SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  40
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Oak Harbor Facilities Plan
                      City Council Meeting

                                       November 20, 2012



Oh910i1-8594.pptx/1
Tonight’s Agenda/Objectives
          1. Review scope and purpose of Amendment 5
          2. Present results of field work completed through
             Amendment 5
                      – Topographical Survey
                      – Environmental Assessment
                      – Geotechnical Borings
                                          g
          3. Summarize estimated cost impacts
                                                    p
          4. Gain direction from Council on next steps:
                      – Resolution 12-33: Complete Facilities Plan for Windjammer
                        Vicinity as defined by Resolution 12-17
                      – Resolution 12-34: Expand Windjammer Vicinity to include
                        adjacent property and complete Facilities Plan
Oh910i1-8594.pptx/2
Resolution 12-17 (August 14, 2012)

    • Proceed with Facilities Plan based on Windjammer Vicinity
                                                j             y
    • Minimize space impacts on Windjammer Park
      to the extent possible
    • C ti
      Continue public process:
                   bli
              – Define the best location
                within the Windjammer
                Vicinity
                Vicinit
              – Define layout and other
                desirable features based
                on the final location




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/3
Amendment 5 Scope and Purpose


     • Technical detail to help select the best location
       (3 to 4 acres) for the new WWTP
     • Field work including:g
               – Phase 1 topographical survey to establish
                 elevations and flood protection requirements
               – Environmental assessment to better define
                 permitting and wetland mitigation requirements
               – Geotechnical borings to characterize soils better
                                                       soils,
                 estimated design requirements and cost


Oh910i1-8594.pptx/4
October 16, 2012 City Council Direction
      • Include adjacent property (Freund property) in
        scope of Amendment 5
                      Does Freund property provide technical/cost
                      advantages relative to Windjammer Vicinity?




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/5
Amendment 5 Current Status


     • Phase 1 survey work complete (Attachment 1)
     • Environmental assessment completed based on
       October 30, 2012 site visit (Attachment 2)
                  ,                (            )
     • Geotechnical borings completed on October 30
       and 31 (Attachment 3)
     • Additional engineering analysis completed to
       compare three sites
               – Windjammer Vicinity (Charrette)
               – Freund
               – Windjammer Vicinity (Alternate)
Oh910i1-8594.pptx/6
Field Work Summary
                      Phase 1 Topographical Survey




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/7
100-Year Floodplain (El 12.5 NAVD 88)


                                        15



                                        9
                            100-Year
                           Floodplain
                           Fl d l i
                            12.5 feet



                      ~7



Oh910i1-8594.pptx/8
Regulations for Floodplain Development

     • Orange Book (
           g       (Criteria for Sewage Works Design, ’08)
                                     g            g ,    )
               – G2-1.5.2 Flood Protection: Locate unit processes
                 above the 100-year flood/wave action or adequately
                 protect from 100-year fl d/
                    t tf      100      flood/wave action
                                                    ti
     • Oak Harbor Municipal Code 17.20
               – 17 20 190(2) Nonresidential Construction: Locate
                 17.20.190(2)
                 construction above the base flood elevation or
                 floodproof structure to 1 ft above base flood elevation
               – 17.20.190(3) Critical Facilities:
                      • Construction permissible if no feasible alternative
                      • Lowest floor > 3 feet above base flood elevation

Oh910i1-8594.pptx/9
Summary of Flood Protection Requirements
     • Portions (or all) of sites being considered lie within 100-year
       flood plain (12.5 NAVD 88)
               – R
                 Recommend elevating grade and/or structures t 13 5
                         d l    ti      d    d/    t t       to 13.5
               – Additional protection for “critical facilities” (e.g. electrical)
     • Southern portions of Windjammer Vicinity sites must be
                 p               j            y
       elevated approximately 3 f
        l     d       i     l   feet
               – Retaining wall or sloped fill
     • Existing grade at Freund property is an average of ~6.5 feet
                                                           6.5
       below 100-year flood elevation
               – Retaining wall/levee
               – Fill site
               – New/improved access to site is needed
     • 100-year flood elevation [+12.5] more conservative than Mean
       Higher High Water (MHHW) + sea level rise [approx + 11 3]
                                                  [approx. 11.3]

Oh910i1-8594.pptx/10
Field Work Summary
                       Environmental Assessment




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/11
Summary of Environmental Assessment
     • Wetland ditches at both Windjammer (Charrette) and Freund sites
     • Federal, state, Oak Harbor permit approvals required for wetland
       fill/buffer impacts
       fill/b ff i      t
     • Windjammer (Charrette) Site
               – Wetland ditch along southern boundary may be filled as result of p j
                                   g                 y   y                        project
               – Mitigation costs estimated between $150,000 and $275,000
               – Risk of delays and/or cost increases relatively low (limited tidal water
                 connection)
     • Freund Site
               – Wetland ditches along boundaries would be filled as result of project
               – Site adjacent to mitigation wetland; portion may be filled for access
               – Mitigation costs estimated from $400,000 to $800,000
               – Risk of delays and/or cost increases relatively high (tidal water
                 connection; impact to previous mitigation wetland)


Oh910i1-8594.pptx/12
Field Work Summary
                       Geotechnical Assessment




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/13
Geotechnical Boring Site Plan




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/14
Geotechnical Cross Sections




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/15
Geotechnical Cross Sections




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/16
Summary of Geotechnical Assessment

     • Ground improvements needed at all sites
     • Dewatering shoring, and flood protection will
       Dewatering, shoring
       also impact cost
                                              j
     • Sites to north, west and center of Windjammer
       Vicinity are preferred
               – Highest ground elevation
               – Sh ll
                 Shallowest t till (25 to 30 f t)
                           t to        t     feet)
     • Park site: deeper to till; additional flood control
     • Freund east sites most difficult/costly
       Freund,
               – Lowest ground elevation
               – Deepest to till (40+ feet)
                                 (40

Oh910i1-8594.pptx/17
Cost Comparison




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/18
Windjammer Charrette Concept
     Conceptual Plan View (August 14 2012)
                                  14,




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/19
Windjammer Charrette Concept
     Conceptual Site Section View (August 14 2012)
                                          14,




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/20
Total Project Cost Components
     Windjammer (
         j      (Charrette) Layout
                          ) y
                                          $100


                                              $95
                                                             $2.9
                                                                             $93.5
                                                                             $93 5 (Total)
                                              $90

                                                             $7.6
                                              $85
                                                                             $83.0
                                                                             $83 0 (WWTP)
                  Estimated Cost (Millions)




                                              $80

                                                                                             Outfall
                                              $75
                                                                                             WW Conveyance
                                                                                                Co eya ce
                                                                                             WWTP
                                              $70

                                                            $83.0
                                              $65


                                              $60


                                              $55


                                              $50
                                                    Windjammer (Charrette)
Oh910i1-8594.pptx/21
WWTP Project Cost Components
     Windjammer (
         j      (Charrette) Layout
                          ) y
                                             $90

                                                                            $83.0 (WWTP)
                                             $80
                                                           $15.0
                                             $70
                                                            $2.1            $68.0 (Construction +
                                                                            Land)
                                             $60
                 Estimated Cost (Millions)




                                             $50
                                                                                            Soft Costs (25%)
                                                                                            Land Acquisition
                                                                                            Land Acquisition
                                             $40
                                                                                            WWTP Construction

