SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  58
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
-1-
ENTRY FOR PROFIT
TRANS-COSMOS INC. CHINA ENTRY STRATEGY
PRESENTATION
February 8, 2013
John Gregg,
Principal, Navigate Consulting Pty Ltd
-2-
AGENDA
Executive Summary
Call Center Business
• Market Overview
• CC Customer Segmentation
- In-house users
- Outsourcers
• Demand
• Customer
• Economics
• Competition
• Recommendations
- Success business model
- Partnering strategy
E-Commerce Market Overview
TCI Tianjin
• Current Situation Analysis
• Recommendations
-3-
AGENDA
Executive Summary
Call Center Business
• Market Overview
• CC Customer Segmentation
- In-house users
- Outsourcers
• Demand
• Customer
• Economics
• Competition
• Recommendations
- Success business model
- Partnering strategy
E-Commerce Market Overview
TCI Tianjin
• Current Situation Analysis
• Recommendations
-4-
CHINA IS BECOMING A HIGHLY DYNAMIC CC MARKET
China’s call center market took off in 1998 with an annual growth rate over 100%
• Non-paging market size reached 364,000 seats in 2012
However past growth was largely driven by demands from administrative driven sector
• In 2011, over 60% CC demand comes from four pillar industries: Banking, Post Services,
Fixed-line Telecom, and Insurance
• Distinctive purchasing behavior identified for these purchases
Future growth will be propelled by service oriented and call centres segments
• call centres market will grow at least 35% a year for the next few years
- However large variance exists for call centres segment growth
Overall, China Call Centres created over 360K seats in 2012
and 430K seats in 2015
-5-
AND IS GAINING GROUND ON KEY DECISION CRITERIA
Multiple call centres destinations around the world have sprung up as supplier bases.
• Besides India and China, popular locations include the Philippines, Malaysia, Romania,
Ukraine, Brazil and Mexico.
Multiple surveys point to new location preferences and trends:
• Alternatives to India are being mixed in with greater frequency. Latin America and
China ranked as the most popular alternatives to India in one recent survey.2
• According to a number of rankings, China is gaining ground on criteria such as financial
attractiveness, people and skills, and business environment.
• Of 30 top destinations identified as best for offshore Call Centre operations, ten
countries were from Asia (China, India, Thailand, Vietnam, Australia, New Zealand,
Singapore, Malaysia, Pakistan, and the Philippines). Thailand was a newcomer to the
list, as were a few other emerging markets such as Egypt, Morocco and Panama.
-6-
Currently, low-price/standard service vendors remain profitable
• Utilization, and therefore, long-term customers, is the key for profitability
• However, high-priced call centres solutions not widely accepted by the market
But high-end services will reach 65% of share off total market by 2014
• We are encouraged by recent positive news on clients’ long-term commitments to
high-end outsourcers
High-end outsourcers can win the game by aggressively establishing long-term client base,
and targeting various call centres opportunities along the value chain
• Five successful strategies identified for new customer development
• Telemarketing and value-added information service most likely to be outsourced
CC OURSOURCERS ARE STILL EXPLORING
-7-
TCI SHOULD PARTNER WITH RIGHT LOCAL CC OUTSOURCERS
A partnering strategy is essential for TCI to capture the great opportunities in China
• TCI lacks a bunch of local capabilities, while time is contingent
TCI should target both money making, and money losing tech advanced outsourcers during
negotiation process, based on two plausible partnership strategies
• Money making ones: share profits and leverage local strength
• Money losing ones: control and negotiate for a bargain deal
Considering the limited number of candidates in China and TCI’s tight schedule, a broader
search can strengthen TCI’s negotiation position
Five promising outsourcers identified during the interview process
• Money making ones: China Motion, 800 Teleservices, and Compaq-Star
• Money losing ones: TCY, ITS Shanghai
-8-
TCI-TJ: RSTRUCTURING AND BUILDING STRATEGIC ALLIANCES
TCI-TJ experienced difficulties due to both promotion and management issues
• Though improving, the firm is intrinsically uncompetitive in China market
It should restructure for better performance…
• Redefine corporate missions and strategies
• Restructure project arrangement, reporting, measurement and incentive systems
• Refocus its sales on Japanese companies in China and in Japan
… and find strategic alliance for TCI’s China expansion
• TCI should only partner with prestigious local software company or system integrators
• Wiseway screened all the potential candidates lists and funneled down 5 most
promising companies for TCI’s further contact
- Longshine; Global eForce; eBIS; Modern Computer; Huateng Software
-9-
AGENDA
Executive Summary
Call Center Business
• Market Overview
• CC Customer Segmentation
- In-house users
- Outsourcers
• Demand
• Customer
• Economics
• Competition
• Recommendations
- Success business model
- Partnering strategy
E-Commerce Market Overview
TCI Tianjin
• Current Situation Analysis
• Recommendations
-10-
CALL CENTRE INDUSTRY WILL REACH 380-400K SEATS IN 2014
Illustration
• Identify major driving factors to CC adoption
- market competition and service awareness
- telecom charges and phone penetration
• Quantify relationships between drivers and CC adoption
- here we used US benchmark
• Project CC development by forecasting development of
drivers
• Project CC penetration in major user’s industries
- banking, telecom, insurance …
• Add up numbers of each industry to give a CC market
overview
• Interview industry experts or knowledgeable industry
practitioners for their opinion of CC market growth
- system integrators and experts
2009 (1)
(’000 seats)
158
132
145
2014 projection(1)
(’000 seats)
390
337
N.A.
Driving
factor
analysis
Bottom-up
analysis
Experts
opinions
(1) Without paging company
-11-
TOP-DOWN APPROACH REVEALS A PROMISING END GAME
Phone line per 1000 people
CC agents per 1000 people
US benchmark
Y = 0.00146X + 4.79
Deflated telecom fee index
Phone line per 1000 people
China phone line
10
21
50
74
158
368
Year
Non-paging CC seats
(‘000)
Source: US Telephone Statistics; Datamonitor;
MII data; China Statistics Yearbook
1998 992000 01 04 12
1000
0
-12-
TELECOM IS THE MOST SIGNIFICANT CC USER NOW
Bottom-up Analysis
Industry
Telecom
Mobile
Banking
Insurance
Post service
Manufacturing
Computer
Airline
Security
Courier
Home appliance
TV selling
Others
Overall
Projected seats CAGR
2000
25,000
7,667
4,545
2,000
1,600
1,501
800
594
257
240
240
300
6,675
51,419
2004
35,714
22,857
11,100
3,760
6,000
7,519
5,250
4,100
4,158
1,000
2,460
1,000
26,669
131,588
2010
41,667
50,000
47,000
9,850
20,833
25,184
14,000
9,600
32,600
3,333
8,800
2,000
71,965
336,832
2000-04
9%
31 %
25 %
17 %
39 %
50 %
60 %
62 %
101 %
43 %
79 %
35 %
41 %
26 %
2004-10
3%
14 %
27 %
17 %
23 %
22 %
18 %
15 %
41 %
22 %
24 %
12 %
18 %
17 %
Source: interviews; online research; experts opinions; Navigate analysis
-13-
AGENDA
Executive Summary
Call Center Business
• Market Overview
• CC Customer Segmentation
- In-house users
- Outsourcers
• Demand
• Customer
• Economics
• Competition
• Recommendations
- Success business model
- Partnering strategy
E-Commerce Market Overview
TCI Tianjin
• Current Situation Analysis
• Recommendations
-14-
CC MARKET ROUGHLY SEGMENTED INTO FOUR CATEGORIES
According to Area of CC Usage, and Willingness to Outsource
Selected industry examples
Willingness
to
outsource
High
Low
Service-oriented
call centres
Generic service
Admin-driven
Securities
Home appliance
Computer/technology
Courier service
Publication
TV selling
MessagingTravel
Simple order taking
Paging
Telecom
Insurance
Bank
Post service
Community service
Utility
Core area Non-core area
Area of CC usage
-15-
THREE CRITERIA TO DISTINGUISH CORE AND NON-CORE AREA
Industry
Core Area
• Securities
• Courier service
• Computer/technology
“Grey Area”
• Home appliance
• Banking
• Insurance
• Publication
• Telecom
• Traveling
Non-core Area (generic)
• Paging service
• Messaging
• TV selling
• Utilities
Functionality • Technical assistance
• Aftersales service
• Customer complaint
settlement
• Sourcing/supplier
coordination
• Customer inquiry settlement
• Telemarketing
• Message delivering
• Simple order taking
Call Center’s impact to overall business
- Core: When CC function is critical to the performance of the industry
Confidentiality requirement
- Core: If the industry/functionality commands strict confidentiality
Call Center operational complexity
- Core: If operating CC in this industry requires great sophistication
Criteria
Many industries have both core and non-core areas
-16-
AGENDA
Executive Summary
Call Center Business
• Market Overview
• CC Customer Segmentation
- In-house users
- Outsourcers
• Demand
• Customer
• Economics
• Competition
• Recommendations
- Success business model
- Partnering strategy
E-Commerce Market Overview
TCI Tianjin
• Current Situation Analysis
• Recommendations
-17-
ADMIN-DRIVEN SEGMENT: MOST IMPORTANT FOR NOW
High % in total new CC demand Driven by “Pillar industries”
Demand surged in a group of China’s important
industries since 2004, aiming to improve service level
•Bank
•Post service
•Fixed-line telecom
•Insurance
Required mostly mid-to-high end call center solutions
(Nortel, Lucent, IBM, Huawei…)
•Big, monopolized, profitable corporations
•High cost of failure
•Budget approval from above
•Often in conjunction with structural reform
1998 1999 2000
4.9
# of new CC
seats (’000)
Year
Admin-driven
11.2
29.5 Total new
demand
Admin-
driven
66%
76%
62%
Source: Navigate Consulting modeling
-18-
UNIQUE THREE-TIER DECISION MAKING PROCESS
System Integrators Should Put Efforts to All
Top-down initiatives
Advocate improving service standard
•Make “service facilities” an evaluation
criteria
•May suggest call center as an option
Determine rolling out call centers in the
corporation
Raise a list of recommended system
integrators
•Present the list to branch companies
Set a budget for different branch companies
Decide call center size and sophistication
based on corporate budget
Negotiate and select a system integrator
mostly suitable to the branch’s requirements
SI should pay attention
to Ministry’s recent
service improvement
incentive
Ministry
SI should approach
promising corporate
headquarters in advance
to get the name on the
list
Corporate headquarter
SI should put most
efforts to influence
branch company’s
selection
Provincial/regional
branches
Admin-driven
-19-
call centres ALMOST NEVER AN OPTION FOR
ADMIN-DRIVEN COMPANIES
Call centres is not considered an option for CC adoption at corporate level
• Worried about unforeseeable consequences
• Money saving is not a priority for these big, monopolized SOEs
• Unable to distinguish different conditions in different geography
- some areas don’t have satisfactory outsourcers
Politically risky for branch managers to be “creative”
• If using outsourcers, branch managers have to bear all responsibilities
- potential for failure is considerable
• CC construction budget would be in vain if not used up
- while call centres budget needs to be reported for upper approval
Only exception is Guangzhou Mobile Company’s call centres of its “Mobile Secretary” service
• By nature a paging service: Ideal to be done by a paging company
• “Mobile Secretary” service is not planned and budgeted from the corporation (China Mobile)
• Guangzhou’s business practice is more liberal than rest of China
Admin-driven
-20-
SERVICE-ORIENTED SEGMENT: A DRIVER FOR LONG-TERM CC
PENETRATION
Rapid growth in the long-term Widespread adoption expected in market-driven industries
Heated competition will stimulate CC usage in mass-
market industries
• WTO not only lifted various local protectionism,
but also introduce global competition
• Current over-capacity situation won’t alleviate for
the next several years
Therefore, service will be more important to create
differentiation
• With better market environment, consumers are
educated to appreciate service
Total non-paging CC
seats (’000)
Service-oriented
2009 2010 2011 2012
10
Year
50
337 Total CC
seats
Service-
oriented
26%
24%
50%
132
42%
Source: Interviews; online research; expert opinions; Navigate Consulting Analysis3
-21-
MORE INDUSTRIES ARE LIKELY TO ADOPT CC OVERTIME
CC Adoption
Area
Home appliance
Automotive
Computer
Mobile
Securities
Retailing
Petrochemical
Distribution
FMCG(1)
Taxi
Textile
Machinery
Chemical
Publication
Health care
Government
Entertainment
Broadcasting/TV Aviation
General Technology
High
Moderate
Low
Competition
intensity
High
Horizontal will
extend overtime
Importance of service
(1) Fast-moving consumer goods
Source: Interviews; literature research summaries; Navigate Consulting Analysis
Horizontal will
extend overtime
Service-oriented
-22-
COMPANIES QUITE SELECTIVE ON CC USAGE
Not blindly chasing after high-end solutions
Integrating call centers with its core business
practice
Interviews summary
Source: Interviews
%
Investment
per seat
(’000 RMB)
54%
31%
15%
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
Oct-70 70-150 150-250
Interviews summary%
Aftersales
service
44%
31%
19%
6%
Order
taking
Information
service
Telemarketing10-70
Service-oriented
-23-
VERY CAUTIONS ON CC call centres
Price
“The price for call centres is too high now,
for example, 95Info charges
15,000RMB/month (180,000RMB/year) per
seat, most companies can not undertake it.”
