SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  56
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Key Growth Sectors in the 
Health-Care Services M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
May 1, 2014 
The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 1
Webcast Information: 
 The webcast can be accessed online and/or by phone. 
 A copy of the slide presentation is sent to each registered 
participant; it is also available by logging in to your online 
account at www.levinassociates.com/user. 
 If you have any trouble with the webcast, please call (800)248- 
1668 for assistance. 
 You can ask questions at any time; use the online question box 
or fax them to THE MERGER AND ACQUISITION WEBCAST at 
(203)846-8300. 
The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 2
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
May 1, 2014 
Agenda: 
 Introduction: Today’s market 
 When to buy, when to sell 
 M&A activity: Hospitals and physicians group sectors 
 M&A activity: Managed care sector, financing 
PLEASE NOTE: You will be given the opportunity to ask questions live during the call. You may also fax 
your questions to (203)846-8300 at any time. 
The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 3
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Christopher Carnahan 
President 
Carnahan Group 
chris.carnahan@carnahangroup.com 
www.carnahangroup.com 
Christopher Carnahan has more than 21 
years of experience in health care and 
finance. He has held executive-level 
positions in health care, technology, and 
manufacturing. Chris is the founder of 
Carnahan Group, Inc. and is responsible for 
the leadership, strategic direction, and 
financial matters of the firm. Chris has been 
involved with more than 150 medical staff 
demand analyses for not-for-profit and for-profit 
entities, including modeling demand 
and supply analysis for health-care services 
within diverse communities. 
The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 4
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Robert James Cimasi 
Chief Executive Officer 
Health Capital Consultants 
rcimasi@healthcapital.com 
www.healthcapital.com 
Robert James Cimasi, MHA, ASA, FRICS, 
MCBA, CVA, CM&AA, serves as Chief Executive 
Officer of Health Capital Consultants (HCC), a 
nationally recognized healthcare financial and 
economic consulting firm headquartered in St. 
Louis, MO, serving clients in 49 states since 
1993. Bob has over thirty years of experience in 
serving clients, with a professional focus on the 
financial and economic aspects of healthcare 
service sector entities including: valuation 
consulting and capital formation services; 
healthcare industry transactions including joint 
ventures, mergers, acquisitions, and 
divestitures; litigation support & expert 
testimony; and, certificate-of-need and other 
regulatory and policy planning consulting. 
The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 5
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Court Houseworth 
Managing Director 
Cain Brothers 
chouseworth@cainbrothers.comw 
ww.cainbrothers.com 
Court Houseworth, Managing Director, 
joined Cain Brothers in 2004 in San Francisco 
and serves as the co-head of the firm’s 
Managed Care and Behavioral Health 
investment banking practices. Prior to 
joining the firm, Court had been a managing 
director at Lehman Brothers and Bear 
Stearns. Over the past 25 years, Court has 
been involved in mergers and acquisitions, 
debt and equity financings, restructurings, 
valuations, and not-for-profit conversions. 
Cain Brothers has more experience with 
mid-market health-care transactions than 
any advisory firm. 
The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 6
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Scott Li 
Vice President 
Hammond Hanlon Camp LLC 
sli@h2cllc.com 
www.h2cllc.com 
Scott Li is a vice president in the New York 
office of Hammond Hanlon Camp LLC. With 
more than 10 years of experience across roles 
in investment banking and the health-care 
industry, Scott provides strategic and financial 
advisory services to a variety of health-care 
clients. He has recently completed or is 
actively working on engagements for clients in 
the hospital, senior living, and health IT 
sectors. Prior to joining Hammond Hanlon 
Camp LLC, Scott was Chief Financial Officer of 
pingmd, a provider of an online 
communication platform for primary care 
physicians. . 
The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 7
Investing In 
Christopher Carnahan Court Houseworth 
(Moderator) 
Scott Li 
Robert Cimasi 
8
Healthcare Continuum 
Prevention 
Diagnosis 
Treatment 
Cure 
Death 
© 2014 Carnahan Group 9
Patients Drive $ 
© 2014 Carnahan Group 10
Patient Lifetime Expenditures 
© 2014 Carnahan Group 11
Personal Economics 
© 2014 Carnahan Group 12
The Economics 
• Total Healthcare spending $2.8 
trillion 
• Population: 318,892,103 
• Life Expectancy: 78.5 
• Average healthcare spending per 
capita: $8,233 
• Growth rate: Depends on who you 
ask 
– Assume long term growth of 3% 
• Total life time spending: $2,793,566 
© 2014 Carnahan Group 13
Impact of Growth 
2% Growth Rate 
Growth Rate i 2% 
Life Expectancy n 78.5 
Average Spending per Capita PMT $ 8,233 
Future Value FV $ 1,948,236 
3% Growth Rate 
Growth Rate i 3% 
Life Expectancy n 78.5 
Average Spending per Capita PMT $ 8,233 
Future Value FV $ 2,793,566 
4% Growth Rate 
Growth Rate i 4% 
Life Expectancy n 78.5 
Average Spending per Capita PMT $ 8,233 
Future Value FV $ 4,473,169 
© 2014 Carnahan Group 14
Macro Economics 2012 
• Hospital Care: increased 4.9 percent to $882.3 billion 
• Physician and Clinical Services: increased 4.6 percent to 
$565.0 billion 
• Other Professional Services: $76.4 billion 
• Dental Services: increased 3.0 percent to $110.9 billion 
• Other Health, Residential, and Personal Care Services: 
grew 4.5 percent to $138.2 billion 
• Home Health Care: increased 5.1 percent to $77.8 billion 
• Nursing Care Facilities and Continuing Care Retirement 
Communities: increased 1.6 percent to $151.5 billion 
• Prescription Drugs: grew 0.4 percent to $263.3 billion 
• Durable Medical Equipment: Retail spending reached 
$41.3 billion 
• Other Non-durable Medical Products: Retail spending for 
over-the-counter medicines, medical instruments, and 
surgical dressings grew 1.8 percent to $53.7 billion 
Source: CMS National Health Expenditures 2012 Highlights 
© 2014 Carnahan Group 15
Trends …Consolidation 
• “Healthcare is a low-margin economic 
activity. Almost a quarter of American 
hospitals are already losing money. 
With that number bound to increase in 
coming years, we already know what 
to expect because we’ve seen it 
before in the airline, supermarket, 
phone and electronics businesses. 
There will be a wave of mergers and 
acquisitions to improve quality and 
lower costs.” Delos Cosgrove, M.D. – CEO and President at 
Cleveland Clinic (Article: The Great Consolidation Begins) 
© 2014 Carnahan Group 16
Deal Winners 
M&A Deal Volume for 2011 and 2012 
Deal Volume Dollar Volume 
Sector 2012 2011 % 
Changed 
2012 2011 % 
Changed 
Behavioral Care 17 13 30.8% $1,005,650,000 $304,488,600 230.6% 
Home Health & Hospice 35 29 20.7% $5,718,950,000 $289,992,000 1872.1% 
Managed Care 27 20 35.0% $18,815,500,000 $7,906,000,000 138.0% 
Physician Medical Groups 68 108 -37.0% $4,411,539,350 $466,534,545 845.6% 
Selected items from 
Source: Irving Levin Associates, January 2013 
Pasted from <http://www.levinassociates.com/pr2013/pr1301mamyearend> 
© 2014 Carnahan Group 17
Perspectives on Healthcare Services M&A Trends 
HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 
May 1, 2014
Overview of Hammond Hanlon Camp 
 Hammond Hanlon Camp (“H2C”) LLC is a healthcare-focused strategic advisory and investment banking firm with 
a particular emphasis on the not-for-profit sector 
 H2C traces its heritage back almost 30 years through its predecessor organizations, including Shattuck Hammond 
Partners 
 H2C has assembled a team of professionals that have worked with leading health systems across the country and 
executed many of the most creative transactions in the not-for-profit healthcare industry 
– Senior professionals average over 20 years of experience serving not-for-profit health systems 
 Offices in Atlanta, Chicago, New York and San Diego 
 Lead advisor on hundreds of transactions in the healthcare industry representing billions of dollars in value 
Strategic Advisory 
 Services designed to assist 
organizations in evaluation of 
options prior to transaction 
Capital Markets & Derivatives 
 Financial advisor and/or 
placement 
agent on all types of debt and 
derivative transactions 
Mergers & Acquisitions 
 Advisor on all types of 
affiliations, joint ventures, 
acquisitions and divestiture 
transactions 
Restructuring 
 Financial advisor to restructure 
distressed credits / sell assets 
Real Estate 
 Advisor on monetization and 
project financing of real estate 
assets 
Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 19
Healthcare Provider Strategic Context 
Tailwinds 
 Demographics: aging 
population, increasing 
life expectancy, etc. 
 Push to lower cost of 
care settings (for certain 
sectors) 
 Newly insured 
population growing 
Headwinds 
 Reimbursement 
uncertainty due to ACA 
 Shift from volume to 
value 
 Intensifying focus on 
cost and choice for 
consumers and insurers 
Econom 
y 
Post-Reform 
Environment 
Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 20
The New Normal 
The realities of shifting from volume to value are causing financial forecasts to evolve 
Illustrative Hospital Operating Income Projections 
Challenging 
reimbursement 
environment 
Inpatient 
admissions 
under pressure 
Shift from 
commercial to 
exchanges 
Increasing 
consumerism 
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 
Projected Operating Income 
Prior Forecast Post-Reform Revised Post-Reform Downside 
Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 21
Not THAT Kind of Sustainability: the New Model for Survival 
Across the continuum of care, providers will need to possess or develop many 
attributes to achieve sustainability or permanence in serving their community or 
customers 
Essential 
market 
position and 
critical mass 
Capital 
Integrated 
physicians 
High quality 
leadership 
and staff 
Measurable 
quality and 
cost 
effectiveness 
Alignment 
with other 
providers / 
payors 
IT and care 
managemen 
t 
infrastructur 
es 
Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 22
2, 4, 6, 8…Who Do We Integrate? 
There are many ways for providers to access or offer these skills and attributes 
 With the ACA sparking new payment systems – bundled payments, capitation, 
narrow networks – the delivery of and payment for service is becoming 
significantly more challenging 
 Hospitals have been and will continue to be the core of the health care system 
but the system will be different 
 A blurring of traditional lines between healthcare service sectors has continued 
with upstream or downstream diversification increasingly common 
– Revenue diversification via cross-sector activity 
– Payer-provider convergence 
– Post-acute or behavioral health capabilities via ownership or partnership 
 The critical questions are: 
– Which of these components will hospitals integrate into their systems? 
– How will providers in other parts of the continuum respond? 
 Overall, providers will be joining together in vertically stacked organizations 
or networks to provide and bill for service 
Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 23
New Kinds of Dance Partners 
 Once upon time, consolidation meant organizations in the same business joined 
forces 
 No longer as simple as saying bigger is better, even though that is often true 
 The new paradigm dictates that providers will need to align, partner, or merge 
with others in the continuum of care for a variety of skills and competencies 
– Population health management capabilities 
– Marketing capabilities to respond to increasing consumerism 
– IT impacting strategic decisions 
– Acquiring or refining activities in other parts of the continuum 
 Access to capital is critical and whether the debt and equity markets are 
supportive will be an especially important consideration 
 Comfort with for-profit operators is growing 
– For-profit management style for not-for-profit organizations – “No Margin, No 
Mission” has never been more applicable 
 Private equity will continue to be a growing force across the continuum of care 
Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 24
Reassessing the Toolkit 
Monetization to 
Improve Balance 
Sheet 
Sharpen Focus on 
Core Businesses 
Harvesting 
Non-Core Assets 
Enhance Service 
Quality and/or 
Reduce Cost 
Increase Managerial 
Bandwidth 
Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 25
Will the M&A Activity Work? 
“Only time will tell whether this merger makes sense or not” 
Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 26
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
The Four Pillars 
27
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
28 
Physician Primacy 
Integration & Coordination Driving Consolidation 
“Healthcare Valuation: The Financial Appraisal of Enterprises, Assets, and Services,” Robert 
James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, p. 980.
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Supply of Physicians, 1975 – 2011 
29 
450,000 
400,000 
350,000 
300,000 
250,000 
200,000 
150,000 
100,000 
50,000 
- 
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2011 
Primary Care 
Specialty Care 
Surgeons 
“Physician Characteristics and Distribution in the U.S.: 2013 Edition,” Derek R. Smart, American 
Medical Association, 2013, p. 288, 441.
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Physician Supply and Demand 
1,000,000 
900,000 
800,000 
700,000 
600,000 
500,000 
400,000 
300,000 
200,000 
100,000 
0 
2008 2010 2015 2020 2025 
Supply Demand 
-The difference 
between supply and 
demand represents 
the anticipated 
physician shortage. 
“Physician Shortages to Worsen Without Increases in Residency Training” Association of American Medical College, 
https://www.aamc.org/download/153160/data/physician_shortages_to_worsen_without_increases_in_residency_tr.pdf 
(Accessed 4/30/14) 30
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Physician Shortage 
70000 
60000 
50000 
40000 
30000 
20000 
10000 
0 
2008 2010 2015 2020 2025 
Specialist Shortage PC Shortage 
Total Physician Shortage 
7,400 13,700 62,900 91,500 130,600 
“Physician Shortages to Worsen Without Increases in Residency Training” Association of American Medical College, 
https://www.aamc.org/download/153160/data/physician_shortages_to_worsen_without_increases_in_residency_tr.pdf 
(Accessed 4/30/14) 
31
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Percent Change in Physician Practice Setting 
Since 2000 
“Physician Characteristics and Distribution in the US” American Medical Association, 2002-2003 edition, p. 329; 2003-2004 
edition, p. 320; 2004 edition, p. 322; 2005 edition, p. 311; 2006 edition, p. 311; 2007 edition, p. 311; 2008 edition, p. 403; 2009 
edition, p. 406; 2010 edition, p. 438; 2011 edition, p. 436. 2011 edition, p. 436; 2012 edition, p. 440; 2013 edition, p. 440. 
125% 
120% 
115% 
110% 
105% 
100% 
95% 
1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 
Physicians in 
Office-Based Practices 
Physicians in 
Hospital-Based Practices 
Total Patient 
Care Physicians 
32
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Organizational Models of Alignment 
Emerging Models in an Era of Reform 
Degree of 
Hospital 
Control 
MOST LEAST 
"A Guide to Consulting Services for Emerging Healthcare Organization," By Robert James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, New 
York, NY, 1999, p. 51-56, 163. “Healthcare Valuation: The Financial Appraisal of Enterprises, Assets, and Services,” Robert 
James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, p. 646. “Hospital/Physician Integration: Three Key Models” by Michael A. Cassidy et 
al., American Health Lawyers Association, October 2011, p. 9. 
33 
Model Description 
Solo/Group Medical Practice Physicians practice independently 
Independent Practice Association (IPA) 
Legal entities of independent physicians that contract with health insurance companies to 
provide medical services 
Co-Management Arrangement 
Typically formed through a contractual agreement between a group of physicians and a 
hospital, for the purpose of the physicians providing management services to a specified 
hospital service line related to the specialty of the contracted physicians 
Management Services Agreement 
(MSA)/Organization (MSO) 
A legal entity that provides administrative and practice management services to a 
physician entity that is owned by participating physicians and that contracts with the MSO 
for services 
Accountable Care Organization (ACO) 
Participant 
A legal entity recognized and authorized under applicable State, Federal, or Tribal Law 
that is identified by a Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN) and is formed by one or more 
ACO participant(s) 
Physician Practice Management 
Company (PPMC) 
Company specializing in physician practice management with the goal of earning a profit; 
often purchase or affiliate with physicians, offering capital, management experience, 
economies of scale, and economic security 
Physician Hospital Organization (PHO) 
(“Clinically Integrated Network”) 
Unites Hospital with Physician through a contractual relationship. Usually owned by 
Physicians and Hospitals, and in many cases non-profit 
Professional Service Agreement (PSA) 
An agreement in which an entity contracts with a physician practice, requiring the 
physician practice to provide professional medical services on behalf of the contracting 
entity 
Physician Hospital Organization (PHO) 
(“Clinically Integrated Network”) 
Unites Hospital with Physician through a contractual relationship. Usually owned by 
Physicians and Hospitals, and in many cases non-profit 
Physician Employment Agreement (PEA) 
Hospital purchases some or all of a medical practice’s assets and begin employing the 
former medical group’s physicians directly
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Provider Consolidation 
Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs) 
• Healthcare organizations with a coordinated set of 
providers 
• Provider mix dependent on whether it is a federal or 
commercial ACO structure 
• Share responsibility and accountability for the 
continuum of care 
• Clinical accountability – Quality of care 
• Financial responsibility – Cost of care 
“Perspectives on Accountable Care Organizations-ACO Overview” by Robert James Cimasi, 2011 International Expo, Health 
Industry Group Purchasing Association & healthcare Industry Supply Chain Institute, Washington, D.C.: Oct. 12-14, 2011, p. 2. 
34 
34
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Different Approaches to Managing the 
Entire Continuum of Care for the Patient 
Historical Forces: 
• Practice of medicine has historically been viewed as a learned profession, 
with physicians perceived as professionals who applied their training and 
knowledge to provide quality patient care within their independent 
practices. 
• Shift from physician-owned, independent private practices to captive 
