Movable Property in Private International Law

BY
ADV. CAROLINE ELIAS
MOVABLE PROPERTY
 Movable properties are either tangible or intangible. The transfer
of movables can be effected by the act of parties or by operation
of law.
 The preliminary and the vital question is whether only one
common system of principles should be allowed to determine
every question that arises in respect of movables or whether there
should be different set of rules that could possibly be applied to
different aspects of the transfer, such as assignability of movables,
to formal validity and to material validity.
THEORIES GOVERNING TRANSFER OF TANGIBLE
MOVABLES
(1) Lex domicile (2) Lex Actus
(3) Lex Situs (4) Proper law theory
(1) Lex domicile theory :-
 This theory is founded upon the principle that since movables
have no fixed situs, their situs can be shifted at any time by its
owner.
 Therefore, the medieval Italian statutists propounded the principle
of mobile sequenter personam. The maxim means that goods
follow the person. The doctrine had wide acceptance beyond the
continental Europe in England and in the USA.
 In Sill v. Worswick [(1791) 1 H B1 665; 126 E.R.379]
This case laid down the doctrine that with respect to the
disposition of moveable property, with respect to the transmission
of it, either by succession, or the act of the party, it follows the
law of the person. It was held that personal property has no
locality, thus meaning that rights over movables are to be
governed by the law of the owner’s domicile.
( criticism : it may cause unjust results)
(2) Lex Actus theory :-
 This theory has not gained much value in the contemporary legal
discourse, though there have been a few instances of judicial
acceptance of its crux (most important point at issue).
 Alcock v. Smith [(1892) 1 Ch. 238]
It was laid down that, the validity of a transfer depends not upon
the law of the domicile of the owner but upon the law of the
country in which transfer of the movable took place.
 Cheshire criticized this on the point that a mere fact that a
transaction was entered into a particular place is no adequate
reason to accord control to the local law.
 Graveson supported this view, on the point that, a reasonable man
is expected to comply with the law of any country in which they
would have performed the transaction.
(3) Lex Situs theory :-
 The lex situs theory obviously has its advantages, important among
them being that situs law provides a single and easily ascertained
system of law based on the focal point of the transaction, namely,
the goods that the transaction concerns itself.
 Moreover, the right of control satisfies the expectations of the
reasonable man as for a party to transfer naturally conclude that the
transaction would be subject to the law of the country in which the
subject-matter is situated.
 But it is difficult to ascertain in matters where the goods are in
transit.
 Graveson opined that this problem can be met by mercantile
practices of treating the normal documents of title to such goods as
bill of lading as representing the goods themselves so that in effect
the relevant situs is generally that of the document of title.
(4) Proper law theory :-
 Cheshire propounded a new theory to explain the law governing
issues arising out of the transfer of movables – is that the law of the
country with which the transfer has the most real connection or to be
more specific, i.e., the proper law of transfer.
 The ascertaining of the proper law would not present any difficulty if
the proper law and the lex situs is the same.
 Difficulty arises in a situation where the two factors are grounded in
two different legal systems.
The content of transfer of property tangible movables largely
addresses three issues:-
(1) Matters arising between parties to the transfer ( Contractual /
proprietary)
(2) Matters arising from the transfer affecting third parties
(3) Certain special types of transfers (Gifts / donatio mortis causa /
goods in transit).
THEORIES ON INTANGIBLE MOVABLES :-
 An intangible movable may be described as an interest which is not
directly related to a physical object or land.
 For e.g. shares, patents, copyrights, debts, and negotiable instruments.
 They may also be referred to as “choses in action”.
 Theories relating to intangible movable properties also includes:-
(1) Lex domicile theory
(2) Lex situs theory
(3) Lex loci actus theory
(4) The proper law theory
 (1) Lex domicile theory:- Philimore was the main proponent to apply
this in relation to intangible movables. He explained that debts , rights
and causes of action are universally perceived as attached to the person
of the creditors and hence should be governed by the law of the
domicile of that creditor.
 (2) Lex situs theory :- Dicey and Justice Atkin applied this
theory in the instances of debt. While situs theory has an
advantage of ascertaining the law in an easier fashion, its
difficulty arises when trying to locate it within the place of the
debtor.
Since the situs of the debt is a debtor, it becomes difficult to
ascertain the situs if the debtor resides at several places, for e.g.,
corporations.
 (3) Lex loci actus theory :- The place of assignment, or the
place where the documents assigning the debt are executed is the
governing factor and the law of that place of execution of the
assignment governs the assignment.
 (4) Proper law theory :- To govern issues on intangible
movables two principles is applied – proper law of assignment
(where assignment is most closely connected) & proper law of
debt.
1 sur 8

