SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  23
The Instrumental Role of UnitedThe Instrumental Role of United
Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC) asNationalities Federal Council (UNFC) as
a Common Platform for the Ethnica Common Platform for the Ethnic
Groups in BurmaGroups in Burma
How superior the tactics of war,
How potent the weapons!
Without gathering in the hearts of the people,
Without relying on the strength of the people,
The sword edge will shatter,
The spear will bend.
Let-We Thondara (d. 1723-99)
Quoted by Aung San Suu Kyi, in
Freedom From Fear and other writings (1995)
Capital: Naypyidaw
Population: 60,280,000
Ethnic groups:
Bamar 68%
Shan 9%
Karen 7%
Rakhine 4%
Chinese 3%
Mon 2%
Indian 2%
Other 5%
IntroductionIntroduction
• The Union of Burma was founded on February 12, 1947.
• Burma obtained its independence from the British in 1948, with U Nu
as the Prime Minister.
• Since 1948 Burma had struggled to establish a modern democratic
political system and unite the people under its rule but failed on both
accounts.
• On November 13, 2010, Aung San Suu Kyi, a pro-democracy leader,
was released from a 15-year house arrest.
• In the year following (2011), Thein Sein was sworn in as the president
of the newly established civilian government of Burma.
Introduction (Cont.)Introduction (Cont.)
• President Thein Sein and Aung San Suu Kyi are the two key political figures actively engaged in
constructing a platform for political reforms and paving a way for future reconciliation.
• There exists three major political forces at work in Burma, Thein Sein’s government (backed up by military
junta), prodemocracy groups symbolized by the National League for Democracy (NLD) and ethnic
groups currently represented by United Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC).
Introduction (Cont.)Introduction (Cont.)
• There still remains a level of mutual distrust and animosity amongst the three major
political forces, which have created a substantial hindrance to any attempts at future
reconciliation and nationwide ceasefires.
• Within the non-major Burma ethnic groups themselves, there exist more than two political
and armed insurgencies representing differing priorities and interests (a source of
factional splits).
• In addition, the fragmented nature of the unity and solidarity amongst the ethnic groups
only makes it difficult for them to achieve a level of political empowerment and
legitimacy required to reduce the power imbalance between Thein Sein’s government
and the ethnic groups in the decision-making process.
• Consequently, these unfortunate developments have led Burma to a critical juncture
(fig. 1.3) that has necessitated a platform that will serve as an instrumental political force
uniting different prominent ethnic groups under one single entity and mobilize their
collective efforts towards rebuilding trust amongst themselves and creating a solid
political legitimacy.
Conflict ProgressionConflict Progression
IndicatorIndicator
DORMANT UNSTABLE DYNAMIC
AWARENESS OF CONFLICT
CONFRONTATION
NEGOTIATION
SUSTAINABLE
PEACE
Source: Adapted from Adam Curle, Making Peace (London: Tavistock Press, 1971)
Figure 1: Conflict Progression Indicator of Myanmar’s Conflict
ENGAGEMENT
ABANDONMENT
PROMOTION
ALL OUT WAR
CRITICAL
JUNCTURE
The Need for Trust-Rebuilding andThe Need for Trust-Rebuilding and
Unity amongst the Ethnic GroupsUnity amongst the Ethnic Groups
• Leaders from all concerned stakeholders have yet to display their sincere
commitment to bring about genuine reforms for the benefit of a whole nation.
• They must do it through reconciling their differences and rebuilding trust across
the lines of conflict amongst the tripartite political forces.
• This is seen as an essential foundation upon which future reconciliation and
mutual recognition of their interdependency can be obtained.
• However, before trust amongst the three major political forces (namely: Thein
Sein’s government and ethnic groups) can be rebuilt, trust amongst the ethnic
groups, or in other words, the leaders themselves has to be first and foremost.
Background: UNFCBackground: UNFC
• The United Nationalities Federal Council was formed on February, 2011 as an
umbrella alliance of all prominent ethnic groups to enable a strong and
legitimate representation in the ceasefire and peace talks.
• And my study attempts to analyze the instrumental role of UNFC as a
common platform for the ethnic groups, which serves as a precursor to:
1. rebuilding trust and forging unity/solidarity amongst the ethnic groups
2. establishing a safe atmosphere for an all-inclusive dialogue, empowerment and
