative activities
     s Appropriation in University (Higher Education –
       HE) teachers (Professional Development - PD)
       workshops
s   But not always
     s If not included in appropriate technological tools
     s Too complex (abstract) for (Primary Education –
       PE) practitioners
     s Do not take into account enactment issues
                                                        17
The need for atomic patterns
 s   Two independent studies by GSIC and SRI using
     GroupScribbles in Primary and Secondary Education
     schools (2008-2011)
 s   Studying enactment and disciplined improvisation
 s   Showed that other small-scale, informal, contextual,
     actionable patterns emerged




                                                     18
A learning design in action
in a Primary Education classroom




                                   19
Using atomic patterns
in a HE PD workshop




                        20
Atomic patterns
as mediating conceptual tools
s   And we need to “fill the gap”, “flesh the bones” with
    appropriate mediating artifacts (conceptual tools)




                                                       21
Evaluation of atomic patterns
in PD workshops
s   Four (2 in PE, 2 in HE) PD workshops (2010-2011)
s   WS4 data quantitative data (scale 1 to 7):
     s Enactment patterns useful (5,31)
     s Feasibility (5,22) and nearness (6,06)
     s 19 out of 22 teachers enriched design
s   Useful but not revolutionary
s   Especially important for non-experienced or pre-
    service teachers
s   Need to condense and classify long list of AP
s   What about inclusion in technological tools?
                                                   22
Approach for multi-level patterns
s   And the way to elicit and use multi-level patterns




                                                         23
Hat 1: Wrap-up
s   Knowledge regarding orchestration for researchers:
     s “3+5 Aspects” framework
     s Approach for multi-level patterns
     s Atomic pattern catalogue and LD representation
s   Support teachers too with conceptual tools:
     s Classroom norms for participation, discourse
       moves for discussion, decision rules for
       contingent teaching (SRI)
     s Multi-level patterns
     s Use in PD workshops Role playing and learning
       design enrichment using cards (GSIC)          24
Hat 2: Technological tools
s   But TEL is not only about
     s Conceptual tools (patterns, moves, …)
s   It is also about
     s enacting learning in TEL complex ecosystems
     s especially in HE distributed learning
        environments where VLE/PLE are combined with
        third-party tools
s    And also support teachers (and learners) with
    technological tools when
     s orchestrating TEL/CSCL ecosystems (less
        orchestration load for teachers – more for tools)
                                                        25
Learning Design tools
s   Articulate/exploit the knowledge of patterns and
    support the learning design process
s   Create a model or representation of a learning
    design (unit of learning, script, scenario, etc.)
     s That allows understanding and reflecting on the
       pedagogy, making the learning design explicit,
       sharing it with others
s   Through the Web Collage tool
s   Or other Learning tools by the Stellar Learning
    Design Grid Theme Team
           http://www.ld-grid.org/home
                                                     26
Web Collage:
Learning & Assessment flows


         Students                          Teacher
     Select and work
                                       Support individual
     individually in a
                                            work
       subproblem

        Write activity    input for…      Review
           report                         report


     Work in expert
      Work expert
   groups of students
    groups students         provide     Support expert
      with the same
      with     same       feedback…      group work
       subproblem
       subproblem



   Form Jigsaw groups
    and explain each                    Support jigsaw
    other the different                  group work
      subproblems

                                                                  27
                                 http://pandora.tel.uva.es/wic2
A learning design
(HE teacher in a PD workshop)




                                28
Web Collage:
Evolution and evaluation
s   Evolution of the Collage tool since 2005
     s Towards a more stable and user-friendly Web-
       based tool that includes learning and assessment
       patterns, as well as support for instantiation
s   Extensive use and evaluation using mixed methods
     s Multi-case studies in authentic settings and PD
       workshops with HE teachers
     s Wide acceptance of the pattern-based design
       process


                                                     29
The deployment gap

s   But teachers wanted to complete the cycle
     s deploy their design in their TEL environment,
       especially their institutional VLE (e.g. Moodle)




                                                          30
Alternatives for deployment

s   Have the learning design “in mind” and then go
    through the VLE/PLE interface and struggle to
    “translate” the design to a course/lesson plan
s   Use a single system (LAMS) to do both design and
    deployment in the same environment
s   Use an LD Tool (LDSE) to create the interpretable
    script and then deploy it to one environment
s   But there are many LD tools and VLEs:
     s Provide intermediary to connect them: Glue!-PS

                                                    31
Glue!-PS
An architectural view




                        32
Glue!-PS:
A functional view




                    33
Glue!-PS
Validation
s   Proof of concept validations using the Planet Game
    (ICALT 2006) scenario
     s Two LD languages: LDL + IMS-LD
     s Two Learning Environments: Moodle +
       MediaWiki
s   Design and deployment
     s by GSIC researchers of 36 learning designs
       created using pen and paper at two HE PD
       workshops (Sep-Nov 2011)
     s by 24 teachers in a follow-up PD workshop (Feb
       2012)
                                                     34
Glue!-PS and atomic patterns
s   Atomic patterns are especially important for flexible
    orchestration
s   University teachers suggested embedding atomic
    patterns in technological tools
s   Initial evidence of use in Glue!-PS
     s Implementation of a subset of atomic patterns
       without architectural changes as e.g.
         s AP: Spontaneous use of additional IT
         s Actions: Add and synchronize in real-time
           resources in an activity
     s Feasibility evidence in 2 cases (Mar-Apr 2012)
                                                       35
Hat 2: Wrap-up
s   Technological tools to support orchestration
s   Patterns (that reflect good educational practices)
    guide a flexible design and deployment process
s   Glue!-PS allows to bridge the deployment gap in
    distributed learning environments
     s time-efficient and less error-prone
     s allows sustainable migration to new VLE and
       connection to various LD tools
s   More naturalistic evaluation is necessary
s   Important role of PD workshops for innovation and
    feedback to research                               36
Hat 2 (cont.): More tools to …
s   Regulate through monitoring and the detection of
    critical aspects of the learning designs (GLUE!-CAS)
s   Find and select appropriate tools and include them
    in learning designs (SEEK)
s   Integrate third-party tools in learning designs
    directly through the VLE interface (GLUE!)
s   Design evaluation of CSCL case studies and
    generate multimedia reports (CSCL-EREM)
s   ….