                                                           $65.9
                                             $30


                                             $20


                                             $10


                                             $0
                                                   Windjammer (Charrette)
Oh910i1-8594.pptx/22
Approximately 17% of WWTP Costs are
     “Variable” Based on Site
                                            $90


                                            $80


                                            $70
                                                                                          $68.0 (Construction + Land)
                                                     $11.7
                                            $60   (“Variable”)
                                                  ( Variable )            $5.2
                                                                          $5 2
                        d Cost (Millions)




                                                                                          $56.3 (“Fixed”)   Land Acquisition
                                                                                                            Architectural Premium
                                            $50
                                                                                                            Added Structural
                                                                                                            Geotechnical Premium
                Estimated




                                            $40
                                                                                                            Wastewater/Effluent Piping
                                                                                                            Sitework
                                            $30                                                             Base WWTP
                                                                         $56.3

                                            $20


                                            $10


                                            $0
                                                                 Windjammer (Charrette)
Oh910i1-8594.pptx/23
Sitework is Largest Variable Cost Component
                                             $12.0
                                                                                         $11.7 (“Variable”)
                                             $11.0
                                                                        $2.1
                                             $10.0

                                              $9.0
                                                                        $1.6

                                              $8.0
                                              $8 0
                         d Cost (Millions)
                                         )




                                                                        $0.8
                                                                                                        Land Acquisition
                                              $7.0
                                                                                                        Architectural Premium
                                                                        $1.7
                                              $6.0                                                      Added Structural
                 Estimated




                                                                        $0.4                            Geotechnical Premium
                                              $5.0                                                      Wastewater/Effluent Piping
                                                                                                        Sitework
                                              $4.0

                                              $3.0
                                                       44%              $5.2
                                              $2.0   Sitework

                                              $1.0

                                              $0.0
                                                                Windjammer (Charrette)
Oh910i1-8594.pptx/24
Sitework Cost Elements
     Windjammer (
          j      (Charrette) Layout
                           ) y
                                             $7.0



                                             $6.0
                                             $6 0


                                                                                          $5.2 Sitework
                                             $5.0
                                                     $1.2 Site
                         d Cost (Millions)




                                                    Allowances
                                             $4.0                                                         Allowance (Wetlands Mitigation)
                                                                                                          Allowance (Flood Protection)
                                                                                                          Allowance (Stormwater Mgmt.)
                                                                                                                    (            g )
                 Estimated




                                             $3.0                                                         Allowance (Clear/Demo)
                                                                                                          Base Sitework Estimate

                                             $2.0



                                             $1.0



                                             $0.0
                                                                 Windjammer (Charrette)
Oh910i1-8594.pptx/25
Property Adjacent to Windjammer Vicinity
     Conceptual Plan View




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/26
Property Adjacent to Windjammer Vicinity
     Conceptual Site Section View




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/27
Offsetting Costs for Alternate (Freund) Property
     Relative to Windjammer (
                     j      (Charrette) Layout
                                      ) y


            Lower Cost                  Higher Costs
     • Property acquisition       • Wastewater/effluent
       (Assessed value)             conveyance
     • Demolition/clearing        • Geotechnical
     • Aeration basin structure   • Sitework
                                     – Flood Protection
                                     – Wetland Mitigation




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/28
Sitework Cost Element Comparison
     Windjammer (
          j      (Charrette) & Freund Layouts
                           )            y
                                             $7.0

                                                                                      Allowances
                                             $6.0
                                             $6 0                                     increase due to
                                                                                      Flood Protection
                                                                                      and Wetlands
                                             $5.0
                                                                                      Mitigation
                         d Cost (Millions)
                                         )




                                             $4.0                                      Allowance (Wetlands Mitigation)
                                                                                       Allowance (Flood Protection)
                                                                                       Allowance (Stormwater Mgmt.)
                 Estimated




                                             $3.0                                      Allowance (Clear/Demo)
                                                                                       Base Sitework Estimate

                                             $2.0



                                             $1.0



                                             $0.0
                                                    Windjammer (Charrette)   Freund
Oh910i1-8594.pptx/29
Windjammer Alternate Concept
     Conceptual Plan and Perspective View (8/14/12)




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/30
Lower Costs for Windjammer (Alternate) Layout
     Relative to Windjammer (
                     j      (Charrette) Layout
                                      ) y


             Same Cost                 Lower Costs
     • Property acquisition     • Aeration basin structure
       (Assessed value)         • Geotechnical
     • Demolition/clearing      • Sitework
     • Wastewater/effluent         – Flood Control
       conveyance                  – Wetland Mitigation




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/31
Sitework Cost Element Comparison
     Windjammer (
          j      (Charrette) & Windjammer (
                           )       j      (Alternate)
                                                    )
                                             $7.0

                                                                                         Allowances
                                             $6.0                                        decrease due to
                                                                                         Flood Protection
                                             $5.0
                                                                                         and Wetlands
                                                                                         Mitigation
                                       ns)
                        ed Cost (Million




                                             $4.0                                         Allowance (Wetlands Mitigation)
                                                                                          Allowance (Flood Protection)
                                                                                          Allowance (Stormwater Mgmt.)
                 Estimate




                                             $3.0
                                             $
                                                                                          Allowance (Clear/Demo)
                                                                                          Base Sitework Estimate

                                             $2.0



                                             $1.0



                                             $0.0
                                                    Windjammer    Freund   Windjammer 
                                                    (Charrette)            (Alternate)
Oh910i1-8594.pptx/32
“Variable” Cost Comparison for All Sites
              $12.0           $11.7
                                                $11.3
              $11.0
                                                                $10.1
              $10.0

                $9.0

                $8.0
                                                                                  Land Acquisition
                $7.0
                                                                                  Architectural Premium
                $6.0                                                              Added Structural
                                                                                  Geotechnical Premium
                                                                                  G t h i lP       i
                $5.0                                                              Wastewater/Effluent Piping
                                                                                  Sitework
                $4.0

                $3.0

                $2.0

                $
                $1.0

                $0.0
                       Windjammer (Charrette)   Freund   Windjammer (Alternate)
Oh910i1-8594.pptx/33
“Variable” Cost Comparison for All Sites
     Estimated Costs Shown in Millions ($)
                                       ( )
                                                         Windjammer               Windjammer
                                                         (Charrette)   Freund      (Alternate)
            Land Acquisition
            L dA     i iti                                      $2.1
                                                                $2 1       $0.2
                                                                           $0 2           $2.1
                                                                                          $2 1
            Architectural Premium                               $1.6       $1.6           $1.6
            Added Structural                                    $0.8       $0.0           $0.0
            Geotechnical Premium                                $1.7       $2.6           $1.4
            Wastewater/Effluent Piping                          $0.4       $0.8           $0.4
                       Base Sitework (Fixed)                    $4.0       $4.0           $4.0
                       Clearing & Demolition Allowance          $0.2       $0.0           $0.2
                       Stormwater Management Allowance          $0.4       $0.4           $0.4
                       Flood Protection All
                       Fl d P       i Allowance                 $0.4
                                                                $          $1.3
                                                                           $              $0.1
                                                                                          $
                       Wetlands Mitigation Allowance            $0.3       $0.4           $0.0
            Subtotal, Sitework                                  $5.2       $6.1           $4.6
            Total Site Specific Items                         $11.7       $11.3         $10.1

Oh910i1-8594.pptx/34
Total Cost Comparison for All Sites
                                             $100.0
                                                             $93.5             $93.1           $92.0
                                              $90.0


