How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
Enterprise Apps, BI & KM Trends 2009
1. Enterprise Applications,
Information & Knowledge
Management 2009
Your Text here Your Text here
Einat Shimoni
EVP & Senior Analyst
Enterprise Applications,
Analytics & KM Strategies
www.einatstki.blogspot.com
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 1
2. Agenda
1 Enterprise Applications general trends
2 Enterprise Applications (CRM, ERP, SCM)
3 Knowledge Management
4 Business Intelligence & MDM
5 BPM
6 Enterprise Portals & External websites
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 2
3. General
IT in Aggressive Cost-Cutting Time Trends
New
IT budget Less budget for models:
decrease new apps
SaaS, OSS
Decrease app 3rd party
Need to cut IT ERP tools?
maint. Self-
costs
service projects E-Service here
Your Text here Your Text
Social &
Interaction with
consumer Social CRM,
employees &
technologies KM 2.0
customers
impact
Innovation, re- BPM, Web 2.0,
Need to help
think processes, Innovation,
increase connect with Social CRM,
revenues customers CEM, BI
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 3
4. General
Application projects in recession Trends
• Zero based budgeting – every project is
examined in payback, maturity, and risk
• Low risk projects
• Small scale projects (< 1 year)
• Proven payback within ½ - 1 year
Problem: sometimes the less mature markets
(MDM, BPM) are the ones that can provide
greater business benefits
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 4
5. General
Questions for every IT project Trends
• What are the business benefits and when is
the payback?
• What is the risk?
Is it mature?
Is it well supported in Israel?
How many ISVs with in depth knowledge?
Are other organizations happy with it?
References!
• What is the TCO?
• Is the application user friendly?
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 5
6. Your Text here Your Text here
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 6
7. Technologies Maturity Model 2009 General
Trends
Business Value
Investment Active BPM
BI Web
to make money 2.0
Collab.
CRM Balanced Data IT+business
Cut costs, Increase Oper. Scorecard Governance, Project
CRM ERP 2 MDM
productivity Financial Ent. Pure
Tactic BI Search Business
BI
Project
ECM
Gateway
Commodity IT portal ERP1
Services Size of figure =
complexity/
cost of project
Financial
Investment sector
Non-
Finance
for regulations reg. sectors
reg.
Using Implementing Looking
Market Maturity
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 7
8. General
IT Services Families Trends
Reduce Expenses Increase Revenues
Increase Increase Increase
Improve Increase
process process governance,
Cut costs customer business
efficiency Intelligence regulation &
Experience agility
risk mng.
Green IT Active BI Regulation
Social CRM BSC
compliance
DC Tech: virtualization CXO
BPM Analytical
etc. BPM/BPA management
CRM
tools
Supply chain Customer
Employee Productivity Innovation IT
intelligence Experience
support tools Governance
Management
IT Sourcing models Marketing
focus
IT portfolio
management
B2B
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 8
9. General
Major trend in enterprise applications Trends
SaaS (Software as a Service):
A software delivery model, delivered via the web, in which users
can consume functionality based on subscription pricing.
SaaS is typically a multi-tenant, one-to-many architecture (one
code base for all), this provides it with economy of scale
The software is hosted remotely, eliminating the need for
users to invest in related hardware or handle the installation, set-
up and daily upkeep & maintenance.
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 9
10. Your Text here Your Text here
Did SaaS make its debut
in Israel?
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 10
11. General
SaaS in Israel Trends
Most Israeli orgs aren’t yet using SAAS
Major adopters: technology, high tech, global companies
Major objectors: Financial orgs and govt.
SaaS projects’ characteristics in Israel:
• Short micro-projects (~3 man months)
• Average of 40 users per installation
• Usually DOES include some sort of integration to
1-2 inhouse applications
• High satisfaction level (worldwide data: 94%)
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 11
12. General
SaaS major setbacks in Israel Trends
• 357 regulation doesn’t allow keeping “linked”
data outside for financial organizations
• Need for local point of contact
• Need for SLA and local support
• Hebrew
• Israeli vendors need to reorganize operations
around this model
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 12
13. General
Characteristics of common SaaS Trends
• Applications that have a “network effect”
Travel management
Social software
• Niche/Point-solutions
• Solutions that are easily separated from others
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 13
14. Application models General
Trends
Self
development
Your Text here Your Text here
Package
Internal External
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 14
15. Where are we now General
Trends
and what’s the next stage?