Sales Manager, SIEMENS
Quality
“Chinese call center outsourcers have
inadequate service mentality, we mostly
worried about their service quality.”
Hot Line Supervisor, EPSON
China
Human resources
“Ordinary outsourcer’s agents can only
handle simple questions. It requires
experienced engineers to deal with complex
problems.”
Hot Line Supervisor,
EPSON China
Confidentiality
“We once wanted to outsource
management to 95Info, but sales data are
secret to the company, so we gave up the call
centres option.”
Call Center Vice -Manager, Founder Computer
Information processing
“Our call center is mainly used to provide
cross-department information for
management, call centres call center might
make the information processing losing
control.”
Executive Officer Beijing,
Guangdong Macro
Major concerns
about call
centres
Their call centres possibility highly depends on outsourcers’ ability to satisfy
their concerns
Source: Interviews
Service-
oriented
-24-
AGENDA
Executive Summary
Call Center Business
• Market Overview
• CC Customer Segmentation
- In-house users
- Outsourcers
• Demand
• Customer
• Economics
• Competition
• Recommendations
- Success business model
- Partnering strategy
E-Commerce Market Overview
TCI Tianjin
• Current Situation Analysis
• Recommendations
-25-
DEMAND PROJECTION DEPENDENT ON A CYCLE OF
FACTORSWide variance in projection... …dependent on a group of factors
# of call centres seats (’000)
3.5
5.2
2004 2009 2014
Virtuous or vicious cycle?
Outsourcer’s
Price
Outsourcer’s
professionalism
Customer
satisfaction
Outsourcer’s
service
sophistication
# of new
customer trial
Education effect
to potential
customers
call centres
industry
reputation
It’s hard to tell whether the industry can establish its reputation or go underdeveloped, at
the very beginning of its emergence
Demand
Outsourcer
51.2
6.6
CAGR = 100%
CAGR =
20%
CAGR = 20%
-26-
POSITIVE CUSTOMER EVOLUTION OBSERVED IN
CHINA’S call centres BUSINESS
Positive projections for future
•Historical trends showed increasing penetration into
high-end business
•China’s massive small-to-medium business constitutes
good potential customer base
•Massive un-exploited geography: outside top 3 cities
•Good outsourcer will emerge with increased business,
which will generate more business for the call centres
industry
call centres service
sophistication
TimeLow
High
Before Recent 2 years
We believe in the positive argument and project demand to grow at least 50% a year for the next 4
years
Paging service call centres for Hong
Kong
“Secretary” service
Simple telemarketing
Order taking
After-sales service
Negative projections for future
•Customer’s negative thoughts about outsourcer’s quality
haven’t changed
•Professionalism will continue to be a headache for China
service industry, including call centres
•Low-end entry (paging companies) will ruin call centres
industry’s pricing structure and make good outsourcer’s
unprofitable
Demand
Outsourcer
-27-
BALANCE BETWEEN LONG-TERM CLIENTS AND
PERIODIC ASSIGNMENTS IS CRITICAL
Customers
Outsourcer
Long-term
clients
Long-term clients are most important to the profitability of an outsourcer
Job nature
Customer
requirement
Compensation
• “Secretary” service
• Order-taking
• After-sales service
• Value-added information
• Trust between company and customer
• Training to agents
• Good understanding of clients’
business
• Smooth communication and feedback
of important information
• A monthly payment per agent seat
• Telemarketing
• Campaign/activity phone
reception
• Brand name in call centres
industry
• Trained agents and
effective management
• Information feedback
• Reasonable price
• Payment per call
Periodic
assignments
-28-
INTERVIEWED OUTSOURCER’S LONG-TERM CUSTOMER LIST
Outsourcer Long-term client Outsourced business type Location Profitable?
TCY Pfizer Pharmacy China After sales Beijing, Shanghai Deficit
CCID Call Center
China InfoWorld
(Newspaper)
Inbound service Beijing Deficit
Guangzhou Mobile
Highway & Bridge Fee collection call out Guangzhou
COMPAQ After sales Shanghai
NEC Mobile China After sales Shanghai
China Motion
China Mobile Management call centres N.A.
Profitable
Beijing Hongfan
Sun Micro Systems Simple question handling N.A.
Channel Beyond Profitable
Compaq Star Profitable
Backup
After sales
“Secretary” service
Fee collection call out
Guangzhou
Vanke Community service Guangzhou
Beijing Telecom Messaging service Beijing Deficit
95 info Nokia After sales (mobile) Beijing Deficit
800 teleservice Motorola After sales (mobile) Shanghai N.A.
ITS Pharmacy companies N.A. Shanghai Deficit
-29-
call centres SALES AND SERVICE HELPS MULTINATIONALS TO
FOCUS ON CORE CAPABILITIES
Advanced product design
Technology
Financial muscle
Operational management
Manufacturing
Distribution network
Customer relationships
Local marketing
Facilities (land, house…)
Regulatory knowhow
ServiceSourcing Manufacturing Sales
X
X
X
Multinational’s strengths
Local company’s strengths
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Customers
OutsourcerBackup
-30-
HIGH-END OUTSOURCERS ARE STILL LOSING MONEY – CAPEX HIGH AND IRR BELOW
ACCEPTED LEVELS
The key determinant: Utilization
Profitability
Economics
Outsourcer
Hi profits
Low
profits
Breakeven
Low
deficits
Hi deficits
Price/seat
(RMB/month)
0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000 30000 35000
China
Motion
Shenghua
Cheng Bo
Compaq-
Star
CCID
Hong
Fan
TCY ITS
95Info
Source: Interviews; Navigate Consulting Analysis
-31-
AGENDA
Executive Summary
Call Center Business
• Market Overview
• CC Customer Segmentation
- In-house users
- Outsourcers
• Demand
• Customer
• Economics
• Competition
• Recommendations
- Success business model
- Partnering strategy
E-Commerce Market Overview
TCI Tianjin
• Current Situation Analysis
• Recommendations
-32-
PREVIOUSLY THE LOW-PRICE/STANDARD SERVICE MODEL PROVED
SUCCESSFUL – Period 1998 - 2007
Takeaway from Interviews
Not technically
feasible
Doomed failure
Possible
to be
successful
, too?
Several
successful
examples
observed
Customize/
High-end
Standard/
low-end
Low High
High-end outsourcers CAGR 2007-2012 14%
• Easier to persuade clients to accept a high
price point
• Trust in big names
• Business not fully streamlined
- software and high-end customer
support not available
• Most assignment periodic
Well-positioned, efficient low-end outsourcers
WERE very profitable
• 70% or above business from long-term
clients
• Both equipment and human resources are
easy and cheap to source
Service
Level
Price
-33-
SUCCESSFUL HIGH-END MODEL HAS TAKEN 40% som Wiseway’s Belief
Long-term clients are most important for high-end CC outsourcer’s success
• Periodic assignment demand is inherently unstable, and demand fluctuation will
worsen utility rate
- Current high-end CC outsourcers lack long-term clients
• Strong long-term client commitments give outsourcers credibility for other call center
assignments
Prestigious long-term clients are beginning to commit to high-end outsourcers
• 95Info’s deal with Nokia in Beijing
• 800 Teleservices’s deal with Motorola in Shanghai
There are clear directions for high-end outsourcers to be profitable
• Establish long-term client base
- for a medium-sized call center, 1~2 long-term clients can turn it into profits
• Identify potential areas for CC call centres
-34-
HIGH-END OUTSOURCERS CAN DEVELOP BUSINESS ALONG
TWO DIMENSIONSCustomerpenetration
Business penetration
Establish long-term client base
1. Build relationship through
periodic assignments
2. Invite client’s equity
investment
3. Provide “one-stop shopping”
4. Serve overseas market
5. Leverage existing relationship
Target various call centres opportunities along the
value chain
Breakdown value chains to find out promising
call centres opportunities
-35-
FIVE SUCCESSFUL STRATEGIES TO WIN LONG-TERM CLIENTS...
Building relationship through periodic
assignments
Outsourcers contact clients first for periodic
assignments, such as telemarketing or promotion
call reception, and sell long-term assignments when
trust and relationships are built
• Example: Guangzhou China Motion vs P&G
Provide “one-stop shopping”
Outsourcers also provide, or have alliances to
provide, other services that are compatible to
call center service. So customers can get all
they need from one company
• Example: Guangzhou Channel Beyond
Leverage existing relationship
Outsourcers develop domestic multinationals
clients leveraging overseas relationship
• Example: 800Teleservice v.s. Motorola
Serve overseas market
Outsourcers provide low-cost services to Hong
Kong, Taiwan or other overseas clients by
leveraging low-cost agents and language
ability in China
• Example: Guangzhou Shenghua
Invite client’s equity investment
Outsourcers ask an important client to make
equity investment, in order to lock in the
relationship and establish needed trust
• Example: Compaq-Star
Strategies proved
successful
1
2 3
4 5
-36-
… EACH WITH ITS UNIQUE ADVANTAGES AND
DISADVANTAGES
Cons
• Lowered entry barrier into
potential clients
• Easier to build relationship and
mutual trust
• Time consuming
• Periodic assignments might not necessarily turn
to long-term commitment
• Lock-in relationships
• Shared risks
• Controlled by clients
• Limited opportunities for other clients
- restrained growth
• Increased customer satisfaction
• Stronger advantages against all
competitors at “one-stop” area
• Strengths restrained in one particular area
• Difficult to extend business to other areas
• Profitable business
• Stable client relationship once
obtained
• Competition
• Generally low-end services
- clients only pursue “low-cost”
• Difficult to acquire overseas clients
• Monopolized client base
• Familiar service standard
• Leverageable software and
management
• Not a lot
• Bad service in China might deteriorate
corporate’s relationship to the outsourcer
Building relationship
through periodic
assignments
Invite client’s equity
investment
Provide “one-stop
shopping”
Serve overseas market
Leverage existing
relationship
1
2
3
4
5
Pros
-37-
call centres MOST PROMISING FOR TELEMARKETING AND
VALUE-ADDED INFORMATION SERVICES
Potential Call Center Adoption Areas
After-sales service
Value-added
information
service
Trouble-
shooting
Complaint
handling
Concerns
Service
quality
Industry
knowledge
Information
processing
Confidentiality
Manu-
facturin
g
Sourcing
Ordering Supplier
mgmt.
Sales
Tele-
marketing
Inquiry
handling
Order
taking
Most
promising
Most
promising
Not a concern
Significant concerns
-38-
call centres OPPORTUNITIES FOR SELECTED INDUSTRIES (I)
Value Chain Breakdown for Sales and ServicesAftersalesservice
Trouble-
shooting
Complaint
handling
Tele-
marketing
Customer
inquiry
handling
Order
taking
Value-added
information
service
Sales
Industry
Telecom
• Complaint reception
• Customer satisfaction survey
Mobile service
• Complaint reception
• Phone-line problem calling
• General trouble - shooting
• Mobile problem calling
(lost, disconnected)
• Call dialing helpdesk
• Phone number inquiry (“114”)
• Phone bill information, etc.
• “Secretary” service
• Phone bill inquiry
• Fixed-line service application
• Other value-added service application
• Mobile service application
• Value-added service application
• Potential customer call-in reception • Potential customer call-in reception
• Long-distance service promotion
• General information of new
products/services
• New service/products promotion
Likely
Unlikely
-39-
call centres OPPORTUNITIES FOR SELECTED INDUSTRIES (II)
Value Chain Breakdown for Sales and ServicesAftersalesservice
Trouble-
shooting
Complaint
handling
Tele-
marketing
Customer
inquiry
handling
Order
taking
Value-added
information
service
Sales
Industry
Banking
• General complaint
handling
Securities
• General complaint
handling
• General trouble-shooting • General trouble-shooting
• Telephone banking
• Personal financial
consulting
• Investment analysis,
suggestion,etc
• General market
information
• Deposit or other orders • Telephone transaction
• General question handling • General question handling
• New service promotion
• Corporate client
relationship building
N.A.
Insurance
• General complaint
handling
• General trouble-shooting
N.A.
• Telephone transaction
• General question
handling
• Promotion of insurance
policies
Likely
Unlikely
-40-
call centres OPPORTUNITIES FOR SELECTED INDUSTRIES (III)
Value Chain Breakdown for Sales and Services
Aftersalesservice
Trouble-
shooting
Complaint
handling
Tele-
marketing
Customer
inquiry
handling
Order
taking
Value-added
information
service
Sales
Industry
Technology Home appliance
• Technology guidance
• Consulting
N.A.
Fast-moving consumer
goods
N.A.
Likely
Unlikely
-41-
AGENDA
Executive Summary
Call Center Business
• Market Overview
• CC Customer Segmentation
- In-house users
- Outsourcers
• Demand
• Customer
• Economics
• Competition
• Recommendations
- Success business model
- Partnering strategy
E-Commerce Market Overview
TCI Tianjin
• Current Situation Analysis
• Recommendations
-42-
ONLY A PARTNERSHIP FITS INTO TCI’S SPECIFICATION
Self-construct a
call center
Partner with local
CC outsourcers
Provide CC call
centres training,
management and
consulting
• No China experience in call center
• No enough human resources to commit
• Little local client knowledge
• Time consuming
• Complement TCI’s local capabilities
• Satisfy time stringency concerns
• Commit little TCI resources
• Serve TCI’s potential clients well with
existing capacity
• Fit into TCI’s strengths well
• Demand less TCI’s commitment
However
• Need to establish local facilities and assign
knowledgeable people to China
• Profits will not be big
Maybe an
opportunity