                                              $80.0


                                              $70.0
                         d Cost (Millions)
                                         )




                                                              $11.7            $11.3            $10.1
                                              $60.0
                                                                                                                 Soft Costs
                                                                                                                 Outfall
                                              $50.0
                                                                                                                 Conveyance
                 Estimated




                                                                                                                 Site Specific Items
                                              $40.0
                                                                                                                 Base WWTP

                                              $30.0


                                              $20.0


                                              $10.0


                                               $0.0
                                                      Windjammer (Charrette)   Freund   Windjammer (Alternate)
Oh910i1-8594.pptx/35
Summary of Technical & Cost
                             Differences




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/36
Summary and Conclusions

     1. Based on assessed value Freund site will likely be less
        costly to acquire
     2. Based on technical field work, Freund site will likely have
        higher construction cost
               –       Wastewater/effluent Conveyance
               –       Geotechnical
               –       Flood Protection
               –       Wetland Mitigation
                       W l d Mi i i
     3. Very little difference in overall cost between sites
     4. Means to reduce the cost of “variable” components will be
                                         variable
        considered regardless of tonight’s decision
     5. Freund site presents higher risk due to environmental
        permitting and regulations for filling within the flood plain

Oh910i1-8594.pptx/37
Next Steps




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/38
Paths Forward Based on Tonight’s Decision
                 Retain Windjammer Vicinity           Expand Windjammer Vicinity (Freund)
                      Resolution 12-33                         Resolution 12-34
     1.        Complete draft technical chapters of
                    p                      p          1.   Amendment 6: Collect community  y
               Facilities Plan                             input; compare locations using TBL+
     2.        Develop phasing/financing plan         2.   Select final location/layout for WWTP
                                                           with public input (Q1, 2013)
     3.        Final Public Open House/Council
               Workshop (Early 2013)                  3.   Complete draft technical chapters of
                                                           Facilities Plan
     4.        Council resolution to submit draft
               plan                                   4.   Develop phasing/financing plan
               (Q1,
               (Q1 2013)
                                                      5.   Final Public Open H
                                                           Fi l P bli O      House/Council
                                                                                  /C    il
     5.        Complete environmental documents            Workshop (Q2, 2013)
               for approval
                                                      6.   Council resolution to submit draft plan
     6.        Begin Preliminary Design                    (Q2, 2013)
               a. Final location & layout of WWTP     7.   Complete environmental documents for
                  with community input                     approval
               b. Equipment procurement
                                                      8.   Begin Preliminary Design
                                                             g             y     g
                                                           a. Final layout of WWTP with community
                                                              input
Oh910i1-8594.pptx/39                                       b. Equipment procurement
Questions?




Oh910i1-8594.pptx/40

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Modelling extreme conditions for wave overtopping at Weymouth - Oliver Way (H...
Modelling extreme conditions for wave overtopping at Weymouth - Oliver Way (H...Modelling extreme conditions for wave overtopping at Weymouth - Oliver Way (H...
Modelling extreme conditions for wave overtopping at Weymouth - Oliver Way (H...Stephen Flood
 
Optimisation of dewatering systems
Optimisation of dewatering systemsOptimisation of dewatering systems
Optimisation of dewatering systemsMartin Preene
 
Improving Reservoir Simulation Modeling with Seismic Attributes
Improving Reservoir Simulation Modeling with Seismic Attributes Improving Reservoir Simulation Modeling with Seismic Attributes
Improving Reservoir Simulation Modeling with Seismic Attributes Society of Petroleum Engineers
 
Borehole Seismic Solutions for Integrated Reservoir Characterization and Moni...
Borehole Seismic Solutions for Integrated Reservoir Characterization and Moni...Borehole Seismic Solutions for Integrated Reservoir Characterization and Moni...
Borehole Seismic Solutions for Integrated Reservoir Characterization and Moni...Society of Petroleum Engineers
 
25 herold 20160830 retrieval final
25 herold 20160830 retrieval final25 herold 20160830 retrieval final
25 herold 20160830 retrieval finalleann_mays
 
Teaching and research with MIKE by DHI - Dr Björn Elsäßer (Queen’s University...
Teaching and research with MIKE by DHI - Dr Björn Elsäßer (Queen’s University...Teaching and research with MIKE by DHI - Dr Björn Elsäßer (Queen’s University...
Teaching and research with MIKE by DHI - Dr Björn Elsäßer (Queen’s University...Stephen Flood
 
Moffett RAB Navy Co-Chair Updates
Moffett RAB Navy Co-Chair UpdatesMoffett RAB Navy Co-Chair Updates
Moffett RAB Navy Co-Chair UpdatesSteve Williams
 
Ten Years of Coupled Hydrology and Hydraulic Modelling Supporting Storm Water...
Ten Years of Coupled Hydrology and Hydraulic Modelling Supporting Storm Water...Ten Years of Coupled Hydrology and Hydraulic Modelling Supporting Storm Water...
Ten Years of Coupled Hydrology and Hydraulic Modelling Supporting Storm Water...Stephen Flood
 
Hydrology and hydraulics for design design
Hydrology and hydraulics for design designHydrology and hydraulics for design design
Hydrology and hydraulics for design designavirup naskar
 
Multifunctional Stormwater Projects - An Innovative Technical Design and Part...
Multifunctional Stormwater Projects - An Innovative Technical Design and Part...Multifunctional Stormwater Projects - An Innovative Technical Design and Part...
Multifunctional Stormwater Projects - An Innovative Technical Design and Part...Adam Berry
 
The Intersection of Environment and EOR: How Carbon Capture is Changing Terti...
The Intersection of Environment and EOR: How Carbon Capture is Changing Terti...The Intersection of Environment and EOR: How Carbon Capture is Changing Terti...
The Intersection of Environment and EOR: How Carbon Capture is Changing Terti...Society of Petroleum Engineers
 
WET Feature 4 - Building bigger and better - Jan_16
WET Feature 4 - Building bigger and better - Jan_16WET Feature 4 - Building bigger and better - Jan_16
WET Feature 4 - Building bigger and better - Jan_16Tim Bail
 
ICE Flooding 2013 - MIKE by DHI Delegate Pack
ICE Flooding 2013 - MIKE by DHI Delegate PackICE Flooding 2013 - MIKE by DHI Delegate Pack
ICE Flooding 2013 - MIKE by DHI Delegate PackStephen Flood
 
Optimisation of dewatering systems
Optimisation of dewatering systemsOptimisation of dewatering systems
Optimisation of dewatering systemsMartin Preene
 
Integrating Flood Risk Into Catchment Management - Michael Butts (DHI)
Integrating Flood Risk Into Catchment Management - Michael Butts (DHI)Integrating Flood Risk Into Catchment Management - Michael Butts (DHI)
Integrating Flood Risk Into Catchment Management - Michael Butts (DHI)Stephen Flood
 
The ACADEMY by DHI - Courses & Events Calendar 2014 - UK
The ACADEMY by DHI - Courses & Events Calendar 2014 - UKThe ACADEMY by DHI - Courses & Events Calendar 2014 - UK
The ACADEMY by DHI - Courses & Events Calendar 2014 - UKStephen Flood
 

Tendances (20)

TeraWatt Project
TeraWatt ProjectTeraWatt Project
TeraWatt Project
 
Modelling extreme conditions for wave overtopping at Weymouth - Oliver Way (H...
Modelling extreme conditions for wave overtopping at Weymouth - Oliver Way (H...Modelling extreme conditions for wave overtopping at Weymouth - Oliver Way (H...
Modelling extreme conditions for wave overtopping at Weymouth - Oliver Way (H...
 
