SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  58
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Samurai & knights: Were
the similarities Greater than
      the Differences?
Answers to Background
   Essay Questions
1.) What Conditions led to the development of feudalism
in both western Europe and Japan?




    Strong central governments lost power, and warlords and
    invaders threatened peace and stability. People agreed to
    exchange services for protection.
2.) IN the feudal system in both Europe and Japan,
what did lesser nobles give to lords in exchange for
grants of land?




 Nobles gave loyalty and military service
3.) What military figure existed in japan,
but not in europe?




 The Shogun, a powerful general who became ruler of the
 country.
4.) What religious figure existed in
europe but not in japan?




 The Pope, who headed the Catholic Church.
5.) What different religions or belief
systems influenced people in the two
regions?




 Roman Catholic Christianity influenced Europeans.

 Confucianism and Buddhism influenced the Japanese.
Define these terms:
Clan



A group of people, sometimes in the hundreds or thousands,
who are descended from a common ancestor.
Feudalism



a political and economic system in which lords gave lands to
nobles in return for military service and loyalty.
knight


Sometimes high-born, sometimes merely tenant farmers,
knights exchanged loyalty and military service to a lord for a
piece of land called a fief.

An European horseman warrior
Samurai



Military group in feudal Japan

Military, horseman warrior in Japan
shogun




A supreme military ruler in Japan
Chivalry




The ideal code of conduct for medieval knights.
bushido




The code of honor and conduct for samurai
Understanding the
 Question & Pre-
   Bucketing
1.) What is the analytical question asked by this Mini-Q?




    Samurai and Knights: Were the Similarities Greater than the
    Differences?
2.) What terms in the question need to be defined?




    Samurai and Knights
3.) Rewrite the question in your own words




    Were the Japanese samurai and European knights more
    alike or more different?
Pre-Bucketing
Documents

Document A: Two Feudal Class Systems

Document B: Loyalty to the Feudal Lord in Japan & Europe

Document C: Military Training of Samurai & Knights

Document D: Armor of Japanese & European Warriors

Document E: Codes of Honor

Document F: Feelings About Death
Documents            Documents               Documents


      A&B                  C&D                     E&F
Comparison Point #1   Comparison Point #2      Comparison Point #3

  Social Position        Military Role      Ideas About Honor & Death
Document A
Two Feudal Class
    Systems
1.) What is the purpose of drawing a
social pyramid?



 The purpose of the social pyramid is to show which groups
 of people have more power, wealth, and social standing than
 the other groups.

 It gives you a quick picture of who is at the top, middle, and
 bottom of a society.
2.) What group in Japan was like lords in
europe?




 The daimyos were like the lords in Europe.
3.) In Japan, what was the relationship
between samurai and daimyos?



 The samurai were the warrior class and the daimyos were
 the lords and landowners.

 The daimyos hired the samurai for protection and making
 war. In return, the samurai received land or payment for
 their services.
4.) IN Europe, what was the relationship
between knights and lords?



 It was similar to the daimyos and samurai.

 The lords were the wealth landowners and the knights were
 the warrior class.

 The knights would receive land or payment from the lords
 for the knights’ loyalty and military service to the lords.
5.) Based JUST on this document, were the similarities between samurai and
knights greater than the differences? Provide evidence that supports your answer.




  My Opinion: There were great similarities between knights
  and samurai. In the social pyramid, they were both in the
  same position in the social hierarchy and they both received
  some sort of payment (land/fee) for their loyalty and
  military service to their lord/daimyo.
Document B
loyalty to the feudal lord
   in japan & Europe
1.) Where was the relationship between lord and
warrior hereditary? What does thaT mean?




 There was a hereditary relationship between lord and
 warrior was in Japan.

 It means that a child MUST follow the same relationship
 that their parents had before them.
2.) What evidence is there that the bond
between lord and samurai in japan was
stroNg?



  In the document it states that the samurai’s allegiance to his
  lord lasts the duration of three lives.....his past existence, his
  present one, and the next life.

  This shows that the bond is forever lasting!
3.) About how many acres might be
required to support a knight in western
Europe?

   FYI: You can find this answer in the Document NOTE




 It took about 600 acres to enable a knight to support
 himself, his horses, his armor, his squire, and his family if he
 had one.
4.) Based on the document what was an important
similarity between samurai and knights?




