SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  24
25-26 November, 2010
Kathmandu, Nepal
Proceedings of the National Consultation with the UN Special
Rapporteur on the situation of Human Rights Defenders
Margaret Sekkagya on
“Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights
Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection
Mechanisms”
Prepared by: Jyotsna Maskay, Giovanna Gioli 	 Layout: Ramesh Bhandari	
Edited by: Dr. Binayak Rajbhandari	 Published Year: 2011
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
2 3
LIST OF THE ACRONYMS AND
ABBREVIATIONS
BDS: Blue Diamond Society
CPA: Comprehensive Peace Accord
ESCR: Economic Social and Cultural Rights
EU: European Union
GoN: Government of Nepal
HRDs: Human Rights Defenders
INSEC: Informal Sector Service Center
IPs: Indigenous People
LGBTI: Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Intersex
NAWHRDs: National Alliance of Women Human Rights Defenders
NDC: National Dalit Commission
NHRC: National Human Rights Commission
NWC: National Women Commission
OHCHR: Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights
UNSR: United Nations Special Rapporteur
UPR: Universal Periodic Review
VAW: Violence Against Women
WHRDs: Women Human Rights Defenders
WOREC: Women's Rehabilitation Center
List of The Acronyms And Abbreviations 	 3
Acknowledgement	4
Introduction: Defenders on the Frontline	 6
Proceedings: Day 1	 11
Open Forum Discussion - Day 1	 22
Proceedings: Day 2	 28
Open Forum Discussion - Day 2	 32
Conclusions	34
Annex	37
List of Participants	 40
Songs by WHRD participants	 41
Table of Contents
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
4 5
Thank to Sudha Uprety, Andrew Palmer, and Bikram Tuladhar
from the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights for
the efforts in putting this event together.
I am highly indebted to Dr. Renu Rajbhandari, Program Advisor
of WOREC Nepal, and Chairperson of the National Alliance
of Women Human Rights Defenders, for her vision and her
encouragement to organize this event. I praise her continuous
struggles and efforts in highlighting the need to recognize women
as Defenders and in interlinking their different movements are
highly appreciated.
Special thanks to all the WOREC Nepal team members for their
relentless efforts, passion, translation support, and for pushing
through late night working hours, showing commitment, patience,
and cooperation.
I owe my deepest gratitude to Shaun Kirven, Human Rights
Defender and crucial member of the Defenders movement in
Nepal. This consultation would not have been possible without
their moral and technical support, and their belief in the Human
Rights Defenders of Nepal
Jyotsna Maskay
Executive Director,
WOREC Nepal
Acknowledgement
I would like to express my gratitude to all those who encouraged
and supported WOREC Nepal in the organization of this National
Consultation.
We salute all the Human Rights Defenders, the Women Human
Rights Defenders, LGBTI Defenders, Marginalized Defenders,
and Journalists for their resilience and their daily struggle to
defend Human Rights for us all. Without their persistent efforts
and their strong voices, this event would have been unthinkable.
This event would not have been successful without the moral
and technical support from INSEC, the Blue Diamond Society,
Advocacy Forum, and Protection Desk Nepal, who supported
the designing of this consultation since the beginning.
I would like to thank the EU Working Group on Human Rights
Defenders for their support in the attempt of negotiating a formal
visit of the United Nation Special Rapporteur on the situation of
Human Rights Defenders;
I would like to thank International Service for Human Rights
(ISHR, Geneva) for their financial and technical cooperation.
Special thanks to Clement Nyaletsossi Voule for his commitment
in promoting the rights of Human Rights Defenders.
Big thanks to all our resource persons and panelists for their
time and cooperation;
I am grateful to all the NGOs, INGOs, Networks, Alliances, and
Associations, for active participation and support in this event.
My sincere appreciation goes to the National Human Rights
Commissions, first of all for recognizing themselves as Defenders,
and for their support and commitment to protect and promote the
rights of Defenders.
Acknowledgement
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
6 7
Defenders on
the Frontline
INTRODUCTION
On the 21st of November 2006, the Seven
Party Alliance (SPA) and the CPN- Maoist
signed the Comprehensive Peace Accord
(CPA) and entered the Peace process, ending
more than a decade long political conflict, and
establishing the Federal Democratic Republic
of Nepal. All the parties involved in the peace
process have expressed their commitment
to uphold human rights and to prioritise the
rights of marginalized communities. However,
change has been very slow and the situation
has not improved substantially.
Even after 4 years of peace process, the
state of human rights in the country is very
fragile. The unwillingness of the government
to address impunity in the past has created a
situation of lawlessness and chaos.
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
8 9
and conviction, being deprived of proper legal
assistance and denied a fair trial. HRDs work
on the frontline, and this exposure opens
avenues of insecurity not only for them but
also for their families and colleagues. In fact,
family members are often used as a tool to
pressurise the defenders to withdraw from
their work.
WHRDs in Nepal have aimed at breaking the
well established culture of silence, responsible
for perpetuating their lack of access to rights.
The proactive stand of WHRDs defies the
feudal and patriarchal structures, relying on
unequal gender power relations and structural
inequalities. WHRDs are discriminated
against twice, for being women and for being
defenders. Similarly, LGBTI defenders often
face double discrimination: on the one hand
for defying the predominant heteronormativity,
and on the other hand for being defenders.
According to the documentation provided by
INSEC online, in 2009 the number of HRDs
victims of violence ranged up to 145, (Table
1). According to the data provided by WOREC
Nepal and BDS, the victims were respectively
69 and 106 (Table 2 and 3).
Table 1: Incidence of Violation of the Rights of Human Rights Defenders
(Jan 1- Dec 30, 2009)
Victims(Professionals) No. Incidence No. Victims Male Female
Teachers 49 71 66 5
Journalists 40 57 47 10
Health Workers 6 7 7
Human Rights Activists 6 8 6 2
Law Practitioners 2 2 2
Total 103 145 128 17
Source: Inseconline, 2009
There are evidences of police personnel
collaborating with criminals in abductions,
murders and other forms of crimes. Similarly,
there are data of abductions, killings and
extortions from members of different political
groups and youth wings of political parties;
however, these perpetrators are not/cannot
be arrested and prosecuted, as they are
being de facto granted amnesty by different
political parties.
Human Rights Defenders (HRDs) who dare
to defy the status quo are exposed to various
risks such as executions, torture, beatings,
arbitrary arrest and detention, death threats,
harassment and defamation. Besides, they
suffer from major restrictions to their freedom
of movement, expression, association and
assembly. HRDs face discrimination on
the basis of race, ethnicity, geography,
economic status, class, caste, access to
education, sexual orientation, ability and
age. In particular, WHRDs and Lesbian,
Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Intersex
defenders (LGBTI) are subjected to specific
risks and vulnerabilities due to their gender
and sexual orientation. Many evidences reveal
that WHRDs and LGBTI Defenders have
been constantly victim of false accusations
The data revealed that
there is an increasing
number of abduction,
killing and abuse
on journalists and
professionals who dare
to raise issues related
to the criminalization of
politics and to political
crimes. HRDs who
are working on issues
such as violence
against women (VAW),
Economic, Social
and Cultural Rights
(hereafter, ESCR),
Sexual Rights, bonded
labour and caste-based discrimination become
the target for violence, WHRDs and LGBTI
defenders being the most vulnerable ones.
Due to the absence of rule of law, the security
of Nepali citizens, and in particular of HRDs,
WHRDs and LGBTI defenders, has been put at
risk. Impunity for the crimes committed against
HRDs, and in particular against WHRDs and
LGBTI defenders, continues to present a
major challenge for the peace process and for
the security of marginalised groups.
The data further show that WHRDs
became victims of marginalization,
face harassment from private actors,
and from both state and non-state
actors. WHRDs face specific threats to
their work and capacity to contribute to
the human rights movement in Nepal.
Often, their own loved ones, male
colleagues, community members and
family members have been cited as
the main source of discrimination and
harassment. The lack of recognition
of the legitimacy and credibility of
women's work, even when they are operating
in the most difficult and risky settings, adds
to the risk faced by WHRDs. In the Nepali
society, even temporarily claiming a space
other than the domestic sphere may lead to
physical violence, threats or even murder.
The State's response to HRDs
The state bears primary responsibility in
respecting and protecting the rights of
individuals within its jurisdiction, including,
Table 2: Violation on WHRD from 2007 to 2009 – WOREC Nepal
S.No. Typology of Violation,
Risks and Constraints
Type of Incident Number
of case
1 Attacks on life, bodily and
mental integrity
Acid burn, Murder,
Attempted murder,
Mass rape, Beating
25
2 Physical and psychological
deprivation
Kidnap 2
3 Attacks against personhood
and reputations
Mental torture,
Threaten, Verbal abuse
39
4 Violations of women's
freedom of expression
Social violence, Loot 3
Total 69 104
Source: WOREC Nepal, 2004-2009
Table 3: Violation on LGBTI defenders
Types of incidents Number
of Case
N u m b e r
of Victim
Rape 2 3
Torture and illegal detention - 85
Killing 1 1
Restriction on movement 1 1
Threat ( Right to life) - 16
Total 106
Source: Blue Diamond Society, 2010
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
10 11
of course, those of HRDs. The state
responsibilities and obligations towards HRDs
have been rightly incorporated in the UN
Declaration on the Right and Responsibility
of Individuals, Groups and Organs of
Society to Promote and Protect Universally
Recognized Human Rights and Fundamental
Freedoms, which was adopted in 1998. Every
state has the responsibility to guarantee the
implementation of the rights enshrined in the
Declaration under the articles 2, 9, 12, 14 and
15. The Declaration emphasises the state's
responsibility to ensure effective remedy for
those who claim to have suffered from human
rights violation. The Nepali Interim Constitution
(2007) guarantees right to constitutional
remedy (corresponding to the rights enshrined
in the declaration), according to which a victim
can pursue judicial remedy. However, the
reality is that, in spite of the constitutional
guarantee of the right to justice, most of
the cases of HRDs are dismissed without
proper investigation. Some of the cases have
indeed been addressed by the judiciary, yet
deficiencies in the implementation can be
observed. During the people’s war, HRDs who
were struggling for rights and democratisation
of the state structures faced various forms
of violence and attacks. However, no inquiry
committee has been formed to investigate
the past human rights violations, nor have the
reported perpetrators been penalized. In this
scenario, it can be concluded that the people’s
right to remedy and reparations has been
largely ignored or not yet prioritised.
Despite the grim situation, some positive steps
have been taken by the government with the
adoption of the Domestic Violence Act, 2009
and the Declaration of the Prime Minister to
end all forms of Gender Based Violence are
two recent exemplary efforts to address VAW.
Also the Supreme Court directives to the
Government of Nepal (GoN) for developing
security policies for HRDs have to be
welcomed. The GoN receives large funding
support from the European Union (EU) for
sustainable peace and reconstruction. This
support obliges the GoN to implement the EU
Guidelines on HRDs and the EU guidelines
on VAW; regrettably, this obligation has been
de facto largely ignored.
In the light of the present scenario, this
consultation has been planned during the
'International 16 Days of Activism to end
Gender Based Violence', in order to shed
light on the situation of HRDs, in particular of
WHRDs and LGBTIs defenders, as well as of
defenders advocating for ESCRs. It aims at
creating a platform to make the work of HRDs
visible and to advocate, in collaboration with
the United Nation Special Rapporteur on the
situation of HRDs (UNSR), for a mechanism
to develop strategies for integrating the
security and protection of women and LGBTI
defenders into the mainstream agendas.
Furthermore, it intends to create and
strengthen the national, sub-regional and
regional coalitions and networks to enhance
the protection of defenders and to develop
proper policy suggestions and strategies in
order to guarantee the rights of HRDs.
T he 2-day National Consultation
comprised of three separate thematic
panels on the situation of HRDs, and on the
emerging and existing security and protection
mechanisms for HRDs.
1. Welcome remarks by Ms. Dev Kumari
Mahara, Women Human Rights Defender,
Terai, Nepal
Ms. Dev Kumari Mahara in her opening
remarks has outlined the main challenges
faced by WHRDs in the Terai region, with a
special focus on the situation of Dalit. The
human rights situation in Terai is particularly
difficult, as the region is infested by violent
armed groups, affiliated to different ideological
parties.Thesegroupshavelargelyaugmented
the violence in the region, as small arms have
been made readily available, thus increasing
the rates of killings, and murders in the region.
Many WHRDs have lost their lives in the past
years and they are constantly subjected to
various forms of assault, including rape and
threats of abduction and/or murder.
2. Mr. Subodh Raj Pyakurel, Chair, INSEC
Mr Subodh Raj Pyakurel stressed that the
very presence of the UNSR who represents
the HRDs worldwide, marks her interest in
addressing the issues and concerns of HRDs
in Nepal.
Pyakurel informed that, despite his persistent
request to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs,
the Ministry of Law, and other relevant
ministries to invite the UNSR on the situation
Proceedings
25 November 2010DAY 1
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
12 13
of HRDs for an official visit, they declined
on the ground that Nepal does not have the
technical capacity and the resources to host
her. Pyakurel also highlighted the immediate
and pressing need for a separate and
comprehensive law on HRDs in Nepal—a law
focusing on the security and protection of the
defenders.
I. 3. Launch of Anbeshi
An important milestone in addressing
the issue of VAW has been the launch of
WOREC Nepal's report "Anbeshi - Violence
Against Women Year Book 2009-2010". The
report was launched by UNSR Ms Margaret
Sakkagya, and by the Hon. Kedar Nath
Upadhaya (Chairperson, NHRC), in the
presence of over hundred HRDs, WHRDs,
LGBTI defenders, different organizations,
and journalists.
The major objectives of Anbeshi are as
follows:
•	 To map the scenario of VAW in Nepal
and to exert pressure on the government
for formulating relevant laws, policies and
action plans for the elimination of VAW.
•	 To identify key areas for ensuring access
of VAW survivors to justice, and lobbying
the government to effectively address
these issues.
•	 To identify the needs of VAW survivors,
and advocate for the creation of relevant
support mechanisms.
3. His Excellency Morten Jespersen, Embassy
of Denmark in Nepal
His Excellency Morten Jespersen thanked
WOREC Nepal for making this event possible,
despite the resistance from the Nepali
government in issuing an official invitation to
Ms. Margaret Segkkaya.
He praised HRDs, and
especially WHRDs,
acknowledging their pivotal
importance as agents of
change. They put their lives
at risk to defend fundamental
rights; they are providing
vital support to Nepal to
ensure that the state fulfills
its international obligations.
Full support to HRDs
is one of the major EU
priorities, as stated in the
EU Guidelines for HRDs, and on behalf of
the international community, Mr. Jespersen
expressed willingness and commitment to
protect HRDs. He explained how the EU
Guidelines have been implemented in close
collaboration with the Nepali chapter of the
EU Working Group on HRDs. It focuses on
the support and protection for HRDs, and on
the creation of networks for HRDs. Moreover,
they are currently working at facilitating an
official visit of the Rapporteur. Mr. Jespersen
clarified how their work is focused on different
issues, such as the protection and support to
HRDs, and the follow up on cases of attack
on HRDs. They also work for the support,
strengthening and broadening of the human
rights network. Field visit are also on the
agenda, to encourage HRDs operating in
rural areas.
As Nepal will be shortly reviewed under UPR,
on the 25th January 2011, Mr Jespersen had
suggested to use the UPR to raise questions
not only on the challenges faced by HRDs,
but also to provide recommendations to the
international community on how to ensure the
protection and security of HRDs.
4. Mr. Roberto Ricci, Officer in charge,
OHCHR, Nepal
Mr. Ricci expressed his gratitude for being
part of the Consultation. He said that whilst
much progress has been achieved in the past
few years, much still remains to be done to
strengthen the security mechanism for HRDs.
Mr. Ricci recalled the moment, in February
2005, when HRDs came under severe attack.
In the wake of that difficult moment, a political
space was created for OHCHR to open
an office in Nepal, in May 2005. He further
stressed on the importance of the initiatives of
various UN agencies in providing protection
to HRDs, such as David Johnson, his friend
and colleague, senior human rights advisor
to the UN Resident Coordinator. Since then,
the OHCHR has been trying to work closely
with the defenders for the improvement of
the human rights situation in Nepal. In fact,
it is fair to say that the OHCHR is in Nepal
because of HRDs and for HRDs.
The question is why a protection mechanism
now, when the peace process is slowly taking
place? Is the government failing to protect
you? Is the situation worse than before?
HRDs are, by definition, actors of change.
HRDs are challenging justice to promote
social transformation. They meet resistances,
as change always meets resistance. Nepal's
constitution is based on human rights, though
it accepts certain forms of discrimination.
Mr. Subodh Raj Pyakurel
Launch of Anbeshi
His Excellency Morten Jespersen
Mr. Roberto Ricci
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
14 15
Resistance shall be overcome. Even
national census, if participated, can become
challenging, as minorities would be exposed.
The NHRC, The National Dalit Commission
and the National Women Commission are
crucial for ensuring the protection of HRDs,
likewise the international community can play
a role (e.g. the EU Working Group on HRDs).
Mr. Ricci reported the OHCHR plan to launch
a tool kit for HRDs next year. The OHCHR
will organize its work around two thematic
priorities: impunity and discrimination. He
further added that they will continue to work
with the defenders on capacity-building,
monitoring and protection. He showed
concern, as in the current year high numbers
of VAW and violence against HRDs have
been recorded by OHCHR. The tool kit will
also address issues related to WHRDs. For
instance, it contains practical guidelines on
the monitoring of sexual and gender -based
violence. This kit should be ready early next
year. Finally, OHCHR will take further its
engagement and cooperation with all the
National Human Rights Institutions, and in
particular, with the NHRC.
5. Hon. Kedar Nath Upadhaya, Chairperson,
National Human Rights Commission
Raising the names of noted human rights
defenders such as Prakash Shah, Uma Singh,
Tika Bista, Laxmi Bohra, the Hon. Kedar
Nath Upadhaya, shed light on the precarious
situation in which HRDs and especially
WHRDs are forced to work. Rapes, murders,
threats, sexual harassment, are just some of
the abuses suffered by WHRDs. He pointed
out that WHRDs are subjected to ‘double
discrimination’, as a consequence of their
status as women, on the one hand, and as
HRDs, on the other. Because of this situation,
stringent laws should be formulated for
punishing the perpetrators. Special laws are
needed to defend HRDs, as they are doing a
very special work. HRDs should have a sense
of security, so that they can continue their
work. However, Nepal is now in a transitional
phase, and as a result of the delayed peace
process, defenders are exposed to higher
risks. Mr Upadhaya stressed the importance
of learning how other countries have tackled
similar problems, and he expressed its
gratitude to Ms. Margaret Sekkgaya and to
the organizers for making this event possible.
However, he conveyed his disappointment in
the GoN failure to formally invite Ms. Margaret
Sekkagya to Nepal, despite its attempt to
discuss this issue with the Prime Minister and
with the Finance Minister.
He finally added that HRDs are always on the
frontline, operating at the local level. Because
of this, the society recognizes and trusts them.
It has to be always kept in mind that HRDs
are citizens too. They need to be protected
and in order to achieve this goal, politicians
have to become accountable; they have to
learn the philosophy that all the citizens of the
state are equal.
5. Ms. Margaret Sekkagya, United Nations
Special Rapporteur on the situation of Human
Rights Defenders
Ms. Sekkagya expressed her gratitude and
empathy for the suffering of HRDs. She
highlighted the similar situation faced by
HRDs in different countries, such as Brazil,
Fiji, Congo, Sudan, and Colombia where
she recently was on an official visit. She
further mentioned the specific context faced
by HRDs in Nepal: discrimination, arrests,
abductions, killings, rape, sexual abuse,
bondage, politicization of the work of HRDs,
poor protection mechanisms, HRDs being
terrorized by groups and being accused of
witchcraft.
She added that HRDs still struggle despite 12
years have passed since the passing of the
UN Declaration on Human Rights Defenders.
However, this declaration must be promoted
in Nepal. The state must investigate human
rights violation, and impunity must be
removed.
She concluded with a pledge to act in her
maximum possible capacity to end violations
and crimes against HRDs in Nepal. She
committed to raise the plights and concerns of
HRDs at the United Nations Security Council
and reiterated her pledge to the WHRDs
hoping that they would advocate for making
the government of Nepal extend an official
invitation to the UNSR.
6. Dr. Renu Rajbhandari, Chairperson,
NAWHRDs
Dr.RenuRajbhandarifocusedherpresentation
on two phenomena that are increasingly
affecting today’s Nepal, the Politicization
of Crime and the Criminalization of Politics.
She shared her concerns on the limitation
currently imposed on freedom of expression
in the country, supporting her speech with
Hon. Kedar Nath Upadhaya
UN Special Rapportuer
Ms. Margaret Sekkagya
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
16 17
recent figures showing increasing number
of abductions, killing and abuse perpetrated
on journalists and professionals who dared
to raise crucial and hot issues related to the
situation of human rights. The scenario is
even darker for HRDs working in the Madesh
region, due to the emergence of 109 armed
groups. The presence of these groups has
resulted in an escalation of violence against
HRDs, which continue to receive threats and
to suffer from violence.
Dr. Rajbhandari further elaborated that unless
the human rights movement proceeds in a
cohesive and integrated manner, massive
violence and human rights violations will
continue on a daily basis. She identified the
human rights movement as the major possible
actor in contrasting the rising militarization
of Nepal. Nevertheless, state commitment
is pivotal, and a crucial step would be the
development of a specific law to ensure the
protection of HRDs.
7. Ms. Bindu P. Gautam, Researcher,
WOREC Nepal
Ms. Gautam presented the result of the
joint research conducted by WOREC Nepal
and Isis WICCE, "Redefining Justice:
Research findings on Access to Justice
for Rape Survivors". The purpose of the
study was to inform policy makers, activists
and organizations enabling them to access
appropriate information in order to effectively
address VAW. Ms. Gautam highlighted as
major objective of the study, the identification
of gaps and challenges in existing response,
and the drafting of policy and action
recommendation for establishing effective
mechanisms and ensuring the survivors’
rights to justice.
Ms. Gautam explained the method and the
sources of the research, which included in-
depth interviews with Survivors (55), and
interview with key Informants (112). The
surveyinvolvedalsoFocusGroupDiscussions
(33), interaction with community women (14),
WHRDs(10), Paralegal Committee (4), and
Others (5). Secondary Source such as media
Survey (201) and case collection and analyses
from different organizations (723) were also
used. The concerned areas are the Terai:
Morang, Dhanusha, Kailali (Eastern, Central,
Far-Western), the Hilly belt: Udayapur (inner-
Terai), Dailekh, Baglung, Kathmandu, Kavre
(Eastern, Western, Mid-Western,, Central),
and the High Hills and Mountains belt:
Dolakha, Darchula (Mid-Western and Far-
Western).
Ms. Gautam shared that women in the
concerned areas are facing different forms
of violence, such as verbal abuses against
WHRDs, witchcraft accusations, polygamy,
domestic violence, sexual violence, marital
rape, rape and murder, vilification and slander.
The victims of rape resulted to be prevalently
women, disabled, sexual minorities, WHRDs,
conflict affected people and boys. Women
bodies are commonly used to seek revenge,
to silence voices of protest, to show power, to
humiliate/defame the family and community,
to prove a male’s masculinity and to fulfill
sexual hunger.
Finally, Ms. Gautam explored the existing
response mechanisms. Family proved to be
disempowering in most cases. As for the
community, organized groups/networks and
(W)HRDs are the most effective in addressing
rape and other violence, however they are
facing major challenges (e.g. abuse, assault,
humiliation, threat), and they are neglected
both by the state and non-state actors.
Paralegal Committees are resent but they
need assessment.
Responses from NGOs/civil society feature
a limited coverage and scope for immediate
support to victim. Some positive steps have
been taken by the government, however
their scope and effectiveness has to be
questioned. No support mechanism is
envisaged at the community level, and NHR
Institutions have limited resources and limited
access. Legally, the major gaps highlighted
by Ms. Gautam are the absence of a clear
definition of rape, and the narrowness of
its, the discriminatory provisions pertaining
punishment; the exclusive focus on the right
of the Criminal, and the absence of legal
provisions ensuring victim’s rights (protection,
