2. Table of Contents
3
Executive Summary
4
Introduction
5
The Mobile Megatrend
7
Recruitment Industry Rings in Mobile
10 Account Managers, Connected Any Time, Anywhere
11 Mobile Access, Fuels Staffing Sales Success
12 Mobile Hang-Ups Holding Firms Back
13 Unlocking Mobile Success
16 The Mobile-Powered Client Meeting
18 Conclusion
19 About Bullhorn
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
2
3. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
• Mobile technology is changing the way recruiting firms operate and the way recruiting
professionals work. While it’s obvious that staffing and recruiting firms must evolve their
online presence to support candidates applying through mobile devices, it is far less clear
how mobile will impact their full-time employees, the recruiting and account management
professionals who work with clients and candidates.
• Mobile access to the ATS gives users the flexibility to perform recruiting tasks from
anywhere at any time, which is a huge advantage for recruiting firms. Bullhorn’s 2013
Staffing and Recruiting Trends Survey reported that 84% of staffing professionals consider
mobile access to their ATS/CRM to be important to their success.
• Bullhorn’s survey research suggests firms see the primary opportunity to leverage
mobile being within their sales function. One-hundred percent (100%) of the staffing
salespeople polled who spent more than half their time outside in meetings considered mobile
access important, with 86% considering it “extremely important.”
• Empowering sales and account managers with fully mobile-ready ATS and CRM
capabilities produces clear business benefits. Account managers and sales personnel
can spend more time face-to-face with clients and prospects, as well as showcase the firm’s
capabilities by having more timely and accurate data available during meetings.
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
3
4. INTRODUCTION
Mobile usage is
soaring worldwide.
Smartphone and tablet usage is on a trajectory to surpass the usage of desktop computers.
Like leaders in other industries, recruitment executives see potential in taking their businesses
mobile. While the need to support candidates — whether searching and applying for jobs or
logging time — via mobile is clear, how recruiting professionals can harness the mobile revolution
to improve performance of internal staff is not. Bullhorn analyzed the actual usage data of the
thousands of recruiting professionals using its fourth generation mobile product to gain insight
into how firms are successfully leveraging mobile technology.
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
4
5. THE MOBILE
Megatrend
Mobile is exploding. By the end of 2013, the number of mobile-connected devices is expected
to exceed the world’s population.1 What’s more, mobile devices aren’t just telephones anymore;
today’s smartphones are powerful computers in their own right, enabling constant Internet
connectivity. Global mobile data traffic grew by 70% in 2012, amounting to nearly 12 times the
size of the entire global Internet in 2000.2 Mobile Internet usage will surpass desktop Internet
use in the next few years.
Mobile vs. Desktop Internet Usage
INTERNET USERS
2,000
1,600
MOBILE
USERS
1,200
800
DESKTOP
USERS
400
2007
1,2
2009
2011
2013
2015
Cisco Visual Networking Index:
Global Mobile Data Traffic
Forecast Update, 2012-2017
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
5
6. The rapid adoption of
Internet-connected
smartphones and tablets
represents a fundamental
shift in the way people
access the Web.
traditional banking landscape; consumers can
This mobile megatrend opens up a whole
The mobile megatrend is impacting not only
new dimension for businesses, just like the
the U.S. but the entire world. In 2012, mobile
Internet did in the ‘90s, shifting the way
data traffic grew by 44% in Western Europe
many industries operate. Uber, Hailo, and
and 95% in the Asia Pacific region.3 Overall
other startups, for example, are transforming
global mobile data traffic is expected to grow
the taxi and car hire industry by enabling
at a CAGR (compound annual growth rate) of
riders to connect directly with drivers via
66% by 2017.4
check their balances, view transaction history,
and transfer money right from their mobile
devices. Also, companies like Starbucks
have rolled out mobile payment software
through prepaid cards, enabling consumers
to pay their bills at the register using their
smartphones.