Recommandé

Immovable Property in Private international Law par
Immovable Property in Private international LawImmovable Property in Private international Law
Immovable Property in Private international Lawcarolineelias239
6.6K vues8 diapositives
Torts in Private international law par
Torts in Private international lawTorts in Private international law
Torts in Private international lawcarolineelias239
11.1K vues15 diapositives
The concept of Marriage under Private International Law par
The concept of Marriage under Private International LawThe concept of Marriage under Private International Law
The concept of Marriage under Private International Lawcarolineelias239
22.5K vues17 diapositives
Legitimacy, Legitimation and Adoption under Private International Law par
Legitimacy, Legitimation and Adoption under Private International LawLegitimacy, Legitimation and Adoption under Private International Law
Legitimacy, Legitimation and Adoption under Private International Lawcarolineelias239
6.3K vues13 diapositives
Concept of Domicile - meaning & characteristics par
Concept of Domicile - meaning & characteristicsConcept of Domicile - meaning & characteristics
Concept of Domicile - meaning & characteristicscarolineelias239
2.2K vues9 diapositives
Contracts in Private International Law par
Contracts in Private International LawContracts in Private International Law
Contracts in Private International Lawcarolineelias239
12K vues18 diapositives

Contenu connexe

Tendances

conflict of Laws or Private International Law par
conflict of Laws or Private International Lawconflict of Laws or Private International Law
conflict of Laws or Private International Lawcarolineelias239
1.6K vues11 diapositives
Domicile of Choice in Private International Law par
Domicile of Choice in Private International LawDomicile of Choice in Private International Law
Domicile of Choice in Private International Lawcarolineelias239
1.6K vues4 diapositives
Doctrin of Renvoi par
Doctrin of RenvoiDoctrin of Renvoi
Doctrin of Renvoicarolineelias239
7.5K vues11 diapositives
Classification of cause of action / characterisation par
Classification of cause of action / characterisationClassification of cause of action / characterisation
Classification of cause of action / characterisationcarolineelias239
11K vues12 diapositives
Private international law par
Private international  lawPrivate international  law
Private international lawMd.Rezaul Hoque Razu
24.8K vues12 diapositives
Domicile in private international law par
Domicile in private international lawDomicile in private international law
Domicile in private international lawAnkush Chattopadhyay
16K vues17 diapositives

Tendances(20)

conflict of Laws or Private International Law par carolineelias239
conflict of Laws or Private International Lawconflict of Laws or Private International Law
conflict of Laws or Private International Law
carolineelias2391.6K vues
Domicile of Choice in Private International Law par carolineelias239
Domicile of Choice in Private International LawDomicile of Choice in Private International Law
Domicile of Choice in Private International Law
carolineelias2391.6K vues
Classification of cause of action / characterisation par carolineelias239
Classification of cause of action / characterisationClassification of cause of action / characterisation
Classification of cause of action / characterisation
carolineelias23911K vues
Domicile of special categories and dependents in Private international law par carolineelias239
Domicile of special categories and dependents in Private international lawDomicile of special categories and dependents in Private international law
Domicile of special categories and dependents in Private international law
carolineelias2391.6K vues
Exclusion of Foreign Law.pptx par LucyPaul10
Exclusion of Foreign Law.pptxExclusion of Foreign Law.pptx
Exclusion of Foreign Law.pptx
LucyPaul10774 vues
Enforceability of foreign_judgments_and_foreign_awards par LegalServicesDelhi
Enforceability of foreign_judgments_and_foreign_awardsEnforceability of foreign_judgments_and_foreign_awards
Enforceability of foreign_judgments_and_foreign_awards
LegalServicesDelhi3.1K vues
Code of civil procedure 1908 reference, review, revision par Dr. Vikas Khakare
Code of civil procedure 1908 reference, review, revisionCode of civil procedure 1908 reference, review, revision
Code of civil procedure 1908 reference, review, revision
Dr. Vikas Khakare20.6K vues
Theory of proper law of contract par Sunit Kapoor
Theory of proper law of contractTheory of proper law of contract
Theory of proper law of contract
Sunit Kapoor13.2K vues
International Torts - Choice of law, par Patrick Aboku
International Torts - Choice of law, International Torts - Choice of law,
International Torts - Choice of law,
Patrick Aboku1.4K vues
Strict interpretation [penal] par SUBHAM AGRAWAL
Strict interpretation [penal]Strict interpretation [penal]
Strict interpretation [penal]
SUBHAM AGRAWAL17.6K vues
Private International Law and Crucial Role of Personal Connecting Factors par FadzliRohami1
Private International Law and Crucial Role of Personal Connecting FactorsPrivate International Law and Crucial Role of Personal Connecting Factors
Private International Law and Crucial Role of Personal Connecting Factors
FadzliRohami11.1K vues
INTERPRETATION OF STATUTE par cpjcollege
INTERPRETATION OF STATUTEINTERPRETATION OF STATUTE
INTERPRETATION OF STATUTE
cpjcollege34.8K vues

