SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  42
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
UNIFIED FRAMEWORK FOR
ONLINE AND OFFLINE
LEARNING ANALYTICS
MAKA ERADZE
PHD STUDENT, SCHOOL OF DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES,
RESEARCH FELLOW AT UNIVERSITA NAPOLI
FEDERICO II
RESEARCH SEMINAR, 11.05.2016
PRESENTER
•  Educational background – humanities (teacher of
languages and literatures) - from modern and ancient
Greek to interdisciplinary TEL research
•  Experience – 2005 to 2012 – software localizer—>teacher
network coordinator (Deer Leap Foundation, MoES of
Georgia), eLearning coordinator –(Tbilisi State University,
Georgia)
•  Current job – Università di Napoli Federico II, EMMA
project, research fellow
•  Research - Unified framework for online and offline
learning analytics
MOTIVATION FOR THE
RESEARCH
Personal
•  Personal experience through participation into online fora
(yes, Latin plural for forum - fora J )
•  Personal ethnographic observations on my informal learning
patterns led me to Learning Analytics research
•  How? Ask Mart!
Professional:
•  Interactions and social dimension of learning leading to big
questions like:
•  what exactly are we analysing
•  What is my research question?
•  How are we going to break the concepts down to analyzable
units?
STRUCTURE OF THE
PRESENTATION
•  Background and statement of the problem
•  State of the art
•  General methodological framework of the research
•  Literature review
•  Work already done
•  Towards a framework - Mind map and diagram
•  Future research - validation phase
•  Applicability
•  Discussion part
BACKGROUND AND
STATEMENT OF THE
PROBLEM
•  The need for this kind of research emerges from the
idea that
•  When dealing with data (especially big), we have to
think about our questions first and search for patterns
in learning data with specific questions and
frameworks in mind. For this, we need to shape our
philosophical and methodological standing.
•  We need to think also about the real world
interactions and think about the ways to facilitate and
connect learning interaction analytics.
•  This research aims at the development of a unified
model for offline and online analytics with a purpose
of gaining insight into learning interactions.
BACKGROUND AND
STATEMENT OF THE
PROBLEM
•  It is focused on the development of a methodological
framework for the analysis of offline and online interaction
patterns and open learning environments.
•  Centered on the idea of the unit of analysis and its
appropriateness for learning analytics research and practice,
it can be applicable to any kind of interaction analysis
(learning analytics).
•  How is the issue of the units of analysis presented in different
disciplines (and learning analytics?)
•  What are the philosophical concepts and considerations
behind the issue of the unit of analysis?
•  How can we make use of xAPI statements and frame this
discourse in a philosophically and methodologically
appropriate way?
RESEARCH
QUESTIONS
•  How can we analyze learning interactions using different
frameworks, theories, philosophies (and pedagogic
scenarios)?
•  What is the appropriate unit of analysis for learning
interaction analytics in online and offline settings?
GENERAL THEORETICAL AND
METHODOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK
OF THE RESEARCH
Theoretically
•  Constructivist approach
•  This research does not use particular theoretical framework. It
rather reviews interdisciplinary approaches and creates a
meta language to redescribe the methodological framework
for learning analytics research
Methodologically
•  Design based research
•  Mainly based on the extensive literature review and inquiry
stage
•  Based on the literature review artifacts will be created that
redescribe and place the issue of the unit of analysis within
the LA research
•  This will serve to create a detailed ontology and validate it
STATE OF THE ART -
INTERACTIONS
•  In order to actually define how can we make use of interaction
traces and data and locate its analytical framework, it is
necessary to define the concept of interaction as it is to
educational sciences - TEL.
•  Interaction functions in a different way in virtual learning
environments where its must convey, mimic or recreate the
traditional communication patterns or build a new type of
learning ambience.
•  Underlining the term - learning interaction. I share Wagner’
definition of interaction as follows “reciprocal events that
require at least two objects and two actions. Interactions occur
when these objects and events mutually influence each
other” (Wagner, 1994).
STATE OF THE ART -
INTERACTIONS
•  According to Anderson (Anderson 2003), interaction online
(or offline) can happen human and inanimate actors.
•  Moore’s theory of Three Types of Interaction
•  To Moor learner-instructor interaction is a four-stage support
of the learner:
1.  Designing the content, maintaining motivation, self-direction
2.  Making presentations (student/teacher)
3.  Practicing and applying acquired competences.
4.  Counseling and encouragement of learners according their
levels of progress. The third type of interaction – learner-
learner for Moor is a new dimension in distance education
STATE OF THE ART-
DEFINITIONS
•  Learning analytics is the measurement, collection,
analysis and reporting of data about learners and
their contexts, for purposes of understanding and
optimizing learning and the environments in which it
occurs.
•  LA as a technology-enhanced learning (TEL)
research area that focuses on the development of
methods for analyzing and detecting patterns within
data collected from educational settings, and
leverages those methods to support the learning
experience. (Chatti et al 2015)
STATE OF THE ART- LA, ITS
CHALLENGES AND FUTURE
DIRECTIONS
Learning analytics is inherently
interdisciplinary
• Operates on the verge of many different
fields
Still in its infancy
• It still has to establish itself as field with its
own traditions and theoretical frameworks
•  Two systematic literature reviews found:
•  Nistor et al(2015): The main issue with LA research is
the frequent lack of an explicit theoretical framework
from educational perspective. The authors call on the
educational and psychological theories for significant
progress of upcoming LA research
•  Gasevic et al(2015): researchers from educational
sciences tend to publish more mature research and
show more rigor
•  Fortunately, the field is evolving quickly and one measure
of this growth is the increasing breadth of methodologies
being applied to learning‐related data sources (Pardo et al,
2014)
•  Big learning analytics
t h a t c o m e f r o m
heterogeneous sources
•  o p e n l e a r n i n g
environments (MOOCs),
with data coming from
outside of platform.
•  Mobile learning analytics
•  Context modeling
•  Privacy-aware analytics.
•  Personalized learning analytics.
•  Life-long learner modeling
•  Learning analytics for open
assessment.
•  Embedded Learning analytics
•  Learning analytics design
patterns.
•  Learning analytics evaluation.
Chatti, M. A., Lukarov, V., Thüs, H., Muslim, A., Yousef, A. M. F., Wahid, U., ... &
Schroeder, U. (2014). Learning Analytics: Challenges and Future Research Directions.
FACTORS
Different factors are involved in LA
Greller and Draschler
From Chatti
LIT.REVIEW -UNIT OF
ANALYSIS
•  Interdisciplinary approach:
•  When choosing what to analyze, how to analysis, what to take
into account, how to operationalize questions, what
methodology to use, what discourse to take in in any field, unit
of analysis is at the same time a problematic but also an
important decision to make.
•  Learning Interaction Analysis needs its own unit of analysis
too.
•  influenced by the work of Matusov who has given an
extensive account on this issue from different perspectives.
•  Building on his understanding on the unit of analysis we will
also bring arguments from:
•  Socio-cultural research, education, human-computer
interaction, computer science, sociology, technology-
enhanced learning, psychology and other fields.
LIT.REVIEW -UNIT OF
ANALYSIS
•  This is not a methodological decision only, but also a
political, and of course, philosophical.
•  Mostly, two types of approaches are used for the
discussion on the unit of analysis: holistic and
reductionist.
•  Holistic approach believes that the unit has to express a
whole phenomenon, while reductionist approach breaks the
unit of analysis down to its most fine grain unit.
•  Matusov thinks, that the unit of analysis changes with the
aim of the research.
•  To Vigotsky it is a “self-contained” “unified smallest
whole”.
UNIT OF ANALYSIS
•  Matusov takes the socio-cultural approach to the issue
and bases his discussion mainly on psychologist
tradition.
•  According to Matusov one must be careful when
searching for a general, universal unit of analysis,
because it always is shaped by the purpose of the
researcher and the subject of study.
•  The construct “unit of analysis” is mainly used for the
methodological critique of others’ research
UNIT OF ANALYSIS
The discussion about the unit of analysis is also a
paradigmatic discussion – exact sciences vs social sciences
with
•  “The exact sciences constitute a monologic form of
knowledge: the intellect contemplates a thing and expounds
upon it. There is only one subject here-cognizing
(contemplating) and speaking (expounding). In opposition to
the subject there is only a voiceless thing. Any object of
knowledge (including man) can be perceived and cognized as
a thing. But a subject as such cannot be perceived and
studied as a thing, for as a subject it cannot, while remaining
a subject, become voiceless, and, consequently, cognition of it
can only be dialogic.” (Bakhtin in Matusov)
2016-05-11 research seminar
UNIT OF ANALYSIS
•  According to Lefstein, while replacing the reductive units of
analysis with more holistic ones, the issue of manageability
arises.
•  Sometimes it can be hard to draw the boundaries, what is the
exact phenomenon to be expressed holistically.
He argues, that “interactional structures of three or more turns
is a methodologically expedient and theoretically sound unit for
