Talk given at the School of Computer Science, The University of Manchester, UK Postgraduate Research Symposium 2019
the Carole Goble Doctoral Paper award was given for the first time
The importance of continents, oceans and plate tectonics for the evolution of...
Reflections on a (slightly unusual) multi-disciplinary academic career
1. Reflections on a (slightly unusual)
multi-disciplinary academic career
Professor Carole Goble CBE FREng FBCS CITP
The University of Manchester, UK
carole.goble@manchester.ac.uk
3. I didn’t intend to stay at the university…
1980s
Ian
Cottam
Behind many a
successful
professor is a
super supportive
partner
Access Grid
4. …I didn’t intend to be an academic…
1980s
Teaching
lectureship
Women in
Computing
1st CoI on a grant: 1988
1st Publication: 1990
1st Conf attended: 1991
1st Conf presentation: 1992
1st Intl Conf presentation: 1993
1st PI on a grant: 1994
1st Keynote: 2000
Full Professor: 2000
5. … I became one anyway…
102funding awards
114journal articles
149refereed
conference articles
Ncollaborators
(Linked-In 1496 connections)
60+ keynotes
60+Research Fellows
Software and Resources
beyond Proof of Concept
6. … some PhD stuff…
oppositions
supervisions
Mr Cottamand one for me
we can walk
different paths
10. 2. Empirical Research
• ". . . the fundamental
difference between a
theoretician and an
engineer is that an engineer
is away and doing
something once he's [sic]
grasped that there's a way
of doing something, and the
theoretician is strangely
enough most of the time
lagging behind, cleaning-up
-- that's the best word I can
use . . ."
Tom Kilburn 1992
Tom Kilburn
12. 2. Empirical Research (e-)Science
1. Empirical describing natural phenomena
2. Theoretical using models, generalizations
3. Computational simulating phenomena
4. Data intensive unify theory, experiment,
and simulation
New
research
outputs
Open, reproducible
science
13. 2. Empirical Research Team Based
Researchers
Computational Biologists
Research Software Engineers
Data management specialists
Mix of complementary skills
I’m a Co-ordinator and Resource Investigator*…
*Belbin Team Role Theories
14. 2. Empirical Research Team Based
A PhD in a team
• Freedom to innovate
• Support & stimulation
• Fast track take up
Watch for
• Setting boundaries
• Sucked into project delivery
• On-boarding frustration
Researchers
Computational Biologists
Research Software Engineers
Data management specialists
PhD students
15. 2. Empirical Research Team Based
Practice - Software and Resources
beyond Proof of Concept
VIEWER
Practice - Standards
COHSE
Researchers
Computational Biologists
Research Software Engineers
Data management specialists
JERM Ontology myGrid Ontology
16. Research Software Matters
2010 - 2024
A national facility for cultivating
and improving research software
to support world-class research.
2006-2010
17. 3. Multi-disciplinary Collaboration
people from
different
disciplines
working
together,
each drawing on
their disciplinary
knowledge*.
*http://www.arj.no/2012/03/12/disciplinarities-2/
Life Sciences
Plant and
Animal
health
Drug
Discovery
Systems &
Synthetic
Biology
‘Omics
Industrial Biotechnology
Biodiversity
Digital
Libraries
HelioPhysics
Astronomy
Rare Disease,Virtual Physiology
Health Informatics,
Precision Medicine
Museum
Collections
Social
Science
22. KnowledgeTurning in Science
[Figures: Josh Sommer, Chordoma Foundation]
GobleC., De Roure D., Bechhofer S. (2013) AcceleratingScientists’ KnowledgeTurns,
doi:10.1007/978-3-642-37186-8_1
Research Commons
Access to resources, Flow of Information
Coordination & Collaboration
Automated processing
Mobilisation of the community
Scale and Change
The FAIR Guiding Principles for
scientific data management and
stewardship Scientific Data 3
(2016) doi:10.1038/sdata.2016.18
23. Data in Science in a Nutshell
Wonderfully messy.Wonderfully human.The spreadsheet is king.
A world of possibilities. Cool
Machine Learning
Uncool
Stewardship
Incompatibility * Metadata
Method
Service ethic
Interoperability
24. Social Studies of Science
Scientific
Instrumentation
Scientific
Information
Technology
Scientific
Community
Steven Shapin Pump and Circumstance: Robert Boyle's LiteraryTechnology (1984)
https://doi.org/10.1177/030631284014004001
25. Computer Science & Software Engineering
Distributed
Computing
Knowledge
Computing
Social
Computing
Computational
Workflows
Open
Science
Cloud based
services
Web services
Portability
Containers
Sharing &
Collaboration
Provenance
TransparencyInteroperability
Reproducibility
FAIR
e-Labs & collaboratories
Interop
SemanticWeb
Ontologies
Linked Data
Reasoning
nanopublications
26. E.g: Computational Workflows
automate data and processing tasks
• Functional programming,
lambda calculus …
• Visual programming …
• Service-oriented and Cloud
computing, repair,
preservation, packaging …
• Semantic description:
validation, planning,
optimisation, discovery,
automated annotation …
• Provenance tracking, credit
propagation …
• Sharable method
• Social workflow collaboratory
• Workflow research objectsLots of e-Infrastructure,
tools and support
27. A systematic strategy for large-scale analysis of genotype–
phenotype correlations: identification of candidate genes
involved in African trypanosomiasis 2007, Vol. 35, No. 16
5625-5633
2007
2017
29. Impact -> time, staying power, trust
2003
2007
2008
EU Workflow collaboratory
2018-2023
Projects
using the
infrastructure
Other people’s
projects using the
infrastructure
2010-2014
30. Multi-Disciplinary Research…
Juggle, Balance, Communicate
Respect the ego-system
Be Patient
BuildTrust & Respect
Be Useful
Be Reliable
Return favours
Avoid servitude
Learn the culture
• Embed
• Bigger picture
• Rewards
• Work practices, language
Align and revisit
• Problem
• Expectations
• Timings
• Availability
• Resources
Complement
32. • Plan with everyone
• Manage expectations
• Define boundaries
• Be pragmatic
• Ask “stupid” questions
• Build a network (mentors)
• Exploit your unique skillset
• Avoid servitude
• Swim against the flow
• Publish for your career
• Adjust to your audience
• Have fun
35. Write for the different
disciplines
Value impact & influence
through all methods
BOSC 2007
Multi-Disciplinary
Scholarly Communication
84,371 views
36. Scholarly Communication
Take more seriously in Computer Science
• Paper ->
Reproducible
Research Objects
• “Executable papers”
• Publish ->
Release
37. TL;DR summary
• slightly unusual
– we can walk different paths & mentors matter.
• multi-disciplinary academic career
– empirical research smoothed the way for me
– multi-disciplinary is rich with possibilities, but…
…requires mindfulness.
…the social and technical are hard to separate.
• think beyond the PDF!
38. Acknowledgements
• The eScience group
• The Information Management Group
• All my collaborators and mentors
• All my students
• All my funders
• Simon Harper for this great honour
• And of course Ian Cottam…otherwise I wouldn’t
have been here.