SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 16
Download to read offline
By Kevin H. Connelly
Executive Vice President
The RWC Group
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING
From the Banker’s Perspective
www.therwcgroup.com
(913) 660-2734
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 1
Customer payments
using currency and
checks are a fact of life
for retailers and small
businesses, which
generate large amounts
of cash and checks
that need to be
deposited to a bank.
CHECKS: A FACT OF LIFE
Customer payments using currency and checks are a fact of life for retailers and
small businesses, which generate large amounts of cash and checks that need to be
deposited to a bank. More than 4.3 million business locations1
make more than two
billion check and cash deposits annually to U.S. banks. These cash and check deposits
enter into the banking system via one of five primary methods:
Since the 2008 financial crisis, U.S. banks have been ramping up mobile, remote
deposit and online services and moving away from physical locations to avoid
overlap. Culling branches, with their real-estate, labor and security costs, has become
a popular way for banks to boost profits at a time of sluggish revenue and loan
growth. The number of branch locations has steadily declined since 2009, according
to data from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.
As banks reshaped their retail infrastructure to cope with ever-increasing operating
costs, bankers have actively sought out — and invested in — technology to improve
and reengineer the commercial deposit process. Banks have introduced new deposit-
taking methods such as remote deposit, which enables the electronic capture of a
check image and depositing of the image via a bank’s web-based application. That
eliminates the need for the customer to travel to a bank branch and make the deposit
over the counter or via the night drop or ATM. The use of remote check deposit
services continues to grow rapidly, but it does not reduce the need to physically
deposit currency and coin.
As banks have reshaped their consumer (i.e., retail) delivery channels, significant
volumes of transactions have migrated to retail automated teller machines (ATMs)
and online banking. Banks have downsized branches in favor of supermarket outlets,
teller-less kiosks, and other non-commercial locations. As a result, businesses have
been left with fewer convenient bank depository locations or are required to pay
for costly armored services to transport deposits to central vaults.
Banks will continue to drive transaction volume out of their branch networks so
that these brick and mortar sites can be dedicated to selling financial products and
services. As a result, bank operational infrastructure is transforming to support
reshaped commercial deposit service delivery channels.
1
U.S. Census Bureau, Statistical Abstract of the United States: 2012
50%
20%
15%
5%
10%
1 Over-the-counter in a
bank branch
2  Into a night drop safe at
a bank branch
3 Via armored carrier to a
central cash vault
4 Via smart safe, then via carrier
to a central cash vault
5 Via remote deposit capture
service (checks only)
Figure B-1
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 2
At the core of a bank’s deposit product strategy is the depositor of cash and
checks. A bank’s deposit product strategy determines its service delivery channel
strategy, which is supported by an operational strategy. Technology, liquidity, and
regulatory strategies are cornerstones of an overall commercial deposit product
and system strategy, as depicted in Figure B-2 below. To remain cost competitive,
banks must develop deposit handling systems that monitor, track, process, and verify
cash on an integrated enterprise-wide common platform.
Consumer Cash and Check Transactions
Somewhat unexpectedly, the use of currency as a consumer payment medium
remains high. However, signs of the ongoing long-term transformation of payments
from paper instruments to cards and electronics remain evident. One catalyst in this
transformation has been the increasing popularity of bill-payment services offered by
consumers’ depository banks. By initiating payments via computer or mobile device,
the consumer avoids the cost of postage and the need to reconcile outstanding
checks; the merchant avoids the cost of processing paper checks and hauling them
to the bank for deposit; and the bank shifts a huge amount of paper processing to
electronic processing and sharply cuts the costs associated with printing and mailing
bank statements with paid checks (among many other savings).
Not only is more currency in circulation, but deposit transaction volume also
continues to increase from more commercial depositing locations. As banks have
transformed their branch systems by replacing large locations with small in-store or
supermarket branches, they have also aggressively replaced tellers with ATMs. Thus,
the banks have shifted consumer transactions from the teller line to the ATM line
and online. With banks downsizing their retail locations, commercial deposits are
increasingly processed through a diminished branch capacity. As a result, banks’ costs
associated with commercial deposit processing have perversely continued to increase
while service levels have declined.
The implications of these payment system trends and transformation of the banking
system delivery channel have driven, and will continue to drive, banks to reengineer
how they process commercial deposits.
Figure B-2
COMMERCIAL
DEPOSIT
SERVICES
DELIVERY
CHANNELS
BRANCH (1)
CASH VAULT (2)
SMART SAFE
ATM (3)
REMOTE
DEPOSIT
CAPTURE
CENTRAL
CHECK
Fees
and
Margin
RealTime
E-Information
and
WebTools
Transportation
and Deposit
Tracking
Cash
Management
and Funds
Availability
Image
Enablement
and
Automation
BSA/AML/KYC
and
Compliance
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 3
Current Business Deposit-Taking Services
Banks provide business customers multiple ways to make their commercial deposits,
including various related deposit services. The primary depository methods banks
provide to business clients are:
• Over-the-counter branch deposit
• Night drop branch deposit
• Check-only branch deposit
• Direct cash vault deposit
• Electronic deposits
• Remote deposit check capture
• Smart safes
• Other deposits (including debit/credit card merchant processing)
The use of one or all of these deposit-taking services depends upon the relative
proximity of the depositor and the bank, the timing and frequency of deposits, and
the amount of funds involved. Based on an industry survey of six major U.S. banks,
approximately 70 percent of commercial cash deposit transactions are made through
a bank branch (50 percent over the counter, 20 percent night drop), with the remain-
ing 20 percent of deposit transactions made directly to a bank’s central cash vault and
10 percent are deposited via remote check capture. Except for electronic deposits,
most of the common depository service processing provided by banks tends to be
archaic and relatively inefficient.
TRANSACTION COSTS
Transaction Cost Analysis
The rise of the digital consumer and the high-cost infrastructure of bank branches
lead to a declining return on investment (ROI) for banks and cut into profitability
of other areas of the bank. Branches remain an important interaction point with
customers, however, and play an essential role in complex product sales and relation-
ship building for both retail and small-business customers. But as customers transform
the way they bank, the value proposition of traditional branches comes into question.
The cost of a branch transaction is approximately 20 times higher than the mobile
transaction and 40 times higher than an online transaction. A 2012 study2
showed
that average transaction costs (including labor and IT costs) for U.S. banks were:
Figure B-3
Call Center
Branch
ATM
Mobile
IVR
Other
						 $4.04
						$4.00
$0.61
$0.19
$0.17
$0.09
Average Transaction
Cost in the US
(includes labor and IT costs)
As customers
transform the way
they bank, the
value proposition of
traditional branches
comes into question.
2
CEB TowerGroup 2012, as reported in “Rebooting the Branch: Branch Strategy in a Multi-
Global Environment,” PwC Financial Services Institute, December 2012 at www.PWC.com/f~i.
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 4
Objectives Regarding Transaction Costs
Banks and their service providers must continue to drive transaction costs lower
as market pricing is increasingly commoditized. The average list price for deposit
services increased by more than five percent between 2011 and 2012, according to
the Blue Book of Bank Prices.3
Meanwhile, the industry average labor cost for all teller
transactions (retail consumer and business) increased from $.61 in 2002 to $1.08 in
2013. Commercial deposit costs remain high, between $5.00 and $8.00 per average
business deposit, including cash and checks deposited over-the-counter or through
the night drop in a bank branch location.
While achieving a paperless environment is a worthy goal for banks, a less-paper
environment is a realistic starting point. Automating processes by deploying imaging
and business process management technologies is a preferred transition strategy for
migrating away from today’s paper-and labor-intensive environment. While the bank
may be actively reengineering, designing, and implementing new systems and processes,
it must build into those systems automated technology-based transaction monitoring
to ensure compliance with federal anti-money laundering laws.
REENGINEERING THE DEPOSIT-TAKING FUNCTION
Financial institutions have spent billions of dollars to automate systems that were
previously manual processes. The commercial deposit process employed by many
banks, however, has remained the same since the money changers handed gold coins
over stone tablets. More than 50 percent of commercial cash deposits continue to
be counted manually by tellers in branches.
The focus of reengineering is to optimize the process flow without focusing on
the efficiency of a particular task. For example, if a cash verification process from
input to its cumulative output requires seven steps in the current environment, the
reengineered environment should take only three steps.
The reengineered environment may certainly utilize automation, such as currency-
counting hardware, to optimize the process but the improvement does not rely on
automation in itself. The process of reengineering commercial deposit processing is
about improving how depository customers interact with the bank, reducing all-in
operational costs while enhancing a bank’ s competitive position.
Research demonstrates that
financial institutions spend
an inordinate amount of
time processing transactions
and handling cash deposit from
commercial customers within
the branch environment.1
Reducing in-branch commer-
cial transaction processing and
cash handling time would
allow financial institutions to
spend more time selling and
servicing their customers.2
Processing 50%
Administration 17%
Sales 18%
Customer Service 15%
Cash Deposit
Verification Hours 10%
Total Teller
Paid Hours 90%
1
Source: Reengineering the Bank,
Paul Allen
2
Source: Major Bank Study
3
The Blue Book of Bank Prices is published by Phoenix-Hecht, Research Triangle Park,
NC (919) 541-9339, www.PhoenixHecht.com
Few banks have
achieved optimal
conversion rates of
the post-deposit
verification service,
especially for over-
the-counter deposits
in branches made
by mid-sized and
small businesses.
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 5
There are eight primary phases involved in reengineering a bank’s commercial
deposit processes, as illustrated in Figure B-4 below. As the figure shows, the eight
phases overlap each other. A bank may implement these phases sequentially or
substantially simultaneously, depending upon larger strategic issues, geographic
limitations, or capital constraints.

