Aperçu de la soirée
1. Définition d’une norme
2. La librairie de normes du PMI
1er atelier/discussions
3. Processus générique de développement et de mise
à jour des normes
4. Développement de normes et « exposure drafts »
en cours
5. Processus de mise à jour du PMBok Guide
2e atelier/discussions
6. Différence de processus entre ANSI et ISO
3e atelier/discussions
2
Yvan Petit, M.Ing. M.B.A., Ph.D., PMP, PfMP
Education
Ph.D. (UQAM) – Gestion de portefeuille
MBA (INSEAD, Fontainebleau, France)
Maîtrise en génie électrique (Polytechnique)
Bacc. Génie physique(Polytechnique)
Affiliations
Membre du comité aviseur des standards PMI
Membre du comité canadien ISO
Expérience
Professeur à ESG UQAM
Ericsson (Montréal, Stockholm)
Reuters (London, U.K., Singapore)
3
Alejandro Romero, M.Ing. Ph.D., PMP
Education
Ph.D. (École Polytechnique de Montréal)
Maîtrise en génie industriel (École Polytechnique
de Montréal)
Bacc. Technologies de l’Information (Mexique)
Affiliations
Membre du comité central du PMBOK version 6
Expérience
Professeur à ESG UQAM
Chercheur Chaire de gestion de projets, CIRANO
Gestionnaire de projets TI (Mexique, Colombie Vénézuela et
Chili)
4
Qu’est-ce qu’une norme?
Une norme est un document qui définit des
• exigences,
• des spécifications,
• des lignes directrices ou
• des caractéristiques
à utiliser systématiquement pour assurer
l'aptitude à l'emploi des
• matériaux,
• produits,
• processus et
• services.
(Site Internet: WWW.ISO.ORG)
Qu’est-ce que c’est une norme selon le PMI?
Un document établi par consensus et approuvé par un
organisme reconnue, qui fournit, pour un usage
commun et répété, des règles, des lignes directrices ou
des caractéristiques pour des activités ou pour leurs
résultats, visant à atteindre le degré optimal d'ordre
dans un contexte donné .
Développé sous un processus fondé sur les notions de
consensus, d'ouverture, d'une procédure régulière, et
de l'équilibre, les normes PMI fournissent des lignes
directrices pour la réalisation du projet, de programme
et de gestion de portefeuille des résultats spécifiques.
6
Consensus
Accord substantiel qui a été atteint par des
parties prenantes directement et
matériellement impliquées. Le consensus
est atteint par une majorité, mais pas
nécessairement l'unanimité.
• Tous les points de vue et les objections sont
considérées
• Des efforts ont été accomplis en vue de la
résolution des conflits
Librairie des normes PMI
Category TITLE
PMI Global Foundational
Standards
PMI American National
Standards
A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK®
Guide)
The Standard for Program Management
The Standard for Portfolio Management
Organizational Project Management Maturity Model (OPM3®
)
PMI Global Practice Standards
Practice Standard for Earned Value Management
Practice Standard for Scheduling
Practice Standard for Project Configuration Management
Practice Standard for Project Risk Management
Practice Standard for Work Breakdown Structures
Practice Standard for Project Estimating
PMI Global Standard
Application Area Extensions
Construction Extension to the PMBOK®
Guide
Government Extension to the PMBOK®
Guide
Software Development Extension to the PMBOK®
Guide
Practice Guides
Managing Change in Organizations: A Practice Guide
Navigating Complexity: A Practice Guide
Implementing Organizational Project Management: A Practice Guide
Business Analysis for Practitioners: A Practice Guide
Governance of Portfolios, Programs, and Projects: A Practice Guide
Requirements Management: A Practice Guide
Other products
Project Manager Competency Development Framework
PMI Lexicon of Project Management Terms (Online resource)
Project Manager Competency Development
Framework – Third Edition
Publication in Spring 2017,
with an electronic version
available ahead of print copy.
Librairie des Standards PMI
Introduced in 2012: The PMI
Lexicon of Project Management
Terms, an online resource.
Updated to Version 3.0 in 2015, with 45 new definitions.
2017 PMI Standards Library:
PMI Lexicon of Project Management Terms
Atelier / Discussion
• Quelles normes ou documents du PMI
utilisez-vous?
• Comment utilisez-vous ces documents
dans votre organisation?
Conformité (bien sûr!)
• ANSI demande une mise à jour des normes
au moins une fois chaque 5 ans
Évolution de la profession
• Les “bonnes pratiques” utilisées dans la
plupart de projets et la plupart du temps
Changer le monde !!
• “… améliorer la pratique de la gestion de
projet dans le monde, faisant ainsi une
différence pour toutes les cultures.”
