SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
Download to read offline
The Role of Brand in the Nonprofit Sector
     By Nathalie Kylander & Christopher Stone




          Stanford Social Innovation Review
                     Spring 2012

         Copyright  2012 by Leland Stanford Jr. University
                       All Rights Reserved




                  Stanford Social Innovation Review
              Email: info@ssireview.org, www.ssireview.org
Many nonprofits continue to use their brands primarily as a fund-
raising tool, but a growing number of nonprofits are developing a
broader and more strategic approach, managing their brands to
create greater social impact and tighter organizational cohesion.




N
By Nathalie Kylander & Christopher Stone




                      onprofit brands are visible every-    Although the ambitions of nonprofit brand managers
                      where. Amnesty International, are growing, the strategic frameworks and management
                      Habitat for Humanity, and World tools available to them have not kept up. The models
                      Wildlife Fund are some of the and terminology used in the nonprofit sector to under-
most widely recognized brands in the world, more stand brand remain those imported from the for-profit
trusted by the public than the best-known for-profit sector to boost name recognition and raise revenue.
brands.1 Large nonprofits, such as the American Can-        Nonprofit leaders need new models that allow
cer Society and the American Red Cross, have detailed their brands to contribute to sustaining their social
policies to manage the use of their names and logos, impact, serving their mission, and staying true to
and even small nonprofits frequently experiment with their organization’s values and culture. In this ar-
putting their names on coffee cups, pens, and T-shirts. ticle, we describe a conceptual framework designed
    Branding in the nonprofit sector appears to be at to help nonprofit organizations do just that. We call
an inflection point in its development. Although many this framework the Nonprofit Brand IDEA (in which
nonprofits continue to take a narrow approach to “IDEA” stands for brand integrity, brand democracy,
brand management, using it as a tool for fundraising, brand ethics, and brand affinity).
a growing number are moving beyond that approach            The framework is the result of an 18-month re-
to explore the wider, strategic roles that brands can search project we led with colleagues at Harvard
play: driving broad, long-term social goals, while University’s Hauser Center for Nonprofit Organiza-
strengthening internal identity, cohesion, and capacity. tions and collaborators at the Rockefeller Foundation.
    The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, for example, Building on previous work in the field, we conducted
recently appointed Tom Scott as director of global structured interviews with 73 nonprofit executives,
brand and innovation. Oxfam International embarked communication directors, consultants, and donors in
on a confederation-wide “global identity project.” And 41 organizations. Then we analyzed these interviews
GBCHealth was one of several organizations complet- to learn how leaders in the field are thinking about
ing a rebranding process. Brand managers in these pio- nonprofit brands today and how they see the role of
neering organizations were focusing less on revenue brands evolving.2
generation and more on social impact and organiza-          The Nonprofit Brand IDEA emerged from the
tional cohesion. Indeed, some of the most interest- distinctive sources of pride that nonprofit leaders
ing brand strategies are being developed in endowed, expressed in what they do—pride in the social mis-
private foundations with no fundraising targets at all. sion, participatory processes, shared values, and key
   “We’re catalysts,” says Scott. “Could we have greater partnerships—and from the distinctive role that they
impact if we leveraged our brand in different ways? said brand plays to create greater cohesion inside
What difference could it make to attach our logo to their organizations. We developed this framework
things to move conversations forward or elevate cer- to capture the most striking things we heard in our
tain issues? Can we use our brand to elevate other interviews, but we’ve found that it also gives nonprofit
brands?” The questions Scott asks aren’t about rais- leaders a vocabulary with which to manage in the new
ing money. Instead, they are about how to leverage brand paradigm. Before we explain the framework in
the Gates Foundation brand in the cause of greater more detail, it is important to be clear about what we
public discourse and social impact.                      mean by brand and how the use of brand is evolving.

                                                                          Spring 2012 • Stanford Social Innovation Review   37
Role of Brands                                                                             and build key partnerships. The trust that strong brands elicit also
A decade ago, the dominant brand paradigm in the nonprofit sec-                            provides organizations with the authority and credibility to deploy
tor focused on communications. Nonprofit executives believed that                          those resources more efficiently and flexibly than can organizations
increased visibility, favorable positioning in relation to competi-                        with weaker brands.
tors, and recognition among target audiences would translate into                               It should be no surprise that nonprofit executives define brand in
fundraising success. Branding was a tool for managing the external                         for-profit language. Business language is spreading in part because
perceptions of an organization, a subject for the communications,                          it is proving useful to nonprofit executives in communicating with
fundraising, and marketing departments.                                                    board members and donors whose own roots are in the for-profit
    In contrast, the emerging paradigm sees brand as having a                              world, and because many of the people managing brands in the
broader and more strategic role in an organization’s core perfor-                          nonprofit sector have themselves come from for-profit businesses.
mance, as well as having an internal role in expressing an orga-                           Indeed, we were struck to find that the majority of the nonprofit
nization’s purposes, methods, and values. Increasingly, branding                           brand managers we interviewed during our research had worked
is a matter for the entire nonprofit executive team. At every step                         first in the commercial world.
in an organization’s strategy and at each juncture in its theory of                             Even with this convergence between the nonprofit and for-profit
change, a strong brand is increasingly seen as critical in helping to                      sectors, the nonprofit brand managers we interviewed said that
build operational capacity, galvanize support, and maintain focus                          brands do play distinctive roles in the nonprofit sector. These dif-
on the social mission.                                                                     ferences relate to the role of brand in driving broad, long-term so-
    By now it should be clear that we are defining brand quite broadly.                    cial goals, the role of brand inside nonprofit organizations, and the
A brand is more than a visual identity: the name, logo, and graphic                        multiplicity of audiences that nonprofits must address. These dif-
design used by an organization. A brand is a psychological construct                       ferences may come down to questions of emphasis and focus, since
held in the minds of all those aware of the branded product, person,                       brands in the for-profit world also contribute to long-term business
organization, or movement. Brand management is the work of man-                            purposes, play internal roles, and speak to multiple audiences. Still,
aging these psychological associations. In the for-profit world, mar-                      we believe the greater weight given to these roles in the nonprofit
keting professionals talk of creating “a total brand experience.”3 In                      sector is fundamental, rooted in the fact that each nonprofit ad-
the nonprofit world, executives talk more about their “global iden-                        vances a multiplicity of value propositions, irreducible to a single
tity” and the “what and why” of their organizations. But the point                         monetary metric, most of which can be advanced only if the other
in both cases is to take branding far beyond the logo.                                     organizations in its field also succeed. 4
    When we asked leading nonprofit practitioners, management                                 “Brand becomes critical when you’re seeking to create partner-
scholars, and nonprofit brand consultants what a brand is, the re-                         ships, when you’re seeking other funders, and when you’re looking
sponses were not any different from what those in other sectors might                      to associate yourself with people in the field,” explains Diane Fusilli,
say. Some described brand as an intangible asset, and a promise that                       a global brand consultant and former communications director at
conveys who you are, what you do, and why that matters. Others felt                        the Rockefeller Foundation. “A strong brand helps bring greater
that a brand captures the persona of an organization and represents                        credibility and trust to a project quicker, and acts as a catalyst for
its very soul or essence. Yet others identified brand in terms of not                      people to want to come to the table.”
only what is projected but also what is perceived. Last, brand was
seen as a source of efficiency because it acts as a time-saving device,                    Engaging Brand Skeptics
providing a shortcut in the decision making of potential investors,                        The Nonprofit Brand IDEA is based on two themes that we discov-
customers, clients, and partners.                                                          ered during our research: the distinctive sources of pride that non-
    When we asked what a strong brand can bring to an organiza-                            profit leaders have in their organizations, and the distinctive roles
tion, the similarity across sectors was again apparent. Peter Walker,                      that brand plays inside these organizations to create cohesion and
director of the Feinstein International Center at Tufts University,                        build capacity. We turn first to the sources of pride.
speaks for many of his peers when he says, “A strong brand allows                              Interestingly enough, the way that we identified the sources of
you to acquire more resources and gives you the authority to have                          pride was by first listening to nonprofit leaders express their skepti-
more freedom over how you use them.” Strong brands in all sectors                          cism about the role of branding in the nonprofit sector. It turns out
help organizations acquire financial, human, and social resources,                         that the old brand paradigm has produced a deep current of skepti-
                                                                                           cism about branding within nonprofit organizations, making many
Nath alie Ky la nder is an adjunct lecturer in public policy at Harvard Univer-
sity’s John F. Kennedy School of Government and a research fellow at Harvard’s
                                                                                           nonprofit leaders ambivalent about both the concept of brand and
Hauser Center for Nonprofit Organizations. She is also an adjunct assistant profes-        the terminology of branding. Although some branding profession-
sor of international business at the Fletcher School at Tufts University. Kylander         als urge nonprofit leaders to push past this skepticism, we believe
has been researching nonprofit brands for more than a decade.
                                                                                           the skepticism suggests how nonprofit brands might be managed
Christopher Stone is the Daniel and Florence Guggenheim Professor of the
                                                                                           differently from their for-profit counterparts. Our interviews sur-
Practice of Criminal Justice at Harvard University’s John F. Kennedy School of
Government and the faculty director of Harvard’s Hauser Center for Nonprofit Orga-         faced at least four legitimate sources of skepticism.
nizations. Before joining Harvard he served 10 years as CEO of the Vera Institute of           First, many nonprofit leaders still widely associate branding with
Justice, a nonprofit that designs, implements, and evaluates innovations in the admin-
istration of justice in the United States and other countries. In July, Stone will leave   the commercial pursuit of monetary gain. Brand skeptics think of
Harvard and become president of George Soros’s Open Society Foundations.                   the premium prices that for-profit firms charge for brand-name