                                                      37
Hats 1 and 2: wrap-up
s   Support bits and pieces but also the complete cycle
    of orchestration
     s flexibly and sustainably
s   Design for orchestration to show added value of
    TEL
     s innovative pedagogies using old and new
       technologies
s   Integrate conceptual and technological tools for
     s researchers, teachers and students



                                                     38
And many open questions
s   Do researchers need an orchestration theory and
    framework and should it be normative?
s   Is the proposed approach for pattern elicitation
    sustainable? (crowd-sourcing ….)
s   How can we support co-orchestration with students
    and integrate efficiently PLE?
s   How various (Web, 3D worlds, augmented physical)
    spaces can be orchestrated?
s   Is there a way to solve the ethical and security
    problems that are involved?
s   …
                                                   39
Some links
s   Publications
     s http://www.gsic.uva.es/public.php?lang=en&list_pu
s   GSIC/EMIC channel at YouTube:
     s http://www.youtube.com/user/gsicemic?
       feature=watch
s   WS on orchestration at ICLS2012 (July 3)
     s https://sites.google.com/site/iclsorchestration2012/




                                                      40

Contenu connexe

Tendances

PhD Thesis: Operationalization of Collaborative Blended Learning Scripts
PhD Thesis: Operationalization of Collaborative Blended Learning ScriptsPhD Thesis: Operationalization of Collaborative Blended Learning Scripts
PhD Thesis: Operationalization of Collaborative Blended Learning ScriptsMar Pérez-Sanagustín
 
Problem Solving Protocols
Problem Solving ProtocolsProblem Solving Protocols
Problem Solving Protocolsigualproject
 
Asld2011 dimitriadis prieto_villagrá-sobrin
Asld2011 dimitriadis prieto_villagrá-sobrinAsld2011 dimitriadis prieto_villagrá-sobrin
Asld2011 dimitriadis prieto_villagrá-sobrinYishay Mor
 
Online peer assessment: an exploratory case study in a higher education civil...
Online peer assessment: an exploratory case study in a higher education civil...Online peer assessment: an exploratory case study in a higher education civil...
Online peer assessment: an exploratory case study in a higher education civil...Gonçalo Cruz Matos
 

Tendances (6)

PhD Thesis: Operationalization of Collaborative Blended Learning Scripts
PhD Thesis: Operationalization of Collaborative Blended Learning ScriptsPhD Thesis: Operationalization of Collaborative Blended Learning Scripts
PhD Thesis: Operationalization of Collaborative Blended Learning Scripts
 
Problem Solving Protocols
Problem Solving ProtocolsProblem Solving Protocols
Problem Solving Protocols
 
Asld2011 dimitriadis prieto_villagrá-sobrin
Asld2011 dimitriadis prieto_villagrá-sobrinAsld2011 dimitriadis prieto_villagrá-sobrin
Asld2011 dimitriadis prieto_villagrá-sobrin
 
Seminar On PISA
Seminar On PISASeminar On PISA
Seminar On PISA
 
OU 2011
OU 2011OU 2011
OU 2011
 
Online peer assessment: an exploratory case study in a higher education civil...
Online peer assessment: an exploratory case study in a higher education civil...Online peer assessment: an exploratory case study in a higher education civil...
Online peer assessment: an exploratory case study in a higher education civil...
 

En vedette

Alternative Pyramid-based scenario
Alternative Pyramid-based scenarioAlternative Pyramid-based scenario
Alternative Pyramid-based scenarioYannis
 
Gsic@decl icls2012 20120701
Gsic@decl icls2012 20120701Gsic@decl icls2012 20120701
Gsic@decl icls2012 20120701Yannis
 
Worksheet of deploying a learning design produced by Web Collage in Moodle
Worksheet of deploying a learning design produced by Web Collage in MoodleWorksheet of deploying a learning design produced by Web Collage in Moodle
Worksheet of deploying a learning design produced by Web Collage in MoodleYannis
 
The pyramid pedagogical pattern and a sample associated educational scenario
The pyramid pedagogical pattern and a sample associated educational scenario The pyramid pedagogical pattern and a sample associated educational scenario
The pyramid pedagogical pattern and a sample associated educational scenario Yannis
 
Yannis@brisbane cipl seminar_workshop_20120716
Yannis@brisbane cipl seminar_workshop_20120716Yannis@brisbane cipl seminar_workshop_20120716
Yannis@brisbane cipl seminar_workshop_20120716Yannis
 
Deployment of a learning design produced by Web Collage at a Moolde VLE
Deployment of a learning design produced by Web Collage at a Moolde VLEDeployment of a learning design produced by Web Collage at a Moolde VLE
Deployment of a learning design produced by Web Collage at a Moolde VLEYannis
 
emadrid_dimtiriadis_orchestration_20130215
emadrid_dimtiriadis_orchestration_20130215emadrid_dimtiriadis_orchestration_20130215
emadrid_dimtiriadis_orchestration_20130215Yannis
 

En vedette (8)

Alternative Pyramid-based scenario
Alternative Pyramid-based scenarioAlternative Pyramid-based scenario
Alternative Pyramid-based scenario
 
Gsic@decl icls2012 20120701
Gsic@decl icls2012 20120701Gsic@decl icls2012 20120701
Gsic@decl icls2012 20120701
 
Worksheet of deploying a learning design produced by Web Collage in Moodle
Worksheet of deploying a learning design produced by Web Collage in MoodleWorksheet of deploying a learning design produced by Web Collage in Moodle
Worksheet of deploying a learning design produced by Web Collage in Moodle
 
The pyramid pedagogical pattern and a sample associated educational scenario
The pyramid pedagogical pattern and a sample associated educational scenario The pyramid pedagogical pattern and a sample associated educational scenario
The pyramid pedagogical pattern and a sample associated educational scenario
 
Yannis@brisbane cipl seminar_workshop_20120716
Yannis@brisbane cipl seminar_workshop_20120716Yannis@brisbane cipl seminar_workshop_20120716
Yannis@brisbane cipl seminar_workshop_20120716
 
Deployment of a learning design produced by Web Collage at a Moolde VLE
Deployment of a learning design produced by Web Collage at a Moolde VLEDeployment of a learning design produced by Web Collage at a Moolde VLE
Deployment of a learning design produced by Web Collage at a Moolde VLE
 
emadrid_dimtiriadis_orchestration_20130215
emadrid_dimtiriadis_orchestration_20130215emadrid_dimtiriadis_orchestration_20130215
emadrid_dimtiriadis_orchestration_20130215
 
7 cs update
7 cs update7 cs update
7 cs update
 

Similaire à Orchestrating collaborative technology-enhanced ecosystems: How to support teachers with conceptual and technological tools

yannis@collabtech_20221110_final.pptx
yannis@collabtech_20221110_final.pptxyannis@collabtech_20221110_final.pptx
yannis@collabtech_20221110_final.pptxYannis
 
Yannis@chili 20171211b
Yannis@chili 20171211bYannis@chili 20171211b
Yannis@chili 20171211bYannis
 
Patterns, approaches and systems to support teachers in designing for technol...
Patterns, approaches and systems to support teachers in designing fortechnol...Patterns, approaches and systems to support teachers in designing fortechnol...
Patterns, approaches and systems to support teachers in designing for technol...Yannis
 
Yannis Dimitriadis: Interweaving learning and assessment patterns in CSCL scr...
Yannis Dimitriadis: Interweaving learning and assessment patterns in CSCL scr...Yannis Dimitriadis: Interweaving learning and assessment patterns in CSCL scr...
Yannis Dimitriadis: Interweaving learning and assessment patterns in CSCL scr...Yishay Mor
 
