Common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L. (Leguminosae) is a crop widely distributed in almost all parts of the world. In Ethiopia, common bean is cultivated for two main purposes namely as a source of protein for local consumption and for export. Mostly, it grows in the warm and lowland areas of the country. This experiment was conducted to identify, select and recommend adaptable, high yielding, as well as Insect pest and disease resistant released variety(ies) for major common bean producing areas mainly Kamashi zone and Mao-komo special Woreda of Benishangul gumuz regional state of Ethiopia. Sixteen varieties were evaluated in RCBD with three replications with plot size of 4m x 2.4m = 9.6m2 at Kamashi and Tongo (Mao-komo) testing sites of Assosa Agricultural Research Centre (AsRC) for two years (2013/14 and 2014/15) main cropping seasons. The result of ANOVA showed that there was a significant varietal difference (P< 0.001) in seed yield. The least seed yield per hectare was recorded for Argene variety (474 kg ha-1) and the highest grain yield for SER 125 variety (2220 kg ha-1) followed by SER 119 (2022 kg ha-1) SER 48 varieties (1891kg ha-1) and Nasir variety (1800 kg ha-1). SER 125, SER 119 and SER 48 varieties were performed well across both locations during the consecutive cropping seasons while Nasir variety has another quality of tolerating soil acidity which was the major problem in the western parts of the country including Assosa and western Oromia. Therefore, these varieties have to be promoted in farmer’s field for dissemination and scaling up.
2. Performance Evaluation of released Common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) varieties at Benishangul Gumuz region, Ethiopia
Alemu and Getachew 331
It is well adapted to areas that receive an annual average
rainfall ranging from 500 to 1500 mm with optimum
temperature range of 16 to 24 0C, and a frost-free period
of 105 to 120 days. Moreover, it performs best on deep,
friable and well aerated soil types with optimum pH range
of 6.0 to 6.8 (Kay, 1979). Beans can be grown on light
sandy soils to heavy clay soils of well drained soils as they
are sensitive to water logging (IAR, 1979).
In Ethiopia, population is growing in more rate than the
agricultural production does. To feed this increasing
population the agricultural production should grow
accordingly with the same pace or even more. Pulses are
the most important crops in the national strategy of food
self-reliance and foreign exchange earnings. Therefore, to
increase the productivity of the farmers, it is crucial to
increase the awareness of farmers towards the usage of
different improved technologies that increase their
production and accelerate food security through proper
implementation.
Access to new and improved agricultural technologies is
limited in Benishangul Gumuz generally and Asosa and
Kamashi Zones as well as Mao-komo especial Wodeda
specifically most probably due to remoteness from the
center of excellence (the research centers were the new
technologies with full packages are introduced) and the
farmers awareness about the new technology is very
limited in the areas. The potential of pulse crops is not
exploited in this part of the region due to lack of improved
varieties, poor management practices, biotic factors
(weeds, diseases and insect pests etc.), and abiotic factor
(soil acidity, high intensity and long duration of rainfall). So
far, the national research institution in collaboration with
different regional research institutes in the country has
released many varieties for commercial Production across
different agro-ecologies. Hence, these technologies did
not test for their adaptability and yielding potential under
Benishangul Gumuz region and did not reach the
smallholder farmers living in the area. Having these points,
to overcome the above stated problems and to acquaint
smallholder farmers with new technologies of widely grown
pulse crops production, the released bean varieties were
tested to identify well-performed, adaptable and high
yielding varieties at Kamashi and Tongo(Mao-komo)
testing sites of Assosa Agricultural Research Center.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The Study Area
The experiment was conducted at Kamashi and Mao-
komo testing sites of Assosa Agricultural Research Center
which were located 250 km and 126 km from the Assosa
Agricultural Research Center. The description of the study
areas was given by the following table.