ASP SaaS PaaS
• Single separate instance • Vendor controls application • Outcome of using PaaS
• Could have shared or • User has No access to core •Platform-Centric
dedicated infrastructure components of the solution • User controls the app.
• … ASP wasn’t a bad idea, • Multitenant, one-to-many • Fully-customized software
it had BAD timing • Semi-customized (view) • Will be more suitable for
• More suitable for generic “heavy” business processes
“lightweight” processes or
consumers
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 15
16. General
Mashup Definition Trends
• Mashup: a “web 2.0” term :
combining data layers from more than one
source into a single integrated interactive
application
http://blogs.zdnet.com/Hinchcliffe/?p=78
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 16
17. General
New Applications = Services Mashups Trends
An application mashup
should define its needed
infrastructure services
Gateway
(=ensemble)
T7 T8 T2
T6 T7 T8
T1 T3 T1 T5
T4 T2 T3 T4
T5 T6
Applications Infrastructure
Services Services
The goal: Puzzle Builder
Optimization of
IT resources!
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 17
18. Cloud enables creation of General
Trends
new business models
• Cloud can enable new Business mashups?
business models*
• By consuming “missing
elements” from the cloud
you can create a whole
new product
• Examples: virtual
network operator
* Source: STKI brain storming session
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 18
19. General
Open Source Software Trends
• Open Source applications used by 65% of
global enterprises
• Most Israeli organizations don’t consider using
OSS in almost any project
• The economic pressure will push Israeli orgs
to consider this model in specific areas:
WCM
Internal IT tools
Collaboration and Web 2.0 tools
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 19
20. There are some major benefits to General
Trends
open source software
Main reasons:
Cost Text here
Your Your Text here
Vendor independence
Sometimes –
Better functionality
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 20
21. General
Open Source pricing appeal Trends
Price of a WCM project based on open
source CAN BE 15-20% cheaper
But will not always be the best choice
Source: Water & Stone
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 21
22. Major Benefits for adopting General
Trends
Open Source Software
Which of the following does your company see as the
major benefits of adopting OSS ?
Source: Open IT, Annual Open Source Survey for 2008, September 29, 2008
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 22
23. What should you do to make Open Source General
Software relevant to your organization? Trends
• Most important: assure available local
professional knowledge with the package:
Specialized Israeli ISVs or in-house
• There should be no compromises on SLA
• Understand the model and legal terms
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 23
24. CRM
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 24
25. CRM
Trends
CRM will be less about transactions
And more about interactions
Think of it as a way of improving customer
experience by managing “conversations”
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 25
26. CRM
Trends
Better customer experience
= better product
Your Text here Your Text here
CRM and CEM can provide a real competitive differentiator
Upcoming STKI Round Table on
CRM: June 17, 2009
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 26
27. CRM
CRM: from the outside looking in Trends
Focus on external clients needs
Your Text here Your Text here
Focus on internal processes
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 27
28. CRM
Multi Channel CRM Trends
• Mobile service • e-billing •More self • newsletters • EPSS/guided
• e-banking • e-service service options • email marketing interactions
• SMS • e-payments and transactions • email response • RTD
• Live chat management • CC
• Collaboration
Proliferation of customer touch points
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 28
29. CRM
Israeli CRM Trends 2009 Trends
• “XRM” – using CRM as a development
platform for various needs
This is an important criteria when choosing CRM
• “Quick win, quick ROI” approach continues
• Reducing contact center costs (self service)
• Analytical CRM continues to be top priority
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 29
30. CRM
Source: STKI CIO Survey 2009 Trends
CRM Priorities2009
40%
35%
35%
30%
25%
20%
18% 20%
14% 15%
8% 10%
5%
0%
Campaign Ecommerce CRM Self-Service Analytical
Management Systems Packages CRM
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 30
31. CRM
Worldwide CRM Trends 2009 Trends
• Think outside of the “CRM” box:
Web virtual agents
Home based CC
Customer centric innovation
• SaaS will rise significantly
• Engagement with the customer – Social marketing
• Managing the customer experience
• Social CRM – clients & employees more “social”
• Self Service is king (but don’t compromise with
the customer experience, i.e poor IVRs)
• Customer data still a problem
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 31
32. Communication with customers CRM
Trends
spurs customer centric innovation
What features should
What do you like about our new product?
product X include?
What don’t you like about
our new product? What do you like about
our company?
Your Text here Your Text here
Do you have ideas
how we can
How do you prefer enhance our
to interact with us? products?