Yannis@etpe2017 20170421b
Yannis@etpe2017 20170421bYannis@etpe2017 20170421b
Yannis@etpe2017 20170421bYannis
 
Papanikolaou Karkanis - Pre-service Teacher Training in Technology Enhanced L...
Papanikolaou Karkanis - Pre-service Teacher Training in Technology Enhanced L...Papanikolaou Karkanis - Pre-service Teacher Training in Technology Enhanced L...
Papanikolaou Karkanis - Pre-service Teacher Training in Technology Enhanced L...VocTEL Conference
 
Overview of C-SAP open educational resources project
Overview of C-SAP open educational resources projectOverview of C-SAP open educational resources project
Overview of C-SAP open educational resources projectCSAPOER
 
C-SAP e-learning forum: Overview of Open Educational Resources project
C-SAP e-learning forum: Overview of Open Educational Resources projectC-SAP e-learning forum: Overview of Open Educational Resources project
C-SAP e-learning forum: Overview of Open Educational Resources projectCSAPSubjectCentre
 
Dimitriadis Et Al Ascilite 7 Dec
Dimitriadis Et Al Ascilite 7 DecDimitriadis Et Al Ascilite 7 Dec
Dimitriadis Et Al Ascilite 7 Decgrainne
 
Analysing and supporting the process of co-designing inquiry-based and techno...
Analysing and supporting the process of co-designing inquiry-based and techno...Analysing and supporting the process of co-designing inquiry-based and techno...
Analysing and supporting the process of co-designing inquiry-based and techno...musart
 
ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024
ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024
ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024EADTU
 
Asld2011 kali ronen-fuhrman
Asld2011 kali ronen-fuhrmanAsld2011 kali ronen-fuhrman
Asld2011 kali ronen-fuhrmanYishay Mor
 
JISC Curriculum Design Cluster C meeting
JISC Curriculum Design Cluster C meetingJISC Curriculum Design Cluster C meeting
JISC Curriculum Design Cluster C meetinggrainne
 
Prog mtg 2010 helen outputs
Prog mtg 2010 helen outputsProg mtg 2010 helen outputs
Prog mtg 2010 helen outputscurricsupport
 
Learning design making sense of collaborative knowledge building in the messy...
Learning design making sense of collaborative knowledge building in the messy...Learning design making sense of collaborative knowledge building in the messy...
Learning design making sense of collaborative knowledge building in the messy...LeRoy Hill
 
The critical role of teachers in optimizing technologies for open learning
The critical role of teachers in optimizing technologies for open learningThe critical role of teachers in optimizing technologies for open learning
The critical role of teachers in optimizing technologies for open learningalanwylie
 
Can web 2.0 help us share learning designs?
Can web 2.0 help us share learning designs?Can web 2.0 help us share learning designs?
Can web 2.0 help us share learning designs?sheilatest
 
Constructing a Learner Centric Semantic Syllabus for Automatic Text Book Gen...
Constructing a Learner Centric Semantic Syllabus for Automatic Text Book Gen...Constructing a Learner Centric Semantic Syllabus for Automatic Text Book Gen...
Constructing a Learner Centric Semantic Syllabus for Automatic Text Book Gen...Aliabbas Petiwala
 

Similaire à Orchestrating collaborative technology-enhanced ecosystems: How to support teachers with conceptual and technological tools (20)

yannis@collabtech_20221110_final.pptx
yannis@collabtech_20221110_final.pptxyannis@collabtech_20221110_final.pptx
yannis@collabtech_20221110_final.pptx
 
Yannis@chili 20171211b
Yannis@chili 20171211bYannis@chili 20171211b
Yannis@chili 20171211b
 
Patterns, approaches and systems to support teachers in designing for technol...
Patterns, approaches and systems to support teachers in designing fortechnol...Patterns, approaches and systems to support teachers in designing fortechnol...
Patterns, approaches and systems to support teachers in designing for technol...
 
Yannis Dimitriadis: Interweaving learning and assessment patterns in CSCL scr...
Yannis Dimitriadis: Interweaving learning and assessment patterns in CSCL scr...Yannis Dimitriadis: Interweaving learning and assessment patterns in CSCL scr...
Yannis Dimitriadis: Interweaving learning and assessment patterns in CSCL scr...
 
Yannis@etpe2017 20170421b
Yannis@etpe2017 20170421bYannis@etpe2017 20170421b
Yannis@etpe2017 20170421b
 
Papanikolaou Karkanis - Pre-service Teacher Training in Technology Enhanced L...
Papanikolaou Karkanis - Pre-service Teacher Training in Technology Enhanced L...Papanikolaou Karkanis - Pre-service Teacher Training in Technology Enhanced L...
Papanikolaou Karkanis - Pre-service Teacher Training in Technology Enhanced L...
 
Inside Out
Inside OutInside Out
Inside Out
 
Overview of C-SAP open educational resources project
Overview of C-SAP open educational resources projectOverview of C-SAP open educational resources project
Overview of C-SAP open educational resources project
 
C-SAP e-learning forum: Overview of Open Educational Resources project
C-SAP e-learning forum: Overview of Open Educational Resources projectC-SAP e-learning forum: Overview of Open Educational Resources project
C-SAP e-learning forum: Overview of Open Educational Resources project
 
Design for learning
Design for learningDesign for learning
Design for learning
 
Dimitriadis Et Al Ascilite 7 Dec
Dimitriadis Et Al Ascilite 7 DecDimitriadis Et Al Ascilite 7 Dec
Dimitriadis Et Al Ascilite 7 Dec
 
Analysing and supporting the process of co-designing inquiry-based and techno...
Analysing and supporting the process of co-designing inquiry-based and techno...Analysing and supporting the process of co-designing inquiry-based and techno...
Analysing and supporting the process of co-designing inquiry-based and techno...
 
ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024
ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024
ENCORE Workshop Webinar 26 February 2024
 
Asld2011 kali ronen-fuhrman
Asld2011 kali ronen-fuhrmanAsld2011 kali ronen-fuhrman
Asld2011 kali ronen-fuhrman
 
JISC Curriculum Design Cluster C meeting
JISC Curriculum Design Cluster C meetingJISC Curriculum Design Cluster C meeting
JISC Curriculum Design Cluster C meeting
 
Prog mtg 2010 helen outputs
Prog mtg 2010 helen outputsProg mtg 2010 helen outputs
Prog mtg 2010 helen outputs
 
Learning design making sense of collaborative knowledge building in the messy...
Learning design making sense of collaborative knowledge building in the messy...Learning design making sense of collaborative knowledge building in the messy...
Learning design making sense of collaborative knowledge building in the messy...
 
The critical role of teachers in optimizing technologies for open learning
The critical role of teachers in optimizing technologies for open learningThe critical role of teachers in optimizing technologies for open learning
The critical role of teachers in optimizing technologies for open learning
 
Can web 2.0 help us share learning designs?
Can web 2.0 help us share learning designs?Can web 2.0 help us share learning designs?
Can web 2.0 help us share learning designs?
 
