SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  14
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
DOI 10.14746/ssp.2018.3.2
Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa
Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań
“Non-campaign of a non-candidate”
– Alexei Navalny
in the 2018 presidential election in Russia
Abstract: In March 2018, another presidential election took place in the Russian
Federation. For the fourth time Vladimir Putin won the election by a large majority of
votes. Alexei Navalny – an opposition candidate who had been preparing his election
campaign since the end of 2016 – was not allowed to stand in the election. Regardless
of his elimination from the election, Navalny remained an active member of Russian
political life before and after the election; he carried out a boycott of the election,
and organized post-election protests. Without a doubt, despite the ban on running in
the election, Navalny was one of the main figures in the electoral process. Thus, the
aim of this article is a detailed analysis of Navalny’s preparations for the campaign
– the authors focused not only on the candidate’s opposition activity, but also on his
unique measures and methods of running a campaign (Internet, social media, crowd-
funding). The article examines the campaign preparations, as well as the reasons for
the rejection of Navalny’s registration as an election candidate, social support index,
relationships with other candidates and the change of strategy after the Central Elec-
tion Commission’s decision. The analysis is based on Russian law, Central Election
Commission’s decisions, opinion poll results and information from the Russian and
international media.
Key words: Russian elections, Russian president,Alexei Navalny, election campaign,
political opposition
On May 7, 2018, seven weeks after the election, the inauguration
of Vladimir Putin’s fourth term as president took place. Two days
earlier, more than ten Russian cities organized demonstrations under the
slogan “He’s not our tsar.”1
The main originator and organizer of the
1
  The biggest demonstrations took place in Moscow and Saint Petersburg. The
cities’ authorities did not give permission to carry out protests, hence both events
were illegal. Despite that, at least several thousand people took part in the protests.
Among the slogans, apart from the main one of “He’s not our tsar” (regarding Putin’s
18 years of presidency) there appeared “Russia without corruption,” “Cast forth the
22	 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa	 ŚSP 3 ’18
protests was the informal leader of the non-parliamentary opposition,
Alexei Navalny, who had planned to run in the presidential election. The
whole process of preparation for the election had been carefully planned
by Navalny himself and his volunteering staff. They took care of details
such as campaign funds, efficient collection of signatures supporting his
candidacy and a PR campaign in the mass media. But on December 25,
2017, the Russian Central Electoral Commission rejected Navalny’s reg-
istration, due to his lack of passive voting rights. In the end, despite an
appeal against the Commission’s decision in court and its interpretation
of a constitutional provision favorable to Navalny, he was not allowed to
stand in the election. In addition to unofficially taking part in the election
campaign, he was an active member of Russian political life before and
after the election. He also carried out a boycott of the election and orga-
nized post-election protests. It is without a doubt that Navalny was one of
the key figures in the electoral process, despite not being allowed to run.
Hence the aim of this article is to analyze Navalny’s campaign prepara-
tions – not only because of the fact that he had a real chance of becoming
the only opposition presidential candidate with a chance of winning,2
but
also because of the means and methods of running his campaign (the use
of the Internet, crowdfunding, etc.). The authors of the article analyzed the
campaign preparations and the reasons for denying Navalny registration,
tsar,” “We are not slaves,” “Putin retire.” During the demonstration, confrontations
between the protesters and the police, including mass arrests took place – over 700
people in Moscow and about 1,600 in the whole country were arrested (data ОВД-
Инфо – independent projects devoted to political oppression in Russia; Литой, 2018).
In Saint Petersburg, when protesters went out onto the main street – the Nevsky Pros-
pect – they were arrested by police within a few minutes. The main organizer of the
protests, Alexei Navalny was also arrested (and sentenced to 30 days in jail). Protests
took place in other cities as well, e.g., Chelyabinsk, Yakutsk, Krasnodar, Voronezh
and many others.
2
  Formally, 8 candidates representing different political parties and initiatives ran
in the election. However, the majority of them originate from parties that, for years,
have been operating in the framework of the Russian political system and do not have
any influence upon it. It is rare for the representatives of these parties to engage in
oppositional actions against the authorities or criticize those in power. Only Ksenia
Sobchak declared that her candidacy would guarantee the presence of opposition in
the election, especially after denying Navalny the possibility of standing in the elec-
tion. However, as a result of the lack of political experience and opposition support,
as well as infinitesimal support from society and doubts about her independence (there
were rumors that the candidate was convenient for Vladimir Putin), Ksenia Sobchak’s
candidacy was not taken seriously.
ŚSP 3 ’18	 “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny...	 23
his social support index, relationships with other candidates and change
of strategy after the Electoral Commission’s decision. The analysis has
been carried out based on research on Russian law, the Central Electoral
Commission’s decisions, results of public opinion polls and information
in Russian and international media.
Russian election ordinance
In Russia, the procedure of carrying out presidential elections is regu-
lated by the following acts: the Constitution of Russia, Federal Law “On
Basic Guarantees of Electoral Rights and the Right of Citizens of the
Russian Federation to Participate in a Referendum,” Federal Law “On the
Election of the President of the Russian Federation,” and selected laws
from other acts (Процедура выборов). Elections are general, equal, di-
rect and are carried out by secret voting. Suffrage has been guaranteed to
everyone, regardless of their sex, race, nationality, parentage, possession
and social status, affiliation to public associations or other circumstanc-
es. The only limitation to active voting is age – voters must be at least
18 years of age. Additionally, voting rights and rights to be elected are not
granted to people who are incapacitated by court decision or in prison at
the time of the election (Федеральный закон „О выборах…”).
A Russian citizen who is at least 35 years of age and has been living on
the country’s territory continually for 10 years can be elected President of
the Russian Federation. In addition, the same person cannot be President
of the Russian Federation for longer than 2 consecutive terms (Konstytucja
Federacji Rosyjskiej, art. 80). No other limitations are stated in the Con-
stitution. Other conditions have been included in the Law “On the Elec-
tion of the President of the Russian Federation” of 2014. According to the
amended paragraph 5.2, article 3, a passive voting right is denied to people
sentenced to prison for major crimes, extremist crimes, and for administra-
tive crimes if the sentence is being served during the election period. An
offender loses their passive voting right not only for the duration of the
sentence, but for a further 10 to 15 years (depending on the seriousness of
the crime) from the date of expungement or discontinuation of the sentence.
After the introduction of these amendments to the election ordinance their
constitutionality was questioned, and it has been assumed that the main ad-
dressee of the law is the opposition candidate –Alexei Navalny. This matter
will be closely analyzed in the following sections.
24	 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa	 ŚSP 3 ’18
The regulations regarding the pre-election campaign can be found in
the above mentioned acts. According to Article 50 of the Federal Law
“On the Election of the President of the Russian Federation” the cam-
paign starts on the day the candidate obtains approval for their candidacy
from the Central Electoral Commission, and ends one day before the ac-
tual voting. Separate regulations have been set out for campaigns using
traditional media – television, radio, press. In that case, the campaign
starts 28 days before the polling day, and ends also one day before the
election. It is forbidden to campaign on the polling day and the day before
it (Федеральный закон „О выборах…”).
Regulations regarding the presidential election procedure in Russia
do not seem to significantly differ from those applied in Western demo-
cratic countries. However, the ability to use them instrumentally led to the
elimination of the only opposition candidate from the election. Although
according to the Russian law he could not be considered an official presi-
dential candidate and his actions did not fall under the definition of an
election campaign given by the law, his presence in the public sphere
influenced not only the election process, but also the perception of it by
Russian citizens and election observers.
Elections without Alexei Navalny
– the Russian Central Electoral Commission’s decision
Three months before the election, on December 18, 2017, a decision
of the Federation Council calling the presidential election was published,
which is considered the beginning of the election campaign. Navalny had
been preparing to stand for months prior to the announcement of the elec-
tion. Even before the official beginning of the campaign, he had almost 80
groups of staff all around Russia, ready to work (Fig. 1). He also accumu-
lated the required amount of 500 signatures under his candidacy.
However, on December 25, 2017, the Central Electoral Commission
refused Navalny’s registration as a candidate for the president of Russia.
The reason was his lack of the passive voting right – in 2013, he received
a 5 year suspended prison sentence for embezzlement in Kirowles. The
first sentence was overruled and another examination of the case was or-
dered by the European Court of Human Rights, which recognized the fact
that Navalny had not been given access to a fair trial. However, the appeal
ruling also convicted him. Therefore, according to the law on the election
ŚSP 3 ’18	 “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny...	 25
of a president, amended in 2014, Navalny cannot run in elections until
2028 (a 5 year sentence plus a 10 year ban on standing in elections after
the end of the sentence) (Strzelecki, 2017).
After the Central Electoral Commission’s decision was issued, Na-
valny argued that the law taking away the passive voting right from per-
sons who are convicted, but do not serve the sentence in prison, is against
the Russian Constitution (which only forbids the incapacitated and those
sentenced to prison from standing in elections). Nonetheless, the Consti-
tutional Court to which Navalny appealed against the Central Electoral
Commission’s decision, refused to consider the matter and, at the same
time, deemed the law limiting the passive voting right constitutional
(Определение Конституционного Суда). As a consequence, Navalny
lost his right to stand in the presidential elections in 2018 and 2024. Nev-
ertheless, he did not abandon his campaign, which had already started,
and decided to use the structures prepared and resources accumulated to
carry out a boycott of the election and build support among Russian soci-
ety for the coming years.
Navalny’s “Non-campaign”
Navalny’s unofficial campaign had begun over a year before the elec-
tion. He expressed his will to run in the Russian presidential election in
December 2016. In February 2017, in Petersburg, the first headquarters
Figure 1. A map created by Navalny showing locations of his staff (as of early
December 2017)
Source: Навальный20!8, https://2018.navalny.com/, 4.12.2017.
26	 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa	 ŚSP 3 ’18
of his presidential campaign was opened, and the opening of dozens more
campaign offices was announced in the following months. The aim was to
build as large a network of people as possible who would not only help in
running the campaign but would also put their signature under Navalny’s
candidacy.3
By the end of 2017, when it was finally certain that the op-
position candidate would not stand in the election, 84 groups of staff in
almost all regions of Russia had been created. They managed to accumu-
late 700,000 declarations from people who put their signature under Na-
valny’s candidacy. Additionally, almost 200,000 volunteers offered their
help in running the potential campaign (Год кампании).
Figure 2. Official website of Navalny as a Russian presidential candidate
Source: Навальный20!8, https://2018.navalny.com/, 4.12.2017.
The candidate’s professional website was also created for the purpose
of the campaign, as well as accounts on social media and other channels of
online communication (Facebook,Twitter, ВКонтакте, Одноклассники).
Cohesive and modern visual identification, daily updates and the interac-
tive form of communication (comments, discussions, etc.) helped Navalny
3
  In accordance with Article 36 of the Law “On the Election of the President
of the Russian Federation,” if Navalny had been allowed to stand in the election,
he would have to get at least 300,000 signatures supporting his candidacy, includ-
ing at least 7,500 in each region of the Russian Federation (Федеральный закон
„О выборах”). If the candidate is put forward by a political party, he is required to
gain only 100,000 signatures. Candidates proposed by a party which has representa-
tives in the State Duma are an exception – they do not need any signatures under
their candidacy.
ŚSP 3 ’18	 “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny...	 27
gain support, especially among young voters.4
The opposition politician,
as part of his campaign, visited many Russian cities and towns, organized
meetings with voters, continued his spectacular anti-corruption initiative
and organized protests.5
These actions showed measurable effects – in
June 2017, more than half of Russians (55%) knew who Navalny was.6
This, of course, could not guarantee him electoral victory, since he only
got 1–2% in the opinion polls. However, in a country where for the past
18 years power has been in the hands of one person, and there are no
independent parties in the Parliament, gradually building support for an
opposition candidate appears to be a good strategy.
During the preparation for the election, funding had also been taken
care of. At the time of collecting signatures under Navalny’s candidacy,
a fund-raiser for the campaign was launched as well. Donations could
be made through the website in various ways – direct transfers from the
biggest Russian banks, account contributions, PayPal payments, card-
2card transfers and even Bitcoins. An online shop was opened, with Na-
valny’s campaign merchandise expressing support for his candidacy for
the president of Russia (t-shirts, bags, pins, stickers, mugs, etc.). The aim
of the store was not only to accumulate funds for the campaign, but also
to spread awareness of the candidate.
In total, 368 million rubles (about 6 million US dollars – exchange
rate as of May 2018) had been collected. Financial reports were shown on
the candidate’s website every month, and in April 2018 detailed financial
coverage of the whole campaign was published. According to the avail-
4
  According to research conducted by the Levada-Center, young Russians
(18–24 years old) are the most likely to use the Internet – in 2017 over 90% of them
went online at least a few times a day. Also, the majority of the age group of 25–39
(almost 80%) uses the Internet several times a day (Левада-Центр, 2017a).
5
  During this peculiar election campaign, in March 2017 the Anti-Corruption
Foundation led by Navalny published a film titled “He Is Not Dimon to You,” in
which the detailed results of the investigation into the connections between corruption
and the concealed estate of Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev were presented. The
film was viewed online by over 27 million people (during the first year, and 12 mil-
lion in the first month). As a result, Medvedev lost public trust, and a large group of
Russians demanded his resignation. Also, thousands of Russians took part in protests
organized by Navalny against corruption among the authorities.
6
  Only 4 years previously, despite the fact that Navalny was one of the faces of
