SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  4
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
In the Media
1
THE NEW OBAMACARE ECONOMY
By E. Tammy Kim
Photo: Stock4B/Getty
07/21/2016
Business is brisk for consulting firms and others who help
employers take advantage of insurance subsidies to
comply with the Affordable Care Act.
The employees of Hope Haven, a nonprofit organization in
Burlington, Iowa, provide services to some five hundred
people with intellectual and physical disabilities, often in their
clients’ homes. Depending on the day, they can be called
upon to work as companions, cleaners, readers, personal
shoppers, cooks, or bathers. “We have situations where we support people twenty-four hours a
day,” Bob Bartles, Hope Haven’s executive director, told me. His staff members perform intimate
labors of compassion, yet, as low-wage workers, they, too, are a vulnerable class. “Our entry
wage is $11.25 per hour,” Bartles said. “We’re about ninety-per-cent funded by the government.
Most of that is Medicaid, and Medicaid doesn’t set rates that allow us to pay much more.”
Bartles has also struggled to offer a decent health-care plan to his workers, in compliance with
the Affordable Care Act’s employer mandate. The best he could find, given Hope Haven’s
financial constraints, came with co-pays and a high deductible, plus extra fees for vision, dental,
and family coverage. Even then, it cost the organization nearly eight thousand dollars per person
per year. So Bartles took note in 2014, when Iowa joined a slim majority of states that expanded
Medicaid, under the A.C.A. Suddenly, Medicaid was available to a larger segment of the working
poor—those with incomes up to a hundred and thirty-eight per cent of the federal poverty level,
or about thirty-three thousand dollars for a family of four.
Around the same time, Bartles heard about BeneStream, a company founded in 2011, in New
York City, that specializes in transferring eligible employees onto government health insurance.
For a fee, BeneStream would screen interested staff members, analyzing their household
earnings, assets, and family composition. Workers who qualified for Medicaid would have no co-
pays, no premiums, and full coverage for the entire family—an option far superior to what Hope
Haven could offer. The nonprofit, for its part, would save tens of thousands of dollars, freeing up
the budget for new hires. Since Hope Haven signed up with BeneStream a few years ago, Bartles
In the Media
2
said, his staff has increased by fifty per cent, while the organization’s health-care costs have
remained steady. “The agency wins. The employee wins. No one loses.”
BeneStream was founded by Benjamin Geyerhahn, a former health-care consultant. After the
Affordable Care Act was enacted, in 2010, he glimpsed a startup opportunity in Medicaid
expansion, which at the time was mandatory for every state. (A 2012 Supreme Court decision
made it optional.) Ideally, low-income people would apply for Medicaid on their own, but the
process is complicated, involving tedious paperwork, pay stubs for the entire household, and in-
person renewals—a challenge for low-income families who often face irregular working hours and
do not have paid leave. “The people we find who are most in need don’t know they’re entitled to
these benefits,” Geyerhahn said. Those who qualify are concentrated in low-wage sectors, such
as retail, hospitality, food manufacturing, and home-health and long-term care, and are often
among the forty-three million Americans burdened with medical debt.
A BeneStream representative told me that the company has helped nearly nine thousand people
obtain government health insurance in the thirty-one states, plus Washington, D.C., now availing
themselves of Medicaid expansion. It expects to earn three million dollars in revenue next year,
and intends to grow by doing business with large unions that are eager to reduce costs and
improve their members’ coverage. Darwin Camacho, a thirty-one-year-old garage attendant and
Teamsters Local 272 member from New York, told me that he switched to Medicaid this spring
with BeneStream’s help. Camacho, who is married and has a three-year-old son, earns eleven
dollars per hour. He had long been on the health plan offered by his union, but, he told me, there
were too many co-payments. “Everybody is struggling in this country at the moment,” he said.
“Only rich people can feel they are very fine.”
Camacho’s comments speak to BeneStream’s peculiar position in the ideological battle over
public health care. It is a for-profit company whose business model shifts costs onto taxpayers.
But, by enlarging the population enrolled in government plans, it highlights the inadequacy of
private-sector insurance. Geyerhahn markets BeneStream as a social enterprise that advocates
