SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 20
Is there a Future for eco-cities?




Prospective roles of Versailles Chantiers within the
Greater Paris: A hub of multi-modal communication


Versailles, 2013




                         1
This is a first global report of the Integration Seminar – a module of innovation and learning within the
International Professional Master in Management of Eco-Innovation. This is a graduate program managed by
the Econoving Chair in Generating Eco-Innovation – a cluster of academic, industrial and government actors
focused on urban sustainability.

Counting for the Work Package 3 – Anticipation of the Econoving’s Rail Station Program (Programme Gare,
2011-2013), this report is the result of the joint work carried out by the Econoving researchers and graduate
students in collaboration with the industrial partners.

Coordination of work, research, text & design: Dr. Ioan M. Ciumasu – ioan.ciumasu@uvsq.fr




The views expressed here are of the author, and do not necessarily
represent those of the institutions



© 2013 Econoving




Acknowledgements – the following have contributed to this work:

Econoving 2011-2012 students: Anna Aghvanyan, Adrian Carrillo, Krishna Chandran, Boubacar Coly, Fanny Courry, Maxim Doubrouski,
Elodie Gonthier, Sirin Hamsho, Alejandra Hoyos, Xiaochao Huang, Collins Ihedioha, Natalia Kozdra, Anna Lomteva, Javad Mahmoodirad,
Ravi Nakulan, Alexandra Ostrovskaya, Kevin Ramirez, Marcel Roquette, Dina Salakhova, Maria Stoica, Sandra Velasco.
Econoving 2012-2013 students: François Apicella, Gabriel Bermeo, Zoheir Haghighi, Ludmila Kobyakova, Renan Le Tohic, Habib Liamidi,
Hélène Luciani, Diego Martinez, Mingyan Meng, Teodora Morar, Surya Muraleedharan-Nair, Julian Muriel, Marina Nikitina, Kalliopi
Ntanou, Maria Lucia Portocarrero, Cécile Tchoubaev.
Expert coaches, jury or institutional support: Jean-Louis Jourdan, Alain Adrianssens, Thierry Lafont (SNCF), Agnes Roux (City of Versailles),
Bernard Blez, Etienne Drouet (GDF Suez), Laurent Schmitt (Alstom Grid), Frédéric Cuq (Saur), Christophe Lombard (Italcementi),
Dominique Agrech (X-Ange), Sylvie Faucheux, Keith Culver, Beat Bürgenmeier, Christelle Hue, Rachel Guilloteau, René Audet, Sophie
Némoz, Caroline Gans-Combe, Quentin Courtier, Frédéric Louradour, Amélie Coulbaut-Lazzarini, Guillaume Bailly (UVSQ).




                                                                     2
TABLE OF CONTENTS

   I.     OVERVIEW
   II.    EXERCISE DESCRIPTION
   III.   LESSONS OF THE 1st YEAR
   IV.    REVIEW OF ECO-CITY RESEARCH & LITERATURE
   V.     RESULTS & PROPOSITIONS AFTER THE 2nd YEAR
   VI.    CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS
                                                      UVSQ – Guyancourt Campus. Photo: Ioan M. Ciumasu
   VII.   THE ROAD AHEAD




                                           3
I.       OVERVIEW

             The Integration Seminar (IS) is an exercise of collaborative integration and application of knowledge
             gained in individual course modules – a student-expert interaction. This is a hands-on undertaking,
             organized in the form of a simulation of an eco-innovation consulting firm responding to a call for
             project proposals launched by a local community – Building the best European eco-innovation hub:
             From Versailles Chantiers railway station to the eco-city of the future.

             By 2030 and 2050 Versailles Chantiers should become:
             1. A Multi-modal pole (“pôle multimodal”) – a hub of combined persons and value exchanges
             2. A development engine of the City of Versailles and a global reference for urban sustainability

             This community of innovators and learners is organized in three teams (consulting firms), each with a
             different angle of approach: Multi-Innovation, Climate Change, and Technology Push. The students-
             experts interaction took the form of lectures, coaching, presentations and jury evaluations. The IS
             allows a realistic exploration of the links and creative tensions between topics and between
             innovation factors; identification of the main drivers of change; co-definition of problems and of the
             potential solutions. The work took place at the Econoving locations in Guyancourt.




UVSQ – Guyancourt Campus. Photo: Ioan M. Ciumasu




                                                                4
II. EXERCISE DESCRIPTION

The IS exercise has been iterated two university years in a row – 2011-2012 & 2012-2013. Each year,
the work went through two phases – vision building and implementation plan, as illustrated below.


                                                 1st Phase – Vision building
    ORGANISATION




                                                                                                - similar projects
                                                                INTERNATIONAL
                                                                                                - methods
       TEAM




                                                                   SURVEY &                     - context
                                                                BENCHMARKING                    - project dynamics
                                                                                                & structure




                                     DIAGNOSIS OF                                                    VISION
                                      VERSAILLES
                                      CHANTIERS                                              & Main Objectives




--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



                                  2nd Phase – Developing the implementation plan




         QUALITY                                         PROJECT &                                      ECO-INNOVATION
      MANAGEMENT                                        INNOVATION                                           ENGINE
       INDICATORS                                       MANAGEMENT                                           & SOLUTIONS




                                                                  5
III. LESSONS FROM THE 1st YEAR

        Participants have engaged in lively professional feedbacks, notably in two deliveries by the students
        in front a jury of academics, industrials, financial experts and public authorities.




UVSQ – Guyancourt Campus – Interactions between 2011-2012 students and experts.
Photos: Elodie Gonthier




        Some first patterns and challenges have emerged:
              It is very difficult to collect reliable, coherent information – in deed, a world-wide known challenge
              Trans-sectorial understanding of a city is a heavy task, due to traditional divisions between disciplines
              New types of knowledge management are needed, which requires sustained effort and learning by all
              The historical heritage and the context of the Greater Paris represent both opportunities & challenges
              Scenarios can address: technology choices, social acceptability, environmental concerns, costs & risks
              Higher spatial scales are important: a train station can only function as embedded in its city context



                                                                                  6
The method has worked very well. It appears that this type of exercise is a very useful tool for
foresight and anticipation in terms of eco-innovation and eco-city development. The approach allows
the people involved in the works, both graduate students and experts, to grasp the project reality at
the city level and to build a solid foundation for future solutions. Various options and scenarios have
been analyzed, so as to link local context with global issues.

Further, the set of three angles of view has proven to be very insightful, as each of them can be taken
autonomously or/and in complementarity with the other two: multi-innovation, climate change and
technology push.
The three perspectives have thus been continued in the 2nd year. The iteration of the exercise two
years in a row is also meant to allow the confirmation and consolidation of the method, and to
further develop the initial results and lessons – to enhance the overall value of the work.


This 2nd run of the exercise was therefore planned using:
    -   The lessons and materials obtained by the 1st year
    -   The recent advances of the researchers in the Railway Station Program
    -   The newest advances and insights on eco-innovation and eco-city in the literature

The 2011-2012 Econoving students & experts have passed the relay over to the next Generation.




                                                  7
IV.     REVIEW OF ECO-CITY RESEARCH & LITERATURE

Cities are becoming the drivers of change. The place and role of Econoving

Cities are veritable “growth machines” for their hinterlands (Molotch 1976), which may explain why
humanity is mostly urban already. The global urbanization rate is accelerating, as do environmental
degradation. Urban transformation is now an ecological research topic in its own right (McDonald
2008). The success or the failure of the transition to sustainability will be determined in cities.
In the globalizing world of the 21st century, global fluxes of matter-energy, information and people
can be understood in terms of exchanges within a global network of interconnected cities – some
“world cities” being more influential than others (Sassen 1991, 2002; Beaverstock et al. 2000). In the
same time, cities are the product of their local context, and are dependent on the natural resources
which they extract from their hinterland (“ecosystem goods and services” which together form the
“ecosystem carrying capacity”; Wackernagel et al. 2006). The sustainability of a city is therefore a
matter of how advanced that city is in the transition from a local identity to a double, local-and-
global identity (Ciumasu & Culver 2011). In deed, this is the core challenge for city planners and
managers for the next years and decades.
Since 2009-2010, Econoving has engaged in its own eco-city development and employs Versailles
Chantiers – a communication hub within Greater Paris – as a pivot and experimental platform for
collaborative innovation for urban sustainability (Culver et al. 2011; Ciumasu 2013a,b). The Greater
Paris has its own global weight: a concept launched by the French President (2007) as an overarching
objective of re-imagining Paris as a world’s mega-city promoting sustainability and competitiveness.
This is the largest project of Paris since G.E. Haussmann has re-organized the city in the 19th century
(as commissioned by Napolen III). The institutional context at Econoving is a university-industry-
government consortium supporting a research and post-graduate education program.

City managers experience the need of knowledge integration

In their quest for sustainable development, many urban communities and research institutions have
pioneered urban foresight, sometimes followed by policies for urban development. But the decision-
making process tended to favor trade-offs which avoided controversy and thus have changed
nothing in the end (Weber et al. 2009). Even a strong political will was not enough. On the other
hand, we now live in a knowledge society, and the fundamental question now towards city
sustainability is: How to develop a functional relation between science and decision makers?

This question may seem straightforward, and yet there is another challenge before us: all disciplines
contributing to sustainability have their distinct understanding of a sustainable city – an ecologist, a
sociologist, an economist, an engineer or an architect talks about what the concept of urban
sustainability means for her/him and there is no real common language (Williams 2010). This causes
mismatches and intricacies that drive effective decision making into a halt. Consequently, it’s easy to
declare aims of urban sustainability, but much more difficult to make it real. This can only commence
with federative efforts – notably the creation of agoras of learning and knowledge co-generation by
various experts. Such efforts often result in great collections of knowledge but this is still not enough:
they stop short of integration (Wheeler and Beatley 2009). As a result, for city managers, an essential
question still awaits answers: How to actually use all this heterogeneous body of knowledge?



