SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  63
Say no to link spam
How to build non-spammy links
Debbie Chew
Global SEO Manager at Dialpad
November 2022
Source: YouTube
“...my guess is
over time, it
[links] won't be
such a big factor
as sometimes it is
today.”
John Mueller,
Search Off The Record podcast
@justdebbb
Are links still going to
be important in the
future? 🔮
“Google is trying
to discourage
people to eat all
that candy...
Bibi Raven,
The Knowledge Panel Show
...but it doesn’t
mean that candy
is ever going to be
out of the picture.”
Bibi Raven,
The Knowledge Panel Show
@justdebbb
Are all links candy?
@justdebbb
Spammy links
are like candy
@justdebbb
Spammy links
can provide
temporary happiness
@justdebbb
Spammy links
can increase your
risk of cavities
@justdebbb
So what exactly is a
spammy link?
December 2022
Source: https://developers.google.com/search/blog/2022/12/december-
22-link-spam-update
Source: Google Search Central Blog
“spammy links are
neutralized...”
Source: Google Search Central Blog
“Our algorithms and
manual actions aim to
nullify these unnatural
links at scale...”
@justdebbb
They’ve called out...
● Paid links
● Forum comments
● Widgets
And also...
● “Excessive” link exchanges
● Guest posts
Source: Authority Hackers (2022)
@justdebbb
There needs to be a
mindset shift
@justdebbb
Instead of...
● How do get a bunch of
links at scale?
Think more about...
● How can I create content
that provides value?
○ Potential clients
○ Existing customers
○ Industry
○ Journalists
○ Content writers
@justdebbb
Instead of...
● Skyscraper technique
Think more about...
● Who you want links from
and...
○ what types of content they
link to
○ what value you can provide
🍬 💊
X
Study of link building tactics
(in select industries)
@justdebbb
How are businesses
getting their links?
Shoutout to
Ross
Simmonds
Shoutout to
Ross
Simmonds
@justdebbb
Methodology
● Explored 6 industries
○ CRM, CRO, PM tools, Design, Email, Finance
● 3-5 companies per industry
○ 23 companies total
● Top 5 pages by links
○ 115 URLs (23 companies)
○ Excluding: homepage, pricing, login, etc.
○ Data from Ahrefs
● Average DR of 88
○ Range: DR 82-93
Icons from The Noun Project
@justdebbb
Methodology
● Is the link on a guest post?
● Is the link from a link exchange?*
*Can’t know for sure, but there are some tell-tale signs
@justdebbb
Top page types that gets links
#1
#2
#3
Guides
Product pages
Glossary
But...
@justdebbb
#1 page type by industry
#1 Guides CRO
Finance
Email (tied)
#1 Product pages CRM
Design
PM tool
Email (tied)
@justdebbb
Free tools
#1 Free tools Martech*
#2 Free tools Design
Finance
*Based on Ross Simmonds’ research
@justdebbb
DR <90
#1
#2
#3
#4
Product pages
Guides
Stats
Glossary
DR 90+
#1
#2
#3
#4
Guides
Product pages
Glossary
@justdebbb
DR <90
#1
#2
#3
#4
Product pages
Guides
Stats
Glossary
DR 90+
#1
#2
#3
#4
Guides
Product pages
Research
Glossary
@justdebbb
Now you know what
pages get links
@justdebbb
How do they get those
links though?
@justdebbb
How do these pages get links?
1
2
Organically
Via outreach Pitch the content
Pitch a guest post
Pitch a link exchange
The reality is...
Reminder: I didn’t check all links to the
top 5 pages since there are too many
36%
of the high DR
sites studied
guest post
@justdebbb
Getting links to product pages
Of 25 product pages:
● 20% guest posts
● 12% link exchange
@justdebbb
Getting links to product pages
Of 25 product pages:
● 24% acquired a product and 301 the links
● 20% guest posts
● 12% link exchange
Also...
50%
of sites studied
may have
exchanged links
Reminder: Cannot be 100% sure
whether or not links were exchanged
“Good brands
don’t accept guest
posts, so the only
way to get links is
to build a
relationship”
Alexandra Tachalova,
Let’s Talk Link Building
So...should I guest post?
Should I do link exchanges?
Core Web Vitals Page
speed
Links
EEAT
User
experience
For visual purposes only. Not based on actual data. @justdebbb
Source: Wix
@justdebbb
Then, there are link
exchanges
@justdebbb
Let’s pretend I’m Mark
@justdebbb
It can be tough
to spot complex
link exchanges
@justdebbb
Think about the “Why”
behind the exchange
So...should I guest post?
Should I do link exchanges?
How do I build non-spammy links?
@justdebbb
Here’s what you
should do...
@justdebbb
1.Identify the vitamins
(stop chasing the 🍬)
@justdebbb
2. Diversify your link
building tactics
@justdebbb
3. Get your content in
front of people who
can benefit from it
Access the raw data here
@justdebbb
Thank you!
@justdebbb