Most major U.S. banks and many large international banks have implemented
Phases 1 and 2 but few have effectively addressed all of the phases of deposit
reengineering. It is important to note that of the banks that have implemented
Phase 1, few have achieved optimal conversion rates of the post-deposit verification
service, especially for over-the-counter deposits in branches made by mid-sized
and small businesses.
BRANCH
CASH VAULT
SMART SAFE
ATM
REMOTE
DEPOSIT
CAPTURE
CENTRAL
CHECK
Packet
Forward
Deposits to
CentralVault
Implement
Deposit Post
for OTC
Deposits
Implement
AML/KYC
Automation
Deploy or
Expand RDC
Service
Capability
BANK
DEPOSIT
SERVICE
REENGINEERING
Deploy
Alternative
Delivery Channels
Including
CommercialATM
Deploy
or Expand
Smart Safe
Service
Integrate Deposit
Tracking System
IntoAll Deposit
Channels
Outsource
Central
Vault Network
1 2
3
4
56
7
8
REVENUE
ENHANCEMENT
COST
MANAGEMENT
FLOAT
MANAGEMENT
RISK
MANAGEMENT
PRODUCT
DEVELOPMENT
Unit Cost
Study and
Operations
Productivity
FeeAnalysis
and
BillingAudit
Implement
AML/KYC
Automation
Deploy or
Expand RDC
Service
Capability
COMMERCIAL
DEPOSIT
SERVICE
PRODUCT
MANAGEMENT
BSA/AML/KYC
Compliance and
Processing Risk
Mitigation
Currency
Optimization
and Fed Balance
Requirements
Integrate Deposit
Tracking System
IntoAll Deposit
Channels
Infrastructure
and Sourcing
Rationalization
1 2
3
4
56
7
8
INVENTORY
MANAGEMENT
Figure B-4
PHASE I: Post-Deposit Verification
A post-deposit verification service enables business customers to deliver cash and
check deposits to a bank branch or other designated drop-off facility prior to
the business day cutoff and receive provisional credit for the deposit prior to the
currency actually being counted and verified. Typically, the credit is provisional; that is,
the deposit is subject to the bank’s final count, verification and, if required, adjust-
ment within a specified period of time, usually no more than forty-eight hours.
Numerous major banks have implemented commercial post verification deposit
services, most of which work in a substantially similar manner.
1 Deposits are placed in disposable, tamper-evident plastic deposit bags with two
compartments: one for checks and the deposit ticket, the other for cash.
2 The cash portion of the bag (usually the top compartment) is sealed through
the use of advanced adhesives and features that provide evidence of tampering
if unauthorized attempts are made to reopen the bag. The check portion of the
bag (usually the bottom compartment) is sealed with a reusable closure.
3 The customer’s name, location identifier, date, cash amount, checks amount, total
deposit amount, and other relevant information are written or pre-printed onto
the outside surface of the bag.
4 The bags are imprinted with unique tracking numbers, and sometimes bar codes.
This allows for effective tracing throughout the deposit process and can be a
useful tool in tracking misrouted or lost deposits. Bar coded deposit documents
are also used by advanced Deposit Tracking Systems that provide real time status
of a deposit from deposit location through final bank verification.
5 The fully prepared and sealed deposit bag is then brought to a bank branch and
presented to a teller, either by the customer or an armored carrier.
6 The teller removes, or “strips,” the checks from the re-sealable portion of the
deposit bag and processes the checks along with the original deposit ticket.
The checks and deposit ticket are entered into the ongoing branch proof-of-
deposit workflow.* The ledger credit and collected funds status of the check
portion of the deposit are based on the bank’s standard availability schedule.
7 The cash portion remains sealed in the bag and unverified. The teller enters
the cash total as a “provisional” credit based upon the “said to contain amount”
written on the deposit ticket. The teller prepares or the system generates a
“cash-in” or “cash-in-transit” transaction ticket, a copy of which accompanies
the cash deposit to the point of verification. Meanwhile, a duplicate cash-in ticket
is placed in the teller’s cash drawer as a substitute for the actual currency.*
8 The bank provides the customer with a deposit receipt indicating provisional
credit has been made to the customer’s bank account.
9 The bank then determines the most efficient and cost-effective location and
times to verify the cash portion of the deposit.
10 The final (i.e., non-provisional) currency credit is typically provided within
24-72 hours depending upon the bank’s policy, branch location, and verifica-
tion processes.
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 6
OPTION 1
Decentralized
Night Drop
Processing
OPTION 2
Centralized
Night Drop
Processing
BANK
BRANCH
DELIVERY
CHANNEL
“Strip” checks and
forwards to branch
POD stream
CASH VAULT
CHECK
PROCESSING
VERIFY CASH
IN-BRANCH
Step 1: Conversion to
dual pocket from single pocket
zipper lock canvas, vinyl,
non-standard plastic bags
Step 2: Implement improved
night drop depository service
processes using industry
“best practices”
The first phase of reengineer-
ing entails migrating night drop
commercial customers to a
standard tamper-evident plastic
deposit bag and improved night
drop process.
* Note: Teller capture or related back branch office image (or 3rd party) capture of check items
and related image workflow provides greater efficiency than physical transportation and
paper workflow.
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 7
Steps to Success
A bank can take several important steps designed to implement a post-verifica-
tion system:
1 Implement new customer deposit preparation procedures.
2 Begin charging for processing over-the-counter and night drop deposits.
3 Implement internal policies, procedures, and systems that support in-branch
post-verification of commercial deposits.
4 By transferring the post-verification process to off-peak times, teller transaction
processing time will be reduced, thereby reducing queue time and enabling
more customers to be serviced more quickly.
5 Ideally, service levels and profitability are optimized when the transaction
processing capacity equals the actual transaction volume throughout the
processing day, or:
Capacity= Volume
In an environment where CV, service levels deteriorate. Commercial depositary
customers typically are unwilling to endure long waits to make their deposits.
Conversely, where CV, idle capacity increases unit costs. This would occur during
low volume periods where tellers would be doing no productive work.
Step 1: Implement OTC post
verification product –
in-branch verification
Step 2: Implement optimal
processing infrastructure with
package forwarding as appropriate
BANK
BRANCH
DELIVERY
CHANNEL
CASH VAULT
CHECK
PROCESSING
Commercial Deposit Branch Workflow Dynamics
Optimizing the commercial deposit workflow processes enables reduction of teller
resource requirements by staffing to average instead of peak transaction volumes.
25
20
15
10
5
BranchTransaction
CommercialVolume
Prior Day
Work
Move to
Next Day
8 am 9 11 1pm 3 5 6
SAVINGS
Move Verification
to Non Peak
Move Verification
to Non Peak
By centralizing
night-drop processing,
the related volumes
can provide the bank
with greater economies
of scale sooner, both
for transportation
and processing.
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 8
PHASE 2: Process Centralization/Package Forwarding
A key element behind centralized processing is the use of package forwarding
to centralize the processing and verification of commercial deposits made over
the counter or via night drop at bank branches. The trend in retail bank delivery
channels continues toward the reduction and eventual elimination of tellers engaged
in processing activity. Instead, they are being redeployed into sales and customer
service activities. Likewise, commercial deposit processes must transition from the
teller lines in branches to a central processing environment.
There are three primary package forwarding models that should be considered in
Phase 2: in-branch, hub-and-spoke, and central vault (the latter two can be
outsourced). Each of these three package forwarding models can be used inde-
pendently or in conjunction with each other, depending upon a bank’s internal
capabilities and external market requirements.
Evaluating the Package Forwarding Models
Any evaluation to determine the optimum package forwarding model must consider
the following influencing factors:
• Changes to resource allocations. As work is transferred out of the branch and
into a hub-and-spoke or central vault environment, the human resource allocation
in the branch system must either be reduced or reallocated to customer service or
selling activities. The objective of Phase 2 is not to just move peas (costs) around
on the plate; rather it is to remove costs altogether by doing things better.*
• Transportation costs. Armored transportation costs are almost certain to
increase in a high-volume package forwarding model. It is very important to
maximize the customer conversion rate in Phase 1 to a post-verification service
first, before implementing Phase 2. Typically, a minimum of 25-35 post verified
deposits per branch, or a conversion rate of approximately 60 to 80 percent should
be achieved before a hub-and-spoke or central vault model offsets the incremental
transportation costs.*
• Night-drop processing. By their nature, night-drop deposits are already post-
verified. By centralizing night-drop processing, the related volumes can provide the
bank with greater economies of scale sooner, both for transportation and processing.
Time Savings for Commercial Customers
Completing verification processes in the back office will significantly reduce
wait time for retail and commercial customers. This differentiates your bank
by “giving more time back” to your commercial and retail customers.
Before Post
Verification
Processing
After Post
Verification
Processing
Immediate Verification
• 10-30 minute wait in line
• 5-15 minute teller
transaction time
Back Office Verification
• 5-10 minute wait in line
• 1-2 minute teller
transaction time
CustomerQueueTime
TimeAwayfromBusiness
CustomerService
CustomerSatisfaction
* Note: Teller capture or related back branch office image (or 3rd party) capture of check items
and related image workflow provides greater efficiency than physical transportation and
paper workflow.
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 9
• Market requirements. Market demands will greatly influence the final design of
the post-verification service and employment of package forwarding. Processing
deadlines, adjustment procedures, and pricing structures will vary by market.
• Inventory levels. Currency inventory levels have a carrying cost to the bank.
Historically, a bank’s inventory of currency could offset a significant portion of its
Federal Reserve required reserves. Now, mostly due to sweep accounts and related
yield management techniques, a bank’s vault cash levels typically equal or exceed
the reserve requirement. The bank, therefore, has a strong incentive to minimize
currency inventory levels by processing the currency and converting it to an earning
asset as quickly as possible.
• Risk mitigation. Processing risks in a decentralized teller environment are
inherently different from those in a centralized processing operation. A hub-and-
spoke or central vault environment can implement risk management procedures
faster, more securely, efficiently and effectively, and with a greater degree of success
than in a decentralized processing system.
Figure B-5
Today, a bank’s vault
cash levels typically
equal or exceed the
reserve requirement.
OPTIMIZE LOGISTICS, SERVICE AND COSTS
Hub-and-Spoke Regional Vault Infrastructure
External Vault Infrastructure Central Vault Hub-and-Spoke Network
In-Branch Cash Processing
DEPOSIT
Teller 1 Teller 2 Teller 3 Night DropTeller 4
Proof and
Check Processing
In-Branch
Post Verification
MIni-Vault Site
DEPOSIT
DEPOSIT
DEPOSIT
DEPOSIT
Post Verification
Hub Vault Site A
Post Verifica-
tion
Branch 1
OTC/ND Branch 2
OTC/ND
Branch 5
OTC/ND
Branch 4
OTC/ND
Branch 3
OTC/ND
Branch 9
OTC/ND
Branch 6
OTC/ND
Branch 7
OTC/ND
Branch 8
OTC/ND
Post Verification
Central Vault
Site
Branch 11
OTC/ND
Branch 15
OTC/ND
Branch 75
OTC/ND
Branch 45
OTC/ND
Branch5
OTC/ND
Direct
Vault
Customer
Branch 1
OTC/ND Branch 2
OTC/ND
Branch 5
OTC/ND
Branch 4
OTC/ND
Branch 3
OTC/ND
Branch 9
OTC/ND
Branch 6
OTC/ND
Branch 7
OTC/ND
Branch 8
OTC/ND
FED
Direct
Vault
Customer
Direct
Vault
Customer
Direct
Vault
Customer
Direct
Vault
Customer
Third-Party
Hub Vault
Size Z
Branch 1
OTC/ND Branch 2
OTC/ND
FED
Direct
Vault
Customer
Direct
Vault
Customer
Direct
Vault
Customer
Direct
Vault
Customer
Branch 4
OTC/NDBranch 3
OTC/ND
Many banks are
increasingly motivated
to outsource their cash
vaults to a third-party
service provider,
typically an armored
carrier or cash-in-
transit (CIT) company.
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 10
PHASE 3: Rationalize Central Vault Operations
Many banks have outsourced all or a portion of their back office cash handling
operations. In some instances a third party cash processor, such as an armored
carrier, can provide cash services at a lower cost than a bank can provide internally.
Four key considerations must be addressed when planning to outsource cash
deposit verification and currency/coin supply services to a third party vendor:
1 Customer ownership. Armored carriers have captured significant cash
processing market share from banks. As the carrier becomes the cash processing
entity, banks can lose not only the related cash processing revenues but also