practices with multiple affiliations within larger integrated health systems; 
another step towards the “corporatization” of professional practices, in 
contrast to the “cottage industry” healthcare delivery system of the past. 
• Healthcare costs continue to rise faster than inflation, driven by advances in 
technology and treatment, as well the increased demand for services from 
the growing baby-boomer population 
Result: A new healthcare delivery paradigm that promotes a 
managed “continuum of care,” in contrast to the current system of 
segmented independent provider “silos.” 
35
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Different Approaches to Managing the 
Entire Continuum of Care for the Patient 
• Provider affiliations are likely to increase due to: 
• Disproportionate number of physicians retiring 
• An inadequate supply medical graduates 
• Expected continuing growth in patient demand 
• The diversification, specialization, and collaboration of 
physician and non-physician practitioners will continue 
to grow to meet the compounding demand, including: 
• Allied health professionals 
• Mid-level providers 
• Technicians and paraprofessionals 
• Complementary and alternative medical practitioners 
36
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
What Has Changed This Time Around? 
• Alignment is being seen as an offensive strategy, 
not merely as a defensive one 
• Large single and multi-specialty groups are 
becoming more common and are often considered 
necessary to achieve optimal results 
• The loss of autonomy is seen as a fair trade-off for 
the benefits of being an employee 
• Much more experimentation 
• Direct employment is no longer the only option 
37
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Direct Employment 
A Fresh Look at an Old Concept 
• Hospitals like the ability to require employees to use their 
facilities (except when patient needs dictate otherwise) 
• Employment supports the use of clinical guidelines and 
emerging concepts such as the medical home 
• Provider-based reimbursement is sometimes available 
• Easier to invest in EMR technology 
• Avoids some of the more difficult aspects of Stark, e.g., 
the severe limits placed on under arrangement deals 
38
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
39
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Merger & Acquisition Volume, 2011-2013 
As derived and calculated from reported transactional data from The Healthcare M&A Report by 
Irving Levin Associates, INC. Quarterly Reports from 2011 to 2013; Note that of the MD 
purchasers, approximately 2/3 were reported as being the original group. As to the remaining 1/3 
of reported transactions, that fact may have been true, but was not reported. 
40 
A B C D E 
Year 
Total 
Deals 
Physician 
Medical Group 
Acquisition 
Non-Physician 
Medical Group 
Acquisition 
Reported Dollars 
Spent on 
Physician Medical 
Groups M&A 
1 2011 107 6 101 $464 Million 
2 2012 68 8 60 $4.4 Billion 
3 2013 65 3 62 $583 Million 
4 Total 240 17 223 $5.447 Billion
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Marcus Welby is Dead 
Increasing Complexity of Integration Transactions 
41
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Types of Tangible and Intangible 
Property/Assets in Healthcare 
“Valuation of Healthcare Entities and Assets: The Impact of 2010 Legislation” By Robert James Cimasi, 
CPA Leadership Institute (11/6/2012) p. 55. 
42
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
43 
“Healthcare Valuation: The Financial Appraisal of Enterprises, Assets, and Services,” Robert 
James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, p. 979.
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
44 
“Healthcare Valuation: The Financial Appraisal of Enterprises, Assets, and Services,” Robert 
James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, p. 980.
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
Managed Care 
Agreements and 
Provider Service 
Agreements 
HMO Enrollment 
Lists 
Assets 
Human Capital- 
Related Intangible 
Assets 
Employee and 
Provider 
Employee 
Agreements 
Trained and 
Assembled 
Workforce In- 
Place 
Non-Copyrighted 
Policies and 
Procedures 
Depth of 
Management 
Intellectual 
Property-Related 
Intangible Assets 
Clinical 
Practice 
Protocols and 
Treatment Plans 
Copyrights 
Trademarks and 
Trade names 
Patents 
Trade Secrets or 
Other Know 
How 
Payor or Client 
Related 
Operations and 
Location Related 
Intangible Assets 
Historical 
Information and 
Documentation 
Supplier 
Contracts 
Asset 
Assemblage 
Factors and 
Going Concern 
Value 
Governance or 
Legal Structure 
Related Intangible 
Assets 
Organizational 
Documents 
Income 
Distribution 
Plans 
Right of First 
Refusal 
Covenants-Not- 
To-Compete 
Marketing and 
Business 
Development 
Related Intangible 
Assets 
Advertising 
Franchise/ 
Licensing 
Agreements 
Joint Venture 
Alliances 
Regulatory or 
Legal-Related 
Intangible Assets 
Provider or 
Medical Licenses 
Certificates of 
Need 
Medicare 
Certification 
Other 
Certifications and 
Accreditations 
Financial or 
Revenue Stream- 
Related Intangible 
Assets 
Office Share 
Arrangements 
Management 
Service 
Agreements 
Financing 
Agreements 
Financial 
Derivatives 
Technology- 
Related Intangible 
Assets 
Computerized 
Management 
Information 
Systems 
Electronic 
Medical Records 
Maintenance and 
Support 
Relationships 
Patient-Related 
Intangible Assets 
Custodial 
Rights to the 
Patient Medical 
Charts and 
Records 
Patient Recall 
Lists 
Goodwill 
Professional 
/Personal 
Goodwill 
Practice/ 
Commercial 
Goodwill 
Easements 
Permits 
Leasehold 
Interests 
In-Place 
Leases 
Zoning 
Waivers/ 
Variances 
Use Rights 
Tangible 
Real 
Property 
Tangible 
Personal 
Property 
Cash and 
Investments 
Accounts 
Receivable 
Supplies & 
Drugs – 
Consumables 
and Inventory 
Held for Sale 
Furniture, 
Fixtures, and 
Equipment 
Leasehold 
Improvements 
Litigation 
Awards and 
Liquidated 
Damages 
Buildings 
Land and 
Land 
Improvements 
Subject Property Interest 
Tangible Assets Intangible Assets 
Intangible 
Real 
Property 
Intangible Personal Property 
45 
“Healthcare Valuation: The Financial Appraisal of Enterprises, Assets, and Services,” Robert 
James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, p. 981.
Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market 
Sponsored by Regions Bank 
46 
“Healthcare Valuation: The Financial Appraisal of Enterprises, Assets, and Services,” Robert 
James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, p. 982.
Webcast: "Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care 
Services M&A Market." 
Managed Care Industry M&A Perspectives 
May 1, 2014
48 
Managed Care Industry M&A Perspectives 
Introduction 
 The Affordable Care Act has caused companies and their executives to turn their attention from 
execution to evaluating and implementing strategic initiatives 
 With the implementation of Health Care Reform, companies are evaluating transactions which 
provide both greater scale and diversification 
 Connolly, an insurance payments auditing company, agreed to acquire iHealth Technologies, a medical claims company 
 Guardian entered an agreement to acquire Premier Access Insurance, a diversified dental benefits company 
 Walgreens and Water Street announced an agreement to merge Take Care Employer Solutions with CHS to form a new 
worksite health company 
 Rite Aid signed agreements to acquire Health Dialog and RediClinic to expand its overall health and wellness strategy 
 Highmark agreed to merge with Blue Cross of Northeastern Pennsylvania 
 DaVita, the leader in kidney dialysis, acquired HealthCare Partners to enter the physician practice management sector 
 Private equity firms have remained interested in acquiring payer related companies 
 Starr Investment Holdings LLC, led by former AIG CEO Hank Greenberg, acquired health insurance claims processor 
MultiPlan Inc for $4.4 billion from private equity firms BC Partners Ltd and Silver Lake 
 KKR acquired two leading Workers’ Comp businesses -- Sedgwick Claims Management Services for $2.4 billion and 
Mitchell International for $1.1 billion 
 Apax Partners acquired One Call Care Management and Align Networks for approximately $3 billion 
 Goldman Sachs acquired MagnaCare
49 
Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives 
Changing Industry Landscape 
The Affordable Care Act is dynamically changing the health care landscape by creating both 
opportunities and challenges that will require managed care organizations to adapt their traditional 
core businesses 
Sector Outlooks 
 Medicaid outlook very favorable due to PPACA expansion 
 Dual eligibles present significant opportunity for those that can effectively manage the population 
 Medicare outlook in the long-term is compelling, but near term reimbursement pressures will challenge plans 
 Individual and small group markets expected to face significant headwinds due to implementation of 
Changing 
Model 
 Renewed focus on controlling costs and improving outcomes through enhanced care management 
 Managing care will require new levels of coordination amongst providers and payers 
 Will require significant information technology investments 
 Increased interest in integrated delivery models between providers and payers 
Scale and 
Diversification 
 Scale will matter, which will lead to further increases in M&A activity 
 Consolidators will be looking to diversify product offerings 
 Increased focus on expansion of care management solutions 
Other Concerns 
 Access to capital will be a critical factor for not-for-profit and provider owned health plans 
 Overhang with respect to the economic recovery, unemployment rate trends and the impact of sequestration 
 Ability to pass along annual insurance fee to mitigate any meaningful impact on health plans
50 
Managed Care M&A Activity 
____________________ 
Source: Irving Levin Associates, PWC October 2013 White Paper, Barclays research. 
Note: Excludes workers’ compensation transactions. 
(1) Total combined deal value includes Irving Levin and Barclays research. Deal volume per Irving Levin research. 
(2) Only includes data for first quarter 2014. 
Deal Value (in millions) 
Deal Volume 
40 
35 
30 
25 
20 
15 
10 
5 
$25,000 
$20,000 
$15,000 
$10,000 
$5,000 
With increased visibility in the post reform era, health plans are expected to continue to use M&A as an 
avenue to increase scale, capabilities and diversification 
(1) 
Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives 
While 2012 was the most robust year for managed care M&A activity since 2005, 2013 and the first 
three months of 2014 were relatively quiet 
(2) 
0 
$0 
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 
Deal Value Deal Volume
51 
Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives 
Recent Acquisition Trends for Managed Care Plans 
Medicaid expansion and the need for cost-containing care management solutions have been driving 
the vast majority of recent M&A activity 
M&A Activity 
____________________ 
Source: Wall Street research. 
Government Programs 
 Commercial plans looking to diversify 
away from individual and small group 
to minimize expected headwinds from 
the exchanges 
 Medicaid plans looking to capitalize on 
Medicaid expansion from PPACA by 
entering new states or expanding 
footprint in existing geographies via 
acquisitions 
 Medicare Advantage plans looking to 
expand their scale in an effort to help 
offset expected MA reimbursement 
cuts and capitalize on long-term 
growth potential 
Providers 
Health Care Information 
Technology 
 Increased coordination with providers 
viewed as an effective tool to more 
effectively manage populations 
 Interest areas include participation in 
integrated provider systems and low-cost 
alternate site clinics 
 Particular interest in acquiring services 
that enable better management of high 
cost populations (chronically ill, elderly, 
etc.) 
 Renewed acquisition appetite of 
physician groups by payers 
 Post reform health care model 
requires an expansion of HCIT 
capabilities for many plans 
 Focus on increasing analytic 
capabilities for enhanced population 
health management 
 Heath Information Exchange platforms 
and solutions will become a necessity 
post reform 
 Payer organizations are vacillating 
between vendor relationships and 
ownership of core technology 
Since 2012, the large managed care companies have invested over $17 billion via acquisitions to improve 
positioning and capabilities to serve seniors, low-income individuals, and the dual eligible population
52 
Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives 
Recent M&A Activity 
Select Medicare 
Operations 
Pension Plans in 
Turkey 
PCCM Network Medicaid Contract 
(1) 
____________________ 
(1) Acquired non-controlling interest.
53 
Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives 
Recent M&A Activity (cont’d) 
Select Medicaid 
Operations 
Arcadian Medicare 
Operations in Arizona 
CareNex LLC 
____________________ 
(1) Announced sale of 1-800 Contacts to Thomas H. Lee Partners on January 8, 2014. 
(2) Acquired minority interest. 
(1) 
Plus One Health 
Management 
Other Selected M&A Activity 
Target Acquirer Target Acquirer Target Acquirer 
Citrus 
Universal 
Healthcare 
Amerigroup 
Virginia 
Michigan 
Ohio 
(2)
54 
Provider and payer consolidation trends have accelerated over the past several years, and these 
trends are expected to continue 
 Neither provider / payer integration nor provider risk-bearing entities are new 
concepts. Provider-owned health plans and other risk bearing provider organizations 
(i.e. capitation) have been around since the 1980s 
 However, few provider-owned plans are truly integrated with the provider owner, and 
risk-bearing entities have long histories only in limited geographies 
 There are approximately 100 provider-owned health plans that manage on average 
around 100,000 lives per plan 
 Strengthen primary care network directly or indirectly 
 Foster coordination among all participating providers 
 Remove fee-for-service payment incentives so as to appropriately manage volume 
and quality 
 Foster accountability for total per-capita costs 
 Provide tools to providers to bear risk and benefit from lower cost / higher quality 
 Develop limited networks in order to coordinate care and lower cost 
Provider and payer 
organization 
concept 
Objectives for 
providers and / or 
payer 
organizations 
Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives 
Provider and Payer Integration – An Accelerating Trend
55 
Recent consolidation activity has included payer acquisitions of providers 
Acquirer / 
Target 
 Highmark formed a 
holding company that is 
the parent of Highmark 
and of new Provider 
subsidiary (WPAHS) 
 WPAHS includes five 
acute care hospitals, 
1,600 beds, and over 
1,700 MDs on staff 
 Purchase Price = Not 
disclosed 
 Acquisition of more than 
75 physicians, 90,000 
active patients, including 
approximately 27,000 
Medicare beneficiaries 
 Purchase Price = $800 
million 
 NAMM is part of the Aveta’s 
family of companies – one of 
the largest providers of 
managed health care 
services 
 Acquisition of NAMM’s 600 
primary care providers and 
1,200 specialists 
 Purchase Price = Not 
disclosed 
 Minority equity 
investment by BCBSNC 
in FastMed. FastMed is 
the largest urgent care 
company in North 
Carolina and the second 
largest urgent care 
company in Arizona 
 Over 320,000 patient 
visits in 2012 
 WPAHS was a 
distressed system. 
Financial commitments 
by Highmark will 
maintain provider choice 
in the region 
 WPAHS part of a 
broader integrated 
delivery network strategy 
by Highmark 
 Driven by local market 
dynamics – competitor is 
an integrated 
provider/payer (UPMC) 
 Will bolster Florida Blue's 
value-based care 
presence in Tampa/St. 
Petersburg area 
 Acquisition will continue 
to promote 
implementation of 
additional aligned 
incentive models to meet 
Diagnostic Clinic Medical 
Group’s overall value-based 
goals of improving 
quality and enhancing 
member experiences 
while lowering overall 
cost 
 Allows continued expansion 
of a successful medical 
management model 
 Extends opportunities for 
UnitedHealth Group to build 
out further physician 
partnerships throughout the 
country 
 NAMM deal adds to strong 
Optum footprint in southern 
California, which includes 
Monarch, AppleCare Medical 
Group and Memorial 
HealthCare 
 Strategic collaboration 
will allow FastMed Urgent 
Care to expand its 
network of physician-owned 
urgent care clinics 
across North Carolina, 
while helping to launch 
innovative programs and 
services for BCBSNC 
customers 
 BCBSNC’s member 
population will receive 
increased access to 
convenient, high quality 
urgent care and lower 
medical costs 
____________________ 
Source: Company press releases and CapitalIQ. 
Transactio 
n Summary 
Transactio 
n Benefits 
and 
Nuances 
Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives 
Recent Provider-Payer Integration Activity
Confidential 
Cain Brothers’ Disclaimer 
This document is for discussion purposes only and does not constitute advice of any kind, including tax, accounting, legal or regulatory advice, and Cain 
Brothers & Company, LLC (“Cain Brothers”) is not and does not hold itself out to be an advisor as to tax, accounting, legal or regulatory matters. We 
recommend that you seek independent third party legal, regulatory, accounting and tax advice regarding the contents of this document. The matters 
discussed herein are subject to our review and assessment from a legal, compliance, accounting policy and risk perspective, as appropriate, following our 
discussion with you. 
This document was prepared on a confidential basis solely for discussion between you and Cain Brothers and not with a view toward public disclosure. This 
document, and any oral information provided in connection herewith, shall be treated as strictly confidential and may not be reproduced, distributed or 
disclosed, in whole or in part, except with our prior written consent. Cain Brothers assumes no obligation to update or otherwise revise these materials. 
No representation or warranty, express or implied, is made as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained herein and nothing contained 
herein is, or shall be relied upon as, a representation or warranty, whether as to the past or the future. Cain Brothers and our affiliates and our and their 
respective officers, employees and agents expressly disclaim any and all liability which may be based on this document and any errors therein or omissions 
therefrom. 
This document does not constitute an offer or solicitation to sell or purchase any securities and is not a commitment by Cain Brothers or any of its affiliates 
to provide or arrange any financing for any transaction or to purchase any security or act as an agent or advisor or in any other capacity in connection 
therewith. This document does not constitute a recommendation to pursue, and is not intended to provide the sole basis for evaluating, a particular 
transaction, and you retain full responsibility for the decision to pursue any specific transaction discussed herein or otherwise.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"
PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"
PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"PYA, P.C.
 
