A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
Beginning your research
1.
2. TOPICS FOR THIS CLASS
Academic Research vs. Personal Research
Different resources are needed for different topics
Creating a research topic
Locate
Information Basics (Sources, Types, Cycles)
Plan
Searching on the Web
Searching Library Resources
Evaluate
Analyzing Information
Information Ethics
Final project
Expected outcome: You will have gathered
sufficient background information to provide a
basic understanding of your topic and to begin
research in earnest.
3. WHAT IS RESEARCH?
Research is not:
gathering data, reorganizing and reporting on it.
Instead, Research creates new knowledge.
Makes a claim
Assesses the quality of available evidence
Support your position.
Information is our research tool.
By using other (credible) sources, we can build on previous knowledge.
4. THE RESEARCH PROCESS
Focus a topic (your claim, opinion, etc.)
Plan a strategy
Locate information
Evaluate information
Organize/synthesize your evidence
Use information to support your claim
6. FOCUSING YOUR TOPIC
Focus
topic
How do you formulate a good thesis?
Gather background information
Identify or focus on one problem or issue relating to
your topic.
Express the problem or issue as a research
question(s).
Make sure that your focus is not to broad or narrow.
Formulate your thesis.
A good research thesis clearly expresses your perspective or stance on a topic or
issue
.
7. HOW TO FOCUS A TOPIC?
Gather background material from:
Specialized references sources, like:
Books
Websites, journal articles
Ask questions (5 W’s).
Who? (limit by gender, age, etc.)
What? (limit by subtopic, issue, problem…)
Where? (limit by geography, location)
When? (limit by time)
Why? (limit by cause)
8. EXAMPLE OF FOCUSING YOUR TOPIC
General topic:
bilingual education
Question:
Is bilingual education working in
America’s schools?
Working thesis:
Bilingual education is the least effective
method for teaching English language
learners.
9. EXAMPLE
General topic:
female soldiers and active duty
Question:
Should soldiers be punished for
becoming pregnant in a war zone?
Working thesis:
Female soldiers who become pregnant in
a war zone threaten the security of their
comrades and should be punished.
10. PLANNING YOUR STRATEGY
Before you start, ask yourself . . .
What keywords will I use to search?
Bilingual education is the least effective
method for teaching English language
learners.
Write them down! Bilingual education, English
language, English learners, schools,
America
11. PLANNING YOUR STRATEGY
Ask yourself . . .
where can I gather background information?
The Web
Encyclopedias
Reference books
Organizations
Textbooks
Experts
Diana Hacker's Research and Documentation
Online
12. LOCATING INFORMATION
Get ready to use the tools!
Web search tools
Search engines
Portals
Library search tools
Online catalogs (to find books)
Online databases (to find articles)
13. EVALUATING INFORMATION
The most important skill you can develop in the
research process is to effectively evaluate what
you find.
On the Web
In a book
In an article
Always evaluate your information, no matter
where you get it!
We will discuss evaluating information later.
Editor's Notes
Read the 2007 “Beyond Google..” article by Alison Head. Then, read the abstract, conclusion, and student comments from the report. While the two studies show some conflicting results, many of the findings are indicative of problems students face when conducting research at the college level. Consider some of these findings and discuss which ones mirror your behavior/experience/anxiety with research. Do you disagree with any of the findings? React to one student comment from the report.Watch a video on the information cycle. Explain how your topic fits into each step of the information cycle. Summarize five steps of the research process that we discussed in class.Focusing your topicRead a tutorial. Write a short paragraph stating what you already know about your topic. You will go through a discovery process as you attempt to learn more in order to support your thesis. Ask yourself five questions that you think you will need to answer in order to do this.+Look for background information on your topic using the tools we discussed in class. a. Using a search engine, go to Wikipedia. Look for information on your topic. Summarize what you found on Wikipedia. Do you think Did you find useful links to other information sources?b. Describe what you discovered about your topic using print reference sources from the library.c. Find one other source that provides background information on your topic. Describe what your findings.Use the table below to begin tracking the terms, phrases, and/or names that you use to search for information.
Teams: find a scholarly article on the Web
Must have a topic before beginning the course.My topic is Everglades restoration.
Think of hierarchical structure: broader topic, narrower topicThink of keywords (for searching)