recovery/ rehabilitation, reintegration into
society).
9. Subodh Raj Pyakurel, Chair, INSEC
Mr. Subodh Raj Pyakurel, highlighted that
despite the amount of energy spent by NGOs
for the upholding of human rights, the situation
will not significantly improve, unless these
activities are included within the National
Action Plan of the government. Culture,
property, dowry, in Nepal, this is all in the
hands of males. In the villages, widespread
practices need to be changed, and economic
discrimination should be challenge. To
succeed, a holistic solution is needed.
He explained that the only institutions which
have the ability to reach every household are
the political parties. If they plan to impart the
•	 PANEL 1: The contemporary issues and challenges faced by Human Rights Defenders
•	 (Moderator: Mandira Sharma, Executive Director, Advocacy Forum).
•	 Objective: The objective of this discussion was to identify the major risks and challenges
faced by different groups of HRDs, such as WHRDs, LGBTI Defenders, marginalized
defenders, and victims groups, active in the promotion and protection of human rights.
The panel will also provide a preview of the specific risks and vulnerabilities faced by
defenders.
Dr. Renu Rajbhandari Ms. Bindu P. Gautam
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
18 19
message of human rights and HRDs during
their election campaign, then they will be able
to bring about pronounced changes in the
country within a single campaign.
Mr. Pyakurel also highlighted the fact that
those defenders who litigate a case of violation
are the most at risk; therefore, it is extremely
important to raise the issue of their protection.
However, Pyakurel pointed out that Nepal
seriously lacks a meaningful decision-making
process and effective decision-makers. He
further stressed the importance of discussing
with the stakeholders in order to develop law
from the perspective of the victims.
10. Ms. Manisha, Blue Diamond Society, on
the situation of LGBTI defenders
Speaking on behalf of the LGBTI community,
Manisha explored some of the key challenges
faced by the group. She stressed the urgent
need to make provisions for LGBTIs and
defenders to fully entitle them to citizenship
rights and to prevent sexuality-based
discrimination.
She explained that LGBTIs are often facing
stigmatization, even from their own families.
They are also severely discriminated against
in the job market, as they encounter major
difficulties in finding employment and are
often forced to leave their jobs. Sometimes,
as a consequence of this lack of opportunities
in the job market, LGBTIs are left with the
only option of entering the sex market.
This situation is fuelled by the widespread
prejudice according to which, all LGBTIs are
sex workers and eunuchs.
On the issue of citizenships, Manisha
highlighted the challenges faced by
transgender people, whose gender identity is
not recognized on the passport. She shared
her recent experience on this issue. While
travelling to Geneva to attend a meeting at
the Human Rights Council, she was treated
with respect by the Nepali officers, but she
encountered problems while transiting in
Doha. As the gender declared on her passport
did not match her physical appearances, she
was stopped and her passport was checked
all over again. After a long time she was
released but the officials kept a photocopy of
her passport. Manisha further stressed that,
despite their huge contribution to the human
rights movement, LGBTI defenders are often
discriminated against by other activists.
Besides, the NHRC has failed into seriously
dealing with the LGBTI community, especially
in the protection of LGBTIs defenders. She
further added that there should be a specific
campaign on sexual health rights. Finally she
added that issues related to LGBTIs remain
unaddressed also in the interim constitution.
Currently, there is no mention of LGBTIs in
any of the committee reports submitted by the
CA.
11. Mr Chandra Singh Kulung, Founder of
the Durban Review Committee (DRC)
Mr. Singh Kulung, pointed out the most
important challenges faced by marginalized
defenders. He first focused on the situation
of indigenous people. They are marginalized,
and their right to preserve their distinct
identity and representation (e.g. respect to
their dress, ornaments, appearance) must be
protected. Indigenous women are even more
discriminated against, and they are more
subjected to trafficking and to HIV/AIDS. In
ordertochangethestatusquo,thegovernment
should implement the ILO 169, UNDRIP, and
other international human rights instruments.
Moreover, the state should recognize all the
indigenous ethnic communities meeting the
characteristics of indigenous nationalities.
It is also necessary to develop a common
understanding about the rights of Indigenous
Peoples (IPs) between/among IPs, non-IPs
and the government. He added that in the
Terai/Madesh region, the situation of IPs is
even more difficult, as they are facing political
pressure form identitarian movements, such
as "One Madhesh One Pradesh".
Mr. Singh Kulung had then addressed the
situation of Dalit in Nepal. The challenge
here would be obtaining a change in the
mind of the feudalists, making room for the
implementation of pro-Dalit law. Moreover,
the government must implement the
Convention on Elimination of All kinds of
Racial Discrimination (CERD), as well as
other relevant human rights treaties.
Common Challenges of HRDs (by State and Non-State actors)
Personal Insecurity (During Profession) Personal Insecurity
(In Custody)
Killing Harassment: Ill-treatment
Abduction •	 Arrests and Fines Incommunicado
Disappearance •	 Restriction on Movement Intimidation
(frightening sb)
Attacks/Physical Destruction •	 Raids Repression
Threatening •	 Eviction (being evicted) Confiscation (loosing
ownership)
•	 In person •	 Refraining (stop doing the
work)
Retaliation
•	 Family/Beloved ones
•	 Family/Beloved Ones •	 Arbitrary Detention Mental Torture
Physical Torture
Ms. Manisha
Mr Chandra Singh Kulung
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
20 21
Mr. Singh finally touched on the measures to
be taken for integrating differently able people,
and LGBTIs. As for the first group, it is central
to ensure friendly means of transportation,
housing, apartment and office, as well as
the proper equipment for education (such
as brail script, sign language etc). Means for
livelihoods - employment, entrepreneurship
and economic activities - have to be provided
too. As for the LGBTI community, a deep
change in the prevailing mindset of society
is required. LGBTIs’ rights must be ensured
through the proper implementation of the
concerned laws.
12. Ms. Rita Thapa on the situation of
Women Human Rights Defenders
Ms. Rita Thapa presented the case study of
Nirmala Thapa, a WHRD who disappeared
in April 2009. After 4 days, her body was
found in the Dhading River. All her jewellery
had been removed, and her underpants had
been stripped off. Her 12 years old son said
that she had been victim of domestic violence
for the past 2 years. WOREC Nepal stepped
in to bring the case to justice, providing
documentation and legal assistance. As a
result of this, Nirmala’s husband was jailed.
After an appeal to the Supreme Court, the
case is currently waiting for the final hearing.
Ms.Thapathensummarisedthecurrentissues
of WHRDs. First of all, there is a dramatic
ineffectiveness of state’s structures, which
need to be reorganized and empowered.
Besides, a heightened state of impunity is
present in the country, facilitating other two
dangerous processes which are currently
increasing: the criminalization of politics, and
the political protection of criminals. This state
of affair has led to increasing rates of violence
(both in the domestic and public sphere),
often resulting in attempts to silence WHRDs
(e.g. Uma Singh, Suntali Dhami, Tika Bista
and many others).
Ms. Thapa shared that due to the patriarchal
values and norms embedded in the Nepali
society, women defenders are relegated to
inferior and subservient positions and roles.
Because of the political instability, rampant
impunity is widespread in the country. As
a consequence, there is no conducive
environment for defenders to exert their right
to defend. Women’s defenders are defying
this situation putting their life at serious
risk. Nevertheless, their action is not at all
recognized as work by both the society and
the state.
Ms Thapa has then provided some
recommendationstoendVAW.Shehighlighted
the pivotal role of the government in ensuring
WHRDs’ protection. Structures, networks
and mechanisms should be developed and
all perpetrators shall be held accountable
(including those under state protection).
Nepal is in a post-conflict, “transitional
phase”, and the government should seriously
take into account the implementation of UN
Security Council Resolution 1325 and 1820.
The other preventive measures should be the
establishment of an Early Warning System,
and the systematic documentation of cases.
Mr. Shaun Kirven (Researcher and
consultant)
Mr. Kirven wanted to ask some questions
about why we are here and what we are
trying to accomplish. He said that despite
the morning being spent speaking about
violence, the core issues concerning what
constitutes violence against women have not
been touched yet.
In Nepal, women cannot inherit
property, they have no access to
economic market, and they are traded
between families, just to mention some
of the major issues. These things need
to be tackled. If perhaps they had
economic status, violence would not
happen. It seems as if we are treating
the symptoms and not the cause.
Discrimination, however, does not
stop there. There is sexuality-based
violence, ethnic-based violence and
many other forms of discrimination, all
leading to violence.
Ms. Rita Thapa
Mr. Shaun Kirven
How to tackle these discriminations? First of
all, a question should be asked: How do we
deal with our own prejudices? We all have
them, but most of the times we do not deal
with them. Maybe even in this consultation.
The state has to protect us, it is its obligation,
but when violence is coming from families and
from the community, the state is not likely to
intervene. Therefore, we have to find ways to
convince the public that our work as HRDs is a
proper job, which benefits everyone. We can
do that only by being inclusive, which means,
in the first place, working on our prejudices.
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
22 23
The floor was open to the participants to
raise their questions, concerns and to
share their experience.
a. Manica Jha, Journalist & WHRD,
Dhanusha. district
Manica Jha, a journalist and WHRD from
Dhanusha district, had expressed serious
concerns over her safety as a WHRD working
in the Terai region. She shared her fear of
being murdered in the same way as her friend
and colleague, Uma Singh (a noted WHRD
journalist).
b. Sanjay Sharma, Eastern Region
Coordinator, Blue Diamond Society (BDS)
Sanjay shared that recently a lesbian was
raped by the cadres of a political group. The
case was filed at the local police station. The
police tried to silence the victim by offering
NRs. 60,000 as compensation. When the
local BDS group went there to investigate
OPEN
FORUM DISCUSSION
on the incident, Sanjay Sharma was beaten
up by a group of people in front of the Senior
Superintendent Police office, in Biratnagar.
ThelackofrecognitionLGBTIdefenders’work,
along with the absence of support systems
for marginalized defenders, greatly enhances
the chance of secondary victimization by the
local or state authorities.
c. Narayan Subedi, INSEC, Nepalgunj
Mr. Subedi shared that HRDs cannot exert
their right to freedom of mobility while
exercising their right to defend human rights
in the mid western region. They face risks and
vulnerabilities such as fear of being attacked
while trying to travel from one part of the
region to another during monitoring of human
rights violation, implementation of activities.
d. Ms. Lata joshi, WHRD network, Doti
Ms. Joshi shared that on the past 8th of
March, one girl was taken to Silguri, in the
attending this Consultation.
f. Mandira Sharma, Executive Director of
Advocacy Forum
Ms. Sharma highlighted how HRDs have
been reacting to the challenges they face
in their work on a daily basis, by organizing
themselves through the creation of networks
at both the central and the district level.
However, no protection mechanism for
ensuring the security of HRDS has been
established yet. There is no national law
addressing the issue. At the international
level there is the UN Declaration, however, in
order to ensure its efficacy, this fundamental
instrument has to become legally binding.
The legal context is very important, but our
strategies as HRDs are equally important. Ms.
Sharma said that HRDs are aware of many
cases, and there is a very active participation
aimed at helping the victim to get justice.
Thanks to their work, HRDs understand the
gravity of the culture of impunity in Nepal,
which has to be addressed and analyzed.
When an incident occurs, HRDs are there,
documenting and supporting, however, over
the time, it evaporates. We shall address
the root causes of such ineffectiveness, by
fighting for justice till the end. We might have
different hats, but as defenders we shall all
follow the principles of HRDs.
Doti Districts by the staff working in a health
post, to work as a domestic helper. Until
April 10th, the girl was sexually abused
by the man. The police then alerted the
WHRDs network. She shares her story with
us and subsequently some members of the
WHRDs network, Mahila Adhikar Manche
and a couple of other organizations brought
the case forward. They went to the police
and submitted a First Information Report,
demanding for the perpetrator to be arrested.
However, due to political protection granted
to the perpetrator by the local political parties,
he was granted amnesty. Ms. Joshi said that
this is very sad, as the very parties which are
supposed to help the movement of HRDs are
actually working against them.
Also many HRDs changed their mind on the
cases, as a result of the pressure exerted
by the political parties they were attached
to. The same thing happened to some of
the perpetrators' colleagues, working at
the health post, who protested blocking the
streets when the Court issued the order to
arrest the perpetrator. On top of this, a case
was filed against us for defamation against
the perpetrators.
e. Woman from the WHRDs network
A WHRD has raised the issue of disability:
disabled women encounter an unfriendly
environment in aircrafts, buses and public
transportation and services. We, as women
and as disabled women, feel discriminated
against. Although the government has ratified
the UN Convention on the Rights of the
People with Disabilities, its implementation
is still rather weak or nonexistent, as it is
illustrated by our experiences. The last
recent examples of this are the difficulties we
had to face in order to reach Kathmandu for
DAY 1
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
24 25
1. Ganga Thapa, Protection Desk-Nepal
Protection Desk-Nepal (PD-N) has been
conducting capacity building and security
training for HRDs across the country since
2006, and has specific programs for WHRDs,
victim groups, and LGBTI defenders and
organizations
PD-N also aims at supporting local defenders,
victims and other vulnerable groups to
integrate their protection into the agendas of
state authorities. National and international
organizations have encouraged an active
role of all stakeholders in the protection of
defenders. As a result, the EU working group
on HRDs was established as a part of the
EU local implementation strategy for the
EU Guidelines on HRDs, of which PD-N is
also a member. Within this working group, a
sub-group has been formed to monitor and
document human rights violation, compile
and analyze information from reliable
sources, generate recommendations, and
work on selected emblematic cases. As a part
of the local implementation strategy, the EU
Working Group organized a trip to Eastern
and Far western Region for assessing the
situation of HRDs.
PD-N organized a regional consultation
(supported by the German Embassy) on
protection mechanism for HRDs in all the
five development regions of Nepal. These
consultations brought together, 1000 people
including WHRDs, LGBTI defenders, trade
unions, religious groups, journalists and
political parties to discuss the diverse
needs of the defenders, who made specific
recommendations for their protection. These
recommendations were directed to the state,
the EU embassies and the national human
rights institutions, as well as to the civil
society.
PANEL 2: Coping mechanisms and strategies
developed by Human Rights Defenders in
the context of impunity, political impasse
and non-recognition of their work—linking
the movement. Moderator: Mr. Ganesh BK,
Human Rights Alliance
Objective: The objective of this discussion
was to understand and analyze the different
mechanisms and strategies developed by
diverse defenders to enforce and protect
human rights. This panel also showed
how defenders have developed collective
strategies to guarantee their security and
protection.
PD-N continuously meets with human rights
organizations and HRDs in the region to
monitor their situation and provide counselling
on security measures. PD-N has been
working closely with WOREC, INSEC and
BDS to implementing the recommendations
of the regional consultation.
2. Mr. Kosh Raj Neupane, Deputy Director,
National Human Rights Commission
Mr. Neupane shared that there is lack of
state policy on the protection and security
of HRDs. Due to geographical disparities,
defenders operating outside the Kathmandu
valley can access limited information and
resources. Likewise, the lack of cohesion and
coordination amongst the defenders prevents
them from accessing effective protection. He
further stressed the need to establish an Early
Warning and Rapid Response Mechanism
for defenders at risks, and the responsibility
of the government to develop specific laws
on HRDs, along with the upholding of the UN
Declaration on HRDs.
Open discussion
a. Mr. Manoj Bachhan, Lawyer and
Secretary, Madeshi HRDS Network, Jagrit
Mr. Bachhan highlighted the situation in
the Madhesh area, where his organization
operates. He said that they have been
experiencing many problems; in particular,
the most worrying are the rampant impunity
and the proliferation of armed groups,
together with the rising of criminal groups.
Given the situation, HRDs are often forced to
work with criminal groups and with corrupted
police personnel.
He explained the nature of the work
performed by its organization, stressing their
collaboration with women’s organizations
and CBOs. He stressed that CBOs (whose
working area is confined) work closely with
WHRDs at the local level.
He further identifies some of the core
issues they are addressing: the issue of
‘untouchability’, domestic violence, witchcraft
accusations, and incestuous rape. Another
major problem in the Terai region is extra
judicial killings: as Nepal shares a border with
India, both border forces are often involved in
cases of VAW.
b. Sunil Kumar Sah, Samagra Jana Uthan
Kedra, Chairperson, Siraha District
Mr. Sah explained that his organization works
in close collaboration with the WHRDs network
in the Siraha district. They provide support for
cases of violence against WHRDs, or for the
relocation of WHRDs from the Siraha and
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
26 27
Saptarai districts. These WHRDs still fight,
irrespective of the attacks and the torture they
have been inflicted. Mr. Sah and its association
recognize the huge contribution to peace and
democracy given by WHRDs and stresses that
they are trying their best to ensure justice for
the victims. HRDs work in close collaboration
with WHRDs, and regular meetings are held.
Mr. Sah shared that recently a 7-year-old girl
was raped by a 35-year-old man. The girl
was saved by his organization. The parents
of the girl did not own enough money to have
her treated adequately at the hospital, so
they prioritized the necessity of protecting
the honour of the family, neglecting the
importance of her treatment. The parents
were stopped in Lahan, by the HRDS network,
which fundraised for the treatment of the girl.
Mr. Sah further elaborated that the network
received support also from the police. The girl
was taken to Rajbiraj for receiving treatment,
and she had to undergo two major operations.
Luckily she was able to return home. This is
just an example of how the HRDs networks
work collaboratively together.
c. Shivamaya Thumbahamphey, member
of the NAWHRDs
Ms. Thumbahamphey shared that WHRDs do
not get any form of support from the police.
Therefore, they mainly work in coordination
with government agencies, and with NGOs,
as they are interested in upholding and
protecting women’s rights. She said that
WHRDs face major challenges, and they try
to cope by sitting together with government
agencies and NGO to discuss possible
remedies. She further added that, when
discussing about the rights of WHRDs, they
should not be the only part concerned. It is in
everyone’s best interest to raise the issue of
human rights.
d. Kasala, WHRDs network, Bardiya
district
Ms. Kasala responded to the presentation of
Mr. Manoj Bachhan, who said that often, HRDs
have to work in close relation with criminal
groups and with the police. She shared that
recently, in the Bardiya district, two children
were killed. They witnessed that government
bodies, such as the security forces and the
investigation section, as well as some HRDs,
were supporting the criminal groups. As a
result of this, the whole definition of HRDs
comes under question. During the conflict,
irrespective of where we work, we worked
as defenders. However, the situation has
changed, and today many HRDs are close to
either criminal groups or political parties.
How do we define a HRD? The universality
of human rights has to be ensured by HRDs,
throughaneutralaction,freefrompartypolitics
and hidden agendas. However, especially in
the Terai region, criminal activities are often
done in the name of human rights. In such
situation it is very difficult to work.
e. WHRD, WHRDs network, Solukhumbu
district
Women across Nepal have become aware of
the budget allocated by the government for
the advancement of women and of gender
equality. Subsequently, they have come to
realise the importance of discussing about
women's issues in order to be able to submit
a consistent proposals to the government.
However, the political parties tend to interfere
in matters of gender budget, not respecting the
fact that the budget is meant to be allocated
for the empowerment of women.
f. Sarita KC, WHRD, Chitwan District
Ms. KC shed lights on the situation of WHRDs,
sharing a case she has been recently involved
in. A woman was raped in her district. After 3
days the perpetrators' families came to her.
The perpetrators had fled away and they were
willing to pay compensation (200.000 rupees)
to the victim. She refused the deal and the 4
perpetrators were imprisoned by the police.
The big political parties exerted pressure
on her, asking why she was getting their
cadre imprisoned. Even members of the CA
were pressuring the police, saying that the
perpetrators should have been released.
HRDs were present too, lobbying the CDO
and the police in order to get justice and avoid
the release of the perpetrators. In the evening,
they received a phone call saying: "Get out of
your house, we are going to vandalise your
property". She replied that she was not a
coward, and she did not run away. After 2-3
days she was stopped by two boys but when
they saw her face, they let her go. This is due
to the fact that she is a recognized HRD and
political leader, so that she could stand for her
own rights, without being violated. However,
had it been another woman, she would have
been raped. Those are the kind of risks faced
by defenders.
WHRD, WHRDs Network, Baglung District
She stated that the situation of women in Nepal
is not homogenous, as, even within women,
Dalit women and women from marginalised
community are disproportionately suffering
from human rights violation.
Mr. Ganesk BK, Human Rights Alliance
Mr. Ganesh BK said that there have not been
significant political changes in the country, in
spite Nepal being declared as a Democratic
FederalRepublicin2007.Hesharedhisrecent
experience in the Dailekh and Baitadi districts,
where he managed to meet with some Haliya
women. They expressed their understanding
of Nepal through a song. The song mentioned
the fact that their landlords are still referred
to as masters, as they were called before the
people's movement. This might be seen as
an irrelevant issue of terminology, but these
women wanted to explain how the feudal
attitude of their master has not changed yet,
and major discriminations are still taking
place. Mr. BK further added that HRDs face a
lot of challenges, which need to be prioritized
in the government agenda.
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
29
DAY 2
1. Mr. Shiva Bhandari, Contact person for
the European Working Group on Human
Rights Defenders
Mr. Bhandari introduced himself as the contact
person for the EU Working Group on HRDs,
shedding light on the existing security and
protection mechanisms for HRDs as foreseen
by the EU Guidelines on HRDs. He further
elaborated on the scope and nature of the
activities of the EU Working Group, focusing
on Gender Specific provisions for WHRDs.
PANEL 3: Emerging and existing mechanisms for the protection and security of
human rights defenders.
Objective: The objective of this discussion is to reflect on the emerging and existing
mechanisms that has been developed and designed for the protection of Human Rights
Defenders by different agencies. This will also discuss how those mechanisms have been
implemented.
He said that issues related to WHRDs shall
be taken into serious consideration, and that
the concerns raised during the first day of the
present National Consultation with the UNSR
must be given the highest attention and
priority. Economical and technical support
shall be provided.
Mr. Bhandari also informed the audience of
the EU Action Plan 2010-2015 on HRDs,
which contains a set of instructions for EU
member states to work on this issue. Finally,
he invited the crowd to directly contact the EU
for further information, e.g. by contacting the
forum of the EU
2. Mr. Kosh Raj Neupane, Deputy Director,
NHRC
Speaking on behalf of the NHRC, Mr.
Neupane said that the mandate of the NHRC
is to promote and protect human rights,
to investigate and monitor human rights
violations, and to provide recommendations
to the government for the improvement of
the human rights situation in the coutry. To
a certain extent, he said, the NHRC mandate
can be assimilated to that of a court.
MrNeupanefurtherelaboratedthattheNHRC,
in case of a violation being committed, follows
a two-step process: 1. Make the perpetrators
accountable; 2. Ensure compensation and
reparation to the survivors and/or their
dependents. As a preventive measure, the
NHRC has established a Rapid Response
Mechanism (RRM), to deal with human rights
violation more effectively.
The NHRC is also responsible for developing
guidelines for HRDs. In addition, the NHRC
also builds the capacity of HRDs through
Mr. Hari Phuyal
Mr. Kosh Raj Neupane
Mr. Shiva Bhandari
training programmes, working in close
collaboration with the civil society.
3. Mr. Hari Phuyal, Human Rights Lawyer
