My session at Maryland Nonprofits Tech to Tell conference on June 7th on how to use online fundraising to engage with and build longterm trusting relationships with your supporters.
11. How Donors Feel
of Americans they donate more than avg
actually contribute the national avg
how nonprofits use their money
hassled
from their funding
12. How Donors Feel
prefer to give to nonprofits but
necessarily the organizations
are to their primary causes
to give to different nonprofits
nonprofits before giving
13. Why? Lack of
All are critical elements of an
engaged, trusting relationship
14. Generational Shift
Generation Born
Depression 1912-1921
WW II 1922-1927
Post-War 1928-1945
“Traditionalists”
18% of total population
“New Philanthropists”
82% and growing
Leading Boomers 1946-1954
Trailing Boomers 1955-1964
Generation X 1965-1976
Millennial / Generation Y 1977-1984
Great Recession/ Boomerang 1985-?
Fundraising methods used today were developed for the “Traditionalists” many
years ago, and have not really evolved for the “New Philanthropists”
15. Traditionalists
Depression (1912 – 1921)
Defining
Moment:
Shared
Values:
• Great Depression • Practicality
• Savings
• Safety/security
• Friends/family
• Trust charities
Best
Approaches:
Marketing
Tips:
• Bequests • Simple &
straightforward
• Unrestricted
endowment
• Visuals and other
cues
• Help the needy in
tough times
• Printed/ face to
face
• Secure our future • No reverse type
World War II (1922 – 1927)
Defining
Moment:
Shared
Values:
• WW II • Patriotic
• Respect for authority
• Romantic
• Self-reliant
• Trust charities
Best
Approaches:
Marketing
Tips:
• Save the world • Concierge-level
treatment
• Delayed
gratification
• Rebates/coupons/disc
ounts
• Remembered for
sacrifices
• Matching
gifts/challenges
• Immortality of
named bequests
• Print
• Families trust them
Post War (1928 – 1945)
Defining
Moments:
Shared
Values:
• End of WW II • The American dream
• Strong economy • Conformity
• Move to burbs • Stability
• McCarthyism • Family
• Rock & roll
• Civil rights movement
• Self-fulfillment
• Trust charities
Best
Approaches:
Marketing
Tips:
• Current gifts • Volunteer
opportunities
• Beneficiary
designation
• Active images
• Gift annuities • Outcomes-based
16. New Philanthropists
Lead Boomers (1946 – 1954)
Defining
Moments:
Shared
Values:
• Assassinations of
JFK, RFK, MLK
• Personalized/
social expression
• Vietnam war • Individualism
• Moon landing • Youth/ health/
wellness
• Lack of trust for
charities
Best
Approaches:
Marketing
Tips:
• Social justice
meets personal
planning
• Impact, outcomes
and verifiability
• Restricted gifts,
complex assets,
structured gifts
• Large type/ high
contrast/ no
glossy
• Advisor
partnerships
• Fun, individualism
and excitement
• Beneficiary
designations
Generation X (1965 – 1976)
Defining
Moment:
Shared
Values:
• Large national
debt/ stock crash
• Free agency/
independence
• Challenger
explosion
• Dependence on
friends
• Fall of Berlin wall • Cynical about future
• 1st Persian Gulf
War
• Street smart
• Quality of life
• AIDS crisis • Lack of trust for
charities
Best
Approaches:
Marketing
Tips:
• Custom gift
solutions
• Impact, outcomes
verifiability and
accountability
• Beneficiary
designations
• Not attractive or rich-
facts
• Restricted gifts • Subtlety/ irony/
irreverence
• Advisor
partnerships
Trailing Boomers (1955 – 1964)
Defining
Moments:
Shared
Values:
• Fall of Vietnam • Lonely individualism
• Watergate • Cynicism/ distrust
• Nixon resignation • Health and wellness
• Energy crisis • Family commitments
• Lack of trust for
charities
Best
Approaches:
Marketing
Tips:
• Gift outcomes • Impact, outcomes
verifiability and
accountability
• Full range of
charitable tools
• Conscious of distrust
• Restricted gifts • Robust stewardship
• Advisor partnerships
17. New Philanthropists
Millennials (1977 – 1984)
Defining
Moments:
Shared
Values:
• The internet • Hopeful about
financial future
• Economic boom • Heightened fears
• Columbine • Change is good
• September 11 • Tolerance/
diversity
• Wars in Iraq and
Afghanistan
• Lack of trust for
charities
Best
Approaches:
Marketing
Tips:
• Beneficiary
designations
• “Get out of the
way”
• Restricted gifts
exclusively
• Change it up
• Modest annual
donations
focused on
mission
• Fresh & multi-
channel
• Brand conscious
loyal
Boomerang (1985 – ?)