the so-called “white revolution” (mass post-election protests of 2012) and succeeded
in Moscow’s mayor election (placing second and getting almost a third of the votes),
only 1 in 3 Russians recognized his name (Левада-Центр, 2017b).
28	 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa	 ŚSP 3 ’18
able information, the most commonly chosen amount of donation for Na-
valny was (median) 500 rubles (about 8 dollars), and the average donation
was 1,500 rubles (about 25 dollars). The opposition candidate’s campaign
was supported by about 100,000 people.Abig part of the collected money
was allocated to staff payments — a few hundred people were responsible
for organizing events and rallies, training and coordination of the vol-
unteers, verification and supervision of the campaign. Additionally, the
maintenance of the network of local groups of staff was funded (premises
and equipment renting, etc.) and funds for political agitation (online and
offline) (Финальный финансовый отчет). Such extensive reporting of
income and expenditure was meant to prevent any accusations of fraud
from political opponents, and also strengthen the image of an honest op-
position candidate who was fighting corruption among the authorities.
Navalny’s election promise
During Navalny’s election preparations, an election manifesto was
published on his website – a part of the campaign required by the Russian
law. According to his declarations, the manifesto had been formulated
based on information gathered during rallies and meetings with the citi-
zens of various cities and towns, and on expert opinions. In “Beautiful
Russia of the Future” (as the platform was named) Navalny mainly refers
to the inappropriate use of the country’s wealth – natural resources, quali-
Figure 3. Online shop with Navalny’s campaign merchandise
Source: Навальный20!8, https://2018.navalny.com/, 4.12.2017.
ŚSP 3 ’18	 “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny...	 29
fied manpower, industry, agriculture and infrastructure, from which the
profits, for almost two decades, have been going to a chosen few closely
linked to authority. He called for the resources to be used as a foundation
for the country’s prosperity. He planned to achieve his goal by increasing
expenditure on healthcare and education.Additional funding was to be ac-
quired by eliminating corruption and reducing spending on bureaucracy,
propaganda, armed conflicts, etc. Human capital was to be a foundation of
the new Russia – especially important were: education, new technologies,
and innovation. A good, well-funded, high-level education was intended
to guarantee the development of the country. Navalny also drew attention
to income inequity (he demanded a raise in the minimum wage, retire-
ment program reform and new taxes, e.g., for using infrastructure built by
previous generations that was unfairly privatized in the 1990s). Among
his promises, one can find those regarding strengthening (or more accu-
rately – building) independent local governments and reinforcing regions.
The main aims of foreign policy were to cooperate with other European
countries, withdraw from armed conflicts (Syria, Ukraine), and regulate
visa issues with CentralAsian countries (exacerbating the requirements to
migrant workers) (Программа; Прекрасная).
The manifesto formulated by Navalny and cooperating experts appears
to contain many tangible solutions to Russia’s main problems – corrup-
tion, underinvested education and healthcare, huge social stratification,
etc. It does not have big, catchy slogans, and empty heroism. References
to unity and history, incomprehensible for the majority of voters, weigh-
ing on democracy, freedom and other abstract concepts, were reduced.
However, the question whether this particular manifesto would interest
Russians remains unanswered – it requires careful reading and at least
a basic level of knowledge.
Election boycott and post-election protests
After the Central Electoral Commission’s decision refusing Navalny’s
registration, the candidate changed his strategy. In place of the electoral
campaign, an election boycott campaign had started – pursuant to the
statement that “if an independent candidate is not allowed to run in the
election, it is not an election at all.” The following objectives were set for
the coming three months: close observation of the election, monitoring
election turnout and encouraging others to take part in the boycott. Nav-
30	 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa	 ŚSP 3 ’18
alny announced that he would not recognize the election results nor the
elected authorities (Объявляем забастовку).
As part of the boycott, an information campaign was carried out; its
main slogans were: “An election without competition is not an election”
and “Election without Navalny, Putin’s main competitor – is a mockery.”7
At the same time, they tried to convince Russians that if there was no pos-
sibility of choosing between real candidates, it was better not to vote at
all. Additionally, several larger protests against eliminating Navalny from
the election took place. For example, the candidate’s supporters protested
on January 28, 2018 in dozens of Russian cities – among others, Irkutsk,
Kemerovo, Omsk, Novosibirsk, Yekaterinburg, Moscow and Saint Pe-
tersburg. In total, police arrested more than 350 people in some of these
cities («Забастовка избирателей»).
Mass protests were organized also after the election – right before the
inauguration of Putin’s fourth presidential term. In the protest under the
slogan “He’s not our tsar” (Russian: Он нам не царь) organized by Nav-
alny in 27 Russian cities “against the actual establishment of a monarchy,
against corruption, against inequalities, censorship and anarchy” several
thousand people took part. In some of the cities, authorities permitted
the protest; however, in the biggest ones – Moscow and Saint Petersburg
– Navalny’s supporters carried them out without the necessary permis-
sions (which could not be obtained). This explains the huge number of ar-
rests (around 1,600 people), including teenagers and random pedestrians.
Those detained complained about the police’s extreme brutality: some
of the people were taken to hospital (Филимонов, 2018; Литой, 2018).
Navalny himself was also arrested, and, for repeatedly breaching the rules
of organizing mass events and for disobedience to police, was sentenced
to 30 days in jail (administrative sanctions) (Лебеденко, 2018). Other
protesters faced trials and sanctions, too; however, the inauguration of
Putin’s presidency was not disturbed.
The effects of Navalny’s “non-campaign”
Initially, the main aim of Navalny’s actions was to run in the election
and gather as many votes as possible. However, after the rejection of his
7
  Russian: Выборы без конкуренции – это не выборы; Выборы без Навально-
го, главного конкурента Путина – это фарс.
ŚSP 3 ’18	 “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny...	 31
candidacy during the registration process, the campaign was transformed
into an election boycott, justified by the fact that there was no real alterna-
tive to the incumbent president. According to the data shared by the staff
of the opposition candidate, the actual voter turnout (obtained through
observations by tens of thousands of volunteers) was 2.5 percentage
points lower than the turnout officially presented by the Central Electoral
Commission (59.6% vs. 62.%). Also, due to the observer group organized
by Navalny, it was possible to register many violations and prove that
more than 10 million votes for Putin were placed in ballot boxes illegally
(Кампания Навального 2018).
Navalny’s campaign has proven that political activity based on tangi-
ble arguments is possible in Russia. Instead of grandiose and meaningless
declarations about patriotism, the Great War, tradition and imaginary en-
emies, Navalny proposed actual solutions to pressing issues – corruption,
social stratification, politicians’ huge fortunes, widespread poverty, etc.
All the protests, rallies and events did not aim at conversing about, for
many, abstract concepts such as democracy, human rights or freedom.
These events exposed the pathology of authority and looked for solutions
for the future. Of course, it was not always a pretty substantive discus-
sion, it included many populist elements as well. Nonetheless, it brought
a new quality to Russian politics.
The campaign on the Internet, social media and on Russian streets
allowed Navalny to build a large group of people supporting his actions
and ready to help in his political activity. Firstly, it consists of a group
of more than 200,000 volunteers who, together with trained specialists,
coordinated the whole campaign process. Secondly, there are thousands
of young people who took part in the protests organized by the opposi-
tion candidate during the campaign. Examples include the March 2017
protests demanding the resignation of Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev
after his hidden fortune and links to corruption were revealed; and the
protests of January 2018 against banning Navalny from running in the
presidential election. And, last but not least, the hundreds, thousands and
even tens of thousands of people who came to the pre-election meetings
with the opposition candidate, organized in dozens of Russian cities.
Navalny did not, of course, have any chance of winning the presi-
dential election, but his actions seem to have been dictated by long-term
goals. His aim is to run for president in either 2024 or 2030, and the
recent campaign was a great opportunity to build his public image and
prepare to run in a future election as a nationwide candidate, an opinion
32	 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa	 ŚSP 3 ’18
shared by an expert from the Carnegie analytical center, Andrei Koles-
nikov (Kolesnikov, 2017). The creation of a strong candidate appears to
be a great strategy for the Russian opposition, especially during the time
of the super-presidency, where neither Parliament, nor the government
play an important role in actual governance. If the Russian authorities
prolong the exclusion of Navalny from the political scene (e.g., through
long-time jail sentences), and he continues to slowly build his position
by completing his manifesto with proposals for tangible change, he can
count on higher support than 1–2% in the next election.
Conclusions
The campaign carried out by Alexei Navalny in 2017 and 2018 un-
doubtedly was only a prelude to the preparations for the next presidential
election; this time it was mainly informational. It has also proven that in
Russian public life there is a demand – although still low – for a different
style of politics. Direct meetings with voters, real conversations about
problems, tangible solutions and demands are the main characteristics of
this campaign, as are anti-government protests, which attracted thousands
of people, hundreds of volunteers and millions of rubles donated by Rus-
sians to the campaign. As a result, the recognition of Navalny has risen,
if only slightly. He also gained necessary experience before his next elec-
tion campaign.
Just after Putin’s fourth electoral victory, his opposition competitor
can now count on the support of 1–2% of Russians. Despite the fact that
he accurately identifies major issues which affect Russians, and his anti-
corruption actions could be appealing to millions of voters from smaller
towns and cities, Navalny has one main problem – he does not exist on
television (he only appears there in a negative context, as a defendant or
leader of another riot). Television is the main medium from which the
majority of Russians acquire information (over 80%). Hence, it will be
extremely difficult to translate the support from protests and rallies to
actual votes.
In mid-May another founding congress of Navalny’s new party, Rus-
sia of the Future, took place. Its aim is to make tangible changes and
reforms in Russia. It will surely provide great support for the opposition
candidate in the coming years. However, in the battle for power, given
the specificity of the Russian political system (strong personalization, the
ŚSP 3 ’18	 “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny...	 33
majority of actual power concentrated in the hands of the President), he
must focus mainly on building his individual position and try to reach the
so-called television Russia. At the same time, it is unlikely the Russian
authorities will allow the uncontrolled increase of his popularity.
Bibliography
«Забастовка избирателей»: по стране задержаны более 350 человек, в их числе
– Навальный, “Новая газета”, https://www.novayagazeta.ru/articles/2018/
01/28/75298-zabastovka-izbirateley-28-yanvarya-onlayn, 21.05.2018.
Kolesnikov A. (2017), Alexei Navalny’s Permanent Revolution, http://carnegie.ru/
2017/10/09/alexei-navalny-s-permanent-revolution-pub-73338, 22.05.2018.
Konstytucja Federacji Rosyjskiej przyjęta w ogólnonarodowym referendum w dniu
12 grudnia 1993 roku, http://libr.sejm.gov.pl/tek01/txt/konst/rosja.html,
19.05.2018.
Strzelecki J. (2017), Nawalny wyeliminowany z wyborów prezydenckich w Rosji,Ana-
lizy OSW, https://www.osw.waw.pl/pl/publikacje/analizy/2017-05-10/nawal-
ny-wyeliminowany-z-wyborow-prezydenckich-w-rosji, 19.05.2018.
Год кампании в цифрах и событиях, https://2018.navalny.com/post/502/,
20.05.2018.
Кампания Навального 2018. Как это было, https://2018.navalny.com/, 22.05.2018.
Лебеденко С. (2018), «Не узнаю без грима». Суд арестовал Навального на 30 су-
ток за акцию «Он вам не царь». Заседание длилось около восьми часов,
https://www.novayagazeta.ru/articles/2018/05/16/76486-ne-uznayu-bez-gri-
ma, 22.05.2018.
Левада-Центр (2017a), Российский Медиаландшафт – 2017, https://www.levada.
ru/2017/08/22/16440/, 20.05.2018.
Левада-Центр(2017b),ПротестыиНавальный,https://www.levada.ru/2017/07/17/
protesty-i-navalnyj/, 20.05.2018.
Литой А. (2018), Акции против «царя»: избитые, задержанные, несовершен-
нолетние, ОВД-Инфо, https://ovdinfo.org/articles/2018/05/08/akcii-protiv-
carya-izbitye-zaderzhannye-nesovershennoletnie, 18.05.2018.
Объявляем забастовку избирателей, https://2018.navalny.com/post/496/,
21.05.2018.
Определение Конституционного Суда Российской Федерайии об отказе в при-
нятии к рассмотрению жалобы гражданина Навального Алексея
Анатольевича на нарушение его конституционных прав подпунктом
1 пункта 52 статьи 3 Федерального закона „О выборах Президента
Российской Федерации”, http://doc.ksrf.ru/decision/KSRFDecision310695.
pdf, 19.05.2018.
Прекрасная Россия Будущего, https://2018.navalny.com/post/492/, 21.05.2018.
34	 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa	 ŚSP 3 ’18
Программа Алексея Навального, https://2018.navalny.com/platform/, 21.05.2018.
Процедура выборов президента в Российской Федерации, РИА Новости, https://
ria.ru/spravka/20171218/1510514992.html, 19.05.2018.
Федеральный закон „О выборах Президента Российской Федерации” от
10.01.2003 N 19-ФЗ, http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_
40445/, 19.05.2018.
Филимонов A. (2018), «Он нам не царь», последствия: полторы тысячи задер-
жанных, рекордные штрафы, тайные суды и одно уголовное дело (за
якобы выбитый у полицейского зуб), https://meduza.io/feature/2018/05/07/
on-nam-ne-tsar-posledstviya-poltory-tysyachi-zaderzhannyh-rekordnye-
shtrafy-taynye-sudy-i-odno-ugolovnoe-delo-za-yakoby-vybityy-u-po­li­t­
seyskogo-zub, 22.05.2018.
Финальный финансовый отчет кампании, Навальный20!8, https://2018.navalny.
com/post/1075/, 20.05.2018.
„Nie/kampania nie/istniejącego kandydata”
– Aleksiej Nawalny w wyborach prezydenckich w Rosji w 2018 r.
Streszczenie
W marcu 2018 r. w Federacji Rosyjskiej odbyły się kolejne wybory prezydenckie.
Elekcję po raz czwarty, zdecydowaną większością głosów, wygrał Władimir Putin.
Do udziału w rywalizacji na urząd prezydenta nie został dopuszczony Aleksiej Na-
walny – opozycjonista, który swoją kampanię wyborczą przygotowywał od końca
2016 r. Pomimo eliminacji z procesu wyborczego, A. Nawalny pozostał aktywnym
uczestnikiem życia politycznego Rosji przed i po wyborach, przeprowadził także ak-
cję bojkotu wyborów oraz zorganizował powyborcze protesty. Nie ulega wątpliwości,
iż pomimo zakazu udziału w elekcji, A. Nawalny był jedną z kluczowych postaci pro-
cesu wyborczego. Dlatego też, celem artykułu jest pogłębiona analiza przygotowań
do kampanii A. Nawalnego – autorzy skupili się nie tylko na opozycyjnej działalności
kandydata, ale również na unikalnych środkach i metodach prowadzenia przez niego
kampanii (internet, media społecznościowe, crowdfunding). W ramach artykułu omó-
wione zostały nie tylko przygotowania do kampanii, ale również przyczyny odmowy
rejestracji A. Nawalnego jako kandydata, wskaźniki społecznego poparcia, relacje
z innymi kandydatami oraz zmiana strategii po decyzji komisji wyborczej. Analiza
powstała w oparciu o badania nad aktami rosyjskiego prawa, decyzjami centralnej
komisji wyborczej, wynikami badań opinii publicznej oraz przekazami w rosyjskich
i międzynarodowych mediach.
Słowa kluczowe: wybory w Rosji, Prezydent Rosji, A. Nawalny, kampania wybor-
cza, opozycja polityczna

