15 january 2017Issue 101
Email: tabloiddiplomasi@kemlu.go.id
www.tabloiddiplomasi.org
january 2017
Issue 101
DiplomasiDiplomasi
TABLOID
Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Republic of Indonesia
THE IMPORTANCE OF DEMOCRACY FOR
STATE LIFE AND RELATION AMONG NATIONS
tabloiddiplomasi.org tabloiddiplomasi@kemlu.org @diplik_kemlu
RI President :
january 2017Issue 101
Diplomasitable of contents
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
Can Integration of Law be done in ASEAN?
A country’s economic, political, social, and technological competi-
tiveness is always an interesting discussion. The competitiveness of
a country is considered as a source of a country’s resilience in fac-
ing all barriers in building national civilization. It is a civilization that
can only be built through superior economic, political, and cultural
strength. With high competitiveness, the economy can maintain its
economic growth and begin to build a regular state life and then the
development of civilization begins. The development of civilization
cannot be done without economic power. And economic power can-
not be enforced without competitiveness. Thus, competitiveness be-
comes very important in addition to the continuation of the economy
as well as the continuation of a nation’s civilization.
History shows that states with high civilization have always been sup-
ported by great economic power. In a legal framework, how does the
MEA work on the legal system of ASEAN member countries that have
different backgrounds? There is common law, civil law, socialist law
systems, or even a hybrid legal system circulating in ten ASEAN coun-
tries. It is possible that ASEAN is creating a harmonization of laws,
such as the EU that initiates integration in several lines including law
and economics.
The integration of laws in ASEAN becomes very important in raising
international issues. For instance, Singapore and Malaysia have cen-
tral issues on climate change and employment, while Indonesia has a
big issue on drugs and corruption, as Thailand focuses on the issue of
terrorism. The advantage of integrating the legal system is that ASE-
AN countries can create a common memorandum of understanding
on important issues including investment and free trade.
Herlambang Prawiro, student of the Faculty of Social and Political
Sciences
Sebelas Maret University
Reader’s Letter
Headline
4 IN THE MIDDLE OF WORLD UNCERTAINTY, INDONESIA’S DIPLOMACY CONTINUES TO WORK
7 THE IMPORTANCE OF DEMOCRACY FOR STATE LIFE AND RELATION AMONG NATIONS
focus
9 BDF BECOMES A MAJOR WORLD DEMOCRACY FORUM
10 INDONESIA CARVES FACTS ISLAM, DEMOCRACY AND PLURALISM CAN CO-EXIST IN HARMONY
11 Indonesia Mampu Menyampaikan Pesan Demokrasi Dan Pluralisme Dengan Tepat
12 RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN RELIGION AND RELIGIOUS HARMONY IN INDONESIA SHOULD BE MADE AS A MODEL
13 Indonesia harus menjadi pelopor kemajuan demokrasi di negara-negara Islam
14 CONVIVIAL LIVING WITH DIFFERENCES
Highlights
15 WAMENLU FACHIR: STRENGTHENING THE ROLES OF MEDIA AND CIVIL SOCIETY IN ADVANCING DEMOCRACY
16 CONFLICTS BETWEEN RELIGION, ETHNIC GROUPS, AND SOCIAL CLASSES HAPPEN AND ARE CORRELATED
17 DEMOCRACY AND TOLERANCE RESPOND TO THE CHALLENGE OF PLURALISM
18 BALI BINA INSANI ISLAMIC BOARDING SCHOOL TEACHES THE MEANING OF CLOSENESS AND TOLERANCE
19 INDONESIA IS A GOOD EXAMPLE IN IMPLEMENTING DIVERSITY AND HARMONY
20 A CLOSE LOOK AT THE ACHIEVEMENT OF THE DIRECTORATE GENERAL FOR INFORMATION AND PUBLIC DIPLOMACY
review
21 BOOK REVIEW: GEM FROM HEAVEN
lens
23 OIC COUNTRIES APPRECIATE RI GOVERNMENT REGARDING RAKHINE STATE ISSUE
24 RI FOREIGN MINISTER GIVES HUMANITARIAN AID TO RAKHINE STATE
15 january 2017Issue 101
Dear Diplomacy Tabloid Readers, in its
inaugural edition of 2017, we are present-
ing three main topics: the implementa-
tion of the Bali Democracy Forum (BDF)
IX, the Annual Press Statement of the
Indonesian Minister of Foreign Affairs,
and the Indonesian humanitarian aid to
Myanmar.
The 2016 BDF IX event was very special
because it was attended by 101 delegates
consisting of 95 State delegates and 6
International Organization delegates,
where as many as 26 delegates were from
the Ministerial and Deputy Ministerial
Levels as well as 75 delegates from the
Ambassador Level. This is the highest
achievement since BDF’s implementa-
tion in 2008.
BDF IX was also attended by world lead-
ers such as 1997-2006 United Nations
Secretary General Kofi Annan, 2008-
2012 ASEAN Secretary-General Surin
Pitsuwan, and 2015 Nobel Peace Prize
winner Ouided Bouchamaoui. In addi-
tion, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon
and President of the 71st UN General
Assembly Peter Thomson also delivered
messages through a video message. This
further confirms the BDF’s position as a
dialogue forum on constructive demo-
cratic development in the Asia Pacific
region.
BDF IX is also special as this is the first
time that President Joko Widodo partici-
pated and officially opened this activity
since he became Indonesia’s President
in 2014.
BDF IX’s another distinction is the BDF
IX delegations’ field visit to Bali Bina In-
sani Islamic Boarding School inTabanan,
where they were received tremendous
greetings from the local community.
The visit was filled with dialogue that
was welcomed by BDF IX delegates, in-
cluding the Ambassadors of Namibia,
Turkey, Australia, and Saudi Arabia.
Then a survey of the boarding school was
done and ended with the signing of the
inscription of the BDF IX delegations’
visit by the Minister of Foreign Affairs,
Retno Marsudi.
In the 2017Annual Press Statement of the
Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Repub-
lic of Indonesia, which was attended by
alltheAmbassadorsof friendlycountries
and also the press, the Minister of For-
eign Affairs, Retno Marsudi stated that
the threat to the stability and security of
the world in 2017 did not diminish. Con-
flicts are still occurring in different parts
of the world, which have always resulted
in global humanitarian tragedy. For that
reason, hard work must still be done and
international cooperation should also be
improved so that world stability, peace,
and prosperity can be better.
Today, the world is increasingly shaded
by uncertainty, but amid this uncertain-
ty, Indonesian diplomacy will continue
to work and continue to strive for na-
tional interests and contribute to world
stability and peace.
To complete this edition, in addition to
these main topics, we also present some
other interesting topics such as the Indo-
nesian humanitarian aid to the Rakhine
community of Myanmar.
Diplomacy tabloid’s editor and staff wish
a Happy New Year for 2017. We hope
that the year 2017 will be a better year,
not only for Indonesia, but also for the
world.
Happy reading and hope it brings value.
Greetings Diplomacy.
Editor’s note Person In Charge
Ambassador Niniek K. Naryatie
(Acting Director General for Information and Public
Diplomacy)
Al Busyra Basnur
(Director Public Diplomacy)
Aziz Nurwahyudi
(Secretary of the Directorate General of Infromation
and Public Diplomacy)
Editor
Arif Suyoko
Contributors
Agus Heryana
Bambang Prihartadi
Tangkuman Alexander
Agus Badrul Jamal
Etty Rachmawati
Pinkan O Tulung
Cherly Natalia Palijama
Purnowidodo
Meylia Wulandari
Khariri
Cahyono
Graphic Design and Photography
Alfons M. Sroyer
Arya Daru Pangayunan
Ibnu Sulhan
Tsabit Latief
Secretariat
Mahendra
Hesty M. Lonmasa
Darmia Dimu
Orchida Sekarratri
Agus Usmawan
Kistono
Dewa Putu Sastrawan
Iskandar Syahputra
Address
Direcorate Public Diplomacy, Ministery of Foreign
Affairs
Jl. Taman Pejambon No.6, Jakarta Pusat
Telp. 021- 68663162,3863708,
Fax : 021- 29095331, 385 8035
http://www.tabloiddiplomasi.org
Email : tabloiddiplomasi@kemlu.go.id
pubhlished by
Direcorate Public Diplomacy, Ministery of Foreign
Affairs
january 2017Issue 101headline4 Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
Annual Press Statement
Minister of Foreign Affairs (PPTM) 2017
The role of Indonesia in the re-
gion and globally continued to
increase in 2016.
The year 2016 has just ended.
Threats to the stability and se-
curity of the world have not di-
minished. Conflicts still occur
in different parts of the world--
conflicts that always result in hu-
manitarian tragedy.
Not counting the huge num-
ber of people who perished due
to the conflicts in Syria, Yemen,
Iraq, Afghanistan, Sudan, Mali
and Central African Republic.
Not counting the number of
people who forcibly left their
countries because of the con-
flicts and the influx of refugees
continues to go on.
Not counting the number of
people who lost their future due
to the conflicts.
These conflicts also create psychological trauma, including chil-
dren. Children are the future hope of the world.
Aside from conflicts, the threat of terrorism is still ongoing. More
than 150 terrorist attacks occurred in different parts of the world in
2016.
The Thamrin bombing on January 13, 2016 and the attack in Ber-
lin on December 19, 2016 show the threat of terrorism, and militant
extremism / radicalism has actually increased. The year 2017 even
started with terrorist attacks in Istanbul last January 1.
The Indonesian government condemned the incident and offered
condolences to the victims and their families.
The tendency of the politics of populism and pragmatism to
emerge also influenced the year 2016.
The world economy is still not recovering. As per World Bank cor-
rections, for three consecutive years, the global economy grew lower
than previous predictions.
We should be grateful that the Indonesian economy is still growing
at 5%. Indonesia’s Coordinating Minister for Economic Affairs stated
that Indonesia’s economic growth is a quality growth, which is indi-
cated by the decline in inequal-
ity, poverty and unemployment.
Back to the world situation,
commodity prices are still low
and provide a challenge for de-
veloping countries which are
commodity producers.
In short, the world is increas-
ingly colored by uncertainties -
uncertainties that have become
more obvious.
In the midst of these uncer-
tainties, Indonesian diplomacy
continues to work - continues
to strive for national interests
and contributes to stability and
world peace.
At the latter part of 2016, In-
donesia was working intensively
to help solve the Rakhine State
issue.
Indonesia expressed concern
for humanitarian and security
developments, particularly re-
lated to the Muslim minority in
Rakhine State. Indonesia empha-
sizes the importance of inclusive
development, respect for human
rights and protection of all com-
munities; while at the same time
offering advice and assistance on
resolving this issue, and offering
cooperation not only immedi-
ate, but also for the medium and
long-term.