intimacy with its customers.
2 Long term cost structure. Carriers tend to dominate certain regional
markets, which can result in significant increases in cash processing costs over
time. Competitive markets can be ensured through efficient and effective
business practices.
3 Risk. Increased risk is associated with maintaining the bank’s cash inventory
at an unregulated non-bank third party provider.
4 Service levels. Although some third party cash processors provide excellent
service levels, some do not. If a bank outsources its cash processing to a third
party and service levels decline, this can negatively impact the bank’s relationship
with its commercial customers regardless of the origin of the quality problem.
Investing in a cash vault infrastructure upgrade is an expensive proposition, but
banks’ aging vault infrastructures cannot support the required service or processing
efficiency levels without some new investment. Consequently, many banks are
increasingly motivated to outsource their cash vaults to a third-party service provider,
typically an armored carrier or cash-in-transit (CIT) company.
Additionally banks can realize great synergy between check and cash operations
reengineering. In particular, distributed check image capture in an outsourced
third-party cash vault can deliver both operational efficiencies as well as improved
service levels, such as later deposit deadlines. Outsourced cash vault check capture
and truncation is becoming commonplace as centralized item processing centers
have given way to distributed capture.
PHASE 4: Integrate Electronic Deposit Tracking Systems
Into All Channels
For most merchants, managing the daily check and cash deposit process is labor-
intensive, risky, and prone to errors. Store employees must manually collect and
count cash, then an employee or an armored truck service delivers it to the bank.
Similarly, the armored carrier and the bank of deposit engage in a manual, paper-
based, labor-intensive and high-cost process. Up to 10 or more paper documents
can be generated for each commercial deposit, and more when deposit discrepancies
and adjustments occur.
Electronic commercial depository systems (ECDS) create commercial deposit
information using machine-readable data formats, typically barcodes. An integrated
Smart safes can
improve employee
safety, minimize
cash-handling risk and
errors, boost staff
productivity, and
accelerate credit for
cash deposits.
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 11
ECDS system seamlessly links the commercial deposit and cash shipment information
through an intranet or Internet system providing real-time cash handling information
to participants at significantly lower costs. The industry leading ECDS service is DTS
Connex. DTS Connex enables online deposit creation and the ability to track
deposits through each step of the chain of custody. This cloud based service reports
when an armored carrier has picked up the deposits, when the depository banks
have received and credited each deposit, and if there were any adjustments to a
deposit.  The service then analyzes all that information to ensure the optimal deposit
process is deployed on a sustainable basis.
Small businesses, especially where they are retailers located in a shopping center or
mall, can facilitate their deposit and change order processing by using centrally located
commercial teller machines, commercial change order machines, and business-only
kiosks. Banks can employ these self-service business transaction machines to replace
or complement existing merchant teller or non-intelligent night-drop facilities.
PHASE 5: Deploy or Expand Smart Safe Service Capability
Technology enables banks to offer more effective solutions for managing coin and
currency. One such solution is a deposit-only electronic “smart” safe that a retailer
typically would contract for with an armored carrier. During the business day, store
employees deposit excess cash and large bills into the safe. At the end of the business
day, instead of preparing a deposit, all funds in excess of the next day’s starting fund
are inserted into the smart safe where they are secure and counted electronically.
Smart safes can improve employee safety, minimize cash-handling risk and errors,
boost staff productivity, and accelerate credit for cash deposits. They do have
limitations, however. Because the smart safes can hold a limited amount of currency,
they are best suited for smaller retailers, gas stations, or quick-serve restaurants. In
addition, most current smart safe products do not accept coins for deposit.
Smart safe deposit services can offer the following benefits:
• Improve cash flow with daily credit for cash placed in smart safes without
having to prepare a physical bank deposit.
• Lower costs by reducing daily armored carrier pickups to every fourth day.
• Virtually eliminate deposit adjustments.
• Save time in preparing and managing currency deposits.
• Mitigate opportunity for theft and provide added security.
PHASE 6: Deploy Alternate, Self-Service Deposit
Delivery Channels
Alternate deposit delivery channels include commercial ATMs with bulk deposit
capacity in high volume locations, commercial change order and change deposit
machines, as well as business-only kiosks and other cash handling technology and
processes designed to improve the profitability and competitiveness of a bank’s
commercial deposit services. Other deposit services can include making deposits
thru the U.S. mail or via a FedEx or UPS service partnership with a depository bank.
Remote Deposit
Capture typically
provides benefits
including merchant
convenience, faster
deposit availability,
quicker return of
dishonored checks,
and reduced tranpor-
tation cost and risk.
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 12
PHASE 7: Deploy or Expand Remote Deposit Capture
Service Capability
The Check 21 Act, which became effective in 2004, paved the way for the develop-
ment of Remote Deposit Capture (RDC) in which the merchant can create the
digital version of the original check and transmit the digital data to the merchant’s
depository bank, usually via a bank-provided Internet application, for credit to the
merchant’s account. The Check 21 Act created a new negotiable instrument called
a “substitute check,” which contains an image of the front and back of the original
check that can be processed in lieu of the original check. A substitute check is the
legal equivalent of an original check under the Check 21 Act.
The merchant captures the image of the check and transforms it into digital form
either as an image or data, then transmits this image or data electronically to the
merchant’s depository bank. The substitute check or the equivalent digital data
is cleared and settled electronically, thereby expediting credit to the customer’s
account. Remote Deposit Capture typically provides benefits including merchant
convenience, faster deposit availability, quicker return of dishonored checks, and
reduced transportation cost and risk. With increased use and service offerings,
the merchant’s cost to use RDC services (banking fees, scanner prices, etc.) are
expected to decrease over time.
Remote Deposit Capture has quickly evolved into a must-have deposit product
in most U.S.-based banks in order to remain competitive. The benefits to
depositors include:
• Saves trips to the bank.
• Accelerates clearing time and improves cash flow.
• Extends bank business hours.
• Reduces return item risk by accelerating returned items to the bank of first deposit.
• Facilitates regional or nationwide consolidation of banking relationships by
bypassing local depository banks.
The benefits of Remote Deposit Capture to banks include:
• Attracts low-cost deposits.
• Accommodates customers located beyond the branch’s local area.
• Reduces branch servicing costs by extending the self-service channel.
• Reduces processing costs.
• Eliminates transportation costs and delays in deposits reaching the bank.
• Reduces paper deposit ticket costs.
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 13
PHASE 8: Implement Enhanced Automated AML and
KYC Technology Solutions
Banks and other financial institutions are subject to the Bank Secrecy Act and its
anti-money laundering provisions. This is frequently referred to as BSA/AML. In
reengineering the depository function, banks must continue to comply with the Act’s
provisions regardless of whether transactions are handled manually or electronically,
or remotely or in a bank branch.
Compliance with BSA/AML policy and regulatory procedures and auditing make it
necessary for banks to increase their investment in expertise, qualified resources,
improved processes, monitoring, and technology in order to monitor critical activities
and transactions. BSA/AML is enforced by FinCEN, the Financial Crimes Enforcement
Network, which is a bureau of the U.S. Treasury Department.
Also driving financial institutions to implement AML software were increased regula-
tory requirements, such as FinCEN’s rule for reporting cross-border electronic funds
transfers, and the due diligence process mandated by the “Know-Your-Customer”
(KYC) provision of the 2001 USA Patriot Act for all financial institutions. New lengths
of customer due diligence and risk evaluation were mandated when a financial
institution opens a new customer relationship.
Another factor driving the spending growth was the broadening of regulatory scrutiny
to new segments such as small banks, credit unions, insurers, and brokerages or non-
bank entities such as PayPal. Previously, many such institutions handled AML require-
ments through manual processes or avoided them altogether. However, regulators
are increasingly putting pressure on these industry segments to implement industry
standard technology.
Finally, the trend to integrate anti-money laundering and antifraud operations onto
a common platform — the enterprise-wide compliance approach — is gathering
steam, with a significant number of financial institutions adding new anti-fraud
modules to existing AML platforms, or replacing legacy systems with software
capable of supporting both AML and anti-fraud functions.
COMMERCIAL DEPOSIT PRODUCT MANAGEMENT
Demand deposit accounts (DDA) and related services, currency and coin services,
and check processing are the cornerstone of a bank’s profit margin for cash
management services. Like any business, the well-managed bank seeks multiple
opportunities to enhance profitability by increasing revenues, controlling costs,
managing its inventory (of coin and currency), and managing the risks inherent
in all of these.
Demand deposit
accounts (DDA)
and related services,
currency and coin
services, and check
processing are the
cornerstone of a bank’s
profit margin for cash
management services.
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 14
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
The payments landscape has changed significantly and bankers must adapt or be
disintermediated by those changes. Check volume will continue to diminish, remote
deposit capture will continue to proliferate, and coin and currency are here to stay.
Online and mobile banking, coupled with increased ATM functionality, will drive
consumer banking while non-bank payments and digital wallet services such as
Apple Pay are becoming more widely accepted among both consumers and their
financial institutions.
New regulations and increased regulatory scrutiny will continue to drive up banks’
costs, while new risks will necessitate improved governance, risk management,
automation, and compliance systems. Banks must reengineer their commercial
deposit products, operations, risk management and cost structures in order to
remain competitive and profitable. All of this affects the way that businesses interface
with their banks and the costs they bear as customers.
The payments land-
scape has changed
significantly and
bankers must adapt or
be disintermediated
by those changes.
KEVIN H. CONNELLY has spent the past 30 years working in the financial
institution and payment system industries. Currently, he is the Executive Vice
President at The RWC Group, a value-added provider of payment system advisory
services and expert contract resources to more than 100 financial institutions and the
federal government. He is also the President and Founder of Treasury Technologies,
LLC, an industry-leading provider of next-generation payment system solutions.
Previously, Kevin was Senior Vice President and Managing Director of the Financial
Services Group at Trintech, a financial software solution company based in Dallas.
Additional positions held by Kevin included Senior Vice President and Manager
of the Treasury/Payments Division of Commerce Bank and Managing Principal at
Carreker Corporation.
Kevin has been a presenter on corporate bank relations and cash forecasting for
the American Management Association course on Corporate Cash Management,
as well as a frequent speaker at cash management and payment industry events.
In addition, he is a co-patent holder of an innovative payment system Internet
application, the Deposit Tracking System.
Kevin earned his B.B.A. in Finance at the R.O. Anderson School of Management
at the University of New Mexico.
White Paper is based upon excerpts from the Deposit Re-engineering – Bankers
Perspective, Chapter 13, Corporate Cash Management Handbook, published 2015
by Thomson Reuters.
Permission to re-print excerpts granted by Thomson Reuters, publisher.
Author: Kevin Connelly. Edited by Richard Bort © Kevin Connelly
DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 15
www.therwcgroup.com
(913) 660-2734

