2. Who is this for?
• Have no clue what Bitcoin/Blockchain/Cryptocurrencies/ICOs are
• Have heard a little but inquisitive to know more to make an
investment decision
• Already invested in Bitcoin because of the hype but want to dive
deeper to make a bigger investment and/or diversify
2
3. Agenda
• Why money?
• What is money?
• Money Systems
• Bitcoin Characteristics
• Bitcoin Price & Valuation
• Bitcoin Investment Arguments
• Other Cryptocurrencies/Tokens
• ICOs
3
5. Why do we have money?
• Money came into existence to make barter more efficient – scales up
exchange
• Sharing and reciprocation becomes difficult to mange as communities
grow - to scale up social obligations
• Created by the government to levy taxes and scale up their power
(war, acquire more tax payers, more demand for currency…)
5
6. What is Money?
• A medium of exchange
• Widely accepted
• Interchangeable
• Divisible
• Transportable
• Transferable
• Hard to counterfeit
• Store of Value
• Stable value
6
7. Why did cryptocurrencies come into
existence and what they do?
• Disillusionment with the
financial system after 2008
crisis
• Cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin
created a system for
exchanging digital money
without the need for banks
• System rules written in
software and open source –
owned by no one entity
7
9. Simple Centralized Money System
• Alice tells bank she wants to send money to Bob
• Bank verifies Alice authorized it and checks her funds
• Bank adds transaction to its proprietary ledger
• Trust in bank essential
• People worry about
• Ledger tamper
• Freezing of accounts
• High transaction fees
9
Source: What are cryptocurrencies, Rasheed Sabar
10. Simple Decentralized Money System
• No bank – replaced by community hall
• No proprietary bank ledger – replaced by public community ledger
• Transaction announced to entire community
• Transaction validated by majority of community members
• Designated person adds transaction to community ledger
• Process managed by community and not a single authority
• But,
• How to keep ledger secure?
• Verification is better shouldered by dedicated
workers than entire community
• No privacy – everyone can see everyone
else’s balances
10
Source: What are cryptocurrencies, Rasheed Sabar
11. Decentralized & Distributed Money System
• Everyone maintains own personal copy of ledger – must be synchronized with others based on certain rules (no single
point of failure as several ledgers would have to be tampered)
• Community members do not verify transactions – they employ validators who get paid for the job in the community’s
currency [validators can be audited by community and ledger is still open, so not like bank]
• System is now digital [no community hall for people to get together] – transactions now between randomized emails
(public addresses, not actual identities) that each member can access with their own secret password, so their balances
remain private
11
Source: What are cryptocurrencies, Rasheed Sabar
12. Secure Decentralized & Distributed
• Instead of randomly choosing validator, choose one that solves a cryptographic puzzle fastest
• Solving puzzles use computer resources and electricity and not as simple as ‘manufacturing’ the longest ledger
• Tampering with a ledger requires more resources than other validators combined
12
Source: What are cryptocurrencies, Rasheed Sabar
13. Bitcoin Money System
• The last slide represents how Bitcoin works very closely!
• In the Bitcoin world,
• Validators are called Miners
• Community Ledger is called the public Blockchain
• Blocks of transactions are chained together via hash functions to create the
blockchain i.e. each block contains condensed version of the previous one
until the first block, making ‘ledger tampering’ almost impossible
• Validators are rewarded via issuance of new bitcoins as opposed to
transaction fees
• Bitcoin supply will plateau to 21M coins by 2040 (16.55M currently) – the
puzzles get more difficult to resolve and the rewards get smaller
13
17. Top 10 Cryptocurrencies by Market Cap
Source: Coinmarketcap.com
17
• Cryptocurrencies serve different
purposes and can differ by
• Features – transaction speed, privacy
• ‘Monetary Policy’ – supply and issuance
rates, tamper resistance mechanics
• Governance structures – developers-
miners-users (Btc), developers-miners-
users-stakeholders (Dash), Single Person
(Ethereum)
19. Bitcoin Adoption – Early Days
Bitcoin is 9 years old: First BTC
Whitepaper was released on 31
Oct 2008
19
20. History of Bitcoin Price Impacting Events
• +Nework Effect
• -Failure of latest Fork
• +Plan to launch bitcoin futures
• +Regulation of 11 Exchanges in JP
• +Goldman Sachs CEO and IMF neutral to
Bitcoin
• -JP Morgan calls Bitcoin fraud
• -China bans BTC exchanges and ICOs
• +Fidelity supports Bitcoin tracking in
client portfolios
• +North Korea – US Tension
• +Yuan’s fall in Jan
• +Brexit
• + Trump elected
• + Steam accepts Bitcoin
20
62: Bitcoin price breaks $1K first time in 3 years
63: SEC denies Winklevos ETF
64: SEC denies second ETF
65: JP declares BTC as legal tender
66: Bitcoin splits into BTC and BCH
21. High Level Framework for Valuing Bitcoin
This was the prediction in 2013. Even #1 has not happened till now and Bitcoin is expected to be valued $10K by end of 2017