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Ukraine human rights report 2017
Ukraine human rights report 2017Ukraine human rights report 2017
Ukraine human rights report 2017DonbassFullAccess
 
Доповідь про порушення прав людини
Доповідь про порушення прав людини Доповідь про порушення прав людини
Доповідь про порушення прав людини RBC-Ukraine
 
Journalists and media in Ukraine - Reporters Without Borders - 2016
Journalists and media in Ukraine - Reporters Without Borders - 2016Journalists and media in Ukraine - Reporters Without Borders - 2016
Journalists and media in Ukraine - Reporters Without Borders - 2016DonbassFullAccess
 
Russias warinukraine themedals_and_treacherousnumbers-4
Russias warinukraine themedals_and_treacherousnumbers-4Russias warinukraine themedals_and_treacherousnumbers-4
Russias warinukraine themedals_and_treacherousnumbers-4John Connor
 
Letter ofac potrnov
Letter ofac potrnovLetter ofac potrnov
Letter ofac potrnovssuser7066e2
 
The Representation of citizens’ Foreign Policy orientations by Ukraine’s Domi...
The Representation of citizens’ Foreign Policy orientations by Ukraine’s Domi...The Representation of citizens’ Foreign Policy orientations by Ukraine’s Domi...
The Representation of citizens’ Foreign Policy orientations by Ukraine’s Domi...Oleh Ivanov
 
Statement on the Commitment of a Criminal Offense in accordance with Art. 214...
Statement on the Commitment of a Criminal Offense in accordance with Art. 214...Statement on the Commitment of a Criminal Offense in accordance with Art. 214...
Statement on the Commitment of a Criminal Offense in accordance with Art. 214...NABU Leaks
 
How Government Works in Ukraine
How Government Works in UkraineHow Government Works in Ukraine
How Government Works in Ukraineradaprogram
 
How Government works in Ukraine
How Government works in Ukraine How Government works in Ukraine
How Government works in Ukraine radaprogram
 