the analysis of classroom discourse”.
•  To him, unit of analysis is a “discourse move” and dialogical.
Though, Lefstein also suggests that aside from the appropriate
phenomenon, the unit of analysis has to be expanded to
sequence.
UNIT OF ANALYSIS
Stahl from his side discusses the issue of unit of analysis in cognition –
•  concepts (Plato),
•  mental and material objects (Descartes) (and relationship between them)
•  observable physical objects (empiricism),
•  mind’s structuring categorization efforts (Kant).
All of the approaches dealt with the inner functions of an individual mind.
•  Hegel entered the discussion with a larger unit of analysis – historically, socially and
culturally determined.
•  Marx views the main unit of analysis as social movements, class conflicts and
transformations of economic systems.
•  Hegel’s philosophy shaped three mainstream schools of thought – Marx (critical
social theory), Heidegger (existential phenomenology) and Wittgenstein (linguistic
analysis).
•  To Stahl, these three main directions influence how the CSCL units of analysis are
formed: For Heidegger the unit of analysis was the man with unified experience of
being-in-the-world.
•  Wingenstein’s shifted unit of analysis from mental meanings to interpersonal
communications in the context of getting something done together. (Stahl)
UNIT OF ANALYSIS -
LATOUR
•  Latour thinks the issue brings us to
•  what phenomenon is worth studying and ‘worth’ for what.
According to a sociocultural framework, this question cannot
be addressed within purely methodological considerations as
it both involves conceptual (paradigmatic) debates within the
academic field and is shaped by practical needs and financial
(and political and institutional) pressure outside of the field
and science in general (Latour, 1987 in Matusov).
•  For Latour and his Action-Network Theory, the main unit of
analysis is embedded in the relationship between the
actions.
UNIT OF ANALYSIS
•  Stahl believes that Engestrom is the one taking the unit of analysis to the whole
activity system.
•  Engeström in his “Learning By Expanding” writes that the insertion of cultural
artifacts into human actions was revolutionary in that the basic unit of analysis now
overcame the split between the Cartesian individual and the untouchable societal
structure.” After this the understanding of an individual could no longer happen
without his or her cultural means; and the understanding of a society was bound to
individuals who use and produce artifacts. He believes that the limitation of the first
generation was that the unit of analysis remained individually focused. The object-
oriented and artifact-mediated collective activity system is the prime unit of analysis
in cultural-historical studies of human conduct;
•  But to Stahl’s understanding Engestrom’s theory is not interested in group
knowledge building but rather with organizational management of the group,
Influenced by Marx, theory tries to see societal issues in the making.
UNIT OF ANALYSIS
•  Stahl believes that even in distributed cognition, which
deals with group-cognitive phenomena, mostly socio-
technical systems and highly developed artifacts are
analyzed.
•  Suthers (2010) with his uptake framework proposes that
the event is the core if we want analyze data and
understand which interactions lead to learning. The
uptake framework suggests that interaction is relational
by its nature, so the most important unit of analysis is not
isolated acts, but rather relationships (based, again, on
Latour 2005) between acts.
UNIT OF ANALYSIS -
KAPTELININ
In activity-theory
•  activity, in a broad sense, is an interaction of the actor (e.g., a
human being) with the world. The interaction, according to
activity theory terminology, is described as a process relating
the subject (S) and the object (O). A common way to
represent activity is “S ⇔ O.
•  According to Kaptelinin, activity is different from other types of
interaction by two key aspects: (a) subjects of activities have
needs, which should be met through an interaction with the
world, and (b) activities and their subjects mutually determine
one another; or, more generally, activities are generative
forces that transform both subjects and objects. Subjects
have needs.
KAPTELININ –
ACTIVITY THEORY
•  Kaptelinin presents the Activity as
•  a “unit of life” of a material subject existing in the
objective world.
•  Subjects have their own needs and to survive, have to
engage in activities, that is, interact with the worldy
objects fulfill their needs
•  assumptions of the social nature of human mind and
inseparability of human mind and activity. (Kaptelinin, Activity
theory).
•  Activity is of fundamental importance to psychology
because of its special function.
•  It places the Subject into the objective reality and transforms
the reality into a form of subjectivity (Leontiev, 1978)
PAAVOLA AND
HAIKAINEN
•  According to Paavola and Haikaninen, in trialogues, the
interaction through “shared objects” that are in the
process of being developed is emphasized.
•  The objects of inquiry can be respresented by the
knowledge artefacts, practices, ideas, models,
representations, etc. but perceived as something to be
collaboratively developed.
•  These objects are important in the interaction and it is an
interaction between subjects, other subjects and
“objects” but not between the subjects.
•  This means that the things are being developed
collaboratively and they do not repeat the existing
knowledge
XAPI
Event-driven analytics
<Actor (learner)> <verb> <object>, with <result>, in <context>
REVIEW: XAPI
●  The Experience API is a service that allows for statements of
experience (typically learning experiences, but could be any
experience) to be delivered to and stored securely in a Learning
Record Store
●  The Experience API is dependent on Learning Activity Providers
to create and track learning.
●  Learning Activity Provider is a software object that
communicates with the LRS to record information about the
learning experience.
●  Learning activity is a unit of instruction, experience or
performance that has to be tracked.
●  A Statement consists of <Actor (learner)> <verb> <object>, with
<result>, in <context> to track an aspect of a learning
experience.
REVIEW: XAPI
●  It repeats the structure of the sentence in practically any
language and is human readable
•  Actor data is a unique information that describes a
specific subject, such as a student or group of students.
•  Verb data classifies the type of activity the actor
participated in and often links to a human readable
description of the event.
•  Object data will link to an artifact that is typically a
byproduct of or related to the activity
XAPI
●  It is much more, than just a simple sentence-like structure. The
context is very important and it makes possible to relate one
activity to another*
•  Quoting Verbert, Suthers and Rosen, Kevan and Ryan believe that
the issue of variety of educational data taxonomies and also the
distributed learning events collection challenges can be solved by
xAPI*
●  Some researchers believe that it is aligned with constructivist
approach and activity theory
●  xAPI has a lot of potential for The xAPI offers a renewed
opportunity to research, develop, and explore theories involving
learning beyond academia’s digital environments.
Kevan, J. M., & Ryan, P. R. Experience API: Flexible, Decentralized and Activity-Centric Data Collection.Technology,
Knowledge and Learning, 1-7.
WORK ALREADY
DONE/PUBLICATIONS
•  Eradze, M. Kai, P., Laanpere, M.: (2013) Analysing Learning Flows in
Digital Learning Ecosystems, KMEL 2013, ICWL2013, Taiwan,
Springer (LNCS), October 2013
•  The first paper that opens the discussion on the unit of analysis, with
detailed background on the interactions, literature review
•  Eradze M., Laanpere M.: (2014) Interrelation Between Pedagogical
Design and Learning Interaction Patterns in Different Virtual
Learning Environments, HCII 2014, Greece, Springer (LNCS) June
2014
•  Three different platforms studied with CoI framework and coding template
(Two MOOC platforms, Moodle and Edufeedr)
•  Eradze, M., Valjataga, T., Laanpere M.: (2014) Observing the use of e-
textbooks in the classroom: towards “Offline” Learning Analytics,
FeT workshop, ICWL 2014, Tallinn, Estonia, Springer (LNCS)
•  Observations in the classroom, tried to document offline interactions with
an mobile app and xAPI type of statements.
PUBLICATION IN
PROGRESS
Unit of Analysis in Learning Analytics, Maka Eradze, Mart
Laanpere
•  The article overviews the state of the art of unit of analysis
issue in educational research, learning analytics and
offers a conceptual framework based on the idea of an
appropriate unit of analysis for learning interaction
analysis.
•  Aiming for - Journal of Computing in Higher Education -
Special Issue on Advancing Research on Open
Education.
MIND MAP –
REDESCRIBING THE
UNIT OF ANALYSIS/XAPI
DIAGRAM -
REDESCRIBING THE
UNIT OF ANALYSIS/XAPI
FUTURE RESEARCH  -
VALIDATION PHASE
•  Based on the inquiry stage and the artefacts, a detailed
ontology will be developed
•  A single semantic structure that can map teacher
intentions – what they are planning to do and what
actually is taking place
•  The ontology will be mapped to specific scenarios
•  Together with teachers validate the ontology with
participatory approach
APPLICABILITY
•  This ontology will be applicable to any context and to any
data
•  It will be flexible and can be applied to different
pedagogic scenarios, philosophies, methodologies
•  With this ontology we will be able to grasp the whole
structures of interactions and analyse it holistically
I know this is not yet a defense and am not yet on Ithaca and I am no
Odysseus (rather Penelope), but this is a journey I am enjoying so:
EXPRESSION OF
GRATITUDE
•  To all in the School of Digital Technologies for
understanding my absent presence or rather present
absence
•  To Mart for being a challenging supervisor and….for
scaffolding/challenging/believing in me J
•  To Kai for giving valuable, critical and helpful feedback
DISCUSSION
Need feedback J
•  Desperately!
•  For thoughts and feedback coming up later: maka@tlu.ee