Constructing a Learner Centric Semantic Syllabus for Automatic Text Book Gen...
Constructing a Learner Centric Semantic Syllabus for Automatic Text Book Gen...Constructing a Learner Centric Semantic Syllabus for Automatic Text Book Gen...
Constructing a Learner Centric Semantic Syllabus for Automatic Text Book Gen...
 

Plus de Yannis

Human-Centered Learning Analytics and Artificial Intelligence in Education: H...
Human-Centered Learning Analytics and Artificial Intelligence in Education: H...Human-Centered Learning Analytics and Artificial Intelligence in Education: H...
Human-Centered Learning Analytics and Artificial Intelligence in Education: H...Yannis
 
yannis@its2022_20220701_final.pptx
yannis@its2022_20220701_final.pptxyannis@its2022_20220701_final.pptx
yannis@its2022_20220701_final.pptxYannis
 
DigiReady+ Implementando un marco basado en datos para medir la preparación ...
DigiReady+ Implementando un marco basado en datos para medir la preparación ...DigiReady+ Implementando un marco basado en datos para medir la preparación ...
DigiReady+ Implementando un marco basado en datos para medir la preparación ...Yannis
 
yannis@jtelss_20220605_final.pptx
yannis@jtelss_20220605_final.pptxyannis@jtelss_20220605_final.pptx
yannis@jtelss_20220605_final.pptxYannis
 
yannis@gu_20221027.pptx
yannis@gu_20221027.pptxyannis@gu_20221027.pptx
yannis@gu_20221027.pptxYannis
 
Yannis@lala2020 20201002
Yannis@lala2020 20201002Yannis@lala2020 20201002
Yannis@lala2020 20201002Yannis
 
Yannis@ascilite 20200908 final
Yannis@ascilite 20200908 finalYannis@ascilite 20200908 final
Yannis@ascilite 20200908 finalYannis
 
Yannis@csedu 20200504 final
Yannis@csedu 20200504 finalYannis@csedu 20200504 final
Yannis@csedu 20200504 finalYannis
 
Yannis@patras seminar a_20150512a
Yannis@patras seminar a_20150512aYannis@patras seminar a_20150512a
Yannis@patras seminar a_20150512aYannis
 
Implementing the Pyramid-based educational scenario using Web Collage: Works...
Implementing the Pyramid-based educational scenario using Web Collage: Works...Implementing the Pyramid-based educational scenario using Web Collage: Works...
Implementing the Pyramid-based educational scenario using Web Collage: Works...Yannis
 
Presentation of the Web Collage tool
Presentation of the Web Collage toolPresentation of the Web Collage tool
Presentation of the Web Collage toolYannis
 
Alternative pyramid-based scenario (simplified version)
Alternative pyramid-based scenario (simplified version)Alternative pyramid-based scenario (simplified version)
Alternative pyramid-based scenario (simplified version)Yannis
 
EEE: The UVA view
EEE: The UVA viewEEE: The UVA view
EEE: The UVA viewYannis
 
EEE project summary
EEE project summaryEEE project summary
EEE project summaryYannis
 
Yannis s11@valladolid ws_20111114
Yannis s11@valladolid ws_20111114Yannis s11@valladolid ws_20111114
Yannis s11@valladolid ws_20111114Yannis
 
Cadmos review dimitriadis_20111014
Cadmos review dimitriadis_20111014Cadmos review dimitriadis_20111014
Cadmos review dimitriadis_20111014Yannis
 

Plus de Yannis (16)

Human-Centered Learning Analytics and Artificial Intelligence in Education: H...
Human-Centered Learning Analytics and Artificial Intelligence in Education: H...Human-Centered Learning Analytics and Artificial Intelligence in Education: H...
Human-Centered Learning Analytics and Artificial Intelligence in Education: H...
 
yannis@its2022_20220701_final.pptx
yannis@its2022_20220701_final.pptxyannis@its2022_20220701_final.pptx
yannis@its2022_20220701_final.pptx
 
DigiReady+ Implementando un marco basado en datos para medir la preparación ...
DigiReady+ Implementando un marco basado en datos para medir la preparación ...DigiReady+ Implementando un marco basado en datos para medir la preparación ...
DigiReady+ Implementando un marco basado en datos para medir la preparación ...
 
yannis@jtelss_20220605_final.pptx
yannis@jtelss_20220605_final.pptxyannis@jtelss_20220605_final.pptx
yannis@jtelss_20220605_final.pptx
 
yannis@gu_20221027.pptx
yannis@gu_20221027.pptxyannis@gu_20221027.pptx
yannis@gu_20221027.pptx
 
Yannis@lala2020 20201002
Yannis@lala2020 20201002Yannis@lala2020 20201002
Yannis@lala2020 20201002
 
Yannis@ascilite 20200908 final
Yannis@ascilite 20200908 finalYannis@ascilite 20200908 final
Yannis@ascilite 20200908 final
 
Yannis@csedu 20200504 final
Yannis@csedu 20200504 finalYannis@csedu 20200504 final
Yannis@csedu 20200504 final
 
Yannis@patras seminar a_20150512a
Yannis@patras seminar a_20150512aYannis@patras seminar a_20150512a
Yannis@patras seminar a_20150512a
 
Implementing the Pyramid-based educational scenario using Web Collage: Works...
Implementing the Pyramid-based educational scenario using Web Collage: Works...Implementing the Pyramid-based educational scenario using Web Collage: Works...
Implementing the Pyramid-based educational scenario using Web Collage: Works...
 
Presentation of the Web Collage tool
Presentation of the Web Collage toolPresentation of the Web Collage tool
Presentation of the Web Collage tool
 
Alternative pyramid-based scenario (simplified version)
Alternative pyramid-based scenario (simplified version)Alternative pyramid-based scenario (simplified version)
Alternative pyramid-based scenario (simplified version)
 
EEE: The UVA view
EEE: The UVA viewEEE: The UVA view
EEE: The UVA view
 
EEE project summary
EEE project summaryEEE project summary
EEE project summary
 
Yannis s11@valladolid ws_20111114
Yannis s11@valladolid ws_20111114Yannis s11@valladolid ws_20111114
Yannis s11@valladolid ws_20111114
 
Cadmos review dimitriadis_20111014
Cadmos review dimitriadis_20111014Cadmos review dimitriadis_20111014
Cadmos review dimitriadis_20111014
 

Dernier

Prescribed medication order and communication skills.pptx
Prescribed medication order and communication skills.pptxPrescribed medication order and communication skills.pptx
Prescribed medication order and communication skills.pptxraviapr7
 
Vani Magazine - Quarterly Magazine of Seshadripuram Educational Trust
Vani Magazine - Quarterly Magazine of Seshadripuram Educational TrustVani Magazine - Quarterly Magazine of Seshadripuram Educational Trust
Vani Magazine - Quarterly Magazine of Seshadripuram Educational TrustSavipriya Raghavendra
 
