SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
Ethical Dilemma at
Lonestar Steakhouse &
        Saloon

     Julia Megan Masters
Step 1: Recognize the Ethical Dilemma



     I was working at Lonestar Steakhouse & Saloon as a host a
      few years ago when I noticed a server was leaving the
      restaurant with twice the amount of tips as everyone else. It
      was then I noticed that she was changing the amount of the
      tip that each customer left her on their credit card.
Step 2: Get the Facts



    After observing my coworker for a few days to make sure she
     was forging the tip amount, I learned that I was correct. I saw
     her adding a one in front of every tip she was given on a
     credit card. This gave her at least ten dollars more on each
     tip.
Step 3: Identify Your Options



     I realized I had two options.

      1. I could tell my manager about what I saw.


      2. I could not say anything and let her keep changing tip amounts.
Step 4: Test Each Option



     If I were to tell my manager, I would be doing the right thing. I
      would be protecting the customer and the restaurant from
      legal impacts.

     If I were to not tell my manager I would be doing the wrong
      thing. I would be allowing a coworker to break the law, and
      steal from customers.
Step 5: Decide Which Option to Follow



     After reviewing my options, it was very clear which one I
      needed to follow. I needed to tell my manager what I saw.
Step 6: Double-check with the spotlight
questions



     I asked myself “How will I feel if my family finds out about my
      decision?”
            - I would feel proud for doing the right thing.
     I asked myself “How will I feel about this if my decision is
      reported in the local newspaper or posted on the Internet?”
            - I would be happy to be recognized for doing the right thing.
Step 7: Take Action



     After double-checking that I was doing the right thing, I went
      to my manager and told him what I had seen. My manager
      then went through her credit card receipts and found the
      proof needed to confront her about the issue.

More Related Content

Similar to MGT Midterm Question 3

Mp midterm 3b
Mp midterm 3bMp midterm 3b
Mp midterm 3b
aubylinn
 
AssignmentScenarioAs a security administrator for Always Fresh
AssignmentScenarioAs a security administrator for Always FreshAssignmentScenarioAs a security administrator for Always Fresh
AssignmentScenarioAs a security administrator for Always Fresh
arleanemlerpj
 
Is just been paid a scam
Is just been paid a scamIs just been paid a scam
Is just been paid a scam
jbpriches
 
1 Published by CCCOnline ccco.desire2learn.org MAR160 Mod.docx
1 Published by CCCOnline ccco.desire2learn.org MAR160 Mod.docx1 Published by CCCOnline ccco.desire2learn.org MAR160 Mod.docx
1 Published by CCCOnline ccco.desire2learn.org MAR160 Mod.docx
teresehearn
 
MOD 1Ethical Decision MakingStart by reading and following the.docx
MOD 1Ethical Decision MakingStart by reading and following the.docxMOD 1Ethical Decision MakingStart by reading and following the.docx
MOD 1Ethical Decision MakingStart by reading and following the.docx
roushhsiu
 
Ethical dilemmas
Ethical dilemmasEthical dilemmas
Ethical dilemmas
tlansaw
 
Own your life part 1 pdf howard mcomber
Own your life part 1 pdf howard mcomberOwn your life part 1 pdf howard mcomber
Own your life part 1 pdf howard mcomber
howardmcomber
 

Similar to MGT Midterm Question 3 (20)

Mp midterm 3b
Mp midterm 3bMp midterm 3b
Mp midterm 3b
 
18 Tips on Conducting Killer Customers Interviews
18 Tips on Conducting Killer Customers Interviews18 Tips on Conducting Killer Customers Interviews
18 Tips on Conducting Killer Customers Interviews
 
AssignmentScenarioAs a security administrator for Always Fresh
AssignmentScenarioAs a security administrator for Always FreshAssignmentScenarioAs a security administrator for Always Fresh
AssignmentScenarioAs a security administrator for Always Fresh
 
Is just been paid a scam
Is just been paid a scamIs just been paid a scam
Is just been paid a scam
 
Customer Decision- Making Process
Customer Decision- Making ProcessCustomer Decision- Making Process
Customer Decision- Making Process
 
1 Published by CCCOnline ccco.desire2learn.org MAR160 Mod.docx
1 Published by CCCOnline ccco.desire2learn.org MAR160 Mod.docx1 Published by CCCOnline ccco.desire2learn.org MAR160 Mod.docx
1 Published by CCCOnline ccco.desire2learn.org MAR160 Mod.docx
 