Summary of the UHHRU report «Story of a City. Occupation and Liberation of Se...
Summary of the UHHRU report «Story of a City. Occupation and Liberation of Se...Summary of the UHHRU report «Story of a City. Occupation and Liberation of Se...
Summary of the UHHRU report «Story of a City. Occupation and Liberation of Se...DonbassFullAccess
 
How Government works in Ukraine
How Government works in Ukraine How Government works in Ukraine
How Government works in Ukraine radaprogram
 
Analytical report «A lost vote. Is this a lifetime silence?»
Analytical report «A lost vote. Is this a lifetime silence?»Analytical report «A lost vote. Is this a lifetime silence?»
Analytical report «A lost vote. Is this a lifetime silence?»DonbassFullAccess
 
2014 annual report of Centre UA
2014 annual report of Centre UA2014 annual report of Centre UA
2014 annual report of Centre UAValeriia Moiseieva
 
How Government Works in Ukraine (14.02.2018)
How Government Works in Ukraine (14.02.2018)How Government Works in Ukraine (14.02.2018)
How Government Works in Ukraine (14.02.2018)radaprogram
 

Tendances (19)

Ukraine human rights report 2017
Ukraine human rights report 2017Ukraine human rights report 2017
Ukraine human rights report 2017
 
Доповідь про порушення прав людини
Доповідь про порушення прав людини Доповідь про порушення прав людини
Доповідь про порушення прав людини
 
Intermediate Report on Monitoring Ukraine's 2019 Presidential Election, 1-28 ...
Intermediate Report on Monitoring Ukraine's 2019 Presidential Election, 1-28 ...Intermediate Report on Monitoring Ukraine's 2019 Presidential Election, 1-28 ...
Intermediate Report on Monitoring Ukraine's 2019 Presidential Election, 1-28 ...
 
Journalists and media in Ukraine - Reporters Without Borders - 2016
Journalists and media in Ukraine - Reporters Without Borders - 2016Journalists and media in Ukraine - Reporters Without Borders - 2016
Journalists and media in Ukraine - Reporters Without Borders - 2016
 
Russias warinukraine themedals_and_treacherousnumbers-4
Russias warinukraine themedals_and_treacherousnumbers-4Russias warinukraine themedals_and_treacherousnumbers-4
Russias warinukraine themedals_and_treacherousnumbers-4
 
“The Threat from the East", as seen by Ukrainians
“The Threat from the East", as seen by Ukrainians“The Threat from the East", as seen by Ukrainians
“The Threat from the East", as seen by Ukrainians
 
Letter ofac potrnov
Letter ofac potrnovLetter ofac potrnov
Letter ofac potrnov
 
The Representation of citizens’ Foreign Policy orientations by Ukraine’s Domi...
The Representation of citizens’ Foreign Policy orientations by Ukraine’s Domi...The Representation of citizens’ Foreign Policy orientations by Ukraine’s Domi...
The Representation of citizens’ Foreign Policy orientations by Ukraine’s Domi...
 
Political and civil rights in Ukraine July September 2018
Political and civil rights in Ukraine July September 2018Political and civil rights in Ukraine July September 2018
Political and civil rights in Ukraine July September 2018
 
Statement on the Commitment of a Criminal Offense in accordance with Art. 214...
Statement on the Commitment of a Criminal Offense in accordance with Art. 214...Statement on the Commitment of a Criminal Offense in accordance with Art. 214...
Statement on the Commitment of a Criminal Offense in accordance with Art. 214...
 
Monitoring "What is happening to freedom of speech in Ukraine. State censorsh...
Monitoring "What is happening to freedom of speech in Ukraine. State censorsh...Monitoring "What is happening to freedom of speech in Ukraine. State censorsh...
Monitoring "What is happening to freedom of speech in Ukraine. State censorsh...
 
How Government Works in Ukraine
How Government Works in UkraineHow Government Works in Ukraine
How Government Works in Ukraine
 
How Government works in Ukraine
How Government works in Ukraine How Government works in Ukraine
How Government works in Ukraine
 
Summary of the UHHRU report «Story of a City. Occupation and Liberation of Se...
Summary of the UHHRU report «Story of a City. Occupation and Liberation of Se...Summary of the UHHRU report «Story of a City. Occupation and Liberation of Se...
Summary of the UHHRU report «Story of a City. Occupation and Liberation of Se...
 
How Government works in Ukraine
How Government works in Ukraine How Government works in Ukraine
How Government works in Ukraine
 
Analytical report «A lost vote. Is this a lifetime silence?»
Analytical report «A lost vote. Is this a lifetime silence?»Analytical report «A lost vote. Is this a lifetime silence?»
Analytical report «A lost vote. Is this a lifetime silence?»
 
Human Rights Practices for 2015 Ukraine
Human Rights Practices for 2015 UkraineHuman Rights Practices for 2015 Ukraine
Human Rights Practices for 2015 Ukraine
 
2014 annual report of Centre UA
2014 annual report of Centre UA2014 annual report of Centre UA
2014 annual report of Centre UA
 
How Government Works in Ukraine (14.02.2018)
How Government Works in Ukraine (14.02.2018)How Government Works in Ukraine (14.02.2018)
How Government Works in Ukraine (14.02.2018)
 

Similaire à “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny in the 2018 presidential election in Russia

SMLA Moscow Mayoral Campaign Presentation Dec 2013
SMLA Moscow Mayoral Campaign Presentation Dec 2013SMLA Moscow Mayoral Campaign Presentation Dec 2013
SMLA Moscow Mayoral Campaign Presentation Dec 2013Vladimir Ashurkov
 
Ucrania, white book
Ucrania, white bookUcrania, white book
Ucrania, white bookLuis Arbide
 
Overview of the Development of Electoral Legislation of the Republic Uzbekistan
Overview of the Development of Electoral Legislation of the Republic UzbekistanOverview of the Development of Electoral Legislation of the Republic Uzbekistan
Overview of the Development of Electoral Legislation of the Republic Uzbekistanijtsrd
 
Freedom of Expression in RussiaAs much as the fre.docx
Freedom of Expression in RussiaAs much as the fre.docxFreedom of Expression in RussiaAs much as the fre.docx
Freedom of Expression in RussiaAs much as the fre.docxhanneloremccaffery
 
Odf euromaidan report_eng
Odf euromaidan report_engOdf euromaidan report_eng
Odf euromaidan report_engodfoundation
 
How Vladimir Putin Maintains his Electoral Authoritarianism
How Vladimir Putin Maintains his Electoral AuthoritarianismHow Vladimir Putin Maintains his Electoral Authoritarianism
How Vladimir Putin Maintains his Electoral AuthoritarianismBrian Ammer
 
Human rights violations it the LNR/DNR
Human rights violations it the LNR/DNRHuman rights violations it the LNR/DNR
Human rights violations it the LNR/DNRDonbassFullAccess
 
Post-election Russia, End of Putin's Era?
Post-election Russia, End of Putin's Era?Post-election Russia, End of Putin's Era?
Post-election Russia, End of Putin's Era?Oleg Kozlovsky
 
Cvu annual report form 2016
Cvu annual report form 2016Cvu annual report form 2016
Cvu annual report form 2016cvusecretar
 
Opposition in authoritarian regimes – a case study of Russian non-systemic op...
Opposition in authoritarian regimes – a case study of Russian non-systemic op...Opposition in authoritarian regimes – a case study of Russian non-systemic op...
Opposition in authoritarian regimes – a case study of Russian non-systemic op...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Odf 06.02.2014 ukraine_military_scenario_eng
Odf 06.02.2014 ukraine_military_scenario_engOdf 06.02.2014 ukraine_military_scenario_eng
Odf 06.02.2014 ukraine_military_scenario_engodfoundation
 
Daniel George Robinson_ Russia politics writing sample
Daniel George Robinson_ Russia politics writing sampleDaniel George Robinson_ Russia politics writing sample
Daniel George Robinson_ Russia politics writing sampleDaniel Robinson
 
Parliamentary sovereignty in the modern legal policy in the russian federatio...
Parliamentary sovereignty in the modern legal policy in the russian federatio...Parliamentary sovereignty in the modern legal policy in the russian federatio...
Parliamentary sovereignty in the modern legal policy in the russian federatio...Alexander Decker
 
Ukrainian revolution from the point of view of the Russian analyst
Ukrainian revolution from the point of view of the Russian analystUkrainian revolution from the point of view of the Russian analyst
Ukrainian revolution from the point of view of the Russian analystЕлена Волковская
 
The Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society report
The Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society reportThe Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society report
The Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society reportIlya Ponomarev
 

Similaire à “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny in the 2018 presidential election in Russia (20)

Report “Political rights and freedoms in Ukraine: Monitoring compliance in 2018”
Report “Political rights and freedoms in Ukraine: Monitoring compliance in 2018”Report “Political rights and freedoms in Ukraine: Monitoring compliance in 2018”
Report “Political rights and freedoms in Ukraine: Monitoring compliance in 2018”
 
SMLA Moscow Mayoral Campaign Presentation Dec 2013
SMLA Moscow Mayoral Campaign Presentation Dec 2013SMLA Moscow Mayoral Campaign Presentation Dec 2013
SMLA Moscow Mayoral Campaign Presentation Dec 2013
 
Ucrania, white book
Ucrania, white bookUcrania, white book
Ucrania, white book
 
Overview of the Development of Electoral Legislation of the Republic Uzbekistan
Overview of the Development of Electoral Legislation of the Republic UzbekistanOverview of the Development of Electoral Legislation of the Republic Uzbekistan
Overview of the Development of Electoral Legislation of the Republic Uzbekistan
 
Freedom of Expression in RussiaAs much as the fre.docx
Freedom of Expression in RussiaAs much as the fre.docxFreedom of Expression in RussiaAs much as the fre.docx
Freedom of Expression in RussiaAs much as the fre.docx
 
HumanRightsRussiaPOL321
HumanRightsRussiaPOL321HumanRightsRussiaPOL321
HumanRightsRussiaPOL321
 
Analytical media project “The reflection of Russian social and political lif...
Analytical media project  “The reflection of Russian social and political lif...Analytical media project  “The reflection of Russian social and political lif...
Analytical media project “The reflection of Russian social and political lif...
 