-43-
TCI SHOULD ALLY WITH A LOCAL PARTNER TO ENTER INTO THE
MARKET
Now is good to enter...
• Nevertheless, China CC call centres
segment is a fast growing market
• There are few high-profile CC call centres
companies in China
• Competition at high-end is not severe
• And…, TCI is in discussion with two
possible long-term clients
… But should ally with a local outsourcer
TCI lacks a lot of local capacities
• Local market understanding
• Local clients relationship
• Experienced agents
• Language
…
And time is tight
• A decision should be made very soon
A local partner with complementary capabilities is ideal for TCI’s fast
rollout in China
-44-
DIFFICULT TO FIND A PARTNER SATISFYING ALL CRITERIA
• Strong local market
understanding
• Good local client
relationship
Provide TCI with
most needed
capabilities
1 Be profitable Demand not too
much TCI’s
involvement
Allow TCI to
develop own brand
and share client
base
2 3 4
Partner’s
profile
• Mature, professional
operations
• Experienced agents
• Sufficient long-term
client base
• Strong, mature
operations already
• Probably not strong
self-brand and
customer base
• Eagerly in need of
TCI’s client, money,
management
What TCI
might
face
• Command very high valuation for its shares
- TCI probably have to pay more under time pressure
• Stick to its right of control
- might agree in appearance, but suffocate in action TCI’s brand
building efforts
• Persist on its own business practice
- TCI might feel difficult to configure to “Japanese standard”
• The outsourcer might
be very bad
- no local client base
- losing money
- low morale
• TCI has to invest a lot
- money
- human resources
-45-
Partnership Strategy
Partner with strong,
money-making local
outsourcers
Partner with money-
losing, but high-end
equipped local
outsourcers
• Leverage partner’s
capabilities to
expand business
• Demand less TCI
investment
• Create synergy
more easily
• Leverage partner’s
advanced facilities
• Easy to control and
develop TCI’s own
brand
• Might be cheap
TWO POTENTIAL PARTNERSHIP STRATEGY SUGGESTED
Reflecting Different Entry Focus
Advantages Disadvantage Entry Focus
• Expensive
• Hard to control
• Potential conflict
with TCI’s practice
• Profit sharing
• Fast rollout
• Synergy creation
• TCI might not benefit
too much from local
partner
• TCI has to invest a
lot
• High risk is entailed
• Control
• TCI brand and
practice
development
• A bargain deal
-46-
FIVE POTENTIAL TARGETS IDENTIFIED
• China Motion
• 800 Teleservice
• Compaq-Star
• Cooperativeness
• Understanding of each other’s
business
• Local outsourcer’s valuation
• % of shares participated
• Profit sharing theme
• TCI brand and practice development
plan
• Shared vision and willingness to
cooperate
• A good price
Money making
• TCY
• ITS Shanghai
• Technology and equipment
advancement
• Controlling shareholding
• Local outsourcer’s valuation
- negotiate for a bargaining price
• TCI’s needed commitment to the new
venture
• A bargaining price
• Total control
Money losing
Names
Negotiation
priorities
When to
decide
TCI should proceed both options simultaneously, and choose a best option in the end
-47-
AGENDA
Executive Summary
Call Center Business
• Market Overview
• CC Customer Segmentation
- In-house users
- Outsourcers
• Demand
• Customer
• Economics
• Competition
• Recommendations
- Success business model
- Partnering strategy
E-Commerce Market Overview
TCI Tianjin
• Current Situation Analysis
• Recommendations
-48-
TCI-TJ EXPERIENCED TREMENDOUS DIFFICULTIES (I)
Most projects not profitable Overhead out of control
Rev.
Profit rate
-200%
-150%
-100%
-50%
0%
50%
100%
16%
-170%
35% 51%
61% 69% 98% 100%
2010
(’000 RMB)
508 997
2575
1758
1990
Gross profit
Salary
Management
fee
Depre.
Misc.
Source: TCI-TJ; Navigate Consulting Analysis
-49-
TCI-TJ EXPERIENCED TREMENDOUS DIFFICULTIES (II)
Programmer’s turnover is
worrying
Utilization rate is low
Human resource
• From official statistics, on
average about 1/3 of
programmer’s working hours
were not staffed, real
situation can be worse
Real estate
• The whole second floor was
empty, while a depreciation
of RMB 2.4 million, 60% of
1999 revenue, is counted
each year as cost
Project schedule often out of
control
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
Total recruited Left
Label
Programmers turnover
(7)
(1)
(20)
(5)
(4)
17
4
28
15
5
A 2011 project
People staffed
(4)
(1)
Time3
months
1 year
2 years
Planned
Actual
Source: TCI-TJ; Navigate Consulting Analysis
-50-
FIVE ROOT CAUSES IDENTIFIED FOR THESE PROBLEMS
Overhead out of
control
Over-invested
Project out of
control
Inadequate
programmer’s
training
Most projects not
profitable
Ineffective and not
disciplined sales
efforts
Low resources
utilization
Programmers not
motivated properly
Worrying
programmer’s
turnover
Compensation and
progression not
enough to retain
HR
-51-
TCI-TJ IS NOT COMPETITIVE IN DOMESTIC SOFTWARE
MARKET
High fixed cost Ineffective domestic sales force
No sales department
Previous sales activities restrained in Tianjin
• And mainly through Japanese invested
companies
Targeting domestic customers means additional
investment on HR and spending
• With unforeseeable results
Equivalent domestic
company
TCI
Annual cost
(RMB ’000)
945
(1) With same actively-used office space, at a metropolitan location in Tianjin
Office cost example
83%
10%
7%
2926
Depreciation
Tax
Land
(1)
-52-
AGENDA
Executive Summary
Call Center Business
• Market Overview
• CC Customer Segmentation
- In-house users
- Outsourcers
• Demand
• Customer
• Economics
• Competition
• Recommendations
- Success business model
- Partnering strategy
E-Commerce Market Overview
TCI Tianjin
• Current Situation Analysis
• Recommendations
-53-
TCI-TJ CAN DEVELOP ALONG TWO PATHS
Restructure for better
performance
Questions are:
• What are advantages and potential risks entailed in different path?
• Which one to choose?
New business development
Introduce TCI Japan’s best-of-
breed technology to China through
TCI-TJ
Existing business penetration and
finance operation
Find strategic alliance for TCI-TJ
-54-
RESTRUCTURING FOR BETTER PERFORMANCE
• Transplant company’s vision to
each employee’s mind
• Create better culture through
informal interactive channels
• Mentor system
• Company activities
• “General Manager Day”
• Declare what should not
be done
- Policies and rules
• Establish a scientific
system to evaluate,
incentivize, and promote
staff
- Staff, evaluation,
compensation and
promotion
Customer strategy
• Focus on Japanese market and
Japanese companies around Tianjin
HR strategy
• Retain and promote the best people
in the company
• Create a programmer-centric
organization
Production strategy
• Adjust product and programming to
satisfy Japanese client
specifications
• Aspire to efficient production
• Improve HR utilization rate
Mission
• Turn into profitability in the next several years
• Develop TCI-TJ’s capability in software programming and service
• Retain best human resources
Belief system
Interactive
control
system
Boundary
system
Diagnostic
system
Control and
measurement system
-55-
ESTABLISH A THREE-TIER HIERARCHY IN PROGRAMMER’S
TEAM
Technology
Director
Project
Manager
Senior programmer
Junior programmer
After 2-4
years
After 1-3
years
College
undergraduate
Out
Out
Responsibilities
Project manager
• Control the quality and time
commitment of a project
• Choose and motivate a
programmer’ team to get the
job done
Technology director
• Provide technical guidance
• Supervise project quality
Senior programmer
• Be in charge of specific
module in a project
• Undertake on-job training
roles to junior programmer
Junior programmer: probation
position
• Program under instruction and
supervision of project
managers
• Learn fast to get promotion
Rights
• Full rights to choose how
many, and which programmer
to get staffed on the team
• Full right to control the project
progress
• Right to choose whether he
would like to be put on a
project
• Right to request mentor on
technical support
• Right to choose whether to be
staffed on a project
Evaluation
• Whether the project is
completed under budget and
time target
• Whether subordinate
programmers are satisfied with
project management and
learning
• Whether clients are satisfied
• Whether he has done an
effective job in handling a
module
• Whether he coached junior
programmers effectively
• Whether he has done an
effective job as a programmer
• Whether he has learned fast
-56-
HUGE BENEFITS OF BUILDING A THREE-TIER HIERARCHY
• Project managers are motivated to successfully compete the project as quickly as
possible
- evaluated by customer satisfaction and time/budget consumed
• Project managers won’t abuse human resources
- better-off to select a small but capable programmer’s team
• Good programmers will be the king in the company: Strong incentive to be good
- treasured by every project manager: Enough good project to do
- compensated well and promoted fast
- incapable programmers will feel not well and have to leave the company
• Junior programmers will have enough training and opportunities to perform
• Senior management is disciplined to their sales efforts
- overly sold projects will be objected by project managers
Project management
HR development
Sales efforts
-57-
TWO TYPES OF STRATEGIC ALLIANCES PROPOSED
TCI-TJ
Advantages
• Use partner’s human
resources
• Benefit from partner’s
brand name
• Leverage partner’s client
base
• Introduce partner’s
management skills
• Retain huge potential
upside
- IPO process will boost
investment return
• Achieve potential
synergies between a
software company and an
E-commerce company
Disadvantages
• Very difficult to find such
a partner
- good companies
probably will find TCI-
TJ unattractive
• Lost control
• Potential risk of cultural
conflict
• Increasing risk of a
satisfactory IPO
• Partner’s experience of
working with a software
programmer
• Morale at TCI-TJ
Wiseway’s preference
Not
preferred
Preferred
Sell, or partner with
a local esteemed
software
programmer
Partner with a local
system integrator,
or E-commerce
company with IPO
potential
We will discuss partnership list in detail in the next part
-58-
Thank You?
Questions
John Gregg,
Principal,
Navigate Consulting Pty Ltd
Ph: +61 402 493 278
Email: johng@navigateconsulting.com.au
Web: www.navigatecoonsulting.com.au