16La vision du PMI quant aux normes
Développement de normes et
« exposure drafts » en cours
22
PMBOK® Guide – Sixth Edition (Publié 2Q2017)
The Standard for Business Analysis (Publié 4Q2017)
The Standard for Portfolio Management – Fourth
Edition (Exposure draft: ouvert pour commentaires jusqu’au 23
février 2017)
The Standard for Program Management – Fourth
Edition (Publié 4Q2017)
Agile Practice Guide (Publié 2Q2017)
Ligne de temps du PMBOK® Guide
1987
1996 20001983
2004
20131969
1998
Founded
2017
Comité central responsable de la version 6
Chair: Cyndi Snyder Dionisio (USA)
Vice-Chair: David Hillson (UK)
PMI Standards Specialist: Kristin Vitello (USA)
Core Committee (multinational, SMEs, high-performers)
• Mike Stratton (USA)
• Mercedes Martinez Sanz (Spain)
• Larkland Brown (USA)
• Pan Kao (China - USA)
• Guy Schleffer (Israel)
• Lynda Bourne (Australia)
• Gwen Whitman (USA)
• Alejandro Romero Torres (Canada - Mexico)
24
Parties prenantes participant à la révision
25
Member Advisory
Group MAG –
Standards (6)
PMBOK Core
Committee (10)
PMBOK
Extended
Committee (50)
Subject Matter
Experts (25)
Market Survey
and Research
PMI
community:
1200 reviewers
Composantes du PMBOK
26
PMBOK® Guide comprend plusieurs
parties:
• “The Standard for Project Management
of a Project”
• Annex A1 de la 5e édition,
maintenant séparé dans la 6e édition
• “A Guide to the Project Management
Body of Knowledge”
• Front End (Chapitres 1-3)
• Knowledge Areas (Chapitres 4-13)
• Back End (Annexes, Références,
Glossaire)
Sources des changements
28
Commentaires de la version 5 par la communauté
du PMI
Sondage réalisé par le PMI
• 615 répondants en Janvier 2015
Region # Completes
North America (NA) 235
Asia Pacific (AP) 181
EMEA 172
Latin America & Caribbean
(LA) 27
Total 615
Functional Unit # Completes
Information Technology 308
Production / Operations 141
Research and
Development
56
Sales & Marketing 16
Finance & Accounting 12
Human Resources 7
Other 75
Total 615
Non IT function
(n=307)
Sources des changements
29
Résultats de recherche
• Besner, C. & Hobbs, B. (2012). Contextualisation of project
management practice and best practice, Project Management
Institute
• Aubry, M., Drouin, N., Jugdev, K., Muller, R., & Shao, J. (2012).
Organizational Enablers for Organizational Project Management.
• Muller, R., Cooke-Davies, T. & Sagahiri, S. (2011) Academic Research
Input into the Project Management Standards Program, International
Centre for Project Management.
• PMI (2014). The pulse of the profession: the high cost of the low
performance, Project Management Institute
• Et autres selon chaque domaine de connaissances
Participer aux activités de développement
ou révision des standards
Des milliers de bénévoles donnent de leur
temps pour participer à l'établissement de
normes et ce pour de nombreuses raisons:
• Faire progresser la profession
• Influence
• Réseautage
• Gestion
• Leadership
31
Atelier / Discussion
• Quelles améliorations proposeriez-vous
pour améliorer le processus de
développement ou révision d’une norme?
• Comment pourriez-vous participer dans ce
processus?
Depuis plus de 60 ans (fondé en 1947)
Plus de 21 000 normes
161 pays participants sur base volontaire
150 employés permanents
PMI Standards Activities at the
International Level
ISO/TC258 –
Project, programme, and portfolio management
Standard for Project Management (ISO 21500)
Standard for Portfolio management (ISO 21504)
Standard for Governance is due to be published in the near future.
Standard for Program management to be published by the end of
2017.
Other TC258 activities include Vocabulary, WBS, EVM, and
Competencies.
39 countries are participating members of TC258.
Standards Overview Presentation 33
Échéancier – PC-236
NP: New Project
WD: Working Document
CD: Committee Draft
DIS: Draft International Standard
FDIS: Final draft International Standard
FS: Final Standard
(Site Internet: Australian Mirror Committee)
37
Atelier / Discussion
• Quels normes ou guides, le PMI devrait-il
développer?
• De quelle façon pourriez-vous utiliser plus
ces normes dans votre organisation?
ATELIER-CONFÉRENCE :
LE DÉVELOPPEMENT DES NORMES EN GESTION DE
PROJET
38
Yvan Petit, M.Ing. M.B.A., Ph.D.,
PMP, PfMP
Alejandro Romero, M.Ing.
Ph.D., PMP
Notes de l'éditeur
This is a representation of all the standards that are currently available in our marketplace. We currently have four foundational standards (PMBOK® Guide - Fifth Edition, The Standard for Program Management - Third Edition, The Standard for Portfolio Management - Third Edition & Organizational Project Management Maturity Model (OPM3) Knowledge Foundation - Third Edition), three extensions (Software Extension to the PMBOK® Guide Fifth Edition, Government Extension to the PMBOK® Guide Third Edition, Construction Extension to the PMBOK® Guide Third Edition), six Practice Standards (Practice Standard for Work Breakdown Structures - Second Edition, Practice Standard for Scheduling - Second Edition, Practice Standard for Project Risk Management, Practice Standard for Project Configuration Management, Practice Standard for Earned Value Management – Second Edition and Practice Standard for Project Estimating), one framework (Project Manager Competency Development Framework – Second Edition) and three Practice Guides (Managing Change in Organizations: A Practice Guide, Navigating Complexity: A Practice Guide, and Implementing Organization Project Management: A Practice Guide.)