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Ectel2017 paper schmitz_mjwm_presentation
Ectel2017 paper schmitz_mjwm_presentationEctel2017 paper schmitz_mjwm_presentation
Ectel2017 paper schmitz_mjwm_presentationMarcel Schmitz
 
Always chasing something - Students' perspective on Social Media in Higher ed...
Always chasing something - Students' perspective on Social Media in Higher ed...Always chasing something - Students' perspective on Social Media in Higher ed...
Always chasing something - Students' perspective on Social Media in Higher ed...Fachhochschule Nordwestschweiz FHNW
 
Impacts of OER: What difference does it make and how?
Impacts of OER: What difference does it make and how?Impacts of OER: What difference does it make and how?
Impacts of OER: What difference does it make and how?ROER4D
 
Doctoral Consortium ECTEL presentation Learning Analytics Learning Design
Doctoral Consortium ECTEL presentation Learning Analytics Learning DesignDoctoral Consortium ECTEL presentation Learning Analytics Learning Design
Doctoral Consortium ECTEL presentation Learning Analytics Learning DesignMarcel Schmitz
 
Presentation at EuroCAT Workshop
Presentation at EuroCAT WorkshopPresentation at EuroCAT Workshop
Presentation at EuroCAT WorkshopBSM UPF Barcelona
 
Self-regulated learning skills matter in dashboard sense-making
Self-regulated learning skills matter in dashboard sense-makingSelf-regulated learning skills matter in dashboard sense-making
Self-regulated learning skills matter in dashboard sense-makingIoana Jivet
 
Modelling presentation
Modelling presentationModelling presentation
Modelling presentationJohn Liakos
 
Offering adaptive support for self-regulated learning with learning analytics...
Offering adaptive support for self-regulated learning with learning analytics...Offering adaptive support for self-regulated learning with learning analytics...
Offering adaptive support for self-regulated learning with learning analytics...Ioana Jivet
 
Cc&Ab&Ae Euro Cat Cscl Def
Cc&Ab&Ae Euro Cat Cscl DefCc&Ab&Ae Euro Cat Cscl Def
Cc&Ab&Ae Euro Cat Cscl DefEuroCAT CSCL
 
Always chasing something – Students‘ Perspective on Social Media in Higher Ed...
Always chasing something – Students‘ Perspective on Social Media in Higher Ed...Always chasing something – Students‘ Perspective on Social Media in Higher Ed...
Always chasing something – Students‘ Perspective on Social Media in Higher Ed...Eva-Christina Edinger
 
Presentation to Umeå Workshop 2010
Presentation to Umeå Workshop 2010Presentation to Umeå Workshop 2010
Presentation to Umeå Workshop 2010Brian Hudson
 
Susan Hippensteele: Critical Thinking and Science Literacy Course Impact on S...
Susan Hippensteele: Critical Thinking and Science Literacy Course Impact on S...Susan Hippensteele: Critical Thinking and Science Literacy Course Impact on S...
Susan Hippensteele: Critical Thinking and Science Literacy Course Impact on S...WASC Senior
 
2022_01_21 «Teaching Computing in School: Is research reaching classroom prac...
2022_01_21 «Teaching Computing in School: Is research reaching classroom prac...2022_01_21 «Teaching Computing in School: Is research reaching classroom prac...
2022_01_21 «Teaching Computing in School: Is research reaching classroom prac...eMadrid network
 
Design Science Of Learning
Design Science Of LearningDesign Science Of Learning
Design Science Of LearningMike Sharples
 
Log Vis All 0729
Log Vis All 0729Log Vis All 0729
Log Vis All 0729hsinyichang
 
Conole Scanlon Final
Conole Scanlon FinalConole Scanlon Final
Conole Scanlon Finalgrainne
 
Listening to Teachers’ Needs: Human-centred Design for Mobile Technologies in...
Listening to Teachers’ Needs: Human-centred Design for Mobile Technologies in...Listening to Teachers’ Needs: Human-centred Design for Mobile Technologies in...
Listening to Teachers’ Needs: Human-centred Design for Mobile Technologies in...Renée Schulz
 
Tpack how big is
Tpack how big isTpack how big is
Tpack how big isehelfant
 
2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Terje Väljataga
2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Terje Väljataga2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Terje Väljataga
2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Terje Väljatagaifi8106tlu
 

Tendances (20)

Ectel2017 paper schmitz_mjwm_presentation
Ectel2017 paper schmitz_mjwm_presentationEctel2017 paper schmitz_mjwm_presentation
Ectel2017 paper schmitz_mjwm_presentation
 
Always chasing something - Students' perspective on Social Media in Higher ed...
Always chasing something - Students' perspective on Social Media in Higher ed...Always chasing something - Students' perspective on Social Media in Higher ed...
Always chasing something - Students' perspective on Social Media in Higher ed...
 
Impacts of OER: What difference does it make and how?
Impacts of OER: What difference does it make and how?Impacts of OER: What difference does it make and how?
Impacts of OER: What difference does it make and how?
 
Doctoral Consortium ECTEL presentation Learning Analytics Learning Design
Doctoral Consortium ECTEL presentation Learning Analytics Learning DesignDoctoral Consortium ECTEL presentation Learning Analytics Learning Design
Doctoral Consortium ECTEL presentation Learning Analytics Learning Design
 
Presentation at EuroCAT Workshop
Presentation at EuroCAT WorkshopPresentation at EuroCAT Workshop
Presentation at EuroCAT Workshop
 
Self-regulated learning skills matter in dashboard sense-making
Self-regulated learning skills matter in dashboard sense-makingSelf-regulated learning skills matter in dashboard sense-making
Self-regulated learning skills matter in dashboard sense-making
 
Modelling presentation
Modelling presentationModelling presentation
Modelling presentation
 
Offering adaptive support for self-regulated learning with learning analytics...
Offering adaptive support for self-regulated learning with learning analytics...Offering adaptive support for self-regulated learning with learning analytics...
Offering adaptive support for self-regulated learning with learning analytics...
 
Cc&Ab&Ae Euro Cat Cscl Def
Cc&Ab&Ae Euro Cat Cscl DefCc&Ab&Ae Euro Cat Cscl Def
Cc&Ab&Ae Euro Cat Cscl Def
 
Always chasing something – Students‘ Perspective on Social Media in Higher Ed...
Always chasing something – Students‘ Perspective on Social Media in Higher Ed...Always chasing something – Students‘ Perspective on Social Media in Higher Ed...
Always chasing something – Students‘ Perspective on Social Media in Higher Ed...
 
Presentation to Umeå Workshop 2010
Presentation to Umeå Workshop 2010Presentation to Umeå Workshop 2010
Presentation to Umeå Workshop 2010
 
Susan Hippensteele: Critical Thinking and Science Literacy Course Impact on S...
Susan Hippensteele: Critical Thinking and Science Literacy Course Impact on S...Susan Hippensteele: Critical Thinking and Science Literacy Course Impact on S...
Susan Hippensteele: Critical Thinking and Science Literacy Course Impact on S...
 
2022_01_21 «Teaching Computing in School: Is research reaching classroom prac...
2022_01_21 «Teaching Computing in School: Is research reaching classroom prac...2022_01_21 «Teaching Computing in School: Is research reaching classroom prac...
2022_01_21 «Teaching Computing in School: Is research reaching classroom prac...
 
Design Science Of Learning
Design Science Of LearningDesign Science Of Learning
Design Science Of Learning
 
Design based research
Design based researchDesign based research
Design based research
 
Log Vis All 0729
Log Vis All 0729Log Vis All 0729
Log Vis All 0729
 
Conole Scanlon Final
Conole Scanlon FinalConole Scanlon Final
Conole Scanlon Final
 
Listening to Teachers’ Needs: Human-centred Design for Mobile Technologies in...
Listening to Teachers’ Needs: Human-centred Design for Mobile Technologies in...Listening to Teachers’ Needs: Human-centred Design for Mobile Technologies in...
Listening to Teachers’ Needs: Human-centred Design for Mobile Technologies in...
 