Optimisation of dewatering systems
Optimisation of dewatering systemsOptimisation of dewatering systems
Optimisation of dewatering systems
 
Improving Reservoir Simulation Modeling with Seismic Attributes
Improving Reservoir Simulation Modeling with Seismic Attributes Improving Reservoir Simulation Modeling with Seismic Attributes
Improving Reservoir Simulation Modeling with Seismic Attributes
 
Borehole Seismic Solutions for Integrated Reservoir Characterization and Moni...
Borehole Seismic Solutions for Integrated Reservoir Characterization and Moni...Borehole Seismic Solutions for Integrated Reservoir Characterization and Moni...
Borehole Seismic Solutions for Integrated Reservoir Characterization and Moni...
 
25 herold 20160830 retrieval final
25 herold 20160830 retrieval final25 herold 20160830 retrieval final
25 herold 20160830 retrieval final
 
Teaching and research with MIKE by DHI - Dr Björn Elsäßer (Queen’s University...
Teaching and research with MIKE by DHI - Dr Björn Elsäßer (Queen’s University...Teaching and research with MIKE by DHI - Dr Björn Elsäßer (Queen’s University...
Teaching and research with MIKE by DHI - Dr Björn Elsäßer (Queen’s University...
 
Moffett RAB Navy Co-Chair Updates
Moffett RAB Navy Co-Chair UpdatesMoffett RAB Navy Co-Chair Updates
Moffett RAB Navy Co-Chair Updates
 
Ten Years of Coupled Hydrology and Hydraulic Modelling Supporting Storm Water...
Ten Years of Coupled Hydrology and Hydraulic Modelling Supporting Storm Water...Ten Years of Coupled Hydrology and Hydraulic Modelling Supporting Storm Water...
Ten Years of Coupled Hydrology and Hydraulic Modelling Supporting Storm Water...
 
ASDSO 2015 NE Jyoung
ASDSO 2015 NE JyoungASDSO 2015 NE Jyoung
ASDSO 2015 NE Jyoung
 
Scoping meeting presentation 4 29-13
Scoping meeting presentation 4 29-13Scoping meeting presentation 4 29-13
Scoping meeting presentation 4 29-13
 
Hydrology and hydraulics for design design
Hydrology and hydraulics for design designHydrology and hydraulics for design design
Hydrology and hydraulics for design design
 
Multifunctional Stormwater Projects - An Innovative Technical Design and Part...
Multifunctional Stormwater Projects - An Innovative Technical Design and Part...Multifunctional Stormwater Projects - An Innovative Technical Design and Part...
Multifunctional Stormwater Projects - An Innovative Technical Design and Part...
 
The Intersection of Environment and EOR: How Carbon Capture is Changing Terti...
The Intersection of Environment and EOR: How Carbon Capture is Changing Terti...The Intersection of Environment and EOR: How Carbon Capture is Changing Terti...
The Intersection of Environment and EOR: How Carbon Capture is Changing Terti...
 
WET Feature 4 - Building bigger and better - Jan_16
WET Feature 4 - Building bigger and better - Jan_16WET Feature 4 - Building bigger and better - Jan_16
WET Feature 4 - Building bigger and better - Jan_16
 
ICE Flooding 2013 - MIKE by DHI Delegate Pack
ICE Flooding 2013 - MIKE by DHI Delegate PackICE Flooding 2013 - MIKE by DHI Delegate Pack
ICE Flooding 2013 - MIKE by DHI Delegate Pack
 
Optimisation of dewatering systems
Optimisation of dewatering systemsOptimisation of dewatering systems
Optimisation of dewatering systems
 
Integrating Flood Risk Into Catchment Management - Michael Butts (DHI)
Integrating Flood Risk Into Catchment Management - Michael Butts (DHI)Integrating Flood Risk Into Catchment Management - Michael Butts (DHI)
Integrating Flood Risk Into Catchment Management - Michael Butts (DHI)
 
Wp mp-update-camp pendleton.-april_25_2013
Wp   mp-update-camp pendleton.-april_25_2013Wp   mp-update-camp pendleton.-april_25_2013
Wp mp-update-camp pendleton.-april_25_2013
 
The ACADEMY by DHI - Courses & Events Calendar 2014 - UK
The ACADEMY by DHI - Courses & Events Calendar 2014 - UKThe ACADEMY by DHI - Courses & Events Calendar 2014 - UK
The ACADEMY by DHI - Courses & Events Calendar 2014 - UK
 

En vedette

C7 aug 14 city council meeting 120814_final
C7 aug 14 city council meeting 120814_finalC7 aug 14 city council meeting 120814_final
C7 aug 14 city council meeting 120814_finalpublicinvolvement
 
Design charrette council presentation
Design charrette council presentationDesign charrette council presentation
Design charrette council presentationpublicinvolvement
 
130306 City Council Workshop
130306 City Council Workshop130306 City Council Workshop
130306 City Council Workshoppublicinvolvement
 
Oak Harbor Design Open House summary
Oak Harbor Design Open House summaryOak Harbor Design Open House summary
Oak Harbor Design Open House summarypublicinvolvement
 
Oak Harbor Design Open House
Oak Harbor Design Open HouseOak Harbor Design Open House
Oak Harbor Design Open Housepublicinvolvement
 
C6 further refine_alts_council_4-18_rev1
C6 further refine_alts_council_4-18_rev1C6 further refine_alts_council_4-18_rev1
C6 further refine_alts_council_4-18_rev1publicinvolvement
 
2015 0617 workshop_presentation_outfall_draft_brm
2015 0617 workshop_presentation_outfall_draft_brm2015 0617 workshop_presentation_outfall_draft_brm
2015 0617 workshop_presentation_outfall_draft_brmpublicinvolvement
 
Oak Harbor Good Neighbor Plan
Oak Harbor Good Neighbor PlanOak Harbor Good Neighbor Plan
Oak Harbor Good Neighbor Planpublicinvolvement
 
January 13, 2011 City Council Workshop
January 13, 2011 City Council WorkshopJanuary 13, 2011 City Council Workshop
January 13, 2011 City Council Workshoppublicinvolvement
 
2015 04-07 city-council_workshop_presentation
2015 04-07 city-council_workshop_presentation2015 04-07 city-council_workshop_presentation
2015 04-07 city-council_workshop_presentationpublicinvolvement
 
140416 oak_harbor_workshp_presentation
140416 oak_harbor_workshp_presentation140416 oak_harbor_workshp_presentation
140416 oak_harbor_workshp_presentationpublicinvolvement
 
Windjammer Park Phase 1 Design Open House
Windjammer Park Phase 1 Design Open HouseWindjammer Park Phase 1 Design Open House
Windjammer Park Phase 1 Design Open Housepublicinvolvement
 
March 9, 2011 City Council Workshop
March 9, 2011 City Council WorkshopMarch 9, 2011 City Council Workshop
March 9, 2011 City Council Workshoppublicinvolvement
 
Oak Harbor City Council Workshop: Design Update
Oak Harbor City Council Workshop: Design UpdateOak Harbor City Council Workshop: Design Update
Oak Harbor City Council Workshop: Design Updatepublicinvolvement
 
Windjammer Park Integration Plan - Council presentation
Windjammer Park Integration Plan - Council presentationWindjammer Park Integration Plan - Council presentation
Windjammer Park Integration Plan - Council presentationpublicinvolvement
 
