SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  9
Digital Behaviour Change
 Evidence-based Approaches and
 Critical Success Factors
 Suzi Bentley Tanner
 10 December, 2012



Bupa   Private and Confidential   26th September 2011   1
There are a large and growing number of web-based, goal-
oriented tools on the market…
…as well as a number that focus specifically on encouraging
health behavior change.
Mobile technologies are present at key trigger moments, and
also support data entry and management.
Although there are many behaviour change tools on the
market, the real question is…are they successful?




          It depends how you measure it...
How can we define success for behaviour change initiatives?
The ‘holy grail’ is measurable health outcomes

                                          Engagement                                       high
                                        •Sign up/participate
                                          •Assess needs




                                           Short-term
                                          achievement
                                       •Take part in activities
                                       •Utilise tracking/social                             Ease of
                                               elements                                   measurement




                                      Sustained Change
                                      •Ongoing involvement
                                      •Measurable biometric
                                       or clinical outcomes



                                                                                           low



                    The challenge in behaviour change is not the initial period of high
        motivation, it’s how do you extend that so it actually becomes a lasting change
Bupa   Private and Confidential                over time.                                         6
There is evidence that digital tools can have a measurable
effect for some people and some interventions.


                                                                                          Emotional/mental health: CCBT

                                                                                      Alcohol consumption

                                                                                                     Safer sexual behaviours

                                                                                                                      Smoking cessation

                                                                                        Increased physical activity
       Clinical outcomes
                                                                       Healthy people engaged in unhealthy
           Weight loss                                                 behaviour
                                                                     Intention and self-efficacy Short term effects
           BMI              Sustained effects
                                                                                                   Knowledge and understanding
       People with long-term Emotional/mental health:
       conditions            social networks/personal stories

        low                         Measurable effect of digital tools on behaviour change                                                    high



Bupa    Private and Confidential   Murray, et al. Web-based interventions for behaviour change and self-management: potential, pitfalls and progress. UCL   7
Research also suggests that larger effects can be achieved by
incorporating a number of elements into digital tools.

                               Strong
                            theoretical         Persuasive techniques
                            foundation             (show users the
                                                 consequence of their
                                                                          Credibility,
                                                                           authority
                          e.g. Theory of         behaviour; normative
                                                      pressure)
                              planned
                             behaviour




                                   Goal
                                                  Tailoring, person         Social
                              setting, action
                                                       alisation          networking
                                 planning




                                                                          Human
                                                      Perceived
                                  Relevance
                                                    effectiveness       support and
                                                                          prompts



Bupa   Private and Confidential                                                          8
The challenge is how we translate these intangible elements
into success.




                         It’s not easy. But neither is change.

Bupa   Private and Confidential                                  9

Contenu connexe

En vedette

Twitter Me This? Using Twitter in Higher Ed
Twitter Me This? Using Twitter in Higher EdTwitter Me This? Using Twitter in Higher Ed
Twitter Me This? Using Twitter in Higher EdNikki Massaro Kauffman
 
4. scott badgeville
4. scott   badgeville4. scott   badgeville
4. scott badgevilleLuke Raskino
 
Yolton mark going beyond social media to social business
Yolton mark   going beyond social media to social businessYolton mark   going beyond social media to social business
Yolton mark going beyond social media to social businessMark Yolton
 
Osmb Keynote Jan2009 Yolton Final
Osmb Keynote Jan2009 Yolton FinalOsmb Keynote Jan2009 Yolton Final
Osmb Keynote Jan2009 Yolton FinalMark Yolton
 
Ideas tackle obesity using tech for lower income groups
Ideas   tackle obesity using tech for lower income groupsIdeas   tackle obesity using tech for lower income groups
Ideas tackle obesity using tech for lower income groupsLuke Raskino
 
Outlook2003
Outlook2003Outlook2003
Outlook2003RS712003
 
Igniting the Imagination of Many
Igniting the Imagination of ManyIgniting the Imagination of Many
Igniting the Imagination of ManyLance Weiler
 
