SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  19
Religious Extremism, Institutions, and Income: Theory and Evidence ESHIA June,2007 Michael Makowsky H.B. Earhart Fellow Center for the Economic Study of Religion Department of Economics George Mason University
Extremism, Religious or Otherwise ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Extremist Groups and Violence ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Why Can Groups Demand Sacrifice? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Sacrifice And Stigma Model ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Quick Version High Beta= Happy with  one or the other Low Beta= Need a  combination of both
The Functions (key on social interactions)
An Agent-Based Model of a Religious Economy  (Built with the  lovely  MASON java library) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Max( U )
MARS – S&S ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
 
Extremism as a Percent of the Population Income Substitutability
Empirical Connections – Krueger and Maleckova 2003 ,[object Object],[object Object]
Regression Analysis of the Model Quantile Regression Estimates: Fraction Log Full Income Dedicated to Club Production Standard errors in parentheses, all coefficients significant at 0.1% level 52272 52272 52272 52272 52272 N (0.014) (0.032) (0.014) (0.022) (0.001) 1.519  1.173 -2.543 -4.959 -9.12  Constant (0.013) (0.032) (0.017) (0.040) (0.002) 1.928  0.184 -3.539 -5.940 -8.478  Log Substitutability (β) (0.003) (0.007) (0.004) (0.007) (0.000) -0.519  -0.961 -0.817 -0.828 -0.250  Log Full Income 90% 75% 50% 25% 10% Quantile
ISSP 1998 + Bootstrap Quantile Regression Religion - Work Ratio 5106 5106 5106 5106 5106 5106 5106 N -6.557 (2.344)** -13.362 (3.208)** -34.246 (5.667)** -29.100 (2.630)** -19.814 (4.092)** -7.041 (2.764)* 15.677 (3.762)** Constant 0.450 (0.140)** 0.921 (0.210)** 2.076 (0.338)** 1.640 (0.140)** 1.035 (0.248)** -0.104 (0.182) -1.486 (0.231)** Muslim 0.332 (0.153)* 1.119 (0.260)** 2.641 (0.223)** 2.475 (0.164)** 1.712 (0.336)** 0.681 (0.100)** -1.092 (0.318)** State Religion -1.025 (0.210)** -0.824 (0.309)** -2.460 (0.694)** -1.554 (0.240)** -1.092 (0.329)** 0.239 (0.446) 1.994 (0.205)** Religious Regulation -0.318 (0.034)** -0.238 (0.041)** -0.348 (0.048)** -0.342 (0.064)** -0.338 (0.068)** -0.000 (0.000) -0.000 (0.000) Earnings 0.376 (0.335) -3.337 (0.641)** 0.210 (1.181) 0.269 (0.433) -0.266 (0.433) -0.375 (0.576) -2.450 (0.331)** Economic Freedom 2.290 (0.623)** 5.660 (1.243)** 12.701 (1.490)** 11.096 (0.814)** 6.071 (1.233)** -0.448 (0.892) -6.618 (1.048)** Civil Liberties 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30%
Testing Suggested Policy
Policy Test (continued) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Conclusions ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The Rest are just Appendices ,[object Object]
Experiment Parameterization ,[object Object],[object Object],1 (prices of good) p S,  p R 60 (number of Groups) G 0.3 b 0.7 a 0.3 α 1.25 s 1 b s , b k Value Related Function Parameter
Nash starting condition ,[object Object],[object Object],R j R i R i =R j

Contenu connexe

Plus de zmiers

Project World Cultures
Project World CulturesProject World Cultures
Project World Cultures
zmiers
 
Limits Of Progressivism
Limits Of ProgressivismLimits Of Progressivism
Limits Of Progressivism
zmiers
 
RELIGION
RELIGIONRELIGION
RELIGION
zmiers
 
Ethicsasse2004
Ethicsasse2004Ethicsasse2004
Ethicsasse2004
zmiers
 
Muinkhoury
MuinkhouryMuinkhoury
Muinkhoury
zmiers
 
Iraq 6
Iraq 6Iraq 6
Iraq 6
zmiers
 
Iraq 7
Iraq 7Iraq 7
Iraq 7
zmiers
 
Iraq 3
Iraq 3Iraq 3
Iraq 3
zmiers
 
Human Rights Vi Form
Human Rights Vi FormHuman Rights Vi Form
Human Rights Vi Form
zmiers
 
Groups In Society
Groups In SocietyGroups In Society
Groups In Society
zmiers
 
Globalizationvic
GlobalizationvicGlobalizationvic
Globalizationvic
zmiers
 
Globalization, Interdependence And Education
Globalization, Interdependence And EducationGlobalization, Interdependence And Education
Globalization, Interdependence And Education
zmiers
 