for employers, employees, and Medicaid alike. Employers, he said, “ought not to have to bear the
cost of health insurance.” This moderate view has helped BeneStream draw support from both
venture capitalists and philanthropists. The Ford Foundation was an early funder, and Andy Stern,
a former president of the two-million-member Service Employees International Union (S.E.I.U.),
sits on the company’s advisory board.
BeneStream is also part of an emergent “Obamacare economy.” Larry Levitt, a senior vice-
president at the Kaiser Family Foundation, told me that health-care-software and consulting firms
such as GetInsured, Manatt Health Solutions, and McKinsey are doing brisk business advising
employers on how to take optimal advantage of the A.C.A. marketplace and insurance subsidies.
Like these companies, BeneStream and its rival Med Enroll, which focus on the Medicaid-
In the Media
3
expansion provision, are profit-driven. But, should they succeed in moving tens of thousands of
low-wage workers onto Medicaid, they could influence the long-standing debate over public and
private approaches to health care.
Nearly a century ago, corporations like Eastman Kodak and Sears, Roebuck established a
tradition of welfare capitalism in the U.S., by providing doctor’s visits, time off, and recreation to
loyal, lifelong workers. Around the same time, reformers attuned to the needs of the poor,
unemployed, and elderly began the call for a national health system—a cause that various
Presidents took up in the decades that followed. Their opponents, including the American Medical
Association, have fought back in remarkably consistent terms. As Jill Lepore wrote in a 2012
feature for the magazine, after President Harry Trumanproposed a federal health program funded
by a payroll tax, an operative hired by the A.M.A. told a group of doctors, “Hitler and Stalin and
the socialistgovernment of Great Britain all have used the opiate of socialized medicine to deaden
the pain of lost liberty . . . compulsory health insurance, if allowed to spread to our New World,
will mark the beginning of the end of free institutions in America.”
Nevertheless, by 1965, Medicaid and Medicare had been signed into law. Retirees and
households living in poverty were given a public option, but employer-derived benefits had long
since become the norm. American liberals, resigned to something far short of a single-payer
system, pivoted to argue that employers should pay a living wage and provide affordable benefit
plans to their employees. Recent worker campaigns, including OUR Walmart and Fight for 15,
have invoked this responsibility as a talking point, broadcasting sympathetic tales of full-time
McDonald’s workers subsisting on charitable donations and food stamps. No gainfully employed
adult should have to rely on public assistance, the logic goes.
In this light, the Affordable Care Act’s move to extend Medicaid to families living above the poverty
line represented an important step toward the public model. Geyerhahn wouldn’t tell me whether
he supported a national single-payer system, but he did say that advocates of “Medicare for All,”
as Bernie Sanders has it, should celebrate what BeneStream does. “If companies are counting
on food stamps and Medicaid as part of their business plan, it means that you will have powerful
interests in favor of those programs,” he said. And Stern, the BeneStream adviser and former
S.E.I.U. president, told methat workers in the so-called 1099 economycould offer further support.
“Obamacare and the expansion of Medicaid represent an incredible shift toward separating
benefits from employers,” he said. “For freelancers and Uber workers, this becomes a muchmore
compelling question moving forward.”
Six years after the Affordable Care Act was enacted, there is evidence that support for Medicaid
expansion is growing. Conservative Louisiana came around just this year, after John Bel
Edwards, a Democrat, succeeded Republican Bobby Jindal as the state’s governor. On July 1st,
Edwards raised the state’s Medicaid income limit, embracing three hundred and seventy-five
In the Media
4
thousand previously uninsured residents and saving the state six hundred and seventy-seven
million dollars over the next five years. “I don’t look at this as some revolutionary thing,” he said.
“This is just the right thing to do.” President Obama echoed this point last week, in an article
published, ironically, in the Journal of the American Medical Association, that longtime foe of
public health care.“The nation typically reaches its greatest heights when we find commonground
between the public and private good and adjust along the way,” he wrote. “That was my approach
with the ACA.” It’s BeneStream’s approach as well.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Radical restructuring
Radical restructuringRadical restructuring
Radical restructuringDocJess
 