                                                    8
The hard but necessary way of experimentation. The role of cityports

Innovation is the most effective way to bridge science and society, both in terms of transforming
industrialized societies (a good start is the 1st Innovation Convention of the European Commission,
05-07 December 2011, http://ec.europa.eu/research/innovation-union/ic2011/index_en.cfm) and in
terms of city systems (Han et al 2012). However, we are facing a set of paramount challenges.
Firstly, the need for trans-disciplinarity (problem solving-oriented research) is widely recognized, but
there is no such thing as a unified theory of sustainability. Secondly, as we speak, we are already
over-consuming the Earth’s carrying capacity, which means that simply “innovation for sustainability”
is not sufficient – we need to innovate fast or face the “perfect storm” within decades (Beddington
2009). Thirdly, having in mind the first two points, postponing decisions is already a ‘worse’ decision,
which means that we often have to act even before we fully understand the process. In summary,
the only practical way towards sustainability is experimentation, i.e., learning and doing in the same
time. In effect, the process of innovation itself is describable as a learning cycle (Ciumasu 2013c). In
terms of the transition management theory, such active generation of innovation is understood as a
double process of learning-by-doing and doing-by-learning (Geels 2010).
In terms of urban renewal initiative types, communities are scattered on a gradient from whole-city
commitments to (only) sectorial developments to plain ignorance and disinterest (Portney 2003; Flint
& Raco 2012). Interestingly, even in the absence of a dedicated national policy, many cities have
major sustainability initiatives, e.g., Seattle, Portland, Chicago, New York, San Francisco (among the
large American cities) (Fitzgerald 2010) or Grand Rapids - Michigan among the smaller cities. Some
key patterns are detectable. One is the re-thinking of the various functions of the city areas so as to
promote walkable neighborhood. Another one is the use of a “city port” (seaport or airport) as a hub
of development and renewal of metropolitan areas (Van Wijk 2007). This reminds the historic role of
railway stations for urban and economic development in the 19th century (Conticelli & Tondelli 2011).
They were initially located outside the town (due to public health considerations) but have gradually
melted into the urban shape and functions (Reusser et al. 2008). Today, in the European context of
good public transportation, high population densities and the arrival of high-speed trains, a strong
competition has emerged between air and train travels across medium-long distances (300-500 km),
with important consequences on cities (e.g. Terrin 2009). Such developments, together with many
other details of modern life, notably the revival of passive urban transportation (walking and cycling)
and the new communication technologies, are generating a great deal of interest in the concept of
“multi-modal transportation”. Stakeholders include citizens, industry and public authorities.
It is in this context that Econoving runs its own foresight exercise and collaborative learning cycles.


V.      RESULTS & PROPOSITIONS AFTER THE 2nd YEAR
The following options have been developed by the 2012-2013 generation of students and experts, as
summarized in the remainder of this reports:

a. URBAN RENEWAL: Integrative planning for radical progress in Versailles Chantiers
b. URBAN RESILIENCE: Smart adaptation & mitigation of climate changes in Versailles Chantiers
c. URBAN TECHNOLOGY: Integrative solutions for augmenting Versailles to the status of all-times
   International Hub of Innovation




                                                    9
Current station. Source: http://www.monversailles.com/transports/ca-coince-sur-la-ligne-ter-paris-chartres/




                 URBAN RENEWAL: Integrative planning for radical progress in Versailles Chantiers


                                                                                               DIAGNOSIS:
              There is an important gap between current situation & the true potential of VC


                                                                     VISION: We want to change that!




                                                                                                                                              Source: bluewaterindia.com/renewable-energy.htm




                                                                                                                                                        Source: http://www.ecochunk.com/
Current station. Original photos
                                                                                                                      Source: bluewaterindia.com/renewable-energy.htm




                                                                                                            10
Conference Centre




Versailles Chantiers should take better advantage of its prominent place within the Greater Paris. To
become a multi-modal hub of transport and communications, Versailles Chantiers station should re-
invent itself together with its neighborhood, become a Global Reference for Eco-Innovative Solutions.

A great number of solutions are now available, and all modern needs of the people should be met in
the same time and in the same place. The key to achieving this has two complementary facets:
    1. Forward-looking, transdisciplinary and problem solving oriented thinking
    2. Pro-active communications to a local, national, European and Global audience

How? The proposition is to mobilize energies and intelligence via transforming Versailles Chantiers
into an International Showroom and Conference Centre by 2020. This should serve as an exhibition
place, and the station itself should be part of the “live exhibition” of new options for sustainable
living through multi-modal communication. Investment required: 1.3-4.1 bn € depending on the
chosen scale (cf. benchmarking), through a financial mix: partnerships, contracts and loans.

A conference space can also be organised nearby the station for: exhibitions, public dialogue, expert
meetings, tourist offices, educational media. Many cities have chosen to build a powerful conference
centre as a strategic way to generate visibility and to attract investments (e.g. Bak et al. 2012, DOI:
10.1007/978-3-642-23550-4_2, available online at http://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F978-
3-642-23550-4_2?LI=true; and Ramirez-Pasillas 2010, DOI: 10.1080/08985620902815106, available
online at http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/08985620902815106).




                                                  11
URBAN RESILIENCE:
         Smart adaptation & mitigation of climate changes in Versailles Chantiers

         DIAGNOSIS. Versailles Chantiers train station has a vast, unused potential to function as a pivot of
         technology and innovation in the Greater Paris and a socio-economic engine for the city of Versailles.


                                           Station today                  Impacts to be expected

          1. Higher t°C, Frequency &       Poor thermal regulation      - Heat stress; Lower productivity
             Duration of heat waves                                     - Higher energy consumption
          2. More days of droughts         No water management          - Water scarcity & higher cost
             during summer                                              - Higher health risks
          3. Extreme precipitations        Low platforms Insuficient    - Operations vs. flood risks
             and natural disasters         shelters                     - Passengers discomfort & risks
                                                                        - Power shortage risk


                                           VISION: By 2050, Versailles Chantiers plays a leading global role as:
                                                Sustainability reference
                                                Benchmark of the best climate-related solutions

                                           How? By establishing a Technology Validation Laboratory (to be
                                           functional by 2030, nearby the station) which will be recognized by
                                           world’s experts as a place where the latest technological solutions
                                           are tested for viability, system integration, and climate relevance.
                                           Rationale: Technology goes through stages of development from
                                           proof-of-concept to demonstrators and commercial prototypes.
                                           The bottleneck of a technological solution is the test of its capacity
                                           to function as part of a system of various technologies: technology
                                           readiness (Azizian et al. 2011, DOI: 10.1002/sys.20186, online at
                                           http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/sys.20186/full).




FINANCE & IMPLEMENTATION                          SNCF / RFF
                                                                                                     12% 6%
Initial investment: 110-130 M€                    PARTNERS & private investors
                                                                                                                    20%
Financial participation based on current          ADEME
renovation & others projects                      Local Authorities (Versailles, Grand Parc)   25%
in the Greater Paris area                                                                                           10%
                                                  European Commission
Mechanisms: Partners investments 30%,             Régional governance (IDF, Dept..)
Tax return/Community grants 30%,                                                                   12%      15%
Public subsidies 25%, Loans 15%                   State




                                                           12
Energy

                                       Green
                                                                                      Water
                                       Areas



                                                                            VC
                                                                          station
                             Green
                                                                                              Services
                            Mobility




                                                Air
                                                                          Waste
                                               Quality



          A series of topics are important and inter-related. But the most prominent and urgent topics are
          related to energy and indoor air quality (related to health and physiological comfort). Therefore, two
          major objectives are forerunning in our approach and proposition:
                                                         st
           1. Versailles Chantiers should become the 1 carbon-neutral city district in the European Union
           2. Green walls & related biotechnologies need to be tested as main solution to indoor pollution &
              comfort in stations




    Proposed for VC building:
 - Indoor air cooling by 4-6°C
 - Cold air cools the building
 - Water reuse (toilets, etc)



                                                                                      Original photos




Proven Technology - shower tower:
 The air is cooled via reversed heat
  transfer (City of Melbourne 2004)




                                                              13
Future Avenue de Sceaux – Versailles. Artwork: Teodora Morar



             URBAN TECHNOLOGY: Integrative solutions for augmenting Versailles to
             the status of All-times International Hub of Innovation

             DIAGNOSIS. Versailles Chantiers train station has a vast, unused potential to function as a pivot of
             technology and innovation in the Greater Paris and a socio-economic engine for the city of Versailles.
             VISION. Avenue de Sceaux will become a strategic axis: an inspiring journey connecting the historical
             heritage of Versailles Castle and the multi-modal pole of communication of Versailles Chantiers. This
             will magnify the profile of Versailles as a European and world eco-city reference.