More Related Content

What's hot

APPLICATION OF E-BANKING IN BANGLADESH
APPLICATION OF  E-BANKING  IN BANGLADESHAPPLICATION OF  E-BANKING  IN BANGLADESH
APPLICATION OF E-BANKING IN BANGLADESHSaibal Nath
 
The Drive to Electronic Remittance Exchange in Business-to Business Payment A...
The Drive to Electronic Remittance Exchange in Business-to Business Payment A...The Drive to Electronic Remittance Exchange in Business-to Business Payment A...
The Drive to Electronic Remittance Exchange in Business-to Business Payment A...Nasreen Quibria
 
Direct Benefits White Paper_April 2016
Direct Benefits White Paper_April 2016Direct Benefits White Paper_April 2016
Direct Benefits White Paper_April 2016Alex Reddish
 
Debitfees costs 2013
Debitfees costs 2013Debitfees costs 2013
Debitfees costs 2013feelrj2
 
The Most Recommended Fintech Solution Providers 2020
The Most Recommended Fintech Solution Providers 2020The Most Recommended Fintech Solution Providers 2020
The Most Recommended Fintech Solution Providers 2020The Business Fame
 
Innovating in Payments - What are some of the big corporates doing
Innovating in Payments - What are some of the big corporates doingInnovating in Payments - What are some of the big corporates doing
Innovating in Payments - What are some of the big corporates doingMohamed T. Khalil
 
Software for Payment Cards: Choosing Wisely
Software for Payment Cards: Choosing WiselySoftware for Payment Cards: Choosing Wisely
Software for Payment Cards: Choosing WiselyCognizant
 
Payments and transaction processing systems - Global and Indian Overview
Payments and transaction processing systems - Global and Indian OverviewPayments and transaction processing systems - Global and Indian Overview
Payments and transaction processing systems - Global and Indian OverviewAkshay Kaul
 
Automation of trade settlement
Automation of trade settlementAutomation of trade settlement
Automation of trade settlementSasquatch S
 
Alternative channels of banking
Alternative channels of bankingAlternative channels of banking
Alternative channels of bankingRavi Arora
 
The New Payments Platform: Fast-Forward to the Future
The New Payments Platform: Fast-Forward to the FutureThe New Payments Platform: Fast-Forward to the Future
The New Payments Platform: Fast-Forward to the FutureCognizant
 
Direct Debit Services
Direct Debit ServicesDirect Debit Services
Direct Debit ServicesAbhinavKofner
 
Digital Banking
Digital BankingDigital Banking
Digital BankingHome
 

What's hot (20)

APPLICATION OF E-BANKING IN BANGLADESH
APPLICATION OF  E-BANKING  IN BANGLADESHAPPLICATION OF  E-BANKING  IN BANGLADESH
APPLICATION OF E-BANKING IN BANGLADESH
 
Direct Debit System
Direct Debit SystemDirect Debit System
Direct Debit System
 
The Drive to Electronic Remittance Exchange in Business-to Business Payment A...
The Drive to Electronic Remittance Exchange in Business-to Business Payment A...The Drive to Electronic Remittance Exchange in Business-to Business Payment A...
The Drive to Electronic Remittance Exchange in Business-to Business Payment A...
 
Direct Benefits White Paper_April 2016
Direct Benefits White Paper_April 2016Direct Benefits White Paper_April 2016
Direct Benefits White Paper_April 2016
 
E banking
E  bankingE  banking
E banking
 
Debitfees costs 2013
Debitfees costs 2013Debitfees costs 2013
Debitfees costs 2013
 
IT in Banking v0 2
IT in Banking v0 2IT in Banking v0 2
IT in Banking v0 2
 
The Most Recommended Fintech Solution Providers 2020
The Most Recommended Fintech Solution Providers 2020The Most Recommended Fintech Solution Providers 2020
The Most Recommended Fintech Solution Providers 2020
 
Innovating in Payments - What are some of the big corporates doing
Innovating in Payments - What are some of the big corporates doingInnovating in Payments - What are some of the big corporates doing
Innovating in Payments - What are some of the big corporates doing
 
Software for Payment Cards: Choosing Wisely
Software for Payment Cards: Choosing WiselySoftware for Payment Cards: Choosing Wisely
Software for Payment Cards: Choosing Wisely
 
Payments and transaction processing systems - Global and Indian Overview
Payments and transaction processing systems - Global and Indian OverviewPayments and transaction processing systems - Global and Indian Overview
Payments and transaction processing systems - Global and Indian Overview
 
Digital banking
Digital banking Digital banking
Digital banking
 
Automation of trade settlement
Automation of trade settlementAutomation of trade settlement
Automation of trade settlement
 
Alternative channels of banking
Alternative channels of bankingAlternative channels of banking
Alternative channels of banking
 
The New Payments Platform: Fast-Forward to the Future
The New Payments Platform: Fast-Forward to the FutureThe New Payments Platform: Fast-Forward to the Future
The New Payments Platform: Fast-Forward to the Future
 
E banking
E banking E banking
E banking
 
Modern banking
Modern bankingModern banking
Modern banking
 
Delivery Channels in Banking
Delivery Channels in BankingDelivery Channels in Banking
Delivery Channels in Banking
 
Direct Debit Services
Direct Debit ServicesDirect Debit Services
Direct Debit Services
 
Digital Banking
Digital BankingDigital Banking
Digital Banking
 

Similar to Deposit Reengineering by Kevin Connelly

PPT18 Banking.pptx
PPT18 Banking.pptxPPT18 Banking.pptx
PPT18 Banking.pptxansal p
 
EBanking.pptx
EBanking.pptxEBanking.pptx
EBanking.pptxansal p
 
31911477 internet-banking-project-documentation
31911477 internet-banking-project-documentation31911477 internet-banking-project-documentation
31911477 internet-banking-project-documentationSwaroop Mane
 
Banking environment has become highly competitive today
Banking environment has become highly competitive todayBanking environment has become highly competitive today
Banking environment has become highly competitive todaygags17aug
 
Ict & banking sector of bangladesh
Ict & banking sector of bangladeshIct & banking sector of bangladesh
Ict & banking sector of bangladeshZahidul Islam
 
Next Generation Mobile Banking and Return on Investment
Next Generation Mobile Banking and Return on InvestmentNext Generation Mobile Banking and Return on Investment
Next Generation Mobile Banking and Return on Investmentmistervandam
 
The-Case-for-Billtrust (1)
The-Case-for-Billtrust (1)The-Case-for-Billtrust (1)
The-Case-for-Billtrust (1)Brian Phelps
 
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION ON E-BANKING SERVICE BY SETHU
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION ON E-BANKING SERVICE BY SETHUCUSTOMER SATISFACTION ON E-BANKING SERVICE BY SETHU
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION ON E-BANKING SERVICE BY SETHUsaravana vel.k
 
Introduction To Banking Operations
Introduction To Banking OperationsIntroduction To Banking Operations
Introduction To Banking Operationsshubhamshete13
 
Technological impact in Banking Operations
Technological impact in Banking OperationsTechnological impact in Banking Operations
Technological impact in Banking OperationsVIRUPAKSHA GOUD
 
E banking by sanjeev kumar chaswal [compatibility mode]
E banking by sanjeev kumar chaswal [compatibility mode]E banking by sanjeev kumar chaswal [compatibility mode]
E banking by sanjeev kumar chaswal [compatibility mode]sanjeev kumar chaswal
 
PROJECT-Impact of Internet banking services on customer loyalty
PROJECT-Impact of Internet banking services on customer loyaltyPROJECT-Impact of Internet banking services on customer loyalty
PROJECT-Impact of Internet banking services on customer loyaltyNabarun Paul
 
Customer satisfaction of ebanking/online banking of SBI
Customer satisfaction of ebanking/online banking of SBICustomer satisfaction of ebanking/online banking of SBI
Customer satisfaction of ebanking/online banking of SBISajid Nasar
 
Digital Banking: Enhancing Customer Experience; Generating Long-Term Loyalty ...
Digital Banking: Enhancing Customer Experience; Generating Long-Term Loyalty ...Digital Banking: Enhancing Customer Experience; Generating Long-Term Loyalty ...
Digital Banking: Enhancing Customer Experience; Generating Long-Term Loyalty ...Cognizant
 