Freud Jeop
Freud JeopFreud Jeop
Freud Jeop
zmiers
 
Globalization
GlobalizationGlobalization
Globalization
zmiers
 
Fool Me Twice
Fool Me TwiceFool Me Twice
Fool Me Twice
zmiers
 
Feral Children Presentation
Feral Children PresentationFeral Children Presentation
Feral Children Presentation
zmiers
 
Evolve 8
Evolve 8Evolve 8
Evolve 8
zmiers
 
Evolve 7
Evolve 7Evolve 7
Evolve 7
zmiers
 
Evolve 4
Evolve 4Evolve 4
Evolve 4
zmiers
 
Evolve 2
Evolve 2Evolve 2
Evolve 2
zmiers
 

Plus de zmiers (20)

Project World Cultures
Project World CulturesProject World Cultures
Project World Cultures
 
Limits Of Progressivism
Limits Of ProgressivismLimits Of Progressivism
Limits Of Progressivism
 
RELIGION
RELIGIONRELIGION
RELIGION
 
Ethicsasse2004
Ethicsasse2004Ethicsasse2004
Ethicsasse2004
 
Muinkhoury
MuinkhouryMuinkhoury
Muinkhoury
 
Iraq 6
Iraq 6Iraq 6
Iraq 6
 
Iraq 7
Iraq 7Iraq 7
Iraq 7
 
Iraq 3
Iraq 3Iraq 3
Iraq 3
 
Human Rights Vi Form
Human Rights Vi FormHuman Rights Vi Form
Human Rights Vi Form
 
Groups In Society
Groups In SocietyGroups In Society
Groups In Society
 
Globalizationvic
GlobalizationvicGlobalizationvic
Globalizationvic
 
Globalization, Interdependence And Education
Globalization, Interdependence And EducationGlobalization, Interdependence And Education
Globalization, Interdependence And Education
 
Freud Jeop
Freud JeopFreud Jeop
Freud Jeop
 
Globalization
GlobalizationGlobalization
Globalization
 
Fool Me Twice
Fool Me TwiceFool Me Twice
Fool Me Twice
 
Feral Children Presentation
Feral Children PresentationFeral Children Presentation
Feral Children Presentation
 
Evolve 8
Evolve 8Evolve 8
Evolve 8
 
Evolve 7
Evolve 7Evolve 7
Evolve 7
 
Evolve 4
Evolve 4Evolve 4
Evolve 4
 
Evolve 2
Evolve 2Evolve 2
Evolve 2
 

Dernier

Professional Amil baba, Kala jadu specialist in Multan and Kala ilam speciali...
Professional Amil baba, Kala jadu specialist in Multan and Kala ilam speciali...Professional Amil baba, Kala jadu specialist in Multan and Kala ilam speciali...
Professional Amil baba, Kala jadu specialist in Multan and Kala ilam speciali...
makhmalhalaaay
 
Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in UK and Kala ilam expert in Saudi Arab...
Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in UK and Kala ilam expert in Saudi Arab...Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in UK and Kala ilam expert in Saudi Arab...
Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in UK and Kala ilam expert in Saudi Arab...
baharayali
 
Top 10 Amil baba list Famous Amil baba In Pakistan Amil baba Kala jadu in Raw...
Top 10 Amil baba list Famous Amil baba In Pakistan Amil baba Kala jadu in Raw...Top 10 Amil baba list Famous Amil baba In Pakistan Amil baba Kala jadu in Raw...
Top 10 Amil baba list Famous Amil baba In Pakistan Amil baba Kala jadu in Raw...
Amil Baba Naveed Bangali
 
Popular Kala Jadu, Kala jadu Expert in Islamabad and Kala jadu specialist in ...
Popular Kala Jadu, Kala jadu Expert in Islamabad and Kala jadu specialist in ...Popular Kala Jadu, Kala jadu Expert in Islamabad and Kala jadu specialist in ...
Popular Kala Jadu, Kala jadu Expert in Islamabad and Kala jadu specialist in ...
baharayali
 
Professional Amil baba, Black magic specialist in Lahore and Kala ilam expert...
Professional Amil baba, Black magic specialist in Lahore and Kala ilam expert...Professional Amil baba, Black magic specialist in Lahore and Kala ilam expert...
Professional Amil baba, Black magic specialist in Lahore and Kala ilam expert...
makhmalhalaaay
 