Modern American Health Care: Balancing Performance and Compliance in the Curr...
Modern American Health Care: Balancing Performance and Compliance in the Curr...Modern American Health Care: Balancing Performance and Compliance in the Curr...
Modern American Health Care: Balancing Performance and Compliance in the Curr...Craig B. Garner
 
Health Care Reform Goes Live: Day Three in the Current Climate of Reform
Health Care Reform Goes Live: Day Three in the Current Climate of ReformHealth Care Reform Goes Live: Day Three in the Current Climate of Reform
Health Care Reform Goes Live: Day Three in the Current Climate of ReformCraig B. Garner
 
Health Plan Week 1-9-17
Health Plan Week 1-9-17Health Plan Week 1-9-17
Health Plan Week 1-9-17Shaun Greene
 
Healthcare Reform Talk 6 6 2010
Healthcare Reform Talk 6 6 2010Healthcare Reform Talk 6 6 2010
Healthcare Reform Talk 6 6 2010jqvd4pc
 
Affordable Care Act
Affordable Care ActAffordable Care Act
Affordable Care Actantonedion
 
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care ActAnalysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care ActKaryssa Costagliola
 
case analysis affordable care act
case analysis affordable care actcase analysis affordable care act
case analysis affordable care actBobbi Jo Glowacki
 
The Future of American Healthcare and ObamaCare
The Future of American Healthcare and ObamaCareThe Future of American Healthcare and ObamaCare
The Future of American Healthcare and ObamaCareVäth Consulting LLC
 
CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2009
CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2009CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2009
CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2009masscare
 
Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...
Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...
Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...Paige Catizone
 
Health care for all, but at what cost the concrete producer
Health care for all, but at what cost    the concrete producerHealth care for all, but at what cost    the concrete producer
Health care for all, but at what cost the concrete producerJoel Ungar
 
Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Patient Protection and Affordable Care ActPatient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Patient Protection and Affordable Care ActPaul English
 
How to stabilize the 2017 healthcare market
How to stabilize the 2017 healthcare marketHow to stabilize the 2017 healthcare market
How to stabilize the 2017 healthcare marketJoshua Feldman
 
Public Option
Public OptionPublic Option
Public Optiontoolgal
 
HSH Service 2012-14 (Proposed) Agenda
HSH Service 2012-14 (Proposed) AgendaHSH Service 2012-14 (Proposed) Agenda
HSH Service 2012-14 (Proposed) AgendaMichael Hill
 
Public Option Paper Final
Public Option Paper FinalPublic Option Paper Final
Public Option Paper Finaltoolgal
 

Tendances (19)

Radical restructuring
Radical restructuringRadical restructuring
Radical restructuring
 
Modern American Health Care: Balancing Performance and Compliance in the Curr...
Modern American Health Care: Balancing Performance and Compliance in the Curr...Modern American Health Care: Balancing Performance and Compliance in the Curr...
Modern American Health Care: Balancing Performance and Compliance in the Curr...
 
Health Care Reform Goes Live: Day Three in the Current Climate of Reform
Health Care Reform Goes Live: Day Three in the Current Climate of ReformHealth Care Reform Goes Live: Day Three in the Current Climate of Reform
Health Care Reform Goes Live: Day Three in the Current Climate of Reform
 
Health Plan Week 1-9-17
Health Plan Week 1-9-17Health Plan Week 1-9-17
Health Plan Week 1-9-17
 
Healthcare Reform Talk 6 6 2010
Healthcare Reform Talk 6 6 2010Healthcare Reform Talk 6 6 2010
Healthcare Reform Talk 6 6 2010
 
