SIT PGDMS &RC
1
A STUDY ON “EMPLOYEE REFERRAL PROGRAM”
COMPREHENSIVE SEMINAR REPORT
SUBMITTED BY
ANITHA.K
USN: 1SI11MBA03
UNDER THE GUIDANCE OF
INTERNAL GUIDE
PROF. SUMATHI.R
FACULTY MEMBER
PGDMS & RC, SIT,
TUMKUR.
POST GRADUATE DEPARTMENT OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES
SIDDAGANGA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
(AN AUTONOMOUS INSTITUTE AFFILIATED TO VISVESWARAYA
TECHNOLOGICAL UNIVERSITY, BELGAUM AND ACCREDITED BY NATIONAL
BOARD OF ACCREDITATION, NEW DELHI.)
TUMKUR-572103
2012-13
SIT PGDMS &RC
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Sl No. CONTENTS PG. NO.
1
2.
3.
4.
5
6
7
8
9
10
INTRODUCTION
DEFNITION
BRIEF NOTE ON EMPLOYEE
REFERRAL PROGRAM
SIGNIFICANT OF EMPLOYEE
REFERRAL PROGRAM
CASE STUDY:
ACCENTURE
IBM
ROUND ONE NETWORK
ADVANTAGES
DISADVANTAGES
CONCLUSION
LEARNING OUTCOME
BIBLIOGRAPHY
3
4
5
5-6
7-9
10-13
14
15
16
17
17
17
SIT PGDMS &RC
3
EMPLOYEE REFERRAL PROGRAM
INTRODUCTION:
Employee referral is an internal recruitment method employed by organizations to
identify potential candidates from their existing employees. An employee referral
scheme encourages a company's existing employees to select and recruit the
suitable candidates from their social networks.
As a reward, the employer typically pays the referring employee a referral bonus.
Recruiting candidates using employee referral is widely acknowledged as being the
most cost effective and efficient recruitment method to recruit candidates and as
such, employers of all sizes, across all industries are trying to increase the volume of
recruits through this channel.
Referral recruitment is the development of a recruitment strategy that is dependent
on referrals by existing employees. This approach is usually favoured when the costs
of recruiting needs to be reduced. In recessions the amount of time and money
invested in referral schemes often increases due to the perceived frivolousness of
other methods of recruiting.
Employee referrals provide better than average candidates because employees
know your company culture and have an idea about what employees work
successfully in your organization. Employee referrals also reflect on the referring
employee who wants to be positively regarded in your organization.
Employee referral scheme’s allows existing employees to screen, select and refer
the best candidates to the recruitment process
Objective of referral program
This policy aims to bring candidates with requisite qualification and skills to the
organization through employees which help in successful placement of the
candidate, where the employee will be awarded on the basis of placement
Why employee referral program
In a recent survey, the results on employee referrals are outstanding. The
results speak for themselves on why having an employee referral program is vital
for every company.
SIT PGDMS &RC
4
Nearly 40% of all hires are generated by employee referrals. 40% is a large
number for one source of hire and it could be even larger with a good employee
referral program in place.46% are still working at that company a year later. This
is good news from companies, as the talent from referrals is top notch.
The above numbers should be enough to convince you to have an employee
referral program in place, but it’s also the most efficient of all other hiring
sources. It takes roughly 29 days to fill a position through a referral – 55% faster
than any other recruiting source. Not only are employee referral programs
efficient, they are a cost saver for the company.
Referring qualified friends, colleagues or even family can create an excellent
source of prospective candidates. Employee referral programs are essentially
used by organizations to hire great talent while reducing acquisition time and
cost, yet prolonging the duration of employment. In short: employees work with
great, trusted talent, the company saves money up front through the recruiting
process, and likely increases the return from the specific employee.
DEFINITION:
Employee referral is defined as recruitment method in which the current employees
are encouraged and rewarded for introducing suitable recruits from among the
people they know.