   Similarity: Both the knights and samurai had to show a
   sense of loyalty to both of their lord in order to receive
   payment. They both had to give their lord military service as
   well.
5.) Based on the document what was an important
difference between samurai and knights?




   Difference:

   Samurai’s bond to his lord was hereditary and it was passed
   down from generation to generation. A samurai’s child will
   always be a samurai.

   Knight had to show allegiance by a contract. A knight’s child
   doesn’t have to become a knight and could stop the contract
   that his father had “signed”.
Document C
 Military training of
samurai and knights
1.) What are three examples of the kind of training
received by young samurai hopefuls?




 Physical Training: Kendo (art of fencing with bamboo sticks)

 Moral Training: Zen Buddhism

 Mental Training: poetry
2.)  What are three examples of the kind of training
received by pages hoping to become knights?




   Horseman Training: refining his horse skills

   Religious Training: some training in religious instructions

   Physical Training: wooden swords
3.) In what ceremony and at what age was a japanese
trainee inducted into the samurai class?




 At the age of 14, Japanese trainee became a samurai in a
 ceremony called genpuku.
4.) At What age did a european page become a squire?
when did a squire become a knight?




   European Pages became a squire at 14.

   At the Age of 21, a squire became a knight.
5.) Based on the document what were the main differences
between samurai and knights?

  Differences:

  Training: Samurai trained in studies as well as in fighting
  and sometimes Japanese girls received warfare instruction.

  There were many different levels of a knight’s training
  unlike that of the Samurai.

  Samurai may have gone into battle at a much younger age
  since they became a samurai at the age of 14 & a knight
  didn’t become “knighted” until the age of 21 where he would
  be in battle alone.
6.) Based on the document what were the main
similarities between samurai and knights?


   Similarities:

   Both samurai & knights began their training in their
   childhood.

   Both trained for many years before they became warriors.

   Both used some sort of fake weapon to train.

   Both received some religious or moral instruction.

   Eventually they both studied poetry.
Document D
Armor of Japanese and
 European Warriors
1.) What was the main purpose of suits of armor?




 The purpose for these suits of armor was to protect the
 warrior in battle.
2.) Both the samurai and knights generally fought on horseback. Who would have been
in the most trouble if he was knocked from his horse or his horse was killed? explain
your thinking.




   The European knight would be in the most trouble because
   of the weight of his armor which ranged anywhere from 40-
   60 pounds. His horse meant that he was able to be move
   about freely and without his horse, he was basically an open
   target.

   The Japanese samurai’s armor allowed for more hand to
   hand fighting.
3.) Military historians speak of the difference between shock warfare (striking the
enemy with weapons like swords, lances or axes) & projectile warfare (shooting or
throwing arrows, javelins, and bullets). Judging from the armor, which kind of
offensive warfare was fought by the samurai and knights? In each case, explain your
thinking.




  Shock warfare: The knights were better suited for this type
  of warfare because his armor allowed the knight to ride up to
  his enemy and make a direct hit. It DIDN’T allow for the
  knight to throw things at his enemy because of its rigidness.

  Projectile warfare: The samurai were better suited for this
  type of warfare because their armor had the right arm free
  which allowed the warrior to THROW things at his enemy or
  use his bow & arrow.
4.) Based on the document, what was an important
similarity between samurai and knight armor?




   Similarities:

   Both warriors had some type of iron plate armor.

   Both warriors’ armor was head to toe...full body.
5.) Based on the document, WHAT was an important
difference between samurai and knight armor?




  Differences:

  The major difference had to be the free arm of the samurai
  armor. This allowed the samurai to fight from either point
  whether it was farther away using a bow and arrow or up
  close using swords and having the ability to move around
  and attack.
Document E
Codes of Honor
1.) What are the main characteristics of bushido? what
are the main characteristics of chivalry?




 Bushido: To be loyal to the master, upholding moral
 principles, ways of peace and be ready to use your weapon at
 all times.

 Chivalry: Loyalty to the king, mercy, courtesy, helpfulness,
 honor, strength, and bravery.
2.) Which code of honor was written first? what is the difference in years between the
writing of these codes?




     The Knights Code was written in 1470.

     The Samurai Code was written in 1600s.