Affordable Care Act
Affordable Care ActAffordable Care Act
Affordable Care Act
 
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care ActAnalysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Analysis of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
 
case analysis affordable care act
case analysis affordable care actcase analysis affordable care act
case analysis affordable care act
 
Jrnl of Healthcare Contracting
Jrnl of Healthcare ContractingJrnl of Healthcare Contracting
Jrnl of Healthcare Contracting
 
The Future of American Healthcare and ObamaCare
The Future of American Healthcare and ObamaCareThe Future of American Healthcare and ObamaCare
The Future of American Healthcare and ObamaCare
 
CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2009
CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2009CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2009
CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2009
 
Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...
Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...
Analysis of the patient protection and affordable care act paper, hcs410, hea...
 
Health care for all, but at what cost the concrete producer
Health care for all, but at what cost    the concrete producerHealth care for all, but at what cost    the concrete producer
Health care for all, but at what cost the concrete producer
 
Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Patient Protection and Affordable Care ActPatient Protection and Affordable Care Act
Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
 
legs 010908
legs 010908legs 010908
legs 010908
 
How to stabilize the 2017 healthcare market
How to stabilize the 2017 healthcare marketHow to stabilize the 2017 healthcare market
How to stabilize the 2017 healthcare market
 
Public Option
Public OptionPublic Option
Public Option
 
HSH Service 2012-14 (Proposed) Agenda
HSH Service 2012-14 (Proposed) AgendaHSH Service 2012-14 (Proposed) Agenda
HSH Service 2012-14 (Proposed) Agenda
 
Public Option Paper Final
Public Option Paper FinalPublic Option Paper Final
Public Option Paper Final
 

En vedette

Unit 27, 6 of 7
Unit 27, 6 of 7Unit 27, 6 of 7
Unit 27, 6 of 7Liam Lee
 
Unit 27, 3 of 7
Unit 27, 3 of 7Unit 27, 3 of 7
Unit 27, 3 of 7Liam Lee
 
Unit 27, 1 of 7
Unit 27, 1 of 7Unit 27, 1 of 7
Unit 27, 1 of 7Liam Lee
 
Unit 5 - Liam Lee
Unit 5 - Liam LeeUnit 5 - Liam Lee
Unit 5 - Liam LeeLiam Lee
 
NPR_NJ Factory Turns To Medicaid To Insure LowestPaid Employees
NPR_NJ Factory Turns To Medicaid To Insure LowestPaid EmployeesNPR_NJ Factory Turns To Medicaid To Insure LowestPaid Employees
NPR_NJ Factory Turns To Medicaid To Insure LowestPaid EmployeesDiane Keefe
 
Unit 27, 6 of 7
Unit 27, 6 of 7Unit 27, 6 of 7
Unit 27, 6 of 7Liam Lee
 
Unit 5, Liam Lee
Unit 5, Liam LeeUnit 5, Liam Lee
Unit 5, Liam LeeLiam Lee
 
Unit 27, 3 of 7
Unit 27, 3 of 7Unit 27, 3 of 7
Unit 27, 3 of 7Liam Lee
 
Unit 27, 1 of 7
Unit 27, 1 of 7Unit 27, 1 of 7
Unit 27, 1 of 7Liam Lee
 
Liam Lee - Unit 5
Liam Lee - Unit 5Liam Lee - Unit 5
Liam Lee - Unit 5Liam Lee
 
Presentation
Presentation Presentation
Presentation Liam Lee
 
SLAs - How to Meet Your Customer Expectations
SLAs - How to Meet Your Customer ExpectationsSLAs - How to Meet Your Customer Expectations
SLAs - How to Meet Your Customer ExpectationsKayako
 
Our 5 step process to hire for excellence - Kayako webinar slides
Our 5 step process to hire for excellence - Kayako webinar slidesOur 5 step process to hire for excellence - Kayako webinar slides
Our 5 step process to hire for excellence - Kayako webinar slidesKayako
 

En vedette (14)