Clean Water Facility 60% Cost Estimate Preview
Clean Water Facility 60% Cost Estimate PreviewClean Water Facility 60% Cost Estimate Preview
Clean Water Facility 60% Cost Estimate Previewpublicinvolvement
 
April 12 Planning Public Forum
April 12 Planning Public ForumApril 12 Planning Public Forum
April 12 Planning Public Forumpublicinvolvement
 
Special Workshop presentation on Finance
Special Workshop presentation on FinanceSpecial Workshop presentation on Finance
Special Workshop presentation on Financepublicinvolvement
 

En vedette (20)

C7 aug 14 city council meeting 120814_final
C7 aug 14 city council meeting 120814_finalC7 aug 14 city council meeting 120814_final
C7 aug 14 city council meeting 120814_final
 
Design charrette council presentation
Design charrette council presentationDesign charrette council presentation
Design charrette council presentation
 
130306 City Council Workshop
130306 City Council Workshop130306 City Council Workshop
130306 City Council Workshop
 
Oh workshop02 full_final
Oh workshop02 full_finalOh workshop02 full_final
Oh workshop02 full_final
 
Oak Harbor Design Open House summary
Oak Harbor Design Open House summaryOak Harbor Design Open House summary
Oak Harbor Design Open House summary
 
Oak Harbor Design Open House
Oak Harbor Design Open HouseOak Harbor Design Open House
Oak Harbor Design Open House
 
C6 further refine_alts_council_4-18_rev1
C6 further refine_alts_council_4-18_rev1C6 further refine_alts_council_4-18_rev1
C6 further refine_alts_council_4-18_rev1
 
2015 0617 workshop_presentation_outfall_draft_brm
2015 0617 workshop_presentation_outfall_draft_brm2015 0617 workshop_presentation_outfall_draft_brm
2015 0617 workshop_presentation_outfall_draft_brm
 
Oak Harbor Good Neighbor Plan
Oak Harbor Good Neighbor PlanOak Harbor Good Neighbor Plan
Oak Harbor Good Neighbor Plan
 
January 13, 2011 City Council Workshop
January 13, 2011 City Council WorkshopJanuary 13, 2011 City Council Workshop
January 13, 2011 City Council Workshop
 
2015 04-07 city-council_workshop_presentation
2015 04-07 city-council_workshop_presentation2015 04-07 city-council_workshop_presentation
2015 04-07 city-council_workshop_presentation
 
140416 oak_harbor_workshp_presentation
140416 oak_harbor_workshp_presentation140416 oak_harbor_workshp_presentation
140416 oak_harbor_workshp_presentation
 
Oak Harbor Rate Study
Oak Harbor Rate StudyOak Harbor Rate Study
Oak Harbor Rate Study
 
Windjammer Park Phase 1 Design Open House
Windjammer Park Phase 1 Design Open HouseWindjammer Park Phase 1 Design Open House
Windjammer Park Phase 1 Design Open House
 
March 9, 2011 City Council Workshop
March 9, 2011 City Council WorkshopMarch 9, 2011 City Council Workshop
March 9, 2011 City Council Workshop
 
Oak Harbor City Council Workshop: Design Update
Oak Harbor City Council Workshop: Design UpdateOak Harbor City Council Workshop: Design Update
Oak Harbor City Council Workshop: Design Update
 
Windjammer Park Integration Plan - Council presentation
Windjammer Park Integration Plan - Council presentationWindjammer Park Integration Plan - Council presentation
Windjammer Park Integration Plan - Council presentation
 
Clean Water Facility 60% Cost Estimate Preview
Clean Water Facility 60% Cost Estimate PreviewClean Water Facility 60% Cost Estimate Preview
Clean Water Facility 60% Cost Estimate Preview
 
April 12 Planning Public Forum
April 12 Planning Public ForumApril 12 Planning Public Forum
April 12 Planning Public Forum
 
Special Workshop presentation on Finance
Special Workshop presentation on FinanceSpecial Workshop presentation on Finance
Special Workshop presentation on Finance
 

Similaire à C8 nov20 city council meeting 121120_final

Solid waste management project wecare organics summary
Solid waste management project wecare organics summarySolid waste management project wecare organics summary
Solid waste management project wecare organics summaryCity of Taunton
 
Flood alleviationbrief170214
Flood alleviationbrief170214Flood alleviationbrief170214
Flood alleviationbrief170214Naoise
 
15.2.2 bored pile wall - method statement
15.2.2   bored pile wall - method statement15.2.2   bored pile wall - method statement
15.2.2 bored pile wall - method statementNECB
 
Geoscience in Offshore Renewables
Geoscience in Offshore RenewablesGeoscience in Offshore Renewables
Geoscience in Offshore RenewablesFarida Ismayilova
 
offshore structural design detailed engineering fixed plate form
offshore structural design detailed engineering fixed plate formoffshore structural design detailed engineering fixed plate form
offshore structural design detailed engineering fixed plate formkhalidsiddig8
 
Solar PV on Dry Lakebed Soil
Solar PV on Dry Lakebed SoilSolar PV on Dry Lakebed Soil
Solar PV on Dry Lakebed SoilYamen Nanne
 
Dollymount externalexpert ommgoc
Dollymount externalexpert ommgocDollymount externalexpert ommgoc
Dollymount externalexpert ommgocNaoise
 
Wind Resource Assessment
Wind Resource AssessmentWind Resource Assessment
Wind Resource AssessmentPia Sorokou
 
Cleanup_224 Oz landfill buffers - audio track
Cleanup_224 Oz landfill buffers - audio trackCleanup_224 Oz landfill buffers - audio track
Cleanup_224 Oz landfill buffers - audio trackPhil Sinclair
 
The Severity Of De-Icing In Airports
The Severity Of De-Icing In AirportsThe Severity Of De-Icing In Airports
The Severity Of De-Icing In AirportsSandra Wood
 
Siting and Planning Design of Wind Turbines
Siting and Planning Design of Wind TurbinesSiting and Planning Design of Wind Turbines
Siting and Planning Design of Wind TurbinesHimanshu Paghdal
 
Risk and standards based riprap design for grahamstown dam barker & hol...
Risk and standards based riprap design for grahamstown dam   barker & hol...Risk and standards based riprap design for grahamstown dam   barker & hol...
Risk and standards based riprap design for grahamstown dam barker & hol...Joseph Ng'ang'a Thuo
 

Similaire à C8 nov20 city council meeting 121120_final (20)

Solid waste management project wecare organics summary
Solid waste management project wecare organics summarySolid waste management project wecare organics summary
Solid waste management project wecare organics summary
 
Flood alleviationbrief170214
Flood alleviationbrief170214Flood alleviationbrief170214
Flood alleviationbrief170214
 
15.2.2 bored pile wall - method statement
15.2.2   bored pile wall - method statement15.2.2   bored pile wall - method statement
15.2.2 bored pile wall - method statement
 
ORP FY13 Budget Workshop
ORP FY13 Budget WorkshopORP FY13 Budget Workshop
ORP FY13 Budget Workshop
 
Geoscience in Offshore Renewables
Geoscience in Offshore RenewablesGeoscience in Offshore Renewables
Geoscience in Offshore Renewables
 
Aoc sediment update_part2
Aoc sediment update_part2Aoc sediment update_part2
Aoc sediment update_part2
 
offshore structural design detailed engineering fixed plate form
offshore structural design detailed engineering fixed plate formoffshore structural design detailed engineering fixed plate form
offshore structural design detailed engineering fixed plate form
 
