SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 19
Relationship
Resuscitation
Using Social Media for Service Recovery
5/25/2015 1@AmandaChanguris
Most of the time, it’s good.
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 2
People Get Upset
When people get upset, they:
• Want a solution
• Want to vent
• Want to “make you pay” in the court of
public opinion
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 3
Sentiment & Behavior Flow
Patients /
Customers
Happy /
Neutral
Upset
Let You
Know
Offline
Online
Seethe in
Silence
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 4
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 5
Step One: Listen So You Can Hear
• Invest in a Paid Tool
o Argyle Social
o HootSuite Pro / Enterprise
o Spredfast, Falcon Social, Sprinklr , Shoutlet, Percolate
o Radian6
• Use Free Tools for Redundancy
o Platform Notifications
o Google Alerts
o Talkwalker
o Hyper Alerts
o Nutshell Mail
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 6
Step Two: Respond. Fast.
• 39% expect a response within an hour
• Average response time: 3.99 hours
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 7
Step Two: Respond. Fast.
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 8
Step Three: Respond Well
• First Response Essentials:
o Empathy
o Blameless Apology
o Offer Assistance
• ACID Test
o Acknowledge
o Contain
o Inform
o Direct
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 9
Be Human
• Address the person by name
• Consider using “I” rather than “we”
• Have a personality (and use it wisely)
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 10
Be Human
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 11
Canned Responses
It’s tempting… but please just don’t.
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 12
Canned Responses
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 13
Challenge: Complaints After the Fact
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 14
Challenge: Coordinated Complaints
• #dontdenykevin
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 15
Challenge: Issues that Keep Coming Back
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 16
Challenge: Issues that Keep Coming Back
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 17
Beyond Recovery
• What Would Retail Do?
• The Plan:
o Identify the right candidates
o Make the gesture personal (if possible)
o No promotion
o Avoid public posts (if possible)
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 18
Put It to Work!
• Don’t expect it to be easy…
• But don’t take the negativity personally.
• Questions?
5/25/2015@AmandaChanguris 19

More Related Content

Similar to Using Social Media for Service Recovery

DOYO Live - Managing Social Media Complaints by Amanda Changuris
DOYO Live - Managing Social Media Complaints by Amanda ChangurisDOYO Live - Managing Social Media Complaints by Amanda Changuris
DOYO Live - Managing Social Media Complaints by Amanda ChangurisDOYO Live
 
Managing Social Media Complaints
Managing Social Media ComplaintsManaging Social Media Complaints
Managing Social Media ComplaintsAmanda Changuris
 
Case Study: How StarHub Discovered What Their Consumers Are Talking About
Case Study: How StarHub Discovered What Their Consumers Are Talking AboutCase Study: How StarHub Discovered What Their Consumers Are Talking About
Case Study: How StarHub Discovered What Their Consumers Are Talking AboutDarren Choo SlideShare
 
Think Before You Tweet: Crisis Communications in an Era of Got to Have Inform...
Think Before You Tweet: Crisis Communications in an Era of Got to Have Inform...Think Before You Tweet: Crisis Communications in an Era of Got to Have Inform...
Think Before You Tweet: Crisis Communications in an Era of Got to Have Inform...Public Relations Society of America
 
Social Media Crisis Management
Social Media Crisis ManagementSocial Media Crisis Management
Social Media Crisis ManagementJanet Bebb
 
Social Media Crisis Management
Social Media Crisis ManagementSocial Media Crisis Management
Social Media Crisis ManagementJanet Bebb
 
6 Social Media Myths
6 Social Media Myths6 Social Media Myths
6 Social Media MythsBizink
 
ASCO Clinic Director Social Media
ASCO Clinic Director Social MediaASCO Clinic Director Social Media
ASCO Clinic Director Social MediaWilliam Zahn
 
How to Handle Negative Viral Social Media
How to Handle Negative Viral Social MediaHow to Handle Negative Viral Social Media
How to Handle Negative Viral Social MediaKaitlin Keeler
 