Contenu connexe

Similaire à Say no to link spam: How to build non-spammy links (SearchLove 2023)

Julie Joyce - How We've Built Almost 20k Links By Hand (MKTFEST 2014)
Julie Joyce - How We've Built Almost 20k Links By Hand (MKTFEST 2014)Julie Joyce - How We've Built Almost 20k Links By Hand (MKTFEST 2014)
Julie Joyce - How We've Built Almost 20k Links By Hand (MKTFEST 2014)Marketing Festival
 
How We've Built Almost 20,000 Links By Hand
How We've Built Almost 20,000 Links By HandHow We've Built Almost 20,000 Links By Hand
How We've Built Almost 20,000 Links By HandJulieJoyce
 
Figaro Digital Marketing Conference: SEO is the New PR - Stephen Kenwright
Figaro Digital Marketing Conference: SEO is the New PR - Stephen KenwrightFigaro Digital Marketing Conference: SEO is the New PR - Stephen Kenwright
Figaro Digital Marketing Conference: SEO is the New PR - Stephen KenwrightBranded3
 
Top 14 SEO Myths...Busted!
Top 14 SEO Myths...Busted!Top 14 SEO Myths...Busted!
Top 14 SEO Myths...Busted!Marketing Mojo
 
Top 14 SEO Myths... Busted!
Top 14 SEO Myths... Busted!Top 14 SEO Myths... Busted!
Top 14 SEO Myths... Busted!Marketing Mojo
 
Search Engine Optimisation
Search Engine OptimisationSearch Engine Optimisation
Search Engine OptimisationJon Payne
 
Mad Science Experiments in SEO & Social Media
Mad Science Experiments in SEO & Social MediaMad Science Experiments in SEO & Social Media
Mad Science Experiments in SEO & Social MediaRand Fishkin
 
Google Featured Snippets, the Discover Feed & More Must-Know SEO Insights, SE...
Google Featured Snippets, the Discover Feed & More Must-Know SEO Insights, SE...Google Featured Snippets, the Discover Feed & More Must-Know SEO Insights, SE...
Google Featured Snippets, the Discover Feed & More Must-Know SEO Insights, SE...Brodie Clark
 
2018 SEO Myths → 12 Common SEO Myths Shattered
2018 SEO Myths → 12 Common SEO Myths Shattered2018 SEO Myths → 12 Common SEO Myths Shattered
2018 SEO Myths → 12 Common SEO Myths ShatteredRosemary Brisco
 
How SEO Blinded Me, Then Opened My Eyes
How SEO Blinded Me, Then Opened My EyesHow SEO Blinded Me, Then Opened My Eyes
How SEO Blinded Me, Then Opened My EyesRand Fishkin
 
What is your link building gameplan
What is your link building gameplanWhat is your link building gameplan
What is your link building gameplanWil Reynolds
 
White vs. Black Hat SEO
White vs. Black Hat SEOWhite vs. Black Hat SEO
White vs. Black Hat SEORand Fishkin
 
Lessons in Link-Building and Good SEO - Christoph Cemper, Link Research Tools
Lessons in Link-Building and Good SEO - Christoph Cemper, Link Research ToolsLessons in Link-Building and Good SEO - Christoph Cemper, Link Research Tools
Lessons in Link-Building and Good SEO - Christoph Cemper, Link Research ToolsPerformanceIN
 
Link building presentation from the London PMI 2014 conference
Link building presentation from the London PMI 2014 conferenceLink building presentation from the London PMI 2014 conference
Link building presentation from the London PMI 2014 conferenceChristoph C. Cemper
 