38   Stanford Social Innovation Review • Spring 2012
products and worry that this elevation of brand over substance           Brands Bring Cohesion and Capacity
will debase their work. They worry that the names of their orga-         Just as the brand skeptics led us to the four sources of pride, the
nizations will be inflated beyond what the quality of their work         brand enthusiasts we interviewed focused our attention on the
alone would support, as the pursuit of revenue becomes a goal            important role that brand plays inside nonprofits to create orga-
in its own right. They also worry that their organizations will          nizational cohesion and build capacity.
be “selling ideas the way you sell cereal,” as Mahnaz Afkhami                Many of our interviewees felt that a brand plays different roles
of the Women’s Learning Partnership for Rights, Development,             with different audiences. Internally, the brand embodies the iden-
and Peace puts it. Scholars studying nonprofit branding similarly        tity of the organization, encapsulating its mission, values, and dis-
worry about the “overcommercialization of the [nonprofit] sector         tinctive activities. Pip Emery, who co-led the most recent global
and misappropriation of techniques developed specifically for the        identity project at Amnesty International, puts it this way: “If you
commercial environment.”5                                                don’t know where you’re going and why you’re relevant, you don’t
    The second source of skepticism is that brand management             have a brand.” Externally, the brand reflects the image held in the
is sometimes seen as a top-down shortcut to avoid a participa-           minds of the organization’s multiple stakeholders, not just its donors
tory strategic planning process—an effort by top management to           and supporters but also those it seeks to influence, assist, or reach.
impose greater conformity in goals and priorities. Indeed, many              A nonprofit brand is most powerful when the organization’s in-
people we interviewed drew contrasts between rebranding efforts          ternal identity and external image are aligned with each other and
and strategic planning. Because rebranding is usually staffed dif-       with its values and mission. As brand consultant Will Novy-Hildesley
ferently and organized with less participation than strategic plan-      describes it, “Brand is an exquisite bridge between program strategy
ning, the new brand can feel peremptorily imposed from above.            and external communications.” Indeed, it is often a misalignment
These concerns can be especially great when a new leader initiates       between internal identity and external image that is the impetus
a rebranding as part of an aggressive effort to change the way an        for rebranding efforts in nonprofit organizations.
organization works.                                                          The result of alignment in mission, values, identity, and image
    Third, brand skeptics sometimes worry that a focus on branding       is a clear brand positioning and increased cohesion among diverse
is grounded in the vanity of an organization’s leadership rather than    internal constituencies. When an organization’s employees and
the needs of the organization. “I’ve seen situations in foundations      volunteers all embrace a common brand identity, it creates orga-
where the brand, the reputation, has become an end in itself, or just    nizational cohesion, concentrates focus, and reinforces shared val-
too personal to the leadership, rather than a tool for fulfilling the    ues. As Marcia Marsh, chief operating officer of the World Wildlife
mission,” says Katherine Fulton, president of the Monitor Institute.     Fund (WWF) in the United States puts it: “Our brand is the single
We also found a broader concern that branding was sometimes              greatest asset that our network has, and it’s what keeps everyone
driven by values that are antithetical to the organization. “Cam-        together.” The result of this alignment and clarity in positioning is
paigns like “save a slave” seem to exploit suffering or marginaliza-     greater trust between the nonprofit and its partners, beneficiaries,
tion to grab people’s attention,” says Afkhami. Beneath both these       participants, and donors. Because nonprofit organizations rely on
examples lies distrust of the value that is motivating what might        establishing trust with many external audiences, doing what you
be an otherwise well-intended branding effort.                           say you do and being who you say you are is crucial.
    The fourth concern skeptics have, particularly in organizations          Strong cohesion and high levels of trust contribute to greater
that work regularly in coalitions and collaborations, is that one        organizational capacity and social impact. A cohesive organization
organization’s powerful brand will overshadow weaker brands,             is able to make more efficient and focused use of existing resources,
reinforcing, rather than correcting, imbalances of power among           and high external trust attracts additional talent, financing, and
partners. When large nonprofits insist that joint activities con-        authority. This increase in organizational capacity enhances an
form to their idea of quality, brand management by the larger or-        organization’s social impact. By leveraging the trust of partners,
ganization can feel to the weaker organization like bullying, and        beneficiaries, and policymakers, an organization can make greater
these bully brands give brand management a bad reputation. As            strides toward achieving its mission. On the flip side, those orga-
Ramesh Singh, former chief executive of ActionAid and now with           nizations that face challenges in terms of internal organizational
Open Society Foundations, notes: “There’s a tension between big-         coherence, or the erosion of trust held by external constituencies
ger brands and smaller brands. The bigger international NGOs             (either because of scandals or misperceptions), struggle to build
and philanthropies can (sometimes) push their own brand more,            organizational capacity and impact.
to the detriment of other organizations that can become invisible,           The role of brand within nonprofit organizations is therefore cycli-
and it’s always resented.”                                               cal and can be captured in a model we call the Role of Brand Cycle. In
    Viewed more positively, each of these four strands of skepticism     this model, brand is nested within organizational strategy, which in
reveals a corresponding source of pride in the nonprofit sector: pride   turn is nested within the mission and values of the organization. Brand
in the mission of an organization, pride in participatory planning,      plays a variety of roles that, when performed well, link together in a
pride in the values that define organizational culture, and pride in     virtuous cycle. A well-aligned identity and image position the organi-
supportive partnerships. The Nonprofit Brand IDEA builds on these        zation to build internal cohesion and trust with external constituents.
four sources of pride, as well as on the distinctive role that brand     Organizations can leverage these to strengthen internal capacity and
plays in the nonprofit sector, to which we now turn.                     achieve impact in the world. The resulting reputation then enhances

                                                                                                           Spring 2012 • Stanford Social Innovation Review   39
the identity and image of the brand with which the cycle began. (For         images with Acumen’s tagline “Seeing a world beyond poverty.”
 a diagram of this model, see “The Role of Brand Cycle” below.)               Acumen avoids “images of poverty that … dehumanize the people
                                                                              whom we want to actually help,” she says, instead promoting im-
The Nonprofit Brand IDEA                                                      ages of “pride and dignity.”
 Having explained the distinctive sources of pride that nonprofit lead-           Brand affinity means that the brand is a good team player, work-
 ers have in their organizations, and the important role that brand           ing well alongside other brands, sharing space and credit generously,
 plays in building organizational cohesion, we turn now to explaining         and promoting collective over individual interests. An organiza-
 the Nonprofit Brand IDEA framework. The four principles of Non-              tion with strong brand affinity attracts partners and collaborators
 profit Brand IDEA are brand integrity, democracy, ethics, and affinity.      because it lends value to the partnerships without exploiting them.
     Brand integrity means that the organization’s internal identity         “We came to view ourselves not as being the leader, but as a partner
 is aligned with its external image and that both are aligned with            of choice,” explains Peter Bell, former CEO of CARE. Organizations
 the mission. We use the word integrity to mean structural integrity,         with the highest brand affinity promote the brands of their partners
 not moral integrity. Internally, a brand with high structural integ-         as much as or more than they promote their own brands, redressing
 rity connects the mission to the identity of the organization, giving        rather than exploiting the power imbalances that inevitably exist in
 members, staff, volunteers, and trustees a common sense of why the           any partnership or collaboration.
 organization does what it does and why it matters in the world. Ex-
 ternally, a brand with high structural integrity captures the mission Putting IDEA to Work
 in its public image and deploys that image in service of its mission at In the section that follows, we explore ways that nonprofit leaders
 every step of a clearly articulated strategy. Singh talks about brand can use the four principles not only to enhance their brand, but
 identity and image as “two sides of the coin,” and explains that in to improve the effectiveness of their entire organization as well.
 his experience, their alignment “allows us to focus, to be brave … to            Nowhere is the practical value of brand integrity more evident
 speak out.” At ActionAid, he says, brand integrity allowed the orga- than in the relationship of brand to an organization’s theory of change.
 nization to create relationships with people in the peasant movement At WWF, for example, part of the theory of change depends on the
“without which we wouldn’t have been able to work.”                           organization’s ability to persuade some of the biggest multinational
     Brand democracy means that the organization trusts its mem- corporations to enter into partnerships that lead the companies to
 bers, staff, participants, and volunteers to communicate their own change their business practices. WWF’s strong global brand is cru-
 understanding of the organization’s core identity. Brand democ- cial to its ability to establish these partnerships. “You’re big, we’re big,
 racy largely eliminates the need to tightly control how the brand so we understand each other,” as Emily Kelton, director of corporate
 is presented and portrayed. The appetite for brand democracy relations at WWF US, puts it. Having a strong brand establishes a
 among nonprofit leaders is largely a response                                                     kind of parity between WWF and the companies
 to the growth of social media, which has made                                                     they want to influence. By starting with a theory
 policing the brand nearly impossible. Alexis                The Role of                           of change, and looking for the contribution that
 Ettinger, head of strategy and marketing at the
 University of Oxford’s Skoll Centre for Social              Brand Cycle                           brand can make at each step, it keeps the brand
                                                                                                   tightly aligned with mission and strategy.
 Entrepreneurship, puts it bluntly, “Given the                                                          Brand democracy requires a fundamental shift
 rise of social media it would be insane to try to              SIO N AND VALU                      in the traditional approach to brand management.
 single-handedly control the brand.”                       MIS                          ES               Organizations aspiring to brand democracy
                                                                       IONAL ST
     Brand ethics means that the brand it-                      IZAT                  RA                     do not police their brands, trying to sup-
                                                             AN                          T
 self and the way it is deployed reflect                 RG       OF  BRAND CY EGY                              press unauthorized graphics or other
 the core values of the organization.                  O       LE                      CL                         representations of the organization,
                                                            RO                            E
 Just as brand integrity aligns the                                                                                 but strive instead to implement a
 brand with mission, brand ethics                                    Identity         Po                             participatory form of brand man-
                                                               n
                                                                io




 aligns both the organization’s                                                                                       agement. They provide resources,
                                                                                        sit