Over the counter (OTC)- Sale, rational use.pptx
Over the counter (OTC)- Sale, rational use.pptxOver the counter (OTC)- Sale, rational use.pptx
Over the counter (OTC)- Sale, rational use.pptxraviapr7
 
3.21.24 The Origins of Black Power.pptx
3.21.24  The Origins of Black Power.pptx3.21.24  The Origins of Black Power.pptx
3.21.24 The Origins of Black Power.pptxmary850239
 
Department of Health Compounder Question ‍Solution 2022.pdf
Department of Health Compounder Question ‍Solution 2022.pdfDepartment of Health Compounder Question ‍Solution 2022.pdf
Department of Health Compounder Question ‍Solution 2022.pdfMohonDas
 
3.26.24 Race, the Draft, and the Vietnam War.pptx
3.26.24 Race, the Draft, and the Vietnam War.pptx3.26.24 Race, the Draft, and the Vietnam War.pptx
3.26.24 Race, the Draft, and the Vietnam War.pptxmary850239
 
KARNAADA.pptx made by - saransh dwivedi ( SD ) - SHALAKYA TANTRA - ENT - 4...
KARNAADA.pptx  made by -  saransh dwivedi ( SD ) -  SHALAKYA TANTRA - ENT - 4...KARNAADA.pptx  made by -  saransh dwivedi ( SD ) -  SHALAKYA TANTRA - ENT - 4...
KARNAADA.pptx made by - saransh dwivedi ( SD ) - SHALAKYA TANTRA - ENT - 4...M56BOOKSTORE PRODUCT/SERVICE
 
Protein Structure - threading Protein modelling pptx
Protein Structure - threading Protein modelling pptxProtein Structure - threading Protein modelling pptx
Protein Structure - threading Protein modelling pptxvidhisharma994099
 
How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17
How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17
How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17Celine George
 
Work Experience for psp3 portfolio sasha
Work Experience for psp3 portfolio sashaWork Experience for psp3 portfolio sasha
Work Experience for psp3 portfolio sashasashalaycock03
 
What is the Future of QuickBooks DeskTop?
What is the Future of QuickBooks DeskTop?What is the Future of QuickBooks DeskTop?
What is the Future of QuickBooks DeskTop?TechSoup
 
Education and training program in the hospital APR.pptx
Education and training program in the hospital APR.pptxEducation and training program in the hospital APR.pptx
Education and training program in the hospital APR.pptxraviapr7
 
Unveiling the Intricacies of Leishmania donovani: Structure, Life Cycle, Path...
Unveiling the Intricacies of Leishmania donovani: Structure, Life Cycle, Path...Unveiling the Intricacies of Leishmania donovani: Structure, Life Cycle, Path...
Unveiling the Intricacies of Leishmania donovani: Structure, Life Cycle, Path...Dr. Asif Anas
 
The Stolen Bacillus by Herbert George Wells
The Stolen Bacillus by Herbert George WellsThe Stolen Bacillus by Herbert George Wells
The Stolen Bacillus by Herbert George WellsEugene Lysak
 
DUST OF SNOW_BY ROBERT FROST_EDITED BY_ TANMOY MISHRA
DUST OF SNOW_BY ROBERT FROST_EDITED BY_ TANMOY MISHRADUST OF SNOW_BY ROBERT FROST_EDITED BY_ TANMOY MISHRA
DUST OF SNOW_BY ROBERT FROST_EDITED BY_ TANMOY MISHRATanmoy Mishra
 
EBUS5423 Data Analytics and Reporting Bl
EBUS5423 Data Analytics and Reporting BlEBUS5423 Data Analytics and Reporting Bl
EBUS5423 Data Analytics and Reporting BlDr. Bruce A. Johnson
 
Diploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdf
Diploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdfDiploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdf
Diploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdfMohonDas
 
CapTechU Doctoral Presentation -March 2024 slides.pptx
CapTechU Doctoral Presentation -March 2024 slides.pptxCapTechU Doctoral Presentation -March 2024 slides.pptx
CapTechU Doctoral Presentation -March 2024 slides.pptxCapitolTechU
 
Slides CapTechTalks Webinar March 2024 Joshua Sinai.pptx
Slides CapTechTalks Webinar March 2024 Joshua Sinai.pptxSlides CapTechTalks Webinar March 2024 Joshua Sinai.pptx
Slides CapTechTalks Webinar March 2024 Joshua Sinai.pptxCapitolTechU
 

Dernier (20)

Prescribed medication order and communication skills.pptx
Prescribed medication order and communication skills.pptxPrescribed medication order and communication skills.pptx
Prescribed medication order and communication skills.pptx
 
Vani Magazine - Quarterly Magazine of Seshadripuram Educational Trust
Vani Magazine - Quarterly Magazine of Seshadripuram Educational TrustVani Magazine - Quarterly Magazine of Seshadripuram Educational Trust
Vani Magazine - Quarterly Magazine of Seshadripuram Educational Trust
 
Over the counter (OTC)- Sale, rational use.pptx
Over the counter (OTC)- Sale, rational use.pptxOver the counter (OTC)- Sale, rational use.pptx
Over the counter (OTC)- Sale, rational use.pptx
 
3.21.24 The Origins of Black Power.pptx
3.21.24  The Origins of Black Power.pptx3.21.24  The Origins of Black Power.pptx
3.21.24 The Origins of Black Power.pptx
 
Department of Health Compounder Question ‍Solution 2022.pdf
Department of Health Compounder Question ‍Solution 2022.pdfDepartment of Health Compounder Question ‍Solution 2022.pdf
Department of Health Compounder Question ‍Solution 2022.pdf
 
3.26.24 Race, the Draft, and the Vietnam War.pptx
3.26.24 Race, the Draft, and the Vietnam War.pptx3.26.24 Race, the Draft, and the Vietnam War.pptx
3.26.24 Race, the Draft, and the Vietnam War.pptx
 
KARNAADA.pptx made by - saransh dwivedi ( SD ) - SHALAKYA TANTRA - ENT - 4...
KARNAADA.pptx  made by -  saransh dwivedi ( SD ) -  SHALAKYA TANTRA - ENT - 4...KARNAADA.pptx  made by -  saransh dwivedi ( SD ) -  SHALAKYA TANTRA - ENT - 4...
KARNAADA.pptx made by - saransh dwivedi ( SD ) - SHALAKYA TANTRA - ENT - 4...
 
Protein Structure - threading Protein modelling pptx
Protein Structure - threading Protein modelling pptxProtein Structure - threading Protein modelling pptx
Protein Structure - threading Protein modelling pptx
 
How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17
How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17
How to Show Error_Warning Messages in Odoo 17
 
Work Experience for psp3 portfolio sasha
Work Experience for psp3 portfolio sashaWork Experience for psp3 portfolio sasha
Work Experience for psp3 portfolio sasha
 
March 2024 Directors Meeting, Division of Student Affairs and Academic Support
March 2024 Directors Meeting, Division of Student Affairs and Academic SupportMarch 2024 Directors Meeting, Division of Student Affairs and Academic Support
March 2024 Directors Meeting, Division of Student Affairs and Academic Support
 
What is the Future of QuickBooks DeskTop?
What is the Future of QuickBooks DeskTop?What is the Future of QuickBooks DeskTop?
What is the Future of QuickBooks DeskTop?
 