mobile without the cost and hassle of using
dispatchers. Mobile banking has changed the
3,4
Cisco Visual Networking Index:
Global Mobile Data Traffic Forecast
Update, 2012-2017
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
6
7. RECRUITMENT
INDUSTRY
Rings in Mobile
How is the mobile
on the recruitment industry
migrate more quickly due
megatrend
is in the way recruiting
to the inherent sensitivity
and staffing firms interact
of new employment-
with millions of candidates
related communication for
multibillion dollar
every day. Much of this
candidates already gainfully
global recruitment
communication has already
employed. It’s only natural
industry? Will mobile be
migrated to the Internet.
that candidates might
transformative or produce
Email now represents the
hesitate to use their work
smaller, more incremental
bulk of pre-placement
desktop when seeking new
changes? While it’s still early
communication, and
opportunities. Millennials,
in the game, it appears that
post-placement time and
mobile will primarily impact
expense management is
two aspects of the recruiting
increasingly handled via
industry: the candidate
online time cards. Much of
experience and sales/
this activity will naturally
account management.
shift to the mobile Internet
who are heavy mobile
users, will further
accelerate the shift
as they become 50%
of the employed
5
workforce.
impacting the
as part of this broad
The most obvious and
trend. In fact, recruiting
immediate impact of mobile
communication may
5
What Millennials Want,
Examiner.com, June, 2010
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
7
8. 86% OF JOB SEEKERS
said they would use mobile technology if it
simplified the process of applying for a job.
There seems
to be a lack of
acknowledgement by
recruiting firms that
job seekers want to
interact with recruiters
and apply for jobs
from their mobile
phones. A 2013 Simply
applying via mobile.
While it’s obvious that
An iMomentous Fortune
recruiting firms must
500 Mobile Readiness
optimize their online
Report recently showed that
presence for mobile, it is far
only 33% of companies have
less clear how mobile will
a mobile-optimized careers
impact their employees and
section and just 3% have a
the way they do their jobs.
mobile apply function. The
These employees already
majority of recruiting and
rely heavily on software
Hired report found that
staffing firms seem similarly
that helps them automate
86% of job seekers said
unprepared. While mobile
the large number of tasks
they would use mobile
apps are convenient for
they perform each day. The
technology if it simplified
pre-placement activities,
average recruiter executes
the process of applying for
they can also be useful for
more than 300 clicks per
a job.6 Despite the fact that
post-placement functions
day in his or her applicant
mobile technology provides
such as time and expense
tracking system/customer
a fast and convenient way
management, which allow
relationship management
to connect with candidates,
employees to submit their
system (ATS/CRM)
many firms are unprepared
hours from the jobsite directly
according to Bullhorn’s
to support job seekers
from their mobile phones.
usage data, which is about
7
six times the number that
6,7
Recruiters – Why You Need a Mobile
Friendly Recruitment Website,
Web-based Recruitment, May 2013
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
8
9. the average non-recruiter executes. The ATS is
53% of respondents saying it was “extremely
used by recruiters to manage job orders and
important.”10
the large volume of resumes and applicants
they receive for each position, which produces
While mobile is considered to be important,
an average of 188 applicants per opening.
salespeople appear to be the only employees
8
fully leveraging mobile and the freedom
Ninety-three percent (93%) of
this technology has given them. Recruiters,
recruiting firms reported using
who are not on the road as often as account
managers, should still harness the power
an applicant tracking system
of mobile to improve efficiency and stay
(ATS) in 2012.
connected with candidates after business hours.
