SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  246
Objectified Assessment of
Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA) in Real-
Time as an Aid for Treat-to-Target
   (T2T) Treatment Strategy
                    Prof. A. N. Malaviya,
                      MD, FRCP (Lond.), M-ACR, FAMS, FNASc
     Ex- HOD Medicine and Chief of Clinical Immunology & Rheumatology, AIIMS
         Consultant Rheumatologist, ISIC Superspeciality Hospital, New Delhi

                          Dr. S. B. Gogia,
                     MS (Surgery), Consultant Surgeon,
                               Past President IAMI
Rheumatoid disease
• A systemic multiorgan disease where the
  brunt of the disease is on the joints in the
  extremities
• It is an autoimmune where the body’s own
  defence system attacks the body itself.
• The disease has genetic basis.
• What is (are) the trigger(s) for these genes to
  start attacking the body remain to be
  discovered (smoking is one of them)
Pathogenesis well characterised

  Imbalanced production of cytokines with
   excess of proinflammatory cytokines the
  main one being tumour necrosis factor – α
                    (TNF-α)
Dramatic advances in the treatment of
                RA
• Disease modifying drugs (DMARDs)
• Biological response modifiers (Biologics)
• Which drug; at what stage of the disease;
  what dose and routes:
  – Monotherapy
  – Combination therapy
  – Strategy for their use
RA treatment
                  From being
 “There is not much that can be done, patient
                  would die”
             It has now become a
“Treatable condition where patients can lead a
                  normal life”
With dramatic advances in drug treatment of this
                    disease
RA can now be compared to
diabetes, hypertension and other
        chronic diseases
         They can be well controlled
  With almost a normal life span with good
                quality of life
         Don’t worry about ‘cure’ –
  Although ~ 20% go in drug-free remission
Basic treatment strategy for these
               diseases
• Keep the disease under ‘tight control’
  – Keep Hb-A1C < 6 (by proper close follow-up and
    regular blood testing) in diabetes
  – Keep BP <140/90 (will need to be adjusted for
    younger people) in patients with hypertension
• This approach of treatment is called ‘treat-to-
  target’ (T2T)
• How do we know what is the target in RA? There
  are so many domains in the disease, very unlike
  diabetes or hypertension!
RA has multiple domains
•   Pain in the joints
•   Swelling in the joints
•   Poor ‘general health’ due to disease
•   Poor ‘function’ due to joint involvement
•   Inflammation in the body
            All this needs to be measured
    How do we obtain a number that represents
           DISEASE ACTIVITY ON THAT DAY?
Composite indices
• Disease activity index (44 joints) – DAS44
   – With erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR)
   – With C-reactive protein (CRP)
• Disease activity index (28 joints) – DAS28
   – With erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR)
   – With C-reactive protein (CRP)
• Clinical Disease activity index – CDAI
• Simplified Disease activity index – SDAI
   – With erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR)
   – With C-reactive protein (CRP)
RA disease assessment using DAS28
• DAS28 = 0.56 * sqrt(tender28) + 0.28 *
  sqrt(swollen28) + 0.70 * ln(ESR) + 0.014 * GH
• < 2.6 = Remission
• < 3.2 = Low disease activity
• < 5.1 = Moderate disease activity
• > 5.1 = High disease activity
RA assessment using CDAI and SDAI
• SDAI = (28TJC) + (28SJC) + MDGA + PtGA + CRP*
  –   Remission = <3.3
  –   Low disease activity = >3.3 to <11
  –   Moderate disease activity = >11 to <26
  –   High disease activity = >26

• CDAI = (28TJC) + (28SJC) + MDGA + PtGA*
  –   Remission ≤2.8
  –   Low disease activity = >2.8 to ≤10
  –   Moderate disease activity = >10 to ≤22
  –   High disease activity = >22
Assessment of RA
• At each patient visit to the clinic we must know the
  status of disease activity to keep it under tight control
  i.e.:
• In ‘remission’
Or at least
• In ‘low disease state’
Therefore:
• It becomes mandatory to have DAS28 or CDAI or SDAI
  at each visit
       To be able to adjust the drugs / drug dosages
         To keep the disease under ‘tight control’
Remember the formulae?
• DAS28 = 0.56 * sqrt(tender28) + 0.28 *
  sqrt(swollen28) + 0.70 * ln(ESR) + 0.014 * GH
• SDAI = (28TJC) + (28SJC) + MDGA + PtGA +
  CRP*
• CDAI = (28TJC) + (28SJC) + MDGA + PtGA*
• Can you imagine doing the calculations and
  finding out whether the patient is in:
  – Remission, low disease state or not?
Gadgets are needed
• Pre-programmed calculators
• On-line DAS calculators (now available)
• Why not have an EMR that would help:
  – Permanent record of patient’s medical record
    including medical history, examination findings,
    laboratory test records
  – Sequential assessment details
  – Make drug prescriptions as well!
      That is the question Dr. Gogia asked us
  (rheumatologists) when he saw us struggling for
    the use of ‘T2T’ approach for our RA patients
Development of rheumatology-specific
                EMR
• Two of us worked closely
• Understanding each other’s way of working
• Work-flow of a rheumatology clinic was
  understood by Dr. Gogia
• ‘Objectified assessment methodology’ as
  discussed including all the composite indices for
  the assessment of disease activity and their
  formulae, cut-off points etc.
• Final EMR (~ 2 ½ years in development) ready for
  use
Front sheet of the medical record
RA assessment in real-time
Prescription
Final appearance of the face-sheet
              now
Face-sheet at the last visit
Prescription handed over to the
            patient
Summary
• Rheumatology-EMR has the following
  advantages:
  – Quick and objectified assessment for guiding
    treatment
  – Clearly stated disease status
  – Neat prescription with detailed instructions
  – Appointment, tests before the next visit
  – Many other benefits: more patients in the same
    time period, data-mining easy for research
Thank you
Significance Of An Appropriate
 Change Management Strategy In
 Successful Implementation Of A
 Health Management Information
 System
Dr. Aman Rana (IIHMR, Delhi)
               &
Dr. Anandhi Ramachandran (IIHMR, Delhi)
HEALTH CARE INFORMATION SYSTEM
  • Corporate Social Responsibility
  • Benefits: for management- Workforce: an asset
    - track of health status
    -underlying occupational hazard
    -success of any health intervention
    -medi-claims easy
    Employees:
    -sense of security
    -all information at one place
    -reduced medical negligence
STUDY BACKGROUND:
• Location
  A notable public organization,
  EMPLOYEE HEALTH MANAGEMENT
  SYSTEMS (EHMS) : Unsuccessful for past 2
  years
OBJECTIVES
• To understand the Knowledge and Attitude of
  the Employees towards EHMS
• To ascertain the reasons for failure of EHMS
  adoption in the organization
• To put forth an operational framework for
  successful adoption of EHMS
• To evaluate the success of the interventions
  implemented
• To provide a suitable recommendations for
  future continuous adoption of EHMS
METHODOLOGY
• STUDY TYPE: Quantitative
• SAMPLE SIZE: 353 employees
• SAMPLING: Convenience Sampling
• DATA UTILIZED: Primary and Secondary data
• TOOLS USED: Questionnaires, Focus Group
 Discussions and Personal Interviews
PRE INTERVENTION STATUS:
• Out of the 353 employees:
 • 5 = somewhat correct awareness of EHMS ( All
   Admin.)
 • 12= filled up self declarations
 • No one had filled up the detailed periodic health
   record.
 • 85 = had some where heard of EHMS but had no clear
   idea of what it is.
 • 251 = people had never heard of EHMS.

• In house doctors (2 in number) found the system too
  technical to understand and time consuming to work
  on.
BARRIER TO ADOPTION

• Technical Barriers
• User Perception of EHMS
• Resisting Change
USE OF IT TO INITIATE CHANGE
MANAGEMENT

                  People




        Process        Technology
8 Steps to Transform an Organization
(‘Harvard business review on change’ by John P.Kotter)
1. Establishing a sense of Urgency
2. Forming a powerful guiding coalition
3. Creating a vision
4. Communicating the vision
5. Empowering others to act on the vision
6. Planning for and creating short-term wins
7. Consolidating improvements and producing
   still more change
8. Institutionalizing new approaches
FRAMEWORK PROPOSED
INTERVENTIONS ADOPTED
POST INTERVENTION STATUS
• AWARENESS REGARDING EHMS:
   all 353 employees.

• SELF- DECLARATIONS FORMS STATUS:
   226

• PERIODIC HEALTH EXAMINATION STATUS:
   26

• DOCTORS’ CONSULTATION
   Motivated and trained. Patient Consultation and Drugs
  dispensing through the system.
CADRE WISE RESPONSE TO THE
  INTERVENTION PROGRAMME
• Management staff:
  ▫ Out of 172 people, 107 filled up declaration forms.
• Non Management staff/ Clerical Staff:
  ▫ 90 out of 124 gave in their self declarations.
• Labor staff:
  ▫ 29 out of 57 filled up their self declarations
ASSESSMENT OF THE CHANGE
MANAGEMENT PROCESS
• 100% awareness raised
• 64% of the staff entered self declaration forms
• Which contained preliminary health data.
• 7% people filled PHR forms which included detailed
  information about person’s health data and past medical
  history.
• Implies in spite of awareness, the workforce still needs to
  accept and be a part of EHMS endeavor. So, the people
  still need to know more about PHR. Awareness needs to
  be accompanied with some visual fringe benefits.
• Privacy and confidentiality issues
RECOMMENDATIONS PROPOSED FOR
FUTURE ACTION
• A Change Management Champion.
• Administration should embrace the change in
  the process, communicate vision and promote
  health seeking behavior in the staff.
• Doctors: not just acceptors but also propagator.
• Doctors, Administrator and staff should sharea
  good rapport.
• Periodic review: every six months
• Teams: Seniors and Juniors equal mix.
POINTS TO BE REMEBERED
• Change management is not an event but a process which needs a
  focused vision and a visionary.
• The employees should be involved in the process from the initial
  level.
• It is the responsibility of top management to assure that the
  workforce stays motivated throughout.
• The leaders, who will propagate the change should be the ones who
  are trusted by all and share excellent rapport with everyone.
• The more aware people are, the easier is the acceptance.
• The Employees’ expectations from the product should be kept
  realistic throughout.
• It is as essential to retain the change as it is to bring the change.
REFERENCES
•   McCarthy,M., and Eastman, D., Change Management Strategies for an Effective EMR
    Implementation. Ohio: HIMSS; 2010. Available from: www.himss.org/content/files/Change
    Management.pdf. Accessed 2011.

•   Strebel, P., „Why Do Employees Resist Change?‟ Harvard Business Review May–June 1996

•   Cohen D. The Heart of Change Field Guide: Tools and Tactics for Leading Change in Your
    Organization. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press; 2005.

•   .Bridges W. Managing Transitions: Making the Most of Change. 2nd ed. Cambridge, MA: Perseus
    Publishing; 2003.

•   Campbell, Robert James. Change Management in Health Care. Health Care Manager. 27(1):23-
    39, January/March 2008.

•   Abraham J, Feldman R, Carlin C,Understanding Employee Awareness of Health Care Quality
    Information: How Can Employers Benefit? Health Services Research 39:6, Part I (December
    2004)

•   Heeks R. (2006) Health information systems: failure, success and improvisation. Int J Med
    Inform. Feb; 75(2), 125-37.

•   Al-Mashari, M., and Zairi, M. (1999) BPR implementation process: An analysis of key success and
    failure factors. Bus. Process Manag. J. 5(1), 87–112

•   Beynon-Davies, P., and Lloyd-Williams,M. (1999) When health informationsystems fail. Top.
    Health Inf. Manage 20(1), 66–79.

•   Chang, R., Process Reengineering in Action: A Practical Guide to Achieving Breakthrough Results.
    Jossey-Bass Pfeiffer, San Francisco, 1999.
Hardeep Singh, MD MPH                         Invited Panelists:
 Houston VA Health Services Research           Max Health Care EHR Team
        Center of Excellence              (Divye Chhabra, Nikhil Mishra, Neena
                                                Pahuja, Shubnum Singh)
         Dean F. Sittig, PhD                               And
 The University of Texas Health Science            Kanav Kahol, PhD,
Center School of Biomedical Informatics     Public Health Foundation of India
   Momentum for large scale health reform to
    improve delivery and patient outcomes

   Transformation must leverage use of
    technology

   Technology use must be accompanied by a
    strategic approach accounting for the context
    of the environment where implemented.
   A Hospital system implements an EHR but a
    year later has to switch to another one
   U.K. Scrapping National Health IT Network
      “…(after) nine years and £11.4 billion
      ($18.7 billion), the British government is
      about to scrap its attempt to build a
      massive, nationwide health IT network
      for the 52 million residents of England,
      a London news report says…”
   Efficiency - 10% reduction
   Inconsistent Clinical Decision Support
    outcomes
   We expect quality & safety to improve, but…
     22 types of computerized provider order entry
      (CPOE) errors
     Unexpected downtimes
     900 patients mistakenly given Viagra instead of
      Zyban due to an error in the dispensing
      pharmacy’s medication mapping table
   National electronic health record (EHR)-
    based intervention in VA
     Required all pathology results (normal or
     abnormal) to be transmitted to ordering providers
     via mandatory automated notifications
   We analyzed 2 hospitals…results were a bit
    surprising…


                                    Laxmisan et al Under Review
Is this ALL bad health IT?
   Design, development, implementation, use,
    and evaluation of health information
    technology is complex and prone to failure

   Need a method of understanding the
    relationships to get it “right”



                         Sittig & Singh JAMA 2009
 Discuss a multi-faceted “socio-
  technical” approach to safe and
  effective health IT implementation
  and use
 Discuss how these socio-technical
  concepts could apply to health IT
  projects currently underway in India
   Dean F. Sittig, PhD - Model Dimensions

   Hardeep Singh, MD MPH – U.S. Case Studies

   Discussion of model application in India:
     Private health system (Max Health Care IT Team
      and Leadership)
     Public health system (Kanav Kahol, PhD, Public
      Health Foundation of India)
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Must be capable of supporting ALL
    required clinical activities.
   EHR should be able to:
     Calculate a medication dose
     Transmit the order to the appropriate
      department
     Notify the nurse of a
      placed order
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Standard medical vocabularies to
    encode clinical findings

   Clinical knowledge to create specialty-
    specific features and functions

   Must be evidence-based, carefully
    constructed, monitored, complete, and
    error free
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Allows clinicians to quickly grasp a complex system
    safely and efficiently
   Displays all the relevant patient data so clinicians can
    rapidly perceive problems, formulate responses, and
    document actions.
   Physical aspects of the interface (e.g., keyboard,
    mouse, or touch screen) may also contribute to error
    in input or selection of information.
   ? Common user interface
    standards
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Trained and knowledgeable personnel are
    essential
     System developers
     Trainers, implementers, and maintenance staff
     Users
   Close interaction among informatics experts,
    clinical application coordinators, and end
    users is essential
   Staff of dedicated
                     knowledge engineers


   Subject matter
    experts
   Clinical content
    committees
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Disruptions in workflow or information
    transfer are fertile grounds for inefficiencies
   Careful workflow analysis that accounts for
    health IT use could lead to identification of
    potential breakdown points
   Errors may result from interventions that are
    not delivered at the best point in the
    workflow
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Work environment
   Culture of innovation, exploration, and
    continual improvement are key
   Organizations should:
     Actively facilitate reporting of errors or barriers to
      care resulting from health IT use,
     carefully review their existing policies and
      procedures before implementation.
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Regulations may act as barriers or facilitators for safe
    EHR use
   Patient privacy
   Policies must address safety and effectiveness of
    health information exchange across organizational
    boundaries
   State and federal governments should create an
    environment compatible with widespread use and
    interoperability
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
 Organizations must continually
 evaluate usability & performance of
 systems after implementation to:
  Reliably measure benefits
  Assess potential e-iatrogenic effects
Acknowledgments:
             VA, NIH, AHRQ, ONC

    Eight Rights of Safe Electronic Health Record Use
              JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113

Safe electronic health record use requires a comprehensive
           monitoring and evaluation framework
               JAMA. 2010 Feb 3;303(5):450-1

A new sociotechnical model for studying health information
   technology in complex adaptive healthcare systems.
      Qual Saf Health Care. 2010 Oct;19 Suppl 3:i68-74.
Hardeep Singh, MD, MPH
                Chief Health Policy Quality Program,
 Houston Veterans Affairs Health Services Research &
                   Development Center of Excellence
       Michael E. DeBakey VA Medical Center & BCM
Director, Houston VA Patient Safety Center of Inquiry
   Research and evaluation case studies in:
     Communication of diagnostic test results
     CPOE prescriptions
     Electronic Referrals

   How can the model guide us towards a
    high performing “EHR enabled work-
    system”
   Safety issues related to communication
    and coordination breakdowns prevalent

   What affect will technology have on
    communication and coordination of test
    results and referrals?