Mr. Phuyal highlighted the legal procedures
28
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
30 31
that can be followed in case of human rights
violation. In the case of criminal offences,
the following actions are envisaged: File the
First Information Reports (FIRs) at the Police
after any occurrence of violence; if the Police
refuse to file the case, the victim can then
approach the Chief District Officer (CDO);
once the case has been endorsed by the
CDO, it can be taken to the Appellate Court.
Mr. Phuyal explained that in incidence of
domestic violence, the victim can approach
the District Court for demanding justice. He
further added that the victims can also lodge
complaints to the National Human Rights
Institutions, such as the NHRC, the NWC and
the NDC, in case of specific types of violation.
He then added that different human rights
organizations can also play a pivotal role
in addressing the redress demand of the
victims. Besides, they are central for raising
the victim’s voice and disseminating it through
the media.
Mr. Phuyal further explained that international
mechanisms are also available, in
conjunction with the national ones. When
national mechanisms fail to provide justice,
international instruments, such as diplomatic
missions and the International Criminal Court
can be approached.
4. Kamal Pathak, Advocacy Forum, on
international and regional mechanisms
Highlighting the fact that there are no regional
security mechanisms in South Asia for
Human Rights Defenders, Mr. Pathak briefed
on the existing regional and international
mechanisms for the protection of (W)HRDs.
He stressed that the South Asian Association
of Regional Coorpearation (SAARC), as a
regional body, lacks separate strategies or
protection mechanisms on human rights.
He explained that there are 5 international
mechanisms and 1 regional mechanism for
South East Asia. The international regional
mechanisms comprises of a) The African
Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights,
b) The Inter-American Commission for
Human Rights, c) The Council of Europe and
its Commission for Human Rights, d) The
Office for Democratic Institutions and Human
Rights for the Organization for Security and
Co-operation in Europe and e) The 2004 EU
Guidelines on HRDs.
Mr. Pathak, stressed the fact that South
Asia is lacking a regional instrument on
HRDs, despite such a possibility has been
explored during the regional consultation,
held in Kathmandu in 2009. During this event
HRDs from all over South Asia met and
discuss various options to establish such a
mechanism.
Mr. Pathak elaborated on the necessity of
a regional instrument. He said that HRDs
are always on the frontline in the promotion
and protection of human rights. However,
despite their efforts to uphold human rights,
governments, national laws, police forces,
etc., fails to provide adequate protection, thus
reducing the scope of HRDs’ action.
5. Ms. Sudha Uprety, OHCHR
Ms. Uprety shared on the implementation
of the UN Declaration on HRDs linking it
with treaty bodies. She explained that the
international human rights mechanisms can
be divided into two, Treaty-based mechanism
(CEDAW; CESCR; HRC; CERD; CAT;
CRC; CMW; CRPD) and Charter-based
mechanism (UPR; human rights council and
Special Procedures). She further elaborated
that national, regional and international
mechanisms are available for the protection
and security of HRDs. Amongst the
international mechanism, the UN Declaration
of HRDs is a legally binding instrument, and
its adoption by the state would strengthen its
potential as a support tool for human rights
and human rights defenders. Its inclusion
within a State’s domestic legislation would
facilitate its application by the judiciary and
respect for it by State authorities.
Ms. Uprety highlighted the importance of a
correct implementation of the Declaration by
the state. This process involve implementing
the Declaration’s provisions, monitoring
the progress made, and publishing a report
indicating what steps have been taken and
those articles in relation to which concerns
remain. Further developing, in consultation
with civil society, shall be considered, and
a plan of action for the implementation
of the Declaration must be published.
The state must also disseminate the
Declaration through information and training
programmes targeting, for example, HRDs
themselves, state officials, intergovernmental
organizations and the media.
Ms. Uprety concluded by stressing on
the importance of linking the three level
of mechanism (national, regional and
international) together. She added that the
international and regional norms require
national implementation to be effective, and
national norms should be consistent with
international and regional standards. Finally,
international and regional judicial protection
shall be used only when national remedies
have been exhausted internationally.
6. Ms. Iona Liddell, Communication Officer,
Peace Brigades International
Ms Liddell explained how the main goal of
PBI is to ‘make space for peace’. Such a
goal is pursued by protecting HRDs and
the space in which they can work. PBI aims
at increasing both the recognition and the
protection of HRDs. In the first place, this is
possible by physically accompanying HRDs
on the field. This has a deterrence effect
against potential perpetrators. Moreover, PBI
builds connections and networks with otherMs. Sudha UpretyMr. Kamal Pathak
Ms. Iona Liddell
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
33
organizations (e.g. WHRDs Network, WOREC
etc.). PBI supports HRDs on the ground with
an established protection mechanism, and
gets their message across and outside Nepal.
PBI also runs a pilot project in Dhanusa, and
community projects in Bardyia and Dafuo.
a. Member of INSEC
A question has been addressed to the NHRC
representative from an INSEC member.
Impunity and other weak legal implementation
have put HRDs at risk. Despite the harsh
situation, there is a remarkable lack of
unity amongst organizations in the districts.
The NHRC could play a catalyst role and
bring together various organizations. So
far, which steps in this direction have been
taken? Recently, there has been an attempt
to disintegrate the human rights movement
in the name of caste, religion, gender and
specific rights. Defenders face additional
risks, due to the geographical disparities too.
Another problem that should be addressed by
the NHRC is the presence of a widespread
culture of self-censorship.
b. Mr. P.B Gautam, INSEC, Rautahat
district
Mr. Gautam raised the problem of the lack
of coordination between human rights
organizations. It is not clear who should
intervene and when. If the OHCHR is asked
to intervene in the Terai, they say that they
don’t have the mandate, but when INSEC
is reporting cases of rape and extra judicial
killings in the Terai, it often does not have the
OPEN
FORUM DISCUSSION DAY 2
mandate too. Moreover, as the OHCHR talks
to armed groups directly, armed groups look
at INSEC and other organizations negatively.
He further shared his experiences about the
mandate of the NHRC on the investigation of
human rights violations. The NHRC claims
that they need approval from their office
to conduct investigation, but the challenge
here is that , by the time that the NHRC gets
the consent to act, the victim can either be
disappeared, or in detention, or even dead.
So what can the NHRC do about it?
c. Member of the WHRD Network
The NHRC is an authoritative body, similar
to the judiciary system. So, how many cases
have been recommended to you and how
many cases have you solved? Can you
please clarify your mandate? What work has
the NHRC done for the capacity building of
WHRDs?
d. WHRD, Kapilvastu district
The NHRC forms task forces to conduct
investigation on human rights violation. Are
these reports public? If not, can the NHRC
lobby to ensure that these reports are made
public?
e. WHRD, Solukhumbu
How can WHRDs get in contact with the
European Union?
f. Mr. Shiva Bhandari shared that the EU has
its partner organizations in various parts of
the country, so that immediate demands can
be met. Protection International is one of such
organization,whichcanbedirectlycontactedin
case of emergencies. In addition, emblematic
cases can be immediately forwarded to EU
focal person. He further added that the EU
delegation is committed to implement the
Action Plan 2010-2015 at the regional level,
in coordination with the NHRC, the OHCHR
and other like-minded organizations and
institutions, to address the current status
quo. Although the EU does not have a direct
implementation mechanism, ambassadors
of the various EU states visit districts as a
gesture for pressurizing the government to
assess, monitor and implement its laws and
policies.
Ms. Margaret Sekkagya, United Nations
Special Rapporteur on the situation of Human
Rights Defenders
Responding to the presentations, queries and
questions presented during the Consultation,
Ms. Margaret Sekkagya highlighted the
following important points on the mandate of
the Special Rapporteur. She shared that it is
not necessary for the national mechanisms to
be exhausted, in order to send the cases to
the UN Special Rapporteur. The cases can be
directly sent to the Special Rapporteur. The
mandate of the UNSR is limited in its scope,
covering only cases of violations against
HRDs. She added that Special Rapporteurs
are independent actors, and they have the
power to recommend governments to address
HRDs’ cases. The UNSR on the situation of
HRDs has the responsibility to promote the
UN Declaration on HRDs
Ms.Sekkagyaavowedandpledgedtoaddress
the issues presented during the consultation
in her report to the UN Human Rights Council
and requested the audience to advocate for
an official invitation from the government of
Nepal to the UNSR.
32
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
34 35I n the context of Nepal, HRDs have
played a recognizable role for the
political transformation of the country from
an autocratic to a federal, democratic state.
Their efforts in denouncing the human rights
violation during the time of the people’s war
have cost immense sacrifices and, often, their
own lives.
In the current political instability, which
has catalyzed the institutionalization of
impunity in the country, HRDs and especially
WHRDs and LGBTI defenders face severe
discrimination and are vulnerable to multiple
violations. There are no security mechanisms
for HRDs, and existing provisions are often
ineffective. There is an urgent need for the
state agencies to develop such mechanisms.
A conducive environment for the protection
of human rights must be created in order to
allow HRDs to do their work.
Existing laws have to be reviewed in the
wake of newer and more unconventional
challenges being faced by WHRDs on a daily
basis. WHRDs have to undergo dual risk: they
are vulnerable as women and as defenders.
Stigmatization has crippled the identity of (W)
HRDs, and consequently enhanced the non-
recognition of their invaluable contribution.
Defending the rights of the LGBTIs,
indigenous minorities, differently able
individuals, Dalits and of other discriminated
minorities, WHRDs are working to the best
of their abilities and capacities so that others
can live a just and meaningful life, free from
threats and violence. Because of the fact that
they challenge the orthodoxy of the society,
WHRDs bear the major brunt— facing
murder, domestic violence, kidnapping, and
threats. Let’s remember that cases such as
that of Laxmi Bohra are still languishing in the
court.
This National Consultation provided a
CONCLUSIONS
platform for over 200 (W)HRDs from all the
five development regions of Nepal to come
under one roof and express their concerns
to the UNSR. Ms. Sekkagya, upon hearing
the poignant accounts of the (W)HRDs,
avowed to include the cases presented
in the consultation in her report to the UN
Security Council. This, we sincerely believe,
will definitely help in making the international
community aware of the professional hazards
of the (W)HRDs, and their impact on their
personal lives; Moreover, it will pressurize
the GON to develop an effective security and
protection mechanisms for the defenders as
well as for the survivors and witnesses.
This National Consultation is also a gesture
of thankfulness towards these heroes who
are putting their lives at stake to promote
and protect the rights of others. We salute
the sense of duty and responsibility of these
magnificent and distinguished individuals,
who are braving all odds to make lasting
changes in the society.
Overall Challenges
Lack of regional security and protection
mechanisms for HRDs in Asia
Many of the speakers reiterated that the
existing political instability in Nepal has lead
to a culture of rampant impunity, still not
addressed by the state. There is lack of
state’s accountability in enforcing justice to the
victims, so that the current justice system can
be defined as highly dysfunctional. Moreover,
this unreliability has discouraged citizens, who
have lost faith in the judicial system, and make
often use of informal justice mechanisms
(e.g. women’s court). The political parties
have infringed the Comprehensive Peace
Agreement (Art. 7), by providing amnesty for
the perpetrators of violence against HRDs. In
fact, the politicisation of the cases occurs on
a daily basis.
Despite the strength of the human rights
movement, many speakers have highlighted
that identity politics based on gender,
ethnicity, religion and political affiliation are
fragmentising the human rights movement,
thus reducing its power.
The participants reiterated the need of
decentralising information from the central
region to the districts. Given the topography
of Nepal, information and resources tend to
be concentrated in the central region, so that
HRDs operating in the districts have scant
access to them. There is impellent need
to create a mechanism so that information
and resources can flow to the districts,
strengthening the capacity of the local HRDs.
As for the root cause of the challenges faced
by HRDs in Nepal, most of the participants
have pointed out that the existing feudal and
patriarchal social structure play a central
role in fostering discrimination in all its
forms. Therefore, discrimination has to be
considered.
Overall Recommendations
	 Advocate to develop a separate
protection strategy and mechanisms
for HRDs in Asia;
	 Strengthen local networks with special
focus ion those working in the districts;
	 Strengthen cooperation between all
organizations working together in a
coordinated manner;
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
36 37
	 Conceptual clarity on the universality
and indivisible nature of human rights
and the role and responsibilities of the
defenders;
	 Enhance the access to information of
community-based defenders
	 NGOs and the civil society should
campaign on the issue of pressurizing
the government to extend a formal
invitation to the UNSR;
	 There should be systemic and
systematic documentation of the
cases of rights violations of HRDs.
Recommendations to the State
	 Implement the EU guidelines on
Violence Against Women in all the
government programs;
	 Develop protection mechanisms for
HRDs, along with a Rapid Response
and Early Warning Mechanism;
	 Enact laws for the protection of the
HRDs, survivors and witnesses
(witness protection);
	 Build the UN Declaration on HRDs
into a binding instrument;
	 Adopt laws reflecting the GON’s
responsibility to protect defenders.
Recommendations to the UNSR on HRDs
	 Take up the issues highlighted in the
Consultation during her meeting with
the GON;
	 To address the issues raised in her
Report to the UN Security Council.
Declaration of the National Consultation
of Women Human Rights Defenders with
the United Nations Special Rapporteur on
the situation of Human Rights Defenders
On November 25-26, 2010, over 200 Human
Rights Defenders, including the activists
working for women’s rights, LGBTI rights,
and marginalized communities gathered
in Kathmandu to discuss issues related to
the security and the protection of defenders
while celebrating the International Day for the
Elimination of all Forms of Violence Against
Women (November 25th).
Given that the commitments to human rights
and to ending impunity for past and present
violations still remains rampant and largely
ignored.
Was the ongoing instability in the country,
lead to increased violence against women,
food insecurity, lack of access to health
care, to justice and support in case of natural
disaster, and to other difficult situations,
creating additional risks for human rights
defenders (HRDs).
Given that HRDs are the targets of physical
assaults, torture, beatings, arbitrary arrest and
detention, death threats, harassment, and
restrictions on their freedom of movement,
expression and opinion, association and
assembly.
Given that Women Human Rights Defenders
(WHRDs) and lesbian, gay, bisexual and
transgender and intersex (LGBTI) defenders,
face specific risks and threats because
of the gender, gender identity and sexual
orientation, and the issues that they work on.
Whereas the absence of the rule of law
has aggravated the security situation of all
Nepali people, and especially that of HRDs
(in particular WHRDs and LGBTI defenders),
no legal and formal support mechanism
has been designed for HRDs which remain
vulnerable to the threats they face.
Given that there is a Supreme Court Directive
to the Government of Nepal aimed at
developing policy to protect HRDs working in
situation of great risk, and specially WHRDs.
Given that the adoption of the Domestic
Violence Act (2009), and the Declaration of
the Prime Minister to end all forms of Gender
Based Violence are two recent progressive
efforts that contribute to ending violence
against women.
Given that the NON RECOGNITION
of the work of WHRDs leads to further
marginalisation and increase the insecurity
faced by women defenders.
Given the imminent need for the creation
of specific mechanisms for the protection of
HRDs.
We, the Human Rights Defenders of Nepal,
call for the following actions to different
agencies to bring an end to impunity
and to promote and protect the rights of
Human Rights Defenders:
ANNEX
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
38 39
To the State
1.	 Focus efforts on the full realization of the
principle that women’s rights are human
rights as expressed in the Universal
Declaration on Human Rights, Vienna
Declaration and Programme of Action
and the Beijing Platform for Action (BPFA)
and other international human rights
instruments. All State action must work on
a policy that the human rights of women
are inalienable, integral and indivisible
part of universal human rights. The full
and equal enjoyment of all human rights
and fundamental freedoms by women
must be a priority for States;
2.	 Ensure constitutional recognition of the
rights to defend human rights. Immediately
develop national protection mechanisms
for HRDs in line with the decision of the
Supreme Court on HRDs, with special
consideration of gender issues;
3.	 Recognize that women are defenders and
are entitled to the full exercise of the right
to defend;
4.	 Address impunity by ensuring
accountability for past and present human
rights violations through establishing
gender sensitive transitional justice
mechanisms;
5.	 Ensure and strengthen the capacity and
independency of the National Human
Rights Commission;
6.	 Sensitize and raise the awareness of the
community and of public opinion on the
right to defend and the value of the work
of HRDs, and, in particular, acknowledge
the legitimacy and credibility of WHRDs;
7.	 Enact, and train security agencies on the
implementation of laws for the protection
of victims and survivors and witness
protection;
8.	 Actively lobby for transforming the UN
Declaration on HRDs into a binding
instrument;
9.	 Advocate to develop a separate protection
strategy and mechanism for HRDs in Asia;
10.	Ensure special protection measures for
protecting the rights of HRDs, especially
WHRDs, LGBTIs, indigenous minorities,
differently able individuals, Dalits, and
marginalized defenders.;
11.	Extend an official invitation to the UNSR on
HRDs, in order to advice the government
on how to best implement the previous
recommendations;
12.	Ensure proper implementation of the EU
Guidelines on Human Rights Defenders
and the EU Guidelines on Violence
Against Women;
13.	Provide education on women’s rights at
all levels, in order to counter patriarchal
norms that impede gender equality and
women’s full enjoyment of their rights;
14.	Extend the term of the Office of the High
Commissioner for Human Right (OHCHR)
s to stay in Nepal until the political impasse
comes to an end;
To the Human Rights Defenders:
1.	 Develop conceptual clarity on the
universalityandindivisiblenatureofhuman
rights and the role and responsibility of
human rights defenders;
2.	 Creation and strengthening of the national,
sub regional and regional coalitions and
networks to enhance the protection of
HRDs and development of proper policies
and strategies in order to ensure the
respect of HRDs;
3.	 Be accountable to provide information
and access to information for community
level defenders;
4.	 Campaign to lobby the government to
send an Official invitation to the SR HRD
5.	 Develop Systematic documentation of the
cases and develop capacity of community
defenders to document violations of
human rights;
To the International Community
1.	 Lobby for the official visit of UNSR HRD;
2.	 Support the establishment of protection
mechanisms for HRDs that includes the
strengthening of contacts and networks
between defenders;
3.	 Follow-up on diplomatic missions to
other parts of Nepal with the Government
highlighting the situation of local human
rights defenders;
4.	 Advocate for developing constitutional
provisions and subsequent legislation
protecting the rights to defend human
rights;
5.	 In line with continued international
support for the protection of defenders
and promotion of human rights actively
engaged South Asian governments on the
creation of a regional human rights body
with an individual complaints procedure;
6.	 Ensure that the European Guidelines
on Violence Against Women becomes
an integral part of any European Union
Funding provided for the government of
Nepal;
7.	 Ensure translation and implementation
of the European Guidelines on Human
Rights Defenders , European Guidelines
on Violence Against Women and
European EU toolkit on the rights of LGBT
persons
To the United Nations Special Rapporteur
on the situation of Human Rights
Defenders;
1.	 To lobby with the Nepal Government and
other Missions to extend an invitation for
an official visit to Nepal;
2.	 To lobby with the different agencies to
formulate specific recommendations on
recognition and security of Human Rights
Defenders for Nepal during the UPR
review in January 2011
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
40 41
Dev Kumari Mahara, WHRD,
siraha.worec@gmail.com
Mr. Subodh Raj Pyakurel, Chairperson, INSEC,
subodh@insec.org.np
Ms. Margaret Sekkagya, UNSR,
urgent-action@ohchr.org
Dr. Renu Rajbhandari, NAWHRDs,
suchana.renu@gmail.com
His Excellency Morten Jespersen, Embassy of
Denmark in Nepal, ditbje@um.dk
Roberto Ricci, Officer in charge, OHCHR Nepal,
rbennett@ohchr.org
Hon. Kedar Nath Upadhaya Chairperson, NHRC
nhrc@nhrcnepal.org
Mandira Sharma, Executive Director Advocacy
Forum, msharma@advocacyforum.org.np
Ganesh BK, President, Human Rights Alliance,
alliance.humanrights@gmail.com
Manisha, Blue Diamond Society,
bluediamondsociety@yahoo.com
Mr. Chandra Singh Kulung
Ms. Rita Thapa, Founder TEWA, Naagarik
Awaaz, WAPPDCA, ritathapa.patan@gmail.com
Monika Jha, Journalist & WHRD, Dhanusha
district
Sanjay Sharma, Blue Diamond Society,
bluediamondsociety@yahoo.com
Narayan Subedi, INSEC insec@insec.org.np
Shiva Maya Thumbahamphey, Member,
NAWHRDs; shiva_tumba@yahoo.com
Sunil Sah, HRDs Network, District,
sunil.rights@gmail.com
Suraj Bhattarai, Federation of Journalists,
suraj.bhattarai@live.com
Manoj Bachan, Manoj Bachan, Madheshi HRDs
Network, mk.bachchan@gmail.com
Ganga Thapa, Protection Officer, Protection
Desk Nepal, pdnepal@protectiondesk-nepal.org
Shaun Kirven, Consultant and Researcher,
shaun.kirven@gmail.com
Dr. Netra Prasad Timsina, President, NGO
Federation, nptimsina@gmail.com
Shiva Bhandari, Contact person for European
Working Group on HRDs,
Shiv.bhandari@ec.europa.eu
Kamal Pathak, Advocacy Forum, Programme
Coordinator, kpathak@advocacyforum.org.np
Advocate Hari Phuyal, Human Rights lawyer,
hariphuyal@yahoo.com
Sudha Uprety, OHCHR,
suprety@ohchr.org
Ms. Iona Liddell, Peace Brigades International,
communication officer,
communications@pbi-nepal.org
Kosh Raj Neupane, Deputy Director, NHRC,
kosh.neupane@nhrcnepal.org
List of Participants Songs by WHRD participants
!
hGdgf ;fy x]nf ef] 5f]/L
k9g klg kfOPg a/Ln}
syf ;'gfpF5'
lhGbuL e/Lsf] Joyf ;'gfpF5'
@
hGdgf ;fy cfdfsf] d/g
cfdf 6f]s'O eg]/ Gjf/g
bf]lif ePF d
of] s'/f ;'g]/ w]/} /f]PF d
#
afpn] NofP ;f}t]gL cfdf
dfof d}n] kfOg hLjgdf
cfF;' aufpFb}
sfd dfq} nufOof] arg nufpFb}
$
3fF; bfp/f u/]/ a;]y]+
vfnL k]6 k6'sL s;]y]+
gfËf] v'§fn]
vfnL e"OFdf ;'ltof] vfgf dfUgfn]
%
cfP dfdf kmsfpg dnfO{
zx/df hfuL/ efGhLnfO{
;'v kfOG5
df;' eft gL vfOG5 uf8L r9LG5
^
3/df dfof gkfsf] eP/
;Dem] d}n] d]/f] kf] s] 5 /
cfzf af]s]/
zx/sf] /dfOnf] x]5'{ eg]/
&
dfdf eP ;f¥x} g} hfnL
bof dfof /x]g5 cn]nL
s]6f] b]vfpFb}
olx;Fu hf eg] cfFvf nufpFb}
*
3fF; bfp/f u/]sL 5f]/LnfO{
s:tf] lk/ ef] xf]nf a/Ln}
s]6f] b]vfpFbf
;f¥x} g} /f]P y] a]Rof yf kfpFbf
(
nfpnL vfpnL ;'vn] a;f}nL
d;Fu a] klg u/f}nL
egL kmsfof]
aDaOdf nu]/ dnfO{ a]lrlbof]
!)
3/sf] ofbn] /fte/L ;'tLg
5f]/f eP of] lbg cfpFy]g
;Dem]/ /f]P
of}g wGbf ug{nfO{ afWo d ePF
!!
d h:tf w]/} 5g km;]sf
/f]O /f]O g/sdf a;]sf
hLjg lwSsf/
h'Ëf d'7] /fIf;sf] eO{ l;sf/
dlxnf dfgj clwsf/ /Ifs ;~hfn sfe|]
;lrj–lgd{nf sfˆn]
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders:
Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms
42 43
s0ff{nL M
h'Dnf x'Dnf d'u'df /f/ftfn
sfnLsf]6] gfgLsf] s] 5 xfn
-8f]Nkf P:t} 5_@
s0ff{nL c~rn lxpF ;]t} 5
e]/L M
hfh/sf]6 k'u]/ 5]p 5]p
b}n]vaf6 ;'v]{tdf hfgb]p
-alb{ofsf] kmfF6_@
s] sfdn] xf]ngL afFs] hfg] cfF6
rf}w c~rn &% lhNnf
uLt ufpg ldNnfsL gldNnf
-ag]kf xf] 3/_@
lg/dnf gfd d]/f] sfˆn] xf] y/
d]rL M
tfKn]h'ª kfFry/ lhNnfdf
Onfd em/L emfkfsf] lsNnfdf
-lrof ;:tf] 5_@
k'u]/ kms{g'; d]rL s:tf] 5
sf]zL M
;+v'jf;ef ef]hk'/ t]x|y'd
wgs'6fdf ljsf; 5 pw'd
-df]/ª ;'g;/L_@
sf]zLsf] lt/}df k'Uof} s;/L
;u/dfyfM
;f]n'v'Da' em/]/ pbok'/
cf]vn9'Ëf vf]6fªdf hfg] ;'/
-;u/dfyf u]6_@
;Kt/L k'u]/ l;/xfdf e]6
hgsk'/ M
dxf]Q/L bf]nvf /fd]5fk
hgsk'/df l;tfsf] kmlnkmfk
-wg'iffsf] bfO{_@
l;Gw'nL psfnf] cfpgf]; ;/nfO{
jfUdtL M
sf7df08f}+ eQmk'/ nlntk'/
sfe|] l;Gw' g'jfsf]6 hfg] ;'/
-jfUdtLsf] lt/_@
/;'jf wflbªdf hfg nfU5 lk/
gf/fo0fL M
dsjfgk'/ k;f{ / lrtjg
hfpF af/f lhGbuL latfpg
-gf/fo0fL k'n_@
/f}tx6 k'u]/ k/]+ /0fe"n
u08sL M
nDh'ª cfpg df]/ª] gfgL
uf]vf{ tgx'F hfg]sL ghfg]
-c~rn u08sL_@
sf:sL / :ofªhfdf latfpF lhGbuL
n'lDagL M
gjnk/f;L u'NdL / kfNkf 5]p
c3f{vfFrL ¿kGb]xL hfg b]p
-slknj:t' ufpF_@
n'lDagL c~rn xf] a'4 v]Nof 7fpF
wf}nflu/L M
wf}nflu/L lxpF k¥of] ;]t}
ls hfpF DofUbL sL cfpgf]; Pt}
-kj{t jfUn'ª s:tf] 5_@
d':tfªsf] /ftf] :ofp ;f¥x} ;:tf] 5
/fKtL M
¿s'd /f]Nkf c~rn /fktL
Ko"7fg hfg kg]{ ef] cfktL
-;Nofgsf] jg_@
bfª k'Ug] s;/L ¿G5 d]/f] dg
lgd{nf sfˆn]
;]tL M
c5fd 8f]6L aemfª / afh'/f
s}nfnLdf em/f}g xh'/
-;]tL c~rn_@
gu/ ltdLn] dg} rGrn
dxfsfnL M
a}t8L / 88]nw'/fdf
xf]nf e]6 s~rgk'/df
-56nf bfr'{nf_@
dxfsfnL k'u]/ d]rL kms'{nf
Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms

Contenu connexe

Similaire à Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms

India chasing numbers-betraying-people-eng-final
India chasing numbers-betraying-people-eng-finalIndia chasing numbers-betraying-people-eng-final
India chasing numbers-betraying-people-eng-finalclac.cab
 
OECD Well-being and Mental Health Conference, Elisabeth Ng Langdal, Mental He...
OECD Well-being and Mental Health Conference, Elisabeth Ng Langdal, Mental He...OECD Well-being and Mental Health Conference, Elisabeth Ng Langdal, Mental He...
OECD Well-being and Mental Health Conference, Elisabeth Ng Langdal, Mental He...StatsCommunications
 
Occasional Paper 1/2014: Conflict-related sexual and gender-based violence: A...
Occasional Paper 1/2014: Conflict-related sexual and gender-based violence: A...Occasional Paper 1/2014: Conflict-related sexual and gender-based violence: A...
Occasional Paper 1/2014: Conflict-related sexual and gender-based violence: A...Australian Civil-Military Centre
 
Global undp 2013 trans health & human rights
Global undp 2013 trans health & human rightsGlobal undp 2013 trans health & human rights
Global undp 2013 trans health & human rightsclac.cab
 
Coercion Verses Empowerment
Coercion Verses EmpowermentCoercion Verses Empowerment
Coercion Verses EmpowermentHRLNIndia
 
Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...
Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...
Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...yusufemamla
 
Arabic: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_...
Arabic: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_...Arabic: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_...
Arabic: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_...surakhbin
 
Qatari Elite Influence on Islamic Norms: A Comprehensive Analysis of the ILGA...
Qatari Elite Influence on Islamic Norms: A Comprehensive Analysis of the ILGA...Qatari Elite Influence on Islamic Norms: A Comprehensive Analysis of the ILGA...
Qatari Elite Influence on Islamic Norms: A Comprehensive Analysis of the ILGA...alkuwarialiahmed7
 
ILGA World State Sponsored Homophobia_report_global legislation 2023 Qatar.pdf
ILGA World State Sponsored Homophobia_report_global legislation 2023 Qatar.pdfILGA World State Sponsored Homophobia_report_global legislation 2023 Qatar.pdf
ILGA World State Sponsored Homophobia_report_global legislation 2023 Qatar.pdfasismerhaba97
 
ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!
ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!
ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!murthimamta2
 
Islamic Norms in Flux: A Closer Look at Qatari Elites in the ILGA Report
Islamic Norms in Flux: A Closer Look at Qatari Elites in the ILGA ReportIslamic Norms in Flux: A Closer Look at Qatari Elites in the ILGA Report
Islamic Norms in Flux: A Closer Look at Qatari Elites in the ILGA Reportalkuwarifarhaajlan
 
Qatar: Ilga World State Sponsored Homophobia Report Global Legislation 2023
Qatar: Ilga World State Sponsored Homophobia Report Global Legislation 2023Qatar: Ilga World State Sponsored Homophobia Report Global Legislation 2023
Qatar: Ilga World State Sponsored Homophobia Report Global Legislation 2023masrafalrayan04
 
The ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!
The ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!The ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!
The ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!ilyahmdalkwary
 
ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation - 2023 Qatar.pdf
ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation - 2023 Qatar.pdfILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation - 2023 Qatar.pdf
ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation - 2023 Qatar.pdfcaselrashid
 
Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...
Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...
Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...Qatar LGBT
 
A midterm Review Report on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in Nepal: Wom...
A midterm Review Report on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in Nepal: Wom...A midterm Review Report on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in Nepal: Wom...
A midterm Review Report on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in Nepal: Wom...WOREC Nepal
 
Apnon Ka Bahut Lagta hai
Apnon Ka Bahut Lagta hai Apnon Ka Bahut Lagta hai
Apnon Ka Bahut Lagta hai sabrangsabrang
 
Rape as torture in the DRC: Sexual violence beyond the conflict zone
Rape as torture in the DRC: Sexual violence beyond the conflict zoneRape as torture in the DRC: Sexual violence beyond the conflict zone
Rape as torture in the DRC: Sexual violence beyond the conflict zoneberat celik
 
International 2013 tv t research-report
International 2013 tv t research-reportInternational 2013 tv t research-report
International 2013 tv t research-reportclac.cab
 
#WCIP2014 IASG - thematic paper violence against girls and women rev1
#WCIP2014 IASG -  thematic paper  violence against girls and women   rev1#WCIP2014 IASG -  thematic paper  violence against girls and women   rev1
#WCIP2014 IASG - thematic paper violence against girls and women rev1Dr Lendy Spires
 

Similaire à Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms (20)

India chasing numbers-betraying-people-eng-final
India chasing numbers-betraying-people-eng-finalIndia chasing numbers-betraying-people-eng-final
India chasing numbers-betraying-people-eng-final
 
OECD Well-being and Mental Health Conference, Elisabeth Ng Langdal, Mental He...
OECD Well-being and Mental Health Conference, Elisabeth Ng Langdal, Mental He...OECD Well-being and Mental Health Conference, Elisabeth Ng Langdal, Mental He...
OECD Well-being and Mental Health Conference, Elisabeth Ng Langdal, Mental He...
 
Occasional Paper 1/2014: Conflict-related sexual and gender-based violence: A...
Occasional Paper 1/2014: Conflict-related sexual and gender-based violence: A...Occasional Paper 1/2014: Conflict-related sexual and gender-based violence: A...
Occasional Paper 1/2014: Conflict-related sexual and gender-based violence: A...
 
Global undp 2013 trans health & human rights
Global undp 2013 trans health & human rightsGlobal undp 2013 trans health & human rights
Global undp 2013 trans health & human rights
 
Coercion Verses Empowerment
Coercion Verses EmpowermentCoercion Verses Empowerment
Coercion Verses Empowerment
 
Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...
Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...
Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...
 
Arabic: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_...
Arabic: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_...Arabic: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_...
Arabic: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_...
 
Qatari Elite Influence on Islamic Norms: A Comprehensive Analysis of the ILGA...
Qatari Elite Influence on Islamic Norms: A Comprehensive Analysis of the ILGA...Qatari Elite Influence on Islamic Norms: A Comprehensive Analysis of the ILGA...
Qatari Elite Influence on Islamic Norms: A Comprehensive Analysis of the ILGA...
 
ILGA World State Sponsored Homophobia_report_global legislation 2023 Qatar.pdf
ILGA World State Sponsored Homophobia_report_global legislation 2023 Qatar.pdfILGA World State Sponsored Homophobia_report_global legislation 2023 Qatar.pdf
ILGA World State Sponsored Homophobia_report_global legislation 2023 Qatar.pdf
 
ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!
ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!
ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!
 
Islamic Norms in Flux: A Closer Look at Qatari Elites in the ILGA Report
Islamic Norms in Flux: A Closer Look at Qatari Elites in the ILGA ReportIslamic Norms in Flux: A Closer Look at Qatari Elites in the ILGA Report
Islamic Norms in Flux: A Closer Look at Qatari Elites in the ILGA Report
 
Qatar: Ilga World State Sponsored Homophobia Report Global Legislation 2023
Qatar: Ilga World State Sponsored Homophobia Report Global Legislation 2023Qatar: Ilga World State Sponsored Homophobia Report Global Legislation 2023
Qatar: Ilga World State Sponsored Homophobia Report Global Legislation 2023
 
The ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!
The ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!The ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!
The ILGA report Qatari Elites Disrupt Islamic Norms!
 
ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation - 2023 Qatar.pdf
ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation - 2023 Qatar.pdfILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation - 2023 Qatar.pdf
ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation - 2023 Qatar.pdf
 
Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...
Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...
Doha: ILGA_World_State_Sponsored_Homophobia_report_global_legislation_2023_Qa...
 
A midterm Review Report on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in Nepal: Wom...
A midterm Review Report on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in Nepal: Wom...A midterm Review Report on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in Nepal: Wom...
A midterm Review Report on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in Nepal: Wom...
 