Fundtech E-invoicing Provides New Adventures for Credit
Fundtech E-invoicing Provides New Adventures for CreditFundtech E-invoicing Provides New Adventures for Credit
Fundtech E-invoicing Provides New Adventures for CreditFundtechFSC
 
Fundtech white paper, e invoicing provides new avenues for credit
Fundtech white paper, e invoicing provides new avenues for creditFundtech white paper, e invoicing provides new avenues for credit
Fundtech white paper, e invoicing provides new avenues for creditFriso de Jong
 

Similar to Deposit Reengineering by Kevin Connelly (20)

PPT18 Banking.pptx
PPT18 Banking.pptxPPT18 Banking.pptx
PPT18 Banking.pptx
 
EBanking.pptx
EBanking.pptxEBanking.pptx
EBanking.pptx
 
31911477 internet-banking-project-documentation
31911477 internet-banking-project-documentation31911477 internet-banking-project-documentation
31911477 internet-banking-project-documentation
 
Cash Management Trends
Cash Management TrendsCash Management Trends
Cash Management Trends
 
Banking environment has become highly competitive today
Banking environment has become highly competitive todayBanking environment has become highly competitive today
Banking environment has become highly competitive today
 
Ict & banking sector of bangladesh
Ict & banking sector of bangladeshIct & banking sector of bangladesh
Ict & banking sector of bangladesh
 
Next Generation Mobile Banking and Return on Investment
Next Generation Mobile Banking and Return on InvestmentNext Generation Mobile Banking and Return on Investment
Next Generation Mobile Banking and Return on Investment
 
The-Case-for-Billtrust (1)
The-Case-for-Billtrust (1)The-Case-for-Billtrust (1)
The-Case-for-Billtrust (1)
 
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION ON E-BANKING SERVICE BY SETHU
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION ON E-BANKING SERVICE BY SETHUCUSTOMER SATISFACTION ON E-BANKING SERVICE BY SETHU
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION ON E-BANKING SERVICE BY SETHU
 
Introduction To Banking Operations
Introduction To Banking OperationsIntroduction To Banking Operations
Introduction To Banking Operations
 
Technological impact in Banking Operations
Technological impact in Banking OperationsTechnological impact in Banking Operations
Technological impact in Banking Operations
 
E banking by sanjeev kumar chaswal [compatibility mode]
E banking by sanjeev kumar chaswal [compatibility mode]E banking by sanjeev kumar chaswal [compatibility mode]
E banking by sanjeev kumar chaswal [compatibility mode]
 
Fcb 2
Fcb 2Fcb 2
Fcb 2
 
Online banking
Online bankingOnline banking
Online banking
 
PROJECT-Impact of Internet banking services on customer loyalty
PROJECT-Impact of Internet banking services on customer loyaltyPROJECT-Impact of Internet banking services on customer loyalty
PROJECT-Impact of Internet banking services on customer loyalty
 
dious joseph
dious josephdious joseph
dious joseph
 
Customer satisfaction of ebanking/online banking of SBI
Customer satisfaction of ebanking/online banking of SBICustomer satisfaction of ebanking/online banking of SBI
Customer satisfaction of ebanking/online banking of SBI
 
Digital Banking: Enhancing Customer Experience; Generating Long-Term Loyalty ...
Digital Banking: Enhancing Customer Experience; Generating Long-Term Loyalty ...Digital Banking: Enhancing Customer Experience; Generating Long-Term Loyalty ...
Digital Banking: Enhancing Customer Experience; Generating Long-Term Loyalty ...
 
Fundtech E-invoicing Provides New Adventures for Credit
Fundtech E-invoicing Provides New Adventures for CreditFundtech E-invoicing Provides New Adventures for Credit
Fundtech E-invoicing Provides New Adventures for Credit
 
Fundtech white paper, e invoicing provides new avenues for credit
Fundtech white paper, e invoicing provides new avenues for creditFundtech white paper, e invoicing provides new avenues for credit
Fundtech white paper, e invoicing provides new avenues for credit
 

Recently uploaded

TVB_The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_May 6th, 2024_ENVol. 006.pdf
TVB_The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_May 6th, 2024_ENVol. 006.pdfTVB_The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_May 6th, 2024_ENVol. 006.pdf
TVB_The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_May 6th, 2024_ENVol. 006.pdfbelieveminhh
 
Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...
Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...
Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...ssuserf63bd7
 
Falcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investors
Falcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investorsFalcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investors
Falcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investorsFalcon Invoice Discounting
 
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League CityHow to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League CityEric T. Tung
 
Over the Top (OTT) Market Size & Growth Outlook 2024-2030
Over the Top (OTT) Market Size & Growth Outlook 2024-2030Over the Top (OTT) Market Size & Growth Outlook 2024-2030
Over the Top (OTT) Market Size & Growth Outlook 2024-2030tarushabhavsar
 
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai KuwaitThe Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwaitdaisycvs
 
Buy Verified TransferWise Accounts From Seosmmearth
Buy Verified TransferWise Accounts From SeosmmearthBuy Verified TransferWise Accounts From Seosmmearth
Buy Verified TransferWise Accounts From SeosmmearthBuy Verified Binance Account
 
Arti Languages Pre Seed Teaser Deck 2024.pdf
Arti Languages Pre Seed Teaser Deck 2024.pdfArti Languages Pre Seed Teaser Deck 2024.pdf
Arti Languages Pre Seed Teaser Deck 2024.pdfwill854175
 
New 2024 Cannabis Edibles Investor Pitch Deck Template
New 2024 Cannabis Edibles Investor Pitch Deck TemplateNew 2024 Cannabis Edibles Investor Pitch Deck Template
New 2024 Cannabis Edibles Investor Pitch Deck TemplateCannaBusinessPlans
 
Jual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cytotec
Jual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan CytotecJual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cytotec
Jual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan CytotecZurliaSoop
 
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAIGetting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAITim Wilson
 
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...daisycvs
 
Mifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in Oman
Mifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in OmanMifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in Oman
Mifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in Omaninstagramfab782445
 
Falcon's Invoice Discounting: Your Path to Prosperity
Falcon's Invoice Discounting: Your Path to ProsperityFalcon's Invoice Discounting: Your Path to Prosperity
Falcon's Invoice Discounting: Your Path to Prosperityhemanthkumar470700
 
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDINGParadip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDINGpr788182
 
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business Potential
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business PotentialFalcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business Potential
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business PotentialFalcon investment
 
Lucknow Housewife Escorts by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
Lucknow Housewife Escorts  by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165Lucknow Housewife Escorts  by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
Lucknow Housewife Escorts by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165meghakumariji156
 
Phases of Negotiation .pptx
 Phases of Negotiation .pptx Phases of Negotiation .pptx
Phases of Negotiation .pptxnandhinijagan9867
 

Recently uploaded (20)

TVB_The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_May 6th, 2024_ENVol. 006.pdf
TVB_The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_May 6th, 2024_ENVol. 006.pdfTVB_The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_May 6th, 2024_ENVol. 006.pdf
TVB_The Vietnam Believer Newsletter_May 6th, 2024_ENVol. 006.pdf
 
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pillsMifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
 
Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...
Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...
Horngren’s Cost Accounting A Managerial Emphasis, Canadian 9th edition soluti...
 
Falcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investors
Falcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investorsFalcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investors
Falcon Invoice Discounting: The best investment platform in india for investors
 
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League CityHow to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
How to Get Started in Social Media for Art League City
 
Over the Top (OTT) Market Size & Growth Outlook 2024-2030
Over the Top (OTT) Market Size & Growth Outlook 2024-2030Over the Top (OTT) Market Size & Growth Outlook 2024-2030
Over the Top (OTT) Market Size & Growth Outlook 2024-2030
 
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai KuwaitThe Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
The Abortion pills for sale in Qatar@Doha [+27737758557] []Deira Dubai Kuwait
 
Buy Verified TransferWise Accounts From Seosmmearth
Buy Verified TransferWise Accounts From SeosmmearthBuy Verified TransferWise Accounts From Seosmmearth
Buy Verified TransferWise Accounts From Seosmmearth
 
Arti Languages Pre Seed Teaser Deck 2024.pdf
Arti Languages Pre Seed Teaser Deck 2024.pdfArti Languages Pre Seed Teaser Deck 2024.pdf
Arti Languages Pre Seed Teaser Deck 2024.pdf
 
New 2024 Cannabis Edibles Investor Pitch Deck Template
New 2024 Cannabis Edibles Investor Pitch Deck TemplateNew 2024 Cannabis Edibles Investor Pitch Deck Template
New 2024 Cannabis Edibles Investor Pitch Deck Template
 
Jual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cytotec
Jual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan CytotecJual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cytotec
Jual Obat Aborsi ( Asli No.1 ) 085657271886 Obat Penggugur Kandungan Cytotec
 
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAIGetting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
Getting Real with AI - Columbus DAW - May 2024 - Nick Woo from AlignAI
 
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
Quick Doctor In Kuwait +2773`7758`557 Kuwait Doha Qatar Dubai Abu Dhabi Sharj...
 
Mifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in Oman
Mifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in OmanMifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in Oman
Mifepristone Available in Muscat +918761049707^^ €€ Buy Abortion Pills in Oman
 
!~+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUD...
!~+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUD...!~+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUD...
!~+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUD...
 