                           Singh & Graber JAMA 2010
▫ Alert in “View
  Alert” window
Example of a
   critical
imaging alert
   Communication more than information
    transfer
     Response and appropriate follow-up action

   Providers may not acknowledge all alerts
    they receive; some lost to follow-up
   Timely follow-up should occur if they
    acknowledge an alert

                                       Singh et al JAMIA 2007
   Evaluation of timely follow-up actions on abnormal
    test result notifications communicated through the
    View Alert system
     1,163 outpatient abnormal labs & 1,196 abnormal
      imaging results
     7% labs lacked timely follow-up despite
      acknowledgment
     8% imaging lacked timely follow-up despite
      acknowledgment
                             Singh et al AJM 2010 and Archives of IM 2009
“One of the issues is just the
sheer volume of alerts, and
there’s a number of alerts that
in all honesty [you] really don’t
have any business seeing.”
   Barriers & solutions span multiple dimensions:
     Software (functionality for saving, tracking, and retrieving
      alerts)
     Content (e.g. what alert types are absolutely necessary)
     Usability/ UI (improving existing functionality to improve
      signal to noise ratio)
     Workflow (e.g., surrogate alerts when providers out of
      office)
     Providers (e.g. knowledge)
     Organizational (e.g. training, policies for follow-up)

                                             Singh et al Under review
 Of 532 scripts reported to have
 inconsistent communication
  20% errors had potential for severe
   harm, if they reached the patient
 Issues: training, complex orders


                           Singh et al Arch Int Med 2009
   Transmission and tracking of referrals
    finally possible!
     Of 61,931 referrals, 36% discontinued and
      0.8% unresolved at 30 days
     Unexplained lack of follow-up actions by
      subspecialists in 6.3% of all referrals
     Unexplained lack of follow-up by PCPs in
      7.4% of discontinued referrals
                                    Singh et al JGIM 2010
   Marked differences in PCPs' and subspecialists'
    communication views (e.g. content)
   Lack of an institutional referral policy,
   Lack of standardization in referral procedures,
   Ambiguity in roles and responsibilities, and
   Inadequate resources to adapt and respond to
    referral requests effectively
   Very few technology barriers
                                    Hysong et al Impl Science 2011
Information Technology

Measuring and Tracking the Progress of Implementing a
  Comprehensive Electronic Health Record: A Mixed-
                 Methods Approach
                   February 5, 2012
Authors

Sandeep Budhiraja MD1
Nikhil Mishra1
Divye Chhabra MD1
Dean F. Sittig, PhD2
Hardeep Singh, MD, MPH3
Neena Pahuja PhD1
1Max   Health Care Institute Ltd., New Delhi

2Professor,School of Biomedical Informatics, University of Texas Health Sciences
   Center, Houston, Texas, USA
3Chief,Health Quality and Policy Program, Houston Veterans Affairs Health
   Services Research and Development Center of Excellence and Baylor College
   of Medicine, Houston, Texas, USA
Disclaimer




No conflict of interest
Some Published Statistics: IT
                             supporting Healthcare

Ref: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-15340102

• Death rates gone down by 17% among emergency patients
  (16,000 deaths preventable)
• Higher accountability of staff
• Lower cases of missed medicine
• Medication allergy alerts supports safer healthcare
• Reduction of medication errors to ½.
• Checks on infection control
Hospital Group Level Systems Integration
             Evolutionary need for Health Information Exchange

                  •Network of 8 hospitals in NCR
                  •Expanded by 4 new, spreading to
                   rest of north India. Altogether ~1900 beds
                  •EHR implementations complete in 4 hospitals

                   Hospital            Data
                 Group level
                 integration          Centre




                    Sheer           Health
                  Volume of
                    Patient           care
                 information        ‘cloud’


51
Information Technology
eCare - Key Terms



•   CPRS - Computerized Patient Record System
•   EHR - Electronic Health Record
•   HIS - Hospital Information System
•   CPOE- Computerized Physician Order Entry
•   BCMA - Bar Coded Medication Administration
•   COWs – Computer On Wheels
The eCare vision

• To have a patient centric clinical record
• Embracing change to standardize care processes across the
  organization
• To improve electronic access and availability of patient clinical
  information
• To capture multi-
  disciplinary patient
  information
• The implementation of a
  minimum data set
  ensuring foolproof
  documentation
Rationale EHR Implementation

• Complete IT Outsourcing
• WorldVistA integrated to Max-HIS
• Rationale
   – Potential reduction of medical errors
   – Improved medication management
   – Rapid access to vital and accurate information
   – Reduced duplication of services and cost
   – Access to a more comprehensive picture of health for promoting
     advances in the diagnosis and treatment of illnesses
   – Improved and informed decision making
   – Providing continuity of care to patients



                                  55
Preparation for EHR Implementation

• External Consultants
• Process mapping of as-is workflows
• Data Cleaning
• Design Future-State Workflows (Map “as-is” to system
  functionality)
• Approach
    –   Prepare patient demographics integration
    –   Prepare for Lab, Radiology & Pharmacy
    –   BCMA (e-MAR + closed loop medicine administration)
    –   CPOE




                                   56
Preparation for EHR Implementation

• Training, Training & more Training
• Change Management is the key
• Big-Bang approach for IT- systems
   – Phased approach “Slow change” for humans
• Super-Users and Change Managers



• 23rd July 2011 6 months




                               57
Study Methodology

• Mixed method for measuring and tracking progress of EHR
   implementation
First
   – quantitative approach
   – six “automated” metrics
   – extracted from Mumps database (Backbone)
                                                             Senior Consultants
Second                                                       Junior Consultants
                                                             Floor Mentors
   – interviewed four groups of representative users         Nursing Supervisor
   – Content analysis of interviews identify major themes
Third
   – fact-finding questionnaires


   A total of 5 months of Data
                                     58
Barcode Medical Administration




COW*– Nurse
Login                     Barcoded Patient
Identifying the nurse     Wrist Band
                          Identifying the
                          patient

                                                 Barcoded Label
                                                 on Drug-
                                                 Identifying the Drug
Right Patient, Right Drug, Right Time

* COW- Computer on wheels                   59
Results I-
                              Quantitative Approach – 6 automated Metrics

 Implementation Metric                                             % Use

 1) Use of Progress Notes                                           76%

 2) Use of CPOE for medications, procedures, lab and               100%
    imaging tests
 3) Documentation of 2 daily inpatient progress notes               65%
    (morning and evening) by a consultant on all
    inpatients
 4) Use of Problem lists involving selection from ICD-9             15%
    coded problems
 5) Documentation of Input and Output logs by nurses    82% in IPD, Critical care on
                                                          parallel paper process
 6) Use of BCMA by nurses                                  Real Time MAR 41%,
                                                        however including after the
                                                            fact goes upto 78%

EHR-Structure                             60
Results II-
                                    Interviews with representative groups

Qualitative Analysis
Younger Doctors        -more comfortable
Senior Consultants     -hesitant with new technology
                       -had low degree of adoption.
Typing issues - Only 28% were comfortable

EHR system “complexity” - main concern of participants
                (mainly senior consultants)
Perceived reduction of efficiency- due to time required in day to day
However most users- post 2-3 days of hands-on EHR use
        -perceived its benefits
        -reported high degree of comfort in its use.
        -Divide between resistors and early adopters



                                       61
Results II contd-
                                          Interviews with representative groups

Differences between doctors and nurses also emerged
    –   100% nurses had to use the system from day one
    –   Also had attended all training sessions
    –   Doctors were hard pressed for time for training as well as day to day use
    –   Ongoing Support

Facilitators of the process
• Leadership role (Top Management)
• Clinical Transformation & Change Management
• User friendly clinical templates
• Easy accessibility of all Max enrolled patients’ records
    – Any Max facility
    – Any Patient
• Light System (client application) - quick response time & stability
    – also be credited with aiding its acceptance.

                                             62
Results III-
                                                     Fact-finding Questionnaires


• “Did You Know” type features of system identified
   – 12 in number, All Specific to doctors, 5 of these generic to nurses
             – Nurses faired 5/5
             – Doctors varied from 5-8


• Additionally 18 specific fact finding questions ranging from
   – Rate your own usage, comfort level, perceived improvements
   perceived benefits, suggestions for improvement




                                           63
Results III contd-
                                                             Fact-finding Questionnaires

        Five level scale used (Very Low Low Medium High Very High)
      Question Group                 Majority             Others
   Comfort level in using system           65% Low to Medium           13-18% on both extremes
 Viewing of existing notes/progress
               notes
                                           83% Medium to High               rest Very High
                                        scattered result 50% low to
   Usage of templates on CPRS                                               very few High
                                                 Medium
           Usage of Orders
     (lab/radio/drug/procedures)
                                          83% High to Very High                   _
  Frequency of entering findings of
                consult
                                           52% Medium to high                 30% Low
Viewing of reports on CPRS software     Majority high to Very High                _
                                        Surprisingly High to Very
       Comfort level of typing
                                                   High
   Ease of use of CPRS software          78% Medium to High            Rest Low, none very high
 Rate the overall improvement in time
           taken for activities
                                           80% Medium to High                 10% low
 Rate the overall improvement in the
        efficiency for activities
                                           90% Medium to High                     _
In your deptt. How would you rate the
                                         Scattered results ranging
   benefit of using systems over the                 64                           _
            existing process               from low to very high
Challenges Identified

• CPOE- Filling time for STAT medication orders,
  only 90% compliance
   Identified as an area for improvement

• An increase in the overall time in the discharge
  process when the EHR was only used partially
   - both paper + electronic records
   - expected to be transitional phase



                       65
Discussion

• Early experience Largest implementation of its kind
   – 4 facilities, comprehensive EHR, large health care system
• Several lessons learned by measuring and tracking
   –   Patience and aggressive Change Management is key
   –   Focus and Support from Leadership
   –   People don’t like to put in data, but once its there they really value it
   –   Benefits are perceived only by the ones who use more and vice-
       versa
             – Early adopters benefit more than laggards
             – Laggards resist most
             – Aggressive Supporting required at least till ratio tips in favor of adopter




                                             66
Thank You
Further Benefits

• Chronic Care Management using clinical reminders
   – Clinical reminders
          – automated reminders
          – for the clinicians based on rules (diagnosis/ lab result/ drug allergy etc)

• Diabetic care
   – Reminders setup for
          – Periodic Glycosylated Hemoglobin (HbA1c)
          – Diabetic Foot Exam (Skin and Neurological)
          – Diabetic Eye Exam
   – Data of these reminders when due is periodically passed to
     Endocrinology team who in turn suggest the same to patients
          – Services with Ophthalmology, Podiatry and Lab services is coordinated
            through Endocrinology




                                          68
Appendix
Ancillaries

• COWS*
• Wrist Bands
• Drug Labels




*COWS- Computer On Wheels
Change Management Is Key

•   It is not an IT project…..its an operations project
•   Leadership support

•   Support support     support…..evolve…support
•   Train train ….retrain….evolve….support
•   Help on call- 24 hour support …..Human aspects




•   Workshops
•   As is workflows/future state
•   Ease everyone in.
                                          71
Change Management After Go-Live

•   Healthcare- Standardized but flexible
•   Operations cannot slow down to support change
•   Shaken users prone to errors
•   Real time support
•   Leadership support




                          72
Results III contd-
                                                                                 Fact-finding Questionnaires

             Five level scale used (Very Low Low Medium High Very High)
            Question Group                                        Majority                           Others
         Comfort level in using system                       65% Low to Medium               13-18% on both extremes
    Viewing of existing notes/progress notes                83% Medium to High                    rest Very High
         Usage of templates on CPRS                  scattered result 50% low to Medium           very few High
  Usage of Orders (lab/radio/drug/procedures)               83% High to Very High                       _
    Frequency of entering findings of consult                52% Medium to high                     30% Low
     Viewing of reports on CPRS software                  Majority high to Very High                    _
             Comfort level of typing                    Surprisingly High to Very High
 Rate the availability of the COW(computer on        Scattered results ranging from low to
               wheels) in a ward
                                                                                                        _
                                                                  very high
         Ease of use of CPRS software                       78% Medium to High               Rest Low, none very high
 Rate the overall improvement in time taken for
                    activities
                                                            80% Medium to High                      10% low
Rate the overall improvement in the efficiency for
                    activities
                                                            90% Medium to High                          _
In your deptt. How would you rate the benefit of     Scattered results ranging from low to
    using systems over the existing process
                                                                                                        _
                                                                  very high

                                                                      73
Kanav Kahol
Division of Affordable Health Technologies
Public Health Foundation of India
kanav.kahol@phfi.org
Recommendation 3.6.4 Establish a Health IT Network
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Mhealth Solutions.
   Portable with long or
    extended battery life.
   Enable non-physicians
    to deliver care with
    supervision and
    monitoring
   Example: Swasthya
    Slate
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Indigenized and local
    language support.
   Allow co-
    development by
    central agencies and
    local players through
    computer supported
    collaborative
    platforms.
   Need support for
    empowerment of
    patients and the
    healthcare workers.
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Use of semiotics and
    images is helpful
   Simplified
    questionnaires and
    sets.
   Affordance of the
    user interface is key.
MyPortal                         State and District Portals
         MyHealth                              Epidemiology
     MyAppointments                        Early Warning Systems
        MyMessages                           Messaging Center
       MyTreatments                          Certification Portal
                                               Learning Portal
                                          Community Health Portal
                        eHealth/mHealth
                            Portals
Physician and Hospital Portal
                                               National Portal
       Patient Alerts
                                     Certification Standards and Results
    Scheduling Manager
                                             Health Promotion
      Message Center
                                          National Security Portal
   Information Reporting
Financial Management Portal
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Technology illiteracy
    is rapidly reducing.
   People born in 1994
    will be 22 in 2016.
   Creation of suitable
    cadres already a part
    of the UHC Report.
   Usable technology is
    the key
   Gap skills training will
    have to be
    undertaken.
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Public Health Decision
    Support System
   Use algorithms from
    supply chain and
    related fields to help
    with optimal resource
    usage and allocation.
   West Bengal and
    Drishti.
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Promote use
    of HealthIT
   Use grants
    and universal
    payer
    mechanism
    to ensure
    compliance.
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Use single payer as a leverage for adoption along
    with grants.
   Clearly define telemedicine (Use telemedicine law
    draft)
   Define privacy and security laws.
   Ensure the right to connectivity.
Hardware and
                             Monitoring
                                                 Software



              Workflow and
                                                              Content
             Communication


                                    Issue Under Study


               State and
                                                                User
                Federal
                                                              Interface
                 Rules



                           Organizational
                                                 Personnel
                           Characteristics



JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
   Monitoring Financial and Clinical measures is the
    key.
   EHR enables a method of authentication and
    verification.
   Case in Point: Mother Child Tracking System and
    Immunization Records.
   Use cloud.
   Caveat: Make reporting easy.
   Caveat: Reporting is not the only or the most
    important feature of ICT.
Personal Eternal Health
        Passbook

                               By
    Dr. G. D. Mogli, Ph.D., MBA., FHRIM (UK), FAHIMA (USA)
                  Chief Executive Officer & MD
         Dr. Mogli Healthcare Management Consultancy
            www.drmogliit.com gdmogli@yahoo.com
                              Formerly served as
    WHO Consultant and Sr. Consultant /Adviser to the Ministries of Health
India, Afghanistan, Iran, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Oman, Bahrain, Qatar, UAE &
                      Sr. Consultant eHealth Management
                           HEARTCOM INC. (USA)
Evolution of medical records

                                                               EHR/PH
                                                               R????