Mobile access to the ATS gives users the
But how exactly are recruiting and staffing
flexibility to perform recruiting tasks from
professionals’ jobs changing as recruiting
anywhere at any time, which is a huge
tools become accessible via smartphones and
advantage for recruiting firms.
tablets? What new ways of working might
9
emerge that better serve clients and improve
Indeed, according to Bullhorn’s 2013 recruiting
effectiveness and efficiency?
trends survey, 84% of staffing professionals
said they consider mobile access to their ATS/
CRM to be important to their success, with
Mobile Access
84% IMPORTANT
EXTREMELY
53% IMPORTANT
News and Trends in Management,
The Wall Street Journal, February 2012
9
2012 Recruiting/Talent Acquisition
Survey: Technology, Staffing Industry
Analysts, July 2012
10
“Two Steps Forward, One Step Back:
North American Staffing and Recruiting
Trends Report,” Bullhorn, Inc., 2013
8
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
9
10. ACCOUNT MANAGERS
Connected Any Time, Anywhere
Bullhorn’s survey research suggests that
While mobile currently provides a
firms see the primary opportunity to
strong advantage for sales and account
leverage mobile being within their sales
management professionals, it may have
function. Indeed, “mobile recruiting” looks
a limited upside for recruiters who don’t
to be a misnomer; “mobile selling” might
spend as much time out in the field. With
be more apt. One-hundred percent of the
the exception of executive search recruiters,
staffing salespeople polled who spent more
most recruiters spend the majority of their
than half their time outside in meetings
time working from their desks and don’t
considered mobile access important, with
often travel out of the office to meet with
86% considering it “extremely important.”
candidates. Although mobile may not seem
The survey results overall suggest
that salespeople are 24% more likely
to consider mobile access to the
ATS/CRM “extremely important”
than recruiters. Perhaps this is because
compelling to recruiters now, it does provide
salespeople travel to meet clients whereas
recruiters work almost entirely from the
office. Salespeople have always been early
adopters of technology. For example, they
them with the ability to perform interviews
after hours (when candidates are more
available) and review activity notes at home
or on the road via tablets. The
flexibility
mobile provides will bring more
speed and collaboration to recruiting
teams that take advantage of this
powerful business tool.
were the first to embrace smartphones and
customer relationship management (CRM)
tools,11 and therefore may be harbingers of
how the general business public will be using
mobile in the future.
11
The Future of Sales Technology,
Inc.com, December 2012
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
10
11. MOBILE ACCESS
Fuels Staffing Sales Success
Empowering sales and account managers with fully mobile-ready ATS
and CRM capabilities produces clear business benefits. Most notably:
1. Better Client Service — Account managers and sales personnel can spend more time
face-to-face with clients and prospects, providing a more personalized experience. A mobile
application also enables account managers to have the latest up-to-date information before and
during each meeting so that they can get more things done.
2. More Timely and Accurate Data — Sales personnel can enter in jobs immediately
after meeting with a client, getting recruiters on the hunt before they even return to the office and
subsequently giving their firms a better chance to fill new job orders. A mobile app allows them to
enter in notes right after a meeting when thoughts are still fresh in their minds.
3. Better-Showcased Capabilities — The ability to look up candidate inventory
on the fly gives clients a more concrete sense of a recruiting firm’s abilities. According to
Bullhorn Mobile usage data, “viewing candidate information” is the most commonly used mobile
functionality. Finding and reviewing actual candidate information side-by-side with the client
leaves a strong impression.
4. Reporting Access — For executives, mobile access provides the ability to stay on top of
the business at all times. Mobile recruiting apps allow executives to view key reports that monitor
activities such as recruiter performance and provide insight into the sales pipeline.
“Mobile allows us access to
the most current information
available about our clients,
candidates, open job orders,
and placements. This allows our
staff to stay informed and enter
more relevant information in the
system in a quicker timeframe.”
— JON THEOPHILUS
Director of Information Technology
Brooksource
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
11
12. MOBILE HANG-UPS
Holding Firms Back
Despite the benefits of a mobile platform, many
recruiting firms have yet to adopt these tools
because they are being held back by a few challenges.