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 32
33. CRM
Trends
Interact with the customers &
Learn more about what they want
Define new customized products
Your Text here Your Text here
IT needs infrastructures to
support diversity of products &
interactions
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 33
34. We will present data on products and integrators: Explanations
on Slides
List of Packages and Integrators
Rep in
Package Integrators Delivery model
Israel
Vendor A Company 1 Integrator a, Integrator b On-premise
Integrator a, Integrator b,
Vendor B Company 2 SaaS
Integrator c
SaaS
Vendor C Company 3 Integrator a
On-premise
Lists only include vendors that are represented in Israel
The location within the lists is random
Lists might not include all players
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 34
35. We will present data on products and integrators: Explanations
STKI Israeli Positioning on Slides
• Not a technological positioning, refers only to Israeli market
• Represents current Israeli market and not our recommendation
•Focused on enterprise market (not SMB) Vendor A
Market Presence (X) Vendor B
Market share - existing and new sales (more emphasis)
Local Support
Mind share (how user organizations rate vendors)
Local Support (Y) – is influenced by (X) Worldwide
Leader
Experience & technical knowledge, localization,
support, number and kind of integrators
Worldwide leaders marked, based on global positioning
Vendors to watch: Are only just entering Israeli market
Vendors to Watch:
so can’t be positioned but should be watched
Vendor C
Market Presence
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 35
36. We will present data on products and integrators: Explanations
Selected Wins 2008-1Q2009 on Slides
Package X: Company 1 (Integrator), Company 2 (Integrator)
Package Y: Company 3 (Integrator), Company 4 (Integrator)
These slides contain examples of selected wins during
2008 and Q12009 (decision and purchase of certain
products, not necessarily ongoing projects)
The lists are only partial and don’t include all wins of
all vendors during this period
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 36
37. CRM Packages & Integrators in Israel:
Package Rep in Israel Integrators Delivery model
Siebel (Oracle) Oracle Israel, Taldor Taldor, IBM, BeyondIT On Premise
Siebel on-Demand Oracle Israel, SaaS;
Taldor, ManofIT, Yael, BeyondIT
Enterprise
(Oracle) Taldor, Yael At customer/partner
Yael, Malam-Team, ONE1UP,
Oracle CRM Oracle Israel On Premise
Oracle, HP-EDS, Advantech
Peoplesoft (Oracle) Oracle, Matrix Matrix On Premise
SAP CRM SAP Israel Ness, Taldor, Advantech On Premise
Amdocs (Clarify) Amdocs Amdocs On Premise
20 Partners, including: Matrix- On Premise;
Microsoft Dynamics Effect, Advantech, SIT, Malam-
Microsoft Hosted by partners;
CRM Team, Netwise, Aman ,Elad,
Yael…. SaaS not yet in Israel
Pivotal ONE1 ONE1 On Premise
Salesforce.com ONE1, Blat-Lapidot SaaS
Mid Tier
MEGA Center Yael Yael On Premise
Onyx (Consona) IT Navigator IT Navigator On Premise
Netsuite Edmiso SaaS
MyBusiness MyBusiness MyBusiness SaaS
SugarCRM OpenIT Open source
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 37
38. Microsoft-Based CRM Solutions in Israel – Part 1
Company Solution
E-Drive (Car Market)
Capital Market: “Optimi”
Advisor Platform ((יועצי השקעות
)פניות ציבור (מענה לחוק חופש המידע
Effect (Matrix) High Tech Solution
פתרון לניהול גביה והליכים משפטיים
Infrastuctures: configuration management, dashboard, self service, CDI
Contact center - moked
Analytical Dynamic CRM
CRM for security org./departments
HRM – Healthcare CRM, hospital risk management
DRM – Donors relationship management
Malam-Team Academy – Alumni, Student, scholarship grant mng, training courses
Retail CRM
VC – Venture capital CRM
Financial services and Retail banking
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 38
39. Microsoft-Based CRM Solutions in Israel – Part 2
Company Solution
Contribution System
Donors CRM
Conferences and training
SIT
Members club
CRM for High-Tech sector
Customer Service Portal
Broad Digital Billing, Rating, Account Receivables
Highview BI for Microsoft Dynamics
Capital Market
ניהול פניות ציבור
Advantech
Surveys module
MOSS and CRM integration
Vehicle Fleet management
Almog SMS distribution
Pricelists update
Agile HR companies’ operations and clients