Tpack how big is
Tpack how big isTpack how big is
Tpack how big is
 
2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Terje Väljataga
2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Terje Väljataga2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Terje Väljataga
2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Terje Väljataga
 

En vedette

Retirement Plan Accounting: A Sponsor's Perspective
Retirement Plan Accounting: A Sponsor's PerspectiveRetirement Plan Accounting: A Sponsor's Perspective
Retirement Plan Accounting: A Sponsor's PerspectiveMcKonly & Asbury, LLP
 
M'Finda Kalunga Community Garden
M'Finda Kalunga Community Garden M'Finda Kalunga Community Garden
M'Finda Kalunga Community Garden Caitlin
 
Teacher Education, the European Dimension
Teacher Education, the European Dimension Teacher Education, the European Dimension
Teacher Education, the European Dimension Mart Laanpere
 
Grafico diario del s&p 500 para el 14 10 2011
Grafico diario del s&p 500 para el 14 10 2011Grafico diario del s&p 500 para el 14 10 2011
Grafico diario del s&p 500 para el 14 10 2011Experiencia Trading
 
Towards educational cloud
Towards educational cloudTowards educational cloud
Towards educational cloudMart Laanpere
 
Posicionamiento en Buscadores Medio (Human Level Communications en Congreso d...
Posicionamiento en Buscadores Medio (Human Level Communications en Congreso d...Posicionamiento en Buscadores Medio (Human Level Communications en Congreso d...
Posicionamiento en Buscadores Medio (Human Level Communications en Congreso d...Fernando Maciá Domene
 
EstCORE veebinar
EstCORE veebinarEstCORE veebinar
EstCORE veebinarifi8106tlu
 
Crédit Agricole S.A. Personae et Parcours
Crédit Agricole S.A. Personae et ParcoursCrédit Agricole S.A. Personae et Parcours
Crédit Agricole S.A. Personae et ParcoursBeMyApp
 
Taller de redes sociales ucjc
Taller de redes sociales ucjcTaller de redes sociales ucjc
Taller de redes sociales ucjcEli Garcia
 
Samsung Digi Pass õpimärgid
Samsung Digi Pass õpimärgidSamsung Digi Pass õpimärgid
Samsung Digi Pass õpimärgidMart Laanpere
 
Google analytics para inbound marketing. Eli Garcia. Mondragon Unibertsitatea
Google analytics para inbound marketing. Eli Garcia. Mondragon UnibertsitateaGoogle analytics para inbound marketing. Eli Garcia. Mondragon Unibertsitatea
Google analytics para inbound marketing. Eli Garcia. Mondragon UnibertsitateaEli Garcia
 
H2 antagonist and ppi
H2 antagonist and ppiH2 antagonist and ppi
H2 antagonist and ppinaseefa
 
Health determinants
Health determinantsHealth determinants
Health determinantsCarlos Amade
 

En vedette (20)

Presentacion jupabus
Presentacion jupabusPresentacion jupabus
Presentacion jupabus
 
Apresentação1
Apresentação1Apresentação1
Apresentação1
 
Retirement Plan Accounting: A Sponsor's Perspective
Retirement Plan Accounting: A Sponsor's PerspectiveRetirement Plan Accounting: A Sponsor's Perspective
Retirement Plan Accounting: A Sponsor's Perspective
 
Cartilla fenicia virtuales
Cartilla fenicia virtualesCartilla fenicia virtuales
Cartilla fenicia virtuales
 
M'Finda Kalunga Community Garden
M'Finda Kalunga Community Garden M'Finda Kalunga Community Garden
M'Finda Kalunga Community Garden
 
Test game
Test gameTest game
Test game
 
Teacher Education, the European Dimension
Teacher Education, the European Dimension Teacher Education, the European Dimension
Teacher Education, the European Dimension
 
Grafico diario del s&p 500 para el 14 10 2011
Grafico diario del s&p 500 para el 14 10 2011Grafico diario del s&p 500 para el 14 10 2011
Grafico diario del s&p 500 para el 14 10 2011
 
Turismo Emprendedor
Turismo EmprendedorTurismo Emprendedor
Turismo Emprendedor
 
Towards educational cloud
Towards educational cloudTowards educational cloud
Towards educational cloud
 
ENTEP and TEPE
ENTEP and TEPEENTEP and TEPE
ENTEP and TEPE
 
Posicionamiento en Buscadores Medio (Human Level Communications en Congreso d...
Posicionamiento en Buscadores Medio (Human Level Communications en Congreso d...Posicionamiento en Buscadores Medio (Human Level Communications en Congreso d...
Posicionamiento en Buscadores Medio (Human Level Communications en Congreso d...
 
EstCORE veebinar
EstCORE veebinarEstCORE veebinar
EstCORE veebinar
 
Capital
CapitalCapital
Capital
 
Crédit Agricole S.A. Personae et Parcours
Crédit Agricole S.A. Personae et ParcoursCrédit Agricole S.A. Personae et Parcours
Crédit Agricole S.A. Personae et Parcours
 
Taller de redes sociales ucjc
Taller de redes sociales ucjcTaller de redes sociales ucjc
Taller de redes sociales ucjc
 
Samsung Digi Pass õpimärgid
Samsung Digi Pass õpimärgidSamsung Digi Pass õpimärgid
Samsung Digi Pass õpimärgid
 
Google analytics para inbound marketing. Eli Garcia. Mondragon Unibertsitatea
Google analytics para inbound marketing. Eli Garcia. Mondragon UnibertsitateaGoogle analytics para inbound marketing. Eli Garcia. Mondragon Unibertsitatea
Google analytics para inbound marketing. Eli Garcia. Mondragon Unibertsitatea
 
H2 antagonist and ppi
H2 antagonist and ppiH2 antagonist and ppi
H2 antagonist and ppi
 
Health determinants
Health determinantsHealth determinants
Health determinants
 

Similaire à 2016-05-11 research seminar

KV712 Intro to Research Methodology Session1
KV712 Intro to Research Methodology Session1KV712 Intro to Research Methodology Session1
KV712 Intro to Research Methodology Session1kturvey
 
The learning styles revelation - research from cognitive science
The learning styles revelation - research from cognitive scienceThe learning styles revelation - research from cognitive science
The learning styles revelation - research from cognitive scienceJolly Holden
 
Sharing postgraduate study experiences
Sharing postgraduate study experiencesSharing postgraduate study experiences
Sharing postgraduate study experiencescurlielamb
 
Thesis writting orientation
Thesis writting orientationThesis writting orientation
Thesis writting orientationBed Dhakal
 
paradigms-190305093939 (1).pdf
paradigms-190305093939 (1).pdfparadigms-190305093939 (1).pdf
paradigms-190305093939 (1).pdfssuser31c469
 
Research paradigms ii (1)
Research paradigms ii (1)Research paradigms ii (1)
Research paradigms ii (1)Amina Tariq
 
Qualitative data analysis
Qualitative data analysisQualitative data analysis
Qualitative data analysisPREETISHARMA548
 
Activity Settings Observation System
Activity Settings Observation SystemActivity Settings Observation System
Activity Settings Observation SystemSara Alvarez
 
Theories and research e leraning uo catalonia
Theories and research e leraning uo cataloniaTheories and research e leraning uo catalonia
Theories and research e leraning uo cataloniaTerry Anderson
 
Presentation teaching & learning colloqium july 2013
Presentation  teaching & learning colloqium july 2013Presentation  teaching & learning colloqium july 2013
Presentation teaching & learning colloqium july 2013Rita Ndagire Kizito
 
qualitative research.pdf
qualitative research.pdfqualitative research.pdf
qualitative research.pdfCityComputers3
 
Action Research And Autoethnography
Action Research And AutoethnographyAction Research And Autoethnography
Action Research And AutoethnographyRoxy Roberts
 
Chapter 1 Educational Research The Basics
Chapter 1 Educational Research The BasicsChapter 1 Educational Research The Basics
Chapter 1 Educational Research The BasicsInternational advisers
 
Frameworks for studies of information behaviour and use
Frameworks for studies of information behaviour and useFrameworks for studies of information behaviour and use
Frameworks for studies of information behaviour and useDiane Rasmussen Pennington
 
Week 2 - What is Social Research & Planning a Research Project.pptx
Week 2 - What is Social Research & Planning a Research Project.pptxWeek 2 - What is Social Research & Planning a Research Project.pptx
Week 2 - What is Social Research & Planning a Research Project.pptxNathan Kerrigan
 

Similaire à 2016-05-11 research seminar (20)

KV712 Intro to Research Methodology Session1
KV712 Intro to Research Methodology Session1KV712 Intro to Research Methodology Session1
KV712 Intro to Research Methodology Session1
 
The learning styles revelation - research from cognitive science
The learning styles revelation - research from cognitive scienceThe learning styles revelation - research from cognitive science
The learning styles revelation - research from cognitive science
 
Sharing postgraduate study experiences
Sharing postgraduate study experiencesSharing postgraduate study experiences
Sharing postgraduate study experiences
 
Thesis writting orientation
Thesis writting orientationThesis writting orientation
Thesis writting orientation
 
Research Paradigms:Ontology's, Epistemologies & Methods
Research Paradigms:Ontology's, Epistemologies & MethodsResearch Paradigms:Ontology's, Epistemologies & Methods
Research Paradigms:Ontology's, Epistemologies & Methods
 
Paradigms
ParadigmsParadigms
Paradigms
 
paradigms-190305093939 (1).pdf
paradigms-190305093939 (1).pdfparadigms-190305093939 (1).pdf
paradigms-190305093939 (1).pdf
 