Table 1: Description of the study areas
Locations Altitude (m.a.s.l.) Temp./min and max (0c) Rain fall Average (mm) Soil type Global position
Latitude Longitude
Kamashi 1000 20 and 30 500-1800 nitosol 10.0670N 34.5170E
Tongo 1215 17.5 and 29.1 1486 nitosol 09031.444’’N 35053.222’E
Treatments and Experimental Design
Sixteen improved varieties of common bean (ICAB UNSI
X 87, SER-125, SER-119, Cherchere, Awash-1,
Dinkinesh, GLP-2, Nazareth-2, Chore, SER-48, Lehode,
Ecab-0056, Argene, Dimtu, Naser and Awash Melka) were
tested in a randomized complete block design (RCBD)
with three replications over two locations for two years.
Common bean was sown in six rows per plot with spacing
of 40 cm between rows and 10 cm between plants within
a row with gross plot area of 9.6m2.
Data Collection
Phenological Parameters
Phenological parameters such as days to flowering and
days to maturity were recorded. Days to flowering was
recorded by counting the number of days after emergence
when 50% of the plants per plot had the first open flower.
Days to maturity was recorded when 90% of pods/plot
matured
Grain Yield and Yield Components
Four central rows were harvested for determination of
grain yield. Grain yield was adjusted to 12.5% moisture
content. Five plants were randomly selected from the four
central rows to determine yield and yield components,
such as number of pods per plant and number of seeds
per pod. Pod number per plant was determined by
counting pods of the five randomly selected plants while
number of seeds per pod was recorded by counting the
total number of seeds in a pod from the five randomly
selected plants. Hundred seed weight was determined by
taking a random sample of 100 seeds from the total yield
Statistical Analysis
GenStat version (18) was used for data analysis. Mean
separation was conducted using Duncan’s Multiple Range
Test (DMRT) at 0.05 probability level.
3. Performance Evaluation of released Common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) varieties at Benishangul Gumuz region, Ethiopia
Int. J. Plant Breed. Crop Sci. 332
Table 2: Combined mean values of yield and yield components of sixteen common bean varieties
Variety YLD DTF DTM PLH PPPT SPPT Sppd HSW
SER-125 2220 a 44.25e 89gh 34e 9.25c-f 37.75b-f 5.25a-d 30.42bc
SER-119 2022ab 45.17de 90.58d-h 39.4cde 10.25b-e 45.33b 5.5abc 25.92de
SER-48 1891bc 44.33e 90.75d-h 40.33cde 12.083bc 43.92bcd 5bcd 28.5cd
Nasir 1800bc 44.58e 91.42d-g 47.03cd 10.917bcd 44bc 5.833a 23.83ef
GLP-2 1686cd 46.58c 91.92c-f 38.8cde 9.25c-f 31.42efg 4.17f 32.92ab
Dimtu 1446de 47.92b 88.58h 47.67cd 10.917bcd 39.75b-e 5.5ab 23.25e-i
Ecab-0056 1380ef 45.17de 91.75c-f 37.8de 6.917fg 24.67g 5.33a-d 34.08a
Chore 1280ef 51.08a 91.92c-f 40.97cde 14.917a 63.5a 5.5ab 27.08d
Awash-melka 1261ef 48.58b 89.58fgh 40.2cde 9.917c-f 39.33b-e 5.5ab 20.17gi
Cherchere 1200ef 49b 90.33e-h 42.13cde 13.083ab 39.5b-e 4.75def 23.58e-h
Lehode 1109f 45.25de 91.25d-g 50.33bc 7.25efg 24.58g 4.33ef 31.5abc
ICAB UNSI x 87 672g 45.08de 94.08bc 63.78a 8.417d-g 33.92c-g 5.17a-d 23.33e-i
Dinkinesh 580g 50.25a 94.92b 50.17bc 5.833g 23.75g 4.83bde 21.58f-i
Awash-1 572g 46.08cd 92.92bcd 49.03bcd 8.917def 29.75efg 5.17a-d 21.67f-i
Nazareth-2 478g 48.83b 97.25a 59.52ab 9.75c-f 31.17efg 4.17f 23.42e-i
Argene 474g 48.25b 91.75c-f 37.97de 7.583efg 28.92fg 4.67def 23.58efg
LSD 550.913 1.99 4.26 15.2 5.22 17.65 1.16 5.9
CV 27.2 2.6 2.9 20.9 23.3 30.1 14.2 14.1
CV=Coefficient of variation, LSD= Least Significant Difference, DTF=Days to 50% flowering, DTM= days to 95%maturity,
PHT= plant height, PPPT= number of pod/plant, SPPT= number of Seed/plant, SPPd= number of seed/pod, HSW=