                                                                       Image
                                                             tat




                                                                                           ion




 internal identity and its exter-                                                                                     such as sample text and online
                                                         Repu




                                                                                              ing




 nal image with its values and                                                                                        templates, that all staff can ac-
 culture. This is about more than                                                                                     cess and adapt to communicate
 being known as an ethical orga-                           Capacity               Cohesion                            the mission, strategy, work, and
 nization, but extends to the orga-                         Impact                  Trust                            values of the organization. As part
 nization’s use of its brand in ways                                                                                of an effort to strengthen the brand
 that convey its values. We heard                                                                                 at WWF US, for example, what be-
 many stories of lapses in brand eth-                                L e v e ra g e                             gan as an internal competition among
 ics, such as using pitiful photographs of                                                                    staff to craft a single “elevator speech”
 an organization’s beneficiaries to motivate                                                              revealed the greater power of personal state-
 donors. Yasmina Zaidman, communication di-                                                          ments over uniform corporate slogans. Instead
 rector at Acumen Fund, contrasts these exploitive                                            of picking one winner, they selected three entries as

40   Stanford Social Innovation Review • Spring 2012
samples to encourage everyone to personalize the brand. “One single       with the mission, values, and strategy of the organization. They are
company line doesn’t work,” says Kerry Zobor, vice president of in-       asking about the alignment of image and identity, and they are ask-
stitutional communications at WWF US. “It just doesn’t ring true.”        ing about the contribution of brand to internal cohesion as well as
    For brand democracy to produce a consistent image, however,           to external trust. Perhaps most importantly, boards are asking about
requires strong organizational cohesion supported by a strong in-         the role of the brand in enhancing operational capacity and driving
ternal brand identity. Brand democracy is not brand anarchy. Or-          social impact. Boards looking for metrics of effectiveness of brand
ganizations need to establish parameters for a brand, even if the         management might measure increases in commitment and pride
space within these limits is large. Rachel Hayes, senior director of      among staff and directors, and those conducting qualitative evalua-
communications and community engagement at Oxfam America,                 tions might probe for signs that mission drift has been reduced and that
describes this as “creating bookends.” “These are the boundaries of       choices about which projects, resources, and partnerships to pursue
our brand. And within those boundaries, each affiliate will have the      have been easier to make. A strong brand should increase both the
ability to dial up and dial down certain messages to meet their local     speed and the breadth of consensus decisions in governing bodies.
market, but they will be unified in overall look, in overall voice, and       Brand management is especially challenging for organizations
in graphic standards so that we do convey one brand.”                     working globally. Because language and symbols vary from country
    Embracing brand democracy leads to the need to manage brand           to country, equating brand with specific words or images can be
ethics. The risk here is not brand anarchy, but rather any individual     perilous for global organizations. These organizations will find it
expression of the brand that offends or contradicts organizational        particularly important to build their brands around mission, values,
values or culture. Traditional values statements seem inadequate to       and strategy, leaving it to the local affiliates operating in particu-
this task, for the values made explicit in such statements tend to be     lar countries or cultures to represent these ideas in their own way.
at a high level of abstraction. The brand images that cause concern           An organization with a low profile and very little reputation may
for brand ethics often are themselves the catalyst for making tacitly     be willing to take great risks, but once the organization has estab-
held values explicit. For example, when one chapter of Amnesty In-        lished a trusted brand it may be hesitant to pursue projects that could
ternational developed a video game designed to engage young people        put the brand at risk. We explored this issue in our interviews and
in the movement to abolish the death penalty, others in the organiza-     were impressed at how often the inevitability of this dynamic was
tion became uncomfortable. There was nothing about the game that          rejected. Nonprofit leaders acknowledged that there can be tension
deviated from the mission, but some people thought making a game          between brand protection and the risks inherent in innovation or
out of something deadly serious violated organizational values. The       advocacy, but these are tensions that good management should be
organization’s value statements provided a starting point for serious     able to handle. Indeed, it appears that high brand integrity may, by
debate about how the game would shape Amnesty's image. The re-            strengthening internal cohesion and trust among partners, enable
sult was a robust discussion in which the chapter leaders convinced       an organization to do more, which may translate into a greater will-
others of the value of the game, so that it was retained.                 ingness to experiment, take risks, and drive innovation.
    The practical implications of a commitment to brand affinity are          Looking ahead, we expect nonprofit executives, boards, and staff
especially clear in coalitions, where multiple organizations join in a    to become increasingly confident about managing their brands in
common cause that has its own image and identity. Nonprofit leaders       distinctive and powerful ways. Just as the specification of theories
in such coalitions often worry that the collective identity will over-    of change has given nonprofit strategy a distinctive feel, brand in-
shadow their own brand, and we heard stories of coalitions—such           tegrity, democracy, ethics, and affinity can help distinguish brand
as the “Make Poverty History” campaign—that collapsed because             management in the nonprofit sector. n
of this concern. The TckTckTck campaign, in contrast, deliberately
allowed the brands of individual members to remain prominent. In          The authors are grateful to their collaborators at Harvard University’s Hauser
                                                                          Center for Nonprofit Organizations, Sherine Jayawickrama, Johanna Chao
this coalition, each organization retained its own identity and logo,     Kreilick, and Alexandra Pittman, and to Zia Khan, Melvin Galloway, and Claudia
which Christian Teriete, communications director for the Global           Juech at the Rockefeller Foundation, who shaped and supported this research.
Campaign for Climate Action, describes as a flotilla of ships with
distinct brand flags. “Everybody [has] this little additional flag on     Note s
the top mast that [has] the [coalition identity]. So, in a way, we are    1	 2011 Edelman Trust Barometer (http://www.edelman.com/trust/2011).
all different groups, but we are all united.”                             2	 In the first phase of the research, we assembled a snowball sample of 31 nonprofit ex-
                                                                             ecutives, consultants, and academics, coding those interviews and analyzing them
                                                                             using software designed for qualitative analysis. In the second phase, we conducted
Further Implications                                                         deeper examinations of selected organizations, interviewing several staff members
In addition to providing a framework for nonprofit managers and              and constituents at each.

organizational strategists to better manage their brands, the Non-        3	 See “More than Virtual: Marketing the Total Brand ‘Experience,’” June 7, 2011, at
                                                                             http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article.cfm?articleid=2791.
profit Brand IDEA may also prove useful in managing other tasks,
                                                                          4	 In 1998, a seminal work on nonprofit brands emphasized both the internal role of non-
such as board governance, global operations, and risk management.            profit brand and the “multiple publics” that nonprofit brands address. Robin Richie,
   The emerging brand paradigm suggests a new role for directors             Sanjeev Swami, and Charles Weinberg, “A Brand New World for Nonprofits,” Interna-
                                                                             tional Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing, Vol. 4, No. 1, 1998: 29-32.
and trustees of nonprofit organizations in the governance of brand.
                                                                          5	 Helen Stride, “An Investigation into the Values Dimensions of Branding: Implica-
Rather than asking how brand management is contributing to revenue,          tions for the Charity Sector,” International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector
boards (like managers) are beginning to ask how the brand is aligned         Marketing, Vol. 11, No. 2, 2006: 115-24.


                                                                                                                     Spring 2012 • Stanford Social Innovation Review   41

More Related Content

What's hot

2016_trends_report
2016_trends_report2016_trends_report
2016_trends_reportFaye Frater
 
Parntership Marketing, The New Age of Raising Money!
Parntership Marketing, The New Age of Raising Money!Parntership Marketing, The New Age of Raising Money!
Parntership Marketing, The New Age of Raising Money!Rebecca Gordon
 
Branding by design
Branding by designBranding by design
Branding by designRbk Asr
 
Brand first, branding second
Brand first, branding secondBrand first, branding second
Brand first, branding secondGordon Graham
 
Diversifying Your Leadership Profile
Diversifying Your Leadership ProfileDiversifying Your Leadership Profile
Diversifying Your Leadership ProfileSusan Manch
 
How to get the most out of your team (and keep the ones you really want for a...
How to get the most out of your team (and keep the ones you really want for a...How to get the most out of your team (and keep the ones you really want for a...
How to get the most out of your team (and keep the ones you really want for a...Leslie S. Pratch
 
Nca partnership marketing 2
Nca partnership marketing 2Nca partnership marketing 2
Nca partnership marketing 2Rebecca Gordon
 
Whatsyourbrandstory
WhatsyourbrandstoryWhatsyourbrandstory
WhatsyourbrandstoryDeb Schmidt
 
Spark change in the workplace
Spark change in the workplaceSpark change in the workplace
Spark change in the workplaceChelse Benham
 
Nonprofit Branding in the Digital Age
Nonprofit Branding in the Digital AgeNonprofit Branding in the Digital Age
Nonprofit Branding in the Digital AgeMatthew Schwartz
 
Article edited - succeeding with sponsorships
Article   edited - succeeding with sponsorshipsArticle   edited - succeeding with sponsorships
Article edited - succeeding with sponsorshipsFerris Corp
 
Reputation Management - Aligning Internal & External Communications
Reputation Management - Aligning Internal & External CommunicationsReputation Management - Aligning Internal & External Communications
Reputation Management - Aligning Internal & External CommunicationsClayton T Ford
 
NONPROFIT COMMUNICATIONS & MARKETING: The Horse & the Cart
NONPROFIT COMMUNICATIONS & MARKETING: The Horse & the CartNONPROFIT COMMUNICATIONS & MARKETING: The Horse & the Cart
NONPROFIT COMMUNICATIONS & MARKETING: The Horse & the CartTrident Communications Group
 
Leadership_Skills
Leadership_SkillsLeadership_Skills
Leadership_SkillsAhmad Ali
 
Empathy-Based Personas: Gaining a Deeper Understanding of Your Audience (Pres...
Empathy-Based Personas: Gaining a Deeper Understanding of Your Audience (Pres...Empathy-Based Personas: Gaining a Deeper Understanding of Your Audience (Pres...
Empathy-Based Personas: Gaining a Deeper Understanding of Your Audience (Pres...Esteban Gonzalez
 
What is Brand Therapy? Relationships that Engage and Delight
What is Brand Therapy? Relationships that Engage and DelightWhat is Brand Therapy? Relationships that Engage and Delight
What is Brand Therapy? Relationships that Engage and DelightEsteban Gonzalez
 
Branding for the Small Nonprofit
Branding for the Small NonprofitBranding for the Small Nonprofit
Branding for the Small NonprofitStone Soup Creative
 
Governance mechanisms for unlisted family businesses
Governance mechanisms for unlisted family businessesGovernance mechanisms for unlisted family businesses
Governance mechanisms for unlisted family businessesBrowne & Mohan
 

What's hot (20)

2016_trends_report
2016_trends_report2016_trends_report
2016_trends_report
 
Parntership Marketing, The New Age of Raising Money!
Parntership Marketing, The New Age of Raising Money!Parntership Marketing, The New Age of Raising Money!
Parntership Marketing, The New Age of Raising Money!
 