Unit 27, 6 of 7
Unit 27, 6 of 7Unit 27, 6 of 7
Unit 27, 6 of 7
 
report A
report Areport A
report A
 
Unit 27, 3 of 7
Unit 27, 3 of 7Unit 27, 3 of 7
Unit 27, 3 of 7
 
Unit 27, 1 of 7
Unit 27, 1 of 7Unit 27, 1 of 7
Unit 27, 1 of 7
 
Unit 5 - Liam Lee
Unit 5 - Liam LeeUnit 5 - Liam Lee
Unit 5 - Liam Lee
 
NPR_NJ Factory Turns To Medicaid To Insure LowestPaid Employees
NPR_NJ Factory Turns To Medicaid To Insure LowestPaid EmployeesNPR_NJ Factory Turns To Medicaid To Insure LowestPaid Employees
NPR_NJ Factory Turns To Medicaid To Insure LowestPaid Employees
 
Unit 27, 6 of 7
Unit 27, 6 of 7Unit 27, 6 of 7
Unit 27, 6 of 7
 
Unit 5, Liam Lee
Unit 5, Liam LeeUnit 5, Liam Lee
Unit 5, Liam Lee
 
Unit 27, 3 of 7
Unit 27, 3 of 7Unit 27, 3 of 7
Unit 27, 3 of 7
 
Unit 27, 1 of 7
Unit 27, 1 of 7Unit 27, 1 of 7
Unit 27, 1 of 7
 
Liam Lee - Unit 5
Liam Lee - Unit 5Liam Lee - Unit 5
Liam Lee - Unit 5
 
Presentation
Presentation Presentation
Presentation
 
SLAs - How to Meet Your Customer Expectations
SLAs - How to Meet Your Customer ExpectationsSLAs - How to Meet Your Customer Expectations
SLAs - How to Meet Your Customer Expectations
 
Our 5 step process to hire for excellence - Kayako webinar slides
Our 5 step process to hire for excellence - Kayako webinar slidesOur 5 step process to hire for excellence - Kayako webinar slides
Our 5 step process to hire for excellence - Kayako webinar slides
 

Similaire à The New Yorker_The New Obamacare Economy

Health Care Reform And The Affordable Care Act
Health Care Reform And The Affordable Care ActHealth Care Reform And The Affordable Care Act
Health Care Reform And The Affordable Care ActJennifer Lyons
 
Affordable Care Act And Small Business
Affordable Care Act And Small BusinessAffordable Care Act And Small Business
Affordable Care Act And Small BusinessRochelle Schear
 
Affordable Care Act Analysis
Affordable Care Act AnalysisAffordable Care Act Analysis
Affordable Care Act AnalysisTracy Clark
 
Welfare Reform Act Of 1996
Welfare Reform Act Of 1996Welfare Reform Act Of 1996
Welfare Reform Act Of 1996Julie Morales
 
Introduction Of Healthcare.Gov As A Health Insurance...
Introduction Of Healthcare.Gov As A Health Insurance...Introduction Of Healthcare.Gov As A Health Insurance...
Introduction Of Healthcare.Gov As A Health Insurance...Katie Parker
 
Health Insurance Exchange Essay
Health Insurance Exchange EssayHealth Insurance Exchange Essay
Health Insurance Exchange EssayLisa Stephens
 
California Aa Case Study
California Aa Case StudyCalifornia Aa Case Study
California Aa Case StudyKimberly Jones
 
The Multi Vs Single Payer System
The Multi Vs Single Payer SystemThe Multi Vs Single Payer System
The Multi Vs Single Payer SystemAmanda Barber
 
[LOOKING BACK... Insurance Advocate, 25 years ago]Mandate.docx
[LOOKING BACK... Insurance Advocate, 25  years ago]Mandate.docx[LOOKING BACK... Insurance Advocate, 25  years ago]Mandate.docx
[LOOKING BACK... Insurance Advocate, 25 years ago]Mandate.docxgerardkortney
 