                                                                                       Tramway on green path. Source:
                                                                                       http://orangerie-strasbourg.e-
                                               Policemen on segways in Versailles.     monsite.com/pages/au-tour-du-parc.html
                                               http://www.flickr.com/photos/86749403
                                               @N08/7944172282/


                                                                                                                                Info panels in parks. Original




             First launch of Montgolfier Balloon in
             Versailles. Source: http://www.france-
             pittoresque.com/spip.php?article6561




                                                                                              14
Milestones and scenarios




 Future VC and Avenue de Sceaux – Versailles
 Artwork: Teodora Morar




FINANCE & IMPLEMENTATION

The estimated investment is: 70.8 M€
[0.8 M for studies & communication, 10 M
for services, 40 M for clean technologies,
20 M for mobility and accessibility].
A Committee of stake-holders & experts
would insure the project governance:
SNCF, GDF Suez, Alstom, Italcementi, Saur,
UVSQ, HEC, Versailles City, other
industrial, academic & public partners
The proposed process of achieving success
is the candidature of the city of Versailles
to become a European Green Capital by
2050, with the technical advice made by a
Technology Committee composed of:
- SNCF as an involved sponsor (also having
   a certain expertise in large projects)
- City of Versailles as coordinator
- Scientists from UVSQ and HEC in Saclay
- Users of transport infrastructure
- Residents of VC eco-district
- Industrial local partners in mobility



                                               15
UVSQ – Guyancourt Campus – Interactions between 2012-2013 students and experts.
Photo: Teodora Morar




VI.       CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS

i.     The Integration Seminar has proven to be a right tool for the Econoving’s objectives to pursue
       innovation hand in hand with learning and experimentation. This report is a summary of the
       extended report which will be presented in April 2013 and counting for the Work Package 3 –
       Anticipation of the Railway Station Programe (Programme Gare). The method is suited for
       prospective work and learning and should be continued and enhanced. Three approaches have
       been identified as useful: “multi-innovation”, the generalist approach focused on horizontal
       integration and governance; “climate change”, which strategically addresses the issue of climate
       challenges and opportunities; and the “technology push”, as creative rethinking of the role of
       recent technological advances within the societal transformations towards sustainability.
ii.    A city district can be an activity hub, but it must be treated as part of a wider system – the city
       itself. A district cannot be a strict managerial unit, because it lacks some essential functions of a
       community. A key recommendation for future developments is therefore to strengthen the role
       of Versailles Chantiers – and that of similar train stations – by augmenting its role within the city.
iii.   Versailles Chantiers has the potential to become a European reference in urban sustainability
       and eco-innovation. The raison d’être of the rail station can be more than “just the place where
       you take the train”. Not all train stations can be nodes of multi-modal communications and
       exchanges, because this depends on the position within the wider network. Versailles Chantiers
       has this vocation, due to its role as communications hub within Greater Paris. But this train
       station has some unique advantages which can make it a very powerful point of convergence of
       urban socio-economic life – for the people of Versailles and for the global citizens.


                                                               16
UVSQ – Guyanco




VII. THE ROAD AHEAD

Aside from the essential conclusions and recommendations resulted from the exercise, the most
valuable outcome of the Integration Seminar is perhaps the progress up the learning curve. We have
a tried-out modus operandi which enables the Econoving’s Master and the cluster itself to address
further challenges and opportunities – other stations and other cities in France and in Europe.
The development of this method has been made possible by a very large number of people since the
establishment of Econoving, and the development of this method is due to all of them (full list on the
second page of this document), most notable Prof. Sylvie Faucheux, Prof. Keith Culver and two of the
core team members so far, Christelle Hue and Rachel Guilloteau.
As our graduate students and industrial and academic experts have shown in their work, this is only
the beginning. The long-term idea is the commitment to using cluster intelligence to transform
sectorial actors into innovation engines – a bottom-up process and dynamics that is capable of
generating system innovation and green jobs.




                                                  17
References
Beaverstock JV, Smith RG, Taylor PJ (2000) World-City Network: A New Metageography? Annals of the Association of
American Geographers 90(1): 123-134.
Beddington J (2009) Food, energy, water and the climate: A perfect storm of global events? UK Government Office for
Science, http://www.bis.gov.uk/go-science/news/speeches/the-perfect-storm, accessed 28/03/2012.
Ciumasu IM (2013a) We need large-scale experimentation platforms for cross-sector innovation in Europe.
Science|Business, http://www.sciencebusiness.net/news/76003/We-need-large-scale-experimentation-platforms-for-
cross-sector-innovation-in-Europe
Ciumasu IM (2013b) Dynamic decision trees for building resilience into future eco-cities. Technological Forecasting & Social
Change. Doi: 10.1016/j.techfore.2012.12.010., http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0040162512003253
Ciumasu IM (2013c) What is Eco-Innovation? (under review by Research Policy)
Ciumasu IM, Culver KC (2011) Eco-cities in a globalized future - from Constantinopolis to "Cosmopolis"? At ESEE 2011:
Advancing Ecological Economics: Theory and Practice, 14-17 June, Istanbul,
http://www.esee2011.org/registration/fullpapers/esee2011_d254c8_1_13049637762012_2354.pdf
Conticelli E, Tondelli S (2011) Railway Station Role in Composing Urban Conflicts. TeMA - Trimestrale del Laboratorio
Territorio Mobilità e Ambiente - TeMALab, 4: 47-58. ISSN 1970-9870
Culver K, Guilloteau R, Hue C (2011) Hard nodes in soft surroundings: A ‘dream of islands’ strategy for urban sustainability.
Development 54(3): 336-342.
Flint J, Raco M (2012) The Future of Sustainable Cities: Critical Reflections. Policy Press, Bristol, UK.
Fitzgerald J (2010) Emerald Cities: Urban Sustainability and Economic Development. Oxford University Press,
http://www.amazon.com/Emerald-Cities-Sustainability-Economic-Development/dp/0195382765/ref=pd_sim_b_1
Geels FW (2010) Ontologies, socio-technical transitions (to sustainability), and the multi-level perspective. Research Policy
39, 495-510.
Han J, Fontanos P, Fukushi K, Herath S, Heeren N, Naso V, Cecchi C, Edwards P, Takeuchi K, 2012. Innovation for
sustainability: toward a sustainable urban future in industrialized cities. Sustainability Science 7 (Suppl. 1): 91-100.
McDonald RI (2008) Global urbanization: can ecologists identify a sustainable way forward? Frontiers in Ecology and the
Environment 6: 99-104.
Molotch H (1976) The City as a Growth Machine: Toward a Political Economy of Place. American Journal of Sociology 82(2):
309-332.
Portney KE (2003) Taking Sustainable Cities Seriously: Economic Development, the Environment, and Quality of Life in
American Cities, MIP Press, http://www.amazon.com/dp/0262661322/ref=rdr_ext_sb_ti_sims_2
Reusser DE, Loukopoulos P, Stauffacher M, Scholz RW (2008) Classifying railway stations for sustainable transitions-
balancing node and place functions. Journal of Transport Geography 16: 191-202.
Sassen S (1991) The Global City: New York, London, Tokyo, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
Sassen S (2002) Locating cities on global circuits. Environment & Urbanization 14: 13-30.
Terrin JJ (2011) Railway stations and urban dynamics. High-speed issues. Editions Paranthèses, Marseilles, ISBN 978-2-
86364-227-6
Van Wijk M (2007) Airports as Cityports in the City-region: Spatial-economic and institutional positions and institutional
learning in Randstad-Schipol (AMS), Frankfurt-Main (FRA), Tokyo Haneda (HND) and Narita (NRT). PhD thesis published by
KNAG/Faculteit Geowetenschappen Universiteit Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Wackernagel M, Kitzes J, Moran D, Goldfinger S, Thomas M (2006). The Ecological Footprint of cities and regions: comparing
resource availability with resource demand. Environment & Urbanization 18(1): 103-112.
Weber KM, Kubeczko K, Kaufmann A, Grunewald B (2009) Trade-offs between impacts of future-oriented analysis:
experiences from innovation policy foresight and strategy process of the City of Vienna. Technology Analysis and Strategic
Management 21(8): 953-969.
                                                                                       nd
Wheeler SM and Beathley T (2009) The Sustainable Urban Development Reader. 2 edition, Routledge, London, UK.
Williams K (2010) Sustainable cities: research and practice challenges. International Journal of Urban Sustainable
Development 1(1-2): 128-132.




                                                                18
19
contact: econoving@uvsq.fr




                        20

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Coastal Defense Management : A Group Report
Coastal Defense Management : A Group ReportCoastal Defense Management : A Group Report
Coastal Defense Management : A Group ReportRavi Nakulan
 
Clase 1 it management.
Clase 1 it management.Clase 1 it management.
Clase 1 it management.Javier Juliac
 
Purchase & Supply Chain Mangagment (Medical Transcription)
Purchase & Supply Chain Mangagment (Medical Transcription)Purchase & Supply Chain Mangagment (Medical Transcription)
Purchase & Supply Chain Mangagment (Medical Transcription)Ravi Nakulan
 
तक्वा इखतियार करो
तक्वा इखतियार करोतक्वा इखतियार करो
तक्वा इखतियार करोFAHIM AKTHAR ULLAL
 
Le journal Direct Matin parle de GettGuard
Le journal Direct Matin parle de GettGuardLe journal Direct Matin parle de GettGuard
Le journal Direct Matin parle de GettGuardPatrick SENIOR
 
Updated Resume Anil Gour
Updated Resume Anil GourUpdated Resume Anil Gour
Updated Resume Anil GourAnil Gour
 
Roche tarran as cw evaluation and overall feedback sheet
Roche tarran as cw evaluation and overall feedback sheetRoche tarran as cw evaluation and overall feedback sheet
Roche tarran as cw evaluation and overall feedback sheetTarran Roche
 
India globalisation
India globalisationIndia globalisation
India globalisationRavi Nakulan
 
Generos musicales
Generos musicalesGeneros musicales
Generos musicalesivocicc
 
Présentation du Groupe BSL
Présentation du Groupe BSLPrésentation du Groupe BSL
Présentation du Groupe BSLPatrick SENIOR
 

Viewers also liked (14)

Clase 1 bus 333
Clase 1 bus 333Clase 1 bus 333
Clase 1 bus 333
 
Coastal Defense Management : A Group Report
Coastal Defense Management : A Group ReportCoastal Defense Management : A Group Report
Coastal Defense Management : A Group Report
 
Clase 1 it management.
Clase 1 it management.Clase 1 it management.
Clase 1 it management.
 