Odf euromaidan report_eng
Odf euromaidan report_engOdf euromaidan report_eng
Odf euromaidan report_eng
 
How Vladimir Putin Maintains his Electoral Authoritarianism
How Vladimir Putin Maintains his Electoral AuthoritarianismHow Vladimir Putin Maintains his Electoral Authoritarianism
How Vladimir Putin Maintains his Electoral Authoritarianism
 
Human rights violations it the LNR/DNR
Human rights violations it the LNR/DNRHuman rights violations it the LNR/DNR
Human rights violations it the LNR/DNR
 
Post-election Russia, End of Putin's Era?
Post-election Russia, End of Putin's Era?Post-election Russia, End of Putin's Era?
Post-election Russia, End of Putin's Era?
 
Cvu annual report form 2016
Cvu annual report form 2016Cvu annual report form 2016
Cvu annual report form 2016
 
MM-Election-2012-ENG
MM-Election-2012-ENGMM-Election-2012-ENG
MM-Election-2012-ENG
 
Putin 3.0 02.04
Putin 3.0 02.04Putin 3.0 02.04
Putin 3.0 02.04
 
Opposition in authoritarian regimes – a case study of Russian non-systemic op...
Opposition in authoritarian regimes – a case study of Russian non-systemic op...Opposition in authoritarian regimes – a case study of Russian non-systemic op...
Opposition in authoritarian regimes – a case study of Russian non-systemic op...
 
Odf 06.02.2014 ukraine_military_scenario_eng
Odf 06.02.2014 ukraine_military_scenario_engOdf 06.02.2014 ukraine_military_scenario_eng
Odf 06.02.2014 ukraine_military_scenario_eng
 
Daniel George Robinson_ Russia politics writing sample
Daniel George Robinson_ Russia politics writing sampleDaniel George Robinson_ Russia politics writing sample
Daniel George Robinson_ Russia politics writing sample
 
Parliamentary sovereignty in the modern legal policy in the russian federatio...
Parliamentary sovereignty in the modern legal policy in the russian federatio...Parliamentary sovereignty in the modern legal policy in the russian federatio...
Parliamentary sovereignty in the modern legal policy in the russian federatio...
 
Ukrainian revolution from the point of view of the Russian analyst
Ukrainian revolution from the point of view of the Russian analystUkrainian revolution from the point of view of the Russian analyst
Ukrainian revolution from the point of view of the Russian analyst
 
The Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society report
The Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society reportThe Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society report
The Russian Opposition - Julia Pettengill, Henry Jackson Society report
 

Plus de Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne

The activity of the Mamy Głos Foundation in the context of youth political a...
The activity of the Mamy Głos Foundation  in the context of youth political a...The activity of the Mamy Głos Foundation  in the context of youth political a...
The activity of the Mamy Głos Foundation in the context of youth political a...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Impact of Brexit on the status of the English language in the European Union
Impact of Brexit on the status of the English  language in the European UnionImpact of Brexit on the status of the English  language in the European Union
Impact of Brexit on the status of the English language in the European UnionŚrodkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Formation of populism in Spain: towards the explanatory framework of the 15-M...
Formation of populism in Spain: towards the explanatory framework of the 15-M...Formation of populism in Spain: towards the explanatory framework of the 15-M...
Formation of populism in Spain: towards the explanatory framework of the 15-M...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Saturation of the media with conspiracy narratives: content analysis of selec...
Saturation of the media with conspiracy narratives: content analysis of selec...Saturation of the media with conspiracy narratives: content analysis of selec...
Saturation of the media with conspiracy narratives: content analysis of selec...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
The Rule of Law and the EU Budget for 2021–2027: More Solidarity or Renouncin...
The Rule of Law and the EU Budget for 2021–2027: More Solidarity or Renouncin...The Rule of Law and the EU Budget for 2021–2027: More Solidarity or Renouncin...
The Rule of Law and the EU Budget for 2021–2027: More Solidarity or Renouncin...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
International sports organizations as diplomatic actors. The case of FIFA exe...
International sports organizations as diplomatic actors. The case of FIFA exe...International sports organizations as diplomatic actors. The case of FIFA exe...
International sports organizations as diplomatic actors. The case of FIFA exe...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Civil society as an actor in the political processes of local governance refo...
Civil society as an actor in the political processes of local governance refo...Civil society as an actor in the political processes of local governance refo...
Civil society as an actor in the political processes of local governance refo...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
The influence of illiberal democracy on the effectiveness of attempts to cont...
The influence of illiberal democracy on the effectiveness of attempts to cont...The influence of illiberal democracy on the effectiveness of attempts to cont...
The influence of illiberal democracy on the effectiveness of attempts to cont...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Education and information in consumer policy in the Republic of Poland
Education and information in consumer policy  in the Republic of PolandEducation and information in consumer policy  in the Republic of Poland
Education and information in consumer policy in the Republic of PolandŚrodkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Farmland and people as essential resources of Poland in the concepts of Poli...
Farmland and people as essential resources  of Poland in the concepts of Poli...Farmland and people as essential resources  of Poland in the concepts of Poli...
Farmland and people as essential resources of Poland in the concepts of Poli...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
The impact of Brexit on the member states’ ability to build blocking coalitio...
The impact of Brexit on the member states’ ability to build blocking coalitio...The impact of Brexit on the member states’ ability to build blocking coalitio...
The impact of Brexit on the member states’ ability to build blocking coalitio...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Dedykowany storytelling – psychologiczne przesłanki perswazyjnej efektywności...
Dedykowany storytelling – psychologiczne przesłanki perswazyjnej efektywności...Dedykowany storytelling – psychologiczne przesłanki perswazyjnej efektywności...
Dedykowany storytelling – psychologiczne przesłanki perswazyjnej efektywności...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Human security, human rights and international law, and interactions between ...
Human security, human rights and international law, and interactions between ...Human security, human rights and international law, and interactions between ...
Human security, human rights and international law, and interactions between ...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Publiczne notowanie akcji jako źródło finansowania małych i średnich przedsię...
Publiczne notowanie akcji jako źródło finansowania małych i średnich przedsię...Publiczne notowanie akcji jako źródło finansowania małych i średnich przedsię...
Publiczne notowanie akcji jako źródło finansowania małych i średnich przedsię...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Polska w strefie euro? Trzy scenariusze i ich prawdopodobne konsekwencje ogól...
Polska w strefie euro? Trzy scenariusze i ich prawdopodobne konsekwencje ogól...Polska w strefie euro? Trzy scenariusze i ich prawdopodobne konsekwencje ogól...
Polska w strefie euro? Trzy scenariusze i ich prawdopodobne konsekwencje ogól...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Próby reformy systemu wyborczego do Rady Najwyższej Ukrainy w okresie przypad...
Próby reformy systemu wyborczego do Rady Najwyższej Ukrainy w okresie przypad...Próby reformy systemu wyborczego do Rady Najwyższej Ukrainy w okresie przypad...
Próby reformy systemu wyborczego do Rady Najwyższej Ukrainy w okresie przypad...Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 
Ustrój samorządu lokalnego w Republice Mołdawii. Ewolucja i stan obecny
Ustrój samorządu lokalnego w Republice Mołdawii. Ewolucja i stan obecnyUstrój samorządu lokalnego w Republice Mołdawii. Ewolucja i stan obecny
Ustrój samorządu lokalnego w Republice Mołdawii. Ewolucja i stan obecnyŚrodkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne
 

Plus de Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne (20)

The activity of the Mamy Głos Foundation in the context of youth political a...
The activity of the Mamy Głos Foundation  in the context of youth political a...The activity of the Mamy Głos Foundation  in the context of youth political a...
The activity of the Mamy Głos Foundation in the context of youth political a...
 
Impact of Brexit on the status of the English language in the European Union
Impact of Brexit on the status of the English  language in the European UnionImpact of Brexit on the status of the English  language in the European Union
Impact of Brexit on the status of the English language in the European Union
 
Formation of populism in Spain: towards the explanatory framework of the 15-M...
Formation of populism in Spain: towards the explanatory framework of the 15-M...Formation of populism in Spain: towards the explanatory framework of the 15-M...
Formation of populism in Spain: towards the explanatory framework of the 15-M...
 
Non-military dimension of the hybrid war in Ukraine
Non-military dimension of the hybrid war  in UkraineNon-military dimension of the hybrid war  in Ukraine
Non-military dimension of the hybrid war in Ukraine
 
Saturation of the media with conspiracy narratives: content analysis of selec...
Saturation of the media with conspiracy narratives: content analysis of selec...Saturation of the media with conspiracy narratives: content analysis of selec...
Saturation of the media with conspiracy narratives: content analysis of selec...
 
Promotion of regional and traditional products
Promotion of regional and traditional productsPromotion of regional and traditional products
Promotion of regional and traditional products
 
The Rule of Law and the EU Budget for 2021–2027: More Solidarity or Renouncin...
The Rule of Law and the EU Budget for 2021–2027: More Solidarity or Renouncin...The Rule of Law and the EU Budget for 2021–2027: More Solidarity or Renouncin...
The Rule of Law and the EU Budget for 2021–2027: More Solidarity or Renouncin...
 
International sports organizations as diplomatic actors. The case of FIFA exe...
International sports organizations as diplomatic actors. The case of FIFA exe...International sports organizations as diplomatic actors. The case of FIFA exe...
International sports organizations as diplomatic actors. The case of FIFA exe...
 
Civil society as an actor in the political processes of local governance refo...
Civil society as an actor in the political processes of local governance refo...Civil society as an actor in the political processes of local governance refo...
Civil society as an actor in the political processes of local governance refo...
 
The influence of illiberal democracy on the effectiveness of attempts to cont...
The influence of illiberal democracy on the effectiveness of attempts to cont...The influence of illiberal democracy on the effectiveness of attempts to cont...
The influence of illiberal democracy on the effectiveness of attempts to cont...
 
Education and information in consumer policy in the Republic of Poland
Education and information in consumer policy  in the Republic of PolandEducation and information in consumer policy  in the Republic of Poland
Education and information in consumer policy in the Republic of Poland
 
Farmland and people as essential resources of Poland in the concepts of Poli...
Farmland and people as essential resources  of Poland in the concepts of Poli...Farmland and people as essential resources  of Poland in the concepts of Poli...
Farmland and people as essential resources of Poland in the concepts of Poli...
 
The impact of Brexit on the member states’ ability to build blocking coalitio...
The impact of Brexit on the member states’ ability to build blocking coalitio...The impact of Brexit on the member states’ ability to build blocking coalitio...
The impact of Brexit on the member states’ ability to build blocking coalitio...
 
