A positive call center environment is critical to a company’s success or failure in the eyes of its customers and its bottom line. Knowing how to leverage call center talent to create a positive atmosphere will ultimately increase agent productivity and performance.
How to Create a Positive Call Center Culture Through Training, Coaching and Active Wait Time
1. From Boot Camp to Teamwork:
How to Create a Positive and
Profitable Call Center Culture
09-08-11
1
2. Agenda
Introductions
Positive and Profitable Call Center Culture
Operationalizing Culture Improvements
Questions and Answers
2
3. Today’s Presenters
David L. Butler, Ph.D.
Director and Associate Professor, The Call Center
Research Laboratory, The University of Southern
Mississippi
Executive Director, The National Association of Call
Centers - a not-for-profit membership organization
Author of Bottom-Line Call Center Management
3
4. Today’s Presenters Continued
Matt McConnell
CEO, Knowlagent
Knowlagent at a Glance
Call center agent productivity solution
Founded in 1995
300,000+ agents in 17 countries using Knowlagent
SaaS
4
5. Quality of the Customer Experience
The Attitude of Agents 26%
The Ability of Agents to Understand the Issue 23%
Queue Lengths 20%
The Ability of Agents to Resolve Issues at the First 20%
Attempt
Agent Knowledge 8%
Consistency of Based on #1 choice ONLY
Information
2%
Agent performance is vital to the customer experience
and customer satisfaction
Source: Ventana Research CEM Benchmark Research
5
7. The Nature of the Beast
Call center created to deal with customers more efficiently
Volume
Lower cost resources
Metrics critical
Easily leads to a command and control environment
8. Response Defines Culture
Pressures remain the same
How you respond to them defines your culture
A tale of two centers
10. Know Thy Agents Continued
Do you find your work challenging?
No
24%
Yes
76%
10
11. A Tale of Two Call Centers
Same city
Same labor area
500 seats each
Similar working hours
Similar benefit plans
11
12. A Tale of Two Call Centers Continued
Pays $2 more an hour more
Turnover rate 3% vs. 90%
Waiting list to join company
Negative culture
12
13. Volume
Can’t
Change varying volume
Can
Make sure agents are prepared
Break up the day with different tasks, alleviate boredom and burnout
Change measurement focus
14. Resources
Can’t
Change demographics of labor pool
Can
Give a career path
Change management approach
Invest in skills
15. Metrics
Can’t
Stop measuring
Can
Balance productivity and performance
Focus on metrics that matter most to customers (which empower agents
and drive behavior)
Empower agents with information, not punish. Drive improvement while
investing in skills
17. Agent Training/Coaching*
29% provide as much
training as they target:
73% say service
level agreements don’t
allow enough time for
training
Coaching: 37% have no set target for amount of
coaching time
Source: Ventana Research Call Center Agent Productivity Poll
17
18. Wait Time: Five Weeks of Really Bad, Boring
Vacation
Wait time = Five weeks; 2 minutes at a time.
Secondary Loss
24 x 2 minute breaks/ day 12% (off-phone work)
Primary Loss
120 x 2 minute breaks/ week 17% (Absenteeism,
vacations, etc.)
480 x 2 minute breaks/ month Wait Time
11%
5,760 x 2 minute breaks/ year
Call Handle time
60%
Costs our industry $30 billion/year
Source: 2010 Contact Center Shrinkage Survey
Category 1
19. Agents have 17 hours of Idle Time Every Month
Contact center
agents spend 11% Break
of their day
unproductively Lunch 50 minutes of
unproductive
waiting for the next wait time
customer Break
interaction
20. Wait Time: Five Weeks of Really Bad, Boring
Vacation
Wait time = Five weeks; 2 minutes at a time.
Secondary Loss
12% (off-phone work)
Primary Loss
Active Wait 17% (Absenteeism, vacations
, etc.)
11% Wait Time
Call Handle time
60%
Source: 2010 Contact Center Shrinkage Survey
Category 1
21. Find time by Converting Idle Wait Time into
Active Wait time
Leverage technology to
redistribute the idle
time and create 15-20
minute activity 20 minutes of
sessions “Active Wait”
Use these dynamically Lunch time
scheduled sessions to +
improve 30 minutes of
Break
skills, communicate unproductive
must reads, coach wait time
agents
22. Time Invested for Improvements
Industry Average Composition of Secondary Loss
21% Training
17% Coaching
Secondary Loss 12% 16% Team Meetings
Primary Loss 17%
11% Projects
Wait time 11%
9% Paperwork
Call Handle time 9% Call Research / Follow-up
60%
17% - Email, Call Back,
Knowledgebase, Etc.
