SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 43
Download to read offline
Datum 21 augustus 2010
Enterprise Search
EAI
Semantic Web
Open Source
Search & Retrieval
Platform
Marc Teutelink
How Apache open source software is used
during the implementation of an
Enterprise Search and Retrieval Platform
(Lucene/SOLR, Nutch, Tika, ServiceMix/Camel, Felix/Ace)
Marc Teutelink
marc.teutelink@luminis.eu
@mteutelink
•Software architect at Luminis
•15+ years experience in software development; specialized in
Enterprise Search, Enterprise Application Integration and
Semantic Web technology
•Currently writing “Enterprise Search in Action” for Manning
(Mid-2011)
Agenda
•Enterprise Search
• What is Enterprise Search: Functions and features
• Challenges
• Logical Architecture
•Enterprise Search Solution
• Technology Stack
• Collection Process
• Publication Process
• Enricher framework
• Deployment
•Conclusion
What is Enterprise Search?
“Enterprise Search offers a solution for searching,
finding and presenting enterprise related information
in the larger sense of the word”
Enterprise search is all about searching through documents from
any type and format from any sources located anywhere with the
upmost flexibility
• Web search: limited to public documents on the web
• Desktop search: limited to private documents on the local machine
• Enterprise search: no limitations on document type and location
Enterprise Search
(features)
•Information Sources and Types
• Wide range of sources: local and remote filesystems, content repositories,
e-mail, databases, internet, intranet and extranet
• Type not limited: any type ranging from structured to unstructured data, text
and binary formats and compound formats (zip)
•Usage
• Not limited to interactive use  automated business processes
•Security
• Integrations with enterprise security infrastructure
•User Interaction and personalization
• Identity enables more personalized search results
Enterprise Search
(features)
•Extended metadata
• More metadata  better and more precise search results
• More control over schema (for example Dynamic Fields)
•Ranking
• More control over ranking: personalized ranking (group)
•Data extraction and derivation
• Extract data using various techniques: Xpath, Xquery
• Derive data: using external knowledge models: RDBMS, RDF Store, Web Services
• Conditional extraction & derivation
•Managing and monitoring
• On-the-fly management (JMX)
• Real time monitoring
Enterprise Search
(features)
•User Interfaces
• Web search
• All about selling advertisements to the mass
• Generalistic & minimalistic screens; focus on adds
• Enterprise search
• All about finding: rich navigation; focus on quick find
• Small targeted audience
• Specialized and customized screens (use of ontologies, taxonomies
and classifications)
• Use of identity (results customized to user) and web 2.0
• Grouping
• field collapsing, faceted search & clustering
Enterprise Search
(Challenges)
•Performance and scalability
•Rich functions and features
•Managebility
•Flexibility
•Easy maintenance
•Quick issue and problem solving
•Reduce total cost of ownerschip
Enterprise Search
(Challenges)
•Performance and scalability
•Rich functions and features
•Managebility
•Flexibility
•Easy maintenance
•Quick issue and problem solving
•Reduce total cost of ownerschip
Commercial Search Engines?
Enterprise Search
(Challenges)
•Performance and scalability
•Rich functions and features
•Managebility
•Flexibility
•Easy maintenance
•Quick issue and problem solving
•Reduce total cost of ownerschip
Apache Based (Open Source)
Search & Retrieval Platform
Enterprise Search
(Logical Architecture)
Actors
Search Engine
Indexing
Sources
Content Inbound
Pull
(Crawling)
Pull
(Harvesting)
Push
(SOAP/ReST)
Searching & Ordering
Filtering Grouping
Request Inbound
HTTP/Get
(URL)
HTTP/Post
(SOAP/ReST)
API
(Java,Perl,...)
Request Validation
Syntactic Semantic
Request Enrichment
Redirection
(Suggestions)
Enhancement
(add/remove clauses)
Response Enrichment
Redirection
(more like this)
Enhancement
(metadata, editorial)
Response Outbound
Stateless
(XSLT, SolrJS)
Statefull
(Webapp Framework)
Sorting
Content Enrichment
Extraction Enhancement Filtering
Collection Process Publication Process
Content Validation
SemanticSyntactic
Enterprise Search
(Collection Process)
Sources
• Any document format
• Any type
• Structured and unstructured
• Textual and binary
• Compound
• Residing Anywhere
• Security
Search Engine
Indexing
Sources
Content Inbound
Pull
(Crawling)
Pull
(Harvesting)
Push
(SOAP/ReST)
Content Enrichment
Extraction Enhancement Filtering
Collection Process
Content Validation
SemanticSyntactic
Enterprise Search
(Collection Process)
Search Engine
Indexing
Sources
Content Inbound
Pull
(Crawling)
Pull
(Harvesting)
Push
(SOAP/ReST)
Content Enrichment
Extraction Enhancement Filtering
Collection Process
Content Validation
SemanticSyntactic
Content Inbound
• Pull (Crawling/Spidering)
• Internet, intranet & extranet
• Local and remote filesystems
• Pull (Harvesting)
• Databases
• Content Repositories / Mgmt Systems
• Webservices inbound
• Push
• Webservices (SOAP/REST)
• Real time indexing
Enterprise Search
(Collection Process)
Search Engine
Indexing
Sources
Content Inbound
Pull
(Crawling)
Pull
(Harvesting)
Push
(SOAP/ReST)
Content Enrichment
Extraction Enhancement Filtering
Collection Process
Content Validation
SemanticSyntactic
Content Validation
• Syntactic validation
• Based on DTD / XML-Schema
• Structure and limited content
• Semantic validation
• Based on algorithms:
• Groovy, XPath, Regex, …
• Think about exception handling
• Placed anywhere in flow
• During inbound: XML-Schema validation
• After Enrichment: Validate derived metadata
Enterprise Search
(Collection Process)
Search Engine
Indexing
Sources
Content Inbound
Pull
(Crawling)
Pull
(Harvesting)
Push
(SOAP/ReST)
Content Enrichment
Extraction Enhancement Filtering
Collection Process
Content Validation
SemanticSyntactic
Content Enrichment
• Extraction
• Metadata
• Content (free text of document)
• Enhancing
• Derive new and alter existing metadata
• Filtering
• Remove (parts of) metadata
• Leverage external knowledge models
• Conditional enrichment
Enterprise Search
(Collection Process)
Search Engine
Indexing
Sources
Content Inbound
Pull
(Crawling)
Pull
(Harvesting)
Push
(SOAP/ReST)
Content Enrichment
Extraction Enhancement Filtering
Collection Process
Content Validation
SemanticSyntactic
Indexing
• Store in search engine(s)
• Content based routing
• Document boosting
Enterprise Search
(Publication Process)
Request Inbound
• HTTP/Get
• URL based with parameters
• Response in XML, JSON, …
• HTTP/Post
• XML (SOAP, REST) request
• XML (SOAP, REST) response
• API
• Java, Perl, …
• Wrappers on HTTP/Get
Actors
Search Engine
Searching & Ordering
Filtering Grouping
Request Inbound
HTTP/Get
(URL)
HTTP/Post
(SOAP/ReST)
API
(Java,Perl,...)
Request Validation
Syntactic Semantic
Request Enrichment
Redirection
(Suggestions)
Enhancement
(add/remove clauses)
Response Enrichment
Redirection
(more like this)
Enhancement
(metadata, editorial)
Response Outbound
Stateless
(XSLT, SolrJS)
Statefull
(Webapp Framework)
Sorting
Publication Process
Enterprise Search
(Publication Process)
Actors
Search Engine
Searching & Ordering
Filtering Grouping
Request Inbound
HTTP/Get
(URL)
HTTP/Post
(SOAP/ReST)
API
(Java,Perl,...)
Request Validation
Syntactic Semantic
Request Enrichment
Redirection
(Suggestions)
Enhancement
(add/remove clauses)
Response Enrichment
Redirection
(more like this)
Enhancement
(metadata, editorial)
Response Outbound
Stateless
(XSLT, SolrJS)
Statefull
(Webapp Framework)
Sorting
Publication Process Request Validation
• Syntactic Validation
• Correct Query syntax?
• Semantic Validation
• Correct Field Filters?
• Based on algorithms: Groovy, Regex
• Placed anywhere in flow
• @inbound: XML-Schema validation
• @enrichment: Validate derived request clauses
Enterprise Search
(Publication Process)
Actors
Search Engine
Searching & Ordering
Filtering Grouping
Request Inbound
HTTP/Get
(URL)
HTTP/Post
(SOAP/ReST)
API
(Java,Perl,...)
Request Validation
Syntactic Semantic
Request Enrichment
Redirection
(Suggestions)
Enhancement
(add/remove clauses)
Response Enrichment
Redirection
(more like this)
Enhancement
(metadata, editorial)
Response Outbound
Stateless
(XSLT, SolrJS)
Statefull
(Webapp Framework)
Sorting
Publication Process Request Enrichment
• Redirection
• Spelling suggestions
• Metadata suggestions
• Enhancing
• Add/Remove clauses
• Stemming, Synonyms, stop words
Enterprise Search
(Publication Process)
Actors
Search Engine
Searching & Ordering
Filtering Grouping
Request Inbound
HTTP/Get
(URL)
HTTP/Post
(SOAP/ReST)
API
(Java,Perl,...)
Request Validation
Syntactic Semantic