Eyron Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI
Einat Election campaign management
Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 39
40. CRM-Related Applications:
Developing/
Solution Description Representing
Company
Enterprise Incentives Incentives, Matrix-
Incentives Pro
Management partner
Kana Collaborative CRM Malam-Team
DSKnowledge Service Center Knowledgebase Danshir
Talisma – CIM (customer
Collaborative CRM Business Solutions
interaction management)
collaborative CRM, KM for
Knova (Consona) IT Navigator
contact centers
Siebel - Social CRM Social tools for CRM Oracle - Siebel
Cemax Feedback Mng, Complaints Mng. Cemax
*Doesn’t include Contact Center/telephony tools
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 40
41. Multi Channel /customer Self Service applications
Product Name Description Israeli Representative
Lyris Email marketing
Neolane Multichannel marketing
Netwise
Cellular apps. SMS dist., WAP, download apps
Self service apps Self Service Kiosks
Kana Collaborative CRM Malam-Team
Talisma – CIM Collaborative CRM Business Solutions
Megacenter Mail
Managing channels (SMS, Fax, email) Yael Software
Server (MCMS)
eBilling + eService +
Self Service Oracle (part of Siebel suite)
eCommerce
Mail-IT + possible Marketing messages management (Mails
cloud model channel)
Matrix
Matrix Mobile Bank2go, Ultra Credit, Calldinator, WFA
solutions MMIS – Matrix mobile info. server
One1 Mobile Mobile channel, SMS One1 Mobile
Cellesense Text and web automated self service Netwise – Integration partner
AMS Billminer (EBPP), self care Lognet
Yodlee Moneycenter Aggregated financial data and payment Bynet SW.
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 41
ISQ Q&A web self-service ISQ
42. CRM - Israeli Market Positioning 1Q09
Siebel Microsoft
Peoplesoft + SOD
SAP
Local Support
Oracle CRM
Pivotal
MEGACenter Worldwide
Salesforce
Leader
Onyx
Amdocs
Vendors to Watch:
NetSuite (on-demand) This analysis should be used with its
supporting documents
SugarCRM (open source)
Market Presence
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 42
43. CRM Selected Wins during 2008/1Q09
(Partial List)
Siebel On-Demand: ECI (Taldor), Test Insight (ManofIT),
Remmon (ManofIT), Pascal (ManofIT), Coreflow (ManofIT),
Civcom (ManofIT), Oridion, Teva, Netafim, Galil College,
Nicast (ManofIT)
Peoplesoft: Bezeq projects
SAP CRM: Zim, Excellence Nesua (Taldor), Given Imaging
(Advantech), Navy, IAI, Machon Mor, Sarel, Technion (Taldor)
Microsoft Dynamics CRM: Leumi-Card (Effect-Matrix),
Random Logic-888 (Almog), Aviv PCB (Almog), Bank Igud
(Effect), Doar Israel (Effect-Matrix), Egged (Advantech), Mey
Eden (Aman), Yad Vashem, Red Data, Africa hotels,
Superpharm (Effect), HTR (Effect), Audiocodes (Effect), Avis
(Effect), Bank Leumi
Pivotal: Moatza Lezarchanut, Madgal, Negev Ceramics, Ambar
Salesforce: Symantech division, Alladin, Scopus
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 43
44. CRM Consultants in Israel (alphabetical)
Partial List
Accenture
Alternative
Aman (widelink)
BI-Pro
Deloitte Touche: Strategy, business case
IT solutions
Luria
Meteor
Sensecom: Contact Centers
Synergy: Campaign Management, Analytical CRM
Several other independent advisors
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 44
45. STKI Rule of Thumb
HIGH-END CRM in Israel: Price Per Seat
• License: $1K - $3K
• Integration: 2 x license
• Hardware: 1 x license
• Maintenance: 0.5 x license (for 3 years)
• Training &
Change Mng: 1 x license
• Testing: 0.25-0.5 x license
• Data Quality: 0.25-0.5 x license
Total: 6 x license
$6,000 - $18,000 per seat
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 45
46. STKI Rule of Thumb
Mid-Tier CRM in Israel: Price Per Seat
• License: $500 - $1K
• Integration: 2 x license
• Maintenance: 0.5 x license (for 3 years)
• Implementation 0.75 x license
(training, testing,
data quality)
Total: ~4 x license
$2,000 - $4,000 per seat
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 46
47. STKI Rule of Thumb
SaaS CRM price model
Pay-as-you-go subscription pricing
Price per user per month: 40$ - 130$
* Depending on functionality, contract period,
scope of modules vs. full suite, number of users
Additional possible costs:
• Relatively very short implementation time
• Internet bandwidth requirement
• Data quality
• Training + HATMAA
• Some possible customization costs
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 47