     The difference is about 130 years.
3.) What should a samurai do if there is a conflict between dealing with a family
problem and one involving the people he serves?




  The samurai’s main concern is to always be loyal to his lord
  and serve his lord even before his own family’s problems.
4.) Based on this document, what were the main
similarities between samurai and knights?




   Similarities:

   The samurai and the knight both have to responsibility to be
   loyal to his lord and to live a honorable life.
5.) Based on the document, WHAT were the main
differences between samurai and knights?



  Differences:

  The samurai’s code seems more loyal and devoted to his lord
  even before his family.

  The knight’s code states that he must be loyal to his lord, but
  also pay attention to being courteous to the ladies, not to
  fight for worldly gain, give mercy to those asking for it.
Document F
Feelings about death
1.) What is the main idea of the first samurai poem?




 One day you are here and the next you are not. It seems like
 the poem expresses the beauty of it all through the mention
 of twilight and autumn breezes.
2.) what is the main idea of the second
samurai poem?




  Death is like any other day. It really is no big deal.
3.) How would you describe the french knight’s view of
life?




 It seems like Roland is a bit afraid of death and asking
 forgiveness for the sins that he has created.

 Roland begs for mercy and it seems like he is fearful of not
 being accepted into heaven.
4.) In general, were the responses to death of the samurai
and the knight similar or different? explain



   Opinion: The responses were very much different. It seems
   like the Samurai never questioned his after life and it was as
   if he knew his place in the after life. The samurai had been
   honorable to his master as well as his ancestors so there was
   no need for fear. Whereas with Roland, a French knight,
   there were evident signs of worry through the beating of his
   chest, the reaching to God as well as the asking for mercy.
   This shows that Roland was not certain that he would be
   offered a place in heaven.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Uniformes Históricos da Força Aérea Brasileira
Uniformes Históricos da Força Aérea BrasileiraUniformes Históricos da Força Aérea Brasileira
Uniformes Históricos da Força Aérea BrasileiraFalcão Brasil
 
Manual cqb shadow
Manual cqb shadow Manual cqb shadow
Manual cqb shadow Vss Sales
 
Defesa com Facas
Defesa com FacasDefesa com Facas
Defesa com FacasPaulo Mello
 
PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO COMUM PPQ/1
PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO COMUM PPQ/1PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO COMUM PPQ/1
PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO COMUM PPQ/1Falcão Brasil
 
Schiltron2--Horsed attack counter
Schiltron2--Horsed attack counterSchiltron2--Horsed attack counter
Schiltron2--Horsed attack counterSilver Caprice
 
Feyattackcity 150326163427-conversion-gate01
Feyattackcity 150326163427-conversion-gate01Feyattackcity 150326163427-conversion-gate01
Feyattackcity 150326163427-conversion-gate01Silver Caprice
 
Regulamento de Uniformes da Marinha do Brasil RUMB
Regulamento de Uniformes da Marinha do Brasil RUMBRegulamento de Uniformes da Marinha do Brasil RUMB
Regulamento de Uniformes da Marinha do Brasil RUMBFalcão Brasil
 
FORMAÇÃO BÁSICA DO COMBATENTE PPB/2 2010
FORMAÇÃO BÁSICA DO COMBATENTE PPB/2 2010FORMAÇÃO BÁSICA DO COMBATENTE PPB/2 2010
FORMAÇÃO BÁSICA DO COMBATENTE PPB/2 2010Falcão Brasil
 
01 COMBATE EM BAIXA LUMINOSIDADE.pdf
01 COMBATE EM BAIXA LUMINOSIDADE.pdf01 COMBATE EM BAIXA LUMINOSIDADE.pdf
01 COMBATE EM BAIXA LUMINOSIDADE.pdfMaikonFortes
 
Highlight Defenders.pdf
Highlight Defenders.pdfHighlight Defenders.pdf
Highlight Defenders.pdfSilver Caprice
 
CADERNO DE INSTRUÇÃO ABRIGOS E ESPALDÕES CI 7-5/1
CADERNO DE INSTRUÇÃO ABRIGOS E ESPALDÕES CI 7-5/1CADERNO DE INSTRUÇÃO ABRIGOS E ESPALDÕES CI 7-5/1
CADERNO DE INSTRUÇÃO ABRIGOS E ESPALDÕES CI 7-5/1Falcão Brasil
 