Why participate in standards development?
To influence the content of standards
To manage the impact of a standard on an organization or industry
For increased networking opportunities and making business connections
To “test market” new concepts
To obtain public perception of being a good corporate citizen (it also looks good on a resume)
To be perceived as an industry leader and innovator—not a follower.
PMI usually has several open projects going on at a given time, and invites volunteers from the project management community who want to contribute to join these project teams.
You don’t have to be a PMI member to participate! We ask for 2-3 hours per week from a volunteer.
The Project Committees are virtual and global, with most of team interactions done by e-mail, phone (conference calls), intranet sites, etc.
Participation is free; there’s no charge to participate. Toll free numbers and a team internet site are provided to the teams for their work.
What is wrong with 5th edition?
As a member of the American National Standards Institute, PMI has to follow certain requirements for updating its ANSI certified standards. One of those requirements is to review the Standard every 5 years and either update it, discontinue it, or leave it as is. PMI uses a four year cycle rather than a five year cycle. Thus we are updating the standard based on an ANSI requirement.
But really…projects are how change happens. It is how we improve products and services, innovate and develop new technology, build infrastructure, and generally make the planet a better place. So we say that we want to improve the practice of project management around the globe, thereby making a difference for all cultures.
The PMI Standards Program Member Advisory Group (MAG) acts as an advisory team to the PMI Standards Department Manager. Some of the responsibilities of the MAG are to advise on the formal selection of projects, assignment of project managers, and on-going over-sight of project progress. They also assist in developing and maintaining PMI Standards Group administration processes and project management methodology processes for managing PMI Standards projects.
ANSI process helps ensure the development of a single American National Standard that does not overlap or conflict with other American National Standards
Use of an accredited, audited process enhances credibility of the resulting standard
ANSI requirements ensure the opportunity for all affected stakeholders to participate in the standards development process
American National Standards are referenced in regulations and legislation throughout the U.S. and internationally.
1969: PMI was founded.
1983: PMI published its first standard as part of the Special Report on Ethics, Standards and Accreditation (ESA).
1987: PMI published the PMBOK® Standards, the precursor to the 1996 version of A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK® Guide).
1996: PMI realized no one document contained the entire body of knowledge and published A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK® Guide). This update introduced the process orientation, the five Process Groups, renamed the functions as Knowledge Areas, and added Project Integration Management as the 9th Knowledge Area.
1998: PMI is accredited as a Standards Development Organization (SDO) by ANSI.
2000: PMBOK® Guide—2000 Edition (second edition) is published.
2004: PMBOK® Guide—Third Edition is published.
2008: PMBOK® Guide—Fourth Edition is published, coinciding with the 25th Anniversary of the PMBOK® Guide
2013: PMBOK® Guide - Fifth Edition is published.
Selecting the team was a really intense process. We had over 100 very well qualified people from around the globe that volunteered to take place in this project. Unfortunately we could only have 10. Of the ten core committee members, half are PhDs, one of them is the very first PhD in project management. We have people from Australia, Israel, the United Kingdom, Spain, Canada and the US. We have academics, consultants, government employees, and individuals from global corporations.
In addition to the core committee we have over 50 content contributors and other volunteers. And we have approximately 25 subject matter experts that review our work and provide feedback. Plus…the Standards MAG provides input and advice.
Selecting the team was a really intense process. We had over 100 very well qualified people from around the globe that volunteered to take place in this project. Unfortunately we could only have 10. Of the ten core committee members, half are PhDs, one of them is the very first PhD in project management. We have people from Australia, Israel, the United Kingdom, Spain, Canada and the US. We have academics, consultants, government employees, and individuals from global corporations.
In addition to the core committee we have over 50 content contributors and other volunteers. And we have approximately 25 subject matter experts that review our work and provide feedback. Plus…the Standards MAG provides input and advice.
« Le Standard de gestion de projets » est un standard certifié ANSI
Demande un processus d'examen formel
Exposé-sondage
Tous les commentaires examinés formellement
Les décisions peuvent être portées en appel, tous les appels jugées
MAG Review
Vote Consensus Body
Why participate in standards development?
To influence the content of standards
To manage the impact of a standard on an organization or industry
For increased networking opportunities and making business connections
To “test market” new concepts
To obtain public perception of being a good corporate citizen (it also looks good on a resume)
To be perceived as an industry leader and innovator—not a follower.
PMI usually has several open projects going on at a given time, and invites volunteers from the project management community who want to contribute to join these project teams.
You don’t have to be a PMI member to participate! We ask for 2-3 hours per week from a volunteer.
The Project Committees are virtual and global, with most of team interactions done by e-mail, phone (conference calls), intranet sites, etc.
Participation is free; there’s no charge to participate. Toll free numbers and a team internet site are provided to the teams for their work.
http://www.iso.org/iso/fr/home/about.htm?=
Doit être asccepté par au moins 75% des membres votants