Request Enrichment
Redirection
(Suggestions)
Enhancement
(add/remove clauses)
Response Enrichment
Redirection
(more like this)
Enhancement
(metadata, editorial)
Response Outbound
Stateless
(XSLT, SolrJS)
Statefull
(Webapp Framework)
Sorting
Publication Process Searching & Ordering
• Filtering
• Field Search
• Grouping
• Add group information
• Field collapsing, Faceted Search & Clustering
• Sorting
• Sort on Field
• Ranking
Enterprise Search
(Publication Process)
Actors
Search Engine
Searching & Ordering
Filtering Grouping
Request Inbound
HTTP/Get
(URL)
HTTP/Post
(SOAP/ReST)
API
(Java,Perl,...)
Request Validation
Syntactic Semantic
Request Enrichment
Redirection
(Suggestions)
Enhancement
(add/remove clauses)
Response Enrichment
Redirection
(more like this)
Enhancement
(metadata, editorial)
Response Outbound
Stateless
(XSLT, SolrJS)
Statefull
(Webapp Framework)
Sorting
Publication Process Response Enrichment
• Redirection
• Suggestions
• More like this
• Enhancing
• Add/Remove response fields
• Schema information
• Editorial information
Enterprise Search
(Publication Process)
Actors
Search Engine
Searching & Ordering
Filtering Grouping
Request Inbound
HTTP/Get
(URL)
HTTP/Post
(SOAP/ReST)
API
(Java,Perl,...)
Request Validation
Syntactic Semantic
Request Enrichment
Redirection
(Suggestions)
Enhancement
(add/remove clauses)
Response Enrichment
Redirection
(more like this)
Enhancement
(metadata, editorial)
Response Outbound
Stateless
(XSLT, SolrJS)
Statefull
(Webapp Framework)
Sorting
Publication Process Response outbound
• Stateless
• No security
• XSLT, SolrJS
• Statefull
• Security
• Web2.0
• Web Application Framework
Technology Stack
(Collection Process)
•Use ESB for the flow: Apache ServiceMix with Camel
• Leverage standard ESB components (Transformers, Validation, Splitter,
Filter, Routers, Scripting)
• Leverage standard ESB transports (WS, SMTP, JMS, JCR, JDBC, FILE)
• Custom: Crawler Apache Nutch
• Leverage only crawl framework
• Extend NutchIndexWriter; asynchronously pushing crawled documents
back into ESB flow (reply-to)
•ESB Makes distributed flow possibleContent based routing
•Hot deploy Easy maintenance
•Reusing services across collection processes
•Search Engine independent
Collection Process Flow
Content Indexer
Content Inbound
2
1
Documents
Message
N
D
Document
Messages
D D
Lucene/Solr
INDEX
HTTP Transport
(Channel Adapter)
Lucene/SOLR
(SOLRJ)
D
SOLR Document
Message
Splitter
Channel
Content Validation Content Enrichment
Enricher
Content Filter
Content Enricher
Syntactic Validation
(Channel Purger)
Push Inbound
(Message Endpoint)
Semantic Validation
(Channel Purger)
Invalid Message
Channel
!
?
Invalid Message
ChannelChannel Transformer
(Message Translator)
Technology Stack
(Publication Process)
•Use flow from Apache Lucene/Solr
• Leverage standard Solr components (synonyms, stopwords,
stemming, MLT, spelling, faceted search, …)
• Custom components: using Solr’s extendability framework
• Security: authority field in schema with Apache Shiro integration
• Field filters (zipcode,…)
•User interfaces
• Stateless: SolrJs, XSLTResponseWriter & VelocityResponseWriter
• Statefull: Apache Wicket with Spring
Actors
Search Engine
Indexing
Sources
Content Inbound
Pull
(Crawling)
Pull
(Harvesting)
Push
(SOAP/ReST)
Searching & Ordering
Filtering Grouping
Request Inbound
HTTP/Get
(URL)
HTTP/Post
(SOAP/ReST)
API
(Java,Perl,...)
Request Validation
Syntactic Semantic
Request Enrichment
Redirection
(Suggestions)
Enhancement
(add/remove clauses)
Response Enrichment
Redirection
(more like this)
Enhancement
(metadata, editorial)
Response Outbound
Stateless
(XSLT, SolrJS)
Statefull
(Webapp Framework)
Sorting
Content Enrichment
Extraction Enhancement Filtering
Collection Process Publication Process
Content Validation
SemanticSyntactic
Enterprise Search
(Logical Architecture)
Actors
Search Engine
Indexing
Sources
Content Inbound
Pull
(Crawling)
Pull
(Harvesting)
Push
(SOAP/ReST)
Searching & Ordering
Filtering Grouping
Request Inbound
HTTP/Get
(URL)
HTTP/Post
(SOAP/ReST)
API
(Java,Perl,...)
Request Validation
Syntactic Semantic
Request Enrichment
Redirection
(Suggestions)
Enhancement
(add/remove clauses)
Response Enrichment
Redirection
(more like this)
Enhancement
(metadata, editorial)
Response Outbound
Stateless
(XSLT, SolrJS)
Statefull
(Webapp Framework)
Sorting
Content Enrichment
Extraction Enhancement Filtering
Collection Process Publication Process
Content Validation
SemanticSyntactic
Lucene/SOLR
ServiceMix/Camel
Nutch
Apache WicketSolrJS/XSLT
Enterprise Search
(Logical Architecture)
Actors
Search Engine
Indexing
Sources
Content Inbound
Pull
(Crawling)
Pull
(Harvesting)
Push
(SOAP/ReST)
Searching & Ordering
Filtering Grouping
Request Inbound
HTTP/Get
(URL)
HTTP/Post
(SOAP/ReST)
API
(Java,Perl,...)
Request Validation
Syntactic Semantic
Request Enrichment
Redirection
(Suggestions)
Enhancement
(add/remove clauses)
Response Enrichment
Redirection
(more like this)
Enhancement
(metadata, editorial)
Response Outbound
Stateless
(XSLT, SolrJS)
Statefull
(Webapp Framework)
Sorting
Content Enrichment
Extraction Enhancement Filtering
Collection Process Publication Process
Content Validation
SemanticSyntactic
Enterprise Search
(Logical Architecture)
Luminis Enricher Framework
Luminis Enricher Framework
•Custom Enricher Framework
• Existing ESB & SOLR enricher capabilities not sufficient.
• Enriching = one or more actions (extraction, enhancing &
filtering) performed on documents with fields
• Same enricher to be used for:
• Collection process:
• Documents  enriching, filtering & splitting
• Publication process:
• Search requests’first-components’ searchcomponent
• Search response’last-components’ searchcomponent
Luminis Enricher Framework
•Custom Enricher Framework
• Existing ESB & SOLR enricher capabilities not sufficient.
• Enriching = one or more actions (extraction, enhancing &
filtering) performed on documents with fields
• Same enricher to be used for:
• Collection process:
• Documents  enriching, filtering & splitting
• Publication process:
• Search requests’first-components’ searchcomponent
• Search response’last-components’ searchcomponent
Content Indexer
Content Inbound
2
1
Documents
Message
N
D
Document
Messages
D D
Lucene/Solr
INDEX
SOLR Indexer
(Channel Adapter)
Lucene/SOLR
(SOLRJ)
D
SOLR Document
Message
Splitter
Channel
Content Validation Content Enrichment
Enricher
Content Filter
Content Enricher
Syntactic Validation
(Channel Purger)
Push Inbound
(Message Endpoint)
Semantic Validation
(Channel Purger)
Invalid Message
Channel
!
?
Invalid Message
ChannelChannel
Luminis Enricher Framework
•Custom Enricher Framework
• Existing ESB & SOLR enricher capabilities not sufficient.
• Enriching = one or more actions (extraction, enhancing &
filtering) performed on documents with fields
• Same enricher to be used for:
• Collection process:
• Documents  enriching, filtering & splitting
• Publication process:
• Search requests’first-components’ searchcomponent
• Search response’last-components’ searchcomponent
Content Indexer
Content Inbound
2
1
Documents
Message
N
D
Document
Messages
D D
Lucene/Solr
INDEX
SOLR Indexer
(Channel Adapter)
Lucene/SOLR
(SOLRJ)
D
SOLR Document
Message
Splitter
Channel
Content Validation Content Enrichment
Enricher
Content Filter
Content Enricher
Syntactic Validation
(Channel Purger)
Push Inbound
(Message Endpoint)
Semantic Validation
(Channel Purger)
Invalid Message
Channel
!
?
Invalid Message
ChannelChannel
<<SearchHandler>>
RequestHandler
"first-components" "components" "last-components"
<<XML>>
Response
<<SearchComponent>>
query
<<SearchComponent>>
facet
<<SearchComponent>>
mlt
<<SearchComponent>>
highlight
<<SearchComponent>>
stats
<<SearchComponent>>
debug
<<SOLRQueryRequest>>
Query
<<XSLT>>
XML2HTML
<<QueryResponseWriter>>
XSLTResponseWriter
<<(X)HTML>>
Resultaat
Luminis Enricher Framework
(architecture)
•Pipe-and-filter architecture
• Documents flow through series of actions
• Output from one action is input to another action
• Fields from input document can be used in action’s clauses: values in
expressions filled by replacing velocity type patterns with field values
•Conditional flows supported
•Reuse of flows & Subflows supported
Luminis Enricher Framework
(architecture)
•Pipe-and-filter architecture
• Documents flow through series of actions
• Output from one action is input to another action
• Fields from input document can be used in action’s clauses: values in
expressions filled by replacing velocity type patterns with field values
•Conditional flows supported
•Reuse of flows & Subflows supported
Action
(select C where ${B})
Action
(remove A2)
Document
[[A1,A2],[B]]
Document
[[A1],[B]]
Document
[[A1],[B],[C1]]
If [B=3]
YES
Action
(select C where ${A})