U motif gamify my health meetup 12 october 2012
U motif gamify my health meetup 12 october 2012U motif gamify my health meetup 12 october 2012
U motif gamify my health meetup 12 october 2012Luke Raskino
 
InnoGage KASCAC Presentation
InnoGage KASCAC PresentationInnoGage KASCAC Presentation
InnoGage KASCAC PresentationTom Williams
 
Widya Amiranti = CV
Widya Amiranti = CVWidya Amiranti = CV
Widya Amiranti = CVguest2d64e0
 
SIRS Statistical Summary, Fall 2008a
SIRS Statistical Summary, Fall 2008aSIRS Statistical Summary, Fall 2008a
SIRS Statistical Summary, Fall 2008akahudson
 
2. richard unilever
2. richard   unilever2. richard   unilever
2. richard unileverLuke Raskino
 
Scn briefing book for sapphire now 2010
Scn briefing book for sapphire now 2010Scn briefing book for sapphire now 2010
Scn briefing book for sapphire now 2010Mark Yolton
 
I behave meeting 26th march 2013 v1 julia
I behave meeting 26th march 2013 v1   juliaI behave meeting 26th march 2013 v1   julia
I behave meeting 26th march 2013 v1 juliaLuke Raskino
 
Sexunzipped damien-hampton
Sexunzipped damien-hamptonSexunzipped damien-hampton
Sexunzipped damien-hamptonLuke Raskino
 
Singulariteit
SingulariteitSingulariteit
SingulariteitMizza00
 
Jive new way_tour_my_sap_24_may2011 final
Jive new way_tour_my_sap_24_may2011 finalJive new way_tour_my_sap_24_may2011 final
Jive new way_tour_my_sap_24_may2011 finalMark Yolton
 
presidential election
presidential electionpresidential election
presidential electionguest41ce8a55
 
Text First! Progressive Enhancement for Multimedia Content
Text First! Progressive Enhancement for Multimedia ContentText First! Progressive Enhancement for Multimedia Content
Text First! Progressive Enhancement for Multimedia ContentNikki Massaro Kauffman
 

En vedette (20)

Twitter Me This? Using Twitter in Higher Ed
Twitter Me This? Using Twitter in Higher EdTwitter Me This? Using Twitter in Higher Ed
Twitter Me This? Using Twitter in Higher Ed
 
4. scott badgeville
4. scott   badgeville4. scott   badgeville
4. scott badgeville
 
Yolton mark going beyond social media to social business
Yolton mark   going beyond social media to social businessYolton mark   going beyond social media to social business
Yolton mark going beyond social media to social business
 
Osmb Keynote Jan2009 Yolton Final
Osmb Keynote Jan2009 Yolton FinalOsmb Keynote Jan2009 Yolton Final
Osmb Keynote Jan2009 Yolton Final
 
Ideas tackle obesity using tech for lower income groups
Ideas   tackle obesity using tech for lower income groupsIdeas   tackle obesity using tech for lower income groups
Ideas tackle obesity using tech for lower income groups
 
Outlook2003
Outlook2003Outlook2003
Outlook2003
 
Igniting the Imagination of Many
Igniting the Imagination of ManyIgniting the Imagination of Many
Igniting the Imagination of Many
 
Gametopia 2.0
Gametopia 2.0Gametopia 2.0
Gametopia 2.0
 
U motif gamify my health meetup 12 october 2012
U motif gamify my health meetup 12 october 2012U motif gamify my health meetup 12 october 2012
U motif gamify my health meetup 12 october 2012
 
InnoGage KASCAC Presentation
InnoGage KASCAC PresentationInnoGage KASCAC Presentation
InnoGage KASCAC Presentation
 
Widya Amiranti = CV
Widya Amiranti = CVWidya Amiranti = CV
Widya Amiranti = CV
 
SIRS Statistical Summary, Fall 2008a
SIRS Statistical Summary, Fall 2008aSIRS Statistical Summary, Fall 2008a
SIRS Statistical Summary, Fall 2008a
 
