Originally given at MIGS2012, this presentation describes the high standard that should be applied to leaders in the video games industry. It also gives examples of how to improve and a description of what you can expect in an organization that focuses on quality leadership.
Email me for the full deck with notes, additional research results, and links to all of the studies backing up the statements made herein.
http://www.fullergameproduction.com
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/.
2. • INTRODUCTION
• WHAT DOES A LEADER DO?
• HOW TO IMPROVE
• WHAT HAPPENS WHEN
LEADERSHIP IMPROVES?
• WHY AREN’T THINGS BETTER?
3. INTRODUCTION
Deficient leadership is the biggest threat to our
industry, our customers, and we developers. It’s a
blight that has gone almost completely unchecked
and that needs to stop.
7. Is a “manager” a Leader?
• Orchestrates
• Expects performance
• Removes impediments
• No explicit
development
• No interpersonal
problem-solving
• E.g. Scrum Master
8. Is a “mentor” a Leader?
• Person-centric
• Input, suggestions
• Seeks your
development
• No “orders”
• Not giving resources
• E.g. HR
9. Leader = Manager + Mentor
• Completes goals (project or
operations) while prioritizing
the development of the team
• Delivers resources
• Motivates
• Sets goals and constraints, lets
team succeed
• Will, when necessary, say,
“Shut up and march”
10. WHAT DOES A LEADER DO?
Upholds the Priorities of the Organization
#2 People
#1 Business purpose
11. Examples
First…the bad
Dave Rushton, founder of Sensory
Sweep Studios
“88 employees filed claims totaling
$663,143 in unpaid wages against
Rushton’s Sensory Sweep Studios, ”
-Salt Lake Tribune
Photo: Utah Attorney General’s Office
12. Examples
Now some better ones…
Tom Crago, CEO of Tantalus Media
“I felt a huge sense of responsibility to
the people working for me…I
determined to be much more
transparent about our business, both in
terms of its challenges and its
successes. ”
Photo: CeBIT Australia -Tom Crago, quoted by Gamasutra.com
13. Examples
Now some better ones…
Sir Ernest Shackleton, Trans-Antarctic
Explorer
“I am clearly one heckuva good
leader.”
-Not actually a quote by Sir Ernest
Photo: public domain
Shackleton
14. Examples
Now some better ones…
Jerry
• Started a small casual games studio
• Lost some contracts
• Paid off every employee, all debts
• Closed the shop
15. WHAT DOES A LEADER DO?
(Specifics, please)
• Communicates honestly
16. MEN WANTED
For hazardous journey, small wages, bitter cold, long
months of complete darkness, constant danger, safe
return doubtful, honor and recognition in case of
success.
17. WHAT DOES A LEADER DO?
(Specifics now)
• Communicates honestly
• Expresses values and goals frequently and
openly
• Gets involved in hiring. Very involved.
• Ensures team members are healthy and
growing
• Defies complicity
18. HOW TO IMPROVE
• Understand the goal, ensure it’s a fit for you
• Get a mentor
• Be a mentor
• Be where seniority and technical knowledge
aren’t prerequisites for leaders
• Keep learning!
19. What are these “soft skills” anyway?
• Personality types (Myers-Briggs, DISC)
• Conflict resolution
20. Peter Senge, “Left-hand column”
Problem: My jerk producer wanted me to add physics support
right before certification.
“Add physics support.”
“This man has no idea how much work “That’s insane. We go to
this would be.” cert next week.”
“Irate Avians has physics.”
“I’m already working overtime to drop
“They designed for it!
my bug count. Something’s got to give.”
They specifically licensed
middleware!”
“This game will fail spectacularly. I will “I get to decide who goes to GDC...”
go to GDC and interview with every
company and work anywhere else.” “FINE”
21. What are these “soft skills” anyway?
• Personality types (Myers-Briggs, DISC)
• Conflict resolution
• Communication styles
• Connecting with coworkers as people
• Ask questions
• Listen
• Intrinsic motivation
22. WHAT HAPPENS WHEN LEADERSHIP
IMPROVES?
• People stick around
• People are happier
• People are more productive
23. WHY AREN’T THINGS BETTER?
• It’s hard
• No concrete ROI
• Politics
• Too busy
• Nobody’s tried
24. CLOSING
How can we improve leadership?
Why should we improve leadership?
25.
26. CLOSING
How can we improve leadership?
Why should we improve leadership?
• Everything rises and falls on leadership
• Game developers are worth it
27. One last thing
Please take this one-question survey:
(even if you got here from Slideshare)
http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/FV2QPXM
Notes de l'éditeur
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/.