Document
[[A1],[B],[C2]]
NO
Luminis Enricher Framework
(Configuration)
•Enricher flow and expression configuration via XML based DSL
• Conditional: if-then-else & switch-case-else (with regex support)
• Actions: Add & remove fields and field values using expressions
• Expression handlers currently supported:
• Field
• Function (execute methods via Java Reflection)
• HttpClient (retrieve content by URL described by field values)
• Xslt, Xpath, Xquery (external XML databases)
• JDBC
• SparQL (OpenRDF)
• Apache Lucene/Solr
• Apache Tika (Meta and Text extraction)
Luminis Enricher Framework
(Examples)
<enricher name="Field" >
<field name="a">AA1</field>
<field name="b">BB1</field>
<field name="b">BB2</field>
<multivalue-field name="c">CC1</multivalue-field>
<multivalue-field name="c">CC2</multivalue-field>
<if test="field::c" pattern="CC2">
<then>
<field name="e">EE1</field>
</then>
</if>
<if test="field::a">
<then>
<field name="f">FF1</field>
</then>
</if>
<rename-field name="b">d</rename-field>
<remove-field name="a"/>
</enricher>
Luminis Enricher Framework
(Examples)
<enricher name="Field" >
<field name="a">AA1</field>
<field name="b">BB1</field>
<field name="b">BB2</field>
<multivalue-field name="c">CC1</multivalue-field>
<multivalue-field name="c">CC2</multivalue-field>
<if test="field::c" pattern="CC2">
<then>
<field name="e">EE1</field>
</then>
</if>
<if test="field::a">
<then>
<field name="f">FF1</field>
</then>
</if>
<rename-field name="b">d</rename-field>
<remove-field name="a"/>
</enricher>
<enricher name="XPath”
xmlns:str="http://exslt.org/strings"
xmlns:fn="http://www.w3.org/2005/xpath-functions"
xmlns:html="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml">
field name="Description" expression-type="xpath">
//html:meta[@name='DC.description']/@content
</field>
<multivalue-field name="Type" expression-type="xpath">
//html:meta[@name='DC.type' and
(@scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeGemeente' or
@scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeProvincie' or
@scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeWaterschap')
]/@content
</multivalue-field>
<field name="publisher" expression-type="xpath">
fn:string-join(('Blow, ', 'blow, ', 'thou ', 'winter ', 'wind!'), '')
</field>
<field name="publisher" expression-type="xpath">
fn:concat(//html:meta[@name='OVERHEID.organisationType']/@content,
//html:meta[@name='DC.creator']/@content)
</field>
</enricher>
Luminis Enricher Framework
(Examples)
<enricher name="Field" >
<field name="a">AA1</field>
<field name="b">BB1</field>
<field name="b">BB2</field>
<multivalue-field name="c">CC1</multivalue-field>
<multivalue-field name="c">CC2</multivalue-field>
<if test="field::c" pattern="CC2">
<then>
<field name="e">EE1</field>
</then>
</if>
<if test="field::a">
<then>
<field name="f">FF1</field>
</then>
</if>
<rename-field name="b">d</rename-field>
<remove-field name="a"/>
</enricher>
<enricher name="XPath”
xmlns:str="http://exslt.org/strings"
xmlns:fn="http://www.w3.org/2005/xpath-functions"
xmlns:html="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml">
field name="Description" expression-type="xpath">
//html:meta[@name='DC.description']/@content
</field>
<multivalue-field name="Type" expression-type="xpath">
//html:meta[@name='DC.type' and
(@scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeGemeente' or
@scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeProvincie' or
@scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeWaterschap')
]/@content
</multivalue-field>
<field name="publisher" expression-type="xpath">
fn:string-join(('Blow, ', 'blow, ', 'thou ', 'winter ', 'wind!'), '')
</field>
<field name="publisher" expression-type="xpath">
fn:concat(//html:meta[@name='OVERHEID.organisationType']/@content,
//html:meta[@name='DC.creator']/@content)
</field>
</enricher>
<enricher name="SPARQL">
<field name="place">http://www.my.com/#channels</field>
<field expression-type="sparql" repository="TESTRDF">
<![CDATA[
PREFIX skos: <http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#>
SELECT ?definition
WHERE {
?${place} skos:definition ?definition.
}
]]>
</field>
</enricher>
Luminis Enricher Framework
(Examples)
<enricher name="Field" >
<field name="a">AA1</field>
<field name="b">BB1</field>
<field name="b">BB2</field>
<multivalue-field name="c">CC1</multivalue-field>
<multivalue-field name="c">CC2</multivalue-field>
<if test="field::c" pattern="CC2">
<then>
<field name="e">EE1</field>
</then>
</if>
<if test="field::a">
<then>
<field name="f">FF1</field>
</then>
</if>
<rename-field name="b">d</rename-field>
<remove-field name="a"/>
</enricher>
<enricher name="XPath”
xmlns:str="http://exslt.org/strings"
xmlns:fn="http://www.w3.org/2005/xpath-functions"
xmlns:html="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml">
field name="Description" expression-type="xpath">
//html:meta[@name='DC.description']/@content
</field>
<multivalue-field name="Type" expression-type="xpath">
//html:meta[@name='DC.type' and
(@scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeGemeente' or
@scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeProvincie' or
@scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeWaterschap')
]/@content
</multivalue-field>
<field name="publisher" expression-type="xpath">
fn:string-join(('Blow, ', 'blow, ', 'thou ', 'winter ', 'wind!'), '')
</field>
<field name="publisher" expression-type="xpath">
fn:concat(//html:meta[@name='OVERHEID.organisationType']/@content,
//html:meta[@name='DC.creator']/@content)
</field>
</enricher>
<enricher name="SPARQL">
<field name="place">http://www.my.com/#channels</field>
<field expression-type="sparql" repository="TESTRDF">
<![CDATA[
PREFIX skos: <http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#>
SELECT ?definition
WHERE {
?${place} skos:definition ?definition.
}
]]>
</field>
</enricher>
<enricher name=”HttpAndTika">
<field name="content.url"><![CDATA[http://na.apachecon.com/c/acna2010/speakers/501]]></field>
<field expression-type=”http" name="content.file">field:content.url</field>
<field name="auteur" source="field::content.file">xpath://H1</field>
<multivalue-field expression-type=”tika.meta” source="field::content.file”/>
<field name=”content" expression-type=”tika.text” source="field::content.file”/>
<switch test=”field::content.url
<case pattern=".*.rijksweb.nl.*"><field name=”source">Rijksweb</field></case>
<case pattern=".*.deventer.nl.*"><field name=”source">Gemeente Deventer</field></case>
<case pattern="file:.*"><field name=”source">Locale Harde Schijf</field></case>
<else><field name=”source">Overige</field></else>
</switch>
</enricher>
Luminis Enricher Framework
(Technology)
•Enricher and expresion handlers are Java based OSGi
services:
• Hot pluggable and updatable
• Flow and expression configuration changes no restart
• Extendible: New expression handlers immediatly available in
actions after installing OSGi bundle
•Runs in Apache Felix
• Collection Process: ServiceMix contains OSGi container
• Publication Process: Custom OSGi loader for Lucene/Solr
•Centralized & transactional provisioning (Apache Ace)
‑ Components & Configuration
Deployment Architecture
<<device>>
Slave Publication Server
(Slave2)
<<Container>>
Apache Tomcat
Enricher
(Luminis)
Lucene/SOLR
(Apache)
Wicket
(Apache)
<<config>>
SOLR::schema.xml
<<config>>
Luminis:Enricher.xml
<<config>>
SOLR::solrconfig.xml
Felix OSGi
(Apache)
<<device>>
Firewall <<device>>
HTTP Load Balancer
<<device>>
Master Collection Server
<<Container>>
Apache Tomcat
Enricher
(Luminis)
Nutch
(Apache)
ServiceMix
(Apache)
Tika
(Apache)
Lucene/SOLR
(Apache)
<<config>>
SOLR::solrconfig.xml
<<config>>
Luminis:Enricher.xml
<<config>>
SOLR::schema.xml
<<config>>
servicenix::config.xml
OpenRDF
<<Data Container>>
SQL
<<Database>>
Knowledge Models
<<RDFTripleStore>>
Knowledge Models
<<HTTP>>
<<HTTP>>
<<HTTP>>
<<JDBC>>
<<HTTP>>
Felix OSGi
(Apache)
<<HTTP>>
<<HTTP/ReST>>
<<HTTP/ReST>>
<<device>>
Deployment Server
Ace
(Apache)
Felix OSGi
(Apache)
<<PROVISIONING>>
<<JDBC>>
<<device>>
Slave Publication Server
(Slave1)
<<Container>>
Apache Tomcat
Enricher
(Luminis)
Lucene/SOLR
(Apache)
Wicket
(Apache)
<<config>>
SOLR::schema.xml
<<config>>
Luminis:Enricher.xml
<<config>>
SOLR::solrconfig.xml
Felix OSGi
(Apache)
Conclusions
•Enterprise Search Solution is not Google search
•Open Source paves the way; misses some ingredients
• Useful ingredients: Lucene/Solr, Nutch, Tika, ServiceMix/Camel,
Wicket, MySQL, OpenRDF, Felix/Ace
• Missing ingredients: Enricher
•Interesting developments:
• Apache Chemistry (CMIS)
• Apache Clerezza
• Apache Nutch
• Apache Connectors Framework (ManifoldCF)
Questions & (answers?)
Marc Teutelink
marc.teutelink@luminis.eu
@mteutelink
MEAP December 2010 