SIT PGDMS &RC
5
BRIEF NOTE ON EMPLOYEE REFERRAL PROGRAM:
An effective employee referral program should be an integral part of any
employee recruiting process. There are many recruiting sources that can be used
perform for your employee recruiting and it is not necessary to limit activities to
any single source.
Referrals from existing employees have been shown to be some of the best
employees. A study has shown that employees referred by existing employees
better and last longer on average. There are many benefits from a well designed
and implemented employee referral program in addition to getting better
employees.
The first area of improvement is significantly reduced costs per hire for bring on
new employees. Employee recruiting is expensive. Running ads, posting on-line
and using head hunters all cost money. In many cases multiple sources will be
used to build a candidate pool and the costs add up.
But giving existing employees a referral bonus can be much more cost effective.
There is only one payment. Calculate an amount that is both attractive to your
employees and cost effective for the business. A good recommendation is 20-
25% of the normal cost per hire number.
The second benefit of a good program is the program can be a significant morale
booster for existing employees. They are much happier when the money spent
on recruiting "stays in the family" instead of being spent on outside sources.
Existing employees appreciate the opportunity to make more money while
helping the company at the same time.
SIGNIFICANCE OF EMPLOYEE REFERRAL PROGRAM
Employee referrals have been accepted as the “number one source of hire”
and often the highest calibre, too. And new studies show this trend will likely
continue, as organizations rely more heavily on their referral programs.
The majority of organizations report not only having an employee referral
program but also focusing on referrals as a key component of their overall
recruitment strategy.
In addition to incentives, however, it’s also critical to design a program that
works best for your team and communicate it in a way that users can
understand. If you don’t, your program is likely to remain stagnant or fail
altogether.
SIT PGDMS &RC
6
Building a successful employee referral program
Here are a few important keys to success to help launch and promote the employee
referral program
1. Keep the process simple
The more time consuming the process becomes to get a referral into and through
your recruiting process, the less likely employees will participate. the following
questions has to be enquired designing or refining the referral program:
Do employees know where to submit employee referrals?
Is the submission of referrals quick and easy?
Is the employee kept up-to-date on their referred applicant’s process?
Is the employee quickly compensated for the referral?
2. Solicit supervisor participation
Employee referral programs are stronger when supervisors and managers are
actively engaged and supportive. When supervisors are on board they have a more
direct influence encouraging employees to add to the company’s pool of talent.
3. Communicate the Benefits for Employees
Many employees are uncomfortable pitching their organization to a potential referral;
afraid they will sound like a salesman . Remind employees its not about the sale, its
about the relationship. Humans naturally desire to feel that they belong and are
wanted. Most people are flattered when they are recognized for their skills or talents
and asked to join the organization.
By building an organization with top-notch people, employees benefits from:
Enhanced collaboration.
Quality hires that mean fewer burdens on existing team members.
Ensuring the organization is successful, resulting in more opportunities for
employees.
Awards to employees range in the value based on the type of
position and how specialized the position is.
SIT PGDMS &RC
7
CASE STUDY
Accenture's best practice in referral recruitment.
This business case study of Accenture serves to illustrate the impact of referral
recruitment.
It highlights some of the best practices in referral recruitment that the
organization should consider adopting. Accenture did win some prestigious
awards like the ERE award for its most innovative employee referral program.
While employee referral programs have always been a top source for high-quality
hires, they can be adapted to become the most effective low-cost/high-quality
source.
The deployment of existing staff to recruit new employees is, if properly
implemented, a powerful recruitment tool. Especially in a tight labour market,
where recruitment of new employees is difficult and costly.
A few facts and figures:
Number one source of candidates, both quantity and quality
In Accenture the employee referral program has grown the percentage of hires
attributed to employee referral from 14% to 33% in the year 2008-09 . The quality of
referrals also improved significantly
Cost saving
Huge cost saving in Accenture like EUR 600,000 in 3 months (instead of
professional recruitment agencies).
Job satisfaction and commitment
In Accenture employee referral program has positive effects on job satisfaction and
commitment of old and new employees.