Don’t Stumble Coming Out of the Gate –Top Ten Issues to Address When Acquirin...
Don’t Stumble Coming Out of the Gate –Top Ten Issues to Address When Acquirin...Don’t Stumble Coming Out of the Gate –Top Ten Issues to Address When Acquirin...
Don’t Stumble Coming Out of the Gate –Top Ten Issues to Address When Acquirin...PYA, P.C.
 
Health Services Tax Conference Day One
Health Services Tax Conference Day OneHealth Services Tax Conference Day One
Health Services Tax Conference Day OnePwC
 
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medtech & Device Industry | Q4 2018
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medtech & Device Industry | Q4 2018 Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medtech & Device Industry | Q4 2018
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medtech & Device Industry | Q4 2018 Mercer Capital
 
Presentation Covers Physician Practice Compliance
Presentation Covers Physician Practice CompliancePresentation Covers Physician Practice Compliance
Presentation Covers Physician Practice CompliancePYA, P.C.
 
Riding the crest of digital health in APAC
Riding the crest of digital health in APACRiding the crest of digital health in APAC
Riding the crest of digital health in APACEY
 
Healthcare Valuations in an Era of Reform and Uncertainty
Healthcare Valuations in an Era of Reform and UncertaintyHealthcare Valuations in an Era of Reform and Uncertainty
Healthcare Valuations in an Era of Reform and UncertaintyPYA, P.C.
 
Hot Topics in Healthcare Valuation
Hot Topics in Healthcare ValuationHot Topics in Healthcare Valuation
Hot Topics in Healthcare ValuationPYA, P.C.
 
Presentation Uncovers Trends in the Unpredictable Healthcare Industry
Presentation Uncovers Trends in the Unpredictable Healthcare IndustryPresentation Uncovers Trends in the Unpredictable Healthcare Industry
Presentation Uncovers Trends in the Unpredictable Healthcare IndustryPYA, P.C.
 