Education and training program in the hospital APR.pptx
Education and training program in the hospital APR.pptxEducation and training program in the hospital APR.pptx
Education and training program in the hospital APR.pptx
 
Unveiling the Intricacies of Leishmania donovani: Structure, Life Cycle, Path...
Unveiling the Intricacies of Leishmania donovani: Structure, Life Cycle, Path...Unveiling the Intricacies of Leishmania donovani: Structure, Life Cycle, Path...
Unveiling the Intricacies of Leishmania donovani: Structure, Life Cycle, Path...
 
The Stolen Bacillus by Herbert George Wells
The Stolen Bacillus by Herbert George WellsThe Stolen Bacillus by Herbert George Wells
The Stolen Bacillus by Herbert George Wells
 
DUST OF SNOW_BY ROBERT FROST_EDITED BY_ TANMOY MISHRA
DUST OF SNOW_BY ROBERT FROST_EDITED BY_ TANMOY MISHRADUST OF SNOW_BY ROBERT FROST_EDITED BY_ TANMOY MISHRA
DUST OF SNOW_BY ROBERT FROST_EDITED BY_ TANMOY MISHRA
 
EBUS5423 Data Analytics and Reporting Bl
EBUS5423 Data Analytics and Reporting BlEBUS5423 Data Analytics and Reporting Bl
EBUS5423 Data Analytics and Reporting Bl
 
Diploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdf
Diploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdfDiploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdf
Diploma in Nursing Admission Test Question Solution 2023.pdf
 
CapTechU Doctoral Presentation -March 2024 slides.pptx
CapTechU Doctoral Presentation -March 2024 slides.pptxCapTechU Doctoral Presentation -March 2024 slides.pptx
CapTechU Doctoral Presentation -March 2024 slides.pptx
 
Slides CapTechTalks Webinar March 2024 Joshua Sinai.pptx
Slides CapTechTalks Webinar March 2024 Joshua Sinai.pptxSlides CapTechTalks Webinar March 2024 Joshua Sinai.pptx
Slides CapTechTalks Webinar March 2024 Joshua Sinai.pptx
 

Orchestrating collaborative technology-enhanced ecosystems: How to support teachers with conceptual and technological tools

