1. KM 2008 - Case Study
Andy Blunden Knowledge & HR Manager McCormick Rankin Cagney
2. Company & History
McCormick Rankin Cagney Pty Ltd
Transport Consultants South East Asia
50% owned by Australian employees and 50% by McCormick
Rankin Corporation (Canada) www.mrc.ca
Reputation for excellence in complex and unusual projects
Business Improvement Division underpins Transport Reform
Agenda and Executive support
Offices
Brisbane, Sydney, Melbourne, Newcastle, Auckland
Operating 7 years
Grown rapidly as niche Transport implementation partner
International and National presence www.mrcagney.com
3. Andy Blunden
MBA (Strategic Management, IT Management), Master
Information Systems
Knowledge & HR Manager
30+ years Training & Development, HR, IR, Organisation
Development experience
Consulting in Strategic development, Quality &
Productivity Improvement, Business Process Re
engineering
Specialising in Knowledge Management in Public and
Private sectors
4. The Traffic Management
Centre Project
Review and modernise Traffic Management Centre Nerang (Gold
Coast District manages over 1000km of state controlled roads in
most densely populate area of Qld)
Implement State of art Traffic Management Centre
Move centre to a 24 hour shift operation
Raise incident management quality & consistency in the district
Implement best practice processes and technologies
Standardise on road response to incidents
Improve relationships with key stakeholders (police, ambulance,
fire, towing services and public)
Implement new traffic management technologies and Motorway
management systems
This project driven by addition of new Tugun motorway connecting
Qld and NSW with Tunnel under Gold Coast airport runway
10 months work – 2 consultants, living and breathing Traffic
Management operations
5. What is a Traffic Management
Centre? – Background
A Traffic Management Centre operates a CCTV
network and other smart incident detection
systems
Responds to road incidents (Crashes, Breakdowns,
Abandoned vehicles, Congestion, Road rage)
Provides Motorist information and warnings (Web,
Phone Radio traffic reports, Variable Message
Signs, SMS, Smart GPS – Road Angel)
Adjusts the road network to (Traffic lights,
diversions)
Supports ‘on road’ Traffic Management response
Coordinates on road response (integrates Police,
Traffic Response Units, Fire, Ambulance, Towing)
Level of risk significantly higher with Tunnels (i.e.
Burnley incident, Mont Blanc tunnel fire)
6. Project Goals
Review the Nerang Traffic Management Centre operations for
efficiency/effectiveness toward best practice (Business process
review)
Codify operational knowledge and best practices
Improve culture
Raise operator performance through improved knowledge, training
and knowledge culture to meet changed operating requirements
Move to 24 hour shift operation
Operate Tugan motorway (incorporating tunnel under Coolangatta
airport runway)
Improve incident response, responder safety and service visibility
Integrate new traffic management technologies with work process
Provide consistent ‘look and feel’ of service as a model for Qld Dept
Main Roads across Qld
Create a model approach for possible other TMC implementations.
7. Project KM Challenges
Recruitment of 10 new staff
Rapid technical knowledge and skill acquisition to meet
Tugun timetable
Existing operational knowledge fragmented, inconsistently
applied and only partially documented
New information technology – complexity and number
Additional risk profile associated with tunnel management
(pressure to respond safely)
Outsourcing of on road (Traffic Management) response
While KM is a ‘Nice’ rather than ‘Nasty’ consulting process
there is still a need for change management in dealing with
Knowledge hoarders, Knowledge sellers and Knowledge
agents.