                             Comprehe             Computer
              • card           nsive      Unit
Writing on                              records     based
                Outpatient    medical              records
  walls         s             records                        Comprehensive
                                                              unit records




                                                             Outpatient cards
Personal Eternal Health Passbook
       The “Personal Eternal Health Passbook (PEHP) containing the ID, is a lifelong
electronic, universally available document, initiated at the time of birth, containing,
mother’s delivery information including congenital anomaly, immunizations given.
This will contain entire information such as episodic, hospitalization, self medications
and other habits including significant events. This is maintained by parents/guardian
and contains immunizations, growth charts, significant events and health status. The
PEHP information is contributed by health care providers and self and maintained in
a secure and private environment, with the individual determining rights of access”.

                                                                         Definition by---
                                                                         Dr G. D Mogli
PEHP

 PEHP kept by individual, EHR by Hospital

 PEHP   is owned by individual and contain every detail.

 PEHP    information is managed by (care providers and himself).


 Right of access of record is owned by PEHP owner.
What EHR cannot have? But
          What PEHP can have?

 Awareness among patients through media.

   Internet forums and blogs for medical information.
   Persons suffering from minor ailments, doesn’t visit, hospitals,
   Applies self medication, self care/treatment.
   Extensive information leads to Self-medication too.




                       This kind of information is not recorded in a EHR which could
                       prove to be detrimental for patient care.
Non Allopathic treatment
 Many types of medicine are coming to light and being practiced.
   Ex: Unani, Acupuncture, homeopathy, ayurvedic, yogic healing etc..




 EHR is based on allopathic only.
  other medications / therapies underwent by the patient is not recorded.
Types of PEHP

 Paper based.

 PC-based.
 Web based. (maintained on private line-accessed by    username and password)

 Hybrid (desktop/Web-based.)
    A mix of both PC’s and Online PEHP.
 PEHP. Connecting through USB port to the computers.
Personal Eternal Health Passbook
What should the PEHP contain

   Patient Identification Data.
   Health Summary.                 Hospitalization.
   Child Development.              Obstetrics & Gynecology.
   Immunizations.                  Surgeries/Therapy.
                                    Chronic Disease (old age).
   Self care/treatments.
                                    Allergies and Drug
   Medications.                    sensitivities.
   Investigations.
Patient ID format
 3 parts
 Part I contains: Personal data.
 Part II contains: allergies, blood group, significant health
   problems.
 Part III    contains: other habits such as food, alcoholic,
   smoking, any addiction, environmental, exercise, etc.
Patient Care Summary
 For recording chronological data.
 Should record details of visits to OP,IP,ER etc..
 Self care or other treatments.
Child Development
 Growth chart for children from 0-5 or 0-14 years.
Immunizations
 Mainly for children and also can be used for adults.
 Indicates due dates for other immunizations e.g. 1st dose, 2nd
  dose etc..
Self-care for medication / treatment
 A unique feature of PEHP.
 Available only with the PEHP and not found in the
  allopathic healthcare organizations.
Medications
 Chronological account of medications used and being used currently.
 E-prescription, refills, and address of the pharmacies
Investigations

 Chronological account of investigations carried out will be available.
Hospitalization record
 Chronological account of all admissions and
  discharges with the results.
Obstetrics & Gynecology
 For women patients from child bearing age onwards.
 Periodic Mammography check information is also recorded.
Therapy
 Different types of therapies such as physical, occupational,
  speech, optometric refractions, radio therapy etc. are recorded.
Implementing PEHP

 People Born prior to implementation

 New born records –to be maintained by the care taker

 Carry a pen-drive, external hard drives or any other
  portable devices on move.

 Patient with conditions (heart diseases, diabetes, hypertension) should
  carry Alert devices for Emergency.
Conclusion…..
 EHR at health institution level and PEHP at personal level
  to gain complete 360 degree information.


 For providing continuity of care to patient, at right time,
  at right place and at right cost.

 PEHP prevents duplication of investigations,
  medications, delay in care, check on risk and cost.
Continue………………
 Standardizing of PEHP information for continuity of care.

 PEHP allows practitioners from different settings and
  disciplines to share information.

 Allows the patient to carry this information with him or her
  upon referral, transfer, or discharge.
Normal condition



              Update
              PEHP                    Physician
                                      treatment
Disease
state




 Self
 medication              Non allopathic
                         therapy
Effects of PEHP on the Patients
Advantages                       Disadvantages
 Information on the go.          Cumbersome for
 Ensure Information is            maintaining.
  accurate and complete.          Access to the Computers.
 Self medication is updated.     Illiteracy.
 Different physicians opinion
  recorded.                       Costs him extra.
 Careful                         Security concerns.
 Handy in Emergency.             Accessing the web in
 Quick treatment                  remote places.
 prevents duplication
Effects of PEHP for the Physicians
Advantages                          Disadvantages
   Complete Information.            Distrust on Information
   Quick treatment.                  viability.
   Opinions of other physicians.    Doesn’t like to expose his
                                      opinion.
   Disease pattern is easy to
    understand.                      Fear of medico-legal issues.
                                     Duplication of records.
                                     Increased workload.
Medical record
 MR history parallels the history of medicine.

 Contains medical information of an individual from
  “Womb to Tomb”.

 “A clear, concise and accurate history of the patient's life and
  illness, written from the health point of view, and is a complete
  compilation of scientific data derived from many sources,
  coordinated and integrated into an orderly document for
  further multifarious uses”.
                                                    --Dr G.D Mogli
Necessity
 Contains patient demographic information, history,
  physical examination, progress notes, investigations,
  consultations opinions, diagnosis, treatment including
  medical, surgical, therapies.


Necessary for various reasons.
                                                                     Insurance sector
             Medico legal cases


                                                 &
                                    analysis    Also for effective
                                  Patients forget but Records remember"
Advantages of EHR
    Manual records             Electronic records
Inaccessibility, parts of   Decentralized,
the records are              simultaneous access all
geographically widely        the time.
distributed.
                             Active it can trigger
Passive: unable to          certain actions according
trigger certain actions      to the data

 “Manual” linkage           “Increased” linkage
                             with external health care
Time consuming to           providers
explore for clinical or
financial studies            Excellent basis to
                             conduct clinical and
                             financial studies
Some Current PEHP Providers




             And many
             more……
Problems with EHR
 Interoperability
       Vendors develop readymade software’s
        / In-house tailor made
        to suit only certain
       health institutions.

 Survey indicates old
      people want to follow the
      manual records.

            These are problems which can be solved by developing
            of standards.
EHR (Electronic health record)
 Refers to an individual patient's longitudinal
  medical record in digital format.
 Easy to maintain.
 Usually accessed on a computer,
  often over a network.
 Instantly accessible to all authorized from
  different stations.


              High end gadgets are available for
             making the recording easy.
Precautions In selecting a PEHP provider
   Ensure Security of the records.
   Maintain Confidentiality of records.
   Ensure Privacy.
   Technologically stable and advanced.
   Should be Interoperable.
   Cost.
   Provide long term support.
A Wireless Sensor Network based Fall
Detection and Activity Monitoring System
             for the Elderly
                         By
  Prof. Subrat Kar, Sanat Sarangi and Akshat Bisht

  Bharti School of Telecommunication Technology and
               Management, IIT Delhi, India

                  NCMI 2012, AIIMS
Motivation
   Prevalent technologies-
       Smart Insole, Smart Cane and Smart Headset monitor underfoot
        pressure, improper usage behaviour and EEG signals
        respectively.
       Armbands, waistbands and ankle-bands have been developed
        that measure skin temperature, energy spent (calories) and
        activity.
   Our concern is to not just to create a smart device but a smart space
    using a number of such devices – a sensor network.
   A sensor network helps communicate events of interest over large
    geographic distances without using a legacy network.
Sensor Networks
Sensor Nodes:
   Low-cost
   Resource-constrained
   Autonomous
   Form a resilient Mesh
    Network, hence the
    term- Sensor Network
   Fault Tolerant
Gaitsense
              (Gait Assessment System)
   Consists of

        A sensor network formed by gait nodes and relay nodes.
        A multi-tier control and notification system (consisting of a gateway, user application and
         DBMS) that talks to Internet and cellular networks.
             Gateway acts as an interface between the sensor network and the GUI-based user
              application and logs all communication in the DBMS.
             User Application provides multi-dimensional visualization capabilities for sensor
              events through charts, tables and maps.
             User Application runs custom algorithms that take specific actions based on user
              requirements and sends appropriate notifications.
Gait Node
   Consists of a sensor node and an accelerometer.
   The Sensor node has a extremely low-power micro-controller and on-board
    radio transmission capabilities.
   The accelerometer can sense acceleration on upto three axes. Acceleration is
    used to recognize gait characteristics.
   Gait Node can be conveniently worn at the waist or ankle to detect the state of
    the subject- standing, sleeping, walking, running, fallen.




                                       Status of gait node 1 as seen in user application

           Gait Node
Deployment Scenario
   A Geriatric care unit as shown, can
    be a possible application scenario
    for GaitSense.
   The objective is to monitor
    residents wearing gait nodes and
    auto-notify events such as postural
    changes, activity changes or
    number of steps taken.
   Fixed relay nodes installed at
    strategic positions and the gait
    nodes form a sensor network that
    reliably streams events to the
    gateway and user application in the
    administrative section.
   Services like email, twitter or sms
    are used to send notifications.
Example Deployment
Conclusion
   A fall detection and activity monitoring system for the elderly is
    proposed and its integration with the public communication
    infrastructure is discussed to enable its widespread adoption.
   By notifying events like a fall, the system promises to help
    reduce human casualties by allowing effective rescue and
    remedial operation-planning.
   The systematic automated recording of all behavioural aspects
    could also provide valuable information to doctors for analysing
    medical conditions.
The work done in this paper is supported by DST project titled
  “Development of a wireless sensor network based gait
  assessment system for fall prediction in elderly patients” vide
  sanction ref- SSD/NI/020/2007-TIE dt. 31 Jan, 2008.
Thank You
                       Contact:
                  Prof. Subrat Kar
Professor, Electrical Engineering & Bharti School of
 Telecom, IIT Delhi, Hauz Khas, New Delhi – 110016
                 Ph: (011) 26591088
            Email: subrat@ee.iitd.ac.in
MediCall: Hospital Resource System
  Based on VistA implemented at
          JPNATC, AIIMS

  Easily Accessible, Affordable &
   Advance Healthcare Solution
                                                                 GTI Infotel
                                         http://www.gtiinfotel.com
         Corporate HQ: A-51 SECTOR 8, NOIDA, UP; Tel: +91-120-427-3656; Fax: 433-7855
Table of Contents
   Affordable, Accessible & Advance Healthcare for Hospital &
    Patients
   VistA Implementation & Integration with HIS
   Integrated HRS Implementation at JPNATC, AIIMS:
    –   Block Diagram
    –   Back ground & Service provided at JPNATC, AIIMS

   Integrated HRS: Components
    –   Hospital Information System:
            Registration, ADT, OPD, Stores, Inventory, Display, Equipment management & Utilization, Waiting
             times, In-patient Bed status

    –   CRM:
            Patient data, Appointments, Complaints, Information, IPD Data & SMS/Email, Integration with PACS
             & other HIS.

    –   Website:
            Real time data of OPD, IPD, Stats, etc. Hospital Info, Faculty Info


   Awards received
Affordable, Accessible & Advance Healthcare for all
      GTI MediCall Hospital Resource System helps in
       providing affordable, accessible & advance
       healthcare for Patients as well as Hospitals:
       – Developed on the most stable healthcare platform
           VistA developed over decades of research.
       –   Accessible over the internet
       –   Accessible over telephone
       –   Availability of Patient Data & Healthcare provider at
           lower cost
       –   Available 24x7 over the internet, telephone (Call
           Center) & on-site (at the hospital)
Healthcare computing:
     Mapping industry needs to technology capabilities

There are several reasons why GTI MediCall HRS is
solution to the health industry’s unique blend of
requirements:
 It can lead to easier update and higher quality
   patient data—a feature especially important in
   health care, where fragmented, redundant, and
   inconsistent data is rampant today.
 SaaS-based electronic medical record (EMR)
   solutions area natural fit for small physician
   practices to which most physicians belong
   because of their affordability, ease of use, and
   small requirement for ongoing technical
   support.
 The exoskeleton nature of the cloud makes it relatively
  easy to inter-connect disparate systems from different
  health organizations, and provide an elastic infrastructure
  that can start inexpensively and quickly scale as adoption
  increases.
 Thus, it provide an ideal architectural alternative for
  Health Information Exchanges (HIEs). There are promising
  advances across a broad spectrum of patient-facing and
  telemedicine/telehealth applications.
 There is also growing attention on providing direct,
  continuous engagement between patients and providers
  through “in the cloud” relationships that include
  advanced continuous home and portable monitoring.
 Technopak Healthcare, a consulting firm, expects
  spending on health care in India to grow from $40 billion
  in 2008 to $323 billion in 2023.
Sources: Gartner, Factiva [from Accenture ‘Cloud Computing in Healthcare’ deck, date Feb 19 2010,
On the Cloud or
    Physically Co-located Solution?
 GTI can provide both On the Cloud as well as
  Physically Co-located solution for the Hospital.
 The Hospital can choose between the two
  solutions or a hybrid of both solutions (as
  implemented at AIIMS)
 Both Systems provide equivalent & optimum
  solution for the Hospital.
MEDICALL HOSPITAL RESOURCE SYSTEM :

SOLUTION IMPLEMENTED AT JPNATC, AIIMS
(VISTA INTEGRATION)


IN ANOTHER FIRST BY AIIMS, AN INTEGRATED HRS STARTED OPERATIONS FOR
JPN APEX TRAUMA CENTRE, AIIMS
Integration & Implementation of VistA &
Development of HIS on top of the VistA Engine




 The company specializes in Implementation of
 VistA for Hospitals & integration with HIS & PACS

 The current system has been Integrated with:
 • VistA at the Hospital
 • PACS at the Hospital
MediCall Hospital Resource System


Services that include
not only call center
for the patients &
doctors but a total
back office support to
the entire hospital.
We integrate with
your existing database
or develop new
software for you to
offer round-the-clock
services.
MediCall Hospital Resource System (HRS)




Communication                                                Call Center




                           Hospital Resource System:
                           - Website
                           - Hospital Info System
                           - Call Center CRM




                Hospital                    Mobile Support
Our Solution features:
   End-to-end solution with Software, Hardware & Manpower:
    The systems & processes are ready & available to be deployed on-site or on the cloud. Hence, providing the right solution
    deployable in 2-3 weeks is now possible.
   Completely outsourced and scalable:
    This frees up valuable real estate at the Hospital besides potentially decreasing the overheads like electricity, parking and
    toilets which an on-site facility would use. Being completely scalable, the call centre can quickly ramp up operations in line
    with increased demand and in case of disasters.
   Professional operations:
    The call centre will provide best-in-class service to clients with quality control at every stage and 100% call recording for
    auditing and quality purposes.
   Patient services:
    With the main thrust on improving the quality of patient care, the call centre will manage all appointments and follow-up of
    patients. The call centre will also answer queries on all admitted patients and will provide information on all diagnostic &
    therapeutic services available, the procedure and pricing of getting a specific service or test done and the approximate wait-
    times. Thus the patients may not need to approach anyone physically for information.
   Research:
    Research is one of the key mandate of AIIMS and the call centre will facilitate research by ensuring follow-up of patients,
    administering surveys and ensuring authenticity of data.
   Centralized help desk & support:
    The call centre will take over the responsibility of logging & initial troubleshooting software & hardware problems helping in
    providing professional 24 X 7 support services
   Inventory Management & support:
    The call centre will act as the single window for all inventory related issues for the Hospital. The call centre can provide
    completely audit trail for any breakdown or even and follow up with the vendor and end user to ensure optimal utilization of
    resources.
MediCallHRS: Hospital Info System Modules (partial listing)

                                                 Registra
                                                   tion
                                                                      Inventor
                              Roster
                                                                       y Mgmt

                                                                                 Equipm
                                                                                   ent
                Billing
                                                                                 Mgmt &
                                                                                 Maint.


