1. Reading from Cultural
Spaces
The Difference that Culture
Makes in Biblical
Interpretation
2. Background
“The Flesh and Blood Reader”
Fernando Segovia. “Toward a Hermeneutics of the
Diaspora: A Hermeneutics of Otherness and
Engagement.” Pages 1-35 in Reading From This Place.
Volume I: Social Location and Biblical Interpretation in
the United States. Ed. Fernando F. Segovia and Mary
Ann Tolbert. Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 1995.
3. The “Culture” Exercise
Three Questions:
What is your culture?
In what ways do you reflect or resist your
culture?
How does your culture influence your reading
of the biblical text?
6. Culturally Contextual
Biblical Interpretation
What is CULTURE?
“The concept of culture I espouse…is essentially a semiotic
one. Believing, with Max Weber, that man is an animal
suspended in webs of significance he himself has spun, I
take culture to be those webs, and the analysis of it to be
therefore not an experimental science in search of law but an
interpretative one in search of meaning.”
~Clifford Gertz, The Interpretation of Culture
Culture is a “system of discriminations and evaluations… it
also means that culture is a system of exclusions”
~Edward Said, The World, the Text, and the Critic
7. Culturally Contextual
Biblical Interpretation
What do we mean by CONTEXT?
Three spheres or “worlds” of context:
1) World behind the text
2) World of the text
3) World in front of the text
8. Culturally Contextual
Biblical Interpretation
What is BIBLICAL INTERPRETATION?
Question(s):
What makes for good biblical interpretation?
What are our assumptions?
What is our criteria?
Who decides?
What role does culture play in the questions
above?
9. Mark 7:24-28
24 From there he set out and went away to the region of
Tyre.* He entered a house and did not want anyone to
know he was there. Yet he could not escape notice, 25but a
woman whose little daughter had an unclean spirit
immediately heard about him, and she came and bowed
down at his feet. 26Now the woman was a Gentile, of
Syrophoenician origin. She begged him to cast the demon
out of her daughter. 27He said to her, „Let the children be
fed first, for it is not fair to take the children‟s food and
throw it to the dogs.‟ 28But she answered him, „Sir,* even
the dogs under the table eat the children‟s crumbs.‟ 29Then
he said to her, „For saying that, you may go—the demon
has left your daughter.‟ 30So she went home, found the
child lying on the bed, and the demon gone.
10. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
Phyllis Trible: late 20th C. first gen. feminist
biblical scholar
Delores Williams: late 20th C. Womanist
theologian
11. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
“…a fainthearted faith that cannot leave things
with God and believes it necessary to help
things along.”
12. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
“…a fainthearted faith that cannot leave things
with God and believes it necessary to help
things along.”
“so conceived in defiance or in little faith cannot
be the heir of promise.”
13. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
“…a fainthearted faith that cannot leave things
with God and believes it necessary to help
things along.”
“so conceived in defiance or in little faith cannot
be the heir of promise.”
14. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
Phyllis Trible: late 20th C. first gen. feminist
biblical scholar
“Yet she experiences exodus without liberation,
revelation without salvation, wilderness without
covenant, wanderings without land, promise
without fulfillment, and unmerited exile without
return.”
15. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
Phyllis Trible: late 20th C. first gen. feminist
biblical scholar
“Yet she experiences exodus without liberation,
revelation without salvation, wilderness without
covenant, wanderings without land, promise
without fulfillment, and unmerited exile without
return.”
16. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
Phyllis Trible: late 20th C. first gen. feminist
biblical scholar
“Yet she experiences exodus without liberation,
revelation without salvation, wilderness without
covenant, wanderings without land, promise
without fulfillment, and unmerited exile without
return.”
17. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
Phyllis Trible: late 20th C. first gen. feminist
biblical scholar
“Yet she experiences exodus without liberation,
revelation without salvation, wilderness without
covenant, wanderings without land, promise
without fulfillment, and unmerited exile without
return.”
18. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
Phyllis Trible: late 20th C. first gen. feminist
biblical scholar
“Yet she experiences exodus without liberation,
revelation without salvation, wilderness without
covenant, wanderings without land, promise
without fulfillment, and unmerited exile without
return.”
19. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
Phyllis Trible: late 20th C. first gen. feminist
biblical scholar
“Yet she experiences exodus without liberation,
revelation without salvation, wilderness without
covenant, wanderings without land, promise
without fulfillment, and unmerited exile without
return.”
20. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
Phyllis Trible: late 20th C. first gen. feminist
biblical scholar
Delores Williams: late 20th C. Womanist
theologian
“The story of the Egyptian slave and her Hebrew
mistress is hauntingly reminiscent of the disturbing
accounts of black slavewomen and white mistresses
during slavery.”
21. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
Phyllis Trible: late 20th C. first gen. feminist
biblical scholar
Delores Williams: late 20th C. Womanist
theologian
“The story of the Egyptian slave and her Hebrew
mistress is hauntingly reminiscent of the disturbing
accounts of black slavewomen and white mistresses
during slavery.”
22. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
Phyllis Trible: late 20th C. first gen. feminist
biblical scholar
Delores Williams: late 20th C. Womanist
theologian
“The story of the Egyptian slave and her Hebrew
mistress is hauntingly reminiscent of the disturbing
accounts of black slavewomen and white mistresses
during slavery.”
23. Readers Reading Abraham/Sarah/Hagar (Gen
16 and 21)
Genesis 16 and 21
Readers Reading Genesis 16 and 21
Gerhard von Rad: 20th C. German scholar,
Lutheran pastor
Phyllis Trible: late 20th C. first gen. feminist
biblical scholar
Delores Williams: late 20th C. Womanist
theologian
Kevin, Interfaith Youth Core, “When Ishmael
Comes Home”