2. richard unilever
2. richard   unilever2. richard   unilever
2. richard unilever
 
Scn briefing book for sapphire now 2010
Scn briefing book for sapphire now 2010Scn briefing book for sapphire now 2010
Scn briefing book for sapphire now 2010
 
I behave meeting 26th march 2013 v1 julia
I behave meeting 26th march 2013 v1   juliaI behave meeting 26th march 2013 v1   julia
I behave meeting 26th march 2013 v1 julia
 
Sexunzipped damien-hampton
Sexunzipped damien-hamptonSexunzipped damien-hampton
Sexunzipped damien-hampton
 
Singulariteit
SingulariteitSingulariteit
Singulariteit
 
Jive new way_tour_my_sap_24_may2011 final
Jive new way_tour_my_sap_24_may2011 finalJive new way_tour_my_sap_24_may2011 final
Jive new way_tour_my_sap_24_may2011 final
 
presidential election
presidential electionpresidential election
presidential election
 
Text First! Progressive Enhancement for Multimedia Content
Text First! Progressive Enhancement for Multimedia ContentText First! Progressive Enhancement for Multimedia Content
Text First! Progressive Enhancement for Multimedia Content
 

Similaire à 3. suzi bupa

Ændring af livstil ved hjælp af teknologi af Henrik Wieland
Ændring af livstil ved hjælp af teknologi af Henrik WielandÆndring af livstil ved hjælp af teknologi af Henrik Wieland
Ændring af livstil ved hjælp af teknologi af Henrik WielandIBM Danmark
 
Behavioral Alignment Instrument
Behavioral Alignment InstrumentBehavioral Alignment Instrument
Behavioral Alignment Instrumentpetersamson
 
Application of outcome mapping - Participatory monitoring and evaluation for ...
Application of outcome mapping - Participatory monitoring and evaluation for ...Application of outcome mapping - Participatory monitoring and evaluation for ...
Application of outcome mapping - Participatory monitoring and evaluation for ...ILRI
 
Mid Point Progression: Part 1
Mid Point Progression: Part 1Mid Point Progression: Part 1
Mid Point Progression: Part 1cforindliv
 
Cbiz Wellness Webinar Slides
Cbiz Wellness Webinar SlidesCbiz Wellness Webinar Slides
Cbiz Wellness Webinar Slidesmhennes110
 
QS Amsterdam Mindfulness Pills Breakout
QS Amsterdam Mindfulness Pills BreakoutQS Amsterdam Mindfulness Pills Breakout
QS Amsterdam Mindfulness Pills BreakoutNancy Dougherty
 
Parallel Session 1.9 Using Health Analytics for Improved Outcomes
Parallel Session 1.9 Using Health Analytics for Improved OutcomesParallel Session 1.9 Using Health Analytics for Improved Outcomes
Parallel Session 1.9 Using Health Analytics for Improved OutcomesNHSScotlandEvent
 
Evaluation of the NZGG Self-Harm & Suicide Prevention Collaborative
Evaluation of the NZGG Self-Harm & Suicide Prevention Collaborative Evaluation of the NZGG Self-Harm & Suicide Prevention Collaborative
Evaluation of the NZGG Self-Harm & Suicide Prevention Collaborative MHF Suicide Prevention
 
ImagineCare: Empowering Patients with Behavioral Science and Technology
ImagineCare: Empowering Patients with Behavioral Science and TechnologyImagineCare: Empowering Patients with Behavioral Science and Technology
ImagineCare: Empowering Patients with Behavioral Science and TechnologyLiz Griffith
 
ARC MGMT 374 Week 12 Presentation
ARC MGMT 374 Week 12 PresentationARC MGMT 374 Week 12 Presentation
ARC MGMT 374 Week 12 PresentationMichael Hill
 