Falcon's Invoice Discounting: Your Path to Prosperity
Falcon's Invoice Discounting: Your Path to ProsperityFalcon's Invoice Discounting: Your Path to Prosperity
Falcon's Invoice Discounting: Your Path to Prosperity
 
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDINGParadip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
 
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business Potential
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business PotentialFalcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business Potential
Falcon Invoice Discounting: Unlock Your Business Potential
 
Lucknow Housewife Escorts by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
Lucknow Housewife Escorts  by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165Lucknow Housewife Escorts  by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
Lucknow Housewife Escorts by Sexy Bhabhi Service 8250092165
 
Phases of Negotiation .pptx
 Phases of Negotiation .pptx Phases of Negotiation .pptx
Phases of Negotiation .pptx
 

Deposit Reengineering by Kevin Connelly

  • 1. By Kevin H. Connelly Executive Vice President The RWC Group DEPOSIT REENGINEERING From the Banker’s Perspective www.therwcgroup.com (913) 660-2734
  • 2. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 1 Customer payments using currency and checks are a fact of life for retailers and small businesses, which generate large amounts of cash and checks that need to be deposited to a bank. CHECKS: A FACT OF LIFE Customer payments using currency and checks are a fact of life for retailers and small businesses, which generate large amounts of cash and checks that need to be deposited to a bank. More than 4.3 million business locations1 make more than two billion check and cash deposits annually to U.S. banks. These cash and check deposits enter into the banking system via one of five primary methods: Since the 2008 financial crisis, U.S. banks have been ramping up mobile, remote deposit and online services and moving away from physical locations to avoid overlap. Culling branches, with their real-estate, labor and security costs, has become a popular way for banks to boost profits at a time of sluggish revenue and loan growth. The number of branch locations has steadily declined since 2009, according to data from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. As banks reshaped their retail infrastructure to cope with ever-increasing operating costs, bankers have actively sought out — and invested in — technology to improve and reengineer the commercial deposit process. Banks have introduced new deposit- taking methods such as remote deposit, which enables the electronic capture of a check image and depositing of the image via a bank’s web-based application. That eliminates the need for the customer to travel to a bank branch and make the deposit over the counter or via the night drop or ATM. The use of remote check deposit services continues to grow rapidly, but it does not reduce the need to physically deposit currency and coin. As banks have reshaped their consumer (i.e., retail) delivery channels, significant volumes of transactions have migrated to retail automated teller machines (ATMs) and online banking. Banks have downsized branches in favor of supermarket outlets, teller-less kiosks, and other non-commercial locations. As a result, businesses have been left with fewer convenient bank depository locations or are required to pay for costly armored services to transport deposits to central vaults. Banks will continue to drive transaction volume out of their branch networks so that these brick and mortar sites can be dedicated to selling financial products and services. As a result, bank operational infrastructure is transforming to support reshaped commercial deposit service delivery channels. 1 U.S. Census Bureau, Statistical Abstract of the United States: 2012 50% 20% 15% 5% 10% 1 Over-the-counter in a bank branch 2 Into a night drop safe at a bank branch 3 Via armored carrier to a central cash vault 4 Via smart safe, then via carrier to a central cash vault 5 Via remote deposit capture service (checks only) Figure B-1
  • 3. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 2 At the core of a bank’s deposit product strategy is the depositor of cash and checks. A bank’s deposit product strategy determines its service delivery channel strategy, which is supported by an operational strategy. Technology, liquidity, and regulatory strategies are cornerstones of an overall commercial deposit product and system strategy, as depicted in Figure B-2 below. To remain cost competitive, banks must develop deposit handling systems that monitor, track, process, and verify cash on an integrated enterprise-wide common platform. Consumer Cash and Check Transactions Somewhat unexpectedly, the use of currency as a consumer payment medium remains high. However, signs of the ongoing long-term transformation of payments from paper instruments to cards and electronics remain evident. One catalyst in this transformation has been the increasing popularity of bill-payment services offered by consumers’ depository banks. By initiating payments via computer or mobile device, the consumer avoids the cost of postage and the need to reconcile outstanding checks; the merchant avoids the cost of processing paper checks and hauling them to the bank for deposit; and the bank shifts a huge amount of paper processing to electronic processing and sharply cuts the costs associated with printing and mailing bank statements with paid checks (among many other savings). Not only is more currency in circulation, but deposit transaction volume also continues to increase from more commercial depositing locations. As banks have transformed their branch systems by replacing large locations with small in-store or supermarket branches, they have also aggressively replaced tellers with ATMs. Thus, the banks have shifted consumer transactions from the teller line to the ATM line and online. With banks downsizing their retail locations, commercial deposits are increasingly processed through a diminished branch capacity. As a result, banks’ costs associated with commercial deposit processing have perversely continued to increase while service levels have declined. The implications of these payment system trends and transformation of the banking system delivery channel have driven, and will continue to drive, banks to reengineer how they process commercial deposits. Figure B-2 COMMERCIAL DEPOSIT SERVICES DELIVERY CHANNELS BRANCH (1) CASH VAULT (2) SMART SAFE ATM (3) REMOTE DEPOSIT CAPTURE CENTRAL CHECK Fees and Margin RealTime E-Information and WebTools Transportation and Deposit Tracking Cash Management and Funds Availability Image Enablement and Automation BSA/AML/KYC and Compliance
  • 4. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 3 Current Business Deposit-Taking Services Banks provide business customers multiple ways to make their commercial deposits, including various related deposit services. The primary depository methods banks provide to business clients are: • Over-the-counter branch deposit • Night drop branch deposit • Check-only branch deposit • Direct cash vault deposit • Electronic deposits • Remote deposit check capture • Smart safes • Other deposits (including debit/credit card merchant processing) The use of one or all of these deposit-taking services depends upon the relative proximity of the depositor and the bank, the timing and frequency of deposits, and the amount of funds involved. Based on an industry survey of six major U.S. banks, approximately 70 percent of commercial cash deposit transactions are made through a bank branch (50 percent over the counter, 20 percent night drop), with the remain- ing 20 percent of deposit transactions made directly to a bank’s central cash vault and 10 percent are deposited via remote check capture. Except for electronic deposits, most of the common depository service processing provided by banks tends to be archaic and relatively inefficient. TRANSACTION COSTS Transaction Cost Analysis The rise of the digital consumer and the high-cost infrastructure of bank branches lead to a declining return on investment (ROI) for banks and cut into profitability of other areas of the bank. Branches remain an important interaction point with customers, however, and play an essential role in complex product sales and relation- ship building for both retail and small-business customers. But as customers transform the way they bank, the value proposition of traditional branches comes into question. The cost of a branch transaction is approximately 20 times higher than the mobile transaction and 40 times higher than an online transaction. A 2012 study2 showed that average transaction costs (including labor and IT costs) for U.S. banks were: Figure B-3 Call Center Branch ATM Mobile IVR Other $4.04 $4.00 $0.61 $0.19 $0.17 $0.09 Average Transaction Cost in the US (includes labor and IT costs) As customers transform the way they bank, the value proposition of traditional branches comes into question. 2 CEB TowerGroup 2012, as reported in “Rebooting the Branch: Branch Strategy in a Multi- Global Environment,” PwC Financial Services Institute, December 2012 at www.PWC.com/f~i.
  • 5. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 4 Objectives Regarding Transaction Costs Banks and their service providers must continue to drive transaction costs lower as market pricing is increasingly commoditized. The average list price for deposit services increased by more than five percent between 2011 and 2012, according to the Blue Book of Bank Prices.3 Meanwhile, the industry average labor cost for all teller transactions (retail consumer and business) increased from $.61 in 2002 to $1.08 in 2013. Commercial deposit costs remain high, between $5.00 and $8.00 per average business deposit, including cash and checks deposited over-the-counter or through the night drop in a bank branch location. While achieving a paperless environment is a worthy goal for banks, a less-paper environment is a realistic starting point. Automating processes by deploying imaging and business process management technologies is a preferred transition strategy for migrating away from today’s paper-and labor-intensive environment. While the bank may be actively reengineering, designing, and implementing new systems and processes, it must build into those systems automated technology-based transaction monitoring to ensure compliance with federal anti-money laundering laws. REENGINEERING THE DEPOSIT-TAKING FUNCTION Financial institutions have spent billions of dollars to automate systems that were previously manual processes. The commercial deposit process employed by many banks, however, has remained the same since the money changers handed gold coins over stone tablets. More than 50 percent of commercial cash deposits continue to be counted manually by tellers in branches. The focus of reengineering is to optimize the process flow without focusing on the efficiency of a particular task. For example, if a cash verification process from input to its cumulative output requires seven steps in the current environment, the reengineered environment should take only three steps. The reengineered environment may certainly utilize automation, such as currency- counting hardware, to optimize the process but the improvement does not rely on automation in itself. The process of reengineering commercial deposit processing is about improving how depository customers interact with the bank, reducing all-in operational costs while enhancing a bank’ s competitive position. Research demonstrates that financial institutions spend an inordinate amount of time processing transactions and handling cash deposit from commercial customers within the branch environment.1 Reducing in-branch commer- cial transaction processing and cash handling time would allow financial institutions to spend more time selling and servicing their customers.2 Processing 50% Administration 17% Sales 18% Customer Service 15% Cash Deposit Verification Hours 10% Total Teller Paid Hours 90% 1 Source: Reengineering the Bank, Paul Allen 2 Source: Major Bank Study 3 The Blue Book of Bank Prices is published by Phoenix-Hecht, Research Triangle Park, NC (919) 541-9339, www.PhoenixHecht.com
  • 6. Few banks have achieved optimal conversion rates of the post-deposit verification service, especially for over- the-counter deposits in branches made by mid-sized and small businesses. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 5 There are eight primary phases involved in reengineering a bank’s commercial deposit processes, as illustrated in Figure B-4 below. As the figure shows, the eight phases overlap each other. A bank may implement these phases sequentially or substantially simultaneously, depending upon larger strategic issues, geographic limitations, or capital constraints. Most major U.S. banks and many large international banks have implemented Phases 1 and 2 but few have effectively addressed all of the phases of deposit reengineering. It is important to note that of the banks that have implemented Phase 1, few have achieved optimal conversion rates of the post-deposit verification service, especially for over-the-counter deposits in branches made by mid-sized and small businesses. BRANCH CASH VAULT SMART SAFE ATM REMOTE DEPOSIT CAPTURE CENTRAL CHECK Packet Forward Deposits to CentralVault Implement Deposit Post for OTC Deposits Implement AML/KYC Automation Deploy or Expand RDC Service Capability BANK DEPOSIT SERVICE REENGINEERING Deploy Alternative Delivery Channels Including CommercialATM Deploy or Expand Smart Safe Service Integrate Deposit Tracking System IntoAll Deposit Channels Outsource Central Vault Network 1 2 3 4 56 7 8 REVENUE ENHANCEMENT COST MANAGEMENT FLOAT MANAGEMENT RISK MANAGEMENT PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT Unit Cost Study and Operations Productivity FeeAnalysis and BillingAudit Implement AML/KYC Automation Deploy or Expand RDC Service Capability COMMERCIAL DEPOSIT SERVICE PRODUCT MANAGEMENT BSA/AML/KYC Compliance and Processing Risk Mitigation Currency Optimization and Fed Balance Requirements Integrate Deposit Tracking System IntoAll Deposit Channels Infrastructure and Sourcing Rationalization 1 2 3 4 56 7 8 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT Figure B-4