1 Functionality
Very few ATS/CRM vendors have provided mobile solutions that are capable of robustly
performing key recruiting functions. Many vendors offer mobile websites that are used for
information gathering; however, this doesn’t do much for salespeople. A credible mobile
experience should focus on only the key functions (e.g. entering notes or jobs) that a team
needs while on the road.
2 Usability
ATS/CRM vendors that do offer some mobile capabilities often just try to shrink their
existing Web software down to a mobile format instead of tailoring it to the specific
screen parameters and interaction properties of mobile devices. This doesn’t work, so it
doesn’t get adopted.
3 Workflow
Firms with highly specific workflow or terminology may need to configure aspects of
their mobile ATS/CRM interface in order to match well enough to generate successful
field adoption.
4 Old Habits
Experienced recruiters who have had success over the years using old techniques may be
hesitant to adopt new tools.
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
12
13. UNLOCKING
Mobile Success
Despite the challenges, some staffing and
picture of how recruitment professionals
recruiting firms already empower their sales
successfully leverage mobile recruiting
and account management teams with easy
technology to improve the way they work.
mobile access to the critical software tools
they need for better client support and
more successful sales calls. To understand
exactly how, Bullhorn analyzed anonymous
Mobile recruitment software usage is
surprisingly consistent across time of day
as shown in the graph below.
second-by-second usage data from
The busiest periods are morning and
thousands of Bullhorn Mobile users over an
afternoon business hours, with another peak
eight-month period. The results paint a vivid
in the evening.
The hard-charging nature — or perhaps also the insomnia-inducing stress
— of the recruiting industry fuels mobile usage deep into the night!
23%
20%
19%
14%
13%
11%
MORNING
LUNCH
AFTERNOON
EVENING
COMMUTE
EVENING
LATE NIGHT
6AM-11AM
11AM-1PM
1PM-5PM
5PM-7PM
7PM-11PM
11PM-6AM
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
13
14. Tasks Performed in Bullhorn Mobile
2% 1%
5%
Client Research
8%
Candidate Search and Review
43%
41%
Viewing Notes
Adding/Updating Notes, Jobs and Other Records
Reports
Client Site Driving Directions
Analyzing the specific
8% of all actions users
At first glance, the
actions users perform
take. Productively sifting
relatively small proportion
with Bullhorn Mobile
through a firm’s entire
of activity devoted to
yields further insight into
database using small
adding and updating
how staffing professionals
smartphone screens
records via mobile — once
are leveraging mobile
and keypads requires a
for every 17 times a user
recruiting technology.
careful UI design. Simply
views records — might
Aggregated into broad
repurposing desktop
suggest low importance.
categories in the graph
search and list viewing is a
But in fact, viewing
above, client research
recipe for user frustration
records is far more
and candidate review
and low adoption.
common than adding
represent by far the
largest amount of activity.
or updating records via
About half of client
desktop applications as
research (20% of total
well. And the immediate
Finding the right client,
usage) entails viewing
capture and sharing of
contact, or candidate
individual client contacts,
new job orders and other
relies heavily on
with the rest of usage
account information from
the mobile “search”
focused on reviewing
account managers in
function; about a tenth
client company records
the field provides their
of research activity is
(11%) and open jobs and
recruiting teams with
searching, comprising
placements (8%).
an enormously valuable
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
14
15. head start. Entering data
Only 2% of mobile activity
account managers means
immediately after meetings
spent viewing reports can
relatively smaller report
instead of hours later back
be attributed to managers
activity, though obviously
at the office helps users
staying on top of their
supervisors highly value
capture details that would
team’s key metrics, such
both the peace of mind
otherwise be forgotten
as placements, open jobs,
of knowing that group
and reduces errors
and activity levels, while
performance is on target as
introduced by less than
on the road. The smaller
well as finding out early that
perfect human memory.
number of supervisors
an issue needs correcting.
compared to recruiters and
Only
2% of mobile activity spent
viewing reports can be attributed to managers
staying on top of their team’s key metrics...