Branding by design
Branding by designBranding by design
Branding by design
 
Brand first, branding second
Brand first, branding secondBrand first, branding second
Brand first, branding second
 
Diversifying Your Leadership Profile
Diversifying Your Leadership ProfileDiversifying Your Leadership Profile
Diversifying Your Leadership Profile
 
How to get the most out of your team (and keep the ones you really want for a...
How to get the most out of your team (and keep the ones you really want for a...How to get the most out of your team (and keep the ones you really want for a...
How to get the most out of your team (and keep the ones you really want for a...
 
Nca partnership marketing 2
Nca partnership marketing 2Nca partnership marketing 2
Nca partnership marketing 2
 
Directors-to-Watch-2014
Directors-to-Watch-2014Directors-to-Watch-2014
Directors-to-Watch-2014
 
Whatsyourbrandstory
WhatsyourbrandstoryWhatsyourbrandstory
Whatsyourbrandstory
 
Spark change in the workplace
Spark change in the workplaceSpark change in the workplace
Spark change in the workplace
 
Nonprofit Branding in the Digital Age
Nonprofit Branding in the Digital AgeNonprofit Branding in the Digital Age
Nonprofit Branding in the Digital Age
 
Article edited - succeeding with sponsorships
Article   edited - succeeding with sponsorshipsArticle   edited - succeeding with sponsorships
Article edited - succeeding with sponsorships
 
Reputation Management - Aligning Internal & External Communications
Reputation Management - Aligning Internal & External CommunicationsReputation Management - Aligning Internal & External Communications
Reputation Management - Aligning Internal & External Communications
 
NONPROFIT COMMUNICATIONS & MARKETING: The Horse & the Cart
NONPROFIT COMMUNICATIONS & MARKETING: The Horse & the CartNONPROFIT COMMUNICATIONS & MARKETING: The Horse & the Cart
NONPROFIT COMMUNICATIONS & MARKETING: The Horse & the Cart
 
Achieving More for Less, Lucian Hudson: NCVO Collaborative Learning Network l...
Achieving More for Less, Lucian Hudson: NCVO Collaborative Learning Network l...Achieving More for Less, Lucian Hudson: NCVO Collaborative Learning Network l...
Achieving More for Less, Lucian Hudson: NCVO Collaborative Learning Network l...
 
Leadership_Skills
Leadership_SkillsLeadership_Skills
Leadership_Skills
 
Empathy-Based Personas: Gaining a Deeper Understanding of Your Audience (Pres...
Empathy-Based Personas: Gaining a Deeper Understanding of Your Audience (Pres...Empathy-Based Personas: Gaining a Deeper Understanding of Your Audience (Pres...
Empathy-Based Personas: Gaining a Deeper Understanding of Your Audience (Pres...
 
What is Brand Therapy? Relationships that Engage and Delight
What is Brand Therapy? Relationships that Engage and DelightWhat is Brand Therapy? Relationships that Engage and Delight
What is Brand Therapy? Relationships that Engage and Delight
 
Branding for the Small Nonprofit
Branding for the Small NonprofitBranding for the Small Nonprofit
Branding for the Small Nonprofit
 
Governance mechanisms for unlisted family businesses
Governance mechanisms for unlisted family businessesGovernance mechanisms for unlisted family businesses
Governance mechanisms for unlisted family businesses
 

Viewers also liked

Developing and building a great nonprofit brand
Developing and building a great nonprofit brandDeveloping and building a great nonprofit brand
Developing and building a great nonprofit brandGreenlights
 
Keys to a Successful Nonprofit Brand
Keys to a Successful Nonprofit BrandKeys to a Successful Nonprofit Brand
Keys to a Successful Nonprofit BrandBill Reynolds
 
Creating Brand Awareness Through Your Employees!
Creating Brand Awareness Through Your Employees!Creating Brand Awareness Through Your Employees!
Creating Brand Awareness Through Your Employees!Tamer Mahmoud
 
Grow My Business - Stephen Ryan 'Creating Brand Awareness in a Digital Age'
Grow My Business - Stephen Ryan 'Creating Brand Awareness in a Digital Age'Grow My Business - Stephen Ryan 'Creating Brand Awareness in a Digital Age'
Grow My Business - Stephen Ryan 'Creating Brand Awareness in a Digital Age'Post Media
 
Functional and emotional benefits
Functional and emotional benefitsFunctional and emotional benefits
Functional and emotional benefitsBeloved Brands Inc.
 
Brand Awarness
Brand AwarnessBrand Awarness
Brand AwarnessPIMOD
 
Top 25 Innovators 2010: A Case Study in Brand Awareness
Top 25 Innovators 2010: A Case Study in Brand AwarenessTop 25 Innovators 2010: A Case Study in Brand Awareness
Top 25 Innovators 2010: A Case Study in Brand AwarenessJon Gatrell
 
Brand Awareness
Brand AwarenessBrand Awareness
Brand AwarenessUm Abrar
 

Viewers also liked (10)

Developing and building a great nonprofit brand
Developing and building a great nonprofit brandDeveloping and building a great nonprofit brand
Developing and building a great nonprofit brand
 
Keys to a Successful Nonprofit Brand
Keys to a Successful Nonprofit BrandKeys to a Successful Nonprofit Brand
Keys to a Successful Nonprofit Brand
 
Creating Brand Awareness Through Your Employees!
Creating Brand Awareness Through Your Employees!Creating Brand Awareness Through Your Employees!
Creating Brand Awareness Through Your Employees!
 
Grow My Business - Stephen Ryan 'Creating Brand Awareness in a Digital Age'
Grow My Business - Stephen Ryan 'Creating Brand Awareness in a Digital Age'Grow My Business - Stephen Ryan 'Creating Brand Awareness in a Digital Age'
Grow My Business - Stephen Ryan 'Creating Brand Awareness in a Digital Age'
 
Functional and emotional benefits
Functional and emotional benefitsFunctional and emotional benefits
Functional and emotional benefits
 
Brand Awarness
Brand AwarnessBrand Awarness
Brand Awarness
 
Top 25 Innovators 2010: A Case Study in Brand Awareness
Top 25 Innovators 2010: A Case Study in Brand AwarenessTop 25 Innovators 2010: A Case Study in Brand Awareness
Top 25 Innovators 2010: A Case Study in Brand Awareness
 
Brand Awareness
Brand AwarenessBrand Awareness
Brand Awareness
 
12 Branding and Awareness Strategies
12 Branding and Awareness Strategies12 Branding and Awareness Strategies
12 Branding and Awareness Strategies
 
Creating a beloved brand
Creating a beloved brandCreating a beloved brand
Creating a beloved brand
 

Similar to The role of brand in the nonprofit sector - Stanford Social Innovation Review

Social as a Business Growth Engine
Social as a Business Growth EngineSocial as a Business Growth Engine
Social as a Business Growth EngineLiveWorld
 
Engaging Employees As Brand Ambassadors Via Social Media October 2011
Engaging Employees As Brand Ambassadors Via Social Media   October 2011Engaging Employees As Brand Ambassadors Via Social Media   October 2011
Engaging Employees As Brand Ambassadors Via Social Media October 2011JayaBohlmann
 
Engaging Employees as Brand Ambassadors via Social Media
Engaging Employees as Brand Ambassadors via Social MediaEngaging Employees as Brand Ambassadors via Social Media
Engaging Employees as Brand Ambassadors via Social MediaJayaBohlmann
 
Beyond the Brand: Why Business Decision Makers Buy Into Strong Cultures
Beyond the Brand: Why Business Decision Makers Buy Into Strong CulturesBeyond the Brand: Why Business Decision Makers Buy Into Strong Cultures
Beyond the Brand: Why Business Decision Makers Buy Into Strong Culturesgyro
 
The CEO Communications Audit
The CEO Communications AuditThe CEO Communications Audit
The CEO Communications AuditThe Gandalf Group
 
Spredfast 7 whiteboard sessions guide
Spredfast 7 whiteboard sessions guideSpredfast 7 whiteboard sessions guide
Spredfast 7 whiteboard sessions guideTuristicae
 
Doing Business on Purpose - Yellowwood (download version)
Doing Business on Purpose - Yellowwood (download version)Doing Business on Purpose - Yellowwood (download version)
Doing Business on Purpose - Yellowwood (download version)David Blyth
 
What type of conductor are you
What type of conductor are youWhat type of conductor are you
What type of conductor are youForum Corporation
 
Ama Symposium 2009
Ama Symposium 2009Ama Symposium 2009
Ama Symposium 2009Rex Whisman
 