11 Things You Didn't Know About Links & Redirects
11 Things You Didn't Know About Links & Redirects11 Things You Didn't Know About Links & Redirects
11 Things You Didn't Know About Links & RedirectsChristoph C. Cemper
 
SEO Trends for 2014 - Smart Insights Digital Marketing Priorities
SEO Trends for 2014 - Smart Insights Digital Marketing PrioritiesSEO Trends for 2014 - Smart Insights Digital Marketing Priorities
SEO Trends for 2014 - Smart Insights Digital Marketing PrioritiesDigital Juggler
 
SEO STRATEGY FOR BEGINNERS - How to get on Google's radar
SEO STRATEGY FOR BEGINNERS - How to get on Google's radarSEO STRATEGY FOR BEGINNERS - How to get on Google's radar
SEO STRATEGY FOR BEGINNERS - How to get on Google's radarApril Brown
 
C3 2012 Institutionalizing SEO - Jeremiah Andrick, Brian McDowell
C3 2012  Institutionalizing SEO - Jeremiah Andrick, Brian McDowellC3 2012  Institutionalizing SEO - Jeremiah Andrick, Brian McDowell
C3 2012 Institutionalizing SEO - Jeremiah Andrick, Brian McDowellConductor
 
SEO Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them
SEO Pitfalls and How to Avoid ThemSEO Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them
SEO Pitfalls and How to Avoid ThemNate Dame
 

Similaire à Say no to link spam: How to build non-spammy links (SearchLove 2023) (20)

Julie Joyce - How We've Built Almost 20k Links By Hand (MKTFEST 2014)
Julie Joyce - How We've Built Almost 20k Links By Hand (MKTFEST 2014)Julie Joyce - How We've Built Almost 20k Links By Hand (MKTFEST 2014)
Julie Joyce - How We've Built Almost 20k Links By Hand (MKTFEST 2014)
 
How We've Built Almost 20,000 Links By Hand
How We've Built Almost 20,000 Links By HandHow We've Built Almost 20,000 Links By Hand
How We've Built Almost 20,000 Links By Hand
 
Figaro Digital Marketing Conference: SEO is the New PR - Stephen Kenwright
Figaro Digital Marketing Conference: SEO is the New PR - Stephen KenwrightFigaro Digital Marketing Conference: SEO is the New PR - Stephen Kenwright
Figaro Digital Marketing Conference: SEO is the New PR - Stephen Kenwright
 
Top 14 SEO Myths...Busted!
Top 14 SEO Myths...Busted!Top 14 SEO Myths...Busted!
Top 14 SEO Myths...Busted!
 
Top 14 SEO Myths... Busted!
Top 14 SEO Myths... Busted!Top 14 SEO Myths... Busted!
Top 14 SEO Myths... Busted!
 
Search Engine Optimisation
Search Engine OptimisationSearch Engine Optimisation
Search Engine Optimisation
 
Mad Science Experiments in SEO & Social Media
Mad Science Experiments in SEO & Social MediaMad Science Experiments in SEO & Social Media
Mad Science Experiments in SEO & Social Media
 
Google Featured Snippets, the Discover Feed & More Must-Know SEO Insights, SE...
Google Featured Snippets, the Discover Feed & More Must-Know SEO Insights, SE...Google Featured Snippets, the Discover Feed & More Must-Know SEO Insights, SE...
Google Featured Snippets, the Discover Feed & More Must-Know SEO Insights, SE...
 
2018 SEO Myths → 12 Common SEO Myths Shattered
2018 SEO Myths → 12 Common SEO Myths Shattered2018 SEO Myths → 12 Common SEO Myths Shattered
2018 SEO Myths → 12 Common SEO Myths Shattered
 
How SEO Blinded Me, Then Opened My Eyes
How SEO Blinded Me, Then Opened My EyesHow SEO Blinded Me, Then Opened My Eyes
How SEO Blinded Me, Then Opened My Eyes
 
What is your link building gameplan
What is your link building gameplanWhat is your link building gameplan
What is your link building gameplan
 
White vs. Black Hat SEO
White vs. Black Hat SEOWhite vs. Black Hat SEO
White vs. Black Hat SEO
 