Apnon Ka Bahut Lagta hai
Apnon Ka Bahut Lagta hai Apnon Ka Bahut Lagta hai
Apnon Ka Bahut Lagta hai
 
Rape as torture in the DRC: Sexual violence beyond the conflict zone
Rape as torture in the DRC: Sexual violence beyond the conflict zoneRape as torture in the DRC: Sexual violence beyond the conflict zone
Rape as torture in the DRC: Sexual violence beyond the conflict zone
 
International 2013 tv t research-report
International 2013 tv t research-reportInternational 2013 tv t research-report
International 2013 tv t research-report
 
#WCIP2014 IASG - thematic paper violence against girls and women rev1
#WCIP2014 IASG -  thematic paper  violence against girls and women   rev1#WCIP2014 IASG -  thematic paper  violence against girls and women   rev1
#WCIP2014 IASG - thematic paper violence against girls and women rev1
 

Plus de WOREC Nepal

Socio-Economic Impact Of COVID-19 On Returnee Migrant Women Workers In Nepa
Socio-Economic Impact Of COVID-19 On Returnee Migrant Women Workers In NepaSocio-Economic Impact Of COVID-19 On Returnee Migrant Women Workers In Nepa
Socio-Economic Impact Of COVID-19 On Returnee Migrant Women Workers In NepaWOREC Nepal
 
लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा | Gender-based violence
लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा  | Gender-based violenceलैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा  | Gender-based violence
लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा | Gender-based violenceWOREC Nepal
 
२८ औं अन्तराष्ट्रिय १६ दिने लैंगिक हिंसा बिरुद्धको अभियान २०१९ अवधारणा पत्र अन्र
२८ औं अन्तराष्ट्रिय १६ दिने लैंगिक हिंसा बिरुद्धको अभियान २०१९ अवधारणा पत्र अन्र२८ औं अन्तराष्ट्रिय १६ दिने लैंगिक हिंसा बिरुद्धको अभियान २०१९ अवधारणा पत्र अन्र
२८ औं अन्तराष्ट्रिय १६ दिने लैंगिक हिंसा बिरुद्धको अभियान २०१९ अवधारणा पत्र अन्रWOREC Nepal
 
बालबिवाह के हो?
बालबिवाह के हो?बालबिवाह के हो?
बालबिवाह के हो?WOREC Nepal
 
बालयौन दुरुपयोग
बालयौन दुरुपयोगबालयौन दुरुपयोग
बालयौन दुरुपयोगWOREC Nepal
 
Say no to violence
Say no to violenceSay no to violence
Say no to violenceWOREC Nepal
 
दाइजोप्रथा
दाइजोप्रथादाइजोप्रथा
दाइजोप्रथाWOREC Nepal
 
Women and health : Key facts in Nepal
Women and health : Key facts in NepalWomen and health : Key facts in Nepal
Women and health : Key facts in NepalWOREC Nepal
 
याैन हिंसा तथा घरेलु हिंसा सम्बन्धी सूचना सामग्री
याैन हिंसा तथा घरेलु हिंसा सम्बन्धी सूचना सामग्रीयाैन हिंसा तथा घरेलु हिंसा सम्बन्धी सूचना सामग्री
याैन हिंसा तथा घरेलु हिंसा सम्बन्धी सूचना सामग्रीWOREC Nepal
 
महिला हिंसा विरुद्धको वर्ष पुस्तक “अन्वेषी”
महिला हिंसा विरुद्धको वर्ष पुस्तक “अन्वेषी”महिला हिंसा विरुद्धको वर्ष पुस्तक “अन्वेषी”
महिला हिंसा विरुद्धको वर्ष पुस्तक “अन्वेषी”WOREC Nepal
 
सहयोगी – लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा र महिला स्वास्थ्य फ्लिप चार्ट | Flip ch...
सहयोगी – लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा र महिला स्वास्थ्य फ्लिप चार्ट | Flip ch...सहयोगी – लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा र महिला स्वास्थ्य फ्लिप चार्ट | Flip ch...
सहयोगी – लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा र महिला स्वास्थ्य फ्लिप चार्ट | Flip ch...WOREC Nepal
 
हाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग ३ | Our bodies ourselves Part Three
हाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग ३ | Our bodies ourselves Part Threeहाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग ३ | Our bodies ourselves Part Three
हाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग ३ | Our bodies ourselves Part ThreeWOREC Nepal
 
हाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग २ | Our bodies ourselves Part Two
हाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग २ | Our bodies ourselves Part Twoहाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग २ | Our bodies ourselves Part Two
हाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग २ | Our bodies ourselves Part TwoWOREC Nepal
 
Annual report 1991
Annual report 1991Annual report 1991
Annual report 1991WOREC Nepal
 
Pairabi WOREC Newsletter
Pairabi WOREC NewsletterPairabi WOREC Newsletter
Pairabi WOREC NewsletterWOREC Nepal
 
Rebuilding Bisdeutar, a Majhi community settlement in Sindhupalchok district
Rebuilding Bisdeutar, a Majhi community settlement in Sindhupalchok districtRebuilding Bisdeutar, a Majhi community settlement in Sindhupalchok district
Rebuilding Bisdeutar, a Majhi community settlement in Sindhupalchok districtWOREC Nepal
 
महिला पुनर्स्थापना केन्द्र (ओरेक) को परिचय
महिला पुनर्स्थापना केन्द्र (ओरेक) को परिचयमहिला पुनर्स्थापना केन्द्र (ओरेक) को परिचय
महिला पुनर्स्थापना केन्द्र (ओरेक) को परिचयWOREC Nepal
 
Introduction to Women's Rehabilitation Centre (WOREC)
Introduction to Women's Rehabilitation Centre (WOREC)Introduction to Women's Rehabilitation Centre (WOREC)
Introduction to Women's Rehabilitation Centre (WOREC)WOREC Nepal
 
Annual Report 2074/075 Nepali
Annual Report 2074/075 NepaliAnnual Report 2074/075 Nepali
Annual Report 2074/075 NepaliWOREC Nepal
 

Plus de WOREC Nepal (20)

Socio-Economic Impact Of COVID-19 On Returnee Migrant Women Workers In Nepa
Socio-Economic Impact Of COVID-19 On Returnee Migrant Women Workers In NepaSocio-Economic Impact Of COVID-19 On Returnee Migrant Women Workers In Nepa
Socio-Economic Impact Of COVID-19 On Returnee Migrant Women Workers In Nepa
 
Anbeshi 2076
Anbeshi 2076Anbeshi 2076
Anbeshi 2076
 
लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा | Gender-based violence
लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा  | Gender-based violenceलैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा  | Gender-based violence
लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा | Gender-based violence
 
२८ औं अन्तराष्ट्रिय १६ दिने लैंगिक हिंसा बिरुद्धको अभियान २०१९ अवधारणा पत्र अन्र
२८ औं अन्तराष्ट्रिय १६ दिने लैंगिक हिंसा बिरुद्धको अभियान २०१९ अवधारणा पत्र अन्र२८ औं अन्तराष्ट्रिय १६ दिने लैंगिक हिंसा बिरुद्धको अभियान २०१९ अवधारणा पत्र अन्र
२८ औं अन्तराष्ट्रिय १६ दिने लैंगिक हिंसा बिरुद्धको अभियान २०१९ अवधारणा पत्र अन्र
 
बालबिवाह के हो?
बालबिवाह के हो?बालबिवाह के हो?
बालबिवाह के हो?
 
बालयौन दुरुपयोग
बालयौन दुरुपयोगबालयौन दुरुपयोग
बालयौन दुरुपयोग
 
Say no to violence
Say no to violenceSay no to violence
Say no to violence
 
दाइजोप्रथा
दाइजोप्रथादाइजोप्रथा
दाइजोप्रथा
 
Women and health : Key facts in Nepal
Women and health : Key facts in NepalWomen and health : Key facts in Nepal
Women and health : Key facts in Nepal
 
याैन हिंसा तथा घरेलु हिंसा सम्बन्धी सूचना सामग्री
याैन हिंसा तथा घरेलु हिंसा सम्बन्धी सूचना सामग्रीयाैन हिंसा तथा घरेलु हिंसा सम्बन्धी सूचना सामग्री
याैन हिंसा तथा घरेलु हिंसा सम्बन्धी सूचना सामग्री
 
महिला हिंसा विरुद्धको वर्ष पुस्तक “अन्वेषी”
महिला हिंसा विरुद्धको वर्ष पुस्तक “अन्वेषी”महिला हिंसा विरुद्धको वर्ष पुस्तक “अन्वेषी”
महिला हिंसा विरुद्धको वर्ष पुस्तक “अन्वेषी”
 
सहयोगी – लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा र महिला स्वास्थ्य फ्लिप चार्ट | Flip ch...
सहयोगी – लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा र महिला स्वास्थ्य फ्लिप चार्ट | Flip ch...सहयोगी – लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा र महिला स्वास्थ्य फ्लिप चार्ट | Flip ch...
सहयोगी – लैङ्गिक विभेदमा आधारित हिंसा र महिला स्वास्थ्य फ्लिप चार्ट | Flip ch...
 
हाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग ३ | Our bodies ourselves Part Three
हाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग ३ | Our bodies ourselves Part Threeहाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग ३ | Our bodies ourselves Part Three
हाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग ३ | Our bodies ourselves Part Three
 
हाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग २ | Our bodies ourselves Part Two
हाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग २ | Our bodies ourselves Part Twoहाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग २ | Our bodies ourselves Part Two
हाम्रो शरीर हाम्रै हो भाग २ | Our bodies ourselves Part Two
 
Annual report 1991
Annual report 1991Annual report 1991
Annual report 1991
 
Pairabi WOREC Newsletter
Pairabi WOREC NewsletterPairabi WOREC Newsletter
Pairabi WOREC Newsletter
 
Rebuilding Bisdeutar, a Majhi community settlement in Sindhupalchok district
Rebuilding Bisdeutar, a Majhi community settlement in Sindhupalchok districtRebuilding Bisdeutar, a Majhi community settlement in Sindhupalchok district
Rebuilding Bisdeutar, a Majhi community settlement in Sindhupalchok district
 
महिला पुनर्स्थापना केन्द्र (ओरेक) को परिचय
महिला पुनर्स्थापना केन्द्र (ओरेक) को परिचयमहिला पुनर्स्थापना केन्द्र (ओरेक) को परिचय
महिला पुनर्स्थापना केन्द्र (ओरेक) को परिचय
 
Introduction to Women's Rehabilitation Centre (WOREC)
Introduction to Women's Rehabilitation Centre (WOREC)Introduction to Women's Rehabilitation Centre (WOREC)
Introduction to Women's Rehabilitation Centre (WOREC)
 
Annual Report 2074/075 Nepali
Annual Report 2074/075 NepaliAnnual Report 2074/075 Nepali
Annual Report 2074/075 Nepali
 

Dernier

ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxAreebaZafar22
 
Measures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SD
Measures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SDMeasures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SD
Measures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SDThiyagu K
 
Web & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdf
Web & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdfWeb & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdf
Web & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdfJayanti Pande
 
Application orientated numerical on hev.ppt
Application orientated numerical on hev.pptApplication orientated numerical on hev.ppt
Application orientated numerical on hev.pptRamjanShidvankar
 
Gardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch Letter
Gardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch LetterGardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch Letter
Gardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch LetterMateoGardella
 
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAPM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAssociation for Project Management
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactdawncurless
 
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...Shubhangi Sonawane
 
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin ClassesMixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin ClassesCeline George
 
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in DelhiRussian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhikauryashika82
 
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfHoldier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfagholdier
 
SECOND SEMESTER TOPIC COVERAGE SY 2023-2024 Trends, Networks, and Critical Th...
SECOND SEMESTER TOPIC COVERAGE SY 2023-2024 Trends, Networks, and Critical Th...SECOND SEMESTER TOPIC COVERAGE SY 2023-2024 Trends, Networks, and Critical Th...
SECOND SEMESTER TOPIC COVERAGE SY 2023-2024 Trends, Networks, and Critical Th...KokoStevan
 
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxThe basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxheathfieldcps1
 
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptxUnit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptxVishalSingh1417
 
Seal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptx
Seal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptxSeal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptx
Seal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptxnegromaestrong
 
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptxUnit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptxVishalSingh1417
 
fourth grading exam for kindergarten in writing
fourth grading exam for kindergarten in writingfourth grading exam for kindergarten in writing
fourth grading exam for kindergarten in writingTeacherCyreneCayanan
 
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityParis 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityGeoBlogs
 
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104misteraugie
 

Dernier (20)

Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"
 
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
 
Measures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SD
Measures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SDMeasures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SD
Measures of Dispersion and Variability: Range, QD, AD and SD
 
Web & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdf
Web & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdfWeb & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdf
Web & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdf
 
Application orientated numerical on hev.ppt
Application orientated numerical on hev.pptApplication orientated numerical on hev.ppt
Application orientated numerical on hev.ppt
 
Gardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch Letter
Gardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch LetterGardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch Letter
Gardella_PRCampaignConclusion Pitch Letter
 
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across SectorsAPM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
APM Welcome, APM North West Network Conference, Synergies Across Sectors
 
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impactAccessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
Accessible design: Minimum effort, maximum impact
 
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
 
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin ClassesMixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
 
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in DelhiRussian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
 
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfHoldier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
 
SECOND SEMESTER TOPIC COVERAGE SY 2023-2024 Trends, Networks, and Critical Th...
SECOND SEMESTER TOPIC COVERAGE SY 2023-2024 Trends, Networks, and Critical Th...SECOND SEMESTER TOPIC COVERAGE SY 2023-2024 Trends, Networks, and Critical Th...
SECOND SEMESTER TOPIC COVERAGE SY 2023-2024 Trends, Networks, and Critical Th...
 
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptxThe basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
The basics of sentences session 2pptx copy.pptx
 
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptxUnit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
 
Seal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptx
Seal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptxSeal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptx
Seal of Good Local Governance (SGLG) 2024Final.pptx
 
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptxUnit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
 
fourth grading exam for kindergarten in writing
fourth grading exam for kindergarten in writingfourth grading exam for kindergarten in writing
fourth grading exam for kindergarten in writing
 
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activityParis 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
Paris 2024 Olympic Geographies - an activity
 
