The Decentralization of Knowledge 
Harry Halpin (W3C/MIT) 
Alexandre Monnin (Inria, expert Etalab)
The Hidden History of Google
Cybernetics is Not Enough
Putting the Symbols Back in the Machine 
Artificial Intelligence, LISP, semantic networks
Knowledge Representation Hypothesis 
Anymechanicallyembodiedintelligentprocesswillbecomprisedofstructuralingredientsthata...
The Frame Problem, Issues with what's in a Link and AI Winter
Afterthe AI winter: The SemanticWeb or Carnap onward 
Carnap 
McCarthy/Hayes 
Berners- Lee/Hayes
AN intellectualgenealogy 
Logical positivism (metrology) 
Logical AI 
Semantic Web/Linked Data
A tale of threeencyclopedias 
Universal Encyclopedia of Unified Science 
CYC 
Wikipedia/DBpedia
The Web and decentralized knowledge
The Web, the Semantic Web and Wikipedia/DBpedia 
First principle behind the Web : anyone can designate anything(any thing...
The Web, the Semantic Web and Wikipedia/DBpedia 
FirstprinciplebehindtheSemanticWeb/LinkedData:theAAAprinciple. 
«Anyonec...
The Web, the Semantic Web and Wikipedia/DBpedia 
how do wecome to an agreement, wheredo wefindthe constituentsof a shared...
The re-centralization of the Web of knowledge
A parliament of things? 
No,Google’sKnowledgeGraph: 
Youcan’tlinktoitsresources(reusesthecommonknowledgeofWikipedia/Dbpe...
The Semantic Web? 
No, one ontologyfor all: schema.org 
Createdby RamanathanGuha(one of the 
brainsbehindCYC and RDF) 
...
Reclaimthe Web, re-de-centralizethe Web: not justa telcoissue 
A deeply, democraticand philosophicalone 
#webwewant
The Decentralized of Knowledge
Prochain SlideShare
Chargement dans…5
×

The Decentralized of Knowledge

3 034 vues

Publié le

Presentation delivered at the ADAM final symposium, October 3 2014.

Publié dans : Sciences
0 commentaire
2 j’aime
Statistiques
Remarques
  • Soyez le premier à commenter

Aucun téléchargement
Vues
Nombre de vues
3 034
Sur SlideShare
0
Issues des intégrations
0
Intégrations
1 502
Actions
Partages
0
Téléchargements
13
Commentaires
0
J’aime
2
Intégrations 0
Aucune incorporation

Aucune remarque pour cette diapositive

The Decentralized of Knowledge

  1. 1. The Decentralization of Knowledge Harry Halpin (W3C/MIT) Alexandre Monnin (Inria, expert Etalab)
  2. 2. The Hidden History of Google
  3. 3. Cybernetics is Not Enough
  4. 4. Putting the Symbols Back in the Machine Artificial Intelligence, LISP, semantic networks
  5. 5. Knowledge Representation Hypothesis Anymechanicallyembodiedintelligentprocesswillbecomprisedofstructuralingredientsthata)weasexternalobserversnaturallytaketorepresentapropositionalaccountoftheknowledgethattheoverallprocessexhibits,andb)independentofsuchexternalsemanticalattribution,playaformalbutcausalandessentialroleinengenderingthebehaviorthatmanifeststhatknowledge[Smith,1982].
  6. 6. The Frame Problem, Issues with what's in a Link and AI Winter
  7. 7. Afterthe AI winter: The SemanticWeb or Carnap onward Carnap McCarthy/Hayes Berners- Lee/Hayes
  8. 8. AN intellectualgenealogy Logical positivism (metrology) Logical AI Semantic Web/Linked Data
  9. 9. A tale of threeencyclopedias Universal Encyclopedia of Unified Science CYC Wikipedia/DBpedia
  10. 10. The Web and decentralized knowledge
  11. 11. The Web, the Semantic Web and Wikipedia/DBpedia First principle behind the Web : anyone can designate anything(any thing, any «resource»).
  12. 12. The Web, the Semantic Web and Wikipedia/DBpedia FirstprinciplebehindtheSemanticWeb/LinkedData:theAAAprinciple. «AnyonecansayAnythingaboutAnything», meaningthatanyonecandesignateanyresourcewithaURI,describeitwithanyresource(withotherURIs)andlinkittoanyresource(again,thankstoevenmoreURIs!).
  13. 13. The Web, the Semantic Web and Wikipedia/DBpedia how do wecome to an agreement, wheredo wefindthe constituentsof a sharedworld? Wheredo wefinda «parliamentof things» (Latour)? Short answer: Wikipediafor the Web, DBpediafor the Web of Data. A centralizedplatformfor decentralizedcontributions
  14. 14. The re-centralization of the Web of knowledge
  15. 15. A parliament of things? No,Google’sKnowledgeGraph: Youcan’tlinktoitsresources(reusesthecommonknowledgeofWikipedia/Dbpediawithoutreinforcingthevirtuouscirclethatmadethempossible) Controversyistreatedasadisposabledefect FueledbyWikidata,aGoogle-fundedWikimediaprojecttoproducestructureddatafortheKnowledgeGraph(atrojanhorse?) Ontologicaldemocracyvscorporationobjectivity
  16. 16. The Semantic Web? No, one ontologyfor all: schema.org Createdby RamanathanGuha(one of the brainsbehindCYC and RDF) One generalontology(enactsnew worlds) for all domains ranby a handfulof corporation(s) …
  17. 17. Reclaimthe Web, re-de-centralizethe Web: not justa telcoissue A deeply, democraticand philosophicalone #webwewant

×