Top Kala Jadu, Bangali Amil baba in Lahore and Kala jadu specialist in Lahore...
Top Kala Jadu, Bangali Amil baba in Lahore and Kala jadu specialist in Lahore...Top Kala Jadu, Bangali Amil baba in Lahore and Kala jadu specialist in Lahore...
Top Kala Jadu, Bangali Amil baba in Lahore and Kala jadu specialist in Lahore...
baharayali
 
Professional Amil baba, Black magic expert in Sialkot and Kala ilam expert in...
Professional Amil baba, Black magic expert in Sialkot and Kala ilam expert in...Professional Amil baba, Black magic expert in Sialkot and Kala ilam expert in...
Professional Amil baba, Black magic expert in Sialkot and Kala ilam expert in...
makhmalhalaaay
 
Popular Kala Jadu, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi...
Popular Kala Jadu, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi...Popular Kala Jadu, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi...
Popular Kala Jadu, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi...
baharayali
 

Dernier (20)

St. Louise de Marillac and Poor Children
St. Louise de Marillac and Poor ChildrenSt. Louise de Marillac and Poor Children
St. Louise de Marillac and Poor Children
 
Hire Best Next Js Developer For Your Project
Hire Best Next Js Developer For Your ProjectHire Best Next Js Developer For Your Project
Hire Best Next Js Developer For Your Project
 
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 5 12 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 5 12 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 5 12 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 5 12 24
 
St. Louise de Marillac and Abandoned Children
St. Louise de Marillac and Abandoned ChildrenSt. Louise de Marillac and Abandoned Children
St. Louise de Marillac and Abandoned Children
 
Jude: The Acts of the Apostates (Jude vv.1-4).pptx
Jude: The Acts of the Apostates (Jude vv.1-4).pptxJude: The Acts of the Apostates (Jude vv.1-4).pptx
Jude: The Acts of the Apostates (Jude vv.1-4).pptx
 
Professional Amil baba, Kala jadu specialist in Multan and Kala ilam speciali...
Professional Amil baba, Kala jadu specialist in Multan and Kala ilam speciali...Professional Amil baba, Kala jadu specialist in Multan and Kala ilam speciali...
Professional Amil baba, Kala jadu specialist in Multan and Kala ilam speciali...
 
Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in UK and Kala ilam expert in Saudi Arab...
Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in UK and Kala ilam expert in Saudi Arab...Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in UK and Kala ilam expert in Saudi Arab...
Famous Kala Jadu, Black magic expert in UK and Kala ilam expert in Saudi Arab...
 
Meaning of 22 numbers in Matrix Destiny Chart | 22 Energy Calculator
Meaning of 22 numbers in Matrix Destiny Chart | 22 Energy CalculatorMeaning of 22 numbers in Matrix Destiny Chart | 22 Energy Calculator
Meaning of 22 numbers in Matrix Destiny Chart | 22 Energy Calculator
 
Top 10 Amil baba list Famous Amil baba In Pakistan Amil baba Kala jadu in Raw...
Top 10 Amil baba list Famous Amil baba In Pakistan Amil baba Kala jadu in Raw...Top 10 Amil baba list Famous Amil baba In Pakistan Amil baba Kala jadu in Raw...
Top 10 Amil baba list Famous Amil baba In Pakistan Amil baba Kala jadu in Raw...
 
Story of The Soldier Son Portrait who died to save others
Story of The Soldier Son Portrait who died to save othersStory of The Soldier Son Portrait who died to save others
Story of The Soldier Son Portrait who died to save others
 
Popular Kala Jadu, Kala jadu Expert in Islamabad and Kala jadu specialist in ...
Popular Kala Jadu, Kala jadu Expert in Islamabad and Kala jadu specialist in ...Popular Kala Jadu, Kala jadu Expert in Islamabad and Kala jadu specialist in ...
Popular Kala Jadu, Kala jadu Expert in Islamabad and Kala jadu specialist in ...
 
Professional Amil baba, Black magic specialist in Lahore and Kala ilam expert...
Professional Amil baba, Black magic specialist in Lahore and Kala ilam expert...Professional Amil baba, Black magic specialist in Lahore and Kala ilam expert...
Professional Amil baba, Black magic specialist in Lahore and Kala ilam expert...
 