                                                                                         Equipm
                                                                                           ent
          OPD
                                                                                         Utilizati
                                             HIS                                           on



                                                                                       Surgery
           ADT                                                                         Patient
                                                                                       Waitlist


                                                                              Real
                      Call
                                                                            Time Pt.
                     Centre
                                                                            Mvmnt
                     & CRM
                                       Nursing                In-           Display
                                       Quality              patient
                                        Imp.                 Bed
                                        Mgmt                Status
Solution Overview

1   Hospital Info.                                    Benefits
    System (HIS)
A   ADT Registration   - Admission
                       - Discharge
                       - Transfer
                       - Registration
B   OPD                Out Patient Department Management
                       - Takes care of all the Waiting lists, Queue management,
                       Appointments etc.
C   Billing            Integrated Billing
D   Duty Roster        Includes duty roster as well as time schedule, leaves, monitoring, etc.
E   Laboratory         Investigations & reporting on all the Lab findings & integrating with
                       other modules
F   Radiology          Supports DICOM for direct access to equipments.
1   Hospital Info.                                     Benefits
    System (HIS)
G   Registration        - Computerized for future access & control
                        - Maintain database
H   Inventory/Stores    - Control pilferage
                        - Know status of each item
                        - Know movement of each item
                        - Know low stock details for ordering
                        - Paperless system
I   Equipment           - Monitor AMC of all medical equipment
    Management &        - Less breakdown
    Maintenance         - No burden on hospital manpower for maintenance issues
J   Utilization of      - Equipment wise utilization details
    Equipment           - Know the utility & cost/use of each equipment
K   Surgery Waitlist    - Transparent & seamless maintenance
                        - Patients get information from the call center regarding date
L   Real-time Patient   - Movement of patient recorded
    Movement            - Realtime info seen by attendants, hence reducing burden on the
    Display             staff
                        - Helps patients to know his movements
#       Functions                                     Benefit
2   CRM integrated      - Appointment system for the Doctors & Patients
    with VistA & Call   - Queue-less OPD
    Center              - Appointment information on phone/SMS
                        - Change of appointment by Patient/Doctor now possible
                        - Patient Information on phone
                        - Hospital Information available on phone
                        - Complaint handling & monitoring
                        - 24x7 availability to patients, attendants, staff
3   Website             - Hospital Information on the internet
                        - Real time appointment & wait-time info to patients
1. Hospital Info System: HIS home
         based on VistA
Registration
   Parameters captured:
     – Name, Address, Phone, Symptom, General
       ID/Ref. No., custom reports, Diagnosis, Pupil,
       Injury & much more
   General Registration
   Specialty Registration based on Gen. Reg:
     – Ortho/Neurosurgery/Surgery
   Output:
     – Online Reports, Specialized Reports, Admin,
       etc.
   Logistics:
     – Operation Timings: 24x7
     – Manpower Required: Minimum 5 for 24x7
       operation
     – Hardware: PC with 30mins UPS
     – Internet Access: Data Card/Broad band
General Registration
ED Registration
Neuro Registration
Update Form
Patient General Report
Admin Report
Inventory Management System
   Inventory of
     – Consumables like medicines, tables, powder,
         etc.
     –   Disposables like syringes, gloves, etc.
     –   Utilities like bed, etc.
     –   Equipment
     –   Complete detail including location of the
         Inventory
   Output:
     – Status, Stock levels at wards/stores/etc.,
         Indents, etc.
   Logistics:
     – Different types of Alarms at various predefined
       levels
     – Operation Timings: 6 days a week (7 hrs x 6
       days)
Inventory Management
Stores Report
Equipment Management & Maintenance module

   Assist to monitor the AMC/Warranty
    of all medical equipments
   Book complaints
   Monitor performance of Contractor
    under AMC/Warranty
   Identify Repeat faults
   Take Preventive maintenance
   Replacements of active elements in
    time
   Mandatory calibration of equipment
Equipment Utilization
   Equipment wise utilization:
    – By day
    – By week
    – By month
   Utilization efficiency of:
    – Machine
    – Operator
 Equipment Applied & removal days
 Equipment used on which Patient
 Breakdown & likely repair time estimation
Surgery Patient Waitlist & OT Management

   Patients earmarked for surgery
   Type of Surgery
   Doctor allocated to carry out the surgery
   Waitlist in weeks/months
   Weekdays for surgery according to its allocation to
    individual Doctor
   Patients to be informed accordingly on
    – Phone/SMS/Email
 Admission to Surgery after waitlist
 OT Management
Patient Waiting List
Waitlist
Admission to Surgery
OT Management
Real Time Patient Movement Display System

   Patient (under treatment) movement display
    system
   Helps attendant to know movement of
    patient undergoing different tests/stages
   Displays on 40” LCD monitor include
    – Patient Name
    – Department
    – Process
 Helps patients in moving from one test to
  another
 Specialty Dept does their own data entry &
  the same is displayed
 Realtime Bed Availability: for the patient &
  Doctor alike
Display: LCD
ED: Data entry
Ortho: Data entry
Bed Availability Entry
In-patient Bed Status
 Real time bed status / availability of Beds.
 Data can be sorted as per
    – Ward
    – Doctor
    – Date
    – Department
 Criticality of Patient including complete detail
  online
 Number days stay & much more
Nurse Quality Improvement Mgmt
   Captures the Error incident detail done by
    the Nurse
   Helps in monitor Nursing Quality service
   Capture Patient Care lapse
   Patient wise details are captured
   Nurse wise details are captured
2. CRM: Integrated with real-time info for
               the call center
Call Center CRM to be deployed at the call center/Cloud to have
following functions:
 Patient Information
 Appointments
 Staff Information/Rosters
 Dashboard for Faculty/Doctor
 SMS/Email
 Reports
 Complaints handling & monitoring
 Inventory/Stores
 Integration with VistA/PACS & other HIS.
Patient Information & Search
Appointment Information & Search
Staff Information & Search
Complaints Registration & Monitoring
SMS to Patient/Staff/Faculty
Appointment Details
#                                                           Patient                                                                     Existing Appointment

                                                                                                                                                                                      Call Status
    TC No.    Name      Disc. Date Resident Dr.    Ward                       Diagnosis                        Procedure                 Date         Time      Exec        Rem




                                      DR. MAMRAJ                                                                                                                         Connected/
1   195719    Akash     FEB 1,2010
                                        GUPTA
                                                   TC6-15             BTA WITH SPLENIC LACERATION       non operative management       Feb 6,2010   10:00am    Bhavana                    Ist Call
                                                                                                                                                                           confirm




                                                                                                      LEFT ICD WITH WATER SEAL DRAIN
                                                                                                     LEFT A/E GUILLOTINE AMPUTATION
                                                                  RTC WITH MULTIPLE RIBS # WITH LEFT UNDER BRACHIAL PLEXUS BLOCK ON
                                      DR. AMAR
             Shri Ram                                              HEMOTHORAX WITH GANGRENOUS           19/10/2010 DELAYED PRIMARY                                       Connected/
2   193779              JAN 31,2010     NATH       TC6-01
                                                                           LEFT FEOREARM             CLOSURE OF LEFT A/E AMPUTATION
                                                                                                                                       Feb 6,2010   10:10am    Bhavana                    Ist Call
              Naresh                   MUKERJI                                                                                                                             confirm
                                                                                                       STUMP UNDER GA ON 25/1/2010




                                                                                                     EXPLORATORY LAPAROTOMY, ILEAL
                                      DR. ANURAG                        RTA WITH BTA AND ILEAL         TRANSECTION EXTERIORIZED AS
3   195089   Pramod     JAN 31,2010
                                        GUPTA
                                                   TC6-19
                                                                             TRANSECTION                DOUBLE BARREL ILEOSTOMY,
                                                                                                                                       Feb 6,2010   10:20am    Bhavana   Wr Number        Ist Call
                                                                                                     PERITONEAL LAVAGE AND CLOSURE




                                                                   BLUNT TRAUMA ABDOMEN WITH
                                      DR. ANURAG                                               EXP. LAP. & PERITONEAL LAVAGE WITH                                        Connected/
4   192915    Satpal    JAN 11,2010
                                        GUPTA
                                                   TC6-18        HEMO. & PNEUMOPERITONEUM WITH
                                                                                                             DRAINAGE.
                                                                                                                                       Feb 6,2010   10:30am    Bhavana                   IInd Call
                                                                         LIVER LACERATION                                                                                  confirm
Dashboard for the Faculty displaying Faculty’s
 Appointments, Patients, Stats, Roster ,etc.
HIS implementation at AIIMS:
 OPD & Doctor Consultation
Gen & OPD Registration &
       Reception
Token Generation for OPD
Server Room & Computer Facility
3. Website: JPNATC dynamic website
Real time stats on homepage
Week, Month & Yearly Statistics
eINDIA 2010 award at Hyderabad
mBILLIONTH 2010 award at N. Delhi
eWorld 2011 Award at N. Delhi
THANK YOU
ROHIT@GTIINFOTEL.COM
098114-12342

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Clinical audit by Dr A. K. Khandelwal
Clinical audit  by Dr A. K. KhandelwalClinical audit  by Dr A. K. Khandelwal
Clinical audit by Dr A. K. KhandelwalDr.Ashok Khandelwal
 
Measures of performance and clinical outcome
Measures of performance and clinical outcomeMeasures of performance and clinical outcome
Measures of performance and clinical outcomeMohamed Mosaad Hasan
 
Audit and stat for medical professionals
Audit and stat for medical professionalsAudit and stat for medical professionals
Audit and stat for medical professionalsNadir Mehmood
 
Admission Disposition: Inpatient or Outpatient Observation
Admission Disposition:  Inpatient or Outpatient ObservationAdmission Disposition:  Inpatient or Outpatient Observation
Admission Disposition: Inpatient or Outpatient Observationampeterson03
 
Quality improvement and patient safety in anesthesia
Quality improvement and patient safety in anesthesiaQuality improvement and patient safety in anesthesia
Quality improvement and patient safety in anesthesiaDr. Ravikiran H M Gowda
 
DASH - does arthritis self-management help?
DASH - does arthritis self-management help?DASH - does arthritis self-management help?
DASH - does arthritis self-management help?epicyclops
 
Rui Maio Portugal - Monday 28 - ICU and Organ Donation
Rui  Maio   Portugal - Monday 28 - ICU and Organ DonationRui  Maio   Portugal - Monday 28 - ICU and Organ Donation
Rui Maio Portugal - Monday 28 - ICU and Organ Donationincucai_isodp
 
Data Driven Improvement
Data Driven ImprovementData Driven Improvement
Data Driven ImprovementAllina Health
 
Pt safety and cultuer safety
Pt safety and cultuer safetyPt safety and cultuer safety
Pt safety and cultuer safetyehab elbaz
 
SICU Critical Care Safety Study
SICU Critical Care Safety StudySICU Critical Care Safety Study
SICU Critical Care Safety Studyshivabirdi
 
Clingov5understandingaudit2003
Clingov5understandingaudit2003Clingov5understandingaudit2003
Clingov5understandingaudit2003Papri Sarkar
 

Tendances (20)

Clinical audit by Dr A. K. Khandelwal
Clinical audit  by Dr A. K. KhandelwalClinical audit  by Dr A. K. Khandelwal
Clinical audit by Dr A. K. Khandelwal
 
Measures of performance and clinical outcome
Measures of performance and clinical outcomeMeasures of performance and clinical outcome
Measures of performance and clinical outcome
 
Audit and stat for medical professionals
Audit and stat for medical professionalsAudit and stat for medical professionals
Audit and stat for medical professionals
 
Incidant report
Incidant reportIncidant report
Incidant report
 
Admission Disposition: Inpatient or Outpatient Observation
Admission Disposition:  Inpatient or Outpatient ObservationAdmission Disposition:  Inpatient or Outpatient Observation
Admission Disposition: Inpatient or Outpatient Observation
 
Role of medical audit
Role of medical auditRole of medical audit
Role of medical audit
 
Flu
FluFlu
Flu
 
Pera Health
Pera HealthPera Health
Pera Health
 
Jci most common question
Jci most common questionJci most common question
Jci most common question
 
Improving patient safety through culture &evidence based practices
Improving patient safety through culture &evidence based practicesImproving patient safety through culture &evidence based practices
Improving patient safety through culture &evidence based practices
 
Quality in icu
Quality in icuQuality in icu
Quality in icu
 
Quality improvement and patient safety in anesthesia
Quality improvement and patient safety in anesthesiaQuality improvement and patient safety in anesthesia
Quality improvement and patient safety in anesthesia
 
DASH - does arthritis self-management help?
DASH - does arthritis self-management help?DASH - does arthritis self-management help?
DASH - does arthritis self-management help?
 
Rui Maio Portugal - Monday 28 - ICU and Organ Donation
Rui  Maio   Portugal - Monday 28 - ICU and Organ DonationRui  Maio   Portugal - Monday 28 - ICU and Organ Donation
Rui Maio Portugal - Monday 28 - ICU and Organ Donation
 
Examination endgame
Examination endgameExamination endgame
Examination endgame
 
Data Driven Improvement
Data Driven ImprovementData Driven Improvement
Data Driven Improvement
 
Pt safety and cultuer safety
Pt safety and cultuer safetyPt safety and cultuer safety
Pt safety and cultuer safety
 
SICU Critical Care Safety Study
SICU Critical Care Safety StudySICU Critical Care Safety Study
SICU Critical Care Safety Study
 
Risk management in healthcare
Risk management in healthcareRisk management in healthcare
Risk management in healthcare
 
Clingov5understandingaudit2003
Clingov5understandingaudit2003Clingov5understandingaudit2003
Clingov5understandingaudit2003
 

En vedette

“8th National Biennial Conference on Medical Informatics 2012”
“8th National Biennial Conference on Medical Informatics 2012” “8th National Biennial Conference on Medical Informatics 2012”
“8th National Biennial Conference on Medical Informatics 2012” Ashu Ash
 
Information Management in Health Care Group E presentation NUR353
Information Management in Health Care Group E presentation NUR353Information Management in Health Care Group E presentation NUR353
Information Management in Health Care Group E presentation NUR353jtglick
 
Week+five+hcs+483
Week+five+hcs+483Week+five+hcs+483
Week+five+hcs+483hlholcomb
 
Emr implementation
Emr implementation Emr implementation
Emr implementation mmorgan73
 
Successful EHR Implementation - Strategy &amp; Tips
Successful EHR Implementation - Strategy &amp; TipsSuccessful EHR Implementation - Strategy &amp; Tips
Successful EHR Implementation - Strategy &amp; TipsJames Muir
 
EHR Implementation Plan Presentation
EHR Implementation Plan PresentationEHR Implementation Plan Presentation
EHR Implementation Plan PresentationDavid Montanez, PMP
 

En vedette (8)

“8th National Biennial Conference on Medical Informatics 2012”
“8th National Biennial Conference on Medical Informatics 2012” “8th National Biennial Conference on Medical Informatics 2012”
“8th National Biennial Conference on Medical Informatics 2012”
 
Information Management in Health Care Group E presentation NUR353
Information Management in Health Care Group E presentation NUR353Information Management in Health Care Group E presentation NUR353
Information Management in Health Care Group E presentation NUR353
 
Week+five+hcs+483
Week+five+hcs+483Week+five+hcs+483
Week+five+hcs+483
 
Emr implementation
Emr implementation Emr implementation
Emr implementation
 
Nsg informatics
Nsg informaticsNsg informatics
Nsg informatics
 
Successful EHR Implementation - Strategy &amp; Tips
Successful EHR Implementation - Strategy &amp; TipsSuccessful EHR Implementation - Strategy &amp; Tips
Successful EHR Implementation - Strategy &amp; Tips
 
EHR Implementation Plan Presentation
EHR Implementation Plan PresentationEHR Implementation Plan Presentation
EHR Implementation Plan Presentation
 
Nursing Documentation: Do Your Medical Records Support Skilled Care?
Nursing Documentation: Do Your Medical Records Support Skilled Care?Nursing Documentation: Do Your Medical Records Support Skilled Care?
Nursing Documentation: Do Your Medical Records Support Skilled Care?
 