21
22. Other Valuation Methods
DEMAND
•Use as a means for payment in financial
transaction
•Use as an instrument for speculation
•Use as a store of value
SUPPLY
22
Source: Seeking Alpha
24. How to detect Bitcoin bubbles?
• Analogous to PE ratio for stocks –
high ratio means overvalued or high
growth stock
• NVT Ratio – Price per
bitcoin/money flowing through
network (like company earnings) or
network value/transaction value
• NVT between 40-90 for BTC implies
no bubble
• Similar concept can be applied
Ethereum where network value is
correlated to daily transaction but
its NVT needs more time to settle
into a long term range for bubble
detection
24
Source: Woobull.com
26. Bitcoin It has no fundamental value
• Provides no interest payments, no claim on
profits or dividends
• No ownership of factories or other hard assets
• Purely speculative
• Positive price-value feedback loop
• Collective self-interest and cryptography (neither
does fiat nor gold)
• Utility exists in countries with no trust in banks
and local currency, high inflation rates or capital
controls, well-off refugees who need to flee and
transfer wealth
26
Source: What are cryptocurrencies, Rasheed Sabar
27. Govt. will crack down on it
• Used by drug dealers, tax evaders, extortionists and dark web users
• Evade capital controls
• If terrorists start financing their operations in bitcoin?
• Ban difficult to impose due to its distributed and de-central nature;
no place; just needs one miner to continue
• Govt. can certainly make it difficult to buy bitcoin but buyers will
move to friendlier countries or move to in-person black markets
• Bitcoin futures approved and ETF approval more likely; JP legalized it;
over time buyers may need to give up some privacy to prevent
demand from criminals
27
Source: What are cryptocurrencies, Rasheed Sabar
28. Central Banks Will Issue their Own
Cryptocurrencies
• Central bank issued cryptocurrencies (CBC) will crowd out Bitcoin –
China, Singapore, IMF urging central banks to consider it
• Just a different implementation of fiat bringing several advantages –
instant taxation, real-time risk monitoring and cross border payments
• But, still not DECENTRALIZED; not stateless or unaffected by
inflationary monetary policy; CBC and Bitcoin likely to co-exist and
latter benefit from legitimization of cryptocurrencies and fuel demand
• Possibility of countries/central banks building reserves of Bitcoin like
Russia and China do with gold to reduce USD reserves
28
Source: What are cryptocurrencies, Rasheed Sabar
29. Safety, Privacy, Miner concentration risk
• Bitcoin funds have been hacked
• Bitcoin addresses are open to public and could be traced back to actual
identities
• Over 70% mining power comes from China
• Blockchain has never been hacked; only private company exchanges or
wallets have been; safe list of these companies has now emerged
• Other services and cryptocurrencies for more privacy; Bitcoin level of
privacy works for majority of users
• Concentration is a risk but unlikely given the resources required for mining;
bitcoin ecosystem technology is evolving with technology improvements
29
Source: What are cryptocurrencies, Rasheed Sabar
30. Crowded Trade
• In the news daily; price gone up too quickly and so
downside risk
• Shorting bitcoin not easy; futures markets arriving
and so price will drop
• Bitcoin ownership is low - ~10M users when there
could be more demand from 100s of millions from
high inflation/capital control countries, 2B
unbanked and 500M millenials
• Futures and ETFs not launched yet – would be
buyers kept out
• Low correlation (10% with stock, 0% with gold)
with tradional assets – will drive demand for
diversifying portfolios
30
Source: What are cryptocurrencies, Rasheed Sabar
32. Bitcoin Investment Arguments - Summary
• Cryptocurrencies can protect against high-inflation and capital
controls.
• They get more secure and more developed as prices go up via price-
value feedback loops.
• Central banks may legitimize them by issuing their own
cryptocurrencies
• And they may prove themselves as safe-havens in the next crisis
32
33. Which Bitcoin Exchange to use?
• Depends on your location
• Currencies supported
• Trading Fees
• Deposit and withdrawal fees
• Deposit methods supported
• Deposit/Withdrawal times
• Verification Requirements
33
36. Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs)
• An unregulated means of
crowdfunding via use of
cryptocurrency, which can be a
source of capital for startup
companies
• In an ICO a percentage of the newly
issued cryptocurrency is sold to
investors in exchange for legal
tender or other cryptocurrencies
such as Ether/Bitcoin.
36
Source: Investopedia, Digital Ventures
The baker has extra bread and wants meat. Hoping to trade bread for meat,
he goes to the butcher. But what if the butcher doesn't want bread? Then there is no exchange, lacking a
\coincidence of wants".
0. At the end of each day, community members gather in person at the town hall to conduct transactions
1. [ANNOUNCE] When someone wants to pay coins to someone else, she stands up and announces the transaction
to everyone at the town hall. One person speaks at a time.