Etiqueta y Protocolo de la Fuerza Armada de El Salvador
Etiqueta y Protocolo de la Fuerza Armada de El SalvadorEtiqueta y Protocolo de la Fuerza Armada de El Salvador
Etiqueta y Protocolo de la Fuerza Armada de El SalvadorWiliam Alexander Hernández
 
MANUAL DE CAMPANHA INSTALAÇÕES NA ZONA DE COMBATE C 5-39
MANUAL DE CAMPANHA INSTALAÇÕES NA ZONA DE COMBATE C 5-39MANUAL DE CAMPANHA INSTALAÇÕES NA ZONA DE COMBATE C 5-39
MANUAL DE CAMPANHA INSTALAÇÕES NA ZONA DE COMBATE C 5-39Falcão Brasil
 
Armas Improvisadas
Armas ImprovisadasArmas Improvisadas
Armas ImprovisadasPaulo Mello
 
The daily throne room set
The daily throne room setThe daily throne room set
The daily throne room setSilver Caprice
 
Even range throne room
Even range throne roomEven range throne room
Even range throne roomSilver Caprice
 
MANUAL DE CAMPANHA ESTADO-MAIOR E ORDENS 1º VOLUME C 101-5
MANUAL DE CAMPANHA ESTADO-MAIOR E ORDENS 1º VOLUME C 101-5MANUAL DE CAMPANHA ESTADO-MAIOR E ORDENS 1º VOLUME C 101-5
MANUAL DE CAMPANHA ESTADO-MAIOR E ORDENS 1º VOLUME C 101-5Falcão Brasil
 
PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO PECULIAR PPQ/2
PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO PECULIAR PPQ/2PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO PECULIAR PPQ/2
PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO PECULIAR PPQ/2Falcão Brasil
 

Tendances (20)

Uniformes Históricos da Força Aérea Brasileira
Uniformes Históricos da Força Aérea BrasileiraUniformes Históricos da Força Aérea Brasileira
Uniformes Históricos da Força Aérea Brasileira
 
Manual cqb shadow
Manual cqb shadow Manual cqb shadow
Manual cqb shadow
 
Defesa com Facas
Defesa com FacasDefesa com Facas
Defesa com Facas
 
PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO COMUM PPQ/1
PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO COMUM PPQ/1PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO COMUM PPQ/1
PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO COMUM PPQ/1
 
Schiltron2--Horsed attack counter
Schiltron2--Horsed attack counterSchiltron2--Horsed attack counter
Schiltron2--Horsed attack counter
 
Feyattackcity 150326163427-conversion-gate01
Feyattackcity 150326163427-conversion-gate01Feyattackcity 150326163427-conversion-gate01
Feyattackcity 150326163427-conversion-gate01
 
Regulamento de Uniformes da Marinha do Brasil RUMB
Regulamento de Uniformes da Marinha do Brasil RUMBRegulamento de Uniformes da Marinha do Brasil RUMB
Regulamento de Uniformes da Marinha do Brasil RUMB
 
FORMAÇÃO BÁSICA DO COMBATENTE PPB/2 2010
FORMAÇÃO BÁSICA DO COMBATENTE PPB/2 2010FORMAÇÃO BÁSICA DO COMBATENTE PPB/2 2010
FORMAÇÃO BÁSICA DO COMBATENTE PPB/2 2010
 
01 COMBATE EM BAIXA LUMINOSIDADE.pdf
01 COMBATE EM BAIXA LUMINOSIDADE.pdf01 COMBATE EM BAIXA LUMINOSIDADE.pdf
01 COMBATE EM BAIXA LUMINOSIDADE.pdf
 
Highlight Defenders.pdf
Highlight Defenders.pdfHighlight Defenders.pdf
Highlight Defenders.pdf
 
CADERNO DE INSTRUÇÃO ABRIGOS E ESPALDÕES CI 7-5/1
CADERNO DE INSTRUÇÃO ABRIGOS E ESPALDÕES CI 7-5/1CADERNO DE INSTRUÇÃO ABRIGOS E ESPALDÕES CI 7-5/1
CADERNO DE INSTRUÇÃO ABRIGOS E ESPALDÕES CI 7-5/1
 
