Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
XNB151 Week 8 Meat, dairy and extras
1. ‘ M E A T ’ , ‘ M I L K A N D M I L K - B A S E D
P R O D U C T S ( D A I R Y ) ’ A N D ‘ E X T R A S ’
XNB151 Food
and Nutrition
Rembrandt,theFlayedOx
Francisco Goya, Still Life
with Slices of Salmon, 1808 Arcimboldo, The Water
Vermeer, The Milkmaid
Velazquez, Old Woman Frying
Eggs
4. Key nutrients obtained from meat and meat alternatives
Macronutrients
Protein- high biological value in meat & fish i.e. A good range of
essential amino acids
Fats
Omega 3 fats (some types of fish only)
Fibre (nuts & seeds only)
Fat content of fish varies from 0.5
to 15% depending on season and
factors such as water temperature
5. Key nutrients obtained from meat and meat alternatives
Minerals
Iron
Zinc (Oysters & crab especially rich)
Potassium
Phosphorous
Iodine (fish)
Selenium (fish & nuts)
Fluoride (fish)
Vitamins
Vitamin B12 (animal products only)
Retinol (Vitamin A) (animal products only)
Vitamin D (Salmon, tuna, sardines, fish liver & eggs only)
Thiamin, niacin, riboflavin (B vitamins)
Much higher bioavailability in
animals
Liver and kidney
especially rich sources
6. Proposed Benefits Proposed Risks
Paleolithic diets rationale
based on evidence that
Homo sapiens evolved
on a relatively high-meat
diet
Good source of pre-
formed arachidonic acid
Most bioavailable source
of many minerals
Satiating
Saturated fat and cholesterol
Nitrites and charring linked
with cancer
Inconsistent link between
high meat intake & colo-rectal
cancer
Evidence for high processed
meat intake & colo-rectal
cancer
Displacement of vegetables
Bovine Spongiform
Encephalopathy →
Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease
Meat and Health
7. Benefits Risks
Mainly related to
omega 3 content (to be
discussed later in this
lecture)
Mercury
Tapeworms if
undercooked
Bacterial spoilage
Tetradoxin poisoning
Fish and Health
8. Benefits Risks
Nut consumption 5+
times per week may
have reduced risk of
CVD
Important source of
healthy fats
Important energy &
nutrient source
Weight gain
Allergy (1% of persons)
Nuts and Health
http://www.nutriset.fr/en/product-range/produit-par-
produit/plumpynut-ready-to-use-therapeutic-food-
rutf.html
11. Key nutrients obtained from Milk & Milk-Products
Macronutrients
Protein
Carbohydrate
Micronutrients
Calcium
Phosphorous
Potassium
Riboflavin
Vitamin D (especially fortified)
12. Benefits Risks
Increased bone mass
and reduced
osteoporosis
Reduced risk of colon
cancer
Non-cariogenic
Nutrient rich
If full fat versions →↑
LDL cholesterol
Milk and Health
13. Roles of key nutrients from meat & meat
alternatives and milk and milk-based products
14. Protein - Basic structure
3-D strands composed of hundreds of amino
acids linked by peptide bonds (i.e. amino acids
join to form proteins)
~½ are essential or indispensable
essential in the diet as cannot be made in the body
Proteins
Peptide bond to form
chains (protein structure
depends on order of
amino acids
15. ProteinCell membrane
componentSelective
transport into/
out of cells
Enzymes
Enable
chemical
reactions
Haemoglobin
Oxygen
delivery to
tissuesAlbumin
Osmotic
pressure
& water
balance
Transferrin
Iron
transport
from gut to
bone
marrow/
other tissues
Nucleoprotein
Stabilise
nucleic acid
structure
Contractile
protein
(muscle)
Muscle
contraction
& movement
Role of proteins in the body
17. High protein intakes
High protein diets for weight loss
Extreme approaches very
low CHO
Moderate approaches
e.g. CSIRO Total Wellbeing Diet
Loss of fluid rather than fat
(especially in short term)
Consider lack of nutrients e.g.
