1.
WHERE WE ARE NOW, WHERE WE ARE
HEADING AND HOW TO GET THERE SAFELY
CHATBOTS AND THE PATH TO
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016

2.
WHAT IS A BOT
A bot is any application that
you communicate with, via
speech or text, in order to
execute commands.
2

3.
INTRO
 The bot revolution can
be compared to the
mobile revolution
 Although it was a
progression, bots are
possible now due to
massive amounts of
data and hardware
 It’s more of a tech-driven
vision, not a response to
concrete user demands
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 3
Facebook‘s M
WeChat
Microsoft Win + Azure
Google

4.
THREE TRENDS DRIVING SMART BOTS
• Messaging-as-OS: Messaging as a new platform
• The app problem: People are reluctant to install
apps, or apps are becoming redundant
• The “conversational interface”: A new model for
interacting with online services
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 4

5.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 5
1974: Command line 2016: A Slack channel
“Command lines were notoriously intimidating and difficult to get the
hang of. Slack is the exact opposite—it’s charming, fun, and easy to
understand—yet it runs off the same principle.”
Archana Madhavan
BACK TO A MINIMAL INTERFACE
The future: ?

6.
1. The Evolution of Bots
Three cases
6

7.
ELIZA
1966
HOWDY
2015
SAMANTHA
-
STATELESS SEMI-STATEFUL STATEFUL + INTELLIGENT
Shallow tracking of conversations Can read, comprehend and
reason
No memory or storage
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016

8.
1. Stateless Bots
2. Semi-Stateful Bots
3. Stateful Bots
8

9.
STATELESS BOTS
• Each request that a program processes disappears
from the server’s memory.
• Bots are stateless by default. Apps receive requests,
bts receive messages. If the web server were to
keep track of the requests it had processed, it would
soon collapse under its own weight.
• Each message is considered a new interaction.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 9

10.
Created by Joseph Weizenbaum (MIT) in
1966.
Acts like a non-directional
psychotherapist in an initial
phsyachriatic interview. Open,
introspective questions.
http://www.masswerk.at/elizabot/
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 10
THE FIRST BOT: ELIZA

11.
Simple pattern matching techniques (parsing and
substitution of key words)
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 11
ELIZA’S INNER WORKINGS

12.
OTHER STATELESS BOTS
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 12
A bot that twits images from
museum collections
A bot that replaces the word „boy“ with „bot“A bot that posts random art assignments
1
2
3

13.
1. Stateless Bots
2. Semi-Stateful Bots
3. Stateful Bots
13

14.
 Made by XOXCO in 2016 and integrated with
Slack.
 Easy to install, works out of the box.
 A „digital coworker“ to automate:
 Asynchronus communication
 Plan meetings
 Collect lunch orders
 Highly effective for a limited scope of tasks.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 14
Howdy
https://howdy.ai/

15.
WHAT SEMI-STATEFUL BOTS ARE GOOD AT
TODAY
 In the workplace: Automating small routine tasks, run
surveys, act as a bridge between gaps
 Healthcare: Follow-ups and reminders (Sense.ly), answer
questions (Your.MD), health coaching
 Onboarding: Guiding through materials
 Used for evil: Social network spamming, profile clonning
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 15

16.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 16
November 1996
Clippy
 Too
anthropomorphic
but not human.
 “Optimized for first
use”. Always.
 Enabled by
default. Every
time.

17.
USEFUL VS FUN
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 17
Why people hate the paperclip:
Labels, appearance, behavior and
Social responses to user interface agents
Luke Swartz
Stanford University 2003

18.
FITNESS ASSISTANT
In 2008, Cory Kidd completed a study with a robot intended to aid in fitness
and weight loss goals, by providing a social presence with which study
participants tracked their routines.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 18
 Most used “he” or
“she” when talking
about their robot
 1 never returned the
robot
Group 1
Pen & Paper
Group 2
Touchscreen
Group 1
Touchscreen + Robot

19.
THE PERCEPTION OF BOTS
 We instinctively treat computers like people and use the
same standards of politeness, gender stereotypes, teamwork
and reciprocity.
 Many said that Eliza helped them, and some asked the
people conducting the test to leave them alone with her so
they could discuss things in private. It was even considered a
low-cost way to handle people with mild psychological
problems.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 19