  • 1. University of Sydney COCO-CHAI-LATTE Joint Seminar Orchestrating collaborative technology-enhanced ecosystems: How to support teachers with conceptual and technological tools Prof. Yannis Dimitriadis GSIC/EMIC research group University of Valladolid May 30, 2012 Based on work by L.P. Prieto – S. Villagrá
  • 3. Outline s The two hats of this seminar s Hat 1: Conceptual tools s A framework on orchestration s Multi-level patterns as mediating tools s Hat 2: Technological tools for s Learning design s Flexible deployment 3
  • 4. The two hats of this seminar s Personal s Engineering background + Interest in education s Audience (and associated drinks …) s CHAI-LATTE and CoCo s TEL research s sound pedagogy + efficient engineering s Quest for sustainable innovation s good research for understanding, abstraction and evidence s effective support to actors – teachers, learners or even service and technology providers 4
  • 5. The two hats of GSIC/EMIC s “Dark and bright side” in a group since 1994 s Focus on CSCL: complex and innovative s Support real-world actors and own action-research s Inquiry cycle (design-enactment-evaluation) for s teaching/learning and technological support 5
  • 6. Hat 1: Conceptual tools s Analyze and understand the field of orchestration in complex TEL ecosystems s The “5+3 aspects” framework for orchestration s Collect and use knowledge in terms of good practices during the CSCL cycle s Multi-level patterns 6
  • 7. Orchestration: Moving target s Increasing presence in literature, but what is it about? Is there a new focus? s Efforts to define the field/concept/metaphor: s Stellar NoE deliverable, CSCL 2011 and ICLS 2012 workshops, collective paper s New proposal for “5+3” orchestration framework and validation through expert panel 7
  • 8. Focus of orchestration on … s Acknowledge complex ecosystems for innovative TEL/CSCL environments s Support teachers as orchestrators (and think of how to minimize-distribute the orchestration load on teachers, learners and systems) s Build on pragmatism and minimalism as keys for sustainability s Explicit emphasis on how to flexibly manage (learning time) enactment s Design for adequate orchestrating and orchestrable technologies (and conceptual tools) 8
  • 9. The “5+3” framework A diagramatic view http://prezi.com/aa2vighak7hh/orchestration-in-tel-cscl-as-easy-as-53/ 9
  • 10. The “5+3” framework A process view 10
  • 11. Evaluating the framework The setup s Research questions on s Completeness of common understanding s Usefulness for researchers s Two panels (March – May 2012) s Pilot phase: 22 Spanish researchers of low- medium expertise (2.58) and more technological profile (16T-7E-1M) s International panel: 24 researchers of medium- high expertise (4,46), high research experience in TEL (15,8 years), more balanced profile (6T-11E-7M) 11
  • 12. Completeness of framework s Quantitative and qualitative data s Non-normative and inclusive s Need to clarify role of actors, technology, theory s More than 4,5 (Lickert scale of 1-6) for all items s Logical: 4,78 –Comprehensive: 4,52 –Relevant: 5,13 12
  • 13. Usefulness of framework s To be referenced in papers, checklist and didactic tool for young researchers s But need for normative advice and real-world examples s Will be used in future (4.43) s Provided new insights (4.17) 13
  • 14. Multi-level patterns s But the “5+3” Orchestration framework is a conceptual tool mainly for researchers s Tools (conceptual or technological) for orchestration should also support “teachers” s Exploiting articulated (design) knowledge s (Pedagogical) patterns as mediating tools regarding various orchestration aspects s Design and Management of learning flow, Assessment, Adaptation … s Related fields of s Learning Design, Educational Modeling, Scripting 14
  • 15. Collaborative Learning Flow and assessment patterns s Learning Flow s Assessment 15
  • 16. Aligning both sets of patterns 16
  • 17. Usefulness of patterns s Are these patterns useful for practitioners? s Evidence for learning flow patterns for OER repurposing to collaborative activities s Appropriation in University (Higher Education – HE) teachers (Professional Development - PD) workshops s But not always s If not included in appropriate technological tools s Too complex (abstract) for (Primary Education – PE) practitioners s Do not take into account enactment issues 17
  • 18. The need for atomic patterns s Two independent studies by GSIC and SRI using GroupScribbles in Primary and Secondary Education schools (2008-2011) s Studying enactment and disciplined improvisation s Showed that other small-scale, informal, contextual, actionable patterns emerged 18
  • 19. A learning design in action in a Primary Education classroom 19
  • 20. Using atomic patterns in a HE PD workshop 20
  • 21. Atomic patterns as mediating conceptual tools s And we need to “fill the gap”, “flesh the bones” with appropriate mediating artifacts (conceptual tools) 21
  • 22. Evaluation of atomic patterns in PD workshops s Four (2 in PE, 2 in HE) PD workshops (2010-2011) s WS4 data quantitative data (scale 1 to 7): s Enactment patterns useful (5,31) s Feasibility (5,22) and nearness (6,06) s 19 out of 22 teachers enriched design s Useful but not revolutionary s Especially important for non-experienced or pre- service teachers s Need to condense and classify long list of AP s What about inclusion in technological tools? 22
  • 23. Approach for multi-level patterns s And the way to elicit and use multi-level patterns 23
  • 24. Hat 1: Wrap-up s Knowledge regarding orchestration for researchers: s “3+5 Aspects” framework s Approach for multi-level patterns s Atomic pattern catalogue and LD representation s Support teachers too with conceptual tools: s Classroom norms for participation, discourse moves for discussion, decision rules for contingent teaching (SRI) s Multi-level patterns s Use in PD workshops Role playing and learning design enrichment using cards (GSIC) 24
  • 25. Hat 2: Technological tools s But TEL is not only about s Conceptual tools (patterns, moves, …) s It is also about s enacting learning in TEL complex ecosystems s especially in HE distributed learning environments where VLE/PLE are combined with third-party tools s And also support teachers (and learners) with technological tools when s orchestrating TEL/CSCL ecosystems (less orchestration load for teachers – more for tools) 25
  • 26. Learning Design tools s Articulate/exploit the knowledge of patterns and support the learning design process s Create a model or representation of a learning design (unit of learning, script, scenario, etc.) s That allows understanding and reflecting on the pedagogy, making the learning design explicit, sharing it with others s Through the Web Collage tool s Or other Learning tools by the Stellar Learning Design Grid Theme Team http://www.ld-grid.org/home 26
  • 27. Web Collage: Learning & Assessment flows Students Teacher Select and work Support individual individually in a work subproblem Write activity input for… Review report report Work in expert Work expert groups of students groups students provide Support expert with the same with same feedback… group work subproblem subproblem Form Jigsaw groups and explain each Support jigsaw other the different group work subproblems 27 http://pandora.tel.uva.es/wic2
  • 28. A learning design (HE teacher in a PD workshop) 28
  • 29. Web Collage: Evolution and evaluation s Evolution of the Collage tool since 2005 s Towards a more stable and user-friendly Web- based tool that includes learning and assessment patterns, as well as support for instantiation s Extensive use and evaluation using mixed methods s Multi-case studies in authentic settings and PD workshops with HE teachers s Wide acceptance of the pattern-based design process 29
  • 30. The deployment gap s But teachers wanted to complete the cycle s deploy their design in their TEL environment, especially their institutional VLE (e.g. Moodle) 30
  • 31. Alternatives for deployment s Have the learning design “in mind” and then go through the VLE/PLE interface and struggle to “translate” the design to a course/lesson plan s Use a single system (LAMS) to do both design and deployment in the same environment s Use an LD Tool (LDSE) to create the interpretable script and then deploy it to one environment s But there are many LD tools and VLEs: s Provide intermediary to connect them: Glue!-PS 31
  • 34. Glue!-PS Validation s Proof of concept validations using the Planet Game (ICALT 2006) scenario s Two LD languages: LDL + IMS-LD s Two Learning Environments: Moodle + MediaWiki s Design and deployment s by GSIC researchers of 36 learning designs created using pen and paper at two HE PD workshops (Sep-Nov 2011) s by 24 teachers in a follow-up PD workshop (Feb 2012) 34
  • 35. Glue!-PS and atomic patterns s Atomic patterns are especially important for flexible orchestration s University teachers suggested embedding atomic patterns in technological tools s Initial evidence of use in Glue!-PS s Implementation of a subset of atomic patterns without architectural changes as e.g. s AP: Spontaneous use of additional IT s Actions: Add and synchronize in real-time resources in an activity s Feasibility evidence in 2 cases (Mar-Apr 2012) 35
  • 36. Hat 2: Wrap-up s Technological tools to support orchestration s Patterns (that reflect good educational practices) guide a flexible design and deployment process s Glue!-PS allows to bridge the deployment gap in distributed learning environments s time-efficient and less error-prone s allows sustainable migration to new VLE and connection to various LD tools s More naturalistic evaluation is necessary s Important role of PD workshops for innovation and feedback to research 36
  • 37. Hat 2 (cont.): More tools to … s Regulate through monitoring and the detection of critical aspects of the learning designs (GLUE!-CAS) s Find and select appropriate tools and include them in learning designs (SEEK) s Integrate third-party tools in learning designs directly through the VLE interface (GLUE!) s Design evaluation of CSCL case studies and generate multimedia reports (CSCL-EREM) s …. 37
  • 38. Hats 1 and 2: wrap-up s Support bits and pieces but also the complete cycle of orchestration s flexibly and sustainably s Design for orchestration to show added value of TEL s innovative pedagogies using old and new technologies s Integrate conceptual and technological tools for s researchers, teachers and students 38
  • 39. And many open questions s Do researchers need an orchestration theory and framework and should it be normative? s Is the proposed approach for pattern elicitation sustainable? (crowd-sourcing ….) s How can we support co-orchestration with students and integrate efficiently PLE? s How various (Web, 3D worlds, augmented physical) spaces can be orchestrated? s Is there a way to solve the ethical and security problems that are involved? s … 39
  • 40. Some links s Publications s http://www.gsic.uva.es/public.php?lang=en&list_pu s GSIC/EMIC channel at YouTube: s http://www.youtube.com/user/gsicemic? feature=watch s WS on orchestration at ICLS2012 (July 3) s https://sites.google.com/site/iclsorchestration2012/ 40