Etiqueta y Protocolo de la Fuerza Armada de El Salvador
Etiqueta y Protocolo de la Fuerza Armada de El SalvadorEtiqueta y Protocolo de la Fuerza Armada de El Salvador
Etiqueta y Protocolo de la Fuerza Armada de El Salvador
 
OGTAB factor.pdf
OGTAB factor.pdfOGTAB factor.pdf
OGTAB factor.pdf
 
MANUAL DE CAMPANHA INSTALAÇÕES NA ZONA DE COMBATE C 5-39
MANUAL DE CAMPANHA INSTALAÇÕES NA ZONA DE COMBATE C 5-39MANUAL DE CAMPANHA INSTALAÇÕES NA ZONA DE COMBATE C 5-39
MANUAL DE CAMPANHA INSTALAÇÕES NA ZONA DE COMBATE C 5-39
 
Armas Improvisadas
Armas ImprovisadasArmas Improvisadas
Armas Improvisadas
 
The daily throne room set
The daily throne room setThe daily throne room set
The daily throne room set
 
Even range throne room
Even range throne roomEven range throne room
Even range throne room
 
Troop Priority List
Troop Priority ListTroop Priority List
Troop Priority List
 
MANUAL DE CAMPANHA ESTADO-MAIOR E ORDENS 1º VOLUME C 101-5
MANUAL DE CAMPANHA ESTADO-MAIOR E ORDENS 1º VOLUME C 101-5MANUAL DE CAMPANHA ESTADO-MAIOR E ORDENS 1º VOLUME C 101-5
MANUAL DE CAMPANHA ESTADO-MAIOR E ORDENS 1º VOLUME C 101-5
 
PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO PECULIAR PPQ/2
PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO PECULIAR PPQ/2PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO PECULIAR PPQ/2
PROGRAMA-PADRÃO QUALIFICAÇÃO DO CABO E DO SOLDADO INSTRUÇÃO PECULIAR PPQ/2
 

En vedette

essay
essayessay
essayJen W
 
DBQ Pointers
DBQ PointersDBQ Pointers
DBQ Pointerskbeacom
 
DBQ Tips and Hints
DBQ  Tips and HintsDBQ  Tips and Hints
DBQ Tips and HintsKim Drugan
 
Dbq essay outline exploration
Dbq essay outline explorationDbq essay outline exploration
Dbq essay outline explorationCherstine Willis
 
Writing a DBQ
Writing a DBQWriting a DBQ
Writing a DBQKristina
 
Mid term study guide answers 2015
Mid term study guide answers 2015Mid term study guide answers 2015
Mid term study guide answers 2015cczulada
 
Online sticky boards!
Online sticky boards!Online sticky boards!
Online sticky boards!cczulada
 
Final exam vocabulary
Final exam vocabularyFinal exam vocabulary
Final exam vocabularycczulada
 
Castle powerpoint 1
Castle powerpoint 1Castle powerpoint 1
Castle powerpoint 1cczulada
 
Chapter 11 workhseet notes
Chapter 11 workhseet notesChapter 11 workhseet notes
Chapter 11 workhseet notescczulada
 
Chapter 1 study guide review
Chapter 1 study guide reviewChapter 1 study guide review
Chapter 1 study guide reviewcczulada
 
Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1
Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1
Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1cczulada
 
Lesson 1 review of worksheet pp
Lesson 1 review of worksheet ppLesson 1 review of worksheet pp
Lesson 1 review of worksheet ppcczulada
 
Apps on the fly!
Apps on the fly!Apps on the fly!
Apps on the fly!cczulada
 
Mid term study guide answers 2014
Mid term study guide answers 2014Mid term study guide answers 2014
Mid term study guide answers 2014cczulada
 
Chapter 12 worksheet notes
Chapter 12 worksheet notesChapter 12 worksheet notes
Chapter 12 worksheet notescczulada
 
The great wall of china mini dbq
The great wall of china mini dbqThe great wall of china mini dbq
The great wall of china mini dbqcczulada
 
Chapter 2 worksheet review 2014
Chapter 2 worksheet review 2014Chapter 2 worksheet review 2014
Chapter 2 worksheet review 2014cczulada
 
Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1
Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1
Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1cczulada
 