mutual cooperation across the prominent ethnic groups
• A common platform has permeated an establishment of grass-roots level
social infrastructure and an implementation of various humanitarian and
developmental assistance that are crucial to addressing unmet human needs
of the ethnic people.
*Nippon Foundation is the sole provider behind the humanitarian/developmental works and Peacebuilding efforts
carried out by the United Nationalities Federal Council and its alliance of 11 ethnic groups.
Objectives of the StudyObjectives of the Study
& Research Questions& Research Questions
• The objectives of the study are:
o To investigate the different roles of the United Nationalities Federal
Council
o To explore the impact of the United Nationalities Federal Council as a
common platform for the ethnic groups in the process of community
rebuilding and peace building
• Research Questions:
1. Why is there a need for a unification of all the ethnic groups under one
single entity?
2. What are the instrumental roles of UNFC and an intermediary agent
(Nippon Foundation) and how do they impact the process of community
rebuilding and peace building
Research MethodologiesResearch Methodologies
• Two types of research methodologies were adopted:
1. Participatory Observation
2. One-on-one interview
The prime objective of this series of in-depth one-on-one interview with the leaders of
the ethnic groups is to understand and analyze the instrumental roles of United
Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC) for the ethnic groups.
• Field Research Locations:
1. First Field Trip (2012) Mae Sot and Chiang Mai, Thailand
2. Second Field Trip (2014) Chiang Mai, Thailand
The Different Roles of UNFC:The Different Roles of UNFC:
The Three Levels of Leadership in Peacebuilding
•Following Lederach (1977), three levels of work are required simultaneously to conceptualize
and construct a comprehensive transformation approach towards a sustainable peace
building process.
•In this setting, UNFC assumes different roles at different levels simultaneously:
1.Top-level leadership: engaging and participating in high-level negotiations
2.Middle-range leadership: providing a safe space for the ethnic minorities to gather
together and share their differing understanding and perceptions of the conflict and analyze
their roles in the conflict.
3.Grass-roots level leadership: although UNFC does not assumes the roles at this level it
nevertheless provides tangible and intangible necessity for the grass-roots level leaders.
•Since UNFC is neither a special peace nor diplomatic envoy, it is under no obligation to
comply with any conditions and/or rules of any entities. The freedom from such unnecessary
bureaucratic restrictions has afforded the UNFC to not concern itself too much with political
correctness/protocol and enabled it to reach out and connect with the grass-roots level
leaders of the ethnic areas and established an “Ethnic Affair Center”.
The Ethnic Affairs CenterThe Ethnic Affairs Center
Figure 7: Organizational Model for the Administration and Implementation of the Ethnic Affairs Center
The Different Roles of UNFCThe Different Roles of UNFC
(Cont.):(Cont.):
Peacemaker, Peacekeeper, and Peacebuilder:
•At the forefront of ethnic political engagement, UNFC with collective efforts and
coordinated cooperation of its 11 alliance members, has actively engaged in the process of
transformation and community rebuilding, which are a prerequisite for a sustainable level of
peacebuilding.
•It serves the roles as the peacemaker, peacekeeper and peace builder simultaneously
whose functions and intervention efforts are to facilitate negotiation process, maintain the
absence of military assault, address the power imbalance, and provide a humanitarian and
developmental assistance dedicating to improving the livelihood of the people in the ethnic
areas.
•The practical application of humanitarian assistance is fundamental to ensuring political
empowerment not only to the ethnic leaders but also to their respective peoples.
•The presence of international humanitarian workers in the ethnic areas serves as an indirect
pressure on the government to bring the ongoing military offensives to a halt, and equally
important, as an indirect counter to any future military offensives against the ethnic
minorities.
Infrastructure forInfrastructure for
Social CommunitySocial Community
Figure 6: A Fundamental Infrastructure for Social Community
Social Community Building consists of four pillars:
1)social infrastructure (basic physical and organizational
structures required for the operation of a society and the services
and facilities necessary for an economy to function, i.e. roads,