Defining
Moments:
Shared
Values:
• TBD • TBD
Best
Approaches:
Marketing
Tips:
• TBD • TBD
23. Crowd is Different than
Traditional Fundraising!
MAJOR GIVING MODEL:
• Prospect for potentials
• Develop a relationship by engaging with them before the
ask
• Ask, but in the right way and not too often
• Engage with them after the give – thank them, show
impact, transparency and accountability
• Nurture the relationship, it’s fragile!
• A small “everyday” donation is a burden
24. Crowd is Different than
Traditional Fundraising!
CROWDGIVING:
• Your supporters prospect for you
• Engage with them electronically, on their terms
• Ask by using a campaign with visuals and storytelling
that compels the potential donor to give
• Engage with them after the give – thank them, show
impact, transparency and accountability
• Make it easy for them to leverage their networks
• Keep them in the loop, on their terms
• A small “everyday” donation is an opportunity
25. View 1st time “Everyday” donor
as a QUALIFIED LEAD
• There’s something about your organization they like,
somehow they found out about your organization
– Personal ask by a family member or friend?
• Get a 2nd transaction you will get a total of 18 on average
– 1st time = I like you
– 2nd time = you won me over, I’m committed
• Give them a reason to come back!
– Engage, be Transparent and Accountable
26. of
start with a donation of
they test the water before writing a big check!
28. NGAGEMENT via Crowd
• Craft a beautiful branded campaign that will compel donors to
give
• Share the campaign with your existing supporters, ask them
to share to their networks
• Provide a great donor experience with a donation flow that’s
quick and easy and simple to share out socially
• Thank your donor onscreen with a customized content
including videos and pictures
• Email the thank you as well with tax information for their
records
• Reach out during the campaign to let your donors know
status – they’re not checking in but they are interested. Ask
29. NGAGEMENT via Crowd
• Reach out and let them know how the campaign finished
– They’re not checking in but they are interested.
– Thank them again
• Reach out to them after you spend the money raised to show
them the impact (pictures, videos, stories). Close the loop
• Keep them updated between asks as to what’s happening at
your organization. Let them see you working and getting
support. Don’t just reach out to them when you need money!
• Remind them of their donation at the end of the year to help
them with their tax return prep
30. RANSPARENCY via
Crowd
• Build a campaign that is very specific
• Tell the potential donor why you need the specific thing,
what impact it will have and on who
• Explain what the cost of the specific thing is and why it is
important to the mission
• Be clear how much the fees are and why there need to be
fees
• Keep your donors updated during the campaign as to its
success OR failure
31. CCOUNTABILITY via Crowd
• Spend the funds raised exactly how you said you would in
the campaign
• Share the impact with all of the donors that made it
happen by sending them pictures, videos or even inviting
them onsite to see their contribution at work
• Respectfully maintain contact with them between asks to
let them know what your organization is up to
• Maintain clear and open lines of communication,
especially in times of crisis or difficulty
• Treat your donors and volunteers as investors in your org
32. Key Crowd Takeaways
• Fundraising is inherently inefficient & resistant to change
• Make it easy and fun! Fundraising doesn’t have to be dry!
• Do more with less - spend more time fulfilling your mission to
change the world, not fundraising.
• Embrace the significant generational differences
– Younger: online, quick, easy, accountability, impact, distrusting
– Older: trusting, mobile is how they access the internet
33. Key Crowd Takeaways
• If you do it right, there’s no donor fatigue in crowdfunding -
paradigm shift needed. Close the loop.
• Treat donors and volunteers as investors, because that’s
what they are!