Similaire à Movable Property in Private International Law

Transfer Of Property Law par
Transfer Of Property LawTransfer Of Property Law
Transfer Of Property LawWrite My Paper Apa Format UK
6 vues8 diapositives
Re examining the theory of savigny, the theory of acquired par
Re   examining the theory of savigny, the theory of acquiredRe   examining the theory of savigny, the theory of acquired
Re examining the theory of savigny, the theory of acquiredAlexander Decker
436 vues9 diapositives
What Is The Ethics Of Odysseus Argument par
What Is The Ethics Of Odysseus ArgumentWhat Is The Ethics Of Odysseus Argument
What Is The Ethics Of Odysseus ArgumentBecki Roy
2 vues42 diapositives
Assignment on civil law vs common law par
Assignment on civil law vs common lawAssignment on civil law vs common law
Assignment on civil law vs common lawnasimbillah1
63 vues7 diapositives
The Logic Of English Land Law par
The Logic Of English Land LawThe Logic Of English Land Law
The Logic Of English Land LawCan You Write My Paper For Me Grand Forks
4 vues20 diapositives
Effects Of The Rule Of Law par
Effects Of The Rule Of LawEffects Of The Rule Of Law
Effects Of The Rule Of LawPay To Write Papers Singapore
5 vues22 diapositives

Similaire à Movable Property in Private International Law(20)

Re examining the theory of savigny, the theory of acquired par Alexander Decker
Re   examining the theory of savigny, the theory of acquiredRe   examining the theory of savigny, the theory of acquired
Re examining the theory of savigny, the theory of acquired
Alexander Decker436 vues
What Is The Ethics Of Odysseus Argument par Becki Roy
What Is The Ethics Of Odysseus ArgumentWhat Is The Ethics Of Odysseus Argument
What Is The Ethics Of Odysseus Argument
Becki Roy2 vues
Assignment on civil law vs common law par nasimbillah1
Assignment on civil law vs common lawAssignment on civil law vs common law
Assignment on civil law vs common law
nasimbillah163 vues
Teaching Social Justice through Statutory Interpretation par Kate Galloway
Teaching Social Justice through Statutory InterpretationTeaching Social Justice through Statutory Interpretation
Teaching Social Justice through Statutory Interpretation
Kate Galloway976 vues
The Principle Of Equity Within The World Of Doctrine, Not... par Kristina Camacho
The Principle Of Equity Within The World Of Doctrine, Not...The Principle Of Equity Within The World Of Doctrine, Not...
The Principle Of Equity Within The World Of Doctrine, Not...
Chris johnson remarks at galloway xi on establishing international norms and ... par Christopher Johnson
Chris johnson remarks at galloway xi on establishing international norms and ...Chris johnson remarks at galloway xi on establishing international norms and ...
Chris johnson remarks at galloway xi on establishing international norms and ...
Deprivation Of The Benefits Of Trial By Jury par Ann Johnson
Deprivation Of The Benefits Of Trial By JuryDeprivation Of The Benefits Of Trial By Jury
Deprivation Of The Benefits Of Trial By Jury
Ann Johnson3 vues

Plus de carolineelias239

Proprietary immunity of sovereign par
Proprietary immunity of sovereignProprietary immunity of sovereign
Proprietary immunity of sovereigncarolineelias239
178 vues5 diapositives
Jurisdiction and Immunities of the Sovereign par
Jurisdiction and Immunities of the SovereignJurisdiction and Immunities of the Sovereign
Jurisdiction and Immunities of the Sovereigncarolineelias239
796 vues14 diapositives
Introduction to Jurisprudence par
Introduction to JurisprudenceIntroduction to Jurisprudence
Introduction to Jurisprudencecarolineelias239
2K vues4 diapositives
Definitions of Jurisprudence. Scope & Relationship with other social sciences par
Definitions of Jurisprudence. Scope & Relationship with other social sciencesDefinitions of Jurisprudence. Scope & Relationship with other social sciences
Definitions of Jurisprudence. Scope & Relationship with other social sciencescarolineelias239
4.4K vues11 diapositives
Domicile of Choice in Private International Law par
Domicile of Choice in Private International LawDomicile of Choice in Private International Law
Domicile of Choice in Private International Lawcarolineelias239
461 vues4 diapositives
Domicile of Origin par
Domicile of OriginDomicile of Origin
Domicile of Origincarolineelias239
916 vues5 diapositives