Various communications and
meetings have been conducted
by Indonesia, including with the
State Counselor of Myanmar,
Daw Aung San Suu Kyi; Chair-
IN THE MIDDLE OF WORLD UNCERTAINTY, INDONESIA’S
DIPLOMACY CONTINUES TO WORK
15 january 2017Issue 101 headline 5Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
man of the Rakhine Advisory
Commission, Kofi Annan; For-
eign Minister and PM of Ban-
gladesh; as well as various stake-
holders both in Jakarta, Yangon
and Dhaka.
As part of the shuttle diplo-
macy effort, the Foreign Minis-
ter also made a direct visit to the
Kutupalong refugee camp in Cox
Baza, on the Bangladesh-Myan-
mar border.
Indonesia’s concern was also
realized through the delivery of
10 humanitarian aid containers
to Rakhine State on December
29, 2016.
Diplomacy for humanity has
been continuously undertaken.
All steps of Indonesian diplo-
macy are carried out construc-
tively, without any noise.
We believe that “Actions
Speak Louder Than Words”.
Four other Indonesians have
also been freed from Somalia, af-
ter four and a half years of hos-
tage taking.
There are still four of our
brothers who still have to be re-
leased in the Southern Philip-
pines. The government will never
remain silent until they safely re-
turn to their respective families.
We will do whatever we can to
release them.
In the Syrian conflict, Indo-
nesia is one of the few countries
that continue to carry out diplo-
matic missions, both through the
Indonesian Embassy in Damas-
cus as well as in consular offices
in Aleppo and Lattakia for shel-
tering Indonesian citizens.
In fact, in 2016, Indonesian
diplomats were able to penetrate
the city of Raqqah, Syria to save
citizens.
In addition, the Government
also successfully handled: the
completion of 11,065 cases of In-
donesian citizens abroad; freeing
71citizensfromthedeathpenalty;
complete and provide protection
to 399 victims of TPPO; facilitat-
ing the return of 41,569 Indone-
sian citizens; returning funds
worth more than Rp 92 billion
to Indonesian citizens through
diyat payments, salary insurance
and other compensation; and
handling 512 sailors who faced
problems abroad.
The ability of immediate re-
sponse in providing protection
to Indonesian citizens abroad is
tested throughout 2016. However,
with good cooperation between
the Ministry and Foreign Affairs
it can be handled well.
Hundreds of Indonesians
trappedinvariousairports inTur-
key during the July 15, 2016 coup
d’état were provided immediate
assistance. 190 students in Turkey
whose studies were threatened
after a coup were assisted. Four
students in Turkey who were ar-
rested due to the political crisis
in Turkey were released. 283 pil-
grims / prospective Indonesian
pilgrims using fake Philippine
passports were deported and re-
leased from lawsuits because of
their status as victims. 34 Indone-
sians who were victims of a ship
that sunk carrying Indonesian
Migrant Workers (BMI) in the
waters of Johor, Malaysia were
saved and repatriated to the area
of origin.
As the dynamics and mobility
of Indonesian Citizens increase,
the use of information technol-
ogy in servicing and protecting
Indonesian citizens became a
necessity.
A number of breakthroughs
have been made, such as the
full integration of WNI data-
bases abroad (e-protection) with
BNP2TKI database. Further inte-
gration with the Population and
Civil Registration database of the
Ministry of Home Affairs is now
being prepared.
Proactively, 8 Indonesian
Representatives have applied
services and protection based
on technology and mobile ap-
plication, namely in KBRI Den
Haag, Seoul, Bangkok, Brussels,
Singapore, Consulate General of
Jeddah, Hong Kong, and in the
Consulate General of Tawau. A
number of other RI Representa-
tives will follow this year.
Today, the Ministry of Foreign
Affairs has launched the beta ver-
sion of the Safe Travel applica-
tion. With this application, the
Ministry of Foreign Affairs can
identify the actual distribution,
location and identity of Indone-
sian citizens abroad and provide
a quick response in emergency
situations.
The trend of Citizens becom-
ing victims of human trafficking
abroad is increasing. Respond-
ing to this matter, the Ministry of
Foreign Affairs has taken several
steps,suchasthesigningof aMoU
on the Handling of Indonesian
Citizens of TPPO Victims abroad
with 6 Ministries / Institutions;
the signing of a bilateral MoU
on TPPO control with the United
Arab Emirates, and exploring a
MoU similar with all Gulf Coop-
eration Countries (GCC).
The efforts to protect migrant
workers also continue, among
others, in ASEAN. Indonesia
succeeded in convincing other
ASEAN countries to agree on
the Vientiane Declaration on the
Transition from Informal Em-
ployment to Formal Employment
to Decent Work Promotions.
Strengthening Economic Di-
plomacy also continues to be en-
couraged.
Economic diplomacy support
is evident for the 14 Economic
Policy Packages issued by the
Government. The Ministry of For-
eign Affairs is part of the Working
Group I handling the Campaign
and Dissemination of Economic
Policy at the Task Force of the Ac-
celeration and Effectiveness of
the Implementation of Economic
Policy (PEPKE).
Atotalof 149bilateralandmul-
tilateral agreements on economic
issues were agreed throughout
2016.
RI diplomats actively raised
the participation of other coun-
tries in the Indonesia Trade Expo
2016 where 125 countries partici-
pated and recorded transactions
amounting to USD 974.76 million.
In addition, 31 trade contracts
were signed with a value of USD
200 million.
The Working Group on Eco-
nomic Diplomacy and RI Repre-
sentatives facilitated more than
35,000 Indonesian business play-
ers to make contacts, handle que-
ries, and match-making with po-
tential transactions of nearly USD
30 billion.
Some other notes in the eco-
nomic field are: PT INKA success-
fully exported 150 railway carriag-
es valued at USD 72.3 million, and
furtherdiscussionsof exportaddi-
tions are being discussed; Exports
of CN 235 aircraft produced by PT
Dirgantara Indonesia to Senegal
and Thailand; Construction of an
Indonesianinstantnoodlefactory
in Serbia worth 11 million euros to
meet the European market.
2016 also recorded intensifica-
tion of CEPA negotiations: Indo-
nesia-EU CEPA Scoping paper has
beencompletedandagreementof
negotiation commenced in 2017;
january 2017Issue 101 Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
headline6
Conducted Indonesia-Australia
CEPA negotiations 4 times; RCEP
negotiations 6 times; Indonesia-
EFTA CEPA negotiations 2 times;
and ASEAN-Hong Kong FTA ne-
gotiations 4 times.
One thing to be grateful for
in 2016 is that the EU has certi-
fied the Forest Law Enforcement
Governance and Trade-Voluntary
Partnership Agreement (FLEGT-
VPA) for Indonesian wood prod-
ucts. Indonesia is the first country
to obtain such certification and
will facilitate the export of Indo-
nesian wood products to other
regions.
Recognition was also achieved
with the permission of three In-
donesian airlines to return to the
European Union. Garuda Airlines
also flies directly to two new des-
tinations, namely Heathrow in
London and in Mumbai.
Indonesia’s role in the re-
gion and internationally
increased in 2016.
Indonesia opens diplo-
matic relations with 3 countries,
Chad, Central African Republic
and Equatorial Guinea. Indone-
sia now has diplomatic relations
with 190 of the 193 UN member
states.
Indonesia actively con-
tributes through various meet-
ings. The President recorded
55 bilateral and international
meetings; the Vice President 13
meetings; the Minister of Foreign
Affairs 302 meetings; and the
Deputy Minister of Foreign Af-
fairs 35 meetings.
Indonesia’s diplomacy
is always directed to create world
peace and stability. Indonesia’s
diplomacy continues to work on
delivering peace messages to Iran
and Saudi Arabia. At the initia-
tive of Indonesia, the establish-
ment of a contact group on peace
and reconciliation at the OIC has
been approved.
Indonesia is one of the
largest contributors to world
peace. Indonesia has sent 2,731
personnel to 9 UN missions.
Through various forums
in the UN, OIC, ASEAN, G20,
Mikta and the BDF, Indonesia
has always voiced the impor-
tance of promoting cooperation
and dialogue and minimizing
confrontation and politicization;
combating terrorism through law
enforcement balanced by cul-
tural and religious approaches;
promoting Islam “that brings
mercy and prosperity” as well as
respect for diversity; encouraging
women’s role in decision-making
mechanisms, as well as fair co-
herence of policies and global
economic order.
Especially for Mikta, at
the initiative of Indonesia, inter-
faith dialogue has been conduct-
ed in Yogyakarta in October 2016.
Along with Norway,
Colombia, Ethiopia, Ghana, Jor-
dan and Mexico, Indonesia has
submitted a UN Reform input to
the new UN Secretary General,
António Guterres, in the form of
UN 70: a new agenda for the next
Secretary-General.
Specifically on Palestine,
we have two choices, whether to
be passive or active - do noth-
ing or do something. Indonesia
chooses to do something.
Indonesia will not back
down in helping the Palestinian
struggle for independence.
Indonesia hosted an ex-
traordinary summit on Palestine,
Al Quds al Sharif, in Jakarta in
March 2016. The summit resulted
ina‘JakartaDeclaration’thatsup-
ported Palestinian independence
with breakthroughs and concrete
action.
Indonesia will raise as
muchsupportaspossibleinorder
to achieve a “two state solution”.
However, we realize that there is
a steep path ahead of us.
For that reason, Indone-
sia supports the initiative of the
French international conference
of ideas. Indonesia has attended
the meeting in Paris in June 2016
and will be present at the January
meeting also in Paris.
As a diplomatic break-
through, Indonesia has opened
an honorary consulate in Ramal-
lah and plans to open an ‘ Indo-
nesian House’ in Palestine.
Furthermore, amid the
world’s concern over the refugee
crisis, Indonesia is progressing
with concrete initiatives.
ThroughtheBaliprocess,
Indonesia mobilizes the approval
of the country of origin, transit
and destination for consultation
mechanisms in response to irreg-
ular migratory emergency situa-
tions in the region.
(Edited from the speech of the
Minister of Foreign Affairs of the
Republic of Indonesia on pptm
2017)
15 january 2017Issue 101Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
headline 7
It is an honor for me to be at
the 9th Bali Democracy Forum
Opening ceremony.
This year’s Bali Democracy
Forum event is very special be-
causeitisattendedbyworldlead-
ers, Nobel Peace winner, Foreign
Ministers from 95 countries and
6 international organizations.
In recent years, I get hold
of the grips and worries of the
countries of the world each time
I attend international meetings.