People are the brand - the unity of Marketing and HR
People are the brand - the unity of Marketing and HRPeople are the brand - the unity of Marketing and HR
People are the brand - the unity of Marketing and HRFelix Wetzel
 
project on research methodology n data analysis
project on research methodology n data analysis project on research methodology n data analysis
project on research methodology n data analysis asha mishra
 
MSLGROUP Reputation Impact Indicator Study 2015 (China Edition)
MSLGROUP Reputation Impact Indicator Study 2015 (China Edition)MSLGROUP Reputation Impact Indicator Study 2015 (China Edition)
MSLGROUP Reputation Impact Indicator Study 2015 (China Edition)MSL
 
Communicopia - IIMA Core Values Presentation
Communicopia - IIMA Core Values PresentationCommunicopia - IIMA Core Values Presentation
Communicopia - IIMA Core Values PresentationMichael Lewkowitz
 
Keeping it real - How authentic is your Corporate Purpose?
 Keeping it real - How authentic is your Corporate Purpose?  Keeping it real - How authentic is your Corporate Purpose?
Keeping it real - How authentic is your Corporate Purpose? Burson-Marsteller
 

Similar to The role of brand in the nonprofit sector - Stanford Social Innovation Review (20)

Social as a Business Growth Engine
Social as a Business Growth EngineSocial as a Business Growth Engine
Social as a Business Growth Engine
 
Engaging Employees As Brand Ambassadors Via Social Media October 2011
Engaging Employees As Brand Ambassadors Via Social Media   October 2011Engaging Employees As Brand Ambassadors Via Social Media   October 2011
Engaging Employees As Brand Ambassadors Via Social Media October 2011
 
Engaging Employees as Brand Ambassadors via Social Media
Engaging Employees as Brand Ambassadors via Social MediaEngaging Employees as Brand Ambassadors via Social Media
Engaging Employees as Brand Ambassadors via Social Media
 
Beyond the Brand: Why Business Decision Makers Buy Into Strong Cultures
Beyond the Brand: Why Business Decision Makers Buy Into Strong CulturesBeyond the Brand: Why Business Decision Makers Buy Into Strong Cultures
Beyond the Brand: Why Business Decision Makers Buy Into Strong Cultures
 
The CEO Communications Audit
The CEO Communications AuditThe CEO Communications Audit
The CEO Communications Audit
 
Spredfast 7 whiteboard sessions guide
Spredfast 7 whiteboard sessions guideSpredfast 7 whiteboard sessions guide
Spredfast 7 whiteboard sessions guide
 
Doing Business on Purpose - Yellowwood (download version)
Doing Business on Purpose - Yellowwood (download version)Doing Business on Purpose - Yellowwood (download version)
Doing Business on Purpose - Yellowwood (download version)
 
What type of conductor are you
What type of conductor are youWhat type of conductor are you
What type of conductor are you
 
The role of the brand in differentiating companies in the new economy of the ...
The role of the brand in differentiating companies in the new economy of the ...The role of the brand in differentiating companies in the new economy of the ...
The role of the brand in differentiating companies in the new economy of the ...
 
Ama Symposium 2009
Ama Symposium 2009Ama Symposium 2009
Ama Symposium 2009
 
Marketing
MarketingMarketing
Marketing
 
From Corporate Brand to Company Brand: Authenticity, Transparency and Origin
From Corporate Brand to Company Brand: Authenticity, Transparency and OriginFrom Corporate Brand to Company Brand: Authenticity, Transparency and Origin
From Corporate Brand to Company Brand: Authenticity, Transparency and Origin
 
People are the brand - the unity of Marketing and HR
People are the brand - the unity of Marketing and HRPeople are the brand - the unity of Marketing and HR
People are the brand - the unity of Marketing and HR
 
project on research methodology n data analysis
project on research methodology n data analysis project on research methodology n data analysis
project on research methodology n data analysis
 
MSLGROUP Reputation Impact Indicator Study 2015 (China Edition)
MSLGROUP Reputation Impact Indicator Study 2015 (China Edition)MSLGROUP Reputation Impact Indicator Study 2015 (China Edition)
MSLGROUP Reputation Impact Indicator Study 2015 (China Edition)
 
Building A Modern Brand
Building A Modern BrandBuilding A Modern Brand
Building A Modern Brand
 
The ceo-view-2013
The ceo-view-2013The ceo-view-2013
The ceo-view-2013
 
Communicopia - IIMA Core Values Presentation
Communicopia - IIMA Core Values PresentationCommunicopia - IIMA Core Values Presentation
Communicopia - IIMA Core Values Presentation
 
Becoming a Leading Edge Brand Consultant
Becoming a Leading Edge Brand ConsultantBecoming a Leading Edge Brand Consultant
Becoming a Leading Edge Brand Consultant
 
Keeping it real - How authentic is your Corporate Purpose?
 Keeping it real - How authentic is your Corporate Purpose?  Keeping it real - How authentic is your Corporate Purpose?
Keeping it real - How authentic is your Corporate Purpose?
 

More from Marcos Eduardo Villa Corrales

Entrevista a Ms Webb - TranscripciĂłn en espaĂąol
Entrevista a Ms Webb - TranscripciĂłn en espaĂąolEntrevista a Ms Webb - TranscripciĂłn en espaĂąol
Entrevista a Ms Webb - TranscripciĂłn en espaĂąolMarcos Eduardo Villa Corrales
 
Duke TIP Program - Freedom Preparatory Academy
Duke TIP Program - Freedom Preparatory AcademyDuke TIP Program - Freedom Preparatory Academy
Duke TIP Program - Freedom Preparatory AcademyMarcos Eduardo Villa Corrales
 
Peace Players Memphis Director - Job description
Peace Players Memphis Director -  Job descriptionPeace Players Memphis Director -  Job description
Peace Players Memphis Director - Job descriptionMarcos Eduardo Villa Corrales
 
IACHR conducted visit to the United States Southern Border
IACHR conducted visit to the United States Southern BorderIACHR conducted visit to the United States Southern Border
IACHR conducted visit to the United States Southern BorderMarcos Eduardo Villa Corrales
 
MICAH - Lead Community Organizer - Job announcement
MICAH - Lead Community Organizer - Job announcementMICAH - Lead Community Organizer - Job announcement
MICAH - Lead Community Organizer - Job announcementMarcos Eduardo Villa Corrales
 
Interculturality, an approach to English Language Learners (ELL)
Interculturality, an approach to English Language Learners (ELL)Interculturality, an approach to English Language Learners (ELL)
Interculturality, an approach to English Language Learners (ELL)Marcos Eduardo Villa Corrales
 
Interculturality: How can we move from racism? - Student Tennessee Education ...
Interculturality: How can we move from racism? - Student Tennessee Education ...Interculturality: How can we move from racism? - Student Tennessee Education ...
Interculturality: How can we move from racism? - Student Tennessee Education ...Marcos Eduardo Villa Corrales
 

More from Marcos Eduardo Villa Corrales (20)

FPA April 28 meeting - Birmingham AL
FPA April 28 meeting - Birmingham ALFPA April 28 meeting - Birmingham AL
FPA April 28 meeting - Birmingham AL
 
FPA - Birmingham AL - First Meeting
FPA - Birmingham AL - First MeetingFPA - Birmingham AL - First Meeting
FPA - Birmingham AL - First Meeting
 
Freedom Prep - Info Sheet
Freedom Prep - Info SheetFreedom Prep - Info Sheet
Freedom Prep - Info Sheet
 
Freedom Prep - General Flyer Alabama
Freedom Prep - General Flyer AlabamaFreedom Prep - General Flyer Alabama
Freedom Prep - General Flyer Alabama
 
UNIDOS US - 2019 Policy Agenda
UNIDOS US - 2019 Policy AgendaUNIDOS US - 2019 Policy Agenda
UNIDOS US - 2019 Policy Agenda
 
Unheard - DACA spoken word
Unheard - DACA spoken wordUnheard - DACA spoken word
Unheard - DACA spoken word
 
Ms Webb FPA CEO/Founder Interview - SDH
Ms Webb FPA CEO/Founder Interview - SDHMs Webb FPA CEO/Founder Interview - SDH
Ms Webb FPA CEO/Founder Interview - SDH
 
Entrevista a Ms Webb - TranscripciĂłn en espaĂąol
Entrevista a Ms Webb - TranscripciĂłn en espaĂąolEntrevista a Ms Webb - TranscripciĂłn en espaĂąol
Entrevista a Ms Webb - TranscripciĂłn en espaĂąol
 
Duke TIP Program - Freedom Preparatory Academy
Duke TIP Program - Freedom Preparatory AcademyDuke TIP Program - Freedom Preparatory Academy
Duke TIP Program - Freedom Preparatory Academy
 
St. Jude Leadership Society
St. Jude Leadership SocietySt. Jude Leadership Society
St. Jude Leadership Society
 
Peace Players Memphis Director - Job description
Peace Players Memphis Director -  Job descriptionPeace Players Memphis Director -  Job description
Peace Players Memphis Director - Job description
 
2018 MICAH Public Meeting Program
2018 MICAH Public Meeting Program2018 MICAH Public Meeting Program
2018 MICAH Public Meeting Program
 
IACHR conducted visit to the United States Southern Border
IACHR conducted visit to the United States Southern BorderIACHR conducted visit to the United States Southern Border
IACHR conducted visit to the United States Southern Border
 
MICAH Public Meeting 2019 - Breaking Through
MICAH Public Meeting 2019 - Breaking ThroughMICAH Public Meeting 2019 - Breaking Through
MICAH Public Meeting 2019 - Breaking Through
 
MICAH public meeting 2019
MICAH public meeting 2019MICAH public meeting 2019
MICAH public meeting 2019
 
MICAH - Lead Community Organizer - Job announcement
MICAH - Lead Community Organizer - Job announcementMICAH - Lead Community Organizer - Job announcement
MICAH - Lead Community Organizer - Job announcement
 
Immigration Detention INC
Immigration Detention INCImmigration Detention INC
Immigration Detention INC
 
MICAH - Issue Convention
MICAH - Issue ConventionMICAH - Issue Convention
MICAH - Issue Convention
 
Interculturality, an approach to English Language Learners (ELL)
Interculturality, an approach to English Language Learners (ELL)Interculturality, an approach to English Language Learners (ELL)
Interculturality, an approach to English Language Learners (ELL)
 
Interculturality: How can we move from racism? - Student Tennessee Education ...
Interculturality: How can we move from racism? - Student Tennessee Education ...Interculturality: How can we move from racism? - Student Tennessee Education ...
Interculturality: How can we move from racism? - Student Tennessee Education ...
 