Similaire à “8th National Biennial Conference on Medical Informatics 2012”

ICN Victoria: Gantner on "Translating Research into Practice"
ICN Victoria: Gantner on "Translating Research into Practice"ICN Victoria: Gantner on "Translating Research into Practice"
ICN Victoria: Gantner on "Translating Research into Practice"Intensive Care Network Victoria
 
Analysis of Medication Possession Ratio for Improved Blood Pressure Control
Analysis of Medication Possession Ratio for Improved Blood Pressure ControlAnalysis of Medication Possession Ratio for Improved Blood Pressure Control
Analysis of Medication Possession Ratio for Improved Blood Pressure ControlHealth Informatics New Zealand
 
Delirium (Charmaine Berggreen)
Delirium (Charmaine Berggreen)Delirium (Charmaine Berggreen)
Delirium (Charmaine Berggreen)honorhealth
 
Pathway 2.0 for RWE and MA 2015 -John Cai
Pathway 2.0 for RWE and MA 2015 -John CaiPathway 2.0 for RWE and MA 2015 -John Cai
Pathway 2.0 for RWE and MA 2015 -John CaiJohn Cai
 
Dr Brent James: quality improvement techniques at the frontline
Dr Brent James: quality improvement techniques at the frontlineDr Brent James: quality improvement techniques at the frontline
Dr Brent James: quality improvement techniques at the frontlineNuffield Trust
 
Knowledge transfer research examples
Knowledge transfer research examplesKnowledge transfer research examples
Knowledge transfer research examplestaem
 
1 elective 2 chronic care introduction
1 elective 2 chronic care introduction1 elective 2 chronic care introduction
1 elective 2 chronic care introductionPeak Review/FSUU
 
Leveraging Predictive Models to Reduce Readmissions
Leveraging Predictive Models to Reduce ReadmissionsLeveraging Predictive Models to Reduce Readmissions
Leveraging Predictive Models to Reduce ReadmissionsHealth Catalyst
 
PERFORMANCE INDICATORS LECTURE LO3.pptx
PERFORMANCE INDICATORS  LECTURE  LO3.pptxPERFORMANCE INDICATORS  LECTURE  LO3.pptx
PERFORMANCE INDICATORS LECTURE LO3.pptxSYEDRAZA56411
 
Transforming the Office Management of Heart Failure Using the Chronic Disease...
Transforming the Office Management of Heart Failure Using the Chronic Disease...Transforming the Office Management of Heart Failure Using the Chronic Disease...
Transforming the Office Management of Heart Failure Using the Chronic Disease...MedicineAndHealthUSA
 
Acr 2012 updates and Philippine applicability
Acr 2012 updates and Philippine applicabilityAcr 2012 updates and Philippine applicability
Acr 2012 updates and Philippine applicabilitySidney Erwin Manahan
 
Rx15 treat tues_200_1_baxter_2barnes_3jeter_4kirsh
Rx15 treat tues_200_1_baxter_2barnes_3jeter_4kirshRx15 treat tues_200_1_baxter_2barnes_3jeter_4kirsh
Rx15 treat tues_200_1_baxter_2barnes_3jeter_4kirshOPUNITE
 
Statistical process control
Statistical process controlStatistical process control
Statistical process controlmasoi1512
 
Monitoring response variables 13Feb2014
Monitoring response variables 13Feb2014Monitoring response variables 13Feb2014
Monitoring response variables 13Feb2014Thira Woratanarat
 
08 Am09 Presentations Kliger
08 Am09 Presentations   Kliger08 Am09 Presentations   Kliger
08 Am09 Presentations KligerSimon Prince
 
How to Define Effective and Efficient Real World Trials
How to Define Effective and Efficient Real World TrialsHow to Define Effective and Efficient Real World Trials
How to Define Effective and Efficient Real World TrialsTodd Berner MD
 
How to design effective and efficient real world trials TB Evidence 2014 10.2...
How to design effective and efficient real world trials TB Evidence 2014 10.2...How to design effective and efficient real world trials TB Evidence 2014 10.2...
How to design effective and efficient real world trials TB Evidence 2014 10.2...Todd Berner MD
 

Similaire à “8th National Biennial Conference on Medical Informatics 2012” (20)

ICN Victoria: Gantner on "Translating Research into Practice"
ICN Victoria: Gantner on "Translating Research into Practice"ICN Victoria: Gantner on "Translating Research into Practice"
ICN Victoria: Gantner on "Translating Research into Practice"
 
Fundamentals of Health Economics and Outcomes Research (HEOR)
Fundamentals of Health Economics and Outcomes Research (HEOR)Fundamentals of Health Economics and Outcomes Research (HEOR)
Fundamentals of Health Economics and Outcomes Research (HEOR)
 
Analysis of Medication Possession Ratio for Improved Blood Pressure Control
Analysis of Medication Possession Ratio for Improved Blood Pressure ControlAnalysis of Medication Possession Ratio for Improved Blood Pressure Control
Analysis of Medication Possession Ratio for Improved Blood Pressure Control
 
Delirium (Charmaine Berggreen)
Delirium (Charmaine Berggreen)Delirium (Charmaine Berggreen)
Delirium (Charmaine Berggreen)
 
Pathway 2.0 for RWE and MA 2015 -John Cai
Pathway 2.0 for RWE and MA 2015 -John CaiPathway 2.0 for RWE and MA 2015 -John Cai
Pathway 2.0 for RWE and MA 2015 -John Cai
 
Dr Brent James: quality improvement techniques at the frontline
Dr Brent James: quality improvement techniques at the frontlineDr Brent James: quality improvement techniques at the frontline
Dr Brent James: quality improvement techniques at the frontline
 
CSM 2017 Stout
CSM 2017 StoutCSM 2017 Stout
CSM 2017 Stout
 
Knowledge transfer research examples
Knowledge transfer research examplesKnowledge transfer research examples
Knowledge transfer research examples
 
1 elective 2 chronic care introduction
1 elective 2 chronic care introduction1 elective 2 chronic care introduction
1 elective 2 chronic care introduction
 
Leveraging Predictive Models to Reduce Readmissions
Leveraging Predictive Models to Reduce ReadmissionsLeveraging Predictive Models to Reduce Readmissions
Leveraging Predictive Models to Reduce Readmissions
 
PERFORMANCE INDICATORS LECTURE LO3.pptx
PERFORMANCE INDICATORS  LECTURE  LO3.pptxPERFORMANCE INDICATORS  LECTURE  LO3.pptx
PERFORMANCE INDICATORS LECTURE LO3.pptx
 
Transforming the Office Management of Heart Failure Using the Chronic Disease...
Transforming the Office Management of Heart Failure Using the Chronic Disease...Transforming the Office Management of Heart Failure Using the Chronic Disease...
Transforming the Office Management of Heart Failure Using the Chronic Disease...
 
Acr 2012 updates and Philippine applicability
Acr 2012 updates and Philippine applicabilityAcr 2012 updates and Philippine applicability
Acr 2012 updates and Philippine applicability
 
Rx15 treat tues_200_1_baxter_2barnes_3jeter_4kirsh
Rx15 treat tues_200_1_baxter_2barnes_3jeter_4kirshRx15 treat tues_200_1_baxter_2barnes_3jeter_4kirsh
Rx15 treat tues_200_1_baxter_2barnes_3jeter_4kirsh
 
Webinar SPC
Webinar SPCWebinar SPC
Webinar SPC
 
Statistical process control
Statistical process controlStatistical process control
Statistical process control
 
Monitoring response variables 13Feb2014
Monitoring response variables 13Feb2014Monitoring response variables 13Feb2014
Monitoring response variables 13Feb2014
 
08 Am09 Presentations Kliger
08 Am09 Presentations   Kliger08 Am09 Presentations   Kliger
08 Am09 Presentations Kliger
 
How to Define Effective and Efficient Real World Trials
How to Define Effective and Efficient Real World TrialsHow to Define Effective and Efficient Real World Trials
How to Define Effective and Efficient Real World Trials
 
How to design effective and efficient real world trials TB Evidence 2014 10.2...
How to design effective and efficient real world trials TB Evidence 2014 10.2...How to design effective and efficient real world trials TB Evidence 2014 10.2...
How to design effective and efficient real world trials TB Evidence 2014 10.2...
 

Dernier

08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
04-2024-HHUG-Sales-and-Marketing-Alignment.pptx
04-2024-HHUG-Sales-and-Marketing-Alignment.pptx04-2024-HHUG-Sales-and-Marketing-Alignment.pptx
04-2024-HHUG-Sales-and-Marketing-Alignment.pptxHampshireHUG
 
Slack Application Development 101 Slides
Slack Application Development 101 SlidesSlack Application Development 101 Slides
Slack Application Development 101 Slidespraypatel2
 
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and MythsArtificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and MythsJoaquim Jorge
 
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘
🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘RTylerCroy
 
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...Drew Madelung
 
CNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of Service
CNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of ServiceCNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of Service
CNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of Servicegiselly40
 
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreterPresentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreternaman860154
 
A Call to Action for Generative AI in 2024
A Call to Action for Generative AI in 2024A Call to Action for Generative AI in 2024
A Call to Action for Generative AI in 2024Results
 
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slideHistor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slidevu2urc
 
GenCyber Cyber Security Day Presentation
GenCyber Cyber Security Day PresentationGenCyber Cyber Security Day Presentation
GenCyber Cyber Security Day PresentationMichael W. Hawkins
 
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps ScriptAutomating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Scriptwesley chun
 
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CV
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CVReal Time Object Detection Using Open CV
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CVKhem
 
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivityBoost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivityPrincipled Technologies
 
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdfBoost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdfsudhanshuwaghmare1
 
The Role of Taxonomy and Ontology in Semantic Layers - Heather Hedden.pdf
The Role of Taxonomy and Ontology in Semantic Layers - Heather Hedden.pdfThe Role of Taxonomy and Ontology in Semantic Layers - Heather Hedden.pdf
The Role of Taxonomy and Ontology in Semantic Layers - Heather Hedden.pdfEnterprise Knowledge
 
What Are The Drone Anti-jamming Systems Technology?
What Are The Drone Anti-jamming Systems Technology?What Are The Drone Anti-jamming Systems Technology?
What Are The Drone Anti-jamming Systems Technology?Antenna Manufacturer Coco
 
TrustArc Webinar - Stay Ahead of US State Data Privacy Law Developments
TrustArc Webinar - Stay Ahead of US State Data Privacy Law DevelopmentsTrustArc Webinar - Stay Ahead of US State Data Privacy Law Developments
TrustArc Webinar - Stay Ahead of US State Data Privacy Law DevelopmentsTrustArc
 
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...apidays
 
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerHow to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerThousandEyes
 

Dernier (20)

08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
 
04-2024-HHUG-Sales-and-Marketing-Alignment.pptx
04-2024-HHUG-Sales-and-Marketing-Alignment.pptx04-2024-HHUG-Sales-and-Marketing-Alignment.pptx
04-2024-HHUG-Sales-and-Marketing-Alignment.pptx
 
Slack Application Development 101 Slides
Slack Application Development 101 SlidesSlack Application Development 101 Slides
Slack Application Development 101 Slides
 
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and MythsArtificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
 
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘
🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘
 
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
 
CNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of Service
CNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of ServiceCNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of Service
CNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of Service
 
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreterPresentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
 
A Call to Action for Generative AI in 2024
A Call to Action for Generative AI in 2024A Call to Action for Generative AI in 2024
A Call to Action for Generative AI in 2024
 
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slideHistor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
 
GenCyber Cyber Security Day Presentation
GenCyber Cyber Security Day PresentationGenCyber Cyber Security Day Presentation
GenCyber Cyber Security Day Presentation
 
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps ScriptAutomating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
 
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CV
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CVReal Time Object Detection Using Open CV
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CV
 
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivityBoost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
 
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdfBoost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
 
The Role of Taxonomy and Ontology in Semantic Layers - Heather Hedden.pdf
The Role of Taxonomy and Ontology in Semantic Layers - Heather Hedden.pdfThe Role of Taxonomy and Ontology in Semantic Layers - Heather Hedden.pdf
The Role of Taxonomy and Ontology in Semantic Layers - Heather Hedden.pdf
 
What Are The Drone Anti-jamming Systems Technology?
What Are The Drone Anti-jamming Systems Technology?What Are The Drone Anti-jamming Systems Technology?
What Are The Drone Anti-jamming Systems Technology?
 
TrustArc Webinar - Stay Ahead of US State Data Privacy Law Developments
TrustArc Webinar - Stay Ahead of US State Data Privacy Law DevelopmentsTrustArc Webinar - Stay Ahead of US State Data Privacy Law Developments
TrustArc Webinar - Stay Ahead of US State Data Privacy Law Developments
 
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
 
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected WorkerHow to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
How to Troubleshoot Apps for the Modern Connected Worker
 

“8th National Biennial Conference on Medical Informatics 2012”