Research paradigms ii (1)
Research paradigms ii (1)Research paradigms ii (1)
Research paradigms ii (1)
 
Qualitative data analysis
Qualitative data analysisQualitative data analysis
Qualitative data analysis
 
Activity Settings Observation System
Activity Settings Observation SystemActivity Settings Observation System
Activity Settings Observation System
 
Theories and research e leraning uo catalonia
Theories and research e leraning uo cataloniaTheories and research e leraning uo catalonia
Theories and research e leraning uo catalonia
 
Presentation teaching & learning colloqium july 2013
Presentation  teaching & learning colloqium july 2013Presentation  teaching & learning colloqium july 2013
Presentation teaching & learning colloqium july 2013
 
qualitative research.pdf
qualitative research.pdfqualitative research.pdf
qualitative research.pdf
 
Qualitative Research Designs and Methods
Qualitative Research Designs and MethodsQualitative Research Designs and Methods
Qualitative Research Designs and Methods
 
Action Research And Autoethnography
Action Research And AutoethnographyAction Research And Autoethnography
Action Research And Autoethnography
 
Approaching the why - Karen Sobel
Approaching the why - Karen SobelApproaching the why - Karen Sobel
Approaching the why - Karen Sobel
 
Chapter 1 Educational Research The Basics
Chapter 1 Educational Research The BasicsChapter 1 Educational Research The Basics
Chapter 1 Educational Research The Basics
 
Frameworks for studies of information behaviour and use
Frameworks for studies of information behaviour and useFrameworks for studies of information behaviour and use
Frameworks for studies of information behaviour and use
 
Week 2 - What is Social Research & Planning a Research Project.pptx
Week 2 - What is Social Research & Planning a Research Project.pptxWeek 2 - What is Social Research & Planning a Research Project.pptx
Week 2 - What is Social Research & Planning a Research Project.pptx
 
Hamid
HamidHamid
Hamid
 

Plus de ifi8106tlu

2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Minna Huotilainen
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Minna Huotilainen2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Minna Huotilainen
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Minna Huotilainenifi8106tlu
 
2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Adolfo Ruiz Calleja
2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Adolfo Ruiz Calleja2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Adolfo Ruiz Calleja
2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Adolfo Ruiz Callejaifi8106tlu
 
2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Sergey Sosnovsky
2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Sergey Sosnovsky2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Sergey Sosnovsky
2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Sergey Sosnovskyifi8106tlu
 
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Luis Pablo Prieto
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Luis Pablo Prieto2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Luis Pablo Prieto
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Luis Pablo Prietoifi8106tlu
 
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Maria Jesus Rodriguez Triana
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Maria Jesus Rodriguez Triana2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Maria Jesus Rodriguez Triana
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Maria Jesus Rodriguez Trianaifi8106tlu
 
2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Paul Seitlinger
2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Paul Seitlinger2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Paul Seitlinger
2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Paul Seitlingerifi8106tlu
 
Venia Legendi 2016: Pille Eslon
Venia Legendi 2016: Pille EslonVenia Legendi 2016: Pille Eslon
Venia Legendi 2016: Pille Eslonifi8106tlu
 
Venia Legendi 2016: Maria Zeltser
Venia Legendi 2016: Maria ZeltserVenia Legendi 2016: Maria Zeltser
Venia Legendi 2016: Maria Zeltserifi8106tlu
 
Venia legendi 2016 Andi Kivinukk
Venia legendi 2016 Andi KivinukkVenia legendi 2016 Andi Kivinukk
Venia legendi 2016 Andi Kivinukkifi8106tlu
 
2016-04-27 research seminar, 2nd presenter
2016-04-27 research seminar, 2nd presenter2016-04-27 research seminar, 2nd presenter
2016-04-27 research seminar, 2nd presenterifi8106tlu
 
2016-04-27 research seminar
2016-04-27 research seminar2016-04-27 research seminar
2016-04-27 research seminarifi8106tlu
 
2016-04-20 research seminar
2016-04-20 research seminar2016-04-20 research seminar
2016-04-20 research seminarifi8106tlu
 
2016-04-13 research seminar appendix
2016-04-13 research seminar appendix2016-04-13 research seminar appendix
2016-04-13 research seminar appendixifi8106tlu
 
2016-04-13 research seminar presentation
2016-04-13 research seminar presentation2016-04-13 research seminar presentation
2016-04-13 research seminar presentationifi8106tlu
 
2016-04-06 research seminar
2016-04-06 research seminar2016-04-06 research seminar
2016-04-06 research seminarifi8106tlu
 
2016 03-16 research seminar
2016 03-16 research seminar2016 03-16 research seminar
2016 03-16 research seminarifi8106tlu
 
2016 03-09 research seminar
2016 03-09 research seminar2016 03-09 research seminar
2016 03-09 research seminarifi8106tlu
 
2016-03-02 research seminar
2016-03-02 research seminar2016-03-02 research seminar
2016-03-02 research seminarifi8106tlu
 
2016-02-10 research seminar, second part
2016-02-10 research seminar, second part2016-02-10 research seminar, second part
2016-02-10 research seminar, second partifi8106tlu
 
2016-02-17 research seminar
2016-02-17 research seminar2016-02-17 research seminar
2016-02-17 research seminarifi8106tlu
 

Plus de ifi8106tlu (20)

2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Minna Huotilainen
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Minna Huotilainen2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Minna Huotilainen
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Minna Huotilainen
 
2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Adolfo Ruiz Calleja
2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Adolfo Ruiz Calleja2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Adolfo Ruiz Calleja
2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Adolfo Ruiz Calleja
 
2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Sergey Sosnovsky
2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Sergey Sosnovsky2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Sergey Sosnovsky
2016-05-31 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Sergey Sosnovsky
 
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Luis Pablo Prieto
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Luis Pablo Prieto2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Luis Pablo Prieto
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Luis Pablo Prieto
 
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Maria Jesus Rodriguez Triana
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Maria Jesus Rodriguez Triana2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Maria Jesus Rodriguez Triana
2016-05-30 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Maria Jesus Rodriguez Triana
 
2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Paul Seitlinger
2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Paul Seitlinger2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Paul Seitlinger
2016-05-27 Venia Legendi (CEITER): Paul Seitlinger
 
Venia Legendi 2016: Pille Eslon
Venia Legendi 2016: Pille EslonVenia Legendi 2016: Pille Eslon
Venia Legendi 2016: Pille Eslon
 
Venia Legendi 2016: Maria Zeltser
Venia Legendi 2016: Maria ZeltserVenia Legendi 2016: Maria Zeltser
Venia Legendi 2016: Maria Zeltser
 
Venia legendi 2016 Andi Kivinukk
Venia legendi 2016 Andi KivinukkVenia legendi 2016 Andi Kivinukk
Venia legendi 2016 Andi Kivinukk
 
2016-04-27 research seminar, 2nd presenter
2016-04-27 research seminar, 2nd presenter2016-04-27 research seminar, 2nd presenter
2016-04-27 research seminar, 2nd presenter
 
2016-04-27 research seminar
2016-04-27 research seminar2016-04-27 research seminar
2016-04-27 research seminar
 
2016-04-20 research seminar
2016-04-20 research seminar2016-04-20 research seminar
2016-04-20 research seminar
 
2016-04-13 research seminar appendix
2016-04-13 research seminar appendix2016-04-13 research seminar appendix
2016-04-13 research seminar appendix
 
2016-04-13 research seminar presentation
2016-04-13 research seminar presentation2016-04-13 research seminar presentation
2016-04-13 research seminar presentation
 
2016-04-06 research seminar
2016-04-06 research seminar2016-04-06 research seminar
2016-04-06 research seminar
 
2016 03-16 research seminar
2016 03-16 research seminar2016 03-16 research seminar
2016 03-16 research seminar
 
2016 03-09 research seminar
2016 03-09 research seminar2016 03-09 research seminar
2016 03-09 research seminar
 
2016-03-02 research seminar
2016-03-02 research seminar2016-03-02 research seminar
2016-03-02 research seminar
 
2016-02-10 research seminar, second part
2016-02-10 research seminar, second part2016-02-10 research seminar, second part
2016-02-10 research seminar, second part
 
2016-02-17 research seminar
2016-02-17 research seminar2016-02-17 research seminar
2016-02-17 research seminar
 

Dernier

PHARMACOGNOSY CHAPTER NO 5 CARMINATIVES AND G.pdf
PHARMACOGNOSY CHAPTER NO 5 CARMINATIVES AND G.pdfPHARMACOGNOSY CHAPTER NO 5 CARMINATIVES AND G.pdf
PHARMACOGNOSY CHAPTER NO 5 CARMINATIVES AND G.pdfSumit Tiwari
 
EDD8524 The Future of Educational Leader
EDD8524 The Future of Educational LeaderEDD8524 The Future of Educational Leader
EDD8524 The Future of Educational LeaderDr. Bruce A. Johnson
 