I see that this view cannot
be detached from the current
world situation, old conflicts
and new conflicts continue in
some countries, including the
Palestinian people’s struggle for
independence which still has no
expected results, the rapid de-
velopment of radicalism and ex-
tremism in various corners of the
world, the decline in tolerance
and willingness to accept dif-
ferences in many of the world’s
societies, and the growing act of
xenophobia.
I can understand if this situa-
tion creates a sense of worry and
anxiety, more so as it is coupled
with a world economic condition
that is filled with uncertainties.
There exist political, economic,
and social domestic challenges
in almost all countries.
Under these circumstances,
we need a sense of optimism. An
optimism that can result from us
speaking to each other, an opti-
mism that can develop from us
exchanging thoughts and experi-
ences, an optimism that I hope
can grow from the presence of
all of us in this Bali Democracy
Forum.
Therefore, I highly value this
year’s Bali Democracy Forum’s
theme of “Religion, Democracy,
and Tolerance as it is relevant to
the current situation of the re-
gion and of the world.
Because we have high confi-
dence that religion is Allah’s gift
to the universe, or that brings
mercy and prosperity. Because we
are optimistic that democracy
brings people’s will and good-
ness to mankind. Because we are
aware that tolerance is necessary
because we are all different.
For centuries, religion has
played an important role for hu-
man, social, economic and po-
litical life, both at the national,
regional and global levels.
No less important is the cul-
ture of mutual respect and toler-
ance that has become a thread,
which unites different world so-
cieties since we existed on earth.
And I am convinced that all
of us in this room agree on the
importance of a democratic state
life in relations between coun-
tries of the world.
So our task here is to ensure
how democracy works well to
support stability and peace, and
to bring prosperity to the people.
For that purpose, the Govern-
ment needs to actively promote
synergy between democracy,
religion, and tolerance. This ef-
fort should be reflected in all na-
tional policies. Therefore, a top-
down approach in the form of an
active role of government is key,
both through good governance
and the supremacy of law, which
is just as important with the ef-
forts in strengthening democracy
from the grassroots.
We in Indonesia are in luck.
Indonesia has a very long history
of pluralism. Indonesia is home
to pluralism. There are more
than 1,300 ethnic groups inhabit-
ing Indonesia.
Indonesia is a country with
the largest Muslim population
in the world. About 85% of over
252 million Indonesians are Mus-
lims.
Islam reached Indonesia
sometime in the 7th century. In-
donesia’s history tells us that the
teaching of Islam was propagat-
ed in a peaceful way. The value
of peace is what continues to be
held by Indonesian Muslims.
Aside from Islam, Indonesia
is home to Christians, Catholics,
Hindus, Buddhists and Confu-
cians.
The value of peace is also held
firmly by all adherents in Indo-
nesia.
You can just imagine how an
Islamic boarding school can ex-
ists safely and comfortably in a
predominantly Hindu commu-
nity without the value of high
tolerance.
All this drives a natural synergy
between religion, tolerance and
democracy in Indonesia.
Historically, the people of In-
donesia persistently strive for de-
mocracy, because with democra-
cy, everyone has the same rights
and obligations, checks and bal-
ances will work, and every single
voice matters.
THE IMPORTANCE OF DEMOCRACY FOR
STATE LIFE AND RELATION AMONG NATIONS
President Joko Widodo
january 2017Issue 101 Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
FOcUS8
The Indonesian people believe
that Indonesia will become bet-
ter through democracy.
Democracy is also a process,
which means we continue to
learn from the democratic pro-
cesses we live in, and we need
to learn from the experiences of
other countries in democracy.
Therefore, Indonesia is highly
committed in making the Bali
Democracy Forum as a conve-
nient forum for every country to
share experiences in democracy,
challenges in democracy, and de-
velop cooperation to help each
other democratically.
This forum is not a “finger point-
ing exercise” forum. Precisely,
this forum should be used to
strengthen each other.
Through the Institute for Peace
and Democracy (IPD), Indonesia
is ready to develop concrete co-
operation in the field of democ-
racy and peace.
In closing, I would like to con-
vey my congratulations on your
dialogue on democracy and tol-
erance. I am sure there will al-
ways be new things which can
be gained from every dialogue.
Thank you.
(Speech of the President of the
Republic of Indonesia at the
Opening of Bali Democracy Fo-
rum IX, at Bali International
Conference Center, Nusa Dua,
Bali, December 7, 2016)
BDF IX Invites Participants to See Real
Practices and Engage All Stakeholders
“We deliberately took this program to
show in the field, at the community level, that
there is togetherness and tolerance. How it
is possible for an Islamic boarding school to
stand and exists comfortably without any dis-
turbance in the midst of a Hindu society. This
is an example of how the difference can be
used as a capital to build human quality with
integrity, “said the Foreign Minister.
Other implemented series of the BDF IX
is the international seminar organized under
the theme “Islam and Democracy, the Chal-
lenge of Pluralism and Security”. It involves
religious figures, NGOs, and media from vari-
ous countries. (Related news on page 15).
The high participation of high-ranking of-
ficials in the implementation of BDF IX has
confirmed the position of BDF as a dialogue
forum on constructive democratic develop-
ment in the Asia Pacific region.
The international recognition of the exis-
tence of BDF is evident from the presence of
world figures such as 1997-2006 UN Secretary
General Kofi Annan, 2008-2012 ASEAN Secre-
tary General Surin Pitsuwan, and 2015 Nobel
Peace prize winner Ouided Bouchamaoui. In
addition, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon
and President of the 71st UN General Assem-
bly Peter Thomson also delivered their mes-
sages through a video message.
BDF IX also became special because this
is the first time that President Joko Widodo
attended and officially opened this activity
since being President of Indonesia in 2014.
Another exceptional feature of the BDF
IX event is the site visit or visit of the BDF IX
delegates to Bali Bina Insani Islamic boarding
school in Tabanan. This activity is intended to
show a form of tolerance in Indonesia, where
a boarding school can run its activities well in
a village where almost all of the population is
Hindu.
This is the first time that such a site visit
activity was done in a BDF event since 2008.
15 january 2017Issue 101Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
FOcUS 9
The Bali Democracy Forum
(BDF) IX at Bali International
Conference Center (BICC), Nusa
Dua, Bali on December 8-9, 2016,
was attended by 101 delegates
consisting of 46 delegates from
participating countries, 49 del-
egates from observing countries,
and 6 delegates of observers from
international organizations.
The delegation of partici-
pating countries consisted of 10
ministerial delegates, 11 delegates
at the deputy minister level, and
25 ambassadorial level delegates.
The observer country delegates
consisted of 2 ministerial level
delegates, 1 deputy ministerial
delegate, and 46 ambassadorial
level delegates. While the delega-
tion of observers from interna-
tional organizations consisted of
1 ministerial delegate, 1 deputy
ministerial level delegate, and 4
ambassadorial level delegates.
Countries that sent minis-
terial level delegations are: Af-
ghanistan, Fiji, Maldives, Nepal,
Palestine, Papua New Guinea,
Philippines, Qatar, Singapore,
and Timor Leste.
Countries that sent deputy
ministerial delegations were: Ar-
menia, Bangladesh, Brunei Dar-
ussalam, China, Iran, Japan, Laos,
Malaysia, Mongolia, Thailand,
and Turkmenistan.
While other countries, name-
ly: Australia, Azerbaijan, Bahrain,
Cambodia, Georgia, India, Iraq,
Jordan, Kazakhstan, Korea, Ku-
wait, Myanmar, New Zealand,
Oman, Pakistan, Russia, Saudi
Arabia, Solomon Island, Srilanka
, Tunisia, Turkey, United Arab
Emirates, Uzbekistan, and Viet-
nam sent ambassadorial level
delegates.
Libya and Suriname are the
two observer countries that sent
a ministerial level delegation, while Zimbabwe sent
a deputy minister level observer delegate. In the
meantime, 46 other observers sent ambassadorial
level delegates. These countries are: Algeria, Argen-
tina, Austria, Belarus, Belgium, Bosnia, Herzegovina,
Brazil, Bulgaria, Canada, Chile, Colombia, Czech,
Denmark, Equador, Ethiopia, France, Finland, Ger-
many, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Lebanon , Luxem-
bourg, Mexico, Morocco, Mozambique, Namibia,
Netherland, Nigeria, Norway, Peru, Poland, Portugal,
Senegal, Serbia, Slovakia, Slovenia, South Africa,
Spain, Sudan, Sweden, Switzerland, Ukraine, UK,
USA, and Venezuela .
International organizations participating in the
implementation of BDF IX 2016 and present as ob-
servers were: MSG (Melanesian spearhead group),
IDEA (institute for democracy and electoral as-
sistance), European Union, community of democ-
racies, ICRC (international committee of the Red
Cross) and UN.
Melanesian Spearhead Group (MSG) sent a min-
isterial level delegate, while IDEA sent a deputy
ministerial level delegate. Meanwhile, four other in-
ternational organizations each sent an ambassado-
rial level delegation.
So overall, the 2016 BDF IX event was attended
by 101 delegates led by 13 ministers, 13 vice ministers
and 75 ambassadors.
Ministerspresentwere:FaizMohammadOsmani
(foreign minister of Afghanistan), Seremaia Cavui-
lati (foreign minister of Fiji), Dr. Mohamed Asim
(foreign minister Maldives), Dr. Prakash Sharan Ma-
hat (Nepalese foreign minister), Dr. Riad al Maliki,
Rimbink Pato (foreign minister of PNG), Ernesto
C. Abella (presidential spokesperson of the Philip-
pines), Sultan bin Saad al Muraikh (foreign minis-
ter of Qatar), Amrin Amin (parliamentary secretary
of Singapore), Hernani Coelho (foreign minister of
Timor Leste ), Mohamed Attaher Siyala (Libyan for-
eign minister), Niermala Badrising (foreign minister
Suriname), and Amena Yauvoli (director general for
Asia, Pacific and Africa MSG). []
BDF BECOMES A MAJOR WORLD
DEMOCRACY FORUM
Countries that sent ministerial
level delegations are: Afghanistan,
Fiji, Maldives, Nepal, Palestine, Papua
New Guinea, Philippines, Qatar, Singa-
pore, and Timor Leste.
january 2017Issue 101 Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi10 FOcUS
INDONESIA CARVES FACTs
ISLAM, DEMOCRACY AND PLURALISM CAN
co-EXIST IN HARMONY
This is for the 9th year in a
row that Indonesia is proud to
host the Bali Democracy Forum.
I hope that next year, we will
be able to welcome the partici-
pation of more countries and
discuss the challenges faced by
other regions.
Through this forum, we can
learn about democracy and oth-
erissuesrelatedtoit,notthrough
finger-pointing or patronizing, but by sharing our experiences.