48. EPSS for CSRs + Unified Agent Desktop
Developing/
Solution Description Representing
Company
Guided Customer Interactions, E-Glue, ONE1-
E-Glue
Unified Desktop, EPSS partner
Guided Customer Interactions, Composia, Matrix-
Composia
Unified Desktop, EPSS partner
Front End integration, Unified
OpenSpan Malam-Team
Desktop
Solan, Yael & SRL -
E-Tracker EPSS
partners
CCF (Customer Care Aggregation, Acceleration and Microsoft, Matrix -
Framework) Automation partner
Expeditor Desktop Integration IBM, Matrix - partner
Acceleration and automation,
SKS for CCF Bynet SW
expanding CCF capabilities
Jacada Front End integration
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 48
49. Campaign Management
Package Vendors in Israel
Product Name Israeli Rep. Integrators
Unica Gstat IBM, Gilon
Chordiant IBM
SAS Mia Computers Gilon
Teradata Analytic CRM Mittwoch Mittwoch, Gilon
Siebel Marketing Automation
Taldor, Oracle Taldor
(Acquired by Oracle)
Neolane Netwise Netwise
Peoplesoft Marketing
Matrix Matrix
Automation
MEGACenter Marketing Module Yael Yael
Other CRM Vendors…
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 49
50. ERP
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 50
51. ERP
ERP Life Cycle Trends
Increase efficiency of
Basic modules ERP operations
HR, Logistics,
Financials Portals, BI, BPM
Stabilizing Upgrades Advanced modules
the system
Increase Hatmaa “Core” modules
ERP 1 ERP 2 ERP 3 ?
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 51
52. ERP
ERP Maturity Model 2009 Trends
Business Value Increase efficiency, advanced/ vertical
modules, upgrade, improve HATMAA,
Investment implement ERP portals, BI, BPM
to make money
IT+business
Cut costs, Increase ERP 2 Process
Project
productivity ERP modeling ERP
Pure
Operational for ERP MDM Business
Portals Project
Commodity IT
ERP1
Services Size of figure =
complexity/
cost of project
ERP
Investment governance
for regulations tools
Using Implementing Looking
Market Maturity
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 52
53. ERP
ERP Benefits Trends
Source: http://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/ERB0401.pdf
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 53
54. ERP Staffing ratio
Average size of Israeli ERP department: 15-20
Implementers: 60%
Developers: 17%
Infrastructure (system/DBAs): 10%
Other: 13%
ERP effort distribution:
New developments: 70%
Maintenance: 30%
Average ratio between ERP staff / ERP users:
SAP 1:66
Oracle 1:30 (due to smaller-scale installations)
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 54
55. ERP
ERP Main priorities for 2009 Trends
How to reduce ongoing maintenance costs?
Sourcing strategies
3rd party tools
Licensing management
Improve HATMAA of ERP to decrease
training costs, improve usability and
lower HD costs
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 55
56. ERP
SAP ERP specific issues in 2009 Trends
BI – BW architectural dilemmas
More willingness to use external services
Increase efficiency with 3rd party tools
Upgrade costs too high for value they provide
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 56
57. ERP
Oracle ERP specific issues in 2009 Trends
Need for software configuration management
Upgrades
More use of internal ERP staff
Increase efficiency with 3rd party tools
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 57
58. STKI Rule of Thumb
Enterprise ERP in Israel: Price Per Seat
License: $1600 - $2500
Integration: 2-3 x license
Hardware: 1 x license
Maintenance: 0.5 x license (for 3 years)
Implementation
(Testing, Training
Data Quality): 1 x license
Total: ~6 x license
~$12,000 per seat
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 58
59. STKI Rule of Thumb
Large - SMB ERP in Israel: Price Per Seat
• License: $1500-$1700
• Integration: 2 x license
• Hardware: 0.25 x license
• Maintenance: 0.5 x license (for 3 years)
• Implementation 0.75 x license
(training, testing,
data quality)
Total: 4.5 x license
$6,750 - $7650 per seat
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 59
60. STKI Rule of Thumb
SMB ERP in Israel: Price Per Seat
• License: $700-$1200
• Integration: 2 x license
• Maintenance: 0.5 x license (for 3 years)
• Implementation 0.5 x license
(training, testing,
data quality)
Total: 4 x license
$2800 – $4,800 per seat
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 60
61. ERP Packages & Integrators: Part 1