bridges, water supply, electrical grids, etc.);
2)education (the subject of language instruction is to be seriously
taken into account);
3)health care, and
4)agriculture
Infrastructure forInfrastructure for
Social CommunitySocial Community
An Instrumental Role of UNFC:An Instrumental Role of UNFC:
a Common Platforma Common Platform
• In the Burmese politics, ethnic groups without any political legitimacy and
empowerment have always been at a disadvantage. Given its de facto
power, militaristic might and guaranteed access to resources, the former
military junta (now replaced by Thein Sein’s government) has demanded that
the ethnic groups abide by its rules when formulating policies, designing
political frameworks, drafting agreements for ceasefires and outlining talks for
future reconciliation. Such mindless demands have only served to distance
themselves from the ethnic groups and further deepen mutual distrust and
antagonism.
• The UNFC was thus formed to serve as a common platform to accommodate
the demands of the ethnic groups, while it creates a safe atmosphere for an
all-inclusive dialogue amongst the different ethnic leaders. This ensures
solidarity amongst the groups and minimizes ‘factional splits’ within the groups.
The Instrument Roles of UNFC (Cont.)The Instrument Roles of UNFC (Cont.)
• Peacebuilding has a wide range of activities that place emphasis on the social, psychological, and
economic environment at the grass-roots (Galtung, 1976; Galtung & Ryan, 1995; Fisher, 1997). But
nevertheless the United Nationalities Federal Council has been able to fulfill a number of functions
demanded by peacebuilding efforts.
• The establishment of the “Ethnic Affair Center” is to address the urgent issues as regards political and
economic injustice and the denial of access to a secure livelihood imposed onto the ordinary people of
the ethnic minorities.
• Amongst the chief objectives of peacebuilding is to ensure that basic human needs of the ordinary
people are secured as well as protected.
• UNFC provides the necessary know-hows, skills, a skill-based infrastructure and the indispensable
financial support for the ethnic leaders to carry out the administrative management of the Ethnic Affair
Center.
• Ethnic leaders and grass-roots level leaders are encouraged to actively and proactively participate in
the process of rebuilding the community for their respective ethnic areas and restoring a secure
livelihood to their respective people.
• UNFC as a common platform thus serves to accommodate the demands of the ethnic groups while
creating a safe atmosphere for an all-inclusive dialogue amongst prominent ethnic groups in order to
ensure unity and solidarity amongst themselves.
The Roles a Political Support and IntermediaryThe Roles a Political Support and Intermediary
Agent of Nippon Foundation (Cont.)Agent of Nippon Foundation (Cont.)
• Nippon Foundation plays two important roles:
1. A financial donor
2. A political supporter
• The peacebuilding efforts and humanitarian work could not have been
possible without a solid and consistent support from Nippon Foundation.
• And equally important is its role as political support to UNFC and at the same
acts as an intermediary agent between Thein Sein’s government and the
ethnic groups.
• Because UNFC does not belong to any governmental and non-governmental
organizations, the question of its legitimacy remains vulnerable. Therefore,
Nippon Foundation with its high visibility at the nation, regional, and
international level leads UNFC the necessary political support required to
validate its legitimacy.
The Roles a Political Support and IntermediaryThe Roles a Political Support and Intermediary
Agent of Nippon Foundation (Cont.)Agent of Nippon Foundation (Cont.)
• Furthermore, having been appointed Japan’s representative to assist in the
reconciliation with the ethnic groups allows Nippon Foundation to play the
role of a political support to UNFC and act as an intermediary agent between
Thein Sein’s government and the ethnic groups.
• In other words, it serves as a connection between the two major political
forces, Thein Sein’s government and the ethnic groups, facilitating mutual
understanding and acknowledgement of the roles played by the two sides
which is crucial to making possible a coordinated cooperation across the top
level leaders.
RecommendationsRecommendations
• Formulating and constructing a greater integrated
peacebuilding efforts (directing not only at the
ordinary ethnic people but also the ordinary
Burman) for greater inclusion
• Fostering reconciliation at the grass-roots level
(Buman and non-Burman)
• Creating a tri-lingual society
UNFC_(AK)

