SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  10
Social Differentiation and Access
to Water Resources: The case study on the
  resettled communities of Yali falls dam,
 Se San River, Kon Tum province, Vietnam

                Tran Chi Trung and Dao Trong Hung
   Centre for Natural Resources and Environmental Studies (CRES)
                      Vietnam National University
The study site

The Yali hydropower was
commissioned in 2001.
                                                                                                           Ko n Tu m
                                                                                                
                                                                                               &                  
                                                                                                                   &
                                                                                                                  &&
                                                                                              & &&
                                                                                                &               &&
                                                                                                                  &
                                                                                               && &               
                                                                                                   &
                                                                                                   &             &
                                                                                                    &           
                                                                                                                 &
                                                                                                     &
                                                                                                    &  
                                                                                                     
                                                                                                     &

                                                                                       Sa Thay
                                                                                                           T
                                                                                                           $ Yaly dam
                                                                                        district


                                                                                                             
                                                                                                             &   Chu Pah
                                                                                                             
                                                                                                             &
                                                                                                           
                                                                                                           &      district

                                                                                                            




Moving about 6,782 people
                                                                                                            &


                                                                                                           Gia La i
                                                                      CAMBODIA



belongs to 1,735 households
of 4 ethnic groups (Kinh, Ro
Ngao, Ba Na and Gia Rai)

                                         Hanoi




                                                                      N
                                                                                                                               Le g e n d

                               Kon Tum
                                                                                                                             Boundary
                               Gia Lai                                                                               
                                                                                                                     &       Res ettle d village s
                                                                                                                     
                                                                                                                     &       Dow nstream villages
                                                                                                                     T
                                                                                                                     $       Yali dam
                                                            100   0       100    200 Kil omet er s                           River
                                         Ho Chi Minh City                                                                    Roa d
Key research questions

1. How have the villagers been using the resources after
   they had resettled and what institutional factors impact
   their use?
2. What are the differences within the community in use
   of resources and other resources in terms of gender,
   age, kinship, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, and
   class?
3. How have the resettlement program affected the local
   people differently?
4. Under which condition and terms different groups of
   people have participated in water governance and how
   has this affected their livelihoods?
The initial findings
The household resource system has totally changed and the
  local people have faced more difficulties.




        Mono-crop based agriculture of cassava
The initial findings (cont’)
Semi-flooded land – the provincial people committee
allocated to the hydropower management board.
The initial findings (cont’)
Lack of consultation & participation in the resettlement process
The initial findings (cont’)
Compensation packages planned but not fair & transparent.
The initial findings (cont’)
Reponses to the challenges of the resettlement site have
  been made but not effective.
Conclusion

• Gaps in understanding the complicated situation of
  the resettlement site would lead to ineffectiveness
  in responses to their challenges.

• The resettled people and local authorities have not
  had a voice in the trade-offs negotiation process
  and have been suffering the consequences of the
  losses.
Thank you very much for your attentions!

Contenu connexe

Plus de CPWF Mekong

Mekong: The Challenges of Scale
Mekong: The Challenges of ScaleMekong: The Challenges of Scale
Mekong: The Challenges of ScaleCPWF Mekong
 
Closing remarks dr kim geheb
Closing remarks dr kim gehebClosing remarks dr kim geheb
Closing remarks dr kim gehebCPWF Mekong
 
Session 20 comparing the nexus along the mekong ganga
Session 20 comparing the nexus along the mekong  gangaSession 20 comparing the nexus along the mekong  ganga
Session 20 comparing the nexus along the mekong gangaCPWF Mekong
 
Sustainability tools in hydropower development & operations
Sustainability tools in hydropower development & operationsSustainability tools in hydropower development & operations
Sustainability tools in hydropower development & operationsCPWF Mekong
 
Efforts to apply to rsat in mekong tributary sub basins under the mrc-ish pro...
Efforts to apply to rsat in mekong tributary sub basins under the mrc-ish pro...Efforts to apply to rsat in mekong tributary sub basins under the mrc-ish pro...
Efforts to apply to rsat in mekong tributary sub basins under the mrc-ish pro...CPWF Mekong
 
Advancing sustainability in the mekong region role of assessment tools and st...
Advancing sustainability in the mekong region role of assessment tools and st...Advancing sustainability in the mekong region role of assessment tools and st...
Advancing sustainability in the mekong region role of assessment tools and st...CPWF Mekong
 