Dedykowany storytelling – psychologiczne przesłanki perswazyjnej efektywności...
Dedykowany storytelling – psychologiczne przesłanki perswazyjnej efektywności...Dedykowany storytelling – psychologiczne przesłanki perswazyjnej efektywności...
Dedykowany storytelling – psychologiczne przesłanki perswazyjnej efektywności...
 
Human security, human rights and international law, and interactions between ...
Human security, human rights and international law, and interactions between ...Human security, human rights and international law, and interactions between ...
Human security, human rights and international law, and interactions between ...
 
Publiczne notowanie akcji jako źródło finansowania małych i średnich przedsię...
Publiczne notowanie akcji jako źródło finansowania małych i średnich przedsię...Publiczne notowanie akcji jako źródło finansowania małych i średnich przedsię...
Publiczne notowanie akcji jako źródło finansowania małych i średnich przedsię...
 
Polska w strefie euro? Trzy scenariusze i ich prawdopodobne konsekwencje ogól...
Polska w strefie euro? Trzy scenariusze i ich prawdopodobne konsekwencje ogól...Polska w strefie euro? Trzy scenariusze i ich prawdopodobne konsekwencje ogól...
Polska w strefie euro? Trzy scenariusze i ich prawdopodobne konsekwencje ogól...
 
Trauma transformacji w Europie Środkowo-Wschodniej
Trauma transformacji w Europie Środkowo-WschodniejTrauma transformacji w Europie Środkowo-Wschodniej
Trauma transformacji w Europie Środkowo-Wschodniej
 
Próby reformy systemu wyborczego do Rady Najwyższej Ukrainy w okresie przypad...
Próby reformy systemu wyborczego do Rady Najwyższej Ukrainy w okresie przypad...Próby reformy systemu wyborczego do Rady Najwyższej Ukrainy w okresie przypad...
Próby reformy systemu wyborczego do Rady Najwyższej Ukrainy w okresie przypad...
 
Ustrój samorządu lokalnego w Republice Mołdawii. Ewolucja i stan obecny
Ustrój samorządu lokalnego w Republice Mołdawii. Ewolucja i stan obecnyUstrój samorządu lokalnego w Republice Mołdawii. Ewolucja i stan obecny
Ustrój samorządu lokalnego w Republice Mołdawii. Ewolucja i stan obecny
 

Dernier

16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdfFIRST INDIA
 
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfkcomplaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfkbhavenpr
 
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012ankitnayak356677
 
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for JusticeRohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for JusticeAbdulGhani778830
 
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.NaveedKhaskheli1
 
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdfGerald Furnkranz
 
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpkManipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpkbhavenpr
 
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global NewsIndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global NewsIndiaWest2
 
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the roundsQuiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the roundsnaxymaxyy
 
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming TrendExperience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming TrendFabwelt
 

Dernier (10)

16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfkcomplaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
 
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
 
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for JusticeRohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
 
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
 
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
 
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpkManipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
 
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global NewsIndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
 
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the roundsQuiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
 
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming TrendExperience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
 

“Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny in the 2018 presidential election in Russia