POST ENCEPHALITIS case study Jitendra bhargav
POST ENCEPHALITIS case study  Jitendra bhargavPOST ENCEPHALITIS case study  Jitendra bhargav
POST ENCEPHALITIS case study Jitendra bhargavJitendra Bhargav
 
BBA 205 BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT UNIT I.pptx
BBA 205 BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT UNIT I.pptxBBA 205 BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT UNIT I.pptx
BBA 205 BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT UNIT I.pptxProf. Kanchan Kumari
 
AI Uses and Misuses: Academic and Workplace Applications
AI Uses and Misuses: Academic and Workplace ApplicationsAI Uses and Misuses: Academic and Workplace Applications
AI Uses and Misuses: Academic and Workplace ApplicationsStella Lee
 
3.14.24 Gender Discrimination and Gender Inequity.pptx
3.14.24 Gender Discrimination and Gender Inequity.pptx3.14.24 Gender Discrimination and Gender Inequity.pptx
3.14.24 Gender Discrimination and Gender Inequity.pptxmary850239
 
THYROID HORMONE.pptx by Subham Panja,Asst. Professor, Department of B.Sc MLT,...
THYROID HORMONE.pptx by Subham Panja,Asst. Professor, Department of B.Sc MLT,...THYROID HORMONE.pptx by Subham Panja,Asst. Professor, Department of B.Sc MLT,...
THYROID HORMONE.pptx by Subham Panja,Asst. Professor, Department of B.Sc MLT,...Subham Panja
 
ASTRINGENTS.pdf Pharmacognosy chapter 5 diploma in Pharmacy
ASTRINGENTS.pdf Pharmacognosy chapter 5 diploma in PharmacyASTRINGENTS.pdf Pharmacognosy chapter 5 diploma in Pharmacy
ASTRINGENTS.pdf Pharmacognosy chapter 5 diploma in PharmacySumit Tiwari
 
Metabolism , Metabolic Fate& disorders of cholesterol.pptx
Metabolism , Metabolic Fate& disorders of cholesterol.pptxMetabolism , Metabolic Fate& disorders of cholesterol.pptx
Metabolism , Metabolic Fate& disorders of cholesterol.pptxDr. Santhosh Kumar. N
 
BBA 205 BE UNIT 2 economic systems prof dr kanchan.pptx
BBA 205 BE UNIT 2 economic systems prof dr kanchan.pptxBBA 205 BE UNIT 2 economic systems prof dr kanchan.pptx
BBA 205 BE UNIT 2 economic systems prof dr kanchan.pptxProf. Kanchan Kumari
 
VIT336 – Recommender System - Unit 3.pdf
VIT336 – Recommender System - Unit 3.pdfVIT336 – Recommender System - Unit 3.pdf
VIT336 – Recommender System - Unit 3.pdfArthyR3
 
2024 March 11, Telehealth Billing- Current Telehealth CPT Codes & Telehealth ...
2024 March 11, Telehealth Billing- Current Telehealth CPT Codes & Telehealth ...2024 March 11, Telehealth Billing- Current Telehealth CPT Codes & Telehealth ...
2024 March 11, Telehealth Billing- Current Telehealth CPT Codes & Telehealth ...Marlene Maheu
 
3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx
3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx
3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptxmary850239
 
Alamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptx
Alamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptxAlamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptx
Alamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptxDhatriParmar
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
Dhavni Theory by Anandvardhana Indian Poetics
Dhavni Theory by Anandvardhana Indian PoeticsDhavni Theory by Anandvardhana Indian Poetics
Dhavni Theory by Anandvardhana Indian PoeticsDhatriParmar
 
Plant Tissue culture., Plasticity, Totipotency, pptx
Plant Tissue culture., Plasticity, Totipotency, pptxPlant Tissue culture., Plasticity, Totipotency, pptx
Plant Tissue culture., Plasticity, Totipotency, pptxHimansu10
 
AUDIENCE THEORY - PARTICIPATORY - JENKINS.pptx
AUDIENCE THEORY - PARTICIPATORY - JENKINS.pptxAUDIENCE THEORY - PARTICIPATORY - JENKINS.pptx
AUDIENCE THEORY - PARTICIPATORY - JENKINS.pptxiammrhaywood
 
3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx
3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx
3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptxmary850239
 
Quantitative research methodology and survey design
Quantitative research methodology and survey designQuantitative research methodology and survey design
Quantitative research methodology and survey designBalelaBoru
 

Dernier (20)

PHARMACOGNOSY CHAPTER NO 5 CARMINATIVES AND G.pdf
PHARMACOGNOSY CHAPTER NO 5 CARMINATIVES AND G.pdfPHARMACOGNOSY CHAPTER NO 5 CARMINATIVES AND G.pdf
PHARMACOGNOSY CHAPTER NO 5 CARMINATIVES AND G.pdf
 
EDD8524 The Future of Educational Leader
EDD8524 The Future of Educational LeaderEDD8524 The Future of Educational Leader
EDD8524 The Future of Educational Leader
 
POST ENCEPHALITIS case study Jitendra bhargav
POST ENCEPHALITIS case study  Jitendra bhargavPOST ENCEPHALITIS case study  Jitendra bhargav
POST ENCEPHALITIS case study Jitendra bhargav
 
BBA 205 BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT UNIT I.pptx
BBA 205 BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT UNIT I.pptxBBA 205 BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT UNIT I.pptx
BBA 205 BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT UNIT I.pptx
 
AI Uses and Misuses: Academic and Workplace Applications
AI Uses and Misuses: Academic and Workplace ApplicationsAI Uses and Misuses: Academic and Workplace Applications
AI Uses and Misuses: Academic and Workplace Applications
 
3.14.24 Gender Discrimination and Gender Inequity.pptx
3.14.24 Gender Discrimination and Gender Inequity.pptx3.14.24 Gender Discrimination and Gender Inequity.pptx
3.14.24 Gender Discrimination and Gender Inequity.pptx
 
THYROID HORMONE.pptx by Subham Panja,Asst. Professor, Department of B.Sc MLT,...
THYROID HORMONE.pptx by Subham Panja,Asst. Professor, Department of B.Sc MLT,...THYROID HORMONE.pptx by Subham Panja,Asst. Professor, Department of B.Sc MLT,...
THYROID HORMONE.pptx by Subham Panja,Asst. Professor, Department of B.Sc MLT,...
 
ASTRINGENTS.pdf Pharmacognosy chapter 5 diploma in Pharmacy
ASTRINGENTS.pdf Pharmacognosy chapter 5 diploma in PharmacyASTRINGENTS.pdf Pharmacognosy chapter 5 diploma in Pharmacy
ASTRINGENTS.pdf Pharmacognosy chapter 5 diploma in Pharmacy
 
Metabolism , Metabolic Fate& disorders of cholesterol.pptx
Metabolism , Metabolic Fate& disorders of cholesterol.pptxMetabolism , Metabolic Fate& disorders of cholesterol.pptx
Metabolism , Metabolic Fate& disorders of cholesterol.pptx
 
BBA 205 BE UNIT 2 economic systems prof dr kanchan.pptx
BBA 205 BE UNIT 2 economic systems prof dr kanchan.pptxBBA 205 BE UNIT 2 economic systems prof dr kanchan.pptx
BBA 205 BE UNIT 2 economic systems prof dr kanchan.pptx
 
VIT336 – Recommender System - Unit 3.pdf
VIT336 – Recommender System - Unit 3.pdfVIT336 – Recommender System - Unit 3.pdf
VIT336 – Recommender System - Unit 3.pdf
 
2024 March 11, Telehealth Billing- Current Telehealth CPT Codes & Telehealth ...
2024 March 11, Telehealth Billing- Current Telehealth CPT Codes & Telehealth ...2024 March 11, Telehealth Billing- Current Telehealth CPT Codes & Telehealth ...
2024 March 11, Telehealth Billing- Current Telehealth CPT Codes & Telehealth ...
 
3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx
3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx
3.12.24 The Social Construction of Gender.pptx
 
Alamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptx
Alamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptxAlamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptx
Alamkara theory by Bhamaha Indian Poetics (1).pptx
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 11 THEO ĐƠN VỊ BÀI HỌC - CẢ NĂM - CÓ FILE NGHE (FRIE...
 