As host, Indonesia strongly believes that ongoing discussions and
lesson-learned sharing are paramount to advancing every progress of
our own democracy.
Such an exchange of views has become more important as chal-
lenges of democracy arise.
In some democratic countries that are becoming more multieth-
nic, multi-religious and multi-valued, horizontal tension is a constant
reality.
To face these challenges, we must further strengthen our com-
mitment to the values of toler-
ance, pluralism and moderation
and make it an integral part of
our community.
Democracy in Indonesia is
in full swing. And it is practiced
in the course of our community
life.
Indonesia is a witness to the
fact that Islam, democracy and
pluralism can coexist harmoni-
ously.
However, this is not some-
thing to be taken for granted. We
have to keep working to nurture
and make it strong.
Therefore, the Bali Democ-
racy Forum is an important plat-
form for us to carry out.
We are reporting that the 9th
Bali Democracy Forum is attend-
ed by delegates from 95 countries
and 6 international organiza-
tions.
We are also honored by the
presence of Mr. Kofi Annan, UN
Secretary General for the period
1997-2006, Madame Ouided Bou-
chamaoui, 2015 Nobel Peace prize
winner, and ASEAN Secretary
General for 2008-2012, HE Surin
Pitsuwan, at this meeting.
In this two-day meeting,
we will discuss Promoting De-
mocracy and Religious Harmony
in Responding to the Challenges
of Pluralism. We also have the
opportunity to share best prac-
tices and important lessons in
fostering religious harmony and
in combating violent extremism
through democratic responses.[]
Foreign Minister Retno
15 january 2017Issue 101 11FOcUSDiplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
I believe that religion, pluralism, and de-
mocracy are not contradictory. On the con-
trary, I believe that religion, pluralism, and
democracy can mutually reinforce the foun-
dations of a healthy, stable, and prosperous
society.
From dawn, and in the four corners of the
world, religion and belief have given human-
ity ethnic code, spiritual guidance and com-
fort. In particular, religion has been a driving
force for personal and social progress. Even
in secular countries, religious norms have in-
spired many of their laws and customs.
But we cannot deny that religion is also
often instrumentalized to exclude, persecute
and even kill “others,” whether external en-
emies or close neighbors.
In our diverse society, the only way to
avoid conflicts and to ensure that people be-
lieve, no matter what their faith, can exercise
freely is to ensure that religion affirms the
principle of pluralism.
The Global Center for Pluralism – which
was founded by Aga Khan and the Canadian
government, where I am a Member of the
Council - defines pluralism as a concept that
not only respects diversity, but is an actual
value and celebrates diversity as it recognizes
its benefits to society.
In his study of the history of the decline
and fall of dominant kingdoms, Yale Univer-
sity professor, Amy Chua, reveals that the
most successful kingdoms in world history,
ranging from Ancient Persia and Rome to the
Tang Empire in China, are based on pragmat-
ic pluralism.
Pluralism allows them to successfully in-
tegrate various nations into their systems,
and then draws different types of talent and
knowledge to defend and expand their em-
pire because they all have shares in it.
Their fall, he argues, stems from their em-
brace of intolerant and exclusive attitudes.
Democracy is the most suitable system
for securing and maintaining pluralism in to-
day’s world.
True democracy perpetuates the rights
and freedoms of all individuals in law and
institutions, regardless of race, gender, or re-
ligion, and provides votes to all.
I cannot think of a better country to deliv-
er this message other than Indonesia, which
has a national motto “Bhinneka Tunggal Ika”
or Unity in Diversity.
This great country consists of about 300
ethnic groups and more than 700 languages,
and many religions, scattered throughout the
vast archipelago, which is a joyful existence
that pluralism can work.
Speaking here in Bali, which has a unique
heritage and tradition and makes Bali one of
the most valuable destinations in the world,
also highlights the benefits of diversity that
can be brought to the country.
However, there are currently many parts
INDONESIA ABLE TO CONVEY
THE RIGHT MESSAGE OF
DEMOCRACY AND PLURALISM
Kofi Annan, Former Secretary-General of the United Nations
january 2017Issue 101Focus12 Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
of theworldthataremutuallyreinforcingand
beneficial to diversity that are under threat.
Globalization, in addition to integrating
the world economy, society, and people more
thanever,andcreatingunprecedentedwealth
around the world, also resulted in a backlash
as the benefits gained were not evenly dis-
tributed and the gap between rich and poor
continued to widen.
The losers of globalization - driven by
populist politicians - retreat to primal identi-
ty, some real, some imagination as a bulwark
of uncertainty and fear.
World over, groups or movements seek
to resist the bonds that bind us all between
religions, nationalities, races, and class divi-
sions.
Populist and xenophobic movements,
which condemn migrants and other minori-
ties in the name of protecting their own iden-
tity, often on the basis of some idea of ethnic
purity and or religion.
Even more brutal, religious extremists
deny humanity not only to people of differ-
ent religions but also to people of their own
religion who does not share their beliefs.
Diversity is increasingly portrayed as a
threat that undermines our society, rather
than as an asset that can benefit all of us.
Unfortunately, well-placed democratic
institutions that resist these forces are also
challenged.
Trust in these institutions declines, and
not just in new democracies. Party member-
ship, voter participation, and trust in politi-
cians decline in old and well-established de-
mocracies.
There is a sense that democracy is empty
and that the running institutions and pro-
cesses are not functioning properly, or in the
interest of the community from whom power
comes from.
In many countries, we see democratically
elected leaders becoming increasingly au-
thoritarian and striving for unlimited power.
If citizens do not believe that they can
change their leaders through the ballot boxes
- the mechanisms adopted for peaceful and
democratic leadership rotation - they will
look for other ways, even with the risk of de-
stabilizing their country.
This trend undermines our belief in one
another and towards our institutions. That
is why my Foundation emphasizes the legiti-
macy of democracy through elections with
integrity.
Elections with integrity are not only free
and fair but also ensure legitimacy for win-
ners and security for the losers.
As I often say, the problem is not belief
but faith. Religion can be used for good, but
it can also be abused.
We must emphasize the basic values com-
mon to all religions: compassion, solidarity,
and a sense of respect for the human person.
At the same time, we need to distance our-
selves from stereotypes, generalizations and
prejudices; and care not to let crimes be com-
mitted by individuals , or small groups; or not
to dictate our views on all people, entire re-
gions, or all religions.
We must also avoid the pitfalls imposed by
extremists who restrict human beings to only
one identity. We all have many identities that
enrich us as individuals.
We may be different but we can share the
common love of our family or our national
heritage, and our faith.
We must accept that what we have together
far exceeded what separates us, and we need
not hate “others” to love who we are.
And we must strive to revitalize democ-
racy itself because maintaining diversity in a
peaceful and productive way is possible only
in a democratic system of government.
To quote Winston Churchill, democracy is
the worst form of government ever created,
except for all others. But we do not just ac-
cept democracy just like that. Recent elec-
tions in a number of countries have shown us
that democracy is a fragile flower.
However, elections have obliged mainstream
leaders to recognize that material benefits
from globalization have not been evenly dis-
tributed and many have been abandoned or
fallen through the safety net.
They also show why polling is problematic.
Many of the most populist fanatic critics do
not vote, and then look shocked and anxious
when they win.
But democracy is not just about elections,
but more than that, democracy is first and
foremost about laws and institutions that
guarantee the rights of its citizens, respect
and even protect, freedom of religion.
Plural societies, however, often prove diffi-
cult to manage because of their diversity.
As Indonesia knows, the government’s suc-
cess in such a plural society requires inclusive
leadership, in order to build and maintain
trust amongst communities over time.
We must also recognize the no one-size-fits-
all approach to this task.
The way forward is difficult but future de-
mands are increasingly challenging. It re-
quires leadership from all regions of the
world, and all parts of society.
Politics is too important if left to politicians
alone, religious leaders, business leaders, civil
society organizations, and ordinary citizens
must demonstrate their commitment to the
moral of their faith and the values of demo-
cratic pluralism.
No one is born as a good democrat and no
one is born as a good citizen. It is an Indone-
sian, Alwi Shihab, who notes that democracy
is our habit that needs to be nurtured.
Mutual respect and tolerance should be nur-
tured and passed on to each generation.
We must learn from each other, make our
traditions and cultures different as sources
of harmony and strength, not disagreements
and weaknesses.
Only by learning from each other can we
build a global community based on the ulti-
mate truth, where every religion teaches us:
respect and love to all mankind, for we are all
children of God.
15 january 2017Issue 101 focus 13Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
Ouided Bouchamaoui
Nobel Peace Prize Winner
Iwillstartbyconveyingwarm-
ly to the organizers of the
Bali Democracy Forum who
had invited me to this event. As a
2015 Nobel Peace Laureate from
Tunisia, I would like to use this
opportunity to convey respect
to the host country, Indonesia,
the world’s largest archipelago
formed as a republic and demo-
cratic, for its major role on cru-
cial themes such as democracy,
religion, and pluralism.
As an admirer of this extraor-
dinary Asian culture, Indonesia
should be proud of the concept
of religious harmony, the cen-
tral concept enshrined in the
Indonesian constitution and
widely respected by the four ma-
jor religions of Indonesia: Islam,
Christianity, Hinduism and Bud-
dhism.
Indonesia has been able to
consolidate interreligious rela-
tions and religious harmony in
an exemplary way. By doing so,
Indonesia has provided an ex-
ample worthy of being followed
by many countries, including my
own country.
Speaking on the experi-
ence of Tunisian democracy,
my country has adopted a new
constitution, the Constitution
of 2014, which replaced
the 1959 Constitution. In
terms of religion, and af-
ter a long debate within
the Assembly of People’s
Representatives (ARP),
it was decided not to
change the first article of
the Constitution of 1959
which states that “Tuni-
sia is a free, independent,
and sovereign state, Is-
lam as its religion, Arabic
as its language, and Republic as
its form.”
This short sentence of con-
sensus speaks of religious com-
plexity when confronted with
political reality. Indeed, the term
used in the ever-relevant phrase
contained in the Tunisian Con-
stitution proves the intelligence
of legislators who respect the
mandate of democracy.
Tunisia has a very long history
thathaslastedforthreethousand
years. Tunisia is a small country
with 11 million inhabitants. Tuni-
sia has been a democratic labora-
tory in the Arab world since the
Jasmine Revolution six years ago.
In 1956, Tunisia proclaimed its
independence. Bourguiba, Tuni-
sia’s first president has enacted
a number of new legal rules for
women and families, which was
enacted for the first time in a
Muslim country. The rule of law
is also a reference to Tunisia’s
new constitution of 2014.