EiR & Engineering Continuing Ed: Understanding the Web Site Feedback Loop
EiR & Engineering Continuing Ed: Understanding the Web Site Feedback LoopEiR & Engineering Continuing Ed: Understanding the Web Site Feedback Loop
EiR & Engineering Continuing Ed: Understanding the Web Site Feedback LoopLaunch Angels
 
Social Media During a Disaster Webinar version
Social Media During a Disaster Webinar versionSocial Media During a Disaster Webinar version
Social Media During a Disaster Webinar versionMark Smith
 
Digital Marketing for Non-Profits: Social Media Best Practices and Tips
Digital Marketing for Non-Profits: Social Media Best Practices and TipsDigital Marketing for Non-Profits: Social Media Best Practices and Tips
Digital Marketing for Non-Profits: Social Media Best Practices and TipsMeg Hogan, MBA
 
Crisis Communication & Social Media: Understanding PR 2.0's Role in Crisis Re...
Crisis Communication & Social Media: Understanding PR 2.0's Role in Crisis Re...Crisis Communication & Social Media: Understanding PR 2.0's Role in Crisis Re...
Crisis Communication & Social Media: Understanding PR 2.0's Role in Crisis Re...Geben Communication
 
How Executives can use Twitter to Attract more Business Opportunities
How Executives can use Twitter to Attract more Business OpportunitiesHow Executives can use Twitter to Attract more Business Opportunities
How Executives can use Twitter to Attract more Business OpportunitiesDigoshen
 
Social Media Presentation at Key4Women networking event
Social Media Presentation at Key4Women networking eventSocial Media Presentation at Key4Women networking event
Social Media Presentation at Key4Women networking eventNiclas Hulting
 
Labatt's Social Media Nation Event - 12.3.13
Labatt's Social Media Nation Event - 12.3.13Labatt's Social Media Nation Event - 12.3.13
Labatt's Social Media Nation Event - 12.3.13Labatt Food Service
 
Navigating the Social Media Jungle for College Professionals
Navigating the Social Media Jungle for College ProfessionalsNavigating the Social Media Jungle for College Professionals
Navigating the Social Media Jungle for College ProfessionalsMinda-at Palmer Powers-Douglas
 
Social Media Training Seminar
Social Media Training SeminarSocial Media Training Seminar
Social Media Training SeminarAlyssa Murfey
 
2014 Business of Farming Conference: Becoming Social Media Savvy Workshop
2014 Business of Farming Conference: Becoming Social Media Savvy Workshop2014 Business of Farming Conference: Becoming Social Media Savvy Workshop
2014 Business of Farming Conference: Becoming Social Media Savvy Workshopasapconnections
 

Similar to Using Social Media for Service Recovery (20)

DOYO Live - Managing Social Media Complaints by Amanda Changuris
DOYO Live - Managing Social Media Complaints by Amanda ChangurisDOYO Live - Managing Social Media Complaints by Amanda Changuris
DOYO Live - Managing Social Media Complaints by Amanda Changuris
 
Managing Social Media Complaints
Managing Social Media ComplaintsManaging Social Media Complaints
Managing Social Media Complaints
 
Case Study: How StarHub Discovered What Their Consumers Are Talking About
Case Study: How StarHub Discovered What Their Consumers Are Talking AboutCase Study: How StarHub Discovered What Their Consumers Are Talking About
Case Study: How StarHub Discovered What Their Consumers Are Talking About
 
Think Before You Tweet: Crisis Communications in an Era of Got to Have Inform...
Think Before You Tweet: Crisis Communications in an Era of Got to Have Inform...Think Before You Tweet: Crisis Communications in an Era of Got to Have Inform...
Think Before You Tweet: Crisis Communications in an Era of Got to Have Inform...
 