  • 7. PHASE I: Post-Deposit Verification A post-deposit verification service enables business customers to deliver cash and check deposits to a bank branch or other designated drop-off facility prior to the business day cutoff and receive provisional credit for the deposit prior to the currency actually being counted and verified. Typically, the credit is provisional; that is, the deposit is subject to the bank’s final count, verification and, if required, adjust- ment within a specified period of time, usually no more than forty-eight hours. Numerous major banks have implemented commercial post verification deposit services, most of which work in a substantially similar manner. 1 Deposits are placed in disposable, tamper-evident plastic deposit bags with two compartments: one for checks and the deposit ticket, the other for cash. 2 The cash portion of the bag (usually the top compartment) is sealed through the use of advanced adhesives and features that provide evidence of tampering if unauthorized attempts are made to reopen the bag. The check portion of the bag (usually the bottom compartment) is sealed with a reusable closure. 3 The customer’s name, location identifier, date, cash amount, checks amount, total deposit amount, and other relevant information are written or pre-printed onto the outside surface of the bag. 4 The bags are imprinted with unique tracking numbers, and sometimes bar codes. This allows for effective tracing throughout the deposit process and can be a useful tool in tracking misrouted or lost deposits. Bar coded deposit documents are also used by advanced Deposit Tracking Systems that provide real time status of a deposit from deposit location through final bank verification. 5 The fully prepared and sealed deposit bag is then brought to a bank branch and presented to a teller, either by the customer or an armored carrier. 6 The teller removes, or “strips,” the checks from the re-sealable portion of the deposit bag and processes the checks along with the original deposit ticket. The checks and deposit ticket are entered into the ongoing branch proof-of- deposit workflow.* The ledger credit and collected funds status of the check portion of the deposit are based on the bank’s standard availability schedule. 7 The cash portion remains sealed in the bag and unverified. The teller enters the cash total as a “provisional” credit based upon the “said to contain amount” written on the deposit ticket. The teller prepares or the system generates a “cash-in” or “cash-in-transit” transaction ticket, a copy of which accompanies the cash deposit to the point of verification. Meanwhile, a duplicate cash-in ticket is placed in the teller’s cash drawer as a substitute for the actual currency.* 8 The bank provides the customer with a deposit receipt indicating provisional credit has been made to the customer’s bank account. 9 The bank then determines the most efficient and cost-effective location and times to verify the cash portion of the deposit. 10 The final (i.e., non-provisional) currency credit is typically provided within 24-72 hours depending upon the bank’s policy, branch location, and verifica- tion processes. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 6 OPTION 1 Decentralized Night Drop Processing OPTION 2 Centralized Night Drop Processing BANK BRANCH DELIVERY CHANNEL “Strip” checks and forwards to branch POD stream CASH VAULT CHECK PROCESSING VERIFY CASH IN-BRANCH Step 1: Conversion to dual pocket from single pocket zipper lock canvas, vinyl, non-standard plastic bags Step 2: Implement improved night drop depository service processes using industry “best practices” The first phase of reengineer- ing entails migrating night drop commercial customers to a standard tamper-evident plastic deposit bag and improved night drop process. * Note: Teller capture or related back branch office image (or 3rd party) capture of check items and related image workflow provides greater efficiency than physical transportation and paper workflow.
  • 8. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 7 Steps to Success A bank can take several important steps designed to implement a post-verifica- tion system: 1 Implement new customer deposit preparation procedures. 2 Begin charging for processing over-the-counter and night drop deposits. 3 Implement internal policies, procedures, and systems that support in-branch post-verification of commercial deposits. 4 By transferring the post-verification process to off-peak times, teller transaction processing time will be reduced, thereby reducing queue time and enabling more customers to be serviced more quickly. 5 Ideally, service levels and profitability are optimized when the transaction processing capacity equals the actual transaction volume throughout the processing day, or: Capacity= Volume In an environment where CV, service levels deteriorate. Commercial depositary customers typically are unwilling to endure long waits to make their deposits. Conversely, where CV, idle capacity increases unit costs. This would occur during low volume periods where tellers would be doing no productive work. Step 1: Implement OTC post verification product – in-branch verification Step 2: Implement optimal processing infrastructure with package forwarding as appropriate BANK BRANCH DELIVERY CHANNEL CASH VAULT CHECK PROCESSING Commercial Deposit Branch Workflow Dynamics Optimizing the commercial deposit workflow processes enables reduction of teller resource requirements by staffing to average instead of peak transaction volumes. 25 20 15 10 5 BranchTransaction CommercialVolume Prior Day Work Move to Next Day 8 am 9 11 1pm 3 5 6 SAVINGS Move Verification to Non Peak Move Verification to Non Peak
  • 9. By centralizing night-drop processing, the related volumes can provide the bank with greater economies of scale sooner, both for transportation and processing. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 8 PHASE 2: Process Centralization/Package Forwarding A key element behind centralized processing is the use of package forwarding to centralize the processing and verification of commercial deposits made over the counter or via night drop at bank branches. The trend in retail bank delivery channels continues toward the reduction and eventual elimination of tellers engaged in processing activity. Instead, they are being redeployed into sales and customer service activities. Likewise, commercial deposit processes must transition from the teller lines in branches to a central processing environment. There are three primary package forwarding models that should be considered in Phase 2: in-branch, hub-and-spoke, and central vault (the latter two can be outsourced). Each of these three package forwarding models can be used inde- pendently or in conjunction with each other, depending upon a bank’s internal capabilities and external market requirements. Evaluating the Package Forwarding Models Any evaluation to determine the optimum package forwarding model must consider the following influencing factors: • Changes to resource allocations. As work is transferred out of the branch and into a hub-and-spoke or central vault environment, the human resource allocation in the branch system must either be reduced or reallocated to customer service or selling activities. The objective of Phase 2 is not to just move peas (costs) around on the plate; rather it is to remove costs altogether by doing things better.* • Transportation costs. Armored transportation costs are almost certain to increase in a high-volume package forwarding model. It is very important to maximize the customer conversion rate in Phase 1 to a post-verification service first, before implementing Phase 2. Typically, a minimum of 25-35 post verified deposits per branch, or a conversion rate of approximately 60 to 80 percent should be achieved before a hub-and-spoke or central vault model offsets the incremental transportation costs.* • Night-drop processing. By their nature, night-drop deposits are already post- verified. By centralizing night-drop processing, the related volumes can provide the bank with greater economies of scale sooner, both for transportation and processing. Time Savings for Commercial Customers Completing verification processes in the back office will significantly reduce wait time for retail and commercial customers. This differentiates your bank by “giving more time back” to your commercial and retail customers. Before Post Verification Processing After Post Verification Processing Immediate Verification • 10-30 minute wait in line • 5-15 minute teller transaction time Back Office Verification • 5-10 minute wait in line • 1-2 minute teller transaction time CustomerQueueTime TimeAwayfromBusiness CustomerService CustomerSatisfaction * Note: Teller capture or related back branch office image (or 3rd party) capture of check items and related image workflow provides greater efficiency than physical transportation and paper workflow.
  • 10. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 9 • Market requirements. Market demands will greatly influence the final design of the post-verification service and employment of package forwarding. Processing deadlines, adjustment procedures, and pricing structures will vary by market. • Inventory levels. Currency inventory levels have a carrying cost to the bank. Historically, a bank’s inventory of currency could offset a significant portion of its Federal Reserve required reserves. Now, mostly due to sweep accounts and related yield management techniques, a bank’s vault cash levels typically equal or exceed the reserve requirement. The bank, therefore, has a strong incentive to minimize currency inventory levels by processing the currency and converting it to an earning asset as quickly as possible. • Risk mitigation. Processing risks in a decentralized teller environment are inherently different from those in a centralized processing operation. A hub-and- spoke or central vault environment can implement risk management procedures faster, more securely, efficiently and effectively, and with a greater degree of success than in a decentralized processing system. Figure B-5 Today, a bank’s vault cash levels typically equal or exceed the reserve requirement. OPTIMIZE LOGISTICS, SERVICE AND COSTS Hub-and-Spoke Regional Vault Infrastructure External Vault Infrastructure Central Vault Hub-and-Spoke Network In-Branch Cash Processing DEPOSIT Teller 1 Teller 2 Teller 3 Night DropTeller 4 Proof and Check Processing In-Branch Post Verification MIni-Vault Site DEPOSIT DEPOSIT DEPOSIT DEPOSIT Post Verification Hub Vault Site A Post Verifica- tion Branch 1 OTC/ND Branch 2 OTC/ND Branch 5 OTC/ND Branch 4 OTC/ND Branch 3 OTC/ND Branch 9 OTC/ND Branch 6 OTC/ND Branch 7 OTC/ND Branch 8 OTC/ND Post Verification Central Vault Site Branch 11 OTC/ND Branch 15 OTC/ND Branch 75 OTC/ND Branch 45 OTC/ND Branch5 OTC/ND Direct Vault Customer Branch 1 OTC/ND Branch 2 OTC/ND Branch 5 OTC/ND Branch 4 OTC/ND Branch 3 OTC/ND Branch 9 OTC/ND Branch 6 OTC/ND Branch 7 OTC/ND Branch 8 OTC/ND FED Direct Vault Customer Direct Vault Customer Direct Vault Customer Direct Vault Customer Third-Party Hub Vault Size Z Branch 1 OTC/ND Branch 2 OTC/ND FED Direct Vault Customer Direct Vault Customer Direct Vault Customer Direct Vault Customer Branch 4 OTC/NDBranch 3 OTC/ND