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Political dynamics and social processes
Political dynamics and social processesPolitical dynamics and social processes
Political dynamics and social processes
Kayode Fayemi
 
Nation State And National Interest
Nation State And National InterestNation State And National Interest
Nation State And National Interest
Anas ali
 
01 basic concepts in international relations
01 basic concepts in international relations01 basic concepts in international relations
01 basic concepts in international relations
fatima d
 
Introduciton to international relation
Introduciton to international relationIntroduciton to international relation
Introduciton to international relation
Anjan Kumar Dahal
 
Theories of International Relations-Introduction
Theories of International Relations-IntroductionTheories of International Relations-Introduction
Theories of International Relations-Introduction
Keshab Giri
 
International relations chapter 1 states
International relations   chapter  1  statesInternational relations   chapter  1  states
International relations chapter 1 states
t-MBA Digital
 
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS PRESENTATION (2)
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS PRESENTATION (2)INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS PRESENTATION (2)
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS PRESENTATION (2)
Gelab Piak
 
Chapter 8 presentation
Chapter 8 presentationChapter 8 presentation
Chapter 8 presentation
krobinette
 

Tendances (20)

Actors of international relations
Actors of international relationsActors of international relations
Actors of international relations
 
WHAT IS FOREIGN POLICY AND WHY STATES MUST HAVE FOREIGN POLICY
WHAT IS FOREIGN POLICY AND WHY STATES MUST HAVE FOREIGN POLICYWHAT IS FOREIGN POLICY AND WHY STATES MUST HAVE FOREIGN POLICY
WHAT IS FOREIGN POLICY AND WHY STATES MUST HAVE FOREIGN POLICY
 
How The Media Can Develop Patriotism
How The Media Can Develop PatriotismHow The Media Can Develop Patriotism
How The Media Can Develop Patriotism
 
Difference State Actors and Non state Actors
Difference State Actors and Non state ActorsDifference State Actors and Non state Actors
Difference State Actors and Non state Actors
 
National power
National powerNational power
National power
 
Political dynamics and social processes
Political dynamics and social processesPolitical dynamics and social processes
Political dynamics and social processes
 
2013-2014 International Relations Lecture Slides
2013-2014 International Relations Lecture Slides2013-2014 International Relations Lecture Slides
2013-2014 International Relations Lecture Slides
 
Assignment on international relation by seerat abbas
Assignment on international relation by seerat abbasAssignment on international relation by seerat abbas
Assignment on international relation by seerat abbas
 
International Relations
International Relations International Relations
International Relations
 
Nation State And National Interest
Nation State And National InterestNation State And National Interest
Nation State And National Interest
 
01 basic concepts in international relations
01 basic concepts in international relations01 basic concepts in international relations
01 basic concepts in international relations
 
Elements of National Power
Elements of National PowerElements of National Power
Elements of National Power
 
Polsc6 1 the study of international relations
Polsc6   1 the study of international relationsPolsc6   1 the study of international relations
Polsc6 1 the study of international relations
 
Introduciton to international relation
Introduciton to international relationIntroduciton to international relation
Introduciton to international relation
 
Theories of International Relations-Introduction
Theories of International Relations-IntroductionTheories of International Relations-Introduction
Theories of International Relations-Introduction
 
Polsc6 3 core principles in ir
Polsc6   3 core principles in irPolsc6   3 core principles in ir
Polsc6 3 core principles in ir
 
International relations chapter 1 states
International relations   chapter  1  statesInternational relations   chapter  1  states
International relations chapter 1 states
 
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS PRESENTATION (2)
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS PRESENTATION (2)INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS PRESENTATION (2)
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS PRESENTATION (2)
 
Slide 7 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
Slide 7 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016Slide 7 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
Slide 7 WestCal Political Science 1 - US Government 2015-2016
 
Chapter 8 presentation
Chapter 8 presentationChapter 8 presentation
Chapter 8 presentation
 

Similaire à UNFC_(AK)

ၿငိမ္းခ်မ္းစြာအတူယွဥ္တြဲေနထိုင္ေရး၀ါဒမွသည္စစ္မွန္ေသာဖက္ဒရယ္ျပည္ေထာင္စုစနစ္သို...
ၿငိမ္းခ်မ္းစြာအတူယွဥ္တြဲေနထိုင္ေရး၀ါဒမွသည္စစ္မွန္ေသာဖက္ဒရယ္ျပည္ေထာင္စုစနစ္သို...ၿငိမ္းခ်မ္းစြာအတူယွဥ္တြဲေနထိုင္ေရး၀ါဒမွသည္စစ္မွန္ေသာဖက္ဒရယ္ျပည္ေထာင္စုစနစ္သို...
ၿငိမ္းခ်မ္းစြာအတူယွဥ္တြဲေနထိုင္ေရး၀ါဒမွသည္စစ္မွန္ေသာဖက္ဒရယ္ျပည္ေထာင္စုစနစ္သို...
ဆရာ ဟိန္းတင့္ေဇာ္
 
Global Trend CHAPTER ONE jjjiiiuyy I iuyy.pdf
Global Trend  CHAPTER ONE jjjiiiuyy I iuyy.pdfGlobal Trend  CHAPTER ONE jjjiiiuyy I iuyy.pdf
Global Trend CHAPTER ONE jjjiiiuyy I iuyy.pdf
seraphimkassa
 
CopyofPositionPaperPrompt (1)
CopyofPositionPaperPrompt (1)CopyofPositionPaperPrompt (1)
CopyofPositionPaperPrompt (1)
Benjamin Fletcher
 
Global Trend AASTU.pptx
Global Trend AASTU.pptxGlobal Trend AASTU.pptx
Global Trend AASTU.pptx
KibromFiseha
 