Social Media Crisis Management
Social Media Crisis ManagementSocial Media Crisis Management
Social Media Crisis Management
 
Social Media Crisis Management
Social Media Crisis ManagementSocial Media Crisis Management
Social Media Crisis Management
 
6 Social Media Myths
6 Social Media Myths6 Social Media Myths
6 Social Media Myths
 
ASCO Clinic Director Social Media
ASCO Clinic Director Social MediaASCO Clinic Director Social Media
ASCO Clinic Director Social Media
 
How to Handle Negative Viral Social Media
How to Handle Negative Viral Social MediaHow to Handle Negative Viral Social Media
How to Handle Negative Viral Social Media
 
EiR & Engineering Continuing Ed: Understanding the Web Site Feedback Loop
EiR & Engineering Continuing Ed: Understanding the Web Site Feedback LoopEiR & Engineering Continuing Ed: Understanding the Web Site Feedback Loop
EiR & Engineering Continuing Ed: Understanding the Web Site Feedback Loop
 
Social Media During a Disaster Webinar version
Social Media During a Disaster Webinar versionSocial Media During a Disaster Webinar version
Social Media During a Disaster Webinar version
 
Digital Marketing for Non-Profits: Social Media Best Practices and Tips
Digital Marketing for Non-Profits: Social Media Best Practices and TipsDigital Marketing for Non-Profits: Social Media Best Practices and Tips
Digital Marketing for Non-Profits: Social Media Best Practices and Tips
 
Social Customer Service
Social Customer ServiceSocial Customer Service
Social Customer Service
 
Crisis Communication & Social Media: Understanding PR 2.0's Role in Crisis Re...
Crisis Communication & Social Media: Understanding PR 2.0's Role in Crisis Re...Crisis Communication & Social Media: Understanding PR 2.0's Role in Crisis Re...
Crisis Communication & Social Media: Understanding PR 2.0's Role in Crisis Re...
 
How Executives can use Twitter to Attract more Business Opportunities
How Executives can use Twitter to Attract more Business OpportunitiesHow Executives can use Twitter to Attract more Business Opportunities
How Executives can use Twitter to Attract more Business Opportunities
 
Social Media Presentation at Key4Women networking event
Social Media Presentation at Key4Women networking eventSocial Media Presentation at Key4Women networking event
Social Media Presentation at Key4Women networking event
 
Labatt's Social Media Nation Event - 12.3.13
Labatt's Social Media Nation Event - 12.3.13Labatt's Social Media Nation Event - 12.3.13
Labatt's Social Media Nation Event - 12.3.13
 
Navigating the Social Media Jungle for College Professionals
Navigating the Social Media Jungle for College ProfessionalsNavigating the Social Media Jungle for College Professionals
Navigating the Social Media Jungle for College Professionals
 
Social Media Training Seminar
Social Media Training SeminarSocial Media Training Seminar
Social Media Training Seminar
 
2014 Business of Farming Conference: Becoming Social Media Savvy Workshop
2014 Business of Farming Conference: Becoming Social Media Savvy Workshop2014 Business of Farming Conference: Becoming Social Media Savvy Workshop
2014 Business of Farming Conference: Becoming Social Media Savvy Workshop
 

Recently uploaded

Social media marketing/Seo expert and digital marketing
Social media marketing/Seo expert and digital marketingSocial media marketing/Seo expert and digital marketing
Social media marketing/Seo expert and digital marketingSheikhSaifAli1
 
Call Girls In Gurgaon Dlf pHACE 2 Women Delhi ncr
Call Girls In Gurgaon Dlf pHACE 2 Women Delhi ncrCall Girls In Gurgaon Dlf pHACE 2 Women Delhi ncr
Call Girls In Gurgaon Dlf pHACE 2 Women Delhi ncrSapana Sha
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida New Ashok Nagar Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida New Ashok Nagar Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida New Ashok Nagar Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida New Ashok Nagar Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 
CASH PAYMENT ON GIRL HAND TO HAND HOUSEWIFE
CASH PAYMENT ON GIRL HAND TO HAND HOUSEWIFECASH PAYMENT ON GIRL HAND TO HAND HOUSEWIFE
CASH PAYMENT ON GIRL HAND TO HAND HOUSEWIFECall girl Jaipur
 
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence PackageYour LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence PackageSocioCosmos
 