Contenu connexe

En vedette

Martec China Medical Reform
Martec China Medical ReformMartec China Medical Reform
Martec China Medical Reformkaiguo1999
 
2014 navigate-what really drives customer satisfaction with their health insu...
2014 navigate-what really drives customer satisfaction with their health insu...2014 navigate-what really drives customer satisfaction with their health insu...
2014 navigate-what really drives customer satisfaction with their health insu...Navigate Consulting Australia Pty Ltd
 
2013 Navigate-cost containment in West Australian healthcare-our perspective
2013 Navigate-cost containment in West Australian healthcare-our perspective2013 Navigate-cost containment in West Australian healthcare-our perspective
2013 Navigate-cost containment in West Australian healthcare-our perspectiveNavigate Consulting Australia Pty Ltd
 

En vedette (20)

2013- multiplying the contribution of chinese tourism to qld
2013- multiplying the contribution of chinese tourism to qld2013- multiplying the contribution of chinese tourism to qld
2013- multiplying the contribution of chinese tourism to qld
 
2015 navigate what makes successful innovation
2015 navigate what makes successful innovation2015 navigate what makes successful innovation
2015 navigate what makes successful innovation
 
2015 navigate-services marketing-what the winners do differently
2015 navigate-services marketing-what the winners do differently2015 navigate-services marketing-what the winners do differently
2015 navigate-services marketing-what the winners do differently
 
2015 - Navigate Consulting-Project Management Masterclass
2015 - Navigate Consulting-Project Management Masterclass2015 - Navigate Consulting-Project Management Masterclass
2015 - Navigate Consulting-Project Management Masterclass
 
2014 navigate-global megatrends
2014 navigate-global megatrends2014 navigate-global megatrends
2014 navigate-global megatrends
 
2011 navigate-dairy indust-global-fact_base
2011 navigate-dairy indust-global-fact_base2011 navigate-dairy indust-global-fact_base
2011 navigate-dairy indust-global-fact_base
 
2015 developments in global gas markets & impact on asia
2015 developments in global gas markets & impact on asia2015 developments in global gas markets & impact on asia
2015 developments in global gas markets & impact on asia
 
2014-The Future of Non Conventional Energy
2014-The Future of Non Conventional Energy2014-The Future of Non Conventional Energy
2014-The Future of Non Conventional Energy
 
Martec China Medical Reform
Martec China Medical ReformMartec China Medical Reform
Martec China Medical Reform
 
2014 navigate-what really drives customer satisfaction with their health insu...
2014 navigate-what really drives customer satisfaction with their health insu...2014 navigate-what really drives customer satisfaction with their health insu...
2014 navigate-what really drives customer satisfaction with their health insu...
 
2015 navigate-wine to china-the next gold rush
2015 navigate-wine to china-the next gold rush2015 navigate-wine to china-the next gold rush
2015 navigate-wine to china-the next gold rush
 
2015 john gregg-navigate-menopause mkt research australia
2015 john gregg-navigate-menopause mkt research australia2015 john gregg-navigate-menopause mkt research australia
2015 john gregg-navigate-menopause mkt research australia
 
Tourism Australia-Business Events Strategy
Tourism Australia-Business Events StrategyTourism Australia-Business Events Strategy
Tourism Australia-Business Events Strategy
 
2013 Navigate-cost containment in West Australian healthcare-our perspective
2013 Navigate-cost containment in West Australian healthcare-our perspective2013 Navigate-cost containment in West Australian healthcare-our perspective
2013 Navigate-cost containment in West Australian healthcare-our perspective
 
Bristol Myers Squibb China
Bristol Myers Squibb ChinaBristol Myers Squibb China
Bristol Myers Squibb China
 
LVMH-Modern Premium Brands
LVMH-Modern Premium BrandsLVMH-Modern Premium Brands
LVMH-Modern Premium Brands
 
2014 navigate-a guide to marketing planning
2014 navigate-a guide to marketing planning2014 navigate-a guide to marketing planning
2014 navigate-a guide to marketing planning
 
2011 spend reduction guide-masterclass
2011 spend reduction guide-masterclass2011 spend reduction guide-masterclass
2011 spend reduction guide-masterclass
 
2014-Navigate-Essentials Foundations of Market Entry Strategies
2014-Navigate-Essentials Foundations of Market Entry Strategies2014-Navigate-Essentials Foundations of Market Entry Strategies
2014-Navigate-Essentials Foundations of Market Entry Strategies
 
2013 navigate-managing your brand as an asset
2013 navigate-managing your brand as an asset2013 navigate-managing your brand as an asset
2013 navigate-managing your brand as an asset
 

Similaire à 2013 john gregg-navigate consult-trans cosmos-china mkt entry-call centre

Transcom investor presentation_may 14
Transcom investor presentation_may 14Transcom investor presentation_may 14
Transcom investor presentation_may 14Transcom
 
IIT K Maverick Regional Round
IIT K Maverick Regional RoundIIT K Maverick Regional Round
IIT K Maverick Regional RoundVishnu Raj
 
TULIP.India is the fastest growing and the 2nd largest telecom market in the ...
TULIP.India is the fastest growing and the 2nd largest telecom market in the ...TULIP.India is the fastest growing and the 2nd largest telecom market in the ...
TULIP.India is the fastest growing and the 2nd largest telecom market in the ...Unitedworld School Of Business
 
Tcs ir presentation_apr_2013
Tcs ir presentation_apr_2013Tcs ir presentation_apr_2013
Tcs ir presentation_apr_2013Zhokpo Sangay
 
Massive Operating Efficiencies of the Digital Customer Experience
Massive Operating Efficiencies of the Digital Customer ExperienceMassive Operating Efficiencies of the Digital Customer Experience
Massive Operating Efficiencies of the Digital Customer ExperienceCourse5i
 
Chris Day, VP Strategy & Performance - AstraZeneca
Chris Day, VP Strategy & Performance - AstraZenecaChris Day, VP Strategy & Performance - AstraZeneca
Chris Day, VP Strategy & Performance - AstraZenecaGlobal Business Intelligence
 
About East Coast Catalyst (Prepared by Tim Bourgeois)
About East Coast Catalyst (Prepared by Tim Bourgeois)About East Coast Catalyst (Prepared by Tim Bourgeois)
About East Coast Catalyst (Prepared by Tim Bourgeois)Tim Bourgeois
 
CRN Intelligence Subscription Package
CRN Intelligence Subscription PackageCRN Intelligence Subscription Package
CRN Intelligence Subscription PackageIncisive Media
 
Corporate strategy in IT sector
Corporate strategy in IT sectorCorporate strategy in IT sector
Corporate strategy in IT sectorAakash Panchal
 
Reliance Communication Sip presentation
Reliance Communication Sip presentationReliance Communication Sip presentation
Reliance Communication Sip presentationVicky Sharma
 
Project report on reliance
Project report on relianceProject report on reliance
Project report on reliance9928424289
 
Thasmai Automation & Consumer Electronics plan
Thasmai Automation & Consumer Electronics planThasmai Automation & Consumer Electronics plan
Thasmai Automation & Consumer Electronics planVijay Chengappa
 
Cool Vendors In Application Services
Cool Vendors In Application ServicesCool Vendors In Application Services
Cool Vendors In Application Servicesjgabster
 
Supply chain management For Axiata
Supply chain management For AxiataSupply chain management For Axiata
Supply chain management For Axiata蔡 阜晋
 
Fairchild Semiconductor - September 2014 Investor Presentation
Fairchild Semiconductor - September 2014 Investor PresentationFairchild Semiconductor - September 2014 Investor Presentation
Fairchild Semiconductor - September 2014 Investor PresentationCompany Spotlight
 

Similaire à 2013 john gregg-navigate consult-trans cosmos-china mkt entry-call centre (20)

Business Analytics: A Strategic Imperative
Business Analytics: A Strategic ImperativeBusiness Analytics: A Strategic Imperative
Business Analytics: A Strategic Imperative
 
Transcom investor presentation_may 14
Transcom investor presentation_may 14Transcom investor presentation_may 14
Transcom investor presentation_may 14
 
IIT K Maverick Regional Round
IIT K Maverick Regional RoundIIT K Maverick Regional Round
IIT K Maverick Regional Round
 
TULIP.India is the fastest growing and the 2nd largest telecom market in the ...
TULIP.India is the fastest growing and the 2nd largest telecom market in the ...TULIP.India is the fastest growing and the 2nd largest telecom market in the ...
TULIP.India is the fastest growing and the 2nd largest telecom market in the ...
 