  • 1. Objectified Assessment of Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA) in Real- Time as an Aid for Treat-to-Target (T2T) Treatment Strategy Prof. A. N. Malaviya, MD, FRCP (Lond.), M-ACR, FAMS, FNASc Ex- HOD Medicine and Chief of Clinical Immunology & Rheumatology, AIIMS Consultant Rheumatologist, ISIC Superspeciality Hospital, New Delhi Dr. S. B. Gogia, MS (Surgery), Consultant Surgeon, Past President IAMI
  • 2. Rheumatoid disease • A systemic multiorgan disease where the brunt of the disease is on the joints in the extremities • It is an autoimmune where the body’s own defence system attacks the body itself. • The disease has genetic basis. • What is (are) the trigger(s) for these genes to start attacking the body remain to be discovered (smoking is one of them)
  • 3. Pathogenesis well characterised Imbalanced production of cytokines with excess of proinflammatory cytokines the main one being tumour necrosis factor – α (TNF-α)
  • 4.
  • 5. Dramatic advances in the treatment of RA • Disease modifying drugs (DMARDs) • Biological response modifiers (Biologics) • Which drug; at what stage of the disease; what dose and routes: – Monotherapy – Combination therapy – Strategy for their use
  • 6. RA treatment From being “There is not much that can be done, patient would die” It has now become a “Treatable condition where patients can lead a normal life” With dramatic advances in drug treatment of this disease
  • 7. RA can now be compared to diabetes, hypertension and other chronic diseases They can be well controlled With almost a normal life span with good quality of life Don’t worry about ‘cure’ – Although ~ 20% go in drug-free remission
  • 8. Basic treatment strategy for these diseases • Keep the disease under ‘tight control’ – Keep Hb-A1C < 6 (by proper close follow-up and regular blood testing) in diabetes – Keep BP <140/90 (will need to be adjusted for younger people) in patients with hypertension • This approach of treatment is called ‘treat-to- target’ (T2T) • How do we know what is the target in RA? There are so many domains in the disease, very unlike diabetes or hypertension!
  • 9. RA has multiple domains • Pain in the joints • Swelling in the joints • Poor ‘general health’ due to disease • Poor ‘function’ due to joint involvement • Inflammation in the body All this needs to be measured How do we obtain a number that represents DISEASE ACTIVITY ON THAT DAY?
  • 10. Composite indices • Disease activity index (44 joints) – DAS44 – With erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) – With C-reactive protein (CRP) • Disease activity index (28 joints) – DAS28 – With erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) – With C-reactive protein (CRP) • Clinical Disease activity index – CDAI • Simplified Disease activity index – SDAI – With erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) – With C-reactive protein (CRP)
  • 11. RA disease assessment using DAS28 • DAS28 = 0.56 * sqrt(tender28) + 0.28 * sqrt(swollen28) + 0.70 * ln(ESR) + 0.014 * GH • < 2.6 = Remission • < 3.2 = Low disease activity • < 5.1 = Moderate disease activity • > 5.1 = High disease activity
  • 12. RA assessment using CDAI and SDAI • SDAI = (28TJC) + (28SJC) + MDGA + PtGA + CRP* – Remission = <3.3 – Low disease activity = >3.3 to <11 – Moderate disease activity = >11 to <26 – High disease activity = >26 • CDAI = (28TJC) + (28SJC) + MDGA + PtGA* – Remission ≤2.8 – Low disease activity = >2.8 to ≤10 – Moderate disease activity = >10 to ≤22 – High disease activity = >22
  • 13. Assessment of RA • At each patient visit to the clinic we must know the status of disease activity to keep it under tight control i.e.: • In ‘remission’ Or at least • In ‘low disease state’ Therefore: • It becomes mandatory to have DAS28 or CDAI or SDAI at each visit To be able to adjust the drugs / drug dosages To keep the disease under ‘tight control’
  • 14. Remember the formulae? • DAS28 = 0.56 * sqrt(tender28) + 0.28 * sqrt(swollen28) + 0.70 * ln(ESR) + 0.014 * GH • SDAI = (28TJC) + (28SJC) + MDGA + PtGA + CRP* • CDAI = (28TJC) + (28SJC) + MDGA + PtGA* • Can you imagine doing the calculations and finding out whether the patient is in: – Remission, low disease state or not?
  • 15. Gadgets are needed • Pre-programmed calculators • On-line DAS calculators (now available) • Why not have an EMR that would help: – Permanent record of patient’s medical record including medical history, examination findings, laboratory test records – Sequential assessment details – Make drug prescriptions as well! That is the question Dr. Gogia asked us (rheumatologists) when he saw us struggling for the use of ‘T2T’ approach for our RA patients
  • 16. Development of rheumatology-specific EMR • Two of us worked closely • Understanding each other’s way of working • Work-flow of a rheumatology clinic was understood by Dr. Gogia • ‘Objectified assessment methodology’ as discussed including all the composite indices for the assessment of disease activity and their formulae, cut-off points etc. • Final EMR (~ 2 ½ years in development) ready for use
  • 17. Front sheet of the medical record
  • 18. RA assessment in real-time
  • 20. Final appearance of the face-sheet now
  • 21. Face-sheet at the last visit
  • 22. Prescription handed over to the patient
  • 23. Summary • Rheumatology-EMR has the following advantages: – Quick and objectified assessment for guiding treatment – Clearly stated disease status – Neat prescription with detailed instructions – Appointment, tests before the next visit – Many other benefits: more patients in the same time period, data-mining easy for research
  • 25. Significance Of An Appropriate Change Management Strategy In Successful Implementation Of A Health Management Information System Dr. Aman Rana (IIHMR, Delhi) & Dr. Anandhi Ramachandran (IIHMR, Delhi)
  • 26. HEALTH CARE INFORMATION SYSTEM • Corporate Social Responsibility • Benefits: for management- Workforce: an asset - track of health status -underlying occupational hazard -success of any health intervention -medi-claims easy Employees: -sense of security -all information at one place -reduced medical negligence
  • 27. STUDY BACKGROUND: • Location A notable public organization, EMPLOYEE HEALTH MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS (EHMS) : Unsuccessful for past 2 years
  • 28. OBJECTIVES • To understand the Knowledge and Attitude of the Employees towards EHMS • To ascertain the reasons for failure of EHMS adoption in the organization • To put forth an operational framework for successful adoption of EHMS • To evaluate the success of the interventions implemented • To provide a suitable recommendations for future continuous adoption of EHMS
  • 29. METHODOLOGY • STUDY TYPE: Quantitative • SAMPLE SIZE: 353 employees • SAMPLING: Convenience Sampling • DATA UTILIZED: Primary and Secondary data • TOOLS USED: Questionnaires, Focus Group Discussions and Personal Interviews
  • 30. PRE INTERVENTION STATUS: • Out of the 353 employees: • 5 = somewhat correct awareness of EHMS ( All Admin.) • 12= filled up self declarations • No one had filled up the detailed periodic health record. • 85 = had some where heard of EHMS but had no clear idea of what it is. • 251 = people had never heard of EHMS. • In house doctors (2 in number) found the system too technical to understand and time consuming to work on.
  • 31.
  • 32. BARRIER TO ADOPTION • Technical Barriers • User Perception of EHMS • Resisting Change
  • 33. USE OF IT TO INITIATE CHANGE MANAGEMENT People Process Technology
  • 34. 8 Steps to Transform an Organization (‘Harvard business review on change’ by John P.Kotter) 1. Establishing a sense of Urgency 2. Forming a powerful guiding coalition 3. Creating a vision 4. Communicating the vision 5. Empowering others to act on the vision 6. Planning for and creating short-term wins 7. Consolidating improvements and producing still more change 8. Institutionalizing new approaches
  • 37. POST INTERVENTION STATUS • AWARENESS REGARDING EHMS: all 353 employees. • SELF- DECLARATIONS FORMS STATUS: 226 • PERIODIC HEALTH EXAMINATION STATUS: 26 • DOCTORS’ CONSULTATION Motivated and trained. Patient Consultation and Drugs dispensing through the system.
  • 38.
  • 39. CADRE WISE RESPONSE TO THE INTERVENTION PROGRAMME • Management staff: ▫ Out of 172 people, 107 filled up declaration forms. • Non Management staff/ Clerical Staff: ▫ 90 out of 124 gave in their self declarations. • Labor staff: ▫ 29 out of 57 filled up their self declarations
  • 40. ASSESSMENT OF THE CHANGE MANAGEMENT PROCESS • 100% awareness raised • 64% of the staff entered self declaration forms • Which contained preliminary health data. • 7% people filled PHR forms which included detailed information about person’s health data and past medical history. • Implies in spite of awareness, the workforce still needs to accept and be a part of EHMS endeavor. So, the people still need to know more about PHR. Awareness needs to be accompanied with some visual fringe benefits. • Privacy and confidentiality issues
  • 41. RECOMMENDATIONS PROPOSED FOR FUTURE ACTION • A Change Management Champion. • Administration should embrace the change in the process, communicate vision and promote health seeking behavior in the staff. • Doctors: not just acceptors but also propagator. • Doctors, Administrator and staff should sharea good rapport. • Periodic review: every six months • Teams: Seniors and Juniors equal mix.
  • 42. POINTS TO BE REMEBERED • Change management is not an event but a process which needs a focused vision and a visionary. • The employees should be involved in the process from the initial level. • It is the responsibility of top management to assure that the workforce stays motivated throughout. • The leaders, who will propagate the change should be the ones who are trusted by all and share excellent rapport with everyone. • The more aware people are, the easier is the acceptance. • The Employees’ expectations from the product should be kept realistic throughout. • It is as essential to retain the change as it is to bring the change.
  • 43. REFERENCES • McCarthy,M., and Eastman, D., Change Management Strategies for an Effective EMR Implementation. Ohio: HIMSS; 2010. Available from: www.himss.org/content/files/Change Management.pdf. Accessed 2011. • Strebel, P., „Why Do Employees Resist Change?‟ Harvard Business Review May–June 1996 • Cohen D. The Heart of Change Field Guide: Tools and Tactics for Leading Change in Your Organization. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press; 2005. • .Bridges W. Managing Transitions: Making the Most of Change. 2nd ed. Cambridge, MA: Perseus Publishing; 2003. • Campbell, Robert James. Change Management in Health Care. Health Care Manager. 27(1):23- 39, January/March 2008. • Abraham J, Feldman R, Carlin C,Understanding Employee Awareness of Health Care Quality Information: How Can Employers Benefit? Health Services Research 39:6, Part I (December 2004) • Heeks R. (2006) Health information systems: failure, success and improvisation. Int J Med Inform. Feb; 75(2), 125-37. • Al-Mashari, M., and Zairi, M. (1999) BPR implementation process: An analysis of key success and failure factors. Bus. Process Manag. J. 5(1), 87–112 • Beynon-Davies, P., and Lloyd-Williams,M. (1999) When health informationsystems fail. Top. Health Inf. Manage 20(1), 66–79. • Chang, R., Process Reengineering in Action: A Practical Guide to Achieving Breakthrough Results. Jossey-Bass Pfeiffer, San Francisco, 1999.
  • 44.
  • 45. Hardeep Singh, MD MPH Invited Panelists: Houston VA Health Services Research Max Health Care EHR Team Center of Excellence (Divye Chhabra, Nikhil Mishra, Neena Pahuja, Shubnum Singh) Dean F. Sittig, PhD And The University of Texas Health Science Kanav Kahol, PhD, Center School of Biomedical Informatics Public Health Foundation of India
  • 46. Momentum for large scale health reform to improve delivery and patient outcomes  Transformation must leverage use of technology  Technology use must be accompanied by a strategic approach accounting for the context of the environment where implemented.
  • 47. A Hospital system implements an EHR but a year later has to switch to another one  U.K. Scrapping National Health IT Network “…(after) nine years and £11.4 billion ($18.7 billion), the British government is about to scrap its attempt to build a massive, nationwide health IT network for the 52 million residents of England, a London news report says…”
  • 48. Efficiency - 10% reduction  Inconsistent Clinical Decision Support outcomes  We expect quality & safety to improve, but…  22 types of computerized provider order entry (CPOE) errors  Unexpected downtimes  900 patients mistakenly given Viagra instead of Zyban due to an error in the dispensing pharmacy’s medication mapping table
  • 49. National electronic health record (EHR)- based intervention in VA  Required all pathology results (normal or abnormal) to be transmitted to ordering providers via mandatory automated notifications  We analyzed 2 hospitals…results were a bit surprising… Laxmisan et al Under Review
  • 50. Is this ALL bad health IT?
  • 51. Design, development, implementation, use, and evaluation of health information technology is complex and prone to failure  Need a method of understanding the relationships to get it “right” Sittig & Singh JAMA 2009
  • 52.  Discuss a multi-faceted “socio- technical” approach to safe and effective health IT implementation and use  Discuss how these socio-technical concepts could apply to health IT projects currently underway in India
  • 53. Dean F. Sittig, PhD - Model Dimensions  Hardeep Singh, MD MPH – U.S. Case Studies  Discussion of model application in India:  Private health system (Max Health Care IT Team and Leadership)  Public health system (Kanav Kahol, PhD, Public Health Foundation of India)
  • 54.
  • 55. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 56. Must be capable of supporting ALL required clinical activities.  EHR should be able to:  Calculate a medication dose  Transmit the order to the appropriate department  Notify the nurse of a placed order
  • 57. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 58. Standard medical vocabularies to encode clinical findings  Clinical knowledge to create specialty- specific features and functions  Must be evidence-based, carefully constructed, monitored, complete, and error free
  • 59.
  • 60. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 61. Allows clinicians to quickly grasp a complex system safely and efficiently  Displays all the relevant patient data so clinicians can rapidly perceive problems, formulate responses, and document actions.  Physical aspects of the interface (e.g., keyboard, mouse, or touch screen) may also contribute to error in input or selection of information.  ? Common user interface standards
  • 62. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 63. Trained and knowledgeable personnel are essential  System developers  Trainers, implementers, and maintenance staff  Users  Close interaction among informatics experts, clinical application coordinators, and end users is essential
  • 64. Staff of dedicated knowledge engineers  Subject matter experts  Clinical content committees
  • 65. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 66. Disruptions in workflow or information transfer are fertile grounds for inefficiencies  Careful workflow analysis that accounts for health IT use could lead to identification of potential breakdown points  Errors may result from interventions that are not delivered at the best point in the workflow
  • 67. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 68. Work environment  Culture of innovation, exploration, and continual improvement are key  Organizations should:  Actively facilitate reporting of errors or barriers to care resulting from health IT use,  carefully review their existing policies and procedures before implementation.
  • 69. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 70. Regulations may act as barriers or facilitators for safe EHR use  Patient privacy  Policies must address safety and effectiveness of health information exchange across organizational boundaries  State and federal governments should create an environment compatible with widespread use and interoperability
  • 71. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 72.  Organizations must continually evaluate usability & performance of systems after implementation to:  Reliably measure benefits  Assess potential e-iatrogenic effects
  • 73. Acknowledgments: VA, NIH, AHRQ, ONC Eight Rights of Safe Electronic Health Record Use JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113 Safe electronic health record use requires a comprehensive monitoring and evaluation framework JAMA. 2010 Feb 3;303(5):450-1 A new sociotechnical model for studying health information technology in complex adaptive healthcare systems. Qual Saf Health Care. 2010 Oct;19 Suppl 3:i68-74.
  • 74. Hardeep Singh, MD, MPH Chief Health Policy Quality Program, Houston Veterans Affairs Health Services Research & Development Center of Excellence Michael E. DeBakey VA Medical Center & BCM Director, Houston VA Patient Safety Center of Inquiry
  • 75. Research and evaluation case studies in:  Communication of diagnostic test results  CPOE prescriptions  Electronic Referrals  How can the model guide us towards a high performing “EHR enabled work- system”
  • 76. Safety issues related to communication and coordination breakdowns prevalent  What affect will technology have on communication and coordination of test results and referrals? Singh & Graber JAMA 2010
  • 77. ▫ Alert in “View Alert” window
  • 78. Example of a critical imaging alert
  • 79. Communication more than information transfer  Response and appropriate follow-up action  Providers may not acknowledge all alerts they receive; some lost to follow-up  Timely follow-up should occur if they acknowledge an alert Singh et al JAMIA 2007
  • 80. Evaluation of timely follow-up actions on abnormal test result notifications communicated through the View Alert system  1,163 outpatient abnormal labs & 1,196 abnormal imaging results  7% labs lacked timely follow-up despite acknowledgment  8% imaging lacked timely follow-up despite acknowledgment Singh et al AJM 2010 and Archives of IM 2009
  • 81.
  • 82. “One of the issues is just the sheer volume of alerts, and there’s a number of alerts that in all honesty [you] really don’t have any business seeing.”
  • 83. Barriers & solutions span multiple dimensions:  Software (functionality for saving, tracking, and retrieving alerts)  Content (e.g. what alert types are absolutely necessary)  Usability/ UI (improving existing functionality to improve signal to noise ratio)  Workflow (e.g., surrogate alerts when providers out of office)  Providers (e.g. knowledge)  Organizational (e.g. training, policies for follow-up) Singh et al Under review
  • 84.
  • 85.
  • 86.  Of 532 scripts reported to have inconsistent communication  20% errors had potential for severe harm, if they reached the patient  Issues: training, complex orders Singh et al Arch Int Med 2009