Factors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptx
Factors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptxFactors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptx
Factors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptxvemusae
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...anilsa9823
 
Lucknow 💋 Dating Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Serv...
Lucknow 💋 Dating Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Serv...Lucknow 💋 Dating Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Serv...
Lucknow 💋 Dating Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Serv...anilsa9823
 
Interpreting the brief for the media IDY
Interpreting the brief for the media IDYInterpreting the brief for the media IDY
Interpreting the brief for the media IDYgalaxypingy
 
DickinsonSlides teeeeeeeeeeessssssssssst.pptx
DickinsonSlides teeeeeeeeeeessssssssssst.pptxDickinsonSlides teeeeeeeeeeessssssssssst.pptx
DickinsonSlides teeeeeeeeeeessssssssssst.pptxednyonat
 
Stunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCR
Stunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCRStunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCR
Stunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCRDelhi Call girls
 
Hire↠Young Call Girls in Hari Nagar (Delhi) ☎️ 9205541914 ☎️ Independent Esco...
Hire↠Young Call Girls in Hari Nagar (Delhi) ☎️ 9205541914 ☎️ Independent Esco...Hire↠Young Call Girls in Hari Nagar (Delhi) ☎️ 9205541914 ☎️ Independent Esco...
Hire↠Young Call Girls in Hari Nagar (Delhi) ☎️ 9205541914 ☎️ Independent Esco...Delhi Call girls
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 
Unlock the power of Instagram with SocioCosmos. Start your journey towards so...
Unlock the power of Instagram with SocioCosmos. Start your journey towards so...Unlock the power of Instagram with SocioCosmos. Start your journey towards so...
Unlock the power of Instagram with SocioCosmos. Start your journey towards so...SocioCosmos
 
SELECTING A SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING COMPANY
SELECTING A SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING COMPANYSELECTING A SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING COMPANY
SELECTING A SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING COMPANYdizinfo
 
Website research Powerpoint for Bauer magazine
Website research Powerpoint for Bauer magazineWebsite research Powerpoint for Bauer magazine
Website research Powerpoint for Bauer magazinesamuelcoulson30
 
VIP Chandigarh Call Girls Service 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our Escorts
VIP Chandigarh Call Girls Service 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our EscortsVIP Chandigarh Call Girls Service 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our Escorts
VIP Chandigarh Call Girls Service 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our Escortssonatiwari757
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Social media marketing/Seo expert and digital marketing
Social media marketing/Seo expert and digital marketingSocial media marketing/Seo expert and digital marketing
Social media marketing/Seo expert and digital marketing
 
Call Girls In Gurgaon Dlf pHACE 2 Women Delhi ncr
Call Girls In Gurgaon Dlf pHACE 2 Women Delhi ncrCall Girls In Gurgaon Dlf pHACE 2 Women Delhi ncr
Call Girls In Gurgaon Dlf pHACE 2 Women Delhi ncr
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida New Ashok Nagar Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida New Ashok Nagar Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida New Ashok Nagar Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida New Ashok Nagar Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
 
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Pari Chowk Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
 
CASH PAYMENT ON GIRL HAND TO HAND HOUSEWIFE
CASH PAYMENT ON GIRL HAND TO HAND HOUSEWIFECASH PAYMENT ON GIRL HAND TO HAND HOUSEWIFE
CASH PAYMENT ON GIRL HAND TO HAND HOUSEWIFE
 
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence PackageYour LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
Your LinkedIn Makeover: Sociocosmos Presence Package
 
Factors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptx
Factors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptxFactors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptx
Factors-on-Authenticity-and-Validity-of-Evidences-and-Information.pptx
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Ashiyana Colony Lucknow best sexual service O...
 
Lucknow 💋 Dating Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Serv...
Lucknow 💋 Dating Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Serv...Lucknow 💋 Dating Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Serv...
Lucknow 💋 Dating Call Girls Lucknow | Whatsapp No 8923113531 VIP Escorts Serv...
 