Purchase & Supply Chain Mangagment (Medical Transcription)
Purchase & Supply Chain Mangagment (Medical Transcription)Purchase & Supply Chain Mangagment (Medical Transcription)
Purchase & Supply Chain Mangagment (Medical Transcription)
 
तक्वा इखतियार करो
तक्वा इखतियार करोतक्वा इखतियार करो
तक्वा इखतियार करो
 
Le journal Direct Matin parle de GettGuard
Le journal Direct Matin parle de GettGuardLe journal Direct Matin parle de GettGuard
Le journal Direct Matin parle de GettGuard
 
масленица
масленицамасленица
масленица
 
Question 2
Question 2Question 2
Question 2
 
Updated Resume Anil Gour
Updated Resume Anil GourUpdated Resume Anil Gour
Updated Resume Anil Gour
 
Roche tarran as cw evaluation and overall feedback sheet
Roche tarran as cw evaluation and overall feedback sheetRoche tarran as cw evaluation and overall feedback sheet
Roche tarran as cw evaluation and overall feedback sheet
 
India globalisation
India globalisationIndia globalisation
India globalisation
 
Generos musicales
Generos musicalesGeneros musicales
Generos musicales
 
Cholinesterase
CholinesteraseCholinesterase
Cholinesterase
 
Présentation du Groupe BSL
Présentation du Groupe BSLPrésentation du Groupe BSL
Présentation du Groupe BSL
 

Similar to Assurance responsabilité civile : A Report of Eco-Cities

DEVELOPING A CONVERGENCE METHODOLOGY BETWEEN ENGINEERING TECHNOLOGY AND FASHI...
DEVELOPING A CONVERGENCE METHODOLOGY BETWEEN ENGINEERING TECHNOLOGY AND FASHI...DEVELOPING A CONVERGENCE METHODOLOGY BETWEEN ENGINEERING TECHNOLOGY AND FASHI...
DEVELOPING A CONVERGENCE METHODOLOGY BETWEEN ENGINEERING TECHNOLOGY AND FASHI...ijejournal
 
2014 11 16 ABC PhD tutti i corsi
2014 11 16 ABC PhD tutti i corsi2014 11 16 ABC PhD tutti i corsi
2014 11 16 ABC PhD tutti i corsiEnrico DeAngelis
 
A Review of Multicriteria Assessment Techniques Applied to Sustainable Infras...
A Review of Multicriteria Assessment Techniques Applied to Sustainable Infras...A Review of Multicriteria Assessment Techniques Applied to Sustainable Infras...
A Review of Multicriteria Assessment Techniques Applied to Sustainable Infras...► Victor Yepes
 
2022 GATF Annual Meeting - Item 7.5 - Sustainable Infrastructure Programme in...
2022 GATF Annual Meeting - Item 7.5 - Sustainable Infrastructure Programme in...2022 GATF Annual Meeting - Item 7.5 - Sustainable Infrastructure Programme in...
2022 GATF Annual Meeting - Item 7.5 - Sustainable Infrastructure Programme in...OECD Environment
 
Lars Frederiksen: Ecocit: Research on innovation and sustainability in urban ...
Lars Frederiksen: Ecocit: Research on innovation and sustainability in urban ...Lars Frederiksen: Ecocit: Research on innovation and sustainability in urban ...
Lars Frederiksen: Ecocit: Research on innovation and sustainability in urban ...STEPS Centre
 
Documento Sena En Ingles (Ientilocos)[1]
Documento Sena En Ingles (Ientilocos)[1]Documento Sena En Ingles (Ientilocos)[1]
Documento Sena En Ingles (Ientilocos)[1]IE Simona Duque
 
Smarcos Newsletter 4 Issue
Smarcos Newsletter 4 IssueSmarcos Newsletter 4 Issue
Smarcos Newsletter 4 IssueSmarcos Eu
 
Become an eco-innovative city by 2030
Become an eco-innovative city by 2030Become an eco-innovative city by 2030
Become an eco-innovative city by 2030JosephIturbide
 
A Triple Bottom Line Reporting Framework For Property Development Portfolios
A Triple Bottom Line Reporting Framework For Property Development PortfoliosA Triple Bottom Line Reporting Framework For Property Development Portfolios
A Triple Bottom Line Reporting Framework For Property Development PortfoliosTony Lisko
 
Molly Webb - Session Outline - Sustainable Cities: Challenges and Solutions
Molly Webb - Session Outline - Sustainable Cities: Challenges and SolutionsMolly Webb - Session Outline - Sustainable Cities: Challenges and Solutions
Molly Webb - Session Outline - Sustainable Cities: Challenges and SolutionsShane Mitchell
 
The new trend to Project Management: Lean construction. A methodology to miti...
The new trend to Project Management: Lean construction. A methodology to miti...The new trend to Project Management: Lean construction. A methodology to miti...
The new trend to Project Management: Lean construction. A methodology to miti...IRJET Journal
 
MAGHRENOV deliverable 2.4: Detailed MSc program
MAGHRENOV deliverable 2.4: Detailed MSc programMAGHRENOV deliverable 2.4: Detailed MSc program
MAGHRENOV deliverable 2.4: Detailed MSc programMaghrenov
 
INNOVATIVE GOALS: CONCEPT, FORMULATION, BUILDING TREE GOALS
INNOVATIVE GOALS: CONCEPT, FORMULATION, BUILDING TREE GOALSINNOVATIVE GOALS: CONCEPT, FORMULATION, BUILDING TREE GOALS
INNOVATIVE GOALS: CONCEPT, FORMULATION, BUILDING TREE GOALSSubmissionResearchpa
 
United States Bankruptcy Law And Java Methods Answers
United States Bankruptcy Law And Java Methods AnswersUnited States Bankruptcy Law And Java Methods Answers
United States Bankruptcy Law And Java Methods AnswersAmanda Burkett
 
FinalPaperS2015-CornellTech-Planning
FinalPaperS2015-CornellTech-PlanningFinalPaperS2015-CornellTech-Planning
FinalPaperS2015-CornellTech-PlanningIlia Savin
 
EFFECTIVE RISK MANAGEMENT IN CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS
EFFECTIVE RISK MANAGEMENT IN CONSTRUCTION PROJECTSEFFECTIVE RISK MANAGEMENT IN CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS
EFFECTIVE RISK MANAGEMENT IN CONSTRUCTION PROJECTSvivatechijri
 
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS FOR A SUSTAINABLE TRAVELING EXHIBITION
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS FOR A SUSTAINABLE TRAVELING EXHIBITION STRATEGIC ANALYSIS FOR A SUSTAINABLE TRAVELING EXHIBITION
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS FOR A SUSTAINABLE TRAVELING EXHIBITION designtango2013
 

Similar to Assurance responsabilité civile : A Report of Eco-Cities (20)

DEVELOPING A CONVERGENCE METHODOLOGY BETWEEN ENGINEERING TECHNOLOGY AND FASHI...
DEVELOPING A CONVERGENCE METHODOLOGY BETWEEN ENGINEERING TECHNOLOGY AND FASHI...DEVELOPING A CONVERGENCE METHODOLOGY BETWEEN ENGINEERING TECHNOLOGY AND FASHI...
DEVELOPING A CONVERGENCE METHODOLOGY BETWEEN ENGINEERING TECHNOLOGY AND FASHI...
 
2014 11 16 ABC PhD tutti i corsi
2014 11 16 ABC PhD tutti i corsi2014 11 16 ABC PhD tutti i corsi
2014 11 16 ABC PhD tutti i corsi
 
Work Package 3
Work Package 3Work Package 3
Work Package 3
 
A Review of Multicriteria Assessment Techniques Applied to Sustainable Infras...
A Review of Multicriteria Assessment Techniques Applied to Sustainable Infras...A Review of Multicriteria Assessment Techniques Applied to Sustainable Infras...
A Review of Multicriteria Assessment Techniques Applied to Sustainable Infras...
 
2022 GATF Annual Meeting - Item 7.5 - Sustainable Infrastructure Programme in...
2022 GATF Annual Meeting - Item 7.5 - Sustainable Infrastructure Programme in...2022 GATF Annual Meeting - Item 7.5 - Sustainable Infrastructure Programme in...
2022 GATF Annual Meeting - Item 7.5 - Sustainable Infrastructure Programme in...
 
Lars Frederiksen: Ecocit: Research on innovation and sustainability in urban ...
Lars Frederiksen: Ecocit: Research on innovation and sustainability in urban ...Lars Frederiksen: Ecocit: Research on innovation and sustainability in urban ...
Lars Frederiksen: Ecocit: Research on innovation and sustainability in urban ...
 
Greenov newsletter 01
Greenov newsletter 01Greenov newsletter 01
Greenov newsletter 01
 
Documento Sena En Ingles (Ientilocos)[1]
Documento Sena En Ingles (Ientilocos)[1]Documento Sena En Ingles (Ientilocos)[1]
Documento Sena En Ingles (Ientilocos)[1]
 
Smarcos Newsletter 4 Issue
Smarcos Newsletter 4 IssueSmarcos Newsletter 4 Issue
Smarcos Newsletter 4 Issue
 
Become an eco-innovative city by 2030
Become an eco-innovative city by 2030Become an eco-innovative city by 2030
Become an eco-innovative city by 2030
 
A Triple Bottom Line Reporting Framework For Property Development Portfolios
A Triple Bottom Line Reporting Framework For Property Development PortfoliosA Triple Bottom Line Reporting Framework For Property Development Portfolios
A Triple Bottom Line Reporting Framework For Property Development Portfolios
 
Molly Webb - Session Outline - Sustainable Cities: Challenges and Solutions
Molly Webb - Session Outline - Sustainable Cities: Challenges and SolutionsMolly Webb - Session Outline - Sustainable Cities: Challenges and Solutions
Molly Webb - Session Outline - Sustainable Cities: Challenges and Solutions
 
The new trend to Project Management: Lean construction. A methodology to miti...
The new trend to Project Management: Lean construction. A methodology to miti...The new trend to Project Management: Lean construction. A methodology to miti...
The new trend to Project Management: Lean construction. A methodology to miti...
 