Recently uploaded

Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Neil Kimberley
 
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitProgress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitHolger Mueller
 
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...Aggregage
 
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptxB.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptxpriyanshujha201
 
Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...
Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...
Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...amitlee9823
 
Creating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature Set
Creating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature SetCreating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature Set
Creating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature SetDenis GagnĂŠ
 
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan CommunicationsPharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communicationskarancommunications
 
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptxMonthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptxAndy Lambert
 
Call Girls In Holiday Inn Express Gurugram➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genu...
Call Girls In Holiday Inn Express Gurugram➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genu...Call Girls In Holiday Inn Express Gurugram➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genu...
Call Girls In Holiday Inn Express Gurugram➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genu...lizamodels9
 
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsValue Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsP&CO
 
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSMMonte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSMRavindra Nath Shukla
 
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...Roland Driesen
 
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataRSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataExhibitors Data
 
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...Paul Menig
 
MONA 98765-12871 CALL GIRLS IN LUDHIANA LUDHIANA CALL GIRL
MONA 98765-12871 CALL GIRLS IN LUDHIANA LUDHIANA CALL GIRLMONA 98765-12871 CALL GIRLS IN LUDHIANA LUDHIANA CALL GIRL
MONA 98765-12871 CALL GIRLS IN LUDHIANA LUDHIANA CALL GIRLSeo
 
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116 - With room Service
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116  - With room ServiceCall Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116  - With room Service
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116 - With room Servicediscovermytutordmt
 
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdfGrateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdfPaul Menig
 
Understanding the Pakistan Budgeting Process: Basics and Key Insights
Understanding the Pakistan Budgeting Process: Basics and Key InsightsUnderstanding the Pakistan Budgeting Process: Basics and Key Insights
Understanding the Pakistan Budgeting Process: Basics and Key Insightsseri bangash
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
 
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst SummitProgress  Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
Progress Report - Oracle Database Analyst Summit
 
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
 
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptxB.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
 
Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...
Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...
Call Girls Jp Nagar Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bang...
 
Creating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature Set
Creating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature SetCreating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature Set
Creating Low-Code Loan Applications using the Trisotech Mortgage Feature Set
 
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan CommunicationsPharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
 
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptxMonthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
Monthly Social Media Update April 2024 pptx.pptx
 
Call Girls In Holiday Inn Express Gurugram➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genu...
Call Girls In Holiday Inn Express Gurugram➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genu...Call Girls In Holiday Inn Express Gurugram➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genu...
Call Girls In Holiday Inn Express Gurugram➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genu...
 
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsValue Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
 
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSMMonte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
Monte Carlo simulation : Simulation using MCSM
 
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
Ensure the security of your HCL environment by applying the Zero Trust princi...
 
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Pune Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataRSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
RSA Conference Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
 
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
 
MONA 98765-12871 CALL GIRLS IN LUDHIANA LUDHIANA CALL GIRL
MONA 98765-12871 CALL GIRLS IN LUDHIANA LUDHIANA CALL GIRLMONA 98765-12871 CALL GIRLS IN LUDHIANA LUDHIANA CALL GIRL
MONA 98765-12871 CALL GIRLS IN LUDHIANA LUDHIANA CALL GIRL
 
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116 - With room Service
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116  - With room ServiceCall Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116  - With room Service
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116 - With room Service
 
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdfGrateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
Grateful 7 speech thanking everyone that has helped.pdf
 
Understanding the Pakistan Budgeting Process: Basics and Key Insights
Understanding the Pakistan Budgeting Process: Basics and Key InsightsUnderstanding the Pakistan Budgeting Process: Basics and Key Insights
Understanding the Pakistan Budgeting Process: Basics and Key Insights
 
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
VVVIP Call Girls In Greater Kailash ➡️ Delhi ➡️ 9999965857 🚀 No Advance 24HRS...
 