Awareness
Employee awareness of the referral program has jumped from 20% to 99%, an
astounding performance
SIT PGDMS &RC
8
Smart reward scheme instead of higher rewards
In Accenture Employees receive a small reward for a successful referral and EUR
500 is donated to charity. They also offer an opportunity for employees who make
successful referrals to participate in a drawing for exciting world trips. In addition,
employees also receive EUR 100 whenever one of their referred candidates is
invited in for an interview. Obviously, any candidate invited for an interview is of
sufficient quality to merit at least some reward and recognition.
Employee scorecard
Employees have their own individual online website that allows them to track the
progress of their referred candidates throughout the hiring process (this increases
employee involvement and transparency).
The scorecard also lists the employee's personal referral success rate. By allowing
the employee to see how well they're doing in their referrals
V.I.P. status referrals
Employee referrals are marked as very important and urgent by the application
process so that they can be prioritized and fast-tracked during the hiring process.
Referral cards
Referral cards can have a major impact on referral program success. Most referral
cards are "paper" and are handed out individually. Accenture has taken the practice
one step further, allowing employees to send electronic referral cards to people in
their network. The e-cards contain a code that allows them to get credit if the
individual submits an application.
Good administration
Good administration of referrals makes the difference to increase employee
involvement and transparency.
Courage
Even though it's an intangible factor, it's critical to referral program success. It's easy
for executives to discourage talk about hiring and winning awards during tough
economic times, but the managers at Accenture had the courage to continue the
development of this important program and to also follow through on the awards
process.
SIT PGDMS &RC
9
ERE award winner 2009- Accenture
It has been an amazing year in recruiting and talent management, despite severe
economic hardships, budget cuts, and widespread hiring freezes. One of the
challenges in the fast-moving profession of recruiting is how to keep up with the
latest evolutions in best practice
ERE Media holds a yearly global competition aimed at identifying the very best “next
practices” in recruiting. Each year, ERE receives hundreds of applications in eight
recruiting program categories from well-known organizations like Microsoft, IBM,
Ernst & Young, Intuit, Accenture, GE, Yahoo!, and from less well-known but equally
innovative organizations like DaVita, the American Cancer Society, and Tata.
The applications year 2009 were so powerful that choosing a winner in several
categories was a challenge.
The eight recruiting program categories in ERE are as follows
Best college recruiting program
Most innovative department
Best careers website
Best employee referral program
Best employer brand
Best strategic use of technology
Best on boarding program
Best military talent program
While employee referral programs have always been a top source for high-quality
hires, during economic downturns, they can be adapted to become the most
effective low-cost/high-quality source.
Accenture’s latest employee referral program is unique because it began life as a
pilot program in The Netherlands. Based on the program’s results, it now serves as a
model for future rollouts around the globe. The new program radically simplifies the
program’s terms and conditions and dedicates resources to marketing the program
internally on a regular basis.
Since inception, just a year ago, the program has grown the percentage of hires
attributed to employee referral from 14% to 32%. Employee awareness of the
referral program has jumped from 20% to 99%, an astounding feat .The quality of
referrals also improved significantly.
SIT PGDMS &RC
10
IBM
"Sampark” which means “reaching out”, epitomizes the essence of the Employee
Referral Program at IBM Daksh. Aimed at creating a work environment that includes
one’s friend, Sampark is a very powerful tool in the hands of the employees to
engineer their work environment and has played a very critical role in building the
culture that IBM Daksh is known for today.
Sampark helps creating an environment where in not only to get the opportunity in
order to work with your friends but also get rewarded for doing so. It is a key
resourcing channel for the organization.
The Sampark program encourages all IBM employees at IBM Daksh Business/IBM
India to refer their friends, relatives and former colleagues as prospective
employees. Once an applicant joins, the referee is rewarded.
The program has a two layer execution strategy. The first layer is a central team in
TAU whose core focus is to drive the Sampark initiative within the organization. The
second layer is that of Sampark Ambassadors who work in specific projects. They
spearhead the program in their respective projects as an additional responsibility.