fibre, vits & mins, not sustainable
Promotes moderate
consumption of nutritious
wholegrains & low GI CHO-
rich foods as well as high
protein
http://www.csiro.au/?sc_itemid={1873A95F-
6935-44F6-86A8-4D94E248F184}
18. High protein diets
Advantages
Prevent muscle
wasting when energy
is restricted
Improve satiety
Easier compliance for
some (at least short-
term)
As effective as low fat
for weight loss
Improved blood
glucose control &
metabolic syndrome
Disadvantages
High in red meat:
(opposing view to
cancer council)
Environmental impact
(non-meat protein
sources) cost
Unsure of long-term
effects, consider kidney
function, osteoporosis
Increased calcium
excretion
Long term compliance
19. Recommended Protein Intakes
RDI
Men 19-70 = 0.84g/kg – ‘average’ 64g/d
Women 19-70 = 0.75g/kg – ‘average’ 46g/d
AMDR
Men & Women 15 to 25%
• Requirements vary for age >70y, 2nd & 3rd trimesters
of pregnancy & lactation
• Infants & children have age-specific requirements
20. Absorption of iron
Factors
enhancing
absorption
• Vitamin C
• Haem iron (↑s
absorption non-haem
iron)
• Cooking
Factors reducing
absorption
• Soy protein
• Tannins
(tea, coffee, wines)
• Phytates/ fibre
(wholegrains)
• Calcium/ phosphorus
(dairy)
21. Role of iron in the body
Iron Haemoglobin
Oxygen
transport in
blood
Myoglobin
Oxygen store
in muscle
Metalloproteins
Ferritin
Iron
storage
Transferrin Iron transport
Cytochromes
Oxidation-reduction
reactions
22. Iron Deficiency Symptoms
• Fatigue (inability to mobilise O2)
• Decline in cognitive function
- inability to concentrate (adult)/ intellectual
impairment (child)
• Susceptibility to infections (impaired immunity)
• Decreased pain threshold
• Impaired heat regulation (can't adapt to cold) (
thyroxine)
23. Iron … excess
≤0.5% Caucasian
population at risk of
hereditary
haemochromatosis
Fe often interacts with
other minerals
Fe & Ca compete for
absorption
Fe poisoning in infants
‘Mummy’s lollies’ i.e. iron
tablets are little & red
24. Iron requirements
RDIs
0-6 months, infants use body stores
6 months+ 8-18mg (varies according to) age/gender
Women 19 to 50 years 18mg
Women aged ≥ 51 years 8mg
Pregnant women 27mg
Men aged ≥19 years 8mg
If iron deficiency anaemia diagnosed, iron supplements often medically
recommended
• Common side effects e.g. constipation
25. Calcium
Calcium is ~2% of total body weight
99.6% deposited as
calcium phosphate
crystals in bone
Strengthens bones & teeth
99.1% in intra- &
extracellular fluids
• Contraction/ relaxation
muscles
• Blood clotting
• Enzyme function
• Nervous system
messagesFood sources high
in calcium
include...
Milk, yogurt &
especially cheese
Fish with bones
26. Calcium absorption
Only ~30-40% absorbed in most Australian
diets
Combinations
that facilitate
absorption
Sugars
(especially
lactose)
Protein (in
milk & cheese)
Combinations
that inhibit
absorption
Dietary fibre
Oxalates
(spinach, beetroot, eggp
lant, celery, leafy
greens, squash etc)
Increases
solubility
Decreases
solubility
• s transit time
• stimulate
bacterial growth &
bacteria bind
minerals
• Phytates bind Ca
27. Calcium deficiency
• Decrease in bone density brittle weak bones (Osteoporosis)
• diet, exercise, body weight & genetics also affect development
• peak bone mass ~30 years of age
28. Calcium requirements
RDIs
1 year+ 500-1300mg
(varies according to age/gender)
Adults 1000mg/day
Older women >50yrs 1300 mg/day
Older men >70yrs 1300mg/day
Food preferred in place of supplementation
• supplementation may be helpful if at risk osteoporosis – consult doctor
• excess can cause GIT upsets
29. Vitamin D
80 to 90% of
requirements obtained
from sunlight
Available from a limited
range of foods
Deficiency/insufficiency
more widespread than
previously thought
Traditionally main role in
calcium absorption &
healthy bones
More recent research
indicates a much wider
role in health & disease
Main Dietary Sources
Tuna, salmon, sardines, eggs, fortified milk, cheese, margarine,
RoyLichtenstein,
SinkingSun,1964
32. Key nutrients obtained from extras
Macronutrients
Fat
Carbohydrate
Alcohol
Micronutrients
Sodium
BY DEFINITION EXTRAS ARE NOT ESSENTIAL FOR
ANY OF THESE NUTRIENTS – ALL CAN BE OBTAINED
FROM OTHER SOURCES
33. Extras – good or bad?
vs
Some ‘extras’ may
provide health benefits
over others
INCLUDING
MODERATION
SOMETIMES
Everything in
moderation
Mostly a concern if →excess energy intake
&/or replacing foods with essential nutrients
35. Fats & Lipids
saturated monounsaturated polyunsaturated
point of
unsaturation
points of
unsaturation
Effect on blood cholesterol levels vary between fats
36.