Reginald M.J. Oduor (Nairobi, Kenya): Identity Politics in the Twenty-first C...
Reginald M.J. Oduor (Nairobi, Kenya): Identity Politics in the Twenty-first C...Reginald M.J. Oduor (Nairobi, Kenya): Identity Politics in the Twenty-first C...
Reginald M.J. Oduor (Nairobi, Kenya): Identity Politics in the Twenty-first C...
Thomas Huebel
 
State and civil resistance
State and civil resistanceState and civil resistance
State and civil resistance
Assam University
 

Similaire à UNFC_(AK) (20)

ၿငိမ္းခ်မ္းစြာအတူယွဥ္တြဲေနထိုင္ေရး၀ါဒမွသည္စစ္မွန္ေသာဖက္ဒရယ္ျပည္ေထာင္စုစနစ္သို...
ၿငိမ္းခ်မ္းစြာအတူယွဥ္တြဲေနထိုင္ေရး၀ါဒမွသည္စစ္မွန္ေသာဖက္ဒရယ္ျပည္ေထာင္စုစနစ္သို...ၿငိမ္းခ်မ္းစြာအတူယွဥ္တြဲေနထိုင္ေရး၀ါဒမွသည္စစ္မွန္ေသာဖက္ဒရယ္ျပည္ေထာင္စုစနစ္သို...
ၿငိမ္းခ်မ္းစြာအတူယွဥ္တြဲေနထိုင္ေရး၀ါဒမွသည္စစ္မွန္ေသာဖက္ဒရယ္ျပည္ေထာင္စုစနစ္သို...
 
E0322040047
E0322040047E0322040047
E0322040047
 
Global Trend CHAPTER ONE jjjiiiuyy I iuyy.pdf
Global Trend  CHAPTER ONE jjjiiiuyy I iuyy.pdfGlobal Trend  CHAPTER ONE jjjiiiuyy I iuyy.pdf
Global Trend CHAPTER ONE jjjiiiuyy I iuyy.pdf
 
National Integration Essay
National Integration EssayNational Integration Essay
National Integration Essay
 
Digital marketing SEO Study Social media media
Digital marketing SEO  Study Social media  mediaDigital marketing SEO  Study Social media  media
Digital marketing SEO Study Social media media
 
Proospects for governance and peace in ethnic states
Proospects for governance and peace in ethnic statesProospects for governance and peace in ethnic states
Proospects for governance and peace in ethnic states
 
PPP - 1, GLOBAL TRENDS.pptx
PPP - 1, GLOBAL TRENDS.pptxPPP - 1, GLOBAL TRENDS.pptx
PPP - 1, GLOBAL TRENDS.pptx
 
PPP - 1, GLOBAL TRENDS.pptx
PPP - 1, GLOBAL TRENDS.pptxPPP - 1, GLOBAL TRENDS.pptx
PPP - 1, GLOBAL TRENDS.pptx
 
Achieving Peace And Ethnic Harmony Through Civil Society Activism Multi Trac...
Achieving Peace And Ethnic Harmony Through Civil Society Activism  Multi Trac...Achieving Peace And Ethnic Harmony Through Civil Society Activism  Multi Trac...
Achieving Peace And Ethnic Harmony Through Civil Society Activism Multi Trac...
 
CopyofPositionPaperPrompt (1)
CopyofPositionPaperPrompt (1)CopyofPositionPaperPrompt (1)
CopyofPositionPaperPrompt (1)
 
global pag 72.pptxhafdabshhxybeudydbskdi
global pag 72.pptxhafdabshhxybeudydbskdiglobal pag 72.pptxhafdabshhxybeudydbskdi
global pag 72.pptxhafdabshhxybeudydbskdi
 
Weaknesses of Ethnic Federalism in Ethiopia
	Weaknesses of Ethnic Federalism in Ethiopia	Weaknesses of Ethnic Federalism in Ethiopia
Weaknesses of Ethnic Federalism in Ethiopia
 
Global Trend AASTU.pptx
Global Trend AASTU.pptxGlobal Trend AASTU.pptx
Global Trend AASTU.pptx
 
Reginald M.J. Oduor (Nairobi, Kenya): Identity Politics in the Twenty-first C...
Reginald M.J. Oduor (Nairobi, Kenya): Identity Politics in the Twenty-first C...Reginald M.J. Oduor (Nairobi, Kenya): Identity Politics in the Twenty-first C...
Reginald M.J. Oduor (Nairobi, Kenya): Identity Politics in the Twenty-first C...
 