  • 87. Transmission and tracking of referrals finally possible!  Of 61,931 referrals, 36% discontinued and 0.8% unresolved at 30 days  Unexplained lack of follow-up actions by subspecialists in 6.3% of all referrals  Unexplained lack of follow-up by PCPs in 7.4% of discontinued referrals Singh et al JGIM 2010
  • 88. Marked differences in PCPs' and subspecialists' communication views (e.g. content)  Lack of an institutional referral policy,  Lack of standardization in referral procedures,  Ambiguity in roles and responsibilities, and  Inadequate resources to adapt and respond to referral requests effectively  Very few technology barriers Hysong et al Impl Science 2011
  • 89.
  • 90.
  • 91. Information Technology Measuring and Tracking the Progress of Implementing a Comprehensive Electronic Health Record: A Mixed- Methods Approach February 5, 2012
  • 92. Authors Sandeep Budhiraja MD1 Nikhil Mishra1 Divye Chhabra MD1 Dean F. Sittig, PhD2 Hardeep Singh, MD, MPH3 Neena Pahuja PhD1 1Max Health Care Institute Ltd., New Delhi 2Professor,School of Biomedical Informatics, University of Texas Health Sciences Center, Houston, Texas, USA 3Chief,Health Quality and Policy Program, Houston Veterans Affairs Health Services Research and Development Center of Excellence and Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas, USA
  • 94. Some Published Statistics: IT supporting Healthcare Ref: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-15340102 • Death rates gone down by 17% among emergency patients (16,000 deaths preventable) • Higher accountability of staff • Lower cases of missed medicine • Medication allergy alerts supports safer healthcare • Reduction of medication errors to ½. • Checks on infection control
  • 95. Hospital Group Level Systems Integration Evolutionary need for Health Information Exchange •Network of 8 hospitals in NCR •Expanded by 4 new, spreading to rest of north India. Altogether ~1900 beds •EHR implementations complete in 4 hospitals Hospital Data Group level integration Centre Sheer Health Volume of Patient care information ‘cloud’ 51
  • 97. eCare - Key Terms • CPRS - Computerized Patient Record System • EHR - Electronic Health Record • HIS - Hospital Information System • CPOE- Computerized Physician Order Entry • BCMA - Bar Coded Medication Administration • COWs – Computer On Wheels
  • 98. The eCare vision • To have a patient centric clinical record • Embracing change to standardize care processes across the organization • To improve electronic access and availability of patient clinical information • To capture multi- disciplinary patient information • The implementation of a minimum data set ensuring foolproof documentation
  • 99. Rationale EHR Implementation • Complete IT Outsourcing • WorldVistA integrated to Max-HIS • Rationale – Potential reduction of medical errors – Improved medication management – Rapid access to vital and accurate information – Reduced duplication of services and cost – Access to a more comprehensive picture of health for promoting advances in the diagnosis and treatment of illnesses – Improved and informed decision making – Providing continuity of care to patients 55
  • 100. Preparation for EHR Implementation • External Consultants • Process mapping of as-is workflows • Data Cleaning • Design Future-State Workflows (Map “as-is” to system functionality) • Approach – Prepare patient demographics integration – Prepare for Lab, Radiology & Pharmacy – BCMA (e-MAR + closed loop medicine administration) – CPOE 56
  • 101. Preparation for EHR Implementation • Training, Training & more Training • Change Management is the key • Big-Bang approach for IT- systems – Phased approach “Slow change” for humans • Super-Users and Change Managers • 23rd July 2011 6 months 57
  • 102. Study Methodology • Mixed method for measuring and tracking progress of EHR implementation First – quantitative approach – six “automated” metrics – extracted from Mumps database (Backbone) Senior Consultants Second Junior Consultants Floor Mentors – interviewed four groups of representative users Nursing Supervisor – Content analysis of interviews identify major themes Third – fact-finding questionnaires A total of 5 months of Data 58
  • 103. Barcode Medical Administration COW*– Nurse Login Barcoded Patient Identifying the nurse Wrist Band Identifying the patient Barcoded Label on Drug- Identifying the Drug Right Patient, Right Drug, Right Time * COW- Computer on wheels 59
  • 104. Results I- Quantitative Approach – 6 automated Metrics Implementation Metric % Use 1) Use of Progress Notes 76% 2) Use of CPOE for medications, procedures, lab and 100% imaging tests 3) Documentation of 2 daily inpatient progress notes 65% (morning and evening) by a consultant on all inpatients 4) Use of Problem lists involving selection from ICD-9 15% coded problems 5) Documentation of Input and Output logs by nurses 82% in IPD, Critical care on parallel paper process 6) Use of BCMA by nurses Real Time MAR 41%, however including after the fact goes upto 78% EHR-Structure 60
  • 105. Results II- Interviews with representative groups Qualitative Analysis Younger Doctors -more comfortable Senior Consultants -hesitant with new technology -had low degree of adoption. Typing issues - Only 28% were comfortable EHR system “complexity” - main concern of participants (mainly senior consultants) Perceived reduction of efficiency- due to time required in day to day However most users- post 2-3 days of hands-on EHR use -perceived its benefits -reported high degree of comfort in its use. -Divide between resistors and early adopters 61
  • 106. Results II contd- Interviews with representative groups Differences between doctors and nurses also emerged – 100% nurses had to use the system from day one – Also had attended all training sessions – Doctors were hard pressed for time for training as well as day to day use – Ongoing Support Facilitators of the process • Leadership role (Top Management) • Clinical Transformation & Change Management • User friendly clinical templates • Easy accessibility of all Max enrolled patients’ records – Any Max facility – Any Patient • Light System (client application) - quick response time & stability – also be credited with aiding its acceptance. 62
  • 107. Results III- Fact-finding Questionnaires • “Did You Know” type features of system identified – 12 in number, All Specific to doctors, 5 of these generic to nurses – Nurses faired 5/5 – Doctors varied from 5-8 • Additionally 18 specific fact finding questions ranging from – Rate your own usage, comfort level, perceived improvements perceived benefits, suggestions for improvement 63
  • 108. Results III contd- Fact-finding Questionnaires Five level scale used (Very Low Low Medium High Very High) Question Group Majority Others Comfort level in using system 65% Low to Medium 13-18% on both extremes Viewing of existing notes/progress notes 83% Medium to High rest Very High scattered result 50% low to Usage of templates on CPRS very few High Medium Usage of Orders (lab/radio/drug/procedures) 83% High to Very High _ Frequency of entering findings of consult 52% Medium to high 30% Low Viewing of reports on CPRS software Majority high to Very High _ Surprisingly High to Very Comfort level of typing High Ease of use of CPRS software 78% Medium to High Rest Low, none very high Rate the overall improvement in time taken for activities 80% Medium to High 10% low Rate the overall improvement in the efficiency for activities 90% Medium to High _ In your deptt. How would you rate the Scattered results ranging benefit of using systems over the 64 _ existing process from low to very high
  • 109. Challenges Identified • CPOE- Filling time for STAT medication orders, only 90% compliance Identified as an area for improvement • An increase in the overall time in the discharge process when the EHR was only used partially - both paper + electronic records - expected to be transitional phase 65
  • 110. Discussion • Early experience Largest implementation of its kind – 4 facilities, comprehensive EHR, large health care system • Several lessons learned by measuring and tracking – Patience and aggressive Change Management is key – Focus and Support from Leadership – People don’t like to put in data, but once its there they really value it – Benefits are perceived only by the ones who use more and vice- versa – Early adopters benefit more than laggards – Laggards resist most – Aggressive Supporting required at least till ratio tips in favor of adopter 66
  • 112. Further Benefits • Chronic Care Management using clinical reminders – Clinical reminders – automated reminders – for the clinicians based on rules (diagnosis/ lab result/ drug allergy etc) • Diabetic care – Reminders setup for – Periodic Glycosylated Hemoglobin (HbA1c) – Diabetic Foot Exam (Skin and Neurological) – Diabetic Eye Exam – Data of these reminders when due is periodically passed to Endocrinology team who in turn suggest the same to patients – Services with Ophthalmology, Podiatry and Lab services is coordinated through Endocrinology 68
  • 114. Ancillaries • COWS* • Wrist Bands • Drug Labels *COWS- Computer On Wheels
  • 115. Change Management Is Key • It is not an IT project…..its an operations project • Leadership support • Support support support…..evolve…support • Train train ….retrain….evolve….support • Help on call- 24 hour support …..Human aspects • Workshops • As is workflows/future state • Ease everyone in. 71
  • 116. Change Management After Go-Live • Healthcare- Standardized but flexible • Operations cannot slow down to support change • Shaken users prone to errors • Real time support • Leadership support 72
  • 117. Results III contd- Fact-finding Questionnaires Five level scale used (Very Low Low Medium High Very High) Question Group Majority Others Comfort level in using system 65% Low to Medium 13-18% on both extremes Viewing of existing notes/progress notes 83% Medium to High rest Very High Usage of templates on CPRS scattered result 50% low to Medium very few High Usage of Orders (lab/radio/drug/procedures) 83% High to Very High _ Frequency of entering findings of consult 52% Medium to high 30% Low Viewing of reports on CPRS software Majority high to Very High _ Comfort level of typing Surprisingly High to Very High Rate the availability of the COW(computer on Scattered results ranging from low to wheels) in a ward _ very high Ease of use of CPRS software 78% Medium to High Rest Low, none very high Rate the overall improvement in time taken for activities 80% Medium to High 10% low Rate the overall improvement in the efficiency for activities 90% Medium to High _ In your deptt. How would you rate the benefit of Scattered results ranging from low to using systems over the existing process _ very high 73
  • 118. Kanav Kahol Division of Affordable Health Technologies Public Health Foundation of India kanav.kahol@phfi.org
  • 119. Recommendation 3.6.4 Establish a Health IT Network
  • 120. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 121. Mhealth Solutions.  Portable with long or extended battery life.  Enable non-physicians to deliver care with supervision and monitoring  Example: Swasthya Slate
  • 122. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 123. Indigenized and local language support.  Allow co- development by central agencies and local players through computer supported collaborative platforms.  Need support for empowerment of patients and the healthcare workers.
  • 124. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 125. Use of semiotics and images is helpful  Simplified questionnaires and sets.  Affordance of the user interface is key.
  • 126. MyPortal State and District Portals MyHealth Epidemiology MyAppointments Early Warning Systems MyMessages Messaging Center MyTreatments Certification Portal Learning Portal Community Health Portal eHealth/mHealth Portals Physician and Hospital Portal National Portal Patient Alerts Certification Standards and Results Scheduling Manager Health Promotion Message Center National Security Portal Information Reporting Financial Management Portal
  • 127. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 128. Technology illiteracy is rapidly reducing.  People born in 1994 will be 22 in 2016.  Creation of suitable cadres already a part of the UHC Report.  Usable technology is the key  Gap skills training will have to be undertaken.
  • 129. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 130. Public Health Decision Support System  Use algorithms from supply chain and related fields to help with optimal resource usage and allocation.  West Bengal and Drishti.
  • 131. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 132. Promote use of HealthIT  Use grants and universal payer mechanism to ensure compliance.
  • 133. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 134. Use single payer as a leverage for adoption along with grants.  Clearly define telemedicine (Use telemedicine law draft)  Define privacy and security laws.  Ensure the right to connectivity.
  • 135. Hardware and Monitoring Software Workflow and Content Communication Issue Under Study State and User Federal Interface Rules Organizational Personnel Characteristics JAMA. 2009;302(10):1111-1113
  • 136. Monitoring Financial and Clinical measures is the key.  EHR enables a method of authentication and verification.  Case in Point: Mother Child Tracking System and Immunization Records.  Use cloud.  Caveat: Make reporting easy.  Caveat: Reporting is not the only or the most important feature of ICT.
  • 137.
  • 138. Personal Eternal Health Passbook By Dr. G. D. Mogli, Ph.D., MBA., FHRIM (UK), FAHIMA (USA) Chief Executive Officer & MD Dr. Mogli Healthcare Management Consultancy www.drmogliit.com gdmogli@yahoo.com Formerly served as WHO Consultant and Sr. Consultant /Adviser to the Ministries of Health India, Afghanistan, Iran, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Oman, Bahrain, Qatar, UAE & Sr. Consultant eHealth Management HEARTCOM INC. (USA)
  • 139. Evolution of medical records EHR/PH R???? Comprehe Computer • card nsive Unit Writing on records based Outpatient medical records walls s records Comprehensive unit records Outpatient cards
  • 140. Personal Eternal Health Passbook The “Personal Eternal Health Passbook (PEHP) containing the ID, is a lifelong electronic, universally available document, initiated at the time of birth, containing, mother’s delivery information including congenital anomaly, immunizations given. This will contain entire information such as episodic, hospitalization, self medications and other habits including significant events. This is maintained by parents/guardian and contains immunizations, growth charts, significant events and health status. The PEHP information is contributed by health care providers and self and maintained in a secure and private environment, with the individual determining rights of access”. Definition by--- Dr G. D Mogli
  • 141. PEHP  PEHP kept by individual, EHR by Hospital  PEHP is owned by individual and contain every detail.  PEHP information is managed by (care providers and himself).  Right of access of record is owned by PEHP owner.
  • 142. What EHR cannot have? But What PEHP can have?  Awareness among patients through media.  Internet forums and blogs for medical information.  Persons suffering from minor ailments, doesn’t visit, hospitals,  Applies self medication, self care/treatment.  Extensive information leads to Self-medication too. This kind of information is not recorded in a EHR which could prove to be detrimental for patient care.
  • 143. Non Allopathic treatment  Many types of medicine are coming to light and being practiced. Ex: Unani, Acupuncture, homeopathy, ayurvedic, yogic healing etc.. EHR is based on allopathic only. other medications / therapies underwent by the patient is not recorded.
  • 144. Types of PEHP  Paper based.  PC-based.  Web based. (maintained on private line-accessed by username and password)  Hybrid (desktop/Web-based.) A mix of both PC’s and Online PEHP.  PEHP. Connecting through USB port to the computers.
  • 146. What should the PEHP contain  Patient Identification Data.  Health Summary.  Hospitalization.  Child Development.  Obstetrics & Gynecology.  Immunizations.  Surgeries/Therapy.  Chronic Disease (old age).  Self care/treatments.  Allergies and Drug  Medications.  sensitivities.  Investigations.
  • 147. Patient ID format  3 parts  Part I contains: Personal data.  Part II contains: allergies, blood group, significant health problems.  Part III contains: other habits such as food, alcoholic, smoking, any addiction, environmental, exercise, etc.
  • 148. Patient Care Summary  For recording chronological data.  Should record details of visits to OP,IP,ER etc..  Self care or other treatments.
  • 149. Child Development  Growth chart for children from 0-5 or 0-14 years.
  • 150. Immunizations  Mainly for children and also can be used for adults.  Indicates due dates for other immunizations e.g. 1st dose, 2nd dose etc..
  • 151. Self-care for medication / treatment  A unique feature of PEHP.  Available only with the PEHP and not found in the allopathic healthcare organizations.
  • 152. Medications  Chronological account of medications used and being used currently.  E-prescription, refills, and address of the pharmacies
  • 153. Investigations  Chronological account of investigations carried out will be available.
  • 154. Hospitalization record  Chronological account of all admissions and discharges with the results.
  • 155. Obstetrics & Gynecology  For women patients from child bearing age onwards.  Periodic Mammography check information is also recorded.
  • 156. Therapy  Different types of therapies such as physical, occupational, speech, optometric refractions, radio therapy etc. are recorded.
  • 157. Implementing PEHP  People Born prior to implementation  New born records –to be maintained by the care taker  Carry a pen-drive, external hard drives or any other portable devices on move.  Patient with conditions (heart diseases, diabetes, hypertension) should carry Alert devices for Emergency.
  • 158. Conclusion…..  EHR at health institution level and PEHP at personal level to gain complete 360 degree information.  For providing continuity of care to patient, at right time, at right place and at right cost.  PEHP prevents duplication of investigations, medications, delay in care, check on risk and cost.
  • 159. Continue………………  Standardizing of PEHP information for continuity of care.  PEHP allows practitioners from different settings and disciplines to share information.  Allows the patient to carry this information with him or her upon referral, transfer, or discharge.
  • 160. Normal condition Update PEHP Physician treatment Disease state Self medication Non allopathic therapy
  • 161.
  • 162. Effects of PEHP on the Patients Advantages Disadvantages  Information on the go.  Cumbersome for  Ensure Information is maintaining. accurate and complete.  Access to the Computers.  Self medication is updated.  Illiteracy.  Different physicians opinion recorded.  Costs him extra.  Careful  Security concerns.  Handy in Emergency.  Accessing the web in  Quick treatment remote places.  prevents duplication