37. Beneficial fats
Monounsaturated FAs
Decrease total
& LDL
cholesterol &
TGs
Found in
• Monounsaturated margarine spreads
• Monounsaturated oils e.g. olive, canola &
peanut oils
• Nuts e.g. peanuts, cashews & almonds
• Seeds
• Avocado
38. Beneficial fats
Polyunsaturated FAs
Omega-6
Omega-3
Decrease total & LDL
cholesterol &
triglycerides
Decrease triglycerides
Increase HDL-cholesterol
Anti-platelet effects – lower risk of thrombosis
Decrease some inflammatory responses
Lower blood pressure
Found in
• Seeds & oils –
sunflower, safflower, soybean, sesa
me, grapeseed
• Polyunsat. margarine spreads &
oils
• Walnuts, brazil nuts, pinenuts
Found in
• Oils from
soybean, canola, mustard seed
• Marine sources (oily fish) e.g.
alantic
salmon, sardines, tuna, silver
perch, bass, herring, rainbow
trout, anchovy
39. Detrimental fats
Saturated fats Trans- fats
Found in
• Fatty meats
• Full fat dairy products
• Butter
• Coconut & palm oil
• Deep fried take-away foods
• Commercially baked products
Increases
total & LDL
cholesterol
Found in
• Small amounts in dairy
products, beef, veal, lamb &
mutton
• Baked goods
• pies & pastries
• cakes, biscuits & buns
Increases
total & LDL
cholesterol
May
Decreases
HDL
cholesterol
40. Functions of fat/fatty acids
Important roles in body!
Provide essential fatty acids & fat soluble vitamins
protect internal organs, provide insulation
membrane fluidity & structure
cell division
n-3 & n-6 affect formation of eicosanoids
Metabolic role in regulating physiological processes (e.g.
blood clotting, immunity, vascular tone)
Functions in palatability of food an satiety
41. Excess energy is stored as fat (triglycerides)
Stored as fat
Energy reserves for muscles
Insulation
thermal
mechanical
42. Recommended intake of fat
No Recommended Dietary Intake for total fat intake
Recommendation of 20-35% of total energy with
saturated & trans fats to be no more than 10% of
energy
i.e. saturated & trans one third of total fat
43. Deficiency Excess
Inadequate intake of
essential fatty acids -
linoleic, α-linolenic
Effect on usual fat
functions
Inadequate absorption
fat soluble vitamins
Inadequate energy
protein breakdown
Weight gain, overweight/
obesity development
chronic lifestyle related
disease
Excess saturated/ trans
increased cardiac risk
Thrombus
Inflammatory
Cells
Smooth
Muscle Cells
Fats & Lipids
44. Benefits Disadvantages
In small amounts
Reduces risk of heart
disease
some beverages
contain
phytochemicals
Inappropriate/excessive use
of
overweight
numerous nutrient
deficiencies
B vitamins
general malnutrition
digestive upsets
raised plasma triglycerides
foetal alcohol syndrome
long term liver & brain disease
accidental & violence related
hospital admissions
risky behaviour
social & psychological harm
Alcohol
45. NHMRC 2009 Alcohol Guidelines
Guideline 1:
For healthy men and women, drinking no
more than two standard drinks on any day
reduces the lifetime risk of harm from
alcohol-related disease or injury.
Guideline 2:
For healthy men and women, drinking no
more than four standard drinks on a single
occasion reduces the risk of alcohol related
injury arising from that occasion.
46. NHMRC 2009 Alcohol Guidelines
Guideline 3:
3A Parents and carers should be advised that
children under 15 years of age are at the
greatest risk of harm from drinking and that
for this age group, not drinking alcohol is
especially important.
3B For young people aged 15–17 years the
safest option is to delay the initiation of
drinking for as long as possible.
47. NHMRC 2009 Alcohol Guidelines
Guideline 4:
4A For women who are pregnant or planning
a pregnancy, not drinking is the safest
option.
4B For women who are breastfeeding, not
drinking is the safest option.
48. Sodium
Kidneys regulate sodium levels
Sweat loss only relevant in prolonged & unaccustomed heavy
exercise
Found in many foods
Traces wholegrains, meat & dairy products
Large amounts processed foods
Sodium
Maintenance of correct
volume of circulating
blood & tissue fluids
Role in electrical activity
of muscles & nerves
Control of water
movements between
muscles and tissues
49. Deficiency Excess
Rare but can be
dangerous
losses through
urine, perspiration, vomiting &
diarrhoea
Excessive loss can lead to
muscle
cramps, nausea, vomiting
& dizziness eventually
shock, coma & death
main causes
acute gastroenteritis
severe sweating
water intoxication (from
drinking too much water)
Mainly thought to
elevate blood pressure &
thus risk CVD & renal
disease
NOTE: not all
hypertension is due to
Na
51. Reducing intake to avoid chronic disease
Easiest effective methods?
high salt foods
choose /low salt breads/cereals/products
processed foods
avoid adding salt, use herbs & spices & fresh vegies for flavour
52. Summary of health effects of meat, dairy and extras
Meat
Dairy
Extras
Iron
Protein
Fat
Vitamin E
Retinol
(discussed in
Week 7)
Saturated
Monounsaturated
Polyunsaturated
Trans
↑d LDL
↑d HDL
↓d LDL
↓d HDL
Selective transport
into/ out of cells
Oxygen delivery/
storage/ transport
Osmotic pressure &
water balance
Iron transport/
storage
Stabilise nucleic acid
structure
Muscle contraction &
movement
Calcium
Strengthens bones &
teeth
Contraction/
relaxation muscles
Blood clotting
Enzyme function
Nervous system
messages
↓d risk heart disease
↑d risk heart disease
Sodium
↑d blood
pressure