Tcs ir presentation_apr_2013
Tcs ir presentation_apr_2013Tcs ir presentation_apr_2013
Tcs ir presentation_apr_2013
 
CHALLENGES.pptx
CHALLENGES.pptxCHALLENGES.pptx
CHALLENGES.pptx
 
CHALLENGES.pptx
CHALLENGES.pptxCHALLENGES.pptx
CHALLENGES.pptx
 
It services in telecom
It services in telecomIt services in telecom
It services in telecom
 
Massive Operating Efficiencies of the Digital Customer Experience
Massive Operating Efficiencies of the Digital Customer ExperienceMassive Operating Efficiencies of the Digital Customer Experience
Massive Operating Efficiencies of the Digital Customer Experience
 
Chris Day, VP Strategy & Performance - AstraZeneca
Chris Day, VP Strategy & Performance - AstraZenecaChris Day, VP Strategy & Performance - AstraZeneca
Chris Day, VP Strategy & Performance - AstraZeneca
 
About East Coast Catalyst (Prepared by Tim Bourgeois)
About East Coast Catalyst (Prepared by Tim Bourgeois)About East Coast Catalyst (Prepared by Tim Bourgeois)
About East Coast Catalyst (Prepared by Tim Bourgeois)
 
CRN Intelligence Subscription Package
CRN Intelligence Subscription PackageCRN Intelligence Subscription Package
CRN Intelligence Subscription Package
 
Corporate strategy in IT sector
Corporate strategy in IT sectorCorporate strategy in IT sector
Corporate strategy in IT sector
 
Reliance Communication Sip presentation
Reliance Communication Sip presentationReliance Communication Sip presentation
Reliance Communication Sip presentation
 
Project report on reliance
Project report on relianceProject report on reliance
Project report on reliance
 
Thasmai Automation & Consumer Electronics plan
Thasmai Automation & Consumer Electronics planThasmai Automation & Consumer Electronics plan
Thasmai Automation & Consumer Electronics plan
 
Cool Vendors In Application Services
Cool Vendors In Application ServicesCool Vendors In Application Services
Cool Vendors In Application Services
 
Supply chain management For Axiata
Supply chain management For AxiataSupply chain management For Axiata
Supply chain management For Axiata
 
Dialog presentation
Dialog presentationDialog presentation
Dialog presentation
 
Fairchild Semiconductor - September 2014 Investor Presentation
Fairchild Semiconductor - September 2014 Investor PresentationFairchild Semiconductor - September 2014 Investor Presentation
Fairchild Semiconductor - September 2014 Investor Presentation
 

Plus de Navigate Consulting Australia Pty Ltd

2014-john gregg-WA Labor:"Fatally Flawed Domestic Violence in Western Australia"
2014-john gregg-WA Labor:"Fatally Flawed Domestic Violence in Western Australia"2014-john gregg-WA Labor:"Fatally Flawed Domestic Violence in Western Australia"
2014-john gregg-WA Labor:"Fatally Flawed Domestic Violence in Western Australia"Navigate Consulting Australia Pty Ltd
 

Plus de Navigate Consulting Australia Pty Ltd (15)

Writing a compelling business plan
Writing a compelling business planWriting a compelling business plan
Writing a compelling business plan
 
Resonate - Presenting Stories That Transform Your Audience
Resonate - Presenting Stories That Transform Your AudienceResonate - Presenting Stories That Transform Your Audience
Resonate - Presenting Stories That Transform Your Audience
 
APG Silver Award-Toyota Landcruiser
APG Silver Award-Toyota LandcruiserAPG Silver Award-Toyota Landcruiser
APG Silver Award-Toyota Landcruiser
 
Corporate Cost Reduction
Corporate Cost ReductionCorporate Cost Reduction
Corporate Cost Reduction
 
2014-john gregg-WA Labor:"Fatally Flawed Domestic Violence in Western Australia"
2014-john gregg-WA Labor:"Fatally Flawed Domestic Violence in Western Australia"2014-john gregg-WA Labor:"Fatally Flawed Domestic Violence in Western Australia"
2014-john gregg-WA Labor:"Fatally Flawed Domestic Violence in Western Australia"
 
2009 john gregg-monitor-china-medical devices-risks & rewards
2009 john gregg-monitor-china-medical devices-risks & rewards2009 john gregg-monitor-china-medical devices-risks & rewards
2009 john gregg-monitor-china-medical devices-risks & rewards
 
2010 monitor-john gregg-tc logistics strategy
2010 monitor-john gregg-tc logistics strategy2010 monitor-john gregg-tc logistics strategy
2010 monitor-john gregg-tc logistics strategy
 
2007 monitor-mulino bianco-us-market_entry
2007 monitor-mulino bianco-us-market_entry2007 monitor-mulino bianco-us-market_entry
2007 monitor-mulino bianco-us-market_entry
 
2008 monitor-the bank-of_new_york-_re-branding
2008 monitor-the bank-of_new_york-_re-branding2008 monitor-the bank-of_new_york-_re-branding
2008 monitor-the bank-of_new_york-_re-branding
 
2007 monitor-club med-world_wide_
2007 monitor-club med-world_wide_2007 monitor-club med-world_wide_
2007 monitor-club med-world_wide_
 
2010 navigate-university branding-_rmit_case_study
2010 navigate-university branding-_rmit_case_study2010 navigate-university branding-_rmit_case_study
2010 navigate-university branding-_rmit_case_study
 
2009 china microwaves strategy
2009 china microwaves strategy2009 china microwaves strategy
2009 china microwaves strategy
 
2013 asia pacific-global_hotel_chain_growth_strategy
2013 asia pacific-global_hotel_chain_growth_strategy2013 asia pacific-global_hotel_chain_growth_strategy
2013 asia pacific-global_hotel_chain_growth_strategy
 
2010 driving africas-competiteness_in_agribusiness
2010 driving africas-competiteness_in_agribusiness2010 driving africas-competiteness_in_agribusiness
2010 driving africas-competiteness_in_agribusiness
 
2010-Firm Valuation Masterclass
2010-Firm Valuation Masterclass2010-Firm Valuation Masterclass
2010-Firm Valuation Masterclass
 

Dernier

Abdul Kader Baba- Managing Cybersecurity Risks and Compliance Requirements i...
Abdul Kader Baba- Managing Cybersecurity Risks  and Compliance Requirements i...Abdul Kader Baba- Managing Cybersecurity Risks  and Compliance Requirements i...
Abdul Kader Baba- Managing Cybersecurity Risks and Compliance Requirements i...itnewsafrica
 
Top 10 Hubspot Development Companies in 2024
Top 10 Hubspot Development Companies in 2024Top 10 Hubspot Development Companies in 2024
Top 10 Hubspot Development Companies in 2024TopCSSGallery
 
Modern Roaming for Notes and Nomad – Cheaper Faster Better Stronger
Modern Roaming for Notes and Nomad – Cheaper Faster Better StrongerModern Roaming for Notes and Nomad – Cheaper Faster Better Stronger
Modern Roaming for Notes and Nomad – Cheaper Faster Better Strongerpanagenda
 
The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...
The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...
The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...Wes McKinney
 
Scale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL Router
Scale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL RouterScale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL Router
Scale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL RouterMydbops
 
Connecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdf
Connecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdfConnecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdf
Connecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdfNeo4j
 
Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pdf
Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pdfMoving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pdf
Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pdfLoriGlavin3
 
Microservices, Docker deploy and Microservices source code in C#
Microservices, Docker deploy and Microservices source code in C#Microservices, Docker deploy and Microservices source code in C#
Microservices, Docker deploy and Microservices source code in C#Karmanjay Verma
 
Bridging Between CAD & GIS: 6 Ways to Automate Your Data Integration
Bridging Between CAD & GIS:  6 Ways to Automate Your Data IntegrationBridging Between CAD & GIS:  6 Ways to Automate Your Data Integration
Bridging Between CAD & GIS: 6 Ways to Automate Your Data Integrationmarketing932765
 
Potential of AI (Generative AI) in Business: Learnings and Insights
Potential of AI (Generative AI) in Business: Learnings and InsightsPotential of AI (Generative AI) in Business: Learnings and Insights
Potential of AI (Generative AI) in Business: Learnings and InsightsRavi Sanghani
 
Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC SalesData and LibraryData -...
Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC SalesData and LibraryData -...Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC SalesData and LibraryData -...
Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC SalesData and LibraryData -...BookNet Canada
 
React Native vs Ionic - The Best Mobile App Framework
React Native vs Ionic - The Best Mobile App FrameworkReact Native vs Ionic - The Best Mobile App Framework
React Native vs Ionic - The Best Mobile App FrameworkPixlogix Infotech
 
Data governance with Unity Catalog Presentation
Data governance with Unity Catalog PresentationData governance with Unity Catalog Presentation
Data governance with Unity Catalog PresentationKnoldus Inc.
 
[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance
[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance
[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality AssuranceInflectra
 
A Journey Into the Emotions of Software Developers
A Journey Into the Emotions of Software DevelopersA Journey Into the Emotions of Software Developers
A Journey Into the Emotions of Software DevelopersNicole Novielli
 
Use of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Use of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxUse of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Use of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxLoriGlavin3
 
Digital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Digital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxDigital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Digital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxLoriGlavin3
 
Microsoft 365 Copilot: How to boost your productivity with AI – Part one: Ado...
Microsoft 365 Copilot: How to boost your productivity with AI – Part one: Ado...Microsoft 365 Copilot: How to boost your productivity with AI – Part one: Ado...
Microsoft 365 Copilot: How to boost your productivity with AI – Part one: Ado...Nikki Chapple
 
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyesHow to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyesThousandEyes
 
Glenn Lazarus- Why Your Observability Strategy Needs Security Observability
Glenn Lazarus- Why Your Observability Strategy Needs Security ObservabilityGlenn Lazarus- Why Your Observability Strategy Needs Security Observability
Glenn Lazarus- Why Your Observability Strategy Needs Security Observabilityitnewsafrica
 

Dernier (20)

Abdul Kader Baba- Managing Cybersecurity Risks and Compliance Requirements i...
Abdul Kader Baba- Managing Cybersecurity Risks  and Compliance Requirements i...Abdul Kader Baba- Managing Cybersecurity Risks  and Compliance Requirements i...
Abdul Kader Baba- Managing Cybersecurity Risks and Compliance Requirements i...
 
Top 10 Hubspot Development Companies in 2024
Top 10 Hubspot Development Companies in 2024Top 10 Hubspot Development Companies in 2024
Top 10 Hubspot Development Companies in 2024
 
Modern Roaming for Notes and Nomad – Cheaper Faster Better Stronger
Modern Roaming for Notes and Nomad – Cheaper Faster Better StrongerModern Roaming for Notes and Nomad – Cheaper Faster Better Stronger
Modern Roaming for Notes and Nomad – Cheaper Faster Better Stronger
 
The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...
The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...
The Future Roadmap for the Composable Data Stack - Wes McKinney - Data Counci...
 
Scale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL Router
Scale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL RouterScale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL Router
Scale your database traffic with Read & Write split using MySQL Router
 
Connecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdf
Connecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdfConnecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdf
Connecting the Dots for Information Discovery.pdf
 
Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pdf
Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pdfMoving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pdf
Moving Beyond Passwords: FIDO Paris Seminar.pdf
 
Microservices, Docker deploy and Microservices source code in C#
Microservices, Docker deploy and Microservices source code in C#Microservices, Docker deploy and Microservices source code in C#
Microservices, Docker deploy and Microservices source code in C#
 
Bridging Between CAD & GIS: 6 Ways to Automate Your Data Integration
Bridging Between CAD & GIS:  6 Ways to Automate Your Data IntegrationBridging Between CAD & GIS:  6 Ways to Automate Your Data Integration
Bridging Between CAD & GIS: 6 Ways to Automate Your Data Integration
 
Potential of AI (Generative AI) in Business: Learnings and Insights
Potential of AI (Generative AI) in Business: Learnings and InsightsPotential of AI (Generative AI) in Business: Learnings and Insights
Potential of AI (Generative AI) in Business: Learnings and Insights
 
Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC SalesData and LibraryData -...
Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC SalesData and LibraryData -...Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC SalesData and LibraryData -...
Transcript: New from BookNet Canada for 2024: BNC SalesData and LibraryData -...
 
React Native vs Ionic - The Best Mobile App Framework
React Native vs Ionic - The Best Mobile App FrameworkReact Native vs Ionic - The Best Mobile App Framework
React Native vs Ionic - The Best Mobile App Framework
 
Data governance with Unity Catalog Presentation
Data governance with Unity Catalog PresentationData governance with Unity Catalog Presentation
Data governance with Unity Catalog Presentation
 
[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance
[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance
[Webinar] SpiraTest - Setting New Standards in Quality Assurance
 
A Journey Into the Emotions of Software Developers
A Journey Into the Emotions of Software DevelopersA Journey Into the Emotions of Software Developers
A Journey Into the Emotions of Software Developers
 
Use of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Use of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxUse of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Use of FIDO in the Payments and Identity Landscape: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
 
Digital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Digital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptxDigital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
Digital Identity is Under Attack: FIDO Paris Seminar.pptx
 
Microsoft 365 Copilot: How to boost your productivity with AI – Part one: Ado...
Microsoft 365 Copilot: How to boost your productivity with AI – Part one: Ado...Microsoft 365 Copilot: How to boost your productivity with AI – Part one: Ado...
Microsoft 365 Copilot: How to boost your productivity with AI – Part one: Ado...
 