Today's Meet
Today's MeetToday's Meet
Today's Meetcczulada
 

En vedette (20)

essay
essayessay
essay
 
DBQ Pointers
DBQ PointersDBQ Pointers
DBQ Pointers
 
DBQ Tips and Hints
DBQ  Tips and HintsDBQ  Tips and Hints
DBQ Tips and Hints
 
Dbq essay outline exploration
Dbq essay outline explorationDbq essay outline exploration
Dbq essay outline exploration
 
Writing a DBQ
Writing a DBQWriting a DBQ
Writing a DBQ
 
Mid term study guide answers 2015
Mid term study guide answers 2015Mid term study guide answers 2015
Mid term study guide answers 2015
 
Online sticky boards!
Online sticky boards!Online sticky boards!
Online sticky boards!
 
Final exam vocabulary
Final exam vocabularyFinal exam vocabulary
Final exam vocabulary
 
Castle powerpoint 1
Castle powerpoint 1Castle powerpoint 1
Castle powerpoint 1
 
Chapter 11 workhseet notes
Chapter 11 workhseet notesChapter 11 workhseet notes
Chapter 11 workhseet notes
 
Chapter 1 study guide review
Chapter 1 study guide reviewChapter 1 study guide review
Chapter 1 study guide review
 
Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1
Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1
Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1
 
Lesson 1 review of worksheet pp
Lesson 1 review of worksheet ppLesson 1 review of worksheet pp
Lesson 1 review of worksheet pp
 
Apps on the fly!
Apps on the fly!Apps on the fly!
Apps on the fly!
 
Mid term study guide answers 2014
Mid term study guide answers 2014Mid term study guide answers 2014
Mid term study guide answers 2014
 
Chapter 12 worksheet notes
Chapter 12 worksheet notesChapter 12 worksheet notes
Chapter 12 worksheet notes
 
The great wall of china mini dbq
The great wall of china mini dbqThe great wall of china mini dbq
The great wall of china mini dbq
 
Chapter 2 worksheet review 2014
Chapter 2 worksheet review 2014Chapter 2 worksheet review 2014
Chapter 2 worksheet review 2014
 
Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1
Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1
Lesson 3 reading notes powerpoint-2014-1
 
Today's Meet
Today's MeetToday's Meet
Today's Meet
 

Similaire à Samurai and knights dbq-Answers to Packet

Similaire à Samurai and knights dbq-Answers to Packet (6)

Japan And Europe03
Japan And Europe03Japan And Europe03
Japan And Europe03
 
Japan And Europe Comparison
Japan And Europe ComparisonJapan And Europe Comparison
Japan And Europe Comparison
 
8 Thperiod1 Exam
8 Thperiod1 Exam8 Thperiod1 Exam
8 Thperiod1 Exam
 
Magna Carta Vs Japan
Magna Carta Vs JapanMagna Carta Vs Japan
Magna Carta Vs Japan
 