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
 

Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms

  • 1.
  • 2. 25-26 November, 2010 Kathmandu, Nepal Proceedings of the National Consultation with the UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of Human Rights Defenders Margaret Sekkagya on “Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms” Prepared by: Jyotsna Maskay, Giovanna Gioli Layout: Ramesh Bhandari Edited by: Dr. Binayak Rajbhandari Published Year: 2011
  • 3. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 2 3 LIST OF THE ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS BDS: Blue Diamond Society CPA: Comprehensive Peace Accord ESCR: Economic Social and Cultural Rights EU: European Union GoN: Government of Nepal HRDs: Human Rights Defenders INSEC: Informal Sector Service Center IPs: Indigenous People LGBTI: Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Intersex NAWHRDs: National Alliance of Women Human Rights Defenders NDC: National Dalit Commission NHRC: National Human Rights Commission NWC: National Women Commission OHCHR: Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights UNSR: United Nations Special Rapporteur UPR: Universal Periodic Review VAW: Violence Against Women WHRDs: Women Human Rights Defenders WOREC: Women's Rehabilitation Center List of The Acronyms And Abbreviations 3 Acknowledgement 4 Introduction: Defenders on the Frontline 6 Proceedings: Day 1 11 Open Forum Discussion - Day 1 22 Proceedings: Day 2 28 Open Forum Discussion - Day 2 32 Conclusions 34 Annex 37 List of Participants 40 Songs by WHRD participants 41 Table of Contents
  • 4. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 4 5 Thank to Sudha Uprety, Andrew Palmer, and Bikram Tuladhar from the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights for the efforts in putting this event together. I am highly indebted to Dr. Renu Rajbhandari, Program Advisor of WOREC Nepal, and Chairperson of the National Alliance of Women Human Rights Defenders, for her vision and her encouragement to organize this event. I praise her continuous struggles and efforts in highlighting the need to recognize women as Defenders and in interlinking their different movements are highly appreciated. Special thanks to all the WOREC Nepal team members for their relentless efforts, passion, translation support, and for pushing through late night working hours, showing commitment, patience, and cooperation. I owe my deepest gratitude to Shaun Kirven, Human Rights Defender and crucial member of the Defenders movement in Nepal. This consultation would not have been possible without their moral and technical support, and their belief in the Human Rights Defenders of Nepal Jyotsna Maskay Executive Director, WOREC Nepal Acknowledgement I would like to express my gratitude to all those who encouraged and supported WOREC Nepal in the organization of this National Consultation. We salute all the Human Rights Defenders, the Women Human Rights Defenders, LGBTI Defenders, Marginalized Defenders, and Journalists for their resilience and their daily struggle to defend Human Rights for us all. Without their persistent efforts and their strong voices, this event would have been unthinkable. This event would not have been successful without the moral and technical support from INSEC, the Blue Diamond Society, Advocacy Forum, and Protection Desk Nepal, who supported the designing of this consultation since the beginning. I would like to thank the EU Working Group on Human Rights Defenders for their support in the attempt of negotiating a formal visit of the United Nation Special Rapporteur on the situation of Human Rights Defenders; I would like to thank International Service for Human Rights (ISHR, Geneva) for their financial and technical cooperation. Special thanks to Clement Nyaletsossi Voule for his commitment in promoting the rights of Human Rights Defenders. Big thanks to all our resource persons and panelists for their time and cooperation; I am grateful to all the NGOs, INGOs, Networks, Alliances, and Associations, for active participation and support in this event. My sincere appreciation goes to the National Human Rights Commissions, first of all for recognizing themselves as Defenders, and for their support and commitment to protect and promote the rights of Defenders. Acknowledgement
  • 5. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 6 7 Defenders on the Frontline INTRODUCTION On the 21st of November 2006, the Seven Party Alliance (SPA) and the CPN- Maoist signed the Comprehensive Peace Accord (CPA) and entered the Peace process, ending more than a decade long political conflict, and establishing the Federal Democratic Republic of Nepal. All the parties involved in the peace process have expressed their commitment to uphold human rights and to prioritise the rights of marginalized communities. However, change has been very slow and the situation has not improved substantially. Even after 4 years of peace process, the state of human rights in the country is very fragile. The unwillingness of the government to address impunity in the past has created a situation of lawlessness and chaos.
  • 6. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 8 9 and conviction, being deprived of proper legal assistance and denied a fair trial. HRDs work on the frontline, and this exposure opens avenues of insecurity not only for them but also for their families and colleagues. In fact, family members are often used as a tool to pressurise the defenders to withdraw from their work. WHRDs in Nepal have aimed at breaking the well established culture of silence, responsible for perpetuating their lack of access to rights. The proactive stand of WHRDs defies the feudal and patriarchal structures, relying on unequal gender power relations and structural inequalities. WHRDs are discriminated against twice, for being women and for being defenders. Similarly, LGBTI defenders often face double discrimination: on the one hand for defying the predominant heteronormativity, and on the other hand for being defenders. According to the documentation provided by INSEC online, in 2009 the number of HRDs victims of violence ranged up to 145, (Table 1). According to the data provided by WOREC Nepal and BDS, the victims were respectively 69 and 106 (Table 2 and 3). Table 1: Incidence of Violation of the Rights of Human Rights Defenders (Jan 1- Dec 30, 2009) Victims(Professionals) No. Incidence No. Victims Male Female Teachers 49 71 66 5 Journalists 40 57 47 10 Health Workers 6 7 7 Human Rights Activists 6 8 6 2 Law Practitioners 2 2 2 Total 103 145 128 17 Source: Inseconline, 2009 There are evidences of police personnel collaborating with criminals in abductions, murders and other forms of crimes. Similarly, there are data of abductions, killings and extortions from members of different political groups and youth wings of political parties; however, these perpetrators are not/cannot be arrested and prosecuted, as they are being de facto granted amnesty by different political parties. Human Rights Defenders (HRDs) who dare to defy the status quo are exposed to various risks such as executions, torture, beatings, arbitrary arrest and detention, death threats, harassment and defamation. Besides, they suffer from major restrictions to their freedom of movement, expression, association and assembly. HRDs face discrimination on the basis of race, ethnicity, geography, economic status, class, caste, access to education, sexual orientation, ability and age. In particular, WHRDs and Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Intersex defenders (LGBTI) are subjected to specific risks and vulnerabilities due to their gender and sexual orientation. Many evidences reveal that WHRDs and LGBTI Defenders have been constantly victim of false accusations The data revealed that there is an increasing number of abduction, killing and abuse on journalists and professionals who dare to raise issues related to the criminalization of politics and to political crimes. HRDs who are working on issues such as violence against women (VAW), Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (hereafter, ESCR), Sexual Rights, bonded labour and caste-based discrimination become the target for violence, WHRDs and LGBTI defenders being the most vulnerable ones. Due to the absence of rule of law, the security of Nepali citizens, and in particular of HRDs, WHRDs and LGBTI defenders, has been put at risk. Impunity for the crimes committed against HRDs, and in particular against WHRDs and LGBTI defenders, continues to present a major challenge for the peace process and for the security of marginalised groups. The data further show that WHRDs became victims of marginalization, face harassment from private actors, and from both state and non-state actors. WHRDs face specific threats to their work and capacity to contribute to the human rights movement in Nepal. Often, their own loved ones, male colleagues, community members and family members have been cited as the main source of discrimination and harassment. The lack of recognition of the legitimacy and credibility of women's work, even when they are operating in the most difficult and risky settings, adds to the risk faced by WHRDs. In the Nepali society, even temporarily claiming a space other than the domestic sphere may lead to physical violence, threats or even murder. The State's response to HRDs The state bears primary responsibility in respecting and protecting the rights of individuals within its jurisdiction, including, Table 2: Violation on WHRD from 2007 to 2009 – WOREC Nepal S.No. Typology of Violation, Risks and Constraints Type of Incident Number of case 1 Attacks on life, bodily and mental integrity Acid burn, Murder, Attempted murder, Mass rape, Beating 25 2 Physical and psychological deprivation Kidnap 2 3 Attacks against personhood and reputations Mental torture, Threaten, Verbal abuse 39 4 Violations of women's freedom of expression Social violence, Loot 3 Total 69 104 Source: WOREC Nepal, 2004-2009 Table 3: Violation on LGBTI defenders Types of incidents Number of Case N u m b e r of Victim Rape 2 3 Torture and illegal detention - 85 Killing 1 1 Restriction on movement 1 1 Threat ( Right to life) - 16 Total 106 Source: Blue Diamond Society, 2010
  • 7. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 10 11 of course, those of HRDs. The state responsibilities and obligations towards HRDs have been rightly incorporated in the UN Declaration on the Right and Responsibility of Individuals, Groups and Organs of Society to Promote and Protect Universally Recognized Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which was adopted in 1998. Every state has the responsibility to guarantee the implementation of the rights enshrined in the Declaration under the articles 2, 9, 12, 14 and 15. The Declaration emphasises the state's responsibility to ensure effective remedy for those who claim to have suffered from human rights violation. The Nepali Interim Constitution (2007) guarantees right to constitutional remedy (corresponding to the rights enshrined in the declaration), according to which a victim can pursue judicial remedy. However, the reality is that, in spite of the constitutional guarantee of the right to justice, most of the cases of HRDs are dismissed without proper investigation. Some of the cases have indeed been addressed by the judiciary, yet deficiencies in the implementation can be observed. During the people’s war, HRDs who were struggling for rights and democratisation of the state structures faced various forms of violence and attacks. However, no inquiry committee has been formed to investigate the past human rights violations, nor have the reported perpetrators been penalized. In this scenario, it can be concluded that the people’s right to remedy and reparations has been largely ignored or not yet prioritised. Despite the grim situation, some positive steps have been taken by the government with the adoption of the Domestic Violence Act, 2009 and the Declaration of the Prime Minister to end all forms of Gender Based Violence are two recent exemplary efforts to address VAW. Also the Supreme Court directives to the Government of Nepal (GoN) for developing security policies for HRDs have to be welcomed. The GoN receives large funding support from the European Union (EU) for sustainable peace and reconstruction. This support obliges the GoN to implement the EU Guidelines on HRDs and the EU guidelines on VAW; regrettably, this obligation has been de facto largely ignored. In the light of the present scenario, this consultation has been planned during the 'International 16 Days of Activism to end Gender Based Violence', in order to shed light on the situation of HRDs, in particular of WHRDs and LGBTIs defenders, as well as of defenders advocating for ESCRs. It aims at creating a platform to make the work of HRDs visible and to advocate, in collaboration with the United Nation Special Rapporteur on the situation of HRDs (UNSR), for a mechanism to develop strategies for integrating the security and protection of women and LGBTI defenders into the mainstream agendas. Furthermore, it intends to create and strengthen the national, sub-regional and regional coalitions and networks to enhance the protection of defenders and to develop proper policy suggestions and strategies in order to guarantee the rights of HRDs. T he 2-day National Consultation comprised of three separate thematic panels on the situation of HRDs, and on the emerging and existing security and protection mechanisms for HRDs. 1. Welcome remarks by Ms. Dev Kumari Mahara, Women Human Rights Defender, Terai, Nepal Ms. Dev Kumari Mahara in her opening remarks has outlined the main challenges faced by WHRDs in the Terai region, with a special focus on the situation of Dalit. The human rights situation in Terai is particularly difficult, as the region is infested by violent armed groups, affiliated to different ideological parties.Thesegroupshavelargelyaugmented the violence in the region, as small arms have been made readily available, thus increasing the rates of killings, and murders in the region. Many WHRDs have lost their lives in the past years and they are constantly subjected to various forms of assault, including rape and threats of abduction and/or murder. 2. Mr. Subodh Raj Pyakurel, Chair, INSEC Mr Subodh Raj Pyakurel stressed that the very presence of the UNSR who represents the HRDs worldwide, marks her interest in addressing the issues and concerns of HRDs in Nepal. Pyakurel informed that, despite his persistent request to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Ministry of Law, and other relevant ministries to invite the UNSR on the situation Proceedings 25 November 2010DAY 1
  • 8. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 12 13 of HRDs for an official visit, they declined on the ground that Nepal does not have the technical capacity and the resources to host her. Pyakurel also highlighted the immediate and pressing need for a separate and comprehensive law on HRDs in Nepal—a law focusing on the security and protection of the defenders. I. 3. Launch of Anbeshi An important milestone in addressing the issue of VAW has been the launch of WOREC Nepal's report "Anbeshi - Violence Against Women Year Book 2009-2010". The report was launched by UNSR Ms Margaret Sakkagya, and by the Hon. Kedar Nath Upadhaya (Chairperson, NHRC), in the presence of over hundred HRDs, WHRDs, LGBTI defenders, different organizations, and journalists. The major objectives of Anbeshi are as follows: • To map the scenario of VAW in Nepal and to exert pressure on the government for formulating relevant laws, policies and action plans for the elimination of VAW. • To identify key areas for ensuring access of VAW survivors to justice, and lobbying the government to effectively address these issues. • To identify the needs of VAW survivors, and advocate for the creation of relevant support mechanisms. 3. His Excellency Morten Jespersen, Embassy of Denmark in Nepal His Excellency Morten Jespersen thanked WOREC Nepal for making this event possible, despite the resistance from the Nepali government in issuing an official invitation to Ms. Margaret Segkkaya. He praised HRDs, and especially WHRDs, acknowledging their pivotal importance as agents of change. They put their lives at risk to defend fundamental rights; they are providing vital support to Nepal to ensure that the state fulfills its international obligations. Full support to HRDs is one of the major EU priorities, as stated in the EU Guidelines for HRDs, and on behalf of the international community, Mr. Jespersen expressed willingness and commitment to protect HRDs. He explained how the EU Guidelines have been implemented in close collaboration with the Nepali chapter of the EU Working Group on HRDs. It focuses on the support and protection for HRDs, and on the creation of networks for HRDs. Moreover, they are currently working at facilitating an official visit of the Rapporteur. Mr. Jespersen clarified how their work is focused on different issues, such as the protection and support to HRDs, and the follow up on cases of attack on HRDs. They also work for the support, strengthening and broadening of the human rights network. Field visit are also on the agenda, to encourage HRDs operating in rural areas. As Nepal will be shortly reviewed under UPR, on the 25th January 2011, Mr Jespersen had suggested to use the UPR to raise questions not only on the challenges faced by HRDs, but also to provide recommendations to the international community on how to ensure the protection and security of HRDs. 4. Mr. Roberto Ricci, Officer in charge, OHCHR, Nepal Mr. Ricci expressed his gratitude for being part of the Consultation. He said that whilst much progress has been achieved in the past few years, much still remains to be done to strengthen the security mechanism for HRDs. Mr. Ricci recalled the moment, in February 2005, when HRDs came under severe attack. In the wake of that difficult moment, a political space was created for OHCHR to open an office in Nepal, in May 2005. He further stressed on the importance of the initiatives of various UN agencies in providing protection to HRDs, such as David Johnson, his friend and colleague, senior human rights advisor to the UN Resident Coordinator. Since then, the OHCHR has been trying to work closely with the defenders for the improvement of the human rights situation in Nepal. In fact, it is fair to say that the OHCHR is in Nepal because of HRDs and for HRDs. The question is why a protection mechanism now, when the peace process is slowly taking place? Is the government failing to protect you? Is the situation worse than before? HRDs are, by definition, actors of change. HRDs are challenging justice to promote social transformation. They meet resistances, as change always meets resistance. Nepal's constitution is based on human rights, though it accepts certain forms of discrimination. Mr. Subodh Raj Pyakurel Launch of Anbeshi His Excellency Morten Jespersen Mr. Roberto Ricci
  • 9. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 14 15 Resistance shall be overcome. Even national census, if participated, can become challenging, as minorities would be exposed. The NHRC, The National Dalit Commission and the National Women Commission are crucial for ensuring the protection of HRDs, likewise the international community can play a role (e.g. the EU Working Group on HRDs). Mr. Ricci reported the OHCHR plan to launch a tool kit for HRDs next year. The OHCHR will organize its work around two thematic priorities: impunity and discrimination. He further added that they will continue to work with the defenders on capacity-building, monitoring and protection. He showed concern, as in the current year high numbers of VAW and violence against HRDs have been recorded by OHCHR. The tool kit will also address issues related to WHRDs. For instance, it contains practical guidelines on the monitoring of sexual and gender -based violence. This kit should be ready early next year. Finally, OHCHR will take further its engagement and cooperation with all the National Human Rights Institutions, and in particular, with the NHRC. 5. Hon. Kedar Nath Upadhaya, Chairperson, National Human Rights Commission Raising the names of noted human rights defenders such as Prakash Shah, Uma Singh, Tika Bista, Laxmi Bohra, the Hon. Kedar Nath Upadhaya, shed light on the precarious situation in which HRDs and especially WHRDs are forced to work. Rapes, murders, threats, sexual harassment, are just some of the abuses suffered by WHRDs. He pointed out that WHRDs are subjected to ‘double discrimination’, as a consequence of their status as women, on the one hand, and as HRDs, on the other. Because of this situation, stringent laws should be formulated for punishing the perpetrators. Special laws are needed to defend HRDs, as they are doing a very special work. HRDs should have a sense of security, so that they can continue their work. However, Nepal is now in a transitional phase, and as a result of the delayed peace process, defenders are exposed to higher risks. Mr Upadhaya stressed the importance of learning how other countries have tackled similar problems, and he expressed its gratitude to Ms. Margaret Sekkgaya and to the organizers for making this event possible. However, he conveyed his disappointment in the GoN failure to formally invite Ms. Margaret Sekkagya to Nepal, despite its attempt to discuss this issue with the Prime Minister and with the Finance Minister. He finally added that HRDs are always on the frontline, operating at the local level. Because of this, the society recognizes and trusts them. It has to be always kept in mind that HRDs are citizens too. They need to be protected and in order to achieve this goal, politicians have to become accountable; they have to learn the philosophy that all the citizens of the state are equal. 5. Ms. Margaret Sekkagya, United Nations Special Rapporteur on the situation of Human Rights Defenders Ms. Sekkagya expressed her gratitude and empathy for the suffering of HRDs. She highlighted the similar situation faced by HRDs in different countries, such as Brazil, Fiji, Congo, Sudan, and Colombia where she recently was on an official visit. She further mentioned the specific context faced by HRDs in Nepal: discrimination, arrests, abductions, killings, rape, sexual abuse, bondage, politicization of the work of HRDs, poor protection mechanisms, HRDs being terrorized by groups and being accused of witchcraft. She added that HRDs still struggle despite 12 years have passed since the passing of the UN Declaration on Human Rights Defenders. However, this declaration must be promoted in Nepal. The state must investigate human rights violation, and impunity must be removed. She concluded with a pledge to act in her maximum possible capacity to end violations and crimes against HRDs in Nepal. She committed to raise the plights and concerns of HRDs at the United Nations Security Council and reiterated her pledge to the WHRDs hoping that they would advocate for making the government of Nepal extend an official invitation to the UNSR. 6. Dr. Renu Rajbhandari, Chairperson, NAWHRDs Dr.RenuRajbhandarifocusedherpresentation on two phenomena that are increasingly affecting today’s Nepal, the Politicization of Crime and the Criminalization of Politics. She shared her concerns on the limitation currently imposed on freedom of expression in the country, supporting her speech with Hon. Kedar Nath Upadhaya UN Special Rapportuer Ms. Margaret Sekkagya
  • 10. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 16 17 recent figures showing increasing number of abductions, killing and abuse perpetrated on journalists and professionals who dared to raise crucial and hot issues related to the situation of human rights. The scenario is even darker for HRDs working in the Madesh region, due to the emergence of 109 armed groups. The presence of these groups has resulted in an escalation of violence against HRDs, which continue to receive threats and to suffer from violence. Dr. Rajbhandari further elaborated that unless the human rights movement proceeds in a cohesive and integrated manner, massive violence and human rights violations will continue on a daily basis. She identified the human rights movement as the major possible actor in contrasting the rising militarization of Nepal. Nevertheless, state commitment is pivotal, and a crucial step would be the development of a specific law to ensure the protection of HRDs. 7. Ms. Bindu P. Gautam, Researcher, WOREC Nepal Ms. Gautam presented the result of the joint research conducted by WOREC Nepal and Isis WICCE, "Redefining Justice: Research findings on Access to Justice for Rape Survivors". The purpose of the study was to inform policy makers, activists and organizations enabling them to access appropriate information in order to effectively address VAW. Ms. Gautam highlighted as major objective of the study, the identification of gaps and challenges in existing response, and the drafting of policy and action recommendation for establishing effective mechanisms and ensuring the survivors’ rights to justice. Ms. Gautam explained the method and the sources of the research, which included in- depth interviews with Survivors (55), and interview with key Informants (112). The surveyinvolvedalsoFocusGroupDiscussions (33), interaction with community women (14), WHRDs(10), Paralegal Committee (4), and Others (5). Secondary Source such as media Survey (201) and case collection and analyses from different organizations (723) were also used. The concerned areas are the Terai: Morang, Dhanusha, Kailali (Eastern, Central, Far-Western), the Hilly belt: Udayapur (inner- Terai), Dailekh, Baglung, Kathmandu, Kavre (Eastern, Western, Mid-Western,, Central), and the High Hills and Mountains belt: Dolakha, Darchula (Mid-Western and Far- Western). Ms. Gautam shared that women in the concerned areas are facing different forms of violence, such as verbal abuses against WHRDs, witchcraft accusations, polygamy, domestic violence, sexual violence, marital rape, rape and murder, vilification and slander. The victims of rape resulted to be prevalently women, disabled, sexual minorities, WHRDs, conflict affected people and boys. Women bodies are commonly used to seek revenge, to silence voices of protest, to show power, to humiliate/defame the family and community, to prove a male’s masculinity and to fulfill sexual hunger. Finally, Ms. Gautam explored the existing response mechanisms. Family proved to be disempowering in most cases. As for the community, organized groups/networks and (W)HRDs are the most effective in addressing rape and other violence, however they are facing major challenges (e.g. abuse, assault, humiliation, threat), and they are neglected both by the state and non-state actors. Paralegal Committees are resent but they need assessment. Responses from NGOs/civil society feature a limited coverage and scope for immediate support to victim. Some positive steps have been taken by the government, however their scope and effectiveness has to be questioned. No support mechanism is envisaged at the community level, and NHR Institutions have limited resources and limited access. Legally, the major gaps highlighted by Ms. Gautam are the absence of a clear definition of rape, and the narrowness of its, the discriminatory provisions pertaining punishment; the exclusive focus on the right of the Criminal, and the absence of legal provisions ensuring victim’s rights (protection, recovery/ rehabilitation, reintegration into society). 9. Subodh Raj Pyakurel, Chair, INSEC Mr. Subodh Raj Pyakurel, highlighted that despite the amount of energy spent by NGOs for the upholding of human rights, the situation will not significantly improve, unless these activities are included within the National Action Plan of the government. Culture, property, dowry, in Nepal, this is all in the hands of males. In the villages, widespread practices need to be changed, and economic discrimination should be challenge. To succeed, a holistic solution is needed. He explained that the only institutions which have the ability to reach every household are the political parties. If they plan to impart the • PANEL 1: The contemporary issues and challenges faced by Human Rights Defenders • (Moderator: Mandira Sharma, Executive Director, Advocacy Forum). • Objective: The objective of this discussion was to identify the major risks and challenges faced by different groups of HRDs, such as WHRDs, LGBTI Defenders, marginalized defenders, and victims groups, active in the promotion and protection of human rights. The panel will also provide a preview of the specific risks and vulnerabilities faced by defenders. Dr. Renu Rajbhandari Ms. Bindu P. Gautam