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyesHow to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
How to Effectively Monitor SD-WAN and SASE Environments with ThousandEyes
 
Glenn Lazarus- Why Your Observability Strategy Needs Security Observability
Glenn Lazarus- Why Your Observability Strategy Needs Security ObservabilityGlenn Lazarus- Why Your Observability Strategy Needs Security Observability
Glenn Lazarus- Why Your Observability Strategy Needs Security Observability
 

2013 john gregg-navigate consult-trans cosmos-china mkt entry-call centre

  • 1. -1- ENTRY FOR PROFIT TRANS-COSMOS INC. CHINA ENTRY STRATEGY PRESENTATION February 8, 2013 John Gregg, Principal, Navigate Consulting Pty Ltd
  • 2. -2- AGENDA Executive Summary Call Center Business • Market Overview • CC Customer Segmentation - In-house users - Outsourcers • Demand • Customer • Economics • Competition • Recommendations - Success business model - Partnering strategy E-Commerce Market Overview TCI Tianjin • Current Situation Analysis • Recommendations
  • 3. -3- AGENDA Executive Summary Call Center Business • Market Overview • CC Customer Segmentation - In-house users - Outsourcers • Demand • Customer • Economics • Competition • Recommendations - Success business model - Partnering strategy E-Commerce Market Overview TCI Tianjin • Current Situation Analysis • Recommendations
  • 4. -4- CHINA IS BECOMING A HIGHLY DYNAMIC CC MARKET China’s call center market took off in 1998 with an annual growth rate over 100% • Non-paging market size reached 364,000 seats in 2012 However past growth was largely driven by demands from administrative driven sector • In 2011, over 60% CC demand comes from four pillar industries: Banking, Post Services, Fixed-line Telecom, and Insurance • Distinctive purchasing behavior identified for these purchases Future growth will be propelled by service oriented and call centres segments • call centres market will grow at least 35% a year for the next few years - However large variance exists for call centres segment growth Overall, China Call Centres created over 360K seats in 2012 and 430K seats in 2015
  • 5. -5- AND IS GAINING GROUND ON KEY DECISION CRITERIA Multiple call centres destinations around the world have sprung up as supplier bases. • Besides India and China, popular locations include the Philippines, Malaysia, Romania, Ukraine, Brazil and Mexico. Multiple surveys point to new location preferences and trends: • Alternatives to India are being mixed in with greater frequency. Latin America and China ranked as the most popular alternatives to India in one recent survey.2 • According to a number of rankings, China is gaining ground on criteria such as financial attractiveness, people and skills, and business environment. • Of 30 top destinations identified as best for offshore Call Centre operations, ten countries were from Asia (China, India, Thailand, Vietnam, Australia, New Zealand, Singapore, Malaysia, Pakistan, and the Philippines). Thailand was a newcomer to the list, as were a few other emerging markets such as Egypt, Morocco and Panama.
  • 6. -6- Currently, low-price/standard service vendors remain profitable • Utilization, and therefore, long-term customers, is the key for profitability • However, high-priced call centres solutions not widely accepted by the market But high-end services will reach 65% of share off total market by 2014 • We are encouraged by recent positive news on clients’ long-term commitments to high-end outsourcers High-end outsourcers can win the game by aggressively establishing long-term client base, and targeting various call centres opportunities along the value chain • Five successful strategies identified for new customer development • Telemarketing and value-added information service most likely to be outsourced CC OURSOURCERS ARE STILL EXPLORING
  • 7. -7- TCI SHOULD PARTNER WITH RIGHT LOCAL CC OUTSOURCERS A partnering strategy is essential for TCI to capture the great opportunities in China • TCI lacks a bunch of local capabilities, while time is contingent TCI should target both money making, and money losing tech advanced outsourcers during negotiation process, based on two plausible partnership strategies • Money making ones: share profits and leverage local strength • Money losing ones: control and negotiate for a bargain deal Considering the limited number of candidates in China and TCI’s tight schedule, a broader search can strengthen TCI’s negotiation position Five promising outsourcers identified during the interview process • Money making ones: China Motion, 800 Teleservices, and Compaq-Star • Money losing ones: TCY, ITS Shanghai
  • 8. -8- TCI-TJ: RSTRUCTURING AND BUILDING STRATEGIC ALLIANCES TCI-TJ experienced difficulties due to both promotion and management issues • Though improving, the firm is intrinsically uncompetitive in China market It should restructure for better performance… • Redefine corporate missions and strategies • Restructure project arrangement, reporting, measurement and incentive systems • Refocus its sales on Japanese companies in China and in Japan … and find strategic alliance for TCI’s China expansion • TCI should only partner with prestigious local software company or system integrators • Wiseway screened all the potential candidates lists and funneled down 5 most promising companies for TCI’s further contact - Longshine; Global eForce; eBIS; Modern Computer; Huateng Software
  • 9. -9- AGENDA Executive Summary Call Center Business • Market Overview • CC Customer Segmentation - In-house users - Outsourcers • Demand • Customer • Economics • Competition • Recommendations - Success business model - Partnering strategy E-Commerce Market Overview TCI Tianjin • Current Situation Analysis • Recommendations
  • 10. -10- CALL CENTRE INDUSTRY WILL REACH 380-400K SEATS IN 2014 Illustration • Identify major driving factors to CC adoption - market competition and service awareness - telecom charges and phone penetration • Quantify relationships between drivers and CC adoption - here we used US benchmark • Project CC development by forecasting development of drivers • Project CC penetration in major user’s industries - banking, telecom, insurance … • Add up numbers of each industry to give a CC market overview • Interview industry experts or knowledgeable industry practitioners for their opinion of CC market growth - system integrators and experts 2009 (1) (’000 seats) 158 132 145 2014 projection(1) (’000 seats) 390 337 N.A. Driving factor analysis Bottom-up analysis Experts opinions (1) Without paging company
  • 11. -11- TOP-DOWN APPROACH REVEALS A PROMISING END GAME Phone line per 1000 people CC agents per 1000 people US benchmark Y = 0.00146X + 4.79 Deflated telecom fee index Phone line per 1000 people China phone line 10 21 50 74 158 368 Year Non-paging CC seats (‘000) Source: US Telephone Statistics; Datamonitor; MII data; China Statistics Yearbook 1998 992000 01 04 12 1000 0
  • 12. -12- TELECOM IS THE MOST SIGNIFICANT CC USER NOW Bottom-up Analysis Industry Telecom Mobile Banking Insurance Post service Manufacturing Computer Airline Security Courier Home appliance TV selling Others Overall Projected seats CAGR 2000 25,000 7,667 4,545 2,000 1,600 1,501 800 594 257 240 240 300 6,675 51,419 2004 35,714 22,857 11,100 3,760 6,000 7,519 5,250 4,100 4,158 1,000 2,460 1,000 26,669 131,588 2010 41,667 50,000 47,000 9,850 20,833 25,184 14,000 9,600 32,600 3,333 8,800 2,000 71,965 336,832 2000-04 9% 31 % 25 % 17 % 39 % 50 % 60 % 62 % 101 % 43 % 79 % 35 % 41 % 26 % 2004-10 3% 14 % 27 % 17 % 23 % 22 % 18 % 15 % 41 % 22 % 24 % 12 % 18 % 17 % Source: interviews; online research; experts opinions; Navigate analysis
  • 13. -13- AGENDA Executive Summary Call Center Business • Market Overview • CC Customer Segmentation - In-house users - Outsourcers • Demand • Customer • Economics • Competition • Recommendations - Success business model - Partnering strategy E-Commerce Market Overview TCI Tianjin • Current Situation Analysis • Recommendations
  • 14. -14- CC MARKET ROUGHLY SEGMENTED INTO FOUR CATEGORIES According to Area of CC Usage, and Willingness to Outsource Selected industry examples Willingness to outsource High Low Service-oriented call centres Generic service Admin-driven Securities Home appliance Computer/technology Courier service Publication TV selling MessagingTravel Simple order taking Paging Telecom Insurance Bank Post service Community service Utility Core area Non-core area Area of CC usage
  • 15. -15- THREE CRITERIA TO DISTINGUISH CORE AND NON-CORE AREA Industry Core Area • Securities • Courier service • Computer/technology “Grey Area” • Home appliance • Banking • Insurance • Publication • Telecom • Traveling Non-core Area (generic) • Paging service • Messaging • TV selling • Utilities Functionality • Technical assistance • Aftersales service • Customer complaint settlement • Sourcing/supplier coordination • Customer inquiry settlement • Telemarketing • Message delivering • Simple order taking Call Center’s impact to overall business - Core: When CC function is critical to the performance of the industry Confidentiality requirement - Core: If the industry/functionality commands strict confidentiality Call Center operational complexity - Core: If operating CC in this industry requires great sophistication Criteria Many industries have both core and non-core areas
  • 16. -16- AGENDA Executive Summary Call Center Business • Market Overview • CC Customer Segmentation - In-house users - Outsourcers • Demand • Customer • Economics • Competition • Recommendations - Success business model - Partnering strategy E-Commerce Market Overview TCI Tianjin • Current Situation Analysis • Recommendations
  • 17. -17- ADMIN-DRIVEN SEGMENT: MOST IMPORTANT FOR NOW High % in total new CC demand Driven by “Pillar industries” Demand surged in a group of China’s important industries since 2004, aiming to improve service level •Bank •Post service •Fixed-line telecom •Insurance Required mostly mid-to-high end call center solutions (Nortel, Lucent, IBM, Huawei…) •Big, monopolized, profitable corporations •High cost of failure •Budget approval from above •Often in conjunction with structural reform 1998 1999 2000 4.9 # of new CC seats (’000) Year Admin-driven 11.2 29.5 Total new demand Admin- driven 66% 76% 62% Source: Navigate Consulting modeling
  • 18. -18- UNIQUE THREE-TIER DECISION MAKING PROCESS System Integrators Should Put Efforts to All Top-down initiatives Advocate improving service standard •Make “service facilities” an evaluation criteria •May suggest call center as an option Determine rolling out call centers in the corporation Raise a list of recommended system integrators •Present the list to branch companies Set a budget for different branch companies Decide call center size and sophistication based on corporate budget Negotiate and select a system integrator mostly suitable to the branch’s requirements SI should pay attention to Ministry’s recent service improvement incentive Ministry SI should approach promising corporate headquarters in advance to get the name on the list Corporate headquarter SI should put most efforts to influence branch company’s selection Provincial/regional branches Admin-driven
  • 19. -19- call centres ALMOST NEVER AN OPTION FOR ADMIN-DRIVEN COMPANIES Call centres is not considered an option for CC adoption at corporate level • Worried about unforeseeable consequences • Money saving is not a priority for these big, monopolized SOEs • Unable to distinguish different conditions in different geography - some areas don’t have satisfactory outsourcers Politically risky for branch managers to be “creative” • If using outsourcers, branch managers have to bear all responsibilities - potential for failure is considerable • CC construction budget would be in vain if not used up - while call centres budget needs to be reported for upper approval Only exception is Guangzhou Mobile Company’s call centres of its “Mobile Secretary” service • By nature a paging service: Ideal to be done by a paging company • “Mobile Secretary” service is not planned and budgeted from the corporation (China Mobile) • Guangzhou’s business practice is more liberal than rest of China Admin-driven
  • 20. -20- SERVICE-ORIENTED SEGMENT: A DRIVER FOR LONG-TERM CC PENETRATION Rapid growth in the long-term Widespread adoption expected in market-driven industries Heated competition will stimulate CC usage in mass- market industries • WTO not only lifted various local protectionism, but also introduce global competition • Current over-capacity situation won’t alleviate for the next several years Therefore, service will be more important to create differentiation • With better market environment, consumers are educated to appreciate service Total non-paging CC seats (’000) Service-oriented 2009 2010 2011 2012 10 Year 50 337 Total CC seats Service- oriented 26% 24% 50% 132 42% Source: Interviews; online research; expert opinions; Navigate Consulting Analysis3