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Web Crawling with Apache Nutch
Web Crawling with Apache NutchWeb Crawling with Apache Nutch
Web Crawling with Apache Nutchsebastian_nagel
 
An introduction to Storm Crawler
An introduction to Storm CrawlerAn introduction to Storm Crawler
An introduction to Storm CrawlerJulien Nioche
 
Metadata Extraction and Content Transformation
Metadata Extraction and Content TransformationMetadata Extraction and Content Transformation
Metadata Extraction and Content TransformationAlfresco Software
 
Large scale crawling with Apache Nutch
Large scale crawling with Apache NutchLarge scale crawling with Apache Nutch
Large scale crawling with Apache NutchJulien Nioche
 
Apache Lucene: Searching the Web and Everything Else (Jazoon07)
Apache Lucene: Searching the Web and Everything Else (Jazoon07)Apache Lucene: Searching the Web and Everything Else (Jazoon07)
Apache Lucene: Searching the Web and Everything Else (Jazoon07)dnaber
 
Introduction to Apache Solr
Introduction to Apache SolrIntroduction to Apache Solr
Introduction to Apache SolrAndy Jackson
 
Apache Solr crash course
Apache Solr crash courseApache Solr crash course
Apache Solr crash courseTommaso Teofili
 
Indexing Text and HTML Files with Solr
Indexing Text and HTML Files with SolrIndexing Text and HTML Files with Solr
Indexing Text and HTML Files with SolrLucidworks (Archived)
 
Mime Magic With Apache Tika
Mime Magic With Apache TikaMime Magic With Apache Tika
Mime Magic With Apache TikaJukka Zitting
 
Drupal + Solr Mejorando la experiencia de búsqueda
Drupal + Solr Mejorando la experiencia de búsquedaDrupal + Solr Mejorando la experiencia de búsqueda
Drupal + Solr Mejorando la experiencia de búsquedaDavid Gil Sánchez
 
Content analysis for ECM with Apache Tika
Content analysis for ECM with Apache TikaContent analysis for ECM with Apache Tika
Content analysis for ECM with Apache TikaPaolo Mottadelli
 
Building Enterprise Search Engines using Open Source Technologies
Building Enterprise Search Engines using Open Source TechnologiesBuilding Enterprise Search Engines using Open Source Technologies
Building Enterprise Search Engines using Open Source TechnologiesRahul Singh
 
Mejorando la búsqueda Web con Apache Solr
Mejorando la búsqueda Web con Apache SolrMejorando la búsqueda Web con Apache Solr
Mejorando la búsqueda Web con Apache SolrIván Campaña Naranjo
 
Alfresco y SOLR, presentación en español
Alfresco y SOLR, presentación en españolAlfresco y SOLR, presentación en español
Alfresco y SOLR, presentación en españolToni de la Fuente
 
PLAT-13 Metadata Extraction and Transformation
PLAT-13 Metadata Extraction and TransformationPLAT-13 Metadata Extraction and Transformation
PLAT-13 Metadata Extraction and TransformationAlfresco Software
 

Viewers also liked (20)

ProjectHub
ProjectHubProjectHub
ProjectHub
 
Web Crawling with Apache Nutch
Web Crawling with Apache NutchWeb Crawling with Apache Nutch
Web Crawling with Apache Nutch
 
An introduction to Storm Crawler
An introduction to Storm CrawlerAn introduction to Storm Crawler
An introduction to Storm Crawler
 
Search engine
Search engineSearch engine
Search engine
 
Metadata Extraction and Content Transformation
Metadata Extraction and Content TransformationMetadata Extraction and Content Transformation
Metadata Extraction and Content Transformation
 
Large scale crawling with Apache Nutch
Large scale crawling with Apache NutchLarge scale crawling with Apache Nutch
Large scale crawling with Apache Nutch
 
Apache Lucene: Searching the Web and Everything Else (Jazoon07)
Apache Lucene: Searching the Web and Everything Else (Jazoon07)Apache Lucene: Searching the Web and Everything Else (Jazoon07)
Apache Lucene: Searching the Web and Everything Else (Jazoon07)
 
Introduction to Apache Solr
Introduction to Apache SolrIntroduction to Apache Solr
Introduction to Apache Solr
 
Apache Solr crash course
Apache Solr crash courseApache Solr crash course
Apache Solr crash course
 
Indexing Text and HTML Files with Solr
Indexing Text and HTML Files with SolrIndexing Text and HTML Files with Solr
Indexing Text and HTML Files with Solr
 
Apache tika
Apache tikaApache tika
Apache tika
 
Mime Magic With Apache Tika
Mime Magic With Apache TikaMime Magic With Apache Tika
Mime Magic With Apache Tika
 
Drupal + Solr Mejorando la experiencia de búsqueda
Drupal + Solr Mejorando la experiencia de búsquedaDrupal + Solr Mejorando la experiencia de búsqueda
Drupal + Solr Mejorando la experiencia de búsqueda
 
Content analysis for ECM with Apache Tika
Content analysis for ECM with Apache TikaContent analysis for ECM with Apache Tika
Content analysis for ECM with Apache Tika
 
Building Enterprise Search Engines using Open Source Technologies
Building Enterprise Search Engines using Open Source TechnologiesBuilding Enterprise Search Engines using Open Source Technologies
Building Enterprise Search Engines using Open Source Technologies
 
Mejorando la búsqueda Web con Apache Solr
Mejorando la búsqueda Web con Apache SolrMejorando la búsqueda Web con Apache Solr
Mejorando la búsqueda Web con Apache Solr
 
Alfresco y SOLR, presentación en español
Alfresco y SOLR, presentación en españolAlfresco y SOLR, presentación en español
Alfresco y SOLR, presentación en español
 
PLAT-13 Metadata Extraction and Transformation
PLAT-13 Metadata Extraction and TransformationPLAT-13 Metadata Extraction and Transformation
PLAT-13 Metadata Extraction and Transformation
 
Introducción a Solr
Introducción a SolrIntroducción a Solr
Introducción a Solr
 
Conferencia 5: Extendiendo Solr
Conferencia 5: Extendiendo SolrConferencia 5: Extendiendo Solr
Conferencia 5: Extendiendo Solr
 

Recently uploaded

JavaScript Usage Statistics 2024 - The Ultimate Guide
JavaScript Usage Statistics 2024 - The Ultimate GuideJavaScript Usage Statistics 2024 - The Ultimate Guide
JavaScript Usage Statistics 2024 - The Ultimate GuidePixlogix Infotech
 
ASRock Industrial FDO Solutions in Action for Industrial Edge AI _ Kenny at A...
ASRock Industrial FDO Solutions in Action for Industrial Edge AI _ Kenny at A...ASRock Industrial FDO Solutions in Action for Industrial Edge AI _ Kenny at A...
ASRock Industrial FDO Solutions in Action for Industrial Edge AI _ Kenny at A...FIDO Alliance
 
WebRTC and SIP not just audio and video @ OpenSIPS 2024
WebRTC and SIP not just audio and video @ OpenSIPS 2024WebRTC and SIP not just audio and video @ OpenSIPS 2024
WebRTC and SIP not just audio and video @ OpenSIPS 2024Lorenzo Miniero
 