Samurai
SamuraiSamurai
Samurai
 
Samurai
SamuraiSamurai
Samurai
 

Samurai and knights dbq-Answers to Packet

  • 1. Samurai & knights: Were the similarities Greater than the Differences?
  • 2. Answers to Background Essay Questions
  • 3. 1.) What Conditions led to the development of feudalism in both western Europe and Japan? Strong central governments lost power, and warlords and invaders threatened peace and stability. People agreed to exchange services for protection.
  • 4. 2.) IN the feudal system in both Europe and Japan, what did lesser nobles give to lords in exchange for grants of land? Nobles gave loyalty and military service
  • 5. 3.) What military figure existed in japan, but not in europe? The Shogun, a powerful general who became ruler of the country.
  • 6. 4.) What religious figure existed in europe but not in japan? The Pope, who headed the Catholic Church.
  • 7. 5.) What different religions or belief systems influenced people in the two regions? Roman Catholic Christianity influenced Europeans. Confucianism and Buddhism influenced the Japanese.
  • 9. Clan A group of people, sometimes in the hundreds or thousands, who are descended from a common ancestor.
  • 10. Feudalism a political and economic system in which lords gave lands to nobles in return for military service and loyalty.
  • 11. knight Sometimes high-born, sometimes merely tenant farmers, knights exchanged loyalty and military service to a lord for a piece of land called a fief. An European horseman warrior
  • 12. Samurai Military group in feudal Japan Military, horseman warrior in Japan
  • 13. shogun A supreme military ruler in Japan
  • 14. Chivalry The ideal code of conduct for medieval knights.
  • 15. bushido The code of honor and conduct for samurai
  • 16. Understanding the Question & Pre- Bucketing
  • 17. 1.) What is the analytical question asked by this Mini-Q? Samurai and Knights: Were the Similarities Greater than the Differences?
  • 18. 2.) What terms in the question need to be defined? Samurai and Knights
  • 19. 3.) Rewrite the question in your own words Were the Japanese samurai and European knights more alike or more different?
  • 21. Documents Document A: Two Feudal Class Systems Document B: Loyalty to the Feudal Lord in Japan & Europe Document C: Military Training of Samurai & Knights Document D: Armor of Japanese & European Warriors Document E: Codes of Honor Document F: Feelings About Death
  • 22. Documents Documents Documents A&B C&D E&F Comparison Point #1 Comparison Point #2 Comparison Point #3 Social Position Military Role Ideas About Honor & Death
  • 23. Document A Two Feudal Class Systems
  • 24. 1.) What is the purpose of drawing a social pyramid? The purpose of the social pyramid is to show which groups of people have more power, wealth, and social standing than the other groups. It gives you a quick picture of who is at the top, middle, and bottom of a society.
  • 25. 2.) What group in Japan was like lords in europe? The daimyos were like the lords in Europe.
  • 26. 3.) In Japan, what was the relationship between samurai and daimyos? The samurai were the warrior class and the daimyos were the lords and landowners. The daimyos hired the samurai for protection and making war. In return, the samurai received land or payment for their services.
  • 27. 4.) IN Europe, what was the relationship between knights and lords? It was similar to the daimyos and samurai. The lords were the wealth landowners and the knights were the warrior class. The knights would receive land or payment from the lords for the knights’ loyalty and military service to the lords.
  • 28. 5.) Based JUST on this document, were the similarities between samurai and knights greater than the differences? Provide evidence that supports your answer. My Opinion: There were great similarities between knights and samurai. In the social pyramid, they were both in the same position in the social hierarchy and they both received some sort of payment (land/fee) for their loyalty and military service to their lord/daimyo.
  • 29. Document B loyalty to the feudal lord in japan & Europe
  • 30. 1.) Where was the relationship between lord and warrior hereditary? What does thaT mean? There was a hereditary relationship between lord and warrior was in Japan. It means that a child MUST follow the same relationship that their parents had before them.
  • 31. 2.) What evidence is there that the bond between lord and samurai in japan was stroNg? In the document it states that the samurai’s allegiance to his lord lasts the duration of three lives.....his past existence, his present one, and the next life. This shows that the bond is forever lasting!
  • 32. 3.) About how many acres might be required to support a knight in western Europe? FYI: You can find this answer in the Document NOTE It took about 600 acres to enable a knight to support himself, his horses, his armor, his squire, and his family if he had one.
  • 33. 4.) Based on the document what was an important similarity between samurai and knights? Similarity: Both the knights and samurai had to show a sense of loyalty to both of their lord in order to receive payment. They both had to give their lord military service as well.
  • 34. 5.) Based on the document what was an important difference between samurai and knights? Difference: Samurai’s bond to his lord was hereditary and it was passed down from generation to generation. A samurai’s child will always be a samurai. Knight had to show allegiance by a contract. A knight’s child doesn’t have to become a knight and could stop the contract that his father had “signed”.
  • 35. Document C Military training of samurai and knights
  • 36. 1.) What are three examples of the kind of training received by young samurai hopefuls? Physical Training: Kendo (art of fencing with bamboo sticks) Moral Training: Zen Buddhism Mental Training: poetry