KM brings into play all of the other usual cultural obstacles
8. Underpinning theories
applied
Main Knowledge Management theories
applied
Davenport & Prusak - 5 modes of Knowledge
Generation
Hansen, Nohria and Teirney
Katzenbach & Smith - Wisdom of teams
Knowles – Androgogy
O'Dell &Grayson - Value Disciplines
Szulanski Knowledge Stickyness
Senge - Mental models & Learning Organisation
Johnson Scholes - Cultural Web
Kaplan and Norton Balanced Scorecard
9. The KM Application
Prusak - 5 modes
Acquisition of knowledge – Recruitment
Fusion – Facilitation of practices and improvement
Adaptation and Knowledge networking (involving all
staff in review of processes)
Hansen, Nohria and Teirney
Codification of explicit processes
Katzenbach & Smith - Wisdom of teams
Power of teams in improving knowledge and
communication – consulting approach
Knowles – Androgogy
Self directed learning, buy in, use of existing knowledge
10. KM Application continued
O'Dell &Grayson - Value Disciplines
Operational excellence
Szulanski Knowledge Stickyness
Removal of knowledge ‘stickyness’ via learning program and
ownership of the knowledge
Senge - Mental models
Challenge existing values and beliefs
Senge - Learning Organisation
Implementation of learning loops (debriefings)
Johnson Scholes - Cultural Web
Understanding the existing culture and thinking
Kaplan and Norton Balanced Scorecard
Providing tangible feedback on performance as an anchor to new
behaviours
11. Scope of work
Structure review
Recruitment of operators and team leader
Process review of the Traffic Management function
Knowledge codification (policy and procedure)
Intranet (Body of Knowledge) BOK development
Cultural alignment
Learning curriculum development and delivery leading
to knowledge transfer and capability
Implementation of innovation and learning loop
Mentoring, facilitation and support
Balanced scorecard
Post implementation audits and coaching
12. My aquired wisdom - Maxims
While the project can be defined as a KM project, KM requires
integration of well rounded project management, facilitation,
process review, documentation, learning & development and
change management skills
A consultant facilitates the long term behaviour changes that
underpins the new process and interactions – he/she needs to be
there a lot!
The cultural change comes from the way the project work is done
– live it, do it, role model it (it=behaviours)
Don’t announce the project – use a low key strategy.
Announcing the project is the same as wearing a target T shirt
Don’t do all the work yourself – Use the team to do it (but help
them) – Make it their system and processes – not yours
Practice Triage as a key change management process
Keep your word – follow through on all promises (write all
promises down)
13. KM Consulting Approach
Build Trust and confidence (no BOHICA)
Build ‘our own system’ (Not To, Not for, - With…)
No surprises – continuous communication
Pygmalion free zone (Treat all with respect)
Theory Y
Triage
Involvement (consultative but not democratic
i.e. ‘a say, not a vote’)
Assign progressive responsibility – reward the
helpers
Have fun
14. Cultural issues
Some staff threatened by hiring of new staff
Some pre - existing cultural issues (the thinking
was wrong)
Several rapid changes of team leader – no
continuity of leadership
Existing level of knowledge fragmented
Policy disconnect
Long term staff unaware of new environmental
threats, need for change or best practice
15. Future of the project
Hopefully this project will roll on to other Main
Roads districts (model the knowledge and
process) as they implement Traffic Management
Centres across Qld
Having representatives from other districts on the
steering committee tactically supports this
outcome
Cost of implementation in other districts will fall
due to Knowledge capture and lower cost of
replication
There are other major service standardisation
benefits likely from ‘domino’ implementation
16. Problem management
strategies
Communication matrix – Track acceptance (Triage)
Steering Committee – made responsible for making it happen
Communication meetings
Joint planning with the client and staff
Have a single project sponsor (who has power to help when
needed)
Early escalation of issues – cut ‘em off early
Risk matrix – continuous re assessment of project risks
Continuous communication (one on one)
Meet commitments and promises
Fix things that don’t work
Project web site (pull rather than push info)
Problem management database (each issue numbered)
17. Success management
Get early wins and celebrate ‘the new way’
Have fun and don’t be too serious
Promote successes – internal media
Capture ‘moments of truth’ and replay them
Engender pride in ‘what we achieved’
Be matter of fact and grounded - do not aim for
‘consultant glory’ or someone will surely shoot you
down
No silver bullets – just constant increments
Be prepared to recognise that something isn’t working
and fix it
Humour is good……
18. Measurement
TMC
Implementation of Balanced Scorecard within the
Traffic Management Centre
Project
Project % done report
Budget
Deliverables matrix
Risk matrix
19. Maintaining post
implementation momentum
Conduct of system audits
Post implementation support
Knowledge and Capability transfer (be able to
manage our system ourselves when you go)
20. Moments of Truth
Watching them respond to self directed
learning
Watching them respond to critical incidents
with confidence
Seeing the system work
Seeing the team grow
Hearing what others are saying about the
project
Being asked to do it again somewhere else