Long journey of Ruby Standard library at RubyKaigi 2024
Long journey of Ruby Standard library at RubyKaigi 2024Long journey of Ruby Standard library at RubyKaigi 2024
Long journey of Ruby Standard library at RubyKaigi 2024Hiroshi SHIBATA
 
State of the Smart Building Startup Landscape 2024!
State of the Smart Building Startup Landscape 2024!State of the Smart Building Startup Landscape 2024!
State of the Smart Building Startup Landscape 2024!Memoori
 
The Metaverse: Are We There Yet?
The  Metaverse:    Are   We  There  Yet?The  Metaverse:    Are   We  There  Yet?
The Metaverse: Are We There Yet?Mark Billinghurst
 
ADP Passwordless Journey Case Study.pptx
ADP Passwordless Journey Case Study.pptxADP Passwordless Journey Case Study.pptx
ADP Passwordless Journey Case Study.pptxFIDO Alliance
 
WebAssembly is Key to Better LLM Performance
WebAssembly is Key to Better LLM PerformanceWebAssembly is Key to Better LLM Performance
WebAssembly is Key to Better LLM PerformanceSamy Fodil
 
Event-Driven Architecture Masterclass: Engineering a Robust, High-performance...
Event-Driven Architecture Masterclass: Engineering a Robust, High-performance...Event-Driven Architecture Masterclass: Engineering a Robust, High-performance...
Event-Driven Architecture Masterclass: Engineering a Robust, High-performance...ScyllaDB
 
Tales from a Passkey Provider Progress from Awareness to Implementation.pptx
Tales from a Passkey Provider  Progress from Awareness to Implementation.pptxTales from a Passkey Provider  Progress from Awareness to Implementation.pptx
Tales from a Passkey Provider Progress from Awareness to Implementation.pptxFIDO Alliance
 
Generative AI Use Cases and Applications.pdf
Generative AI Use Cases and Applications.pdfGenerative AI Use Cases and Applications.pdf
Generative AI Use Cases and Applications.pdfalexjohnson7307
 
Vector Search @ sw2con for slideshare.pptx
Vector Search @ sw2con for slideshare.pptxVector Search @ sw2con for slideshare.pptx
Vector Search @ sw2con for slideshare.pptxjbellis
 
Simplified FDO Manufacturing Flow with TPMs _ Liam at Infineon.pdf
Simplified FDO Manufacturing Flow with TPMs _ Liam at Infineon.pdfSimplified FDO Manufacturing Flow with TPMs _ Liam at Infineon.pdf
Simplified FDO Manufacturing Flow with TPMs _ Liam at Infineon.pdfFIDO Alliance
 
Intro to Passkeys and the State of Passwordless.pptx
Intro to Passkeys and the State of Passwordless.pptxIntro to Passkeys and the State of Passwordless.pptx
Intro to Passkeys and the State of Passwordless.pptxFIDO Alliance
 
Secure Zero Touch enabled Edge compute with Dell NativeEdge via FDO _ Brad at...
Secure Zero Touch enabled Edge compute with Dell NativeEdge via FDO _ Brad at...Secure Zero Touch enabled Edge compute with Dell NativeEdge via FDO _ Brad at...
Secure Zero Touch enabled Edge compute with Dell NativeEdge via FDO _ Brad at...FIDO Alliance
 
How we scaled to 80K users by doing nothing!.pdf
How we scaled to 80K users by doing nothing!.pdfHow we scaled to 80K users by doing nothing!.pdf
How we scaled to 80K users by doing nothing!.pdfSrushith Repakula
 
2024 May Patch Tuesday
2024 May Patch Tuesday2024 May Patch Tuesday
2024 May Patch TuesdayIvanti
 
Design and Development of a Provenance Capture Platform for Data Science
Design and Development of a Provenance Capture Platform for Data ScienceDesign and Development of a Provenance Capture Platform for Data Science
Design and Development of a Provenance Capture Platform for Data SciencePaolo Missier
 
UiPath manufacturing technology benefits and AI overview
UiPath manufacturing technology benefits and AI overviewUiPath manufacturing technology benefits and AI overview
UiPath manufacturing technology benefits and AI overviewDianaGray10
 
Portal Kombat : extension du réseau de propagande russe
Portal Kombat : extension du réseau de propagande russePortal Kombat : extension du réseau de propagande russe
Portal Kombat : extension du réseau de propagande russe中 央社
 

Recently uploaded (20)

JavaScript Usage Statistics 2024 - The Ultimate Guide
JavaScript Usage Statistics 2024 - The Ultimate GuideJavaScript Usage Statistics 2024 - The Ultimate Guide
JavaScript Usage Statistics 2024 - The Ultimate Guide
 
ASRock Industrial FDO Solutions in Action for Industrial Edge AI _ Kenny at A...
ASRock Industrial FDO Solutions in Action for Industrial Edge AI _ Kenny at A...ASRock Industrial FDO Solutions in Action for Industrial Edge AI _ Kenny at A...
ASRock Industrial FDO Solutions in Action for Industrial Edge AI _ Kenny at A...
 
WebRTC and SIP not just audio and video @ OpenSIPS 2024
WebRTC and SIP not just audio and video @ OpenSIPS 2024WebRTC and SIP not just audio and video @ OpenSIPS 2024
WebRTC and SIP not just audio and video @ OpenSIPS 2024
 
Long journey of Ruby Standard library at RubyKaigi 2024
Long journey of Ruby Standard library at RubyKaigi 2024Long journey of Ruby Standard library at RubyKaigi 2024
Long journey of Ruby Standard library at RubyKaigi 2024
 
State of the Smart Building Startup Landscape 2024!
State of the Smart Building Startup Landscape 2024!State of the Smart Building Startup Landscape 2024!
State of the Smart Building Startup Landscape 2024!
 
The Metaverse: Are We There Yet?
The  Metaverse:    Are   We  There  Yet?The  Metaverse:    Are   We  There  Yet?
The Metaverse: Are We There Yet?
 
ADP Passwordless Journey Case Study.pptx
ADP Passwordless Journey Case Study.pptxADP Passwordless Journey Case Study.pptx
ADP Passwordless Journey Case Study.pptx
 
WebAssembly is Key to Better LLM Performance
WebAssembly is Key to Better LLM PerformanceWebAssembly is Key to Better LLM Performance
WebAssembly is Key to Better LLM Performance
 
Event-Driven Architecture Masterclass: Engineering a Robust, High-performance...
Event-Driven Architecture Masterclass: Engineering a Robust, High-performance...Event-Driven Architecture Masterclass: Engineering a Robust, High-performance...
Event-Driven Architecture Masterclass: Engineering a Robust, High-performance...
 
Tales from a Passkey Provider Progress from Awareness to Implementation.pptx
Tales from a Passkey Provider  Progress from Awareness to Implementation.pptxTales from a Passkey Provider  Progress from Awareness to Implementation.pptx
Tales from a Passkey Provider Progress from Awareness to Implementation.pptx
 
Generative AI Use Cases and Applications.pdf
Generative AI Use Cases and Applications.pdfGenerative AI Use Cases and Applications.pdf
Generative AI Use Cases and Applications.pdf
 
Vector Search @ sw2con for slideshare.pptx
Vector Search @ sw2con for slideshare.pptxVector Search @ sw2con for slideshare.pptx
Vector Search @ sw2con for slideshare.pptx
 
Simplified FDO Manufacturing Flow with TPMs _ Liam at Infineon.pdf
Simplified FDO Manufacturing Flow with TPMs _ Liam at Infineon.pdfSimplified FDO Manufacturing Flow with TPMs _ Liam at Infineon.pdf
Simplified FDO Manufacturing Flow with TPMs _ Liam at Infineon.pdf
 
Intro to Passkeys and the State of Passwordless.pptx
Intro to Passkeys and the State of Passwordless.pptxIntro to Passkeys and the State of Passwordless.pptx
Intro to Passkeys and the State of Passwordless.pptx
 
Secure Zero Touch enabled Edge compute with Dell NativeEdge via FDO _ Brad at...
Secure Zero Touch enabled Edge compute with Dell NativeEdge via FDO _ Brad at...Secure Zero Touch enabled Edge compute with Dell NativeEdge via FDO _ Brad at...
Secure Zero Touch enabled Edge compute with Dell NativeEdge via FDO _ Brad at...
 