Accounting Update Overview with a Healthcare Slant
Accounting Update Overview with a Healthcare SlantAccounting Update Overview with a Healthcare Slant
Accounting Update Overview with a Healthcare SlantPYA, P.C.
 
Using the Relief from Royalty Method to Value Trade Names
Using the Relief from Royalty Method to Value Trade NamesUsing the Relief from Royalty Method to Value Trade Names
Using the Relief from Royalty Method to Value Trade NamesPYA, P.C.
 
The Next Revolution in Healthcare: Why the New MSSP Revisions Matter Now More...
The Next Revolution in Healthcare: Why the New MSSP Revisions Matter Now More...The Next Revolution in Healthcare: Why the New MSSP Revisions Matter Now More...
The Next Revolution in Healthcare: Why the New MSSP Revisions Matter Now More...Health Catalyst
 
How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...
How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...
How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...PYA, P.C.
 
The FDA and industry: A recipe for collaborating in the New Health Economy
The FDA and industry:  A recipe for collaborating in the New Health EconomyThe FDA and industry:  A recipe for collaborating in the New Health Economy
The FDA and industry: A recipe for collaborating in the New Health EconomyPwC
 
Payer Analytics In A Shifting Healthcare Landscape - June Presentation To Chi...
Payer Analytics In A Shifting Healthcare Landscape - June Presentation To Chi...Payer Analytics In A Shifting Healthcare Landscape - June Presentation To Chi...
Payer Analytics In A Shifting Healthcare Landscape - June Presentation To Chi...Dan Wellisch
 
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible Assets
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible AssetsExploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible Assets
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible AssetsPYA, P.C.
 
The Future of Employer Health Insurance
The Future of Employer Health InsuranceThe Future of Employer Health Insurance
The Future of Employer Health InsuranceHealth Catalyst
 
Presentation Offers Valuation Strategies for Tax-Effective Practice Transactions
Presentation Offers Valuation Strategies for Tax-Effective Practice TransactionsPresentation Offers Valuation Strategies for Tax-Effective Practice Transactions
Presentation Offers Valuation Strategies for Tax-Effective Practice TransactionsPYA, P.C.
 

Tendances (20)

PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"
PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"
PYA Presentation: “Thorny Issues in FMV and Commercial Reasonableness"
 
Don’t Stumble Coming Out of the Gate –Top Ten Issues to Address When Acquirin...
Don’t Stumble Coming Out of the Gate –Top Ten Issues to Address When Acquirin...Don’t Stumble Coming Out of the Gate –Top Ten Issues to Address When Acquirin...
Don’t Stumble Coming Out of the Gate –Top Ten Issues to Address When Acquirin...
 
Cats Corporate Presentation_May_2017
Cats Corporate Presentation_May_2017 Cats Corporate Presentation_May_2017
Cats Corporate Presentation_May_2017
 
Health Services Tax Conference Day One
Health Services Tax Conference Day OneHealth Services Tax Conference Day One
Health Services Tax Conference Day One
 
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medtech & Device Industry | Q4 2018
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medtech & Device Industry | Q4 2018 Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medtech & Device Industry | Q4 2018
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medtech & Device Industry | Q4 2018
 
Presentation Covers Physician Practice Compliance
Presentation Covers Physician Practice CompliancePresentation Covers Physician Practice Compliance
Presentation Covers Physician Practice Compliance
 
Riding the crest of digital health in APAC
Riding the crest of digital health in APACRiding the crest of digital health in APAC
Riding the crest of digital health in APAC
 
Healthcare Valuations in an Era of Reform and Uncertainty
Healthcare Valuations in an Era of Reform and UncertaintyHealthcare Valuations in an Era of Reform and Uncertainty
Healthcare Valuations in an Era of Reform and Uncertainty
 
Hot Topics in Healthcare Valuation
Hot Topics in Healthcare ValuationHot Topics in Healthcare Valuation
Hot Topics in Healthcare Valuation
 
Presentation Uncovers Trends in the Unpredictable Healthcare Industry
Presentation Uncovers Trends in the Unpredictable Healthcare IndustryPresentation Uncovers Trends in the Unpredictable Healthcare Industry
Presentation Uncovers Trends in the Unpredictable Healthcare Industry
 
Accounting Update Overview with a Healthcare Slant
Accounting Update Overview with a Healthcare SlantAccounting Update Overview with a Healthcare Slant
Accounting Update Overview with a Healthcare Slant
 
Using the Relief from Royalty Method to Value Trade Names
Using the Relief from Royalty Method to Value Trade NamesUsing the Relief from Royalty Method to Value Trade Names
Using the Relief from Royalty Method to Value Trade Names
 
The Next Revolution in Healthcare: Why the New MSSP Revisions Matter Now More...
The Next Revolution in Healthcare: Why the New MSSP Revisions Matter Now More...The Next Revolution in Healthcare: Why the New MSSP Revisions Matter Now More...
The Next Revolution in Healthcare: Why the New MSSP Revisions Matter Now More...
 
How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...
How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...
How to Have a Successful Engagement and a Happily Ever After: “New Age” Nuanc...
 
The FDA and industry: A recipe for collaborating in the New Health Economy
The FDA and industry:  A recipe for collaborating in the New Health EconomyThe FDA and industry:  A recipe for collaborating in the New Health Economy
The FDA and industry: A recipe for collaborating in the New Health Economy
 
Payer Analytics In A Shifting Healthcare Landscape - June Presentation To Chi...
Payer Analytics In A Shifting Healthcare Landscape - June Presentation To Chi...Payer Analytics In A Shifting Healthcare Landscape - June Presentation To Chi...
Payer Analytics In A Shifting Healthcare Landscape - June Presentation To Chi...
 
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible Assets
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible AssetsExploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible Assets
Exploring Methodologies and Discount Rates in Valuing Intangible Assets
 
Therapix Bioscience
Therapix Bioscience Therapix Bioscience
Therapix Bioscience
 
The Future of Employer Health Insurance
The Future of Employer Health InsuranceThe Future of Employer Health Insurance
The Future of Employer Health Insurance
 
Presentation Offers Valuation Strategies for Tax-Effective Practice Transactions
Presentation Offers Valuation Strategies for Tax-Effective Practice TransactionsPresentation Offers Valuation Strategies for Tax-Effective Practice Transactions
Presentation Offers Valuation Strategies for Tax-Effective Practice Transactions
 

En vedette

Valuing Healthcare Management Services Agreements
Valuing Healthcare Management Services AgreementsValuing Healthcare Management Services Agreements
Valuing Healthcare Management Services AgreementsPYA, P.C.
 
From “Big Data” to Digital Medicine--PYA Explores Innovations in Healthcare
From “Big Data” to Digital Medicine--PYA Explores Innovations in HealthcareFrom “Big Data” to Digital Medicine--PYA Explores Innovations in Healthcare
From “Big Data” to Digital Medicine--PYA Explores Innovations in HealthcarePYA, P.C.
 
MSO Program Overview
MSO Program OverviewMSO Program Overview
MSO Program OverviewCRISP
 
Strategic Physician Solutions - Physician Advisory Council
Strategic Physician Solutions - Physician Advisory Council Strategic Physician Solutions - Physician Advisory Council
Strategic Physician Solutions - Physician Advisory Council Coors Healthcare Solutions
 
Gary Hourselt Healtheconomics 150219052339-conversion-gate02
Gary Hourselt Healtheconomics 150219052339-conversion-gate02Gary Hourselt Healtheconomics 150219052339-conversion-gate02
Gary Hourselt Healtheconomics 150219052339-conversion-gate02Gary Hourselt
 
Demand for healthcare umadhay
Demand for healthcare umadhayDemand for healthcare umadhay
Demand for healthcare umadhayBarryCRNA
 
Introduction to Health Economics
Introduction to Health EconomicsIntroduction to Health Economics
Introduction to Health EconomicsJosep Vidal-Alaball
 
Basics of Health Economics
Basics of Health EconomicsBasics of Health Economics
Basics of Health Economicseseidler
 
2016 Survey of US Physicians: Physician awareness, perspectives, and readines...
2016 Survey of US Physicians: Physician awareness, perspectives, and readines...2016 Survey of US Physicians: Physician awareness, perspectives, and readines...
2016 Survey of US Physicians: Physician awareness, perspectives, and readines...Deloitte United States
 
Roche's Acquisition of Genentech
Roche's Acquisition of GenentechRoche's Acquisition of Genentech
Roche's Acquisition of GenentechYu Cao
 

En vedette (19)

Valuing Healthcare Management Services Agreements
Valuing Healthcare Management Services AgreementsValuing Healthcare Management Services Agreements
Valuing Healthcare Management Services Agreements
 
Basics health economics
Basics health economicsBasics health economics
Basics health economics
 
From “Big Data” to Digital Medicine--PYA Explores Innovations in Healthcare
From “Big Data” to Digital Medicine--PYA Explores Innovations in HealthcareFrom “Big Data” to Digital Medicine--PYA Explores Innovations in Healthcare
From “Big Data” to Digital Medicine--PYA Explores Innovations in Healthcare
 
MSO Program Overview
MSO Program OverviewMSO Program Overview
MSO Program Overview
 
Strategic Physician Solutions - Physician Advisory Council
Strategic Physician Solutions - Physician Advisory Council Strategic Physician Solutions - Physician Advisory Council
Strategic Physician Solutions - Physician Advisory Council
 
Gary Hourselt Healtheconomics 150219052339-conversion-gate02
Gary Hourselt Healtheconomics 150219052339-conversion-gate02Gary Hourselt Healtheconomics 150219052339-conversion-gate02
Gary Hourselt Healtheconomics 150219052339-conversion-gate02
 
Demand for healthcare umadhay
Demand for healthcare umadhayDemand for healthcare umadhay
Demand for healthcare umadhay
 
THE SUPPLY OF HEALTH SERVICES
THE SUPPLY OF HEALTH SERVICESTHE SUPPLY OF HEALTH SERVICES
THE SUPPLY OF HEALTH SERVICES
 
THE DEMAND FOR HEALTH CARE
THE DEMAND FOR HEALTH CARETHE DEMAND FOR HEALTH CARE
THE DEMAND FOR HEALTH CARE
 
Introduction to Health Economics
Introduction to Health EconomicsIntroduction to Health Economics
Introduction to Health Economics
 
Health economics what is it
Health economics what is itHealth economics what is it
Health economics what is it
 
Health Economics
Health EconomicsHealth Economics
Health Economics
 
Basics of Health Economics
Basics of Health EconomicsBasics of Health Economics
Basics of Health Economics
 
Demand in health care
Demand in health careDemand in health care
Demand in health care
 
Health economics
Health economicsHealth economics
Health economics
 
Roche Genentech Acquisition Analysis
Roche   Genentech Acquisition AnalysisRoche   Genentech Acquisition Analysis
Roche Genentech Acquisition Analysis
 
2016 Survey of US Physicians: Physician awareness, perspectives, and readines...
2016 Survey of US Physicians: Physician awareness, perspectives, and readines...2016 Survey of US Physicians: Physician awareness, perspectives, and readines...
2016 Survey of US Physicians: Physician awareness, perspectives, and readines...
 
Health economics
Health economicsHealth economics
Health economics
 
Roche's Acquisition of Genentech
Roche's Acquisition of GenentechRoche's Acquisition of Genentech
Roche's Acquisition of Genentech
 

Similaire à Key Growth Sectors in the Health Care Services M&A Market

FLAACOs 2014 Conference - Shift in the Payer Movement in the Provider Space t...
FLAACOs 2014 Conference - Shift in the Payer Movement in the Provider Space t...FLAACOs 2014 Conference - Shift in the Payer Movement in the Provider Space t...
FLAACOs 2014 Conference - Shift in the Payer Movement in the Provider Space t...MARCYINC
 
Aco sept 21st
Aco sept 21stAco sept 21st
Aco sept 21stfwcroft
 
UNC DaVita Final Paper
UNC DaVita Final PaperUNC DaVita Final Paper
UNC DaVita Final PaperJacobs Connor
 
Quality Systems Presentation 04/01/10
Quality Systems Presentation 04/01/10Quality Systems Presentation 04/01/10
Quality Systems Presentation 04/01/10Quality Systems, Inc.
 