Dhavni Theory by Anandvardhana Indian Poetics
Dhavni Theory by Anandvardhana Indian PoeticsDhavni Theory by Anandvardhana Indian Poetics
Dhavni Theory by Anandvardhana Indian Poetics
 
Plant Tissue culture., Plasticity, Totipotency, pptx
Plant Tissue culture., Plasticity, Totipotency, pptxPlant Tissue culture., Plasticity, Totipotency, pptx
Plant Tissue culture., Plasticity, Totipotency, pptx
 
AUDIENCE THEORY - PARTICIPATORY - JENKINS.pptx
AUDIENCE THEORY - PARTICIPATORY - JENKINS.pptxAUDIENCE THEORY - PARTICIPATORY - JENKINS.pptx
AUDIENCE THEORY - PARTICIPATORY - JENKINS.pptx
 
3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx
3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx
3.12.24 Freedom Summer in Mississippi.pptx
 
Quantitative research methodology and survey design
Quantitative research methodology and survey designQuantitative research methodology and survey design
Quantitative research methodology and survey design
 

2016-05-11 research seminar

  • 1. UNIFIED FRAMEWORK FOR ONLINE AND OFFLINE LEARNING ANALYTICS MAKA ERADZE PHD STUDENT, SCHOOL OF DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES, RESEARCH FELLOW AT UNIVERSITA NAPOLI FEDERICO II RESEARCH SEMINAR, 11.05.2016
  • 2. PRESENTER •  Educational background – humanities (teacher of languages and literatures) - from modern and ancient Greek to interdisciplinary TEL research •  Experience – 2005 to 2012 – software localizer—>teacher network coordinator (Deer Leap Foundation, MoES of Georgia), eLearning coordinator –(Tbilisi State University, Georgia) •  Current job – Università di Napoli Federico II, EMMA project, research fellow •  Research - Unified framework for online and offline learning analytics
  • 3. MOTIVATION FOR THE RESEARCH Personal •  Personal experience through participation into online fora (yes, Latin plural for forum - fora J ) •  Personal ethnographic observations on my informal learning patterns led me to Learning Analytics research •  How? Ask Mart! Professional: •  Interactions and social dimension of learning leading to big questions like: •  what exactly are we analysing •  What is my research question? •  How are we going to break the concepts down to analyzable units?
  • 4. STRUCTURE OF THE PRESENTATION •  Background and statement of the problem •  State of the art •  General methodological framework of the research •  Literature review •  Work already done •  Towards a framework - Mind map and diagram •  Future research - validation phase •  Applicability •  Discussion part
  • 5. BACKGROUND AND STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM •  The need for this kind of research emerges from the idea that •  When dealing with data (especially big), we have to think about our questions first and search for patterns in learning data with specific questions and frameworks in mind. For this, we need to shape our philosophical and methodological standing. •  We need to think also about the real world interactions and think about the ways to facilitate and connect learning interaction analytics. •  This research aims at the development of a unified model for offline and online analytics with a purpose of gaining insight into learning interactions.
  • 6. BACKGROUND AND STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM •  It is focused on the development of a methodological framework for the analysis of offline and online interaction patterns and open learning environments. •  Centered on the idea of the unit of analysis and its appropriateness for learning analytics research and practice, it can be applicable to any kind of interaction analysis (learning analytics). •  How is the issue of the units of analysis presented in different disciplines (and learning analytics?) •  What are the philosophical concepts and considerations behind the issue of the unit of analysis? •  How can we make use of xAPI statements and frame this discourse in a philosophically and methodologically appropriate way?
  • 7. RESEARCH QUESTIONS •  How can we analyze learning interactions using different frameworks, theories, philosophies (and pedagogic scenarios)? •  What is the appropriate unit of analysis for learning interaction analytics in online and offline settings?
  • 8. GENERAL THEORETICAL AND METHODOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK OF THE RESEARCH Theoretically •  Constructivist approach •  This research does not use particular theoretical framework. It rather reviews interdisciplinary approaches and creates a meta language to redescribe the methodological framework for learning analytics research Methodologically •  Design based research •  Mainly based on the extensive literature review and inquiry stage •  Based on the literature review artifacts will be created that redescribe and place the issue of the unit of analysis within the LA research •  This will serve to create a detailed ontology and validate it
  • 9. STATE OF THE ART - INTERACTIONS •  In order to actually define how can we make use of interaction traces and data and locate its analytical framework, it is necessary to define the concept of interaction as it is to educational sciences - TEL. •  Interaction functions in a different way in virtual learning environments where its must convey, mimic or recreate the traditional communication patterns or build a new type of learning ambience. •  Underlining the term - learning interaction. I share Wagner’ definition of interaction as follows “reciprocal events that require at least two objects and two actions. Interactions occur when these objects and events mutually influence each other” (Wagner, 1994).
  • 10. STATE OF THE ART - INTERACTIONS •  According to Anderson (Anderson 2003), interaction online (or offline) can happen human and inanimate actors. •  Moore’s theory of Three Types of Interaction •  To Moor learner-instructor interaction is a four-stage support of the learner: 1.  Designing the content, maintaining motivation, self-direction 2.  Making presentations (student/teacher) 3.  Practicing and applying acquired competences. 4.  Counseling and encouragement of learners according their levels of progress. The third type of interaction – learner- learner for Moor is a new dimension in distance education
  • 11. STATE OF THE ART- DEFINITIONS •  Learning analytics is the measurement, collection, analysis and reporting of data about learners and their contexts, for purposes of understanding and optimizing learning and the environments in which it occurs. •  LA as a technology-enhanced learning (TEL) research area that focuses on the development of methods for analyzing and detecting patterns within data collected from educational settings, and leverages those methods to support the learning experience. (Chatti et al 2015)
  • 12. STATE OF THE ART- LA, ITS CHALLENGES AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS Learning analytics is inherently interdisciplinary • Operates on the verge of many different fields Still in its infancy • It still has to establish itself as field with its own traditions and theoretical frameworks
  • 13. •  Two systematic literature reviews found: •  Nistor et al(2015): The main issue with LA research is the frequent lack of an explicit theoretical framework from educational perspective. The authors call on the educational and psychological theories for significant progress of upcoming LA research •  Gasevic et al(2015): researchers from educational sciences tend to publish more mature research and show more rigor •  Fortunately, the field is evolving quickly and one measure of this growth is the increasing breadth of methodologies being applied to learning‐related data sources (Pardo et al, 2014)
  • 14. •  Big learning analytics t h a t c o m e f r o m heterogeneous sources •  o p e n l e a r n i n g environments (MOOCs), with data coming from outside of platform. •  Mobile learning analytics •  Context modeling •  Privacy-aware analytics. •  Personalized learning analytics. •  Life-long learner modeling •  Learning analytics for open assessment. •  Embedded Learning analytics •  Learning analytics design patterns. •  Learning analytics evaluation. Chatti, M. A., Lukarov, V., Thüs, H., Muslim, A., Yousef, A. M. F., Wahid, U., ... & Schroeder, U. (2014). Learning Analytics: Challenges and Future Research Directions.
  • 15. FACTORS Different factors are involved in LA Greller and Draschler
  • 17. LIT.REVIEW -UNIT OF ANALYSIS •  Interdisciplinary approach: •  When choosing what to analyze, how to analysis, what to take into account, how to operationalize questions, what methodology to use, what discourse to take in in any field, unit of analysis is at the same time a problematic but also an important decision to make. •  Learning Interaction Analysis needs its own unit of analysis too. •  influenced by the work of Matusov who has given an extensive account on this issue from different perspectives. •  Building on his understanding on the unit of analysis we will also bring arguments from: •  Socio-cultural research, education, human-computer interaction, computer science, sociology, technology- enhanced learning, psychology and other fields.
  • 18. LIT.REVIEW -UNIT OF ANALYSIS •  This is not a methodological decision only, but also a political, and of course, philosophical. •  Mostly, two types of approaches are used for the discussion on the unit of analysis: holistic and reductionist. •  Holistic approach believes that the unit has to express a whole phenomenon, while reductionist approach breaks the unit of analysis down to its most fine grain unit. •  Matusov thinks, that the unit of analysis changes with the aim of the research. •  To Vigotsky it is a “self-contained” “unified smallest whole”.
  • 19. UNIT OF ANALYSIS •  Matusov takes the socio-cultural approach to the issue and bases his discussion mainly on psychologist tradition. •  According to Matusov one must be careful when searching for a general, universal unit of analysis, because it always is shaped by the purpose of the researcher and the subject of study. •  The construct “unit of analysis” is mainly used for the methodological critique of others’ research
  • 20. UNIT OF ANALYSIS The discussion about the unit of analysis is also a paradigmatic discussion – exact sciences vs social sciences with •  “The exact sciences constitute a monologic form of knowledge: the intellect contemplates a thing and expounds upon it. There is only one subject here-cognizing (contemplating) and speaking (expounding). In opposition to the subject there is only a voiceless thing. Any object of knowledge (including man) can be perceived and cognized as a thing. But a subject as such cannot be perceived and studied as a thing, for as a subject it cannot, while remaining a subject, become voiceless, and, consequently, cognition of it can only be dialogic.” (Bakhtin in Matusov)