2. [CHECK] When a transaction is announced, everyone at the town hall checks if the transaction is valid by
Verifying that the payer authorized it
Verifying vs the community ledger that the payer has enough funds
3. [APPEND] The process for adding the transaction to the community ledger is as follows:
If the transaction is validated by a majority of community members, then a designated person
{ Appends the transaction to the community ledger
1. [ANNOUNCE] When someone wants to pay coins to someone else, she broadcasts the transaction to the
community over the internet.
Anyone can broadcast a transaction at any time
Transactions contain public addresses rather than actual identities
Due to physical realities of internet lines, broadcasts are not heard by everyone in the same order
2. [CHECK] Validators pick an unconrmed transaction that they've heard about and check validity by
Verifying that the payer authorized it (by checking its digital signature7)
Verifying vs their copy of the community ledger that the payer has enough funds to cover the transaction
3. [APPEND] The process for adding to the community ledger is as follows:
Every 10 minutes, the network randomly selects a validator (V2) and that validator:
{ Appends his veried transaction to his copy of the community ledger, and
{ Broadcasts his updated community ledger to other validators
Other validators conrm that:
{ V2's ledger is valid, and
{ V2's ledger is longer than their own ledger (the \longest ledger policy")
If conrmed, then validators update their ledger copy to match V2's and V2 receives .01 coins
1. [ANNOUNCE] When someone wants to pay coins to someone else, she broadcasts the transaction to the
community over the internet.
Anyone can broadcast a transaction at any time
Transactions contain pseudonyms rather than actual identities
Due to physical realities of internet lines, broadcasts are not heard by everyone in the same order
2. [CHECK] Validators pick an unconrmed transaction that they've heard about and check validity by
Verifying that the payer authorized it (by checking the digital signature)
Verifying vs their copy of the community ledger that the payer has enough funds to cover the transaction
Then they begin work on a cryptographic puzzle
3. [APPEND] The process for adding to the community ledger is as follows:
When a validator (V3) solves his cryptographic puzzle, that validator:
{ Appends his veried transaction and puzzle solution to his copy of the community ledger, and
{ Broadcasts his updated community ledger to other validators
Other validators conrm that:
{ V3's ledger is valid, and
{ V3's ledger is longer than their own ledger (the \longest ledger policy")
If conrmed, then validators update their ledger copy to match V3's and V3 receives .01 coins
On a micro-level, cryptocurrencies dier in terms of features. Each cryptocurrency has its own ledger
and its own rules for transactions. Each is a system unto itself. For example, Litecoin, worth over $3 billion,
originated as a fork of Bitcoin's code and has faster transactions. Zcash has more privacy.
On a macro-level, cryptocurrencies dier in money supply issuance and tamper-resistance. Each has
its own pre-programmed monetary policy. In Bitcoin, long-term supply is xed at 21 million bitcoins; in
others, issuance rates remain non-zero and supply grows forever. Bitcoin achieves tamper-resistance by
forcing validators to solve cryptographic puzzles; some researchers are developing other tamper-resistance
mechanics.12
On a meta-level, cryptocurrencies are a profound social experiment in how people agree on rules to
govern themselves in the absence of central authority. Their governance structures are fascinating. In
Bitcoin, only a handful of core developers can make changes to the code. However, only if the miners accept
code changes do they become real. And if miners accept code changes that users don't like, users may stop
holding bitcoin, which in turn hurts miners (since they are paid in bitcoin). There are implicit checks-and-
balances in place between developers, miners, and users that discourages a change in rules beneting only
one group. When the community disagrees on a rule change, the ledger splits (\forks") and the separate
groups follow dierent rules, with each ledger constituting a dierent currency going forward.
When price rises more engineers are attracted to the space, more hiring happens and more useful services get built, driving user adoption and increases value for everyone in the ecosystem. More validators more ledger security.
When price rises more engineers are attracted to the space, more hiring happens and more useful services get built, driving user adoption and increases value for everyone in the ecosystem. Morning validators more ledger security.
When price rises more engineers are attracted to the space, more hiring happens and more useful services get built, driving user adoption and increases value for everyone in the ecosystem. Morning validators more ledger security.
When price rises more engineers are attracted to the space, more hiring happens and more useful services get built, driving user adoption and increases value for everyone in the ecosystem. Morning validators more ledger security.
When price rises more engineers are attracted to the space, more hiring happens and more useful services get built, driving user adoption and increases value for everyone in the ecosystem. Morning validators more ledger security.
Cryptocurrencies are tokens, that use special software that controls, their supply, rate of inflation and use a blockchain to make the network trusted. It’s the only and very significant difference. A token can be produced by anyone, with no ruling of supply and confirmations.
Altcoins have a blockchain of their own which can be independent of bitcoin blockhain derived.
A “token” by definition is a representation any fungible tradible good such as currency, loyalty points, gold certificates, in game items and more. It represents that I own a underlying tradable asset. Tokens are on top of an existing blockchain to represent a utililty or service. You pay $2 at a pinball machine effectively exchanging your currency for 3 pin balls (tokens) to be used to play within the pinball game.
The main difference between altcoins and tokens is in their structure; altcoins are separate currencies with their own separate blockchain while tokens operate on top of a blockchain that facilitates the creation of decentralized applications.