Sustainability Let\'s Get Real About Change
Sustainability Let\'s Get Real About ChangeSustainability Let\'s Get Real About Change
Sustainability Let\'s Get Real About ChangeLeanne Smith
 
Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012
Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012
Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012vivek_shaw
 
David Behan: implications of the Health and Social Care Act – the role of the...
David Behan: implications of the Health and Social Care Act – the role of the...David Behan: implications of the Health and Social Care Act – the role of the...
David Behan: implications of the Health and Social Care Act – the role of the...The King's Fund
 
Implementation of an Evaluation Model for Evaluating Complex Health Research ...
Implementation of an Evaluation Model for Evaluating Complex Health Research ...Implementation of an Evaluation Model for Evaluating Complex Health Research ...
Implementation of an Evaluation Model for Evaluating Complex Health Research ...aihs
 
Program assessment guide_Pelletier_5.1.12
Program assessment guide_Pelletier_5.1.12Program assessment guide_Pelletier_5.1.12
Program assessment guide_Pelletier_5.1.12CORE Group
 
Pnwbha Poster 2012
Pnwbha Poster 2012Pnwbha Poster 2012
Pnwbha Poster 2012dzeviar
 
Are you pondering what i'm pondering
Are you pondering what i'm ponderingAre you pondering what i'm pondering
Are you pondering what i'm ponderingJacob Campbell
 

Similaire à 3. suzi bupa (20)

Ændring af livstil ved hjælp af teknologi af Henrik Wieland
Ændring af livstil ved hjælp af teknologi af Henrik WielandÆndring af livstil ved hjælp af teknologi af Henrik Wieland
Ændring af livstil ved hjælp af teknologi af Henrik Wieland
 
Behaviour Change. Achieving Success
Behaviour Change. Achieving SuccessBehaviour Change. Achieving Success
Behaviour Change. Achieving Success
 
Behavioral Alignment Instrument
Behavioral Alignment InstrumentBehavioral Alignment Instrument
Behavioral Alignment Instrument
 
Application of outcome mapping - Participatory monitoring and evaluation for ...
Application of outcome mapping - Participatory monitoring and evaluation for ...Application of outcome mapping - Participatory monitoring and evaluation for ...
Application of outcome mapping - Participatory monitoring and evaluation for ...
 
Mid Point Progression: Part 1
Mid Point Progression: Part 1Mid Point Progression: Part 1
Mid Point Progression: Part 1
 
Cbiz Wellness Webinar Slides
Cbiz Wellness Webinar SlidesCbiz Wellness Webinar Slides
Cbiz Wellness Webinar Slides
 
QS Amsterdam Mindfulness Pills Breakout
QS Amsterdam Mindfulness Pills BreakoutQS Amsterdam Mindfulness Pills Breakout
QS Amsterdam Mindfulness Pills Breakout
 
Parallel Session 1.9 Using Health Analytics for Improved Outcomes
Parallel Session 1.9 Using Health Analytics for Improved OutcomesParallel Session 1.9 Using Health Analytics for Improved Outcomes
Parallel Session 1.9 Using Health Analytics for Improved Outcomes
 
Mobile health: clinical aspects
Mobile health: clinical aspectsMobile health: clinical aspects
Mobile health: clinical aspects
 
Evaluation of the NZGG Self-Harm & Suicide Prevention Collaborative
Evaluation of the NZGG Self-Harm & Suicide Prevention Collaborative Evaluation of the NZGG Self-Harm & Suicide Prevention Collaborative
Evaluation of the NZGG Self-Harm & Suicide Prevention Collaborative
 
ImagineCare: Empowering Patients with Behavioral Science and Technology
ImagineCare: Empowering Patients with Behavioral Science and TechnologyImagineCare: Empowering Patients with Behavioral Science and Technology
ImagineCare: Empowering Patients with Behavioral Science and Technology
 