The role of brand in the nonprofit sector - Stanford Social Innovation Review

  • 1. The Role of Brand in the Nonprofit Sector By Nathalie Kylander & Christopher Stone Stanford Social Innovation Review Spring 2012 Copyright  2012 by Leland Stanford Jr. University All Rights Reserved Stanford Social Innovation Review Email: info@ssireview.org, www.ssireview.org
  • 2.
  • 3. Many nonprofits continue to use their brands primarily as a fund- raising tool, but a growing number of nonprofits are developing a broader and more strategic approach, managing their brands to create greater social impact and tighter organizational cohesion. N By Nathalie Kylander & Christopher Stone onprofit brands are visible every- Although the ambitions of nonprofit brand managers where. Amnesty International, are growing, the strategic frameworks and management Habitat for Humanity, and World tools available to them have not kept up. The models Wildlife Fund are some of the and terminology used in the nonprofit sector to under- most widely recognized brands in the world, more stand brand remain those imported from the for-profit trusted by the public than the best-known for-profit sector to boost name recognition and raise revenue. brands.1 Large nonprofits, such as the American Can- Nonprofit leaders need new models that allow cer Society and the American Red Cross, have detailed their brands to contribute to sustaining their social policies to manage the use of their names and logos, impact, serving their mission, and staying true to and even small nonprofits frequently experiment with their organization’s values and culture. In this ar- putting their names on coffee cups, pens, and T-shirts. ticle, we describe a conceptual framework designed Branding in the nonprofit sector appears to be at to help nonprofit organizations do just that. We call an inflection point in its development. Although many this framework the Nonprofit Brand IDEA (in which nonprofits continue to take a narrow approach to “IDEA” stands for brand integrity, brand democracy, brand management, using it as a tool for fundraising, brand ethics, and brand affinity). a growing number are moving beyond that approach The framework is the result of an 18-month re- to explore the wider, strategic roles that brands can search project we led with colleagues at Harvard play: driving broad, long-term social goals, while University’s Hauser Center for Nonprofit Organiza- strengthening internal identity, cohesion, and capacity. tions and collaborators at the Rockefeller Foundation. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, for example, Building on previous work in the field, we conducted recently appointed Tom Scott as director of global structured interviews with 73 nonprofit executives, brand and innovation. Oxfam International embarked communication directors, consultants, and donors in on a confederation-wide “global identity project.” And 41 organizations. Then we analyzed these interviews GBCHealth was one of several organizations complet- to learn how leaders in the field are thinking about ing a rebranding process. Brand managers in these pio- nonprofit brands today and how they see the role of neering organizations were focusing less on revenue brands evolving.2 generation and more on social impact and organiza- The Nonprofit Brand IDEA emerged from the tional cohesion. Indeed, some of the most interest- distinctive sources of pride that nonprofit leaders ing brand strategies are being developed in endowed, expressed in what they do—pride in the social mis- private foundations with no fundraising targets at all. sion, participatory processes, shared values, and key “We’re catalysts,” says Scott. “Could we have greater partnerships—and from the distinctive role that they impact if we leveraged our brand in different ways? said brand plays to create greater cohesion inside What difference could it make to attach our logo to their organizations. We developed this framework things to move conversations forward or elevate cer- to capture the most striking things we heard in our tain issues? Can we use our brand to elevate other interviews, but we’ve found that it also gives nonprofit brands?” The questions Scott asks aren’t about rais- leaders a vocabulary with which to manage in the new ing money. Instead, they are about how to leverage brand paradigm. Before we explain the framework in the Gates Foundation brand in the cause of greater more detail, it is important to be clear about what we public discourse and social impact. mean by brand and how the use of brand is evolving. Spring 2012 • Stanford Social Innovation Review 37
  • 4. Role of Brands and build key partnerships. The trust that strong brands elicit also A decade ago, the dominant brand paradigm in the nonprofit sec- provides organizations with the authority and credibility to deploy tor focused on communications. Nonprofit executives believed that those resources more efficiently and flexibly than can organizations increased visibility, favorable positioning in relation to competi- with weaker brands. tors, and recognition among target audiences would translate into It should be no surprise that nonprofit executives define brand in fundraising success. Branding was a tool for managing the external for-profit language. Business language is spreading in part because perceptions of an organization, a subject for the communications, it is proving useful to nonprofit executives in communicating with fundraising, and marketing departments. board members and donors whose own roots are in the for-profit In contrast, the emerging paradigm sees brand as having a world, and because many of the people managing brands in the broader and more strategic role in an organization’s core perfor- nonprofit sector have themselves come from for-profit businesses. mance, as well as having an internal role in expressing an orga- Indeed, we were struck to find that the majority of the nonprofit nization’s purposes, methods, and values. Increasingly, branding brand managers we interviewed during our research had worked is a matter for the entire nonprofit executive team. At every step first in the commercial world. in an organization’s strategy and at each juncture in its theory of Even with this convergence between the nonprofit and for-profit change, a strong brand is increasingly seen as critical in helping to sectors, the nonprofit brand managers we interviewed said that build operational capacity, galvanize support, and maintain focus brands do play distinctive roles in the nonprofit sector. These dif- on the social mission. ferences relate to the role of brand in driving broad, long-term so- By now it should be clear that we are defining brand quite broadly. cial goals, the role of brand inside nonprofit organizations, and the A brand is more than a visual identity: the name, logo, and graphic multiplicity of audiences that nonprofits must address. These dif- design used by an organization. A brand is a psychological construct ferences may come down to questions of emphasis and focus, since held in the minds of all those aware of the branded product, person, brands in the for-profit world also contribute to long-term business organization, or movement. Brand management is the work of man- purposes, play internal roles, and speak to multiple audiences. Still, aging these psychological associations. In the for-profit world, mar- we believe the greater weight given to these roles in the nonprofit keting professionals talk of creating “a total brand experience.”3 In sector is fundamental, rooted in the fact that each nonprofit ad- the nonprofit world, executives talk more about their “global iden- vances a multiplicity of value propositions, irreducible to a single tity” and the “what and why” of their organizations. But the point monetary metric, most of which can be advanced only if the other in both cases is to take branding far beyond the logo. organizations in its field also succeed. 4 When we asked leading nonprofit practitioners, management “Brand becomes critical when you’re seeking to create partner- scholars, and nonprofit brand consultants what a brand is, the re- ships, when you’re seeking other funders, and when you’re looking sponses were not any different from what those in other sectors might to associate yourself with people in the field,” explains Diane Fusilli, say. Some described brand as an intangible asset, and a promise that a global brand consultant and former communications director at conveys who you are, what you do, and why that matters. Others felt the Rockefeller Foundation. “A strong brand helps bring greater that a brand captures the persona of an organization and represents credibility and trust to a project quicker, and acts as a catalyst for its very soul or essence. Yet others identified brand in terms of not people to want to come to the table.” only what is projected but also what is perceived. Last, brand was seen as a source of efficiency because it acts as a time-saving device, Engaging Brand Skeptics providing a shortcut in the decision making of potential investors, The Nonprofit Brand IDEA is based on two themes that we discov- customers, clients, and partners. ered during our research: the distinctive sources of pride that non- When we asked what a strong brand can bring to an organiza- profit leaders have in their organizations, and the distinctive roles tion, the similarity across sectors was again apparent. Peter Walker, that brand plays inside these organizations to create cohesion and director of the Feinstein International Center at Tufts University, build capacity. We turn first to the sources of pride. speaks for many of his peers when he says, “A strong brand allows Interestingly enough, the way that we identified the sources of you to acquire more resources and gives you the authority to have pride was by first listening to nonprofit leaders express their skepti- more freedom over how you use them.” Strong brands in all sectors cism about the role of branding in the nonprofit sector. It turns out help organizations acquire financial, human, and social resources, that the old brand paradigm has produced a deep current of skepti- cism about branding within nonprofit organizations, making many Nath alie Ky la nder is an adjunct lecturer in public policy at Harvard Univer- sity’s John F. Kennedy School of Government and a research fellow at Harvard’s nonprofit leaders ambivalent about both the concept of brand and Hauser Center for Nonprofit Organizations. She is also an adjunct assistant profes- the terminology of branding. Although some branding profession- sor of international business at the Fletcher School at Tufts University. Kylander als urge nonprofit leaders to push past this skepticism, we believe has been researching nonprofit brands for more than a decade. the skepticism suggests how nonprofit brands might be managed Christopher Stone is the Daniel and Florence Guggenheim Professor of the differently from their for-profit counterparts. Our interviews sur- Practice of Criminal Justice at Harvard University’s John F. Kennedy School of Government and the faculty director of Harvard’s Hauser Center for Nonprofit Orga- faced at least four legitimate sources of skepticism. nizations. Before joining Harvard he served 10 years as CEO of the Vera Institute of First, many nonprofit leaders still widely associate branding with Justice, a nonprofit that designs, implements, and evaluates innovations in the admin- istration of justice in the United States and other countries. In July, Stone will leave the commercial pursuit of monetary gain. Brand skeptics think of Harvard and become president of George Soros’s Open Society Foundations. the premium prices that for-profit firms charge for brand-name 38 Stanford Social Innovation Review • Spring 2012
  • 5. products and worry that this elevation of brand over substance Brands Bring Cohesion and Capacity will debase their work. They worry that the names of their orga- Just as the brand skeptics led us to the four sources of pride, the nizations will be inflated beyond what the quality of their work brand enthusiasts we interviewed focused our attention on the alone would support, as the pursuit of revenue becomes a goal important role that brand plays inside nonprofits to create orga- in its own right. They also worry that their organizations will nizational cohesion and build capacity. be “selling ideas the way you sell cereal,” as Mahnaz Afkhami Many of our interviewees felt that a brand plays different roles of the Women’s Learning Partnership for Rights, Development, with different audiences. Internally, the brand embodies the iden- and Peace puts it. Scholars studying nonprofit branding similarly tity of the organization, encapsulating its mission, values, and dis- worry about the “overcommercialization of the [nonprofit] sector tinctive activities. Pip Emery, who co-led the most recent global and misappropriation of techniques developed specifically for the identity project at Amnesty International, puts it this way: “If you commercial environment.”5 don’t know where you’re going and why you’re relevant, you don’t The second source of skepticism is that brand management have a brand.” Externally, the brand reflects the image held in the is sometimes seen as a top-down shortcut to avoid a participa- minds of the organization’s multiple stakeholders, not just its donors tory strategic planning process—an effort by top management to and supporters but also those it seeks to influence, assist, or reach. impose greater conformity in goals and priorities. Indeed, many A nonprofit brand is most powerful when the organization’s in- people we interviewed drew contrasts between rebranding efforts ternal identity and external image are aligned with each other and and strategic planning. Because rebranding is usually staffed dif- with its values and mission. As brand consultant Will Novy-Hildesley ferently and organized with less participation than strategic plan- describes it, “Brand is an exquisite bridge between program strategy ning, the new brand can feel peremptorily imposed from above. and external communications.” Indeed, it is often a misalignment These concerns can be especially great when a new leader initiates between internal identity and external image that is the impetus a rebranding as part of an aggressive effort to change the way an for rebranding efforts in nonprofit organizations. organization works. The result of alignment in mission, values, identity, and image Third, brand skeptics sometimes worry that a focus on branding is a clear brand positioning and increased cohesion among diverse is grounded in the vanity of an organization’s leadership rather than internal constituencies. When an organization’s employees and the needs of the organization. “I’ve seen situations in foundations volunteers all embrace a common brand identity, it creates orga- where the brand, the reputation, has become an end in itself, or just nizational cohesion, concentrates focus, and reinforces shared val- too personal to the leadership, rather than a tool for fulfilling the ues. As Marcia Marsh, chief operating officer of the World Wildlife mission,” says Katherine Fulton, president of the Monitor Institute. Fund (WWF) in the United States puts it: “Our brand is the single We also found a broader concern that branding was sometimes greatest asset that our network has, and it’s what keeps everyone driven by values that are antithetical to the organization. “Cam- together.” The result of this alignment and clarity in positioning is paigns like “save a slave” seem to exploit suffering or marginaliza- greater trust between the nonprofit and its partners, beneficiaries, tion to grab people’s attention,” says Afkhami. Beneath both these participants, and donors. Because nonprofit organizations rely on examples lies distrust of the value that is motivating what might establishing trust with many external audiences, doing what you be an otherwise well-intended branding effort. say you do and being who you say you are is