Package Israel Rep Integrators Delivery model
Yael, Malam-Team, ONE1UP, Oracle
Oracle
Oracle Israel consulting, HP-EDS, Advantech, Ernst & On-premise
Apps
Young, Unitask, Motorola
Oracle Unitask (Oracle Easy), Afek, Motorola,
Oracle Accelerated ONE1UP, Advanteck, E&Y, Yael, AKT (HR On-premise
Edition module)
SAP, Ness, IBM, Taldor, Advantech, Malam-Team,
HP-EDS, Accenture, Aman, SRL, Danshir, CB
SAP All-in- SAP Israel On-premise
I.T, E121, EPS SAP, Gav, IGC, Opex,
One SAPLM, SDM, AKT (HR module)
SAP Xioma, Malam-Team (Etop), RELS, Harel
Business SAP Israel comp Malal, Complete, Menahel4U, Todan, On-premise
One Reut-ONE, Synopsis
E-Tafnit Matrix Matrix, Alpha Consultants On-premise
QAD SIT SIT, ManofIT, Tirosh On-premise, SaaS
Lawson
Intentia Israel Intentia Israel On-premise
(M3, S3)
Ashbal, Meidatech, FBC On-premise, SaaS
Priority Ashbal
Afek, Tulip, RAAN, HP-EDS, IlitERP (meidatech)
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 61
62. ERP Packages & Integrators: Part 2
Package Israel Rep Integrators Delivery Model
Microsoft Israel. Matrix, Oregano, Malam-Team,
Microsoft Dynamics Localization & Prodware, Tadiad, Maxoft On-premise
AX Distribution by
mAXimum ERP (Matrix) other partners in qualifications
Aviv, MARS Aviv Aviv On-premise
ONE ERP ONE1 ONE1 On-premise
KAV systems Kav Kav, Ardom On-premise
FinPro, Logistic Pro Almog Almog On-premise
Gan Tochnot On-demand,
Aman Aman
Heshev Hosted
Comax (on On-demand,
Comax
demand) Hosted
On-premise,
Bgate Bgate
SaaS
IFS Teldan On-premise
BPCS, Baan Matrix Matrix, Afek, IBM, Tulip (Baan) On-premise
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 62
63. ERP
SMB ERP in Israel Trends
Pressure from large players in generic ERP
Verticalization, Verticalization, Verticalization
SMB ERP providers develop very deep and
verticalized solutions
On-demand models – also in Israel!
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 63
64. ERP On-demand model ERP
Trends
Kicking in
• Comax
• Meida-Tech (Priority on demand)
• SIT – QAD
• Ggate
• Gan Tochnot Heshev
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 64
65. ERP - Israeli Market Positioning 1Q09
Enterprise ERP Medium - Large ERP SMB ERP
Priority
Oracle SAP SAP Oracle
AIO SAP BOONE1
ERP
ONE1 Priority Oracle
ERP AE/easy QAD Tafnit
QAD Tafnit
Kav
Aviv Movex Aviv
Movex
Vendors to Watch:
Ggate IFS
Microsoft Dynamics AX COMAX
Market Presence
This analysis should be used
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portionsupporting documents
with its of graphic 65
66. ERP Selected Wins 2008-1Q09
(Partial List)
SAP: Rakevet Israel (Malam-Team)
SAP All-in-one (Best Practices): Gidron (Taldor), Ashdod medical center
(Taldor), Batey Zikuk (Taldor)
Sap modules: GRC – Dead Sea, BIA – Coca Cola, Learning solution - Bazan,
IDM – Ness, Billing - Meitav
SAP ECC upgrades: Mecan-Ericsoon, M.of Health, Tadiran Solelot
Oracle: Object (R12), Ashot (ONE1up), LUZ II, Actimize
Accelerated Edition: Modu (Advantech, R12), Retalix, ITL, Rion
Tafnit: Barzilay hospital, Leumicard, Albar, Sani, Visa, Mizrachi, Ayalon, Ampa
investments
QAD: Vishey international, Expansions in AVT, Seragon. On-demand ERP:
Enlyten, RGI
Microsoft Dynamics AX (not localized version): Random Logic 888 (Malam-
Team), Aviv PCB (Oregano)
Comax (on demand): Hazi hinam, 2 municipalities, Domisil
ONE1 ERP: Agami, Beit Yanai, Ambar
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 66
67. 3rd party SAP complimentary tools (partial list) – Part 1
Solution Israel Rep. Description
EPIuse Ness Selective data copies
Zoption Ness Integrating financial functions with Office - excel
Panaya Panaya Simulation and guidance for SAP upgrades
Intellicorp – Live
Ness Impact analysis (for SAP upgrades)
compare
Object Manager Ness Software configuration management
OrgPlus Ness Visual HR management
Xpandion Ness Risk mng, behavioral analysis, license audit
ARX Cosign Ness Digital signature
IXOS - (OpenText) Top Solutions SAP content management and archiving
Printboss - Consist Consist, Ness Design/distribution of SAP forms
MessageManager Ness Unified messaging for SAP
SteerU SteerU EPSS for SAP
Innowera Shimoni’s work CopyrightNess
Einat 2009 @STKI
Integration of SAP transactions with Excel
Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 67
68. 3rd party SAP complimentary tools (partial list) – Part 2
Solution Israel Rep. Description
Item Field -
Aman Data transformation for SAP