  • 21. -21- MORE INDUSTRIES ARE LIKELY TO ADOPT CC OVERTIME CC Adoption Area Home appliance Automotive Computer Mobile Securities Retailing Petrochemical Distribution FMCG(1) Taxi Textile Machinery Chemical Publication Health care Government Entertainment Broadcasting/TV Aviation General Technology High Moderate Low Competition intensity High Horizontal will extend overtime Importance of service (1) Fast-moving consumer goods Source: Interviews; literature research summaries; Navigate Consulting Analysis Horizontal will extend overtime Service-oriented
  • 22. -22- COMPANIES QUITE SELECTIVE ON CC USAGE Not blindly chasing after high-end solutions Integrating call centers with its core business practice Interviews summary Source: Interviews % Investment per seat (’000 RMB) 54% 31% 15% 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 Oct-70 70-150 150-250 Interviews summary% Aftersales service 44% 31% 19% 6% Order taking Information service Telemarketing10-70 Service-oriented
  • 23. -23- VERY CAUTIONS ON CC call centres Price “The price for call centres is too high now, for example, 95Info charges 15,000RMB/month (180,000RMB/year) per seat, most companies can not undertake it.” Sales Manager, SIEMENS Quality “Chinese call center outsourcers have inadequate service mentality, we mostly worried about their service quality.” Hot Line Supervisor, EPSON China Human resources “Ordinary outsourcer’s agents can only handle simple questions. It requires experienced engineers to deal with complex problems.” Hot Line Supervisor, EPSON China Confidentiality “We once wanted to outsource management to 95Info, but sales data are secret to the company, so we gave up the call centres option.” Call Center Vice -Manager, Founder Computer Information processing “Our call center is mainly used to provide cross-department information for management, call centres call center might make the information processing losing control.” Executive Officer Beijing, Guangdong Macro Major concerns about call centres Their call centres possibility highly depends on outsourcers’ ability to satisfy their concerns Source: Interviews Service- oriented
  • 24. -24- AGENDA Executive Summary Call Center Business • Market Overview • CC Customer Segmentation - In-house users - Outsourcers • Demand • Customer • Economics • Competition • Recommendations - Success business model - Partnering strategy E-Commerce Market Overview TCI Tianjin • Current Situation Analysis • Recommendations
  • 25. -25- DEMAND PROJECTION DEPENDENT ON A CYCLE OF FACTORSWide variance in projection... …dependent on a group of factors # of call centres seats (’000) 3.5 5.2 2004 2009 2014 Virtuous or vicious cycle? Outsourcer’s Price Outsourcer’s professionalism Customer satisfaction Outsourcer’s service sophistication # of new customer trial Education effect to potential customers call centres industry reputation It’s hard to tell whether the industry can establish its reputation or go underdeveloped, at the very beginning of its emergence Demand Outsourcer 51.2 6.6 CAGR = 100% CAGR = 20% CAGR = 20%
  • 26. -26- POSITIVE CUSTOMER EVOLUTION OBSERVED IN CHINA’S call centres BUSINESS Positive projections for future •Historical trends showed increasing penetration into high-end business •China’s massive small-to-medium business constitutes good potential customer base •Massive un-exploited geography: outside top 3 cities •Good outsourcer will emerge with increased business, which will generate more business for the call centres industry call centres service sophistication TimeLow High Before Recent 2 years We believe in the positive argument and project demand to grow at least 50% a year for the next 4 years Paging service call centres for Hong Kong “Secretary” service Simple telemarketing Order taking After-sales service Negative projections for future •Customer’s negative thoughts about outsourcer’s quality haven’t changed •Professionalism will continue to be a headache for China service industry, including call centres •Low-end entry (paging companies) will ruin call centres industry’s pricing structure and make good outsourcer’s unprofitable Demand Outsourcer
  • 27. -27- BALANCE BETWEEN LONG-TERM CLIENTS AND PERIODIC ASSIGNMENTS IS CRITICAL Customers Outsourcer Long-term clients Long-term clients are most important to the profitability of an outsourcer Job nature Customer requirement Compensation • “Secretary” service • Order-taking • After-sales service • Value-added information • Trust between company and customer • Training to agents • Good understanding of clients’ business • Smooth communication and feedback of important information • A monthly payment per agent seat • Telemarketing • Campaign/activity phone reception • Brand name in call centres industry • Trained agents and effective management • Information feedback • Reasonable price • Payment per call Periodic assignments
  • 28. -28- INTERVIEWED OUTSOURCER’S LONG-TERM CUSTOMER LIST Outsourcer Long-term client Outsourced business type Location Profitable? TCY Pfizer Pharmacy China After sales Beijing, Shanghai Deficit CCID Call Center China InfoWorld (Newspaper) Inbound service Beijing Deficit Guangzhou Mobile Highway & Bridge Fee collection call out Guangzhou COMPAQ After sales Shanghai NEC Mobile China After sales Shanghai China Motion China Mobile Management call centres N.A. Profitable Beijing Hongfan Sun Micro Systems Simple question handling N.A. Channel Beyond Profitable Compaq Star Profitable Backup After sales “Secretary” service Fee collection call out Guangzhou Vanke Community service Guangzhou Beijing Telecom Messaging service Beijing Deficit 95 info Nokia After sales (mobile) Beijing Deficit 800 teleservice Motorola After sales (mobile) Shanghai N.A. ITS Pharmacy companies N.A. Shanghai Deficit
  • 29. -29- call centres SALES AND SERVICE HELPS MULTINATIONALS TO FOCUS ON CORE CAPABILITIES Advanced product design Technology Financial muscle Operational management Manufacturing Distribution network Customer relationships Local marketing Facilities (land, house…) Regulatory knowhow ServiceSourcing Manufacturing Sales X X X Multinational’s strengths Local company’s strengths X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X Customers OutsourcerBackup
  • 30. -30- HIGH-END OUTSOURCERS ARE STILL LOSING MONEY – CAPEX HIGH AND IRR BELOW ACCEPTED LEVELS The key determinant: Utilization Profitability Economics Outsourcer Hi profits Low profits Breakeven Low deficits Hi deficits Price/seat (RMB/month) 0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000 30000 35000 China Motion Shenghua Cheng Bo Compaq- Star CCID Hong Fan TCY ITS 95Info Source: Interviews; Navigate Consulting Analysis
  • 31. -31- AGENDA Executive Summary Call Center Business • Market Overview • CC Customer Segmentation - In-house users - Outsourcers • Demand • Customer • Economics • Competition • Recommendations - Success business model - Partnering strategy E-Commerce Market Overview TCI Tianjin • Current Situation Analysis • Recommendations
  • 32. -32- PREVIOUSLY THE LOW-PRICE/STANDARD SERVICE MODEL PROVED SUCCESSFUL – Period 1998 - 2007 Takeaway from Interviews Not technically feasible Doomed failure Possible to be successful , too? Several successful examples observed Customize/ High-end Standard/ low-end Low High High-end outsourcers CAGR 2007-2012 14% • Easier to persuade clients to accept a high price point • Trust in big names • Business not fully streamlined - software and high-end customer support not available • Most assignment periodic Well-positioned, efficient low-end outsourcers WERE very profitable • 70% or above business from long-term clients • Both equipment and human resources are easy and cheap to source Service Level Price
  • 33. -33- SUCCESSFUL HIGH-END MODEL HAS TAKEN 40% som Wiseway’s Belief Long-term clients are most important for high-end CC outsourcer’s success • Periodic assignment demand is inherently unstable, and demand fluctuation will worsen utility rate - Current high-end CC outsourcers lack long-term clients • Strong long-term client commitments give outsourcers credibility for other call center assignments Prestigious long-term clients are beginning to commit to high-end outsourcers • 95Info’s deal with Nokia in Beijing • 800 Teleservices’s deal with Motorola in Shanghai There are clear directions for high-end outsourcers to be profitable • Establish long-term client base - for a medium-sized call center, 1~2 long-term clients can turn it into profits • Identify potential areas for CC call centres
  • 34. -34- HIGH-END OUTSOURCERS CAN DEVELOP BUSINESS ALONG TWO DIMENSIONSCustomerpenetration Business penetration Establish long-term client base 1. Build relationship through periodic assignments 2. Invite client’s equity investment 3. Provide “one-stop shopping” 4. Serve overseas market 5. Leverage existing relationship Target various call centres opportunities along the value chain Breakdown value chains to find out promising call centres opportunities
  • 35. -35- FIVE SUCCESSFUL STRATEGIES TO WIN LONG-TERM CLIENTS... Building relationship through periodic assignments Outsourcers contact clients first for periodic assignments, such as telemarketing or promotion call reception, and sell long-term assignments when trust and relationships are built • Example: Guangzhou China Motion vs P&G Provide “one-stop shopping” Outsourcers also provide, or have alliances to provide, other services that are compatible to call center service. So customers can get all they need from one company • Example: Guangzhou Channel Beyond Leverage existing relationship Outsourcers develop domestic multinationals clients leveraging overseas relationship • Example: 800Teleservice v.s. Motorola Serve overseas market Outsourcers provide low-cost services to Hong Kong, Taiwan or other overseas clients by leveraging low-cost agents and language ability in China • Example: Guangzhou Shenghua Invite client’s equity investment Outsourcers ask an important client to make equity investment, in order to lock in the relationship and establish needed trust • Example: Compaq-Star Strategies proved successful 1 2 3 4 5
  • 36. -36- … EACH WITH ITS UNIQUE ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES Cons • Lowered entry barrier into potential clients • Easier to build relationship and mutual trust • Time consuming • Periodic assignments might not necessarily turn to long-term commitment • Lock-in relationships • Shared risks • Controlled by clients • Limited opportunities for other clients - restrained growth • Increased customer satisfaction • Stronger advantages against all competitors at “one-stop” area • Strengths restrained in one particular area • Difficult to extend business to other areas • Profitable business • Stable client relationship once obtained • Competition • Generally low-end services - clients only pursue “low-cost” • Difficult to acquire overseas clients • Monopolized client base • Familiar service standard • Leverageable software and management • Not a lot • Bad service in China might deteriorate corporate’s relationship to the outsourcer Building relationship through periodic assignments Invite client’s equity investment Provide “one-stop shopping” Serve overseas market Leverage existing relationship 1 2 3 4 5 Pros
  • 37. -37- call centres MOST PROMISING FOR TELEMARKETING AND VALUE-ADDED INFORMATION SERVICES Potential Call Center Adoption Areas After-sales service Value-added information service Trouble- shooting Complaint handling Concerns Service quality Industry knowledge Information processing Confidentiality Manu- facturin g Sourcing Ordering Supplier mgmt. Sales Tele- marketing Inquiry handling Order taking Most promising Most promising Not a concern Significant concerns
  • 38. -38- call centres OPPORTUNITIES FOR SELECTED INDUSTRIES (I) Value Chain Breakdown for Sales and ServicesAftersalesservice Trouble- shooting Complaint handling Tele- marketing Customer inquiry handling Order taking Value-added information service Sales Industry Telecom • Complaint reception • Customer satisfaction survey Mobile service • Complaint reception • Phone-line problem calling • General trouble - shooting • Mobile problem calling (lost, disconnected) • Call dialing helpdesk • Phone number inquiry (“114”) • Phone bill information, etc. • “Secretary” service • Phone bill inquiry • Fixed-line service application • Other value-added service application • Mobile service application • Value-added service application • Potential customer call-in reception • Potential customer call-in reception • Long-distance service promotion • General information of new products/services • New service/products promotion Likely Unlikely