MAGHRENOV deliverable 2.4: Detailed MSc program
MAGHRENOV deliverable 2.4: Detailed MSc programMAGHRENOV deliverable 2.4: Detailed MSc program
MAGHRENOV deliverable 2.4: Detailed MSc program
 
INNOVATIVE GOALS: CONCEPT, FORMULATION, BUILDING TREE GOALS
INNOVATIVE GOALS: CONCEPT, FORMULATION, BUILDING TREE GOALSINNOVATIVE GOALS: CONCEPT, FORMULATION, BUILDING TREE GOALS
INNOVATIVE GOALS: CONCEPT, FORMULATION, BUILDING TREE GOALS
 
United States Bankruptcy Law And Java Methods Answers
United States Bankruptcy Law And Java Methods AnswersUnited States Bankruptcy Law And Java Methods Answers
United States Bankruptcy Law And Java Methods Answers
 
Call arcom32 (1)
Call arcom32 (1)Call arcom32 (1)
Call arcom32 (1)
 
FinalPaperS2015-CornellTech-Planning
FinalPaperS2015-CornellTech-PlanningFinalPaperS2015-CornellTech-Planning
FinalPaperS2015-CornellTech-Planning
 
EFFECTIVE RISK MANAGEMENT IN CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS
EFFECTIVE RISK MANAGEMENT IN CONSTRUCTION PROJECTSEFFECTIVE RISK MANAGEMENT IN CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS
EFFECTIVE RISK MANAGEMENT IN CONSTRUCTION PROJECTS
 
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS FOR A SUSTAINABLE TRAVELING EXHIBITION
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS FOR A SUSTAINABLE TRAVELING EXHIBITION STRATEGIC ANALYSIS FOR A SUSTAINABLE TRAVELING EXHIBITION
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS FOR A SUSTAINABLE TRAVELING EXHIBITION
 

More from Ravi Nakulan

Project Management Sample
Project Management SampleProject Management Sample
Project Management SampleRavi Nakulan
 
Count of Candies - Happy Halloween Day
Count of Candies - Happy Halloween DayCount of Candies - Happy Halloween Day
Count of Candies - Happy Halloween DayRavi Nakulan
 
Discriminant analysis ravi nakulan slideshare
Discriminant analysis ravi nakulan slideshareDiscriminant analysis ravi nakulan slideshare
Discriminant analysis ravi nakulan slideshareRavi Nakulan
 
SVM Vs Naive Bays Algorithm (Jupyter Notebook)
SVM Vs Naive Bays Algorithm (Jupyter Notebook)SVM Vs Naive Bays Algorithm (Jupyter Notebook)
SVM Vs Naive Bays Algorithm (Jupyter Notebook)Ravi Nakulan
 
500 Hollywood Movies - An Analysis
500 Hollywood Movies - An Analysis500 Hollywood Movies - An Analysis
500 Hollywood Movies - An AnalysisRavi Nakulan
 
Data Visualization with Strava
Data Visualization with StravaData Visualization with Strava
Data Visualization with StravaRavi Nakulan
 
Risk Management Plan
Risk Management PlanRisk Management Plan
Risk Management PlanRavi Nakulan
 
Communication Map Plan for Business
Communication Map Plan for Business Communication Map Plan for Business
Communication Map Plan for Business Ravi Nakulan
 
U.S.-China Aircraft Collision Incident
U.S.-China Aircraft Collision IncidentU.S.-China Aircraft Collision Incident
U.S.-China Aircraft Collision IncidentRavi Nakulan
 
INDIA Globalisation 3
INDIA Globalisation 3INDIA Globalisation 3
INDIA Globalisation 3Ravi Nakulan
 
India globalisation 1
India globalisation 1India globalisation 1
India globalisation 1Ravi Nakulan
 
Corruption & Triablism_India
Corruption & Triablism_IndiaCorruption & Triablism_India
Corruption & Triablism_IndiaRavi Nakulan
 
Employer branding (Mobile)
Employer branding (Mobile)Employer branding (Mobile)
Employer branding (Mobile)Ravi Nakulan
 

More from Ravi Nakulan (14)

Project Management Sample
Project Management SampleProject Management Sample
Project Management Sample
 
Count of Candies - Happy Halloween Day
Count of Candies - Happy Halloween DayCount of Candies - Happy Halloween Day
Count of Candies - Happy Halloween Day
 
Discriminant analysis ravi nakulan slideshare
Discriminant analysis ravi nakulan slideshareDiscriminant analysis ravi nakulan slideshare
Discriminant analysis ravi nakulan slideshare
 
SVM Vs Naive Bays Algorithm (Jupyter Notebook)
SVM Vs Naive Bays Algorithm (Jupyter Notebook)SVM Vs Naive Bays Algorithm (Jupyter Notebook)
SVM Vs Naive Bays Algorithm (Jupyter Notebook)
 
500 Hollywood Movies - An Analysis
500 Hollywood Movies - An Analysis500 Hollywood Movies - An Analysis
500 Hollywood Movies - An Analysis
 
Data Visualization with Strava
Data Visualization with StravaData Visualization with Strava
Data Visualization with Strava
 
Entrepreneur
EntrepreneurEntrepreneur
Entrepreneur
 
Risk Management Plan
Risk Management PlanRisk Management Plan
Risk Management Plan
 
Communication Map Plan for Business
Communication Map Plan for Business Communication Map Plan for Business
Communication Map Plan for Business
 
U.S.-China Aircraft Collision Incident
U.S.-China Aircraft Collision IncidentU.S.-China Aircraft Collision Incident
U.S.-China Aircraft Collision Incident
 
INDIA Globalisation 3
INDIA Globalisation 3INDIA Globalisation 3
INDIA Globalisation 3
 
India globalisation 1
India globalisation 1India globalisation 1
India globalisation 1
 
Corruption & Triablism_India
Corruption & Triablism_IndiaCorruption & Triablism_India
Corruption & Triablism_India
 
Employer branding (Mobile)
Employer branding (Mobile)Employer branding (Mobile)
Employer branding (Mobile)
 

Recently uploaded

Piece by Piece Magazine
Piece by Piece Magazine                      Piece by Piece Magazine
Piece by Piece Magazine CharlottePulte
 
guest bathroom white and blue ssssssssss
guest bathroom white and blue ssssssssssguest bathroom white and blue ssssssssss
guest bathroom white and blue ssssssssssNadaMohammed714321
 
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...Rishabh Aryan
 
group_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdf
group_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdfgroup_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdf
group_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdfneelspinoy
 
Unit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptx
Unit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptxUnit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptx
Unit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptxNitish292041
 
cda.pptx critical discourse analysis ppt
cda.pptx critical discourse analysis pptcda.pptx critical discourse analysis ppt
cda.pptx critical discourse analysis pptMaryamAfzal41
 
Niintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptx
Niintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptxNiintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptx
Niintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptxKevinYaelJimnezSanti
 
The spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenology
The spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenologyThe spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenology
The spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenologyChristopher Totten
 
Pharmaceutical Packaging for the elderly.pdf
Pharmaceutical Packaging for the elderly.pdfPharmaceutical Packaging for the elderly.pdf
Pharmaceutical Packaging for the elderly.pdfAayushChavan5
 
Interior Design for Office a cura di RMG Project Studio
Interior Design for Office a cura di RMG Project StudioInterior Design for Office a cura di RMG Project Studio
Interior Design for Office a cura di RMG Project StudioRMG Project Studio
 
General Knowledge Quiz Game C++ CODE.pptx
General Knowledge Quiz Game C++ CODE.pptxGeneral Knowledge Quiz Game C++ CODE.pptx
General Knowledge Quiz Game C++ CODE.pptxmarckustrevion
 
Pearl Disrtrict urban analyusis study pptx
Pearl Disrtrict urban analyusis study pptxPearl Disrtrict urban analyusis study pptx
Pearl Disrtrict urban analyusis study pptxDanielTamiru4
 
Map of St. Louis Parks
Map of St. Louis Parks                              Map of St. Louis Parks
Map of St. Louis Parks CharlottePulte
 
Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...
Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...
Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...Associazione Digital Days
 
Karim apartment ideas 02 ppppppppppppppp
Karim apartment ideas 02 pppppppppppppppKarim apartment ideas 02 ppppppppppppppp
Karim apartment ideas 02 pppppppppppppppNadaMohammed714321
 
10 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 2024
10 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 202410 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 2024
10 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 2024digital learning point
 
Color Theory Explained for Noobs- Think360 Studio
Color Theory Explained for Noobs- Think360 StudioColor Theory Explained for Noobs- Think360 Studio
Color Theory Explained for Noobs- Think360 StudioThink360 Studio
 
Making and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.ppt
Making and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.pptMaking and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.ppt
Making and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.pptJIT KUMAR GUPTA
 
怎么办理英国Newcastle毕业证纽卡斯尔大学学位证书一手渠道
怎么办理英国Newcastle毕业证纽卡斯尔大学学位证书一手渠道怎么办理英国Newcastle毕业证纽卡斯尔大学学位证书一手渠道
怎么办理英国Newcastle毕业证纽卡斯尔大学学位证书一手渠道yrolcks
 