Emails, Facebook, WhatsApp and the Dhamma (English and Chinese).pdf
Emails, Facebook, WhatsApp and the Dhamma  (English and Chinese).pdfEmails, Facebook, WhatsApp and the Dhamma  (English and Chinese).pdf
Emails, Facebook, WhatsApp and the Dhamma (English and Chinese).pdf
 
"The Magnificent Surah Rahman: PDF Version"
"The Magnificent Surah Rahman: PDF Version""The Magnificent Surah Rahman: PDF Version"
"The Magnificent Surah Rahman: PDF Version"
 
Amil baba in Lahore /Amil baba in Karachi /Amil baba in Pakistan
Amil baba in Lahore /Amil baba in Karachi /Amil baba in PakistanAmil baba in Lahore /Amil baba in Karachi /Amil baba in Pakistan
Amil baba in Lahore /Amil baba in Karachi /Amil baba in Pakistan
 
St. Louise de Marillac and Galley Prisoners
St. Louise de Marillac and Galley PrisonersSt. Louise de Marillac and Galley Prisoners
St. Louise de Marillac and Galley Prisoners
 
Top Kala Jadu, Bangali Amil baba in Lahore and Kala jadu specialist in Lahore...
Top Kala Jadu, Bangali Amil baba in Lahore and Kala jadu specialist in Lahore...Top Kala Jadu, Bangali Amil baba in Lahore and Kala jadu specialist in Lahore...
Top Kala Jadu, Bangali Amil baba in Lahore and Kala jadu specialist in Lahore...
 
Exploring the Meaning of Jesus’ Ascension
Exploring the Meaning of Jesus’ AscensionExploring the Meaning of Jesus’ Ascension
Exploring the Meaning of Jesus’ Ascension
 
Professional Amil baba, Black magic expert in Sialkot and Kala ilam expert in...
Professional Amil baba, Black magic expert in Sialkot and Kala ilam expert in...Professional Amil baba, Black magic expert in Sialkot and Kala ilam expert in...
Professional Amil baba, Black magic expert in Sialkot and Kala ilam expert in...
 
Popular Kala Jadu, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi...
Popular Kala Jadu, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi...Popular Kala Jadu, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi...
Popular Kala Jadu, Kala ilam specialist in USA and Bangali Amil baba in Saudi...
 

Extremismpresentation

  • 1. Religious Extremism, Institutions, and Income: Theory and Evidence ESHIA June,2007 Michael Makowsky H.B. Earhart Fellow Center for the Economic Study of Religion Department of Economics George Mason University
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6. The Functions (key on social interactions)
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.  
  • 10. Extremism as a Percent of the Population Income Substitutability
  • 11.
  • 12. Regression Analysis of the Model Quantile Regression Estimates: Fraction Log Full Income Dedicated to Club Production Standard errors in parentheses, all coefficients significant at 0.1% level 52272 52272 52272 52272 52272 N (0.014) (0.032) (0.014) (0.022) (0.001) 1.519 1.173 -2.543 -4.959 -9.12 Constant (0.013) (0.032) (0.017) (0.040) (0.002) 1.928 0.184 -3.539 -5.940 -8.478 Log Substitutability (β) (0.003) (0.007) (0.004) (0.007) (0.000) -0.519 -0.961 -0.817 -0.828 -0.250 Log Full Income 90% 75% 50% 25% 10% Quantile
  • 13. ISSP 1998 + Bootstrap Quantile Regression Religion - Work Ratio 5106 5106 5106 5106 5106 5106 5106 N -6.557 (2.344)** -13.362 (3.208)** -34.246 (5.667)** -29.100 (2.630)** -19.814 (4.092)** -7.041 (2.764)* 15.677 (3.762)** Constant 0.450 (0.140)** 0.921 (0.210)** 2.076 (0.338)** 1.640 (0.140)** 1.035 (0.248)** -0.104 (0.182) -1.486 (0.231)** Muslim 0.332 (0.153)* 1.119 (0.260)** 2.641 (0.223)** 2.475 (0.164)** 1.712 (0.336)** 0.681 (0.100)** -1.092 (0.318)** State Religion -1.025 (0.210)** -0.824 (0.309)** -2.460 (0.694)** -1.554 (0.240)** -1.092 (0.329)** 0.239 (0.446) 1.994 (0.205)** Religious Regulation -0.318 (0.034)** -0.238 (0.041)** -0.348 (0.048)** -0.342 (0.064)** -0.338 (0.068)** -0.000 (0.000) -0.000 (0.000) Earnings 0.376 (0.335) -3.337 (0.641)** 0.210 (1.181) 0.269 (0.433) -0.266 (0.433) -0.375 (0.576) -2.450 (0.331)** Economic Freedom 2.290 (0.623)** 5.660 (1.243)** 12.701 (1.490)** 11.096 (0.814)** 6.071 (1.233)** -0.448 (0.892) -6.618 (1.048)** Civil Liberties 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30%
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.