Utah DMC Presents: SEO Night - July 2019
Utah DMC Presents: SEO Night - July 2019Utah DMC Presents: SEO Night - July 2019
Utah DMC Presents: SEO Night - July 2019
 
Lessons in Link-Building and Good SEO - Christoph Cemper, Link Research Tools
Lessons in Link-Building and Good SEO - Christoph Cemper, Link Research ToolsLessons in Link-Building and Good SEO - Christoph Cemper, Link Research Tools
Lessons in Link-Building and Good SEO - Christoph Cemper, Link Research Tools
 
Link building presentation from the London PMI 2014 conference
Link building presentation from the London PMI 2014 conferenceLink building presentation from the London PMI 2014 conference
Link building presentation from the London PMI 2014 conference
 
11 Things You Didn't Know About Links & Redirects
11 Things You Didn't Know About Links & Redirects11 Things You Didn't Know About Links & Redirects
11 Things You Didn't Know About Links & Redirects
 
SEO Trends for 2014 - Smart Insights Digital Marketing Priorities
SEO Trends for 2014 - Smart Insights Digital Marketing PrioritiesSEO Trends for 2014 - Smart Insights Digital Marketing Priorities
SEO Trends for 2014 - Smart Insights Digital Marketing Priorities
 
SEO STRATEGY FOR BEGINNERS - How to get on Google's radar
SEO STRATEGY FOR BEGINNERS - How to get on Google's radarSEO STRATEGY FOR BEGINNERS - How to get on Google's radar
SEO STRATEGY FOR BEGINNERS - How to get on Google's radar
 
C3 2012 Institutionalizing SEO - Jeremiah Andrick, Brian McDowell
C3 2012  Institutionalizing SEO - Jeremiah Andrick, Brian McDowellC3 2012  Institutionalizing SEO - Jeremiah Andrick, Brian McDowell
C3 2012 Institutionalizing SEO - Jeremiah Andrick, Brian McDowell
 
SEO Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them
SEO Pitfalls and How to Avoid ThemSEO Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them
SEO Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them
 

Dernier

2024's Top PPC Tactics: Triple Your Google Ads Local Leads
2024's Top PPC Tactics: Triple Your Google Ads Local Leads2024's Top PPC Tactics: Triple Your Google Ads Local Leads
2024's Top PPC Tactics: Triple Your Google Ads Local LeadsSearch Engine Journal
 
Most Influential HR Leaders Leading the Corporate World, 2024 (Final file).pdf
Most Influential HR Leaders Leading the Corporate World, 2024 (Final file).pdfMost Influential HR Leaders Leading the Corporate World, 2024 (Final file).pdf
Most Influential HR Leaders Leading the Corporate World, 2024 (Final file).pdfCIO Business World
 
The Pitfalls of Keyword Stuffing in SEO Copywriting
The Pitfalls of Keyword Stuffing in SEO CopywritingThe Pitfalls of Keyword Stuffing in SEO Copywriting
The Pitfalls of Keyword Stuffing in SEO CopywritingJuan Pineda
 
DGR_Digital Advertising Strategies for a Cookieless World_Presentation.pdf
DGR_Digital Advertising Strategies for a Cookieless World_Presentation.pdfDGR_Digital Advertising Strategies for a Cookieless World_Presentation.pdf
DGR_Digital Advertising Strategies for a Cookieless World_Presentation.pdfDemandbase
 
2024 SEO Trends for Business Success (WSA)
2024 SEO Trends for Business Success (WSA)2024 SEO Trends for Business Success (WSA)
2024 SEO Trends for Business Success (WSA)Jomer Gregorio
 
Common Culture: Paul Willis Symbolic Creativity
Common Culture: Paul Willis Symbolic CreativityCommon Culture: Paul Willis Symbolic Creativity
Common Culture: Paul Willis Symbolic CreativityMonishka Adhikari
 
Word Count for Writers: Examples of Word Counts for Sample Genres
Word Count for Writers: Examples of Word Counts for Sample GenresWord Count for Writers: Examples of Word Counts for Sample Genres
Word Count for Writers: Examples of Word Counts for Sample GenresLisa M. Masiello
 
Fueling A_B experiments with behavioral insights (1).pdf
Fueling A_B experiments with behavioral insights (1).pdfFueling A_B experiments with behavioral insights (1).pdf
Fueling A_B experiments with behavioral insights (1).pdfVWO
 