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. Special thanks to Luis Palblo Prieto (doctoral student) and Juan Ignacio Asensio (co-director), Sara Villagrá (doctoral student) and Iván Manuel Jorrín (director) from the Technology and Education “divisions” of GSIC respectively.
  2. Complex TEL/CSCL ecosystems Multiple tasks activities, multiple social levels, multiple tools How can we manage them and survive (ina sustainable way!), especially the teachers?
  3. Technology-enhanced classrooms or distributed learning environments are becoming increasingly complex ecosystems, which may include VLEs, Web 2.0 tools, 3D worlds, or tangible artifacts, either digital or not. In CSCL environments, multiple social planes are involved in multiple teaching and learning activities that may take place using multiple devices or tools. Orchestration of such collaborative ecosystems is challenging, since it may require creation and flexible deployment of learning designs or real-time class monitoring and management. This seminar presents a view of conceptual and technological tools that may support teachers in orchestrating CSCL classes. Different aspects of orchestration will be discussed focusing on design and atomic enactment patterns, as mediating conceptual artifacts. On the other hand, various technology-based tools will be presented that enable the teachers perform the complete orchestration life cycle. The presentation will draw on data from two years of field studies in a primary classroom, as well as professional development workshops and field studies with university teachers, where the conceptual and technological tools have been employed.
  4. Cite main people and proposals, especially Dillenbourg Mention here and in the beginning the work by Luis Pablo and his publications and thesis (and Sara, etc.)
  5. Cite main people and proposals, especially Dillenbourg Mention here and in the beginning the work by Luis Pablo and his publications and thesis (and Sara, etc.)
  6. Will be used in future: 4.43 (international) – 4.40 (spanish) Provided new insights: 4.17 (international) – 3.36 (spanish)
  7. CLFP and assessment patterns
  8. Related and structured according to the models, maps or pattern languages
  9. Learning Design composed of JIGSAW learning flow pattern And the REPORT REVIEW and OBSERVATIONS OF COLABORATIVE WORK assessment patterns
  10. From 2 LD formalizations: one widely used (IMS-LD) and one specialized/higly expressive (LDL) ... ... to 2 different LEs: one widely used (Moodle) and one peculiar/lo-fi (MediaWiki) GLUE!-PS WORKSHOP EVALUATION * 24 teachers, multi-disciplinary, most had experience with CL, patterns, routines... from a previous workshop * Tried both deployment and (some) real-time flexibility (but Moodle is limited in this regard!) * Questionnaire responses indicated overwhelmingly positive feedback from respondents (21/24): all were able to deploy, only 2 could not deploy their own design (because of lack of time) ** Very good ratings for usability (in a 1-8 scale, WebCollage 6.76, GLUEPS 7, Moodle 6.47!), usefulness (7.38), time-efficiency (7.14) ** Good ratings for immediate future use (in a 1-8 scale, 6.19), still some reluctance due to beliefs (do not like CL, or prefer pen/paper), or lack of adequate support * Mini-focus groups (debates) indicated very positive feedback, with a few "buts": ** using CL (independent of CS) would depend very much on the context (subject, number of students, own expertise), sp. since current education/evaluation paradigm is very individualistic ** positive feedback on GLUEPS (intuitive, flexible), but they need more technical support (human resources, manuals, courses...) and reliability of ICT tools ** Some other well-known issues: some teachers still think that ICT is more complex than social/pen&paper, to do basically the same things, students sometimes prefer the individual/IRE mode
  11. ATOMIC PATTERNS AND GLUE!-PS MAIN IDEAS * Of the original 169 atomic patterns in the catalogue, 21 were selected for eventual implementation (on the basis of: the AP being implementable through technology, having APs from all orchestration aspects, APs that appear frequently) * From these 21, GLUEPS functionalities have been abstracted, and generated an implementation roadmap * The implementation has shown certain architecture/system issues (e.g. having an API favors flexibility in real-time, synchronizing the VLE and GLUEPS/GLUE is difficult) IMPLEMENTATION * 8 of them were supported "by design" Monitoring the task On -the- fly assessment (Monitoring + Formative Assessment) Use results of a task in a different task / Reuse generated artifacts Teacher as participant in student groups Teacher chooses tools Use Moodle to automate submissions Use wiki to do collaborative writing Use wiki to structure activities * the next 5 most common have been implemented Strategies to group formation / Form groups Reform groups in face of the current attendants (only in MW) Spontaneous use of additional ICT (only in MW) Successive deployment of activities (only in Moodle, for now) Use pre-existing groups (only in Moodle) * 1-2 more are being implemented till the end of the thesis Peer review Adding improvised activities TRIED WITH SARA AND BEA * Authentic experiences, one with Moodle, one with MW * TICs-Sara2 (WebCollage -> MediaWiki, jigsaw pattern) ** Real-time changes in groups (many!) were needed. The teacher chose to make changes manually (it was feasible because it had no external tool), because the changes would have overwritten manual changes that she did after deploying ** Underlying issue to take into account in DLEs: state synchronization among elements, in both ways (VLE <-> GLUEPS, GLUElet Manager...), which is not trivial without modifying the VLE ** The teacher tried the real-time changes afterwards and valued GLUEPS very positively ** Still, a lot of time was needed to make sense of the (large) jigsaw and seeing if all instrinsic constraints were complied with. GLUEPS does not help with that * OyT-Bea (Pattern Collector -> Moodle, non-CLFP role playing) ** Integrate the design into an existing, ongoing Moodle course. Large number of groups/students (16 groups, around 60 students) ** Slight usability problems, resolved as the experiment went on ** Incremental deployments, to help with contingent elements of the design (i.e. materials/resources that could not be known in design-time) ** Teacher valued highly the usability enhancements, but... ** ... instantiation of groups and resources still took a lot of time. More automation/intelligence needed! (e.g. we will implement the peer review atomic pattern, and tell Bea to do it again) *** social coordination is still a desirable option, if you are willing to decrease usability for students a little bit (e.g. put all links to resources in the moodle, and tell socially who reviews what - instead of hardwiring the data flow as GLUEPS does). However, in larger groups social coordination might not be feasible...
  12. We begin to bridge the deployment gap in DLEs - time is saved and the process is less error-prone ** ... but the real time savings is in sharing/reusing (e.g. deploy a design in 8 minutes when reusing, vs. in 48 min without GLUEPS) GLUEPS makes possible the deployment of LDs in DLEs which teachers thought were not feasible ** But still...*** ... average teachers (e.g. in our PD workshops) are reluctant to rely so much on ICT (they need support, help, tutorials, time to try...) also a hint for managers/policy-makers *** ... many operations in instantiation are repetitive (e.g. peer reviews con Bea) - there is still room for improvement by automating * More naturalistic evaluation needed (up to now, all cases were "special teachers")! ** Highlight the role of PD workshops to disseminate and get feedback from "more real" people... and "capture" them for experiments ;)
  13. From 5+3 ** do we (or do researchers) really want orchestration to be defined? do we want an "orchestration theory"? from our study, not everybody does! ** descriptive frameworks are fine, but we also need a more normative frame, for concrete advice: is it possible to give advice, regardless of context? can atomic patterns be the beginning of an answer? Are we really sustainable? ** Atomic patterns are "expensive" to elicit, and are quite contextual... could we "crowdsource" it to e.g. teachers? (but let us remember the failure of Crea-TIC - what is in it for the (average) teacher?) ** The GSIC technological tools currently put a big orchestration burden/responsibility on the teacher... could we co-orchestrate with students (e.g. teacher defines high-level structure, students choose the tools and other fine-grained stuff) - but still maintaining teacher control somehow (e.g. for monitoring)? * Security, ethical questions... where is the data? is it protected? (e.g. CSCL-EREM tool does not want your data, only links to it) permissions across this complex service ecosystem... (e.g. see the problems GLUE is having with implementing supposedly standard stuff like Oauth) * To which extent our current CSCL focus can be extended to more integrated curriculum (which includes, IBL, even more IRE stuff...)?