  • 163. Effects of PEHP for the Physicians Advantages Disadvantages  Complete Information.  Distrust on Information  Quick treatment. viability.  Opinions of other physicians.  Doesn’t like to expose his opinion.  Disease pattern is easy to understand.  Fear of medico-legal issues.  Duplication of records.  Increased workload.
  • 164. Medical record  MR history parallels the history of medicine.  Contains medical information of an individual from “Womb to Tomb”.  “A clear, concise and accurate history of the patient's life and illness, written from the health point of view, and is a complete compilation of scientific data derived from many sources, coordinated and integrated into an orderly document for further multifarious uses”. --Dr G.D Mogli
  • 165. Necessity  Contains patient demographic information, history, physical examination, progress notes, investigations, consultations opinions, diagnosis, treatment including medical, surgical, therapies. Necessary for various reasons. Insurance sector Medico legal cases & analysis Also for effective Patients forget but Records remember"
  • 166. Advantages of EHR Manual records Electronic records Inaccessibility, parts of Decentralized, the records are simultaneous access all geographically widely the time. distributed. Active it can trigger Passive: unable to certain actions according trigger certain actions to the data  “Manual” linkage “Increased” linkage with external health care Time consuming to providers explore for clinical or financial studies Excellent basis to conduct clinical and financial studies
  • 167. Some Current PEHP Providers And many more……
  • 168. Problems with EHR  Interoperability Vendors develop readymade software’s / In-house tailor made to suit only certain health institutions.  Survey indicates old people want to follow the manual records. These are problems which can be solved by developing of standards.
  • 169. EHR (Electronic health record)  Refers to an individual patient's longitudinal medical record in digital format.  Easy to maintain.  Usually accessed on a computer, often over a network.  Instantly accessible to all authorized from different stations.  High end gadgets are available for making the recording easy.
  • 170. Precautions In selecting a PEHP provider  Ensure Security of the records.  Maintain Confidentiality of records.  Ensure Privacy.  Technologically stable and advanced.  Should be Interoperable.  Cost.  Provide long term support.
  • 171. A Wireless Sensor Network based Fall Detection and Activity Monitoring System for the Elderly By Prof. Subrat Kar, Sanat Sarangi and Akshat Bisht Bharti School of Telecommunication Technology and Management, IIT Delhi, India NCMI 2012, AIIMS
  • 172. Motivation  Prevalent technologies-  Smart Insole, Smart Cane and Smart Headset monitor underfoot pressure, improper usage behaviour and EEG signals respectively.  Armbands, waistbands and ankle-bands have been developed that measure skin temperature, energy spent (calories) and activity.  Our concern is to not just to create a smart device but a smart space using a number of such devices – a sensor network.  A sensor network helps communicate events of interest over large geographic distances without using a legacy network.
  • 173. Sensor Networks Sensor Nodes:  Low-cost  Resource-constrained  Autonomous  Form a resilient Mesh Network, hence the term- Sensor Network  Fault Tolerant
  • 174. Gaitsense (Gait Assessment System)  Consists of  A sensor network formed by gait nodes and relay nodes.  A multi-tier control and notification system (consisting of a gateway, user application and DBMS) that talks to Internet and cellular networks.  Gateway acts as an interface between the sensor network and the GUI-based user application and logs all communication in the DBMS.  User Application provides multi-dimensional visualization capabilities for sensor events through charts, tables and maps.  User Application runs custom algorithms that take specific actions based on user requirements and sends appropriate notifications.
  • 175. Gait Node  Consists of a sensor node and an accelerometer.  The Sensor node has a extremely low-power micro-controller and on-board radio transmission capabilities.  The accelerometer can sense acceleration on upto three axes. Acceleration is used to recognize gait characteristics.  Gait Node can be conveniently worn at the waist or ankle to detect the state of the subject- standing, sleeping, walking, running, fallen. Status of gait node 1 as seen in user application Gait Node
  • 176. Deployment Scenario  A Geriatric care unit as shown, can be a possible application scenario for GaitSense.  The objective is to monitor residents wearing gait nodes and auto-notify events such as postural changes, activity changes or number of steps taken.  Fixed relay nodes installed at strategic positions and the gait nodes form a sensor network that reliably streams events to the gateway and user application in the administrative section.  Services like email, twitter or sms are used to send notifications.
  • 178. Conclusion  A fall detection and activity monitoring system for the elderly is proposed and its integration with the public communication infrastructure is discussed to enable its widespread adoption.  By notifying events like a fall, the system promises to help reduce human casualties by allowing effective rescue and remedial operation-planning.  The systematic automated recording of all behavioural aspects could also provide valuable information to doctors for analysing medical conditions. The work done in this paper is supported by DST project titled “Development of a wireless sensor network based gait assessment system for fall prediction in elderly patients” vide sanction ref- SSD/NI/020/2007-TIE dt. 31 Jan, 2008.
  • 179. Thank You Contact: Prof. Subrat Kar Professor, Electrical Engineering & Bharti School of Telecom, IIT Delhi, Hauz Khas, New Delhi – 110016 Ph: (011) 26591088 Email: subrat@ee.iitd.ac.in
  • 180. MediCall: Hospital Resource System Based on VistA implemented at JPNATC, AIIMS Easily Accessible, Affordable & Advance Healthcare Solution GTI Infotel http://www.gtiinfotel.com Corporate HQ: A-51 SECTOR 8, NOIDA, UP; Tel: +91-120-427-3656; Fax: 433-7855
  • 181. Table of Contents  Affordable, Accessible & Advance Healthcare for Hospital & Patients  VistA Implementation & Integration with HIS  Integrated HRS Implementation at JPNATC, AIIMS: – Block Diagram – Back ground & Service provided at JPNATC, AIIMS  Integrated HRS: Components – Hospital Information System:  Registration, ADT, OPD, Stores, Inventory, Display, Equipment management & Utilization, Waiting times, In-patient Bed status – CRM:  Patient data, Appointments, Complaints, Information, IPD Data & SMS/Email, Integration with PACS & other HIS. – Website:  Real time data of OPD, IPD, Stats, etc. Hospital Info, Faculty Info  Awards received
  • 182. Affordable, Accessible & Advance Healthcare for all  GTI MediCall Hospital Resource System helps in providing affordable, accessible & advance healthcare for Patients as well as Hospitals: – Developed on the most stable healthcare platform VistA developed over decades of research. – Accessible over the internet – Accessible over telephone – Availability of Patient Data & Healthcare provider at lower cost – Available 24x7 over the internet, telephone (Call Center) & on-site (at the hospital)
  • 183. Healthcare computing: Mapping industry needs to technology capabilities There are several reasons why GTI MediCall HRS is solution to the health industry’s unique blend of requirements:  It can lead to easier update and higher quality patient data—a feature especially important in health care, where fragmented, redundant, and inconsistent data is rampant today.  SaaS-based electronic medical record (EMR) solutions area natural fit for small physician practices to which most physicians belong because of their affordability, ease of use, and small requirement for ongoing technical support.
  • 184.  The exoskeleton nature of the cloud makes it relatively easy to inter-connect disparate systems from different health organizations, and provide an elastic infrastructure that can start inexpensively and quickly scale as adoption increases.  Thus, it provide an ideal architectural alternative for Health Information Exchanges (HIEs). There are promising advances across a broad spectrum of patient-facing and telemedicine/telehealth applications.  There is also growing attention on providing direct, continuous engagement between patients and providers through “in the cloud” relationships that include advanced continuous home and portable monitoring.  Technopak Healthcare, a consulting firm, expects spending on health care in India to grow from $40 billion in 2008 to $323 billion in 2023. Sources: Gartner, Factiva [from Accenture ‘Cloud Computing in Healthcare’ deck, date Feb 19 2010,
  • 185. On the Cloud or Physically Co-located Solution?  GTI can provide both On the Cloud as well as Physically Co-located solution for the Hospital.  The Hospital can choose between the two solutions or a hybrid of both solutions (as implemented at AIIMS)  Both Systems provide equivalent & optimum solution for the Hospital.
  • 186. MEDICALL HOSPITAL RESOURCE SYSTEM : SOLUTION IMPLEMENTED AT JPNATC, AIIMS (VISTA INTEGRATION) IN ANOTHER FIRST BY AIIMS, AN INTEGRATED HRS STARTED OPERATIONS FOR JPN APEX TRAUMA CENTRE, AIIMS
  • 187. Integration & Implementation of VistA & Development of HIS on top of the VistA Engine The company specializes in Implementation of VistA for Hospitals & integration with HIS & PACS The current system has been Integrated with: • VistA at the Hospital • PACS at the Hospital
  • 188. MediCall Hospital Resource System Services that include not only call center for the patients & doctors but a total back office support to the entire hospital. We integrate with your existing database or develop new software for you to offer round-the-clock services.
  • 189. MediCall Hospital Resource System (HRS) Communication Call Center Hospital Resource System: - Website - Hospital Info System - Call Center CRM Hospital Mobile Support
  • 190. Our Solution features:  End-to-end solution with Software, Hardware & Manpower: The systems & processes are ready & available to be deployed on-site or on the cloud. Hence, providing the right solution deployable in 2-3 weeks is now possible.  Completely outsourced and scalable: This frees up valuable real estate at the Hospital besides potentially decreasing the overheads like electricity, parking and toilets which an on-site facility would use. Being completely scalable, the call centre can quickly ramp up operations in line with increased demand and in case of disasters.  Professional operations: The call centre will provide best-in-class service to clients with quality control at every stage and 100% call recording for auditing and quality purposes.  Patient services: With the main thrust on improving the quality of patient care, the call centre will manage all appointments and follow-up of patients. The call centre will also answer queries on all admitted patients and will provide information on all diagnostic & therapeutic services available, the procedure and pricing of getting a specific service or test done and the approximate wait- times. Thus the patients may not need to approach anyone physically for information.  Research: Research is one of the key mandate of AIIMS and the call centre will facilitate research by ensuring follow-up of patients, administering surveys and ensuring authenticity of data.  Centralized help desk & support: The call centre will take over the responsibility of logging & initial troubleshooting software & hardware problems helping in providing professional 24 X 7 support services  Inventory Management & support: The call centre will act as the single window for all inventory related issues for the Hospital. The call centre can provide completely audit trail for any breakdown or even and follow up with the vendor and end user to ensure optimal utilization of resources.
  • 191. MediCallHRS: Hospital Info System Modules (partial listing) Registra tion Inventor Roster y Mgmt Equipm ent Billing Mgmt & Maint. Equipm ent OPD Utilizati HIS on Surgery ADT Patient Waitlist Real Call Time Pt. Centre Mvmnt & CRM Nursing In- Display Quality patient Imp. Bed Mgmt Status
  • 192. Solution Overview 1 Hospital Info. Benefits System (HIS) A ADT Registration - Admission - Discharge - Transfer - Registration B OPD Out Patient Department Management - Takes care of all the Waiting lists, Queue management, Appointments etc. C Billing Integrated Billing D Duty Roster Includes duty roster as well as time schedule, leaves, monitoring, etc. E Laboratory Investigations & reporting on all the Lab findings & integrating with other modules F Radiology Supports DICOM for direct access to equipments.
  • 193. 1 Hospital Info. Benefits System (HIS) G Registration - Computerized for future access & control - Maintain database H Inventory/Stores - Control pilferage - Know status of each item - Know movement of each item - Know low stock details for ordering - Paperless system I Equipment - Monitor AMC of all medical equipment Management & - Less breakdown Maintenance - No burden on hospital manpower for maintenance issues J Utilization of - Equipment wise utilization details Equipment - Know the utility & cost/use of each equipment K Surgery Waitlist - Transparent & seamless maintenance - Patients get information from the call center regarding date L Real-time Patient - Movement of patient recorded Movement - Realtime info seen by attendants, hence reducing burden on the Display staff - Helps patients to know his movements
  • 194. # Functions Benefit 2 CRM integrated - Appointment system for the Doctors & Patients with VistA & Call - Queue-less OPD Center - Appointment information on phone/SMS - Change of appointment by Patient/Doctor now possible - Patient Information on phone - Hospital Information available on phone - Complaint handling & monitoring - 24x7 availability to patients, attendants, staff 3 Website - Hospital Information on the internet - Real time appointment & wait-time info to patients
  • 195. 1. Hospital Info System: HIS home based on VistA
  • 196. Registration  Parameters captured: – Name, Address, Phone, Symptom, General ID/Ref. No., custom reports, Diagnosis, Pupil, Injury & much more  General Registration  Specialty Registration based on Gen. Reg: – Ortho/Neurosurgery/Surgery  Output: – Online Reports, Specialized Reports, Admin, etc.  Logistics: – Operation Timings: 24x7 – Manpower Required: Minimum 5 for 24x7 operation – Hardware: PC with 30mins UPS – Internet Access: Data Card/Broad band
  • 198.
  • 204. Inventory Management System  Inventory of – Consumables like medicines, tables, powder, etc. – Disposables like syringes, gloves, etc. – Utilities like bed, etc. – Equipment – Complete detail including location of the Inventory  Output: – Status, Stock levels at wards/stores/etc., Indents, etc.  Logistics: – Different types of Alarms at various predefined levels – Operation Timings: 6 days a week (7 hrs x 6 days)
  • 207. Equipment Management & Maintenance module  Assist to monitor the AMC/Warranty of all medical equipments  Book complaints  Monitor performance of Contractor under AMC/Warranty  Identify Repeat faults  Take Preventive maintenance  Replacements of active elements in time  Mandatory calibration of equipment
  • 208.
  • 209. Equipment Utilization  Equipment wise utilization: – By day – By week – By month  Utilization efficiency of: – Machine – Operator  Equipment Applied & removal days  Equipment used on which Patient  Breakdown & likely repair time estimation
  • 210.
  • 211. Surgery Patient Waitlist & OT Management  Patients earmarked for surgery  Type of Surgery  Doctor allocated to carry out the surgery  Waitlist in weeks/months  Weekdays for surgery according to its allocation to individual Doctor  Patients to be informed accordingly on – Phone/SMS/Email  Admission to Surgery after waitlist  OT Management
  • 216.
  • 217. Real Time Patient Movement Display System  Patient (under treatment) movement display system  Helps attendant to know movement of patient undergoing different tests/stages  Displays on 40” LCD monitor include – Patient Name – Department – Process  Helps patients in moving from one test to another  Specialty Dept does their own data entry & the same is displayed  Realtime Bed Availability: for the patient & Doctor alike
  • 222. In-patient Bed Status  Real time bed status / availability of Beds.  Data can be sorted as per – Ward – Doctor – Date – Department  Criticality of Patient including complete detail online  Number days stay & much more
  • 223.
  • 224.
  • 225. Nurse Quality Improvement Mgmt  Captures the Error incident detail done by the Nurse  Helps in monitor Nursing Quality service  Capture Patient Care lapse  Patient wise details are captured  Nurse wise details are captured
  • 226.
  • 227.
  • 228. 2. CRM: Integrated with real-time info for the call center Call Center CRM to be deployed at the call center/Cloud to have following functions:  Patient Information  Appointments  Staff Information/Rosters  Dashboard for Faculty/Doctor  SMS/Email  Reports  Complaints handling & monitoring  Inventory/Stores  Integration with VistA/PACS & other HIS.
  • 234. Appointment Details # Patient Existing Appointment Call Status TC No. Name Disc. Date Resident Dr. Ward Diagnosis Procedure Date Time Exec Rem DR. MAMRAJ Connected/ 1 195719 Akash FEB 1,2010 GUPTA TC6-15 BTA WITH SPLENIC LACERATION non operative management Feb 6,2010 10:00am Bhavana Ist Call confirm LEFT ICD WITH WATER SEAL DRAIN LEFT A/E GUILLOTINE AMPUTATION RTC WITH MULTIPLE RIBS # WITH LEFT UNDER BRACHIAL PLEXUS BLOCK ON DR. AMAR Shri Ram HEMOTHORAX WITH GANGRENOUS 19/10/2010 DELAYED PRIMARY Connected/ 2 193779 JAN 31,2010 NATH TC6-01 LEFT FEOREARM CLOSURE OF LEFT A/E AMPUTATION Feb 6,2010 10:10am Bhavana Ist Call Naresh MUKERJI confirm STUMP UNDER GA ON 25/1/2010 EXPLORATORY LAPAROTOMY, ILEAL DR. ANURAG RTA WITH BTA AND ILEAL TRANSECTION EXTERIORIZED AS 3 195089 Pramod JAN 31,2010 GUPTA TC6-19 TRANSECTION DOUBLE BARREL ILEOSTOMY, Feb 6,2010 10:20am Bhavana Wr Number Ist Call PERITONEAL LAVAGE AND CLOSURE BLUNT TRAUMA ABDOMEN WITH DR. ANURAG EXP. LAP. & PERITONEAL LAVAGE WITH Connected/ 4 192915 Satpal JAN 11,2010 GUPTA TC6-18 HEMO. & PNEUMOPERITONEUM WITH DRAINAGE. Feb 6,2010 10:30am Bhavana IInd Call LIVER LACERATION confirm
  • 235. Dashboard for the Faculty displaying Faculty’s Appointments, Patients, Stats, Roster ,etc.
  • 236. HIS implementation at AIIMS: OPD & Doctor Consultation
  • 237. Gen & OPD Registration & Reception
  • 239. Server Room & Computer Facility
  • 240. 3. Website: JPNATC dynamic website
  • 241. Real time stats on homepage
  • 242. Week, Month & Yearly Statistics
  • 243. eINDIA 2010 award at Hyderabad
  • 244. mBILLIONTH 2010 award at N. Delhi
  • 245. eWorld 2011 Award at N. Delhi