hundred seed weight, YLD=Yield,
RESULT AND DISCUSSION
Combined analysis of variance for both years and seasons
was done to test the response of varieties to both
environment and seasons after testing the homogeneity of
the data. The result of analysis of variance based on
randomized complete block design experiment was
presented in Appendices 1. Analyses of variance revealed
significant varietal differences (P< 0.001) in seed yield, but
no significant varietal differences observed in all other
characters across both location and years. This result
indicated that there was significant variation among
varieties on their yielding abilities at both Kamashi and
Tongo during both cropping seasons. The highest number
of pods per plant (14.917pods/plant), was obtained from
Chore, while the lowest number of pods per plant was
obtained from Dinkinesh (5.833) followed by Ecab-0056
(6.917 pods/plant). The longest days to flowering were
recorded from Dinkinesh (50.25 days) while the shortest
days to flowering were recorded from Nasir variety (44.58)
followed by SER 48 (44.33). The highest number of seed
per pod (5.833) was recorded from Nasir variety whereas
the lowest seed per pod number was from both Nazereth-
2 and GLP-2(4.17seeds/pod). Similarly, Chore variety
gave the highest number of seed per plant (63.5seed per
plant) while variety Ecab-0056 gave the least number of
seed per plant (24.67 seed/plant). The tallest plant height
was recorded from ICAB UNSI x 87 (63.78cm) whereas
the shortest plant height was recorded from SER-125
(34cm). Finally, SER-125 variety produced the highest
seed yield per hectare (2220kg/ha) followed by SER-119
(2022 kg/ha), SER-48 (1891kg/ha) and Nasir (1800kg/ha)
varieties respectively. In contrary, Argene variety
produced the lowest (474 kg/ha) seed yield per hectare
followed by Nazareth-2 (478 kg/ha), Awash-1 (572kg/ha),
dinkinesh (580kg/ha) and ICAB UNSI x 87 (672 kg/ha)
varieties (Table 1). In line with this findings Kassaye, 2006;
Shahid and Kamaluddin, 2013 and Fahad et al., 2014,
reported that significant variability was observed for plant
height, days to 50% flowering, days to 90% physiological
maturity, pods per plant, seed yield per pod, hundred seed
weight and yield characters. When locations were
compared, the highest Seed yield was obtained at
Kamashi during 2014/15 cropping season from SER-48
Variety (2,710 kg/ha) followed by SER-125 (2,524 kg/ha),
while Argene (110 kg/ha) was poor yielding variety at
Tongo for 2013/14 cropping season (Appendix Table 2).
Generally, tongo was less yielder than kamashi during
both cropping seasons which may be resulted from the
heavy rain fall at Tongo than Kamashi. Significant SYD
variations among varieties and across locations could be
due to inherent character of varieties and uneven rainfall
distribution. Sperling et al., (1994) stated that during the
season on heavy rains, bush bean yields are nearly cut in
half.
CONCLUSION
Evaluating the adaptability of improved varieties is the
major and important activity where there is no technology
delivered before. Based on the result of the evaluation the
production and productivity can be improved using the
recommendation of the varieties for specific and wider
adaptation. The result of this experiment indicated that
varieties SER-125, SER-119, SER-48 and Nasir gave
higher yield respectively over both years and locations.
Nasir variety showed great character in tolerating abiotic
factors specifically, soil acidity which has been a
bottleneck problem to agricultural production and