Draft agenda session 19 for panelists
Draft agenda session 19 for panelistsDraft agenda session 19 for panelists
Draft agenda session 19 for panelistsCPWF Mekong
 
Lessons learnt about hydropower decision making processes in cambodia
Lessons learnt about hydropower decision making processes in cambodiaLessons learnt about hydropower decision making processes in cambodia
Lessons learnt about hydropower decision making processes in cambodiaCPWF Mekong
 
Decision making on hydropower development in lao pdr
Decision making on hydropower development in lao pdrDecision making on hydropower development in lao pdr
Decision making on hydropower development in lao pdrCPWF Mekong
 
Chinese studies on impacts of dams
Chinese studies on impacts of damsChinese studies on impacts of dams
Chinese studies on impacts of damsCPWF Mekong
 
Governance, institutions and decision making
Governance, institutions and decision makingGovernance, institutions and decision making
Governance, institutions and decision makingCPWF Mekong
 
Integrated water resource management
Integrated water resource managementIntegrated water resource management
Integrated water resource managementCPWF Mekong
 
How hydropower operations can accommodate local livelihoods
How hydropower operations can accommodate local livelihoodsHow hydropower operations can accommodate local livelihoods
How hydropower operations can accommodate local livelihoodsCPWF Mekong
 
Gender, livelihoods & decision making
Gender, livelihoods & decision makingGender, livelihoods & decision making
Gender, livelihoods & decision makingCPWF Mekong
 
Better dams for food and livelihoods overview
Better dams for food and livelihoods overviewBetter dams for food and livelihoods overview
Better dams for food and livelihoods overviewCPWF Mekong
 
Assessing livelihood piloting experiences associated with hydropower development
Assessing livelihood piloting experiences associated with hydropower developmentAssessing livelihood piloting experiences associated with hydropower development
Assessing livelihood piloting experiences associated with hydropower developmentCPWF Mekong
 
Day 1 session 5.3 direct vs indirect pes could microcredit be an option
Day 1 session 5.3  direct vs indirect pes could microcredit be an optionDay 1 session 5.3  direct vs indirect pes could microcredit be an option
Day 1 session 5.3 direct vs indirect pes could microcredit be an optionCPWF Mekong
 
Optimising fish friendly criteria for incorporation into the design of mini-h...
Optimising fish friendly criteria for incorporation into the design of mini-h...Optimising fish friendly criteria for incorporation into the design of mini-h...
Optimising fish friendly criteria for incorporation into the design of mini-h...CPWF Mekong
 
Solar pv in vietnam power sector benefits, costs and policy
Solar pv in vietnam power sector  benefits, costs and policySolar pv in vietnam power sector  benefits, costs and policy
Solar pv in vietnam power sector benefits, costs and policyCPWF Mekong
 
Technology review
Technology reviewTechnology review
Technology reviewCPWF Mekong
 

Plus de CPWF Mekong (20)

Mekong: The Challenges of Scale
Mekong: The Challenges of ScaleMekong: The Challenges of Scale
Mekong: The Challenges of Scale
 
Closing remarks dr kim geheb
Closing remarks dr kim gehebClosing remarks dr kim geheb
Closing remarks dr kim geheb
 
Session 20 comparing the nexus along the mekong ganga
Session 20 comparing the nexus along the mekong  gangaSession 20 comparing the nexus along the mekong  ganga
Session 20 comparing the nexus along the mekong ganga
 
Sustainability tools in hydropower development & operations
Sustainability tools in hydropower development & operationsSustainability tools in hydropower development & operations
Sustainability tools in hydropower development & operations
 
Efforts to apply to rsat in mekong tributary sub basins under the mrc-ish pro...
Efforts to apply to rsat in mekong tributary sub basins under the mrc-ish pro...Efforts to apply to rsat in mekong tributary sub basins under the mrc-ish pro...
Efforts to apply to rsat in mekong tributary sub basins under the mrc-ish pro...
 
Advancing sustainability in the mekong region role of assessment tools and st...
Advancing sustainability in the mekong region role of assessment tools and st...Advancing sustainability in the mekong region role of assessment tools and st...
Advancing sustainability in the mekong region role of assessment tools and st...
 