办理卡尔顿大学毕业证成绩单|购买加拿大文凭证书
办理卡尔顿大学毕业证成绩单|购买加拿大文凭证书办理卡尔顿大学毕业证成绩单|购买加拿大文凭证书
办理卡尔顿大学毕业证成绩单|购买加拿大文凭证书zdzoqco
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Piece by Piece Magazine
Piece by Piece Magazine                      Piece by Piece Magazine
Piece by Piece Magazine
 
guest bathroom white and blue ssssssssss
guest bathroom white and blue ssssssssssguest bathroom white and blue ssssssssss
guest bathroom white and blue ssssssssss
 
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
 
group_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdf
group_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdfgroup_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdf
group_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdf
 
Unit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptx
Unit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptxUnit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptx
Unit1_Syllbwbnwnwneneneneneneentation_Sem2.pptx
 
cda.pptx critical discourse analysis ppt
cda.pptx critical discourse analysis pptcda.pptx critical discourse analysis ppt
cda.pptx critical discourse analysis ppt
 
Niintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptx
Niintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptxNiintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptx
Niintendo Wii Presentation Template.pptx
 
The spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenology
The spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenologyThe spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenology
The spirit of digital place - game worlds and architectural phenomenology
 
Pharmaceutical Packaging for the elderly.pdf
Pharmaceutical Packaging for the elderly.pdfPharmaceutical Packaging for the elderly.pdf
Pharmaceutical Packaging for the elderly.pdf
 
Interior Design for Office a cura di RMG Project Studio
Interior Design for Office a cura di RMG Project StudioInterior Design for Office a cura di RMG Project Studio
Interior Design for Office a cura di RMG Project Studio
 
General Knowledge Quiz Game C++ CODE.pptx
General Knowledge Quiz Game C++ CODE.pptxGeneral Knowledge Quiz Game C++ CODE.pptx
General Knowledge Quiz Game C++ CODE.pptx
 
Pearl Disrtrict urban analyusis study pptx
Pearl Disrtrict urban analyusis study pptxPearl Disrtrict urban analyusis study pptx
Pearl Disrtrict urban analyusis study pptx
 
Map of St. Louis Parks
Map of St. Louis Parks                              Map of St. Louis Parks
Map of St. Louis Parks
 
Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...
Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...
Giulio Michelon, Founder di @Belka – “Oltre le Stime: Sviluppare una Mentalit...
 
Karim apartment ideas 02 ppppppppppppppp
Karim apartment ideas 02 pppppppppppppppKarim apartment ideas 02 ppppppppppppppp
Karim apartment ideas 02 ppppppppppppppp
 
10 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 2024
10 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 202410 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 2024
10 Best WordPress Plugins to make the website effective in 2024
 
Color Theory Explained for Noobs- Think360 Studio
Color Theory Explained for Noobs- Think360 StudioColor Theory Explained for Noobs- Think360 Studio
Color Theory Explained for Noobs- Think360 Studio
 
Making and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.ppt
Making and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.pptMaking and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.ppt
Making and Unmaking of Chandigarh - A City of Two Plans2-4-24.ppt
 
怎么办理英国Newcastle毕业证纽卡斯尔大学学位证书一手渠道
怎么办理英国Newcastle毕业证纽卡斯尔大学学位证书一手渠道怎么办理英国Newcastle毕业证纽卡斯尔大学学位证书一手渠道
怎么办理英国Newcastle毕业证纽卡斯尔大学学位证书一手渠道
 
办理卡尔顿大学毕业证成绩单|购买加拿大文凭证书
办理卡尔顿大学毕业证成绩单|购买加拿大文凭证书办理卡尔顿大学毕业证成绩单|购买加拿大文凭证书
办理卡尔顿大学毕业证成绩单|购买加拿大文凭证书
 