  • 22. UNIT OF ANALYSIS •  According to Lefstein, while replacing the reductive units of analysis with more holistic ones, the issue of manageability arises. •  Sometimes it can be hard to draw the boundaries, what is the exact phenomenon to be expressed holistically. He argues, that “interactional structures of three or more turns is a methodologically expedient and theoretically sound unit for the analysis of classroom discourse”. •  To him, unit of analysis is a “discourse move” and dialogical. Though, Lefstein also suggests that aside from the appropriate phenomenon, the unit of analysis has to be expanded to sequence.
  • 23. UNIT OF ANALYSIS Stahl from his side discusses the issue of unit of analysis in cognition – •  concepts (Plato), •  mental and material objects (Descartes) (and relationship between them) •  observable physical objects (empiricism), •  mind’s structuring categorization efforts (Kant). All of the approaches dealt with the inner functions of an individual mind. •  Hegel entered the discussion with a larger unit of analysis – historically, socially and culturally determined. •  Marx views the main unit of analysis as social movements, class conflicts and transformations of economic systems. •  Hegel’s philosophy shaped three mainstream schools of thought – Marx (critical social theory), Heidegger (existential phenomenology) and Wittgenstein (linguistic analysis). •  To Stahl, these three main directions influence how the CSCL units of analysis are formed: For Heidegger the unit of analysis was the man with unified experience of being-in-the-world. •  Wingenstein’s shifted unit of analysis from mental meanings to interpersonal communications in the context of getting something done together. (Stahl)
  • 24. UNIT OF ANALYSIS - LATOUR •  Latour thinks the issue brings us to •  what phenomenon is worth studying and ‘worth’ for what. According to a sociocultural framework, this question cannot be addressed within purely methodological considerations as it both involves conceptual (paradigmatic) debates within the academic field and is shaped by practical needs and financial (and political and institutional) pressure outside of the field and science in general (Latour, 1987 in Matusov). •  For Latour and his Action-Network Theory, the main unit of analysis is embedded in the relationship between the actions.
  • 25. UNIT OF ANALYSIS •  Stahl believes that Engestrom is the one taking the unit of analysis to the whole activity system. •  Engeström in his “Learning By Expanding” writes that the insertion of cultural artifacts into human actions was revolutionary in that the basic unit of analysis now overcame the split between the Cartesian individual and the untouchable societal structure.” After this the understanding of an individual could no longer happen without his or her cultural means; and the understanding of a society was bound to individuals who use and produce artifacts. He believes that the limitation of the first generation was that the unit of analysis remained individually focused. The object- oriented and artifact-mediated collective activity system is the prime unit of analysis in cultural-historical studies of human conduct; •  But to Stahl’s understanding Engestrom’s theory is not interested in group knowledge building but rather with organizational management of the group, Influenced by Marx, theory tries to see societal issues in the making.
  • 26. UNIT OF ANALYSIS •  Stahl believes that even in distributed cognition, which deals with group-cognitive phenomena, mostly socio- technical systems and highly developed artifacts are analyzed. •  Suthers (2010) with his uptake framework proposes that the event is the core if we want analyze data and understand which interactions lead to learning. The uptake framework suggests that interaction is relational by its nature, so the most important unit of analysis is not isolated acts, but rather relationships (based, again, on Latour 2005) between acts.
  • 27. UNIT OF ANALYSIS - KAPTELININ In activity-theory •  activity, in a broad sense, is an interaction of the actor (e.g., a human being) with the world. The interaction, according to activity theory terminology, is described as a process relating the subject (S) and the object (O). A common way to represent activity is “S ⇔ O. •  According to Kaptelinin, activity is different from other types of interaction by two key aspects: (a) subjects of activities have needs, which should be met through an interaction with the world, and (b) activities and their subjects mutually determine one another; or, more generally, activities are generative forces that transform both subjects and objects. Subjects have needs.
  • 28. KAPTELININ – ACTIVITY THEORY •  Kaptelinin presents the Activity as •  a “unit of life” of a material subject existing in the objective world. •  Subjects have their own needs and to survive, have to engage in activities, that is, interact with the worldy objects fulfill their needs •  assumptions of the social nature of human mind and inseparability of human mind and activity. (Kaptelinin, Activity theory). •  Activity is of fundamental importance to psychology because of its special function. •  It places the Subject into the objective reality and transforms the reality into a form of subjectivity (Leontiev, 1978)
  • 29. PAAVOLA AND HAIKAINEN •  According to Paavola and Haikaninen, in trialogues, the interaction through “shared objects” that are in the process of being developed is emphasized. •  The objects of inquiry can be respresented by the knowledge artefacts, practices, ideas, models, representations, etc. but perceived as something to be collaboratively developed. •  These objects are important in the interaction and it is an interaction between subjects, other subjects and “objects” but not between the subjects. •  This means that the things are being developed collaboratively and they do not repeat the existing knowledge
  • 30. XAPI Event-driven analytics <Actor (learner)> <verb> <object>, with <result>, in <context>
  • 31. REVIEW: XAPI ●  The Experience API is a service that allows for statements of experience (typically learning experiences, but could be any experience) to be delivered to and stored securely in a Learning Record Store ●  The Experience API is dependent on Learning Activity Providers to create and track learning. ●  Learning Activity Provider is a software object that communicates with the LRS to record information about the learning experience. ●  Learning activity is a unit of instruction, experience or performance that has to be tracked. ●  A Statement consists of <Actor (learner)> <verb> <object>, with <result>, in <context> to track an aspect of a learning experience.
  • 32. REVIEW: XAPI ●  It repeats the structure of the sentence in practically any language and is human readable •  Actor data is a unique information that describes a specific subject, such as a student or group of students. •  Verb data classifies the type of activity the actor participated in and often links to a human readable description of the event. •  Object data will link to an artifact that is typically a byproduct of or related to the activity
  • 33. XAPI ●  It is much more, than just a simple sentence-like structure. The context is very important and it makes possible to relate one activity to another* •  Quoting Verbert, Suthers and Rosen, Kevan and Ryan believe that the issue of variety of educational data taxonomies and also the distributed learning events collection challenges can be solved by xAPI* ●  Some researchers believe that it is aligned with constructivist approach and activity theory ●  xAPI has a lot of potential for The xAPI offers a renewed opportunity to research, develop, and explore theories involving learning beyond academia’s digital environments. Kevan, J. M., & Ryan, P. R. Experience API: Flexible, Decentralized and Activity-Centric Data Collection.Technology, Knowledge and Learning, 1-7.
  • 34. WORK ALREADY DONE/PUBLICATIONS •  Eradze, M. Kai, P., Laanpere, M.: (2013) Analysing Learning Flows in Digital Learning Ecosystems, KMEL 2013, ICWL2013, Taiwan, Springer (LNCS), October 2013 •  The first paper that opens the discussion on the unit of analysis, with detailed background on the interactions, literature review •  Eradze M., Laanpere M.: (2014) Interrelation Between Pedagogical Design and Learning Interaction Patterns in Different Virtual Learning Environments, HCII 2014, Greece, Springer (LNCS) June 2014 •  Three different platforms studied with CoI framework and coding template (Two MOOC platforms, Moodle and Edufeedr) •  Eradze, M., Valjataga, T., Laanpere M.: (2014) Observing the use of e- textbooks in the classroom: towards “Offline” Learning Analytics, FeT workshop, ICWL 2014, Tallinn, Estonia, Springer (LNCS) •  Observations in the classroom, tried to document offline interactions with an mobile app and xAPI type of statements.
  • 35. PUBLICATION IN PROGRESS Unit of Analysis in Learning Analytics, Maka Eradze, Mart Laanpere •  The article overviews the state of the art of unit of analysis issue in educational research, learning analytics and offers a conceptual framework based on the idea of an appropriate unit of analysis for learning interaction analysis. •  Aiming for - Journal of Computing in Higher Education - Special Issue on Advancing Research on Open Education.
  • 36. MIND MAP – REDESCRIBING THE UNIT OF ANALYSIS/XAPI
  • 38. FUTURE RESEARCH  - VALIDATION PHASE •  Based on the inquiry stage and the artefacts, a detailed ontology will be developed •  A single semantic structure that can map teacher intentions – what they are planning to do and what actually is taking place •  The ontology will be mapped to specific scenarios •  Together with teachers validate the ontology with participatory approach
  • 39. APPLICABILITY •  This ontology will be applicable to any context and to any data •  It will be flexible and can be applied to different pedagogic scenarios, philosophies, methodologies •  With this ontology we will be able to grasp the whole structures of interactions and analyse it holistically
  • 40. I know this is not yet a defense and am not yet on Ithaca and I am no Odysseus (rather Penelope), but this is a journey I am enjoying so:
  • 41. EXPRESSION OF GRATITUDE •  To all in the School of Digital Technologies for understanding my absent presence or rather present absence •  To Mart for being a challenging supervisor and….for scaffolding/challenging/believing in me J •  To Kai for giving valuable, critical and helpful feedback
  • 42. DISCUSSION Need feedback J •  Desperately! •  For thoughts and feedback coming up later: maka@tlu.ee