Solar PV on Dry Lakebed Soil
Solar PV on Dry Lakebed SoilSolar PV on Dry Lakebed Soil
Solar PV on Dry Lakebed Soil
 
Dollymount externalexpert ommgoc
Dollymount externalexpert ommgocDollymount externalexpert ommgoc
Dollymount externalexpert ommgoc
 
Wind Resource Assessment
Wind Resource AssessmentWind Resource Assessment
Wind Resource Assessment
 
alipres-0315.ppt
alipres-0315.pptalipres-0315.ppt
alipres-0315.ppt
 
Using Weep Berms to Control Water Quality by Richard Warner and Greg Higgins
Using Weep Berms to Control Water Quality by Richard Warner and Greg Higgins Using Weep Berms to Control Water Quality by Richard Warner and Greg Higgins
Using Weep Berms to Control Water Quality by Richard Warner and Greg Higgins
 
WMA & Admixtures
WMA & AdmixturesWMA & Admixtures
WMA & Admixtures
 
addition consideration in pile
addition consideration in pileaddition consideration in pile
addition consideration in pile
 
Report 020
Report 020Report 020
Report 020
 
Cleanup_224 Oz landfill buffers - audio track
Cleanup_224 Oz landfill buffers - audio trackCleanup_224 Oz landfill buffers - audio track
Cleanup_224 Oz landfill buffers - audio track
 
The Severity Of De-Icing In Airports
The Severity Of De-Icing In AirportsThe Severity Of De-Icing In Airports
The Severity Of De-Icing In Airports
 
PClayton_accomplishments
PClayton_accomplishmentsPClayton_accomplishments
PClayton_accomplishments
 
Siting and Planning Design of Wind Turbines
Siting and Planning Design of Wind TurbinesSiting and Planning Design of Wind Turbines
Siting and Planning Design of Wind Turbines
 
Risk and standards based riprap design for grahamstown dam barker & hol...
Risk and standards based riprap design for grahamstown dam   barker & hol...Risk and standards based riprap design for grahamstown dam   barker & hol...
Risk and standards based riprap design for grahamstown dam barker & hol...
 

Plus de publicinvolvement

Guaranteed Maximum Price Amendment #13
Guaranteed Maximum Price Amendment #13Guaranteed Maximum Price Amendment #13
Guaranteed Maximum Price Amendment #13publicinvolvement
 
Presentation of Windjammer Park 60% Design to City Council
Presentation of Windjammer Park 60% Design to City CouncilPresentation of Windjammer Park 60% Design to City Council
Presentation of Windjammer Park 60% Design to City Councilpublicinvolvement
 
Preview of Windjammer Park 30% Design to City Council
Preview of Windjammer Park 30% Design to City CouncilPreview of Windjammer Park 30% Design to City Council
Preview of Windjammer Park 30% Design to City Councilpublicinvolvement
 
Oak Harbor City Council Meeting: GMP 9
Oak Harbor City Council Meeting: GMP 9Oak Harbor City Council Meeting: GMP 9
Oak Harbor City Council Meeting: GMP 9publicinvolvement
 
Presentation of Windjammer Park Integration Plan to City Council
Presentation of Windjammer Park Integration Plan to City CouncilPresentation of Windjammer Park Integration Plan to City Council
Presentation of Windjammer Park Integration Plan to City Councilpublicinvolvement
 
Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 5
Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 5Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 5
Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 5publicinvolvement
 
Community Advisory Group meeting 5
Community Advisory Group meeting 5Community Advisory Group meeting 5
Community Advisory Group meeting 5publicinvolvement
 
Oak Harbor Clean Water Facility GMP #7
Oak Harbor Clean Water Facility GMP #7Oak Harbor Clean Water Facility GMP #7
Oak Harbor Clean Water Facility GMP #7publicinvolvement
 
Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 4
Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 4Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 4
Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 4publicinvolvement
 
Oak Harbor Windjammer Park Integration Plan
Oak Harbor Windjammer Park Integration Plan Oak Harbor Windjammer Park Integration Plan
Oak Harbor Windjammer Park Integration Plan publicinvolvement
 
Oak Harbor Community Advisory Group meeing 2 and public open house
Oak Harbor Community Advisory Group meeing 2 and public open houseOak Harbor Community Advisory Group meeing 2 and public open house
Oak Harbor Community Advisory Group meeing 2 and public open housepublicinvolvement
 
Windjammer Park Integration Plan CAG meeting 1
Windjammer Park Integration Plan CAG meeting 1Windjammer Park Integration Plan CAG meeting 1
Windjammer Park Integration Plan CAG meeting 1publicinvolvement
 
Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Facility: Resolution 15-34, Community Room
Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Facility: Resolution 15-34, Community RoomOak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Facility: Resolution 15-34, Community Room
Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Facility: Resolution 15-34, Community Roompublicinvolvement
 
60% Design and Cost Estimate
60% Design and Cost Estimate60% Design and Cost Estimate
60% Design and Cost Estimatepublicinvolvement
 
150604 Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Plant Update
150604 Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Plant Update150604 Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Plant Update
150604 Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Plant Updatepublicinvolvement
 
130306 city council workshop revised
130306 city council workshop revised130306 city council workshop revised
130306 city council workshop revisedpublicinvolvement
 

Plus de publicinvolvement (16)

Guaranteed Maximum Price Amendment #13
Guaranteed Maximum Price Amendment #13Guaranteed Maximum Price Amendment #13
Guaranteed Maximum Price Amendment #13
 
Presentation of Windjammer Park 60% Design to City Council
Presentation of Windjammer Park 60% Design to City CouncilPresentation of Windjammer Park 60% Design to City Council
Presentation of Windjammer Park 60% Design to City Council
 
Preview of Windjammer Park 30% Design to City Council
Preview of Windjammer Park 30% Design to City CouncilPreview of Windjammer Park 30% Design to City Council
Preview of Windjammer Park 30% Design to City Council
 
Oak Harbor City Council Meeting: GMP 9
Oak Harbor City Council Meeting: GMP 9Oak Harbor City Council Meeting: GMP 9
Oak Harbor City Council Meeting: GMP 9
 
Presentation of Windjammer Park Integration Plan to City Council
Presentation of Windjammer Park Integration Plan to City CouncilPresentation of Windjammer Park Integration Plan to City Council
Presentation of Windjammer Park Integration Plan to City Council
 
Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 5
Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 5Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 5
Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 5
 
Community Advisory Group meeting 5
Community Advisory Group meeting 5Community Advisory Group meeting 5
Community Advisory Group meeting 5
 
Oak Harbor Clean Water Facility GMP #7
Oak Harbor Clean Water Facility GMP #7Oak Harbor Clean Water Facility GMP #7
Oak Harbor Clean Water Facility GMP #7
 
Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 4
Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 4Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 4
Windjammer Park Integration Plan Community Advisory Group meeting 4
 
Oak Harbor Windjammer Park Integration Plan
Oak Harbor Windjammer Park Integration Plan Oak Harbor Windjammer Park Integration Plan
Oak Harbor Windjammer Park Integration Plan
 
Oak Harbor Community Advisory Group meeing 2 and public open house
Oak Harbor Community Advisory Group meeing 2 and public open houseOak Harbor Community Advisory Group meeing 2 and public open house
Oak Harbor Community Advisory Group meeing 2 and public open house
 