State and civil resistance
State and civil resistanceState and civil resistance
State and civil resistance
 
POWER SHARING CLASS 10 DEMO POL
POWER SHARING CLASS 10 DEMO POLPOWER SHARING CLASS 10 DEMO POL
POWER SHARING CLASS 10 DEMO POL
 
HRU GLOBAL AFFAIRS (1).pptx
HRU GLOBAL AFFAIRS (1).pptxHRU GLOBAL AFFAIRS (1).pptx
HRU GLOBAL AFFAIRS (1).pptx
 
Chapter 5 Introductin to Civics and Ethics LART 1001 (1).pptx
Chapter 5  Introductin to Civics and Ethics  LART 1001 (1).pptxChapter 5  Introductin to Civics and Ethics  LART 1001 (1).pptx
Chapter 5 Introductin to Civics and Ethics LART 1001 (1).pptx
 
ေန႔စဥ္ၿငိမ္းခ်မ္းေရးသတင္းစဥ္ ၊ မတ္လ (၂၁) ရက္ေန႔ ၊ ၂၀၁၇ ခုႏွစ္။
ေန႔စဥ္ၿငိမ္းခ်မ္းေရးသတင္းစဥ္ ၊ မတ္လ (၂၁) ရက္ေန႔ ၊ ၂၀၁၇ ခုႏွစ္။ ေန႔စဥ္ၿငိမ္းခ်မ္းေရးသတင္းစဥ္ ၊ မတ္လ (၂၁) ရက္ေန႔ ၊ ၂၀၁၇ ခုႏွစ္။
ေန႔စဥ္ၿငိမ္းခ်မ္းေရးသတင္းစဥ္ ၊ မတ္လ (၂၁) ရက္ေန႔ ၊ ၂၀၁၇ ခုႏွစ္။
 
Youth and Peacebuilding
Youth and PeacebuildingYouth and Peacebuilding
Youth and Peacebuilding
 

UNFC_(AK)

