5. NIAC:
Threshold requirement:
By reference to the intensity of the violence and
the organisation of the armed group.
So internal armed conflicts:
Those which meet the threshold(IHL apply)
Those which do not(HRL, domestic laws apply)
6. Qualification of Conflicts between state and
armed group:
Any difficulty?
Based on the good will of governments?
7. Motives/purpose of armed groups is irrelevant
ICTY:
the determination of the existence of NIAC is
based solely on:
The intensity of conflict
and organization of parties
8. Global war on terrorism:
An armed conflict (NIAC)( US position)
ICRC position:
Case by case approach,
And IHL applies only if violence involved reaches
the level of armed conflict
9. End of an armed conflict:
Terminative processes:
End of active hostility
Transformative/metamorphic processes:
Internationalization: from NIAC to IAC
Internalization: From IAC to NIAC
10. From IAC to NIAC: Libya, Iraq, Afghanistan
Foreign intervention toppling governments
And the newly formed government fighting the
former government
11. Possible scenarios under NIAC:
Government vs armed group with in
territory of a single state
Between armed groups with in a territory
of single state
Armed group vs state and the conflict
spilling over into the territory of another
state
12. NIAC:
MNFs with a government of a host state against an
armed groups in the territory of the latter
UN/AU forces sent to stabilize a host state by
fighting against armed groups in the host country.
13. NIAC:
When a state engages an armed
group that originate from the
territory of another state without
the latter’s control or support
The seventh is when NIAC is waged
across territories by non-state
armed group/transnational
14. Rules applicable to NIAC:
Common art.3
Additional Protocol II
Hague Rules
Customary Rules
Marten’s Clause
General Principles of IHL
Analogous Application of rules of IAC
16. Protection against torture, and humiliating
treatment
Those who have laid down their arms
Those placed horse de combat by sickness,
wound, detention
Those not taking direct part in hostilities
17. Prohibition of pillage, slavery, taking hostage,
displacement
Prohibition of recruitment of children
Civilian population shall be protected
Protection of medical personnel
Protection of cultural objects
18. Protection of works and installations containing
dangerous forces
Protection of cultural objects
Protection of relief societies
20. Similarities:
Protection of hors de combat
Protection of civilians
Protection of civilian objects
Rules on conduct of hostilities
Principles of IHL
21. Protection of those not taking direct part in
hostilities
Judicial guarantees
Principles of non-discrimination
Prohibition of torture, inhumane and degrading
treatment
Prohibition of pillage, displacement
22. ICC Rome Statute
Genocide
War crime
Crime against humanity