Windjammer Park Integration Plan CAG meeting 1
Windjammer Park Integration Plan CAG meeting 1Windjammer Park Integration Plan CAG meeting 1
Windjammer Park Integration Plan CAG meeting 1
 
Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Facility: Resolution 15-34, Community Room
Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Facility: Resolution 15-34, Community RoomOak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Facility: Resolution 15-34, Community Room
Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Facility: Resolution 15-34, Community Room
 
60% Design and Cost Estimate
60% Design and Cost Estimate60% Design and Cost Estimate
60% Design and Cost Estimate
 
150604 Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Plant Update
150604 Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Plant Update150604 Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Plant Update
150604 Oak Harbor Wastewater Treatment Plant Update
 
130306 city council workshop revised
130306 city council workshop revised130306 city council workshop revised
130306 city council workshop revised
 

C8 nov20 city council meeting 121120_final

  • 1. Oak Harbor Facilities Plan City Council Meeting November 20, 2012 Oh910i1-8594.pptx/1
  • 2. Tonight’s Agenda/Objectives 1. Review scope and purpose of Amendment 5 2. Present results of field work completed through Amendment 5 – Topographical Survey – Environmental Assessment – Geotechnical Borings g 3. Summarize estimated cost impacts p 4. Gain direction from Council on next steps: – Resolution 12-33: Complete Facilities Plan for Windjammer Vicinity as defined by Resolution 12-17 – Resolution 12-34: Expand Windjammer Vicinity to include adjacent property and complete Facilities Plan Oh910i1-8594.pptx/2
  • 3. Resolution 12-17 (August 14, 2012) • Proceed with Facilities Plan based on Windjammer Vicinity j y • Minimize space impacts on Windjammer Park to the extent possible • C ti Continue public process: bli – Define the best location within the Windjammer Vicinity Vicinit – Define layout and other desirable features based on the final location Oh910i1-8594.pptx/3
  • 4. Amendment 5 Scope and Purpose • Technical detail to help select the best location (3 to 4 acres) for the new WWTP • Field work including:g – Phase 1 topographical survey to establish elevations and flood protection requirements – Environmental assessment to better define permitting and wetland mitigation requirements – Geotechnical borings to characterize soils better soils, estimated design requirements and cost Oh910i1-8594.pptx/4
  • 5. October 16, 2012 City Council Direction • Include adjacent property (Freund property) in scope of Amendment 5 Does Freund property provide technical/cost advantages relative to Windjammer Vicinity? Oh910i1-8594.pptx/5
  • 6. Amendment 5 Current Status • Phase 1 survey work complete (Attachment 1) • Environmental assessment completed based on October 30, 2012 site visit (Attachment 2) , ( ) • Geotechnical borings completed on October 30 and 31 (Attachment 3) • Additional engineering analysis completed to compare three sites – Windjammer Vicinity (Charrette) – Freund – Windjammer Vicinity (Alternate) Oh910i1-8594.pptx/6
  • 7. Field Work Summary Phase 1 Topographical Survey Oh910i1-8594.pptx/7
  • 8. 100-Year Floodplain (El 12.5 NAVD 88) 15 9 100-Year Floodplain Fl d l i 12.5 feet ~7 Oh910i1-8594.pptx/8
  • 9. Regulations for Floodplain Development • Orange Book ( g (Criteria for Sewage Works Design, ’08) g g , ) – G2-1.5.2 Flood Protection: Locate unit processes above the 100-year flood/wave action or adequately protect from 100-year fl d/ t tf 100 flood/wave action ti • Oak Harbor Municipal Code 17.20 – 17 20 190(2) Nonresidential Construction: Locate 17.20.190(2) construction above the base flood elevation or floodproof structure to 1 ft above base flood elevation – 17.20.190(3) Critical Facilities: • Construction permissible if no feasible alternative • Lowest floor > 3 feet above base flood elevation Oh910i1-8594.pptx/9
  • 10. Summary of Flood Protection Requirements • Portions (or all) of sites being considered lie within 100-year flood plain (12.5 NAVD 88) – R Recommend elevating grade and/or structures t 13 5 d l ti d d/ t t to 13.5 – Additional protection for “critical facilities” (e.g. electrical) • Southern portions of Windjammer Vicinity sites must be p j y elevated approximately 3 f l d i l feet – Retaining wall or sloped fill • Existing grade at Freund property is an average of ~6.5 feet 6.5 below 100-year flood elevation – Retaining wall/levee – Fill site – New/improved access to site is needed • 100-year flood elevation [+12.5] more conservative than Mean Higher High Water (MHHW) + sea level rise [approx + 11 3] [approx. 11.3] Oh910i1-8594.pptx/10
  • 11. Field Work Summary Environmental Assessment Oh910i1-8594.pptx/11
  • 12. Summary of Environmental Assessment • Wetland ditches at both Windjammer (Charrette) and Freund sites • Federal, state, Oak Harbor permit approvals required for wetland fill/buffer impacts fill/b ff i t • Windjammer (Charrette) Site – Wetland ditch along southern boundary may be filled as result of p j g y y project – Mitigation costs estimated between $150,000 and $275,000 – Risk of delays and/or cost increases relatively low (limited tidal water connection) • Freund Site – Wetland ditches along boundaries would be filled as result of project – Site adjacent to mitigation wetland; portion may be filled for access – Mitigation costs estimated from $400,000 to $800,000 – Risk of delays and/or cost increases relatively high (tidal water connection; impact to previous mitigation wetland) Oh910i1-8594.pptx/12
  • 13. Field Work Summary Geotechnical Assessment Oh910i1-8594.pptx/13
  • 14. Geotechnical Boring Site Plan Oh910i1-8594.pptx/14
  • 17. Summary of Geotechnical Assessment • Ground improvements needed at all sites • Dewatering shoring, and flood protection will Dewatering, shoring also impact cost j • Sites to north, west and center of Windjammer Vicinity are preferred – Highest ground elevation – Sh ll Shallowest t till (25 to 30 f t) t to t feet) • Park site: deeper to till; additional flood control • Freund east sites most difficult/costly Freund, – Lowest ground elevation – Deepest to till (40+ feet) (40 Oh910i1-8594.pptx/17
  • 19. Windjammer Charrette Concept Conceptual Plan View (August 14 2012) 14, Oh910i1-8594.pptx/19
  • 20. Windjammer Charrette Concept Conceptual Site Section View (August 14 2012) 14, Oh910i1-8594.pptx/20