Informatica
Clicksoftware Clicksoftware SAP workforce optimization
HR Load runner HP Israel software performance testing tools
HP Quality Center HP Israel automate QA testing
Cisco Data Privacy Cisco Data security on the network
CA Wily CA Israel Monitoring customer transactions in real time
Arcplan Danshir Dashboard for SAP data
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 68
69. 3rd party Oracle e-Business Suite
complimentary products (partial list)
Solution Israel Rep. Description
Oracle
UPK (acquired by Partners: Tools to increase productivity, usability,
Oracle) Yana-Smart, deployment & content creation
John Bryce,
Blat Lapidot
OMM (Object Migration management and change
Migration Manager) management for Oracle e-business
Print Director Unitask Enhanced Oracle printing
Dynamic Entity Data management and control tool
AOA
AOA Travel management system
(Add-on Applications)
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 69
70. ERP Consultants (Alphabetical list)
Partial List
Accenture
Bit-Plus
Byon
Deloitte Touche
Ernst & Young
HMS
Meteor
OIC
Seker
Tulip
Several Independent advisors
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 70
71. SCM
Supply Chain Management Trends
Information focus Strategic measurements,
Balanced Scorecard
SCP: Supply
Demand
Chain planning &
Planning forecasting Inventory Advanced
planning & planning &
optimization optimization
Product Data Management
SRM
SCE: Supply
Chain ERP 1, ERP 2
WMS Supplier
Execution portal
Transportation
Management
Transaction focus
Demand Logistics Operations Supply
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 71
72. Supply Chain Management SCM
Trends
Global trends
From Execution to Planning:
try to match demand and deliver the right
product to the right place at the right time at
the right price
Organizations becoming demand sensitive:
More data that will help predict demand from
POS, suppliers, internal sales/marketing people
Ability to respond near real time
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 72
73. Supply Chain Management SCM
Trends
Israel trends
Gap between IT and logistics/SCM business departments
SCM very broad and complex, requires special expertise
Confusion regarding what ERP packages can and can’t do
why do we need a BoB solution if we have an ERP?
SCM package decisions are still based on BoB:
Solution has to be flexible, be able to include many
dynamic constraints that change as you go
Solution has to include transactional as well as analytical
(multi dimensional analysis)
SCM packages are also facing suppliers and partners
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 73
74. KM
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 74
75. KM
Knowledge Management Trends
But don’t think too much…
Get practical
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 75
76. KM
The problem with Knowledge Trends
It takes too much time to find
existing information needed to
complete tasks
The Problem: Too much info!
Lack of information
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 76
77. KM
Let’s see the numbers Trends
The typical IW spends up to 25% of the day searching
for the right information to complete a given task.
Ineffective searches/wasting time looking for
information can cost companies up to 10% in salary
expenses (Butler Group)
Employees spend 12 hours a week on info-gathering
tasks: mostly, unsuccessfully. (Accenture)
Knowledge workers spend 15%-30% of their time
gathering information, but are successful less than 50
percent of the time. (IDC)
The amount of new technical information is doubling
every two years
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 77
78. Internal KM Maturity Model 2009 KM
Trends
Business Value
Investment
to make money
Blogs IT+business
Cut costs, Increase Social
tools
Project
productivity
Wikis Pure
Ent.
Business
ECM Search
Project
Gateway
Commodity IT portal
Services Archiving Size of figure =
complexity/
cost of project
Investment
for regulations
Using Implementing Looking
Market Maturity
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 78
79. KM
KM Best Practices Trends
KM should be process-dependent and
combined in every-day tasks
Accommodate different types of users
Digital natives
Digital immigrants
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 79
80. What isn’t acceptable for the KM
Trends
Digital native (generation X)?
