6. • Photographs are not actually objective
• They come from individual perspectives
• They often perform specific jobs
• They contribute to familiar narratives
• They often make arguments
• They work both directly and indirectly
7.
8. • What job does it do?
• What argument does it seem to
make?
• Why are we seeing it?
• What story is it telling?
• How do different viewers interpret
the image?
9. Consider its
elements:
• Close focus on the face
• Face painted, dirty, bleeding
• Cigarette hanging loosely, almost casually
• Smoke billowing around and in front of the Marine’s face
• Eyes squinting, looking “over our shoulders”: reads of
alertness, “hard edge,” almost reminiscent of James Dean
• Little to no background or terrain, except desert gray
• Face framed by the helmet and the strap
10. Consider its
context:
• After a day of bloody fighting during the battle for Fallujah
• At that point, this battle had claimed more American lives
than any other campaign in the Iraq war
• The battle for Fallujah was fought door-to-door, in the streets
and in the houses, instead of from the air or from a distance.
• The Iraq War was beginning to become less “popular” back in
the US, but still held support among a majority of Americans.
11.
12. Consider its
elements:
• Once more: focus on the face, but in profile, with hand
loosely up
• Face is clean—and looks radically different. Rounder, softer,
much less strong.
• Cigarette is still here, but it feels very different here: the hold,
the ash—even the length—all seem less at ease.
• Eyes look away, now downward: feels like regret, like loss.
• We see part of the USMC tattoo—but it’s upside down and
partially obscured.
13. Consider its
context:
• 2007: near the end of the Bush administration. The war is
much less popular, and more than half of the American public
are now in favor of withdrawal.
• It had become hard to identify, clearly, why the US was still
fighting in Iraq: many used the word “quagmire” to describe
the war.
• The article was talking about the difficult conditions soldiers
returned to in the US, and of the toll that the war had taken
on them.