Plus de carolineelias239(10)

Jurisdiction and Immunities of the Sovereign par carolineelias239
Jurisdiction and Immunities of the SovereignJurisdiction and Immunities of the Sovereign
Jurisdiction and Immunities of the Sovereign
carolineelias239796 vues
Definitions of Jurisprudence. Scope & Relationship with other social sciences par carolineelias239
Definitions of Jurisprudence. Scope & Relationship with other social sciencesDefinitions of Jurisprudence. Scope & Relationship with other social sciences
Definitions of Jurisprudence. Scope & Relationship with other social sciences
carolineelias2394.4K vues
Domicile of Choice in Private International Law par carolineelias239
Domicile of Choice in Private International LawDomicile of Choice in Private International Law
Domicile of Choice in Private International Law
carolineelias239461 vues
Trade Unions Act - Definition; Recognition & Registration par carolineelias239
Trade Unions Act - Definition; Recognition & Registration Trade Unions Act - Definition; Recognition & Registration
Trade Unions Act - Definition; Recognition & Registration
carolineelias2392.4K vues

Dernier

Kruse Law.pdf par
Kruse Law.pdfKruse Law.pdf
Kruse Law.pdfKruse Law
6 vues4 diapositives
PSI InternetPacketAllFormsJanuary2023.pdf par
PSI InternetPacketAllFormsJanuary2023.pdfPSI InternetPacketAllFormsJanuary2023.pdf
PSI InternetPacketAllFormsJanuary2023.pdfTodd Spodek
6 vues48 diapositives
2024 Kairos Capital Legal Fellow Listing.pdf par
2024 Kairos Capital Legal Fellow Listing.pdf2024 Kairos Capital Legal Fellow Listing.pdf
2024 Kairos Capital Legal Fellow Listing.pdfKairos Capital Legal Advisors,LLC
46 vues1 diapositive
Senate Bill 232 Timeline and Information Sheet par
Senate Bill 232 Timeline and Information SheetSenate Bill 232 Timeline and Information Sheet
Senate Bill 232 Timeline and Information Sheetaddie42
10 vues2 diapositives
الازمة الروسية الاوكرانية على ضوء نظريات العلاقات الدولية.pdf par
الازمة الروسية الاوكرانية على ضوء نظريات العلاقات الدولية.pdfالازمة الروسية الاوكرانية على ضوء نظريات العلاقات الدولية.pdf
الازمة الروسية الاوكرانية على ضوء نظريات العلاقات الدولية.pdfmboubouche
7 vues22 diapositives
DADAN LAW FIRM par
DADAN LAW FIRM DADAN LAW FIRM
DADAN LAW FIRM DADAN LAW FIRM
7 vues1 diapositive

Dernier(9)

PSI InternetPacketAllFormsJanuary2023.pdf par Todd Spodek
PSI InternetPacketAllFormsJanuary2023.pdfPSI InternetPacketAllFormsJanuary2023.pdf
PSI InternetPacketAllFormsJanuary2023.pdf
Todd Spodek6 vues
Senate Bill 232 Timeline and Information Sheet par addie42
Senate Bill 232 Timeline and Information SheetSenate Bill 232 Timeline and Information Sheet
Senate Bill 232 Timeline and Information Sheet
addie4210 vues
الازمة الروسية الاوكرانية على ضوء نظريات العلاقات الدولية.pdf par mboubouche
الازمة الروسية الاوكرانية على ضوء نظريات العلاقات الدولية.pdfالازمة الروسية الاوكرانية على ضوء نظريات العلاقات الدولية.pdf
الازمة الروسية الاوكرانية على ضوء نظريات العلاقات الدولية.pdf
mboubouche7 vues
Jamaica's Data Protection Act: Compliance required from the business community par Emerson Bryan
Jamaica's Data Protection Act: Compliance required from the business communityJamaica's Data Protection Act: Compliance required from the business community
Jamaica's Data Protection Act: Compliance required from the business community
Emerson Bryan35 vues