IBM Daksh Employee Referral Bonus Policy
1. Objective
The Employee Referral Bonus Program (ERBP) is designed to supplement
IBM GPS's normal recruiting activity and enhance the pool of diverse,
qualified candidates available for hire into IBM GPS.
The primary purpose for this program is to identify those highly skilled
individuals who may not ordinarily apply to open positions through traditional
channels. It provides a system by which employees can be involved in the
identification of candidates for positions and recognized for their efforts
thereby. It extends IBM's capability for experienced hiring to meet the growing
critical skill gaps. Through the Employee Referral Bonus Program, an effort is
made to monetarily recognize IBMers referral efforts in bringing new
employees into the organization.
SIT PGDMS &RC
11
2. Eligibility & applicability
All IBMers on the rolls of IBM Corporation Companies/ Organizations in India
including people manager are eligible to refer. The referring IBMer must be on
the permanent rolls of the organization with a valid employee ID including
Fixed Term Hire (FTH) / Interns & Part time hires.
The following employees/ types of employees can refer but are not entitled
for a Referral Bonus payout
Executive Bands (Band D and above employees)
Members of the TTBU & Leadership Acquisition team
Referrers/Referee (eligible for payment) cannot participate in any hiring
activities associated with the referred candidate.
interviews, interviewing the candidate and hiring decision.
Candidate hired in direct Reporting line of the referee (if the referred
Candidate is the Direct Reporting line of the referee, at the time of
joining, they will not be eligible for the ERBP).
Employees are not eligible to receive a referral bonus if the candidate is hired
directly into their reporting line. Reporting relationship is determined by IBM
GPS HRMS.
3. Scope
This program is aimed at inviting referrals only for permanent / regular - full time
hires, fixed term hires and interns positions only.
Candidates not eligible under the ERP:
The following persons will be considered as Referred Candidates however no
referral bonus payout will be made to the referee. (All these roles are as defined by
IBM Management)
IBM Regular employees rejoining IBM within 12 months of separating from
IBM,
Sub contracted employees
SSPs, Contractors or Vendors,
Consultants and owners of other independent contractor firms currently on
contract with IBM,
Persons employed by Vendors, Consultants, or other independent
contractors who are currently performing dedicated work for IBM or any
IBM GPS India Delivery teams on behalf of their employer at any IBM GPS India
Delivery locations, employees of clients or business partners with whom the
referrer has a direct business relationship in the course of his/her employment
in IBM
SIT PGDMS &RC
12
4. POLICY DETAILS
ERP advice will be made to payroll for the eligible referrers after the referred
candidate has been employed at IBM for a minimum of 90 Days. Payouts will be
made as a part of the payroll disbursement and will be subject to all applicable
taxes.
The referee and referral must be active employees of IBM and neither of them
should have resignation initiated status on system or an AOD case as on 15th
of the payout month.
Recoveries of Incorrect payouts: Incorrect & duplicate payouts are recoverable
in full including the applicable tax amount.
100% of the referral payout will be paid to the referee in the payroll post
completion of 90 Days by the referral in the organization. The payment
timelines will follow below mentioned guidelines
Every employee joining IBM through the ERP program will need to undergo a
background check as per the usual IBM process where referrer will be entitled
to the ERP only for cases where the referred employee has successfully cleared
the background check. In cases where the referred employee has not cleared
the background check but the ERP has been paid to the referee, the ERP will
be recovered from the referee in subsequent payroll.
In the event that the referred employee is absconding from work, any Referral
payment applicable will be withheld until the employee resumed work. If the
referred employee does not resume work, referrer shall be deemed to have
waived his/her right to the Referral Payment.
IBM retains the right to reject referrals, if, in IBM's sole judgment, too many
candidates have been referred by the same Referring IBMer.
SIT PGDMS &RC
13
User Guidance
IBMers should refer candidates who are known through personal or professional
network, and not by using any web/ job portal or any other sourcing channel.
This relationship may be a result on account of participation in various social
networks which are either formal (examples of formal networks are LinkedIn,
Facebook, Twitter, industry and competency associations) or informal
(examples of informal networks are former employment with the same company,
friends circle, alumni from same educational institution or study circles) .
