This document summarizes recent policy developments affecting English for Speakers of Other Languages (ESOL) provision for unemployed learners in England and their implications. Key points include: new funding arrangements and qualifications starting in 2013-2014; increased conditionality for unemployment benefits requiring ESOL training; emphasis on progressing learners to Functional Skills English and GCSEs; and implications for providers including potential increased demand and pressure on budgets.
ESOL for unemployed learners - implications and developments
1. #esolshoestring @alexsNIACE
ESOL for unemployed learners:
recent developments and their
implications
Stuart Hollis
Alex Stevenson, Senior Project Officer
alex.stevenson@niace.org.uk
2. It’s all change – well, sort of…
•
•
•
New funding arrangements for 13/14
Skills conditionality and Universal Credit
(UC) affecting unemployed learners
Policy emphasis on Functional Skills and
GCSE English Language
3. •
•
New Knowledge of Language and Life in
the UK (KoLL) requirements from 28th Oct
2013
New ESOL qualifications from Sept. 2014
6. •
•
‘non-regulated’ learning aims are still
funded (pre-entry to Level 2)
Issue in L1/L2 full qualifications around the
replacement for the Adult Literacy test –
delays putting on LARA
7. Job Outcome Payments
•
•
•
Reduces disincentive if an unemployed
learner leaves the course early to start a job
50% of the achievement payment (20%)
Providers will be able to record an
employment outcome in the ILR
8. •
•
To be eligible, the job must be for more
than 16 hours a week, for 4 weeks in a row
Requires a declaration from the learners
that they have stopped claiming
unemployment related benefits and have
entered work
9. Skills Conditionality
•
•
Increased conditionality regime for JSA has
become part of the ESOL landscape
Many providers have adapted and reorganised some or all of their provision in
response, and increased partnership
working with JCP
10. •
•
NIACE ran ‘ESOL and Employability’
workshops nationally Jan – March 2013
‘ESOL Toolkit’ for JCP advisers produced
11. ESOL and Employability
•
Partnership working critical
•
•
•
•
JCP awareness of ESOL provision and issues
More effective referral processes
Could assist with learner outcomes
Programme planning more effective where
given priority by senior management
12. •
•
Concern about the implications for those not
in a position to work but who need ESOL
NIACE hopes to share some good practice
models
13. Universal Credit (1)
•
•
Combines an array of working age benefits
into a single, means-tested benefit for those
both in and out of work
Intended to ensure that claimants are better
off in work
14. •
•
•
Currently piloted in Tameside, Greater
Manchester
6 further pilots to commence October 2013,
including Hammersmith
Roll out by 2017
15. Universal Credit (2)
•
•
Eligibility for SFA funding basically similar
existing JSA arrangements, no ‘16 hour
rule’
Claimants mandated to skills training where
identified as a barrier (increased sanctions)
16. •
•
Screened and referred as a matter of
course where language needs identified
If mandated, eligible for full funding even if
belong to a UC group only currently eligible
at provider’s discretion
17. Implications for Providers
•
•
Increased referrals from JCP and potentially
other sources e.g. housing providers
NIACE understands that JCP will expect
more intensive provision (“full time”?)
18. •
•
•
Focus on Speaking and Listening,
employability skills and job search skills
Demand for provision to support budgeting
skills and on-line UC claims
Increased pressure on Adult Skills budget,
staffing and accommodation
19. New KoLL Requirements
•
•
From 28th October 2013, learners will have
to demonstrate spoken language skills at
B1 (ESOL Entry 3) and pass the Life in the
UK test
No longer the requirement for the course to
be delivered by an accredited provider
20. •
•
Learners will have to stay in provision
longer to achieve E3 Speaking and
Listening
Concerns about length of time needed for
study and level required
21. Pressure on the Adult Skills
Budget
•
•
•
Skills conditionality / UC – more referrals
Increased intensiveness of provision
Demand for other provision in preparation
for UC e.g. budgeting, digital access skills
22. •
•
•
New KoLL requirements
Adult Skills budget reduced and potential for
other capacity issues
Providers have flexibilities – but are some
types of learning (and learners) being
pushed out?