• Assume every donor may be a major donor, no matter the
size of gift. Bill Gates example
• Access and engage your future major donors sooner
• Increase your donor database via peer-2-peer fundraising
34. What’s wrong with
Crowdfunding Platforms?
Existing platforms were not designed for nonprofits.
Fundraising for nonprofits is much, much different than
funding a film, project, product or personal cause. Square
peg / round hole.
The Unanswered Questions:
• Where to begin? Hundreds of platforms to chose from.
• Now what? You get no coaching, you’re on your own.
• Where’s the “magic money”? You didn’t tell me that donors
need to be driven to the button!
• How do I do that? Social media? I’m already overworked!!!
35. Why Not Use the Well Known
Crowdfunding Platforms?
nonprofit folks who give up on crowdfunding.
They feel its a big , which
the tools are not made for the job. It’s like using a tiny
brush to paint an entire room. It can be done, but boy will it be hard
and frustrating! Think .
Nonprofit fundraising is different than funding a project, movie,
personal cause, etc –
IT’S ABOUT BUILDING RELATIONSHIPS!
36. Think UX 1st: responsive design that is screen size agnostic, intuitive,
clean, simple
Easily create a beautiful, meaningful and specific campaign
Include powerful eye catching imagery with a compelling story
Empower your supporters via peer-to-peer fundraising
Encourage your supporters to share to their social networks
Agility - determine what best strikes a chord by editing on the fly,
experiment, test, multi-channel
Monitor progress and coach your fundraisers with powerful campaign
management
Simple and clean donation flow that eliminates speed bumps
Thank your supporters after they give
Engage supporters before, during and after the campaign
Repeat
38. The Face of a Campaign
Eye Catching Imagery
Is this image relevant to my campaign?
Is it good quality and the proper orientation? (not blurry or pixelated)
Is the image appropriately cropped?
Is it visually engaging?
39. The Heart of a Campaign
Compelling Story
3 Essential Questions
Who or what is your
campaign supporting?
What is the conflict?
How will your donor’s gift
help make an impact?
40. The Legs of a Campaign
Peer-to-Peer Fundraisers
Fundraising Champions
give your campaign the muscle it
needs to move forward by tapping
their networks with a personal
connection.
Personal asks
Donations
66. • A powerful 24-hour online fundraising event that unites
a community around local causes. A great way to build
community, expose nonprofits to donors, teach
organizations to use digital tools and generate
excitement for all involved. Leverage the marketing
power of the whole and the platform being used.
• Think Jerry Lewis Telethon, but online
Day of Giving
67. The DoG Potential
North Texas is the Gold Star!
– Year 1 = $1.2 million, ~350 nonprofits
– Year 7 = , ~2,000+ nonprofits
68.
69.
70.
71.
72.
73.
74.
75.
76.
77. https://www.givegab.com/about/case_studies
“Change is hard. GiveGab was not. The FAQ’s and Toolkit helped me and I was able to help
my constituents. It was GiveGabTastic!”
“Working with GiveGab has been a wonderful experience for ProLiteracy. Givegab.com is a
great platform to begin with but it’s the staff support that really sets it apart. This being our first
Day of Giving, we were very grateful to have a Give Gab team help us walk through the setup,
getting our members involved and excited, teaching people how to use the site, marketing
ideas and a bunch of other behind-the-scenes help. We couldn’t have been as successful
without their help. I’d recommend Give Gab to anyone trying to crowdfund or find volunteers,
and I already have!”
82. Risk-Free, Simple and
Transparent Pricing
We are completely aligned with our nonprofit partners - we only
succeed if they succeed. It makes absolutely no sense to us to
charge ANY fees to a nonprofit before they raise $ one. Why would
we start them in the hole when they are trying to raise money?
Subscriptions, contracts, commitments, etc are for cowards – we are
so confident that you’ll love our platform and use it over and over that
we take all the risk!
• Platform Fee . No other fees,
period!
of donors elect to cover, result is avg cost of
• Net funds are by Stripe daily, we
don’t have access to credit card info or the funds, only our
small fee
83. 5.0% Platform Fee
+2.7% Credit Card Fee (Stripe)
7.7% Maximum Fee
-5.3% Donors Elect to Cover 70%*
The Simple Math Behind Low
Fees
*Over 100’s of campaigns. Our platform fee is completely paid for by the donors at 65%!