The Massachusetts Model Of Healthcare Reform
The Massachusetts Model Of Healthcare ReformThe Massachusetts Model Of Healthcare Reform
The Massachusetts Model Of Healthcare ReformJen Cloud
 
Health Care Delivery System Essay
Health Care Delivery System EssayHealth Care Delivery System Essay
Health Care Delivery System EssayKarrie Garcia
 
CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2006
CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2006CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2006
CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2006masscare
 
575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01
575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01
575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01Jon Nadler
 
The Patient Protection Affordable Care Act Essay
The Patient Protection Affordable Care Act EssayThe Patient Protection Affordable Care Act Essay
The Patient Protection Affordable Care Act EssayErica Baldwin
 

Similaire à The New Yorker_The New Obamacare Economy (20)

Implementing the Affordable Care Act in New Jersey, March 2011
Implementing the Affordable Care Act in New Jersey, March 2011Implementing the Affordable Care Act in New Jersey, March 2011
Implementing the Affordable Care Act in New Jersey, March 2011
 
Benefit Package Case Study
Benefit Package Case StudyBenefit Package Case Study
Benefit Package Case Study
 
Health Care Reform And The Affordable Care Act
Health Care Reform And The Affordable Care ActHealth Care Reform And The Affordable Care Act
Health Care Reform And The Affordable Care Act
 
Affordable Care Act
Affordable Care ActAffordable Care Act
Affordable Care Act
 
Affordable Care Act And Small Business
Affordable Care Act And Small BusinessAffordable Care Act And Small Business
Affordable Care Act And Small Business
 
Affordable Care Act Analysis
Affordable Care Act AnalysisAffordable Care Act Analysis
Affordable Care Act Analysis
 
Welfare Reform Act Of 1996
Welfare Reform Act Of 1996Welfare Reform Act Of 1996
Welfare Reform Act Of 1996
 
Introduction Of Healthcare.Gov As A Health Insurance...
Introduction Of Healthcare.Gov As A Health Insurance...Introduction Of Healthcare.Gov As A Health Insurance...
Introduction Of Healthcare.Gov As A Health Insurance...
 
Health Insurance Exchange Essay
Health Insurance Exchange EssayHealth Insurance Exchange Essay
Health Insurance Exchange Essay
 
Obama care
Obama careObama care
Obama care
 
California Aa Case Study
California Aa Case StudyCalifornia Aa Case Study
California Aa Case Study
 
Political ppt
Political pptPolitical ppt
Political ppt
 
Medicare Pros And Cons
Medicare Pros And ConsMedicare Pros And Cons
Medicare Pros And Cons
 
The Multi Vs Single Payer System
The Multi Vs Single Payer SystemThe Multi Vs Single Payer System
The Multi Vs Single Payer System
 
[LOOKING BACK... Insurance Advocate, 25 years ago]Mandate.docx
[LOOKING BACK... Insurance Advocate, 25  years ago]Mandate.docx[LOOKING BACK... Insurance Advocate, 25  years ago]Mandate.docx
[LOOKING BACK... Insurance Advocate, 25 years ago]Mandate.docx
 
The Massachusetts Model Of Healthcare Reform
The Massachusetts Model Of Healthcare ReformThe Massachusetts Model Of Healthcare Reform
The Massachusetts Model Of Healthcare Reform
 
Health Care Delivery System Essay
Health Care Delivery System EssayHealth Care Delivery System Essay
Health Care Delivery System Essay
 
CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2006
CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2006CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2006
CommonHealth Newsletter - Spring 2006
 
575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01
575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01
575c1cf5 7528-425e-b718-b2261305cc8b-150320130848-conversion-gate01
 
The Patient Protection Affordable Care Act Essay
The Patient Protection Affordable Care Act EssayThe Patient Protection Affordable Care Act Essay
The Patient Protection Affordable Care Act Essay
 