  • 21. Total Project Cost Components Windjammer ( j (Charrette) Layout ) y $100 $95 $2.9 $93.5 $93 5 (Total) $90 $7.6 $85 $83.0 $83 0 (WWTP) Estimated Cost (Millions) $80 Outfall $75 WW Conveyance Co eya ce WWTP $70 $83.0 $65 $60 $55 $50 Windjammer (Charrette) Oh910i1-8594.pptx/21
  • 22. WWTP Project Cost Components Windjammer ( j (Charrette) Layout ) y $90 $83.0 (WWTP) $80 $15.0 $70 $2.1 $68.0 (Construction + Land) $60 Estimated Cost (Millions) $50 Soft Costs (25%) Land Acquisition Land Acquisition $40 WWTP Construction $65.9 $30 $20 $10 $0 Windjammer (Charrette) Oh910i1-8594.pptx/22
  • 23. Approximately 17% of WWTP Costs are “Variable” Based on Site $90 $80 $70 $68.0 (Construction + Land) $11.7 $60 (“Variable”) ( Variable ) $5.2 $5 2 d Cost (Millions) $56.3 (“Fixed”) Land Acquisition Architectural Premium $50 Added Structural Geotechnical Premium Estimated $40 Wastewater/Effluent Piping Sitework $30 Base WWTP $56.3 $20 $10 $0 Windjammer (Charrette) Oh910i1-8594.pptx/23
  • 24. Sitework is Largest Variable Cost Component $12.0 $11.7 (“Variable”) $11.0 $2.1 $10.0 $9.0 $1.6 $8.0 $8 0 d Cost (Millions) ) $0.8 Land Acquisition $7.0 Architectural Premium $1.7 $6.0 Added Structural Estimated $0.4 Geotechnical Premium $5.0 Wastewater/Effluent Piping Sitework $4.0 $3.0 44% $5.2 $2.0 Sitework $1.0 $0.0 Windjammer (Charrette) Oh910i1-8594.pptx/24
  • 25. Sitework Cost Elements Windjammer ( j (Charrette) Layout ) y $7.0 $6.0 $6 0 $5.2 Sitework $5.0 $1.2 Site d Cost (Millions) Allowances $4.0 Allowance (Wetlands Mitigation) Allowance (Flood Protection) Allowance (Stormwater Mgmt.) ( g ) Estimated $3.0 Allowance (Clear/Demo) Base Sitework Estimate $2.0 $1.0 $0.0 Windjammer (Charrette) Oh910i1-8594.pptx/25
  • 26. Property Adjacent to Windjammer Vicinity Conceptual Plan View Oh910i1-8594.pptx/26
  • 27. Property Adjacent to Windjammer Vicinity Conceptual Site Section View Oh910i1-8594.pptx/27
  • 28. Offsetting Costs for Alternate (Freund) Property Relative to Windjammer ( j (Charrette) Layout ) y Lower Cost Higher Costs • Property acquisition • Wastewater/effluent (Assessed value) conveyance • Demolition/clearing • Geotechnical • Aeration basin structure • Sitework – Flood Protection – Wetland Mitigation Oh910i1-8594.pptx/28
  • 29. Sitework Cost Element Comparison Windjammer ( j (Charrette) & Freund Layouts ) y $7.0 Allowances $6.0 $6 0 increase due to Flood Protection and Wetlands $5.0 Mitigation d Cost (Millions) ) $4.0 Allowance (Wetlands Mitigation) Allowance (Flood Protection) Allowance (Stormwater Mgmt.) Estimated $3.0 Allowance (Clear/Demo) Base Sitework Estimate $2.0 $1.0 $0.0 Windjammer (Charrette) Freund Oh910i1-8594.pptx/29
  • 30. Windjammer Alternate Concept Conceptual Plan and Perspective View (8/14/12) Oh910i1-8594.pptx/30
  • 31. Lower Costs for Windjammer (Alternate) Layout Relative to Windjammer ( j (Charrette) Layout ) y Same Cost Lower Costs • Property acquisition • Aeration basin structure (Assessed value) • Geotechnical • Demolition/clearing • Sitework • Wastewater/effluent – Flood Control conveyance – Wetland Mitigation Oh910i1-8594.pptx/31
  • 32. Sitework Cost Element Comparison Windjammer ( j (Charrette) & Windjammer ( ) j (Alternate) ) $7.0 Allowances $6.0 decrease due to Flood Protection $5.0 and Wetlands Mitigation ns) ed Cost (Million $4.0 Allowance (Wetlands Mitigation) Allowance (Flood Protection) Allowance (Stormwater Mgmt.) Estimate $3.0 $ Allowance (Clear/Demo) Base Sitework Estimate $2.0 $1.0 $0.0 Windjammer  Freund Windjammer  (Charrette) (Alternate) Oh910i1-8594.pptx/32
  • 33. “Variable” Cost Comparison for All Sites $12.0 $11.7 $11.3 $11.0 $10.1 $10.0 $9.0 $8.0 Land Acquisition $7.0 Architectural Premium $6.0 Added Structural Geotechnical Premium G t h i lP i $5.0 Wastewater/Effluent Piping Sitework $4.0 $3.0 $2.0 $ $1.0 $0.0 Windjammer (Charrette) Freund Windjammer (Alternate) Oh910i1-8594.pptx/33
  • 34. “Variable” Cost Comparison for All Sites Estimated Costs Shown in Millions ($) ( ) Windjammer Windjammer (Charrette) Freund (Alternate) Land Acquisition L dA i iti $2.1 $2 1 $0.2 $0 2 $2.1 $2 1 Architectural Premium $1.6 $1.6 $1.6 Added Structural $0.8 $0.0 $0.0 Geotechnical Premium $1.7 $2.6 $1.4 Wastewater/Effluent Piping $0.4 $0.8 $0.4 Base Sitework (Fixed) $4.0 $4.0 $4.0 Clearing & Demolition Allowance $0.2 $0.0 $0.2 Stormwater Management Allowance $0.4 $0.4 $0.4 Flood Protection All Fl d P i Allowance $0.4 $ $1.3 $ $0.1 $ Wetlands Mitigation Allowance $0.3 $0.4 $0.0 Subtotal, Sitework $5.2 $6.1 $4.6 Total Site Specific Items $11.7 $11.3 $10.1 Oh910i1-8594.pptx/34
  • 35. Total Cost Comparison for All Sites $100.0 $93.5 $93.1 $92.0 $90.0 $80.0 $70.0 d Cost (Millions) ) $11.7 $11.3 $10.1 $60.0 Soft Costs Outfall $50.0 Conveyance Estimated Site Specific Items $40.0 Base WWTP $30.0 $20.0 $10.0 $0.0 Windjammer (Charrette) Freund Windjammer (Alternate) Oh910i1-8594.pptx/35
  • 36. Summary of Technical & Cost Differences Oh910i1-8594.pptx/36
  • 37. Summary and Conclusions 1. Based on assessed value Freund site will likely be less costly to acquire 2. Based on technical field work, Freund site will likely have higher construction cost – Wastewater/effluent Conveyance – Geotechnical – Flood Protection – Wetland Mitigation W l d Mi i i 3. Very little difference in overall cost between sites 4. Means to reduce the cost of “variable” components will be variable considered regardless of tonight’s decision 5. Freund site presents higher risk due to environmental permitting and regulations for filling within the flood plain Oh910i1-8594.pptx/37
  • 39. Paths Forward Based on Tonight’s Decision Retain Windjammer Vicinity Expand Windjammer Vicinity (Freund) Resolution 12-33 Resolution 12-34 1. Complete draft technical chapters of p p 1. Amendment 6: Collect community y Facilities Plan input; compare locations using TBL+ 2. Develop phasing/financing plan 2. Select final location/layout for WWTP with public input (Q1, 2013) 3. Final Public Open House/Council Workshop (Early 2013) 3. Complete draft technical chapters of Facilities Plan 4. Council resolution to submit draft plan 4. Develop phasing/financing plan (Q1, (Q1 2013) 5. Final Public Open H Fi l P bli O House/Council /C il 5. Complete environmental documents Workshop (Q2, 2013) for approval 6. Council resolution to submit draft plan 6. Begin Preliminary Design (Q2, 2013) a. Final location & layout of WWTP 7. Complete environmental documents for with community input approval b. Equipment procurement 8. Begin Preliminary Design g y g a. Final layout of WWTP with community input Oh910i1-8594.pptx/39 b. Equipment procurement