Assurance responsabilité civile : A Report of Eco-Cities

  • 1. Is there a Future for eco-cities? Prospective roles of Versailles Chantiers within the Greater Paris: A hub of multi-modal communication Versailles, 2013 1
  • 2. This is a first global report of the Integration Seminar – a module of innovation and learning within the International Professional Master in Management of Eco-Innovation. This is a graduate program managed by the Econoving Chair in Generating Eco-Innovation – a cluster of academic, industrial and government actors focused on urban sustainability. Counting for the Work Package 3 – Anticipation of the Econoving’s Rail Station Program (Programme Gare, 2011-2013), this report is the result of the joint work carried out by the Econoving researchers and graduate students in collaboration with the industrial partners. Coordination of work, research, text & design: Dr. Ioan M. Ciumasu – ioan.ciumasu@uvsq.fr The views expressed here are of the author, and do not necessarily represent those of the institutions © 2013 Econoving Acknowledgements – the following have contributed to this work: Econoving 2011-2012 students: Anna Aghvanyan, Adrian Carrillo, Krishna Chandran, Boubacar Coly, Fanny Courry, Maxim Doubrouski, Elodie Gonthier, Sirin Hamsho, Alejandra Hoyos, Xiaochao Huang, Collins Ihedioha, Natalia Kozdra, Anna Lomteva, Javad Mahmoodirad, Ravi Nakulan, Alexandra Ostrovskaya, Kevin Ramirez, Marcel Roquette, Dina Salakhova, Maria Stoica, Sandra Velasco. Econoving 2012-2013 students: François Apicella, Gabriel Bermeo, Zoheir Haghighi, Ludmila Kobyakova, Renan Le Tohic, Habib Liamidi, Hélène Luciani, Diego Martinez, Mingyan Meng, Teodora Morar, Surya Muraleedharan-Nair, Julian Muriel, Marina Nikitina, Kalliopi Ntanou, Maria Lucia Portocarrero, Cécile Tchoubaev. Expert coaches, jury or institutional support: Jean-Louis Jourdan, Alain Adrianssens, Thierry Lafont (SNCF), Agnes Roux (City of Versailles), Bernard Blez, Etienne Drouet (GDF Suez), Laurent Schmitt (Alstom Grid), Frédéric Cuq (Saur), Christophe Lombard (Italcementi), Dominique Agrech (X-Ange), Sylvie Faucheux, Keith Culver, Beat Bürgenmeier, Christelle Hue, Rachel Guilloteau, René Audet, Sophie Némoz, Caroline Gans-Combe, Quentin Courtier, Frédéric Louradour, Amélie Coulbaut-Lazzarini, Guillaume Bailly (UVSQ). 2
  • 3. TABLE OF CONTENTS I. OVERVIEW II. EXERCISE DESCRIPTION III. LESSONS OF THE 1st YEAR IV. REVIEW OF ECO-CITY RESEARCH & LITERATURE V. RESULTS & PROPOSITIONS AFTER THE 2nd YEAR VI. CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS UVSQ – Guyancourt Campus. Photo: Ioan M. Ciumasu VII. THE ROAD AHEAD 3
  • 4. I. OVERVIEW The Integration Seminar (IS) is an exercise of collaborative integration and application of knowledge gained in individual course modules – a student-expert interaction. This is a hands-on undertaking, organized in the form of a simulation of an eco-innovation consulting firm responding to a call for project proposals launched by a local community – Building the best European eco-innovation hub: From Versailles Chantiers railway station to the eco-city of the future. By 2030 and 2050 Versailles Chantiers should become: 1. A Multi-modal pole (“pôle multimodal”) – a hub of combined persons and value exchanges 2. A development engine of the City of Versailles and a global reference for urban sustainability This community of innovators and learners is organized in three teams (consulting firms), each with a different angle of approach: Multi-Innovation, Climate Change, and Technology Push. The students- experts interaction took the form of lectures, coaching, presentations and jury evaluations. The IS allows a realistic exploration of the links and creative tensions between topics and between innovation factors; identification of the main drivers of change; co-definition of problems and of the potential solutions. The work took place at the Econoving locations in Guyancourt. UVSQ – Guyancourt Campus. Photo: Ioan M. Ciumasu 4
  • 5. II. EXERCISE DESCRIPTION The IS exercise has been iterated two university years in a row – 2011-2012 & 2012-2013. Each year, the work went through two phases – vision building and implementation plan, as illustrated below. 1st Phase – Vision building ORGANISATION - similar projects INTERNATIONAL - methods TEAM SURVEY & - context BENCHMARKING - project dynamics & structure DIAGNOSIS OF VISION VERSAILLES CHANTIERS & Main Objectives -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2nd Phase – Developing the implementation plan QUALITY PROJECT & ECO-INNOVATION MANAGEMENT INNOVATION ENGINE INDICATORS MANAGEMENT & SOLUTIONS 5
  • 6. III. LESSONS FROM THE 1st YEAR Participants have engaged in lively professional feedbacks, notably in two deliveries by the students in front a jury of academics, industrials, financial experts and public authorities. UVSQ – Guyancourt Campus – Interactions between 2011-2012 students and experts. Photos: Elodie Gonthier Some first patterns and challenges have emerged:  It is very difficult to collect reliable, coherent information – in deed, a world-wide known challenge  Trans-sectorial understanding of a city is a heavy task, due to traditional divisions between disciplines  New types of knowledge management are needed, which requires sustained effort and learning by all  The historical heritage and the context of the Greater Paris represent both opportunities & challenges  Scenarios can address: technology choices, social acceptability, environmental concerns, costs & risks  Higher spatial scales are important: a train station can only function as embedded in its city context 6
  • 7. The method has worked very well. It appears that this type of exercise is a very useful tool for foresight and anticipation in terms of eco-innovation and eco-city development. The approach allows the people involved in the works, both graduate students and experts, to grasp the project reality at the city level and to build a solid foundation for future solutions. Various options and scenarios have been analyzed, so as to link local context with global issues. Further, the set of three angles of view has proven to be very insightful, as each of them can be taken autonomously or/and in complementarity with the other two: multi-innovation, climate change and technology push. The three perspectives have thus been continued in the 2nd year. The iteration of the exercise two years in a row is also meant to allow the confirmation and consolidation of the method, and to further develop the initial results and lessons – to enhance the overall value of the work. This 2nd run of the exercise was therefore planned using: - The lessons and materials obtained by the 1st year - The recent advances of the researchers in the Railway Station Program - The newest advances and insights on eco-innovation and eco-city in the literature The 2011-2012 Econoving students & experts have passed the relay over to the next Generation. 7
  • 8. IV. REVIEW OF ECO-CITY RESEARCH & LITERATURE Cities are becoming the drivers of change. The place and role of Econoving Cities are veritable “growth machines” for their hinterlands (Molotch 1976), which may explain why humanity is mostly urban already. The global urbanization rate is accelerating, as do environmental degradation. Urban transformation is now an ecological research topic in its own right (McDonald 2008). The success or the failure of the transition to sustainability will be determined in cities. In the globalizing world of the 21st century, global fluxes of matter-energy, information and people can be understood in terms of exchanges within a global network of interconnected cities – some “world cities” being more influential than others (Sassen 1991, 2002; Beaverstock et al. 2000). In the same time, cities are the product of their local context, and are dependent on the natural resources which they extract from their hinterland (“ecosystem goods and services” which together form the “ecosystem carrying capacity”; Wackernagel et al. 2006). The sustainability of a city is therefore a matter of how advanced that city is in the transition from a local identity to a double, local-and- global identity (Ciumasu & Culver 2011). In deed, this is the core challenge for city planners and managers for the next years and decades. Since 2009-2010, Econoving has engaged in its own eco-city development and employs Versailles Chantiers – a communication hub within Greater Paris – as a pivot and experimental platform for collaborative innovation for urban sustainability (Culver et al. 2011; Ciumasu 2013a,b). The Greater Paris has its own global weight: a concept launched by the French President (2007) as an overarching objective of re-imagining Paris as a world’s mega-city promoting sustainability and competitiveness. This is the largest project of Paris since G.E. Haussmann has re-organized the city in the 19th century (as commissioned by Napolen III). The institutional context at Econoving is a university-industry- government consortium supporting a research and post-graduate education program. City managers experience the need of knowledge integration In their quest for sustainable development, many urban communities and research institutions have pioneered urban foresight, sometimes followed by policies for urban development. But the decision- making process tended to favor trade-offs which avoided controversy and thus have changed nothing in the end (Weber et al. 2009). Even a strong political will was not enough. On the other hand, we now live in a knowledge society, and the fundamental question now towards city sustainability is: How to develop a functional relation between science and decision makers? This question may seem straightforward, and yet there is another challenge before us: all disciplines contributing to sustainability have their distinct understanding of a sustainable city – an ecologist, a sociologist, an economist, an engineer or an architect talks about what the concept of urban sustainability means for her/him and there is no real common language (Williams 2010). This causes mismatches and intricacies that drive effective decision making into a halt. Consequently, it’s easy to declare aims of urban sustainability, but much more difficult to make it real. This can only commence with federative efforts – notably the creation of agoras of learning and knowledge co-generation by various experts. Such efforts often result in great collections of knowledge but this is still not enough: they stop short of integration (Wheeler and Beatley 2009). As a result, for city managers, an essential question still awaits answers: How to actually use all this heterogeneous body of knowledge? 8
  • 9. The hard but necessary way of experimentation. The role of cityports Innovation is the most effective way to bridge science and society, both in terms of transforming industrialized societies (a good start is the 1st Innovation Convention of the European Commission, 05-07 December 2011, http://ec.europa.eu/research/innovation-union/ic2011/index_en.cfm) and in terms of city systems (Han et al 2012). However, we are facing a set of paramount challenges. Firstly, the need for trans-disciplinarity (problem solving-oriented research) is widely recognized, but there is no such thing as a unified theory of sustainability. Secondly, as we speak, we are already over-consuming the Earth’s carrying capacity, which means that simply “innovation for sustainability” is not sufficient – we need to innovate fast or face the “perfect storm” within decades (Beddington 2009). Thirdly, having in mind the first two points, postponing decisions is already a ‘worse’ decision, which means that we often have to act even before we fully understand the process. In summary, the only practical way towards sustainability is experimentation, i.e., learning and doing in the same time. In effect, the process of innovation itself is describable as a learning cycle (Ciumasu 2013c). In terms of the transition management theory, such active generation of innovation is understood as a double process of learning-by-doing and doing-by-learning (Geels 2010). In terms of urban renewal initiative types, communities are scattered on a gradient from whole-city commitments to (only) sectorial developments to plain ignorance and disinterest (Portney 2003; Flint & Raco 2012). Interestingly, even in the absence of a dedicated national policy, many cities have major sustainability initiatives, e.g., Seattle, Portland, Chicago, New York, San Francisco (among the large American cities) (Fitzgerald 2010) or Grand Rapids - Michigan among the smaller cities. Some key patterns are detectable. One is the re-thinking of the various functions of the city areas so as to promote walkable neighborhood. Another one is the use of a “city port” (seaport or airport) as a hub of development and renewal of metropolitan areas (Van Wijk 2007). This reminds the historic role of railway stations for urban and economic development in the 19th century (Conticelli & Tondelli 2011). They were initially located outside the town (due to public health considerations) but have gradually melted into the urban shape and functions (Reusser et al. 2008). Today, in the European context of good public transportation, high population densities and the arrival of high-speed trains, a strong competition has emerged between air and train travels across medium-long distances (300-500 km), with important consequences on cities (e.g. Terrin 2009). Such developments, together with many other details of modern life, notably the revival of passive urban transportation (walking and cycling) and the new communication technologies, are generating a great deal of interest in the concept of “multi-modal transportation”. Stakeholders include citizens, industry and public authorities. It is in this context that Econoving runs its own foresight exercise and collaborative learning cycles. V. RESULTS & PROPOSITIONS AFTER THE 2nd YEAR The following options have been developed by the 2012-2013 generation of students and experts, as summarized in the remainder of this reports: a. URBAN RENEWAL: Integrative planning for radical progress in Versailles Chantiers b. URBAN RESILIENCE: Smart adaptation & mitigation of climate changes in Versailles Chantiers c. URBAN TECHNOLOGY: Integrative solutions for augmenting Versailles to the status of all-times International Hub of Innovation 9