  • 1. The Instrumental Role of UnitedThe Instrumental Role of United Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC) asNationalities Federal Council (UNFC) as a Common Platform for the Ethnica Common Platform for the Ethnic Groups in BurmaGroups in Burma
  • 2. How superior the tactics of war, How potent the weapons! Without gathering in the hearts of the people, Without relying on the strength of the people, The sword edge will shatter, The spear will bend. Let-We Thondara (d. 1723-99) Quoted by Aung San Suu Kyi, in Freedom From Fear and other writings (1995)
  • 3.
  • 4. Capital: Naypyidaw Population: 60,280,000 Ethnic groups: Bamar 68% Shan 9% Karen 7% Rakhine 4% Chinese 3% Mon 2% Indian 2% Other 5%
  • 5. IntroductionIntroduction • The Union of Burma was founded on February 12, 1947. • Burma obtained its independence from the British in 1948, with U Nu as the Prime Minister. • Since 1948 Burma had struggled to establish a modern democratic political system and unite the people under its rule but failed on both accounts. • On November 13, 2010, Aung San Suu Kyi, a pro-democracy leader, was released from a 15-year house arrest. • In the year following (2011), Thein Sein was sworn in as the president of the newly established civilian government of Burma.
  • 6. Introduction (Cont.)Introduction (Cont.) • President Thein Sein and Aung San Suu Kyi are the two key political figures actively engaged in constructing a platform for political reforms and paving a way for future reconciliation. • There exists three major political forces at work in Burma, Thein Sein’s government (backed up by military junta), prodemocracy groups symbolized by the National League for Democracy (NLD) and ethnic groups currently represented by United Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC).
  • 7. Introduction (Cont.)Introduction (Cont.) • There still remains a level of mutual distrust and animosity amongst the three major political forces, which have created a substantial hindrance to any attempts at future reconciliation and nationwide ceasefires. • Within the non-major Burma ethnic groups themselves, there exist more than two political and armed insurgencies representing differing priorities and interests (a source of factional splits). • In addition, the fragmented nature of the unity and solidarity amongst the ethnic groups only makes it difficult for them to achieve a level of political empowerment and legitimacy required to reduce the power imbalance between Thein Sein’s government and the ethnic groups in the decision-making process. • Consequently, these unfortunate developments have led Burma to a critical juncture (fig. 1.3) that has necessitated a platform that will serve as an instrumental political force uniting different prominent ethnic groups under one single entity and mobilize their collective efforts towards rebuilding trust amongst themselves and creating a solid political legitimacy.
  • 8. Conflict ProgressionConflict Progression IndicatorIndicator DORMANT UNSTABLE DYNAMIC AWARENESS OF CONFLICT CONFRONTATION NEGOTIATION SUSTAINABLE PEACE Source: Adapted from Adam Curle, Making Peace (London: Tavistock Press, 1971) Figure 1: Conflict Progression Indicator of Myanmar’s Conflict ENGAGEMENT ABANDONMENT PROMOTION ALL OUT WAR CRITICAL JUNCTURE
  • 9. The Need for Trust-Rebuilding andThe Need for Trust-Rebuilding and Unity amongst the Ethnic GroupsUnity amongst the Ethnic Groups • Leaders from all concerned stakeholders have yet to display their sincere commitment to bring about genuine reforms for the benefit of a whole nation. • They must do it through reconciling their differences and rebuilding trust across the lines of conflict amongst the tripartite political forces. • This is seen as an essential foundation upon which future reconciliation and mutual recognition of their interdependency can be obtained. • However, before trust amongst the three major political forces (namely: Thein Sein’s government and ethnic groups) can be rebuilt, trust amongst the ethnic groups, or in other words, the leaders themselves has to be first and foremost.
  • 10. Background: UNFCBackground: UNFC • The United Nationalities Federal Council was formed on February, 2011 as an umbrella alliance of all prominent ethnic groups to enable a strong and legitimate representation in the ceasefire and peace talks. • And my study attempts to analyze the instrumental role of UNFC as a common platform for the ethnic groups, which serves as a precursor to: 1. rebuilding trust and forging unity/solidarity amongst the ethnic groups 2. establishing a safe atmosphere for an all-inclusive dialogue, empowerment and mutual cooperation across the prominent ethnic groups • A common platform has permeated an establishment of grass-roots level social infrastructure and an implementation of various humanitarian and developmental assistance that are crucial to addressing unmet human needs of the ethnic people. *Nippon Foundation is the sole provider behind the humanitarian/developmental works and Peacebuilding efforts carried out by the United Nationalities Federal Council and its alliance of 11 ethnic groups.
  • 11. Objectives of the StudyObjectives of the Study & Research Questions& Research Questions • The objectives of the study are: o To investigate the different roles of the United Nationalities Federal Council o To explore the impact of the United Nationalities Federal Council as a common platform for the ethnic groups in the process of community rebuilding and peace building • Research Questions: 1. Why is there a need for a unification of all the ethnic groups under one single entity? 2. What are the instrumental roles of UNFC and an intermediary agent (Nippon Foundation) and how do they impact the process of community rebuilding and peace building
  • 12. Research MethodologiesResearch Methodologies • Two types of research methodologies were adopted: 1. Participatory Observation 2. One-on-one interview The prime objective of this series of in-depth one-on-one interview with the leaders of the ethnic groups is to understand and analyze the instrumental roles of United Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC) for the ethnic groups. • Field Research Locations: 1. First Field Trip (2012) Mae Sot and Chiang Mai, Thailand 2. Second Field Trip (2014) Chiang Mai, Thailand
  • 13. The Different Roles of UNFC:The Different Roles of UNFC: The Three Levels of Leadership in Peacebuilding •Following Lederach (1977), three levels of work are required simultaneously to conceptualize and construct a comprehensive transformation approach towards a sustainable peace building process. •In this setting, UNFC assumes different roles at different levels simultaneously: 1.Top-level leadership: engaging and participating in high-level negotiations 2.Middle-range leadership: providing a safe space for the ethnic minorities to gather together and share their differing understanding and perceptions of the conflict and analyze their roles in the conflict. 3.Grass-roots level leadership: although UNFC does not assumes the roles at this level it nevertheless provides tangible and intangible necessity for the grass-roots level leaders. •Since UNFC is neither a special peace nor diplomatic envoy, it is under no obligation to comply with any conditions and/or rules of any entities. The freedom from such unnecessary bureaucratic restrictions has afforded the UNFC to not concern itself too much with political correctness/protocol and enabled it to reach out and connect with the grass-roots level leaders of the ethnic areas and established an “Ethnic Affair Center”.