The Impact of Digital Technologies
The Impact of Digital Technologies The Impact of Digital Technologies
The Impact of Digital Technologies bruguardarib
 
DIGITAL MARKETING STRATEGY_INFOGRAPHIC IMAGE.pdf
DIGITAL MARKETING STRATEGY_INFOGRAPHIC IMAGE.pdfDIGITAL MARKETING STRATEGY_INFOGRAPHIC IMAGE.pdf
DIGITAL MARKETING STRATEGY_INFOGRAPHIC IMAGE.pdfmayanksharma0441
 
Storyboards for my Final Major Project Video
Storyboards for my Final Major Project VideoStoryboards for my Final Major Project Video
Storyboards for my Final Major Project VideoSineadBidwell
 
Snapshot of Consumer Behaviors of March 2024-EOLiSurvey (EN).pdf
Snapshot of Consumer Behaviors of March 2024-EOLiSurvey (EN).pdfSnapshot of Consumer Behaviors of March 2024-EOLiSurvey (EN).pdf
Snapshot of Consumer Behaviors of March 2024-EOLiSurvey (EN).pdfEastern Online-iSURVEY
 
The power of SEO-driven market intelligence
The power of SEO-driven market intelligenceThe power of SEO-driven market intelligence
The power of SEO-driven market intelligenceHinde Lamrani
 
What are the 4 characteristics of CTAs that convert?
What are the 4 characteristics of CTAs that convert?What are the 4 characteristics of CTAs that convert?
What are the 4 characteristics of CTAs that convert?Juan Pineda
 
From Chance to Choice - Tactical Link Building for International SEO
From Chance to Choice - Tactical Link Building for International SEOFrom Chance to Choice - Tactical Link Building for International SEO
From Chance to Choice - Tactical Link Building for International SEOSzymon Słowik
 
The 10 Most Influential CMO's Leading the Way of Success, 2024 (Final file) (...
The 10 Most Influential CMO's Leading the Way of Success, 2024 (Final file) (...The 10 Most Influential CMO's Leading the Way of Success, 2024 (Final file) (...
The 10 Most Influential CMO's Leading the Way of Success, 2024 (Final file) (...CIO Business World
 
Most Impressive Construction Leaders in Tech, Making Waves in the Industry, 2...
Most Impressive Construction Leaders in Tech, Making Waves in the Industry, 2...Most Impressive Construction Leaders in Tech, Making Waves in the Industry, 2...
Most Impressive Construction Leaders in Tech, Making Waves in the Industry, 2...CIO Business World
 
Influencer Marketing Power point presentation
Influencer Marketing  Power point presentationInfluencer Marketing  Power point presentation
Influencer Marketing Power point presentationdgtivemarketingagenc
 
ASO Process: What is App Store Optimization
ASO Process: What is App Store OptimizationASO Process: What is App Store Optimization
ASO Process: What is App Store OptimizationAli Raza
 
Digital Marketing Spotlight: Lifecycle Advertising Strategies.pdf
Digital Marketing Spotlight: Lifecycle Advertising Strategies.pdfDigital Marketing Spotlight: Lifecycle Advertising Strategies.pdf
Digital Marketing Spotlight: Lifecycle Advertising Strategies.pdfDemandbase
 

Dernier (20)

2024's Top PPC Tactics: Triple Your Google Ads Local Leads
2024's Top PPC Tactics: Triple Your Google Ads Local Leads2024's Top PPC Tactics: Triple Your Google Ads Local Leads
2024's Top PPC Tactics: Triple Your Google Ads Local Leads
 
Most Influential HR Leaders Leading the Corporate World, 2024 (Final file).pdf
Most Influential HR Leaders Leading the Corporate World, 2024 (Final file).pdfMost Influential HR Leaders Leading the Corporate World, 2024 (Final file).pdf
Most Influential HR Leaders Leading the Corporate World, 2024 (Final file).pdf
 
The Pitfalls of Keyword Stuffing in SEO Copywriting
The Pitfalls of Keyword Stuffing in SEO CopywritingThe Pitfalls of Keyword Stuffing in SEO Copywriting
The Pitfalls of Keyword Stuffing in SEO Copywriting
 
