A review on the relevance of Forums in Social Media Marketing and current trends.
A discussion on product development, consumer research, crowdsourcing, ethics, and the new trust framework.
Tips on setting up your own forum and becoming influential.
Includes examples from Dell, Gaia Online, and Royal Caribbean Cruises.
5. Forums types and users
Cultures
0 As many as possible – e.g. Rolia – Canadian Chinese
Topics & interest
0 Politics, family, hobbies, economy, religion, technology, and others
Ownership
0 Corporate owned forum
0 Grassroots community forums
Users
0 Moderators & administrators
0 Registered members and Visitors
0 Influencers, followers, and lurkers
6. Organic Word of Mouth Communication & Online Forum
Forum users – consumer products end users love to share
experience, make recommendation.
8. 22% of Businesses Surveyed Use Forums
Question: Is your organization using any of the
following media channels? (Check all that apply)
Don't know 2%
Review sites/ discussion forums 22%
Microblogs (e.g. Twitter) 53%
Multimedia Sharing 58%
Blogs 58%
Social Networks 87%
Source: Harvard Business Review Analytic Services. (2010)
9. 96% of Businesses using Forums have found
success in them
Source: Center for Marketing Research, University of Massachusetts (2012)
11. Influence on consumer brand evaluation
depends on pre-existing brand image
0 Favorableness
0 Stronger effect on a low-image brand
0 Weaker effect for a high-image brand
0 Message Number
0 Does not affect low-image brand
0 Larger numbers favorable for high-image brand
Low image brands should be more careful in having its
own internet discussion forum as negative comments
affect its consumer brand evaluation more easily.
Source: (Chiou & Cheng, Journal for Interactive Marketing ,2003)
13. Benefits of using online forums for social
media marketing
0 Consumer Research
0 Product feedback for improvement or development
0 Consumer Support
0 Outsource some of your customer service to the "crowd“
0 Brand awareness and loyalty building
0 Forums have self-segmented, target consumers
0 Customer Relationship Building
0 Build relationships- you, consumers, and other consumers
0 Moderated discussion
0 Some control possible in company’s forum
16. Forum: Anime Role Playing
Members: 25,717,446
Posts: 2,017,979,377
Demographic: 14 – 25 yrs. old
Narrative Strategy: Embracing
Acceptance: Consumer- marketer
role enthusiastically adopted
Community Reaction - Positive as
communal norms, forum, and
communicator narrative are
congruent with WOMM campaign.
Choose appropriate forum
Understand norms
Promote WOMM accordingly
18. Consumer Research
Forums are an archive of consumer’s WOM where one can get consumer
insights into products and marketing programs
- para. Kozinets, Wojnicki, & Wilner (2010)
19. Online communities provide insight to
product development
Forums provide a niche community that has an inherent interest in a
particular product or service and can be used to further improve these.
Source: Fuhler, Johann (2006)
21. Dell has established
an online
community for
customer support.
Dell representatives
or other customers
help answer
support questions
promptly
Monitor forums regularly and respond quickly
22. Tips to be influential in online forums
0 Establish Trust. Understand the community. Register
early. Be respectful. Don’t self promote.
0 Be Competent. Provide quality and engaging content
0 Be Accessible. Monitor, share, and respond regularly
Source: Edelman (2011)
23. Tips in setting up your own online forum
0 Set goals – what you expect from your community
0 Understand community – what motivates them
0 Use right software
0 Help create meaningful content
0 Allow members to share control
Source: inc.com (2011)
25. Royal Caribbean Cruise Lines engages a small group of
influential posters to the Royal Champions program. The
Royal Champions continue to post at the Cruise Critic
website.
27. Cruise Critic Member Reaction
“Personally, I think most of the vitriol toward the Royal Champions
would be quashed if there were to be a sticky placed at the top of this
forum, explaining precisely what/who these folks are and how they are
"compensated" (if at all) for their commentary. Easy. I had no idea what
a "Royal Champion" was until yesterday, and I probably wouldn't have
given it much thought if I were to have seen the title in a poster's
signature. Now I know.
It's one thing to read a review of a particular line or ship knowing full
well that it was authored by a paid Cruise Critic staffer, and something
entirely different when "member reviews" are potentially seeded with
ones written by shills for that particular cruise line. When anyone - like
me - who might be looking for unbiased, critical commentary believes
there may be corporate influence involved in their words, the member
reviews suddenly lose so much value.”