How we scaled to 80K users by doing nothing!.pdf
How we scaled to 80K users by doing nothing!.pdfHow we scaled to 80K users by doing nothing!.pdf
How we scaled to 80K users by doing nothing!.pdf
 
2024 May Patch Tuesday
2024 May Patch Tuesday2024 May Patch Tuesday
2024 May Patch Tuesday
 
Design and Development of a Provenance Capture Platform for Data Science
Design and Development of a Provenance Capture Platform for Data ScienceDesign and Development of a Provenance Capture Platform for Data Science
Design and Development of a Provenance Capture Platform for Data Science
 
UiPath manufacturing technology benefits and AI overview
UiPath manufacturing technology benefits and AI overviewUiPath manufacturing technology benefits and AI overview
UiPath manufacturing technology benefits and AI overview
 
Portal Kombat : extension du réseau de propagande russe
Portal Kombat : extension du réseau de propagande russePortal Kombat : extension du réseau de propagande russe
Portal Kombat : extension du réseau de propagande russe
 

Open source enterprise search and retrieval platform

  • 1. Datum 21 augustus 2010 Enterprise Search EAI Semantic Web Open Source Search & Retrieval Platform Marc Teutelink
  • 2. How Apache open source software is used during the implementation of an Enterprise Search and Retrieval Platform (Lucene/SOLR, Nutch, Tika, ServiceMix/Camel, Felix/Ace)
  • 3. Marc Teutelink marc.teutelink@luminis.eu @mteutelink •Software architect at Luminis •15+ years experience in software development; specialized in Enterprise Search, Enterprise Application Integration and Semantic Web technology •Currently writing “Enterprise Search in Action” for Manning (Mid-2011)
  • 4. Agenda •Enterprise Search • What is Enterprise Search: Functions and features • Challenges • Logical Architecture •Enterprise Search Solution • Technology Stack • Collection Process • Publication Process • Enricher framework • Deployment •Conclusion
  • 5. What is Enterprise Search? “Enterprise Search offers a solution for searching, finding and presenting enterprise related information in the larger sense of the word” Enterprise search is all about searching through documents from any type and format from any sources located anywhere with the upmost flexibility • Web search: limited to public documents on the web • Desktop search: limited to private documents on the local machine • Enterprise search: no limitations on document type and location
  • 6. Enterprise Search (features) •Information Sources and Types • Wide range of sources: local and remote filesystems, content repositories, e-mail, databases, internet, intranet and extranet • Type not limited: any type ranging from structured to unstructured data, text and binary formats and compound formats (zip) •Usage • Not limited to interactive use  automated business processes •Security • Integrations with enterprise security infrastructure •User Interaction and personalization • Identity enables more personalized search results
  • 7. Enterprise Search (features) •Extended metadata • More metadata  better and more precise search results • More control over schema (for example Dynamic Fields) •Ranking • More control over ranking: personalized ranking (group) •Data extraction and derivation • Extract data using various techniques: Xpath, Xquery • Derive data: using external knowledge models: RDBMS, RDF Store, Web Services • Conditional extraction & derivation •Managing and monitoring • On-the-fly management (JMX) • Real time monitoring
  • 8. Enterprise Search (features) •User Interfaces • Web search • All about selling advertisements to the mass • Generalistic & minimalistic screens; focus on adds • Enterprise search • All about finding: rich navigation; focus on quick find • Small targeted audience • Specialized and customized screens (use of ontologies, taxonomies and classifications) • Use of identity (results customized to user) and web 2.0 • Grouping • field collapsing, faceted search & clustering
  • 9. Enterprise Search (Challenges) •Performance and scalability •Rich functions and features •Managebility •Flexibility •Easy maintenance •Quick issue and problem solving •Reduce total cost of ownerschip
  • 10. Enterprise Search (Challenges) •Performance and scalability •Rich functions and features •Managebility •Flexibility •Easy maintenance •Quick issue and problem solving •Reduce total cost of ownerschip Commercial Search Engines?
  • 11. Enterprise Search (Challenges) •Performance and scalability •Rich functions and features •Managebility •Flexibility •Easy maintenance •Quick issue and problem solving •Reduce total cost of ownerschip Apache Based (Open Source) Search & Retrieval Platform
  • 12. Enterprise Search (Logical Architecture) Actors Search Engine Indexing Sources Content Inbound Pull (Crawling) Pull (Harvesting) Push (SOAP/ReST) Searching & Ordering Filtering Grouping Request Inbound HTTP/Get (URL) HTTP/Post (SOAP/ReST) API (Java,Perl,...) Request Validation Syntactic Semantic Request Enrichment Redirection (Suggestions) Enhancement (add/remove clauses) Response Enrichment Redirection (more like this) Enhancement (metadata, editorial) Response Outbound Stateless (XSLT, SolrJS) Statefull (Webapp Framework) Sorting Content Enrichment Extraction Enhancement Filtering Collection Process Publication Process Content Validation SemanticSyntactic
  • 13. Enterprise Search (Collection Process) Sources • Any document format • Any type • Structured and unstructured • Textual and binary • Compound • Residing Anywhere • Security Search Engine Indexing Sources Content Inbound Pull (Crawling) Pull (Harvesting) Push (SOAP/ReST) Content Enrichment Extraction Enhancement Filtering Collection Process Content Validation SemanticSyntactic
  • 14. Enterprise Search (Collection Process) Search Engine Indexing Sources Content Inbound Pull (Crawling) Pull (Harvesting) Push (SOAP/ReST) Content Enrichment Extraction Enhancement Filtering Collection Process Content Validation SemanticSyntactic Content Inbound • Pull (Crawling/Spidering) • Internet, intranet & extranet • Local and remote filesystems • Pull (Harvesting) • Databases • Content Repositories / Mgmt Systems • Webservices inbound • Push • Webservices (SOAP/REST) • Real time indexing
  • 15. Enterprise Search (Collection Process) Search Engine Indexing Sources Content Inbound Pull (Crawling) Pull (Harvesting) Push (SOAP/ReST) Content Enrichment Extraction Enhancement Filtering Collection Process Content Validation SemanticSyntactic Content Validation • Syntactic validation • Based on DTD / XML-Schema • Structure and limited content • Semantic validation • Based on algorithms: • Groovy, XPath, Regex, … • Think about exception handling • Placed anywhere in flow • During inbound: XML-Schema validation • After Enrichment: Validate derived metadata
  • 16. Enterprise Search (Collection Process) Search Engine Indexing Sources Content Inbound Pull (Crawling) Pull (Harvesting) Push (SOAP/ReST) Content Enrichment Extraction Enhancement Filtering Collection Process Content Validation SemanticSyntactic Content Enrichment • Extraction • Metadata • Content (free text of document) • Enhancing • Derive new and alter existing metadata • Filtering • Remove (parts of) metadata • Leverage external knowledge models • Conditional enrichment
  • 17. Enterprise Search (Collection Process) Search Engine Indexing Sources Content Inbound Pull (Crawling) Pull (Harvesting) Push (SOAP/ReST) Content Enrichment Extraction Enhancement Filtering Collection Process Content Validation SemanticSyntactic Indexing • Store in search engine(s) • Content based routing • Document boosting
  • 18. Enterprise Search (Publication Process) Request Inbound • HTTP/Get • URL based with parameters • Response in XML, JSON, … • HTTP/Post • XML (SOAP, REST) request • XML (SOAP, REST) response • API • Java, Perl, … • Wrappers on HTTP/Get Actors Search Engine Searching & Ordering Filtering Grouping Request Inbound HTTP/Get (URL) HTTP/Post (SOAP/ReST) API (Java,Perl,...) Request Validation Syntactic Semantic Request Enrichment Redirection (Suggestions) Enhancement (add/remove clauses) Response Enrichment Redirection (more like this) Enhancement (metadata, editorial) Response Outbound Stateless (XSLT, SolrJS) Statefull (Webapp Framework) Sorting Publication Process
  • 19. Enterprise Search (Publication Process) Actors Search Engine Searching & Ordering Filtering Grouping Request Inbound HTTP/Get (URL) HTTP/Post (SOAP/ReST) API (Java,Perl,...) Request Validation Syntactic Semantic Request Enrichment Redirection (Suggestions) Enhancement (add/remove clauses) Response Enrichment Redirection (more like this) Enhancement (metadata, editorial) Response Outbound Stateless (XSLT, SolrJS) Statefull (Webapp Framework) Sorting Publication Process Request Validation • Syntactic Validation • Correct Query syntax? • Semantic Validation • Correct Field Filters? • Based on algorithms: Groovy, Regex • Placed anywhere in flow • @inbound: XML-Schema validation • @enrichment: Validate derived request clauses