24. ESOL and Functional Skills
English
•
•
Relationship of ESOL to Adult Literacy –
linked, but distinct in many respects
Long-standing concerns about the use of
inappropriate assessment in ESOL i.e. the
Adult Literacy test
25. •
•
New forms of multilingualism mean that
distinctions between ESOL and English are
not always clear (for learners or providers)
ESOL learners are already accessing FS –
e.g. 16 – 19, WBL, funding purposes
26. New NIACE Work
•
•
•
Commissioned by BIS to look at
ESOL learners’ progression to
FS English and GCSE English
language
Call for information until 9th Dec
2013
http://bit.ly/18e0OGh
27. Towards a ‘New Curriculum for
Difficult Times’?
•
•
NIACE report on work by ACL providers –
‘A New Curriculum for Difficult Times’
Smarter use of available resources to
address language, literacy, digital literacy,
financial literacy, citizenship needs
Introduce self – new to NIACE from Aug 2013. Lead on ESOL, work on E&M also
Welcome opportunity to present at NATECLA event, nice to see so many participants
Questions – no time during this slot, please keep for panel discussion or tweet them –highlight handle / e-mail.
All change – always say this, but a kind of hiatus at the moment: lots of developments to come, but many are new and implications and impact not yet known – too early to say
Looking mainly here at funding arrangements, skills conditionality and universal credit, and functional skills
KoLL and qualifications – other important developments in the field, with implications yet to be known in the longer term
The Policy Context
Worth starting with a quick look at Government thinking on ESOL.
Highlight:
- labour market / support for employability (nothing new there)
- support of children’s education (welcome this)
- progression to FS and GCSE (more on this later)
Show of hands re
- difficulties with transitional funding
- use of non-regulated aims
- issues with L1 and L2
NB – FS, GCSE, remaining adult lit quals are now listed in Annex of funding rules as ESOL qualification aims
Some instititions are experimenting with new delivery models – e.g. building courses with lots of smaller qualifications (lots of work for tutors, exams admin and costs)
Others are taking the opportunity to continue with existing models for a further year
Job Outcome Payments
- 50% of achievement funding so will receive 90% of the normal funding. 100% if employment outcome and achieves qualification
- employment outcome not positive in terms of success rates.
- Issue for ESOL provision – how best to get a declaration from the learner – language / contact issues, type of employment (if provider requires employer confirmation)
Unemployment-related benefits = JSA / ESA wrag, don’t have to stop claiming other benefits e.g housing benefit
The toolkit is with DWP, who may decide to use with JCP advisers.
ESOL issues e.g.
Language levels
Length of time needed
Referrals
Dedicated points of contact
Regular meetings
Handovers
Agreement of outcomes for each learner i.e. working around JCP / provider targets to decide which is the priority for the learner
Can support e.g. where adequate administrative provision is made to reduce the load on tutors / co-ordinators
Those wishing to access ESOL for other purposes
Pilot is limited – 4 jobcentres (we think)
Other pilots from October are : Rugby, Inverness, Harrogate, Bath, Shotton
In practice, few ESOL learners are coming through on UC and from provider point of view little difference with JSA
13 councils have been piloting ways to improve support to residents in how to claim e.g. Internet skills, budgeting etc. Digital champions.
Especially where ‘poor spoken English’ a barrier – however defined?
This is Osbourne’s spending review announcement
13 councils have been piloting ways to improve support to residents in how to claim e.g. Internet skills, budgeting etc. Digital champions
S&L at the expense of R&W?
No news on any further funding to support JCP mandated learners.
Accredited in this sense meant e.g. In receipt of SFA funding, inspected by Ofsted, British Council etc.
Invite comments on the types of learning – ACL? Community? being pushed out for the panel discussion.
Invite providers to contact NIACE in confidence if have demand exceeding supply.
NB – FS, GCSE, remaining adult lit quals are now listed in Annex of funding rules as ESOL qualification aims
Particularly interested to hear from providers doing QCF English units with ESOL learners
- new curriculum is creative and locally driven – local partnerships innovating
Also the DCLG competition results will be interesting here