MOD 1Ethical Decision MakingStart by reading and following the.docx
MOD 1Ethical Decision MakingStart by reading and following the.docxMOD 1Ethical Decision MakingStart by reading and following the.docx
MOD 1Ethical Decision MakingStart by reading and following the.docx
 
SSSSsssssales-done-130909053626-.pdf
SSSSsssssales-done-130909053626-.pdfSSSSsssssales-done-130909053626-.pdf
SSSSsssssales-done-130909053626-.pdf
 
Marketing Success - How it all Started
Marketing Success - How it all StartedMarketing Success - How it all Started
Marketing Success - How it all Started
 
Real Estate Agents: 7 No-Brainers to Improve Your Client Experiece
Real Estate Agents: 7 No-Brainers to Improve Your Client ExperieceReal Estate Agents: 7 No-Brainers to Improve Your Client Experiece
Real Estate Agents: 7 No-Brainers to Improve Your Client Experiece
 
Improving Your Selling Skills
Improving Your Selling SkillsImproving Your Selling Skills
Improving Your Selling Skills
 
Effective First Prospecting Call
Effective First Prospecting CallEffective First Prospecting Call
Effective First Prospecting Call
 
Service is Your Best Marketing Strategy: 5 Quick Tips
Service is Your Best Marketing Strategy: 5 Quick TipsService is Your Best Marketing Strategy: 5 Quick Tips
Service is Your Best Marketing Strategy: 5 Quick Tips
 
Ebay
EbayEbay
Ebay
 
Chamber Customer Service August Presentation
Chamber Customer Service August PresentationChamber Customer Service August Presentation
Chamber Customer Service August Presentation
 
Online Reputation Workshop for Car Dealers
Online Reputation Workshop for Car DealersOnline Reputation Workshop for Car Dealers
Online Reputation Workshop for Car Dealers
 
5-Star Customer Service 06-2014
5-Star Customer Service 06-20145-Star Customer Service 06-2014
5-Star Customer Service 06-2014
 
Ethical dilemmas
Ethical dilemmasEthical dilemmas
Ethical dilemmas
 
Marketing-Consumer behavior
Marketing-Consumer behaviorMarketing-Consumer behavior
Marketing-Consumer behavior
 
Own your life part 1 pdf howard mcomber
Own your life part 1 pdf howard mcomberOwn your life part 1 pdf howard mcomber
Own your life part 1 pdf howard mcomber
 

MGT Midterm Question 3

  • 1. Ethical Dilemma at Lonestar Steakhouse & Saloon Julia Megan Masters
  • 2. Step 1: Recognize the Ethical Dilemma  I was working at Lonestar Steakhouse & Saloon as a host a few years ago when I noticed a server was leaving the restaurant with twice the amount of tips as everyone else. It was then I noticed that she was changing the amount of the tip that each customer left her on their credit card.
  • 3. Step 2: Get the Facts  After observing my coworker for a few days to make sure she was forging the tip amount, I learned that I was correct. I saw her adding a one in front of every tip she was given on a credit card. This gave her at least ten dollars more on each tip.
  • 4. Step 3: Identify Your Options  I realized I had two options. 1. I could tell my manager about what I saw. 2. I could not say anything and let her keep changing tip amounts.
  • 5. Step 4: Test Each Option  If I were to tell my manager, I would be doing the right thing. I would be protecting the customer and the restaurant from legal impacts.  If I were to not tell my manager I would be doing the wrong thing. I would be allowing a coworker to break the law, and steal from customers.
  • 6. Step 5: Decide Which Option to Follow  After reviewing my options, it was very clear which one I needed to follow. I needed to tell my manager what I saw.
  • 7. Step 6: Double-check with the spotlight questions  I asked myself “How will I feel if my family finds out about my decision?” - I would feel proud for doing the right thing.  I asked myself “How will I feel about this if my decision is reported in the local newspaper or posted on the Internet?” - I would be happy to be recognized for doing the right thing.
  • 8. Step 7: Take Action  After double-checking that I was doing the right thing, I went to my manager and told him what I had seen. My manager then went through her credit card receipts and found the proof needed to confront her about the issue.