Draft agenda session 19 for panelists
Draft agenda session 19 for panelistsDraft agenda session 19 for panelists
Draft agenda session 19 for panelists
 
Lessons learnt about hydropower decision making processes in cambodia
Lessons learnt about hydropower decision making processes in cambodiaLessons learnt about hydropower decision making processes in cambodia
Lessons learnt about hydropower decision making processes in cambodia
 
Decision making on hydropower development in lao pdr
Decision making on hydropower development in lao pdrDecision making on hydropower development in lao pdr
Decision making on hydropower development in lao pdr
 
Chinese studies on impacts of dams
Chinese studies on impacts of damsChinese studies on impacts of dams
Chinese studies on impacts of dams
 
Governance, institutions and decision making
Governance, institutions and decision makingGovernance, institutions and decision making
Governance, institutions and decision making
 
Integrated water resource management
Integrated water resource managementIntegrated water resource management
Integrated water resource management
 
How hydropower operations can accommodate local livelihoods
How hydropower operations can accommodate local livelihoodsHow hydropower operations can accommodate local livelihoods
How hydropower operations can accommodate local livelihoods
 
Gender, livelihoods & decision making
Gender, livelihoods & decision makingGender, livelihoods & decision making
Gender, livelihoods & decision making
 
Better dams for food and livelihoods overview
Better dams for food and livelihoods overviewBetter dams for food and livelihoods overview
Better dams for food and livelihoods overview
 
Assessing livelihood piloting experiences associated with hydropower development
Assessing livelihood piloting experiences associated with hydropower developmentAssessing livelihood piloting experiences associated with hydropower development
Assessing livelihood piloting experiences associated with hydropower development
 
Day 1 session 5.3 direct vs indirect pes could microcredit be an option
Day 1 session 5.3  direct vs indirect pes could microcredit be an optionDay 1 session 5.3  direct vs indirect pes could microcredit be an option
Day 1 session 5.3 direct vs indirect pes could microcredit be an option
 
Optimising fish friendly criteria for incorporation into the design of mini-h...
Optimising fish friendly criteria for incorporation into the design of mini-h...Optimising fish friendly criteria for incorporation into the design of mini-h...
Optimising fish friendly criteria for incorporation into the design of mini-h...
 
Solar pv in vietnam power sector benefits, costs and policy
Solar pv in vietnam power sector  benefits, costs and policySolar pv in vietnam power sector  benefits, costs and policy
Solar pv in vietnam power sector benefits, costs and policy
 
Technology review
Technology reviewTechnology review
Technology review
 

Social Differentiation and Access to Water Resources

  • 1. Social Differentiation and Access to Water Resources: The case study on the resettled communities of Yali falls dam, Se San River, Kon Tum province, Vietnam Tran Chi Trung and Dao Trong Hung Centre for Natural Resources and Environmental Studies (CRES) Vietnam National University
  • 2. The study site The Yali hydropower was commissioned in 2001. Ko n Tu m & & && & && & && & && & & & & & & & & & Sa Thay T $ Yaly dam district & Chu Pah & & district Moving about 6,782 people & Gia La i CAMBODIA belongs to 1,735 households of 4 ethnic groups (Kinh, Ro Ngao, Ba Na and Gia Rai) Hanoi N Le g e n d Kon Tum Boundary Gia Lai & Res ettle d village s & Dow nstream villages T $ Yali dam 100 0 100 200 Kil omet er s River Ho Chi Minh City Roa d
  • 3. Key research questions 1. How have the villagers been using the resources after they had resettled and what institutional factors impact their use? 2. What are the differences within the community in use of resources and other resources in terms of gender, age, kinship, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, and class? 3. How have the resettlement program affected the local people differently? 4. Under which condition and terms different groups of people have participated in water governance and how has this affected their livelihoods?
  • 4. The initial findings The household resource system has totally changed and the local people have faced more difficulties. Mono-crop based agriculture of cassava
  • 5. The initial findings (cont’) Semi-flooded land – the provincial people committee allocated to the hydropower management board.
  • 6. The initial findings (cont’) Lack of consultation & participation in the resettlement process
  • 7. The initial findings (cont’) Compensation packages planned but not fair & transparent.
  • 8. The initial findings (cont’) Reponses to the challenges of the resettlement site have been made but not effective.
  • 9. Conclusion • Gaps in understanding the complicated situation of the resettlement site would lead to ineffectiveness in responses to their challenges. • The resettled people and local authorities have not had a voice in the trade-offs negotiation process and have been suffering the consequences of the losses.
  • 10. Thank you very much for your attentions!