crucial. The fourth concern skeptics have, particularly in organizations Strong cohesion and high levels of trust contribute to greater that work regularly in coalitions and collaborations, is that one organizational capacity and social impact. A cohesive organization organization’s powerful brand will overshadow weaker brands, is able to make more efficient and focused use of existing resources, reinforcing, rather than correcting, imbalances of power among and high external trust attracts additional talent, financing, and partners. When large nonprofits insist that joint activities con- authority. This increase in organizational capacity enhances an form to their idea of quality, brand management by the larger or- organization’s social impact. By leveraging the trust of partners, ganization can feel to the weaker organization like bullying, and beneficiaries, and policymakers, an organization can make greater these bully brands give brand management a bad reputation. As strides toward achieving its mission. On the flip side, those orga- Ramesh Singh, former chief executive of ActionAid and now with nizations that face challenges in terms of internal organizational Open Society Foundations, notes: “There’s a tension between big- coherence, or the erosion of trust held by external constituencies ger brands and smaller brands. The bigger international NGOs (either because of scandals or misperceptions), struggle to build and philanthropies can (sometimes) push their own brand more, organizational capacity and impact. to the detriment of other organizations that can become invisible, The role of brand within nonprofit organizations is therefore cycli- and it’s always resented.” cal and can be captured in a model we call the Role of Brand Cycle. In Viewed more positively, each of these four strands of skepticism this model, brand is nested within organizational strategy, which in reveals a corresponding source of pride in the nonprofit sector: pride turn is nested within the mission and values of the organization. Brand in the mission of an organization, pride in participatory planning, plays a variety of roles that, when performed well, link together in a pride in the values that define organizational culture, and pride in virtuous cycle. A well-aligned identity and image position the organi- supportive partnerships. The Nonprofit Brand IDEA builds on these zation to build internal cohesion and trust with external constituents. four sources of pride, as well as on the distinctive role that brand Organizations can leverage these to strengthen internal capacity and plays in the nonprofit sector, to which we now turn. achieve impact in the world. The resulting reputation then enhances Spring 2012 • Stanford Social Innovation Review 39
  • 6. the identity and image of the brand with which the cycle began. (For images with Acumen’s tagline “Seeing a world beyond poverty.” a diagram of this model, see “The Role of Brand Cycle” below.) Acumen avoids “images of poverty that … dehumanize the people whom we want to actually help,” she says, instead promoting im- The Nonprofit Brand IDEA ages of “pride and dignity.” Having explained the distinctive sources of pride that nonprofit lead- Brand affinity means that the brand is a good team player, work- ers have in their organizations, and the important role that brand ing well alongside other brands, sharing space and credit generously, plays in building organizational cohesion, we turn now to explaining and promoting collective over individual interests. An organiza- the Nonprofit Brand IDEA framework. The four principles of Non- tion with strong brand affinity attracts partners and collaborators profit Brand IDEA are brand integrity, democracy, ethics, and affinity. because it lends value to the partnerships without exploiting them. Brand integrity means that the organization’s internal identity “We came to view ourselves not as being the leader, but as a partner is aligned with its external image and that both are aligned with of choice,” explains Peter Bell, former CEO of CARE. Organizations the mission. We use the word integrity to mean structural integrity, with the highest brand affinity promote the brands of their partners not moral integrity. Internally, a brand with high structural integ- as much as or more than they promote their own brands, redressing rity connects the mission to the identity of the organization, giving rather than exploiting the power imbalances that inevitably exist in members, staff, volunteers, and trustees a common sense of why the any partnership or collaboration. organization does what it does and why it matters in the world. Ex- ternally, a brand with high structural integrity captures the mission Putting IDEA to Work in its public image and deploys that image in service of its mission at In the section that follows, we explore ways that nonprofit leaders every step of a clearly articulated strategy. Singh talks about brand can use the four principles not only to enhance their brand, but identity and image as “two sides of the coin,” and explains that in to improve the effectiveness of their entire organization as well. his experience, their alignment “allows us to focus, to be brave … to Nowhere is the practical value of brand integrity more evident speak out.” At ActionAid, he says, brand integrity allowed the orga- than in the relationship of brand to an organization’s theory of change. nization to create relationships with people in the peasant movement At WWF, for example, part of the theory of change depends on the “without which we wouldn’t have been able to work.” organization’s ability to persuade some of the biggest multinational Brand democracy means that the organization trusts its mem- corporations to enter into partnerships that lead the companies to bers, staff, participants, and volunteers to communicate their own change their business practices. WWF’s strong global brand is cru- understanding of the organization’s core identity. Brand democ- cial to its ability to establish these partnerships. “You’re big, we’re big, racy largely eliminates the need to tightly control how the brand so we understand each other,” as Emily Kelton, director of corporate is presented and portrayed. The appetite for brand democracy relations at WWF US, puts it. Having a strong brand establishes a among nonprofit leaders is largely a response kind of parity between WWF and the companies to the growth of social media, which has made they want to influence. By starting with a theory policing the brand nearly impossible. Alexis The Role of of change, and looking for the contribution that Ettinger, head of strategy and marketing at the University of Oxford’s Skoll Centre for Social Brand Cycle brand can make at each step, it keeps the brand tightly aligned with mission and strategy. Entrepreneurship, puts it bluntly, “Given the Brand democracy requires a fundamental shift rise of social media it would be insane to try to SIO N AND VALU in the traditional approach to brand management. single-handedly control the brand.” MIS ES Organizations aspiring to brand democracy IONAL ST Brand ethics means that the brand it- IZAT RA do not police their brands, trying to sup- AN T self and the way it is deployed reflect RG OF BRAND CY EGY press unauthorized graphics or other the core values of the organization. O LE CL representations of the organization, RO E Just as brand integrity aligns the but strive instead to implement a brand with mission, brand ethics Identity Po participatory form of brand man- n io aligns both the organization’s agement. They provide resources, sit Image tat ion internal identity and its exter- such as sample text and online Repu ing nal image with its values and templates, that all staff can ac- culture. This is about more than cess and adapt to communicate being known as an ethical orga- Capacity Cohesion the mission, strategy, work, and nization, but extends to the orga- Impact Trust values of the organization. As part nization’s use of its brand in ways of an effort to strengthen the brand that convey its values. We heard at WWF US, for example, what be- many stories of lapses in brand eth- L e v e ra g e gan as an internal competition among ics, such as using pitiful photographs of staff to craft a single “elevator speech” an organization’s beneficiaries to motivate revealed the greater power of personal state- donors. Yasmina Zaidman, communication di- ments over uniform corporate slogans. Instead rector at Acumen Fund, contrasts these exploitive of picking one winner, they selected three entries as 40 Stanford Social Innovation Review • Spring 2012
  • 7. samples to encourage everyone to personalize the brand. “One single with the mission, values, and strategy of the organization. They are company line doesn’t work,” says Kerry Zobor, vice president of in- asking about the alignment of image and identity, and they are ask- stitutional communications at WWF US. “It just doesn’t ring true.” ing about the contribution of brand to internal cohesion as well as For brand democracy to produce a consistent image, however, to external trust. Perhaps most importantly, boards are asking about requires strong organizational cohesion supported by a strong in- the role of the brand in enhancing operational capacity and driving ternal brand identity. Brand democracy is not brand anarchy. Or- social impact. Boards looking for metrics of effectiveness of brand ganizations need to establish parameters for a brand, even if the management might measure increases in commitment and pride space within these limits is large. Rachel Hayes, senior director of among staff and directors, and those conducting qualitative evalua- communications and community engagement at Oxfam America, tions might probe for signs that mission drift has been reduced and that describes this as “creating bookends.” “These are the boundaries of choices about which projects, resources, and partnerships to pursue our brand. And within those boundaries, each affiliate will have the have been easier to make. A strong brand should increase both the ability to dial up and dial down certain messages to meet their local speed and the breadth of consensus decisions in governing bodies. market, but they will be unified in overall look, in overall voice, and Brand management is especially challenging for organizations in graphic standards so that we do convey one brand.” working globally. Because language and symbols vary from country Embracing brand democracy leads to the need to manage brand to country, equating brand with specific words or images can be ethics. The risk here is not brand anarchy, but rather any individual perilous for global organizations. These organizations will find it expression of the brand that offends or contradicts organizational particularly important to build their brands around mission, values, values or culture. Traditional values statements seem inadequate to and strategy, leaving it to the local affiliates operating in particu- this task, for the values made explicit in such statements tend to be lar countries or cultures to represent these ideas in their own way. at a high level of abstraction. The brand images that cause concern An organization with a low profile and very little reputation may for brand ethics often are themselves the catalyst for making tacitly be willing to take great risks, but once the organization has estab- held values explicit. For example, when one chapter of Amnesty In- lished a trusted brand it may be hesitant to pursue projects that could ternational developed a video game designed to engage young people put the brand at risk. We explored this issue in our interviews and in the movement to abolish the death penalty, others in the organiza- were impressed at how often the inevitability of this dynamic was tion became uncomfortable. There was nothing about the game that rejected. Nonprofit leaders acknowledged that there can be tension deviated from the mission, but some people thought making a game between brand protection and the risks inherent in innovation or out of something deadly serious violated organizational values. The advocacy, but these are tensions that good management should be organization’s value statements provided a starting point for serious able to handle. Indeed, it appears that high brand integrity may, by debate about how the game would shape Amnesty's image. The re- strengthening internal cohesion and trust among partners, enable sult was a robust discussion in which the chapter leaders convinced an organization to do more, which may translate into a greater will- others of the value of the game, so that it was retained. ingness to experiment, take risks, and drive innovation. The practical implications of a commitment to brand affinity are Looking ahead, we expect nonprofit executives, boards, and staff especially clear in coalitions, where multiple organizations join in a to become increasingly confident about managing their brands in common cause that has its own image and identity. Nonprofit leaders distinctive and powerful ways. Just as the specification of theories in such coalitions often worry that the collective identity will over- of change has given nonprofit strategy a distinctive feel, brand in- shadow their own brand, and we heard stories of coalitions—such tegrity, democracy, ethics, and affinity can help distinguish brand as the “Make Poverty History” campaign—that collapsed because management in the nonprofit sector. n of this concern. The TckTckTck campaign, in contrast, deliberately allowed the brands of individual members to remain prominent. In The authors are grateful to their collaborators at Harvard University’s Hauser Center for Nonprofit Organizations, Sherine Jayawickrama, Johanna Chao this coalition, each organization retained its own identity and logo, Kreilick, and Alexandra Pittman, and to Zia Khan, Melvin Galloway, and Claudia which Christian Teriete, communications director for the Global Juech at the Rockefeller Foundation, who shaped and supported this research. Campaign for Climate Action, describes as a flotilla of ships with distinct brand flags. “Everybody [has] this little additional flag on Note s the top mast that [has] the [coalition identity]. So, in a way, we are 1 2011 Edelman Trust Barometer (http://www.edelman.com/trust/2011). all different groups, but we are all united.” 2 In the first phase of the research, we assembled a snowball sample of 31 nonprofit ex- ecutives, consultants, and academics, coding those interviews and analyzing them using software designed for qualitative analysis. In the second phase, we conducted Further Implications deeper examinations of selected organizations, interviewing several staff members In addition to providing a framework for nonprofit managers and and constituents at each. organizational strategists to better manage their brands, the Non- 3 See “More than Virtual: Marketing the Total Brand ‘Experience,’” June 7, 2011, at http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article.cfm?articleid=2791. profit Brand IDEA may also prove useful in managing other tasks, 4 In 1998, a seminal work on nonprofit brands emphasized both the internal role of non- such as board governance, global operations, and risk management. profit brand and the “multiple publics” that nonprofit brands address. Robin Richie, The emerging brand paradigm suggests a new role for directors Sanjeev Swami, and Charles Weinberg, “A Brand New World for Nonprofits,” Interna- tional Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing, Vol. 4, No. 1, 1998: 29-32. and trustees of nonprofit organizations in the governance of brand. 5 Helen Stride, “An Investigation into the Values Dimensions of Branding: Implica- Rather than asking how brand management is contributing to revenue, tions for the Charity Sector,” International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector boards (like managers) are beginning to ask how the brand is aligned Marketing, Vol. 11, No. 2, 2006: 115-24. Spring 2012 • Stanford Social Innovation Review 41