  • 11. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 18 19 message of human rights and HRDs during their election campaign, then they will be able to bring about pronounced changes in the country within a single campaign. Mr. Pyakurel also highlighted the fact that those defenders who litigate a case of violation are the most at risk; therefore, it is extremely important to raise the issue of their protection. However, Pyakurel pointed out that Nepal seriously lacks a meaningful decision-making process and effective decision-makers. He further stressed the importance of discussing with the stakeholders in order to develop law from the perspective of the victims. 10. Ms. Manisha, Blue Diamond Society, on the situation of LGBTI defenders Speaking on behalf of the LGBTI community, Manisha explored some of the key challenges faced by the group. She stressed the urgent need to make provisions for LGBTIs and defenders to fully entitle them to citizenship rights and to prevent sexuality-based discrimination. She explained that LGBTIs are often facing stigmatization, even from their own families. They are also severely discriminated against in the job market, as they encounter major difficulties in finding employment and are often forced to leave their jobs. Sometimes, as a consequence of this lack of opportunities in the job market, LGBTIs are left with the only option of entering the sex market. This situation is fuelled by the widespread prejudice according to which, all LGBTIs are sex workers and eunuchs. On the issue of citizenships, Manisha highlighted the challenges faced by transgender people, whose gender identity is not recognized on the passport. She shared her recent experience on this issue. While travelling to Geneva to attend a meeting at the Human Rights Council, she was treated with respect by the Nepali officers, but she encountered problems while transiting in Doha. As the gender declared on her passport did not match her physical appearances, she was stopped and her passport was checked all over again. After a long time she was released but the officials kept a photocopy of her passport. Manisha further stressed that, despite their huge contribution to the human rights movement, LGBTI defenders are often discriminated against by other activists. Besides, the NHRC has failed into seriously dealing with the LGBTI community, especially in the protection of LGBTIs defenders. She further added that there should be a specific campaign on sexual health rights. Finally she added that issues related to LGBTIs remain unaddressed also in the interim constitution. Currently, there is no mention of LGBTIs in any of the committee reports submitted by the CA. 11. Mr Chandra Singh Kulung, Founder of the Durban Review Committee (DRC) Mr. Singh Kulung, pointed out the most important challenges faced by marginalized defenders. He first focused on the situation of indigenous people. They are marginalized, and their right to preserve their distinct identity and representation (e.g. respect to their dress, ornaments, appearance) must be protected. Indigenous women are even more discriminated against, and they are more subjected to trafficking and to HIV/AIDS. In ordertochangethestatusquo,thegovernment should implement the ILO 169, UNDRIP, and other international human rights instruments. Moreover, the state should recognize all the indigenous ethnic communities meeting the characteristics of indigenous nationalities. It is also necessary to develop a common understanding about the rights of Indigenous Peoples (IPs) between/among IPs, non-IPs and the government. He added that in the Terai/Madesh region, the situation of IPs is even more difficult, as they are facing political pressure form identitarian movements, such as "One Madhesh One Pradesh". Mr. Singh Kulung had then addressed the situation of Dalit in Nepal. The challenge here would be obtaining a change in the mind of the feudalists, making room for the implementation of pro-Dalit law. Moreover, the government must implement the Convention on Elimination of All kinds of Racial Discrimination (CERD), as well as other relevant human rights treaties. Common Challenges of HRDs (by State and Non-State actors) Personal Insecurity (During Profession) Personal Insecurity (In Custody) Killing Harassment: Ill-treatment Abduction • Arrests and Fines Incommunicado Disappearance • Restriction on Movement Intimidation (frightening sb) Attacks/Physical Destruction • Raids Repression Threatening • Eviction (being evicted) Confiscation (loosing ownership) • In person • Refraining (stop doing the work) Retaliation • Family/Beloved ones • Family/Beloved Ones • Arbitrary Detention Mental Torture Physical Torture Ms. Manisha Mr Chandra Singh Kulung
  • 12. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 20 21 Mr. Singh finally touched on the measures to be taken for integrating differently able people, and LGBTIs. As for the first group, it is central to ensure friendly means of transportation, housing, apartment and office, as well as the proper equipment for education (such as brail script, sign language etc). Means for livelihoods - employment, entrepreneurship and economic activities - have to be provided too. As for the LGBTI community, a deep change in the prevailing mindset of society is required. LGBTIs’ rights must be ensured through the proper implementation of the concerned laws. 12. Ms. Rita Thapa on the situation of Women Human Rights Defenders Ms. Rita Thapa presented the case study of Nirmala Thapa, a WHRD who disappeared in April 2009. After 4 days, her body was found in the Dhading River. All her jewellery had been removed, and her underpants had been stripped off. Her 12 years old son said that she had been victim of domestic violence for the past 2 years. WOREC Nepal stepped in to bring the case to justice, providing documentation and legal assistance. As a result of this, Nirmala’s husband was jailed. After an appeal to the Supreme Court, the case is currently waiting for the final hearing. Ms.Thapathensummarisedthecurrentissues of WHRDs. First of all, there is a dramatic ineffectiveness of state’s structures, which need to be reorganized and empowered. Besides, a heightened state of impunity is present in the country, facilitating other two dangerous processes which are currently increasing: the criminalization of politics, and the political protection of criminals. This state of affair has led to increasing rates of violence (both in the domestic and public sphere), often resulting in attempts to silence WHRDs (e.g. Uma Singh, Suntali Dhami, Tika Bista and many others). Ms. Thapa shared that due to the patriarchal values and norms embedded in the Nepali society, women defenders are relegated to inferior and subservient positions and roles. Because of the political instability, rampant impunity is widespread in the country. As a consequence, there is no conducive environment for defenders to exert their right to defend. Women’s defenders are defying this situation putting their life at serious risk. Nevertheless, their action is not at all recognized as work by both the society and the state. Ms Thapa has then provided some recommendationstoendVAW.Shehighlighted the pivotal role of the government in ensuring WHRDs’ protection. Structures, networks and mechanisms should be developed and all perpetrators shall be held accountable (including those under state protection). Nepal is in a post-conflict, “transitional phase”, and the government should seriously take into account the implementation of UN Security Council Resolution 1325 and 1820. The other preventive measures should be the establishment of an Early Warning System, and the systematic documentation of cases. Mr. Shaun Kirven (Researcher and consultant) Mr. Kirven wanted to ask some questions about why we are here and what we are trying to accomplish. He said that despite the morning being spent speaking about violence, the core issues concerning what constitutes violence against women have not been touched yet. In Nepal, women cannot inherit property, they have no access to economic market, and they are traded between families, just to mention some of the major issues. These things need to be tackled. If perhaps they had economic status, violence would not happen. It seems as if we are treating the symptoms and not the cause. Discrimination, however, does not stop there. There is sexuality-based violence, ethnic-based violence and many other forms of discrimination, all leading to violence. Ms. Rita Thapa Mr. Shaun Kirven How to tackle these discriminations? First of all, a question should be asked: How do we deal with our own prejudices? We all have them, but most of the times we do not deal with them. Maybe even in this consultation. The state has to protect us, it is its obligation, but when violence is coming from families and from the community, the state is not likely to intervene. Therefore, we have to find ways to convince the public that our work as HRDs is a proper job, which benefits everyone. We can do that only by being inclusive, which means, in the first place, working on our prejudices.
  • 13. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 22 23 The floor was open to the participants to raise their questions, concerns and to share their experience. a. Manica Jha, Journalist & WHRD, Dhanusha. district Manica Jha, a journalist and WHRD from Dhanusha district, had expressed serious concerns over her safety as a WHRD working in the Terai region. She shared her fear of being murdered in the same way as her friend and colleague, Uma Singh (a noted WHRD journalist). b. Sanjay Sharma, Eastern Region Coordinator, Blue Diamond Society (BDS) Sanjay shared that recently a lesbian was raped by the cadres of a political group. The case was filed at the local police station. The police tried to silence the victim by offering NRs. 60,000 as compensation. When the local BDS group went there to investigate OPEN FORUM DISCUSSION on the incident, Sanjay Sharma was beaten up by a group of people in front of the Senior Superintendent Police office, in Biratnagar. ThelackofrecognitionLGBTIdefenders’work, along with the absence of support systems for marginalized defenders, greatly enhances the chance of secondary victimization by the local or state authorities. c. Narayan Subedi, INSEC, Nepalgunj Mr. Subedi shared that HRDs cannot exert their right to freedom of mobility while exercising their right to defend human rights in the mid western region. They face risks and vulnerabilities such as fear of being attacked while trying to travel from one part of the region to another during monitoring of human rights violation, implementation of activities. d. Ms. Lata joshi, WHRD network, Doti Ms. Joshi shared that on the past 8th of March, one girl was taken to Silguri, in the attending this Consultation. f. Mandira Sharma, Executive Director of Advocacy Forum Ms. Sharma highlighted how HRDs have been reacting to the challenges they face in their work on a daily basis, by organizing themselves through the creation of networks at both the central and the district level. However, no protection mechanism for ensuring the security of HRDS has been established yet. There is no national law addressing the issue. At the international level there is the UN Declaration, however, in order to ensure its efficacy, this fundamental instrument has to become legally binding. The legal context is very important, but our strategies as HRDs are equally important. Ms. Sharma said that HRDs are aware of many cases, and there is a very active participation aimed at helping the victim to get justice. Thanks to their work, HRDs understand the gravity of the culture of impunity in Nepal, which has to be addressed and analyzed. When an incident occurs, HRDs are there, documenting and supporting, however, over the time, it evaporates. We shall address the root causes of such ineffectiveness, by fighting for justice till the end. We might have different hats, but as defenders we shall all follow the principles of HRDs. Doti Districts by the staff working in a health post, to work as a domestic helper. Until April 10th, the girl was sexually abused by the man. The police then alerted the WHRDs network. She shares her story with us and subsequently some members of the WHRDs network, Mahila Adhikar Manche and a couple of other organizations brought the case forward. They went to the police and submitted a First Information Report, demanding for the perpetrator to be arrested. However, due to political protection granted to the perpetrator by the local political parties, he was granted amnesty. Ms. Joshi said that this is very sad, as the very parties which are supposed to help the movement of HRDs are actually working against them. Also many HRDs changed their mind on the cases, as a result of the pressure exerted by the political parties they were attached to. The same thing happened to some of the perpetrators' colleagues, working at the health post, who protested blocking the streets when the Court issued the order to arrest the perpetrator. On top of this, a case was filed against us for defamation against the perpetrators. e. Woman from the WHRDs network A WHRD has raised the issue of disability: disabled women encounter an unfriendly environment in aircrafts, buses and public transportation and services. We, as women and as disabled women, feel discriminated against. Although the government has ratified the UN Convention on the Rights of the People with Disabilities, its implementation is still rather weak or nonexistent, as it is illustrated by our experiences. The last recent examples of this are the difficulties we had to face in order to reach Kathmandu for DAY 1
  • 14. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 24 25 1. Ganga Thapa, Protection Desk-Nepal Protection Desk-Nepal (PD-N) has been conducting capacity building and security training for HRDs across the country since 2006, and has specific programs for WHRDs, victim groups, and LGBTI defenders and organizations PD-N also aims at supporting local defenders, victims and other vulnerable groups to integrate their protection into the agendas of state authorities. National and international organizations have encouraged an active role of all stakeholders in the protection of defenders. As a result, the EU working group on HRDs was established as a part of the EU local implementation strategy for the EU Guidelines on HRDs, of which PD-N is also a member. Within this working group, a sub-group has been formed to monitor and document human rights violation, compile and analyze information from reliable sources, generate recommendations, and work on selected emblematic cases. As a part of the local implementation strategy, the EU Working Group organized a trip to Eastern and Far western Region for assessing the situation of HRDs. PD-N organized a regional consultation (supported by the German Embassy) on protection mechanism for HRDs in all the five development regions of Nepal. These consultations brought together, 1000 people including WHRDs, LGBTI defenders, trade unions, religious groups, journalists and political parties to discuss the diverse needs of the defenders, who made specific recommendations for their protection. These recommendations were directed to the state, the EU embassies and the national human rights institutions, as well as to the civil society. PANEL 2: Coping mechanisms and strategies developed by Human Rights Defenders in the context of impunity, political impasse and non-recognition of their work—linking the movement. Moderator: Mr. Ganesh BK, Human Rights Alliance Objective: The objective of this discussion was to understand and analyze the different mechanisms and strategies developed by diverse defenders to enforce and protect human rights. This panel also showed how defenders have developed collective strategies to guarantee their security and protection. PD-N continuously meets with human rights organizations and HRDs in the region to monitor their situation and provide counselling on security measures. PD-N has been working closely with WOREC, INSEC and BDS to implementing the recommendations of the regional consultation. 2. Mr. Kosh Raj Neupane, Deputy Director, National Human Rights Commission Mr. Neupane shared that there is lack of state policy on the protection and security of HRDs. Due to geographical disparities, defenders operating outside the Kathmandu valley can access limited information and resources. Likewise, the lack of cohesion and coordination amongst the defenders prevents them from accessing effective protection. He further stressed the need to establish an Early Warning and Rapid Response Mechanism for defenders at risks, and the responsibility of the government to develop specific laws on HRDs, along with the upholding of the UN Declaration on HRDs. Open discussion a. Mr. Manoj Bachhan, Lawyer and Secretary, Madeshi HRDS Network, Jagrit Mr. Bachhan highlighted the situation in the Madhesh area, where his organization operates. He said that they have been experiencing many problems; in particular, the most worrying are the rampant impunity and the proliferation of armed groups, together with the rising of criminal groups. Given the situation, HRDs are often forced to work with criminal groups and with corrupted police personnel. He explained the nature of the work performed by its organization, stressing their collaboration with women’s organizations and CBOs. He stressed that CBOs (whose working area is confined) work closely with WHRDs at the local level. He further identifies some of the core issues they are addressing: the issue of ‘untouchability’, domestic violence, witchcraft accusations, and incestuous rape. Another major problem in the Terai region is extra judicial killings: as Nepal shares a border with India, both border forces are often involved in cases of VAW. b. Sunil Kumar Sah, Samagra Jana Uthan Kedra, Chairperson, Siraha District Mr. Sah explained that his organization works in close collaboration with the WHRDs network in the Siraha district. They provide support for cases of violence against WHRDs, or for the relocation of WHRDs from the Siraha and
  • 15. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 26 27 Saptarai districts. These WHRDs still fight, irrespective of the attacks and the torture they have been inflicted. Mr. Sah and its association recognize the huge contribution to peace and democracy given by WHRDs and stresses that they are trying their best to ensure justice for the victims. HRDs work in close collaboration with WHRDs, and regular meetings are held. Mr. Sah shared that recently a 7-year-old girl was raped by a 35-year-old man. The girl was saved by his organization. The parents of the girl did not own enough money to have her treated adequately at the hospital, so they prioritized the necessity of protecting the honour of the family, neglecting the importance of her treatment. The parents were stopped in Lahan, by the HRDS network, which fundraised for the treatment of the girl. Mr. Sah further elaborated that the network received support also from the police. The girl was taken to Rajbiraj for receiving treatment, and she had to undergo two major operations. Luckily she was able to return home. This is just an example of how the HRDs networks work collaboratively together. c. Shivamaya Thumbahamphey, member of the NAWHRDs Ms. Thumbahamphey shared that WHRDs do not get any form of support from the police. Therefore, they mainly work in coordination with government agencies, and with NGOs, as they are interested in upholding and protecting women’s rights. She said that WHRDs face major challenges, and they try to cope by sitting together with government agencies and NGO to discuss possible remedies. She further added that, when discussing about the rights of WHRDs, they should not be the only part concerned. It is in everyone’s best interest to raise the issue of human rights. d. Kasala, WHRDs network, Bardiya district Ms. Kasala responded to the presentation of Mr. Manoj Bachhan, who said that often, HRDs have to work in close relation with criminal groups and with the police. She shared that recently, in the Bardiya district, two children were killed. They witnessed that government bodies, such as the security forces and the investigation section, as well as some HRDs, were supporting the criminal groups. As a result of this, the whole definition of HRDs comes under question. During the conflict, irrespective of where we work, we worked as defenders. However, the situation has changed, and today many HRDs are close to either criminal groups or political parties. How do we define a HRD? The universality of human rights has to be ensured by HRDs, throughaneutralaction,freefrompartypolitics and hidden agendas. However, especially in the Terai region, criminal activities are often done in the name of human rights. In such situation it is very difficult to work. e. WHRD, WHRDs network, Solukhumbu district Women across Nepal have become aware of the budget allocated by the government for the advancement of women and of gender equality. Subsequently, they have come to realise the importance of discussing about women's issues in order to be able to submit a consistent proposals to the government. However, the political parties tend to interfere in matters of gender budget, not respecting the fact that the budget is meant to be allocated for the empowerment of women. f. Sarita KC, WHRD, Chitwan District Ms. KC shed lights on the situation of WHRDs, sharing a case she has been recently involved in. A woman was raped in her district. After 3 days the perpetrators' families came to her. The perpetrators had fled away and they were willing to pay compensation (200.000 rupees) to the victim. She refused the deal and the 4 perpetrators were imprisoned by the police. The big political parties exerted pressure on her, asking why she was getting their cadre imprisoned. Even members of the CA were pressuring the police, saying that the perpetrators should have been released. HRDs were present too, lobbying the CDO and the police in order to get justice and avoid the release of the perpetrators. In the evening, they received a phone call saying: "Get out of your house, we are going to vandalise your property". She replied that she was not a coward, and she did not run away. After 2-3 days she was stopped by two boys but when they saw her face, they let her go. This is due to the fact that she is a recognized HRD and political leader, so that she could stand for her own rights, without being violated. However, had it been another woman, she would have been raped. Those are the kind of risks faced by defenders. WHRD, WHRDs Network, Baglung District She stated that the situation of women in Nepal is not homogenous, as, even within women, Dalit women and women from marginalised community are disproportionately suffering from human rights violation. Mr. Ganesk BK, Human Rights Alliance Mr. Ganesh BK said that there have not been significant political changes in the country, in spite Nepal being declared as a Democratic FederalRepublicin2007.Hesharedhisrecent experience in the Dailekh and Baitadi districts, where he managed to meet with some Haliya women. They expressed their understanding of Nepal through a song. The song mentioned the fact that their landlords are still referred to as masters, as they were called before the people's movement. This might be seen as an irrelevant issue of terminology, but these women wanted to explain how the feudal attitude of their master has not changed yet, and major discriminations are still taking place. Mr. BK further added that HRDs face a lot of challenges, which need to be prioritized in the government agenda.
  • 16. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 29 DAY 2 1. Mr. Shiva Bhandari, Contact person for the European Working Group on Human Rights Defenders Mr. Bhandari introduced himself as the contact person for the EU Working Group on HRDs, shedding light on the existing security and protection mechanisms for HRDs as foreseen by the EU Guidelines on HRDs. He further elaborated on the scope and nature of the activities of the EU Working Group, focusing on Gender Specific provisions for WHRDs. PANEL 3: Emerging and existing mechanisms for the protection and security of human rights defenders. Objective: The objective of this discussion is to reflect on the emerging and existing mechanisms that has been developed and designed for the protection of Human Rights Defenders by different agencies. This will also discuss how those mechanisms have been implemented. He said that issues related to WHRDs shall be taken into serious consideration, and that the concerns raised during the first day of the present National Consultation with the UNSR must be given the highest attention and priority. Economical and technical support shall be provided. Mr. Bhandari also informed the audience of the EU Action Plan 2010-2015 on HRDs, which contains a set of instructions for EU member states to work on this issue. Finally, he invited the crowd to directly contact the EU for further information, e.g. by contacting the forum of the EU 2. Mr. Kosh Raj Neupane, Deputy Director, NHRC Speaking on behalf of the NHRC, Mr. Neupane said that the mandate of the NHRC is to promote and protect human rights, to investigate and monitor human rights violations, and to provide recommendations to the government for the improvement of the human rights situation in the coutry. To a certain extent, he said, the NHRC mandate can be assimilated to that of a court. MrNeupanefurtherelaboratedthattheNHRC, in case of a violation being committed, follows a two-step process: 1. Make the perpetrators accountable; 2. Ensure compensation and reparation to the survivors and/or their dependents. As a preventive measure, the NHRC has established a Rapid Response Mechanism (RRM), to deal with human rights violation more effectively. The NHRC is also responsible for developing guidelines for HRDs. In addition, the NHRC also builds the capacity of HRDs through Mr. Hari Phuyal Mr. Kosh Raj Neupane Mr. Shiva Bhandari training programmes, working in close collaboration with the civil society. 3. Mr. Hari Phuyal, Human Rights Lawyer Mr. Phuyal highlighted the legal procedures 28