Valuing Physician Practices
Valuing Physician PracticesValuing Physician Practices
Valuing Physician PracticesErica Hammond
 
Healthcare Financial Transformation: Five Leading Strategies
Healthcare Financial Transformation: Five Leading StrategiesHealthcare Financial Transformation: Five Leading Strategies
Healthcare Financial Transformation: Five Leading StrategiesHealth Catalyst
 
Reasons Why You Need An Experienced Account Manager
Reasons Why You Need An Experienced Account ManagerReasons Why You Need An Experienced Account Manager
Reasons Why You Need An Experienced Account Managergingin4
 
Closing the Gaps in Behavioral and Mental Health Programs - Joy Figarsky, S...
 Closing the Gaps in Behavioral and Mental Health Programs  - Joy Figarsky, S... Closing the Gaps in Behavioral and Mental Health Programs  - Joy Figarsky, S...
Closing the Gaps in Behavioral and Mental Health Programs - Joy Figarsky, S...Healthcare Network marcus evans
 
HIDA Thought Leaders Paper Rodney Rotton
HIDA Thought Leaders Paper Rodney RottonHIDA Thought Leaders Paper Rodney Rotton
HIDA Thought Leaders Paper Rodney RottonRodney Cotton
 
The Coming Industrialization in Healthcare: a 360° View
The Coming Industrialization in Healthcare: a 360° ViewThe Coming Industrialization in Healthcare: a 360° View
The Coming Industrialization in Healthcare: a 360° ViewSage Growth Partners
 
Centric Health Corporation - Investor Presentation - May 2020
Centric Health Corporation - Investor Presentation - May 2020Centric Health Corporation - Investor Presentation - May 2020
Centric Health Corporation - Investor Presentation - May 2020SharePitch
 
Obamacare and the Health IT Opportunity with Christopher McCord
Obamacare and the Health IT Opportunity with Christopher McCordObamacare and the Health IT Opportunity with Christopher McCord
Obamacare and the Health IT Opportunity with Christopher McCordPlatform Houston
 
Health Services Tax Conference Day Two
Health Services Tax Conference Day TwoHealth Services Tax Conference Day Two
Health Services Tax Conference Day TwoPwC
 
2020 Medicare AEP Campaign Highlights - Media Logic
2020 Medicare AEP Campaign Highlights - Media Logic2020 Medicare AEP Campaign Highlights - Media Logic
2020 Medicare AEP Campaign Highlights - Media LogicMedia Logic
 
Personal care physicians series b preferred investment presentation
Personal care physicians series b preferred investment presentationPersonal care physicians series b preferred investment presentation
Personal care physicians series b preferred investment presentationPersonalCare
 
Preparing for Healthcare Transformation - John Reza
Preparing for Healthcare Transformation - John RezaPreparing for Healthcare Transformation - John Reza
Preparing for Healthcare Transformation - John RezaJohn Reza, MBA
 

Similaire à Key Growth Sectors in the Health Care Services M&A Market (20)

FLAACOs 2014 Conference - Shift in the Payer Movement in the Provider Space t...
FLAACOs 2014 Conference - Shift in the Payer Movement in the Provider Space t...FLAACOs 2014 Conference - Shift in the Payer Movement in the Provider Space t...
FLAACOs 2014 Conference - Shift in the Payer Movement in the Provider Space t...
 
pages
pagespages
pages
 
Aco sept 21st
Aco sept 21stAco sept 21st
Aco sept 21st
 
Top5Challengessm
Top5ChallengessmTop5Challengessm
Top5Challengessm
 
UNC DaVita Final Paper
UNC DaVita Final PaperUNC DaVita Final Paper
UNC DaVita Final Paper
 
Quality Systems Presentation 04/01/10
Quality Systems Presentation 04/01/10Quality Systems Presentation 04/01/10
Quality Systems Presentation 04/01/10
 
Where Is Healthcare Going? And How Will We Get There?
Where Is Healthcare Going? And How Will We Get There? Where Is Healthcare Going? And How Will We Get There?
Where Is Healthcare Going? And How Will We Get There?
 
Valuing Physician Practices
Valuing Physician PracticesValuing Physician Practices
Valuing Physician Practices
 
Healthcare Financial Transformation: Five Leading Strategies
Healthcare Financial Transformation: Five Leading StrategiesHealthcare Financial Transformation: Five Leading Strategies
Healthcare Financial Transformation: Five Leading Strategies
 
industry-in-focus
industry-in-focusindustry-in-focus
industry-in-focus
 
Reasons Why You Need An Experienced Account Manager
Reasons Why You Need An Experienced Account ManagerReasons Why You Need An Experienced Account Manager
Reasons Why You Need An Experienced Account Manager
 
Closing the Gaps in Behavioral and Mental Health Programs - Joy Figarsky, S...
 Closing the Gaps in Behavioral and Mental Health Programs  - Joy Figarsky, S... Closing the Gaps in Behavioral and Mental Health Programs  - Joy Figarsky, S...
Closing the Gaps in Behavioral and Mental Health Programs - Joy Figarsky, S...
 
HIDA Thought Leaders Paper Rodney Rotton
HIDA Thought Leaders Paper Rodney RottonHIDA Thought Leaders Paper Rodney Rotton
HIDA Thought Leaders Paper Rodney Rotton
 
The Coming Industrialization in Healthcare: a 360° View
The Coming Industrialization in Healthcare: a 360° ViewThe Coming Industrialization in Healthcare: a 360° View
The Coming Industrialization in Healthcare: a 360° View
 
Centric Health Corporation - Investor Presentation - May 2020
Centric Health Corporation - Investor Presentation - May 2020Centric Health Corporation - Investor Presentation - May 2020
Centric Health Corporation - Investor Presentation - May 2020
 
Obamacare and the Health IT Opportunity with Christopher McCord
Obamacare and the Health IT Opportunity with Christopher McCordObamacare and the Health IT Opportunity with Christopher McCord
Obamacare and the Health IT Opportunity with Christopher McCord
 
Health Services Tax Conference Day Two
Health Services Tax Conference Day TwoHealth Services Tax Conference Day Two
Health Services Tax Conference Day Two
 
2020 Medicare AEP Campaign Highlights - Media Logic
2020 Medicare AEP Campaign Highlights - Media Logic2020 Medicare AEP Campaign Highlights - Media Logic
2020 Medicare AEP Campaign Highlights - Media Logic
 
Personal care physicians series b preferred investment presentation
Personal care physicians series b preferred investment presentationPersonal care physicians series b preferred investment presentation
Personal care physicians series b preferred investment presentation
 
Preparing for Healthcare Transformation - John Reza
Preparing for Healthcare Transformation - John RezaPreparing for Healthcare Transformation - John Reza
Preparing for Healthcare Transformation - John Reza
 

Dernier

AI in Pediatrics: Taking Baby Steps in the Big World of Data
AI in Pediatrics: Taking Baby Steps in the Big World of DataAI in Pediatrics: Taking Baby Steps in the Big World of Data
AI in Pediatrics: Taking Baby Steps in the Big World of DataIris Thiele Isip-Tan
 
Subconjunctival Haemorrhage,causes,treatment..pptx
Subconjunctival Haemorrhage,causes,treatment..pptxSubconjunctival Haemorrhage,causes,treatment..pptx
Subconjunctival Haemorrhage,causes,treatment..pptxvideosfildr
 
The Best Diet for Preventing and Managing Kidney Stones .pptx
The Best Diet for Preventing and Managing Kidney Stones .pptxThe Best Diet for Preventing and Managing Kidney Stones .pptx
The Best Diet for Preventing and Managing Kidney Stones .pptxBarshaBarsha6
 
Immediate care of newborn, midwifery and obstetrical nursing
Immediate care of newborn, midwifery and obstetrical nursingImmediate care of newborn, midwifery and obstetrical nursing
Immediate care of newborn, midwifery and obstetrical nursingNursing education
 
Mark-Klimek-Lectures-1-To-12 NCLEX EXAMINATION
Mark-Klimek-Lectures-1-To-12 NCLEX EXAMINATIONMark-Klimek-Lectures-1-To-12 NCLEX EXAMINATION
Mark-Klimek-Lectures-1-To-12 NCLEX EXAMINATIONes5735583
 
The future of change - strategic translation
The future of change - strategic translationThe future of change - strategic translation
The future of change - strategic translationHelenBevan4
 
CASE STUDY ON CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE.pptx
CASE  STUDY ON CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE.pptxCASE  STUDY ON CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE.pptx
CASE STUDY ON CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE.pptxdrsriram2001
 
2024 Compliatric Webinar Series - OSV Overview and Panel Discussion April 202...
2024 Compliatric Webinar Series - OSV Overview and Panel Discussion April 202...2024 Compliatric Webinar Series - OSV Overview and Panel Discussion April 202...
2024 Compliatric Webinar Series - OSV Overview and Panel Discussion April 202...Compliatric Where Compliance Happens
 
Weighing the Risks and Benefits: Angioplasty at Gokuldas Hospitals
Weighing the Risks and Benefits: Angioplasty at Gokuldas HospitalsWeighing the Risks and Benefits: Angioplasty at Gokuldas Hospitals
Weighing the Risks and Benefits: Angioplasty at Gokuldas HospitalsGokuldas Hospital
 
Advance Directives and Advance Care Planning: Ensuring Patient Voices Are Heard
Advance Directives and Advance Care Planning: Ensuring Patient Voices Are HeardAdvance Directives and Advance Care Planning: Ensuring Patient Voices Are Heard
Advance Directives and Advance Care Planning: Ensuring Patient Voices Are HeardVITASAuthor
 
The Rise of Telehealth in Weight Loss - Revolutionizing Health .pdf
The Rise of Telehealth in Weight Loss - Revolutionizing Health .pdfThe Rise of Telehealth in Weight Loss - Revolutionizing Health .pdf
The Rise of Telehealth in Weight Loss - Revolutionizing Health .pdfmodmd8654
 
Unlocking the Mysteries of the Lymphatic System
Unlocking the Mysteries of the Lymphatic SystemUnlocking the Mysteries of the Lymphatic System
Unlocking the Mysteries of the Lymphatic SystemSasikiranMarri
 
Emergency ambulance portal-PPT-3g2pqy.pptx
Emergency ambulance portal-PPT-3g2pqy.pptxEmergency ambulance portal-PPT-3g2pqy.pptx
Emergency ambulance portal-PPT-3g2pqy.pptxdragonaklevel7
 
Information about acne, detail description of their treatment by topical and ...
Information about acne, detail description of their treatment by topical and ...Information about acne, detail description of their treatment by topical and ...
Information about acne, detail description of their treatment by topical and ...mauryashreya478
 
Back care and back massage. powerpoint presentation
Back care and back massage. powerpoint presentationBack care and back massage. powerpoint presentation
Back care and back massage. powerpoint presentationpratiksha ghimire
 
Preventing Common Nutritional Deficiencies In Poultry Flocks (PPT).pdf
Preventing Common Nutritional Deficiencies In Poultry Flocks (PPT).pdfPreventing Common Nutritional Deficiencies In Poultry Flocks (PPT).pdf
Preventing Common Nutritional Deficiencies In Poultry Flocks (PPT).pdfAditiAlishetty
 
arpita 1-1.pptx management of nursing service and education
arpita 1-1.pptx management of nursing service and educationarpita 1-1.pptx management of nursing service and education
arpita 1-1.pptx management of nursing service and educationNursing education
 
Local Advanced Esophageal Cancer (T3-4N0-2M0): Artificial Intelligence, Syner...
Local Advanced Esophageal Cancer (T3-4N0-2M0): Artificial Intelligence, Syner...Local Advanced Esophageal Cancer (T3-4N0-2M0): Artificial Intelligence, Syner...
Local Advanced Esophageal Cancer (T3-4N0-2M0): Artificial Intelligence, Syner...Oleg Kshivets
 