  • 39. -39- call centres OPPORTUNITIES FOR SELECTED INDUSTRIES (II) Value Chain Breakdown for Sales and ServicesAftersalesservice Trouble- shooting Complaint handling Tele- marketing Customer inquiry handling Order taking Value-added information service Sales Industry Banking • General complaint handling Securities • General complaint handling • General trouble-shooting • General trouble-shooting • Telephone banking • Personal financial consulting • Investment analysis, suggestion,etc • General market information • Deposit or other orders • Telephone transaction • General question handling • General question handling • New service promotion • Corporate client relationship building N.A. Insurance • General complaint handling • General trouble-shooting N.A. • Telephone transaction • General question handling • Promotion of insurance policies Likely Unlikely
  • 40. -40- call centres OPPORTUNITIES FOR SELECTED INDUSTRIES (III) Value Chain Breakdown for Sales and Services Aftersalesservice Trouble- shooting Complaint handling Tele- marketing Customer inquiry handling Order taking Value-added information service Sales Industry Technology Home appliance • Technology guidance • Consulting N.A. Fast-moving consumer goods N.A. Likely Unlikely
  • 41. -41- AGENDA Executive Summary Call Center Business • Market Overview • CC Customer Segmentation - In-house users - Outsourcers • Demand • Customer • Economics • Competition • Recommendations - Success business model - Partnering strategy E-Commerce Market Overview TCI Tianjin • Current Situation Analysis • Recommendations
  • 42. -42- ONLY A PARTNERSHIP FITS INTO TCI’S SPECIFICATION Self-construct a call center Partner with local CC outsourcers Provide CC call centres training, management and consulting • No China experience in call center • No enough human resources to commit • Little local client knowledge • Time consuming • Complement TCI’s local capabilities • Satisfy time stringency concerns • Commit little TCI resources • Serve TCI’s potential clients well with existing capacity • Fit into TCI’s strengths well • Demand less TCI’s commitment However • Need to establish local facilities and assign knowledgeable people to China • Profits will not be big Maybe an opportunity  
  • 43. -43- TCI SHOULD ALLY WITH A LOCAL PARTNER TO ENTER INTO THE MARKET Now is good to enter... • Nevertheless, China CC call centres segment is a fast growing market • There are few high-profile CC call centres companies in China • Competition at high-end is not severe • And…, TCI is in discussion with two possible long-term clients … But should ally with a local outsourcer TCI lacks a lot of local capacities • Local market understanding • Local clients relationship • Experienced agents • Language … And time is tight • A decision should be made very soon A local partner with complementary capabilities is ideal for TCI’s fast rollout in China
  • 44. -44- DIFFICULT TO FIND A PARTNER SATISFYING ALL CRITERIA • Strong local market understanding • Good local client relationship Provide TCI with most needed capabilities 1 Be profitable Demand not too much TCI’s involvement Allow TCI to develop own brand and share client base 2 3 4 Partner’s profile • Mature, professional operations • Experienced agents • Sufficient long-term client base • Strong, mature operations already • Probably not strong self-brand and customer base • Eagerly in need of TCI’s client, money, management What TCI might face • Command very high valuation for its shares - TCI probably have to pay more under time pressure • Stick to its right of control - might agree in appearance, but suffocate in action TCI’s brand building efforts • Persist on its own business practice - TCI might feel difficult to configure to “Japanese standard” • The outsourcer might be very bad - no local client base - losing money - low morale • TCI has to invest a lot - money - human resources
  • 45. -45- Partnership Strategy Partner with strong, money-making local outsourcers Partner with money- losing, but high-end equipped local outsourcers • Leverage partner’s capabilities to expand business • Demand less TCI investment • Create synergy more easily • Leverage partner’s advanced facilities • Easy to control and develop TCI’s own brand • Might be cheap TWO POTENTIAL PARTNERSHIP STRATEGY SUGGESTED Reflecting Different Entry Focus Advantages Disadvantage Entry Focus • Expensive • Hard to control • Potential conflict with TCI’s practice • Profit sharing • Fast rollout • Synergy creation • TCI might not benefit too much from local partner • TCI has to invest a lot • High risk is entailed • Control • TCI brand and practice development • A bargain deal
  • 46. -46- FIVE POTENTIAL TARGETS IDENTIFIED • China Motion • 800 Teleservice • Compaq-Star • Cooperativeness • Understanding of each other’s business • Local outsourcer’s valuation • % of shares participated • Profit sharing theme • TCI brand and practice development plan • Shared vision and willingness to cooperate • A good price Money making • TCY • ITS Shanghai • Technology and equipment advancement • Controlling shareholding • Local outsourcer’s valuation - negotiate for a bargaining price • TCI’s needed commitment to the new venture • A bargaining price • Total control Money losing Names Negotiation priorities When to decide TCI should proceed both options simultaneously, and choose a best option in the end
  • 47. -47- AGENDA Executive Summary Call Center Business • Market Overview • CC Customer Segmentation - In-house users - Outsourcers • Demand • Customer • Economics • Competition • Recommendations - Success business model - Partnering strategy E-Commerce Market Overview TCI Tianjin • Current Situation Analysis • Recommendations
  • 48. -48- TCI-TJ EXPERIENCED TREMENDOUS DIFFICULTIES (I) Most projects not profitable Overhead out of control Rev. Profit rate -200% -150% -100% -50% 0% 50% 100% 16% -170% 35% 51% 61% 69% 98% 100% 2010 (’000 RMB) 508 997 2575 1758 1990 Gross profit Salary Management fee Depre. Misc. Source: TCI-TJ; Navigate Consulting Analysis
  • 49. -49- TCI-TJ EXPERIENCED TREMENDOUS DIFFICULTIES (II) Programmer’s turnover is worrying Utilization rate is low Human resource • From official statistics, on average about 1/3 of programmer’s working hours were not staffed, real situation can be worse Real estate • The whole second floor was empty, while a depreciation of RMB 2.4 million, 60% of 1999 revenue, is counted each year as cost Project schedule often out of control 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 Total recruited Left Label Programmers turnover (7) (1) (20) (5) (4) 17 4 28 15 5 A 2011 project People staffed (4) (1) Time3 months 1 year 2 years Planned Actual Source: TCI-TJ; Navigate Consulting Analysis
  • 50. -50- FIVE ROOT CAUSES IDENTIFIED FOR THESE PROBLEMS Overhead out of control Over-invested Project out of control Inadequate programmer’s training Most projects not profitable Ineffective and not disciplined sales efforts Low resources utilization Programmers not motivated properly Worrying programmer’s turnover Compensation and progression not enough to retain HR
  • 51. -51- TCI-TJ IS NOT COMPETITIVE IN DOMESTIC SOFTWARE MARKET High fixed cost Ineffective domestic sales force No sales department Previous sales activities restrained in Tianjin • And mainly through Japanese invested companies Targeting domestic customers means additional investment on HR and spending • With unforeseeable results Equivalent domestic company TCI Annual cost (RMB ’000) 945 (1) With same actively-used office space, at a metropolitan location in Tianjin Office cost example 83% 10% 7% 2926 Depreciation Tax Land (1)
  • 52. -52- AGENDA Executive Summary Call Center Business • Market Overview • CC Customer Segmentation - In-house users - Outsourcers • Demand • Customer • Economics • Competition • Recommendations - Success business model - Partnering strategy E-Commerce Market Overview TCI Tianjin • Current Situation Analysis • Recommendations
  • 53. -53- TCI-TJ CAN DEVELOP ALONG TWO PATHS Restructure for better performance Questions are: • What are advantages and potential risks entailed in different path? • Which one to choose? New business development Introduce TCI Japan’s best-of- breed technology to China through TCI-TJ Existing business penetration and finance operation Find strategic alliance for TCI-TJ
  • 54. -54- RESTRUCTURING FOR BETTER PERFORMANCE • Transplant company’s vision to each employee’s mind • Create better culture through informal interactive channels • Mentor system • Company activities • “General Manager Day” • Declare what should not be done - Policies and rules • Establish a scientific system to evaluate, incentivize, and promote staff - Staff, evaluation, compensation and promotion Customer strategy • Focus on Japanese market and Japanese companies around Tianjin HR strategy • Retain and promote the best people in the company • Create a programmer-centric organization Production strategy • Adjust product and programming to satisfy Japanese client specifications • Aspire to efficient production • Improve HR utilization rate Mission • Turn into profitability in the next several years • Develop TCI-TJ’s capability in software programming and service • Retain best human resources Belief system Interactive control system Boundary system Diagnostic system Control and measurement system
  • 55. -55- ESTABLISH A THREE-TIER HIERARCHY IN PROGRAMMER’S TEAM Technology Director Project Manager Senior programmer Junior programmer After 2-4 years After 1-3 years College undergraduate Out Out Responsibilities Project manager • Control the quality and time commitment of a project • Choose and motivate a programmer’ team to get the job done Technology director • Provide technical guidance • Supervise project quality Senior programmer • Be in charge of specific module in a project • Undertake on-job training roles to junior programmer Junior programmer: probation position • Program under instruction and supervision of project managers • Learn fast to get promotion Rights • Full rights to choose how many, and which programmer to get staffed on the team • Full right to control the project progress • Right to choose whether he would like to be put on a project • Right to request mentor on technical support • Right to choose whether to be staffed on a project Evaluation • Whether the project is completed under budget and time target • Whether subordinate programmers are satisfied with project management and learning • Whether clients are satisfied • Whether he has done an effective job in handling a module • Whether he coached junior programmers effectively • Whether he has done an effective job as a programmer • Whether he has learned fast
  • 56. -56- HUGE BENEFITS OF BUILDING A THREE-TIER HIERARCHY • Project managers are motivated to successfully compete the project as quickly as possible - evaluated by customer satisfaction and time/budget consumed • Project managers won’t abuse human resources - better-off to select a small but capable programmer’s team • Good programmers will be the king in the company: Strong incentive to be good - treasured by every project manager: Enough good project to do - compensated well and promoted fast - incapable programmers will feel not well and have to leave the company • Junior programmers will have enough training and opportunities to perform • Senior management is disciplined to their sales efforts - overly sold projects will be objected by project managers Project management HR development Sales efforts
  • 57. -57- TWO TYPES OF STRATEGIC ALLIANCES PROPOSED TCI-TJ Advantages • Use partner’s human resources • Benefit from partner’s brand name • Leverage partner’s client base • Introduce partner’s management skills • Retain huge potential upside - IPO process will boost investment return • Achieve potential synergies between a software company and an E-commerce company Disadvantages • Very difficult to find such a partner - good companies probably will find TCI- TJ unattractive • Lost control • Potential risk of cultural conflict • Increasing risk of a satisfactory IPO • Partner’s experience of working with a software programmer • Morale at TCI-TJ Wiseway’s preference Not preferred Preferred Sell, or partner with a local esteemed software programmer Partner with a local system integrator, or E-commerce company with IPO potential We will discuss partnership list in detail in the next part
  • 58. -58- Thank You? Questions John Gregg, Principal, Navigate Consulting Pty Ltd Ph: +61 402 493 278 Email: johng@navigateconsulting.com.au Web: www.navigatecoonsulting.com.au