As I mentioned earlier, diver-
sity and pluralism are the basic
features of Tunisian character
and society. These two main fea-
tures are written in the Tunisian
Constitution, and are the basic
foundation of Tunisian history.
Synagogues and churches stand
side by side with mosques in Tu-
nisia. Minorities, both Jews and
Christians, perform their wor-
ship activities in total freedom.
In fact, Tunisia always pro-
tects plurality, for instance, by
encouraging Tunisian Jews to
celebrate the pilgrimage to Ghi-
ba, the 33rd day of the Jewish
Passover. The pilgrimage is at the
heartof thetraditionof thiscom-
munity. The Ghriba Synagogue
on the island of Djerba is known
as one of the most ancient syna-
gogues in North Africa.
Some of the reasons for the
“Tunisian exception” are also
causedbyTunisia’smulti-cultural
history as well as the geographi-
cal position of Tunisia. Tunisia
is one of the most diverse coun-
tries in the world because mi-
grants from Africa, Arabia, Tur-
key, Europe (Italy, Spain, France,
and others) can find their place
in Tunisia and integrate well. It
makes a beautiful mixture and
has formed an open and colored
Tunisia.
Thus,Iwanttomakeaseman-
ticshiftinexplainingtheconcept
of “cultural harmony”. In Tunisia,
we have a historical obligation to
honor those who share the same
history with us, regardless of reli-
gion, belief, or faith.
The important thing to em-
phasize in this case is how we can
As a country with the larg-
est Muslim population, In-
donesia has a big role in en-
couraging the development
of democracy in Islamic coun-
tries in the world. Although
the Middle East consists of
Islamic countries, the devel-
opment of democracy is not as
good as Indonesia. Therefore,
Indonesia should be a pioneer
of democratic progress in the
Islamic countries. The world
sees it as a representation of
the largest Islamic state in the
world.
Indonesia should encour-
age democratic development
of Muslim countries especial-
ly in the Middle East. There is
still much to do, such as the
best exchange of democratic
experiences in various Islamic
countries. Show the world that
Islam is suitable for democ-
racy.
Indonesia should not lec-
ture other large countries, but
rather approach in a diplo-
matic way.[]
INDONESIA SHOULD BE A FORERUNNER
FOR THE ADVANCEMENT OF DEMOCRACY IN
ISLAMIC COUNTRIES
Azyumardi Azra
Jakarta State Islamic University Professor
RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN RELIGION AND RELIGIOUS
HARMONY IN INDONESIA SHOULD BE MADE AS A MODEL
Dok.Termpo
january 2017Issue 101Focus14 Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
promote and build a model soci-
ety that is not only conditioned
to “cultural harmony”, which is
one step with “religious harmo-
ny” practiced in Indonesia, but
also by building a pillar of har-
mony that is no less important to
me, namely “social harmony”.
In Tunisia, we are faced with
a crucial question regarding “so-
cial harmony”. We are called to
recognize that every Tunisian
society, male and female, aspires
to live in dignity in a society that
recognizes its social and eco-
nomic rights.
Today, the most difficult
challenge for us is basically eco-
nomic. We need to eradicate in-
justice, poverty, unemployment,
inequality, social exclusion, and
intolerance. There is no doubt
that forming the ideals of “har-
mony” as universally perceived
in your culture and mine is a
daunting task.
It is recognized that these
two ideals conceptually go hand
in hand to achieve the same
goal of peace and prosperity for
all. It should be understood that
religious harmony includes ele-
ments of social harmony, such
as solidarity, sharing, caring for
others, honesty, mutual respect
in difference, and protection for
the weak.
However, there is no denying
that there will be no harmony of
democracy without harmony of
religion, harmony of culture, and
social harmony.
Accepting diversity with all
its richness emphasizes the im-
portance of creating ideal con-
ditions for “total harmony”, both
religious, cultural and social: the
most important thing is to re-
spect differences with others, to
diversity, to respect their differ-
ences, to respect the beliefs of
others, while moving to achieve
the welfare of the whole society.
The optimal condition for a
better life in democracy should
be based on approaches that in-
volve better regulation of natu-
ral and human resources, and
promote a just and prosperous
society, regardless of political,
religious or cultural tendencies.
Rest assured that this short
message is not intended to un-
derminethecomplexityandrich-
ness contained in the concept of
harmony; both harmony on an
individual scale, intercommuni-
ty, or harmony on a wider scale of
harmony with nature, which is a
central concept so close to Asian
culture that today has become a
universal dimension.
I want to end by stressing that
in any event, what can unite us is
much greater than what can di-
vide us. Let us be constantly on
alert so that our collective source
of inspiration does not fade in
ensuring prosperity or preserv-
ing peace, security, tolerance,
and respect for others. []
In early December 2016, Indonesia
again hosted the 9th Bali Democracy
Forum (BDF) with the theme “Reli-
gion, pluralism and Democracy” joined by
ministers and ambassadors from 95 coun-
tries. This activity is also filled with Dialogue
involving civil society and media. An impor-
tant message from BDF IX is that all major world religions including
Islam have values that are in line with pluralism and democracy.
BDF IX asserts that 60% of Muslim societies are people who ac-
cept democracy. In the BDF forum, countries just practicing democ-
racy and Muslim communities from around the world can dialogue
and share experiences from various aspects to strengthen laws and
legislation.
The role of Indonesia as a country hosting the BDF is very signifi-
cant. Indonesia as the third largest democracy and also the largest
Muslim country in the world has shown the way. Despite many chal-
lenges, support for extremists in the archipelago is very small.
Although support for extremists is considered very small, it does
not mean that Indonesia has no challenges in repressing terrorist
movements.
There are some lessons that we can learn from Indonesia’s experi-
ence.
These concepts have inspired the leaders of the nation to build an
open political culture - a political culture that does not encourage the
fusion of diverse cultures into a dominant identity, but unifies eth-
nic differences and cultural identities to be melted in the Indonesian
framework.
Second, the role of civil society, such as NU and Muhammadiyah,
each estimated to have 70 million members that has very significant
roles for Indonesian Muslims from time to time.The two mass organi-
zations are not only preparing for spiritual activities in the mosque or
preparing educational institutions, but also develop women empow-
erment programs and promote national brotherhood.
The combination of programs based on spiritual and social activi-
ties has provided relevance and capability not only to the communi-
ties served but also very useful in synergizing with the government.
If Indonesia is active and successful, it will be able to assists many
countries in facing the challenge of terrorism. And if it fails, Indo-
nesia will face the threat of terrorist groups entering from abroad
and spreading into the archipelago. This is the greatest alertness that
should be anticipated by the third largest democratic country.
(Published in The Jakarta Post, January 27, 2017 titled Living with
Differences)
Living with Differences
Moazzam Malik
The British Ambassador in Jakarta
Dok.Bangkapost
15 january 2017Issue 101 highlight 15Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
Deputy foreign minister FACHIR:
STRENGTHENING THE ROLES OF MEDIA AND
CIVIL SOCIETY IN ADVANCING DEMOCRACY
MODERATION, TOLERANCE AND
DIALOGUE is a VALUE IN THE
LIFE OF DEMOCRACY IN INDO-
NESIA. VARIOUS EVENTS LIKE INCREASING
EXTREMISM, RADICALISM, XENOPHOBIA,
AND EXPRESSED RESPECTIVE FREEDOMS
CAN THREATEN THE LIFE OF DEMOC-
RACY. THEREFORE, THE ROLE OF MEDIA
AND THE PEOPLE IN advancing DEMOC-
RACY IS VERY IMPORTANT AND MUST BE
STRONGLY STRENGTHENed.
This was said by the Deputy Minister of
Foreign Affairs, Ambassador Dr. A.M Fachir,
when opening the International Seminar on
“December 6, 2016 on “ Islam, Democracy, the
Challenges of Pluralism and Security.
The seminar was organized by the Insti-
tute for Peace and Democracy (IPD), Press
Council and the RI Ministry of Foreign Af-
fairs.
Deputy Minister Fachir further asserted
that the peaceful action on 2 December in
Jakarta became a reflection that Indonesia,
through its spirit of tolerance and modera-
tion, is able to maintain diversity in a demo-
cratic life. All levels ranging from civil society,
the media, to the government need to con-
tinue to hold this value and work together in
strengthening the development of democracy
in the country and also address the threat of
extremism and the spread of hate speech.
In the meantime, Dr. Nur Hassan Wira-
juda, IPD patron, in his speech stated that
Indonesia is an example that Islam, democ-
racy and modernity can go hand in hand. The
Arab spring events and the global migration
caused by the conflict in the Middle East over
the past few years, which led to conflict and
inter-faith clashes among religions, are ex-
amples that pluralism and democracy are still
and will be a challenge to other countries in
the world.
The opening ceremony was followed by
an interactive discussion until December 7,
2016. Almost 100 participants from media, re-
ligious leaders, academics, diplomatic corps
and NGOs from Indonesia,Timor-Leste, Laos,
Vietnam, Austria, use, and Solomon Islands
attended this event.
This international seminar is a pre-event
of the 9th Bail Democracy Forum held on 8
- 9 December 2016 with the theme “religion,
democracy and pluralism” at the Bail Interna-
tional Convention Center (BICC), Nusa Dua,
Bali. The results of the seminar were reported
to the 9th BDF as a form of attention as well
as input in strengthening the promotion of
democracy in the Asia pacific region. []
january 2017Issue 10116 Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
highlight
CONFLICTS BETWEEN RELIGION, ETHNIC
GROUPS, AND SOCIAL CLASSES HAPPEN
AND ARE CORRELATED
Anumber of Ministers and Ambassadors from various countries
attending the Bali Democracy Forum IX, during the two-day
General Debate session, presented their respective countries’
views, ideas and experiences on issues related to the theme of this
year’s forum, “Religion, Democracy and Pluralism “.
Palestinian Foreign Minister Riad Maliki views that an increasing
religious identity in every corner of the world today is not caused by
spiritual awareness but are caused by fear of another identity. He cited
the growing Islamophobia in Europe and the growing number of peo-
ple expressing objections to the refugee recruitment in negative and
disadvantageous ways.
On the other hand, continued Riad Maliki, some teenagers and de-
spairing youth in the Middle East respond to false promises sold by
extremists, a comfortable life after death. In hopeless and future con-
ditions of life, extremist ideas sound very attractive and trigger hateful
thoughts toward others.
According to Riad Maliki, most people in the Middle East are or-
dinary people who aim to live worthily and still need to make further
efforts on human rights and gender, but intolerance and xenophobia
will further aggravate the situation.
For that, the government is required to work more on education
in order to develop understanding between everyone in the world. He
quoted Helen Keller, a writer and lecturer in America who said, “The
highest educational outcome is tolerance”.