9953056974 Young Call Girls In Kirti Nagar Indian Quality Escort service
9953056974 Young Call Girls In  Kirti Nagar Indian Quality Escort service9953056974 Young Call Girls In  Kirti Nagar Indian Quality Escort service
9953056974 Young Call Girls In Kirti Nagar Indian Quality Escort service
 
Interpreting the brief for the media IDY
Interpreting the brief for the media IDYInterpreting the brief for the media IDY
Interpreting the brief for the media IDY
 
DickinsonSlides teeeeeeeeeeessssssssssst.pptx
DickinsonSlides teeeeeeeeeeessssssssssst.pptxDickinsonSlides teeeeeeeeeeessssssssssst.pptx
DickinsonSlides teeeeeeeeeeessssssssssst.pptx
 
Stunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCR
Stunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCRStunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCR
Stunning ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Paharganj Delhi NCR
 
Hire↠Young Call Girls in Hari Nagar (Delhi) ☎️ 9205541914 ☎️ Independent Esco...
Hire↠Young Call Girls in Hari Nagar (Delhi) ☎️ 9205541914 ☎️ Independent Esco...Hire↠Young Call Girls in Hari Nagar (Delhi) ☎️ 9205541914 ☎️ Independent Esco...
Hire↠Young Call Girls in Hari Nagar (Delhi) ☎️ 9205541914 ☎️ Independent Esco...
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 120 Call Me: 8448380779
 
Unlock the power of Instagram with SocioCosmos. Start your journey towards so...
Unlock the power of Instagram with SocioCosmos. Start your journey towards so...Unlock the power of Instagram with SocioCosmos. Start your journey towards so...
Unlock the power of Instagram with SocioCosmos. Start your journey towards so...
 
SELECTING A SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING COMPANY
SELECTING A SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING COMPANYSELECTING A SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING COMPANY
SELECTING A SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING COMPANY
 
Website research Powerpoint for Bauer magazine
Website research Powerpoint for Bauer magazineWebsite research Powerpoint for Bauer magazine
Website research Powerpoint for Bauer magazine
 
VIP Chandigarh Call Girls Service 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our Escorts
VIP Chandigarh Call Girls Service 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our EscortsVIP Chandigarh Call Girls Service 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our Escorts
VIP Chandigarh Call Girls Service 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our Escorts
 
🔝9953056974 🔝Call Girls In Mehrauli Escort Service Delhi NCR
🔝9953056974 🔝Call Girls In Mehrauli  Escort Service Delhi NCR🔝9953056974 🔝Call Girls In Mehrauli  Escort Service Delhi NCR
🔝9953056974 🔝Call Girls In Mehrauli Escort Service Delhi NCR
 

Using Social Media for Service Recovery

Editor's Notes

  1. A major challenge for health care providers is that patients and family members will often wait until they’re discharged to tell you they’re not happy (at least online). This example is an oldie but a goodie from back in my hospital days. Kevin’s daughter-in-law came to our hospital and – at least according to him – was with us for almost a month before we transferred her to the University of Maryland, where they were able to give her effective treatment. If I take this as gospel truth, I’m appalled at all of the slackers at my hospital that can’t treat this poor woman … but I’m pretty sure there’s a lot more to the story than this tidbit. I don’t need to know the details in order to respond with empathy and a blameless apology, but an offer of assistance is a tougher sell. I’m glad his daughter-in-law is doing well now, but there’s not a great deal I – or we as a hospital – have to offer. Just like we’ve discussed, I start with empathy and a blameless apology. In his original post, Kevin posited that we’d just delete his comments and move on, so I take a moment to reassure him that we won’t remove his post and – again – apologize for the experience. Then I reached out to my friends in the hospital’s patient relations department. While we couldn’t do anything to improve his daughter-in-law’s experience, we could demonstrate that we took his feedback seriously and wanted to get the details so we could make sure something similar wouldn’t happen again. This may or may not be of any comfort to Kevin or his daughter-in-law, but to an impartial third party we’ve taken some tough criticism to heart and taken the actions available to us to dig into the details and learn from whatever happened. That’s worth a little good faith.