Category 1
Source: 2010 Contact Center Shrinkage Survey
23. Structured Activity Queues Drive the Right
Work at the Right Time
Occupancy
100%
95%
90%
1) Urgent Must Reads
85% 2) Social Learning
3) Coaching
80%
4) QM Review
75%
70%
Personalized based on agent need, prioritized based
on business objectives
23
24. Customer Satisfaction
Getting First Call Resolution Done
Major U.S. Telecommunications Company
Using Knowlagent to deliver more
training, coaching, and communications to over
45,000 agents
Increased Delivery
“Delivered more training time to a site in 5 days using
RightTime than was delivered over 1 month when
manually scheduling time”
Improved Take Rate
“71.7% take rate for RightTime
vs. 59.4% take rate for pre-scheduled breaks”
25. Operationalizing Culture Improvements
Volume: Make idle time work for you and your agents
Resources: Find time to make them better
Metrics: Guide your improvements, prioritize off-phone
activities
26. Q&As and Contact Information
David L. Butler, Ph.D.
601-266-4735
david.butler@usm.edu
Matt McConnell
678-365-3500
matt.mcconnell@knowlagent.com
26
Notes de l'éditeur
Matt to discuss
Matt to introduce David.
Matt to introduce himself
Discuss how to improve the customer experience, stressing importance of agent performance and discussing details of benchmark research that indicates this.
Average new training cost per call center agent is $5000.Average annual turnover rate in call centers is 33%.This means that in a 100 seat center, a loss of $165,000 per year alone in people leaving.This does not include the cost of a bad reputation in terms of future hires, diminished labor pool, and the cost of keeping the existing agents.These agents that leave, many go and work for your local competition. You have just subsidized your competition with your $5000 training.Positive culture=lower turnover. Lower turnover means more experienced agents, fewer hires, more advanced training for existing agents, and less subsidy from you to your competition. In short, more profit.Turnover, has been, and continues to be, the number one problem facing the call center industry-even during the recession.Turnover is a problem because it absorbs a huge amount of resources that could otherwise go to other functions in the call center.Number one reason people leave a call center-bad management (an aspect of culture).POLL #1: MattWhat is the biggest driver for a positive culture:Customer satisfactionCost reduction
Culture within a call center is critical.All call centers have a culture-the question is which type? One that is positive or one that is negative?It takes effort to create a positive culture.Once a positive culture is established, it can become self-replicating over time.A strong positive culture in a call center saves money both short term and long term.
Poll #2: MattTrue or False: Call Center Agents have a clearly defined career path within my organization.True False
Both call center operations are in the same city.Both draw from the same labor area of the city.Both are national brands that attract workers.Both are larger call centers with over 500 seats each.Both have similar working hours.Both have similar benefit plansCall Center A pays $2.00 an hour more than Call Center B.Call Center A has an annual turnover rate of 90%.Call Center B has an annual turnover rate of 3%.Call Center A cannot hire enough people to keep the center going with a turnover rate of 90%. Call Center B has a waiting list of 2 years to join the company.This is the cost of a negative culture.POLL #3: MattDo you measure agent satisfaction?YesNoPlan toDon’t plan to
Take or make the time to make sure agents are knowledgeableBreak up the day with different tasks, alleviate boredom and burnout (note attention span and engagement) Don’t just measure volume-based metrics
Productivity and performance or efficiency and effectiveness. Understand the trade-offs and where the biggest benefits to the company are.Give agents visibility into the metrics and aligned goals. Use the information available to drive improvements in behavior and give the agents accountability for that.POLL #4: MattWhich metric listed below has a higher priority within your call center?FCRAHTCustomer Satisfaction
Matt to discuss. That same survey gave us some insight on some of the struggles call centers have with trying to increase performance around their top goals.
Matt to discuss
Matt to discussTransition slide – explain call center environment, management held to meet service levels and other key metrics, improvement initiatives not met due to lack of timeVentana Research stat: Only 29% achieve coaching and training targets, mostly (73%) because their service level agreements don’t allow for enough time
Matt to discuss
Matt to discussTransition slide – explain call center environment, management held to meet service levels and other key metrics, improvement initiatives not met due to lack of timeVentana Research stat: Only 29% achieve coaching and training targets, mostly (73%) because their service level agreements don’t allow for enough time
Matt to discuss
Matt: discuss finding time by moving shrinkage to wait time