DGR_Digital Advertising Strategies for a Cookieless World_Presentation.pdf
DGR_Digital Advertising Strategies for a Cookieless World_Presentation.pdfDGR_Digital Advertising Strategies for a Cookieless World_Presentation.pdf
DGR_Digital Advertising Strategies for a Cookieless World_Presentation.pdf
 
2024 SEO Trends for Business Success (WSA)
2024 SEO Trends for Business Success (WSA)2024 SEO Trends for Business Success (WSA)
2024 SEO Trends for Business Success (WSA)
 
Common Culture: Paul Willis Symbolic Creativity
Common Culture: Paul Willis Symbolic CreativityCommon Culture: Paul Willis Symbolic Creativity
Common Culture: Paul Willis Symbolic Creativity
 
Word Count for Writers: Examples of Word Counts for Sample Genres
Word Count for Writers: Examples of Word Counts for Sample GenresWord Count for Writers: Examples of Word Counts for Sample Genres
Word Count for Writers: Examples of Word Counts for Sample Genres
 
Fueling A_B experiments with behavioral insights (1).pdf
Fueling A_B experiments with behavioral insights (1).pdfFueling A_B experiments with behavioral insights (1).pdf
Fueling A_B experiments with behavioral insights (1).pdf
 
The Impact of Digital Technologies
The Impact of Digital Technologies The Impact of Digital Technologies
The Impact of Digital Technologies
 
DIGITAL MARKETING STRATEGY_INFOGRAPHIC IMAGE.pdf
DIGITAL MARKETING STRATEGY_INFOGRAPHIC IMAGE.pdfDIGITAL MARKETING STRATEGY_INFOGRAPHIC IMAGE.pdf
DIGITAL MARKETING STRATEGY_INFOGRAPHIC IMAGE.pdf
 
Storyboards for my Final Major Project Video
Storyboards for my Final Major Project VideoStoryboards for my Final Major Project Video
Storyboards for my Final Major Project Video
 
Snapshot of Consumer Behaviors of March 2024-EOLiSurvey (EN).pdf
Snapshot of Consumer Behaviors of March 2024-EOLiSurvey (EN).pdfSnapshot of Consumer Behaviors of March 2024-EOLiSurvey (EN).pdf
Snapshot of Consumer Behaviors of March 2024-EOLiSurvey (EN).pdf
 
The power of SEO-driven market intelligence
The power of SEO-driven market intelligenceThe power of SEO-driven market intelligence
The power of SEO-driven market intelligence
 
What are the 4 characteristics of CTAs that convert?
What are the 4 characteristics of CTAs that convert?What are the 4 characteristics of CTAs that convert?
What are the 4 characteristics of CTAs that convert?
 
From Chance to Choice - Tactical Link Building for International SEO
From Chance to Choice - Tactical Link Building for International SEOFrom Chance to Choice - Tactical Link Building for International SEO
From Chance to Choice - Tactical Link Building for International SEO
 
The 10 Most Influential CMO's Leading the Way of Success, 2024 (Final file) (...
The 10 Most Influential CMO's Leading the Way of Success, 2024 (Final file) (...The 10 Most Influential CMO's Leading the Way of Success, 2024 (Final file) (...
The 10 Most Influential CMO's Leading the Way of Success, 2024 (Final file) (...
 
Most Impressive Construction Leaders in Tech, Making Waves in the Industry, 2...
Most Impressive Construction Leaders in Tech, Making Waves in the Industry, 2...Most Impressive Construction Leaders in Tech, Making Waves in the Industry, 2...
Most Impressive Construction Leaders in Tech, Making Waves in the Industry, 2...
 
Influencer Marketing Power point presentation
Influencer Marketing  Power point presentationInfluencer Marketing  Power point presentation
Influencer Marketing Power point presentation
 
ASO Process: What is App Store Optimization
ASO Process: What is App Store OptimizationASO Process: What is App Store Optimization
ASO Process: What is App Store Optimization
 
Digital Marketing Spotlight: Lifecycle Advertising Strategies.pdf
Digital Marketing Spotlight: Lifecycle Advertising Strategies.pdfDigital Marketing Spotlight: Lifecycle Advertising Strategies.pdf
Digital Marketing Spotlight: Lifecycle Advertising Strategies.pdf
 

Say no to link spam: How to build non-spammy links (SearchLove 2023)