  • 37. 2.) What are three examples of the kind of training received by pages hoping to become knights? Horseman Training: refining his horse skills Religious Training: some training in religious instructions Physical Training: wooden swords
  • 38. 3.) In what ceremony and at what age was a japanese trainee inducted into the samurai class? At the age of 14, Japanese trainee became a samurai in a ceremony called genpuku.
  • 39. 4.) At What age did a european page become a squire? when did a squire become a knight? European Pages became a squire at 14. At the Age of 21, a squire became a knight.
  • 40. 5.) Based on the document what were the main differences between samurai and knights? Differences: Training: Samurai trained in studies as well as in fighting and sometimes Japanese girls received warfare instruction. There were many different levels of a knight’s training unlike that of the Samurai. Samurai may have gone into battle at a much younger age since they became a samurai at the age of 14 & a knight didn’t become “knighted” until the age of 21 where he would be in battle alone.
  • 41. 6.) Based on the document what were the main similarities between samurai and knights? Similarities: Both samurai & knights began their training in their childhood. Both trained for many years before they became warriors. Both used some sort of fake weapon to train. Both received some religious or moral instruction. Eventually they both studied poetry.
  • 42. Document D Armor of Japanese and European Warriors
  • 43. 1.) What was the main purpose of suits of armor? The purpose for these suits of armor was to protect the warrior in battle.
  • 44. 2.) Both the samurai and knights generally fought on horseback. Who would have been in the most trouble if he was knocked from his horse or his horse was killed? explain your thinking. The European knight would be in the most trouble because of the weight of his armor which ranged anywhere from 40- 60 pounds. His horse meant that he was able to be move about freely and without his horse, he was basically an open target. The Japanese samurai’s armor allowed for more hand to hand fighting.
  • 45. 3.) Military historians speak of the difference between shock warfare (striking the enemy with weapons like swords, lances or axes) & projectile warfare (shooting or throwing arrows, javelins, and bullets). Judging from the armor, which kind of offensive warfare was fought by the samurai and knights? In each case, explain your thinking. Shock warfare: The knights were better suited for this type of warfare because his armor allowed the knight to ride up to his enemy and make a direct hit. It DIDN’T allow for the knight to throw things at his enemy because of its rigidness. Projectile warfare: The samurai were better suited for this type of warfare because their armor had the right arm free which allowed the warrior to THROW things at his enemy or use his bow & arrow.
  • 46. 4.) Based on the document, what was an important similarity between samurai and knight armor? Similarities: Both warriors had some type of iron plate armor. Both warriors’ armor was head to toe...full body.
  • 47. 5.) Based on the document, WHAT was an important difference between samurai and knight armor? Differences: The major difference had to be the free arm of the samurai armor. This allowed the samurai to fight from either point whether it was farther away using a bow and arrow or up close using swords and having the ability to move around and attack.
  • 49. 1.) What are the main characteristics of bushido? what are the main characteristics of chivalry? Bushido: To be loyal to the master, upholding moral principles, ways of peace and be ready to use your weapon at all times. Chivalry: Loyalty to the king, mercy, courtesy, helpfulness, honor, strength, and bravery.
  • 50. 2.) Which code of honor was written first? what is the difference in years between the writing of these codes? The Knights Code was written in 1470. The Samurai Code was written in 1600s. The difference is about 130 years.
  • 51. 3.) What should a samurai do if there is a conflict between dealing with a family problem and one involving the people he serves? The samurai’s main concern is to always be loyal to his lord and serve his lord even before his own family’s problems.
  • 52. 4.) Based on this document, what were the main similarities between samurai and knights? Similarities: The samurai and the knight both have to responsibility to be loyal to his lord and to live a honorable life.
  • 53. 5.) Based on the document, WHAT were the main differences between samurai and knights? Differences: The samurai’s code seems more loyal and devoted to his lord even before his family. The knight’s code states that he must be loyal to his lord, but also pay attention to being courteous to the ladies, not to fight for worldly gain, give mercy to those asking for it.
  • 55. 1.) What is the main idea of the first samurai poem? One day you are here and the next you are not. It seems like the poem expresses the beauty of it all through the mention of twilight and autumn breezes.
  • 56. 2.) what is the main idea of the second samurai poem? Death is like any other day. It really is no big deal.
  • 57. 3.) How would you describe the french knight’s view of life? It seems like Roland is a bit afraid of death and asking forgiveness for the sins that he has created. Roland begs for mercy and it seems like he is fearful of not being accepted into heaven.
  • 58. 4.) In general, were the responses to death of the samurai and the knight similar or different? explain Opinion: The responses were very much different. It seems like the Samurai never questioned his after life and it was as if he knew his place in the after life. The samurai had been honorable to his master as well as his ancestors so there was no need for fear. Whereas with Roland, a French knight, there were evident signs of worry through the beating of his chest, the reaching to God as well as the asking for mercy. This shows that Roland was not certain that he would be offered a place in heaven.