Dernier (20)

AI in Pediatrics: Taking Baby Steps in the Big World of Data
AI in Pediatrics: Taking Baby Steps in the Big World of DataAI in Pediatrics: Taking Baby Steps in the Big World of Data
AI in Pediatrics: Taking Baby Steps in the Big World of Data
 
Subconjunctival Haemorrhage,causes,treatment..pptx
Subconjunctival Haemorrhage,causes,treatment..pptxSubconjunctival Haemorrhage,causes,treatment..pptx
Subconjunctival Haemorrhage,causes,treatment..pptx
 
The Best Diet for Preventing and Managing Kidney Stones .pptx
The Best Diet for Preventing and Managing Kidney Stones .pptxThe Best Diet for Preventing and Managing Kidney Stones .pptx
The Best Diet for Preventing and Managing Kidney Stones .pptx
 
Immediate care of newborn, midwifery and obstetrical nursing
Immediate care of newborn, midwifery and obstetrical nursingImmediate care of newborn, midwifery and obstetrical nursing
Immediate care of newborn, midwifery and obstetrical nursing
 
Check Your own POSTURE & treat yourself.pptx
Check Your own POSTURE & treat yourself.pptxCheck Your own POSTURE & treat yourself.pptx
Check Your own POSTURE & treat yourself.pptx
 
Mark-Klimek-Lectures-1-To-12 NCLEX EXAMINATION
Mark-Klimek-Lectures-1-To-12 NCLEX EXAMINATIONMark-Klimek-Lectures-1-To-12 NCLEX EXAMINATION
Mark-Klimek-Lectures-1-To-12 NCLEX EXAMINATION
 
The future of change - strategic translation
The future of change - strategic translationThe future of change - strategic translation
The future of change - strategic translation
 
CASE STUDY ON CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE.pptx
CASE  STUDY ON CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE.pptxCASE  STUDY ON CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE.pptx
CASE STUDY ON CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE.pptx
 
2024 Compliatric Webinar Series - OSV Overview and Panel Discussion April 202...
2024 Compliatric Webinar Series - OSV Overview and Panel Discussion April 202...2024 Compliatric Webinar Series - OSV Overview and Panel Discussion April 202...
2024 Compliatric Webinar Series - OSV Overview and Panel Discussion April 202...
 
Dr Sujit Chatterjee Hiranandani Hospital Kidney.pdf
Dr Sujit Chatterjee Hiranandani Hospital Kidney.pdfDr Sujit Chatterjee Hiranandani Hospital Kidney.pdf
Dr Sujit Chatterjee Hiranandani Hospital Kidney.pdf
 
Weighing the Risks and Benefits: Angioplasty at Gokuldas Hospitals
Weighing the Risks and Benefits: Angioplasty at Gokuldas HospitalsWeighing the Risks and Benefits: Angioplasty at Gokuldas Hospitals
Weighing the Risks and Benefits: Angioplasty at Gokuldas Hospitals
 
Advance Directives and Advance Care Planning: Ensuring Patient Voices Are Heard
Advance Directives and Advance Care Planning: Ensuring Patient Voices Are HeardAdvance Directives and Advance Care Planning: Ensuring Patient Voices Are Heard
Advance Directives and Advance Care Planning: Ensuring Patient Voices Are Heard
 
The Rise of Telehealth in Weight Loss - Revolutionizing Health .pdf
The Rise of Telehealth in Weight Loss - Revolutionizing Health .pdfThe Rise of Telehealth in Weight Loss - Revolutionizing Health .pdf
The Rise of Telehealth in Weight Loss - Revolutionizing Health .pdf
 
Unlocking the Mysteries of the Lymphatic System
Unlocking the Mysteries of the Lymphatic SystemUnlocking the Mysteries of the Lymphatic System
Unlocking the Mysteries of the Lymphatic System
 
Emergency ambulance portal-PPT-3g2pqy.pptx
Emergency ambulance portal-PPT-3g2pqy.pptxEmergency ambulance portal-PPT-3g2pqy.pptx
Emergency ambulance portal-PPT-3g2pqy.pptx
 
Information about acne, detail description of their treatment by topical and ...
Information about acne, detail description of their treatment by topical and ...Information about acne, detail description of their treatment by topical and ...
Information about acne, detail description of their treatment by topical and ...
 
Back care and back massage. powerpoint presentation
Back care and back massage. powerpoint presentationBack care and back massage. powerpoint presentation
Back care and back massage. powerpoint presentation
 
Preventing Common Nutritional Deficiencies In Poultry Flocks (PPT).pdf
Preventing Common Nutritional Deficiencies In Poultry Flocks (PPT).pdfPreventing Common Nutritional Deficiencies In Poultry Flocks (PPT).pdf
Preventing Common Nutritional Deficiencies In Poultry Flocks (PPT).pdf
 
arpita 1-1.pptx management of nursing service and education
arpita 1-1.pptx management of nursing service and educationarpita 1-1.pptx management of nursing service and education
arpita 1-1.pptx management of nursing service and education
 
Local Advanced Esophageal Cancer (T3-4N0-2M0): Artificial Intelligence, Syner...
Local Advanced Esophageal Cancer (T3-4N0-2M0): Artificial Intelligence, Syner...Local Advanced Esophageal Cancer (T3-4N0-2M0): Artificial Intelligence, Syner...
Local Advanced Esophageal Cancer (T3-4N0-2M0): Artificial Intelligence, Syner...
 