  • 20. Enterprise Search (Publication Process) Actors Search Engine Searching & Ordering Filtering Grouping Request Inbound HTTP/Get (URL) HTTP/Post (SOAP/ReST) API (Java,Perl,...) Request Validation Syntactic Semantic Request Enrichment Redirection (Suggestions) Enhancement (add/remove clauses) Response Enrichment Redirection (more like this) Enhancement (metadata, editorial) Response Outbound Stateless (XSLT, SolrJS) Statefull (Webapp Framework) Sorting Publication Process Request Enrichment • Redirection • Spelling suggestions • Metadata suggestions • Enhancing • Add/Remove clauses • Stemming, Synonyms, stop words
  • 21. Enterprise Search (Publication Process) Actors Search Engine Searching & Ordering Filtering Grouping Request Inbound HTTP/Get (URL) HTTP/Post (SOAP/ReST) API (Java,Perl,...) Request Validation Syntactic Semantic Request Enrichment Redirection (Suggestions) Enhancement (add/remove clauses) Response Enrichment Redirection (more like this) Enhancement (metadata, editorial) Response Outbound Stateless (XSLT, SolrJS) Statefull (Webapp Framework) Sorting Publication Process Searching & Ordering • Filtering • Field Search • Grouping • Add group information • Field collapsing, Faceted Search & Clustering • Sorting • Sort on Field • Ranking
  • 22. Enterprise Search (Publication Process) Actors Search Engine Searching & Ordering Filtering Grouping Request Inbound HTTP/Get (URL) HTTP/Post (SOAP/ReST) API (Java,Perl,...) Request Validation Syntactic Semantic Request Enrichment Redirection (Suggestions) Enhancement (add/remove clauses) Response Enrichment Redirection (more like this) Enhancement (metadata, editorial) Response Outbound Stateless (XSLT, SolrJS) Statefull (Webapp Framework) Sorting Publication Process Response Enrichment • Redirection • Suggestions • More like this • Enhancing • Add/Remove response fields • Schema information • Editorial information
  • 23. Enterprise Search (Publication Process) Actors Search Engine Searching & Ordering Filtering Grouping Request Inbound HTTP/Get (URL) HTTP/Post (SOAP/ReST) API (Java,Perl,...) Request Validation Syntactic Semantic Request Enrichment Redirection (Suggestions) Enhancement (add/remove clauses) Response Enrichment Redirection (more like this) Enhancement (metadata, editorial) Response Outbound Stateless (XSLT, SolrJS) Statefull (Webapp Framework) Sorting Publication Process Response outbound • Stateless • No security • XSLT, SolrJS • Statefull • Security • Web2.0 • Web Application Framework
  • 24. Technology Stack (Collection Process) •Use ESB for the flow: Apache ServiceMix with Camel • Leverage standard ESB components (Transformers, Validation, Splitter, Filter, Routers, Scripting) • Leverage standard ESB transports (WS, SMTP, JMS, JCR, JDBC, FILE) • Custom: Crawler Apache Nutch • Leverage only crawl framework • Extend NutchIndexWriter; asynchronously pushing crawled documents back into ESB flow (reply-to) •ESB Makes distributed flow possibleContent based routing •Hot deploy Easy maintenance •Reusing services across collection processes •Search Engine independent
  • 25. Collection Process Flow Content Indexer Content Inbound 2 1 Documents Message N D Document Messages D D Lucene/Solr INDEX HTTP Transport (Channel Adapter) Lucene/SOLR (SOLRJ) D SOLR Document Message Splitter Channel Content Validation Content Enrichment Enricher Content Filter Content Enricher Syntactic Validation (Channel Purger) Push Inbound (Message Endpoint) Semantic Validation (Channel Purger) Invalid Message Channel ! ? Invalid Message ChannelChannel Transformer (Message Translator)
  • 26. Technology Stack (Publication Process) •Use flow from Apache Lucene/Solr • Leverage standard Solr components (synonyms, stopwords, stemming, MLT, spelling, faceted search, …) • Custom components: using Solr’s extendability framework • Security: authority field in schema with Apache Shiro integration • Field filters (zipcode,…) •User interfaces • Stateless: SolrJs, XSLTResponseWriter & VelocityResponseWriter • Statefull: Apache Wicket with Spring
  • 27. Actors Search Engine Indexing Sources Content Inbound Pull (Crawling) Pull (Harvesting) Push (SOAP/ReST) Searching & Ordering Filtering Grouping Request Inbound HTTP/Get (URL) HTTP/Post (SOAP/ReST) API (Java,Perl,...) Request Validation Syntactic Semantic Request Enrichment Redirection (Suggestions) Enhancement (add/remove clauses) Response Enrichment Redirection (more like this) Enhancement (metadata, editorial) Response Outbound Stateless (XSLT, SolrJS) Statefull (Webapp Framework) Sorting Content Enrichment Extraction Enhancement Filtering Collection Process Publication Process Content Validation SemanticSyntactic Enterprise Search (Logical Architecture)
  • 28. Actors Search Engine Indexing Sources Content Inbound Pull (Crawling) Pull (Harvesting) Push (SOAP/ReST) Searching & Ordering Filtering Grouping Request Inbound HTTP/Get (URL) HTTP/Post (SOAP/ReST) API (Java,Perl,...) Request Validation Syntactic Semantic Request Enrichment Redirection (Suggestions) Enhancement (add/remove clauses) Response Enrichment Redirection (more like this) Enhancement (metadata, editorial) Response Outbound Stateless (XSLT, SolrJS) Statefull (Webapp Framework) Sorting Content Enrichment Extraction Enhancement Filtering Collection Process Publication Process Content Validation SemanticSyntactic Lucene/SOLR ServiceMix/Camel Nutch Apache WicketSolrJS/XSLT Enterprise Search (Logical Architecture)
  • 29. Actors Search Engine Indexing Sources Content Inbound Pull (Crawling) Pull (Harvesting) Push (SOAP/ReST) Searching & Ordering Filtering Grouping Request Inbound HTTP/Get (URL) HTTP/Post (SOAP/ReST) API (Java,Perl,...) Request Validation Syntactic Semantic Request Enrichment Redirection (Suggestions) Enhancement (add/remove clauses) Response Enrichment Redirection (more like this) Enhancement (metadata, editorial) Response Outbound Stateless (XSLT, SolrJS) Statefull (Webapp Framework) Sorting Content Enrichment Extraction Enhancement Filtering Collection Process Publication Process Content Validation SemanticSyntactic Enterprise Search (Logical Architecture) Luminis Enricher Framework
  • 30. Luminis Enricher Framework •Custom Enricher Framework • Existing ESB & SOLR enricher capabilities not sufficient. • Enriching = one or more actions (extraction, enhancing & filtering) performed on documents with fields • Same enricher to be used for: • Collection process: • Documents  enriching, filtering & splitting • Publication process: • Search requests’first-components’ searchcomponent • Search response’last-components’ searchcomponent
  • 31. Luminis Enricher Framework •Custom Enricher Framework • Existing ESB & SOLR enricher capabilities not sufficient. • Enriching = one or more actions (extraction, enhancing & filtering) performed on documents with fields • Same enricher to be used for: • Collection process: • Documents  enriching, filtering & splitting • Publication process: • Search requests’first-components’ searchcomponent • Search response’last-components’ searchcomponent Content Indexer Content Inbound 2 1 Documents Message N D Document Messages D D Lucene/Solr INDEX SOLR Indexer (Channel Adapter) Lucene/SOLR (SOLRJ) D SOLR Document Message Splitter Channel Content Validation Content Enrichment Enricher Content Filter Content Enricher Syntactic Validation (Channel Purger) Push Inbound (Message Endpoint) Semantic Validation (Channel Purger) Invalid Message Channel ! ? Invalid Message ChannelChannel
  • 32. Luminis Enricher Framework •Custom Enricher Framework • Existing ESB & SOLR enricher capabilities not sufficient. • Enriching = one or more actions (extraction, enhancing & filtering) performed on documents with fields • Same enricher to be used for: • Collection process: • Documents  enriching, filtering & splitting • Publication process: • Search requests’first-components’ searchcomponent • Search response’last-components’ searchcomponent Content Indexer Content Inbound 2 1 Documents Message N D Document Messages D D Lucene/Solr INDEX SOLR Indexer (Channel Adapter) Lucene/SOLR (SOLRJ) D SOLR Document Message Splitter Channel Content Validation Content Enrichment Enricher Content Filter Content Enricher Syntactic Validation (Channel Purger) Push Inbound (Message Endpoint) Semantic Validation (Channel Purger) Invalid Message Channel ! ? Invalid Message ChannelChannel <<SearchHandler>> RequestHandler "first-components" "components" "last-components" <<XML>> Response <<SearchComponent>> query <<SearchComponent>> facet <<SearchComponent>> mlt <<SearchComponent>> highlight <<SearchComponent>> stats <<SearchComponent>> debug <<SOLRQueryRequest>> Query <<XSLT>> XML2HTML <<QueryResponseWriter>> XSLTResponseWriter <<(X)HTML>> Resultaat
  • 33. Luminis Enricher Framework (architecture) •Pipe-and-filter architecture • Documents flow through series of actions • Output from one action is input to another action • Fields from input document can be used in action’s clauses: values in expressions filled by replacing velocity type patterns with field values •Conditional flows supported •Reuse of flows & Subflows supported