20.
THE UNCANNY VALLEY
However, making
making machines
more humanlike is
good up to a point,
after which they
become
discomforting or
creepy.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 20

21.
WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR CHATBOTS?
Project Name | Date 21

22.
PERSONALITY
 Most users will build a relationship
with their bots.
 In conversational UIs, personality is
the new UX. The entire app experience
is reduced to a few lines of text.
Microcopy is now king.
 Writers and comedians collaborate with
UX to create engaging bots.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 22

23.
CHAT BOTS WORKING ALONGSIDE HUMANS
Supervised A.I: In Facebook M, bots gather information for an
eventual interaction with a human rep.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 23
While the rep
answers, the
machine learns.
How?

24.
1. Stateless Bots
2. Semi-Stateful Bots
3. Stateful Bots
24

25.
A.I. POWERED BOTS: MACHINE LEARNING
For a machine to recognise cats, a person must first provide it with
thousands of photos of cats and not cats.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 25
CAT!
Feed the machine thousands
of photos of cats (and noncats)
Show the machine a photo of a cat,
and it should recognise it as such.
?
cat
cat cat
cat cat
Not cat
Not cat

26.
A.I. POWERED BOTS: DEEP NEURAL
NETWORKS
Neural network are
used to simulate
densely interconnected
brain cells.
The computer can learn
things, recognize
patterns, and make
decisions in a
humanlike way.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 26
NOT CAT!
CAT!
color
edges
color
blobs

27.
Samatha is an intelligent personal OS from
the movie Her by Spike Jonze.
 Has impressive knowledge of the physical world.
 Can understand human emotion and show empathy.
 Can reason and debate.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 27

28.
BOTS AND LANGUAGE
Our language is a compact and effective system, but relies
on the assumption of intelligence and a common social and
physical world.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 28
„The trophy will not fit in the brown suitcase
because it was too big.“
What was too big? Answer 0: the trophy; Answer 1: the suitcase.

29.
BOTS AND LANGUAGE
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 29
• Bots need to learn to speak (or think) like us, without a physical
world or the time to learn about it like we have.
• Machines also need to understand how humans work on an
emotional level: Detect and analyse emotions, extract concepts
from dialog, showing empathy.
• Symbolic processing (humans) + machine learning (system)
• We both need a model of the other, as well of one of the world.

30.
ONCE OUR BOTS CAN TALK...
• Do we want „always-aware“ systems?
• Should our assistant bots interact with other people’s?
• How can we teach the machine introspection? (the ability to
communicate the exact process that leads to their choices.)
• Is it necessary to make machines human-like? Do they need to
converse? Do you talk to a bot, or use one?
• What are the dangers of captology and creating bots that can be truly
persuasive?
• Human Rights Watch is looking for an international treaty to ban
military robots with autonomous lethal firing power. How far are we
from this?
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 30

31.
IF YOU EVER MAKE A BOT...
1. A robot may not injure a human being or, through
inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.
2. A robot must obey orders given it by human beings
except where such orders would conflict with the First
Law.
3. A robot must protect its own existence as long as such
protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.
31

32.
REFERENCES
• Weizenbaum, Joseph "ELIZA – A Computer Program For the Study of Natural Language
Communication Between Man and Machine" in: Communications of the ACM; Volume 9 , Issue 1
(January 1966): p 36-45.
• About neural networks: http://www.explainthatstuff.com/introduction-to-neural-networks.html
• How Humans Respond to Robots: Building Public Policy through Good Design
https://www.brookings.edu/research/how-humans-respond-to-robots-building-public-policy-through-
good-design/
• "WHY PEOPLE HATE THE PAPERCLIP: LABELS, APPEARANCE, BEHAVIOR AND SOCIAL
RESPONSES TO USER INTERFACE AGENTS", Luke Swartz, June 12, 2003, Honors Thesis for
Symbolic Systems Program, Stanford University
• C. Kidd and C. Breazeal. A Robotic Weight Loss Coach. Twenty-Second Conference on Artificial
Intelligence, 2007.
Yisela Alvarez Trentini | MRM McCann, August 2016 32