The New Yorker_The New Obamacare Economy

  • 1. In the Media 1 THE NEW OBAMACARE ECONOMY By E. Tammy Kim Photo: Stock4B/Getty 07/21/2016 Business is brisk for consulting firms and others who help employers take advantage of insurance subsidies to comply with the Affordable Care Act. The employees of Hope Haven, a nonprofit organization in Burlington, Iowa, provide services to some five hundred people with intellectual and physical disabilities, often in their clients’ homes. Depending on the day, they can be called upon to work as companions, cleaners, readers, personal shoppers, cooks, or bathers. “We have situations where we support people twenty-four hours a day,” Bob Bartles, Hope Haven’s executive director, told me. His staff members perform intimate labors of compassion, yet, as low-wage workers, they, too, are a vulnerable class. “Our entry wage is $11.25 per hour,” Bartles said. “We’re about ninety-per-cent funded by the government. Most of that is Medicaid, and Medicaid doesn’t set rates that allow us to pay much more.” Bartles has also struggled to offer a decent health-care plan to his workers, in compliance with the Affordable Care Act’s employer mandate. The best he could find, given Hope Haven’s financial constraints, came with co-pays and a high deductible, plus extra fees for vision, dental, and family coverage. Even then, it cost the organization nearly eight thousand dollars per person per year. So Bartles took note in 2014, when Iowa joined a slim majority of states that expanded Medicaid, under the A.C.A. Suddenly, Medicaid was available to a larger segment of the working poor—those with incomes up to a hundred and thirty-eight per cent of the federal poverty level, or about thirty-three thousand dollars for a family of four. Around the same time, Bartles heard about BeneStream, a company founded in 2011, in New York City, that specializes in transferring eligible employees onto government health insurance. For a fee, BeneStream would screen interested staff members, analyzing their household earnings, assets, and family composition. Workers who qualified for Medicaid would have no co- pays, no premiums, and full coverage for the entire family—an option far superior to what Hope Haven could offer. The nonprofit, for its part, would save tens of thousands of dollars, freeing up the budget for new hires. Since Hope Haven signed up with BeneStream a few years ago, Bartles
  • 2. In the Media 2 said, his staff has increased by fifty per cent, while the organization’s health-care costs have remained steady. “The agency wins. The employee wins. No one loses.” BeneStream was founded by Benjamin Geyerhahn, a former health-care consultant. After the Affordable Care Act was enacted, in 2010, he glimpsed a startup opportunity in Medicaid expansion, which at the time was mandatory for every state. (A 2012 Supreme Court decision made it optional.) Ideally, low-income people would apply for Medicaid on their own, but the process is complicated, involving tedious paperwork, pay stubs for the entire household, and in- person renewals—a challenge for low-income families who often face irregular working hours and do not have paid leave. “The people we find who are most in need don’t know they’re entitled to these benefits,” Geyerhahn said. Those who qualify are concentrated in low-wage sectors, such as retail, hospitality, food manufacturing, and home-health and long-term care, and are often among the forty-three million Americans burdened with medical debt. A BeneStream representative told me that the company has helped nearly nine thousand people obtain government health insurance in the thirty-one states, plus Washington, D.C., now availing themselves of Medicaid expansion. It expects to earn three million dollars in revenue next year, and intends to grow by doing business with large unions that are eager to reduce costs and improve their members’ coverage. Darwin Camacho, a thirty-one-year-old garage attendant and Teamsters Local 272 member from New York, told me that he switched to Medicaid this spring with BeneStream’s help. Camacho, who is married and has a three-year-old son, earns eleven dollars per hour. He had long been on the health plan offered by his union, but, he told me, there were too many co-payments. “Everybody is struggling in this country at the moment,” he said. “Only rich people can feel they are very fine.” Camacho’s comments speak to BeneStream’s peculiar position in the ideological battle over public health care. It is a for-profit company whose business model shifts costs onto taxpayers. But, by enlarging the population enrolled in government plans, it highlights the inadequacy of private-sector insurance. Geyerhahn markets BeneStream as a social enterprise that