  • 34. Luminis Enricher Framework (architecture) •Pipe-and-filter architecture • Documents flow through series of actions • Output from one action is input to another action • Fields from input document can be used in action’s clauses: values in expressions filled by replacing velocity type patterns with field values •Conditional flows supported •Reuse of flows & Subflows supported Action (select C where ${B}) Action (remove A2) Document [[A1,A2],[B]] Document [[A1],[B]] Document [[A1],[B],[C1]] If [B=3] YES Action (select C where ${A}) Document [[A1],[B],[C2]] NO
  • 35. Luminis Enricher Framework (Configuration) •Enricher flow and expression configuration via XML based DSL • Conditional: if-then-else & switch-case-else (with regex support) • Actions: Add & remove fields and field values using expressions • Expression handlers currently supported: • Field • Function (execute methods via Java Reflection) • HttpClient (retrieve content by URL described by field values) • Xslt, Xpath, Xquery (external XML databases) • JDBC • SparQL (OpenRDF) • Apache Lucene/Solr • Apache Tika (Meta and Text extraction)
  • 36. Luminis Enricher Framework (Examples) <enricher name="Field" > <field name="a">AA1</field> <field name="b">BB1</field> <field name="b">BB2</field> <multivalue-field name="c">CC1</multivalue-field> <multivalue-field name="c">CC2</multivalue-field> <if test="field::c" pattern="CC2"> <then> <field name="e">EE1</field> </then> </if> <if test="field::a"> <then> <field name="f">FF1</field> </then> </if> <rename-field name="b">d</rename-field> <remove-field name="a"/> </enricher>
  • 37. Luminis Enricher Framework (Examples) <enricher name="Field" > <field name="a">AA1</field> <field name="b">BB1</field> <field name="b">BB2</field> <multivalue-field name="c">CC1</multivalue-field> <multivalue-field name="c">CC2</multivalue-field> <if test="field::c" pattern="CC2"> <then> <field name="e">EE1</field> </then> </if> <if test="field::a"> <then> <field name="f">FF1</field> </then> </if> <rename-field name="b">d</rename-field> <remove-field name="a"/> </enricher> <enricher name="XPath” xmlns:str="http://exslt.org/strings" xmlns:fn="http://www.w3.org/2005/xpath-functions" xmlns:html="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"> field name="Description" expression-type="xpath"> //html:meta[@name='DC.description']/@content </field> <multivalue-field name="Type" expression-type="xpath"> //html:meta[@name='DC.type' and (@scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeGemeente' or @scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeProvincie' or @scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeWaterschap') ]/@content </multivalue-field> <field name="publisher" expression-type="xpath"> fn:string-join(('Blow, ', 'blow, ', 'thou ', 'winter ', 'wind!'), '') </field> <field name="publisher" expression-type="xpath"> fn:concat(//html:meta[@name='OVERHEID.organisationType']/@content, //html:meta[@name='DC.creator']/@content) </field> </enricher>
  • 38. Luminis Enricher Framework (Examples) <enricher name="Field" > <field name="a">AA1</field> <field name="b">BB1</field> <field name="b">BB2</field> <multivalue-field name="c">CC1</multivalue-field> <multivalue-field name="c">CC2</multivalue-field> <if test="field::c" pattern="CC2"> <then> <field name="e">EE1</field> </then> </if> <if test="field::a"> <then> <field name="f">FF1</field> </then> </if> <rename-field name="b">d</rename-field> <remove-field name="a"/> </enricher> <enricher name="XPath” xmlns:str="http://exslt.org/strings" xmlns:fn="http://www.w3.org/2005/xpath-functions" xmlns:html="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"> field name="Description" expression-type="xpath"> //html:meta[@name='DC.description']/@content </field> <multivalue-field name="Type" expression-type="xpath"> //html:meta[@name='DC.type' and (@scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeGemeente' or @scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeProvincie' or @scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeWaterschap') ]/@content </multivalue-field> <field name="publisher" expression-type="xpath"> fn:string-join(('Blow, ', 'blow, ', 'thou ', 'winter ', 'wind!'), '') </field> <field name="publisher" expression-type="xpath"> fn:concat(//html:meta[@name='OVERHEID.organisationType']/@content, //html:meta[@name='DC.creator']/@content) </field> </enricher> <enricher name="SPARQL"> <field name="place">http://www.my.com/#channels</field> <field expression-type="sparql" repository="TESTRDF"> <![CDATA[ PREFIX skos: <http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#> SELECT ?definition WHERE { ?${place} skos:definition ?definition. } ]]> </field> </enricher>
  • 39. Luminis Enricher Framework (Examples) <enricher name="Field" > <field name="a">AA1</field> <field name="b">BB1</field> <field name="b">BB2</field> <multivalue-field name="c">CC1</multivalue-field> <multivalue-field name="c">CC2</multivalue-field> <if test="field::c" pattern="CC2"> <then> <field name="e">EE1</field> </then> </if> <if test="field::a"> <then> <field name="f">FF1</field> </then> </if> <rename-field name="b">d</rename-field> <remove-field name="a"/> </enricher> <enricher name="XPath” xmlns:str="http://exslt.org/strings" xmlns:fn="http://www.w3.org/2005/xpath-functions" xmlns:html="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"> field name="Description" expression-type="xpath"> //html:meta[@name='DC.description']/@content </field> <multivalue-field name="Type" expression-type="xpath"> //html:meta[@name='DC.type' and (@scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeGemeente' or @scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeProvincie' or @scheme='OVERHEIDbm.bekendmakingtypeWaterschap') ]/@content </multivalue-field> <field name="publisher" expression-type="xpath"> fn:string-join(('Blow, ', 'blow, ', 'thou ', 'winter ', 'wind!'), '') </field> <field name="publisher" expression-type="xpath"> fn:concat(//html:meta[@name='OVERHEID.organisationType']/@content, //html:meta[@name='DC.creator']/@content) </field> </enricher> <enricher name="SPARQL"> <field name="place">http://www.my.com/#channels</field> <field expression-type="sparql" repository="TESTRDF"> <![CDATA[ PREFIX skos: <http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#> SELECT ?definition WHERE { ?${place} skos:definition ?definition. } ]]> </field> </enricher> <enricher name=”HttpAndTika"> <field name="content.url"><![CDATA[http://na.apachecon.com/c/acna2010/speakers/501]]></field> <field expression-type=”http" name="content.file">field:content.url</field> <field name="auteur" source="field::content.file">xpath://H1</field> <multivalue-field expression-type=”tika.meta” source="field::content.file”/> <field name=”content" expression-type=”tika.text” source="field::content.file”/> <switch test=”field::content.url <case pattern=".*.rijksweb.nl.*"><field name=”source">Rijksweb</field></case> <case pattern=".*.deventer.nl.*"><field name=”source">Gemeente Deventer</field></case> <case pattern="file:.*"><field name=”source">Locale Harde Schijf</field></case> <else><field name=”source">Overige</field></else> </switch> </enricher>
  • 40. Luminis Enricher Framework (Technology) •Enricher and expresion handlers are Java based OSGi services: • Hot pluggable and updatable • Flow and expression configuration changes no restart • Extendible: New expression handlers immediatly available in actions after installing OSGi bundle •Runs in Apache Felix • Collection Process: ServiceMix contains OSGi container • Publication Process: Custom OSGi loader for Lucene/Solr •Centralized & transactional provisioning (Apache Ace) ‑ Components & Configuration
  • 41. Deployment Architecture <<device>> Slave Publication Server (Slave2) <<Container>> Apache Tomcat Enricher (Luminis) Lucene/SOLR (Apache) Wicket (Apache) <<config>> SOLR::schema.xml <<config>> Luminis:Enricher.xml <<config>> SOLR::solrconfig.xml Felix OSGi (Apache) <<device>> Firewall <<device>> HTTP Load Balancer <<device>> Master Collection Server <<Container>> Apache Tomcat Enricher (Luminis) Nutch (Apache) ServiceMix (Apache) Tika (Apache) Lucene/SOLR (Apache) <<config>> SOLR::solrconfig.xml <<config>> Luminis:Enricher.xml <<config>> SOLR::schema.xml <<config>> servicenix::config.xml OpenRDF <<Data Container>> SQL <<Database>> Knowledge Models <<RDFTripleStore>> Knowledge Models <<HTTP>> <<HTTP>> <<HTTP>> <<JDBC>> <<HTTP>> Felix OSGi (Apache) <<HTTP>> <<HTTP/ReST>> <<HTTP/ReST>> <<device>> Deployment Server Ace (Apache) Felix OSGi (Apache) <<PROVISIONING>> <<JDBC>> <<device>> Slave Publication Server (Slave1) <<Container>> Apache Tomcat Enricher (Luminis) Lucene/SOLR (Apache) Wicket (Apache) <<config>> SOLR::schema.xml <<config>> Luminis:Enricher.xml <<config>> SOLR::solrconfig.xml Felix OSGi (Apache)
  • 42. Conclusions •Enterprise Search Solution is not Google search •Open Source paves the way; misses some ingredients • Useful ingredients: Lucene/Solr, Nutch, Tika, ServiceMix/Camel, Wicket, MySQL, OpenRDF, Felix/Ace • Missing ingredients: Enricher •Interesting developments: • Apache Chemistry (CMIS) • Apache Clerezza • Apache Nutch • Apache Connectors Framework (ManifoldCF)
  • 43. Questions & (answers?) Marc Teutelink marc.teutelink@luminis.eu @mteutelink MEAP December 2010 