84. Chris Smith
Chief Financial Officer
chris.smith@givegab.com 914-443-2850
@smithGiveGabinkedin.com/in/kcichris
Notes de l'éditeur
ASK the audience who how successful they’ve been at online fundraising
Originally from Buffalo – ever seen a snow forecast like that?!?!?!
The picture on the right is a street with a “Welcome to Buffalo” sign
Now I live in the beautiful Hudson Valley, just North of NYC
I have 3 kids – 9, 7, 5
And I’m a CPA
A little bit about GiveGab – we’re an online fundraising and engagement platform that helps nonprofits build long-term relationships with “every day donors”
Is this how your nonprofit tools are? Disconnected, lots to manage… inefficient! Shouldn’t it be easier????
Isn’t this the way it should be? Why is there no one-stop shop for nonprofit administrators? There is now…
Founded as a VOLUNTEER MANAGEMENT & engagement platform in 2011
Launched CROWDFUNDING in late 2014 in response to repeat requests by our nonprofit customers
Added EVENT MANAGEMENT in April 2015 in response to customer needs
Added GIVING DAYS in June 2015, for Engage Mississippi
Building out DONOR CRM in response to customer requests – highly profitable
MARKETING & COMMUNICATIONS functionality to come to keep nonprofit admins from leaving the platform
All of this in response to customer feedback and focus groups – nonprofits literally in our office
The nonprofit industry is huge, something like the 3rd biggest industry in the US
2015 numbers are coming out June 14th in the Giving USA report
Donors are out there looking for places to give. If not properly engaged, they jump somewhere else; but they still give
Think about it – say your friend personally asks you to donate to a charity she feels deeply about, you’ll probably give because your friend asked you. Now if that nonprofit does not engage you, does not even thank you, you’re probably not going to come back next time. You’ll go elsewhere!
A lot of smaller nonprofits
ALL are under resourced
Many no IT resources
Many no professional fundraisers
Many staffed by volunteers
Spend time on administration and fundraising rather than the mission
How can you survive?
Why does this happen?
Extreme inefficiency
Clearly the methods developed in the past need improvement!
A ton of work to lose ground – think of the gerbil in a cage on a wheel, running and running but going nowhere
It’s really hard and expensive to get new donors
Keep them once you have them!
MANY of these issues are completely in your control – how can you do a better job? How can you engage with ALL donors, not simply the major donors?
This speaks more to how they decide who to give to
March of Dimes example
I donate $50 per year
Get solicited each and every week, with address labels and a dime – they’ve more than spent my donation on soliciting me
Don’t get thanked
I know that the funds are not going to where they say “Goshen Area Fund” or stay local
Going to the corporate HQ and being allocated out
Never tell me what they did with my donation
Result is I feel no impact, my donation does not matter
Source – AFP webinar January 2015
Point of slide is to to show there is a line of demarcation
Fundraising methods used today were developed for the “Traditionalists” many years ago, and have not really evolved for the “New Philanthropists”
Not going over in detail
Notice they trust charities as charities were instrumental in helping people during the Great Depression and WW2
They prefer the big, national brands
Notice lack of trust
Want impact, outcomes, verifiability and accountability
Boomerang yet to be determined, assume like the millenials.
Instant gratification!!!
Another way to think about it
Your Donate Now button is not online fundraising! Honestly, how often does hit get used???? It’s probably buried somewhere on your text and information heavy website. And if someone happens to find it, the process is absolutely not engaging whatsoever. It does not make the donor feel god – feels simply like a transaction. Ugly!
Not surprising
Remember online shopping 10 -15 years ago?
Now at 50% or so of all purchases
Smaller nonprofits typically fit the New Philanthropist mentality – not trusting of larger national orgs, want impact
Younger generations drive, however older generations often times mobile is their 1st exposure to the internet, facebook
Mobile is the future.
Is your website MOBILE RESPONSIVE? If it’s not, there is no chance someone is going to use your donate now button!
Google changed their search ranking algorithm such that if you are not mobile responsive, you do not show up on page 1. Who goes past page 1? Nobody!