- Davey Interweb,
Posted March 10, 2009,
Member since June 2005, Posts 965
28. Narrative Strategy:
Evaluation
Concealment: Minimized
mention of participation
in WOMM campaign
Leadership: positioned
as safe information source
Community Reaction:
Negative due to
incongruence to norms
Be transparent and authentic
30. Astroturfing - An orchestrated expression of support for a
product or service, designed to give the impression of a
genuine "grassroots" movement or groundswell of support.
31. On Disclosure
To disclose or not to disclose paid online endorsements –
that is no longer the question.
(The answer is yes.)
- Heenan Blakie, Canadian Marketing, Advertising &
Regulatory Law Update (Sept. 2011)
34. Is online forum still relevant in today’s social
media marketing world?
Weaknesses of Online Forum
• Delayed nature of conversation
• One of the earliest forms of social media
Strengths of Online Forum
• Strong community bonding,
• Attracts long term traffic
• Niche market sharing common interest
• Length and detail friendly – perfect for sharing stories and experiences
Yes, forums should still be considered
36. Sources
1. Kozinets, R. V., Wojnicki, A. C., & Wilner, S. J. (2010). Networked Narratives: Understanding Word-of-Mouth Marketing in
Online Communities. Journal of Marketing, 87.
2. Fuhler, Johann (2006); Community based innovation: How to integrate members of virtual communities into new
product development
3. Brown, J., Broderick, A,., & Lee, N. (2007) Word of mouth communication within online communities: conceptualizing
the online social network. Journal of Interactive Marketing
4. Edelman (2011). 2011 Trust Barometer Canadian Summary
5. Zabin, J. and Jefferies, A. (2008) Social media monitoring and analysis: Generating consumer insights from online
conversation. Aberdeen Group Benchmark Report
6. Chiou, J.-S., & Cheng, C. (2003). Should a Company Have Message Boards on its Websites. Journal for Interactive
Marketing, 17(3), 50-59.
7. Heenan Blakie. (2011). Canadian Marketing, Advertising & Regulatory Law Update.
8. http://www.cruisebruise.com/Royal_Caribbean_Caught_Infiltrating_Forums_March_9_2009_2.html
9. http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showpost.php?p=18545037&postcount=287
10. http://consumerist.com/2009/03/royal-caribbean-caught-infiltrating-review-sites-with-viral-marketing-team.html
11. http://rankings.big-boards.com/
12. http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/29554810/ns/travel-cruise_travel/t/does-cruise-lines-viral-campaign-cross-
line/#.T0c4cvnuay4
13. http://www.conversionation.net/2011/07/word-of-mouth-marketing-when-a-human-phenomenon-goes-business/
14. http://www.bytelaunch.com/bytelaunch-blog/misc/ethical-issues-in-advertising-with-social-media-marketing/
15. http://www.clappingtrees.com/archives/2008/08/the-biggest-ethical-issues-in-social-media-today/
16. http://www.idea-sandbox.com/blog/2010/10/word-of-mouth-reasons-people-talk-reasons-people-listen/
17. All images by their respective copyright owners
Notes de l'éditeur
The topics of the forums can cover anything, not limited to the few examples we have just run. They can cover pets, art, family, nature, motorcycles, politics, sports, economy, fashion, professions, family, study, religion, technology. If we are to classify by ownership, there are two types – company’s commercial forum and community owned forums. Most forums are moderated. There are rules and regulations to be followed for joining the forums. Depending on the activities level of the participants, we can classify them to influencers, followers and lurkers. It is influencers whose IDs become recognized and whose posts get most attention. Obviously, as marketers, these are the people we would like to work with.
No matter who owns it, a good forum should be a thriving one, with considerable traffic and active participation. On these forums, participants, end of day, consumer good end users exchange ideas on products, share experience on product and services, make recommendations . Organic word of mouth communication occurs. Just to prove how online forum contributes successfully to marketing:, I bought baby products recommended on Baby forum, I bought a stir fry wok recommended on Cooking forum... Just imagine it multiples to hundreds, thousands, or even millions...
Once you find the right forums for your company. They can be a rich source of consumer insight that you can use to develop or assess products or marketing campaigns.Companies can respond to the consumer insights retrieved through social media monitoring and analysis by modifying their marketingmessages, brand positioning, product development, and other activities accordingly
Moderators can go through the forums and monitor conversations to see how they can improve Gaia online or even sponsors marketing campaigns.
Naturally, due to the delayed nature of online forums, and given the increasing popularity of more real time social media sites out there, we may question the usefulness of online forum. The answer is Yes, we should still include it , at least in the mix of social medial marketing tools. Online forum is very attractive in long term traffic. Once you belong to a certain community, you will always come back. The space allowed in online community makes it easier and possible to share story, experience in details with other users. In addition, forums are community members sharing similar interest, thus make it very targeted niche market.