Key Growth Sectors in the Health Care Services M&A Market

  • 1. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care Services M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank May 1, 2014 The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 1
  • 2. Webcast Information:  The webcast can be accessed online and/or by phone.  A copy of the slide presentation is sent to each registered participant; it is also available by logging in to your online account at www.levinassociates.com/user.  If you have any trouble with the webcast, please call (800)248- 1668 for assistance.  You can ask questions at any time; use the online question box or fax them to THE MERGER AND ACQUISITION WEBCAST at (203)846-8300. The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 2
  • 3. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank May 1, 2014 Agenda:  Introduction: Today’s market  When to buy, when to sell  M&A activity: Hospitals and physicians group sectors  M&A activity: Managed care sector, financing PLEASE NOTE: You will be given the opportunity to ask questions live during the call. You may also fax your questions to (203)846-8300 at any time. The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 3
  • 4. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Christopher Carnahan President Carnahan Group chris.carnahan@carnahangroup.com www.carnahangroup.com Christopher Carnahan has more than 21 years of experience in health care and finance. He has held executive-level positions in health care, technology, and manufacturing. Chris is the founder of Carnahan Group, Inc. and is responsible for the leadership, strategic direction, and financial matters of the firm. Chris has been involved with more than 150 medical staff demand analyses for not-for-profit and for-profit entities, including modeling demand and supply analysis for health-care services within diverse communities. The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 4
  • 5. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Robert James Cimasi Chief Executive Officer Health Capital Consultants rcimasi@healthcapital.com www.healthcapital.com Robert James Cimasi, MHA, ASA, FRICS, MCBA, CVA, CM&AA, serves as Chief Executive Officer of Health Capital Consultants (HCC), a nationally recognized healthcare financial and economic consulting firm headquartered in St. Louis, MO, serving clients in 49 states since 1993. Bob has over thirty years of experience in serving clients, with a professional focus on the financial and economic aspects of healthcare service sector entities including: valuation consulting and capital formation services; healthcare industry transactions including joint ventures, mergers, acquisitions, and divestitures; litigation support & expert testimony; and, certificate-of-need and other regulatory and policy planning consulting. The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 5
  • 6. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Court Houseworth Managing Director Cain Brothers chouseworth@cainbrothers.comw ww.cainbrothers.com Court Houseworth, Managing Director, joined Cain Brothers in 2004 in San Francisco and serves as the co-head of the firm’s Managed Care and Behavioral Health investment banking practices. Prior to joining the firm, Court had been a managing director at Lehman Brothers and Bear Stearns. Over the past 25 years, Court has been involved in mergers and acquisitions, debt and equity financings, restructurings, valuations, and not-for-profit conversions. Cain Brothers has more experience with mid-market health-care transactions than any advisory firm. The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 6
  • 7. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Scott Li Vice President Hammond Hanlon Camp LLC sli@h2cllc.com www.h2cllc.com Scott Li is a vice president in the New York office of Hammond Hanlon Camp LLC. With more than 10 years of experience across roles in investment banking and the health-care industry, Scott provides strategic and financial advisory services to a variety of health-care clients. He has recently completed or is actively working on engagements for clients in the hospital, senior living, and health IT sectors. Prior to joining Hammond Hanlon Camp LLC, Scott was Chief Financial Officer of pingmd, a provider of an online communication platform for primary care physicians. . The Merger & Acquisition Webcast Series 7
  • 8. Investing In Christopher Carnahan Court Houseworth (Moderator) Scott Li Robert Cimasi 8
  • 9. Healthcare Continuum Prevention Diagnosis Treatment Cure Death © 2014 Carnahan Group 9
  • 10. Patients Drive $ © 2014 Carnahan Group 10
  • 11. Patient Lifetime Expenditures © 2014 Carnahan Group 11
  • 12. Personal Economics © 2014 Carnahan Group 12
  • 13. The Economics • Total Healthcare spending $2.8 trillion • Population: 318,892,103 • Life Expectancy: 78.5 • Average healthcare spending per capita: $8,233 • Growth rate: Depends on who you ask – Assume long term growth of 3% • Total life time spending: $2,793,566 © 2014 Carnahan Group 13
  • 14. Impact of Growth 2% Growth Rate Growth Rate i 2% Life Expectancy n 78.5 Average Spending per Capita PMT $ 8,233 Future Value FV $ 1,948,236 3% Growth Rate Growth Rate i 3% Life Expectancy n 78.5 Average Spending per Capita PMT $ 8,233 Future Value FV $ 2,793,566 4% Growth Rate Growth Rate i 4% Life Expectancy n 78.5 Average Spending per Capita PMT $ 8,233 Future Value FV $ 4,473,169 © 2014 Carnahan Group 14
  • 15. Macro Economics 2012 • Hospital Care: increased 4.9 percent to $882.3 billion • Physician and Clinical Services: increased 4.6 percent to $565.0 billion • Other Professional Services: $76.4 billion • Dental Services: increased 3.0 percent to $110.9 billion • Other Health, Residential, and Personal Care Services: grew 4.5 percent to $138.2 billion • Home Health Care: increased 5.1 percent to $77.8 billion • Nursing Care Facilities and Continuing Care Retirement Communities: increased 1.6 percent to $151.5 billion • Prescription Drugs: grew 0.4 percent to $263.3 billion • Durable Medical Equipment: Retail spending reached $41.3 billion • Other Non-durable Medical Products: Retail spending for over-the-counter medicines, medical instruments, and surgical dressings grew 1.8 percent to $53.7 billion Source: CMS National Health Expenditures 2012 Highlights © 2014 Carnahan Group 15
  • 16. Trends …Consolidation • “Healthcare is a low-margin economic activity. Almost a quarter of American hospitals are already losing money. With that number bound to increase in coming years, we already know what to expect because we’ve seen it before in the airline, supermarket, phone and electronics businesses. There will be a wave of mergers and acquisitions to improve quality and lower costs.” Delos Cosgrove, M.D. – CEO and President at Cleveland Clinic (Article: The Great Consolidation Begins) © 2014 Carnahan Group 16
  • 17. Deal Winners M&A Deal Volume for 2011 and 2012 Deal Volume Dollar Volume Sector 2012 2011 % Changed 2012 2011 % Changed Behavioral Care 17 13 30.8% $1,005,650,000 $304,488,600 230.6% Home Health & Hospice 35 29 20.7% $5,718,950,000 $289,992,000 1872.1% Managed Care 27 20 35.0% $18,815,500,000 $7,906,000,000 138.0% Physician Medical Groups 68 108 -37.0% $4,411,539,350 $466,534,545 845.6% Selected items from Source: Irving Levin Associates, January 2013 Pasted from <http://www.levinassociates.com/pr2013/pr1301mamyearend> © 2014 Carnahan Group 17
  • 18. Perspectives on Healthcare Services M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com May 1, 2014
  • 19. Overview of Hammond Hanlon Camp  Hammond Hanlon Camp (“H2C”) LLC is a healthcare-focused strategic advisory and investment banking firm with a particular emphasis on the not-for-profit sector  H2C traces its heritage back almost 30 years through its predecessor organizations, including Shattuck Hammond Partners  H2C has assembled a team of professionals that have worked with leading health systems across the country and executed many of the most creative transactions in the not-for-profit healthcare industry – Senior professionals average over 20 years of experience serving not-for-profit health systems  Offices in Atlanta, Chicago, New York and San Diego  Lead advisor on hundreds of transactions in the healthcare industry representing billions of dollars in value Strategic Advisory  Services designed to assist organizations in evaluation of options prior to transaction Capital Markets & Derivatives  Financial advisor and/or placement agent on all types of debt and derivative transactions Mergers & Acquisitions  Advisor on all types of affiliations, joint ventures, acquisitions and divestiture transactions Restructuring  Financial advisor to restructure distressed credits / sell assets Real Estate  Advisor on monetization and project financing of real estate assets Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 19
  • 20. Healthcare Provider Strategic Context Tailwinds  Demographics: aging population, increasing life expectancy, etc.  Push to lower cost of care settings (for certain sectors)  Newly insured population growing Headwinds  Reimbursement uncertainty due to ACA  Shift from volume to value  Intensifying focus on cost and choice for consumers and insurers Econom y Post-Reform Environment Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 20
  • 21. The New Normal The realities of shifting from volume to value are causing financial forecasts to evolve Illustrative Hospital Operating Income Projections Challenging reimbursement environment Inpatient admissions under pressure Shift from commercial to exchanges Increasing consumerism 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Projected Operating Income Prior Forecast Post-Reform Revised Post-Reform Downside Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 21
  • 22. Not THAT Kind of Sustainability: the New Model for Survival Across the continuum of care, providers will need to possess or develop many attributes to achieve sustainability or permanence in serving their community or customers Essential market position and critical mass Capital Integrated physicians High quality leadership and staff Measurable quality and cost effectiveness Alignment with other providers / payors IT and care managemen t infrastructur es Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 22
  • 23. 2, 4, 6, 8…Who Do We Integrate? There are many ways for providers to access or offer these skills and attributes  With the ACA sparking new payment systems – bundled payments, capitation, narrow networks – the delivery of and payment for service is becoming significantly more challenging  Hospitals have been and will continue to be the core of the health care system but the system will be different  A blurring of traditional lines between healthcare service sectors has continued with upstream or downstream diversification increasingly common – Revenue diversification via cross-sector activity – Payer-provider convergence – Post-acute or behavioral health capabilities via ownership or partnership  The critical questions are: – Which of these components will hospitals integrate into their systems? – How will providers in other parts of the continuum respond?  Overall, providers will be joining together in vertically stacked organizations or networks to provide and bill for service Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 23
  • 24. New Kinds of Dance Partners  Once upon time, consolidation meant organizations in the same business joined forces  No longer as simple as saying bigger is better, even though that is often true  The new paradigm dictates that providers will need to align, partner, or merge with others in the continuum of care for a variety of skills and competencies – Population health management capabilities – Marketing capabilities to respond to increasing consumerism – IT impacting strategic decisions – Acquiring or refining activities in other parts of the continuum  Access to capital is critical and whether the debt and equity markets are supportive will be an especially important consideration  Comfort with for-profit operators is growing – For-profit management style for not-for-profit organizations – “No Margin, No Mission” has never been more applicable  Private equity will continue to be a growing force across the continuum of care Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 24
  • 25. Reassessing the Toolkit Monetization to Improve Balance Sheet Sharpen Focus on Core Businesses Harvesting Non-Core Assets Enhance Service Quality and/or Reduce Cost Increase Managerial Bandwidth Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 25
  • 26. Will the M&A Activity Work? “Only time will tell whether this merger makes sense or not” Healthcare M&A Trends HAMMOND HANLON CAMP LLC h2cllc.com 26
  • 27. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank The Four Pillars 27
  • 28. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank 28 Physician Primacy Integration & Coordination Driving Consolidation “Healthcare Valuation: The Financial Appraisal of Enterprises, Assets, and Services,” Robert James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, p. 980.
  • 29. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Supply of Physicians, 1975 – 2011 29 450,000 400,000 350,000 300,000 250,000 200,000 150,000 100,000 50,000 - 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2011 Primary Care Specialty Care Surgeons “Physician Characteristics and Distribution in the U.S.: 2013 Edition,” Derek R. Smart, American Medical Association, 2013, p. 288, 441.
  • 30. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Physician Supply and Demand 1,000,000 900,000 800,000 700,000 600,000 500,000 400,000 300,000 200,000 100,000 0 2008 2010 2015 2020 2025 Supply Demand -The difference between supply and demand represents the anticipated physician shortage. “Physician Shortages to Worsen Without Increases in Residency Training” Association of American Medical College, https://www.aamc.org/download/153160/data/physician_shortages_to_worsen_without_increases_in_residency_tr.pdf (Accessed 4/30/14) 30
  • 31. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Physician Shortage 70000 60000 50000 40000 30000 20000 10000 0 2008 2010 2015 2020 2025 Specialist Shortage PC Shortage Total Physician Shortage 7,400 13,700 62,900 91,500 130,600 “Physician Shortages to Worsen Without Increases in Residency Training” Association of American Medical College, https://www.aamc.org/download/153160/data/physician_shortages_to_worsen_without_increases_in_residency_tr.pdf (Accessed 4/30/14) 31
  • 32. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Percent Change in Physician Practice Setting Since 2000 “Physician Characteristics and Distribution in the US” American Medical Association, 2002-2003 edition, p. 329; 2003-2004 edition, p. 320; 2004 edition, p. 322; 2005 edition, p. 311; 2006 edition, p. 311; 2007 edition, p. 311; 2008 edition, p. 403; 2009 edition, p. 406; 2010 edition, p. 438; 2011 edition, p. 436. 2011 edition, p. 436; 2012 edition, p. 440; 2013 edition, p. 440. 125% 120% 115% 110% 105% 100% 95% 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 Physicians in Office-Based Practices Physicians in Hospital-Based Practices Total Patient Care Physicians 32
  • 33. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Organizational Models of Alignment Emerging Models in an Era of Reform Degree of Hospital Control MOST LEAST "A Guide to Consulting Services for Emerging Healthcare Organization," By Robert James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY, 1999, p. 51-56, 163. “Healthcare Valuation: The Financial Appraisal of Enterprises, Assets, and Services,” Robert James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, p. 646. “Hospital/Physician Integration: Three Key Models” by Michael A. Cassidy et al., American Health Lawyers Association, October 2011, p. 9. 33 Model Description Solo/Group Medical Practice Physicians practice independently Independent Practice Association (IPA) Legal entities of independent physicians that contract with health insurance companies to provide medical services Co-Management Arrangement Typically formed through a contractual agreement between a group of physicians and a hospital, for the purpose of the physicians providing management services to a specified hospital service line related to the specialty of the contracted physicians Management Services Agreement (MSA)/Organization (MSO) A legal entity that provides administrative and practice management services to a physician entity that is owned by participating physicians and that contracts with the MSO for services Accountable Care Organization (ACO) Participant A legal entity recognized and authorized under applicable State, Federal, or Tribal Law that is identified by a Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN) and is formed by one or more ACO participant(s) Physician Practice Management Company (PPMC) Company specializing in physician practice management with the goal of earning a profit; often purchase or affiliate with physicians, offering capital, management experience, economies of scale, and economic security Physician Hospital Organization (PHO) (“Clinically Integrated Network”) Unites Hospital with Physician through a contractual relationship. Usually owned by Physicians and Hospitals, and in many cases non-profit Professional Service Agreement (PSA) An agreement in which an entity contracts with a physician practice, requiring the physician practice to provide professional medical services on behalf of the contracting entity Physician Hospital Organization (PHO) (“Clinically Integrated Network”) Unites Hospital with Physician through a contractual relationship. Usually owned by Physicians and Hospitals, and in many cases non-profit Physician Employment Agreement (PEA) Hospital purchases some or all of a medical practice’s assets and begin employing the former medical group’s physicians directly
  • 34. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Provider Consolidation Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs) • Healthcare organizations with a coordinated set of providers • Provider mix dependent on whether it is a federal or commercial ACO structure • Share responsibility and accountability for the continuum of care • Clinical accountability – Quality of care • Financial responsibility – Cost of care “Perspectives on Accountable Care Organizations-ACO Overview” by Robert James Cimasi, 2011 International Expo, Health Industry Group Purchasing Association & healthcare Industry Supply Chain Institute, Washington, D.C.: Oct. 12-14, 2011, p. 2. 34 34