advocates for employers, employees, and Medicaid alike. Employers, he said, “ought not to have to bear the cost of health insurance.” This moderate view has helped BeneStream draw support from both venture capitalists and philanthropists. The Ford Foundation was an early funder, and Andy Stern, a former president of the two-million-member Service Employees International Union (S.E.I.U.), sits on the company’s advisory board. BeneStream is also part of an emergent “Obamacare economy.” Larry Levitt, a senior vice- president at the Kaiser Family Foundation, told me that health-care-software and consulting firms such as GetInsured, Manatt Health Solutions, and McKinsey are doing brisk business advising employers on how to take optimal advantage of the A.C.A. marketplace and insurance subsidies. Like these companies, BeneStream and its rival Med Enroll, which focus on the Medicaid-
  • 3. In the Media 3 expansion provision, are profit-driven. But, should they succeed in moving tens of thousands of low-wage workers onto Medicaid, they could influence the long-standing debate over public and private approaches to health care. Nearly a century ago, corporations like Eastman Kodak and Sears, Roebuck established a tradition of welfare capitalism in the U.S., by providing doctor’s visits, time off, and recreation to loyal, lifelong workers. Around the same time, reformers attuned to the needs of the poor, unemployed, and elderly began the call for a national health system—a cause that various Presidents took up in the decades that followed. Their opponents, including the American Medical Association, have fought back in remarkably consistent terms. As Jill Lepore wrote in a 2012 feature for the magazine, after President Harry Trumanproposed a federal health program funded by a payroll tax, an operative hired by the A.M.A. told a group of doctors, “Hitler and Stalin and the socialistgovernment of Great Britain all have used the opiate of socialized medicine to deaden the pain of lost liberty . . . compulsory health insurance, if allowed to spread to our New World, will mark the beginning of the end of free institutions in America.” Nevertheless, by 1965, Medicaid and Medicare had been signed into law. Retirees and households living in poverty were given a public option, but employer-derived benefits had long since become the norm. American liberals, resigned to something far short of a single-payer system, pivoted to argue that employers should pay a living wage and provide affordable benefit plans to their employees. Recent worker campaigns, including OUR Walmart and Fight for 15, have invoked this responsibility as a talking point, broadcasting sympathetic tales of full-time McDonald’s workers subsisting on charitable donations and food stamps. No gainfully employed adult should have to rely on public assistance, the logic goes. In this light, the Affordable Care Act’s move to extend Medicaid to families living above the poverty line represented an important step toward the public model. Geyerhahn wouldn’t tell me whether he supported a national single-payer system, but he did say that advocates of “Medicare for All,” as Bernie Sanders has it, should celebrate what BeneStream does. “If companies are counting on food stamps and Medicaid as part of their business plan, it means that you will have powerful interests in favor of those programs,” he said. And Stern, the BeneStream adviser and former S.E.I.U. president, told methat workers in the so-called 1099 economycould offer further support. “Obamacare and the expansion of Medicaid represent an incredible shift toward separating benefits from employers,” he said. “For freelancers and Uber workers, this becomes a muchmore compelling question moving forward.” Six years after the Affordable Care Act was enacted, there is evidence that support for Medicaid expansion is growing. Conservative Louisiana came around just this year, after John Bel Edwards, a Democrat, succeeded Republican Bobby Jindal as the state’s governor. On July 1st, Edwards raised the state’s Medicaid income limit, embracing three hundred and seventy-five
  • 4. In the Media 4 thousand previously uninsured residents and saving the state six hundred and seventy-seven million dollars over the next five years. “I don’t look at this as some revolutionary thing,” he said. “This is just the right thing to do.” President Obama echoed this point last week, in an article published, ironically, in the Journal of the American Medical Association, that longtime foe of public health care.“The nation typically reaches its greatest heights when we find commonground between the public and private good and adjust along the way,” he wrote. “That was my approach with the ACA.” It’s BeneStream’s approach as well.