  • 10. Current station. Source: http://www.monversailles.com/transports/ca-coince-sur-la-ligne-ter-paris-chartres/ URBAN RENEWAL: Integrative planning for radical progress in Versailles Chantiers DIAGNOSIS: There is an important gap between current situation & the true potential of VC VISION: We want to change that! Source: bluewaterindia.com/renewable-energy.htm Source: http://www.ecochunk.com/ Current station. Original photos Source: bluewaterindia.com/renewable-energy.htm 10
  • 11. Conference Centre Versailles Chantiers should take better advantage of its prominent place within the Greater Paris. To become a multi-modal hub of transport and communications, Versailles Chantiers station should re- invent itself together with its neighborhood, become a Global Reference for Eco-Innovative Solutions. A great number of solutions are now available, and all modern needs of the people should be met in the same time and in the same place. The key to achieving this has two complementary facets: 1. Forward-looking, transdisciplinary and problem solving oriented thinking 2. Pro-active communications to a local, national, European and Global audience How? The proposition is to mobilize energies and intelligence via transforming Versailles Chantiers into an International Showroom and Conference Centre by 2020. This should serve as an exhibition place, and the station itself should be part of the “live exhibition” of new options for sustainable living through multi-modal communication. Investment required: 1.3-4.1 bn € depending on the chosen scale (cf. benchmarking), through a financial mix: partnerships, contracts and loans. A conference space can also be organised nearby the station for: exhibitions, public dialogue, expert meetings, tourist offices, educational media. Many cities have chosen to build a powerful conference centre as a strategic way to generate visibility and to attract investments (e.g. Bak et al. 2012, DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-23550-4_2, available online at http://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F978- 3-642-23550-4_2?LI=true; and Ramirez-Pasillas 2010, DOI: 10.1080/08985620902815106, available online at http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/08985620902815106). 11
  • 12. URBAN RESILIENCE: Smart adaptation & mitigation of climate changes in Versailles Chantiers DIAGNOSIS. Versailles Chantiers train station has a vast, unused potential to function as a pivot of technology and innovation in the Greater Paris and a socio-economic engine for the city of Versailles. Station today Impacts to be expected 1. Higher t°C, Frequency & Poor thermal regulation - Heat stress; Lower productivity Duration of heat waves - Higher energy consumption 2. More days of droughts No water management - Water scarcity & higher cost during summer - Higher health risks 3. Extreme precipitations Low platforms Insuficient - Operations vs. flood risks and natural disasters shelters - Passengers discomfort & risks - Power shortage risk VISION: By 2050, Versailles Chantiers plays a leading global role as:  Sustainability reference  Benchmark of the best climate-related solutions How? By establishing a Technology Validation Laboratory (to be functional by 2030, nearby the station) which will be recognized by world’s experts as a place where the latest technological solutions are tested for viability, system integration, and climate relevance. Rationale: Technology goes through stages of development from proof-of-concept to demonstrators and commercial prototypes. The bottleneck of a technological solution is the test of its capacity to function as part of a system of various technologies: technology readiness (Azizian et al. 2011, DOI: 10.1002/sys.20186, online at http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/sys.20186/full). FINANCE & IMPLEMENTATION SNCF / RFF 12% 6% Initial investment: 110-130 M€ PARTNERS & private investors 20% Financial participation based on current ADEME renovation & others projects Local Authorities (Versailles, Grand Parc) 25% in the Greater Paris area 10% European Commission Mechanisms: Partners investments 30%, Régional governance (IDF, Dept..) Tax return/Community grants 30%, 12% 15% Public subsidies 25%, Loans 15% State 12
  • 13. Energy Green Water Areas VC station Green Services Mobility Air Waste Quality A series of topics are important and inter-related. But the most prominent and urgent topics are related to energy and indoor air quality (related to health and physiological comfort). Therefore, two major objectives are forerunning in our approach and proposition: st 1. Versailles Chantiers should become the 1 carbon-neutral city district in the European Union 2. Green walls & related biotechnologies need to be tested as main solution to indoor pollution & comfort in stations Proposed for VC building: - Indoor air cooling by 4-6°C - Cold air cools the building - Water reuse (toilets, etc) Original photos Proven Technology - shower tower: The air is cooled via reversed heat transfer (City of Melbourne 2004) 13
  • 14. Future Avenue de Sceaux – Versailles. Artwork: Teodora Morar URBAN TECHNOLOGY: Integrative solutions for augmenting Versailles to the status of All-times International Hub of Innovation DIAGNOSIS. Versailles Chantiers train station has a vast, unused potential to function as a pivot of technology and innovation in the Greater Paris and a socio-economic engine for the city of Versailles. VISION. Avenue de Sceaux will become a strategic axis: an inspiring journey connecting the historical heritage of Versailles Castle and the multi-modal pole of communication of Versailles Chantiers. This will magnify the profile of Versailles as a European and world eco-city reference. Tramway on green path. Source: http://orangerie-strasbourg.e- Policemen on segways in Versailles. monsite.com/pages/au-tour-du-parc.html http://www.flickr.com/photos/86749403 @N08/7944172282/ Info panels in parks. Original First launch of Montgolfier Balloon in Versailles. Source: http://www.france- pittoresque.com/spip.php?article6561 14
  • 15. Milestones and scenarios Future VC and Avenue de Sceaux – Versailles Artwork: Teodora Morar FINANCE & IMPLEMENTATION The estimated investment is: 70.8 M€ [0.8 M for studies & communication, 10 M for services, 40 M for clean technologies, 20 M for mobility and accessibility]. A Committee of stake-holders & experts would insure the project governance: SNCF, GDF Suez, Alstom, Italcementi, Saur, UVSQ, HEC, Versailles City, other industrial, academic & public partners The proposed process of achieving success is the candidature of the city of Versailles to become a European Green Capital by 2050, with the technical advice made by a Technology Committee composed of: - SNCF as an involved sponsor (also having a certain expertise in large projects) - City of Versailles as coordinator - Scientists from UVSQ and HEC in Saclay - Users of transport infrastructure - Residents of VC eco-district - Industrial local partners in mobility 15
  • 16. UVSQ – Guyancourt Campus – Interactions between 2012-2013 students and experts. Photo: Teodora Morar VI. CONCLUSIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS i. The Integration Seminar has proven to be a right tool for the Econoving’s objectives to pursue innovation hand in hand with learning and experimentation. This report is a summary of the extended report which will be presented in April 2013 and counting for the Work Package 3 – Anticipation of the Railway Station Programe (Programme Gare). The method is suited for prospective work and learning and should be continued and enhanced. Three approaches have been identified as useful: “multi-innovation”, the generalist approach focused on horizontal integration and governance; “climate change”, which strategically addresses the issue of climate challenges and opportunities; and the “technology push”, as creative rethinking of the role of recent technological advances within the societal transformations towards sustainability. ii. A city district can be an activity hub, but it must be treated as part of a wider system – the city itself. A district cannot be a strict managerial unit, because it lacks some essential functions of a community. A key recommendation for future developments is therefore to strengthen the role of Versailles Chantiers – and that of similar train stations – by augmenting its role within the city. iii. Versailles Chantiers has the potential to become a European reference in urban sustainability and eco-innovation. The raison d’être of the rail station can be more than “just the place where you take the train”. Not all train stations can be nodes of multi-modal communications and exchanges, because this depends on the position within the wider network. Versailles Chantiers has this vocation, due to its role as communications hub within Greater Paris. But this train station has some unique advantages which can make it a very powerful point of convergence of urban socio-economic life – for the people of Versailles and for the global citizens. 16
  • 17. UVSQ – Guyanco VII. THE ROAD AHEAD Aside from the essential conclusions and recommendations resulted from the exercise, the most valuable outcome of the Integration Seminar is perhaps the progress up the learning curve. We have a tried-out modus operandi which enables the Econoving’s Master and the cluster itself to address further challenges and opportunities – other stations and other cities in France and in Europe. The development of this method has been made possible by a very large number of people since the establishment of Econoving, and the development of this method is due to all of them (full list on the second page of this document), most notable Prof. Sylvie Faucheux, Prof. Keith Culver and two of the core team members so far, Christelle Hue and Rachel Guilloteau. As our graduate students and industrial and academic experts have shown in their work, this is only the beginning. The long-term idea is the commitment to using cluster intelligence to transform sectorial actors into innovation engines – a bottom-up process and dynamics that is capable of generating system innovation and green jobs. 17
  • 18. References Beaverstock JV, Smith RG, Taylor PJ (2000) World-City Network: A New Metageography? Annals of the Association of American Geographers 90(1): 123-134. Beddington J (2009) Food, energy, water and the climate: A perfect storm of global events? UK Government Office for Science, http://www.bis.gov.uk/go-science/news/speeches/the-perfect-storm, accessed 28/03/2012. Ciumasu IM (2013a) We need large-scale experimentation platforms for cross-sector innovation in Europe. Science|Business, http://www.sciencebusiness.net/news/76003/We-need-large-scale-experimentation-platforms-for- cross-sector-innovation-in-Europe Ciumasu IM (2013b) Dynamic decision trees for building resilience into future eco-cities. Technological Forecasting & Social Change. Doi: 10.1016/j.techfore.2012.12.010., http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0040162512003253 Ciumasu IM (2013c) What is Eco-Innovation? (under review by Research Policy) Ciumasu IM, Culver KC (2011) Eco-cities in a globalized future - from Constantinopolis to "Cosmopolis"? At ESEE 2011: Advancing Ecological Economics: Theory and Practice, 14-17 June, Istanbul, http://www.esee2011.org/registration/fullpapers/esee2011_d254c8_1_13049637762012_2354.pdf Conticelli E, Tondelli S (2011) Railway Station Role in Composing Urban Conflicts. TeMA - Trimestrale del Laboratorio Territorio Mobilità e Ambiente - TeMALab, 4: 47-58. ISSN 1970-9870 Culver K, Guilloteau R, Hue C (2011) Hard nodes in soft surroundings: A ‘dream of islands’ strategy for urban sustainability. Development 54(3): 336-342. Flint J, Raco M (2012) The Future of Sustainable Cities: Critical Reflections. Policy Press, Bristol, UK. Fitzgerald J (2010) Emerald Cities: Urban Sustainability and Economic Development. Oxford University Press, http://www.amazon.com/Emerald-Cities-Sustainability-Economic-Development/dp/0195382765/ref=pd_sim_b_1 Geels FW (2010) Ontologies, socio-technical transitions (to sustainability), and the multi-level perspective. Research Policy 39, 495-510. Han J, Fontanos P, Fukushi K, Herath S, Heeren N, Naso V, Cecchi C, Edwards P, Takeuchi K, 2012. Innovation for sustainability: toward a sustainable urban future in industrialized cities. Sustainability Science 7 (Suppl. 1): 91-100. McDonald RI (2008) Global urbanization: can ecologists identify a sustainable way forward? Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 6: 99-104. Molotch H (1976) The City as a Growth Machine: Toward a Political Economy of Place. American Journal of Sociology 82(2): 309-332. Portney KE (2003) Taking Sustainable Cities Seriously: Economic Development, the Environment, and Quality of Life in American Cities, MIP Press, http://www.amazon.com/dp/0262661322/ref=rdr_ext_sb_ti_sims_2 Reusser DE, Loukopoulos P, Stauffacher M, Scholz RW (2008) Classifying railway stations for sustainable transitions- balancing node and place functions. Journal of Transport Geography 16: 191-202. Sassen S (1991) The Global City: New York, London, Tokyo, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. Sassen S (2002) Locating cities on global circuits. Environment & Urbanization 14: 13-30. Terrin JJ (2011) Railway stations and urban dynamics. High-speed issues. Editions Paranthèses, Marseilles, ISBN 978-2- 86364-227-6 Van Wijk M (2007) Airports as Cityports in the City-region: Spatial-economic and institutional positions and institutional learning in Randstad-Schipol (AMS), Frankfurt-Main (FRA), Tokyo Haneda (HND) and Narita (NRT). PhD thesis published by KNAG/Faculteit Geowetenschappen Universiteit Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands. Wackernagel M, Kitzes J, Moran D, Goldfinger S, Thomas M (2006). The Ecological Footprint of cities and regions: comparing resource availability with resource demand. Environment & Urbanization 18(1): 103-112. Weber KM, Kubeczko K, Kaufmann A, Grunewald B (2009) Trade-offs between impacts of future-oriented analysis: experiences from innovation policy foresight and strategy process of the City of Vienna. Technology Analysis and Strategic Management 21(8): 953-969. nd Wheeler SM and Beathley T (2009) The Sustainable Urban Development Reader. 2 edition, Routledge, London, UK. Williams K (2010) Sustainable cities: research and practice challenges. International Journal of Urban Sustainable Development 1(1-2): 128-132. 18
  • 19. 19