  • 11. Many banks are increasingly motivated to outsource their cash vaults to a third-party service provider, typically an armored carrier or cash-in- transit (CIT) company. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 10 PHASE 3: Rationalize Central Vault Operations Many banks have outsourced all or a portion of their back office cash handling operations. In some instances a third party cash processor, such as an armored carrier, can provide cash services at a lower cost than a bank can provide internally. Four key considerations must be addressed when planning to outsource cash deposit verification and currency/coin supply services to a third party vendor: 1 Customer ownership. Armored carriers have captured significant cash processing market share from banks. As the carrier becomes the cash processing entity, banks can lose not only the related cash processing revenues but also intimacy with its customers. 2 Long term cost structure. Carriers tend to dominate certain regional markets, which can result in significant increases in cash processing costs over time. Competitive markets can be ensured through efficient and effective business practices. 3 Risk. Increased risk is associated with maintaining the bank’s cash inventory at an unregulated non-bank third party provider. 4 Service levels. Although some third party cash processors provide excellent service levels, some do not. If a bank outsources its cash processing to a third party and service levels decline, this can negatively impact the bank’s relationship with its commercial customers regardless of the origin of the quality problem. Investing in a cash vault infrastructure upgrade is an expensive proposition, but banks’ aging vault infrastructures cannot support the required service or processing efficiency levels without some new investment. Consequently, many banks are increasingly motivated to outsource their cash vaults to a third-party service provider, typically an armored carrier or cash-in-transit (CIT) company. Additionally banks can realize great synergy between check and cash operations reengineering. In particular, distributed check image capture in an outsourced third-party cash vault can deliver both operational efficiencies as well as improved service levels, such as later deposit deadlines. Outsourced cash vault check capture and truncation is becoming commonplace as centralized item processing centers have given way to distributed capture. PHASE 4: Integrate Electronic Deposit Tracking Systems Into All Channels For most merchants, managing the daily check and cash deposit process is labor- intensive, risky, and prone to errors. Store employees must manually collect and count cash, then an employee or an armored truck service delivers it to the bank. Similarly, the armored carrier and the bank of deposit engage in a manual, paper- based, labor-intensive and high-cost process. Up to 10 or more paper documents can be generated for each commercial deposit, and more when deposit discrepancies and adjustments occur. Electronic commercial depository systems (ECDS) create commercial deposit information using machine-readable data formats, typically barcodes. An integrated
  • 12. Smart safes can improve employee safety, minimize cash-handling risk and errors, boost staff productivity, and accelerate credit for cash deposits. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 11 ECDS system seamlessly links the commercial deposit and cash shipment information through an intranet or Internet system providing real-time cash handling information to participants at significantly lower costs. The industry leading ECDS service is DTS Connex. DTS Connex enables online deposit creation and the ability to track deposits through each step of the chain of custody. This cloud based service reports when an armored carrier has picked up the deposits, when the depository banks have received and credited each deposit, and if there were any adjustments to a deposit.  The service then analyzes all that information to ensure the optimal deposit process is deployed on a sustainable basis. Small businesses, especially where they are retailers located in a shopping center or mall, can facilitate their deposit and change order processing by using centrally located commercial teller machines, commercial change order machines, and business-only kiosks. Banks can employ these self-service business transaction machines to replace or complement existing merchant teller or non-intelligent night-drop facilities. PHASE 5: Deploy or Expand Smart Safe Service Capability Technology enables banks to offer more effective solutions for managing coin and currency. One such solution is a deposit-only electronic “smart” safe that a retailer typically would contract for with an armored carrier. During the business day, store employees deposit excess cash and large bills into the safe. At the end of the business day, instead of preparing a deposit, all funds in excess of the next day’s starting fund are inserted into the smart safe where they are secure and counted electronically. Smart safes can improve employee safety, minimize cash-handling risk and errors, boost staff productivity, and accelerate credit for cash deposits. They do have limitations, however. Because the smart safes can hold a limited amount of currency, they are best suited for smaller retailers, gas stations, or quick-serve restaurants. In addition, most current smart safe products do not accept coins for deposit. Smart safe deposit services can offer the following benefits: • Improve cash flow with daily credit for cash placed in smart safes without having to prepare a physical bank deposit. • Lower costs by reducing daily armored carrier pickups to every fourth day. • Virtually eliminate deposit adjustments. • Save time in preparing and managing currency deposits. • Mitigate opportunity for theft and provide added security. PHASE 6: Deploy Alternate, Self-Service Deposit Delivery Channels Alternate deposit delivery channels include commercial ATMs with bulk deposit capacity in high volume locations, commercial change order and change deposit machines, as well as business-only kiosks and other cash handling technology and processes designed to improve the profitability and competitiveness of a bank’s commercial deposit services. Other deposit services can include making deposits thru the U.S. mail or via a FedEx or UPS service partnership with a depository bank.
  • 13. Remote Deposit Capture typically provides benefits including merchant convenience, faster deposit availability, quicker return of dishonored checks, and reduced tranpor- tation cost and risk. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 12 PHASE 7: Deploy or Expand Remote Deposit Capture Service Capability The Check 21 Act, which became effective in 2004, paved the way for the develop- ment of Remote Deposit Capture (RDC) in which the merchant can create the digital version of the original check and transmit the digital data to the merchant’s depository bank, usually via a bank-provided Internet application, for credit to the merchant’s account. The Check 21 Act created a new negotiable instrument called a “substitute check,” which contains an image of the front and back of the original check that can be processed in lieu of the original check. A substitute check is the legal equivalent of an original check under the Check 21 Act. The merchant captures the image of the check and transforms it into digital form either as an image or data, then transmits this image or data electronically to the merchant’s depository bank. The substitute check or the equivalent digital data is cleared and settled electronically, thereby expediting credit to the customer’s account. Remote Deposit Capture typically provides benefits including merchant convenience, faster deposit availability, quicker return of dishonored checks, and reduced transportation cost and risk. With increased use and service offerings, the merchant’s cost to use RDC services (banking fees, scanner prices, etc.) are expected to decrease over time. Remote Deposit Capture has quickly evolved into a must-have deposit product in most U.S.-based banks in order to remain competitive. The benefits to depositors include: • Saves trips to the bank. • Accelerates clearing time and improves cash flow. • Extends bank business hours. • Reduces return item risk by accelerating returned items to the bank of first deposit. • Facilitates regional or nationwide consolidation of banking relationships by bypassing local depository banks. The benefits of Remote Deposit Capture to banks include: • Attracts low-cost deposits. • Accommodates customers located beyond the branch’s local area. • Reduces branch servicing costs by extending the self-service channel. • Reduces processing costs. • Eliminates transportation costs and delays in deposits reaching the bank. • Reduces paper deposit ticket costs.
  • 14. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 13 PHASE 8: Implement Enhanced Automated AML and KYC Technology Solutions Banks and other financial institutions are subject to the Bank Secrecy Act and its anti-money laundering provisions. This is frequently referred to as BSA/AML. In reengineering the depository function, banks must continue to comply with the Act’s provisions regardless of whether transactions are handled manually or electronically, or remotely or in a bank branch. Compliance with BSA/AML policy and regulatory procedures and auditing make it necessary for banks to increase their investment in expertise, qualified resources, improved processes, monitoring, and technology in order to monitor critical activities and transactions. BSA/AML is enforced by FinCEN, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, which is a bureau of the U.S. Treasury Department. Also driving financial institutions to implement AML software were increased regula- tory requirements, such as FinCEN’s rule for reporting cross-border electronic funds transfers, and the due diligence process mandated by the “Know-Your-Customer” (KYC) provision of the 2001 USA Patriot Act for all financial institutions. New lengths of customer due diligence and risk evaluation were mandated when a financial institution opens a new customer relationship. Another factor driving the spending growth was the broadening of regulatory scrutiny to new segments such as small banks, credit unions, insurers, and brokerages or non- bank entities such as PayPal. Previously, many such institutions handled AML require- ments through manual processes or avoided them altogether. However, regulators are increasingly putting pressure on these industry segments to implement industry standard technology. Finally, the trend to integrate anti-money laundering and antifraud operations onto a common platform — the enterprise-wide compliance approach — is gathering steam, with a significant number of financial institutions adding new anti-fraud modules to existing AML platforms, or replacing legacy systems with software capable of supporting both AML and anti-fraud functions. COMMERCIAL DEPOSIT PRODUCT MANAGEMENT Demand deposit accounts (DDA) and related services, currency and coin services, and check processing are the cornerstone of a bank’s profit margin for cash management services. Like any business, the well-managed bank seeks multiple opportunities to enhance profitability by increasing revenues, controlling costs, managing its inventory (of coin and currency), and managing the risks inherent in all of these. Demand deposit accounts (DDA) and related services, currency and coin services, and check processing are the cornerstone of a bank’s profit margin for cash management services.
  • 15. DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 14 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS The payments landscape has changed significantly and bankers must adapt or be disintermediated by those changes. Check volume will continue to diminish, remote deposit capture will continue to proliferate, and coin and currency are here to stay. Online and mobile banking, coupled with increased ATM functionality, will drive consumer banking while non-bank payments and digital wallet services such as Apple Pay are becoming more widely accepted among both consumers and their financial institutions. New regulations and increased regulatory scrutiny will continue to drive up banks’ costs, while new risks will necessitate improved governance, risk management, automation, and compliance systems. Banks must reengineer their commercial deposit products, operations, risk management and cost structures in order to remain competitive and profitable. All of this affects the way that businesses interface with their banks and the costs they bear as customers. The payments land- scape has changed significantly and bankers must adapt or be disintermediated by those changes.
  • 16. KEVIN H. CONNELLY has spent the past 30 years working in the financial institution and payment system industries. Currently, he is the Executive Vice President at The RWC Group, a value-added provider of payment system advisory services and expert contract resources to more than 100 financial institutions and the federal government. He is also the President and Founder of Treasury Technologies, LLC, an industry-leading provider of next-generation payment system solutions. Previously, Kevin was Senior Vice President and Managing Director of the Financial Services Group at Trintech, a financial software solution company based in Dallas. Additional positions held by Kevin included Senior Vice President and Manager of the Treasury/Payments Division of Commerce Bank and Managing Principal at Carreker Corporation. Kevin has been a presenter on corporate bank relations and cash forecasting for the American Management Association course on Corporate Cash Management, as well as a frequent speaker at cash management and payment industry events. In addition, he is a co-patent holder of an innovative payment system Internet application, the Deposit Tracking System. Kevin earned his B.B.A. in Finance at the R.O. Anderson School of Management at the University of New Mexico. White Paper is based upon excerpts from the Deposit Re-engineering – Bankers Perspective, Chapter 13, Corporate Cash Management Handbook, published 2015 by Thomson Reuters. Permission to re-print excerpts granted by Thomson Reuters, publisher. Author: Kevin Connelly. Edited by Richard Bort © Kevin Connelly DEPOSIT REENGINEERING 15 www.therwcgroup.com (913) 660-2734