ARC MGMT 374 Week 12 Presentation
ARC MGMT 374 Week 12 PresentationARC MGMT 374 Week 12 Presentation
ARC MGMT 374 Week 12 Presentation
 
Sustainability Let\'s Get Real About Change
Sustainability Let\'s Get Real About ChangeSustainability Let\'s Get Real About Change
Sustainability Let\'s Get Real About Change
 
Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012
Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012
Man org session 14_org decision making_16th august 2012
 
David Behan: implications of the Health and Social Care Act – the role of the...
David Behan: implications of the Health and Social Care Act – the role of the...David Behan: implications of the Health and Social Care Act – the role of the...
David Behan: implications of the Health and Social Care Act – the role of the...
 
Implementation of an Evaluation Model for Evaluating Complex Health Research ...
Implementation of an Evaluation Model for Evaluating Complex Health Research ...Implementation of an Evaluation Model for Evaluating Complex Health Research ...
Implementation of an Evaluation Model for Evaluating Complex Health Research ...
 
Program assessment guide_Pelletier_5.1.12
Program assessment guide_Pelletier_5.1.12Program assessment guide_Pelletier_5.1.12
Program assessment guide_Pelletier_5.1.12
 
Pnwbha Poster 2012
Pnwbha Poster 2012Pnwbha Poster 2012
Pnwbha Poster 2012
 
Are you pondering what i'm pondering
Are you pondering what i'm ponderingAre you pondering what i'm pondering
Are you pondering what i'm pondering
 
Healthcare Without Walls
Healthcare Without WallsHealthcare Without Walls
Healthcare Without Walls
 

3. suzi bupa

  • 1. Digital Behaviour Change Evidence-based Approaches and Critical Success Factors Suzi Bentley Tanner 10 December, 2012 Bupa Private and Confidential 26th September 2011 1
  • 2. There are a large and growing number of web-based, goal- oriented tools on the market…
  • 3. …as well as a number that focus specifically on encouraging health behavior change.
  • 4. Mobile technologies are present at key trigger moments, and also support data entry and management.
  • 5. Although there are many behaviour change tools on the market, the real question is…are they successful? It depends how you measure it...
  • 6. How can we define success for behaviour change initiatives? The ‘holy grail’ is measurable health outcomes Engagement high •Sign up/participate •Assess needs Short-term achievement •Take part in activities •Utilise tracking/social Ease of elements measurement Sustained Change •Ongoing involvement •Measurable biometric or clinical outcomes low The challenge in behaviour change is not the initial period of high motivation, it’s how do you extend that so it actually becomes a lasting change Bupa Private and Confidential over time. 6
  • 7. There is evidence that digital tools can have a measurable effect for some people and some interventions. Emotional/mental health: CCBT Alcohol consumption Safer sexual behaviours Smoking cessation Increased physical activity Clinical outcomes Healthy people engaged in unhealthy Weight loss behaviour Intention and self-efficacy Short term effects BMI Sustained effects Knowledge and understanding People with long-term Emotional/mental health: conditions social networks/personal stories low Measurable effect of digital tools on behaviour change high Bupa Private and Confidential Murray, et al. Web-based interventions for behaviour change and self-management: potential, pitfalls and progress. UCL 7
  • 8. Research also suggests that larger effects can be achieved by incorporating a number of elements into digital tools. Strong theoretical Persuasive techniques foundation (show users the consequence of their Credibility, authority e.g. Theory of behaviour; normative pressure) planned behaviour Goal Tailoring, person Social setting, action alisation networking planning Human Perceived Relevance effectiveness support and prompts Bupa Private and Confidential 8
  • 9. The challenge is how we translate these intangible elements into success. It’s not easy. But neither is change. Bupa Private and Confidential 9

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. Attrition is high – may undermine effectiveness
  2. I haven’t included financial incentives here. Research shows that financial incentives focus on immediate return, rather than long-term change, and also affects the psychological nature of the change (‘we don’t think you can do it so we have to bribe you’ rather than ‘we believe you have the power to change’.