  • 1. DOI 10.14746/ssp.2018.3.2 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny in the 2018 presidential election in Russia Abstract: In March 2018, another presidential election took place in the Russian Federation. For the fourth time Vladimir Putin won the election by a large majority of votes. Alexei Navalny – an opposition candidate who had been preparing his election campaign since the end of 2016 – was not allowed to stand in the election. Regardless of his elimination from the election, Navalny remained an active member of Russian political life before and after the election; he carried out a boycott of the election, and organized post-election protests. Without a doubt, despite the ban on running in the election, Navalny was one of the main figures in the electoral process. Thus, the aim of this article is a detailed analysis of Navalny’s preparations for the campaign – the authors focused not only on the candidate’s opposition activity, but also on his unique measures and methods of running a campaign (Internet, social media, crowd- funding). The article examines the campaign preparations, as well as the reasons for the rejection of Navalny’s registration as an election candidate, social support index, relationships with other candidates and the change of strategy after the Central Elec- tion Commission’s decision. The analysis is based on Russian law, Central Election Commission’s decisions, opinion poll results and information from the Russian and international media. Key words: Russian elections, Russian president,Alexei Navalny, election campaign, political opposition On May 7, 2018, seven weeks after the election, the inauguration of Vladimir Putin’s fourth term as president took place. Two days earlier, more than ten Russian cities organized demonstrations under the slogan “He’s not our tsar.”1 The main originator and organizer of the 1   The biggest demonstrations took place in Moscow and Saint Petersburg. The cities’ authorities did not give permission to carry out protests, hence both events were illegal. Despite that, at least several thousand people took part in the protests. Among the slogans, apart from the main one of “He’s not our tsar” (regarding Putin’s 18 years of presidency) there appeared “Russia without corruption,” “Cast forth the
  • 2. 22 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa ŚSP 3 ’18 protests was the informal leader of the non-parliamentary opposition, Alexei Navalny, who had planned to run in the presidential election. The whole process of preparation for the election had been carefully planned by Navalny himself and his volunteering staff. They took care of details such as campaign funds, efficient collection of signatures supporting his candidacy and a PR campaign in the mass media. But on December 25, 2017, the Russian Central Electoral Commission rejected Navalny’s reg- istration, due to his lack of passive voting rights. In the end, despite an appeal against the Commission’s decision in court and its interpretation of a constitutional provision favorable to Navalny, he was not allowed to stand in the election. In addition to unofficially taking part in the election campaign, he was an active member of Russian political life before and after the election. He also carried out a boycott of the election and orga- nized post-election protests. It is without a doubt that Navalny was one of the key figures in the electoral process, despite not being allowed to run. Hence the aim of this article is to analyze Navalny’s campaign prepara- tions – not only because of the fact that he had a real chance of becoming the only opposition presidential candidate with a chance of winning,2 but also because of the means and methods of running his campaign (the use of the Internet, crowdfunding, etc.). The authors of the article analyzed the campaign preparations and the reasons for denying Navalny registration, tsar,” “We are not slaves,” “Putin retire.” During the demonstration, confrontations between the protesters and the police, including mass arrests took place – over 700 people in Moscow and about 1,600 in the whole country were arrested (data ОВД- Инфо – independent projects devoted to political oppression in Russia; Литой, 2018). In Saint Petersburg, when protesters went out onto the main street – the Nevsky Pros- pect – they were arrested by police within a few minutes. The main organizer of the protests, Alexei Navalny was also arrested (and sentenced to 30 days in jail). Protests took place in other cities as well, e.g., Chelyabinsk, Yakutsk, Krasnodar, Voronezh and many others. 2   Formally, 8 candidates representing different political parties and initiatives ran in the election. However, the majority of them originate from parties that, for years, have been operating in the framework of the Russian political system and do not have any influence upon it. It is rare for the representatives of these parties to engage in oppositional actions against the authorities or criticize those in power. Only Ksenia Sobchak declared that her candidacy would guarantee the presence of opposition in the election, especially after denying Navalny the possibility of standing in the elec- tion. However, as a result of the lack of political experience and opposition support, as well as infinitesimal support from society and doubts about her independence (there were rumors that the candidate was convenient for Vladimir Putin), Ksenia Sobchak’s candidacy was not taken seriously.
  • 3. ŚSP 3 ’18 “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny... 23 his social support index, relationships with other candidates and change of strategy after the Electoral Commission’s decision. The analysis has been carried out based on research on Russian law, the Central Electoral Commission’s decisions, results of public opinion polls and information in Russian and international media. Russian election ordinance In Russia, the procedure of carrying out presidential elections is regu- lated by the following acts: the Constitution of Russia, Federal Law “On Basic Guarantees of Electoral Rights and the Right of Citizens of the Russian Federation to Participate in a Referendum,” Federal Law “On the Election of the President of the Russian Federation,” and selected laws from other acts (Процедура выборов). Elections are general, equal, di- rect and are carried out by secret voting. Suffrage has been guaranteed to everyone, regardless of their sex, race, nationality, parentage, possession and social status, affiliation to public associations or other circumstanc- es. The only limitation to active voting is age – voters must be at least 18 years of age. Additionally, voting rights and rights to be elected are not granted to people who are incapacitated by court decision or in prison at the time of the election (Федеральный закон „О выборах…”). A Russian citizen who is at least 35 years of age and has been living on the country’s territory continually for 10 years can be elected President of the Russian Federation. In addition, the same person cannot be President of the Russian Federation for longer than 2 consecutive terms (Konstytucja Federacji Rosyjskiej, art. 80). No other limitations are stated in the Con- stitution. Other conditions have been included in the Law “On the Elec- tion of the President of the Russian Federation” of 2014. According to the amended paragraph 5.2, article 3, a passive voting right is denied to people sentenced to prison for major crimes, extremist crimes, and for administra- tive crimes if the sentence is being served during the election period. An offender loses their passive voting right not only for the duration of the sentence, but for a further 10 to 15 years (depending on the seriousness of the crime) from the date of expungement or discontinuation of the sentence. After the introduction of these amendments to the election ordinance their constitutionality was questioned, and it has been assumed that the main ad- dressee of the law is the opposition candidate –Alexei Navalny. This matter will be closely analyzed in the following sections.
  • 4. 24 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa ŚSP 3 ’18 The regulations regarding the pre-election campaign can be found in the above mentioned acts. According to Article 50 of the Federal Law “On the Election of the President of the Russian Federation” the cam- paign starts on the day the candidate obtains approval for their candidacy from the Central Electoral Commission, and ends one day before the ac- tual voting. Separate regulations have been set out for campaigns using traditional media – television, radio, press. In that case, the campaign starts 28 days before the polling day, and ends also one day before the election. It is forbidden to campaign on the polling day and the day before it (Федеральный закон „О выборах…”). Regulations regarding the presidential election procedure in Russia do not seem to significantly differ from those applied in Western demo- cratic countries. However, the ability to use them instrumentally led to the elimination of the only opposition candidate from the election. Although according to the Russian law he could not be considered an official presi- dential candidate and his actions did not fall under the definition of an election campaign given by the law, his presence in the public sphere influenced not only the election process, but also the perception of it by Russian citizens and election observers. Elections without Alexei Navalny – the Russian Central Electoral Commission’s decision Three months before the election, on December 18, 2017, a decision of the Federation Council calling the presidential election was published, which is considered the beginning of the election campaign. Navalny had been preparing to stand for months prior to the announcement of the elec- tion. Even before the official beginning of the campaign, he had almost 80 groups of staff all around Russia, ready to work (Fig. 1). He also accumu- lated the required amount of 500 signatures under his candidacy. However, on December 25, 2017, the Central Electoral Commission refused Navalny’s registration as a candidate for the president of Russia. The reason was his lack of the passive voting right – in 2013, he received a 5 year suspended prison sentence for embezzlement in Kirowles. The first sentence was overruled and another examination of the case was or- dered by the European Court of Human Rights, which recognized the fact that Navalny had not been given access to a fair trial. However, the appeal ruling also convicted him. Therefore, according to the law on the election
  • 5. ŚSP 3 ’18 “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny... 25 of a president, amended in 2014, Navalny cannot run in elections until 2028 (a 5 year sentence plus a 10 year ban on standing in elections after the end of the sentence) (Strzelecki, 2017). After the Central Electoral Commission’s decision was issued, Na- valny argued that the law taking away the passive voting right from per- sons who are convicted, but do not serve the sentence in prison, is against the Russian Constitution (which only forbids the incapacitated and those sentenced to prison from standing in elections). Nonetheless, the Consti- tutional Court to which Navalny appealed against the Central Electoral Commission’s decision, refused to consider the matter and, at the same time, deemed the law limiting the passive voting right constitutional (Определение Конституционного Суда). As a consequence, Navalny lost his right to stand in the presidential elections in 2018 and 2024. Nev- ertheless, he did not abandon his campaign, which had already started, and decided to use the structures prepared and resources accumulated to carry out a boycott of the election and build support among Russian soci- ety for the coming years. Navalny’s “Non-campaign” Navalny’s unofficial campaign had begun over a year before the elec- tion. He expressed his will to run in the Russian presidential election in December 2016. In February 2017, in Petersburg, the first headquarters Figure 1. A map created by Navalny showing locations of his staff (as of early December 2017) Source: Навальный20!8, https://2018.navalny.com/, 4.12.2017.
  • 6. 26 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa ŚSP 3 ’18 of his presidential campaign was opened, and the opening of dozens more campaign offices was announced in the following months. The aim was to build as large a network of people as possible who would not only help in running the campaign but would also put their signature under Navalny’s candidacy.3 By the end of 2017, when it was finally certain that the op- position candidate would not stand in the election, 84 groups of staff in almost all regions of Russia had been created. They managed to accumu- late 700,000 declarations from people who put their signature under Na- valny’s candidacy. Additionally, almost 200,000 volunteers offered their help in running the potential campaign (Год кампании). Figure 2. Official website of Navalny as a Russian presidential candidate Source: Навальный20!8, https://2018.navalny.com/, 4.12.2017. The candidate’s professional website was also created for the purpose of the campaign, as well as accounts on social media and other channels of online communication (Facebook,Twitter, ВКонтакте, Одноклассники). Cohesive and modern visual identification, daily updates and the interac- tive form of communication (comments, discussions, etc.) helped Navalny 3   In accordance with Article 36 of the Law “On the Election of the President of the Russian Federation,” if Navalny had been allowed to stand in the election, he would have to get at least 300,000 signatures supporting his candidacy, includ- ing at least 7,500 in each region of the Russian Federation (Федеральный закон „О выборах”). If the candidate is put forward by a political party, he is required to gain only 100,000 signatures. Candidates proposed by a party which has representa- tives in the State Duma are an exception – they do not need any signatures under their candidacy.
  • 7. ŚSP 3 ’18 “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny... 27 gain support, especially among young voters.4 The opposition politician, as part of his campaign, visited many Russian cities and towns, organized meetings with voters, continued his spectacular anti-corruption initiative and organized protests.5 These actions showed measurable effects – in June 2017, more than half of Russians (55%) knew who Navalny was.6 This, of course, could not guarantee him electoral victory, since he only got 1–2% in the opinion polls. However, in a country where for the past 18 years power has been in the hands of one person, and there are no independent parties in the Parliament, gradually building support for an opposition candidate appears to be a good strategy. During the preparation for the election, funding had also been taken care of. At the time of collecting signatures under Navalny’s candidacy, a fund-raiser for the campaign was launched as well. Donations could be made through the website in various ways – direct transfers from the biggest Russian banks, account contributions, PayPal payments, card- 2card transfers and even Bitcoins. An online shop was opened, with Na- valny’s campaign merchandise expressing support for his candidacy for the president of Russia (t-shirts, bags, pins, stickers, mugs, etc.). The aim of the store was not only to accumulate funds for the campaign, but also to spread awareness of the candidate. In total, 368 million rubles (about 6 million US dollars – exchange rate as of May 2018) had been collected. Financial reports were shown on the candidate’s website every month, and in April 2018 detailed financial coverage of the whole campaign was published. According to the avail- 4   According to research conducted by the Levada-Center, young Russians (18–24 years old) are the most likely to use the Internet – in 2017 over 90% of them went online at least a few times a day. Also, the majority of the age group of 25–39 (almost 80%) uses the Internet several times a day (Левада-Центр, 2017a). 5   During this peculiar election campaign, in March 2017 the Anti-Corruption Foundation led by Navalny published a film titled “He Is Not Dimon to You,” in which the detailed results of the investigation into the connections between corruption and the concealed estate of Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev were presented. The film was viewed online by over 27 million people (during the first year, and 12 mil- lion in the first month). As a result, Medvedev lost public trust, and a large group of Russians demanded his resignation. Also, thousands of Russians took part in protests organized by Navalny against corruption among the authorities. 6   Only 4 years previously, despite the fact that Navalny was one of the faces of the so-called “white revolution” (mass post-election protests of 2012) and succeeded in Moscow’s mayor election (placing second and getting almost a third of the votes), only 1 in 3 Russians recognized his name (Левада-Центр, 2017b).