Our customers face shoddy product choices, our industry is beset by intellectual theft and manipulative business practices, and the developers upon whom the industry relies are regularly devalued and abused, all as a result of inadequate leadership.In this session we’ll recognize what quality leadership should look like, how to improve our own leadership, and how to address the obstacles that prevent improvement.
What proof do I give that deficient leadership is a blight on our industry?http://kotaku.com/5940672/pissed-off-employees-bash-pretty-much-every-major-video-game-company
First principles: why does a game company exist? To serve two priorities.
The last bullet might be controversial, but the leader is trusted and empowered to finish a project as a priority of the business and therefore has to make tough choices. Without this, you get Half-Life 2: Episode 3.Look at “prioritizing the development of the team” and “Shut up and march.” How are these not in conflict? Because there’s a difference between exploiting devs for the sake of the project and temporarily putting project needs above other things. Nonetheless, the standard should be upheld: complete the project goals while putting the team first. We should expect this level of excellence of our leaders.
A leader acts to accomplish objectives based on the purpose of the business (priority #1) while demonstrating the utmost care for the needs of the developers (priority #2).
Salt Lake Tribune, http://www.sltrib.com/sltrib/news/55065295-78/claims-rushton-unpaid-employees.html.csp
There are all sorts of other things that should come part and parcel with a good leader – the ability to delegate, respect others, trust the team. We’ll get to some of them, but we can’t exactly have exhaustive coverage in less than an hour.
Asked Twitter what makes a good leader:“Someone who gives people the resources and support they need to succeed, and encourages creativity and active involvement.”“Leaders need to have the respect of their peers and underlings. They also have to give respect their peers and underlings.”“Someone who motivates and enables you to do your absolute best work.”
1. Realize the goal is to be someone who is particularly adept at empathy, self-awareness, and communication. Be someone who values every team member and works to see them grow and learn and get closer to doing what they’re passionate about. This isn’t about becoming a subject matter expert within your particular discipline. If you want to be really good at specific skills or really knowledgeable about some area, that’s great – pursue that! But that’s not core to being a good leader. It’s not mutually exclusive, either, but it’s not core.2. “The one thing people are never good at is seeing themselves as others see them. A coach really, really helps.” Eric Schmidt, Google CEO3. Game Mentor Online (http://gmo.chronus.com/p/main/about)4. “First Break All the Rules”, Marcus Buckingham and Curt Coffman – Career path shouldn’t include leadership by default (from 25 years of interviews with 80,000 managers in 400 companies). Authors concluded that a company that lacks great frontline managers will bleed talent, no matter how attractive the compensation packages and training opportunities. With this in mind, they sought the answers to the follow-up questions: "How do great managers find, focus and keep talented employees.“ The Twelve Questions give the info needed to attract, focus, and keep the most talented employees. ALSO…an organization that defaults to leadership as a career path shows a misunderstanding of leadership abilities and is implicitly jeopardizing the quality of leaders in the company. In such an environment, you’ll be held to bogus standards even if you *are* a good leader (or a good candidate).5. Keep learning. Don’t expect the knowledge and training will come to you. Seek out opportunities to learn, don’t wait for them to appear. Marc Merrill of Riot Games (11/4/2010), “Never assume we’re as optimal at *anything* as we can be.”
From “The Fifth Discipline”, by Peter SengeRecall an interpersonal work problem.Draw a vertical line. On the right side write the dialogue that resulted.In the left column write what you were thinking but didn’t say.Ask yourself, “What led me to think this way?” “How might my comments have contributed to the problem?” etc.Rewrite the conversation, bringing your left-hand thoughts into the right-hand column in a way that contributes to a positive ending.
“People Stick Around” - When employees aren’t challenged and don’t experience growth opportunities, they leave (Harvard Business Review): http://finance.yahoo.com/news/biggest-reason-talented-young-employees-175800178.html“People Are Happier” - Better leaders yield higher engagement and satisfaction amongst staff (Harvard Business Review): http://blogs.hbr.org/cs/2012/07/how_damaging_is_a_bad_boss_exa.html Also, everything at http://www.happybrainscience.com/“People Are More Productive” – Improved leadership means increasing use of intrinsic motivation rather than external motivation: http://www.fullergameproduction.com/journal-page/2012/1/4/what-four-decades-of-scientific-research-can-teach-us-about.html
Given all the benefits of improved leadership, why don’t we see more movement on this front?Why don’t we see more stringent standards – or, in some cases, *any* standards (other than tenure) – for being moved into a leadership role?I bet people within your organization still think of it as, “being *promoted* to a leadership position”.Why?Well, why should you pursue improvement, and why focus on things like soft skills? http://hbr.org/2004/01/what-makes-a-leader/ar/1See Daniel Goleman’s research on “Emotional Intelligence”