  • 17. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 30 31 that can be followed in case of human rights violation. In the case of criminal offences, the following actions are envisaged: File the First Information Reports (FIRs) at the Police after any occurrence of violence; if the Police refuse to file the case, the victim can then approach the Chief District Officer (CDO); once the case has been endorsed by the CDO, it can be taken to the Appellate Court. Mr. Phuyal explained that in incidence of domestic violence, the victim can approach the District Court for demanding justice. He further added that the victims can also lodge complaints to the National Human Rights Institutions, such as the NHRC, the NWC and the NDC, in case of specific types of violation. He then added that different human rights organizations can also play a pivotal role in addressing the redress demand of the victims. Besides, they are central for raising the victim’s voice and disseminating it through the media. Mr. Phuyal further explained that international mechanisms are also available, in conjunction with the national ones. When national mechanisms fail to provide justice, international instruments, such as diplomatic missions and the International Criminal Court can be approached. 4. Kamal Pathak, Advocacy Forum, on international and regional mechanisms Highlighting the fact that there are no regional security mechanisms in South Asia for Human Rights Defenders, Mr. Pathak briefed on the existing regional and international mechanisms for the protection of (W)HRDs. He stressed that the South Asian Association of Regional Coorpearation (SAARC), as a regional body, lacks separate strategies or protection mechanisms on human rights. He explained that there are 5 international mechanisms and 1 regional mechanism for South East Asia. The international regional mechanisms comprises of a) The African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights, b) The Inter-American Commission for Human Rights, c) The Council of Europe and its Commission for Human Rights, d) The Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights for the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe and e) The 2004 EU Guidelines on HRDs. Mr. Pathak, stressed the fact that South Asia is lacking a regional instrument on HRDs, despite such a possibility has been explored during the regional consultation, held in Kathmandu in 2009. During this event HRDs from all over South Asia met and discuss various options to establish such a mechanism. Mr. Pathak elaborated on the necessity of a regional instrument. He said that HRDs are always on the frontline in the promotion and protection of human rights. However, despite their efforts to uphold human rights, governments, national laws, police forces, etc., fails to provide adequate protection, thus reducing the scope of HRDs’ action. 5. Ms. Sudha Uprety, OHCHR Ms. Uprety shared on the implementation of the UN Declaration on HRDs linking it with treaty bodies. She explained that the international human rights mechanisms can be divided into two, Treaty-based mechanism (CEDAW; CESCR; HRC; CERD; CAT; CRC; CMW; CRPD) and Charter-based mechanism (UPR; human rights council and Special Procedures). She further elaborated that national, regional and international mechanisms are available for the protection and security of HRDs. Amongst the international mechanism, the UN Declaration of HRDs is a legally binding instrument, and its adoption by the state would strengthen its potential as a support tool for human rights and human rights defenders. Its inclusion within a State’s domestic legislation would facilitate its application by the judiciary and respect for it by State authorities. Ms. Uprety highlighted the importance of a correct implementation of the Declaration by the state. This process involve implementing the Declaration’s provisions, monitoring the progress made, and publishing a report indicating what steps have been taken and those articles in relation to which concerns remain. Further developing, in consultation with civil society, shall be considered, and a plan of action for the implementation of the Declaration must be published. The state must also disseminate the Declaration through information and training programmes targeting, for example, HRDs themselves, state officials, intergovernmental organizations and the media. Ms. Uprety concluded by stressing on the importance of linking the three level of mechanism (national, regional and international) together. She added that the international and regional norms require national implementation to be effective, and national norms should be consistent with international and regional standards. Finally, international and regional judicial protection shall be used only when national remedies have been exhausted internationally. 6. Ms. Iona Liddell, Communication Officer, Peace Brigades International Ms Liddell explained how the main goal of PBI is to ‘make space for peace’. Such a goal is pursued by protecting HRDs and the space in which they can work. PBI aims at increasing both the recognition and the protection of HRDs. In the first place, this is possible by physically accompanying HRDs on the field. This has a deterrence effect against potential perpetrators. Moreover, PBI builds connections and networks with otherMs. Sudha UpretyMr. Kamal Pathak Ms. Iona Liddell
  • 18. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 33 organizations (e.g. WHRDs Network, WOREC etc.). PBI supports HRDs on the ground with an established protection mechanism, and gets their message across and outside Nepal. PBI also runs a pilot project in Dhanusa, and community projects in Bardyia and Dafuo. a. Member of INSEC A question has been addressed to the NHRC representative from an INSEC member. Impunity and other weak legal implementation have put HRDs at risk. Despite the harsh situation, there is a remarkable lack of unity amongst organizations in the districts. The NHRC could play a catalyst role and bring together various organizations. So far, which steps in this direction have been taken? Recently, there has been an attempt to disintegrate the human rights movement in the name of caste, religion, gender and specific rights. Defenders face additional risks, due to the geographical disparities too. Another problem that should be addressed by the NHRC is the presence of a widespread culture of self-censorship. b. Mr. P.B Gautam, INSEC, Rautahat district Mr. Gautam raised the problem of the lack of coordination between human rights organizations. It is not clear who should intervene and when. If the OHCHR is asked to intervene in the Terai, they say that they don’t have the mandate, but when INSEC is reporting cases of rape and extra judicial killings in the Terai, it often does not have the OPEN FORUM DISCUSSION DAY 2 mandate too. Moreover, as the OHCHR talks to armed groups directly, armed groups look at INSEC and other organizations negatively. He further shared his experiences about the mandate of the NHRC on the investigation of human rights violations. The NHRC claims that they need approval from their office to conduct investigation, but the challenge here is that , by the time that the NHRC gets the consent to act, the victim can either be disappeared, or in detention, or even dead. So what can the NHRC do about it? c. Member of the WHRD Network The NHRC is an authoritative body, similar to the judiciary system. So, how many cases have been recommended to you and how many cases have you solved? Can you please clarify your mandate? What work has the NHRC done for the capacity building of WHRDs? d. WHRD, Kapilvastu district The NHRC forms task forces to conduct investigation on human rights violation. Are these reports public? If not, can the NHRC lobby to ensure that these reports are made public? e. WHRD, Solukhumbu How can WHRDs get in contact with the European Union? f. Mr. Shiva Bhandari shared that the EU has its partner organizations in various parts of the country, so that immediate demands can be met. Protection International is one of such organization,whichcanbedirectlycontactedin case of emergencies. In addition, emblematic cases can be immediately forwarded to EU focal person. He further added that the EU delegation is committed to implement the Action Plan 2010-2015 at the regional level, in coordination with the NHRC, the OHCHR and other like-minded organizations and institutions, to address the current status quo. Although the EU does not have a direct implementation mechanism, ambassadors of the various EU states visit districts as a gesture for pressurizing the government to assess, monitor and implement its laws and policies. Ms. Margaret Sekkagya, United Nations Special Rapporteur on the situation of Human Rights Defenders Responding to the presentations, queries and questions presented during the Consultation, Ms. Margaret Sekkagya highlighted the following important points on the mandate of the Special Rapporteur. She shared that it is not necessary for the national mechanisms to be exhausted, in order to send the cases to the UN Special Rapporteur. The cases can be directly sent to the Special Rapporteur. The mandate of the UNSR is limited in its scope, covering only cases of violations against HRDs. She added that Special Rapporteurs are independent actors, and they have the power to recommend governments to address HRDs’ cases. The UNSR on the situation of HRDs has the responsibility to promote the UN Declaration on HRDs Ms.Sekkagyaavowedandpledgedtoaddress the issues presented during the consultation in her report to the UN Human Rights Council and requested the audience to advocate for an official invitation from the government of Nepal to the UNSR. 32
  • 19. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 34 35I n the context of Nepal, HRDs have played a recognizable role for the political transformation of the country from an autocratic to a federal, democratic state. Their efforts in denouncing the human rights violation during the time of the people’s war have cost immense sacrifices and, often, their own lives. In the current political instability, which has catalyzed the institutionalization of impunity in the country, HRDs and especially WHRDs and LGBTI defenders face severe discrimination and are vulnerable to multiple violations. There are no security mechanisms for HRDs, and existing provisions are often ineffective. There is an urgent need for the state agencies to develop such mechanisms. A conducive environment for the protection of human rights must be created in order to allow HRDs to do their work. Existing laws have to be reviewed in the wake of newer and more unconventional challenges being faced by WHRDs on a daily basis. WHRDs have to undergo dual risk: they are vulnerable as women and as defenders. Stigmatization has crippled the identity of (W) HRDs, and consequently enhanced the non- recognition of their invaluable contribution. Defending the rights of the LGBTIs, indigenous minorities, differently able individuals, Dalits and of other discriminated minorities, WHRDs are working to the best of their abilities and capacities so that others can live a just and meaningful life, free from threats and violence. Because of the fact that they challenge the orthodoxy of the society, WHRDs bear the major brunt— facing murder, domestic violence, kidnapping, and threats. Let’s remember that cases such as that of Laxmi Bohra are still languishing in the court. This National Consultation provided a CONCLUSIONS platform for over 200 (W)HRDs from all the five development regions of Nepal to come under one roof and express their concerns to the UNSR. Ms. Sekkagya, upon hearing the poignant accounts of the (W)HRDs, avowed to include the cases presented in the consultation in her report to the UN Security Council. This, we sincerely believe, will definitely help in making the international community aware of the professional hazards of the (W)HRDs, and their impact on their personal lives; Moreover, it will pressurize the GON to develop an effective security and protection mechanisms for the defenders as well as for the survivors and witnesses. This National Consultation is also a gesture of thankfulness towards these heroes who are putting their lives at stake to promote and protect the rights of others. We salute the sense of duty and responsibility of these magnificent and distinguished individuals, who are braving all odds to make lasting changes in the society. Overall Challenges Lack of regional security and protection mechanisms for HRDs in Asia Many of the speakers reiterated that the existing political instability in Nepal has lead to a culture of rampant impunity, still not addressed by the state. There is lack of state’s accountability in enforcing justice to the victims, so that the current justice system can be defined as highly dysfunctional. Moreover, this unreliability has discouraged citizens, who have lost faith in the judicial system, and make often use of informal justice mechanisms (e.g. women’s court). The political parties have infringed the Comprehensive Peace Agreement (Art. 7), by providing amnesty for the perpetrators of violence against HRDs. In fact, the politicisation of the cases occurs on a daily basis. Despite the strength of the human rights movement, many speakers have highlighted that identity politics based on gender, ethnicity, religion and political affiliation are fragmentising the human rights movement, thus reducing its power. The participants reiterated the need of decentralising information from the central region to the districts. Given the topography of Nepal, information and resources tend to be concentrated in the central region, so that HRDs operating in the districts have scant access to them. There is impellent need to create a mechanism so that information and resources can flow to the districts, strengthening the capacity of the local HRDs. As for the root cause of the challenges faced by HRDs in Nepal, most of the participants have pointed out that the existing feudal and patriarchal social structure play a central role in fostering discrimination in all its forms. Therefore, discrimination has to be considered. Overall Recommendations  Advocate to develop a separate protection strategy and mechanisms for HRDs in Asia;  Strengthen local networks with special focus ion those working in the districts;  Strengthen cooperation between all organizations working together in a coordinated manner;
  • 20. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 36 37  Conceptual clarity on the universality and indivisible nature of human rights and the role and responsibilities of the defenders;  Enhance the access to information of community-based defenders  NGOs and the civil society should campaign on the issue of pressurizing the government to extend a formal invitation to the UNSR;  There should be systemic and systematic documentation of the cases of rights violations of HRDs. Recommendations to the State  Implement the EU guidelines on Violence Against Women in all the government programs;  Develop protection mechanisms for HRDs, along with a Rapid Response and Early Warning Mechanism;  Enact laws for the protection of the HRDs, survivors and witnesses (witness protection);  Build the UN Declaration on HRDs into a binding instrument;  Adopt laws reflecting the GON’s responsibility to protect defenders. Recommendations to the UNSR on HRDs  Take up the issues highlighted in the Consultation during her meeting with the GON;  To address the issues raised in her Report to the UN Security Council. Declaration of the National Consultation of Women Human Rights Defenders with the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the situation of Human Rights Defenders On November 25-26, 2010, over 200 Human Rights Defenders, including the activists working for women’s rights, LGBTI rights, and marginalized communities gathered in Kathmandu to discuss issues related to the security and the protection of defenders while celebrating the International Day for the Elimination of all Forms of Violence Against Women (November 25th). Given that the commitments to human rights and to ending impunity for past and present violations still remains rampant and largely ignored. Was the ongoing instability in the country, lead to increased violence against women, food insecurity, lack of access to health care, to justice and support in case of natural disaster, and to other difficult situations, creating additional risks for human rights defenders (HRDs). Given that HRDs are the targets of physical assaults, torture, beatings, arbitrary arrest and detention, death threats, harassment, and restrictions on their freedom of movement, expression and opinion, association and assembly. Given that Women Human Rights Defenders (WHRDs) and lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender and intersex (LGBTI) defenders, face specific risks and threats because of the gender, gender identity and sexual orientation, and the issues that they work on. Whereas the absence of the rule of law has aggravated the security situation of all Nepali people, and especially that of HRDs (in particular WHRDs and LGBTI defenders), no legal and formal support mechanism has been designed for HRDs which remain vulnerable to the threats they face. Given that there is a Supreme Court Directive to the Government of Nepal aimed at developing policy to protect HRDs working in situation of great risk, and specially WHRDs. Given that the adoption of the Domestic Violence Act (2009), and the Declaration of the Prime Minister to end all forms of Gender Based Violence are two recent progressive efforts that contribute to ending violence against women. Given that the NON RECOGNITION of the work of WHRDs leads to further marginalisation and increase the insecurity faced by women defenders. Given the imminent need for the creation of specific mechanisms for the protection of HRDs. We, the Human Rights Defenders of Nepal, call for the following actions to different agencies to bring an end to impunity and to promote and protect the rights of Human Rights Defenders: ANNEX
  • 21. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 38 39 To the State 1. Focus efforts on the full realization of the principle that women’s rights are human rights as expressed in the Universal Declaration on Human Rights, Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action and the Beijing Platform for Action (BPFA) and other international human rights instruments. All State action must work on a policy that the human rights of women are inalienable, integral and indivisible part of universal human rights. The full and equal enjoyment of all human rights and fundamental freedoms by women must be a priority for States; 2. Ensure constitutional recognition of the rights to defend human rights. Immediately develop national protection mechanisms for HRDs in line with the decision of the Supreme Court on HRDs, with special consideration of gender issues; 3. Recognize that women are defenders and are entitled to the full exercise of the right to defend; 4. Address impunity by ensuring accountability for past and present human rights violations through establishing gender sensitive transitional justice mechanisms; 5. Ensure and strengthen the capacity and independency of the National Human Rights Commission; 6. Sensitize and raise the awareness of the community and of public opinion on the right to defend and the value of the work of HRDs, and, in particular, acknowledge the legitimacy and credibility of WHRDs; 7. Enact, and train security agencies on the implementation of laws for the protection of victims and survivors and witness protection; 8. Actively lobby for transforming the UN Declaration on HRDs into a binding instrument; 9. Advocate to develop a separate protection strategy and mechanism for HRDs in Asia; 10. Ensure special protection measures for protecting the rights of HRDs, especially WHRDs, LGBTIs, indigenous minorities, differently able individuals, Dalits, and marginalized defenders.; 11. Extend an official invitation to the UNSR on HRDs, in order to advice the government on how to best implement the previous recommendations; 12. Ensure proper implementation of the EU Guidelines on Human Rights Defenders and the EU Guidelines on Violence Against Women; 13. Provide education on women’s rights at all levels, in order to counter patriarchal norms that impede gender equality and women’s full enjoyment of their rights; 14. Extend the term of the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Right (OHCHR) s to stay in Nepal until the political impasse comes to an end; To the Human Rights Defenders: 1. Develop conceptual clarity on the universalityandindivisiblenatureofhuman rights and the role and responsibility of human rights defenders; 2. Creation and strengthening of the national, sub regional and regional coalitions and networks to enhance the protection of HRDs and development of proper policies and strategies in order to ensure the respect of HRDs; 3. Be accountable to provide information and access to information for community level defenders; 4. Campaign to lobby the government to send an Official invitation to the SR HRD 5. Develop Systematic documentation of the cases and develop capacity of community defenders to document violations of human rights; To the International Community 1. Lobby for the official visit of UNSR HRD; 2. Support the establishment of protection mechanisms for HRDs that includes the strengthening of contacts and networks between defenders; 3. Follow-up on diplomatic missions to other parts of Nepal with the Government highlighting the situation of local human rights defenders; 4. Advocate for developing constitutional provisions and subsequent legislation protecting the rights to defend human rights; 5. In line with continued international support for the protection of defenders and promotion of human rights actively engaged South Asian governments on the creation of a regional human rights body with an individual complaints procedure; 6. Ensure that the European Guidelines on Violence Against Women becomes an integral part of any European Union Funding provided for the government of Nepal; 7. Ensure translation and implementation of the European Guidelines on Human Rights Defenders , European Guidelines on Violence Against Women and European EU toolkit on the rights of LGBT persons To the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the situation of Human Rights Defenders; 1. To lobby with the Nepal Government and other Missions to extend an invitation for an official visit to Nepal; 2. To lobby with the different agencies to formulate specific recommendations on recognition and security of Human Rights Defenders for Nepal during the UPR review in January 2011
  • 22. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 40 41 Dev Kumari Mahara, WHRD, siraha.worec@gmail.com Mr. Subodh Raj Pyakurel, Chairperson, INSEC, subodh@insec.org.np Ms. Margaret Sekkagya, UNSR, urgent-action@ohchr.org Dr. Renu Rajbhandari, NAWHRDs, suchana.renu@gmail.com His Excellency Morten Jespersen, Embassy of Denmark in Nepal, ditbje@um.dk Roberto Ricci, Officer in charge, OHCHR Nepal, rbennett@ohchr.org Hon. Kedar Nath Upadhaya Chairperson, NHRC nhrc@nhrcnepal.org Mandira Sharma, Executive Director Advocacy Forum, msharma@advocacyforum.org.np Ganesh BK, President, Human Rights Alliance, alliance.humanrights@gmail.com Manisha, Blue Diamond Society, bluediamondsociety@yahoo.com Mr. Chandra Singh Kulung Ms. Rita Thapa, Founder TEWA, Naagarik Awaaz, WAPPDCA, ritathapa.patan@gmail.com Monika Jha, Journalist & WHRD, Dhanusha district Sanjay Sharma, Blue Diamond Society, bluediamondsociety@yahoo.com Narayan Subedi, INSEC insec@insec.org.np Shiva Maya Thumbahamphey, Member, NAWHRDs; shiva_tumba@yahoo.com Sunil Sah, HRDs Network, District, sunil.rights@gmail.com Suraj Bhattarai, Federation of Journalists, suraj.bhattarai@live.com Manoj Bachan, Manoj Bachan, Madheshi HRDs Network, mk.bachchan@gmail.com Ganga Thapa, Protection Officer, Protection Desk Nepal, pdnepal@protectiondesk-nepal.org Shaun Kirven, Consultant and Researcher, shaun.kirven@gmail.com Dr. Netra Prasad Timsina, President, NGO Federation, nptimsina@gmail.com Shiva Bhandari, Contact person for European Working Group on HRDs, Shiv.bhandari@ec.europa.eu Kamal Pathak, Advocacy Forum, Programme Coordinator, kpathak@advocacyforum.org.np Advocate Hari Phuyal, Human Rights lawyer, hariphuyal@yahoo.com Sudha Uprety, OHCHR, suprety@ohchr.org Ms. Iona Liddell, Peace Brigades International, communication officer, communications@pbi-nepal.org Kosh Raj Neupane, Deputy Director, NHRC, kosh.neupane@nhrcnepal.org List of Participants Songs by WHRD participants ! hGdgf ;fy x]nf ef] 5f]/L k9g klg kfOPg a/Ln} syf ;'gfpF5' lhGbuL e/Lsf] Joyf ;'gfpF5' @ hGdgf ;fy cfdfsf] d/g cfdf 6f]s'O eg]/ Gjf/g bf]lif ePF d of] s'/f ;'g]/ w]/} /f]PF d # afpn] NofP ;f}t]gL cfdf dfof d}n] kfOg hLjgdf cfF;' aufpFb} sfd dfq} nufOof] arg nufpFb} $ 3fF; bfp/f u/]/ a;]y]+ vfnL k]6 k6'sL s;]y]+ gfËf] v'§fn] vfnL e"OFdf ;'ltof] vfgf dfUgfn] % cfP dfdf kmsfpg dnfO{ zx/df hfuL/ efGhLnfO{ ;'v kfOG5 df;' eft gL vfOG5 uf8L r9LG5 ^ 3/df dfof gkfsf] eP/ ;Dem] d}n] d]/f] kf] s] 5 / cfzf af]s]/ zx/sf] /dfOnf] x]5'{ eg]/ & dfdf eP ;f¥x} g} hfnL bof dfof /x]g5 cn]nL s]6f] b]vfpFb} olx;Fu hf eg] cfFvf nufpFb} * 3fF; bfp/f u/]sL 5f]/LnfO{ s:tf] lk/ ef] xf]nf a/Ln} s]6f] b]vfpFbf ;f¥x} g} /f]P y] a]Rof yf kfpFbf ( nfpnL vfpnL ;'vn] a;f}nL d;Fu a] klg u/f}nL egL kmsfof] aDaOdf nu]/ dnfO{ a]lrlbof] !) 3/sf] ofbn] /fte/L ;'tLg 5f]/f eP of] lbg cfpFy]g ;Dem]/ /f]P of}g wGbf ug{nfO{ afWo d ePF !! d h:tf w]/} 5g km;]sf /f]O /f]O g/sdf a;]sf hLjg lwSsf/ h'Ëf d'7] /fIf;sf] eO{ l;sf/ dlxnf dfgj clwsf/ /Ifs ;~hfn sfe|] ;lrj–lgd{nf sfˆn]
  • 23. Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms Identity, Recognition and Resilience of Human Rights Defenders: Strengthening the Security and Protection Mechanisms 42 43 s0ff{nL M h'Dnf x'Dnf d'u'df /f/ftfn sfnLsf]6] gfgLsf] s] 5 xfn -8f]Nkf P:t} 5_@ s0ff{nL c~rn lxpF ;]t} 5 e]/L M hfh/sf]6 k'u]/ 5]p 5]p b}n]vaf6 ;'v]{tdf hfgb]p -alb{ofsf] kmfF6_@ s] sfdn] xf]ngL afFs] hfg] cfF6 rf}w c~rn &% lhNnf uLt ufpg ldNnfsL gldNnf -ag]kf xf] 3/_@ lg/dnf gfd d]/f] sfˆn] xf] y/ d]rL M tfKn]h'ª kfFry/ lhNnfdf Onfd em/L emfkfsf] lsNnfdf -lrof ;:tf] 5_@ k'u]/ kms{g'; d]rL s:tf] 5 sf]zL M ;+v'jf;ef ef]hk'/ t]x|y'd wgs'6fdf ljsf; 5 pw'd -df]/ª ;'g;/L_@ sf]zLsf] lt/}df k'Uof} s;/L ;u/dfyfM ;f]n'v'Da' em/]/ pbok'/ cf]vn9'Ëf vf]6fªdf hfg] ;'/ -;u/dfyf u]6_@ ;Kt/L k'u]/ l;/xfdf e]6 hgsk'/ M dxf]Q/L bf]nvf /fd]5fk hgsk'/df l;tfsf] kmlnkmfk -wg'iffsf] bfO{_@ l;Gw'nL psfnf] cfpgf]; ;/nfO{ jfUdtL M sf7df08f}+ eQmk'/ nlntk'/ sfe|] l;Gw' g'jfsf]6 hfg] ;'/ -jfUdtLsf] lt/_@ /;'jf wflbªdf hfg nfU5 lk/ gf/fo0fL M dsjfgk'/ k;f{ / lrtjg hfpF af/f lhGbuL latfpg -gf/fo0fL k'n_@ /f}tx6 k'u]/ k/]+ /0fe"n u08sL M nDh'ª cfpg df]/ª] gfgL uf]vf{ tgx'F hfg]sL ghfg] -c~rn u08sL_@ sf:sL / :ofªhfdf latfpF lhGbuL n'lDagL M gjnk/f;L u'NdL / kfNkf 5]p c3f{vfFrL ¿kGb]xL hfg b]p -slknj:t' ufpF_@ n'lDagL c~rn xf] a'4 v]Nof 7fpF wf}nflu/L M wf}nflu/L lxpF k¥of] ;]t} ls hfpF DofUbL sL cfpgf]; Pt} -kj{t jfUn'ª s:tf] 5_@ d':tfªsf] /ftf] :ofp ;f¥x} ;:tf] 5 /fKtL M ¿s'd /f]Nkf c~rn /fktL Ko"7fg hfg kg]{ ef] cfktL -;Nofgsf] jg_@ bfª k'Ug] s;/L ¿G5 d]/f] dg lgd{nf sfˆn] ;]tL M c5fd 8f]6L aemfª / afh'/f s}nfnLdf em/f}g xh'/ -;]tL c~rn_@ gu/ ltdLn] dg} rGrn dxfsfnL M a}t8L / 88]nw'/fdf xf]nf e]6 s~rgk'/df -56nf bfr'{nf_@ dxfsfnL k'u]/ d]rL kms'{nf