  • 8. 28 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa ŚSP 3 ’18 able information, the most commonly chosen amount of donation for Na- valny was (median) 500 rubles (about 8 dollars), and the average donation was 1,500 rubles (about 25 dollars). The opposition candidate’s campaign was supported by about 100,000 people.Abig part of the collected money was allocated to staff payments — a few hundred people were responsible for organizing events and rallies, training and coordination of the vol- unteers, verification and supervision of the campaign. Additionally, the maintenance of the network of local groups of staff was funded (premises and equipment renting, etc.) and funds for political agitation (online and offline) (Финальный финансовый отчет). Such extensive reporting of income and expenditure was meant to prevent any accusations of fraud from political opponents, and also strengthen the image of an honest op- position candidate who was fighting corruption among the authorities. Navalny’s election promise During Navalny’s election preparations, an election manifesto was published on his website – a part of the campaign required by the Russian law. According to his declarations, the manifesto had been formulated based on information gathered during rallies and meetings with the citi- zens of various cities and towns, and on expert opinions. In “Beautiful Russia of the Future” (as the platform was named) Navalny mainly refers to the inappropriate use of the country’s wealth – natural resources, quali- Figure 3. Online shop with Navalny’s campaign merchandise Source: Навальный20!8, https://2018.navalny.com/, 4.12.2017.
  • 9. ŚSP 3 ’18 “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny... 29 fied manpower, industry, agriculture and infrastructure, from which the profits, for almost two decades, have been going to a chosen few closely linked to authority. He called for the resources to be used as a foundation for the country’s prosperity. He planned to achieve his goal by increasing expenditure on healthcare and education.Additional funding was to be ac- quired by eliminating corruption and reducing spending on bureaucracy, propaganda, armed conflicts, etc. Human capital was to be a foundation of the new Russia – especially important were: education, new technologies, and innovation. A good, well-funded, high-level education was intended to guarantee the development of the country. Navalny also drew attention to income inequity (he demanded a raise in the minimum wage, retire- ment program reform and new taxes, e.g., for using infrastructure built by previous generations that was unfairly privatized in the 1990s). Among his promises, one can find those regarding strengthening (or more accu- rately – building) independent local governments and reinforcing regions. The main aims of foreign policy were to cooperate with other European countries, withdraw from armed conflicts (Syria, Ukraine), and regulate visa issues with CentralAsian countries (exacerbating the requirements to migrant workers) (Программа; Прекрасная). The manifesto formulated by Navalny and cooperating experts appears to contain many tangible solutions to Russia’s main problems – corrup- tion, underinvested education and healthcare, huge social stratification, etc. It does not have big, catchy slogans, and empty heroism. References to unity and history, incomprehensible for the majority of voters, weigh- ing on democracy, freedom and other abstract concepts, were reduced. However, the question whether this particular manifesto would interest Russians remains unanswered – it requires careful reading and at least a basic level of knowledge. Election boycott and post-election protests After the Central Electoral Commission’s decision refusing Navalny’s registration, the candidate changed his strategy. In place of the electoral campaign, an election boycott campaign had started – pursuant to the statement that “if an independent candidate is not allowed to run in the election, it is not an election at all.” The following objectives were set for the coming three months: close observation of the election, monitoring election turnout and encouraging others to take part in the boycott. Nav-
  • 10. 30 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa ŚSP 3 ’18 alny announced that he would not recognize the election results nor the elected authorities (Объявляем забастовку). As part of the boycott, an information campaign was carried out; its main slogans were: “An election without competition is not an election” and “Election without Navalny, Putin’s main competitor – is a mockery.”7 At the same time, they tried to convince Russians that if there was no pos- sibility of choosing between real candidates, it was better not to vote at all. Additionally, several larger protests against eliminating Navalny from the election took place. For example, the candidate’s supporters protested on January 28, 2018 in dozens of Russian cities – among others, Irkutsk, Kemerovo, Omsk, Novosibirsk, Yekaterinburg, Moscow and Saint Pe- tersburg. In total, police arrested more than 350 people in some of these cities («Забастовка избирателей»). Mass protests were organized also after the election – right before the inauguration of Putin’s fourth presidential term. In the protest under the slogan “He’s not our tsar” (Russian: Он нам не царь) organized by Nav- alny in 27 Russian cities “against the actual establishment of a monarchy, against corruption, against inequalities, censorship and anarchy” several thousand people took part. In some of the cities, authorities permitted the protest; however, in the biggest ones – Moscow and Saint Petersburg – Navalny’s supporters carried them out without the necessary permis- sions (which could not be obtained). This explains the huge number of ar- rests (around 1,600 people), including teenagers and random pedestrians. Those detained complained about the police’s extreme brutality: some of the people were taken to hospital (Филимонов, 2018; Литой, 2018). Navalny himself was also arrested, and, for repeatedly breaching the rules of organizing mass events and for disobedience to police, was sentenced to 30 days in jail (administrative sanctions) (Лебеденко, 2018). Other protesters faced trials and sanctions, too; however, the inauguration of Putin’s presidency was not disturbed. The effects of Navalny’s “non-campaign” Initially, the main aim of Navalny’s actions was to run in the election and gather as many votes as possible. However, after the rejection of his 7   Russian: Выборы без конкуренции – это не выборы; Выборы без Навально- го, главного конкурента Путина – это фарс.
  • 11. ŚSP 3 ’18 “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny... 31 candidacy during the registration process, the campaign was transformed into an election boycott, justified by the fact that there was no real alterna- tive to the incumbent president. According to the data shared by the staff of the opposition candidate, the actual voter turnout (obtained through observations by tens of thousands of volunteers) was 2.5 percentage points lower than the turnout officially presented by the Central Electoral Commission (59.6% vs. 62.%). Also, due to the observer group organized by Navalny, it was possible to register many violations and prove that more than 10 million votes for Putin were placed in ballot boxes illegally (Кампания Навального 2018). Navalny’s campaign has proven that political activity based on tangi- ble arguments is possible in Russia. Instead of grandiose and meaningless declarations about patriotism, the Great War, tradition and imaginary en- emies, Navalny proposed actual solutions to pressing issues – corruption, social stratification, politicians’ huge fortunes, widespread poverty, etc. All the protests, rallies and events did not aim at conversing about, for many, abstract concepts such as democracy, human rights or freedom. These events exposed the pathology of authority and looked for solutions for the future. Of course, it was not always a pretty substantive discus- sion, it included many populist elements as well. Nonetheless, it brought a new quality to Russian politics. The campaign on the Internet, social media and on Russian streets allowed Navalny to build a large group of people supporting his actions and ready to help in his political activity. Firstly, it consists of a group of more than 200,000 volunteers who, together with trained specialists, coordinated the whole campaign process. Secondly, there are thousands of young people who took part in the protests organized by the opposi- tion candidate during the campaign. Examples include the March 2017 protests demanding the resignation of Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev after his hidden fortune and links to corruption were revealed; and the protests of January 2018 against banning Navalny from running in the presidential election. And, last but not least, the hundreds, thousands and even tens of thousands of people who came to the pre-election meetings with the opposition candidate, organized in dozens of Russian cities. Navalny did not, of course, have any chance of winning the presi- dential election, but his actions seem to have been dictated by long-term goals. His aim is to run for president in either 2024 or 2030, and the recent campaign was a great opportunity to build his public image and prepare to run in a future election as a nationwide candidate, an opinion
  • 12. 32 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa ŚSP 3 ’18 shared by an expert from the Carnegie analytical center, Andrei Koles- nikov (Kolesnikov, 2017). The creation of a strong candidate appears to be a great strategy for the Russian opposition, especially during the time of the super-presidency, where neither Parliament, nor the government play an important role in actual governance. If the Russian authorities prolong the exclusion of Navalny from the political scene (e.g., through long-time jail sentences), and he continues to slowly build his position by completing his manifesto with proposals for tangible change, he can count on higher support than 1–2% in the next election. Conclusions The campaign carried out by Alexei Navalny in 2017 and 2018 un- doubtedly was only a prelude to the preparations for the next presidential election; this time it was mainly informational. It has also proven that in Russian public life there is a demand – although still low – for a different style of politics. Direct meetings with voters, real conversations about problems, tangible solutions and demands are the main characteristics of this campaign, as are anti-government protests, which attracted thousands of people, hundreds of volunteers and millions of rubles donated by Rus- sians to the campaign. As a result, the recognition of Navalny has risen, if only slightly. He also gained necessary experience before his next elec- tion campaign. Just after Putin’s fourth electoral victory, his opposition competitor can now count on the support of 1–2% of Russians. Despite the fact that he accurately identifies major issues which affect Russians, and his anti- corruption actions could be appealing to millions of voters from smaller towns and cities, Navalny has one main problem – he does not exist on television (he only appears there in a negative context, as a defendant or leader of another riot). Television is the main medium from which the majority of Russians acquire information (over 80%). Hence, it will be extremely difficult to translate the support from protests and rallies to actual votes. In mid-May another founding congress of Navalny’s new party, Rus- sia of the Future, took place. Its aim is to make tangible changes and reforms in Russia. It will surely provide great support for the opposition candidate in the coming years. However, in the battle for power, given the specificity of the Russian political system (strong personalization, the
  • 13. ŚSP 3 ’18 “Non-campaign of a non-candidate” – Alexei Navalny... 33 majority of actual power concentrated in the hands of the President), he must focus mainly on building his individual position and try to reach the so-called television Russia. At the same time, it is unlikely the Russian authorities will allow the uncontrolled increase of his popularity. Bibliography «Забастовка избирателей»: по стране задержаны более 350 человек, в их числе – Навальный, “Новая газета”, https://www.novayagazeta.ru/articles/2018/ 01/28/75298-zabastovka-izbirateley-28-yanvarya-onlayn, 21.05.2018. Kolesnikov A. (2017), Alexei Navalny’s Permanent Revolution, http://carnegie.ru/ 2017/10/09/alexei-navalny-s-permanent-revolution-pub-73338, 22.05.2018. Konstytucja Federacji Rosyjskiej przyjęta w ogólnonarodowym referendum w dniu 12 grudnia 1993 roku, http://libr.sejm.gov.pl/tek01/txt/konst/rosja.html, 19.05.2018. Strzelecki J. (2017), Nawalny wyeliminowany z wyborów prezydenckich w Rosji,Ana- lizy OSW, https://www.osw.waw.pl/pl/publikacje/analizy/2017-05-10/nawal- ny-wyeliminowany-z-wyborow-prezydenckich-w-rosji, 19.05.2018. Год кампании в цифрах и событиях, https://2018.navalny.com/post/502/, 20.05.2018. Кампания Навального 2018. Как это было, https://2018.navalny.com/, 22.05.2018. Лебеденко С. (2018), «Не узнаю без грима». Суд арестовал Навального на 30 су- ток за акцию «Он вам не царь». Заседание длилось около восьми часов, https://www.novayagazeta.ru/articles/2018/05/16/76486-ne-uznayu-bez-gri- ma, 22.05.2018. Левада-Центр (2017a), Российский Медиаландшафт – 2017, https://www.levada. ru/2017/08/22/16440/, 20.05.2018. Левада-Центр(2017b),ПротестыиНавальный,https://www.levada.ru/2017/07/17/ protesty-i-navalnyj/, 20.05.2018. Литой А. (2018), Акции против «царя»: избитые, задержанные, несовершен- нолетние, ОВД-Инфо, https://ovdinfo.org/articles/2018/05/08/akcii-protiv- carya-izbitye-zaderzhannye-nesovershennoletnie, 18.05.2018. Объявляем забастовку избирателей, https://2018.navalny.com/post/496/, 21.05.2018. Определение Конституционного Суда Российской Федерайии об отказе в при- нятии к рассмотрению жалобы гражданина Навального Алексея Анатольевича на нарушение его конституционных прав подпунктом 1 пункта 52 статьи 3 Федерального закона „О выборах Президента Российской Федерации”, http://doc.ksrf.ru/decision/KSRFDecision310695. pdf, 19.05.2018. Прекрасная Россия Будущего, https://2018.navalny.com/post/492/, 21.05.2018.
  • 14. 34 Łukasz Donaj, Natalia Kusa ŚSP 3 ’18 Программа Алексея Навального, https://2018.navalny.com/platform/, 21.05.2018. Процедура выборов президента в Российской Федерации, РИА Новости, https:// ria.ru/spravka/20171218/1510514992.html, 19.05.2018. Федеральный закон „О выборах Президента Российской Федерации” от 10.01.2003 N 19-ФЗ, http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_ 40445/, 19.05.2018. Филимонов A. (2018), «Он нам не царь», последствия: полторы тысячи задер- жанных, рекордные штрафы, тайные суды и одно уголовное дело (за якобы выбитый у полицейского зуб), https://meduza.io/feature/2018/05/07/ on-nam-ne-tsar-posledstviya-poltory-tysyachi-zaderzhannyh-rekordnye- shtrafy-taynye-sudy-i-odno-ugolovnoe-delo-za-yakoby-vybityy-u-po­li­t­ seyskogo-zub, 22.05.2018. Финальный финансовый отчет кампании, Навальный20!8, https://2018.navalny. com/post/1075/, 20.05.2018. „Nie/kampania nie/istniejącego kandydata” – Aleksiej Nawalny w wyborach prezydenckich w Rosji w 2018 r. Streszczenie W marcu 2018 r. w Federacji Rosyjskiej odbyły się kolejne wybory prezydenckie. Elekcję po raz czwarty, zdecydowaną większością głosów, wygrał Władimir Putin. Do udziału w rywalizacji na urząd prezydenta nie został dopuszczony Aleksiej Na- walny – opozycjonista, który swoją kampanię wyborczą przygotowywał od końca 2016 r. Pomimo eliminacji z procesu wyborczego, A. Nawalny pozostał aktywnym uczestnikiem życia politycznego Rosji przed i po wyborach, przeprowadził także ak- cję bojkotu wyborów oraz zorganizował powyborcze protesty. Nie ulega wątpliwości, iż pomimo zakazu udziału w elekcji, A. Nawalny był jedną z kluczowych postaci pro- cesu wyborczego. Dlatego też, celem artykułu jest pogłębiona analiza przygotowań do kampanii A. Nawalnego – autorzy skupili się nie tylko na opozycyjnej działalności kandydata, ale również na unikalnych środkach i metodach prowadzenia przez niego kampanii (internet, media społecznościowe, crowdfunding). W ramach artykułu omó- wione zostały nie tylko przygotowania do kampanii, ale również przyczyny odmowy rejestracji A. Nawalnego jako kandydata, wskaźniki społecznego poparcia, relacje z innymi kandydatami oraz zmiana strategii po decyzji komisji wyborczej. Analiza powstała w oparciu o badania nad aktami rosyjskiego prawa, decyzjami centralnej komisji wyborczej, wynikami badań opinii publicznej oraz przekazami w rosyjskich i międzynarodowych mediach. Słowa kluczowe: wybory w Rosji, Prezydent Rosji, A. Nawalny, kampania wybor- cza, opozycja polityczna