Further, Riad Maliki insists that world governments should work
more to open dialogue channels between each other and strictly en-
force the rule of law that will contribute reducing Islamophobia in
Europe and extremism in the Middle East, and thus, global security
and religious harmony can be created.
Meanwhile, the Executive Vice President of the Institute of Chi-
nese Society, Lu Shumin, highlighted the current trend of peace, de-
velopment and mutual cooperation to promote stability and develop-
ment into the choice of state policy and people’s aspirations.
At the same time, Lu Shumin said, the state also faces increasing
problems and challenges in economic and social development with
increasingly diverse national interests and social structure, rising an-
ti-globalization, anti-establishment, anti-elite and anti-immigration
voices and interfaith, ethnic and social class conflicts.
China has several achievements and experiences in promoting de-
velopment and maintaining social harmony and stability, where suc-
cess is achieved because China adheres to a path that is in line with
national conditions. After repeated mistakes and trials, and learning
from the experiences of other countries, China finally chose and built
a socialist system with Chinese characteristics.
China focuses on development as a priority because development
is the key to solving all of China’s problems. By focusing on develop-
ment, deepening reform and opening up, China has created a miracle
of high and long economic growth since the end of World War II.
Meanwhile, Italian Foreign Minister Benedetto Della Vedova stat-
ed that the Bali Democracy Forum (BDF) has truly become one of the
most relevant opportunities for dialogue on important issues related
to democracy in the Asia-Pacific region.
This year’s BDF theme is highly relevant and timely and Indonesia
can be a source of inspiration in tolerance and harmonious coexis-
tence between different religions and cultures, as well as becoming a
frontline state in combating extremism and radicalization, Benedetto
said.
“Intolerance, religious and sectarian violence, and discrimination
have sparked conflict in various regions of the world. And we believe
that the education of democratic and pluralistic values is the best tool
to fight extremist waves, “concluded Benedetto. []
Lu Shumin, Vice President of the Chinese
People’s Institute of Foreign Affairs
Riad Maliki, Palestinian Foreign Minister Benedetto Della Vedova,
The Italian State Secretary for Foreign
Affairs
15 january 2017Issue 101 17Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
highlight
DEMOCRACY AND TOLERANCE RESPOND TO
THE CHALLENGE OF PLURALISM
S
elain menggelar sesi
Debat Umum, Bali
Democracy Forum
IX juga menggelar
dua sesi Diskusi Pa-
nel. Diskusi Panel I dengan tema
“Promoting Democracy and Re-
ligious Harmony in Responding
to the Challenges of Pluralism”
dengan fokus pada sejumlah hal
yang terjadi di Eropa.
Salah satu topik yang dibahas
adalah tentang mobilisasi pe-
ngungsi Muslim dari negara-
negara Timur Tengah ke Eropa.
“Diskusiinimembantumem-
bukapikiranbanyaknegara,khu-
susnya di Eropa tentang problem
mereka. Bukan tidak mungkin
apa yang didiskusikan disini bisa
dibawa ke Konferensi Perda-
maian Timur Tengah di Paris (21
Desember 2016)” kata Ketua Dis-
kusi Panel I, Dr. Hassan Wirajuda
(Menlu RI pada 2001-2009).
“Bayangkan Eropa dengan
negara-negara tua, yang berusia
lebih dari 300 tahun, tapi dengan
tren globalisasi kemudian terjadi
migrasi dalam jumlah besar.
Tahun lalu terdapat 1,2 juta
pengungsi dari Timur Tengah
dan Afrika Utara yang masuk
ke Eropa, dan sejumlah negara
di benua itu pun mendirikan
tembok untuk menghalangi
masuknya imigran” terang Dr.
Hassan Wirajuda.
Terkait hal itu, Dr. Hassan Wi-
rajuda mengingatkan bahwa ma-
sih ada sekitar 70 juta pengungsi
yang masih bergerak ke seluruh
dunia, dan bahwa tembok-tem-
bok yang dibangun di Eropa itu
tidak akan efektif.
Lebih lanjut Dr. Hassan
Wirajuda mengatakan bahwa
hal tersebut terjadi karena masih
ada tugas untuk menyelesaikan
konflik di berbagai belahan
dunia,yangmerupakanpenyebab
orang-orangharusmeninggalkan
tempat tinggalnya.
“Kedua, kita masih harus ber-
upaya untuk mengurangi kesen-
jangan antara kemakmuran di
negara maju dan kemiskinan di
negara berkembang, dan ini bu-
kanlah hal yang mudah” terang
Dr. Hassan Wirajuda.
Menurutnya Indonesia bisa
belajar dari apa yang dihadapi
oleh Eropa sebagai bangsa tua,
yang konsep bangsanya sendiri
sudah mulai terancam, baik dari
luar maupun dari dalam.
Sebagai bangsa yang berusia
308 tahun, Inggris harus meng-
hadapi tuntutan Irlandia Utara
yang mendesak memisahkan
diri. Sementara itu, Spanyol yang
telah berdiri selama 305 tahun
juga mengalami masalah serupa
dengan Catalunya yang mende-
sak untuk merdeka.
“Sebagai bangsa yang relatif
muda, Indonesia masih men-
ghadapi tuntutan separatis. Mes-
ki sebagian besar sudah terse-
lesaikan, tapi juga membangun
bagaimana kohesi kita sebagai
bangsa yang majemuk menjadi
satu tantangan” tutur Dr. Hassan
Wirajuda.
Diskusi Panel I menghadir-
kan tiga pembicara, yaitu; Dr. Siti
Ruhaini Dzuhayatin, Komisioner
pada IndependentPermanentHu-
man Rights Commission (IPHRC)
OKI dengan sub-tema “Promo-
ting Democracy and Religious
Harmony in Plural Society”; Oui-
ded Bouchamaoui, pemenang
Nobel Perdamaian 2015 dan ang-
gota Tunisian National Dialogue
Quartet, dengan sub-tema “Re-
building Society and Promoting
Religious Harmony: Democratic
Responses”; dan Charles Powell,
Direktur Elcano Royal Institute,
Spanyol, dengan sub-tema “Ma-
naging the Change of Social Con-
tours in Europe”.
Selanjutnya, Diskusi Panel II
yang dipimpin oleh Dr. Dino Pat-
ti Djalal (Wakil Menlu RI pada
2014), mengangkat tema “Fos-
tering Religious Harmony and
Countering Violent Extremism
and Discrimination through De-
mocratic Responses”.
Panel ini juga menghadirkan
tiga pembicara, yaitu; Ketua In-
stitute for Peace and Democracy
Foundation, Letjen. Agus Widjoyo,
dengan sub-tema “Fostering Mo-
deration and Public Civility: the
Rolesof theState”;DutaBesarIng-
gris Dr. Moazzam Malik, dengan
sub-tema “Countering Violent
Extremism: Building Rule of Law
and Engaging Religious Commu-
nities”; dan Dr. Surin Pitsuwan,
Sekretaris Jenderal ASEAN pada
2008-2012, dengan sub-tema
“Building Regional Cooperation to
Foster Religious Harmony”.
Dr. Dino Patti Djalal me-
ngungkapkan bahwa para pem-
bicara pada sesi ini merasa kha-
watir melihat multikulturisme,
pluralisme, demokrasi dan tole-
ransi yang semakin terdesak da-
lam situasi dunia saat ini.
Lebih lanjut Dr. Dino Patti
Djalal memaparkan bahwa para
peserta diskusi panel juga me-
rasa khawatir melihat semakin
tingginya rasa xenophobia (ke-
takutan terhadap orang asing).
“Ada perasaan bahwa demo-
krasi tengah berada dalam kon-
disi defensif di berbagai wilayah,
dimana demokrasi menghadapi
banyak hambatan. Kita tidak
bisa takit for granted demokrasi,
pluralisme dan toleransi. Kita
harus benar-benar menegakkan
prinsip-prinsip yang penting”
kata Dr. Dino Patti Djalal.
Selain itu, dalam Diskusi Pa-
nel II ini juga dibahas mengenai
kaitan Islam dengan demokrasi
dan pluralisme. Terkait hal ini,
Dr. Dino Patti Djalal mengata-
kan bahwa saat ini Islam tengah
menghadapi tantangan persepsi
di dunia barat yang terlihat dari
semakin maraknya Islamofobia.
Diskusi panel menyimpulkan ba-
hwa umat Islam harus berbenah
diri untuk menyelesaikan hal-hal
seperti ketidakadilan, keterbela-
kangan, kemiskinan yang terjadi
di dunia Islam dan juga dalam
berkomunikasi dengan komuni-
tas non Muslim.
january 2017Issue 10118 highlight Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
The Bali Bina Insane Islamic Boarding
School is located in Meliling Village,
Kerambitan district, Tabanan Regency.
This boarding school is somewhat different
than other boarding schools because it is in a
village environment where all the inhabitants
are Hindus.
Related to this, the founder of the Bali Bina
Insane Islamic Boarding School, Drs. H. Ketut
Imaduddin Djamal, SH. MM. states that this
is not a deliberate thing. “I do not know why
I chose this location. No thoughts whatsoever.
Incidentally, there is a land that is sold and
then I bought it and built this boarding school
here. Just like that, there are no other thoughts
“.
H. Ketut Imaduddin Djamal believes that
God has shown a way for him to further in-
crease inter-religiousness. He seems to be ap-
pointed to teach the meaning of tolerance to
the boarding school students, where the edu-
cation of tolerance is not only delivered ver-
bally in the classroom, but practiced through
direct interaction.
The students are in direct contact with the
Hindu community and experience the value of
tolerance, interact with the different religious
communities and learn to perceive the mean-
ing of mutual understanding and mutual re-
spect without showing much difference.
In fact, H. Ketut Imaduddin Djamal did
not stop by only “teaching” tolerance through
interaction with the surrounding community,
but also opened up to Hindu teachers and em-
ployees. Currently, there are 16 Hindu teach-
ers who teach at The Bali Bina Insane Islamic
Boarding School. Even in Madrasah Aliyah, the
number of Hindu teachers is the same as the
number of teachers who are Muslims, which
are 10 teachers respectively.
The teachers came voluntarily and ex-
pressed their desire to teach at The Bali Bina
Insane Islamic Boarding School. What make
teachers proud is that they do not only teach
economics, history, mathematics, biology and
the likes but they also teach Balinese dances to
the students, not only in class but also outside
the classroom, including extracurricular activ-
ities . Thus, students’ passion towards Balinese
arts and culture increased.
Drawing the students closer to the environ-
ment, interacting positively with the Hindu
community within the boarding school is part
of how to educate students to accept Balinese
culture, as part of their lives while staying and
living in Bali.