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
15
16. THE MOBILE-POWERED
Client Meeting
A powerful view into how mobile technology improves
account managers’ ability to prepare for, manage, and
follow up on sales calls emerges from detailed insight into
mobile recruiting activity and timing. This “playbook” can
serve as a starting point for almost any type of recruiting
firm seeking to better serve clients and win a larger share
of business.
First, mobile recruiting can help a salesperson find out
how to physically get to a client’s office. Integration
with smartphones’ GPS and mapping capabilities means
mobile recruiting software can automatically provide
precise directions to the client site. This process is less
time consuming than tracking down and printing driving
directions from a client website.
As usage data makes abundantly clear, one of the most
valuable benefits that mobile ATS/CRM access provides
is complete, up-to-date knowledge of account status. In
the minutes before the meeting starts, mobile-powered
sales reps can quickly look up the company as well as
individual client contacts to review recent notes, open jobs,
placements, and more. Reps can kick off meetings with
timely, accurate updates on current business and reduce
the chances of being blindsided by new client issues. As
successful staffing and recruiting firms know well, superior
client service sets the stage for business success.
Reduce the chances of being
blindsided by new client issues.
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
16
17. With luck, having a good track record with
gives recruiting teams a jump on rivals who
previous job orders can help salespeople
must wait hours for sales reps to get back
facilitate a discussion of a client’s additional
to the office or connect their laptop before
needs. Salespeople with mobile access to
they can start working on reqs. Furthermore,
their ATS/CRM system can demonstrate their
sales representatives can capture and share
firm’s capabilities during a client meeting
important meeting outcomes, issues raised,
by instantly sharing insight into the strength
and other pertinent information as notes
of their candidate database with clients on
before leaving the parking lot. Follow-up
the spot. This can further differentiate an
actions can commence immediately. The
agency from competitors whose salespeople
entire team benefits from an instantaneous,
respond to questions only with bluster or
accurate, and complete understanding of
promises to “get back to you soon.”
the client which enables them to deliver a
superior level of service. And in a business
After the meeting, effective mobile recruiting
where every minute counts, the extra speed
software gives firms further advantages.
delivered through mobile recruiting means
Submitting new job orders immediately
better bottom line results.
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
17
18. Conclusion
Mobile technology is changing the way recruiting firms operate and the way recruiting
professionals work. Mobile access to client and candidate data enables recruiting firms to work
faster and more efficiently. For any firms looking to incorporate mobile into their recruiting
strategy, start by rolling it out to employees who often work remotely like sales and account
management teams. However, before investing in a mobile solution, make sure it’s going to
deliver all of the functionality you need. For example, very few applications today offer the
ability to browse lists, search for candidates, add notes or job orders, view reports, and get
directions using a built-in GPS. These are all key capabilities that a team needs while on the
road. Managers may also want the ability to customize the workflow on their mobile apps
in order to mirror their team’s recruiting process. With the right features and functionality,
recruiting firms will quickly find success using mobile technology.
To learn more about Bullhorn Mobile, visit:
http://www.bullhorn.com/products/mobile-recruiting
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
18
19. About
Bullhorn
Bullhorn creates software and
services that help recruiters put the
world to work. For thirteen years our
innovations have powered the recruiting and
staffing operations of fast-growing start-ups up
through the world’s largest employment brands.
Headquartered in Boston, with offices in St.
Louis, Richmond, Vancouver, London and Sydney,
Bullhorn’s applicant tracking system, recruiting
CRM, and social recruiting products serve more
than 10,000 clients representing nearly 200,000
users across 150 countries.
Please visit our website at www.bullhorn.com to
learn more about Bullhorn’s full suite of recruiting
software tools.
Have an immediate question?
Speak with an expert: call 1-888-GoLive8.
1.888.GOLIVE8 • SALES@BULLHORN.COM • @BULLHORN
19