  • 35. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Different Approaches to Managing the Entire Continuum of Care for the Patient Historical Forces: • Practice of medicine has historically been viewed as a learned profession, with physicians perceived as professionals who applied their training and knowledge to provide quality patient care within their independent practices. • Shift from physician-owned, independent private practices to captive practices with multiple affiliations within larger integrated health systems; another step towards the “corporatization” of professional practices, in contrast to the “cottage industry” healthcare delivery system of the past. • Healthcare costs continue to rise faster than inflation, driven by advances in technology and treatment, as well the increased demand for services from the growing baby-boomer population Result: A new healthcare delivery paradigm that promotes a managed “continuum of care,” in contrast to the current system of segmented independent provider “silos.” 35
  • 36. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Different Approaches to Managing the Entire Continuum of Care for the Patient • Provider affiliations are likely to increase due to: • Disproportionate number of physicians retiring • An inadequate supply medical graduates • Expected continuing growth in patient demand • The diversification, specialization, and collaboration of physician and non-physician practitioners will continue to grow to meet the compounding demand, including: • Allied health professionals • Mid-level providers • Technicians and paraprofessionals • Complementary and alternative medical practitioners 36
  • 37. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank What Has Changed This Time Around? • Alignment is being seen as an offensive strategy, not merely as a defensive one • Large single and multi-specialty groups are becoming more common and are often considered necessary to achieve optimal results • The loss of autonomy is seen as a fair trade-off for the benefits of being an employee • Much more experimentation • Direct employment is no longer the only option 37
  • 38. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Direct Employment A Fresh Look at an Old Concept • Hospitals like the ability to require employees to use their facilities (except when patient needs dictate otherwise) • Employment supports the use of clinical guidelines and emerging concepts such as the medical home • Provider-based reimbursement is sometimes available • Easier to invest in EMR technology • Avoids some of the more difficult aspects of Stark, e.g., the severe limits placed on under arrangement deals 38
  • 39. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank 39
  • 40. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Merger & Acquisition Volume, 2011-2013 As derived and calculated from reported transactional data from The Healthcare M&A Report by Irving Levin Associates, INC. Quarterly Reports from 2011 to 2013; Note that of the MD purchasers, approximately 2/3 were reported as being the original group. As to the remaining 1/3 of reported transactions, that fact may have been true, but was not reported. 40 A B C D E Year Total Deals Physician Medical Group Acquisition Non-Physician Medical Group Acquisition Reported Dollars Spent on Physician Medical Groups M&A 1 2011 107 6 101 $464 Million 2 2012 68 8 60 $4.4 Billion 3 2013 65 3 62 $583 Million 4 Total 240 17 223 $5.447 Billion
  • 41. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Marcus Welby is Dead Increasing Complexity of Integration Transactions 41
  • 42. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Types of Tangible and Intangible Property/Assets in Healthcare “Valuation of Healthcare Entities and Assets: The Impact of 2010 Legislation” By Robert James Cimasi, CPA Leadership Institute (11/6/2012) p. 55. 42
  • 43. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank 43 “Healthcare Valuation: The Financial Appraisal of Enterprises, Assets, and Services,” Robert James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, p. 979.
  • 44. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank 44 “Healthcare Valuation: The Financial Appraisal of Enterprises, Assets, and Services,” Robert James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, p. 980.
  • 45. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank Managed Care Agreements and Provider Service Agreements HMO Enrollment Lists Assets Human Capital- Related Intangible Assets Employee and Provider Employee Agreements Trained and Assembled Workforce In- Place Non-Copyrighted Policies and Procedures Depth of Management Intellectual Property-Related Intangible Assets Clinical Practice Protocols and Treatment Plans Copyrights Trademarks and Trade names Patents Trade Secrets or Other Know How Payor or Client Related Operations and Location Related Intangible Assets Historical Information and Documentation Supplier Contracts Asset Assemblage Factors and Going Concern Value Governance or Legal Structure Related Intangible Assets Organizational Documents Income Distribution Plans Right of First Refusal Covenants-Not- To-Compete Marketing and Business Development Related Intangible Assets Advertising Franchise/ Licensing Agreements Joint Venture Alliances Regulatory or Legal-Related Intangible Assets Provider or Medical Licenses Certificates of Need Medicare Certification Other Certifications and Accreditations Financial or Revenue Stream- Related Intangible Assets Office Share Arrangements Management Service Agreements Financing Agreements Financial Derivatives Technology- Related Intangible Assets Computerized Management Information Systems Electronic Medical Records Maintenance and Support Relationships Patient-Related Intangible Assets Custodial Rights to the Patient Medical Charts and Records Patient Recall Lists Goodwill Professional /Personal Goodwill Practice/ Commercial Goodwill Easements Permits Leasehold Interests In-Place Leases Zoning Waivers/ Variances Use Rights Tangible Real Property Tangible Personal Property Cash and Investments Accounts Receivable Supplies & Drugs – Consumables and Inventory Held for Sale Furniture, Fixtures, and Equipment Leasehold Improvements Litigation Awards and Liquidated Damages Buildings Land and Land Improvements Subject Property Interest Tangible Assets Intangible Assets Intangible Real Property Intangible Personal Property 45 “Healthcare Valuation: The Financial Appraisal of Enterprises, Assets, and Services,” Robert James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, p. 981.
  • 46. Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care M&A Market Sponsored by Regions Bank 46 “Healthcare Valuation: The Financial Appraisal of Enterprises, Assets, and Services,” Robert James Cimasi, John Wiley & Sons, 2014, p. 982.
  • 47. Webcast: "Key Growth Sectors in the Health-Care Services M&A Market." Managed Care Industry M&A Perspectives May 1, 2014
  • 48. 48 Managed Care Industry M&A Perspectives Introduction  The Affordable Care Act has caused companies and their executives to turn their attention from execution to evaluating and implementing strategic initiatives  With the implementation of Health Care Reform, companies are evaluating transactions which provide both greater scale and diversification  Connolly, an insurance payments auditing company, agreed to acquire iHealth Technologies, a medical claims company  Guardian entered an agreement to acquire Premier Access Insurance, a diversified dental benefits company  Walgreens and Water Street announced an agreement to merge Take Care Employer Solutions with CHS to form a new worksite health company  Rite Aid signed agreements to acquire Health Dialog and RediClinic to expand its overall health and wellness strategy  Highmark agreed to merge with Blue Cross of Northeastern Pennsylvania  DaVita, the leader in kidney dialysis, acquired HealthCare Partners to enter the physician practice management sector  Private equity firms have remained interested in acquiring payer related companies  Starr Investment Holdings LLC, led by former AIG CEO Hank Greenberg, acquired health insurance claims processor MultiPlan Inc for $4.4 billion from private equity firms BC Partners Ltd and Silver Lake  KKR acquired two leading Workers’ Comp businesses -- Sedgwick Claims Management Services for $2.4 billion and Mitchell International for $1.1 billion  Apax Partners acquired One Call Care Management and Align Networks for approximately $3 billion  Goldman Sachs acquired MagnaCare
  • 49. 49 Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives Changing Industry Landscape The Affordable Care Act is dynamically changing the health care landscape by creating both opportunities and challenges that will require managed care organizations to adapt their traditional core businesses Sector Outlooks  Medicaid outlook very favorable due to PPACA expansion  Dual eligibles present significant opportunity for those that can effectively manage the population  Medicare outlook in the long-term is compelling, but near term reimbursement pressures will challenge plans  Individual and small group markets expected to face significant headwinds due to implementation of Changing Model  Renewed focus on controlling costs and improving outcomes through enhanced care management  Managing care will require new levels of coordination amongst providers and payers  Will require significant information technology investments  Increased interest in integrated delivery models between providers and payers Scale and Diversification  Scale will matter, which will lead to further increases in M&A activity  Consolidators will be looking to diversify product offerings  Increased focus on expansion of care management solutions Other Concerns  Access to capital will be a critical factor for not-for-profit and provider owned health plans  Overhang with respect to the economic recovery, unemployment rate trends and the impact of sequestration  Ability to pass along annual insurance fee to mitigate any meaningful impact on health plans
  • 50. 50 Managed Care M&A Activity ____________________ Source: Irving Levin Associates, PWC October 2013 White Paper, Barclays research. Note: Excludes workers’ compensation transactions. (1) Total combined deal value includes Irving Levin and Barclays research. Deal volume per Irving Levin research. (2) Only includes data for first quarter 2014. Deal Value (in millions) Deal Volume 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 $25,000 $20,000 $15,000 $10,000 $5,000 With increased visibility in the post reform era, health plans are expected to continue to use M&A as an avenue to increase scale, capabilities and diversification (1) Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives While 2012 was the most robust year for managed care M&A activity since 2005, 2013 and the first three months of 2014 were relatively quiet (2) 0 $0 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Deal Value Deal Volume
  • 51. 51 Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives Recent Acquisition Trends for Managed Care Plans Medicaid expansion and the need for cost-containing care management solutions have been driving the vast majority of recent M&A activity M&A Activity ____________________ Source: Wall Street research. Government Programs  Commercial plans looking to diversify away from individual and small group to minimize expected headwinds from the exchanges  Medicaid plans looking to capitalize on Medicaid expansion from PPACA by entering new states or expanding footprint in existing geographies via acquisitions  Medicare Advantage plans looking to expand their scale in an effort to help offset expected MA reimbursement cuts and capitalize on long-term growth potential Providers Health Care Information Technology  Increased coordination with providers viewed as an effective tool to more effectively manage populations  Interest areas include participation in integrated provider systems and low-cost alternate site clinics  Particular interest in acquiring services that enable better management of high cost populations (chronically ill, elderly, etc.)  Renewed acquisition appetite of physician groups by payers  Post reform health care model requires an expansion of HCIT capabilities for many plans  Focus on increasing analytic capabilities for enhanced population health management  Heath Information Exchange platforms and solutions will become a necessity post reform  Payer organizations are vacillating between vendor relationships and ownership of core technology Since 2012, the large managed care companies have invested over $17 billion via acquisitions to improve positioning and capabilities to serve seniors, low-income individuals, and the dual eligible population
  • 52. 52 Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives Recent M&A Activity Select Medicare Operations Pension Plans in Turkey PCCM Network Medicaid Contract (1) ____________________ (1) Acquired non-controlling interest.
  • 53. 53 Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives Recent M&A Activity (cont’d) Select Medicaid Operations Arcadian Medicare Operations in Arizona CareNex LLC ____________________ (1) Announced sale of 1-800 Contacts to Thomas H. Lee Partners on January 8, 2014. (2) Acquired minority interest. (1) Plus One Health Management Other Selected M&A Activity Target Acquirer Target Acquirer Target Acquirer Citrus Universal Healthcare Amerigroup Virginia Michigan Ohio (2)
  • 54. 54 Provider and payer consolidation trends have accelerated over the past several years, and these trends are expected to continue  Neither provider / payer integration nor provider risk-bearing entities are new concepts. Provider-owned health plans and other risk bearing provider organizations (i.e. capitation) have been around since the 1980s  However, few provider-owned plans are truly integrated with the provider owner, and risk-bearing entities have long histories only in limited geographies  There are approximately 100 provider-owned health plans that manage on average around 100,000 lives per plan  Strengthen primary care network directly or indirectly  Foster coordination among all participating providers  Remove fee-for-service payment incentives so as to appropriately manage volume and quality  Foster accountability for total per-capita costs  Provide tools to providers to bear risk and benefit from lower cost / higher quality  Develop limited networks in order to coordinate care and lower cost Provider and payer organization concept Objectives for providers and / or payer organizations Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives Provider and Payer Integration – An Accelerating Trend
  • 55. 55 Recent consolidation activity has included payer acquisitions of providers Acquirer / Target  Highmark formed a holding company that is the parent of Highmark and of new Provider subsidiary (WPAHS)  WPAHS includes five acute care hospitals, 1,600 beds, and over 1,700 MDs on staff  Purchase Price = Not disclosed  Acquisition of more than 75 physicians, 90,000 active patients, including approximately 27,000 Medicare beneficiaries  Purchase Price = $800 million  NAMM is part of the Aveta’s family of companies – one of the largest providers of managed health care services  Acquisition of NAMM’s 600 primary care providers and 1,200 specialists  Purchase Price = Not disclosed  Minority equity investment by BCBSNC in FastMed. FastMed is the largest urgent care company in North Carolina and the second largest urgent care company in Arizona  Over 320,000 patient visits in 2012  WPAHS was a distressed system. Financial commitments by Highmark will maintain provider choice in the region  WPAHS part of a broader integrated delivery network strategy by Highmark  Driven by local market dynamics – competitor is an integrated provider/payer (UPMC)  Will bolster Florida Blue's value-based care presence in Tampa/St. Petersburg area  Acquisition will continue to promote implementation of additional aligned incentive models to meet Diagnostic Clinic Medical Group’s overall value-based goals of improving quality and enhancing member experiences while lowering overall cost  Allows continued expansion of a successful medical management model  Extends opportunities for UnitedHealth Group to build out further physician partnerships throughout the country  NAMM deal adds to strong Optum footprint in southern California, which includes Monarch, AppleCare Medical Group and Memorial HealthCare  Strategic collaboration will allow FastMed Urgent Care to expand its network of physician-owned urgent care clinics across North Carolina, while helping to launch innovative programs and services for BCBSNC customers  BCBSNC’s member population will receive increased access to convenient, high quality urgent care and lower medical costs ____________________ Source: Company press releases and CapitalIQ. Transactio n Summary Transactio n Benefits and Nuances Managed Care M&A Industry Perspectives Recent Provider-Payer Integration Activity
  • 56. Confidential Cain Brothers’ Disclaimer This document is for discussion purposes only and does not constitute advice of any kind, including tax, accounting, legal or regulatory advice, and Cain Brothers & Company, LLC (“Cain Brothers”) is not and does not hold itself out to be an advisor as to tax, accounting, legal or regulatory matters. We recommend that you seek independent third party legal, regulatory, accounting and tax advice regarding the contents of this document. The matters discussed herein are subject to our review and assessment from a legal, compliance, accounting policy and risk perspective, as appropriate, following our discussion with you. This document was prepared on a confidential basis solely for discussion between you and Cain Brothers and not with a view toward public disclosure. This document, and any oral information provided in connection herewith, shall be treated as strictly confidential and may not be reproduced, distributed or disclosed, in whole or in part, except with our prior written consent. Cain Brothers assumes no obligation to update or otherwise revise these materials. No representation or warranty, express or implied, is made as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained herein and nothing contained herein is, or shall be relied upon as, a representation or warranty, whether as to the past or the future. Cain Brothers and our affiliates and our and their respective officers, employees and agents expressly disclaim any and all liability which may be based on this document and any errors therein or omissions therefrom. This document does not constitute an offer or solicitation to sell or purchase any securities and is not a commitment by Cain Brothers or any of its affiliates to provide or arrange any financing for any transaction or to purchase any security or act as an agent or advisor or in any other capacity in connection therewith. This document does not constitute a recommendation to pursue, and is not intended to provide the sole basis for evaluating, a particular transaction, and you retain full responsibility for the decision to pursue any specific transaction discussed herein or otherwise.

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. Source: U.S. Census Bureau, International Data Base. 2. SOURCE: CDC/NCHS, National Vital Statistics System. Expectation of life, by age, sex, race, and Hispanic origin: United States, 2009
  2. National Health Expenditures 2012 Highlights
  3. 49
  4. 50
  5. 51