The village of Pegayaman, Buleleng, Bali,
which is the birthplace of H. Ketut Imadud-
din Djamal, is a village that is often regarded
as a “monument” to the peaceful adoption of
Balinese culture by the Muslim community. It
seems that the beauty that was born from the
cultural adoption in the village has been firmly
planted in H. Ketut Imaduddin Djamal and
became an inspiration when establishing the
Bali Bina Insane Islamic Boarding School.
“I want to create this boarding school into a
tolerant boarding school, where students and
all founders really implement tolerance in ev-
eryday life,” said H. Ketut Imaduddin Djamal.
The desire is then manifested and goes just
like water flowing with the spirit of ‘lakum
dinukum waliyadin’ (for you is your religion,
and for me is my religion), because at that time
there is no boarding school in Indonesia that
can be used as a reference or a model for a tol-
erant boarding school.
“We just walk away, try to be as good as
possible, get along as closely as possible with
the Hindu community in our neighborhood by
sticking to the Islamic guidance that requires
to live in coexistence and brotherhood”, ex-
plained H. Ketut Imaduddin Djamal.[]
BALI BINA INSANI ISLAMIC BOARDING
SCHOOL TEACHES THE MEANING OF
CLOSENESS AND TOLERANCE
15 january 2017Issue 101Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi 19highlight
It is a great honor for me to
be present representing the
Government of the Repub-
lic of Namibia at this important
event with an equally important
topic. The theme of the 9th Bali
Democracy Forum: “Religion,
Democracy and Pluralism” is
very appropriate. The fact that it
exists and runs in Indonesia and
Southeast Asia also makes this
theme very significant.
Indonesia is the fourth most
populous country in the world
and has the largest Muslim
population in the world. Almost
half of Southeast Asia’s 650 mil-
lion people are in Indonesia.
Therefore, Indonesia can play a
very important role in providing
education to other nations about
how to coexist peacefully and
harmoniously between various
religions and cultures.
Recent trends in migration,
identity politics and global se-
curity are all challenges not only
faced in the Asia-Pacific region
but also in all other regions of
the world. In Africa, we have so
many people risking their lives
to cross the oceans, especially
to Europe, which happens to be
close enough geographically.
Conflicts in other countries
have also led refugees and asy-
lum seekers and immigrants
from these countries to come to
Southeast Asia and try to find a
better place to live.
This means the government
should address the problem of
assimilating these migrants in
the local community, and this
can lead to conflict. The frustra-
tions experienced by migrant
communities can cause dissatis-
faction and can expose them to
easy recruitment by extremist
groups and even terrorists.
Indonesia is a good example
of harmony in diversity and
peaceful coexistence. This is
not surprising, since Indonesia
was the birthplace of the Non-
Aligned Movement at the 1955
Bandung Conference. In fact, a
number of participants gathered
in this forum today also partici-
pated in the 60th Anniversary of
the Bandung Conference in 2015,
in a very historic place. The spirit
of partnership and Asia-Africa
relations indeed arose during the
conference.
Namibia has a good and re-
liable role on the international
stage in working with other
countries to ensure protection of
international peace and security
as stated in the UN Charter.
Therefore, we will contribute
in our own way in terms of multi-
lateral cooperation, both within
sub-regional, regional and inter-
national frameworks to ensure
tolerance and peaceful coexis-
tence, and unity in diversity.[]
INDONESIA IS A GOOD EXAMPLE IN
IMPLEMENTING DIVERSITY AND HARMONY
Anne Namakau Mutelo, Ambassador of The Republik of Namibia
Dok.Kompasiana
Indonesia can play a very important role in
providing education to other nations about how to
coexist peacefully and harmoniously between vari-
ous religions and cultures.
“
“
january 2017Issue 10120 lens Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
not farming? Eventually, they
chose to help and continue their
parents’ farming undertakings.
Therefore, it is evident that the
impact of this program can be
domestic and international, and
they are very grateful to us be-
cause of this program.
Ithinkweshouldalsodevelop
how the youths in a region would
not have to go out of their areas
to work.We must develop the job
creating potential that exists in
an area. In relation to this, I have
asked friends in DG IDP and the
Technical Cooperation section,
as soft power diplomacy imple-
menters, to load their activities
in instagram or twitter so their
activities can easily be dissemi-
nated to the public.
Another training program
that many other countries are
asking is entrepreneurship. They
see that Indonesia has a highly
developed entrepreneurship and
economy, and it is all part of In-
donesia’s soft power diplomacy.
We can then make all of these
as instruments and value-added.
We will not only provide capac-
ity training, but also benefit from
the training we provide, both po-
litically and economically.
Therefore, there is now a ‘one
gate policy’ which is in the Min-
istry of Foreign Affairs. So, if we
are going to provide capacity
training, it is the Ministry of For-
eign Affairs that decides. In this
case, the Foreign Ministry will
see whether a country deserves
the training.
This year, Indonesia is con-
centrating on obtaining sup-
port in its candidacy of UNDEF
Non-Permanent Members for
2019-2020 where election will be
held in 2018. For two years, Indo-
nesia must pursue such support,
So far, there are quite a lot
of achievements that the
Directorate General of In-
formation and Public Diplomacy
(DG IDP) has accomplished.
Among them is the implementa-
tion of the Indonesian Art and
Culture Scholarship program
(BSBI). Through this program,
more and more people, especial-
ly young people in various coun-
tries around the world are able to
recognize Indonesia better and
deeper.
Requests for becoming a par-
ticipant in this BSBI program
continue to increase from year
to year. The program, which was
initially devoted to countries in
the Pacific region and ASEAN
countries, has grown as demand
for this program has come from
all regions of the world.
The BSBI program has been
instrumental in promoting In-
donesia’s rich art and culture to
various countries in the world.
On the other hand, the BSBI pro-
gram has enhanced passion of
Indonesian art and culture, not
only from program participants
from all over the world, but also
from Indonesia’s youth.
The next noticeable success-
ful program is the Bali Democra-
cy Forum (BDF) as the program
makes people aware that democ-
ratization brings people to good
governance, which is also linked
to corruption eradication efforts.
Another achievement of the
DG IDP is in the implementa-
tion of Technical Cooperation
and Capacity building programs,
where we have provided our own
capacity building trainings to
other countries that do not have
the capacity.
Ultimately, the capacity is
not only in technical form (giv-
ing capacity training) but also
opens the potential for coopera-
tion between the Directorate of
Technical Cooperation with the
Directorate of Public Diplomacy
as well as other Ministries / Insti-
tutions.
What is interesting is when
we brought some farmers from
Gambia to study farming in Gar-
ut. The young people in Garut,
who initially want to work in the
city and are reluctant to become
farmers, finally chose to become
farmers. They were amazed that
there are non-Muslims, speaking
Arabic and French, who learned
to farm in their villages. They
then realized that even people
from abroad learn to farm from
their parents, then why are they
A CLOSE LOOK AT THE ACHIEVEMENT OF THE
DIRECTORATE GENERAL FOR INFORMATION
AND PUBLIC DIPLOMACY
Esti Andayani, Director General for Information & public DiplomacyAmid the busy schedule of Ambassador Esti Andayani, who
will soon end her term as Director General of Information &
Public Diplomacy (DG IDP), she is preparing for her new as-
signment as Indonesian Ambassador to Italy. Diplomacy tab-
loid conducted an interview with one of Indonesia’s diplomatic
heroine regarding the achievements of the Director General
of IDP. We are summarizing the result of this interview in the
form of an open writing.
15 january 2017Issue 101 21Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi
LENS
among others, through soft di-
plomacy by carrying out techni-
cal cooperation.
Inthisconnection,wewillsee
countries which do not support
Indonesia. Then, we should also
see what is needed by a country.
We also need to consider the pos-
sibility of not being supported by
a country despite providing it
with training.
Hence, the duty of the Direc-
tor General of the IDP, together
with the team, is to make sure
which requests we can meet and
what their main interests are. We
should not provide all of their
needs because our ability to pro-
vide capacity is also limited.
Now, there is an effort for
pooling resources and decision is
withintheMinistryof ForeignAf-
fairs. Bappenas and the Ministry
of Finance have also agreed. This
certainly also allows Indonesia to
be easily recognized in the world,
and we also can value how much
we have given.
Prior to this, it is difficult for
us to know how much budget
each K / L has incurred in provid-
ing assistance to other countries.
But if the one gate policy is essen-
tially functioning, it will definite-
ly make it easier for us to know
how big the numbers are.
Thisisourachievementasthe
South-South Cooperation coor-
dination was previously held by
Bappenas, but it has been trans-
ferred to the Ministry of Foreign
Affairs since January this year.
However, Bappenas remains a
part of us because budget plan-
ning remains with Bappenas.
Next is the Digital Diplomacy
program that is currently in prog-
ress. Actually, the framework was
just created this year. Now, we do
notonlyhaveawebsiteportalbut
also twitter, facebook and insta-
gram, including in PWNI / BHI,
where people can communicate,
comment, and we also reply.
In addition, we also have an
ASEAN Community blogger that
was formed to help us in socializ-
ing the ASEAN Community and
ASEAN Economic Community.
Evidently, it was very effective.
We also have a team work-
ing on video blogs, such as video
activities of the Foreign Minister
in Rakhine State, Myanmar. The
video turned out to be widely ac-
cessible to the public. Then this
team, with certain applications,
also monitored how much posi-
tive, neutral or negative news
were related to the Ministry of
Foreign Affairs, or to the govern-
ment on a daily basis. So, it is
easy for us to neutralize or coun-
ter negative things. Currently,
we are also building cooperation
with Comcent to be even faster
in countering negative or hoax
news.
Iconsideralltheseasachieve-
ments of the DG IDP. Probably, it
is not considered successful be-
cause only a handful knows that
they were done by the DG IDP.
For ASEAN, we have a very
good procedure where we never
interfere in the internal affairs of
ASEAN countries. We only give
advice, and in such advice, ca-
pacity building is also provided
step by step and BDF is one way
that can make Myanmar more
open.
We go into Myanmar in a
very courteous way. As the larg-
est Muslim populated country,
we not only provide assistance
to Muslims but also to Buddhists.
For us, harmony is important
and we do not raise hostility, so
we go to Rakhine State not only
with Islamic organizations but
also Buddhist and Christian or-
ganizations. This is what makes
Indonesia more trustworthy, and
this needs to be known by the in-
ternational community.
Today, with Economic Diplo-
macy, we also have Expert Staff
for Economic Diplomacy as well
as Expert Staff for Social and Cul-
tural Affairs and for Empower-
ing Indonesians Abroad. We see
that whatever capacity building
we provide to different countries
the outcome is finally economic
cooperation, which is mutually
beneficial.