Statue of Liberty base
This is important to remember – many of the “rules” of the major giving model DO NOT APPLY to crowdgiving. Think about it - you’re not going to treat that $10 donor the same as that $10,000 donor, and that’s OK!
Add the dating analogy??
You have to treat every donor as a potential major donor.
Crowdfunding helps do this
They see many small donors
They see the nonprofit doing things
They are not the only donor
Let’s talk about Engagement via CrowdGiving
Quick read and comment
Quick read and comment
How to be Transparent viaCrowdGiving
Quick read and comment
How to be Accountable via CrowdGiving
Quick read and comment
Quick read and comment
Paradigm shift about repeat asks
Donors and volunteers as INVESTORS
Treat all donors as major donors
don’t segment by $ amount - $ doesn’t mean anything or an indication of capacity to give
Anyone had success with crowdfunding?
How do you define success?
What did you crowdfund?
Wrong tools for the job, no coaching, intimidating
Great imagery can set your campaign apart and draw in potential donors
A relevant image or video can help donors quickly understand what your campaign is about
Your campaign should not only educate, but paint a bigger picture. 3 essential questions
Children in grades 2-3 who are falling behind
74% of chldren not reading at grade level by 3rd grade
By supporting we can provide quality educators to help these kids succeed
Campaigns where more than 50% of funds come in from P2P
Selecting the right P2P – Huber ex
Help your supporters help you – give them everything they need, it has to be easy!
Promotion is the key
Start with direct asks – send emails to friends and family and urge them to share
Get social – use social media to promote and update
Networks are powerful!!!! Every donor provides not only money but more importantly access to their networks
Know what’s going on
Don’t just engage your supporters when you need money – no one likes that person…
Story, leaderboards
Minimalistic data capture = more people who want to give complete the transaction
Why do we need to collect all the other info? – because its always been done!
Basically everyone who starts the process completes the process
Does that happen with PayPal or crowdfunding platforms?
Break down the fees – transparent
Give further explanation as to the reason for the fee
Give the donors option to cover the fees – and the do!
Why?
Transparent
Simple process – “that’s it?”
Built for small donations:
$25 donation ~ $2.00 in fees – “why not?”
$25 to nonproft
$2 to GiveGab/ Stripe
$27 credit card charge
Give the nonprofit the intended donation
Instantaneously
Add copy, pictures and videos – make the donor feel great!
Encourage to share on Facebook and twitter “sharing is caring”
Also received via email
Available in their GiveGab personal profile
Super powerful
Fundraising Champions become fundraisers for you!
Reach out personally to their networks – a good chunk will give
The platform walks them through it – quick, easy and fun!
As an admin, you can see all of the folks who are fundraising and what steps they have done
Can reach out to them individually or a group
Positively coach and encourage them
1 Facebook post is not fundraising!
Big, successful event last month
2,172 donors
835 of them became fundraisers, and you can see them all!
How we started- social network for volunteers
This is the org’s profile page – post info about the org, volunteer opportunities.
Some nonprofits without a website have used this as their website - flexible
Over 100 colleges and universities use us for volunteer management and tracking, service learning
MSU is a heavy, heavy user
Customer developed Cornell’s volunteer platform back in 2011 still being used and enhanced today – got us going!
You can see and communicate with your members
Powerful reports, analytics, etc
Your branding, your look
Its about you not givegab
Fully editable and customizable
Edit toolkit – super easy to do!
So easy and accountant can get creative!
Fun and addicting
Campaign manager
Content provided by members, users, nonprofits
Looks great on any screen – a must today
Can’t donate via an app – Apple policy
Don’t need an app – so clean and easy
Member profile page
All donations here
Can add offline donations
Here’s a Day of Giving we held last month
$145,000 raised for 201 nonprofits,
Elevated the exposure of giving overall as well as specific nonprofits
Lots of Prizes that NONPROFITS could win - designed to help them raise more!
Social Media feed
Social Media feed
Social Media feed
Social Media feed
Behind the scenes, see where the activity is coming from!
Behind the scenes, see where the activity is coming from!
Here’s an example of a repeat user on GiveGab
Another super user – originally volunteer management, added fundraising mid-2015
Brandon uses all sorts of tools and technology, and has moved all volunteering to GiveGab