Movable Property in Private International Law

  • 2. MOVABLE PROPERTY  Movable properties are either tangible or intangible. The transfer of movables can be effected by the act of parties or by operation of law.  The preliminary and the vital question is whether only one common system of principles should be allowed to determine every question that arises in respect of movables or whether there should be different set of rules that could possibly be applied to different aspects of the transfer, such as assignability of movables, to formal validity and to material validity. THEORIES GOVERNING TRANSFER OF TANGIBLE MOVABLES (1) Lex domicile (2) Lex Actus (3) Lex Situs (4) Proper law theory
  • 3. (1) Lex domicile theory :-  This theory is founded upon the principle that since movables have no fixed situs, their situs can be shifted at any time by its owner.  Therefore, the medieval Italian statutists propounded the principle of mobile sequenter personam. The maxim means that goods follow the person. The doctrine had wide acceptance beyond the continental Europe in England and in the USA.  In Sill v. Worswick [(1791) 1 H B1 665; 126 E.R.379] This case laid down the doctrine that with respect to the disposition of moveable property, with respect to the transmission of it, either by succession, or the act of the party, it follows the law of the person. It was held that personal property has no locality, thus meaning that rights over movables are to be governed by the law of the owner’s domicile. ( criticism : it may cause unjust results)
  • 4. (2) Lex Actus theory :-  This theory has not gained much value in the contemporary legal discourse, though there have been a few instances of judicial acceptance of its crux (most important point at issue).  Alcock v. Smith [(1892) 1 Ch. 238] It was laid down that, the validity of a transfer depends not upon the law of the domicile of the owner but upon the law of the country in which transfer of the movable took place.  Cheshire criticized this on the point that a mere fact that a transaction was entered into a particular place is no adequate reason to accord control to the local law.  Graveson supported this view, on the point that, a reasonable man is expected to comply with the law of any country in which they would have performed the transaction.
  • 5. (3) Lex Situs theory :-  The lex situs theory obviously has its advantages, important among them being that situs law provides a single and easily ascertained system of law based on the focal point of the transaction, namely, the goods that the transaction concerns itself.  Moreover, the right of control satisfies the expectations of the reasonable man as for a party to transfer naturally conclude that the transaction would be subject to the law of the country in which the subject-matter is situated.  But it is difficult to ascertain in matters where the goods are in transit.  Graveson opined that this problem can be met by mercantile practices of treating the normal documents of title to such goods as bill of lading as representing the goods themselves so that in effect the relevant situs is generally that of the document of title.
  • 6. (4) Proper law theory :-  Cheshire propounded a new theory to explain the law governing issues arising out of the transfer of movables – is that the law of the country with which the transfer has the most real connection or to be more specific, i.e., the proper law of transfer.  The ascertaining of the proper law would not present any difficulty if the proper law and the lex situs is the same.  Difficulty arises in a situation where the two factors are grounded in two different legal systems. The content of transfer of property tangible movables largely addresses three issues:- (1) Matters arising between parties to the transfer ( Contractual / proprietary) (2) Matters arising from the transfer affecting third parties (3) Certain special types of transfers (Gifts / donatio mortis causa / goods in transit).
  • 7. THEORIES ON INTANGIBLE MOVABLES :-  An intangible movable may be described as an interest which is not directly related to a physical object or land.  For e.g. shares, patents, copyrights, debts, and negotiable instruments.  They may also be referred to as “choses in action”.  Theories relating to intangible movable properties also includes:- (1) Lex domicile theory (2) Lex situs theory (3) Lex loci actus theory (4) The proper law theory  (1) Lex domicile theory:- Philimore was the main proponent to apply this in relation to intangible movables. He explained that debts , rights and causes of action are universally perceived as attached to the person of the creditors and hence should be governed by the law of the domicile of that creditor.
  • 8.  (2) Lex situs theory :- Dicey and Justice Atkin applied this theory in the instances of debt. While situs theory has an advantage of ascertaining the law in an easier fashion, its difficulty arises when trying to locate it within the place of the debtor. Since the situs of the debt is a debtor, it becomes difficult to ascertain the situs if the debtor resides at several places, for e.g., corporations.  (3) Lex loci actus theory :- The place of assignment, or the place where the documents assigning the debt are executed is the governing factor and the law of that place of execution of the assignment governs the assignment.  (4) Proper law theory :- To govern issues on intangible movables two principles is applied – proper law of assignment (where assignment is most closely connected) & proper law of debt.