To handle the diaspora, now
we also have the Sub-Directorate
of Indonesian Community Em-
powerment abroad. This diaspo-
racancontributetodevelopment
in Indonesia.
Currently, we are seeking to
provide ease through one year
multiple visas and ease in get-
ting Temporary Residency Per-
mit for the Indonesian diaspora.
Therefore, we should be able to
make a diaspora map and decide
what policy is most appropriate
and necessary. The final policy
required is to provide a Diaspora
Card in the hope of providing
convenience to the Indonesian
diaspora upon returning to Indo-
nesia.[]
Duta Besar Esti Andayani, Dirjen IDP bersama Wamenlu A.M Fachir, Dr. Hasan Wirajuda, seluruh pimpinan dan staf IDP dan Kemlu Pendukung BDF IX.
january 2017Issue 101 Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi22 review
book review : gem of heaven
Harmonization of life is an inevitable
need in the midst of a multiethnic
and multicultural Indonesian society.
In this condition, it is necessary to continue
to uphold the nation’s local wisdom values
that teach about dialogue, tolerance and em-
pathy.
History proves that since ancient times,
the archipelago has a strategic position be-
cause it became the meeting point of the
world’s great civilization, where the legacy of
noble values is formed from the acculturation
of Hindu-Buddhist and Islamic cultures, and
this can be found in the form of religious so-
cial practices in Indonesia.
As a multiethnic and multicultural coun-
try, Indonesians perceive difference as a
beauty and an inherent part of life that needs
to be nurtured, where Bhinneka Tunggal Ika
and Pancasila are the actualization of values
for the need to maintain harmony in a multi-
cultural nation.
With this foundation, the Indonesian
people proactively continue and develop a
culture of dialogue, tolerance and mutual
understanding between religious adherents
and civilizations. This is seen as desirable to
remove suspicion and misunderstandings
between religions and cultures, and promote
harmony and cooperation in the midst of dif-
ferences and diversity.
The book “Gem of Heaven: Portrait of Re-
ligious Life in Indonesia” provides compre-
hensive, accurate and objective information
and images of the relations and tolerance
between the religions existing in Indonesia:
Islam, Catholicism, Protestantism, Hinduism,
Buddhism and Confucianism.
This book is not merely conceptually pro-
posing the conditions of religious life and
the dynamics of relations between religions
because it also discusses how the praxis of
interaction and communication of different
religions in some parts of Indonesia in it.
This book is very useful, not only for re-
ligious and social issue researchers, but also
as a reference and guidance for community
groups in various places, including policy-
makers at various social levels in order to
build a harmonious and tolerant existence
among religious followers.
Academically, this book contributes to
the treasure of scientific literature in various
scientific disciplines, such as theology, com-
parative religion, history, and sociology of re-
ligions in Indonesia.
Generally, this book discusses the concept
of relations and tolerance in the teachings of
major religions in Indonesia. Its discussion
refers to scripture or the interpretation of the
main characters. It also discusses the pattern
of relationships, praxis tolerance of each be-
liever in everyday life, and not leaving behind
the state’s position in facilitating the creation
of good relations and harmonious inter-faith
in various forms and levels.
In addition to comparing the concept
of relation and tolerance in every religious
teachingwiththepraxisof tolerancebetween
different religions, this book also presents the
factors supporting the creation of harmoni-
ous relations and tolerance in religious life
in Indonesia. Among them are progressive
government policies on the recognition and
protection of the existence of religions.
This book uses a framework approach
which considers that conflicts between ad-
herents of religion are not only caused by
internal factors of religion but also non-re-
ligious factors, such as economic slackness,
access to employment, struggle for position
and political status or position in govern-
ment. Thus, theoretically, it can be asserted
that religion is not a triggering factor of con-
flict, because in principle all religions carry a
mission of peace.
This book consists of two parts. The First
Part consists of five Chapters and contains
theoretical discussions on the meaning of
religion and its elements. In the first section,
it reviews the history of the introduction of
major religions into Indonesia, the factors
supporting the establishment of religious
tolerance, harmonious relations between re-
ligions and relations between religions and
countries, including the challenge of toler-
ance and the strategy of strengthening reli-
gious harmony.
Part Two discusses the model of harmony
and harmonious relations of the religious
praxis level in some parts of Indonesia. A
number of provinces or cities in Indonesia
are selected to show the dynamics and har-
mony of relations between religious commu-
nities in various forms. These areas include
Jakarta, Semarang, Pontianak, Singkawang,
Bali and Bangka Belitung.
Part Two also looks at the relation of re-
ligions with the state, from prehistoric times,
Hindu-Buddhist,Islamictimes,colonialtimes,
to the time of independence.
The 218-page book, which brings the im-
portant message of harmony and tolerance
among religious people, is the fruit of cooper-
ation between the Ministry of Foreign Affairs
of the Republic of Indonesia and the Syarif
Hidayatullah Jakarta State Islamic University
(UIN). This book can be a source of inspira-
tion among the followers of religion in Indo-
nesia and abroad who still cannot develop a
congruent relationship pattern, which is har-
monious and peaceful.[]
15 january 2017Issue 101Diplomasi
TABLOID
Media Komunikasi dan Interaksi 23LENS
Representatives of OIC
countries in New York
expressed their appre-
ciation for the constructive
steps and inclusive approach
of the Government of Indo-
nesia towards the problem-
solving efforts in Rakhine State,
Myanmar. It includes several
recent occasions, including
OIC’s last meeting in New York
on December 29, 2016. The
Indonesian Foreign Minister’s
meeting and shuttle diplomacy
initiative with various parties
included holding a live meeting
with Aung San Suu Kyi (ASSK),
as well as Indonesia’s bilateral
visit to Bangladesh intended to
help build trust and strengthen
constructive engagement with
the Government of Myanmar.
The Minister of Foreign Af-
fairs is also said to play a key
role in the implementation of
the ASEAN Foreign Ministers
Retreat by discussing it with
ASSK on December 19, 2016 in
Yangon.
Furthermore, appreciation
was also given to Indonesia’s
humanitarian aid to Rakhine
State, especially to the Mus-
lim minority group, includ-
ing the last humanitarian aid
released by the President on
29 December 2016 in the form
of dispatching 10 containers
of humanitarian aid for the
Rohingyas, as well as previous
various Indonesian aids like the
construction of a number of
hospitals and schools.
Representatives of OIC
Countries welcomed the Gov-
ernment of Indonesia’s offer as
it serves as a bridging role for
OIC’s constructive communica-
tion with the Government of
Myanmar.
OIC COUNTRIES APPRECIATE RI
GOVERNMENT REGARDING RAKHINE
STATE ISSUE
THE INITIATIVE MEETING AND SHUTTLE DIPLOMACY DONE by
ri’s foreign minister WITH VARIOUS PARTIES, INCLUDING
a DIRECT MEETING WITH AUNG SAN SUU KYI (ASSK) AND IN-
DONESIA’s BILATERAL VISIT TO BANGLADESH AIMed TO HELP
BUILD CONFIDENCE AND STRENGTHEN CONSTRUCTIVE EN-
GAGEMENT WITH MYANMAR’s GOVERNMENT.
january 2017Issue 101
http://www.tabloiddiplomasi.org
www.tabloiddiplomasi.org
ISSUE 101, januari 2017
Direktorat Diplomasi Publik
Jalan Taman Pejambon 6 Jakarta 10110
Phone : 021-3813480
Fax : 021-3858035Diplomasi
TABLOID
Diplomasi
http://www.tabloiddiplomasi.org
Email : tabloiddiplomasi@kemlu.go.id
www.tabloiddiplomasi.org
771978 9173869
ISSN 1978-9173
Foreign Minister Retno
Lestari Priansari Marsudi
Marsudi made a visit to
Myanmar to provide assistance
to unrest victims in the Sitte
region of Rakhine State. The
Minister of Foreign Affairs of
the Republic of Indonesia is the
first ASEAN Foreign Minister to
be granted access by Myanmar’s
government to visit the Rakhine
State inland after the riots of Oc-
tober 12, 2016.
Foreign Minister Retno said
the aid was to help Rakhine’s
post-conflict society. Foreign
Minister Retno presented the as-
sistance to Rakhine State Chief
Minister, U Nyi Pu. “Alhamdulil-
lah, the handover of aid went
smoothly and we thank the
Government of Myanmar who
has welcomed this activity,” said
Retno at Rakhine State, Saturday
(21/1).
In addition to providing
assistance, Retno also asked
the Government of Myanmar
to grant access to the inland
areas of Rakhine. “We also ask
the Myanmar government to
open access to the interior,”
said Retno. Retno thanked the
Government of Myanmar for
approving and opening access to
provide assistance to the Rakh-
ine people.
Indonesia’s assistance to
Rakhine did not just happen
this time. Previously, Indonesia
also helped Myanmar in the
form of school construction.
Indonesian humanitarian aid to
Rohingya Muslims in Rakhine
State, Myanmar, continues to be
channeled. Indonesia built two
public schools worthy of use
and equipment. “Everything was
inaugurated by Foreign Minister
Retno Marsudi in time,” said the
Ambassador of the Republic
of Indonesia to the Republic of
Myanmar, Ito Sumardi Dju-
nisanyoto, in Jakarta, as quoted
by republika.co.id, December
20, 2016.
The Ministry of Foreign
Affairs, through the Embassy
of the Republic of Indonesia
(KBRI) in Yangon, facilitates
assistance right on target and
does not overlap. Permission is
fully acquired by KBRI Yangon.
The Government of Indonesia’s
inclusive approach based on
humanitarian aspects is accept-
able to Myanmar’s government
and society.
“The Government of Myan-
mar greatly appreciates the atti-
tude of the Indonesian Govern-
ment and the Indonesian people
which do not see the problems
in Rakhine--particularly those
involving ethnic Rohingyas---
emotionally but more on the ba-
sis of accurate data in the field.
The Indonesian school building
in Myanmar has been ongo-
ing since 2013. The Indonesian
government has disbursed USD
1 million to construct three Pri-
mary School units in Rakhine.
Education is for all ethnicity. In
addition to Rakhine State, In-
donesia also plays an active role
in assisting Myanmar’s progress
in several sectors. “Bilaterally,
Indonesia continues to encour-
age and cooperate in promoting
democratization and promoting
the principles of human rights
and decentralization. []
RI FOREIGN MINISTER : GIVES
HUMANITARIAN AID TO RAKHINE
STATE
Indonesian Foreign Minister Retno Lestari Priansari Marsudi officially handed humanitarian aid to Myanmar Government
in Rakhine. (12/10/2017)