  • 14. The Ethnic Affairs CenterThe Ethnic Affairs Center Figure 7: Organizational Model for the Administration and Implementation of the Ethnic Affairs Center
  • 15. The Different Roles of UNFCThe Different Roles of UNFC (Cont.):(Cont.): Peacemaker, Peacekeeper, and Peacebuilder: •At the forefront of ethnic political engagement, UNFC with collective efforts and coordinated cooperation of its 11 alliance members, has actively engaged in the process of transformation and community rebuilding, which are a prerequisite for a sustainable level of peacebuilding. •It serves the roles as the peacemaker, peacekeeper and peace builder simultaneously whose functions and intervention efforts are to facilitate negotiation process, maintain the absence of military assault, address the power imbalance, and provide a humanitarian and developmental assistance dedicating to improving the livelihood of the people in the ethnic areas. •The practical application of humanitarian assistance is fundamental to ensuring political empowerment not only to the ethnic leaders but also to their respective peoples. •The presence of international humanitarian workers in the ethnic areas serves as an indirect pressure on the government to bring the ongoing military offensives to a halt, and equally important, as an indirect counter to any future military offensives against the ethnic minorities.
  • 16. Infrastructure forInfrastructure for Social CommunitySocial Community Figure 6: A Fundamental Infrastructure for Social Community
  • 17. Social Community Building consists of four pillars: 1)social infrastructure (basic physical and organizational structures required for the operation of a society and the services and facilities necessary for an economy to function, i.e. roads, bridges, water supply, electrical grids, etc.); 2)education (the subject of language instruction is to be seriously taken into account); 3)health care, and 4)agriculture Infrastructure forInfrastructure for Social CommunitySocial Community
  • 18. An Instrumental Role of UNFC:An Instrumental Role of UNFC: a Common Platforma Common Platform • In the Burmese politics, ethnic groups without any political legitimacy and empowerment have always been at a disadvantage. Given its de facto power, militaristic might and guaranteed access to resources, the former military junta (now replaced by Thein Sein’s government) has demanded that the ethnic groups abide by its rules when formulating policies, designing political frameworks, drafting agreements for ceasefires and outlining talks for future reconciliation. Such mindless demands have only served to distance themselves from the ethnic groups and further deepen mutual distrust and antagonism. • The UNFC was thus formed to serve as a common platform to accommodate the demands of the ethnic groups, while it creates a safe atmosphere for an all-inclusive dialogue amongst the different ethnic leaders. This ensures solidarity amongst the groups and minimizes ‘factional splits’ within the groups.
  • 19. The Instrument Roles of UNFC (Cont.)The Instrument Roles of UNFC (Cont.) • Peacebuilding has a wide range of activities that place emphasis on the social, psychological, and economic environment at the grass-roots (Galtung, 1976; Galtung & Ryan, 1995; Fisher, 1997). But nevertheless the United Nationalities Federal Council has been able to fulfill a number of functions demanded by peacebuilding efforts. • The establishment of the “Ethnic Affair Center” is to address the urgent issues as regards political and economic injustice and the denial of access to a secure livelihood imposed onto the ordinary people of the ethnic minorities. • Amongst the chief objectives of peacebuilding is to ensure that basic human needs of the ordinary people are secured as well as protected. • UNFC provides the necessary know-hows, skills, a skill-based infrastructure and the indispensable financial support for the ethnic leaders to carry out the administrative management of the Ethnic Affair Center. • Ethnic leaders and grass-roots level leaders are encouraged to actively and proactively participate in the process of rebuilding the community for their respective ethnic areas and restoring a secure livelihood to their respective people. • UNFC as a common platform thus serves to accommodate the demands of the ethnic groups while creating a safe atmosphere for an all-inclusive dialogue amongst prominent ethnic groups in order to ensure unity and solidarity amongst themselves.
  • 20. The Roles a Political Support and IntermediaryThe Roles a Political Support and Intermediary Agent of Nippon Foundation (Cont.)Agent of Nippon Foundation (Cont.) • Nippon Foundation plays two important roles: 1. A financial donor 2. A political supporter • The peacebuilding efforts and humanitarian work could not have been possible without a solid and consistent support from Nippon Foundation. • And equally important is its role as political support to UNFC and at the same acts as an intermediary agent between Thein Sein’s government and the ethnic groups. • Because UNFC does not belong to any governmental and non-governmental organizations, the question of its legitimacy remains vulnerable. Therefore, Nippon Foundation with its high visibility at the nation, regional, and international level leads UNFC the necessary political support required to validate its legitimacy.
  • 21. The Roles a Political Support and IntermediaryThe Roles a Political Support and Intermediary Agent of Nippon Foundation (Cont.)Agent of Nippon Foundation (Cont.) • Furthermore, having been appointed Japan’s representative to assist in the reconciliation with the ethnic groups allows Nippon Foundation to play the role of a political support to UNFC and act as an intermediary agent between Thein Sein’s government and the ethnic groups. • In other words, it serves as a connection between the two major political forces, Thein Sein’s government and the ethnic groups, facilitating mutual understanding and acknowledgement of the roles played by the two sides which is crucial to making possible a coordinated cooperation across the top level leaders.
  • 22. RecommendationsRecommendations • Formulating and constructing a greater integrated peacebuilding efforts (directing not only at the ordinary ethnic people but also the ordinary Burman) for greater inclusion • Fostering reconciliation at the grass-roots level (Buman and non-Burman) • Creating a tri-lingual society