Ce diaporama a bien été signalé.
Nous utilisons votre profil LinkedIn et vos données d’activité pour vous proposer des publicités personnalisées et pertinentes. Vous pouvez changer vos préférences de publicités à tout moment.
“Alt”	
  is	
  German	
  for	
  “old”:	
  
It’s	
  &me	
  to	
  stop	
  talking	
  	
  
about	
  metrics	
  in	
  terms	
 ...
!  Non-­‐profit	
  industry	
  trade	
  associa&on	
  	
  
accredited	
  by	
  ANSI	
  
!  Mission	
  of	
  developing	
  a...
1980s Alternative	
  
John	
  Taylor,	
  
Duran	
  Duran	
  
1920s Alternative	
  
2010s Not-so Alternative	
  
Cole	
  Plante	
  
When it becomes a standard,
its not alterative any more…	
  
Since	
  Jason	
  Priem	
  coined	
  the	
  term	
  
•  There	
  have	
  been	
  some	
  6,200	
  scholarly	
  ar&cles	
  ...
More	
  than	
  just	
  popularity	
  
Research	
  is	
  poin&ng	
  to	
  the	
  fact	
  that	
  there	
  is	
  a	
  
mode...
Would	
  a	
  researcher	
  focus	
  on	
  only	
  one	
  data	
  
source	
  or	
  methodological	
  approach?	
  
	
  
Fe...
There	
  aren’t	
  	
  
metrics	
  and	
  “altmetrics;	
  
there	
  are	
  only	
  metrics!	
  
	
  
February	
  23,	
  20...
We	
  have	
  been	
  using	
  	
  
non-­‐cita&on-­‐based	
  
metrics	
  for	
  decades	
  
February	
  23,	
  2015	
   11...
February	
  23,	
  2015	
   12	
  
February	
  23,	
  2015	
   13	
  
Traverse	
  Area	
  District	
  Library	
  (TADL)	
  
What	
  has	
  changed	
  is	
  our	
  
ability	
  to	
  collect	
  and	
  
analyze	
  data	
  	
  
in	
  ways	
  that	
  ...
TRUST	
  
=	
  
What are the
infrastructure elements
of metrics we need
standards for?	
  
Granularity	
  
Time Scale	
  
Identification	
  Definition	
  
Exchange
Granularity	
  
Time Scale	
  
Identification	
  Definition	
  
Exchange
However,	
  there	
  are	
  different	
  metrics	
  
for	
  different	
  things.	
  
	
  
There	
  are	
  even	
  different	
...
How fast are we going?	
  
Pound-foot/seconds or
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation
Prochain SlideShare
Chargement dans…5
×

Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation

Todd Carpenter's presentation at the Electronic Resources in Libraries (ER&L) conference in Austin, TX, February 23, 2015. Todd discussed how new forms of assessment are entering the mainstream and how those metrics shouldn't be considered "alternative" any longer. The session also covered the advancements made in 2014 on the NISO Alternative Assessment initiative, that was generously funded by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation.

Carpenter - Lets remove "alt" from altmetrics - ER&L Presentation

  1. 1. “Alt”  is  German  for  “old”:   It’s  &me  to  stop  talking     about  metrics  in  terms  of   “alterna&ve”  metrics.   Todd Carpenter   Executive Director, NISO February 23, 2015
  2. 2. !  Non-­‐profit  industry  trade  associa&on     accredited  by  ANSI   !  Mission  of  developing  and  maintaining  technical   standards  related  to  informa&on,  documenta&on,   discovery  and  distribu&on  of  published  materials   and  media   !  Volunteer  driven  organiza&on:  400+  contributors   spread  out  across  the  world   !  Responsible  (directly  and  indirectly)  for  standards   like  ISSN,  DOI,  Dublin  Core  metadata,  DAISY  digital   talking  books,  OpenURL,  MARC  records,  and  ISBN   About     February  23,  2015   2  
  3. 3. 1980s Alternative   John  Taylor,   Duran  Duran  
  4. 4. 1920s Alternative  
  5. 5. 2010s Not-so Alternative   Cole  Plante  
  6. 6. When it becomes a standard, its not alterative any more…  
  7. 7. Since  Jason  Priem  coined  the  term   •  There  have  been  some  6,200  scholarly  ar&cles   (per  Google  Scholar)   •  There  have  been  8  altmetrics  conferences   •  Even  I  have  presented  on  altmetrics  12  &mes!     (Just  kidding)   February  23,  2015   7  
  8. 8. More  than  just  popularity   Research  is  poin&ng  to  the  fact  that  there  is  a   modest  posi&ve  correla&on  between     early-­‐signal  metrics  (altmetrics)  and     later-­‐signal  metrics  (cita&ons)   Do  altmetrics  correlate  with  cita7ons?  Extensive  comparison  of  altmetric  indicators  with   cita7ons  from  a  mul7disciplinary  perspec7ve  by  Rodrigo  Costas,  Zohreh  Zahedi,  Paul  Wouters     Do  Altmetrics  Work?  TwiCer  and  Ten  Other  Social  Web  Services  by  Mike  Thelwall  ,  Stefanie   Haustein,    Vincent  Larivière,  &  Cassidy  R.  Sugimoto       (2006)  Earlier  web  usage  sta&s&cs  as  predictors  of  later  cita&on  impact  by  Brody  T,  Harnad  S  &   Carr  L       February  23,  2015   8  
  9. 9. Would  a  researcher  focus  on  only  one  data   source  or  methodological  approach?     February  23,  2015   9  Duke  University  -­‐    Informa&on  Ini&a&ve  at  Duke  (IID)  
  10. 10. There  aren’t     metrics  and  “altmetrics;   there  are  only  metrics!     February  23,  2015   10  
  11. 11. We  have  been  using     non-­‐cita&on-­‐based   metrics  for  decades   February  23,  2015   11  
  12. 12. February  23,  2015   12  
  13. 13. February  23,  2015   13   Traverse  Area  District  Library  (TADL)  
  14. 14. What  has  changed  is  our   ability  to  collect  and   analyze  data     in  ways  that  are   meaningful  to  others   February  23,  2015   14  
  15. 15. TRUST   =  
  16. 16. What are the infrastructure elements of metrics we need standards for?  
  17. 17. Granularity   Time Scale   Identification  Definition   Exchange
  18. 18. Granularity   Time Scale   Identification  Definition   Exchange
  19. 19. However,  there  are  different  metrics   for  different  things.     There  are  even  different  metrics     for  the  same  thing   February  23,  2015   19  
  20. 20. How fast are we going?  
  21. 21. Pound-foot/seconds or

×