Paper application E-form on
form company portal
2 hour classroom Simulation games,
session with PPT online courses,
slides community
Posting ideas on
Suggestion box
company blog
Interaction, relevancy,
ease of use
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 80
81. The digital native KM
Technology “consumerization” Trends
• New-age knowledge workers are used to:
• Communicate
• Share
• Collaborate
• Plan
… in a different way.
They will probably grow grassroots web 2.0 initiatives,
whether IT likes it or not
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 81
82. KM
Web 2.0: User is at the center Trends
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 82
83. KM
Web 2.0 tools: Adoption vs. Complexity Trends
Most known
most deployed
Least known
least deployed
Source: Cutter
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 83
84. General
Innovation Sources Trends
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 84
85. Enterprise 2.0 Social tools
Integration
Product Category Israeli Rep
partners
Elgg (open source) Social networks tools OpenIT
IBM Quickr, Blogs, Wikis, RSS, Elad-Risotech &
IBM
connections Social networks other WS partners
Kwizcom, Byon
Bynet SW, Matrix
MOSS 2007 Wiki, blog, RSS Microsoft
& other MOSS
partners
Kwizcom Web 2.0 Wiki, Tagging, rating,
Kwizcom
bundle (MOSS addons) forum
Mediawiki (open
Wiki Byon, Matrix
source)
Atlasian Hosted Wiki Elad Byon
“Beshutaf” Community tools Consist Consist
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 85
86. KM
Participatory Technology Trends
“Participatory technologies have the highest chance of
success when incorporated into a user’s daily workflow”
(McKinsey)
• Google’s engineers report their projects work into blogs
and wikis (Collaborative project management)
Your Text here Your Text here
• Pixar animators use wikis with videos to share and discuss
ideas
• STKI analysts are measured also by their blogs contribution;
every new round table summary is uploaded
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 86
87. KM
How to use participatory technology? Trends
Make it a part of a specific daily work process (for
example, project-specific wikis)
Find the right “base” of users that will create the mass
Maintain the right balance of freedom and control
(different for each topic and industry) Your Text here
Your Text here
Do what is needed to make it RELEVANT for specific need
• Make it more friendly
• Add missing capabilities
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 87
88. Issues with using Web 2.0 KM
Trends
in the organization
• Isn’t “controlled” like other tools are
• Software usually isn’t proprietary
• Hard/impossible to govern and control processes
• What’s in & what’s out? Data leakage concerns
• When using mashups – concerns regarding
integrity and security of outside services
• Almost zero training, different adoption cycle
Adopting Web 2.0 in the organization
requires a new approach
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 88
89. KM
Web 2.0: Recommendations Trends
• Find key leaders
• Define areas in which Web 2.0 provides value:
• Project teams “environments”
• Internal/external Ideas blogs for product innovation
• Define areas where Web 2.0 shouldn’t be used
• Determine a certain control level
• No “anonymous” posts
• Feedback mechanism
Upcoming STKI Round Table
Web 2.0 for KM: May 13, 2009
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 89
90. Enterprise Content Management ECM
Types of documents (definitions) Trends
• Operational documents:
Documents that support the organizations day-to-day operations.
“Must have”/ Important
Documents linked to applications’ transaction and flow (viewed via app)
Important documents but can be separate repository (viewed via ECM app)
Examples: Contracts, customer records, employee records
• Soft documents:
Documents that help “knowledge management” and sharing.
Not linked to a specific process, considered a “Nice to have”.
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 90
91. ECM
ECM Market in Israel Trends
• Most large organizations managing operational docs (partially)
Managed in different separate environments
Documents around core processes mostly managed
Other important documents hardly managed
“Soft” documents are rarely managed
• Most common failure reasons for ECM projects:
Poor integration leads to lack of HATMAA of these tools
Ongoing HATMAA is problematic, tools are complex to use
and no budget for training
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 91
92. ECM
ECM state of the market in Israel Trends
Source: STKI ECM Round table, 2008:
http://einatstki.blogspot.com/2008/06/blog-post.html
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 92
93. ECM
ECM market size in Israel Trends
• During 2007-2009 (3 years) we estimate the
ECM market size in Israel to be $70M*:
• High End (15-20 large projects): $15-20M
• Low End: 100-200 projects sometimes
combined in different projects such as
portals
* Includes both SW licenses and services
Einat Shimoni’s work Copyright 2009 @STKI Do not remove source or attribution from any graphic or portion of graphic 93