If proven that the candidate and the referrer do not know each other, it will lead
to disciplinary action including termination.IBM Employee/ Referee while
referring candidates must submit a referee declaration (frontline and support
positions) / resume (for leadership positions only) of the candidate.
Referee’s declaration will only be accepted via e-mail if sent from official IBM
/IBM GPS India Delivery e-mail Id or personal email id updated on PeopleSoft.
Referee Declaration template format as follows
Referee is required to provide the following information:
Candidate Name: _______________________________________
Candidate’s Telephone/mobile number: _____
How do I know the candidate? ___________________
Referee Name: _______________________________________
Referee Emp. ID: _______________________________________
Referee Telephone/mobile Number: ___________________
SIT PGDMS &RC
14
Round One network
Round One is a first of its kind internet platform that connects jobseekers with
company employees so they can interact and earn job referrals, it aim to create a
meritocratic and transparent system which levels the playing field by removing the
need for 'contacts'.
Round One Network Pvt Ltd, (www.roundone.in) a Delhi based internet platform
started by INSEAD MBA Nishant Mathur, completed its beta trial and launched
services in the year 2012. Round One’s unique model enables jobseekers to register
for unofficial phone interviews with employees in a company, and earn a job referral
from them.
Employees at over 120 companies, including Accenture, American Express, Bank of
New York Mellon, Capital IQ, Deloitte, Google, Evalueserve, HP, Infibeam, JM
Financial, McKnsey, Nielsen, Samsung, TATA Motors, and ZS Associates, have
interviewed and referred candidates through Round One during its beta trial.
How the round one works?
Firstly job seeker’s sends referral request to an employee of a company
he/she interested in. If the request is accepted, the candidate has to pay fee
and speaks to the employee over the phone. If the employee is satisfied with
the job seeker’s credentials, the employee refers the candidate to the HR
department.
Secondly job seeker is allowed to connect with the referrer over the phone
only after the amount is received by round one.
Since the referrer would already have screened the job seeker’s profile by the
time they talk, 80% of the job seekers are referred after the conversation. In
case they are not referred, their fee is refunded.
Recommendation in round one increases an employee’s chances of getting hired by
as much as 10 times. Where Mathur cites a 2010 report by CareerBuilder, which
says 69% of organisations have a formal employee referral program. It also gives
referees “round one point” which Mathur likens to frequent flier miles. “They are
given 500 points worth Rs 100 for each person
According to Mathur, Round One has over 12,000 referrers from 2,000 companies,
and 400,000 job seekers registered with its service. They are mostly from the IT,
banking, KPO and consultancy sectors. Round One’s customers are typically lies
between 20-35 years age as mentioned by the company
SIT PGDMS &RC
15
Round One’s primary method of marketing so far has been social media, especially
LinkedIn. In the past couple of months, the company has started search engine
optimisation marketing as well. it earns revenue from the one-time registration fee of
Rs 100 and the additional fees (from Rs 500 to Rs 900, depending on how
experienced the job seeker is) job seekers pay to interact with referrers
The revenues of round one have been growing at 25% every month. Company is
also exploring a model where it can get companies to sponsor interactions.
“Companies benefit from referrals as well and looking for expanding scope of its
services by adding a networking platform and to connect with students and
universities
Other outstanding referral features from other companies:
Acumen Solutions
Rather than the traditional passive approach, targeted referral percentage goals are
set for each department in order to increase healthy internal competition. They
provide a toolkit to educate their employees how to more effectively network. They
celebrate referral successes publicly at all major company events.
SIT PGDMS &RC
16
Microsoft
Microsoft raises the bar on employee referral related branding with their
"Spreadthelove" website. This site allows Microsoft employees to "write up" their own
individual story about their career with Microsoft . Employees can then share the web
link and "spread the love" with targeted friends, family and potential referrals.
Microsoft has increased its process effectiveness by ensuring that every referral is
contacted first by an employment specialist, which then introduces them to a
recruiter that will manage their experience moving forward.
Tata Consultancy
Adapted a marketing/CRM model for its referral program (i.e., the company
offers a 24x7 referral help desk with a toll-free number). Another component
allows newly hired candidates who have not yet joined the firm to refer their
former colleagues (in order to capitalize on their "top of mind" knowledge of
their networks in their previous organization).
They also instituted a "Rapid Hire" process where resumes were collected at
referral desks that provide "on the spot" screening followed by preliminary
evaluation and instant feedback. They also offer early bird & spot prizes as
well as contests between business units to foster a competitive mindset
around referrals. The metrics demonstrated (as many other firms have) that
referral turnover rates during the first year are significantly lower than
traditional experienced hires (2.9% for referral hires versus 8%).
BENEFITS OF EMPLOYEE-REFERRAL PROGRAMS:
One benefit of an employee-referral program is that it can provide the
employer with a source of passive candidates, those workers who are not
actively seeking new jobs. This not only expands the employer’s pool of
potential candidates but also tends to produce higher-quality candidates.
Candidates referred by employees also tend to be of higher quality because
the referring employee usually screens his or her referrals closely. After all,
his or her reputation is somewhat on the line with every person he refers for a
position. Referring a string of unqualified candidates reflects poorly on the
referring employee’s judgment, which may affect his or her own career
prospects.
SIT PGDMS &RC
17
The usual monetary bonus paid to a referring employee for a successful
referral can be a significant morale booster. It reinforces the tendency to refer
high-quality candidates to one’s own company, even when no positions are
available. This helps to establish an ongoing recruitment process.
Employee-referral programs can replace more expensive recruitment
channels such as newspaper advertising, employment agencies, job fairs and
so on.
Employee-referral programs are especially effective in the case of highly
specialized positions that might be difficult to fill through conventional
channels. People tend to associate with others in their professions, which
gives them access to specialized or rare talent.
PITFALLS OF EMPLOYEE-REFERRAL PROGRAMS:
There are some aspects of employee-referral programs that can cause
problems for a company. Some are subtle, while others, like lawsuits, can
literally slap a business in the face.
Overreliance on an employee-referral program can lead to
underrepresentation of certain protected groups in a company’s job-applicant
pool. This can add credence to charges of employment discrimination from
rejected candidates.
Also, some competing businesses may retaliate against your company for
stealing their happily employed workers via employee-referral programs.
Excessive reliance upon an employee-referral program can lead to an inbred
organization that lacks breadth of ideas, and it can foster a "stick-together"
attitude that masks underlying problems in organizational behavior. Relying
too heavily on an employee-referral program can also create cliques within an
organization, leading to resentment and friction with other employees.
Some managers may have biases against employee-referral programs,
feeling that referrals are favours done for shiftless in-laws rather than for the
company.
Overly restrictive bonus qualifications or excessive qualifications for employee
referrals can lead to disillusionment with an employee-referral program. Under
such circumstances, an employee-referral program may actually become a
source of employee discontent.
Overall, the benefits of employee-referral programs decisively outweigh the
potential pitfalls. A well-designed and highly visible employee-referral program
is a critical part of any company’s recruitment strategy.
SIT PGDMS &RC
18
CONCLUSIONS:
It’s safe to say that every company/business has its own Employee Referral
Program, whether formal or informal, that they promote to varying degrees at
various times. Larger companies with hundreds of open positions, in some
cases, have a full-time employee dedicated to running and optimizing their
ERP. Smaller companies that hire a few people a year often rely on their
employees to refer candidates for those position
A good referral program will have many benefits, both in cost and the time
savings
LEARNING OBJECTIVE:
This topic has made me to learn about employee referral program and how it
help the company in recruitment process
Employee referrals provide a win situation to all the parties involved –
Employer , Employee and the Candidate
More and more firms are resorting to employee referrals and are reaping the
benefits.
BIBILOGRAPHY :
https://india.jobs.accenture.com/
http://www.referralrecruitment.com/home/accenture
http://www.ere.net/
business outlook 2013